article
stringlengths 0
745k
| abstract
stringlengths 0
92.7k
|
|---|---|
the nature of the cma , discovered by @xcite , remains a controversial subject .
whether the cma is a distinct , disrupting dwarf galaxy or a feature of the galactic disk remains open to debate .
previous studies using either 2mass or broadband johnson - cousins photometry have shown indications that over - densities in the red giant branch ( rgb ) , red clump ( rc ) and old main - sequence ( oms)(age = 4 - 10 gyrs ) exist , centered near l = 240 , b = -7 . each of these populations lie red - ward of the thin / thick disk turnoff and are identified using statistical methods which compare expected model densities to observations .
this type of analysis is necessitated because of the enormous number of foreground / background stars along the line - of - sight for these samples .
results from these investigations are confounded by the difficulty in constraining the differential reddening which is prevalent in this portion of the sky .
further , the use of smooth stellar models which may not accurately account for the galactic warp and flare allow serious consideration that the cma is simply a natural feature of the disk of the galaxy @xcite .
it is only the young main - sequence ( yms ) of the bp that stands out as being virtually free of field contamination , and it is the one cma component which can be more cleanly modeled in order to constrain the distance to the cma . the bp present in the central cma fields
have been studied photometrically by @xcite . @xcite
successfully fit the bp sequence using theoretical isochrones and predicted a distance to the bp of 9 - 10 kpc ( depending on the assumed [ fe / h ] ) and suggested that it was consistent with the distance of both the oms and the cma .
this result , however , depends on the correct determination of reddening , and the location of the ms turn - off for the bp population . without the strength of argument supplied by the bp stars in the yms
, the case for the galactic origin of the cma is severely diminished . in this letter we present new results from our spectroscopic study of bp stars along the line - of - sight to the cma .
a full paper will follow that provides complete details of our methods and results , including new spectra from a pending observing run at ctio on the 4 m blanco telescope .
our study began with initial photometry obtained at mcdonald observatory ( mcd ) using the 0.8 m telescope .
we used this photometry to choose candidate bp stars for preliminary , low - resolution , spectroscopy using the large cassegrain spectrograph ( lcs ) on the 2.7 m at mcd .
these data helped us understand the populations present in the cma .
based on these data , we applied for time at ctio through noao .
the photometry data in this paper were then obtained using the 0.9 m telescope at ctio 24 - 29 november 2006 .
ubv images were obtained for sixteen 13.5 fields under photometric conditions .
these data were reduced using standard techniques , including flat field and bias corrections , using quadproc in iraf .
@xcite standard fields were observed to calibrate the photometry .
typical residuals in the solution were 1% in v and b , and a few percent in u. color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) and color - color ( c - c ) plots were made from the photometry data .
these were used to select bp stars as targets for future spectroscopy , and to estimate the reddening . a representative cmd and c - c plot
are shown in figure 1 .
the targets for spectroscopy were drawn from a 3x3 grid of the photometry fields , or a field 40 on a side , centered on l = 238.65 , b = -7.52 .
we obtained spectra for 58 bp stars using the hydra multi - object spectrograph on the wiyn 3.5 m telescope at kpno .
the spectra have a wavelength coverage from 3500 to 5400 @xmath3 with a resolution of r @xmath4 and typical s / n @xmath5 at h@xmath6 and s / n @xmath7 at h@xmath8 .
the data were reduced using dohydra in iraf and helio - centric radial velocities were determined using fxcor with synthetic spectral templates .
analysis of the stellar parameters of teff , logg , and [ fe / h ] used a combination of the balmer - line widths and dereddened ( see below ) ubv photometry as described in @xcite .
it was not possible to use the caii k line to establish metallicity , due to the extensive amount of contamination from interstellar ca so near the galactic plane .
instead , metallicity for the stars with teff @xmath0 9750 ( k ) was determined using synthetic template comparison to metal - line regions in the observed spectra ( wilhelm et al .
the average metal abundance for these stars was found to be @xmath0[fe / h]@xmath1 = -0.37 with a 1@xmath9 spread of @xmath10 .
the hotter stars in the sample were assigned [ fe / h ] = -0.5 using comparison of theoretical isochrones from @xcite in the teff / logg plane .
see figure 2 below .
figure 2 is a plot of our results for 44 stars with data of sufficient quality for analysis .
we find that the majority of hot stars in this sample have log g values consistent with main - sequence stars and not the lower surface - gravity main - sequence turn - off .
distances were computed using absolute magnitudes , the theoretical isochrone fits to the teff - logg plane and the extinction corrected v magnitudes .
the cma has a low galactic latitude ( @xmath11 -8 degrees ) which results in heavy differential reddening . dealing with
this reddening is crucial to understanding the populations present in the cma .
the most common means of estimating the reddening is the use of the @xcite ( sfd ) dust maps , or the correction of these maps provided by @xcite .
we instead used two methods to determine the reddening for individual stars .
color - color plots were made for our fields using our photometry . since the bp is purported to be a yms ( de jong et al . ) , we fit @xcite zams curves to the c - c plots to account for the effect of differential reddening across the fields . by shifting the zams on a c - c plot until a given bp star fell on the curve , individual reddening could be determined .
a degeneracy arose since there can be two e(b - v ) values that fit the zams to a star , as can be seen in figure 1 . a second value for e(b - v )
was obtained through analyzing the spectra independent of the zams reddening value . in this method to constrain the reddening we use a comparison between the h - beta line profile and the reddening - free q - parameter given by : @xmath12 the line profile was determined by measuring the width of the h - beta line at 13 positions starting with 10% below the local - pseudo continuum and moving downward in increments of 3% for 12 further measures .
the widths were analyzed using a @xmath13 goodness - of - fit of all 13 widths compared to identically produced profiles of synthetically generated h - beta lines created from @xcite atlas9 model atmospheres and the spectral synthesis routine spectrum @xcite .
local minima where identified with a typical degeneracy found for cooler and hotter stars which lie on the either side of the a0 maximum .
typical differences in the observed q - value between the degenerate minima were on the order of 0.2 - 0.3 .
this was sufficient to break the degeneracy and assign a true global minimum .
the observed q - values were then compared to theoretical q - values supplied by atlas9 generated ubv colors and synthetic ( b - v ) colors were directly compared to the unreddening corrected , observed ( b - v ) in order to establish the e(b - v ) for the star . for the 48 stars with sufficient s / n in their spectra to apply both methods , the standard deviation of the differences in the e(b - v ) estimates was 0.022 .
we then compared our adopted e(b - v ) with the values predicted by @xcite ( bmb ) .
e(b - v ) ranged from 0.02 to 0.555 for our method , and from 0.20 to 0.32 for the bmb method .
we found an average e(b - v ) of 0.286 using our method and an average of 0.268 using the bmb method , showing that the two approaches give the same reddening estimate to within in the error estimate of 16% claimed by sfd for their maps .
the standard deviation in e(b - v ) for our method is 0.133 , compared to 0.038 for the bmb method .
clearly our method reproduces the expected average value , but is better able to account for the rapid changes in the value that result in this highly differential field .
the scale resolution of the sfd maps is 6. this shows that the maps are not able to adequately deal with these differential fields .
figure 3 shows a frequency histogram of the number of stars versus heliocentric distance and radial velocity .
both of these plots have a result different than what has been attributed to the cma .
first , the radial velocity average for our sample is 90 km / s rather than the 109 km / s found by martin et al . for the rc .
further , the bp is clearly not located at a distance of 8 or 10 kpc , but is rather distributed throughout the entire line of sight to the cma .
the mean distance for our bp sample was around 6 kpc , with a large dispersion of 2.7 kpc .
this is at odds with the result found by de jong et al .
, who predict a bp clump either at the distance of the cma as predicted by martin et al . or farther away and presumably associated with spiral arm structure in the milky way .
this is not surprising since the fitting techniques employed in their paper presume that the top of the bp coincides with the turn - off for the yms . as can be seen in figure 2 , the stars at the top of our bp are clearly ms dwarfs rather than turn - off stars .
the stars are also scattered at various distances making their analysis an inappropriate treatment of their data .
finally , our result is in keeping with that of @xcite who find similar bp stars at various galactic longitudes which are very different from the line - of - sight longitude to cma .
our result also shows that the proper motion study of @xcite is flawed by this same assumption .
they base their measurements on the assumption that the bp behaves as martin et al .
predict , namely that the clump lies at a distance of 8.1 @xmath14 kpc , and that it has a radial velocity average of 109 @xmath15 km / s .
we observe a bp with a dramatically different morphology and kinematic signature .
@xcite discuss the evidence that the cma is simply due to the warp of the galaxy , and refutes the arguments in favor of a dwarf galaxy origin for the cma .
figure 3 in this article shows a schematic view of the milky way based on various models .
the morphology we observe for the bp seems to fit well with these models if we presume that we are looking along the spiral arms .
figure 16 in their paper shows a cut in the yz plane of a warped and flared disk .
our line of sight would trace a projected scale height of around one for much of the distance to the cma . in light of these arguments , we see no other viable explanation for our observed bp morphology than that we are seeing the stars of a warped galactic disk .
bonifacio , p. , monai , s. , & beers , t.c .
2000 , aj , 120 , 2065 butler et al .
2007 , aj , 133 , 2274 carraro et al .
2005 , apj , 630 , l153 de long et al .
2007 , aj , 662 , 259 dinescu , d. et al .
2005 , apj , 631 , l49 giardia et al .
2002 a&a , 391 , 195 gray , r. o. , & corbally , c. j. 1994 , 107 , 742 landolt , a.u .
1992 , 104 , 340 kurucz , r. l. 1993 , kurucz cd - rom 13 , atlas9 stellar atmosphere programs and 2 km / s grid ( cambridge : sao ) martin et al .
2004 , mnras , 348 , 12 momany et al .
2004 , a&a , 421 , l29 momany et al .
2006 , a&a , 451 , 515 schlegel , d.j . ,
finkbeiner , d.p . , &
davis , m. 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 schmidt - kaler , th .
1982 , in landolt - bornstein numerical data and functional relationships in science and technology : new series , vol .
2(b ) , 14 wilhelm , r. et al . 1999 , , 117 , 2329 | we obtained new ubv photometry and spectroscopy of blue plume ( bp ) stars near the center of the canis major over - density ( cma ) .
we combined analyses of color - color diagrams with a new comparison of the hydrogen balmer - line profile to the reddening - free q parameter to improve the reddening and extinction estimates for this low - latitude , differentially reddened , area of the sky .
results of our stellar parameter analysis for b / a spectral type stars associated with the bp show that the majority of the stars have main - sequence surface gravities placing them at an average heliocentric distance of @xmath0d@xmath1 = @xmath2 kpc .
this distance is more consistent with membership in the intervening perseus spiral arm and strongly suggests that the bp stars are not associated with the other stellar populations previously reported to make up the cma .
this result casts serious doubt on the proposed dwarf galaxy origin for the cma . |
the possible existence of a second critical point of water in the liquid supercooled metastable phase has been the subject of a long debate in the literature .
the first hypothesis of its existence originated from the results of a computer simulation on water modeled with the st2 potential @xcite .
on the basis of those results the thermodynamic anomalies of water upon supercooling were interpreted in terms of the long range fluctuations induced by the presence of a second critical point .
this critical point would be a liquid - liquid critical point ( llcp ) located at the end of the coexistence line between a low density liquid ( ldl ) phase and a high density liquid ( hdl ) phase of water . in the llcp scenario
, these liquid phases would be the counterpart at higher temperature of the well - known low density amorphous ( lda ) and high density amorphous ( hda ) phases of glassy water .
the hypothesis of a llcp scenario for water motivated a large number of experimental , computational and theoretical investigations @xcite .
different interpretations of the origin of the thermodynamic anomalies of water have been also proposed as alternatives to the llcp scenario . in the singularity free scenario @xcite the anomalies of water are due to local density fluctuations and no critical phenomena take place .
recently a critical point free scenario @xcite has also been proposed in which the transition between hdl and ldl is seen as an order - disorder transition without a critical point .
a number of computer simulations , performed on supercooled water with different model potentials , confirmed the plausibility of the llcp scenario @xcite .
there are also indications from experiments of the existence of the llcp in bulk water @xcite
. it would be approximately located at @xmath0 k at @xmath1 mpa .
because of the difficulties of performing experiments in the region where the llcp would reside in bulk water , the possibility of observing the llcp of water in aqueous solutions that can be more easily supercooled @xcite has been recently explored theoretically @xcite and in computer simulations @xcite .
results compatible with the existence of a llcp have been also found in aqueous solutions of salts through thermometric experiments @xcite . in a recent paper @xcite , by means of a computer simulation study of the phase diagram
, we indicated the possible detection in thermometric experiments of the llcp in a nacl(aq ) solution . since the detection of low and high density forms of water can also offer a viable path to the experimental detection of a llcp , structural properties of supercooled water and aqueous solutions are of extreme interest in this context .
the structure of water and of aqueous solutions , can be studied with neutron diffraction using isotopic substitution @xcite or by x - ray scattering @xcite . in the present paper we focus on the structural properties of bulk tip4p water and of the nacl(aq )
solution with @xmath2 mol / kg , in order to analyze and compare the results in hdl and ldl especially close to the llcp .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ details ] the details of the computer simulations are given . in sec .
[ thermo ] we summarize the main results obtained on the thermodynamics of bulk water and nacl(aq ) and we present the potential energy of the systems .
the new results for the structural properties of the systems are presented in sec .
[ results ] .
this section is divided in two parts : water - water structure is discussed in subsection [ water ] , while the hydration structure of ions is addressed in subsection [ hydration ] .
finally , conclusions are given in sec .
[ conclusions ] .
molecular dynamics ( md ) computer simulations were performed on bulk water and on nacl(aq ) with concentration @xmath2 mol / kg .
the interaction potential between pairs of particles is given by the sum of the electrostatic and the lennard - jones ( lj ) potentials . @xmath3\ ] ] water molecules were modeled using the tip4p potential @xcite . the details about this potential are reported in the appendix .
tip4p potential is known to well describe water properties in its liquid supercooled state @xcite and also to be able to reproduce the very complex ices phase diagram @xcite .
the lj interaction parameters for the ions were taken from jensen and jorgensen @xcite and the ion - water interaction parameters were calculated by using geometrical mixing rules @xmath4 and @xmath5 .
the ion - ion and ion - water parameters are reported in table [ tab:1 ] .
these parameters were optimized for use with tip4p water and they well reproduce structural characteristics and free energies of hydration of the ions @xcite .
although the presence of ions would suggest the use of polarizable potentials , at the moment no joint set of polarizable potentials for water and ions are tested as reliable for very low temperatures .
.ion - ion and ion - water lj interaction parameters @xcite . [
cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab:2 ] as shown in fig .
[ fig:5 ] and fig .
[ fig:6 ] , the ions seem to affect the ldl more than the hdl . the most significant difference in the hydration shells of the ions
is noticed in the second shell of the cl - o rdf .
we have also already mentioned that the hydration structure around the chloride ion resembles the o - o and o - h structures ( fig .
[ fig:8 ] ) with the chloride ion able to substitute oxygen in shells of other oxygen atoms . to further inquire this possibility and to assess the effect of the chloride ion hydration on hdl / ldl we plot together in fig .
[ fig:10 ] the o - o and cl - o rdfs for hdl and ldl with distances rescaled by the respective lj interaction distance parameter @xmath6 . for the o - o pair @xmath7 as given in the tip4p model @xcite , for the cl - o pair @xmath8 as reported in table [ tab:1 ] . in both ldl and hdl the first and the second shell of oxygen atoms are closer in the case of the cl - o rdf
( see also fig .
[ fig:5 ] and fig .
[ fig:9 ] ) . to make a quantitative comparison we can look at the distance between the first peak and the second peak of the rdfs @xmath9 . in hdl , for the o - o pair @xmath10 , for the cl - o @xmath11 . in ldl , for the o - o pair @xmath12 and for cl - o @xmath13 ( distances in real units
are obtained multiplying @xmath9 by the respective @xmath6 ) .
thus we see that in ldl the chloride ion has the major effect in pulling inward its second hydration shell of oxygens . as shown in fig .
[ fig:4 ] and fig .
[ fig:5 ] the main difference in the structure of the hdl and ldl is in the position of the second shell of the o - o rdfs , therefore , a possible explanation for why the presence of ions affect the ldl more than the hdl . in fact
the chloride ion can take the place of the central oxygen atom in oxygen shells and can be accommodated in water - water structure at the price of bending hydrogen bonds and pulling the second shell of oxygen closer to the first shell .
this can be tolerated in hdl where the molecular structure is already collapsed in the second shell @xcite but the ldl structure results instead disrupted .
in essence , the substitution of oxygen atoms by chloride atoms together with the hydrogen bond disruption caused by na@xmath14 forces the ldl structure to become more hdl - like . hence , we can understand also from a structural point of view why the region of existence of the ldl phase shrinks in the nacl(aq ) with respect to bulk water .
by the use of md computer simulations , we have studied the structural properties of tip4p bulk water and of a sodium chloride solution in tip4p water with concentration @xmath2 mol / kg . in particular , we were interested in the structural differences between the two phases of water , hdl and ldl , that appear in the deep supercooled region . from our previous work
@xcite we knew accurately the phase diagrams of these systems and in particular the position of the llcp .
our results showed that the tip4p model can reproduce well the structural properties of the two phases of supercooled liquid water in addition to being a very good potential for the study of liquid @xcite and solid @xcite water thermodynamics . comparing water - water rdfs in bulk water and in nacl(aq )
we have seen that the ldl is affected by the presence of ions more than the hdl , as indicated also by the shrinkage of the ldl phase observed in the study of the thermodynamics .
the study of the hydration structure of ions in hdl and ldl revealed that a disturbance to the ldl structure is induced by the substitution of oxygen by chloride ions in coordination shells of other oxygen atoms .
the chloride ions in fact pull inward its second shell of oxygen atoms , disrupting the ldl structure .
this , together with the hydrogen bond breaking caused by the sodium ion , causes the ldl phase to be less stable in nacl(aq ) solutions and its region of existence in the thermodynamic plane to reduce , with a consequent shift of the liquid - liquid coexistence line and of the llcp to lower pressures with respect to bulk water .
since from our thermodynamic results we hypothesize that the llcp region is above the nucleation line in this solution , an observation of the structural features presented in this paper in x - ray and neutron scattering experiments , can also represent a viable route for experimentalists to solve the quest of the llcp in bulk water . along this line experimental indications of a hdl and ldl phase coexistence and llcp have been recently found @xcite .
we gratefully acknowledge the computational resources offered by cineca for the `` progetto calcolo 891 '' , by the infn rm3-grid at roma tre university and by the democritos national simulation center at sissa ( trieste , italy ) .
the tip4p model for water is a nonpolarizable potential where three sites are arranged according to the molecular geometry .
the two sites representing the hydrogens are positively charged with @xmath15 @xmath16 ; each one forms a rigid bond with the site of the oxygen at distance @xmath17 .
the angle between the bonds is @xmath18 .
the site of the oxygen is neutral while a fourth site carries the negative charge of the oxygen @xmath19 .
this site is located in the same plane of the molecule at a distance @xmath20 from the oxygen with an angle @xmath21 from the @xmath22 bond .
the intermolecular interactions are represented by eq .
the lj parameters are given by @xmath23 and @xmath24 kj / mol . | we consider and compare the structural properties of bulk tip4p water and of a sodium chloride aqueous solution in tip4p water with concentration c = 0.67 mol / kg , in the metastable supercooled region . in a previous paper [ d. corradini , m. rovere and p. gallo , j. chem .
phys . * 132 * , 134508 ( 2010 ) ] we found in both systems the presence of a liquid - liquid critical point ( llcp ) .
the llcp is believed to be the end point of the coexistence line between a high density liquid ( hdl ) and a low density liquid ( ldl ) phase of water . in the present paper
we study the different features of water - water structure in hdl and ldl both in bulk water and in the solution .
we find that the ions are able to modify the bulk ldl structure , rendering water - water structure more similar to the bulk hdl case . by the study of the hydration structure in hdl and ldl , a possible mechanism for the modification of the bulk ldl structure in the solution
is identified in the substitution of the oxygen by the chloride ion in oxygen coordination shells . |
the top quark is the heaviest `` elementary '' particle with a mass approximately equal to the sum of the masses of the w - boson and z - boson .
the top quark , the w - boson and the higg boson form an interesting triptych of elementary particles . in the standard model knowing the mass of the w - boson and top quark allows one to predict the mass of the higgs boson . therefore in this proceedings
i will primarily focus on the top quark physics but i will also discuss the w - boson mass and the possibility of discovering the light higgs boson at the proton - antiproton collider at fermilab , the tevatron .
the most surprising thing about the top quark is that its mass is approximately 175 gev , nearly twice as heavy as the w and z bosons and more than 30 times the mass of its electro - weak partner the b - quark .
the yukawa coupling constant of the top quark m_t & ~ & 1 whereas for the electron the yukawa coupling is @xmath0 .
why is the top quark so heavy ?
does top have a special roll in electro - weak symmetry breaking ?
does top have standard model couplings ?
these are some of the critical question that need to be answered at this time . at a hadron collider
the dominant mode of top quark production at hadron colliders is via quark - antiquark annihilation or gluon - gluon fusion q & & t + g g & & t .
fig [ fig - roots ] is the lowest order cross sections for these subprocesses verses @xmath1 for @xmath2 for both proton - antiproton and proton - proton accelerators . for the tevatron the dominant production mechanism ,
80 to 90 % of the total cross section , is quark - antiquark annihilation whereas at the lhc gluon - gluon fusion is 80 to 90 % of the total . at the tevatron
the top quark pairs are produced with a typical speed in the zero momentum frame of 0.6c whereas at the lhc this speed is 0.8c .
recently a number of authors @xcite @xmath3 @xcite have calculated the cross section for top quark pair production not only at next to leading order but they have summed the large logarithms to all orders in perturbation theory . for the tevatron
these results are displayed in fig [ fig - all ] . even though these authors all agree on the top cross - section at the tevatron they disagree in principal on how these calculations should be performed .
fig [ fig - xsec ] is the cross section verses the mass of the top quark for the calculation by catani et al @xcite .
the functional dependence of the other calculations is essentially the same with the cross section dropping by a factor of 2 for every 20 gev increase in the top quark mass .
also shown on this figure are the results from cdf and d0 . in raising the energy of the tevatron from 1.8 to 2.0 tev the top cross section increases by 38 % with the gluon - gluon fusion component increasing from 10 to 20 % of the total . in the standard model
the top quark decays primarily into b - quark and a w boson , t b w^+ & & b l^+ + & & b |d u. for a 175 gev the width of this decay mode is 1.5 gev , see bigi etal @xcite .
thus the top quark decays before it hadronizes and any spin information introduced in the production mechanism is passed on to the decay products .
fig [ fig - decay - corr ] gives the correlations of the decay products with the spin direction for a polarized top quark @xcite .
also shown on this figure is the correlation of the charged lepton ( or d - type quark ) with the b - quark direction in the w - boson rest frame showing the @xmath4 ratio of longitudinal to transverse w - bosons in top quark decay .
fig [ fig - contours ] shows the correlations between the w - boson decay direction relative to the spin - direction and the charge lepton ( or d - type quark ) direction relative to the minus b - quark direction in the w - boson rest frame . that is , if the @xmath5 is emitted in the spin direction it is longitudinal and in the minus spin direction it is transverse . in the zero momentum frame .
fig [ fig - spins ] is the relevant three vectors for the spin correlation studies of the top quark pairs produced by quark - antiquark annihilation @xcite .
if the angle @xmath6 is chosen such that & = & ^2 ^ * ^ * ( 1-^2 ^2^ * ) then the top quarks are produced in only the up - down and down - up configurations _
i.e. _ the up - up and down - down components identically vanish @xcite , @xcite .
this spin basis is known as the off - diagonal basis .
for the up - down spin configuration , the preferred emission directions for the charged leptons ( or d - type quarks ) of the top and anti - top quark are given by the directions of @xmath7 and @xmath8 respectively .
whereas for the down - up configuration the preferred directions are @xmath9 and @xmath10 respectively .
these vectors make an angle @xmath11 with respect to the beam direction with & = & ^*. near threshold @xmath12 whereas for ultrarelativisitic tops @xmath13 as expected .
hill and parke @xcite have studied the effects of new physics on top quark production in a general operator formalism as well as in topcolor models . in these models
the distortions in top quark production and shape are due to new physics in the @xmath14 subprocess .
the effects of a coloron which couples weakly to the light generations but strongly to the heavy generation is given in fig [ fig - mtttopcolor ] .
similarly eichten and lane @xcite have studied the effects of multi - scale technicolor on top production through the production of a techni - eta resonance , see fig [ fig - mtttechni ] . here the coupling of the techni - eta is to @xmath15 , therefore only this subprocess is different than the standard model . at the fermilab tevatron top production
is dominated by @xmath14 annihilation while at the lhc it is the @xmath15 fusion subprocess that dominates .
therefore these models predict very different consequences for top production at the lhc .
both cdf and d0 have observed the top quark pair events in the dilepton channel , the lepton plus jet channel and the all jets channel . to get
the latest information on the measurement of the mass and production cross sections see the cdf web page at www-cdf.fnal.gov and the d0 web page at www-d0.fnal.gov . at the time of this conference
the cdf @xcite results are m_t & = & 176.8 4.4 4.8 gev + _ t & = & 7.5^+1.9_-1.6 1.67 pb and for d0 @xcite m_t & = & 173.3 5.6 6.2 gev + _ t & = & 5.53 1.67 pb for a comparison with theory see fig [ fig - xsec ] .
what is surprising about these results is that with approximately 100 top quark events in total the top mass is already known quite accurately .
unfortunately all top quark experimental results so far are consistent with the standard model .
recently reliable results for the next to leading order calculations for single top quark production at hadron colliders via a virtual w - boson @xcite or via w - gluon fusion @xcite have been presented .
a comparison of the rates for these processes can be found in fig [ fig - comp ] for events with the topology positron , missing transverse energy plus jets .
the rates for both of these single top processes are proportional to the ckm matrix element @xmath16 squared therefore these processes can be used to measured this important standard model parameter . for 2 ( 30 ) of data at the tevatron
the expected uncertainty on @xmath16 is 12% ( 3% ) .
single top quark production is a great source of polarized top quarks with the polarization being in the direction of the d - type quark in the event _ i.e. _ the anti - proton direction for w@xmath17 production and the spectator jet for production via w - gluon fusion .
the production of single top quarks through a virtual w - boson is sensitive to form factors in the @xmath18 vertex at a @xmath19 .
hints of new physics could be discovered in this process .
in the standard model the mass of the top quark , w - boson and higgs boson are all related to one another .
so precision measurements of the top quark mass and w - boson mass will give us information on the higgs boson mass .
the latest result on the w - boson mass from cdf @xcite is m_w & = & 80.38 0.12 gev and from d0 @xcite is m_w & = & 80.44 0.11 gev .
fig [ fig - w - mass ] is a summary of the current results from all experiments on the w - boson mass . in the standard model , because of radiative corrections , knowing the w - boson mass and the top quark mass gives a determination of the higgs boson mass .
fig [ fig - wvt - mass ] shows the current experimental results on this indirect measurement of the higgs boson mass .
unfortunately at the current level of accuracy on the w and top mass measurements little can be said about the higgs boson mass except that light values seem to be preferred .
if this holds up with increased precision on these measurements it is great news as it means the higgs boson is easily accessible or there is new physics near at hand .
either outcome would be great for particle physics .
improvements in the w - boson mass can be expected from lep2 possible reaching an uncertainty of 34 mev . with a few fb@xmath20s of data
the tevatron should reach an uncertainty of 40 mev on the w - boson mass and almost 2 gev on the top quark mass .
if tev33 gets 30 to 100 fb@xmath20 of data the uncertainty on the w - boson mass will probably reach 20 mev and top quark mass of 1 gev .
this would greatly enhance the determination of the higgs boson mass from fig [ fig - wvt - mass ] .
the mass of the w - boson and mass of the top quark suggest that the higgs boson is light .
susy models predict that the lightest higgs be less than 150 gev ( 125 gev in the minimal model , mssm ) .
lep2 will explore up to a mass of 95 gev by the year 2000 . at the tevatron a light higgs @xcite
can be explored up to a mass of 130 gev @xcite @xmath3 @xcite with sufficient integrated luminosity , 30 - 100 , using the subprocess q ^ & & w + h with the w decaying leptonically and the higgs decaying to @xmath21 . the physics backgrounds for this process are q ^ & & w + b + |b ( qcd ) + & & t + |b + & & w + z. this physics requires double b - tagging with high efficiency and low fake rates .
also one needs good resolution on the @xmath21 mass , above the z - boson peak , then with very large data sets the higgs boson will be observable if its mass is below 130 gev
. the process @xmath22 will also be useful @xcite .
hopefully the tevatron can obtain these large data sets before the lhc has obtained significant data sets .
hadron colliders provide a rich , diverse `` feast of physics '' .
the top quark , w - boson and higgs boson form a very rich triptych but there is also qcd , b - physics , electroweak , susy etc .
while the fermilab tevatron still holds the energy frontier it should be exploited to the fullest possible extent with luminosity upgrades to both accelerator and detectors .
special thanks to the local organizers of this conference .
i also wish to thank the authors of many of the references who provided data from their work for the plots in this presentation .
fermi national accelerator laboratory is operated by the universities research association , inc .
, under contract de - ac02 - 76cho3000 with the united states of america department of energy . 9
# 1#2#3 nucl . phys . * b#1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys . lett . *
b#1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys .
# 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys . rev .
* # 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys . rev .
* d#1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 phys . rep . *
# 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 rev .
# 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 z. phys .
* c#1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 comm .
# 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3_ibid .
_ * # 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 jetp lett . *
# 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) # 1#2#3 sov .
# 1 * , # 3 , ( # 2 ) e. laenen , j. smith and w. van neerven , ; .
e. berger and h. contopanagos , ; ; anl - hep - pr-97 - 01 preprint hep - ph/970626 .
s. catani , m. mangano , p. nason and l. trentadue ; .
i. bigi , y. dokshitzer , v. khoze , j. khn , and p. zerwas , . m. jeabek and j.h .
g. mahlon and s. parke , ; t. stelzer and s. willenbrock , . s. parke and y. shadmi , . g. mahlon and s. parke , fermilab - pub-97 - 185-t , hep - ph/9706304 . c. hill and s. parke , .
e. eichten and k. lane , .
s. vejcik , the cdf collaboration , fermilab - conf-97 - 249-e .
li , the d0 collaboration , fermilab - conf-97 - 229-e . m. smith and s. willenbrock , .
t. stelzer , z. sullivan and s. willenbrock , hep - ph/9705398 .
r. g. wagner , the cdf collaboration , fermi - conf-97 - 293-e .
the d0 collaboration , fermilab - conf-97 - 222-e , july 1997 .
a. stange , w. maricano and s. willenbrock , .
s. kim , s. kuhlman and w. yao , cdf - anal - exotic - public-3904 , oct .
. w. yao , fermilab - conf-96 - 383-e , jun 96 .
j. womersley , d0 note 3227 , apr 97 . | in this presentation i will primarily focus on top quark physics but i will include a discussion of the w - boson mass and the possibility of discovering a light higgs boson via associated production at the tevatron .
= cmr8 epsf 1.5pt # 1#2#3#4#1 * # 2 * , # 3 ( # 4 ) # 1(#3)=@urnal , _ # 1 * # 2 ( @ur 255=#3 ) , * _ @ur255<100 255 by 1900 255 @urnal @=reference foul up : nested macros = you forgot & or ( ) after the last # 1,#3(#4 ) , # 1 * # 2 * , # 3 ( 19#4 ) ps . ps |
exotic hadron spectroscopy opens a new window into quark - gluon dynamics that could shift the paradigm that mesons and baryons consist of @xmath4 and @xmath5 constituent quarks , respectively .
recent lattice qcd studies of the nucleon spectrum indicate that the excited nucleon states may exist with a substantial admixture of glue @xcite .
these recent predictions initiated the efforts aimed at a search for hybrid baryons in the future experiments at jefferson lab with the clas12 detector @xcite . in this paper
we discuss the feasibility of using the clas12 detector in search for exotic baryons with the quark core consisting of five constituent quarks including charm .
this is motivated by refs .
@xcite , where the authors propose to use photons to produce hidden - charm pentaquarks of the type that were reported by the lhcb collaboration in the @xmath6 channel @xcite . in the lhcb data , two structures were observed , the broader has a width of @xmath7 and mass @xmath8 , and the narrower has width @xmath9 and mass @xmath10 .
the preferred spin - parity assignment of these structures is that of @xmath11 or @xmath12 and opposite parities .
here we focus on the narrower structure , referred to as @xmath0 , since we expect the broad one to be more susceptible to variations in the analysis model used to describe the coherent background .
various interpretations of these structures have been proposed .
the possibility of a loosely - bound molecular state of charmed baryons and mesons was investigated in @xcite , while a resonance interpretation in terms of quark degrees of freedom was proposed in @xcite .
the possibility that these structures are nonresonant , for example due to the presence of nearby singularities in cross channels was discussed in @xcite ( for recent reviews on the exotic charmonium - like sector , see @xcite ) .
if the resonant nature holds , it would be the first time that a signature of a hidden - charm baryon state is found .
it is therefore important to look for other ways to produce the @xmath1 system near threshold @xcite .
for example , if a peak in the @xmath1 mass spectrum appears in photoproduction , the nonresonant interpretation of the lhcb result would be less likely . in this paper
we make a prediction for the @xmath2 photoproduction cross section measurement for the clas12 experiment at jlab .
we closely follow the arguments of @xcite , in particular for the application of vector - meson dominance ( vmd ) . to describe the baryon - resonance photoproduction we use the model of @xcite that was successfully applied in the past to the analysis of @xmath13 photo- and electroproduction in the exclusive @xmath14 channel .
compared to hadronic production , the exclusive @xmath3 photoproduction off protons is expected to have a large @xmath0 resonant contribution relative to the background .
furthermore , unlike the lhcb case , there is no third " particle in the final state that the @xmath1 system could rescatter from .
the existing photoproduction data @xcite mainly cover the range of photon energies above @xmath15 , _
i.e._well above the possible resonance signal , and it can be well understood as diffractive production .
the few data points in the energy range of interest @xcite have a mass resolution which is too low to identify a potential resonance signal .
the lhcb peak in photoproduction is expected in a photon energy range where the diffractive cross section is rather low and one can expect a clearly visible resonance peak .
the clas12 detector is replacing the clas apparatus in hall b at jlab and was optimized for measurements of nucleon resonances in electro- and photoproduction via decays to several exclusive meson - nucleon final states @xcite .
the excitation of the possible hidden charm resonance in the @xmath1 system requires photons with energies up to @xmath16 , and the identification of the resonance involves partial wave analysis . therefore the measurement of the differential cross section and spin - density matrix elements would be desired
. the cross section measurement will be possible with the data from the forward tagger built into the new clas12 detector . ultimately , if the resonance signal is found , it would be of interest to extend the present study to @xmath1 electroproduction , to investigate its internal structure .
the @xmath2-polarization information is currently not feasible with clas12 without muon detection capability , but if the signal is found it would be a good candidate for a detector upgrade .
the nonresonant background is modeled by an effective pomeron exchange ( a ) while the resonant contribution of the @xmath0 in the direct channel ( b ) is modeled by a breit - wigner amplitude.,title="fig : " ] [ fjpsiblob ] photoproduction .
the nonresonant background is modeled by an effective pomeron exchange ( a ) while the resonant contribution of the @xmath0 in the direct channel ( b ) is modeled by a breit - wigner amplitude.,title="fig : " ] [ fjpsipc ] the processes contributing to @xmath17 are shown in fig .
[ fjpsiprod ] .
the nonresonant background is expected to be dominated by the @xmath18-channel pomeron exchange , and we saturate the @xmath19-channel by the @xmath0 resonance . in the following
we consider only the most favored @xmath20 and @xmath21 spin - parity assignments for the resonance .
we adopt the usual normalization conventions @xcite , and express the differential cross section in terms of the helicity amplitudes @xmath22 , @xmath23 here , @xmath24 and @xmath25 are the incoming and outgoing center - of - mass frame momenta , respectively , @xmath26 is the center - of - mass scattering angle , and @xmath27 is the invariant mass .
note that the electric charge @xmath28 is explicitly factored out from the matrix element .
the contribution of the @xmath0 resonance is parametrized using the breit - wigner ansatz @xcite , @xmath29 the numerator is given by the product of photo - excitation and hadronic decay helicity amplitudes .
the measured width is narrow enough to be approximated with a constant , @xmath30 .
the angular momentum conservation restricts the sum over @xmath31 , the spin projection along the beam direction in the center of mass frame , to @xmath32 .
the hadronic helicity amplitude @xmath33 , which represents the decay of the resonance of spin @xmath34 to the @xmath1 state , is given by @xmath35 where @xmath36 are the helicity couplings between the resonance and the final state .
there are three independent couplings with @xmath37 , @xmath38 , being the other three related by parity . for simplicity ,
we assume all these couplings to be equal , _
i.e._@xmath39 . the helicity amplitudes and the partial decay width @xmath40 are related by @xmath41 with @xmath42 being the branching ratio of @xmath43 and @xmath44 the momentum @xmath25 evaluated at the resonance peak .
we assume that the @xmath0 decay is dominated by the lowest partial wave , with angular momentum @xmath45 for @xmath46 and @xmath47 for @xmath48 .
we recall that the following near - threshold behavior of the helicity amplitudes holds : @xmath49 .
the helicity matrix elements of @xmath50 are usually parametrized in terms of two independent coupling constants , @xmath51 and @xmath52 , which are related to the matrix elements with @xmath53 , respectively .
the other two helicities @xmath54 and @xmath55 are constrained by parity . using the standard normalization convention , in which the helicity couplings @xmath56 have units of @xmath57 and are proportional to the unit electromagnetic charge , @xmath58 with @xmath59 the momentum @xmath24 evaluated at the resonance peak .
the electromagnetic decay width @xmath60 is given by @xmath61.\ ] ] the photon helicity amplitudes for a pentaquark are not known . to rely on data as much as possible , we start by following ref . @xcite and assume a vmd relation for the transverse vector - meson helicity amplitudes @xmath62 with @xmath63 being the @xmath3decay constant which is proportional to the electromagnetic current matrix elements , @xmath64 the decay constant is related to the @xmath2 wave function via the van royen - weisskopf relation , and can be estimated from the leptonic decay width of the @xmath65 , yielding @xmath66 .
finally , the vmd leads to @xmath67 with the factor @xmath68 due to the fact that in eq . only the transverse polarizations of the @xmath3contribute .
again , we use @xmath45 for @xmath46 and @xmath47 for @xmath48 . with the help of eqs . and
, one can constrain the size of the photocouplings .
[ flow ] [ flow60 ] [ flow120 ] .parameters of the fits with @xmath0 incorporated as a spin-@xmath69 resonance .
uncertainties in the parameters are provided at a 1@xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) cl except for the branching ratio @xmath42 , whose upper limits are provided at a @xmath72 cl .
the first line provides the smearing applied to the three lowest - energy experimental data points in fig .
[ flowlarge ] . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the most recent and accurate data for this reaction come from the zeus @xcite and h1 @xcite experiments , with a photon energy in the laboratory frame @xmath73 .
we use the data points with @xmath74 to constrain the pomeron parameters .
for the low - energy region , we use data from camerini _ et al . _
@xcite , collected at slac , that cover the @xmath75 energy range .
to further constrain the fit , we consider the two lowest - energy data points shown in slac preprints @xcite , right across the pentaquark peak . in total , we consider 137 @xmath76 data points for the @xmath77 differential cross sections , with @xmath78 gev@xmath79 , covering energy ranges from threshold to @xmath80 in the lab frame . to compare with the data it is necessary to consider effects of experimental resolution , mainly due to the uncertainty in photon energy .
we introduce a smearing in the calculation of the observables , by convoluting the theoretical cross section with a gaussian distribution @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the smearing . the convolution is then given by introducing this function into @xmath83 where @xmath84 is the photon energy in the laboratory frame .
all the parameters of the model are treated as free parameters in our fits , _
i.e. _ , the @xmath85 branching ratio @xmath42 and the pomeron parameters : @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 . only the three lowest - energy data with @xmath91 ( see fig .
[ flowlarge ] ) have been smeared with the experimental resolution .
the mean value of the parameters and the uncertainties have been computed employing the bootstrap technique @xcite .
the bootstrap technique allows to take into account the correlations among parameters and to properly propagate their uncertainties to the observables @xcite .
the procedure is as follows .
first we explored the parameter space with @xmath92 fits using minuit @xcite in order to identify the region where the absolute minimum lies .
the staring values of the parameters were randomly selected in a very wide range .
once the parameter - space region where the absolute minimum lies has been identified , we use this information to randomly seed the starting values of the parameters for our fits .
we generate @xmath93 data sets for each one of the two @xmath94 options ( @xmath95 and @xmath21 ) and three smearings ( @xmath96 , and @xmath97 mev ) by randomly sampling the experimental points and the pentaquark mass and width according to their uncertainties .
the mass of the @xmath0 ( @xmath98 mev ) is sampled according to a gaussian distribution , while the width , in order to avoid negative values , is sampled according to a gamma distribution @xmath99 where @xmath100 mev is the pentaquark width and @xmath101 mev its uncertainty .
the experimental data point with the lowest photon energy and @xmath91 ( see figs . [ flowlarge ] and [ flowall ] ) is also sampled according to a gamma distribution to avoid a negative value of the differential cross section , while the rest of the experimental data points are sampled according to gaussian distributions . for each data
set , an independent maximum likelihood fit is performed using minuit @xcite . for each smearing option , once the @xmath93 data sets have been fitted , we can extract the best @xmath71 fits , whose mean value for each parameter provides the best values reported in tables [ tab : spin32parameters ] and [ tab : spin52parameters ] and the upper and lower values for each parameter provide the uncertainties .
with this set of parameters that correspond to @xmath102 confidence level ( cl ) we can compute each observable and its uncertainty @xcite . computing quantities at a any other cl ( _ e.g. _ @xmath103 ) can be achieved in the same way , given that enough fits are computed .
figure [ flowall ] shows the results of the fits for the different smearing parameters we also show the high - energy data compared to our fit result for the case of no smearing in fig .
[ fhighall ] .
since there are no data for the resonance peak and there is no known lower limit for the branching fraction , the mean values of the parameters are naturally consistent with the non existence of the @xmath0 .
we find that the upper limit for the branching ratio @xmath42 at a 95% cl ranges from @xmath104 to @xmath105 for @xmath11 , depending on the experimental resolution , and from @xmath106 to @xmath107 for @xmath12 .
the resulting hadronic couplings , as well as the photocouplings , are summarized in table [ tabresparams ] .
it is worth noting that @xmath86 is highly correlated with @xmath87 , @xmath88 and @xmath90 are also highly correlated , and that @xmath89 is correlated with @xmath86 and @xmath90 .
@xmath42 is equally correlated with all the parameters .
[ fhighold ] [ fhighnew ] it is possible that a structure at @xmath108 had indeed not been seen in the past , because of the finite resolution as the peak strength decreases and becomes broader and flatter .
its detection requires finer energy binning .
the peak is expected to be narrow , falling in between two bins where data is available .
therefore , it is important to perform an energy scan in this region to confirm the existence of the resonance .
while there are no data on the angular dependence near threshold yet , we can make a few predictions based on the model presented above . in order to be able to do a deeper study of this dependence ,
we now relax the vmd condition and let the relative sizes of the photocouplings vary .
as expected , the results depend on the relative size of the helicity amplitudes , as shown in fig .
[ fdiffcostheo ] for three different cases @xmath109 , @xmath110 , and @xmath111 , while maintaining the sum of the squares @xmath112 constant .
pronounced differences in the predicted angular distributions under different assignments for the @xmath0 photocouplings and spins demonstrate the prospect of determining these quantities from the future experimental data on @xmath3 photoproduction cross sections measured with clas12 in the near - threshold region . finally , we discuss the results for the total cross section , shown in fig .
[ ftot ] for the two possible spin assignments @xmath69 and @xmath113 , and the different experimental resolutions shown in tabs .
[ tab : spin32parameters ] to [ tabresparams ] .
the resonant piece of the resulting cross section is consistent with the one predicted by ref .
@xcite when taking the same spin and branching - ratio assumptions : @xmath11 and @xmath114 .
we studied the possibility of observing the @xmath0 resonance in @xmath2 photoproduction at clas12 .
the data available in this energy range are scarce and there is no measurement of the differential cross section .
we tested the compatibility of the data and a simple two - component model containing the directly produced resonance and a diffractive background .
we conclude that , the resonance peak being narrow enough , it could have escaped detection due to poor energy resolution . from the fits to the available @xmath2 photoproduction data ,
we show that the magnitude of the peak for the @xmath0 resonance can range from very strong to barely visible .
our results demonstrate the possibility to observe the @xmath0 resonance and to determine its spin and photocouplings .
therefore , the future data on @xmath2 photoproduction off protons measured in the near threshold region with a quasi - real photon beam at jlab will allow us to explore photoexcitation of the @xmath0 state suggested by lhcb data .
we made a prediction for the angular distribution which can be used to disentangle the spin of the resonance and helicity dependence of the resonance production .
if the resonance signal is found , photon - virtuality dependence can be used to investigate the resonance structure .
this material is based upon work supported in part by the u.s .
department of energy , office of science , office of nuclear physics under contracts de - ac05 - 06or23177 and de - fg0287er40365 , national science foundation under grants phy-1415459 and nsf - phy-1205019 , and iu collaborative research grant .
this work was also supported by the spanish ministerio de economa y competitividad ( mineco ) and
european feder funds under contract no .
fis2014 - 51948-c2 - 2-p and sev-2014 - 0398 .
anhb acknowledges support from the santiago grisola program of the generalitat valenciana and from the center for exploration of energy and matter at indiana university .
r. aaij _ et al._(lhcb collaboration ) , phys .
* 115 * , 072001 ( 2015 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1507.03414[arxiv:1507.03414 [ hep - ex ] ] ] ; unresolved structures also appear in the cabibbo suppressed channel , r. aaij _ et al._(lhcb collaboration ) http://arxiv.org/abs/1604.05708[arxiv:1604.05708 [ hep - ex ] ] .
h. x. chen , w. chen , x. liu , and s. l. zhu , phys .
rept . * 639 * , 1 ( 2016 ) [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1601.02092[arxiv:1601.02092 [ hep - ph ] ] ] ; a. esposito , a. l. guerrieri , f. piccinini , a. pilloni , and a. d. polosa , int .
j. mod .
a * 30 * , 1530002 ( 2015 ) [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1411.5997[arxiv:1411.5997 [ hep - ph ] ] ] .
v. i. mokeev _ et al._(clas collaboration ) , phys .
c * 86 * , 035203 ( 2012 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1205.3948[arxiv:1205.3948 [ nucl - ex ] ] ] ; v. i. mokeev , i. aznauryan , v. burkert , and r. gothe , epj web conf . * 113 * , 01013 ( 2016 ) [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1508.04088[arxiv:1508.04088 [ nucl - ex ] ] ] .
i. g. aznauryan and v. d. burkert , prog .
* 67 * , 1 ( 2012 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1109.1720[arxiv:1109.1720 [ hep - ph ] ] ] ; i. g. aznauryan , v. d. burkert , t .- s .
h. lee , and v. i. mokeev , j. phys .
ser . * 299 * , 012008 ( 2011 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1102.0597[arxiv:1102.0597 [ nucl - ex ] ] ] ; v. d. burkert , int .
j. mod .
a * 26 * , 493 ( 2011 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/1008.2809[arxiv:1008.2809 [ nucl - ex ] ] ] ; v. d. burkert , prog . part .
. phys . *
55 * , 108 ( 2005 ) ; v. d. burkert and t .- s .
h. lee , int .
j. mod .
e * 13 * , 108 ( 2004 ) , [ http://arxiv.org/abs/nucl-ex/0407020[nucl-ex/0407020 ] ] ; v. i. mokeev _ et al .
_ , phys .
c * 93 * , 025206 ( 2016 ) .
v. n. gribov , y. l. dokshitzer , and j. nyiri , _ strong interactions of hadrons at high energies _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 2009 ) ; v.n .
gribov , _ the theory of complex angular momenta _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england , 2003 ) . | a resonance - like structure , the @xmath0 , has recently been observed in the @xmath1 spectrum by the lhcb collaboration .
we discuss the feasibility of detecting this structure in @xmath2 photoproduction in the clas12 experiment at jlab .
we present a first estimate of the upper limit for the branching ratio of the @xmath0 to @xmath1 .
our estimates , which take into account the experimental resolution effects , predict that it will be possible to observe a sizable cross section close to the @xmath3 production threshold and shed light on the @xmath0 resonance in the future photoproduction measurements . |
exo 0748676 is an intensively studied low - mass x - ray binary that was initially discovered with the european x - ray observatory satellite ( _ exosat _ ) in 1985 february @xcite .
however , in retrospect the source already appeared active in _ exosat _
slew survey observations several times beginning 1984 july @xcite , whereas the earliest detection dates back to 1980 may , when exo 0748676 was serendipitously observed with the _ einstein _ satellite @xcite .
the system exhibits irregular x - ray dips and displays eclipses that last for @xmath4 min and recur every 3.82 hr , which allow the unambiguous determination of the orbital period of the binary @xcite .
the detection of type - i x - ray bursts ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) conclusively identify the compact primary as a neutron star .
a few x - ray bursts have been observed that exhibited photospheric radius expansion ( pre ) , which indicates that the eddington luminosity is reached near the burst peak and allows for a distance estimate towards the source @xcite . for a helium - dominated photosphere ,
a distance of @xmath5 kpc can be derived , while assuming solar composition results in a distance estimate of @xmath6 kpc @xcite .
the rise time and duration of the pre bursts observed from exo 0748676 suggest pure helium ignition , rendering 7.4 kpc as the best distance estimate @xcite , although this value is subject to several uncertainties @xcite . at the time of its discovery , exo 0748676
was detected at 210 kev luminosities of @xmath7 @xcite .
however , during the _ einstein _ observation of 1980 , several years prior to the _ exosat _ detections , it displayed a 0.510 kev luminosity of @xmath8 @xcite .
the source can therefore be classified as a transient x - ray binary .
nevertheless , such systems typically exhibit accretion outbursts that last only weeks to months ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , whereas exo 0748676 was persistently detected at luminosities of @xmath9 by various satellites for over 24 years .
similar prolonged accretion episodes continuing for years to decades have been observed for a few other systems , which are termed quasi - persistent x - ray binaries ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) . in 2008
september , observations with the proportional counter array ( pca ) onboard the _ rossi x - ray timing explorer _
( _ rxte _ ) and _ swift _ s x - ray telescope ( xrt ) indicated that the x - ray flux of exo 0748676 was declining @xcite .
optical and near - ir observations of the optical counterpart , uy vol , performed in 2008 october showed that the optical emission had also faded compared to the brighter x - ray state @xcite .
these events indicated that the accretion was ceasing and that the system was transitioning from outburst to quiescence .
this is also illustrated by fig .
[ fig : asm ] , which displays the x - ray lightcurve of exo 0748676 as observed with the all - sky monitor ( asm ) onboard _ rxte _ since 1996 .
the decrease in source activity is clearly seen around @xmath10 days .
chandra _ observations carried out in 2008 mid - october ( i.e. , after the transition to quiescence started ) revealed an x - ray spectrum composed of a soft , thermal component joined by a hard powerlaw tail that dominates the spectrum above @xmath11 kev ( * ? ? ?
* see also section [ subsec : spectraldata ] ) .
this is frequently seen for neutron star x - ray binaries in quiescence ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the non - thermal component is usually well - fitted by a simple powerlaw with index 12 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
the fractional contribution of the hard powerlaw tail to the 0.510 kev x - ray flux widely varies amongst sources and possibly also with changing luminosity @xcite .
the physical process that is responsible for the powerlaw spectral component remains elusive ( see e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
although the soft spectral component has been ascribed to low - level accretion @xcite , it is most often interpreted as thermal surface radiation from the cooling neutron star @xcite . according to this model
, the accretion of matter compresses the neutron star crust , which induces a series of electron captures , neutron emissions and pycnonuclear fusion reactions ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the heat energy released in these processes is spread over the neutron star via thermal conduction .
the neutron star cools primarily via neutrino emissions from the stellar core , as well as photon radiation from the surface .
the former depends on the equation of state of cold nuclear matter and the central density of the neutron star ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the neutron star core reaches a thermal steady state in @xmath12 years , yielding an incandescent emission from the neutron star surface set by the time - averaged accretion rate of the system , as well as the rate of neutrino emissions from the stellar core ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
when combined with estimates of the outburst history , observations of quiescent neutron stars can constrain the rate of neutrino emissions , thereby providing insight into the interior properties of the neutron star ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
once the steady state is reached , the neutron star core temperature will not change appreciably during a single outburst , but the temperature of the crust can be dramatically altered . in regular transients that have a typical outburst duration of weeks to months , the crustal heating processes will only cause a slight increase in the crust temperature @xcite
. however , in quasi - persistent x - ray binaries the prolonged accretion episodes can cause a significant temperature gradient between the neutron star crust and core .
once the accretion ceases , the crust is expected to thermally relax on a time scale of years , until equilibrium with the core is re - established @xcite . during the initial stages of the quiescent phase the thermal emission
will therefore be dominated by the cooling crust , whereas eventually a quiescent base level is reached that is set by the thermal state of the core @xcite .
this provides the special opportunity to separately probe the properties of the neutron star crust @xcite . in 2001 , the neutron star x - ray binaries ks 1731260 and mxb 165929 both made the transition to quiescence , following accretion episodes of 12.5 and 2.5 years , respectively @xcite .
more recently , in 2007 , the @xmath13-year long outburst of xte j1701462 came to a halt @xcite .
all three systems were subsequently monitored with _
chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ , which revealed that thermal flux and neutron star temperature were gradually decreasing over the course of years ( see also section [ sec : discussion ] ) .
this can be interpreted as cooling of the neutron star crust that has been heated during the prolonged accretion outburst .
successful modelling of the observed quiescent x - ray lightcurves with neutron star thermal evolution models supports this hypothesis and provides important constraints on the crust properties , such as the thermal conductivity @xcite . along these lines
we have pursued an observational campaign of exo 0748676 to study the time evolution of the quiescent x - ray emission following its long accretion outburst . in @xcite
, we discussed _
chandra _ and
_ swift _ observations obtained between 2008 september 28 and 2009 january 30 .
we found a relatively hot and luminous quiescent system with a temperature of @xmath14 kev and a thermal 0.01100 kev luminosity of @xmath15 .
no clear decrease in effective temperature and thermal bolometric flux was found over the five - month time span . in this paper
we report on continued _ swift _ and _ chandra _ observations of exo 0748676 during its quiescent state .
in addition , we include an archival _ xmm - newton _ observation performed @xmath16 months after the cessation of the outburst .
chandra _ and
_ swift _
observations discussed by @xcite were re - analysed in this work in order to obtain a homogeneous quiescent lightcurve .
table [ tab : obs ] gives an overview of all new observations of exo 0748676 discussed in this paper .
a list of earlier _ chandra _ and _ swift _ observations obtained during the quiescent phase can be found in @xcite
. .observation log .
[ cols= " < , < , < , < " , ] [ tab : spec ] note .
the observations marked by a dagger were already discussed in @xcite , but re - fitted in this work .
these results were obtained by using a combined absorbed nsatmos and powerlaw model , where @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 km , @xmath20 kpc and @xmath21 were kept fixed .
the quoted errors represent 90 percent confidence levels .
@xmath22 represents the 0.510 kev total model flux and @xmath23 gives the 0.01100 kev nsatmos flux ; both are unabsorbed and in units of @xmath24 .
@xmath25 gives the 0.01100 kev luminosity of the nsatmos model component in units of @xmath26 and assuming a source distance of d=7.4 kpc .
@xmath27 represents the time interval of the observations in days and the fractional powerlaw contribution is given in a percentage of the total unabsorbed 0.510 kev flux .
as discussed in section [ subsec : spectraldata ] , the quiescent spectrum of exo 0748676 can be described by a combination of a neutron star atmosphere model and a non - thermal powerlaw tail .
we fitted the _
chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ data simultaneously within xspec to a combined nsatmos and powerlaw model subject to interstellar absorption , to explore the best - fit values for the neutron star mass and radius , source distance and hydrogen column density .
we include the first set of _ chandra _ observations obtained in 2008 october ( discussed in * ? ? ?
* ) in the analysis .
as before , we use the phabs model with the default xspec abundances and cross - sections to take into account the neutral hydrogen absorption along the line of sight . the powerlaw index is fixed to @xmath21 ( the best fit - value obtained from _ xmm - newton _ observations ; see section [ subsec : spectraldata ] ) , because there are not sufficient counts at higher energies in the _ chandra _ spectra to allow this component to vary .
the powerlaw normalisation is left as a free parameter .
if the neutron star mass and radius are fixed to canonical values of @xmath18 and @xmath28 km , and in addition the source distance is fixed to @xmath20 kpc , the hydrogen column density pegs at its lower limit ( @xmath29 ) . when the distance is left to vary freely ,
the best - fit value is @xmath30 kpc , which is just outside the range obtained from x - ray burst analysis ( 58.3 kpc ; * ? ? ?
therefore , we choose to keep the distance fixed at 7.4 kpc , and instead allow the neutron star radius to vary .
this way , we obtain best - fit values of @xmath31 and @xmath32 km .
if additionally the neutron star mass is left free to vary in the fit , this parameter is not strongly constrained ( @xmath33 ) . in the final fits we choose to fix the neutron star mass to @xmath34 , because otherwise the uncertainty in this quantity will dominate the errors of the other parameters . for the final spectral analysis
, we fit all _ xmm - newton _ ,
_ chandra _ and _ swift _ data with an absorbed nsatmos plus powerlaw model , where @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 km , @xmath20 kpc and @xmath21 are fixed , while the neutron star effective temperature is left as a free parameter .
the powerlaw normalisation is left to vary freely for the _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ observations , but fixed for the _ swift _ data ( so that this component contributes 10 percent to the total unabsorbed 0.510 kev flux ) .
we fit all data in the 0.510 kev energy range and deduce the absorbed and unabsorbed fluxes in this band .
the thermal model fit is extrapolated to the energy range of 0.01100 kev to estimate the thermal bolometric flux .
the results from fitting the x - ray spectra in this way are presented in table [ tab : spec ] .
the effective temperatures and thermal bolometric fluxes derived from _
chandra _ ,
_ swift _ and _ xmm - newton _ data are displayed in fig .
[ fig : temp ] . examination of fig .
[ fig : temp ] suggests that there is a small but discernible offset in the thermal flux and neutron star temperature as deduced from the different satellites .
this is briefly discussed in section [ subsec : crosscal ] . ) .
, width=302 ] fig .
[ fig : temp ] clearly reveals a decaying trend in thermal flux and temperature . to investigate the decay shape
, we fit the temperature curve with an exponential decay function of the form @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is a normalisation constant , @xmath37 is the start time of the cooling curve and @xmath38 the e - folding time . given the apparent offset between the different instruments ( see section [ subsec : crosscal ] ) , we perform different fits to the _ chandra _ and _ swift _ data .
we fix @xmath37 to 2009 september 5 ( mjd 54714 ) , which is in between the first non - detection by _ rxte_/pca and the first _ swift_/xrt observation of the source @xcite . the simple exponential decay , represented by the dotted lines in fig . [ fig : temp_chanfit ] , yields an e - folding time of @xmath39 days for the _ chandra _ data , but does not provide a good fit ( @xmath40 for 2 d.o.f . ) .
for the _ swift _ lightcurve we find @xmath41 days ( @xmath42 for 12 d.o.f . ) .
if we include a constant offset ( i.e. , @xmath43 ; solid lines in fig . [ fig : temp_chanfit ] ) , we obtain a better fit for the _ chandra _ data , yielding a normalisation of @xmath44 ev , an e - folding decay time of @xmath45 days and a constant offset of @xmath46 ev ( @xmath47 for 1 d.o.f . ) . for the _ swift _ data we find @xmath48 ev , @xmath49 days and @xmath50 ev ( @xmath51 for 11 d.o.f . ) , which is consistent with the _ chandra _ fit .
although an exponential decay provides an adequate description of the data of exo 0748676 , as has been found for other sources ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , mathematically a neutron star crust is expected to cool via a ( broken ) powerlaw @xcite .
if we fit a single powerlaw of the form @xmath52 to the _ chandra _ data , we find an index of @xmath53 and a normalisation of @xmath54 ev ( @xmath55 for 2 d.o.f . ) .
for the _ swift _
observations we find @xmath56 and @xmath57 ev ( @xmath58 for 12 d.o.f . ) .
these powerlaw fits are indicated by the dashed lines in fig .
[ fig : temp_chanfit ] .
a broken powerlaw also yields an acceptable fit to the _ swift _ data ( @xmath59 for 10 d.o.f . ) .
we find a normalisation of @xmath60 ev , a break at @xmath61 days and decay indices of @xmath62 and @xmath63 before and after the break , respectively .
this fit is indicated by the dashed - dotted curve in fig .
[ fig : temp_chanfit ] .
there are not sufficient _ chandra _ observations to fit a broken powerlaw decay .
we note that the shape of the decay curve of exo 0748676 is not strongly affected by our choice of spectral parameters ( @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 ) or assumed distance ( see also previous studies by e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the quiescent lightcurve presented in fig .
[ fig : temp ] shows indications that the thermal flux and temperature inferred from the _ chandra _ observations lie below the trend of the _ swift _ data points .
this possible shift ( @xmath68 percent for the flux lightcurve ) may be due to cross - calibration issues between the two satellites .
a study of the crab nebula indeed revealed an offset between _ chandra _ and _ swift _ , whereas such a discrepancy was not found between _ swift _ and _ xmm - newton _
this might be reflected in our results as well , since the _ xmm - newton _ data point appears to line up with the trend indicated by the _
swift _ data .
however , our _ chandra _ and _ swift _
data points may also be ( partly ) offset due to the fact that we can not constrain the powerlaw component in the _ swift _ data , which we therefore fixed to contribute @xmath69 percent of the total 0.510 kev unabsorbed flux ( see section [ subsec : spectraldata ] ) .
we discuss _ chandra _ , _ swift _ and _ xmm - newton _ observations obtained after the cessation of the very long ( @xmath7024 year ) active period of exo 0748676 .
fitting the spectral data with a neutron star atmosphere model nsatmos , did not reveal clear indications of a changing thermal spectrum during the first five months of the quiescent phase @xcite .
however , now that the quiescent monitoring has extended to 19 months ( 1.6 years ) , we find a significant decrease in neutron star effective temperature from @xmath71 to @xmath3 ev .
the thermal bolometric flux was observed to decay from @xmath72 to @xmath73 .
in addition to a soft , thermal component , the _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ observations show evidence for a hard powerlaw tail with index @xmath21 .
the fractional contribution of the hard spectral component to the total unabsorbed 0.510 kev flux initially decreased from @xmath74 percent in 2008 october to @xmath75 percent in 2009 june .
however , observations carried out in 2010 april suggest that the powerlaw fraction increased again to @xmath76 percent .
similar behaviour has been observed for several other quiescent neutron star systems @xcite , although others show more irregular behaviour @xcite . in cen x-4
, the powerlaw tail in the quiescent spectrum shows variations that appear to be linked to changes in the thermal component , possibly caused by low - level accretion @xcite . the gradual decrease in thermal flux and neutron star temperature observed for exo 0748676
can be interpreted as the neutron star crust cooling down in quiescence after it has been heated during its long accretion outburst .
[ fig : sources ] compares our data of exo 0748676 with the crust cooling curves observed for the neutron star x - ray binaries ks 1731260 , mxb 165929 and xte j1701462 .
this plot shows that the amount of cooling following the end of the outburst is markedly smaller for exo 0748676 than for the other three sources . we have observed our target over the first 19 months after the cessation of the outburst and during this time the thermal bolometric flux has decreased by a factor of @xmath77 . in a similar time span ,
the thermal bolometric fluxes of ks 1731260 , mxb 165929 and xte j1701462 had decreased by a factor of @xmath78 , 6 and 2.5 , respectively ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) .
the effective neutron star temperature of exo 0748676 has decreased by about 10 percent , compared to @xmath79 , 40 and 20 percent for ks 1731260 , mxb 165929 and xte j1701462 .
although the observed fractional changes in neutron star temperature and thermal bolometric flux are smaller for exo 0748676 than for the other three sources , the decay itself may not be markedly different .
the quiescent lightcurves of ks 1731260 , mxb 165929 and xte j1701462 can be fit with an exponential decay function levelling off to a constant value , yielding e - folding times of @xmath80 , @xmath81 and @xmath82 days , respectively @xcite . for the _ chandra _ data of exo 0748676 , we find an e - folding time of @xmath83 days ( see section [ subsec : decay ] ) .
these decay times provide a measure of the thermal relaxation time of the neutron star crust , which depends on the composition and structure of the lattice , the distribution of heating sources and the thickness of the crust ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
@xcite and @xcite calculate theoretical cooling curves for ks 1731260 , assuming different physics for the crust and core .
these authors present simulations for both an amorphous crust and an ordered crystalline lattice . for the latter ,
the spread of nuclide charge numbers ( @xmath84 ) in the crust matter is small , which is referred to as a low level of impurities and results in a highly conductive crust .
a large number of impurities gives an amorphous structure , which affects the thermal properties of the crust and results in a low conductivity .
in addition , @xcite explore standard ( i.e. , slow ) and enhanced neutrino cooling mechanisms , yielding different core temperatures . comparing our results on exo 0748676 with the decay shapes resulting from those calculations suggests that the neutron star has a highly conductive crust , similar to what has been inferred for the other three sources @xcite .
the fact that the decay curve of exo 0748676 is rather shallow may be explained in terms of a relatively small temperature gradient and thus lower thermal flux across the core - crust boundary ( cf .
the model curves for a highly conductive crust and different core temperatures presented by * ? ? ?
. this can be due to a combination of a warm neutron star core and a relatively low mass - accretion rate during outburst .
the exponential decay fit to the _ chandra _ data of exo 0748676 indicates that the neutron star crust might already be close to restoring equilibrium with the core .
the fit results in a quiescent base level of @xmath85 ev , while we found a temperature of @xmath86 ev for the observation performed in 2010 april .
prior to its last outburst , exo 0748676 was observed in quiescence with the _ einstein _
observatory , displaying a 0.510 kev unabsorbed flux of @xmath87 @xcite .
our _ chandra _ observations of 2010 april detected exo 0748676 at a 0.510 kev unabsorbed flux of @xmath88 ( see table [ tab : spec ] ) . assuming that the _ einstein _ detection caught exo 0748676 at its quiescent base level , this supports the idea that the crust has nearly cooled down .
this would imply that the neutron star core in exo 0748676 is relatively hot ( cf .
* ) , suggesting that either standard cooling mechanisms are operating and that the neutron star is not very massive , or that the time - averaged mass - accretion rate of the system is very high due to a short recurrence time ( see below ) .
the energy deposited during outburst is given by @xmath89 ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
, @xmath90 mev is the nuclear energy deposited per accreted baryon @xcite , @xmath91 is the atomic mass unit and @xmath92 is the time - averaged accretion rate of the system .
the latter can be expressed as @xmath93 , where @xmath94 is the average accretion rate during outburst episodes , @xmath95 is the outburst duration and @xmath96 is the system s recurrence time .
the factor @xmath97 represents the duty cycle of the system .
the neutron star core is expected to be in a steady state , in which the energy radiated during quiescence balances the heat deposited during outburst .
we can thus obtain an estimate of the duty cycle of exo 0748676 by equating the heating and cooling rates .
a neutron star cools primarily via photon radiation from the surface and neutrino emissions from the stellar core . if the lightcurve of exo 0748676 has indeed ( nearly ) levelled off , the bolometric luminosity emitted as photons is thus @xmath98 ( as measured during the _ chandra _ observation of 2010 april ) .
the rate of neutrino emissions depends on the temperature of the neutron star core , which can be estimated from the effective surface temperature once the crust has thermally relaxed . a quiescent base level of @xmath99 ev ( as suggested by exponential decay fits to the _ chandra _ data ) , implies an effective surface temperature in the neutron star frame of @xmath100 ev ( @xmath101 k ) , for a canonical values of @xmath18 and @xmath28 km ( i.e. , @xmath102 ) . using the relation between the effective surface temperature and the interior temperature calculated by @xcite , yields @xmath103 k. for such a core temperature , the minimum energy escaping the neutron star as neutrino s ( i.e. , assuming standard core cooling ) is @xmath104 @xcite .
equating the energy losses via photon radiation from the neutron star surface ( @xmath105 ) and neutrino emissions from the stellar core ( @xmath106 ) with the energy gained via crustal reactions during outburst ( @xmath107 ) , suggests that exo 0748676 must have a time - averaged mass - accretion rate of @xmath108 . during outburst ,
exo 0748676 displayed an average bolometric luminosity of @xmath109 @xcite . assuming that the accretion luminosity is given by @xmath110 , this translates into a mass - accretion rate during outburst of @xmath111 for a canonical neutron star with @xmath112 and @xmath113 km .
if the crust has indeed thermally relaxed , the above estimates show that exo 0748676 must have a duty cycle of @xmath114 percent to explain the observed quiescent bolometric luminosity of @xmath115 in terms of thermal emission from the cooling neutron star ( i.e. , opposed to continued accretion ) .
the outburst of exo 0748676 started between 1980 may and 1984 july and the system returned to quiescence in 2008 september , i.e. , @xmath116 years .
if the observed outburst is typical for the long - term behaviour of this source , the expected recurrence time is thus @xmath117 years . in case
the neutron star cools via more efficient core neutrino emission processes , the recurrence time required to explain the observed quiescent luminosity is shorter ( i.e. , the duty cycle is higher ) .
although the above calculation is only a crude approximation ( e.g. , there is a significant uncertainty in the relation between the surface- and interior temperature of the neutron star , depending on the atmospheric composition and the depth of the light element layer ; * ? ? ?
* ) , it illustrates that exo 0748676 must have a high duty cycle if the cooling curve has indeed reached its quiescent base level .
@xcite , @xcite and @xcite have suggested that exo 0748676 continues to accrete in quiescence , because the quiescent luminosity inferred from the 1980 _ einstein _ observation is higher than predicted by standard cooling models .
however , these conclusions are based on an assumed duty cycle of @xmath118 percent , but we have no a priori knowledge about this .
although we can not exclude that the system is indeed accreting in quiescence , the above estimates show that a duty cycle of @xmath114 percent can explain the observed quiescent level of exo 0748676 as being due to thermal emission from the cooling neutron star .
a duty cycle of @xmath114 percent is high , although not unprecedented for neutron star transients ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
recently , @xcite demonstrated that the cooling of a neutron star crust is expected to follow a broken powerlaw decay .
a break is predicted to occur due to a transition in the crystal structure of the crust matter , and the slope before the break reflects the heat flux from the outer crustal layers .
therefore , we also fitted the neutron star temperatures obtained for exo 0748676 to a powerlaw and found decay indices of @xmath119 and @xmath120 for the _ chandra _ and _ swift _ data sets , respectively .
the _ swift _
observations indicate that a possible break in the quiescent lightcurve may have occurred @xmath121 days after the cessation of the outburst ( see section [ subsec : decay ] ) . by fitting a broken powerlaw function
, we obtain a decay index of @xmath62 before the break , which steepens to @xmath63 thereafter .
however , since these slopes are consistent with being equal , further observations are required to confirm whether a break has indeed occurred .
the decay parameters that we find for exo 0748676 are comparable to that obtained by @xcite for xte j1701462 .
these authors found that the quiescent lightcurve breaks @xmath122 days post - outburst and report decay indices of @xmath123 and @xmath124 before and after the break , respectively .
@xcite note that possible cross - calibration effects between _ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ might introduce small shifts that also allow a single powerlaw decay with slope @xmath125 .
the cooling curves of ks 1731260 and mxb 165929 appear to have steeper decays with indices of @xmath126 and @xmath127 , respectively @xcite . due to the scarcity of data points
it is unclear whether a break occurred in the quiescent lightcurves of the latter two sources @xcite .
the powerlaw fits show no indications that the quiescent lightcurve of exo 0748676 is levelling off .
thus , it is also possible that the neutron star temperature continues to decay further and that the core is cooler than suggested by the exponential decay fits and the 1980 _ einstein _ detection . the relatively slow decrease of exo 0748676
might then reflect that the crust has a high conductivity , albeit lower than that of the neutron stars in ks 1731260 and mxb 165929 .
further observations are thus required to determine whether the neutron star crust in exo 0748676 has nearly cooled down and to be able to draw firm conclusions on the crust and core properties .
this work was supported by the netherlands organisation for scientific research ( nwo ) and made use of the _ swift _ public data archive .
we acknowledge _ swift _ pi n. gehrels and the _ swift _ planning team for their help in carrying out the too campaign .
emc was supported by nasa through the chandra fellowship program .
mtw , psr and ksw acknowledge the united states office of naval research .
jh and whgl acknowledge support from chandra grant go8 - 9045x .
p. a. , beardmore a. p. , page k. l. , tyler l. g. , osborne j. p. , goad m. r. , obrien p. t. , vetere l. , racusin j. , morris d. , burrows d. n. , capalbi m. , perri m. , gehrels n. , romano p. , 2007
, , 469 , 379 g. p. , bautz m. w. , ford p. g. , nousek j. a. , ricker jr .
g. r. , 2003 , in j. e. truemper & h. d. tananbaum ed . , society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series vol .
4851 of presented at the society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference , advanced ccd imaging spectrometer ( acis ) instrument on the chandra x - ray observatory .
pp 2844 p. g. , 2008 , in c. bassa , z. wang , a. cumming , & v. m. kaspi ed .
, 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more vol . 983 of american institute of physics conference
series , constraining the neutron star equation of state using quiescent low - mass x - ray binaries . | in late 2008 , the quasi - persistent neutron star x - ray transient and eclipsing binary exo 0748676 started a transition from outburst to quiescence , after it had been actively accreting for more than 24 years . in a previous work
, we discussed _
chandra _ and
_ swift _ observations obtained during the first five months after this transition . here
, we report on further x - ray observations of exo 0748676 , extending the quiescent monitoring to 1.6 years .
_ chandra _ and _ xmm - newton _ data reveal quiescent x - ray spectra composed of a soft , thermal component that is well - fitted by a neutron star atmosphere model . an additional hard powerlaw tail is detected that changes non - monotonically over time , contributing between 4 and 20 percent to the total unabsorbed 0.510 kev flux .
the combined set of _ chandra _ , _ xmm - newton _ and _ swift _
data reveals that the thermal bolometric luminosity fades from @xmath0 to @xmath1 , whereas the inferred neutron star effective temperature decreases from @xmath2 to @xmath3 ev .
we interpret the observed decay as cooling of the neutron star crust and show that the fractional quiescent temperature change of exo 0748676 is markedly smaller than observed for three other neutron star x - ray binaries that underwent prolonged accretion outbursts .
[ firstpage ] accretion , accretion disks - binaries : eclipsing - stars : individual ( exo 0748676 ) - stars : neutron - x - rays : binaries |
for the first decade of microlens planet detections , beginning with ogle-2003-blg-235 lb @xcite , the great majority of detections required a combination of survey and followup data .
this is a consequence of two effects .
first , the survey coverage was generally too sparse to characterize the planetary anomalies in the detected events @xcite .
second , thanks to aggressive alert capability , pioneered by the optical gravitational lensing experiment ( ogle ) early warning system ( ews , @xcite ) , it became possible to organize intensive followup of planet - sensitive events or even ongoing planetary anomalies and so obtain sufficient time resolution to detect and characterize the planets .
however , as surveys have become more powerful over the past decade , they have become increasingly capable of detecting planets without follow up observations .
that is , making use of larger cameras , the surveys are able to monitor fairly wide areas at cadences of up to several times per hour .
while still substantially lower than follow - up observations of the handful of events that were monitored by follow - up groups , this is still adequate to detect most planets ( provided that the anomalies occur when the survey is observing ) . very simple reasoning given below , which is supported by detailed simulations
@xcite , leads one to expect that the transition from survey+followup to survey - only mode implies a corresponding transition from planets detected primarily in high - magnification events via central and resonant caustics to planets primarily detected in lower magnification events via planetary caustics .
high - magnification events are intrinsically sensitive to planets because they probe the so - called `` central caustic '' that lies close to ( or overlays ) the position of the host @xcite .
planets that are separated from the hosts by substantially more ( less ) than the einstein radius generate one ( two ) other caustics that are typically much larger than the central caustic and thus have a higher cross section for anomalous deviations from a point - lens light curve due to a random source trajectory .
however , for high - magnification events , the source is by definition passing close to the host and hence close to or over the central caustic . for planet - host separations that are comparable to the einstein radius ,
the two sets of caustics merge into a single ( and larger ) `` resonant caustic '' , which is even more likely to generate anomalous deviations of a high - magnification event . for many years
, the microlensing follow up network ( @xmath3fun ) employed a strategy based on this high planet sensitivity of high - magnification events .
they made detailed analyses of alerts of ongoing events from the ogle and the microlensing observations in astrophysics ( moa ) teams to predict high - magnification events and then mobilized followup observations over the predicted peak .
@xcite showed that @xmath3fun was able to get substantial data over peak for about 50% of all identified events with maximum magnification @xmath4 , but that its success rate dropped off dramatically at lower magnification , i.e. , even for @xmath5 .
the reason for this drop off was fundamentally limited observing resources : there are twice as many events @xmath6 compared to @xmath4 , and monitoring the full - width half - maximum requires twice as much observing time .
hence , observations grow quadratically with effective magnification cutoff . by contrast , because planetary caustics are typically much larger than central caustics , most planets detected in survey - only mode are expected to be from anomalies generated by the former , which occur primarily in garden - variety ( rather than high - mag ) events @xcite . for example , @xcite detected a large planetary caustic in ogle-2012-blg-0406 based purely upon ogle data , while @xcite detected one in moa - bin-1 based mostly on moa data . in the latter case
it would have been completely impossible to discover the planet by survey+followup mode because the `` primary event '' ( due to the host ) was so weak that it was never detected in the data .
nevertheless , there has been a steady stream of survey - only detections of planets in high - magnification events as well .
the first of these was moa-2007-blg-192 lb , a magnification @xmath7 event , which required a combination of moa and ogle data @xcite .
the first planet detected by combining three surveys ( moa , ogle , wise ) , moa-2011-blg-322 lb , was also via a central caustic , although in this case the caustic was very large so that the magnification did not have to be extremely large @xmath8 @xcite . similarly , @xcite detected a large central caustic due to the large planet ogle-2015-blg-0954 lb despite modest peak magnification of the underlying event @xmath9 .
this case was notable because high - cadence data from the korea microlensing telescope network ( kmtnet ) captured the caustic entrance despite the extremely short source self - crossing time , @xmath10min .
kmtnet is still in the process of testing its reduction pipeline .
motivated by the above experience , the kmtnet team focused its tests on high - magnification events identified as such on the ogle web page .
in addition to exposing the reduction algorithms to a wide range of brightnesses , this testing has the added advantage that there is a high probability to find planets . here
we report on the first planet found by these tests from among the first seven high - mag events that were examined : ogle-2016-blg-(0261,0353,0471,0528,0572,0596,0612 ) .
these events were chosen to have model point - lens magnifications @xmath11 and modeled peak times @xmath12 .
the lower limit was set by the beginning of the kmtnet observing season and the upper limit was the time of the last ogle update when the seven events were selected .
on 2016 april 8 ut 12:15 ( hjd@xmath13 hjd@xmath14 ) , ogle alerted the community to a new microlensing event ogle-2016-blg-0596 based on observations with the 1.4 deg@xmath15 camera on its 1.3 m warsaw telescope at the las campanas observatory in chile @xcite using its ews real - time event detection software @xcite .
most observations were in @xmath16 band , but with some @xmath17 band observations that are , in general , taken for source characterization .
these @xmath17-band data are not used in the modeling . at equatorial coordinates ( 17:51:12.81 , @xmath18:50:59.4 ) and galactic coordinates @xmath19
, this event lies in ogle field blg534 , with an observing cadence during the period of the anomaly of roughly 0.4 per hour .
kmtnet employs three @xmath20 cameras mounted on 1.6 m telescopes at ctio / chile , saao / south africa , and sso / australia @xcite . in 2015
kmtnet had concentrated observations on 4 fields . however , in 2016 , this strategy was radically modified to cover ( 12 , 40 , 80 ) @xmath21 at cadences of @xmath22 . for the three highest - cadence fields ,
kmtnet observations are alternately offset by about @xmath23 in order to ensure coverage of events in gaps between chips . as a result
, ogle-2016-blg-0596 lies in two slightly offset fields blg01 and blg41 , which are each observed at a cadence 2 per hour .
kmtnet observes primarily in @xmath16 band , but 1/11 observations from ctio and 1/21 observations from saao are in @xmath17-band .
reductions of the primary data were made using difference image analysis ( dia ) @xcite .
however , due to issues discussed in section 3 , special variants of dia were developed specifically for this event .
see below .
kmt ctio @xmath17 and @xmath16 images were , in addition , reduced using dophot @xcite , solely for the purpose of determining the source color .
the ogle-2016-blg-0596 light curve shows clear variability over the course of 6 seasons of ogle - iv data prior to 2016 . this variability is roughly consistent with being sinusoidal at period @xmath24 days .
see figure [ fig : one ] . while the semi - amplitude of the variability is only @xmath25 of the baseline flux @xmath26 , this semi - amplitude turns out to be roughly equal to the source flux derived from the model . assuming ( as proves to be the case ) that it is not the source itself that is variable , such low level variability can not significantly impact characterization of the anomalous features of the lightcurve because they are at relatively high magnification and take place on much shorter timescales .
however , if not properly accounted for , such variability can seriously impact the estimate of the source flux and , as a direct consequence of this , the einstein timescale @xmath27 here @xmath28 is the angular einstein radius , @xmath29 is the lens - source relative parallax , and @xmath3 is the lens - source relative proper motion in the earth frame .
errors in these quantities would propagate into the estimates of the planet - star mass ratio @xmath30 , the einstein radius @xmath28 , and the proper motion @xmath3 , all of which are important for assessing the physical implications of the detection .
the reason that @xmath31 is potentially impacted by unmodeled variability is that it is determined primarily from the wings of the light curve where the amplitude of the amplification of flux is comparable to that of the variability .
hence , it is important to track down the source of this variability and correct for it to the extent possible .
see , e.g. , @xcite . in principle , tracking down such a low level of variability in such a crowded field could have been very difficult .
however , in the present case , it turns out to be due to a star @xmath32 to the southeast , which is quite bright @xmath33 and shows variability with the same period and phase . within the framework of standard dia
, it is natural that this variable should impact the microlensing light curve because the difference image contains residuals from the variable that overlap the point spread function ( psf ) of the microlensed star .
hence , when the difference image is dot - multiplied by the psf to estimate the flux , it includes a contribution from the residual flux of the variable .
it is straightforward to simultaneously fit for two ( or @xmath34 ) variables with possibly overlapping psfs . after constructing difference images in the standard way ,
one simply generalizes the normal procedure by calculating the @xmath34 flux - difference values @xmath35 where @xmath36 @xmath37 is the ( unit normalized : @xmath38 ) amplitude of the @xmath39th psf in the @xmath40th pixel and @xmath41 are the value and error of the difference flux in the @xmath40th pixel .
we use a variant of this formalism to reduce the ogle data with @xmath42 stars , including the microlensed source , the bright variable , and one other very nearby ( but non - variable ) blended star .
the result is shown in the second panel of figure [ fig : one ] .
first note that the fluxes have decreased by about 0.5 mag because the non - variable neighboring blend ( third star in the fit ) has been removed from the baseline flux .
the semi - periodic variations are removed
. however there remains an annual trend .
the bottom panel of figure [ fig : one ] shows that this annual trend is due to variations with sidereal time , almost certainly due to the impact of the bright red neighbor ( even if it were constant ) via differential refraction .
we fit this variation to polynomials of order @xmath34 , but find that there is no significant improvement beyond @xmath43 , for which @xmath44 , where @xmath45 is flux in units of @xmath46 .
note that the variation from 0.3 to 0.7 ( on the figure ) is @xmath47 which is 1.5 times larger than the source flux derived below .
the third panel shows the results of applying this sidereal - time correction . as expected the annual trend
we apply this flux correction to all data , not just the baseline data shown in this figure .
we find ( as expected ) that this corrects the slope of the rising part of the light curve , which indeed impacts the estimate of @xmath31 , though by less than 10% .
note that while , in most cases , it is possible to derive an accurate estimate of the photometric error bars from those reported by the photometric pipeline @xcite , in this case we did not apply this simple prescription because the data were reduced using a special customized pipeline .
we apply the same formalism given by equations ( [ eqn : multifit1 ] ) and ( [ eqn : multifit2 ] ) to the kmtnet data , but with only two stars , i.e. , the microlensed source and the neighboring variable .
note that this difference between ogle and kmtnet reductions plays no role in the final result because the third star incorporated into the ogle fit is not variable , and the kmtnet flux scale is ultimately aligned to ogle through the microlens fit .
thus , in particular , we retain the advantage of resolving out this blend , thus placing better limits on flux from the lens .
the formalism introduced in section 3.3 can also be used to gain intuition about the impact of uncorrected variability , which can then be used to assess whether such corrections are necessary in specific cases .
first note that for @xmath43 , equations ( [ eqn : multifit1 ] ) and ( [ eqn : multifit2 ] ) reduce to the standard formula : @xmath48 equation ( [ eqn : singlefit ] ) then allows us to express the properly corrected `` true '' photometry in terms of the `` naive '' single - source photometry that ignores neighbors .
we first `` infer '' the value , @xmath49 , which then yields , @xmath50 hence , the correction is governed by the ratio of the psf overlap integral @xmath51 to the integral of the psf squared , @xmath52 .
we can evaluate this explicitly for the special case of a gaussian psf and below - sky sources ( @xmath53const ) @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the separation between the two sources . if the two sources are reasonably well separated , @xmath56fwhm , and ( as in the present case ) the target ( 1 ) is below sky while the contaminating variable ( 2 ) is well above sky , then the effect is roughly half of that given by equation ( [ eqn : gaussbelow ] ) .
this is because the squared psf integral is basically unaffected while the half of the contribution to the overlap integral that is closer to the contaminant is heavily suppressed by the higher flux errors per pixel .
we close by re - emphasizing that these order - or - magnitude estimates are not used in the present analysis but are intended as guidance for future cases .
the lightcurve has two principal features : a strong caustic entrance near peak at hjd@xmath57 and a weak caustic exit at hjd@xmath58 .
apart from these caustic crossings , the morphology is that of a slightly distorted point - lens event .
this morphology points to a binary lens with very unequal mass ratio @xmath59 , i.e. , in the brown - dwarf or planetary regime .
the long duration of the caustic ( 16 days ) then points to a resonant caustic , and so projected separation ( in units of @xmath28 ) of @xmath60 .
a thorough search of the parameter space leads to only one viable solution , which confirms the above naive reasoning ( so , before the caustic exit ) already led to essentially this same solution ( although the predicted caustic exit was 2.6 days later than the one subsequently observed ) . ] .
the model is described by seven parameters .
these include three that are analogous to a point - lens event @xmath61 , i.e. , the time of closest approach to the center of magnification , the impact parameter normalized to @xmath28 and the einstein crossing time ; three to describe the binary companion @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the angle of binary axis relative to the source trajectory ; and @xmath64 , where @xmath65 is the angular radius of the source .
ccrr @xmath66 & day & 7486.464 & 0.010 + @xmath67 & @xmath68 & 1.112 & 0.031 + @xmath69 & day & 81.694 & 2.195 + @xmath2 & & 1.075 & 0.003 + @xmath30 & @xmath68 & 1.168 & 0.040 + @xmath63 & radian & 5.886 & 0.009 + @xmath70 & @xmath68 & 0.060 & 0.008 + @xmath71 & & 21.510 & 0.028 + @xmath72 & & 19.739 & 0.028 the best fit parameters and errors ( determined from a markov chain ) are given in table [ table : one ] .
the light curve and model are shown in figure [ fig : two ] , while the lens geometry is shown in figure [ fig : three ] .
we note that compared to other planetary and binary events with well - covered caustic crossings , the parameter @xmath73 ( and the parameter combination @xmath74 ) have relatively large errors .
these parameters are usually better measured because caustic crossings tend to be bright ( since the caustic itself is a contour of formally infinite magnification ) , which means that the photometry over the caustic crossing is relatively precise .
since @xmath75 depends almost entirely on the duration of this crossing , with only weak dependence on other model parameters , it can then be determined quite precisely . in the present case , however , the first crossing
was entirely missed simply because it was not visible from any of the five survey telescopes currently in operation ( ogle , moa , and three from kmtnet : ctio , saao , sso ) .
the caustic exit was captured by kmtnet saao , with 12 points taken over 3.63 hours ( i.e. , 20 minute cadence ) . however , since this caustic was quite weak , peaking at @xmath76 , the photometry has much larger errors than the saao photometry near peak .
see upper two panels of figure [ fig : two ] . adopting a more glass - half - full orientation , we should assess the prior probability that either of the two caustic crossings would have been adequately observed to measure @xmath70 .
considering the 20 days between hjd@xmath77 7485 and 7505 , the three kmtnet observatories each took at least two points on 13 nights , with total durations , ( 2.11,2.76,2.52 ) days for sso , saao , and ctio , i.e. , a total 7.39 days .
essentially all of these 39 intervals had approximately continuous coverage .
we estimate that the probability that @xmath70 can be measured is the same as the probability that the caustic peak is covered , which may be slightly too conservative . under this assumption ,
the probability that the caustics would be observed are each 37% , so that the probability that at least one would be observed is @xmath78 .
of course , since the midpoint of the two caustic crossings was 16 april , this probability is adversely affected by the shortness of the bulge observing window relative to microlensing `` high season '' ( 21 may
21 july ) . at that time
the observing window is roughly 2.5 hours longer , and so ( assuming comparable weather conditions ) , the probability for each crossing would be 52% and the probability for at least one would be 77% .
nevertheless , the mid - april values may be considered as a proxy for the microlensing season as a whole .
we use kmtnet ctio dophot reductions to construct an instrumental color magnitude diagram ( cmd ) that is presented in figure [ fig : four ] .
we find the instrumental source color from model - independent regression and the instrumental source magnitude by fitting the @xmath16 band light curve to the model .
we then find the offset from the clump @xmath79=(-0.23,4.06)\pm ( 0.03,0.10)$ ] , where the error in the color offset is dominated by the regression measurement while the error in the magnitude offset is dominated by fitting for the clump centroid .
we then adopt @xmath80_{0,\rm clump}=(1.06,14.49)$ ] @xcite to obtain @xmath80_{0,s}=(0.83,18.55)$ ] . then using standard techniques @xcite
, we convert from @xmath81 to @xmath82 using the @xcite @xmath83 color - color relations and then use the @xcite color / surface - brightness relations to derive @xmath84 the error in @xmath65 is dominated by the uncertainties in transforming from color to surface brightness ( 8% ) , with a significant contribution from the error in @xmath71 ( 5% ) .
the fractional errors in @xmath28 and @xmath3 are substantially larger than in @xmath65 due to the relatively large error in @xmath70 .
see section 4 .
the relatively large value of @xmath28 almost certainly implies that the lens lies in the galactic disk since the lens - source relative parallax is @xmath85 that is , only if the lens were substantially heavier than @xmath86 could it be in the bulge ( @xmath87 ) .
however , first , there are almost no such massive stars in the bulge and second , its light would then exceed the blended light @xmath88 , even allowing for the @xmath89 extinction toward this line of sight @xcite . the only exception to this line of reasoning
would be if the lens were a black hole .
the most notable characteristic of ogle-2016-blg-0596 is its high mass ratio @xmath90 , implying that the mass is @xmath91 .
hence , if the host is one solar mass , this planet would be just below the the deuterium - burning limit ( usually regarded as the planet / brown - dwarf boundary ) . while the host could in principle have arbitrarily low mass ( and so , by equation ( [ eqn : mpirel ] ) , be arbitrarily close ) , distances closer than @xmath92 are strongly disfavored by the relatively low proper motion as well as the paucity of nearby lenses . at this limiting distance , and so @xmath93
, the planet would still be @xmath94 , i.e. , quite massive for such a low - mass host .
hence , regardless of the host mass , this is a fairly extreme system . to distinguish among these interesting possibilities
will require measuring ( or strongly constraining ) the host mass .
this can be accomplished with high resolution imaging , either using the _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ or ground - based adaptive optics ( ao ) imaging on an 8 m class telescope .
an advantage of _ hst _ is that it can observe in the @xmath16 band for which the source flux is directly measured from the event .
hence , the source light can be most reliably separated from the blended light in @xmath16 .
in contrast to many previous cases , there are no @xmath95 band observations during the event , so ground - based ao observations ( which must be in the infrared ) can not be directly compared to an event - derived source flux .
nevertheless , it is probably possible to transform from @xmath81 light - curve measurement to @xmath96 source flux with a precision of 0.2 mag , using a @xmath97 color - color diagram . for definiteness
, we will assume that the lens can be reliably detected from _
hst _ or ao observations provided that the flux is at least half that of the source , i.e. , @xmath98 .
for example , if the lens were an @xmath99 middle m dwarf ( so @xmath100 ) , then it would have @xmath101 ( and brighter if , as is almost certainly the case , a substantial fraction of the dust is beyond 1.3 kpc ) .
thus , there is a good chance that ao or _
_ observations could detect the lens , and even if this failed , the observations would strongly constrain the host to be of very low mass .
ogle-2016-blg-0596 lb is a very high mass - ratio @xmath102 planet that lies projected very close to the einstein ring @xmath103 , which consequently generated a huge resonant caustic that required 16 days for the source to traverse .
the underlying event was of quite high magnification @xmath104 , which led to pronounced features at peak .
it therefore would seem to be extremely easy to discover .
while the data set posted on the ogle web site are adversely affected by the nearby variable , it is still the case that a free fit to these data leads to a solution qualitatively similar to the one presented here ( except that it lacks a measurement of @xmath70 ) .
it is therefore striking that none of the automated programs nor active individual investigators that query this site noticed this event ( or at least they did not alert the community to what they found as they do for a wide range of other events , many less interesting ) .
this suggests that there may be many other planets `` hidden in plain sight '' in existing data .
these three characteristics , high - magnification ( which is usually associated with survey+followup rather than survey - only mode ) , very high mass ratio , and apparent failure of both machine and by - eye recognition of the planetary perturbation , prompt us to address two questions . first , how do the real ( as opposed to theoretical ) planet sensitivities differ between survey - only and survey+followup modes .
second , why was this planet discovered only based on systematic analysis and what does this imply about the need for such systematic analysis of all events ?
[ [ summary - of - microlens - planet - detections - in - the - observational - sq - plane ] ] summary of microlens planet detections in the observational @xmath1 plane ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ many papers contain figures that summarize microlensing planet detections in the physical plane of planet - mass versus projected separation ( with the latter sometimes normalized by the snow line ) , e.g. , figure 1 of @xcite .
and there are many studies that show plots of _ planet sensitivity _ in the observational @xmath1 plane , ( e.g. , @xcite ) . but to our knowledge ,
there are no published figures ( or even figures shown at conferences ) showing the census of microlensing planet discoveries on this plane .
figure [ fig : five ] illustrates the position of ogle-2016-blg-0596 ( green pentagon ) among the 44 previously published planets ( or , to the extent we have such knowledge , submitted for publication ) .
discovered bodies are defined to be `` planets '' if their measured or best - estimated mass @xmath105 and if they are known to orbit a more massive body .
planets are color - coded by discovery method : discovered by followup observations ( black ) , discovered ( or discoverable ) in survey - only observations but requiring followup for full - characterization ( magenta ) , fully ( or essentially fully ) characterized by survey observations ( green ) .
the shapes of the symbols indicate the type of caustic that gave rise to the planetary perturbation : circles , squares , and triangles for planetary , central , and resonant caustics , respectively . in many cases , solutions with @xmath106 and @xmath107 yield almost equally good fits to the data @xcite . in these cases ,
the two solutions are shown as open symbols in order to diminish their individual visual `` weight '' relative to the filled symbols used when this degeneracy is broken . hence , ogle-2016-blg-0596 lb would be a green filled triangle if it were not being singled out by making it larger pentagon .
the most striking feature of this figure is that , in sharp contrast to the triangular appearance of high - magnification - event planet - sensitivity plots ( e.g. , @xcite ) and to `` double pronged '' low - magnification sensitivity plots ( e.g. , @xcite ) , this detection plot looks basically like a cross , with a vertical band of detections near @xmath108 and a horizontal band near @xmath109 .
the part of this structure at high mass ratio @xmath110 is easily explained : companions with high mass ratio are , a priori , most likely stars or brown dwarfs ( bds ) and can only be claimed as `` planets '' if the host mass is known to be low .
this in turn usually requires a measurement of the microlens parallax , which for ground based observations is much more likely if there is a large caustic and so @xmath60 .
however , the absence of detections @xmath111 is puzzling .
there are 4 such detections on the opposite side @xmath112 .
all of these derive from planetary caustics and three of them are pure survey detections moa-2011-blg-028 lb , ogle-2008-blg-092 lb , and moa-2013-blg-605 lb @xcite .
the remaining planet , ogle-2005-blg-390 lb @xcite , dates from an era when follow - up groups intensively monitored the wings of events , primarily due to the paucity of better targets .
thus we may expect that surveys will gradually fill in this quadrant . apart from this quadrant , it is not obvious that surveys are probing a different part of parameter space from the previously dominant survey+followup mode . to further investigate this ,
we show in figures [ fig : six ] and [ fig : seven ] the cumulative distributions of planets by log mass ratio @xmath113 and ( absolute value of ) log separation @xmath114 . in this case
we distinguish only between events that could be fully characterized by survey observations ( green ) and those that required significant followup ( including auto - followup by surveys ) .
these distributions generally appear quite similar . for the mass ratio distribution , the greatest difference ( 0.259 )
is at @xmath115 , which is very typical ( kolmogorov - smirnoff ( ks ) probability 40% ) .
the greatest difference for the separation distribution ( 0.334 at @xmath116 ) has a ks probability of 8.5% .
this may be indicative of a real difference .
if so , the difference would be that pure - survey is relatively more efficient at finding widely separated lenses , which was already hinted at by inspection of the @xmath106 scatter plot . finally ,
in figure [ fig : eight ] , we show cumulative distributions by year of discovery
. one might expect that with the massive ramp - up of surveys , survey - only discoveries would move strongly ahead of survey+followup .
this expectation is confirmed in its sign but not its magnitude by figure [ fig : eight ] .
it shows that in ( 2014 , 2015 , 2016 ) there have been ( 2,2,1 ) and ( 0,1,0 ) discoveries by survey - only and survey+followup , respectively .
this is certainly not a complete accounting , in part because 2016 has just begun and in part because historically there has been a considerable delay in microlensing planet publications for a variety of reasons .
for example , of the 28 planets discovered prior to 2012 , the number with delays ( publication year minus discovery year ) of @xmath117 years was @xmath118 . in the history of microlensing , there has been only one planet published during the discovery year , ogle-2005-blg-071 lb @xcite .
hence , we will only get a full picture of this transition after a few years .
[ [ challenges - to - the - by - eye - and - by - machine - discovery - of - ogle-2016-blg-0596 ] ] challenges to the by - eye and by - machine discovery of ogle-2016-blg-0596 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ there are three interrelated reasons why ogle-2016-blg-0596 may have escaped notice as a potentially planetary event until the kmtnet data for this event were examined ( for reasons unrelated to any apparent anomaly ) .
first , it is relatively faint at peak .
second , it has a variable baseline .
third , it was not announced as a microlensing event until one day after the peak . as a general rule ,
high - magnification events are singled out for intensive followup observations only if they are still rising .
when such intensive observations would have been reduced , they would have immediately revealed the anomalous nature of the event , probably triggering additional observations .
this is how many of the planets discovered by @xmath3fun were found . while @xmath3fun itself is now semi - dormant , its protocols are directly relevant here because what is of interest is whether there is prima facie evidence for a population of missed planets during past years , during most of which @xmath3fun was active .
now , in fact , ogle-2016-blg-0596 met the criteria for an ogle alert 24 hours previously , but no alert was issued because of caution due to the variable baseline .
nevertheless , even if such an alert had been issued , it would not have triggered any followup observations because ( due to the anomaly ) the event would have appeared to have already peaked at that time .
finally , the variability of the baseline may have influenced modelers and followup groups to discount the evident irregularities in the light curve near peak as being due to data artifacts .
this could have been exacerbated by the faintness of the event , which increases both the formal error bars and the probability of centroiding errors ( hence irregular photometry ) due to bright blends .
both of these effects reduce the confidence of modelers that apparent anomalies in online `` quick look '' photometry are due to physical effects .
it is nevertheless a fact that when the original ogle data are modeled , they show a clear signal for a massive planet or low - mass bd , which would trigger a re - reduction of the data , such as the one we report here .
we therefore conclude that while ogle-2016-blg-0596 has some near - unique features that increased the difficulty of recognizing it as a planetary event , such recognition was clearly feasible .
hence , we do indeed regard this event as prima facie evidence for more such events in archival data , particularly ogle - iv data 2010 - 2015 .
the ogle project has received funding from the national science centre , poland , grant maestro 2014/14/a / st9/00121 to au .
the ogle team thanks profs .
m. kubiak and g. pietrzyski , former members of the ogle team , for their contribution to the collection of the ogle photometric data over the past years .
work by jcy was performed under contract with the california institute of technology ( caltech)/jet propulsion laboratory ( jpl ) funded by nasa through the sagan fellowship program executed by the nasa exoplanet science institute .
work by c.h .
was supported by creative research initiative program ( 2009 - 0081561 ) of national research foundation of korea .
this research has made the telescopes of kmtnet operated by the korea astronomy and space science institute ( kasi ) .
99 alard , c. & lupton , r.h.,1998 , , 503 , 325 beaulieu , j .-
bennett , d.p . ,
fouqu , p. et al .
2006 , nature , 439 , 437 bennett , d.p . , bond , i.a . ,
udalski , a. , et al .
2008 , , 684 , 663 bennett , d.p . , sumi , t. , bond , i.a . , et al .
2012 , , 757 , 119 bensby , t. yee , j.c . , feltzing , s. et al . 2013 , , 549a , 147 bessell , m.s . , & brett , j.m . 1988 , , 100 , 1134 bond , i.a . ,
udalski , a. , jaroszyski , m. et al .
2004 , , 606 , l155 gaudi , b.s . , albrow , m.d . , an , j. 2002 , , 566 , 463 gould , a. & loeb , a. 1992 , , 396 , 104 gould , a. , dong , s. , gaudi , b.s .
2010 , , 720 , 1073 griest , k. & safizadeh , n. 1998 , , 500 , 37 kervella , p. , thvenin , f. , di folco , e. , & sgransan , d. 2004 , , 426 , 297 kim , s .- l .
, lee , c .- u . , park , b .-
, et al . 2016 , jkas , 49 , 37 nataf , d.m . , gould , a. , fouqu , p. et al .
2013 , , 769 , 88 poleski , r. , skowron , j. , udalski , a. , et al . 2014a , , 755 , 42 poleski , r. , udalski , a. , dong , s. et al . 2014b , , 782 , 47 schechter , p.l . ,
mateo , m. , & saha , a. 1993 , , 105 , 1342 shin , i .-
, ryu , y.h , udalski , a. et al .
2016 , jkas , 49 , 73 shvartzvald , y. , maoz , d. , kaspi , s. et al .
2014 , , 439 , 604 skowron , j. , udalski , a. , poleski , r. et al .
2016 , , 820 , 4 skowron , j. , udalski , a. , kozowski , s. et al .
2016 , acta astron . , 66 , 1 sumi , t. , udalski , a. , bennett , d.p . , et al .
2016 , in press arxiv:1512.00134 udalski , a. 2003 , acta astron . , 53 , 291 udalski , a.,szymanski , m. , kaluzny , j. , kubiak , m. , mateo , m. , krzeminski , w. , & paczyski , b. 1994 , acta astron .
, 44 , 317 udalski , a. , jaroszyski , m. , paczyski , b , et al .
2005 , , 628 , l109 .
udalski , a. , szymaski , m.k .
& szymaski , g. 2015b , acta astronom . , 65 , 1 yee , j.c . ,
shvartzvald , y. , gal - yam , a. et al .
2012 , , 755 , 102 yoo , j. , depoy , d.l . , gal - yam , a. et al .
2004 , , 603 , 139 zhu , w. , penny , m. , mao , s. , gould , a. , & gendron , r. 2014 , , 788 , 73 | we report the discovery of a high mass - ratio planet @xmath0 , i.e. , 13 times higher than the jupiter / sun ratio .
the host mass is not presently measured but can be determined or strongly constrained from adaptive optics imaging .
the planet was discovered in a small archival study of high - magnification events in pure - survey microlensing data , which was unbiased by the presence of anomalies .
the fact that it was previously unnoticed may indicate that more such planets lie in archival data and could be discovered by similar systematic study . in order to understand the transition from predominantly survey+followup to predominately survey - only planet detections , we conduct the first analysis of these detections in the observational @xmath1 plane . here
@xmath2 is projected separation in units of the einstein radius .
we find some evidence that survey+followup is relatively more sensitive to planets near the einstein ring , but that there is no statistical difference in sensitivity by mass ratio . |
the normalization amplitude of the linear matter power spectrum is one of the key cosmological parameters that are required to complete the theoretical description of the initial conditions of the universe @xcite .
it is often quantified in terms of @xmath2 , the rms fluctuations of the linear density field within a top - hat spherical radius @xmath3mpc .
various observables have so far been used to constrain the value of @xmath2 : the cluster abundance ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , the weak lensing cosmic shear ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , strong lensing arc statistics ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) , the cluster shapes @xcite , and the cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmb ) temperature map ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
yet , these observables depend not solely on @xmath2 but concurrently on the other key parameters such as the matter density parameter @xmath4 , primordial non - gaussianity parameter @xmath5 , and dark energy equation of state @xmath6 .
furthermore , it has been realized that complicated systematics involved in the measurement of these observables could bias strongly the estimates of @xmath2 .
hence , to break the parameter degeneracy and to diminish any systematic bias , it is very important to consider as many alternative probes as possible .
recently , ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter , pl07 ) have proposed the void ellipticity function as another sensitive probe of @xmath2 . noting that the shapes of voids are modulated by the competition between tidal distortion and cosmic expansion
, they have analytically derived the void ellipticity function under the assumption that the dynamics of void galaxies can be well described by the zeldovich approximation just as that of the dark matter particles are in the linear regime .
they have tested their model against the results from the millennium run simulations @xcite , which proved the validity of the pl07 model . for the comparison with observational data
, however , the pl07 model has to be extended to incorporate the redshift distortion effect since in pratice the void ellipticities can be measured only in redshift space .
moreover , there is one condition that the success of the pl07 analytic model is contingent upon .
its validity has been tested only for the case that the voids are found through the specific void - finding algorithm of ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter hv02 ) .
since there is no unique definition of voids , the ellipticity distribution may well depend on the way in which voids are identified @xcite .
for the fair comparison with the pl07 model , the hv02 algorithm should be consistently used for the identification of voids from observations . very recently , ( * ? ? ?
* hereafter fn09 ) have constructed a catalog of @xmath7 voids from the sloan digital sky survey data release 5 ( sdss dr5 ) .
now that the voids of the fn09 catalog are identified using the hv02 algorithm , it must provide the most optimal dataset against which the pl07 analytic model can be compared . in this letter
our goal is to constrain the value of @xmath2 by comparing the extended pl07 analytic model of the redshifted void ellipticity function with the observational result from the fn07 catalog of sdss voids .
let us first give a brief overview on the pl07 theoretical model .
an analytic expression for the probability density distribution of the minor - to - major axial ratio , @xmath8 , of a void at redshift @xmath9 on the lagrangian scale @xmath10 was found by pl07 as @xmath11 \cr & = & \int_{\nu}^{1}d\mu \frac{3375\sqrt{2}}{\sqrt{10\pi}\sigma^{5}_{r_l } } \exp\left[-\frac{5\delta^{2}_{v}}{2\sigma^{2}_{r_l } } + \frac{15\delta_{v}(\lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2})}{2\sigma^{2}_{r_l}}\right ] \cr & & \times\exp\left[-\frac{15(\lambda^{2}_{1}+\lambda_{1}\lambda_{2}+ \lambda^{2}_{2})}{2\sigma^{2}_{r_l}}\right ] \cr & & \times(2\lambda_{1}+\lambda_{2}-\delta_{v})(\lambda_{1}-\lambda_{2 } ) ( \lambda_{1}+2\lambda_{2}-\delta_{v } ) \cr & & \times\frac{4(\delta_{v}-3)^2\mu\nu}{(\mu^{2}+\nu^{2}+1)^{3 } } , \label{eqn : nu}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath12 represents the rms fluctuations of the linear density field smoothed on scale @xmath10 at redshift @xmath9 , and @xmath13 ( with @xmath14 ) represent the two axial ratios of cosmic voids that can be obtained from the inertia momentum tensors of the anisotropic spatial positions of void galaxies .
the key concept of this analytic expression is that the two axial ratios , @xmath8 and @xmath15 , are related to the largest and second to the largest eigenvalues , @xmath16 and @xmath17 , of the tidal field smoothed on the scale @xmath10 as @xmath18 where @xmath19 denotes the critical density contrast of a void linearly extrapolated to @xmath20 .
pl07 calculated the value of @xmath19 as the galaxy number density contrast as @xmath21 where @xmath22 and @xmath23 represent the number density of void galaxies and the mean number density of all galaxies in a given sample .
pl09 found that @xmath24 on average but also noted a tendency that @xmath19 decreases gradually with the sizes of voids .
the lagrangian scale radius @xmath10 was calculated as @xmath25 . here
@xmath26 represents the effective ( comoving ) spherical radius of a void defined as @xmath27 with the void volume @xmath28 .
the values of @xmath19 and @xmath26 have to be determined from the observed voids that are to be used for comparison .
it is worth mentioning here that this relation between @xmath10 and @xmath26 holds good also in redshift space . defining the ellipticity of a void as @xmath29 , the probability density distribution of the void ellipticities on scale @xmath10 at redshift @xmath9
is calculated as @xmath30 .
pl07 originally derived equations ( [ eqn : nu]-[eqn : lamu2 ] ) for the present epoch @xmath20 .
it was @xcite who extended the analytic model to higher redshifts , according to which the dependence of @xmath31 on @xmath9 and @xmath10 comes from the dependence of @xmath32 on @xmath9 and @xmath10 : @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the top - hat filter of scale radius @xmath10 , @xmath35 is the linear growth factor normalized as @xmath36 , @xmath37 is the dimensionless linear matter power spectrum .
the functional shapes of @xmath35 and @xmath37 vary with the background cosmology . assuming a @xmath38cdm cosmology , we use the following formula for @xmath35 and @xmath37 @xcite .
@xmath39^{1/2}\cr & & \times\int_{z}^{\infty}dz^{\prime } \frac{1+z^{\prime}}{[\omega_{m}(1+z^{\prime})^{3 } + \omega_{\lambda}]^{3/2 } } , \cr \delta^{2}(k ) & \propto & \frac{1}{2\pi^{2}}k^{n_s+3 } \left[\frac{\ln(1 + 2.34q)}{2.34q}\right]^{2}\cr \times & & [ 1 + 3.89q + ( 16.1q)^{2 } + ( 5.46)^{3 } + ( 6.71q)^{4}]^{-1/2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath40 @xcite and @xmath41 is a spectral index of the primordial power spectrum .
the void ellipticity function , @xmath42 , is now defined as the differential number density of voids as a function of @xmath43 , @xmath44 where @xmath45 is the total number of voids . to extend the above analytic expression for the redshifted void ellipticity distribution
, we consider the simplest case where the redshift distortion effect can be described by a single linear distortion parameter , @xmath46 , which is related to the background cosmology as ( * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) : @xmath47\frac{1}{b_{g}},\ ] ] where @xmath48 is a linar galaxy bias factor measured in real space .
since we are interested in the redshift distortion effect on voids , we should use a bias factor of the void galaxies , say @xmath49 .
@xcite have measured the real - space clustering of the hi galaxies and found that the galaxies in low - density regions are anti - biased , exhibiting @xmath50 .
now , the redshifted power spectrum can be approximated at first order as @xcite @xmath51 where @xmath46 is calculated using the void galaxy bias factor @xmath52 . replacing the real - space power spectrum @xmath37 by the redshifted power spectrum @xmath53
, we finally obtain an analytic expression for the redshifted void ellipticity function , @xmath54 . figure [ fig : sig ] plots the analytic predictions of the redshifted void ellipticity function for the three different cases of the linear power - spectrum normalization ( @xmath55 and @xmath56 as dotted , dashed and solid , respectively ) .
the lagrangian void scale , redshift , and total number of voids are set at the values consistent with the ones used for the void catalog ( see 3 ) .
as it can be seen , the void ellipticity function depends very sensitively on the @xmath2 value .
fn09 extended the hv02 void - finding algorithm to improve its statistical robustness and applied it to the volume - limited spectroscopic sample of the galaxies from sdss dr5 to construct a catalog of @xmath7 voids ( available at http://physics.ubishops.ca/sdssvoids ) .
the volume limited sample has a total of @xmath57 galaxies in a volume of @xmath58 ( c. foster in private communication ) .
the mean galaxy number density of this sample is thus @xmath59 in unit of @xmath60 . in the catalog
is listed the redshift @xmath9 , effective spherical radius @xmath26 , number of the void galaxies @xmath61 , three axis - lengths ( @xmath62 with @xmath63 of the best - fit ellipsoids of each sdss void .
the effective spherical radius @xmath26 of each void is related to its three axis - lengths as @xmath64 .
fn09 determined the best - fit ellipsoid of each void with the help of the prescription of @xcite , assuming a flat @xmath38cdm cosmology with @xmath65 , @xmath66 and @xmath67 . throughout this paper
, we also adopt the same cosmology , setting the other key parameters at @xmath68 and @xmath69 from the wmap priors @xcite .
the mean values of @xmath9 , @xmath26 , and @xmath61 averaged over all voids are found to be @xmath70 , @xmath71mpc , and @xmath72 , respectively . using information on @xmath62
, we measure the ellipticity of each void as @xmath73 . binning the ellipticities as @xmath74 , counting the number of sdss voids in each ellipticity bin , and dividing the void number counts by @xmath75
, we determine the observational void ellipticity function , @xmath76 . to estimate the statistical errors in the measurement of @xmath76
, we separate the voids into six subsamples each of which has approximately the same number of voids , and then calculate the void ellipticity function separately from each subsample . the errors at each ellipticity bin @xmath74 is now calculated as the standard deviation of @xmath77 between the six subsamples , which include both the cosmic variance and the poisson noise .
figure [ fig : com ] plots the resulting void ellipticity function as dots .
the density contrast of each void is computed as @xmath78 where @xmath79 with @xmath80 . and
the mean density contrast averaged over all voids is determined to be @xmath81 . using the values of @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 ,
the lagrangian void scale is obtained to be @xmath85mpc .
we fit the analytic model of the redshifted void ellipticity function to the observational results by adjusting the value of @xmath2 with the help of the generalized @xmath0 minimization method where @xmath0 is given as @xmath86c^{-1}_{ij } [ f^{o}_{s}(\varepsilon_{j})-f^{t}_{s}(\varepsilon_{j};\sigma_{8})],\ ] ] where @xmath87 and @xmath88 denote the observed and the theoretical ellipticity function at the @xmath89-th ellipticity bin , respectively .
the covariance matrix @xmath90 is defined as @xmath91 where the ensemble average is taken over the six subsamples .
since the number of the subsamples ( six ) is larger than the number of the ellipticity bins ( five ) , it is guaranteed that @xmath90 is invertible @xcite .
the best - fit @xmath2 that minimizes @xmath0 is found to be @xmath92 where the errors are calculated as @xmath93 .
figure [ fig : com ] plots the analytic model with best - fit @xmath2 , demonstrating that the analytic model agrees well with the observational results .
although a fixed value , @xmath65 , is assumed for the construction of the fn09 void catalog , it is worth examining the parameter degeneracy between @xmath2 and @xmath4 when the void ellipticity function is used as a probe of @xmath2 .
varying the values of @xmath2 and @xmath4 simultaneously , we repeat the whole fitting process .
figure [ fig : con ] plots the contours of @xmath94 ( thick solid , thin solid and dotted lines , respectively ) in the @xmath95 plane , where @xmath96 is the reduced @xmath0 .
as it can be seen , the best - fit @xmath2 decreases very mildly as @xmath4 increases .
we have constrained the matter power spectrum normalization as @xmath1 by comparing the void ellipticity function from sdss dr5 with the extended pl07 model .
it is intriguing to note that our result is higher than the wmap5 value ( @xmath97 ) but consistent with that from the recent work of @xcite who casted a doubt on the accuracy of the cosmological parameters estimated by the wmap team . using a new improved cmb map constructed by employing an independent software scheme , @xcite have found @xmath98 .
the advantage of using the void ellipticity function as a probe of the power spectrum normalization is that it is purely analytical , free from any nuisance parameters and ad - hoc assumptions .
besides , as shown recently by @xcite , the void ellipticity function does not depend on the primordial non - gaussianity parameter , unlike the other prominent probe of @xmath2 , the cluster mass function .
it depends most sensitively on @xmath2 among the key cosmological parameters and thus it is in principle one of the most optimal probes of the power spectrum normalization .
yet , it is worth noting that there is one weak point about using the void ellipticity function as a cosmological probe .
the number of observable voids at different redshifts is relatively small compared with that of observable clusters , which means that it tends to suffer from small - number statistics .
the future galaxy surveys may allow us to overcome this limitation .
our future work is in the direction of forecasting constraints on @xmath2 and @xmath6 from the forthcoming galaxy surveys by exploiting the void ellipticity function ( c. cunha and j. lee in preparation ) .
i thank c. foster , c.cunha and d.huterer for many inspiring comments .
i also thank a.e.evrard and the physics department of university of michigan and michigan center for theoretical physics at ann arbor for the warm hospitality during my sabbatical when this research is conducted .
i acknowledge financial support from the korea science and engineering foundation ( kosef ) grant funded by the korean government ( most , no .
r01 - 2007 - 000 - 10246 - 0 ) .
adelman - mccarthy , j. k. , et al .
2007 , , 172 , 634 bardeen , j. m. , bond , j. r. , kaiser , n. , & szalay , a. s. 1986 , , 304 , 15 basilakos , s. , plionis , m. , kova , k. , & voglis , n. 2007 , , 378 , 301 colberg , j. m. , et al .
2008 , , 387 , 933 dodelson , s. 2003 , modern cosmology , ( amsterdam : academic press ) dunkley , j. , et al .
2009 , , 180 , 306 foster , c. , & nelson , l. a. 2009 , , 699 , 1252 hamilton , a. j. s. 1998 , the evolving universe , 231 , 185 ( astro - ph/9708102 ) hartlap , j. , simon , p. , & schneider , p. 2007
, , 464 , 399 henry , j. p. , evrard , a. e. , hoekstra , h. , babul , a. , & mahdavi , a. 2009 , , 691 , 1307 hoyle , f. , & vogeley , m. s. 2002 , , 566 , 641 huterer , d. , & ma , c .- p .
2004 , , 600 , l7 jang - condell , h. , & hernquist , l. 2001 , , 548 , 68 kaiser , n. 1987 , , 227 , 1 lahav , o. , lilje , p. b. , primack , j. r. , & rees , m. j. 1991 , , 251 , 128 lee , j. 2006 , , 643 , 724 lee , j. , & park , d. 2009 , , 696 , l10 lam , t. y. , sheth , r. k. , & desjacques , v. 2009 , arxiv:0905.1706 liu , h. , & li , t .-
2009 , submitted to mnras , arxiv:0907.2731 park , d. , & lee , j. 2007 , physical review letters , 98 , 081301 peacock , j. a. 1999 , cosmological physics , ( cambridge : cambridge univ . press ) peacock , j. a. , & dodds , s. j. 1994 , , 267 , 1020 refregier , a. , rhodes , j. , & groth , e. j. 2002 , , 572 , l131 springel , v. , et al .
2005 , , 435 , 629 tegmark , m. et al .
2006 , , 74 , 123507 van waerbeke , l. , et al .
2000 , , 358 , 30 | the ellipticity function of cosmic voids exhibits strong dependence on the amplitude of the linear matter power spectrum . analyzing the most recent void catalogs constructed by foster and nelson from the fifth data release of the sloan digital sky survey , we measure observationally the ellipticity function of giant galaxy voids .
then , we incorporate the redshift distortion and galaxy bias effect into the analytic model of the void ellipticity function and fit it to the observational result by adjusting the value of the power - spectrum normalization with the help of the generalized @xmath0-minimization method .
the best - fit normalization of the linear power spectrum is found to be @xmath1 .
our result is higher than the wmap @xmath2-value but consistent with that from the recent work of liu and li who have constructed a new improved cmb map independently . |
many structures are able to change their mechanical properties and dimensions when an appropriate stimulus is applied .
this phenomenon is commonly called actuation . the energy from an external source triggers changes in the internal state of the system , leading to a mechanical response much larger than the initial input .
this ability to unlock internal work in a solid state structure is of key importance for many actuator applications .
actuators with differing characteristics and mechanisms have been widely adopted by industry to fill a variety of technological requirements @xcite with some having a one - way response , while others providing an equilibrium , reversible response to the given stimulus .
shape - memory alloys @xcite or polymers @xcite are good examples of such smart actuating systems . however , in most cases a shape memory system works only in one direction , requiring a reset after the actuation .
only very few systems can reversibly actuate and then return back to the equilibrium shape once the stimulus is removed .
so far only liquid crystal elastomers @xcite have proven to be a truly equilibrium reversible actuating system .
a polymer benign to external stimulus can also be made to actuate when blended with of one or more distinctly different materials to impart a new physical response leading to the actuation process .
a recent article has demonstrated one such system , based on a common silicon rubber filled with a low concentration of aligned carbon nanotubes , actuating in response to infrared radiation @xcite .
apart from actuation itself , the stimulation of functionalized nanotubes by infrared ( ir ) radiation is also proving an effective technique , e.g. in biomedical applications @xcite . clearly , there are rich prospects and much motivation to understand nanotube action and the actuation behavior under ir irradiation when they are embedded in a polymer matrix .
the work presented here focuses on the use of multi - walled carbon nanotubes ( mwcnts ) to impart equilibrium mechanical actuation in the rubbery matrix .
the properties of multi - walled nanotubes has been well documented for over a decade @xcite .
their behavior in polymer composites is less well understood but some reviews have recently appeared in the literature @xcite . for mechanical applications ,
the interface between the tube surface and the host polymer is of critical importance and most of the studies have focussed on this aspect .
in contrast , the nature of the active response of nanotubes within a polymeric matrix has yet to be fully understood .
the complex behavior of tubes is often simplified and analogies are made with aligned rigid rods .
it is unclear whether such analogies are always valid , especially when the tubes do not necessarily form rigid rods in a polymer matrix and certainly do not align unless an external field is present @xcite .
the actuating properties of mwcnts have recently being elucidated upon with the possibility of designing nanoelectromechanical ( nems ) systems @xcite .
the actuator properties of individual bending mwcnts under an applied electric field have been studied experimentally @xcite .
the torsional actuation behavior of multi - walled tubes has also been reported @xcite .
these works are important but we note that all these studies focus on individual tubes and not a collection of tubes , nor their properties within a continuous elastic matrix .
the massive elastic response of single - walled nanotube bundles , when stimulated by light , was very effectively demonstrated by zhang and iijima @xcite , although little work has followed from their discovery .
they showed the bundles responding to visible light and a near ir laser radiation by elastically changing their dimensions ; examining the figures in @xcite we deduce that the induced strain must be about 20% . in the context of this paper
, we shall refer to the actuation stroke as the change in strain , when an external stimulus is applied .
there are several reports of actuation behavior of polymer - nanotube composites @xcite .
these works have focussed on accentuating the already present features of the host matrix by adding nanotubes .
the tubes act to exaggerate the response by either improving electromechanical properties or increasing heat transfer efficiency due to the inherent high conductivity that originates from their delocalized @xmath0-bonded skeleton .
recent work has departed from this traditional ` improvement ' scheme and asked whether it is possible to blend nanotubes with benign polymers to create new composite actuator properties , that otherwise would not occur in that system .
such effects have been observed by courty _ et al . _
@xcite where electric field stimulation of liquid crystal elastomers with embedded mwcnts lead to mechanical contraction .
similarly , the photomechanical response from mwcnts when embedded in a silicone rubber ( pdms ) matrix @xcite is a new effect .
the pristine elastomer shows no response to near ir radiation , yet the presence of nanotubes causes a strong reversible response that can be tailored by manipulating the degree of alignment the tubes experience .
the present work expands on such a simple polymer nanocomposite system and goes on to show that the effect can exist independently of the host polymer matrix which , by the presence of mwcnts , produces a mechanical response to the ir irradiation .
we show that both a compression and an extension response can be achieved ( depending on the external uniaxial strain applied to the composite sample ) , but that the magnitude of the actuation stroke strongly depends on the host polymer used .
we also develop a simple model that considers the orientational ordering of nanotubes in the matrix along with their individual and bulk actuating behavior .
this paper is organized as following : after giving details of preparation and basic composite characterization , we concentrate on the analysis of tube orientation induced by stretching of the host polymer matrix , section iii .
we then turn to the ir - stimulated actuation , section iv , and study different nanocomposite systems in some detail ( although the majority of our studies remain on the pdms system ) .
section v presents a simple theoretical model that might well describe the actuation mechanism and compares it with our experimental data and the literature .
we conclude that two - way actuation behavior is dependent on nanotube orientation , but is independent of the chosen homogenous polymer matrix and can occur in any rubbery solid , albeit with varying magnitude .
it is thought that no other materials of any class ( metal , polymer , ceramic ) can display this behavior and to such large effect , thus , the study of the underlying physics of such systems is of clear scientific , medical and commercial importance .
there are many different sources of carbon nanotubes on the market today . after extensive searching and testing ,
we have settled on nanotubes provided by nanostructured & amorphous materials , inc .
these are multi - walled , with the core diameter between 5 - 10 nm , outer diameter of 60 - 100 nm and length between 5 - 15 microns .
purity has been verified ( with sem ) as @xmath195% in raw form from the supplier , in agreement with specification .
these nanotubes were not surface - modified at any time during processing and are used throughout this study for all polymers tested .
chemical functionalization is necessary in many nanocomposite fields , but in our work it has been avoided to reduce the number of variables in the system .
we share the views of other authors that chemical functionalization of the tube walls will degrade the properties of the tubes overall due to further introduction of sp@xmath2 hybridized carbon defects @xcite .
three types of polymer have been tested ; pdms rubber ( crosslinked polydimethylsiloxane ) , sis ( styrene - isoprene - styrene ) triblock thermoplastic elastomer and a nematic liquid crystal elastomer ( lce , in both mono and polydomain form ) .
each type of polymer has a unique preparation method outlined in the following sections . where possible , similarities in processing have been kept .
table [ tablemats ] lists the composites made and their abbreviations .
.list of host polymer materials , nanotube loading and the abbreviations of resulting composites . [ cols="^,<,<",options="header " , ] the pdms ( sylgard 184@xmath3 ) silicone elastomer system was obtained from dow corning , usa , in the form of the main compound and the hydrosilane curing agent ( crosslinker ) . in pristine conditions ,
the mixing and crosslinking procedure gives a uniform solvent - free elastomer .
we have verified ( with sem on cryo - microtomed and freeze - fractured surfaces ) that the resulting polymer network is pure crosslinked pdms with no filler particles , as sometimes is the case with supplied elastomer mixes .
the nanotube - polymer composite was fabricated by first carefully weighing the desired quantity of nanotubes and the polymer compound .
calculations of weight percentage take into account the weight of crosslinker , to be later used in the mixture .
the highly viscous fluid was sheared using an ika labortechnik mixer for a minimum of 24 hours .
the crosslinker was added to the mixture after 24 hours .
the ratio of crosslinker to pdms was 1:10 , according to sylgard 184@xmath3 specification , ensuring negligible sol fraction after preparation of the pristine network .
the sample was then further sheared for another 30 seconds before being placed in vacuum for 5 minutes to degas , at all times remaining at ambient temperature to ensure little crosslinking reaction takes place in this time . after removing the air cavities , that unavoidably form during shear mixing , the mixture was deposited in a specially designed reactor ( centrifuge compartment with ptfe film lining its inner wall ) and placed in a centrifuge at 5000rpm and 80@xmath4c . at this temperature
the pdms crosslinking is much faster and the centrifugation achieves the uniform thickness and full homogenization of resulting rubber composite samples .
the subsequent processing depends on the target sample properties .
if we require a completely non - aligned nanotube dispersion , the sample remains in the reactor for 24 hours , resulting in a homogeneous elastomer composite . in some cases
( as will be clear from the text below ) we aim to produce a sample with nanotubes permanently pre - aligned . in this case
the initial mix remains in the reactor , at 80@xmath4c , for 14 minutes ( calculated from separate measurements of crosslinking reaction rates ) .
the partially crosslinked network was then removed from the reactor and aligned mechanically by applying uniaxial extension using specially designed clamps .
removing the sample from the reactor after what is a relatively short period of time ensures that it is being mechanically aligned while still having over 50% of crosslinking to take place . finally ,
while still constrained in the clamps , the sample was placed in an oven at 70@xmath4c for a further 24 hours as it finished its crosslinking cycle under stress . as a result
a homogeneous elastomer was prepared where the nanotubes had a preferred orientation induced by the processing technique and are also well dispersed in the matrix .
the degree of nanotube alignment in each sample was quantified using x - ray techniques ( discussed below ) .
there is a separate question of solvent and shearing conditions , and the time required for the full mwcnt dispersion ; systematic studies of nanotube dispersion and re - aggregation rates are to be published shortly . the quality of nanotube dispersion is monitored throughout the processing with the use , initially , of optical microscopes and later with a high - resolution scanning electron microscope ( hrsem , phillips xl 30 series ) as aggregate sizes reduce below optical resolution .
we find that a shearing regime of high - viscosity mixture , lasting 24 hours , is suitable in removing nanotube aggregates .
samples are identified by the wt% of mwcnts mixed with the pdms and the abbreviations assigned to them in table [ tablemats ] .
most experiments have been conducted on the 0 , 0.02 , 0.3 , 0.5 , 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 and 7wt% mwcnts in pdms elastomer films .
a sample with 3wt% carbon black instead of nanotubes has also been made using the same procedure .
there is a wealth of literature regarding liquid crystal elastomer ( lce ) preparation @xcite . for our purposes ,
we have tested two specific types of lce : polydomain and monodomain , with uniaxially aligned nematic director .
control samples containing no nanotubes were made , following the procedure introduced in @xcite and widely used in the field since .
the procedure of nanocomposite preparation was detailed in @xcite .
the polysiloxane backbone chains ( @xmath5 monomer units long ) had their si@xmath6h bonds reacted , using platinic acid catalyst , with the terminal vinyl groups of the mesogenic rod - like molecule @xmath7methoxyphenyl ) @xmath8buteneoxy benzoate ( mbb ) and the two - functional crosslinker @xmath9,@xmath7di-@xmath10undeceneoxy benzene ( 11ub ) , with the molar ratio 18:1 ( thus achieving the 9:1 ratio of substituted groups on each chain , or the effective 10% crosslinking density ) .
the crosslinking was initiated by a combination of adding the catalyst and heating to 80@xmath11c in the already described centrifugation reaction chamber .
the subsequent procedure of two - stage crosslinking , with intermediate stretching to induce director alignment , is similar to the procedure of pdms alignment above .
polydomain control samples were made identically with the single exception that no uniaxial extension is applied during the crosslinking cycle .
this avoids orientational bias being introduced during processing . for lce nanocomposites ,
a minor modification is made . before the crosslinker and catalyst were added ,
mwcnts were shear mixed into the polymer to ensure homogenous dispersion . due to the sensitivity of the crosslinker and catalyst ,
shear mixing is reduced to 4 hours at elevated temperatures ( @xmath1250@xmath13 .
this is acceptable as the nanotube concentration in such systems was very small ( 0.15 - 0.2wt% ) while the nematic polymer is highly viscous . a higher concentration in such a system is currently unachievable due to catalyst and crosslinker sensitivity limitations .
the sis nanocomposite was made by adding the desired quantity of tubes ( 0.01wt% ) to the melt of sis symmetric triblock copolymer ( 14% of polystyrene , obtained from sigma aldrich ) in the presence of small amount of toluene solvent .
the solvent dilutes the otherwise rubbery thermoplastic system and allows shear mixing at 40@xmath13 for 24 hours .
the solvent was added in small portions during the mixing cycle to maintain the mixture in a high - viscosity state .
once the dispersed state was achieved , fibers could be drawn from the mixture and left to air dry . during this period
the ps micelles are formed in the usual way @xcite to form the elastic network surrounding and encapsulating the nanotubes .
we note that too high a loading of mwcnt prevents physical crosslinks from occurring in the host polymer and thus nanotube content was kept to a very low level . in all cases
the sample dimensions were kept approximately constant , 1.5 mm @xmath14 3 cm , with thickness 0.2 mm . the main part of this study , and purpose of this paper ,
is concerned with the response of these materials to infrared radiation and to that end a specially constructed rig was built to test the actuator response .
two dynamometers were used in this study ; a 25 g dynamometer for small sensitive measurements and a larger 55 g dynamometer allowing a larger range of responses to be tested . the dynamometers ( pioden systems ltd ) were housed in a custom made thermal - control box with an open front end .
the device , together with an independent thermocouple , outputs data via a daq card to a pc , see fig .
[ appa ] . the sample ( s )
was clamped in the frame with its length controlled by the micrometer ( m ) , with @xmath150.001 mm accuracy , and the exerted force measured by the dynamometer ( d ) .
thermocouples ( @xmath16 and @xmath17 ) were placed in front and behind , on the sample surface .
the actuation was induced by the light source ( ir ) , schott kl1500 lcd , with quoted peak power density at @xmath18675 nm , 702 @xmath19w/@xmath20 at 1 m distance .
the source uniformly illuminated the sample from @xmath21 cm distance .
measuring the scaling of the intensity decay with distance , we obtained that the power density delivered to the sample was @xmath22 at 675 nm .
the rig was enclosed in the thermally controlled compartment , and calibrated with weights to give a direct measure of stress and strain .
figure [ absorbance ] shows the spectral distribution of the light source , as well as the nanotube absorbance .
these measurements were carried out on a varian cary 300 bio uv - visible spectrophotometer in the 190 - 1000 nm range , adjusted for the background .
absorbtion units au@xmath23 $ ] indicate that the pdms control sample of given thickness transmits @xmath24% of light across the spectrum .
in contrast , the same thickness of low - loading pdms0.3 composite absorbs @xmath25% of light across a range of wavelengths .
the strong absorbtion of light by nanotubes is a well - known effect , although the relatively flat spectral distribution was a surprise in our case , fig .
[ absorbance ] . to standardize the results across all samples
, pre - experimental checks were undertaken to accurately find the zero strain value of each experiment .
the gradient of the stress - strain curve for a buckled sample was equated with the gradient for the stress - strain curve of the taut sample the meeting point of the two lines designates the zero - point strain , with the length of sample defined as @xmath26 .
the imposed extensional strain is calculated by @xmath27 , with @xmath28 provided from the micrometer reading .
after a fixed pre - strain was applied to each sample , the stress was allowed to relax for a minimum of 10 minutes .
after this relaxation period , readings of stress were taken for 1 - 2 minutes , to verify that the material is equilibrated , and then the ir source was switched on to full intensity .
after a period of exposure , the light source was switched off and further relaxation data collected .
after completion , the sample was relaxed and then this protocol was repeated for a different applied pre - strain @xmath29 .
each sample is tested under a range of applied pre - strains between 2% and 40% ( @xmath30 . in order to avoid a systematic influence of pre - strain , through thermal history and possible degradation
, we applied the different values of @xmath29 in random order , not sequentially .
the lce composites have been tested for even larger deformation as they can spontaneously undergo thermal strains of hundreds of percent @xcite .
our attempts to rationalize the observed response , changing qualitatively on increasing the applied pre - strain , invoke the concept of increasing nanotube alignment under uniaxial deformation . to monitor this , wide angle x - ray diffraction measurements were carried out on a phillips pw1830 wide angle x - ray generator ( waxs ) using cu@xmath31 radiation ( 1.54@xmath32 ) , running at 40kv and 40ma .
a specially designed clamp was used allowing measurement of the x - ray images as a function of the applied strain during the experiment .
azimuthal scans of intensity were generated , fig .
[ xray ] , and fitted with theoretical models .
the method of background correction employed is crucial .
two to three different regions were selected from an image to gather an average of background noise which is then subtracted from the azimuthal curves generated .
this is repeated for all scattering images before order parameter was calculated . with the ir irradiation
, the question always exists , whether the response is due to photon absorption , or the trivial heating of the materials ( which does take place during irradiation ) .
the technique used to measure temperature involves two thermocouples and we were reasonably sure that the measured increase in temperature ( @xmath1215 - 20@xmath33c ) is a true temperature across the sample .
a separate study was conducted using thermocouples on the surface and embedded within the sample which showed similar values throughout for any relevant time - scale .
the samples were kept purposely thin to ensure very quick heat conduction . to compare the effects ,
the same experiment was carried out on the pdms1 sample , with the infrared source replaced by a mica - insulated heater ( minco products inc . )
mounted approximately 10 mm away from the sample .
temperature was regulated through an integrating controller using thermocouples mounted on the sample .
the maximum temperature reached was 15 - 20@xmath34 above ambient , and although thermo - mechanical response was present , it was much slower and almost an order of magnitude smaller than the direct ir - irradiation effect .
figure [ modu ] shows a summary of the linear mechanical response of our nanocomposites for different nanotube loadings in the crosslinked pdms matrix . as the concentration of mwcnts
is increased the rubbery network becomes stiffer and young modulus @xmath35 ( the response to static linear extension ) of the composites increases .
this is expected and in line with literature findings @xcite .
an account for subtle variations in measured moduli could be obtained from the analysis of the polymer - nanotube interface and relaxation of local stress in the composites .
this is not the focus of the work presented here . at very low
nanotube loading one might expect that large regions of rubbery network are still pristine .
however , even with the lowest nanotube loading ( @xmath120.02wt% ) , a small but significant increase in modulus was observed suggesting that the presence of the tubes even in tiny quantities has an immediate mechanical effect . starting from @xmath120.02wt% the linear increase of the modulus
was observed , characteristic of non - interacting inclusions in the elastic matrix .
we observe an almost three - fold linear increase in the elastic modulus from 0 - 7wt% .
it can be argued that at higher loading the concentration dependence must become non - linear , quadratic at first indicating the pair interactions between nanotube inclusions , etc .
this may signify the onset of a ` mechanical ' percolation within the composite system .
one may be tempted to make a connection between the onset of this non - linear regime and the separately determined electric percolation threshold , when the composite becomes conducting through nanotube contacts .
unfortunately , it is difficult to make an unambiguous connection in a crosslinked system : an increase in tube concentration would undoubtedly increase the modulus @xmath35 but would also cause a reduction in the crosslinker concentration ( the presence of nanotubes has an inhibitive effect on siloxane reactions ) .
overall , the young s modulus of such a nanocomposite would not be able to directly reflect the nanotube interactions . for completeness ,
let us quote the measured young modulus values for the other nanocomposite systems under study
mlce0.2 : @xmath36 mpa , plce0.15 : @xmath36 mpa , sis0.01 : @xmath37 mpa . as a crucial part of material characterization , before and during the main actuation experiment
, we need a more quantitative analysis of the nanotube orientation in the matrix .
it is a key element in our model of the actuation mechanism , but also has its own merit considering the high interest in all aspects of polymer nanocomposite studies .
wide angle x - ray diffraction is used as a method to determine the average tube orientation as a function of increasing applied uniaxial strain .
figure [ xray](a ) shows characteristic features of the diffraction image .
the image is for pdms7 , initially non - aligned , stretched by @xmath38 ( 33% ) .
the scattering reflection at an angle corresponding to mwcnt [ 002 ] layer periodicity ( inter - shell spacing @xcite ) of 3.4@xmath39 allows calculation of the tube orientation distribution from the corresponding azimuthal intensity variation , fig .
[ xray](b ) . in this separate study of deformation - induced alignment
we used a 7wt% loaded pdms7 composite simply to enhance the x - ray contrast and enable using a desktop x - ray generator ( as opposed to the synchrotron study required for very low - loading composites ) . note that the scattering intensity at 3.4@xmath39 is still relatively low , because of the small contrast between the nanotubes and pdms matrix .
a question must arise about the bright scattering ring corresponding to the length scale @xmath40 .
this is a very interesting feature , but totally irrelevant for our work : this scattering is exactly the same in the pristine pdms rubber prepared in the same batch . in the pdms network , with no solvent , the only x - ray contrast may arise due to the difference between the chains and crosslinks .
a very clear scattering length must be an indication of crosslink density fluctuations ( in other terminology called clustering ) .
as the extensive theory of this clustering phenomenon suggests @xcite , at the given chain lengths and crosslinking density the network is well below the ` crosslink saturation threshold ' and the correlation length of clustering should be of the order of network mesh size .
the length scale of @xmath40 is very accurately this size and , accordingly , we believe this scattering to be produced by very small scale crosslink density fluctuations .
these should not affect macroscopic properties , or even the local mwcnt embedding .
intensity variation along the azimuthal arcs , @xmath41 in fig .
[ xray](b ) , is the signature of the orientational distribution function .
when @xmath41 is approximated as a legendre polynomial series in @xmath42 , it gives a measure of the orientational order parameter s@xmath43 : @xmath44 where the averaging is performed with @xmath41 as the distribution function .
this is called the herman s orientation parameter and it adequately describes the true orientational ordering at very small bias , when @xmath45 . at higher degree of alignment
( such as , for instance , in nematic liquid crystals ) the orientational distribution function significantly deviates from the measured @xmath41 .
the analytic treatment of the problem of x - ray scattering from orientationally biased medium is developed by deutsch @xcite , mainly in the context of nematic liquid crystals .
instead of using the full theory , we have derived an interpolating analytical approximation to the complete results of @xcite . with that , the orientational order parameter is given by @xmath46 \bigg\ } d\beta \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath47 this expression also properly accounts for nontrivial geometric factors involved in projecting the 3d orientational distribution onto a 2d detector plane .
experimental data was analyzed using both herman s approximation and deutsch s interpolated analytic result .
we conclude that in the range of parameters we are working with both expressions were in agreement qualitatively but slightly differ quantitatively .
we favor the deutsch analytical method and used it exclusively in this study .
figure [ order ] presents the results of the calculation of orientational order parameter @xmath48 , acquired as a function of sample strain applied to the pdms7 sample , as well as the prediction of the theoretical model discussed below . as the applied strain is increased , the initially disordered nanotubes align along the strain axis resulting in bias in the azimuthal curve @xmath41
this phenomenon has recently been confirmed by synchrotron experiments @xcite although it should be noted that the focus of the work by kelarakis _
et al . _ was not on nanotube reorientation in a rubbery matrix .
our composites , with no significant initial alignment , on subsequent stretching reached substantial values of induced orientational order .
furthermore , the change in orientation on stretching was reversible , i.e. equilibrium , which is discussed later . to our knowledge ,
this is the first time nanotube _ reorientation _ has been reported and analyzed in a semisolid / rubbery sample . as will be described in section [ ir - sec ] ,
there is good evidence that much better nanotube alignment can be achieved if dispersed in a monodomain liquid crystal elastomer during processing the mesogenic moieties act to align the tubes .
a similar effect has been demonstrated for pure liquid crystals @xcite , and also is well - known in the field of ferronematics @xcite .
x - ray diffraction of such a system is not reported due to the continuing problem of poor contrast between the two species and only low nanotube concentrations studied . there is an issue , well argued in the literature @xcite , about whether a truly isotropic nanotube dispersion can be obtained . regarding the tubes as rigid rods with extremely high aspect ratio ,
well dispersed in an amorphous medium , the onsager transition to the steric orientational ordering could start at very low concentrations as has been recently reported @xcite .
we have as yet observed no clear indication of truly nematic liquid crystalline architecture in our system , although this could be due to a number of factors including matrix viscosity and sample preparation .
let us compare the observed induced orientational order parameter @xmath49 with a simple model prediction based on the affine deformation of the rubbery matrix .
the most straightforward approach is to evaluate the average orientational bias resulting from an imposed uniaxial extension of such a matrix , in which the ensemble of rigid rods is initially embedded isotropically .
the direction , known as the director @xmath50 , is the average axis along which nanotubes can and do align .
this is a local property of the system obtained as a result of averaging of individual particle axes , @xmath51 , over the macroscopically infinitesimal volume .
this averaging applies equally well for rigid rod - like particles and for the segments of semi - flexible chains , e.g. in the study of nematic polymers @xcite .
the corresponding local orientational order parameter is a second - rank tensor @xmath52 which for the uniaxial alignment ( reflecting the quadrupolar symmetry breaking ) is defined as : @xmath53 where the principal axes are aligned with @xmath54 along the uniform ordering direction @xmath50 , cf .
the value of the local scalar order parameter is indeed the average of the second legendre polynomial of orientation of embedded rods , @xmath55 \ , p(\theta ) \
, \sin\theta d\theta d\varphi . \label{defq}\ ] ] here @xmath56 for each rod , and @xmath57 is the orientational probability distribution , normalized such that @xmath58 .
let us assume the initial state is un - aligned , and thus characterized by the flat distribution @xmath59 .
the uniaxial extension of an incompressible elastic body is described by the matrix of strain tensor @xmath60 where the axis of stretching is taken as @xmath54 and the magnitude of stretching is @xmath61 is the ratio of the stretched and the initial sample length along @xmath54 , fig .
this tensor describes the affine change of shape , which could also be visualized as locally transforming an embedded sphere ( representing the orientational distribution @xmath62 ) into the ellipsoid ( representing the induced orientational bias ) of the same volume and the aspect ratio @xmath63 .
after such a deformation , every element of length in the body changes affinely according to the matrix product @xmath64 , which in our case of uniaxial incompressible extension means that @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
this corresponds to the new angle of the rod , @xmath67 such that @xmath68 .
therefore , to obtain the new ( now biased ) orientational distribution function we need to convert the variable @xmath69 into the new ( current ) variable @xmath67 , which gives ( after some algebraic manipulation ) @xmath70 this defines the expression for the normalized orientational distribution function @xmath71 which is an explicit function of the uniaxial strain applied to the body and can be used to calculate the induced order parameter @xmath72 : @xmath73 ^ 3 \sin \theta ' d\theta'd\varphi}{4\pi ( \cos^2 \theta ' + [ 1+\varepsilon]^3 \sin^2 \theta')^{3/2 } } - \frac{1}{2}. \label{orderaffine}\ ] ] analytical integration of this expression gives a function @xmath49 , which is plotted as a solid line in fig .
[ order ] : @xmath74 @xmath75.$ ] at relatively small strains , it approaches the linear regime : @xmath76 .
the experimental data displays a lower order parameter than that predicted by the affine model , although has the same qualitative trend .
one must remember that the model presented here does not account for tube flexibility .
also , some proportion of the tubes would be unable to orientate affinely due to the entanglements .
the experimental data reflects this and , accordingly , gives slightly lower values of order parameter .
the detailed response to infrared stimuli is presented in figs . [ steps ] , showing the stress measured in the pdms1 sample .
results for all composites are qualitatively similar
. we shall later examine the dependence on the host polymer and the tube concentration .
composites , initially un - aligned , are subjected to an increasing extension that we call pre - strain @xmath29 . at each @xmath29 ,
the ir - irradiation takes place and the stress response recorded .
the complexity of the plots necessitates more detailed description of what takes place .
we begin with a 2% pre - strain ( @xmath77 ) applied to it initially . at @xmath78mins
the light source is switched on and the stress reading changes downwards , meaning that the sample natural length @xmath26 has expanded on actuation ( recall that the actual length @xmath28 is fixed through @xmath79 ) . after a period of constant irradiation , at @xmath80mins ,
the light source is switched off and the stress reading returns to its original value .
this experiment is then repeated with the same sample pre - strained at different values , up to 40% , as shown by the sequence of stress - reading curves in fig .
[ steps ] . the data in fig .
[ speed ] is assembled to demonstrate the speed of the actuation process more clearly , while fig .
[ steps2wt ] helps differentiate between the light- and heat - driven actuation response . in this case
the data is for a pdms3 composite ; as was mentioned above , all materials exhibit the same qualitative features .
we plot the change in stress and change in temperature , normalized by their maximal value at saturation in the given experiment ; plotted in this form , all the results ( for different tube loading and different pre - strain ) appear universal .
the change in temperature by ir - heating is unavoidable and reaches @xmath81c maximally on the sample surface , in our setting ( thermocouples placed below the surface and embedded in the center of the sample may report the temperature change of up to @xmath82c depending on nanotube concentration , but we avoided disturbing the sample in mechanical experiments ) .
this highlights an important question as to whether the mechanical response is due to the photon absorption or plain heat .
figure [ steps2wt ] shows that the stress reaches its peak and saturation in @xmath83min , while the thermal takes over 2min to reach its peak .
although the difference in rates is not very dramatic , the fact that the stress response is faster suggests that its mechanism is not caused by the trivial sample heating . in a separate study ( not shown )
we reach the conclusion that thermo - mechanical effects do exist ( i.e. the mwcnt - loaded composite has a stronger mechanical response to heating than a pristine polymer ) but their magnitude is almost an order of magnitude smaller than the direct ir - photon absorption mechanism . of great interest is the observation that this response changes sign at a certain level of pre - strain ( at @xmath84 in fig . [ steps ] ) . in other words ,
relaxed or weakly stretched composites show the reversible _ expansion _ on irradiation , while the same sample , once strained more significantly , demonstrates an increasing tendency to _ contract _ ( hence the increase in the measured stress ) .
this is our key finding .
figure [ sum ] summarizes the magnitude of the ir - actuation effect by plotting the stress step at saturation ( @xmath85 ) in the ir - on state , at different levels of pre - strain and for samples with increasing mwcnt loading .
although this is not explicitly measured in our ( isostrain , @xmath86const ) experiment , we can directly calculate the change of the underlying natural length @xmath26(ir ) of the samples on actuation from the known young modulus values .
this is shown on the right axis of the same plot , highlighting the regions of expansion and contraction .
remarkably , all samples with different nanotube loading appear to have a crossover at the same point , around 10% pre - strain . for comparison ,
the pristine pdms rubber in the same experiment , shows no discernible stress response at all . also , the response of the pdms composite with a 3wt% of carbon black is much lower . indeed
, this 3wt% carbon - black composite closely follows the low - concentration pdms0.02 composite .
we believe the response is due to trace amounts of nanotubes that can often be found in commercially supplied carbon black .
hence the very small response from such a highly loaded sample .
the shift in transition pre - strain may well be due to the trace nanotubes having their alignment hindered by the activated carbon black .
the interaction between filler particles is also evident when the nanotube concentration is increased beyond 2wt% loading . above this value , the magnitude of the actuation stroke decreases sharply .
figure [ interplay ] displays the effect clearly by plotting the maximal change in natural length @xmath26 on ir irradiation , at a fixed @xmath87 , for all pdms - nanotube composites , and the 3wt% carbon black system for comparison .
a rapid increase in the stroke is observed with increasing concentration , which then peaks at 2wt% nanotube loading .
the reason for the subsequent decline is not obvious .
there may well be a number of factors that interplay to reduce the stroke magnitude . at high concentrations entanglements between the long tubes
could take place .
note that through conservation of volume , a contraction in the @xmath54-axis of the tube will be concomitant with an expansion in the @xmath88-@xmath89 plane ; such expansion may be hindered for a significant number of nanotubes by their nearest neighbors ( another representation of entanglement ) .
there may also be an issue of photon screening at higher concentration which is difficult to avoid . other polymers acting as a crosslinked host matrix for the low - concentration nanocomposite display the same qualitative behavior as pdms systems .
figure [ polydomaincnt ] summarizes the response of lce and sis composites .
the direction of the actuation , changing from expansive to contractive mode with increasing mwcnt alignment , as observed in pdms - nanotube samples , is unambiguously reproduced for vastly different materials . the magnitude of the actuation stroke is shown in fig . [ polydomaincnt ] , in comparison with some of the pdms composites .
the value of actuation stress is different for various polymeric systems considered in this work , which is due to the different young modulus ( which we use to calculate the stroke from the measured stress @xmath90 ) .
we see that the stroke magnitude in these differing materials is in the same range of magnitudes .
sis0.01 has a much lower filler concentration , and again its stroke is comparable to that of a similarly loaded pdms0.02 .
this important finding demonstrates the universality of multi - walled nanotubes behaving as photo - actuators regardless of the soft matrix they are in .
the response of nematic liquid crystal elastomers to heat is well documented @xcite . because they can be thermo - responsive materials , the data in fig .
[ polydomaincnt ] is obtained by a complex procedure of subtraction of such background effects .
we do not go into its details , as this is irrelevant to the main points of the present paper , however , must emphasize that the plotted response highlights the effect of nanotubes within the given matrix . in fig .
[ polydomaincnt ] we note that the mlce0.2 sample shows no expansive actuation and a crossover , while the similar polydomain ( un - aligned ) composite does .
this is clearly because the two - step crosslinking at preparation of the monodomain material involves aligning the mesogenic groups @xcite .
the embedded nanotubes align strongly under such conditions , as others have found in ordinary liquid nematics @xcite .
as already discussed , the expansive mode of actuation will only occur when the degree of nanotube alignment is very low .
it is important that the crossover occurs at @xmath91% for all studied materials with nanotubes not aligned before pre - strain .
there are two main questions to answer : what mechanism is responsible for such a large photo - mechanical response , and why does it reverse its direction on sample extension ? we shall try to deduce the actuation behavior of individual tubes from the macroscopic observations detailed above .
we believe the change of actuation direction on increasing sample extension is due to the nanotube alignment induced by pre - strain , as described in section [ xraydata ] and before . in the whole region of our pre - strains ,
the orientational order induced in the mwcnt distribution is , to a good approximation , a linear function of the strain : @xmath92 in the affine model . at the crossover strain @xmath93
, the value of the order parameter would be @xmath94 .
we now apply the same ideas about the induced orientational bias and averaging of the ( hypothetical ) individual nanotube response .
let us assume this individual nanotube response to the ir photon absorbtion is , in essence , a contraction because this is what our data shows the better - aligned composite response to be .
it is easy to imagine why this could be for an initially rod - like tube : on photon absorption it could generate instabilities in the form of kinks , thus decreasing the net length due to the charge carrier separation .
the resulting elastic deformation would be most pronounced in the already defect - dominated regions of the nanotube .
such an explanation , based on concentration of induced polarons @xcite , would also link with the earlier observation of a similar actuation response under dc electric field @xcite .
an alternative possibility is to suggest that large ( and fast ) local tube heating @xcite causes the surrounding region of locally aligned elastomer to contract and `` crush '' the nanotube .
this version of microscopic events does not contradict the discussion and the data in fig .
[ steps2wt ] , which shows the ( slow ) global thermal effect . at this stage
we have to leave open the question of individual tube response to near ir radiation . using an affine approach similar to the earlier analysis of ordering ,
let us assume that each nanotube undergoes a linear contraction by a factor @xmath95 ( certainly proportional to radiation intensity , which was kept constant in our work but has previously been shown to effect the elastic response @xcite ) .
this contraction must be accompanied by a transversely - isotropic volume conserving expansion @xmath96 .
this means that a local strain is created with the principal axes along the nanotube orientation ( at angle @xmath69 to the macroscopic @xmath54-axis , see fig .
[ affi ] ) @xmath97 the projection of this local strain on the macroscopic axis of sample extension ( and force measurement ) is @xmath98 averaging the local contribution with the probability to find the nanotube at this orientation , @xmath99 obtained in section [ xraydata ] , gives an estimate of the effective stroke of the actuation .
when multiplied by the corresponding young modulus , the exerted stress of fig .
[ sum ] is also obtained : @xmath100 at small deformations .
such a model is very crude indeed , ignoring a large number of undoubtedly important and delicate factors of continuum elasticity and nanotube response .
however , it is elastically self - consistent and has only one parameter , @xmath101 that presumably carries all the underlying complexity of the problem in it .
the orientational averaging is given by using the distribution @xmath99 with the projection of local strain in eq .
( [ lz ] ) : @xmath102 p(\theta ) \ , \sin\theta d\theta d\varphi \nonumber \\ &
\approx & { \textstyle{\frac{1}{3 } } } \left(\delta + 2/\sqrt{\delta } \right ) -{\textstyle{\frac{2}{5 } } } \varepsilon \left ( 1/\sqrt{\delta } - \delta \right ) \label{avl}\end{aligned}\ ] ] although the integral above has a full analytic form , it is more transparent to present its expansion to the linear order of small imposed pre - strain @xmath29 as shown in the second line of eq.([avl ] ) .
this demonstrates the key point : at very low pre - strain , @xmath103 , the average uniaxial deformation of the disordered nanocomposite is positive @xmath104 , i.e. the expansion of its natural length .
however , above a threshold pre - strain @xmath105 this average deformations transforms into the sample contraction along @xmath54 .
it is easy to find the crossover , @xmath106 so that the prediction would be to observe the crossover at @xmath107 if the nanotube response factor @xmath108 .
that is , on ir - irradiation the nanotube contracts overall by @xmath1220% .
the value is higher than one might expect , considering early reports in the literature of nanotube strains of only 1 - 2% .
however , as fig .
[ affi ] indicates , our proposition is not that of the lattice strain of nanotube walls but a contortion of the tube as a whole .
although this has not been yet directly observed and reported in the literature , a similar effect of resonant undulation has been seen ( in simulation @xcite and in experiment @xcite ) in response to distortion beyond the linear regime .
furthermore , the more recent theoretical work on single - walled tubes supports the idea that massive @xmath109axis contraction .
although in our system the multi - walled tubes respond under different conditions , being embedded in an elastic matrix under strain and absorbing the ir photons , the overall distortion factor of 20% suggested by the model fit is perhaps not altogether unreasonable .
figure [ theo ] plots the full ( non - expanded ) result of orientational averaging of actuation stroke @xmath110 from the integral in eq.([avl ] ) to illustrate the points discussed in this section . the qualitative behavior ( as summarized in fig . [ sum ] )
is reproduced here almost exactly , including the magnitude of the predicted actuation stroke [ that is , the ratio @xmath111 .
note that we use only one parameter , @xmath101 to match both the crossover @xmath105 and the actuation stroke magnitude , so the conclusion is quite satisfactory and agrees with an apparent universality discussed in section [ hosts ] .
it is very likely that the orientational feature of the effect , with its change of actuation direction at a critical level of induced alignment , @xmath112 , is captioned correctly , while much more work is required to understand the individual nanotube response to ir radiation generating the phenomenological factor @xmath101 used in this analysis .
to summarize , this work describes the rich photo - actuation phenomena of carbon nanotubes embedded in crosslinked rubbery matrices .
the composite materials show the ability to change their actuation direction , from expansive to contractive response , as greater imposed strain is applied to the sample .
we use differing host polymers and confirm their relatively neutral role in the actuation mechanism .
theoretical models have been put forward to describe the orientational order imposed on the nanotubes by a uniaxial strain and the resulting actuation .
treating the nanotubes as rigid rods that rotate affinely in a deforming matrix is a very simplistic view , but it gives predictions that agree with experiment qualitatively and often quantitatively .
we believe that the ( certainly wrong ) idea of the whole tube acting as a rigid rod is not actually necessary in effect , in our model , the `` rigid rods '' are nanotube segments below persistence length . in that case , as in main - chain semiflexible nematic polymers , the model is non - controversial and the agreement with experiment not coincidental .
the tube orientational distribution appears to account well for the key macroscopic features of the observed photo - actuation .
the strength of photo - mechanical response , at a given radiation intensity , is of the order of tens of kpa .
translated into the stroke , this corresponds to actuation strains of + 2 ( expansion ) to -10% ( contraction ) depending on the nanotube concentration , alignment ( controlled by pre - applied strain ) and the host matrix .
as expected , the response increases at higher nanotube loading
however , only up to a limit . beyond this limit ( @xmath113 in pdms ) , the macroscopic actuation is inhibited by inter - tube interactions and possible charge accumulation .
the similar ( thermal actuation ) behavior is also observed when the samples are heated by the same amount , but this has a much lower amplitude .
understanding the nature of the actuator mechanisms in this system certainly warrants further theoretical and experimental investigation .
many questions remain completely unclear , in particular , what the effect would be if different types of nanotube were used i.e. smaller multi - wall diameters , single - wall tubes , various chirality etc . with actuating materials already used in such widespread applications , from micromanipulators to vibration control , the discovery of a structure that can respond to stimulus in both directions may open new possibilities and could mean an important new step toward finding applications for nanotube based materials above and beyond improvements in existing carbon fibre technologies .
we thank h. krner , r. vaia , a. craig and p. cicuta for useful discussions , and k. channon for help with nanotube absorbance data .
this work was carried out with the support of the engineering and physical sciences research council and a case award from makevale ltd . | rubber composites containing multi - walled carbon nanotubes have been irradiated with near infrared light to study their reversible photo - mechanical actuation response .
we demonstrate that the actuation is reproducible across differing polymer systems .
the response is directly related to the degree of uniaxial alignment of the nanotubes in the matrix , contracting the samples along the alignment axis .
the actuation stroke depends on the specific polymer being tested , however , the general response is universal for all composites tested .
we conduct a detailed study of tube alignment induced by stress and propose a model for the reversible actuation behavior , based on the orientational averaging of the local response .
the single phenomenological parameter of this model describes the response of an individual tube to adsorption of low - energy photons ; its experimentally determined value may suggest some ideas about such a response . |
it is well - known that the linear inequalities always satisfied by ranks of subspaces of a vector space ( referred to here as _ linear rank inequalities _ ) are closely related to the linear inequalities satisfied by entropies of jointly distributed random variables ( often referred to as _ information inequalities _ ) . for background material on this relationship and other topics used here , a useful source is hammer , romashchenko , shen , and vereshchagin @xcite .
the present paper is about linear rank inequalities ; nonetheless , the basic results from information theory will be useful enough that we choose to use the notation of information theory here .
we use the following common definitions : @xmath0 there are two interpretations of these equations .
when @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 are random variables , @xmath4 denotes the joint random variable combining @xmath1 and @xmath2 ; @xmath5 is the entropy of @xmath1 ; @xmath6 is the entropy of @xmath1 given @xmath2 ; @xmath7 is the mutual information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 ; and @xmath8 is the mutual information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 given @xmath3 .
but when @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 denote subspaces of a vector space , then @xmath4 denotes the space spanned by @xmath1 and @xmath2 , which is @xmath9 or , since @xmath1 and @xmath2 are subspaces , just @xmath10 ; @xmath5 is the rank of @xmath1 ; @xmath6 is the excess of the rank of @xmath1 over that of @xmath11 ; @xmath7 is the rank of @xmath11 ; and @xmath8 is the excess of the rank of @xmath12 over that of @xmath3 . in either interpretation ,
the equations above are valid .
the basic shannon inequalities state that @xmath8 ( as well as the reduced forms @xmath7 , @xmath6 , and @xmath5 ) is nonnegative for any random variables @xmath13
. any nonnegative linear combination of basic shannon inequalities is called a shannon inequality .
we will use standard shannon computations such as @xmath14 ( one can check this by expanding into basic @xmath15 terms ) and @xmath16 ( because the difference is @xmath8 ) throughout this paper ; an excellent source for background material on this is yeung @xcite .
a key well - known fact is that all information inequalities ( and in particular the shannon inequalities ) are also linear rank inequalities for finite - dimensional vector spaces . to see this
, first note that in the case of a _ finite _ vector space @xmath17 over a finite field @xmath18 , each subspace can be turned into a random variable so that the entropy of the random variable is the same ( up to a constant factor ) as the rank of the subspace : let @xmath19 be a random variable ranging uniformly over @xmath20 ( the set of linear functions from @xmath17 to @xmath18 ) , and to each subspace @xmath1 of @xmath17 associate the random variable @xmath21 .
the entropy of this random variable will be the rank of @xmath1 , if entropy logarithms are taken to base @xmath22 .
for the infinite case , one can use the theorem of rado @xcite that any representable matroid is representable over a finite field , and hence any configuration of finite - rank vector spaces over any field has a corresponding configuration over some finite field .
the converse is not true ; there are linear rank inequalities which are not information inequalities .
the first such example is the ingleton inequality , which in terms of basic ranks or joint entropies is @xmath23 but which can be written more succinctly using the @xmath24 notation as @xmath25 ingleton @xcite proved this inequality and asked whether there are still further independent inequalities of this kind . a key tool used by hammer et al .
@xcite is the notion of common information .
a random variable @xmath26 is a _ common information _ of random variables @xmath1 and @xmath2 if it satisfies the following conditions : @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath29 . in other words
, @xmath26 encapsulates the mutual information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 . in general , two random variables @xmath1 and @xmath2 might not have a common information .
but in the context of vector spaces ( or the random variables coming from them ) , common informations always exist ; if @xmath1 and @xmath2 are subspaces of a vector space , one can just let @xmath26 be the intersection of @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and @xmath26 will have the desired properties . hammer et al .
@xcite showed that the ingleton inequality ( and its permuted - variable forms ) and the shannon inequalities fully characterize the cone of linearly representable entropy vectors on four random variables ( i.e. , there are no more linear rank inequalities to be found on four variables ) .
we will answer ingleton s question here . using the existence of common informations
, one can prove the following twenty - four new linear rank inequalities on five variables ( this is a complete and irreducible list , as will be explained below ) .
@xmath30 @xmath31 ( note that there is much more variety of form in these inequalities than there is in the four - variable non - shannon - type inequalities from @xcite . )
each of these inequalities is provable from the shannon inequalities if we assume that each mutual information on the left - hand side of the inequality is in fact realized by a common information .
( hence , since such common informations always exist in the linear case , the inequalities are all linear rank inequalities . ) for instance , inequalities ( 1)(10 ) all hold if we assume that there is a random variable @xmath26 such that @xmath32 and @xmath33 ; inequality ( 23 ) holds if there exist random variables @xmath26 and @xmath34 such that @xmath35 , @xmath33 , and @xmath36 ; and so on .
these assertions can all be verified using the program itip @xcite .
in fact , all of these become shannon inequalities if we replace the left - hand mutual information(s ) with terms @xmath37 or @xmath38 and add to the right - hand side appropriate terms like @xmath39 for a sufficiently large coefficient @xmath40 ( @xmath41 suffices for all of these inequalities ) .
for example , for inequality ( 1 ) , one can show that @xmath42 is a shannon inequality ; if we set @xmath26 to be a common information for @xmath1 and @xmath2 , we get inequality ( 1 ) . again
the verifications of these shannon inequalities can be performed using itip , or one can work them out explicitly . in section [ proofs ]
we will present various alternate proof techniques .
these inequalities can be written in other equivalent forms .
obvious rewrites ( move the first term on the right to the left ) : @xmath43 obvious rewrites ( enlarge terms on the left so they can be combined ) : @xmath44 non - obvious rewrites : @xmath45 note that , for these variant forms , we do _ not _ make the claim that the inequality follows from the existence of common informations corresponding to the left - hand - side terms .
for instance , inequality ( 19c ) does not follow from the shannon inequalities and the existence of a common information for @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
it turns out that inequality ( 24b ) is provable from existence of a common information for @xmath46 and @xmath47 , and inequalities ( 19b ) , ( 21b ) , ( 22b ) , and ( 23b ) are provable from existence of a common information for @xmath1 and @xmath48 , but inequalities ( 18b ) and ( 20b ) are not ; in fact , no single common information ( together with the shannon inequalities ) suffices to prove ( 18 ) or ( 20 ) .
in this section we will provide some alternate proof techniques for the inequalities .
this will lead to natural generalizations .
[ lem : rtoz ] the inequality @xmath49 is a shannon inequality . using shannon inequalities , we see that @xmath50 so @xmath51 ; add @xmath52 to both sides to get the desired result . if @xmath53 , then @xmath54 . + [ cor:1 ] let @xmath26 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 , so that @xmath32 and @xmath33 . then @xmath55}\\ & \ge i(z;z|c)+i(z;z|d)+i(c;d ) & { & [ \mbox{from corollary \ref{cor:1 } using $ h(z|b)=0$}]}\\ & = h(z|c)+h(z|d)+i(c;d)\\ & \ge h(z|c ) + i(z;c ) & { & [ \mbox{from lemma \ref{lem : rtoz}}]}\\ & \ge i(z;z ) & { & [ \mbox{from lemma \ref{lem : rtoz}}]}\\ & = h(z)\\ & = i(a;b).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is essentially the proof given in hammer et al
. @xcite .
let @xmath26 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 ; then @xmath56}\\ & = h(z|c)+h(z|d)+i(c;d|e)+i(z;e ) \\
& \ge i(z;z|e)+i(z;e ) & { & [ \mbox{from lemma \ref{lem : rtoz } twice}]}\\ & = h(z|e)+i(z;e ) \\ & = h(z ) \\ & = i(a;b).\end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath26 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 ; then @xmath57}\\ & = h(z|c)+i(z;c|d)+i(z;d|e)+i(z;e ) \\ & \ge i(z;z|d)+i(z;d|e)+i(z;e ) & { & [ \mbox{from lemma \ref{lem : rtoz}}]}\\ & = h(z|d)+i(z;d|e)+i(z;e)\\ & \ge i(z;z|e)+i(z;e ) & { & [ \mbox{from lemma \ref{lem : rtoz}}]}\\ & = h(z|e)+i(z;e ) \\ & = h(z)\\ & = i(a;b).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the same pattern allows us to prove more general inequalities : if @xmath58 and @xmath59 have a common information , then : @xmath60 ( note that is related to results in makarychev and makarychev @xcite . )
these can be generalized further ; for instance , in the right hand side of any number of @xmath58 s may be replaced by @xmath59 s and/or vice versa . in fact :
[ thm : tree1 ] suppose we have a finite binary tree where the root is labeled with an information term @xmath61 and each other node is labeled with a term @xmath62 .
these terms may involve any variables .
we single out two variables or combinations of variables , called @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
suppose that , for each node of the tree , if its label is @xmath62 [ we allow @xmath63 to be empty at the root ] , then : @xmath64 @xmath65 is @xmath1 or @xmath2 and there is no left child , or @xmath66 there is a left child and it is labeled @xmath67 for some @xmath68 and @xmath69 ; and @xmath70 @xmath71 is @xmath1 or @xmath2 and there is no right child , or @xmath72 there is a right child and it is labeled @xmath73 for some @xmath74 .
then the inequality @xmath75 is a linear rank inequality ( in fact , it is true whenever @xmath1 and @xmath2 have a common information ) .
let @xmath26 be a new variable .
we prove by induction in the tree ( from the leaves toward the root ) that , for each node @xmath76 , if @xmath77 is the subtree rooted at @xmath76 , and the node label at @xmath76 is @xmath78 , then we have as a shannon inequality @xmath79 for some @xmath80 .
( the inductive step uses lemma [ lem : rtoz ] . )
applying this when @xmath76 is the root and @xmath26 is a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 gives the desired result .
we get the ingleton inequality and inequalities ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) by applying this to the trees : ( 6.5,1)(-0.25,-0.25 ) ( 1,0.5)(0,0)[r]ingleton : ( 3,0.5)(0,0)@xmath81 ( 2.625,0.125)(1,2)0.125 ( 3.375,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.375,0)(0,0)@xmath8 ( 3.625,0)(0,0)@xmath82 ( 6.5,1.5)(0.375,-0.25 ) ( 1.625,1)(0,0)[r](1 ) : ( 3,1)(0,0)@xmath83 ( 3.375,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.625,0.5)(0,0)@xmath84 ( 3.25,0.125)(1,2)0.125 ( 4,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3,0)(0,0)@xmath8 ( 4.25,0)(0,0)@xmath82 ( 6.5,2)(0.6875,-0.25 ) ( 1.9375,1.5)(0,0)[r](2 ) : ( 3,1.5)(0,0)@xmath85 ( 3.375,1.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.625,1)(0,0)@xmath86 ( 4,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 4.25,0.5)(0,0)@xmath87 ( 4.625,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 4.875,0)(0,0)@xmath8 a longer `` linear '' tree like the last one gives , while a complete binary tree of height @xmath76 gives . here
is another version of theorem [ thm : tree1 ] : [ thm : list1 ] let @xmath88 , @xmath89 , @xmath90 , @xmath91 be a list of information terms , where each @xmath92 is chosen from the list @xmath93 with the exception that @xmath94 is empty ( i.e. , the first information term is just @xmath95 ) .
suppose that each of the variables @xmath96 is used exactly twice , once as a @xmath97 and once as an @xmath98 or @xmath99 ; while variables @xmath1 and @xmath2 may be used as many times as desired as an @xmath98 or @xmath99 , but are not used as a @xmath97 .
then the inequality @xmath100 is a linear rank inequality ( in fact , it is true whenever @xmath1 and @xmath2 have a common information ) .
we build a tree for use in theorem [ thm : tree1 ] .
each node will be labeled with one of the terms @xmath101 .
the root is labeled @xmath95 .
if we have a node @xmath101 where @xmath98 is not @xmath1 or @xmath2 , then create a left child for this node and label it @xmath102 for the unique @xmath103 such that @xmath104 .
similarly , if @xmath99 is not @xmath1 or @xmath2 , then create a right child for this node and label it @xmath102 for the unique @xmath103 such that @xmath105 .
it is easy to show that no term @xmath101 will be used more than once in this construction ( look for the counterexample nearest the root ) .
hence , the constuction will terminate , and the sum of the labels used is less than or equal to @xmath106 ( it does not matter if some of the terms @xmath101 are not used as labels ) .
now theorem [ thm : tree1 ] gives the desired result .
theorem [ thm : list1 ] directly gives the ingleton inequality and inequalities ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) .
it also gives a number of the other listed inequalities once we write them in an equivalent form using equations such as @xmath107 : @xmath108 for instance , inequality ( 5d ) is obtained from theorem [ thm : list1 ] using the list of random variables @xmath109 another approach is to prove the inequality @xmath110 directly from theorem [ thm : list1 ] and then apply the variable substitution @xmath111 to get ( 5d ) .
similarly , the other inequalities listed above are substitution instances of linear - variable inequalities on five to eight variables .
( note that ( 3d ) , ( 4d ) , and ( 11d ) are substitution instances of ( 1c ) . )
we will now generalize theorem [ thm : tree1 ] so as to generate additional inequalities .
one easy but apparently useless generalization is to replace the binary tree with a binary forest ( a finite disjoint union of binary trees ) .
then the hypotheses of theorem [ thm : tree1 ] can be stated just as before ( with `` the root '' replaced by `` each root '' ) ; and the conclusion is the same except that the inequality becomes @xmath112 where @xmath113 is the number of trees ( eqivalently , the number of root nodes ) .
this modification alone is useless because the resulting inequality is just a sum of theorem [ thm : tree1 ] inequalities , one for each tree .
but it will become useful when combined with another modification .
for this we need a tightening of lemma [ lem : rtoz ] : [ lem : rtozplus ] the inequality @xmath114 is a shannon inequality .
the proof is just as for lemma [ lem : rtoz ] , with the slack made explicit in one step . using shannon inequalities , we see that @xmath115 so @xmath116 ; add @xmath52 to both sides to get the desired result .
using this twice ( and noting that @xmath117 and @xmath118 ) , we get @xmath119 the case where @xmath120 is a null variable gives @xmath121 these give us additional options in proving inequalities , as shown below .
let @xmath26 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 ; then @xmath122}\\ & = h(z|c)+h(z|d)+h(z|e)+i(c;d)+i({{c},{d}};e)\\ & \ge h(z)+h(z|{{c},{d}})+h(z|e)+i({{c},{d}};e ) & { & [ \mbox{from \eqref{eq : zrs}}]}\\ & \ge h(z)+h(z)+h(z|{{c},{d},{e } } ) & { & [ \mbox{from \eqref{eq : zrs}}]}\\ & \ge 2h(z ) \\ & = 2i(a;b).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this proof immediately generalizes to give : if @xmath1 and @xmath2 have a common information , then @xmath123 .
\label{eq : np2varineq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression in brackets is actually symmetric in @xmath124 ; it is equal to @xmath125 one can use lemma [ lem : rtozplus ] to produce an extended form of theorem [ thm : tree1 ] in which an additional option is available : instead of having a left child , a node can have a _ left pointer _ pointing to some other node anywhere in the tree or forest , and similarly on the right side .
[ thm : tree2 ] suppose we have a finite binary forest where each node is labeled with an information term @xmath62 , where @xmath63 is empty at each root node ( i.e. , the root labels are of the form @xmath61 ) .
these terms may involve any variables .
we single out two variables or combinations of variables , called @xmath1 and @xmath2 .
suppose that , for each node of the forest , if its label is @xmath62 [ with @xmath63 possibly empty ] , then : @xmath64 @xmath65 is @xmath1 or @xmath2 and there is no left child , or @xmath66 there is a left child of this node and it is labeled @xmath67 for some @xmath126 , or @xmath127 there is a left pointer at this node pointing to some other node whose label is @xmath128 where @xmath129 ; and @xmath70 @xmath71 is @xmath1 or @xmath2 and there is no right child , or @xmath72 there is a right child of this node and it is labeled @xmath73 for some @xmath74 , or @xmath130 there is a right pointer at this node pointing to some other node whose label is @xmath128 where @xmath131 .
suppose further that no node is the destination of more than one pointer .
let @xmath113 be the number of trees in the forest ( equivalently , the number of root nodes ) .
then the inequality @xmath132 is a linear rank inequality ( in fact , it is true whenever @xmath1 and @xmath2 have a common information ) .
as with theorem [ thm : tree1 ] , let @xmath26 be a new variable . for any left or right pointer , if @xmath78 is the label at the destination of the pointer , we say that the _ term associated with the pointer _ is @xmath133 .
we prove by induction in the forest ( upward from the leaves toward the roots ) that , for each node @xmath76 , if @xmath77 is the subtree rooted at @xmath76 , and the node label at @xmath76 is @xmath78 , then we have as a shannon inequality @xmath134 for some @xmath80 , where @xmath135 is the sum of the terms associated with pointers _ from _ nodes in @xmath77 and @xmath136 is the sum of the terms asasociated with pointers _ to _ nodes in @xmath77 .
( a pointer whose source and destination are both in @xmath77 will contribute to both sums , but these contributions will cancel each other out . )
the inductive step uses lemma [ lem : rtozplus ] ; the new term in that lemma is used to handle the case where there is a pointer with destination @xmath76 ( note that , by assumption , there is at most one such pointer ) .
once is proved , apply it to all of the root nodes and add the resulting inequalities together to get @xmath137 for some @xmath138 ; the pointer sums cancel out because each pointer contributes to one @xmath139 sum and one @xmath140 sum . applying when @xmath26 is a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 gives the desired result .
theorem [ thm : tree2 ] can be used to prove inequalities ( 8) and ( 9 ) using the following diagrams ( pointers are represented as dashed curves ) : ( 6.5,1.25)(-0.25,-0.25 ) ( 0.4,0.5)(0,0)[r](8 ) : ( 4,0.5)(0,0)@xmath141 ( 4.375,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2,0.5)(0,0)@xmath81 ( 4.625,0)(0,0)@xmath142 ( 1.625,0.125)(1,2)0.125 ( 2.375,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.375,0)(0,0)@xmath8 ( 2.625,0)(0,0)@xmath82 ( 3.0,0.5)(0,0)=1.5 ( 6.5,1.5)(-0.25,-0.5 ) ( 0.4,0.5)(0,0)[r](9 ) : ( 1.625,0.5)(0,0)@xmath143 ( 2,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.25,0)(0,0)@xmath144 ( 4.5,0.5)(0,0)@xmath145 ( 4.125,0.125)(1,2)0.125 ( 4.875,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.875,0)(0,0)@xmath82 ( 5.125,0)(0,0)@xmath142 ( 3.375,0.25)(0,0)=1.8 and by using equivalent forms of terms as was done in formulas ( 3d ) through ( 17d ) , one can use theorem [ thm : tree2 ] to prove formulas ( 6 ) , ( 10 ) , ( 19b ) , and ( 21b)(24b ) via the following diagrams : ( 6.5,2.25)(-0.25,-0.5 ) ( 0.4,1.5)(0,0)[r](6 ) : ( 2.125,1.5)(0,0)@xmath143 ( 2.5,1.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.75,1.0)(0,0)@xmath146 ( 2.375,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 2.125,0.5)(0,0)@xmath147 ( 3.125,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.375,0.5)(0,0)@xmath148 ( 3.75,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 4,0)(0,0)@xmath149 ( 3.9375,0.5)(0,0)=1.9 ( 6.5,2)(-0.25,-0.5 ) ( 0.4,1.0)(0,0)[r](10 ) : ( 1.125,1.0)(0,0)@xmath83 ( 1.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath148 ( 2.125,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.375,0)(0,0)@xmath150 ( 4.125,1)(0,0)@xmath81 ( 3.75,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 4.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.5,0.5)(0,0)@xmath8 ( 4.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath82 ( 3.25,0.5)(0,0)=1.3 ( 6.5,2.5)(-0.25,-1 ) ( 0.4,1)(0,0)[r](19b ) : ( 1.125,1.0)(0,0)@xmath151 ( 0.75,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 0.5,0.5)(0,0)@xmath152 ( 1.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath153 ( 2.125,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.375,0)(0,0)@xmath154 ( 4.125,1)(0,0)@xmath145 ( 3.625,0.625)(1,1)0.25 ( 4.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.375,0.5)(0,0)@xmath87 ( 3.75,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 4,0)(0,0)@xmath155 ( 5.125,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 5.375,0)(0,0)@xmath156 ( 4.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath157 ( 3.25,0.5)(0,0)=1.3 ( 3.59,0.25)(0,0)=4.5 ( 6.5,2.25)(-0.25,-0.75 ) ( 0.4,1)(0,0)[r](21b ) : ( 1.125,1.0)(0,0)@xmath151 ( 0.75,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 0.5,0.5)(0,0)@xmath152 ( 1.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath153 ( 2.125,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.375,0)(0,0)@xmath158 ( 2.75,-0.375)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3,-0.5)(0,0)@xmath159 ( 4.125,1)(0,0)@xmath160 ( 3.75,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 4.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.5,0.5)(0,0)@xmath155 ( 5.125,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 5.375,0)(0,0)@xmath161 ( 4.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath162 ( 3.25,0.5)(0,0)=3.8 ( 5.3125,0.5)(0,0)=1.9 ( 6.5,3)(-0.25,-0.5 ) ( 0.32,2)(0,0)[r](22b ) : ( 1.0,1.0)(0,0)@xmath85 ( 0.625,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 0.375,0.5)(0,0)@xmath152 ( 1.375,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.625,0.5)(0,0)@xmath162 ( 2,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.25,0)(0,0)@xmath163 ( 2.75,1.5)(0,0)@xmath81 ( 2.375,1.125)(1,2)0.125 ( 2.125,1)(0,0)@xmath155 ( 3.125,1.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3.375,1)(0,0)@xmath164 ( 3.75,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 4,0.5)(0,0)@xmath165 ( 4.5,2.0)(0,0)@xmath85 ( 4.125,1.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 3.875,1.5)(0,0)@xmath152 ( 4.875,1.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 5.125,1.5)(0,0)@xmath166 ( 5.5,1.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 5.75,1)(0,0)@xmath155 ( 0.875,0.5)(0,0)=2.3 ( 2.3125,0.75)(0,0)=1.8 ( 4.0625,1.25)(0,0)=1.8 ( 6.5,2.5)(-0.125,-1 ) ( 0.525,1)(0,0)[r](23b ) : ( 1.125,1.0)(0,0)@xmath85 ( 0.75,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 0.5,0.5)(0,0)@xmath152 ( 1.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath167 ( 2.125,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 2.375,0)(0,0)@xmath168 ( 2.75,-0.375)(-1,2)0.125 ( 3,-0.5)(0,0)@xmath169 ( 4.125,1)(0,0)@xmath145 ( 3.625,0.625)(1,1)0.25 ( 4.625,0.625)(-1,1)0.25 ( 3.375,0.5)(0,0)@xmath164 ( 3.75,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 4,0)(0,0)@xmath165 ( 5.25,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 5.5,0)(0,0)@xmath170 ( 4.875,0.5)(0,0)@xmath167 ( 2.92,0.25)(0,0)=3.1 ( 5.375,0.5)(0,0)=2.1 ( 6.5,2.25)(-0.25,-0.75 ) ( 0.4,1)(0,0)[r](24b ) : ( 1.125,1.0)(0,0)@xmath83 ( 0.75,0.625)(1,2)0.125 ( 0.5,0.5)(0,0)@xmath171 ( 1.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath172 ( 2.25,0.125)(-1,1)0.25 ( 2.5,0)(0,0)@xmath173 ( 1.25,0.125)(1,1)0.25 ( 1,0)(0,0)@xmath174 ( 1.375,-0.375)(-1,2)0.125 ( 1.625,-0.5)(0,0)@xmath175 ( 4.125,1)(0,0)@xmath151 ( 3.625,0.625)(1,1)0.25 ( 4.5,0.625)(-1,2)0.125 ( 4.75,0.5)(0,0)@xmath176 ( 5.125,0.125)(-1,2)0.125 ( 5.375,0)(0,0)@xmath177 ( 3.375,0.5)(0,0)@xmath178 ( 3.25,0.5)(0,0)=3.8 ( 5.3125,0.5)(0,0)=1.9 one can also get a new extended version of theorem [ thm : list1 ] in the same way , though it is harder to state precisely .
it is also slightly less flexible because it disallows reuse of the same variable or combination of variables ; and the forest diagrams are easier to verify by inspection . here
are two more explicit proofs .
let @xmath26 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and let @xmath34 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath3 ; note that we have @xmath179 .
then @xmath180}\\ & = i(z;y)+h(z|d)+h(y|d)+i(z;d|e ) \notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + i(y;d|e)+i({{y},{z}};e)\\ & \ge i(z;y)+h(y|d)+i(z;z|e)+i(y;d|e)+i({{y},{z}};e ) & { & [ \mbox{from lemma \ref{lem : rtoz}}]}\\ & \ge i(z;y)+i(z;z|e)+i(y;y|e)+i({{y},{z}};e ) & { & [ \mbox{from lemma \ref{lem : rtoz}}]}\\ & = i(z;y)+h(z|e)+h(y|e)+i({{y},{z}};e)\\ & \ge i(z;y)+h({{y},{z}}|e)+i({{y},{z}};e)\\ & = i(z;y)+h({{y},{z}})\\ & = h(z)+h(y)\\ & = i(a;b)+i(a;c).\end{aligned}\ ] ] let @xmath26 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and let @xmath34 be a common information of @xmath1 and @xmath3 ; note that we have @xmath179 and @xmath181 . then @xmath182}\\ & = i(b;y)+i(z;d)+i({{y},{z}};{{c},{y}}|d)\notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + i(z;z|e)+i(y;e|b)+ i(y;d|e)+i(z;e|{{c},{y},{d } } ) \notag\\ & = i({{b},{e}};y)+i(z;d)+i({{y},{z}};{{c},{y}}|d)\notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + i(z;z|e)+ i(y;d|e)+i(z;e|{{c},{y},{d } } ) \notag\\ & \ge i(e;y)+i(z;d)+i({{y},{z}};{{c},{y}}|d)\notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + i(z;z|e)+ i(y;d|e)+i(z;e|{{c},{y},{d } } ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;d)+i({{y},{z}};{{c},{y}}|d)\notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + i(z;z|e)+i(z;e|{{c},{y},{d } } ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;d)+i(z;{{c},{y}}|d)+i(y;{{c},{y}}|{{d},{z}})\notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + i(z;z|e)+i(z;e|{{c},{y},{d } } ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;d)+i(z;{{c},{y}}|d)+h(y|{{d},{z}})\notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + h(z|e)+i(z;e|{{c},{y},{d } } ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;d)+i(z;{{c},{e},{y}}|d)+h(y|{{d},{z } } ) + h(z|e ) \notag\\ & \ge i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;d)+i(z;{{e},{y}}|d)+h(y|{{d},{z } } ) + h(z|e ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;{{d},{e},{y}})+h(y|{{d},{z } } ) + h(z|e ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;{{d},{e}})+i(z;y|{{d},{e}})+h(y|{{d},{z } } ) + h(z|e ) \notag\\ & \ge i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;{{d},{e}})+i(z;y|{{d},{e}})\notag\\ & { \ \ \ \ } + h(y|{{d},{e},{z}})+h(z|{{d},{e } } ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+i(z;{{d},{e}})+h(y|{{d},{e } } ) + h(z|{{d},{e } } ) \notag\\ & = i({{d},{e}};y)+h(z)+h(y|{{d},{e } } ) \notag\\ & = h(z)+h(y)\\ & = i(a;b)+i(a;c).\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is not yet clear how to generalize these .
the complete ( and verified nonredundant ) list of linear - variable inequalities on five variables consists of : * the elemental shannon inequalities : @xmath183 and the inequalities obtained from these by permuting the five variables @xmath184 ( see yeung @xcite for a proof that these imply all other 5-variable shannon inequalities ) ; * the following instances of the ingleton inequality : @xmath185 and the ones obtained from these by permuting the five variables @xmath184 ( see guill , chan , and grant @xcite for a proof that these imply all other 5-variable instances of the ingleton inequality ) ; and * inequalities ( 1)(24 ) and their permuted - variable forms . to verify the completeness of this list ,
we consider the 31-dimensional real space whose coordinates are labeled by the subsets of @xmath186 in the usual binary order : @xmath187 each of the listed inequalities , once it is rewritten in terms of the basic entropy terms @xmath188 defines a half - space of this space ; the intersection of these half - spaces is a polyhedral cone which can also be described as the convex hull of its extreme rays . if one of these extreme rays contains a nonzero point @xmath189 which is _ ( linearly ) representable _ (
i.e. , there exist a vector space @xmath190 and subspaces @xmath191 of @xmath190 such that @xmath192 , @xmath193 , @xmath194 , and so on ) , then this extreme ray can never be excluded by any as - yet - unknown linear rank inequality .
if we verify that _ all _ of the extreme rays contain linearly representable points , then there can be no linear rank inequality which cuts down the polyhedral cone further , so the list of inequalities must be complete .
there are 7943 extreme rays in @xmath195 determined by the elemental shannon inequalities and inequalities ( 1)(24 ) and ( and permutations ) .
if one considers two such rays to be essentially the same when one can be obtained from the other by a permutation of the five variables , then there are 162 essentially different extreme rays .
a full list of the vectors generating these rays is available at : http://zeger.us/linrank the authors have shown that each of these vectors is representable over the field of real numbers ; in fact , up to a scalar multiple , this representation can be done using matrices with integer entries which actually represent the vector over any field ( finite or infinite ) .
for instance , consider the extreme ray given by the vector @xmath196 ( a list of 31 ranks or entropies in the order given by ) . to this
we associate the five matrices : @xmath197\\ m_b & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrr } 0 & 1 & 0\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_c & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrr } 0 & 0 & 1\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_d & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrr } 1 & 1 & 1\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_e & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrr } 1 & 1 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 1\\ \end{array } \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] the interpretation here is that we have a fixed field @xmath18 , and the row space of each of these matrices specifies a subspace of @xmath198 .
the specified vector gives @xmath199 , and the row space of @xmath200 has dimension 1 ; the vector gives @xmath201 , and the row space of @xmath202 has dimension 1 ; the vector gives @xmath203 , and the vector sum of the row spaces of @xmath200 and @xmath202 ( i.e. , the row space of @xmath200-on - top - of-@xmath202 ) has dimension 2 ; and so on .
equivalently , if we take three random variables @xmath204 chosen uniformly and independently over the finite field @xmath18 , and let @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 , @xmath208 , and @xmath209 , then the entropies of all combinations of @xmath184 ( with logarithms to base @xmath22 ) are as specified by the above vector . the dimensions of the row spaces listed above are easily computed over the real field ( as ranks of the corresponding matrices ) . in order to verify that the same dimensions would be obtained over any field , one just has to note that , in each case where a matrix rank is computed to be @xmath40 , there is actually a @xmath210 submatrix whose determinant is @xmath211 , so the selected @xmath40 rows will still be independent even after being reduced modulo any prime .
( actually , it would suffice to verify that the greatest common divisor of the determinants of all @xmath210 submatrices is 1 . )
all of the other listed vectors turn out to be representable in the same way , except that for a few of them a scalar multiplier must be applied .
for instance , consider the vector @xmath212 to represent this , we would normally take @xmath200 to be a @xmath213 matrix and @xmath214 to be @xmath215 matrices whose unique rows have the property that any two are independent but any three are dependent .
( in other words , these row vectors are a linear representation for the uniform matroid @xmath216 . ) for example , we could take @xmath217\\ m_b & = \left [ \begin{array}{rr } 1 & 0\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_c & = \left [ \begin{array}{rr } 0 & 1\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_d & = \left [ \begin{array}{rr } 1 & 1\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_e & = \left [ \begin{array}{rr } 1 & 2\\ \end{array } \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] over the real field , but these would not work over the field of two elements .
in fact , no such choice of row vectors works over the field of two elements ( the first two row vectors would be independent , but then the only choice for the third vector would be the sum of the first two , and the same would hold for the fourth vector , contradicting the independence of the third and fourth vectors ) .
but if we instead take the vector @xmath218 which is twice the preceding vector and hence determines the same extreme ray , then we can get suitable representing matrices @xmath217\\ m_b & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrrr } 1 & 0 & 0 & 0\\ 0 & 1 & 0 & 0\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_c & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrrr } 0 & 0 & 1 & 0\\ 0 & 0 & 0 & 1\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_d & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrrr } 1 & 0 & 1 & 0\\ 0 & 1 & 0 & 1\\ \end{array } \right]\\ m_e & = \left [ \begin{array}{rrrr } 1 & 1 & 0 & 1\\ 0 & 1 & 1 & 0\\ \end{array } \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] which work over any field .
the same doubling is needed for 13 more of the 162 vectors ; and one additional vector , the vector @xmath219 corresponding to the uniform matroid @xmath220 , had to be tripled in order to get a matrix representation that works over all fields .
the list of five - variable linear rank inequalities was produced by the following iterative process .
initially , we had the shannon and ingleton inequalities . at each stage
, we took the current list of inequalities and used komei fukuda s cddlib software @xcite to get the corresponding list of extreme rays .
we then examined the vectors generating the extreme rays to see whether they were representable ( over the reals ; we did not try to get representations working over all fields until after the iterative process was complete ) .
when such a vector provably could not be represented , the proof ( in each case we ran into here ) yielded a new linear rank inequality provable via common informations ; when we examined a vector where we had difficulty determining whether it was representable or not , we ran exhaustive tests on all ways of specifying a single common information ( toward the end , we had to try a pair of common informations ) to see whether itip could verify that the specified vector contradicted the shannon inequalities together with the common information specification .
again each such verification led to a new linear rank inequality .
( of course , this is a highly sanitized version of the process as it actually occurred . )
the testing of extreme rays for linear representability soon became a large task , so we gradually developed software to automatically find such representations in a number of cases ( and we added more cases when we found new ways to represent vectors ) .
this software used combinatorial rather than linear - algebra methods ; for instance , the output of the program for the sample vector @xmath221 used above was a specification of five vector spaces @xmath184 which could be paraphrased as : `` @xmath1 is generated by one vector , @xmath2 is generated by one vector not in @xmath1 , @xmath3 is generated by one vector not in @xmath10 [ the space spanned by @xmath1 and @xmath2 ] , @xmath223 is generated by one vector in general position in @xmath224 , and @xmath225 is generated by two vectors , one in @xmath226 and one in @xmath3 . ''
the development of the software involved recognizing as many cases as possible where one could find such a specification which could be met over the reals ( or over any sufficiently large finite field ) and would yield the desired rank vector .
the ( attempted ) construction of a representation is done one basic subspace at a time : first the representation of @xmath1 is constructed ( this step is trivial ) , then the representation of @xmath2 given @xmath1 , then the representation of @xmath3 given @xmath1 and @xmath2 , and so on . and each of these subspace representations is constructed one basis vector at a time . given the representation of @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath223
, the algorithm will determine how many basis vectors are needed for subspace @xmath225 and successively try to choose them in suitable positions relative to the existing subspaces . at each step
, a new vector will be chosen in general position in a subspace which is a sum of some of the already - handled subspaces @xmath227 .
( here `` general position '' means in the selected subspace but not in any relevant proper subspace of it .
which subspaces are relevant depends on the current situation ; we avoid having to determine this explicitly by just saying that the underlying field is sufficiently large , or infinite . )
if there is a problem with specifying that the vector is in such a sum of basic subspaces , then we may have to specify that the vector is in the intersection of two sums of basic subspaces .
once the first vector is chosen , we take quotients of all of the existing spaces by this vector to get the new situation in which the second vector needs to be chosen .
this is all done by counting dimensions , not by constructing actual numerical vectors .
for instance , suppose the first vector is chosen to be in general position in subspace @xmath228 which is a sum of basic subspaces from @xmath227 ( e.g. , @xmath229 ) .
for each other sum subspace @xmath120 , if the new vector is in @xmath120 , then the quotient by the chosen vector will reduce the dimension of @xmath120 by 1 ; if the chosen vector is not in @xmath120 , then the quotient will not change the dimension of @xmath120 . since the vector is in general position in @xmath228 , the vector will be in @xmath120 if and only if @xmath230 , and to check whether @xmath230 one simply has to see whether @xmath231 .
the case where the vector is chosen from an intersection of two sum subspaces @xmath228 and @xmath232 is more complicated ; more on this below .
consider the example .
suppose that we have already constructed the representations for subspaces @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath223 , and we are now ready to construct the representation for subspace @xmath225 .
the current situation can be summarized by the following two - row array : @xmath233 here the first row is the ranks of sums from @xmath227 in the order given by , but starting with the empty space . for each of these sums
, the second row gives the amount by which adding the new subspace @xmath225 will increase the dimension of the sum .
( so the second entry in this row is @xmath234 , the fourth entry is @xmath235 , and so on . ) from this array , we can see that , since @xmath225 has dimension 2 but only increases the dimension of @xmath10 by 1 , one of the nonzero vectors in @xmath225 must be in @xmath10 .
so let us start by assuming that one of the vectors in @xmath225 is a vector chosen in general position in @xmath229 .
we can now check for all sums from @xmath227 whether the sum will contain this chosen vector ; this information is summarized in the row @xmath236 where 1 means the chosen vector is in the corresponding sum . to get the result of taking a quotient by ( the subspace generated by ) the chosen vector , we subtract from the first row of ( because we have used up one vector from each of the indicated subspaces ) and subtract the one s complement of from the second row of ( because we have taken care of one of the new vectors for @xmath225 beyond each of the indicated subspaces ) .
so the situation after the first vector is chosen is given by : @xmath237 of course , the negative entry in this array means that a problem has occurred : we tried to take a new vector not in @xmath238 , but the given ranks require all vectors in @xmath225 to be in @xmath238 .
so we will try again ; instead of taking a vector in general position in @xmath239 , we take a vector in general position in @xmath240 , where @xmath241 .
this leaves the problem of determining , for each sum subspace @xmath120 , whether the chosen vector is in @xmath120 ; as before , this is equivalent to determining whether @xmath242 .
this is not as straightforward as it was to determine whether @xmath243 ; in fact , there are situations where the given data on ranks of sum subspaces simply do not determine whether @xmath244 .
but we have identified many situations where the given data do allow this determination to be made .
here is a list ; note that ( a ) each such test can also be applied with @xmath228 and @xmath232 interchanged , and ( b ) reading this list is not necessary for understanding the rest of the algorithm . * if @xmath230 , then @xmath244 . *
if the dimensions of @xmath240 , @xmath245 , and @xmath246 are all equal , then @xmath244 .
[ if two subspaces have the same ( finite ) dimension and one is included in the other , then the two subspaces are equal .
hence , we get @xmath247 , so @xmath248 , so @xmath244 .
also , recall that the dimension of @xmath249 can be determined from the given data ; it is equal to @xmath250 . ] * if the dimensions of @xmath251 , @xmath252 , @xmath253 , and @xmath249 are all equal , then @xmath244 .
[ we have @xmath254 , so @xmath255 .
but now @xmath256 , so @xmath257 , so @xmath244 . ]
* if @xmath258 , then @xmath259 , so we must have @xmath260 . *
let @xmath261 be the `` nominal intersection '' of @xmath228 and @xmath232 ( i.e. , the sum of the basic subspaces listed both in the sum @xmath228 and the sum @xmath232 ) .
clearly @xmath262 , so , if @xmath263 , then @xmath260 .
* if @xmath264 , then @xmath260 .
[ first note that , if @xmath265 are subspaces such that @xmath266 , then @xmath267 .
( the right - to - left inclusion is easy . for the left - to - right inclusion , if @xmath268 where @xmath269 , @xmath270 , and @xmath271 , then @xmath272 , so @xmath273 . ) hence , if @xmath244 , then @xmath274 , so @xmath275 . ] * if @xmath276 and @xmath277 , then @xmath244 . if @xmath278 and @xmath279 , then @xmath260 .
* let @xmath280 be the `` nominal difference '' of @xmath228 and @xmath232 ( i.e. , the sum of the basic subspaces listed in the sum @xmath228 but not in the sum @xmath232 ) , and let @xmath281 . if @xmath282 , then @xmath283 [ the right - to - left inclusion is easy . for the left - to - right inclusion , note that @xmath284 and @xmath285 .
hence , if @xmath286 , then we we have @xmath287 for some @xmath288 , @xmath289 , and @xmath290 . then @xmath291 is in @xmath292 , so we have @xmath293 and @xmath294 ; hence , @xmath295 and @xmath296 is in the desired form . ] hence , if @xmath282 , @xmath297 , and @xmath298 , then @xmath244 .
these tests do suffice for the example here ; the resulting membership vector is @xmath299 and the new array after taking a quotient by the first chosen vector is : @xmath300 let us call the new quotient spaces @xmath301 .
the new ranks indicate that the remaining vector in @xmath302 must be chosen to be in @xmath303 .
if we take the new vector in general position in @xmath303 , then the resulting membership vector is : @xmath304 ( note that we needed the chosen vector to be in @xmath305 as well as in @xmath303 , but this turned out to be automatic , because the given ranks implied @xmath306 . ) and the result of taking a quotient by the second chosen vector is : @xmath307 the all-0 row means that the representation of @xmath225 has been successfully completed .
the current algorithm does not try many possibilities for the next vector to choose ; it simply chooses one sum subspace ( usually at the beginning of the list of available ones ) to try to add a vector to , and , if that yields an immediate contradiction , perhaps tries one intersection of two sum subspaces .
if any such step fails ( either because of a contradiction , or because the algorithm can not determine whether @xmath244 in some case ) , the algorithm gives up .
however , the algorithm does give itself up to 120 chances by trying all permutations of the 5 basic variables .
each time a new extreme ray was produced , the above algorithm was applied as a positive test for representability , while tests against common informations were used as negative tests .
if both sides failed , the ray was examined by hand .
sometimes this examination yielded a representation because we found a new way of determining whether @xmath308 ; if so , this new test was added to the algorithm . at the end ,
the algorithm was able to verify representability of 152 of the final 162 extreme rays , leaving only 10 to be done by hand ( by methods which did not fit in the framework of this algorithm ) .
there are other possibilities for improving the algorithm that we have not yet implemented .
one is doing a backtrack search to consider more possibilities for choosing vectors to add ; another is to use the information on representation of previous subspaces in the construction of the representation of the current subspace .
( in the preceding example , we used only the dimension data for @xmath227 in the construction of the representation for @xmath225 ; we did not use the actual representations constructed for @xmath227 . )
more ambitious would be to allow more options for choosing new vectors in terms of the known relations between the current subspaces .
this iterative process for finding all linear rank inequalities is likely to be infeasible to complete for six or more variables .
( each cddlib polytope computation in 31 dimensions took about 23 days ; in 63 dimensions it would take far longer , as well as rapidly exceeding the memory available . ) but we plan to continue the study , because we expect to find new phenomena at higher levels , possibly including extreme rays that are representable over some fields but not over others ( hence yielding rank inequalities which hold only over those other fields ) , and inequalities which hold for ranks of vector spaces but are not provable via common informations . for instance , such situations could come from the variables associated with the fano and non - fano networks in @xcite , or the network in @xcite . in order to make any progress at all , we had to take some shortcuts ( since , as noted above , 63-dimensional polytope computations were out of the question ) .
one of these was to reduce the dimension of the search by assuming equality for one or more of the inequalities found so far ; in effect , this is just concentrating on one face , corner , or intermediate - dimensional extreme part of the current region .
another was to work hard on trying to improve already - obtained inequalities , find additional instances of them , or strengthen them in multiple ways if they were not already faces of the region .
we will show here some of the 6-variable inequalities we have found so far ; a much longer list is available at : http://zeger.us/linrank all of these have been verified to be faces of the linear rank region ( so they can not be improved ) . to do this
, we used a stockpile of linearly representable 6-variable polymatroids ( the representability was proved by the algorithm described in the preceding section ) encountered during the polytope computations .
if a 6-variable linear rank inequality is satisfied with equality by 62 linearly independent vectors from the stockpile , then it must give a face of the linear rank region .
( the stockpile currently contains 3220 polymatroids , or 1846734 after one takes all instances obtained by permuting the six basic variables .
it is also available at the above website . )
first , there are the 6-variable elemental shannon inequalities ; there are 6 of these if one lists just one of each form , but 246 of them if all of the permuted - variable versions are counted .
then there are 12 instances of the ingleton inequality ( 1470 counting permuted forms ) .
again , see yeung @xcite and guill , chan , and grant @xcite for the proof that these inequalities imply all of the other shannon and ingleton inequalities .
next come the instances of the 5-variable inequalities ( 1)(24 ) .
the initial computation found 183 of these instances that ( with permuted forms ) proved all of the others .
however , 16 of these instances did not pass the face verification above and were later superseded by other 6-variable inequalities ; this left 167 ( 61740 counting permuted forms ) 5-variable instances which were faces of the 6-variable rank region .
finally , there are the true 6-variable inequalities .
we have found 3490 of these so far ( 2395095 counting permuted forms ) which pass the face verification , along with several hundred more which do not pass and which we expect to be superseded later ( though this is not guaranteed ; perhaps our stockpile of representable polymatroids is insufficient , although the face test has been very reliable so far ) .
we give some examples of these here ; see the website mentioned above for the full list .
some inequalities follow directly from theorem [ thm : tree1 ] , such as : @xmath309 and others follow directly from theorem [ thm : tree2 ] , such as : @xmath310 then there are inequalities which follow from theorem [ thm : tree1 ] or theorem [ thm : tree2 ] using equivalent forms : @xmath311 all of the sharp inequalities found so far using one common information have been verified to be instances of theorem [ thm : tree2 ] .
it seems quite possible that this theorem generates all one - common - information inequalities , but we have no proof of this .
there are also hundreds of inequalities that required two common informations to prove .
( inequalities requiring more than two common informations are beyond the range of our software at present . )
these are of two types .
one type is those like inequalities ( 18 ) and ( 20 ) which have two information terms on the left side and use the common informations corresponding to those terms : @xmath312 the other type has just one information term on the left side but requires a second common information in addition to the one from the left term : @xmath313 inequality is proved using a common information for @xmath1 and @xmath2 along with a common information for @xmath225 and @xmath314 ; inequality is proved using a common information for @xmath315 and @xmath316 along with a common information for @xmath317 and @xmath318 ; and inequality is proved using a common information @xmath26 for @xmath1 and @xmath319 along with a common information for @xmath18 and @xmath26 .
( the possible need for such iteration of common informations along with joining of variables makes it conceivable that an unbounded number of common informations could be needed to prove linear rank inequalities even on a fixed number of initial variables such as 6 . ) since the inequalities in this paper have been proven using only common informations and the shannon inequalities , they apply not only to linear ranks but also in any other situation where we have random variables which are known to have common informations . for instance , chan notes in ( * ? ? ?
* definition 4 ) that abelian group characterizable random variables always have common informations ( which are still abelian group characterizable random variables ) ; hence , the inequalities proven here hold for such variables .
the following theorem shows that there will be essentially new inequalities for each number of variables : [ thm : independence ] for any @xmath320 , the inequality @xmath321 is a linear rank inequality on @xmath322 variables which is not a consequence of instances of linear rank inequalities on fewer than @xmath322 variables .
first , it is not hard to show that is equivalent to , and we have already seen that is a linear rank inequality ( this can also be proved using theorem [ thm : tree2 ] ) , so is a linear rank inequality . in the following , if @xmath323 , we will write @xmath324 for @xmath325 .
define a rank vector @xmath189 on the subsets of @xmath326 as follows : for any @xmath327 , @xmath328 one can easily check that @xmath189 does not satisfy .
we will show that @xmath189 does satisfy all instances ( using the variables @xmath329 ) of all linear rank inequalities on fewer than @xmath322 variables ; this will imply that is not a consequence of these instances , as desired . for this purpose ,
we construct rank vectors @xmath330 , each of which is the same as @xmath189 except for one value .
the changed values are : @xmath331 we will show that each of these @xmath332 vectors is linearly representable over any infinite or sufficiently large finite field @xmath18 . in each case , the representation will use a vector space @xmath17 over @xmath18 of dimension @xmath333 , with a basis @xmath334 , and the variable @xmath335 ( @xmath336 ) will be represented by the two - dimensional subspace @xmath337 . for the representations of @xmath1 and @xmath2 , instead of giving explicit formulas , it will be convenient to use the following concept .
suppose @xmath190 is a nontrivial subspace of @xmath17 .
a point @xmath338 is said to be _ in general position _ in @xmath190 ,
relative to a given finite set @xmath232 of points ( if @xmath232 is not specified , then we let @xmath232 be the set of all points that have previously been mentioned explicitly ) , if @xmath339 does not lie in any subspace @xmath340 of @xmath17 spanned by a subset of @xmath232 unless @xmath340 includes all of @xmath190 .
if the set @xmath232 is of size bounded by @xmath341 , then the `` in general position '' condition excludes at most @xmath342 proper subspaces of @xmath190 ( including the trivial subspace ) , so there is no problem finding points in general position as long as the field size is greater than @xmath342 .
if we refer to multiple points being chosen in general position , then they should be considered as chosen successively , with later points being in general position relative to earlier points as well as the previous set @xmath232 .
this concept has been referred to by various terms ; for instance , in in @xcite such points are referred to as `` freely placed '' .
points chosen in this way make it easy to compute augmented subspace dimensions : if @xmath339 is in general position in @xmath190 relative to @xmath232 and @xmath340 is a subspace spanned by points in @xmath232 , then @xmath343 is equal to @xmath344 unless @xmath345 , in which case it is equal to @xmath346 . for each @xmath347 , a representation of @xmath97
is obtained by assigning to @xmath1 the space @xmath348 and assigning to @xmath2 the space spanned by all of the @xmath65 vectors except @xmath98 , together with @xmath349 additional points chosen in general position in @xmath17 . for the representation of @xmath350
, we again assign to @xmath1 the space @xmath19 ; @xmath2 is assigned a space spanned by @xmath351 points in general position in @xmath19 together with @xmath349 additional points in general position in @xmath17 . to represent @xmath352 , choose points @xmath353 in general position in @xmath19 , and assign to @xmath1 and @xmath2 the spaces @xmath354 and @xmath355 , respectively .
it remains to show that , if @xmath356 is a linear rank inequality on @xmath40 variables with @xmath357 , then no instance of this inequality fails for @xmath189 .
an instance of this inequality which applies to @xmath189 is given by a map @xmath358 from @xmath359 to the subsets of @xmath360 .
( then the definition of @xmath358 can be immediately extended to the subsets of @xmath359 by the formula @xmath361 . )
so suppose we have an instance , given by @xmath3 and @xmath358 as above , which fails for @xmath189 . since @xmath356 is a linear rank inequality , the instance must not fail for the representable vector @xmath352
therefore , the instance must use the value where @xmath189 disagrees with @xmath352 .
this means that there is a subset of @xmath359 which is mapped by @xmath358 to @xmath362 ; it follows that there is some single value @xmath363 such that @xmath364 .
similarly , since the instance must not fail for @xmath350 , there is a subset of @xmath359 which is mapped by @xmath358 to @xmath365 , so there exists @xmath366 such that @xmath367 . and
, for each @xmath347 , the instance must not fail for @xmath97 , so there is a subset of @xmath359 which is mapped by @xmath358 to @xmath368 ; hence , there exists @xmath369 such that @xmath370 is either @xmath371 or @xmath368 .
it is clear from these @xmath358 values that the numbers @xmath372 are distinct ; but this is impossible because @xmath373 has fewer than @xmath322 members .
this contradiction completes the proof of the theorem .
during the preparation of this paper , the authors became aware of closely related concurrent work .
chan , grant , and kern @xcite show nonconstructively that there exist linear rank inequalities not following from the ingleton inequality .
kinser @xcite presents a sequence of inequalities which can be written in the form @xmath374 for @xmath375 .
( this is a variant of which follows from theorem [ thm : list1 ] ; the instance for @xmath376 and @xmath377 are permuted - variable forms of the ingleton inequality and inequality ( 1c ) , respectively . )
kinser shows that is a linear rank inequality for each @xmath375 and uses a method similar to the proof of theorem [ thm : independence ] above to show that instance @xmath76 of is not a consequence of linear rank inequalities on fewer than @xmath76 variables .
( the authors found the proof of theorem [ thm : independence ] after the initial posting date of @xcite , but independently . )
19 t. chan , `` group characterizable entropy functions '' , _ 2007 ieee international symposium on information theory _ , 2429 june 2007 , pp
. t. chan , a. grant , and d. kern , `` existence of new inequalities for representable polymatroids '' , arxiv 0907.5030 ( 2009 ) .
r. dougherty , c. freiling , and k. zeger , `` insufficiency of linear coding in network information flow '' , _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , vol .
51 , no . 8 , pp . 27452759 , august 2005 .
r. dougherty , c. freiling , and k. zeger , `` networks , matroids , and non - shannon information inequalities '' , _ ieee transactions on information theory _ , vol .
53 , no . 6 , pp .
19491969 , june 2007 .
r. dougherty , c. freiling , and k. zeger , `` non - shannon information inequalities '' , in preparation .
r. dougherty , c. freiling , and k. zeger , `` achievable rate regions for network coding '' , in preparation .
k. fukuda , cddlib , http://www.cs.mcgill.ca/~fukuda/soft/cdd_home/cdd.html l. guill , t. h. chan , and a. grant , `` the minimal set of ingleton inequalities '' , _ 2008 ieee international symposium on information theory _ , 611 july 2008 , pp .
d. hammer , a.e .
romashchenko , a. shen , and n.k .
vereshchagin , `` inequalities for shannon entropy and kolmogorov complexity '' , _ journal of computer and systems sciences _ , vol .
442464 , 2000 .
a. w. ingleton , `` representation of matroids '' , in _ combinatorial mathematics and its applications _
, d. j. a. welsh , ed . , pp . 149167 , academic press , london , 1971 .
r. kinser , `` new inequalities for subspace arrangements '' , arxiv 0905.1519 ( 2009 ) .
k. makarychev and y. makarychev , `` conditionally independent random variables '' , arxiv : cs/0510029 .
d. mayhew , m. newman , and g. whittle , `` on excluded minors for real - representability '' , _
j. combin .
theory ser .
b _ , vol . 99 , pp . 685689 , 2009 .
r. rado , `` note on independence functions '' , _ proc .
london math .
( 3 ) _ , vol . 7 ,
pp . 300320 , 1957 .
r. w. yeung , _ a first course in information theory _ , kluwer , 2002 .
r. w. yeung and y .- o .
yan , itip ( information theoretic inequality prover ) , | ranks of subspaces of vector spaces satisfy all linear inequalities satisfied by entropies ( including the standard shannon inequalities ) and an additional inequality due to ingleton .
it is known that the shannon and ingleton inequalities generate all such linear rank inequalities on up to four variables , but it has been an open question whether additional inequalities hold for the case of five or more variables . here
we give a list of 24 inequalities which , together with the shannon and ingleton inequalities , generate all linear rank inequalities on five variables . we also give a partial list of linear rank inequalities on six variables and general results which produce such inequalities on an arbitrary number of variables ; we prove that there are essentially new inequalities at each number of variables beyond four ( a result also proved recently by kinser ) .
[ theorem ] lemma [ theorem ] corollary [ theorem ] proposition [ theorem ] remark [ theorem ] algorithm [ theorem ] conjecture [ theorem ] example [ theorem ] definition |
a great deal about galaxy evolution can be learned by studying their broadband properties .
broadband observations give an immediate impression of the spectral energy distribution and thereby information on stellar and dust content .
even though integrated magnitudes of galaxies can be used to study global properties of galaxies , even more can be learned from examining the detailed distribution of their light and colors .
the star formation history in galaxies seems to be related to their surface density properties ( kennicutt @xcite ; ryder and dopita @xcite ; de jong @xcite ) , and therefore it is imperative to have a statistical knowledge of surface brightness distributions in galaxies to understand galaxy evolution .
the image data set presented here was collected to study the surface brightness distribution of spiral galaxies .
of especial interest was the question whether disks in spiral galaxies have a preferred central surface brightness value as proposed by freeman ( @xcite ) .
the observations were made in such a way that they were suitable to study this central surface brightness effect , but this might make the observations less useful for some other studies due to two limitations .
( 1 ) disk central surface brightnesses are in general determined from one - dimensional ( 1d ) luminosity profiles , constructed by some kind of azimuthal averaging of the light distribution .
no effort was made to obtain images with high signal - to - noise per pixel , as large numbers of pixels were to be averaged in the process of creating luminosity profiles .
furthermore the depth " of the optical images were matched to the near - ir observations , which are more limited by the high sky background level than by signal - to - noise ratios .
a considerable fraction of the images have too low signal - to - noise per pixel to allow detailed morphological studies of non - axisymmetric structures ( ie .
bars and spiral arms ) except in the highest surface brightness regions .
( 2 ) the used telescope / camera combinations had a limited field - of - view , especially in the near - ir .
often only the major axis was imaged of the larger galaxies , as this was sufficient to measure the radial luminosity distribution of the galaxy .
this again limits the usefulness of the images to study non - axisymmetric light distributions in the outer part of galaxies .
the structure of this paper is as follows : the selection of the sample is described in section 2 and the observations in section 3 .
section 4 explains the different data reduction techniques used . in section 5
i describe the format of the fits images on the cd - rom , in section 6 the format of the luminosity profiles and in section 7 the format of the bulge / disk decomposition files . a more detailed description of the selection , observations and data reduction can be found in paper i. the bulge / disk decomposition methods
are explained in more detail in paper ii .
the galaxies were selected from the uppsala general catalogue of galaxies ( ugc , nilson @xcite ) .
only spiral galaxies in the range s1-dwarfsp were selected , excluding galaxies with classifications as s0-s1 , sb0-sb1 , s3-irr , irr and dwarf irr .
ideally one would like to have a volume - limited sample of galaxies for a statistical study of galaxy properties , but this is impossible due to selection effects . to create a sample that is correctable for selection effects , the galaxies were selected to have ugc red diameters of at least 2 .
the galaxies have red ugc minor over major axis ratios larger than 0.625 to reduce problems with projection effects and dust extinction .
this axis ratio range corresponds to inclinations less than approximately 51 .
only galaxies with an absolute galactic latitude @xmath6 were selected , to minimize the effect of galactic extinction and to reduce the number of foreground stars .
these selection criteria resulted in a sample of 368 galaxies .
the final sample of 86 galaxies observed was selected on the basis of hour angle and declination only , in such a way that we had about equal number of observable galaxies during the whole night in the granted observing time .
the total selected areas cover about 12.5% of the sky .
all global parameters of the observed galaxies are listed in table [ globpar ] .
nearly all _ bvri _ images were obtained with the 1 m jacobus kapteyn telescope ( jkt ) at la palma , equipped with a 385x578 gec ccd camera , in march and september 1991 and april 1992 .
the kitt peak _ bvri _ filter set ( rgo / la palma technical notes @xcite ) was used , the pixel size was 0.3 .
the ccd camera was used in both its normal imaging mode as well as in its driftscan mode . in driftscan mode ,
optimal use is made of the way ccds are designed : while the telescope is tracking the object , the ccd camera is shifted under the telescope at the same speed as the image is shifted down the columns of the ccd while it is read out .
typical exposure times were 600s in @xmath0 and 400s for the other optical passbands .
twilight flatfields were obtained at the beginning or at the end of the night and globular cluster fields with standard stars were observed at regular intervals through the night for calibration .
a small number of optical observations were obtained from the la palma archive .
the near - ir @xmath4 and @xmath5 passband observations were made at the united kingdom infrared telescope at hawaii with ircam ii containing a 58x62 insb array . during the february 1992 run standard @xmath4 and @xmath5 filters were used , but a @xmath7 filter was used in september 1991 .
the pixel size was 1.2 .
for accurate sky subtraction and flatfielding sky frames were obtained before and after every two object frames at a position offset a few arcmin from the object .
images were taken in a strip along the major axis of the galaxies , spending about twice as much time on the outer part of galaxies than on the central region to increase signal - to - noise in these low surface brightness regions .
calibration stars from the list of elias et al .
( @xcite ) were imaged at regular intervals .
dark frames with exposure times equal to the object exposure times were also obtained at regular intervals .
the full observing log with observing method ( driftscan , mosaic ) , exposure times , photometric quality and seeing estimates can be found in paper i. these values are also store in the fits headers of the images .
the normal data reduction procedure for ccd data was followed to create calibrated images from the direct imaging data obtained with the jkt .
a bias value was subtracted from the images using the average value in the overscan region .
the images were divided by normalized flatfields created by averaging several twilight frames .
no dark current was subtracted as this was found to be insignificant for this ccd . in general two observations at the same position of an object were made , which allowed cosmic - ray removal when they were averaged .
the data reduction of the driftscans was more elaborate .
a driftscan image consists of a ramp up part ( rows that were not exposed for a full chip length before being read out ) , a flat fully - exposed part and a ramp down part ( rows that are read out after the shutter has closed ) .
the first rows of the ramp up part showed a gradient in the bias level in the cross - scan direction .
therefore , the bias level was determined by fitting the first half of the ramp up part of each column , giving a bias level for each column at the first row .
the images were flatfielded by flatlines created averaging normal flatfields in column direction .
the ramp up and down parts were corrected for the shorter exposure times , extending the field - of - view beyond the area that was exposed to the sky for a full chip length .
careful attention had to be given to flatfielding of the near - ir images , as flux levels 5@xmath8 times below the sky level were measured .
we first subtracted the dark current from all near - ir images ( object and sky ) using the average of the two dark frames obtained nearest in time .
a normalized flatfield image was created for each galaxy by taking the median of the 4 - 5 sky frames observed around the galaxy .
after flatfielding , known hot " and dead " pixels were set to undefined " by a bad pixel mask and remaining dubious pixels were set to
undefined by hand .
these undefined " pixels were not used in further analysis .
the different object frames of a galaxy were mosaiced together to create a full image along the major axis .
the spatial offset between frames was determined by a cross - correlation technique or by using the telescope offsets if no structure was available to be used in the cross - correlation technique .
the relative spatial offsets between all overlapping frame combinations were determined and a least - square - fit determined the relative offset of all frames with respect to the central frame . zero point ( due to sky fluctuations ) and intensity scaling factors ( only for non - photometric observations ) were determined in a similar fashion .
all zero point ( and when necessary intensity ) offsets between overlapping frames ( using the just determined spatial offsets ) were calculated and a least - squares - fit through all relative offsets provided the intensity offset with respect to the central frame .
all frames were mosaiced together using these spatial and intensity offsets , taking the average in the overlapping areas .
the images were calibrated using the standard star fields observed during each night under different airmasses .
the optical standard star fields we used were calibrated to landolt ( @xcite ) stars , and therefore our system response has been transformed to johnson @xmath0 and @xmath1 and kron - cousins @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
the near - ir was calibrated to @xmath4 and @xmath5 standard stars of elias et al .
( @xcite ) , using the corrections of wainscoat and cowie ( @xcite ) to transform the @xmath7 passband to the @xmath5 passband .
instrumental magnitudes ( -2.5log(number of counts ) ) of the different stars in the calibration fields were measured with daophot ( stetson @xcite ) .
all photometric calibration measurements of one observing run were combined to least - square - fit equations of the form : @xmath9 where @xmath10 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 are the standard star magnitudes , @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 and @xmath14 the instrumental magnitudes per second , @xmath15 the airmass of the observation and @xmath16 the unknown transformation coefficients . the results of these fits can be found in tables [ mag0tab ] and [ mag0tabir ] and in the fits headers of the images .
non - photometric observations were calibrated with aperture photometry from the literature when available .
we first determined magnitudes in synthetic apertures of the size of the literature photometry using the calibration of a photometric night .
if our magnitude differed more than the expected error from the literature value , all magnitude parameters were corrected for this difference ( indicated by header item corr in the fits files ) .
the optical pixel size was determined to be [email protected] , using images of globular clusters which contained accurately known star positions .
this pixel size agreed to within its uncertainty to the instrumental specification , and therefore a value of 0.30 was adopted .
the near - ir pixel size was derived from the scaling factor to align the near - ir images with the optical images ( see next paragraph ) .
the near - ir pixel size was 1.20 per pixel .
we determined the sky background level on the fully reduced images using the box method .
average sky values were measured in small boxes around the galaxies .
sky level was set to the median value of these measurements .
the uncertainty in the sky value was taken to be half the difference between the maximum and minimum average sky values found in these boxes .
this uncertainty will reflect errors due to imperfect flatfielding and mosaicing .
we aligned the images in the different passbands using foreground stars in common between the different frames .
images obtained during the same observing run were only allowed to shift , between different runs also rotation and scaling was allowed .
the near - ir data was regridded to the much smaller pixel scale of the optical images , which means that nothing smaller than the original pixel size ( 1.2 ) should be trusted on these images .
a linear interpolation was used for regridding and therefore the new smaller pixels contain values that are representative of the original surface brightness in the pixels of the original size .
total flux in the image is not conserved in this process , but the original number of counts in an area can easily be calculated by multiplying the new number of counts in an area with the ratio of the square of the pixel sizes , ( pixelsize@xmath18/pixelsize@xmath19)@xmath20 .
all aligned images are stored in fits format on the cd - rom in the directory images/ , with a separate directory for each galaxy .
the aligned near - ir images in these directories have been compressed with gzip , but the `` raw '' near - ir images ( ie . before aligning and regridding to the optical images )
are available in uncompressed fits format in the directory irimages/. the fits headers contain all the essential information for analysis .
the images are in analog - to - digital - units ( adu ) , which corresponds approximately to the number of detected photons for the optical images and to 50 detected photons in the near - ir images .
undefined pixels in the images contain the value -999 .
the header items of interest are as follows : naxis1 , naxis2 : : number of pixels in ra and dec respectively ctype1 , ctype2 : : ra - tan , dec - tan axis type and projection system crval1 , crval2 : : should contain the ra and dec value at the reference pixel ( * crpix1 , crpix2 * ) , but as the exact position of the galaxies was often unknown , the stored values have no meaning cdelt1 , cdelt2 : : the pixel size in _ degrees_. the same value is stored in arcseconds in header item * pixsizim * filter : : passband filter ( b , v , r , i , h , k or k@xmath21 ) seeing : : full - width - at - half - maximum ( fwhm ) of seeing estimate in arcsec phot : : photometric quality estimate as in paper i ( 1 : photometric , 2 : 0.0 - 0.2 mag , 3 : 0.2 - 0.5 mag , 4 : 0.5 - 1.0 mag and 5 : @xmath221.0 mag error ) qual : : quick look quality estimate , taking into account ( in order of importance ) flatfield quality , area to measure the sky level , signal - to - noise and seeing .
the numbers mean , 1 : excellent , 2 : reasonable , but take into account some of the limitations such as limited sky area , 3 : poor , do not use except in case of an emergency mag0 : : zero point calibration constant for a 1 second exposure ( -@xmath23 in eq .
[ caleq ] ) ccol : : color calibration constant , when not used 0 ( @xmath24 ) col : : average color of this galaxy used for calibration cair : : airmass calibration constant ( @xmath25 ) airmass : : airmass during the observation ( @xmath15 ) corr : : correction for non - photometric observation to put this image on literature photometry pixsize : : pixel size in arcsec of original image ( before rebinning ) pixsizim : : pixel size in arcsec of this image ( after rebinning / aligning ) exptime : : exposure time calibration constant ( if several images were averaged , this contains the average exposure time ) skylev : : estimate of the sky background level in adu skyerr : : maximum uncertainty in sky background magoff : : for convenience , this constant gives the calibration to convert pixel adu values into mag arcsec@xmath26 .
it is equal to * @xmath27mag0@xmath27ccol@xmath28col@xmath27cair@xmath28airmass @xmath27 corr @xmath29pixsize@xmath20@xmath28exptime * ) .
the surface brightness in mag arcsec@xmath26 of a pixel with adu counts in the galaxy is * magoff*@xmath30pixel@xmath31adu@xmath32*skylev*@xmath33 . to use this constant to calculate the magitude in an area , take into acount that flux
was not conserved per area in the rebinning / alligning proces . the magnitude in an area with total of adu counts is * magoff@xmath30*area@xmath31adu@xmath32*skylev@xmath34pixsize@xmath35pixsizim@xmath36 *
the radial luminosity distribution of each galaxy was determined in each passband and these are also present on the cd - rom .
the areas in the @xmath2 passband images affected by foreground stars were masked using a polygon editor .
this mask was transfered to the other passbands , thus making certain that the same area was used in all passbands .
the center of the galaxy was determined by fitting an ellipse to the central peak in the @xmath2 passband image .
next , with this center fixed , ellipses were fit to the isophotes at the 23.5 , 24.0 and 24.5 @xmath2-mag arcsec@xmath26 level .
the median values found for the minor / major axis ratio ( @xmath37 ) and position angle ( pa ) in the @xmath2-band were used in all passbands to determine the luminosity profiles .
average adu values were determined in concentric elliptical annuli of increasing radius with the already determined center , @xmath37 and pa fixed . for face - on galaxies this method gives a better estimate of the average luminostity at each radius than methods which freely fit ellipses at each isophote , if we assume that the galaxy is not strongly warped .
bars , spiral arms and hii regions make isophote fitting methods unreliable for face - on spiral galaxies .
the profiles are provided in ascii in the directory profiles/ and the graphs can be found in paper i. the surface brightness profiles are in mag arcsec@xmath26 , the radii in arcsec .
undefined values are indicated by a .
note that the central regions of ugc7540 were saturated in the @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 passband .
further header information in these files are incl : : inclination in degrees ( actually cos@xmath38(@xmath37 ) ) used for profile extraction pa : : position angle in degrees used for profile extraction , measured from north to east exptime : : exposure time in seconds of image used magoff : : magnitude calibration constant ( see image catalog ) magsky : : sky surface brightness in mag arcsec@xmath26 magskyerr : : uncertainty in * magsky * magtot : : total apparent magnitude of the galaxy derived from the surface brightness profile ( see paper i ) magerr : : uncertainty in apparent magnitude seeing : : fwhm of seeing estimate in arcsec date : : date of observation photq : : photometry quality estimate ( see image catalog )
a number bulge / disk decomposition methods was applied to the data ( see paper ii for details ) and the results are stored in directory b_dratio/. the results of the 1d profile decompositions with @xmath39 , @xmath40 and exponential bulges can be found in the files bd4qfpar.dat , bd4ffpar.dat and bd4efpar.dat respectively .
the results of the 2d decompositions with exponential bulges and disks and with freeman bars can be found in bd4fpar.dat .
note that not all observations were photometric and that for non - photometric observations the listed numbers are the lower limits in surface brightness flux .
obviously the scale parameters are correct for the non - photometric observations .
check the file pht.dat for a listing of the photometric quality of the observations .
the description of all the columns in these files can be found in file bd4read.me .
this research was supported under grant no .
782 - 373 - 044 from the netherlands foundation for research in astronomy ( astron ) , which receives its funds from the netherlands foundation for scientific research ( nwo ) .
this paper is based on observations with the jacobus kapteyn telescope and the isaac newton telescope operated by the royal greenwich observatory at the observatorio del roque de los muchachos of the instituto de astrofsica de canarias with financial support from the pparc ( uk ) and nwo ( nl ) and with the uk infrared telescope at mauna kea operated by the royal observatory edinburgh with financial support of the pparc .
.global parameters of the galaxies in the observed sample .
the positions and the @xmath41 recession velocities ( cz ) are obtained from the rc3 catalog , @xmath42 is the red ugc major axis diameter , @xmath37 is the red ugc minor over major axis diameter ratio .
[ globpar ] [ cols="<,<,>,>,>,>,>,>,^,^,^,^,>",options="header " , ] cccc + passband & zero - point ( @xmath23 ) & color coef .
( @xmath24 ) & extinction coef .
( @xmath25 ) + + @xmath0 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath2 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath3 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + @xmath0 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath2 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath3 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + @xmath0 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath2 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath3 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + + @xmath0 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath1 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath2 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath3 & [email protected] & [email protected] & [email protected] + ccc + color & zero point ( @xmath23 ) & extinction coefficient ( @xmath25 ) + + @xmath4 & [email protected] & + @xmath43 & [email protected] & [email protected] + + @xmath4 & [email protected] & [email protected] + @xmath5 & [email protected] & [email protected] + | fits images in the @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 and @xmath5 passbands are presented of a sample of 86 face - on spiral galaxies .
the galaxies were selected from the ugc to have a diameter of at least 2 and a minor over major axis ratio larger than 0.625 .
the selected galaxies have an absolute galactic latitude @xmath6 , to minimize the effect of galactic extinction and foreground stars .
nearly all _ bvri _ data were obtained with the 1 m jacobus kapteyn telescope at la palma and the @xmath4 and @xmath5 data were obtained at the 3.8 m uk infra - red telescope at hawaii .
the field of view of the telescope / camera combinations were often smaller than the observed galaxies , therefore driftscanning and mosaicing techniques were employed to image at least along the major axis of the galaxies .
most images were obtained during photometric nights and calibrated using standard stars .
a small fraction of the images was calibrated from literature aperture photometry .
the azimuthally averaged radial luminosity profiles derived from these galaxy images ( see de jong and van der kruit @xcite , paper i ) are also made available in machine readable format , as are the results of the bulge / disk decompositions described in de jong ( @xcite , paper ii ) .
a detailed statistical analysis of the bulge and disk parameters of this data set can be found in de jong ( @xcite , paper iii ) .
the dust and stellar content of the galaxies as derived from the color profiles is described in de jong ( @xcite , paper iv ) .
evidence for secular evolution as found in this sample is shown in courteau , de jong and broeils ( @xcite ) .
* keywords : * surveys - galaxies : fundamental parameters - galaxies : photometry - galaxies : spiral - galaxies : structure |
consider the problem of transmitting two correlated gaussian sources over a gaussian broadcast channel with two receivers , each of which desires only to recover one of the sources . in @xcite
, it was proven that analog ( uncoded ) transmission , the simplest possible scheme , is actually optimal when the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) is below a threshold for the case of matched source and channel bandwidth . to solve the problem for other cases , various hybrid digital / analog ( hda ) schemes
have been proposed in @xcite , and @xcite .
in fact , the hda scheme in @xcite achieves optimal performance for matched bandwidth whenever pure analog transmission does not , thereby leading to a complete characterization of the achievable power - distortion tradeoff . for the bandwidth - mismatch case ,
the hda schemes proposed in @xcite and @xcite comprise of different combinations of previous schemes using either superposition or dirty - paper coding . in all the aforementioned work ,
authors also compared achieved performances with that of separate source - channel coding .
since the channel is degraded , source coding boils down to sending a `` common '' message to both decoders and a `` refinement '' message to the decoder at the end of the better channel . in both of the two source coding schemes proposed in @xcite ,
the first source is encoded as the common message , but one scheme encodes ( as the refinement message ) the second source independently , and the other after _ de - correlating _ it with the first source . in @xcite , on the other hand , the second source is encoded after it is de - correlated with the _ reconstruction _ of the first source .
although this approach provably yields a better performance than the schemes in @xcite , it is still not optimal . in @xcite
, it was shown that the optimal rate - distortion ( rd ) tradeoff in this source coding scenario is in fact achieved by a scheme called successive coding , whereby both common and refinement messages are generated by encoding both sources jointly , instead of using any kind of de - correlation .
although successive coding is a special case of successive refinement in its general sense , _ computation _ of the rd tradeoff , even for gaussians , turned out to be non - trivial .
a shannon - type lower bound derived for the problem was rigorously shown to be tight , yielding an analytical characterization of the rd tradeoff . in this paper
, we investigate the performance of separate source and channel coding for any bandwidth compression / expansion ratio .
as discussed in the previous paragraph , the source coding method to be used for optimal performance is successive coding .
we first show that this separate coding scheme achieves the optimal power - distortion tradeoff when one receiver requires almost lossless recovery , and the other requires a small enough distortion . comparing with best - known schemes and outer bounds , we then show that this scheme is competitive in other cases as well .
our results imply that with a ( sometimes marginal ) sacrifice of power - distortion performance , we can design separate source and channel codes , and thus enjoy the advantages such as simple extension to different bandwidth compression / expansion ratios . in section
ii , the problem is formally defined .
our main results are proved in section iii and the separate coding scheme is compared with other separation - based schemes and hybrid schemes in section iv .
as depicted in fig . [ fig : system ] , a pair of correlated gaussian sources @xmath0 are broadcast to two receivers , and receiver @xmath1 , @xmath2 , is only to reconstruct @xmath3 . without loss of generality
, we assume the source sequences are generated in an i.i.d .
fashion by @xmath4 , where @xmath5\ ] ] and @xmath6 $ ] .
the transmitter encodes the source sequences to @xmath7 and thus can be described mathematically as @xmath8 .
we define bandwidth compression / expansion ratio @xmath9 with the unit of channel uses per source symbol .
the channel also has an average input power constraint , given by @xmath10 \leq p \ ; .\ ] ] at receiver @xmath1 , @xmath7 is corrupted by i.i.d .
additive gaussian noise @xmath11 , which satisfies @xmath12 , where we assume that @xmath13 .
the channel output @xmath14 is then a gaussian sequence given by @xmath15 .
decoder @xmath16 reconstructs @xmath17 from the channel output @xmath18 and can be described as a function @xmath19 .
analogously , decoder @xmath20 computes @xmath21 .
the reconstruction quality is measured with squared - error distortion , i.e. , @xmath22 for any source block @xmath23 and reconstruction block @xmath24 .
the problem is to find the optimal tradeoff between the channel input power constraint @xmath25 and the expected distortion pair @xmath26 achieved at the receivers . in @xcite ,
an outer bound to the distortion region is obtained for @xmath27 by assuming full knowledge of @xmath28 at the second ( strong ) receiver . in @xcite , that outer bound is extended to bandwidth - mismatched case , in the form of @xmath29 where @xmath30 $ ] and @xmath31 .
several separation - based schemes have been previously proposed , differing only in their source coding strategy . in the first separation - based scheme , termed scheme a in @xcite , sources @xmath28 and @xmath32
are encoded as if they are independent , resulting in the distortion region given by @xmath33 in scheme b in @xcite , the second source is written as @xmath34 , where @xmath35 , and @xmath28 and @xmath36 are treated as two new independent sources .
hence we obtain @xmath37 in the scheme introduced in @xcite , which we call scheme c , @xmath28 is quantized to @xmath38 and @xmath32 is then encoded conditioned on @xmath38 .
the resultant distortion region becomes @xmath39 \left ( 1+\frac{\bar{\eta } p}{n_2 } \right ) ^ { -\kappa}\ ; .
\label{eq : tiand2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] of the three , it is obvious that scheme c achieves the best performance .
however , it is still not optimal as we will show in section iv .
the optimal strategy is in fact what is called successive coding in @xcite , whereby the sources are encoded jointly at both the common and the refinement layers .
the rd tradeoff for successive coding of gaussian sources with squared - error distortion was given in @xcite parametrically with respect to @xmath40 $ ] as , the optimal strategy degenerates into sending only a common message and estimating @xmath41 solely from @xmath42 .
so this trivial case is excluded from the discussion in the sequel . ]
@xmath43^+\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath44 , @xmath45^+ = \max\{x , 0\}$ ] , and @xmath46 with @xmath47 , and @xmath48 is the unique root of @xmath49 in the interval @xmath50 $ ] .
we first show the rd region of successive coding can be simplified by eliminating both the parameter @xmath51 and the need to find the roots of the cubic polynomial @xmath52 .
the achievable source coding rate pair @xmath53 , for any distortion pair @xmath26 , is given by @xmath54^+\ ; , \label{eq : sourcerate2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath55 $ ] .
the proof is deferred to appendix a. in separate coding , the region of all achievable @xmath56 triplets can be determined using one of two methods .
the conventional method fixes @xmath25 and searches for the lower envelope of all @xmath26 whose source rate region intersects with the capacity region given in @xcite .
alternatively , we can fix @xmath26 and search for the minimum @xmath25 whose corresponding capacity region intersects with the source rate region given in lemma @xmath16 .
we find this alternative both more convenient and more meaningful .
more specifically , it is easier to compare schemes based on the minimum power they need to achieve the same distortion pair , and the ratio of minimum powers yields a single number as a quality measure . to be able to use this alternative , first we need to find out the minimum required power for any given source coding rate pair @xmath57 . for any source coding rate pair @xmath57 ,
the minimal required power is given by @xmath58 for a gaussian broadcast channel where the better receiver is the second one , @xmath59 and @xmath60 , rates of common and private information , respectively , can be achieved if and only if there exists @xmath61 such that @xmath62 where @xmath31 .
this , in turn , implies that @xmath25 is achievable if and only if there exists @xmath63 such that @xmath64 since the terms in the maximum exhibit opposite monotonicity with respect to @xmath65 with asymptotes at @xmath66 and @xmath67 , the minimum power is achieved when the two terms are equal , that is , when @xmath68 and has the form in ( [ eq : mismatchedp ] ) . by substituting ( [ eq : sourcerate1 ] ) and ( [ eq : sourcerate2 ] ) into ( [ eq : mismatchedp ] ) , we obtain the minimum power required for the separate coding scheme as a function of @xmath69 : @xmath70^ { 1/ \kappa } -1\right ) \\
+ n_2\left [ \left ( \frac{1-\nu^2 \delta}{d_2 } \right ) ^ { 1/ \kappa } -1\right ] \left [ \frac{1-\rho^2}{d_1(1-\nu^2 \delta ) - ( \rho-\nu \delta)^2 } \right]^ { 1 / \kappa } \ ; . \label{eq : pnu}\end{gathered}\ ] ] for bandwidth - matched case , the minimum power of separate coding @xmath71 can actually be found analytically for any @xmath72 .
we omit the details here .
the following theorem is our first main result .
separate source - channel coding achieves optimal power - distortion tradeoff when @xmath26 satisfies either of the following conditions 1 .
@xmath73 and @xmath74 , 2 .
@xmath75 and @xmath76 .
we first find the minimum power the outer bound ( [ eq : ob1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ob2 ] ) requires .
note that when @xmath77 , ( [ eq : ob2 ] ) will hold for any @xmath30 $ ] , and hence the minimum power is obtained solely from ( [ eq : ob1 ] ) , whereas when @xmath74 , the minimum power satisfies equality in both ( [ eq : ob1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ob2 ] ) .
combining the two cases , we obtain the concise expression @xmath78^+ + n_1(d_1^{-1/\kappa } -1 ) \ ; .
% & = \frac { -(d_1d_2)^{1/\kappa } n_1 + d_2^{1/\kappa } ( n_1-n_2 ) + n_2 ( 1-\rho^2)^{1/\kappa } } { ( d_1d_2)^{1/\kappa } } \ ; . \end{split}\ ] ] on the other hand , from ( [ eq : pnu ] ) , we have @xmath79 d_1^ { - 1 / \kappa } \\ = n_2d_1^{-1/\kappa } \left [ \left(\frac{d_2}{1-\rho^2 \delta } \right)^{- 1 / \kappa } - 1 \right ] + n_1(d_1^{-1 / \kappa }
-1 ) \ ; .\ ] ] since @xmath44 , it is easy to see that when @xmath74 @xmath80 and since @xmath81 is feasible , the minimum power of separate coding satisfies @xmath82
. therefore the performance of separate coding scheme approaches the outer bound , or @xmath83 similarly , by setting @xmath84 , we have @xmath85^ { 1 / \kappa}-1\right)\\ & + n_2\left [ \left ( \frac{1-\frac{\rho^2 } { \delta}}{d_2 } \right ) ^ { 1 / \kappa } -1\right ] \left [ \frac{1-\rho^2}{d_1(1-\frac{\rho^2 } { \delta } ) } \right]^ { 1 / \kappa } \ ; , \end{split}\ ] ] and when @xmath75 , @xmath86 .
note when @xmath87 , @xmath88 , which again implies @xmath89 , thus proving the second part of the theorem .
here we proved that the outer bound is tight in the region of @xmath87 when either @xmath90 or @xmath91 goes to @xmath92 , and the performance of separate coding approaches the outer bound .
the condition that either @xmath90 or @xmath91 goes to @xmath92 translates to infinite channel snr .
in fact , as we show in the following theorem , separate coding is approximately optimal for the entire region @xmath87 , in the sense that the power ratio @xmath93 can be upper - bounded universally in @xmath94 . when @xmath87 , @xmath95 } { ( 1+\rho)^{1/ \kappa}-(1-\rho)^{1/ \kappa } } , \\
\left ( \frac{(1+\rho)^2}{1 + 2\rho } \right)^{1 / \kappa } + \frac{\left ( \frac{(1+\rho)^2}{1 + 2\rho } \right)^{1 / \kappa } - 1}{(1-\rho^2)^{-1/ \kappa } - 1}\bigg\ } \ ; .\end{gathered}\ ] ] the first half is true because @xmath96 + d_2^{1/ \kappa } ( 1- d_1^{1/ \kappa})}{\frac{n_2}{n_1}\left [ ( 1-\rho^2)^{1/ \kappa } - d_2^{1/ \kappa } \right ] + d_2^{1/ \kappa } ( 1- d_1^{1/ \kappa } ) } \\ & \stackrel{(b)}{\leq } & \frac{(1-\rho^2 \delta)^{1/ \kappa } - ( d_1 d_2)^{1/ \kappa } } { ( 1-\rho^2)^{1/ \kappa } - ( d_1 d_2)^{1/ \kappa } } \\ & \stackrel{(c)}{\leq } & \frac{(1-\rho^2 \delta)^{1/ \kappa } - ( 1-\rho)^{2/ \kappa}}{(1-\rho^2)^{1/ \kappa } - ( 1-\rho)^{2/ \kappa } } \\ &
\stackrel{(d)}{\leq } & 1+\frac{(1+\rho)^{1/ \kappa } \left [ ( 1+\rho^2)^{1/ \kappa}-1 \right ] } { ( 1+\rho)^{1/ \kappa}-(1-\rho)^{1/ \kappa}}\ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath97 follows since @xmath81 is feasible , @xmath98 by @xmath99 , @xmath100 follows since @xmath101 , and @xmath102 since @xmath103 . by relaxing @xmath104 to @xmath105
, the second half of the bound can be obtained in a similar way .
the detailed proof is omitted here due to lack of space .
+ as illustrated in @xcite for @xmath106 , the outer bound in ( [ eq : ob1 ] ) and ( [ eq : ob2 ] ) is not always tight .
nevertheless , we can still compare @xmath104 and @xmath107 for any @xmath72 , which provides an upper bound to the ratio of the minimum separate and joint coding power levels . to show the optimality of our separate coding scheme
, we also compare our scheme with scheme c , which provides the best performance among the three separation - based schemes mentioned earlier .
the minimum required power of scheme c can be obtained from ( [ eq : tiand1 ] ) and ( [ eq : tiand2 ] ) as @xmath108 d_1^{-1/\kappa } -n_1 \ ; .
p_c = n_2d_1^{-1/\kappa}\left [ \left(\frac{d_2}{1-\rho^2 \delta } \right)^{-1/\kappa } -1 \right ] + n_1(d_1^{-1/\kappa } -1 ) \ ; .
% \label{eq : pc}\ ] ] note that @xmath109 in the non - trivial distortion regions , so it is immediately clear that the successive coding scheme outperforms scheme c. as an example with bandwidth compression , we show the power ratio between our separate coding scheme and the outer bound in figure [ fig : tian ] , and that between scheme c and our separate coding scheme in figure [ fig : tian ] , both in db . for reference ,
the black curves illustrate the different distortion regions for a related problem in @xcite , where only one receiver is in presence and interested in reconstructing both sources .
the lower left corner region is actually @xmath87 , where , in general , small db differences are observed , as implied by the two theorems above .
as can be seen from the figure , even for highly correlated sources , the optimum separate coding scheme does not require too much extra power in most of the @xmath72 plane .
again , since the outer bound is not always tight , the large power difference in some regions may be dramatically reduced when the outer bound is replaced by the optimum performance . for smaller @xmath110 values ,
we observe that the power difference is very small in the entire plane , as an example illustrates in the next section .
this is a natural result because separate coding is optimal for independent sources and small @xmath110 value means the sources are not highly dependent .
there is also noticeable power difference between our scheme and scheme c , and we numerically observe large db values near the point @xmath111 and @xmath112 , for which we can obtain analytically the power ratio . when @xmath113 and @xmath75 , @xmath114 the proof uses the fact that the power of our separate coding scheme goes to that of the outer bound when approaching this point .
when the two receivers have the same noise level , i.e. , @xmath115 , it can be shown that our separate coding scheme achieves the corresponding rate - distortion function @xmath116 in @xcite , whereas none of the three separate coding schemes mentioned earlier has the same performance .
+ in @xcite and @xcite , a group of hybrid digital / analog ( hda ) schemes were proposed for bandwidth - mismatched case , where analog , digital , and hybrid schemes are layered with superposition or dirty - paper - coding .
the achievable distortion region can be found by varying power allocation and scaling coefficients . in @xcite , an hda scheme from @xcite for broadcasting a common source with bandwidth expansion
was adapted for the problem of broadcasting correlated sources and is termed the rfz scheme . in addition , a scheme , termed the hwz scheme , containing an analog layer and two digital layers each with a wyner - ziv coder and a channel coder , was also proposed .
it is argued by an example in @xcite that the hwz scheme performs similar to the rfz scheme .
here we compare our separate coding scheme with the outer bound and the rfz / hwz scheme in figure [ fig : hamid ] . for this comparison
, we revert to the more familiar @xmath72 plot for the exact same @xmath117 as those used in the examples in @xcite .
as seen in figure [ fig : hamid ] , when @xmath110 is small , the separate coding scheme almost coincides with the outer bound and outperforms rfz / hwz schemes . when the sources are highly correlated as in figure [ fig : hamid ] , the separate coding scheme is still better than the rfz / hwz schemes when @xmath91 is lower than a certain value , and also provides competitive performance when it is higher .
we observed similar performance behavior when we compared the separate coding scheme to the layered schemes in @xcite for bandwidth compression .
the performance of optimum separate source - channel coding scheme for broadcasting two correlated gaussians is analyzed . the minimum power required for a given distortion pair
is used as a tool to compare performances of different schemes .
it is illustrated that this separate coding scheme outperforms other known separate schemes , and is competitive in general in the sense that its minimum required power is close to the power implied by the outer bound .
also , in a certain `` low distortion '' region , the power difference is analytically bounded .
in fact , within this region , in the extreme cases of almost lossless reconstruction of either source , the separate scheme is provably optimal .
the cubic function in @xcite is @xmath118 and when @xmath119 , it can be re - written as @xmath120 } \ ; .\ ] ] it will be shown that varying @xmath121 in @xmath122 $ ] is equivalent with varying @xmath69 in @xmath123 $ ] , by showing @xmath121 is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath69 .
when @xmath124 , @xmath125 and also note @xmath126 when @xmath127 , respectively .
we examine @xmath128 instead of @xmath121 , and @xmath129 the right hand side is a quadratic function of @xmath69 centered at @xmath84 and the maximum value is @xmath130 .
( when @xmath81 , the function value is @xmath131 . )
similarly , when @xmath132 , we have @xmath133 and in this case , @xmath126 when @xmath134 .
we examine @xmath135 and thus have @xmath136 the right hand side is centered at @xmath137 and the maximum value is @xmath138 . @xmath139
h. behroozi , f. alajaji , and t. linder , `` hybrid digital - analog joint source - channel coding for broadcasting correlated gaussian sources , '' _ proc .
inf . theory ( isit 2009 ) _ ,
seoul , korea , june 2009 .
c. tian , s. diggavi , and s. shamai , `` the achievable distortion region of bivariate gaussian source on gaussian broadcast channel , '' _ proc .
theory ( isit 2010 ) _ , austin , tx , june 2010 . | the problem of broadcasting a pair of correlated gaussian sources using optimal separate source and channel codes is studied .
considerable performance gains over previously known separate source - channel schemes are observed .
although source - channel separation yields suboptimal performance in general , it is shown that the proposed scheme is very competitive for any bandwidth compression / expansion scenarios .
in particular , for a high channel snr scenario , it can be shown to achieve optimal power - distortion tradeoff . |
many models of galaxy formation and evolution in recent years take as a reference for the observational side the results coming from qso absorption studies and in particular those objects that show a large hi column density , namely , the damped lyman@xmath0 systems ( dlas ) with @xmath9 atoms 2 ( see for example pei et al .
dlas have been widely studied both because they are believed to be the progenitors of present day galaxies and because the large hi column density allows one to probe the chemical enrichment problem .
dlas constitute so far the best laboratory where to directly measure the heavy element enrichment in a large interval of evolutionary phases , and to understand the processes of star formation and metal pollution of the universe .
however , this kind of investigation requires a careful consideration of the effects of dust depletion suffered by dlas ( pei et al .
1991 ; pettini et al .
we present the analysis of a sample of dlas in the redshift range @xmath1 to investigate their chemical state .
we find that , after allowance for dust depletion corrections which are obtained with a very general approach , the dla population clearly shows a metallicity redshift evolution .
.mean element abundances relative to hydrogen [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] we have collected data from the literature for a dla sample , which includes objects . this sample represents the largest and most complete sample of dlas for which measurements of hi and heavy element column densities are available .
the ions considered for abundance measurements are feii , znii , crii , siii , mnii , sii , niii .
these ions are the dominant contributors to the abundances of the corresponding elements in hi clouds with high column densities , because they all have ionization potentials below 13.6 ev . in table
1 we give the mean metal abundances relative to hydrogen and iron . they are presented with the customary definition [ x / h]@xmath12 , where x@xmath13 and y@xmath13 are the ion column densities of element x and y. for comparison , the mean abundances for warm halo ( wh ) clouds ( savage and sembach 1996 ) and the small magellanic cloud ( smc , welty et al .
1997 ) are also shown .
we note that globally dlas show [ x / h ] and [ x / fe ] abundance ratios more similar to those of smc and wh clouds , respectively .
this suggests that metal abundances in dlas are the result of chemical enrichment processes similar from the ones operating in the smc and that the most common depletion pattern operating in dlas is similar to the one observed in wh clouds . indeed , to derive a complete picture of the dla chemical state ,
one must correct for dust depletion effects . since every element considered is affected by dust depletion differently , one must consider all measured species simultaneously . in the milky way ,
a number of depletion patterns have been identified , showing highest depletions in dense disk clouds and lowest depletions in low density , warm halo clouds ( savage & sembach 1996 ) .
we make a simplification assuming that the depletion patterns in dlas may be reproduced by one of the four depletion patterns identified for the mw : warm halo , warm halo + disk ( whd ) , warm disk ( wd ) and cool disk ( cd ) clouds ( savage & sembach 1996 ) , thus modifying the dust to metals ratio to obtain the best match with the observations . by means of a @xmath2 minimization procedure
we determine the best fit dla metallicities and the dust to metals ratios . fig .
1 shows the metallicity as a function of redshift .
filled symbols represent dlas with three or more measured elemental abundances for which it has been possible to obtain a proper best fit solution ( 37 dlas ) . for the cases with only two elements
observed , each fit has a zero formal error and , therefore , a reduced @xmath2 can not be calculated ; thus , the best fit is considered less significant ( 16 dlas , empty symbols and solid error bars ) . finally , for the cases where only one element is measured
, we estimate the metallicity assuming a wh depletion pattern ( 16 dlas , empty symbols and dotted error bars ) . the combination of the largest sample available ( dlas )
, a large redshift baseline ( @xmath14 ) and a more accurate dust correction applied have led to the unambiguous detection of the redshift evolution of metallicity in dla galaxies , with mean values around 1/30 of solar at @xmath4 to 3/5 of solar at @xmath6 .
we found a significant linear correlation of metallicity with redshift ( 99.99% significance level ) with a slope of @xmath15 , which is clearly not consistent with a null gradient , indicating genuine evolution of dla metallicity with redshift . in fig . 1 we also show six boxes centered on the weighted averages over @xmath16 intervals and whose vertical widths mark the corresponding @xmath17 weighted dispersion . in addition
, we note that the vertical dispersion of points greatly exceeds the total errors , indicating that , although all dlas align along an average trend , there are real differences among individual objects in either initial conditions , or time of formation , or metal enrichment efficiency , or all of the above .
pei & fall ( 1995 ) consider that a mean heavy element abundance in the interstellar medium of dla galaxies is given by the ratio of the total metal content to the total gas content ( i.e. @xmath18 ) , which means that large hi dlas dominate when calculating the global metallicity .
this kind of analysis has been performed on a sample of dlas using the znii absorption line and a null result has been found for the evolution ( pettini et al .
1999 ) , and it is not disproved if our sample is used
. however , the lack of evident evolution in this case appears to be due to the fact that those dlas with large hi column density are concentrated in the central redshift region ( 84% of dlas with @xmath19 are in the bin @xmath20 ) . in other words , we can not exclude the redshift evolution of metallicity in high hi dlas till when the considered sample will be fairly distributed in the considered redshift range .
if there were a metallicity evolution also for high hi dlas , dust obscuration could be too large at @xmath21 to make dlas detectable ( a dla with @xmath22 and metallicity @xmath23 would extinct about 1.5 magnitude in the ly@xmath0 ) .
moreover , this is where uv observations , required to detect ly@xmath0 absorption , are very sensitive to any appreciable dust opacity .
in 37 dlas for which we have obtained a best fit solution , we have found that the majority ( @xmath24% ) show a wh like depletion pattern , then @xmath25% and @xmath26% have a whd like and wd like depletion pattern , respectively .
the predominance of wh like conditions may be interpreted as evidence for a lower density in the absorbing clouds relative to clouds in the mw disk and/or to more efficient dust destruction processes operating in dla galaxies , possibly due to more active star formation that may produce a more turbulent , dust hostile environment . in our sample
there are 31 dlas with measured si and for which it has to perform @xmath2 minimization . for 8 over 31 systems
, there is evidence of deviation of si with respect the expectations , having a mean value of @xmath27 .
no correlation with redshift and metallicity is revealed .
this result may be indicative of @xmath0element enrichment in a fraction of dlas , or of a lower efficiency of silicate formation than is found in the milky way .
we like to stress that it is the combination of a large sample of dlas ( objects ) , a wide redshift baseline ( @xmath14 ) and a more accurate dust correction applied to all heavy elements measured , that has allowed us to demonstrate that the metallicity of dlas evolves with redshift .
the combined use of as many elements as possible allows one to much more efficiently track the metallicity evolution down to very metal poor gas clouds . | we have collected data for damped lyman@xmath0 ( dla ) systems , to investigate the chemical evolution of galaxies in the redshift interval @xmath1 . in doing that
, we have adopted the most general approach used so far to correct for dust depletion .
the best solution , obtained through @xmath2 minimization , gives as output parameters the global dla metallicity and the dust to metals ratio .
clear evolution of the metallicity vs. redshift is found ( 99.99% significance level ) , with average values going from @xmath3 solar at @xmath4 to @xmath5 solar at @xmath6 .
we also find that the majority of dlas ( @xmath7% ) shows dust depletion patterns which most closely resemble that of the warm halo clouds in the milky way , and have dust to metals ratios very close to warm halo clouds .
2@xmath8 # 1_#1 _ # 1_#1 _ = # 1 1.25 in .125 in .25 in |
in this paper we continue the geometric construction of a sequence of flips associated to an embedded projective variety begun in @xcite . we give hypotheses under which this sequence of flips exists , and state some conjectures on how positive a line bundle on a curve must be to satisfy these hypotheses .
these conjectures deal with the degrees of forms defining various secant varieties to curves and seem interesting outside of the context of the flip construction . as motivation
, we have the work of a. bertram and m. thaddeus . in @xcite this sequence of flips is constructed in the case of smooth curves via git , in the context of the moduli space of rank two vector bundles on a smooth curve .
an understanding of this as a sequence of log flips is given in @xcite , and further examples of sequences of flips of this type , again constructed via git , are given in @xcite,@xcite .
our construction , however , does not use the tools of geometric invariant theory and is closer in spirit to @xcite,@xcite . in section [ review ] , we review the constructions in @xcite and @xcite and describe the relevant results from @xcite . in section [ genofsecants ]
we discuss the generation of @xmath0 by cubics .
in particular , we show ( theorem [ settheo ] ) that large embeddings of varieties have secant varieties that are at least set theoretically defined by cubics .
we also offer some general conjectures and suggestions in this direction for the generation of higher secant varieties .
the construction of the new flips is somewhat more involved than that of the first in @xcite .
we give a general construction of a sequence of birational transformations in section [ genflipconst ] , and we describe in detail the second flip in section [ secondflip ] .
we mention that some of the consequences of these constructions and this point of view are worked out in @xcite .
* notation : * we will decorate a projective variety @xmath1 as follows : @xmath2 is the @xmath3 cartesian product of @xmath1 ; @xmath4 is @xmath5 , the @xmath3 symmetric product of @xmath1 ; and @xmath6 is @xmath7 , the hilbert scheme of zero dimensional subschemes of @xmath1 of length @xmath8 . recall ( cf .
@xcite ) that if @xmath1 is a smooth projective variety then @xmath6 is also projective , and is smooth if and
only if either @xmath9 or @xmath10 . write @xmath11 for the ( complete ) variety of @xmath12-secant @xmath13-planes to @xmath1 .
as this notation can become cluttered , we simply write @xmath14 for @xmath15 and @xmath0 for @xmath16 .
note also the convention @xmath17 .
if @xmath18 is a @xmath12-vector space , we denote by @xmath19 the space of 1-dimensional quotients of @xmath18 . unless otherwise stated , we work throughout over the field @xmath20 of complex numbers .
we use the terms locally free sheaf ( resp .
invertible sheaf ) and vector bundle ( resp .
line bundle ) interchangeably . recall that a line bundle @xmath21 on @xmath1 is _ nef _ if @xmath22 for every irreducible curve @xmath23 .
a line bundle @xmath21 is _ big _ if @xmath24 induces a birational map for all @xmath25 .
* acknowledgments : * i would like to thank aaron bertram , sheldon katz , zhenbo qin , and jonathan wahl for their helpful conversations and communications .
fix a line bundle @xmath26 on a fixed smooth curve @xmath1 , and denote by @xmath27 the moduli space of semi - stable rank two vector bundles @xmath28 with @xmath29 .
there is a natural rational map , the _ serre correspondence _ @xmath30 given by the duality @xmath31 , taking an extension class @xmath32 to @xmath28 .
one has an embedding @xmath33 ( at least in the case @xmath34 ) and @xmath35 , defined only for semi - stable @xmath28 , is a morphism off @xmath36 where @xmath37 $ ] @xcite .
this map is resolved in @xcite by first blowing up along @xmath1 , then along the proper transform of @xmath0 , then along the transform of @xmath38 and so on until we have a morphism to @xmath27 .
a different approach is taken in @xcite . there , for a fixed smooth curve @xmath1 of genus at least @xmath39 and a fixed line bundle @xmath26 , the moduli problem of semi - stable pairs @xmath40 consisting of a rank two bundle @xmath28 with @xmath29 , and a section @xmath41 , is considered .
this , in turn , is interpreted as a git problem , and by varying the linearization of the group action , a collection of ( smooth ) moduli spaces @xmath42 ( @xmath12 as above ) is constructed . as stability is an open condition , these spaces are birational .
in fact , they are isomorphic in codimension one , and may be linked via a diagram & & & & & & + m_1 & & m_2 & & & & m_k where there is a morphism @xmath43 .
the relevant observations are first that this is a diagram of flips ( in fact it is shown in @xcite that it is a sequence of log flips ) where the ample cone of each @xmath44 is known .
second , @xmath45 is the blow up of @xmath46 along @xmath1 , @xmath47 is the blow up of @xmath45 along the proper transform of the secant variety , and all of the flips can be seen as blowing up and down various higher secant varieties . finally , the @xmath44 are isomorphic off loci which are projective bundles over appropriate symmetric products of @xmath1 .
our approach is as follows : the sequence of flips in thaddeus construction can be realized as a sequence of geometric constructions depending only on the embedding of @xmath48 .
an advantage of this approach is that the smooth curve @xmath1 can be replaced by any smooth variety . even in the curve case
, our approach applies to situations where thaddeus construction does not hold ( e.g. for canonical curves with @xmath49 ) . in @xcite ,
we show how to construct the first flip using only information about the syzygies among the equations defining the variety @xmath48 .
we summarize this construction here .
[ kd ] let @xmath1 be a subscheme of @xmath50 .
the pair @xmath51 * satisfies condition @xmath52 * if @xmath1 is scheme theoretically cut out by forms @xmath53 of degree @xmath8 such that the trivial ( or koszul ) relations among the @xmath54 are generated by linear syzygies .
we say @xmath55 satisfies @xmath52 for @xmath56 if @xmath18 is spanned by forms @xmath54 satisfying the above condition .
we say simply @xmath1 satisfies @xmath52 if there exists a set @xmath57 such that @xmath51 satisfies @xmath52 , and if the discussion depends only on the existence of such a set , not on the choice of a particular set . as @xmath58 is a weakening of green s property @xmath59@xcite , examples of varieties satisfying @xmath58 include smooth curves embedded by complete linear systems of degree at least @xmath60 , canonical curves with @xmath61 , and sufficiently large embeddings of arbitrary projective varieties . to any projective variety @xmath62 defined ( as a scheme ) by forms
@xmath63 of degree @xmath8 , there is an associated rational map @xmath64 defined off the common zero locus of the @xmath54 , i.e. off @xmath1 .
this map may be resolved to a morphism @xmath65 by blowing up @xmath50 along @xmath1 , or equivalently by projecting from the closure of the graph @xmath66 .
we have the following results on the structure of @xmath67 : [ embed]@xcite let @xmath51 be a pair that satisfies @xmath52 .
then : 1 .
@xmath68 is an embedding off of @xmath69 , the variety of @xmath8-secant lines . 2 .
the projection of a positive dimensional fiber of @xmath67 to @xmath70 is either contained in a linear subspace of @xmath1 or is a linear space intersecting @xmath1 in a @xmath8-tic hypersurface .
if , furthermore , @xmath1 does not contain a line then @xmath67 is an embedding off the proper transform of @xmath69 .
@xmath71 [ getabundle]@xcite let @xmath55 satisfy @xmath58 and assume @xmath62 is smooth , irreducible , contains no lines and contains no quadrics .
then : 1 .
the image of @xmath72 under @xmath67 is @xmath73 .
2 . @xmath74 is a rank two vector bundle on @xmath73 , where @xmath75 is the proper transform of the hyperplane section on @xmath70 .
@xmath76 is the @xmath77-bundle @xmath78 .
+ @xmath71 this implies @xmath79 , and hence @xmath80 , are smooth . to complete the flip
, we construct a base point free linear system on @xmath47 , and take @xmath81 to be the image of the associated morphism . denoting @xmath82 , the sheaf @xmath83 is locally free of rank @xmath84 on @xmath73 .
write @xmath85 and rename @xmath67 as @xmath86 : [ flip]@xcite let @xmath55 satisfy @xmath58 and assume @xmath62 is smooth , irreducible , contains no lines and contains no plane quadrics . then there is a flip as pictured below with : 1 .
@xmath87 , @xmath47 , and @xmath81 smooth 2 .
@xmath88 , hence if @xmath89 then @xmath90 3 .
@xmath91 is the blow up of @xmath81 along @xmath92 4 .
@xmath93 is the blow up of @xmath87 along @xmath94 5 .
@xmath95 , induced by @xmath96 , is an embedding off of @xmath92 , and the restriction of @xmath95 is the projection @xmath97 6 .
@xmath86 , induced by @xmath98 , is an embedding off of @xmath94 , and the restriction of @xmath86 is the projection @xmath99 & e_2 _ ^h_1 & & & _ ^h_1 & + (e ) _ ^+ & & (f ) ^^- & ^^+ & & m_2 ^^- + & h^2x & & ^s_0 |>__1 & ^s_1 & to continue this process following thaddeus , we need to construct a birational morphism @xmath100 which contracts the transforms of @xmath101-secant @xmath39-planes to points , and is an embedding off their union .
the natural candidate is the map induced by the linear system @xmath102 .
we discuss two different reasons for this choice that will guide the construction of the entire sequence of flips .
section [ genofsecants ] addresses the question of when this system is globally generated .
note that we abuse notation throughout and identify line bundles via the isomorphism @xmath103 .
the first reason is quite naive : just as quadrics collapse secant lines because their restriction to such a line is a quadric hypersurface , so too do cubics vanishing twice on a variety collapse every @xmath101-secant @xmath104 because they vanish on a cubic hypersurface in such a plane .
similarly , to collapse the transform of each @xmath105-secant @xmath106 via a morphism @xmath107 , the natural system is @xmath108 .
another reason is found by studying the ample cones of the @xmath44 .
note that the ample cone on @xmath109 is bounded by the line bundles @xmath75 and @xmath98 .
both of these bundles are globally generated , and by theorems [ embed ] and [ getabundle ] , they each give birational morphisms whose exceptional loci are projective bundles over hilbert schemes of points of @xmath1 ( @xmath110 and @xmath73 respectively ) .
on @xmath81 , the ample cone is bounded on one side by @xmath96 .
this gives the map @xmath111 mentioned in theorem [ flip ] ; in particular it is globally generated , the induced morphism is birational , and its exceptional locus is a projective bundle over @xmath73 . on the other side ,
the ample cone contains a line bundle of the form @xmath112 ( @xcite ) .
in fact , if @xmath1 is a smooth curve embedded by a line bundle of degree at least @xmath113 , it is shown in @xcite that the case @xmath114 suffices , i.e. that the ample cone is bounded by @xmath96 and @xmath102 .
therefore , it is natural to look for conditions under which @xmath102 is globally generated .
thaddeus further shows that under similar positivity conditions , the ample cone of @xmath115 is bounded by @xmath116 and @xmath108 .
noting the fact that @xmath117 , it is not difficult to see ( using zariski s main theorem ) that this system will be globally generated if @xmath118 is scheme theoretically defined by cubics , because a cubic vanishing twice on a variety must also vanish on its secant variety . unfortunately , there are no general theorems on the cubic generation of secant varieties analogous to quadric generation of varieties .
we address this question in the next section .
examplesomecubics some examples of varieties whose secant varieties are _ ideal _ theoretically defined by cubics include : 1 .
@xmath1 is any veronese embedding of @xmath50 @xcite 2 .
@xmath1 is the plcker embedding of the grassmannian @xmath119 for any @xmath120 @xcite .
@xmath1 is the segre embedding of @xmath121 @xcite .
+ @xmath71 we prove a general result : [ settheo ] let @xmath62 satisfy condition @xmath58 . then @xmath122 is * set * theoretically defined by cubics for @xmath123 .
we begin with the case @xmath124 , the higher embeddings being more elementary .
let @xmath125 , @xmath126 , and @xmath127 the linear subspace of @xmath128 defined by the hyperplanes corresponding to all the quadrics in @xmath70 vanishing on @xmath1
. then @xmath129 as schemes and we show , noting that @xmath130 is ideal theoretically defined by cubics , that @xmath131 as sets .
note that the map @xmath132 can be viewed as the composition of the embedding @xmath133 with the projection from @xmath127 , @xmath134 .
let @xmath135 . if @xmath136 , then @xmath137 hence @xmath138 .
otherwise , any secant line @xmath139 to @xmath18 through @xmath140 intersects @xmath18 in a length two subscheme @xmath141 .
@xmath141 considered in @xmath70 determines a unique line in @xmath70 whose image in @xmath128 is a plane quadric @xmath142 spanning a plane @xmath143 . if @xmath144 is non - empty then @xmath145 , hence either @xmath127 intersects @xmath143 in a line @xmath146 through @xmath140 or @xmath147 . in the first case
@xmath146 is a secant line to @xmath148 , in the second @xmath149 . in either situation @xmath138 .
cubics.ps31.5 all that remains is the case @xmath150 and @xmath151 is empty .
however in this case the line @xmath139 , and hence the scheme @xmath152 is collapsed to a point by the projection .
as the rational map @xmath153 is an embedding off @xmath0 , this implies @xmath141 lies on the image of a secant line to @xmath62 . as a length two subscheme of @xmath70 determines a unique line , @xmath154 must be the image of a secant line to @xmath62 contradicting the assumption that @xmath151 is empty . for @xmath155 ,
note that the projection from @xmath127 is an embedding off @xmath156 ( this can be derived directly from theorem [ embed ] or see @xcite ) .
therefore , if @xmath127 intersects a secant line , the line lies in @xmath127 , hence is a secant line to @xmath148 .
examplecubics as green s @xmath59 implies @xmath58 , this shows that the secant varieties to the following varieties are set theoretically defined by cubics : 1 .
@xmath1 a smooth curve embedded by a line bundle of degree @xmath157 , @xmath158 .
@xmath1 a smooth curve with @xmath49 , embedded by @xmath159 , @xmath160 .
3 . @xmath1 a smooth variety embedded by @xmath161 , @xmath162 , @xmath139 very ample .
@xmath1 a smooth variety embedded by @xmath163 for all @xmath164 , @xmath139 ample .
+ @xmath71 remarkalmostk3 notice that in the case @xmath124 of proposition [ settheo ] , the cubics that at least set theoretically define the secant variety satisfy @xmath165 .
this is because : 1 .
the ideal of the secant variety of @xmath166 is generated by cubics , and the module of syzygies is generated by linear relations @xcite .
hence @xmath167 satisfies @xmath165 .
it is clear from the definition that if @xmath168 satisfies @xmath52 , then any linear section does as well .
+ @xmath71 examplequadhyp if @xmath168 is a smooth quadric hypersurface , then @xmath169 is given by the intersection of @xmath170 with a hyperplane @xmath127 . furthermore , the intersection of @xmath171 with @xmath127 is a scheme @xmath172 with @xmath173 .
therefore , a general smooth quadric hypersurface has @xmath174 as schemes , hence @xmath175 satisfies @xmath165 .
@xmath71 we record here a related conjecture of eisenbud , koh , and stillman as well as a partial answer proven by m.s .
ravi : @xcite let @xmath139 be a very ample line bundle that embeds a smooth curve @xmath1 .
for each @xmath12 there is a bound on the degree of @xmath139 such that @xmath36 is ideal theoretically defined by the @xmath176 minors of a matrix of linear forms .
@xcite if @xmath177 , then @xmath36 is * set * theoretically defined by the @xmath176 minors of a matrix of linear forms .
these statements provide enough evidence to make the following basic : let @xmath139 be an ample line bundle on a smooth variety @xmath1 , @xmath178 fixed .
then for all @xmath25 , @xmath179 embeds @xmath1 so that @xmath36 is ideal theoretically defined by forms of degree @xmath180 , and furthermore satisfies condition @xmath181 .
remark5secant3plane if @xmath1 is a curve with a @xmath182-secant @xmath101-plane , then any cubic vanishing on @xmath0 must vanish on that @xmath101-plane .
hence @xmath0 can not be set theoretically defined by cubics .
this should be compared to the fact that if @xmath1 has a trisecant line , then @xmath1 can not be defined by quadrics . in particular , this shows that green s condition @xmath59 is not even sufficient to guarantee that their exists a cubic vanishing on @xmath0 .
for example , if @xmath1 is an elliptic curve embedded in @xmath183 by a line bundle of degree @xmath182 , then @xmath0 is a quintic hypersurface .
therefore , any uniform bound on the degree of a linear system that would guarantee @xmath0 is even set theoretically defined by cubics must be at least @xmath184 .
@xmath71 we can use earlier work to give a more geometric necessary condition for @xmath0 to be defined as a scheme by cubics . specifically , in @xcite it is shown that the intersection of @xmath79 with the exceptional divisor @xmath28 of the blow up of @xmath70 along @xmath1 is isomorphic to @xmath185 .
this implies that if @xmath186 is the blow up along @xmath1 , then @xmath187 .
in fact , it is easy to verify that if @xmath1 is embedded by a line bundle @xmath139 , then @xmath188 where @xmath189 is identified with the fiber over @xmath140 of the projectivized conormal bundle of @xmath62 .
now , if @xmath0 is defined as a scheme by cubics , then the base scheme of @xmath190 is precisely @xmath79 .
the restriction of this series to @xmath189 is thus a system of quadrics whose base scheme is @xmath191 . in other words ,
if @xmath1 is a smooth variety embedded by a line bundle @xmath139 that satisfies @xmath58 and if @xmath0 is scheme theoretically defined by cubics , then for every @xmath192 the line bundle @xmath193 is very ample on @xmath191 and @xmath194 is scheme theoretically defined by quadrics . in the case
@xmath1 is a curve , this implies that a uniform bound on @xmath195 that would imply @xmath0 is defined by cubics must be at least @xmath184 , the same bound encountered in remark [ 5secant3plane ] .
the construction in @xcite shows similarly that any uniform bound that would imply @xmath36 is defined by @xmath196-tics must be at least @xmath197 .
we combine these observations with the degree bounds encountered in the constructions of @xcite and @xcite to form the following : [ degreeboundsconj ] let @xmath1 be a smooth curve embedded by a line bundle @xmath139 . if @xmath198 then @xmath199 is defined as a scheme by forms of degree @xmath105 . if @xmath200 then @xmath199 satisfies condition @xmath201 .
suppose that @xmath1 satisfies @xmath58 , is smooth , and contains no lines and no plane quadrics .
suppose further that @xmath0 is scheme theoretically defined by cubics @xmath202 , and that @xmath0 satisfies @xmath165 .
under these hypotheses , we construct a second flip as follows : we know that @xmath102 is globally generated by the discussion above ; hence this induces a morphism @xmath100 which agrees with the map given by the cubics @xmath203 on the locus where @xmath81 and @xmath70 are isomorphic . by theorem
[ embed ] , @xmath204 is a birational morphism .
we wish first to identify the exceptional locus of @xmath204 .
it is clear that @xmath204 will collapse the image of a @xmath101-secant @xmath39-plane to a point , hence the exceptional locus must contain the transform of @xmath38 .
however by theorem [ embed ] , we know that the rational map @xmath205 is an embedding off @xmath206 , the trisecant variety to the secant variety .
this motivates the following [ secantsareequal ] let @xmath48 be an irreducible variety .
assume either of the following : 1 .
@xmath36 is defined as a scheme by forms of degree @xmath207 .
2 . @xmath1 is a smooth curve embedded by a line bundle of degree at least @xmath208 .
then @xmath209 as schemes
. first , choose a @xmath210-secant @xmath12-plane @xmath143 .
@xmath143 then intersects @xmath199 in a hypersurface of degree @xmath105 , hence every line in @xmath143 lies in @xmath211 . as @xmath212 is reduced and irreducible , @xmath213 as schemes . for the converse , assume the first condition is satisfied
choose a line @xmath139 that intersects @xmath199 in a scheme of length at least @xmath105 .
it is easy to verify that @xmath36 is singular along @xmath199 , hence every form that vanishes on @xmath36 must vanish @xmath214 times on @xmath139 . by hypothesis , however , @xmath36 is scheme theoretically defined by forms of degree @xmath207 , hence each of these forms must vanish on @xmath139 .
the sufficiency of the second condition follows from thaddeus construction and ( * ? ? ?
* , ( i ) ) .
this implies that if @xmath36 satisfies @xmath181 and if @xmath209 , then the map @xmath215 given by the forms defining @xmath36 is an embedding off of @xmath216 .
we use theorem [ embed ] to understand the structure of these maps via the following two lemmas : [ nolines ] if the embedding of a projective variety @xmath168 is @xmath217-very ample , then the intersection of two @xmath196-secant @xmath210-planes , if nonempty , must lie in @xmath36 ( in fact , it must be an @xmath218 secant @xmath219 for some @xmath220 ) .
in particular , @xmath216 has dimension @xmath221 .
the first statement is elementary : assume two @xmath196-secant @xmath210-planes intersect at a single point .
if the point is not on @xmath1 , then there are @xmath222 points of @xmath1 that span a @xmath223-plane , which is impossible by hypothesis .
hence the intersection lies in @xmath17 . a simple repetition of this argument for larger dimensional intersections gives the desired result .
the statement of the dimension follows immediately ; or see @xcite . [ possiblepreimages ]
let @xmath62 be an irreducible variety whose embedding is @xmath217-very ample .
assume that @xmath36 satisfies @xmath181 , and that @xmath224 as schemes .
let @xmath225 be the closure of the graph of @xmath226 with projection @xmath227 .
if @xmath228 is a point in the closure of the image of @xmath226 and @xmath229 is the fiber over @xmath228 then @xmath230 is one of the following : 1 . a reduced point in @xmath231 2 . a @xmath196-secant @xmath210-plane 3 . * contained * in a linear subspace of @xmath36 the first and third possibilities follow directly from theorem [ embed ]
for the second , note that a priori @xmath230 could be any linear space intersecting @xmath36 in a hypersurface of degree @xmath180 .
however , lemma [ nolines ] and the hypothesis that @xmath224 immediately imply that any such linear space must be @xmath105 dimensional ; hence a @xmath196-secant @xmath210-plane . with these results in hand we present the general construction .
let @xmath232 be an irreducible projective variety and suppose @xmath233 , is a collection of dominant , birational maps . define the * dominating variety * of the collection , denoted @xmath234 , to be the closure of the graph of @xmath235 denote by @xmath236 the projection of @xmath234 to @xmath237 .
note that @xmath236 is birationally isomorphic to @xmath238 for all @xmath239 .
note further that if the @xmath240 are all morphisms then @xmath241 , in other words only rational maps contribute to the structure of the dominating variety .
definition / notationk2l we say @xmath62 satisfies condition @xmath242 if @xmath243 satisfies condition @xmath244 for @xmath245 ; hence @xmath1 satisfies @xmath246 if and only if @xmath1 satisfies @xmath58 , @xmath1 satisfies @xmath247 if and only if @xmath1 satisfies @xmath58 and @xmath0 satisfies @xmath165 , etc
. @xmath71 if @xmath62 satisfies condition @xmath242 , then each rational map @xmath248 is birational onto its image for @xmath249 , and assuming the conclusion of lemma [ secantsareequal ] each @xmath250 is an embedding off @xmath243 .
therefore @xmath251 is the closure of the image of @xmath250 , @xmath252 is the closure of the graph of @xmath250 , and in the notation of theorem [ flip ] @xmath253 and @xmath254 .
note @xmath255 .
[ allblowups ] @xmath256 is the blow up of @xmath257 along the proper transform of @xmath258 , @xmath249 .
this is immediate from the definition ( or see @xcite ) .
remarkbert - thadspaces the spaces constructed in @xcite are of the type @xmath259 .
the spaces @xmath260 and @xmath115 constructed in @xcite are @xmath261 and @xmath262 .
@xmath71 our goal is to understand explicitly the geometry of this web of varieties generalizing theorem [ flip ] . in the next section
we describe in detail the structure of the second flip . as each subsequent flip
requires the understanding of @xmath263 for larger @xmath12 , it is not clear that the process will continue nicely beyond the second flip ( at least for varieties of arbitrary dimension ) .
let @xmath62 be a smooth , irreducible variety that satisfies @xmath247 .
the diagram of varieties we study in this section is : where @xmath264 is the dominating variety of the pair of birational maps @xmath265 and @xmath266 ; and where we have yet to construct the two rightmost varieties .
we write @xmath267 and @xmath268 ( recall all three spaces are smooth by theorem [ flip ] ) . [ wtv2 ] let @xmath269 be a smooth , irreducible variety of dimension @xmath270 that satisfies @xmath247 .
assume that @xmath1 is embedded by a complete linear system @xmath271 and that the following conditions are satisfied : 1 .
@xmath139 is @xmath272-very ample 2 . if @xmath160 , then for every point @xmath192 , @xmath273 3 .
@xmath274 as schemes 4 .
the projection of @xmath1 into @xmath275 , from any embedded tangent space is such that the image is projectively normal and satisfies @xmath58 as the proof of theorem [ wtv2 ] is somewhat involved , we break it into several pieces .
we begin with a lemma and a crucial observation , followed by the proof of the theorem .
the observation invokes a technical lemma whose proof is postponed until the end .
remark on the hypotheseseasilysatisfied note that if @xmath1 is a smooth curve embedded by a line bundle of degree at least @xmath113 , then conditions @xmath278 are automatically satisfied .
conjecture [ degreeboundsconj ] would imply condition @xmath247 holds also .
furthermore , if @xmath279 and @xmath280 then condition @xmath281 implies condition @xmath39 . if @xmath160 , then the image of the projection from the space tangent to @xmath1 at @xmath140 is @xmath282
furthermore , by the discussion after remark [ 5secant3plane ] any such projection of @xmath1 will be generated as a scheme by quadrics when @xmath0 is defined by cubics , hence condition @xmath283 is not unreasonable .
[ projectionsarenotsobad ] with hypotheses as in theorem [ wtv2 ] , the image of the projection of @xmath1 into @xmath284 , @xmath285 , is @xmath191 , hence is smooth .
furthermore , it contains no lines and it contains no plane quadrics except for the exceptional divisor , which is the quadratic veronese embedding of @xmath286 . if @xmath287 the statement is clear .
otherwise , let @xmath288 denote the closure of the image of projection from the embedded tangent space to @xmath1 at @xmath140 . as mentioned above , @xmath289 ,
hence is smooth .
let @xmath290 denote the exceptional divisor .
the existence of a line or plane quadric not contained in @xmath291 is immediately seen to be impossible by the @xmath272-very ampleness hypothesis .
observationcrucialobs let @xmath295 be the projection and let @xmath296 be the fiber over @xmath192 ; hence @xmath296 is the blow up of @xmath284 along a copy of @xmath191 .
we again denote this variety by @xmath297 , and the embedding of @xmath298 into @xmath284 satisfies @xmath58 by hypothesis .
the restriction of @xmath299 to @xmath296 can thus be identified with @xmath300 , and , noting lemma [ projectionsarenotsobad ] , it seems that theorem [ embed ] could be applied .
unfortunately , it is not clear that this restriction should be surjective on global sections . however , by lemma [ nearsurjrest ] below , the image of the morphism on @xmath296 induced by the restriction of global sections is isomorphic to the image of the morphism given by the complete linear system @xmath301 .
hence by the fourth hypothesis and lemma [ projectionsarenotsobad ] , the only collapsing that occurs in @xmath296 under the morphism @xmath302 is that of secant lines to @xmath288 .
now , for some @xmath192 , suppose that a secant line @xmath172 in @xmath296 is collapsed to a point by the projection @xmath302 .
then @xmath172 is the proper transform of a secant line to @xmath303 , but every such secant line is the intersection of @xmath296 with a @xmath101-secant @xmath104 through @xmath192 .
for example , if @xmath304 is the secant line through @xmath305 , @xmath306 , then @xmath172 is the intersection of @xmath296 with the proper transform of the plane spanned by @xmath307 .
it should be noted that the two dimensional fiber associated to the collapsing of a plane spanned by a quadric in the exceptional divisor ( lemma [ projectionsarenotsobad ] ) will take the place of a @xmath101-secant @xmath104 spanned by a non - curvilinear scheme contained in the tangent space at @xmath140 .
( of theorem [ wtv2 ] ) let @xmath308 be a point in the image of @xmath204 .
the fiber over @xmath228 is mapped isomorphically into @xmath309 by the projection @xmath310 .
we are therefore able to study @xmath311 by looking at the fiber of the projection @xmath302 , and projecting to @xmath312 and to @xmath309 . by applying lemma [ possiblepreimages ] to the map @xmath313 , the projection to @xmath312
is contained as a scheme in the _ total _ transform of one of the following ( note the more refined division of possibilities ) : 1 . a point in @xmath314 2 .
a @xmath101-secant @xmath39-plane to @xmath1 not contained in @xmath0 3 .
a linear subspace of @xmath0 not tangent to @xmath1 4 . a linear subspace of @xmath0 tangent to @xmath1
if the projection is a @xmath101-secant @xmath39-plane , then by observation [ crucialobs ] the projection to @xmath312 is a @xmath101-secant @xmath39-plane blown up at the three points of intersection , and so the image in @xmath309 is a @xmath104 that has undergone a cremona transformation . in the third case
, observation [ crucialobs ] shows that either the projection to @xmath312 is the _ proper _ transform of a secant line to @xmath1 , or that the projection to @xmath315 is a linear subspace of @xmath0 that is not a secant line . in the first case ,
every such space is collapsed to a point by @xmath86 .
the second implies @xmath204 has a fiber of dimension @xmath8 that is contained in @xmath316 .
because @xmath317 is a @xmath77-bundle , this implies the projection of the fiber to @xmath315 is contained in a linear subspace @xmath143 of @xmath0 of dimension @xmath318 .
furthermore , the proper transform of @xmath143 is collapsed to a @xmath8 dimensional subspace of @xmath309 , in particular the general point of @xmath143 lies on a secant line _ contained in @xmath143 _ by theorem [ getabundle ] .
therefore @xmath319 has @xmath320 , hence @xmath321 but this is impossible by lemma [ nolines ] and the restriction that @xmath143 not be tangent to @xmath1 . in the final case , the proper transform in @xmath312 of a linear space @xmath322 tangent to @xmath1 at a point @xmath140 is @xmath323 .
denote the exceptional @xmath324 by @xmath154 ; lemma [ projectionsarenotsobad ] implies @xmath325 is the quadratic veronese embedding of @xmath326 .
a simple dimension count shows that the restriction to @xmath154 of the projective bundle @xmath327 arising from the blow up of @xmath312 along @xmath79 is precisely the restriction to @xmath154 of the projective bundle arising from the _ induced _ blow up of @xmath328 along @xmath191 ; denote this variety @xmath329 .
furthermore , the transform of @xmath323 in @xmath264 is a @xmath77-bundle over @xmath330 .
now by lemma [ nearsurjrest ] , every fiber of @xmath204 contained in @xmath330 is either a point or is isomorphic to a @xmath104 spanned by a plane quadric in @xmath154 .
remarkaltprooffork=2 for curves , parts @xmath101 and @xmath283 of the proof can also be concluded by showing that any line contained in @xmath0 must be a secant or tangent line ( this is immediate from the @xmath331-very ample hypothesis ) .
[ killideal ] let @xmath332 be a flat morphism of smooth projective varieties .
let @xmath333 be a smooth fiber and let @xmath139 be a locally free sheaf on @xmath1 . if @xmath334 and @xmath335 for all @xmath336 , then @xmath337 for all @xmath336 .
the hypotheses easily give the vanishing @xmath337 for all @xmath338 . for @xmath339 ,
take the exact sequence on @xmath148 @xmath340 because @xmath341 is supported at the point @xmath140 , it suffices to check that @xmath342 .
@xmath93 flat implies @xmath343 , hence @xmath344 is trivial .
now , @xmath345 implies @xmath346 .
[ nearsurjrest ] under the hypotheses of theorem [ wtv2 ] , the image of @xmath296 under the projection @xmath302 is isomorphic to the image of @xmath296 under the morphism induced by the complete linear system associated to @xmath347 .
* step 1 : * _ if @xmath348 are mapped to the same point under the projection to @xmath349 , then @xmath228 and @xmath350 map to the same point under the projection to @xmath351 .
_ this is clear from the construction of the maps in question as the projections @xmath352 and @xmath353 respectively .
* step 2 : * _ re - embed @xmath354 via the map associated to @xmath355 .
_ this gives a map @xmath356 induced by a subspace of @xmath357 where @xmath358 .
as @xmath354 is an embedding , the induced maps on @xmath296 have isomorphic images for all @xmath178 .
we have , therefore , only to show @xmath359 surjects onto @xmath360 for some @xmath12 .
* step 3 : * _ the map @xmath361 is surjective for all @xmath362 .
_ this follows directly from the fact that @xmath0 is scheme theoretically defined by cubics and the construction of @xmath363 as @xmath364 .
we show @xmath366 .
let @xmath367 be the projection .
by the projective normality assumption of theorem [ wtv2 ] , @xmath368 for all @xmath369 since @xmath370 is flat .
ampleness of @xmath371 implies @xmath372 for all @xmath373 , where @xmath374 may depend on @xmath13 . from the exact sequence @xmath375 a finite
induction shows that if @xmath376 for @xmath377 , some @xmath378 then @xmath366 for all @xmath362 . as @xmath379
, we have @xmath380 as soon as @xmath381 , the right side is @xmath382-nef and , because @xmath382 is birational , the restriction of the right side to the general fiber of @xmath382 is big .
hence by @xcite , @xmath383 for @xmath384 .
again by the ampleness of @xmath371 , we have @xmath376 for @xmath377 , @xmath13 as above . as in theorem [ getabundle ] , we show that the restriction of @xmath204 to the transform of @xmath38 is a projective bundle over @xmath386 . by a slight abuse of notation ,
write @xmath387 for the image of the proper transform of @xmath38 .
note the following : a point @xmath395 determines a unique @xmath39-plane @xmath396 in @xmath397 by theorem [ wtv2 ] .
for every such @xmath140 , the homomorphism @xmath398 has rank @xmath101 , hence gives a point in @xmath399 .
the image of the associated morphism clearly coincides with the natural embedding of @xmath386 into @xmath399 described in @xcite . as in @xcite , there is a morphism @xmath400 so that the composition factors @xmath401 .
this is constructed by associating to every @xmath389 the rank @xmath281 homomorphism : @xmath402 where @xmath396 is the @xmath104 in @xmath403 associated to @xmath141 .
we wish to show further that blowing up @xmath38 along @xmath1 and then along @xmath0 resolves the singularities of @xmath38 . by theorem [ flip ]
, @xmath407 is the blow up of @xmath403 along @xmath92 , hence it suffices to show @xmath408 is a smooth subvariety of @xmath409 .
let @xmath414 denote the universal subscheme .
we have morphisms @xmath415 and @xmath416 , and it is routine to check that @xmath417
. hence ( cf .
@xcite ) @xmath418 maps @xmath419 to the nested hilbert scheme @xmath411 , where closed points of @xmath420 correspond to pairs of subschemes @xmath421 with @xmath422 . furthermore , via the description of the structure of the map @xmath204 , it is clear that the morphism of @xmath386-schemes @xmath423 is finite and birational .
it is shown in @xcite that @xmath420 is smooth , hence this is an isomorphism .
let @xmath424 be the blow up of @xmath403 along @xmath409 ; note @xmath424 is smooth . to construct @xmath425
, we first construct the exceptional locus as a projective bundle over @xmath386 .
write @xmath426 .
it is important to note that @xmath438 for all @xmath439 as the direct image on the right will differ from @xmath440 by a line bundle .
hence for all @xmath439 the same morphism @xmath436 is induced by the surjection @xmath441
@xcite[free ] let @xmath21 be an invertible sheaf on a complete variety @xmath1 , and let @xmath442 be any locally free sheaf .
assume that the map @xmath443 induced by @xmath444 is a birational morphism and that @xmath445 is an isomorphism in a neighborhood of @xmath192 .
then for all @xmath120 sufficiently large , the map @xmath446 is surjective .
taking @xmath447 and @xmath448 , the map induced by the linear system associated to @xmath449 is base point free off @xmath450 for @xmath451 . to show this gives a morphism ,
one shows the restriction of above linear system to the divisor @xmath450 induces a surjection on global sections , hence restricts to the map @xmath452 above . for this , define @xmath453 and write @xmath454 where @xmath455 and @xmath456 . by the above discussion , @xmath457 is nef for @xmath362 and it is routine to verify that @xmath458 is a big and nef @xmath459-divisor ; hence @xmath460 .
[ topofflip2 ] with hypotheses as in theorem [ wtv2 ] and for @xmath12 sufficiently large , the morphism @xmath461 induced by the linear system @xmath462 is an embedding off of @xmath450 and the restriction of @xmath463 to @xmath450 is the morphism @xmath436 described above . because @xmath425 is the image of a smooth variety with reduced , connected fibers it is normal ( cf .
let @xmath466 be a fiber of @xmath463 over a point @xmath467 .
@xmath468 is a fiber of a @xmath433 bundle over @xmath386 , hence the normal bundle sequence becomes : @xmath469 this sequence splits , and allowing the elementary calculations @xmath470 and @xmath471 for all @xmath472 , @xmath425 is smooth by a natural extension of the smoothness portion of castelnuovo s contractibility criterion for surfaces given in @xcite .
[ flip2 ] let @xmath269 be a smooth , irreducible variety of dimension @xmath270 that satisfies @xmath247 , with @xmath475 .
assume that @xmath1 is embedded by a complete linear system @xmath271 and that the following conditions are satisfied : 1 .
@xmath139 is @xmath272-very ample and @xmath274 as schemes 2 .
the projection of @xmath1 into @xmath275 , from any embedded tangent space is such that the image is projectively normal and satisfies @xmath58 3 . if @xmath160 , then for every point @xmath192 , @xmath273 1 . @xmath476 and @xmath477 smooth 2 .
@xmath478 ; as @xmath475 , @xmath479 3 .
@xmath480 and @xmath481 4 .
@xmath482 is the blow up of @xmath476 along @xmath483 5 .
@xmath484 is the blow up along @xmath485 6 .
@xmath486 , induced by @xmath487 , is an embedding off of @xmath483 , and the restriction of @xmath486 is the projection @xmath488 7 .
@xmath489 , induced by @xmath490 , is an embedding off of @xmath491 , and the restriction of @xmath489 is the projection @xmath492 8 .
@xmath493 is isomorphic to the nested hilbert scheme @xmath494 , hence is smooth .
m andreatta and j a winiewski , a view on contractions of higher - dimensional varieties , in _ algebraic geometry - santa cruz 1995 _ , proc .
pure math .
, 62 , part 1 , amer
soc . , providence , ri 1997 , pp .
153 - 183 .
t jzefiak , p pragacz , and j weyman , resolutions of determinantal varieties and tensor complexes associated with symmetric and antisymmetric matrices , in _ tableaux de young et foncteurs de schur en algbre et gomtrie _ , astrisque 87 - 88 , socit mathmatique de france , 1981 , pp .
109 - 189 . | we show how to use information about the equations defining secant varieties to smooth projective varieties in order to construct a natural collection of birational transformations .
these were first constructed as flips in the case of curves by m. thaddeus via geometric invariant theory , and the first flip in the sequence was constructed by the author for varieties of arbitrary dimension in an earlier paper .
we expose the finer structure of a second flip ; again for varieties of arbitrary dimension .
we also prove a result on the cubic generation of the secant variety and give some conjectures on the behavior of equations defining the higher secant varieties . |
in plasma physics , turbulence is an underlying problem for numerous topics of research , ranging from the study of anomalous transport across magnetic surfaces in fusion relevant plasmas to the problem of plasma heating in astrophysical conditions .
one of the most identifiable characteristics of turbulence is the self - organization of turbulent structures .
mathematically , following a fourier decomposition , the nonlinear interactions between various scales of the system can be discerned ( here length scales being defined simply as @xmath0 ) and the self - organization of turbulence can be described in term of energy transfers and scale fluxes@xcite . while this methodology is primarily used in the case of homogenous isotropic turbulence , large scale motions like the zonal flows are captured by particular modes of the system . as these modes can lead to the development of an anisotropy that can affect the energy transfers and the scale fluxes ,
expanding the definitions of various nonlinear based diagnostics becomes necessary for a better understanding of the underlying dynamics of the turbulent system and the subsequent development of models .
micro - turbulence in gradient driven magnetized plasmas represents one of the best examples where large structures in turbulence self - organize to give rise to zonal flows@xcite that in turn dominate the self - organization of smaller scales . since the turbulent structures in plasma reach scales much smaller than that of the ion gyroradius in the presence of a strong magnetic guide field , using the five - dimensional gyrokinetic ( gk ) formalism ( for which , due to the gyrokinetic ordering , the gyration phase of charged particles around the magnetic guide field has been removed consistently@xcite ) represents the most efficient method for the description of the problem@xcite .
this approach@xcite is of particular interest in sheared toroidal magnetic geometries characteristic of tokamaks .
as turbulent structures tend to elongate along magnetic field lines , the natural coordinate system for the problem , namely field - aligned coordinates@xcite @xmath1 , becomes nonorthogonal .
any modal decomposition along nonorthogonal directions show complicated couplings of primary instabilities ( responsible for the source of free energy ; the quantity of interest for the nonlinear redistribution@xcite in gk turbulence ) and secondary instabilities ( responsible for the self - organization of structures ) . to simplify the analysis of the interplay between primary and zonal - flow modes and the subsequent impact on the turbulent energy redistribution
, we turn towards a simpler yet non - trivial problem , that of the z - pinch@xcite . in a z - pinch configuration ,
described using a simple cylindrical coordinate system ( @xmath2 ) , a cylindrically symmetric equilibrium magnetic guide field is given as , @xmath3 .
unlike the complicated tokamak geometry ( even local equilibrium models@xcite have a non - diagonal metric tensor ) , for such a simple closed field line system a fourier mode can only contribute energy to one scale , drastically simplifying the energy redistribution analysis .
the primary instability driving gk turbulence in this system is the small scale entropy - mode@xcite .
it manifests itself by the development of streamer like structures in the radial direction .
as secondary instabilities are excited , zonal flows develop in the @xmath4-direction .
depending on the parameters of the system , zonal flows will dominate the self - organization of turbulence@xcite , leading to a predator - prey type oscillation@xcite between streamer and zonal flows like structures .
form this interplay , coherent vortices can emerge , as seen in other plasma configurations@xcite . while the study of z - pinch plasmas represents an area of interest on its own , we limit our analysis to the impact made by zonal flow structures on the redistribution of energy between scales and the subsequent wavenumber anisotropy developed .
as such , we introduce a series of nonlinear diagnostics that can describe the wavenumber anisotropy from the perspective of free energy fluxes .
this represents the focus of the current work , for which the z - pinch configuration is used as a simple framework for these ideas to be put forward . in the final section
, we will discuss an extension of these diagnostics and their applicability to tokamak geometries .
numerically , we make use of the eulerian code gene@xcite , which can solve the nonlinear gyrokinetic equations in both global@xcite and local@xcite ( flux - tube ) geometries . here , the standard field - aligned coordinates @xmath1 are employed for a local flux - surface approximation of the z - pinch geometry ( @xmath2 ) . in this approximation , a small periodic domain , mapped by the radial coordinate @xmath5 ,
is centered around a specific flux - surface identified by @xmath6 .
as the equilibrium magnetic field lines are hard - coded along the third direction ( @xmath7 ) , the @xmath8 coordinate represents the mapping of @xmath9 .
the macroscopic normalization length , used throughout our work to normalize gradient lengths and curvature terms for example , is set to @xmath10 . with this in mind , performing a z - pinch geometry run in gene requires no special alteration to the code .
it is only necessary to provide the appropriately normalized cylindrical metric coefficients ( @xmath11 , @xmath12 ) , the resulting jacobian ( @xmath13 ) and the magnetic radial gradient @xmath14 ( using ref . [ ] notations for the magnetic curvature coefficients ; listing only the nonzero contribution ) .
the velocity space coordinates @xmath15 are , respectively , the velocity parallel to the magnetic field and the magnetic moment ( containing the perpendicular velocity information ) .
the system is near a state of equilibrium , prescribed for the species @xmath16 by an appropriately normalized maxwellian distribution , @xmath17 .
we use a kinetic description for both ion and electron species , with the mass ratio @xmath18 and equal background temperature ( @xmath19 ) and density ( @xmath20 ; quasi - neutrality ) .
the coordinates perpendicular to the magnetic field are fourier transformed @xmath21 and the gk system is solved numerically using respectively @xmath22=@xmath23 modes / points in each direction . in the perpendicular directions , the smallest wavenumbers considered are @xmath24 . due to the reality condition ,
only positive @xmath25 modes are solved , the largest wavenumbers considered being equal ( @xmath26 ) .
the wavenumbers are taken in units of the ion gyroradius ( @xmath27 ) , the real space domain spanning @xmath28 units , where @xmath29 is the ion thermal velocity , @xmath30 is the ion cyclotron frequency and @xmath31 is the electric charge sign for an ion species ( @xmath32 in units of @xmath33 ) .
the same definitions are employed for the electron species , for which naturally , @xmath34 .
since we limit our analysis to plasmas for which the magnetic pressure is dominant over the thermal pressure ( @xmath35 ) , we neglect additional magnetic fluctuations and consider solely electrostatic field fluctuations . for this case , from the perturbed gyro - center distribution functions @xmath36 we extract the non - adiabatic part as @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the gyro - averaged self - consistent electrostatic field contribution . the gyro - averaged electrostatic potential ( @xmath38 ) is obtained in the fourier representations simply as the bessel function ( @xmath39 ) screened self - consistent electrostatic potential ( @xmath40 ) , i.e. @xmath41 , with @xmath42 . neglecting debye length corrections , @xmath40 is found as , @xmath43 } } \sum_{s } n_{0s } q_s\int \!\!j_0(\lambda_s ) f_s { d}v_{\parallel } { d}\mu \;,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath44 , @xmath45 the modified bessel function and @xmath46 . the normalized gk equation for each species s is given as , @xmath47 f_{0s }
ik_y\phi \nonumber\\ & -\frac{v_{ts}}{\sqrt{g}b_0}v_\parallel \frac{\partial h_s}{\partial z } -\frac{t_{0s}(2v_\parallel^2+\mu
b_0)}{q_s b_0 } k_y ik_y h_s \nonumber\\ & + { \cal n}_s+{\cal h}_s+{\cal c}_s \;.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath48 and @xmath49 are , respectively , the normalized density and temperature gradients . omitting the directions of no immediate interest
, @xmath50 is the @xmath51 drift velocity nonlinearity and has the form , @xmath52\ , \phi(\kk'_\perp)h_s(\kk_\perp-\kk'_\perp ) \label{eq_nl}\;. \end{aligned}\ ] ] numerically it is de - aliased using a three - halves rule .
in addition , @xmath53 refers to hyperdiffusion terms in the @xmath54 and @xmath55 directions given by , @xmath56 these hyperdiffusion terms are necessary to stabilize spurious grid - size oscillations @xcite .
for all the cases , the coefficients are set to @xmath57 and @xmath58 , since these values have been found to be well suited for a wide range of cases .
the @xmath59 term is a linearized landau- boltzmann collision operator with energy and momentum conserving terms @xcite , where an electron - ion collision frequency @xcite of value @xmath60 is used in this work . finally , to remove any unphysical accumulation of energy at high wavenumbers , a large - eddy - simulation ( les ) model is used ; see ref .
[ ] and references within for details regarding using les models in gk plasmas .
as it is mentioned in ref [ ] , the collisional and hyperdiffusion terms can affect the growth rate of the modes .
however , since this work concentrates on the study of the anisotropic redistribution of free energy , a high @xmath61 energy accumulation is deemed more problematic than a shift in growth rates . as numerically @xmath62
is taken to be zero , the pressure gradient is neglected and the ideal mhd interchange mode does not enter into our system .
this is equivalent to the ideally stable parameter regime in which the free energy injected in the system is due only to the entropy - mode instability@xcite . in fig .
[ fig_benchmark ] , as this is the first time gene has been used for a z - pinch geometry , the linear growth rates for the entropy mode in the collisionless case are benchmarked against the gs2 values that are listed by ref . [ ] in figs . 2 and 6a , therein .
throughout this work we take @xmath63 and consider two values for @xmath64 .
the @xmath65 case has been used and reported on in other works@xcite in the literature .
the analysis of the nonlinear energy redistribution between perpendicular spatial scales , presented here , is based solely on the computation of @xmath66 , defined as @xmath67 from the perspective of the underlying triadic interactions , @xmath66 can be interpreted as the energy received by a mode @xmath68 from the interaction with all other modes .
seeing @xmath66 as the total energy received rather than the total energy given is just an arbitrary choice that does not change the results as long as this interpretation is used consistently ; here a mode receives energy if @xmath69 and gives energy if @xmath70 .
unlike previous works@xcite , which use a shell decomposition for the nonlinear energy transfers that requires multiple computations of the nonlinear terms ( of the order of the number of shells , or even its square ) , an analysis based solely on @xmath71 terms requires only one computation of the nonlinear term . while using this approach prohibits the computation of shell - to - shell energy transfers@xcite or obtaining information related to the locality of interactions@xcite , it is still possible to obtain data related to the transfer spectra and the energy fluxes , as we will see next .
the conservation of energy by the nonlinear interactions implies that @xmath72 where the second integral limit is taken from @xmath73 rather than @xmath74 due to the reality condition for the dynamical quantities , which translates to @xmath75 .
the free energy is independently conserved by the @xmath51 nonlinear term for each species .
however , it would be improper to think of the nonlinear interactions that contribute to these two individual energy channels as being separate . as the gyro - averaged electrostatic potential enters the nonlinearities from the @xmath51 drift velocity , it acts as a mediator for the energy exchanges .
seeing the electrostatic potential as the sum of moments of the distribution functions , leads to the interpretation that each species mediates the energy exchanges of all other species , or equivalently that each energy transfer for a species is mediated by all the other species . rewriting the condition given by eq .
( [ sumtxy_zero ] ) in term of a polar decomposition , @xmath76 , allows for a more transparent interpretation in terms of scales ( @xmath77 ) , @xmath78 where again we use the fact that the reality condition implies @xmath79 .
the transfer spectra @xmath80 is then simply defined as @xmath81 since the integral of @xmath82 across all @xmath61 s is zero , splitting this integral in regard to a cutoff wavenumber @xmath83 , @xmath84 leads to two terms of equal value and opposite sign .
this forms the basis for the definition of the energy flux across a scale @xmath83 , @xmath85}\;. \label{def_flux}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this definition takes into account that @xmath82 stands in for the net energy received by a scale @xmath61 and leads to a positive value flux for a flow of energy from large to small scales ( direct cascade ) .
consequently , a negative value for the flux denotes an inverse cascade of energy across scales . in a similar fashion
, we can define an angular flux that measures how much energy is flowing across a direction that cuts across all @xmath61 s , identified by an angle @xmath86 .
considering that the quantity @xmath87 is invariant under a @xmath88 rotation , @xmath89 , the integral of @xmath90 over any @xmath88 interval is zero .
shifting the integration limits by @xmath91 around the direction of interest and splitting the integral with respect to @xmath86 leads to two terms of equal value and opposite sign , @xmath92 doing so ensures that the two terms sweep over the same number of modes regardless of the @xmath86 choice , simplifying the interpretation . the angular flux @xmath93 , taken as positive if it occurs in a trigonometric direction , is now defined as , @xmath94}\;. \label{def_angflux}\end{aligned}\ ] ] an ideally isotropic system will have a zero angular flux across all directions .
it should be noted that the angular flux can be defined to be positive if energy is being moved towards a given direction ( towards the @xmath25 direction for instance ) . while simpler conceptually , the definition given here leads a transfer of energy from the @xmath95-axis towards the @xmath25-axis to generate a positive flux in the @xmath96 $ ] interval and a negative value one in the @xmath97 $ ] interval .
we introduce another quantity that can help characterize the anisotropic redistribution of free energy .
the angular density of the free energy scale flux can be defined as , @xmath98 from the start it is evident that the scale flux is recovered by integrating over @xmath99 , @xmath100 highlighting the role of @xmath101 as an angular density of the free energy scale flux . however , while the three definitions of the scale flux given by eq .
( [ def_flux ] ) are equivalent , the resulting angular densities are not .
the choice adopted here , is dictated by practical concerns .
numerically , we obtain @xmath102 from an angular decomposition of @xmath66 , using here angular sections spawning @xmath103 arcs each . as small @xmath61 angular sections
can fail to capture any modes from the rectangular grid , it is preferred to use the given definition ( computed numerically in the interval @xmath104 $ ] ) , which is not as sensitive to the angular distribution of small @xmath61 modes .
while the results obtained from the definition adopted here are smoother in appearance , the visual representation of the anisotropy is the same regardless of the definition adopted .
we stress that the angular density of the scale flux is still a quantity related to the transfer of energy across scales and it should not be interpreted as a measure of the movement of energy from one direction to another ( which is the angular flux given by eq .
[ def_angflux ] ) .
we report on the steady state regimes for the @xmath65 and @xmath105 cases ; the gradient levels for both ion and electron species are equal . in both cases ,
zonal flows develop that shear the radially ( @xmath5 ) elongated structures ( streamers ) . the steady state for @xmath65 is characterized by elongated structures in the @xmath106direction for the gyro - averaged electrostatic potential , fig .
[ fig_phi ] .
this case represents a textbook example of what we come to associate with zonal flows .
however , the steady state for the @xmath105 case presents a series of peculiarities .
a recent work@xcite talks about the predator - prey behavior of zonal flows ( predator ) and turbulent streamers ( prey ) .
the case @xmath105 exhibits such a behavior during its transient state , consisting of streamer like structures being broken by zonal flows only to reform again .
this interplay during the transient state corresponds in fig .
[ fig_free - energy]-(a ) to the large oscillations seen in the time evolution of the free energy ( @xmath107 ) . as
this behavior subsides , coherent vorticies@xcite emerge as the dominant structures during the steady state regime , as seen in fig .
[ fig_phi ] . for @xmath105 ,
a lot of the energy is contained at seemingly frozen large scales
. however , smaller scales are energetically active , as seen from the free energy spectra , fig .
[ fig_free - energy]-(c ) . for both cases , due to the nonlocal influence of the zonal flows
, the free energy spectra seems to follow a @xmath108 law , consistent with the prediction made by ref .
[ ] ( note that their estimates are made for the electrostatic fluctuation spectra , using a pad approximation for the finite larmor radius contributions ) that calls for a steeper energy spectra slope than the @xmath109 power law@xcite .
central to this work , for the steady state regimes , we present the free energy scale flux ( eq . [ def2_f ] ) and its respective angular density ( eq . [ def2_fa ] ) for each species . these quantities are presented for @xmath65 in fig . [ fig_fluxes_16 ] and for @xmath105 in fig .
[ fig_fluxes_40 ] .
looking at the maximal values , the ion scale flux is about twice as large as the electron flux ( @xmath110 ) for the @xmath65 case . at large scales ( @xmath111 ) , while the ion flux is slowly growing in value ( seemingly as @xmath112 ) , the electron flux exhibits an inverse cascade process ( negative valued flux ) . at smaller scales ( @xmath113 ) , the ion scale flux becomes scale independent , a fact associated with inertial range dynamics . for the @xmath105 case ,
[ fig_fluxes_40 ] , the maximal value of the ion scale flux is smaller than its electron counterpart ( @xmath114 ) . in this case
, it s the ion scale flux that exhibits an inverse cascade process at small wavenumbers ( @xmath111 ) . for small scales ( @xmath113 )
, the ion scale flux seems to achieve scale independence and is positive in value , even if this value is much smaller that the maximal negative one .
a more interesting behavior is exhibited by the electron scale flux , which in this case exhibits a @xmath115 scaling .
this yet unexplained scaling has been observed for other systems ( astrophysical and tokamak conditions ) and merits more future work to try to explain it .
while the scale flux represents a good way to determine the type of energy cascade ( direct or inverse ) and provides additional information regarding its saturation value and wavenumber dependence ( or lack thereof ) , by construction , it can not distinguish between contributions made by different directions .
for both cases and both species , looking at the angular density of the scale flux we clearly see the anisotropic wavenumber makeup . in the case of @xmath65
, while negative angular sections are present for the ion flux , the electron angular density clearly shows that both negative and positive angular sections coexist .
while the dominance of one aspect gives the overall direct or inverse characteristic to the scale flux , it should be clear that both energy redistribution mechanisms are present at the same time .
for the electrons we see that the positive fluxes ( from large to small scales ) are in the @xmath5-direction , while the negative fluxes ( traditionally associated with the reorganization of large scales in turbulence ) are along the @xmath8-direction .
this indicates the radial break up of large structures into smaller ones , while at the same time joining together to form even larger scales in the @xmath106direction ; a picture consistent with what we come to expect from turbulence in the presence of zonal flows . for the case
@xmath105 , the positive valued electron scale flux is clearly shown to be composed of negative angular sections , when looking at the angular density .
moreover , we see that both species exhibit dominant positive value fluxes in the @xmath116 directions .
we associate this behavior with the vortex dominated turbulent state .
as vortices are structures with comparable @xmath95 and @xmath25 wavenumbers , observing preferential @xmath116 directions in the energy redistribution is not surprising .
looking at the ions , we also notice that the contributions to the flux are close to zero along the @xmath25-axis , indicating the suppression of the energy cascade along this direction at larger @xmath61 .
while the angular density of the scale flux allows us to measure the anisotropy of the cascade of energy between large and small scales , it does not tell us how much energy is moved from one direction to the other .
this is important , as gauging the amount of energy transferred through a direction can help us understand the development of anisotropy .
we present the angular flux ( @xmath117 ) for the case @xmath65 in fig .
[ fig_aflux16 ] and for the case @xmath105 in fig .
[ fig_aflux40 ] .
normalizing the angular flux to the maximal value of the scale flux allows us to assess the strength of the angular energy redistribution .
while for an ideal isotropic case we expect to see zero angular flux , oscillations around zero are to be expected in practice , especially when long time averages are not possible . for @xmath65 , for both ion and electron angular fluxes , negative values can be see in the @xmath118 $ ] interval and positive values in the @xmath119 $ ] interval .
this is a sign of energy flowing from the @xmath25-axis towards the @xmath95-axis .
the @xmath120 $ ] interval just reproduces this behavior , due to the reality condition .
it is interesting to note that the ion angular flux is substantially reduced in value compared to its flux across k. also , as the ion angular flux curve is more flat across each interval compared to the electrons , we can infer a more constant angular flow of energy
. for @xmath105 , looking at the angular fluxes , we see that the energy flows in opposite directions for ion and electron species .
while for the ions the energy is flowing towards the @xmath95-axis , for the electrons the energy is flowing towards the @xmath25-axis .
as the angular flux is integrated over all possible scales , we can not say if the energy represents an exchange between streamer and zonal - flow modes or smaller scale structures .
in this paper we introduced a series of novel diagnostics related to the assessment of anisotropy of the nonlinear energy redistribution between scales for turbulent systems .
results are reported for a gyrokinetic plasma in a z - pinch magnetic geometry . from the angular density of the scale flux
we see that while scale fluxes indicative of direct energy cascades are observed for gk turbulent systems , they are highly anisotropic . not only do most positive contributions come from the @xmath121 direction ( @xmath95-axis ) , or solely from the @xmath122 one , but negative values denoting an inverse exchange of energy is found along the @xmath8 direction ( @xmath123 ) .
the z - pinch case reported here is a perfect example where the backscatter of energy in a direct cascade scenario is found to occupy a distinct wavenumber domain .
while the direct cascade is associated with the removal of energy at small scales , the backscatter of energy is associated with the self - organization of structures in turbulence .
a similar behavior is expected for the more complex sheared toroidal geometry case .
looking at the angular density plots for the two cases , we can infer another interesting result . while certain wavenumber domains show the backscatter of energy , this occurs for relatively small @xmath61 . at large @xmath61 , the angular density shows positive values for all angles @xmath99 .
this seems to indicate a certain universality of the small scales , which just move the free energy to ever smaller scales until they become thermalized .
larger direct numerical simulations are needed to properly validate this interpretation . however ,
this is consistent with what we expect form turbulence : complex self - organization of larger scales , interacting with universal small scales ; especially when zonal flows are present .
relating the @xmath99 angle arc for the domain that exhibits a backscatter of energy to the parameters characterizing the zonal flows is a desired goal for the future .
moreover , as the development of coherent structures ( vortices ) is related to intermittency in turbulence , we see that the angular density plots can capture these effects ( the @xmath116 enhanced contributions for the @xmath105 case ) .
one particular line of work that will benefit from this analysis consists in the further development of les models for gyrokinetics .
in essence , les models attempt to reproduce the correct scale flux value for a given @xmath61 , while neglecting the contributions made to this flux from interactions that involve small scales ( not present in the simulation ) .
while les methods are successful in removing energy accumulation at large wavenumbers , they fail when coupled solely with the largest scales that govern the transport levels in plasma .
the fact that les models depend on a constant , which even when dynamically computed is taken to be positive , can explain this failure .
as les methods were primarily developed to remove energy , they are not designed to take into account inverse cascades ( negative scale fluxes ) , for which a negative value constant is presumably needed . however , as seen by looking at the angular density of the scale flux , both positive and negative angular sections coexist for the same @xmath61 .
this implies that computing either a positive or negative constant for the les method will lead to one of the contributions to the flux to be faulty at very large scales .
the results presented in this work suggest the need for a constant that has a @xmath99 dependence for each @xmath61 . in general , regardless of the source of anisotropy , a similar @xmath124 object can be constructed for any quadratic nonlinearity , where the parallel and perpendicular wavenumbers are taken in reference to the anisotropic direction .
thus , all diagnostics built on the net energy transfer are general and valid for various turbulent problems . moreover , as the nonlinear diagnostics presented here are much cheeper from a numerical perspective , it is the hope of the authors that they will be used on a larger scale by the plasma community , helping to accumulate information related to the nonlinear energy exchanges for a wide variety of cases .
computing the energy transfers between various wavenumber shells and angular sections is technically possible ; this was done in the past for three - dimensional magnetohydrodynamic turbulence using a ring decomposition@xcite . however , in practice , the computational cost compared to the benefits of such an analysis makes this a prohibitive endeavor for gk turbulence . in a tokamak geometry , and even for simpler flux - tube simulations , due to the metric dependence on @xmath54 , a @xmath125 object needs to form the starting point for a similar analysis , to allow for the recovery of scale fluxes .
while this involves a larger memory requirement ( not a particularly stringent constraint ) , the computational costs remain the same . finally , an interesting result that is worth mentioning is the @xmath126 slope exhibited by the electron scale flux for steady state turbulence dominated by the electron cascade ( @xmath127 ) .
the same @xmath126 scaling for the electron scale flux was observed in slab simulations pertinent to astrophysical conditions , while an antenna driven ions species was found to have a scale independent flux .
this puzzling and interesting behavior will be analyzed in detail elsewhere and remains an open question .
we would like to thank daniel told ( ucla ) for discussions related to gyrokinetic plasma turbulence in astrophysical conditions .
we also acknowledge paul crandall ( ucla ) for his comments that led to a clearer presentation of the manuscript .
the gyrokinetic simulations presented in this work used resources of the national energy research scientific computing center , a doe office of science user facility supported by the office of science of the u.s .
department of energy under contract no .
de - ac02 - 05ch11231 .
26ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ]
+ 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty link:\doibase 10.1017/s0022112059000362 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0741 - 3335/47/5/r01 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0741 - 3335/57/4/045005 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.79.421 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1146/annurev - fluid-120710 - 101223 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0741 - 3335/52/12/124038 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.871232 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0741 - 3335/50/12/124024 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/0741 - 3335/53/9/093001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3096710 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.2205830 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.103.055003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3677355 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4920965 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.3356048 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.874014 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/j.jcp.2011.05.034 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) \doibase http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cpc.2010.04.010 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.48.239 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4868235 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.055001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.109.235003 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1063/1.4890127 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1017/s002211201000371x [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.79.046312 [ * * , ( ) ] | for a z - pinch geometry , we report on the nonlinear redistribution of free energy across scales perpendicular to the magnetic guide field , for a turbulent plasma described in the framework of gyrokinetics .
the analysis is performed using a local flux - surface approximation , in a regime dominated by electrostatic fluctuations driven by the entropy mode , with both ion and electron species being treated kinetically . to explore the anisotropic nature of the free energy redistribution caused by the emergence of zonal flows
, we use a polar coordinate representation for the field - perpendicular directions and define an angular density for the scale flux .
positive values for the classically defined ( angle integrated ) scale flux , which denote a direct energy cascade , are shown to be also composed of negative angular sections , a fact that impacts our understanding of the backscatter of energy and the way in which it enters the modeling of sub - grid scales for turbulence .
a definition for the flux of free energy across each perpendicular direction is introduced as well , which shows that the redistribution of energy in the presence of zonal flows is highly anisotropic . |
precise measurements of the lifetimes of charm meson weak decays are important for understanding qcd in both perturbative and nonperturbative regimes . for mesons a joint expansion in heavy quark effective theory and perturbative qcd parameters treated through
the third order in the heavy quark mass shows a term including non - spectator w - annihilation as well as pauli interference .
the resulting non - leptonic decay rate differences between w - exchange in @xmath9 and w - annihilation in @xmath8 produce lifetime differences of order 10 - 20 % @xcite .
the @xmath8 lifetime @xcite was dominated by the measurements from e687 collaboration ( 0.475 @xmath11 0.020 @xmath11 0.007 ps ) @xcite .
recently new precision measurements of the @xmath8 lifetime have been made by the e791 collaboration ( 0.518 @xmath11 0.014 @xmath11 0.007 ps ) @xcite and the cleo collaboration ( 486.3 @xmath11 15.0 @xmath12 fs ) @xcite .
both groups have taken advantage of improved precision in the @xmath13 lifetime measurement to report new results for the @xmath14 lifetime ratio of @xmath15 @xcite and @xmath16 @xcite .
their average is 7.4 @xmath17 from unity , emphasizing the large difference in w contributions to @xmath8 and @xmath9 decays . in this letter
we report the results of a new measurement of the @xmath8 lifetime based on data from the hadroproduction experiment selex ( e781 ) at fermilab .
the measurement is based on about 1000 fully reconstructed decays into @xmath18 from a sample of 15.3 @xmath19 hadronic triggers .
the selex detector at fermilab is a 3-stage magnetic spectrometer .
the negatively charged 600 gev/@xmath1 beam contains nearly equal fractions of @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
the positive beam contains 92% protons .
beam particles are identified by a transition radiation detector .
the spectrometer was designed to study charm production in the forward hemisphere with good mass and decay vertex resolution for charm momenta in the range 100 - 500 gev/@xmath1 .
five interaction targets ( 2 cu and 3 c ) had a total target thickess of 4.2% @xmath22 for protons .
the targets are spaced by 1.5 cm .
downstream of the targets are 20 silicon planes with a strip pitch of 20 - 25 @xmath23 m oriented in x , y , u and v views .
the scattered - particle spectrometers have momentum cutoffs of 2.5 gev/@xmath1 and 15 gev/@xmath1 respectively .
a ring - imaging cerenkov detector ( rich ) @xcite , filled with neon at room temperature and pressure , provides single track ring radius resolution of 1.4% and 2@xmath17 @xmath24 separation up to about 165 gev/@xmath1 .
a layout of the spectrometer can be found elsewhere @xcite .
the charm trigger is very loose .
it requires a valid beam track , at least 4 charged secondaries in the forward 150 mrad cone , and two hodoscope hits after the second bending magnet from tracks of charge opposite to that of the beam .
we triggered on about 1/3 of all inelastic interactions .
a computational filter linked pwc tracks having momenta @xmath25 gev/@xmath1 to hits in the vertex silicon and made a full reconstruction of primary and secondary vertices in the event .
events consistent with only a primary vertex are not saved .
about 1/8 of all triggers are written to tape , for a final sample of about @xmath26 events . in the full analysis
the vertex reconstruction was repeated with tracks of all momenta .
again , only events inconsistent with having a single primary vertex were considered .
the rich detector identified charged tracks above 25 gev/@xmath1 .
results reported here come from a preliminary reconstruction through the data , using a production code optimized for speed , not ultimate efficiency .
the simulated reconstruction efficiency of any charmed state is constant at about 40% for @xmath27 where @xmath28 of selex events lie . to separate the signal from the noncharm background
we require that : ( i ) the spatial separation @xmath29 between the reconstructed production and decay vertices exceeds 8 times the combined error @xmath30 , ( ii ) each decay track , extrapolated to the primary vertex @xmath31 position , must miss by a transverse distance length @xmath32 2.5 times its error @xmath33 , ( iii ) the secondary vertex must lie outside any target by at least 0.05 cm and ( iv ) decays must occur within a fiducial region .
there are @xmath34 events @xmath35 candidates , each having two rich - identified kaons and a pion , for which no particle identification is required .
we divide them into three decay channels : @xmath6 , @xmath7 and other kk@xmath21 .
the resonant mass window for the @xmath36 ( @xmath37 ) was @xmath38 mev/@xmath39 ( @xmath40 mev/@xmath39 ) .
@xmath41 misidentification causes a reflection of @xmath42 under the @xmath8 peak .
we limit the maximum kaon momentum to 160 gev/@xmath1 to reduce misidentification in the rich . to evaluate the shape of this background we use the @xmath43 sample that passes all the cuts listed above and lies within @xmath11 15 mev/@xmath44 of the @xmath45 mass .
we formed the invariant mass distribution of these events when one pion is interpreted as a kaon . at most one of the two possible reflections per event
falls into the @xmath35 mass window .
the reflected mass distribution was fit by a polynomial function rising at 1925 mev/@xmath44 and decreasing to zero at large invariant mass .
dividing this distribution by the number of @xmath42 events gives us the contribution per mass bin for each misidentified @xmath42 in the @xmath35 sample .
we count the misidentified @xmath42 in the @xmath8 sample by fitting the @xmath35 mass distribution within @xmath11 20 mev/@xmath44 interval around the @xmath35 mass with the sum of a gaussian signal , a linear background shape estimated from the sidebands and the @xmath42 shape with variable normalization .
the resultant misidentified @xmath42 contribution to the @xmath35 mass distribution is shown as the hatched areas in fig .
1(a ) , ( b ) .
the fit gives @xmath46 and @xmath47 misidentified @xmath42 events in the @xmath48 and @xmath49 decay mode , respectively ( the error quoted is statistical only ) . the rich kaon identification is a very powerful tool for rejecting @xmath42 contamination ; @xmath37 decay kinematics further reduces particle identification confusion in the @xmath50 channel . to estimate yields
, we subtracted the sideband background and @xmath42 contamination as evaluated above from the total number of events in the signal region .
we find 430 @xmath11 24 @xmath51 and 330 @xmath11 19 @xmath49 events .
a gaussian fit to the combined data shown in fig .
1(a ) , ( b ) gives a mass of @xmath52 mev@xmath53 and @xmath54 mev@xmath53 .
note that these fitted yields are not used as constraints in the lifetime fit , as discussed below .
the average longitudinal error @xmath55 on the primary and secondary vertices is 270 @xmath23 m and 500 @xmath23 m , which gives a combined error of 570 @xmath23 m . in the @xmath8 sample ,
the average momentum is 215 gev/@xmath1 , corresponding to a time resolution of 18 fs , about @xmath56 of @xmath57 .
because bin - smearing effects are small , we used a binned maximum likelihood fitting technique to determine the @xmath8 lifetime .
the fit was applied to a reduced proper time distribution , @xmath58 where m is the known charm mass @xcite , @xmath4 the reconstructed momentum , @xmath29 the measured vertex separation and @xmath59 the minimum @xmath29 for each event to pass all the imposed selection cuts .
@xmath59 is determined event - by - event , along with the acceptance , by the procedure described below .
we fitted all events with @xmath60 fs in the mass range @xmath61 gev@xmath53 , @xmath62 from the @xmath8 central mass value . to evaluate the mean lifetime we used a maximum likelihood method .
the probability density was performed by the function : @xmath63 @xmath64 where @xmath65 the function is the sum of a term for the @xmath8 exponential decay corrected by the acceptance function @xmath66 plus a background function @xmath67 consisting of a single exponential plus a constant to account for a flat background extending to large proper time .
its parameters were determined from the @xmath68 distribution from the @xmath8 sidebands .
it also includes a term for the @xmath42 exponential decay normalized to the number of misidentified events in the signal region .
the @xmath69 lifetime used in the fit is 1051 @xmath70 fs @xcite .
the mass range of the sideband background windows , @xmath71 gev@xmath53 and @xmath72 gev@xmath53 was twice the signal mass window .
we defined asymmetric sidebands to avoid the influence of @xmath73 , and we excluded the @xmath74 mass region .
the four parameters are : @xmath57 ( @xmath8 lifetime ) , @xmath75 ( background lifetime ) , @xmath76 ( background fraction in the signal region ) and @xmath77 ( background splitting function ) .
@xmath78 is the total number of events in the signal region after @xmath42 contamination subtraction .
the proper - time - dependent acceptance @xmath66 is independent of spectrometer features after the first magnet , e.g. , rich efficiency and tracking efficiency .
these efficiencies affect only the overall number of events detected .
the proper time distribution of these events depends crucially on vertex reconstruction . to evaluate @xmath66
we reanalyze each @xmath79 @xmath35 event after moving it to a large set of different proper times @xmath80 .
only the longitudinal position of the charm decay point and the axial orientation of the 3-body decay vectors are changed @xcite .
a reanalyzed event is accepted if it passes the same cuts as those applied to the data .
the minimum flight path after which an event is accepted defines @xmath59 for this event .
this method is independent of details of the true @xmath81 or transverse momentum distributions @xcite .
2 shows the overall fits to the data distributions as a function of reduced proper time for @xmath82 and @xmath83 decay modes .
it also shows the acceptance @xmath84 , which differs significantly from unity only after 4 lifetimes where statistics are limited .
table 1 summarizes the lifetime results for the two modes analyzed : @xmath85 ; and @xmath86 .
the uncertainties are statistical only , evaluated where @xmath87 increases by 0.5 . combining these results for the two resonant modes , we measure an average lifetime @xmath88 fs . .lifetime results and signal yields for the two @xmath35 modes analyzed .
the last row is the weighted average of the two resonant channels @xmath89 and @xmath90 .
the errors are statistical only . [ cols="<,^,^,^",options="header " , ]
the systematic uncertainties for the @xmath8 lifetime analysis are listed in table 2 and described below .
we group them in the following categories : lifetime shifts due to reconstruction errors have been well studied in our @xmath13 and @xmath91 work , with an order of magnitude higher statistics @xcite . because of the high redundancy and good precision of the silicon vertex detector , vertex mismeasurement effects are small at all momenta .
proper time assignment depends on correct momentum determination .
the selex momentum error is less than 0.5% in all cases .
we assign a maximum systematic error from proper time mismeasurement of 1 fs .
the effect of @xmath42 contamination under the @xmath92 peak was studied by changing the width of the exclusion window around the nominal @xmath42 mass for the k/@xmath21 interchange discussed above .
effects on the @xmath49 mode are negligible . for the @xmath6 mode
this gives a systematic error of 2 fs .
the technique to determine the acceptance correction dependence on proper time is discussed extensively in ref .
it has been verified with much larger statistics there .
the maximum systematic error here is dominated by the @xmath6 correction , 3 fs . for the @xmath7 mode
it is less than 2 fs .
the fit was performed by the maximum likelihood method using a background parametrized by an exponential function plus a constant .
we varied the width of the sidebands and the @xmath93 independently .
the sytematic error due to the fit procedure is 5 fs and less than 0.5 fs for @xmath6 and @xmath7 decay modes respectively . that error is mainly dominated by the @xmath35 background parametrization . combining in quadrature all the sources of systematic errors listed in table 2 we obtain a total systematic error of 6.2 fs ( 2.2 fs ) for the @xmath94 ( @xmath7 ) mode .
we have made a new measurement of the @xmath35 lifetime in two independent resonant decay channels , @xmath94 and @xmath7 using a maximum likelihood fit .
selex measures the @xmath35 lifetime to be @xmath95 fs . using the result reported in the pdg @xcite @xmath96 fs we evaluate a ratio @xmath97 , 3@xmath17 from unity . the @xmath98 lifetime reported in this letter
is comparable in precision with previous experiments @xcite .
our result , combined with other world data , @xcite , lowers the overall @xmath35 lifetime somewhat .
nevertheless , it is clear that the lifetime ratio @xmath99 is significantly larger than unity for all the precision measurements .
the authors are indebted to the staff of fermi national accelerator laboratory and for invaluable technical support from the staffs of collaborating institutions .
this project was supported in part by bundesministerium fr bildung , wissenchaft , forschung und tecnologie , consejo nacional de ciencia y tecnologia ( conacyt ) , conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnlogico , fondo de apoyo a la investigaci ' on ( uaslp ) , funda~ ao de amparo pesquisa do estado de s~ ao paulo ( fapesp ) , the israel science fundation founded by the israel academy of sciences and humanities , istituto nazionale di fisica nucleare ( infn ) , the international science foundation ( isf ) , the national science foundation ( phy 9602178 ) , nato ( grant cr6.941058 - 1360 - 94 ) , the russian academy of science , the russian ministry of science and technological research board ( t " ubitak),the u.s .
department of energy ( doe grant de - fg02 - 91er40664 and doe contract number de - ac02 - 76cho3000 ) , and the u.s .- israel binational science foundation ( bsf ) .
s. frixione , m. mangano , p. nason and g. ridolfi , `` heavy quark production in heavy flavour ii '' , a. j. buras and m. lindner eds .
( world scientific publishing singapore 1997 ) ; i.i . bigi and n.g .
uraltsev , z. phys .
c62 , 623 ( 1994 ) .
particle data group d.e .
et al . _ ,
j. c15 , 1 ( 2000 ) .
p. l. frabetti _ et .
e687 collaboration , phys .
71 , 827 ( 1993 ) .
et al . _ e791 collaboration , phys .
b445 , 449 ( 1999 ) .
g. bonvicini _
et al . _ ,
cleo collaboration , phys .
82 , 4586 ( 1999 ) .
j. engelfried _ et al .
methods a431 , 53 ( 1999 ) .
et al . _ , in _ proceedings of the 29th international conference on high energy physics , _ 1998 , edited by a. astbury _
et al . _ ( word scientific , singapore , 1998 ) vol .
ii , p. 1259
; hep - ex/9812031 .
kushnirenko , ph .
d. thesis , carnegie mellon university , 2000 ( unpublished ) .
a.y . kushnirenko _
et al . _ ,
accepted to be published . | we report a precise measurement of the @xmath0 meson lifetime .
the data were taken by the selex experiment ( e781 ) spectrometer using 600 gev/@xmath1 @xmath2 , @xmath3 and @xmath4 beams .
the measurement has been done using 918 reconstructed @xmath0 .
the lifetime of the @xmath0 is measured to be @xmath5 fs , using @xmath6 and @xmath7 decay modes .
the lifetime ratio of @xmath8 to @xmath9 is @xmath10 .
( selex collaboration ) , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
close - in giant planets are the most easily detected exoplanets today , as they are able to imprint significant radial velocities to their host star , and generate very clear transits . due to their proximity , the two main interactions with their host ( tides and magnetism , see * ? ? ?
* ) are very strong compared to the case of solar system planets . in theory , fast and efficient exchanges of angular momentum and energy between the planet and its host are hence possible in theses systems , altering their secular evolution . as a result
, significant efforts have been made in the past decades to look for observational signatures of these interactions , along with thorough theoretical research to better understand the physical mechanisms sustaining them .
numerous puzzling observations of close - in systems have been recently reported .
periodic anomalous chromospheric emissions have been observed on star harbouring a close - in hot jupiter @xcite .
the on / off nature of these emissions suggest either a magnetic origin @xcite , or material infall from the orbiting planet @xcite . wasp-18 also possesses a close - in planet , and was reported to present a surprising lack x - ray emissions @xcite , which could also be accounted for by its interaction with the orbiting planet .
finally , radio and uv emissions in close - in systems are intensively looked for today @xcite .
these emissions are difficult to observe as they were not found to induce any statistical observational trend @xcite , likely due to their on / off nature .
they may nevertheless be observed for some systems like hd 189733 for which an excess of absorption was reported during transit @xcite .
the signal is possibly tracing the existence of a bow shock in front of the orbiting planet created by the magneto - hydrodynamical interaction between the planet and the wind of the host star .
the population of exoplanets itself is also affected by star - planet interactions .
stars hosting close - in planets tend to rotate more rapidly than planet - free twin stars @xcite .
the physical origin of this trend is still debated today , but tides , magnetic interactions , or a combination of both are likely key to make close - in planets migrate and be absorbed by their host , transferring at the same time significant angular momentum to the star @xcite . in addition , a dearth of close - in planets around fast rotators was reported by several authors @xcite using kepler data .
again , both tides and magnetic interactions could be vectors of angular momentum transfers in such systems , making close - in planets migrate efficiently and explaining this dearth .
finally , some recent observations also report a possbile influence of close - in hot jupiter on the rotation and magnetic activity of their host @xcite , albeit larger samples of stars are today needed to confirm these trends .
these observations challenge our understanding of interactions between a close - in planet and its host star .
furthermore , a refined physical description of star - planet interaction is also today needed to guide the hunt for exoplanets .
finally the anomalous , enhanced emissions ( being either in radios , uv or x - ray ) in such systems likely trace the existence of the magnetic field of the planet
. a better theoretical understanding of the physical mechanisms sustaining these emissions could provide a way to characterize the magnetic field of close - in exoplanets with observations , or help us constrain the internal properties of the planet if it does not possess an intrinsic magnetic field , for which we do not have any constrains yet ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . among the means of interactions between a star and close - in planets , tides are by far the most studied aspect .
they are known to lead to spin - orbit synchronisation @xcite , planet migration @xcite and star spin - up @xcite due to angular momentum exchange between the planet and the star .
their efficiency was recently shown to depend on the internal structure of both the planet and the hosting star @xcite .
while significant insights have been recently gained for tidal gravito - inertial waves ( see , _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ) , the fully non - linear interactions between tidal waves , and the properties of magneto - gravito - inertial waves , still need to be characterized to obtain a satisfying understanding of angular momentum transfers by tidal waves in planetary and stellar interiors .
the close - in planets also receive intense radiation from their host due to their proximity .
the associated ionization of the atmosphere of the planet allows an enhanced atmospheric escape from the planet @xcite .
various types of such planetary outflows were found to exist , depending on the properties of the hosting star @xcite .
if the planet is in a sufficiently close - in orbit , the escaping material may fall on the stellar surface , providing an additional variability to the chromospheric emissions of the star ( see , _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
finally , magnetic fields provide another systematic source of interaction between a star and close - in planet , often referenced to as `` star - planet magnetic interaction '' ( spmi ) .
close - in giant planets are generally thought to orbit inside the alfvn surface of the wind of their host , _
i.e. _ in a region where the local alfvn speed exceeds the velocity of the wind .
this allows for particularly efficient transfers between the planet and its host @xcite , as alfvn waves carrying energy and momentum are able to travel between the two bodies .
such close - in exoplanet systems are similar to planet - satellite systems in the solar system , with the additional complexity of the existence of a stellar wind . as a result ,
the superposition of the alfvnic perturbations triggered by the orbital motion of the planet will form alfvn wings @xcite , which structure depends on the properties of the wind and of the planet magnetic field ( if any , see * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the spmis will generally be a source of planet migration @xcite and stellar spin - up @xcite .
for fast - rotating stars , the magnetic torque can be opposite such as to slow down the hosting star when the planet is beyond the co - rotation radius ( see * ? ? ? * ) .
it nevertheless appears to be too weak to fully solve the so - called _ angular momentum problem for young stars _ @xcite .
the energy channelled in the alfvn wings can also be a source of additional heating in the chromosphere of the host @xcite , which could potentially lead to anomalous emissions related to the existence of a close - in planet .
this mechanism was recently shown @xcite to naturally provide an on / off source of energy for enhanced emissions .
spmis are shaped by the stellar wind of the host star .
the plasma conditions in the stellar wind determine whether the spmi will be super- or sub - alfvnic .
the non - axisymmetry of real stellar magnetic fields can thus cause the spmi to change as a planet orbits in the wind @xcite .
observations of the magnetic field ( using the zeeman doppler imaging technique , see _
e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ) of planet - hosting star are thus of great importance to help constraining the possible spmis in real systems ( _ e.g. _ * ? ?
* for the kepler-78 system ) .
dedicated numerical simulations of stellar winds , based on observed magnetic topologies in 3d , are consequently necessary today @xcite .
spmis also generally depend on the internal structure of the planet @xcite .
when the planet is not able to sustain its own magnetic field , the stellar wind field is able to permeate into its interior , depending on its internal composition .
this interaction , dubbed as _ unipolar _ ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ) , can lead to planet inflation due to ohmic dissipation , as well as planet migration due to magnetic torques . in the case of a close - in planet operating a dynamo and sustaining its own magnetosphere
, magnetic torques still develop depending on the magnetic topology @xcite , and the interaction is then referred to as _
dipolar_. the aim of this work is to provide a parametrization of the main effects of magnetic interaction in the dipolar case , relevant for ( i ) the orbital migration of a planet and the associated spin - up ( or down ) of its host , and ( ii ) the existence of enhanced emissions in close - in systems .
our study is built on a 3d magneto - hydrodynamical ( mhd ) global model , in which a magnetized planet is introduced in a close - in orbit in a self - consistently simulated stellar wind .
this model will be briefly described in section [ sec : param - based - grid ] .
we present here a grid of numerical simulations where we vary the orbital radius of the planet and the strength of its magnetic field .
we propose a parametrization of the magnetic torque applied to the planet ( section [ sec : planet - migration - due ] ) , and of the magnetic energy flux driving enhanced emissions in the system ( section [ sec : magn - energy - flux ] ) .
the effect of ohmic dissipation on spmis is quantified in section [ sec : role - dissipation-1 ] , and we finally summarize and discuss our results in section [ sec : summary - conclusions ] .
the model used in this work is described in details in @xcite .
it is based on the mhd formalism to describe the interaction of a magnetized planet with a self - consistently driven stellar wind .
the system of equations is written in a frame rotating with the orbiting planet , which enables numerically to set the orbiting planet at a fix position in a grid centered on the rotating hosting star .
the grid resolution is enhanced around the star ( @xmath0 ) and the planetary magnetosphere ( @xmath1 ) , and the grid is stretched away from the central star elsewhere .
the grid used in this work is slightly coarser than in @xcite , in order to be able to produce a grid of numerical simulations with accessible computational ressources .
the set of mhd equations we solve is @xmath2 where @xmath3 is the plasma density , @xmath4 its velocity , @xmath5 the gas pressure , @xmath6 the magnetic field , @xmath7 is composed of the gravity , coriolis , and centrifugal forces , @xmath8 the sound speed ( @xmath9 is the adiabatic exponent , taken to be the equal to the ratio of specific heats and set in this work to 1.05 ) , and @xmath10 is the current density .
we use an ideal gas equation of state @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the internal energy per mass .
compared to the model described in @xcite , we have here added the possibility to introduce ohmic diffusivity .
two types of diffusivities can be used .
the first , controlled by the ohmic diffusion coefficient @xmath13 , is a standard ohmic diffusion used only inside the planetary boundary condition mimicking a crude ionospheric layer ( for more details see * ? ? ?
this standard diffusivity can be viewed as a very simple modelling of the actual pedersen conductivity which dominates ohmic dissipation in this region ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the second , controlled by the ohmic diffusion coefficient @xmath14 , is an enhanced diffusivity which is restricted to current sheets in the simulations .
an activation criterion @xmath15 is defined by @xmath16 where @xmath17 is the maximal size of the local grid cell , and @xmath18 ensures that @xmath15 does not diverge .
the enhanced diffusivity is activated based on the criterion @xmath15 as follows ( see , _ e.g. _ , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the anomalous diffusion coefficient .
such enhanced diffusion is very useful to control how the magnetic field reconnects in current sheets , while not affecting the remaining of the modelled system with an additional spurious ohmic dissipation . in section [ sec : role - dissipation-1 ]
we quantify the dependency of the global trends derived with a grid of numerical simulations ( see sections [ sec : planet - migration - due ] and [ sec : magn - energy - flux ] ) to the enhanced diffusivity , which can be used to trace the impact of the reconnection efficiency and/or the numerical resolution in other studies .
the mhd equations are discretized and solved using the pluto code @xcite .
they are solved using a second - order , linear spatial interpolation coupled to an hll riemann solver with a _ minmod _ flux limiter .
they are advanced in time with a second - order runge - rutta method .
the solenoidality of @xmath21 ( equation [ eq : divb ] ) is ensured with a constrained transport method @xcite , and the magnetic field is decomposed into a background field ( composed of two dipolar fields , one for the star and one for the planet ) .
pioneering numerical simulations of star - planet magnetic interaction were conducted by @xcite in a local domain around a close - in planet for prescribed stellar wind parameters .
inhomogeneities in stellar winds and the detailed global magnetic topology nevertheless strongly impact the strength and geometry of star - planet magnetic interactions , which warrants a global modelling of star - planet systems . in particular , the detailed knowledge of the three dimensional structure of the alfvn wings developing in the system is needed to calculate the magnetic torque which applies to a close - in orbiting planet ( see section [ sec : planet - migration - due ] ) .
@xcite carried out the first 3d global simulations of star - planet systems by including a planet as a boundary layer in a stellar wind numerical model and neglecting the planet orbital motion .
this limitation was further alleviated in @xcite by considering a planetary boundary condition changing position with time to mimic an orbital motion .
here we follow a different route and hold the planet fixed in the numerical grid by solving equations ( [ eq : mass_consrv_pluto]-[eq : divb ] ) in a frame rotating at the orbital rotation rate .
finally , the last particularity of our model lies in its planetary boundary condition : it is designed to mimic the coupling to an ionospheric layer which conductive properties affect the strength of the star - planet magnetic interaction ( see _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and section [ sec : role - dissipation-1 ] ) . in this work
, we consider only a dipolar ( axisymmetric ) magnetic field for the star . the planetary magnetic field is also considered to be a dipole , but can be locally either _ aligned _ or _ anti - aligned _ with the ambient stellar wind field at the orbital radius .
we restrict the present exploration to these two topologies , which are expected to give respectively the maximal and minimal magnetic interaction strength @xcite .
we present here a grid of such numerical simulations where the orbital radius ( 4 different radii ) and the planetary magnetic field ( 3 different amplitudes ) are varied for each of the two topologies .
we furthermore explored the influence of ohmic diffusion for two of these simulations , giving a total of 36 3d non - linear simulations in this study .
a summary of the parameters of this set of simulations , as well as the main numerical results discussed in the following sections , are given in appendix [ sec : mod_param_appendix ] .
by analogy with an obstacle in a flow , the magnetic torque applied to the planet due to spmi is generally written as ( _ e.g. _ , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the orbital radius of the planet , @xmath24 is the effective obstacle area exposed to the flow , @xmath25 the total ( thermal plus ram plus magnetic ) pressure of the wind in the frame where the planet is at rest , and @xmath26 a drag coefficient . the right hand side is conveniently composed of the total angular momentum that can be transfered to an obstacle of cross - section area @xmath24 , multiplied by @xmath26 . in the case of spmi ,
the drag coefficient @xmath26 and the effective area @xmath24 should generally depend on the topology of the interaction , _
i.e. _ on the relative orientations of the orbital motion , the interplanetary magnetic field , and the planetary magnetic field . due to this complexity , the drag coefficient @xmath26 and the effective interaction area @xmath24 can be non trivial to estimate .
fortunately , most terms in equation [ eq : proto_torq ] can be directly estimated in our set of numerical simulations .
the net torque @xmath27 applied to the planet can be calculated by integrating the angular momentum balance on a sphere encircling the planet ( see appendix a in * ? ? ?
the total pressure of the wind @xmath25 can naturally be estimated from the plasma conditions in the wind at the planetary orbit in our simulations and can be _ a priori _ parametrized from the stellar parameters ( section [ sec : effect - press - plan ] ) .
the two remaining parameters , @xmath26 and @xmath28 , require a careful evaluation in our simulations .
we detail their estimation in sections [ sec : drag - coefficient ] and [ sec : effect - area - inter ] respectively .
( black line ) is well approximated with equation [ eq : pt_approx ] ( magenta dashed line ) . ] because we consider planets orbiting inside the alfvn surface around cool stars , the magnetic pressure of the wind almost always dominates its total pressure ( since the wind speed is smaller than the local alfvn speed ) .
if the dominant topology of the stellar magnetic field is a dipole or a quadrupole , the magnetic pressure also generally dominates the ram pressure @xmath29 ( the ram velocity is defined as @xmath30 is the keplerian velocity for a circular orbit . ] ) , even for close - in planets ( we recall here that the effective total pressure is evaluated in the frame where the planet is at rest , which is why the keplerian velocity enters the definition of the ram pressure ) .
we show in figure [ fig : pressures ] the magnetic , ram and thermal components of the total pressure @xmath25 in the wind considered in this work .
we indeed observe that the total pressure is dominated by the magnetic component for the close - in planets considered here ( @xmath31 ) .
note nevertheless that this is not necessarily true for higher order topologies , and depends strongly on how the density profile falls off in the lower corona . in the case of a dipolar magnetic field
, the total pressure @xmath25 at the orbital radius can be approximated by ( see dashed line in figure [ fig : pressures ] ) @xmath32 nevertheless , we will hereafter always consider the total pressure @xmath25 rather than this approximated formulation . when applied to a case where the stellar magnetic field is mainly dipolar and aligned with the rotation axis , one may simply use the approximation in equation [ eq : pt_approx ] .
the drag coefficient is generally thought to represent in the case of spmi the reconnection efficiency between the stellar wind and the planetary magnetic field , at the boundaries of the planetary magnetosphere or of the alfvn wings themselves . in some interaction cases
, it also depends on the conductivity of the obstacle . in the context of planetary radio emissions in the unipolar interaction case ( similar to io - jupiter interaction ) , @xcite approximated @xmath26 with @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the local alfvnic mach number near the obstacle ( @xmath35 is the local alfvn speed ) .
they argue that in the case of a dipolar interaction , @xmath26 depends on the conductivity in the ionosphere but takes similar values as in equation [ eq : reconnection_coeff ] . @xcite use a different measure of @xmath26 based on the pedersen conductance @xmath36 ( which is the pedersen conductivity integrated over the ionosphere ) , which can be approximated by @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the alfvn conductance ( where @xmath39 is the speed of light ) .
it is instructive to note that in the limit of small @xmath40 ( for which equation [ eq : reconnection_coeff_2 ] was derived ) , and for small @xmath41 ( in this work @xmath42 cm / s , while conservative estimates of @xmath36 give value of the order of @xmath43 cm / s , see * ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , both expressions reduce to @xmath44 .
we show @xmath40 and @xmath26 as a function of the orbital radius in figure [ fig : ma_and_cd ] for the stellar wind considered here ( for more details about the parameters of the simulated stellar wind , see * ? ? ?
in the remainder of this work , we will denote @xmath45 .
we choose here to explicitly separate the impact of ohmic dissipation ( through the coefficients @xmath13 and @xmath14 , see sections [ sec : param - based - grid ] and [ sec : role - dissipation-1 ] ) from @xmath26 .
( blue ) , the drag coefficient @xmath46 ( red , see equation [ eq : reconnection_coeff ] ) , and the drag coefficient @xmath47 ( with @xmath48 cm / s , see equation [ eq : reconnection_coeff_2 ] ) as a function of the orbital distance on the ecliptic plane , for the stellar wind considered in this work . the alfvnic point ( @xmath49 ) is identified by the dashed black lines . ] , deduced from the magnetic torque applied to the planet ( see equations [ eq : aeff_num ] and [ eq : aeff_fit ] ) . in the top panel ,
the effective areas are shown as a function of the pressure ratio @xmath50 .
the fitted trends for the aligned ( diamonds ) and anti - aligned ( circle ) cases are respectively shown by the red and blue dotted lines .
the different orbital radii are color - coded as indicated by the legend . in the bottom panel , the dependency of @xmath24 upon @xmath50 is removed to show only the variation with the alfvn mach number @xmath40 . in this lower panel
, the darkened region corresponds to super - alfvnic interactions cases which were not included in the fit .
the coefficients of the fits are also reported in table [ ta : aeff_fit ] . ]
the effective area of interaction in spmi has been a widely used concept in the past years ( _ see , e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
it is generally viewed as an effective obstacle area @xmath24 , and is often approximated by a magnetospheric size obtained from a simple pressure balance between the planetary magnetosphere and the wind pressure which gives @xmath51 where we define @xmath52 as this pressure ratio . however , as argued in @xcite , the effective area depends strongly on the topology of the interaction , and is not well approximated by @xmath53 in the aligned case .
the effective area of the interaction can be deduced from equation [ eq : proto_torq ] in our set of numerical simulations by writing : @xmath54 where @xmath27 and @xmath25 are directly computed from the numerical simulation and @xmath26 is computed using equation [ eq : reconnection_coeff ] .
we fit the deduced effective area as a function of @xmath50 and @xmath40 through @xmath55 the deduced areas in our set of simulations are shown in figure [ fig : fit_a ] for anti - aligned ( circles ) and aligned ( diamonds ) cases , as a function of the pressure ratio @xmath50 ( upper panel ) and alfvnic mach number @xmath40 ( lower panel ) .
the fits ( equation [ eq : aeff_fit ] ) are shown by the red ( aligned ) and blue ( anti - aligned ) dotted lines , and the numerical values are given in table [ ta : aeff_fit ] .
lccc anti - aligned & 3.5 @xmath56 0.3 & 0.28 @xmath56 0.01 & 0.02 @xmath56 0.04 + aligned & 10.8 @xmath56 0.4 & 0.28 @xmath56 0.01 & -0.56 @xmath56 0.02 the effective area of interaction increases with @xmath50 with an exponent @xmath57 in all cases , which is close to the @xmath58 exponent expected from a simple pressure balance ( equation [ eq : aeff_v0 ] , shown by the dotted black line ) . in both types of interaction , the effective area is larger than the predicted obstacle area @xmath53 . in the aligned case
, this is awaited @xcite as the effective area incorporates a part of the aflvn wings themselves ( we will come back to this point below ) . in the anti - aligned case ,
though , the effective area is systematically higher than the naive estimation from pressure balance .
this is due to the fact that the interaction between the magnetosphere and the stellar wind leads to a compression of the magnetosphere at the nose of the interaction , and a subsequent widening of the magnetosphere perpendicular to the flow @xmath59 , which results in the tear - like shape for the magnetosphere on the equatorial plane .
this phenomenon is illustrated on the left panels of figure [ fig : effective_area_2cases ] for an anti - aligned case , where the magnetic field lines in the plane perpendicular to ecliptic plane are shown in the upper panel , and the streamlines of the flow ( in the frame where the planet is at rest ) in the ecliptic are shown in the bottom panel .
the obstacle size deduced from equation [ eq : aeff_v0 ] is shown by the thick black circles .
the magnetosphere exceeds the naive obstacle size , and on the ecliptic the compressed tear - like shape of the magnetosphere appears clearly . + and @xmath60 ( cases 8 in table [ tab : tab0 ] ) .
the circular area @xmath53 ( equation [ eq : aeff_v0 ] ) is delimited by the thick black circle , and the planet by the grey disk .
_ bottom panels _ streamlines of the flow on the ecliptic plane ( cyan ) .
again , the thick black circle labels @xmath53 . the orange colormap represents @xmath15 ( equation [ eq : crit_diffusivity ] ) . note that in the cases shown here , no enhanced resistivity was considered ( section [ sec : role - dissipation-1 ] ) . on the right
, a clear current sheet appears on the ecliptic at the boundary between the stellar wind stream and the planetary magnetosphere .
the parallel size @xmath61 deduced from the magnetic torque applied to the planet ( see equation [ eq : d_parallel ] ) is indicated by the magenta segment for the aligned case . ]
the effective area of the interaction also strongly depends on the alfvnic mach number @xmath40 in the aligned case ( @xmath62 , see figure [ fig : fit_a ] ) , while it has merely no incidence on @xmath24 in the anti - aligned cases ( the exponent @xmath63 in this case is not significant , see table [ ta : aeff_fit ] ) .
the origin of this dependency lies in the type of obstacle that develops in the aligned case . in this case
, the open magnetic field lines at the pole of the planet ( which we suppose to be anchored to the planet ) , face the stellar wind and henceforth have to be considered as part of the planetary obstacle . as a result ,
the effective area depends on the inclination angle of the alfvn wings , which is controlled by @xmath40 , and the effective area in the aligned case has also to depend on @xmath40 , as observed in figure [ fig : fit_a ] .
though , should the full alfvn wing cross - section be considered as the effective obstacle area ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
in fact , the situation is slightly more complicated and can be understood as follows ( see schematics in the upper panels of figure [ fig : effective_area ] ) .
the alfvn wings are populated by alfvnic perturbations triggered on the ecliptic plane at the magnetopause where the stellar wind magnetic field and the planetary magnetic field reconnect ( see the current sheet in the lower right panel of figure [ fig : effective_area_2cases ] ) .
if one follows the trajectory of such a perturbation launched at the nose of the reconnecting region ( panel a in figure [ fig : effective_area ] ) , by the time the wind plasma has swept around the planetary magnetosphere on the ecliptic plane ( panel b ) the perturbation has travelled a given distance along the alfvn wing ( panel c ) .
this distance defines the portion of the alfvn wings that is relevant for the angular momentum extraction from the planetary orbit by the magnetic interaction .
we show in panel d the flow in the ecliptic plane and the alfvn characteristics out of it with a 3d view for an aligned case .
the reconnection area on the ecliptic plane is traced by the orange region showing @xmath64 , as in figure [ fig : effective_area_2cases ] . in order to support this interpretation
, we _ a posteriori _ calculate the cross - section of the alfvn wings that corresponds to the measured effective area of the interaction @xmath24 in this case .
this area is shown by the blue and red areas in panel e ( we have two areas here since interaction develops two alfvn wings ) . using these alfvn wing areas we can associate a travel distance [ @xmath65 from the reconnection site on the ecliptic plane , which corresponds to a travel time @xmath66 of the alfvnic perturbations up to such a distance along the alfvn wings , given by @xmath67 for the northern alfvn wing , where @xmath68 is the infinitesimal distance along the alfvn wing , and @xmath69 is the corresponding alfvn characteristic .
considering that the plasma sweeps around the magnetospheric obstacle with an average velocity @xmath70 on the ecliptic plane , we can deduce what should be the extent of the magnetospheric obstacle in the stream direction [ @xmath61 ] to account for an effective area of interaction @xmath24 by @xmath72 we report this deduced distance on the lower right panel in figure [ fig : effective_area_2cases ] .
we recall here that we deduced @xmath73 only from the effective area of interaction @xmath24 ( equation [ eq : aeff_num ] ) , and from the shape of the alfvn wings ( to estimate @xmath66 ) .
we observe that @xmath61 is indeed an excellent approximation of the size of the magnetospheric obstacle in the stream direction ( see figure [ fig : effective_area_2cases ] ) , validating our interpretation of the effective area of interaction in the aligned case of the close - in star - planet interaction ( figure [ fig : effective_area ] ) .
we recall that in the anti - aligned case , the magnetosphere is closed and this interpretation naturally does not apply .
our sample of simulations also include super - alfvnic cases , shown in magenta in figure [ fig : fit_a ] . in the aligned case
, they seem to follow the same trend as the sub - alfvnic cases .
the effective area appears to drop for the anti - aligned cases , certainly due to the appearance of a shock in front of the magnetospheric obstacle .
this warrants further investigation of the sub- to super - alfvnic transition of the interaction .
we intend to explore this transition in a future work .
the magnetic torque that develop in close - in star - planet systems can hence be parametrized using a combination of equations [ eq : proto_torq ] and [ eq : aeff_fit ] , with different exponents ( listed in table [ ta : aeff_fit ] ) depending on the magnetic topology of the interaction topology .
the migration time - scale of the planet due to the magnetic interaction can subsequently be calculated as follows : @xmath74 where @xmath75 is the orbital angular momentum of the planet and the factor 2 accounts for the @xmath76 dependancy of @xmath77 . note that the magnetospheric obstacle on the ecliptic plane may also depend on the reconnection efficiency of magnetic field lines in the current sheet that develops .
we will detail this aspect in section [ sec : diss - reconn - curr ] , and conclude on the generic parametrization of the magnetic torque @xmath27 in section [ sec : summary - conclusions ] .
the alfvn wings also channel energy between the planet and the star in the form of alfvn waves . the energy flux can be quantified by the poynting flux in the alfvn wing , given by @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the electric field in the ideal mhd approximation and @xmath80 are the alfvn characteristics .
the power @xmath81 associated with the poynting flux can be simply obtained by integrating @xmath82 over the alfvn wing cross - section ( for more details see * ? ? ?
* ) , @xmath83 in order to estimate the accessible power for radio emissions in star - planet systems , @xcite proposed the following formulation @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the incident poynting flux of the stellar wind . in a more recent study , and in the context of aligned configurations
, @xcite found analytically a slightly different formulation which can be written @xmath86 where @xmath47 is defined in equation [ eq : reconnection_coeff_1 ] . in our simulations ,
we know _ a priori _ the values of @xmath26 ( see section [ sec : drag - coefficient ] ) and @xmath87 .
we hence follow the same procedure as in section [ sec : planet - migration - due ] ( see equation [ eq : aeff_fit ] ) and fit the following normalized total poynting flux with @xmath88 the fitted coefficients are shown in table [ ta : poy_fit ] and the resulting fits in figure [ fig : fit_poy ] .
the expression of the poynting flux proposed in the literature ( equations [ eq : p_zarka ] and [ eq : p_saur ] ) directly depend on the obstacle area , in a similar fashion than the torque derived in section [ sec : planet - migration - due ] . as a result , it can be surprising that in our simulations the poynting flux appears to vary with @xmath50 with slightly weaker exponent than the torque .
note nonetheless that within the error bars of the two fits , one may consider a common exponent for the two expressions , _
i.e. _ @xmath89 .
it is remarkable that all simulations , including the two different topologies , can be approximated with a single exponent for the dependancy upon @xmath50 .
this shows the robustness of the primary source of the magnetic star - planet interaction under various situations , which is characterized by the pressure balance between the ram pressure of the impacting wind and the magnetic pressure of the magnetospheric obstacle .
lccc anti - aligned & 0.8 @xmath56 0.2 & 0.26 @xmath56 0.03 & 1.40 @xmath56 0.10 + aligned & 9.7 @xmath56 2.8 & 0.23 @xmath56 0.04 & 1.09 @xmath56 0.13 in contrast with the magnetic torque , the poynting flux depends on @xmath40 in both the aligned and anti - aligned cases ( lower panel in figure [ fig : fit_poy ] ) .
previous estimates of the poynting flux ( equations [ eq : p_zarka ] and [ eq : p_saur ] ) imply that @xmath90 only depends on the effective obstacle area . in @xcite ,
the obstacle is the simplified magnetospheric obstacle @xmath53 ( equation [ eq : aeff_v0 ] ) , and as result in their scaling law @xmath90 only depends on @xmath50 .
we already saw that at least in the aligned case the obstacle estimation ( equation [ eq : aeff_v0 ] ) is not satisfying , hence we do not expect our results to follow equation [ eq : p_zarka ] . in @xcite , the effective area appearing in equation
[ eq : p_saur ] corresponds to the cross - section of the alfvn wing itself .
this cross - section is not trivial to estimate without calculating the non - linear interaction between the planet magnetosphere and the stellar wind .
our numerical results provide a simple parametrization of the dependancy of this area to the wind alfvnic mach number @xmath40 , as shown in the lower panel of figure [ fig : fit_poy ] .
they allow us to extend the scaling law derived by @xcite by clarifying an additional dependancy of the cross - section area of the alfvn wings .
( see equation [ eq : poy_fit ] ) .
the symbols are the same as in figure [ fig : fit_a ] .
the coefficients of the fits are reported in table [ ta : poy_fit ] . ]
the fact that @xmath90 depends on @xmath40 in the anti - aligned case can appear counter - intuitive .
in fact , one has to remember that we quantify here the energy flux channelled _ through the wings_. since the wings themselves depend on @xmath40 , @xmath90 is expected to depend on @xmath40 in all cases .
this was not the case for the magnetic torque in the anti - aligned cases , as in these cases the torque applies mainly on the magnetospheric obstacle rather than the alfvn wings themselves .
up to this point we have not considered yet the important aspect of ohmic dissipation in our discussion .
because all the simulations carried in this work have an equivalent numerical resolution around the planetary magnetosphere , we expect the scaling laws we derived in sections [ sec : planet - migration - due ] and [ sec : magn - energy - flux ] to hold up to different dissipation properties .
nonetheless , we expect the multiplicative coefficients of the scaling laws ( @xmath91 and @xmath92 ) to be sensitive to dissipation .
we now quantify this effect .
we have considered so far only cases with no explicit dissipation ( @xmath93 in equations [ eq : ener_consrv_pluto ] and [ eq : induction_pluto ] ) , letting the numerical scheme set the level of dissipation in our simulations .
we explore here two important aspects of ohmic dissipation that can affect the scaling laws derived in sections [ sec : planet - migration - due ] and [ sec : magn - energy - flux ] .
we first explore the influence of ohmic dissipation [ @xmath13 ] in the ionospheric boundary layer of our model ( section [ sec : diss - ionosph ] ) .
we then turn to the effect of anomalous ohmic dissipation [ @xmath14 ] that is triggered automatically ( see equation [ eq : enhanced_res ] ) in strong currents sheets in our model ( section [ sec : diss - reconn - curr ] ) .
we first consider an enhanced ohmic dissipation coefficient @xmath13 in our planetary boundary condition mimicking a crude ionospheric layer .
the ohmic diffusion coefficient can be related to the integrated pedersen conductivity by ( see _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ) @xmath96 where @xmath97 stands for the characteristic height of the atmosphere ( or ionosphere ) of the exoplanet . both the pedersen conductivity @xmath36 and @xmath97 are observationally unconstrained for close - in planets possessing an ionosphere .
conservative estimates of both parameters ( based on solar system planets and moons ) lead to ohmic diffusion coefficients between @xmath43 and @xmath98 @xmath99/s ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in order to alleviate the degeneracy of our scalings laws with respect to @xmath13 , we report here on a series of simulations with @xmath100 and @xmath101 for which we systematically increased @xmath13 up to @xmath102 @xmath99/s .
the resulting effective area of the interaction @xmath24 ( equation [ eq : aeff_num ] ) and normalized poynting flux @xmath90 ( equation [ eq : poy_fit ] ) are shown in figure [ fig : fit_etap ] for the aligned ( diamonds ) and anti - aligned ( circle ) cases . .
all the cases have @xmath103 and @xmath101 .
the layout is the same as in figures [ fig : fit_a ] and [ fig : fit_poy ] .
the horizontal lines label the values obtained when no explicit dissipation is considered . ]
we first notice that the anti - aligned cases are largely insensitive to @xmath13 .
indeed , in the anti - aligned cases the planetary magnetosphere is closed and only a few field lines are able to reconnect between the polar cap of the planet and the ambient wind . as a result , the resistivity in the ionospheric boundary layer is largely unimportant in those cases .
the aligned cases show a weak dependency upon @xmath13 , shown by the black dashed line in each panel .
this trend allows us to estimate that @xmath104 @xmath99/s in our reference models with no explicit diffusivities . as @xmath13
is decreased ( which here could be achieved by reducing the grid size , for an increased computational cost ) , the associated pedersen conductance increases and finally ends up dominating over the alfvn conductance @xmath105 ( see equation [ eq : reconnection_coeff_2 ] ) . in this case
the interaction is supposed to saturate , with an effective drag that can be approximated by @xmath40 . given that both the torque and the poynting flux depend weakly on @xmath13 , our set of simulations already give robust estimates of both effects .
nevertheless , depending on the star - planet system one is interested in , the ohmic dissipation coefficient @xmath13 ( when estimated from adequate modelling of the exoplanet ionosphere ) can be added to our scaling laws of the magnetic torque and poynting fluxes .
we now turn to the stronger effect of an anomalous resistivity in the strong current sheets developing due to the magnetic interaction .
we now turn to a series of simulations where we activate the enhanced dissipation @xmath14 ( equation [ eq : enhanced_res ] ) controlled by the ohmic diffusion coefficient @xmath20 .
this enhanced dissipation activates only in strong current sheets that develop in the simulation .
it is designed to mimic fast reconnection process , that would otherwise be completely controlled by the unavoidable ( and slow ) numerical dissipation of the numerical scheme .
we show the effective area of interaction and the normalized poynting flux in figure [ fig : fit_eta ] .
the layout is the same as in figure [ fig : fit_etap ] , with the horizontal axis representing the anomalous ohmic diffusion coefficient @xmath20 .
we first note that for either the aligned and anti - aligned cases , the effective area of interaction is only mildly affected by the enhanced dissipation .
the reconnection rate between the planetary and wind magnetic fields has indeed little impact on the shape of the obstacle , and hence does not affect much the torque that applies to the planetary obstacle .
in the aligned case , the anomalous dissipation nevertheless changes slightly the size of the magnetospheric obstacle in the stream direction ( see bottom right panel in figure [ fig : effective_area_2cases ] ) .
a larger dissipation tends to extend spatially the currents sheets ( while reducing their strength ) , leading to an effective increase of the stream - wise size @xmath106 of the obstacle , and consequently of @xmath24 .
our simulations suggest that the effective area changes roughly proportionally to @xmath107 in the aligned case ( more simulations would be needed to determine this exponent more accurately ) . .
the layout is the same as in figure [ fig : fit_etap ] . ] while anomalous diffusion has only a small effect on the magnetic torque that applies to the planet , the poynting flux generated by the magnetic interaction is strongly affected by it ( lower panel in figure [ fig : fit_eta ] ) . in the anti - aligned case ,
the closed magnetosphere makes the reconnection sites located primarily near the poles of the planetary magnetic field , restricted to a small area . in this case , the poynting flux is carried by perturbations launched from those sites , and as a result turns to be very sensitive to magnetic field reconnection there .
the poynting flux in the aligned cases presents a significantly weaker ( though not negligible ) dependancy to @xmath20 ( @xmath108 ) .
this weaker dependancy reflects the change in topology : in the aligned case , the interface between the magnetosphere and the stellar wind on the ecliptic plane is the main the reconnection site of the interaction .
its shape , size and properties are hence primarily set by the pressure balance shaping the magnetospheric obstacle ( see section [ sec : effect - area - inter ] ) , and the reconnection efficiency controlled by @xmath20 then adds second - order effects to its shape and size . as a result , the poynting flux in the aligned case is less sensitive than in the anti - aligned case , for which the reconnection site is almost completely controlled by @xmath20 .
finally , it is interesting to note the poynting flux systematically decreases with the anomalous diffusion coefficient .
this relatively strong dependency warrants further investigation of the close - in spmis using more realistic magnetic reconnection models .
we intend to return to this aspect in a future publication , in a particular for the aligned topologies for which spmis could provide an innovative mean of characterizing the magnetic fields of exoplanets .
in this work we have explored a parametrization of the effects of star - planet magnetic interaction in close - in systems in the dipolar case .
we have parametrized the magnetic torque applied to the planet , and the magnetic energy flux that can be channeled towards the star due to this interaction .
thanks to a grid of numerical simulations spanning various planetary orbits , planetary magnetic fields , and dissipation properties , we propose the following generic parameterizations @xmath109 the two formulations are separated into groups of parameters depending only on the wind properties ( first parenthesis ) , the planet properties ( second parenthesis ) , and a combination of both ( third parenthesis ) .
the exponents appearing in these formulations are given in tables [ ta : aeff_fit ] and [ ta : poy_fit ] , and in figures [ fig : fit_etap ] and [ fig : fit_eta ] for @xmath110 .
they depend on the topology of the interaction , and are given here for the two extreme cases of aligned ( strong interaction ) and anti - aligned ( weak interaction ) topologies . as a result , these generic formulations can be used in combination with observational data formulations ( [ eq : param_final_t]-[eq : param_final_p ] ) can furthermore be used in combination with independent stellar wind models . as an example
, one could use a simple potential field extrapolation technique @xcite to derive the magnetic properties of the stellar wind of a given star , and further use the torque and poynting fluxes formulations proposed in this work to estimate the migration time - scale and accessible energy fluxes for particular close - in star - planet systems .
we have furthermore explored the dependency of our results upon ohmic dissipation in the planet ionosphere ( section [ sec : diss - ionosph ] ) and in the reconnecting sites ( section [ sec : diss - reconn - curr ] ) .
we have introduced the normalized ohmic dissipation coefficients @xmath111 and @xmath112 , which are the physical dissipation coefficients normalized to the numerical dissipation coefficients deduced from our set of simulations .
a normalizing ohmic dissipation coefficient @xmath113 @xmath99/s can be used as a first approximation in all cases ( see section [ sec : role - dissipation-1 ] for details ) . in combination with the numerical values of the multiplicative factor @xmath91 and @xmath92 , that were derived for a given numerical resolution
, these normalized ohmic dissipation coefficients make the formulations independent of our grid resolution .
we have shown that in the aligned case of the dipolar interaction , the effective area of the interaction is not well approximated by the classical magnetospheric obstacle .
we demonstrated that it could be viewed as a portion of the alfvn wings developing due to the magnetic interaction .
the exact subpart of the wings that composes the effective area depends on the elongation of the magnetosphere of the planet in the stream direction , as schematized in figure [ fig : effective_area ] . as a result , the magnetic torque applied to the orbiting body can be much larger than if it was only applied to a simple magnetospheric obstacle .
our estimates of the magnetic torque ( equation [ eq : param_final_t ] ) can readily be implemented in secular evolution models involving close - in planets , to be systematically compared to tidal migration ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
various topologies and magnetic field amplitudes can easily be considered .
coupled to simple stellar wind models , our formulation allows to determine possible synthetic populations of exoplanets accounting for the magnetic interactions , which could be compared to the actual distribution of close - in exoplanets observed today . the poynting flux formulation ( equation [ eq : param_final_p ] ) can be used to estimate potentially observable traces of star - planet magnetic interactions in distant systems ( _ e.g. _ * ? ? ?
thanks to the versatile formulation presented here , the cases of aligned and anti - aligned configurations can be easily considered , a quantitative estimate of the energy flux originating from the magnetic interaction can be obtained , and the dependancy upon the ionospheric properties of the planet can be incorporated . in combination with dedicated stellar wind models for real non - axisymmetric magnetic configurations ,
the poynting flux ( equation [ eq : param_final_p ] ) can be applied to estimate the energy source which could drive enhanced emissions on particular stars hosting close - in planets . in turn
, the observations of such enhanced emissions could be combined with our estimate of the poynting flux to infer the possible magnetic field of observed exoplanets ( for a first step in this direction , see * ? ? ?
finally , some caveats need to be mentioned before using the scaling laws derived in this work .
first , our modelling of the ionosphere of the planet remains very crude at this stage . a more detailed ionospheric coupling ( see , _
e.g. _ , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) could be implemented to incorporate more realistic current distributions in the ionosphere , and inhomogeneous pedersen conductance profiles that likely arise in tidally synchronized close - in system due to the day / night asymmetry .
second , the sensitivity of the simulated poynting flux to an anomalous ohmic diffusion warrants further investigations with more realistic magnetic reconnection models .
we aim to study the implications of these aspects for the scaling laws derived here in a future work .
finally , we have focused here on the cases of planets sustaining their own magnetic field .
star - planet magnetic interactions can also develop in cases where the planet does not possess an intrinsic magnetic field , nor an ionosphere ( see , _
e.g. _ , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) . when applying the scaling laws to real systems , the possibility that the exoplanet does not operate a dynamo shall always be considered along the dipolar interaction scenario .
we also wish to explore this unipolar regime with numerical simulations in a future publication .
i want to thank here j. bouvier , a. s brun , d. cbron , s. p. matt , v. rville , and p. zarka for stimulating discussions about star - planet interactions .
i want to also thank a. mignone and his team for giving the pluto code to the research community .
i acknowledge support from the canadian institute of theoretical astrophysics ( national fellow ) , and from the canada s natural sciences and engineering research council .
this work was also supported by the anr 2011 blanc http://ipag.osug.fr/anr_toupies/[toupies ] and the erc project http://www.stars2.eu/[stars2 ] .
i acknowledge access to supercomputers through genci ( project 1623 ) , prace , and computecanada infrastructures . 70 alvarado - gmez , j. d. , hussain , g. a. j. , cohen , o. , et al .
2016 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201527832 [ , 588 , a28 ] auclair - desrotour , p. , le poncin - lafitte , c. , & mathis , s. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201322782 [ , 561 , l7 ] auclair - desrotour , p. , mathis , s. , & le poncin - lafitte , c. 2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201526246 [ , 581 , a118 ] barker , a. j. , & ogilvie , g. i. 2011 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2011.19322.x [ , 417 , 745 ] baruteau , c. , crida , a. , paardekooper , s. j. , et al .
2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.2458/azu_uapress_9780816531240-ch029 [ , 667 ] bolmont , e. , raymond , s. n. , leconte , j. , & matt , s. p. 2012
, http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201219645 [ , 544 , 124 ] bouvier , j. , & cbron , d. 2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stv1824 [ , 453 , 3720 ] cauley , p. w. , redfield , s. , jensen , a. g. , et al .
2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/810/1/13 [ , 810 , 13 ] cohen , o. , drake , j. j. , kashyap , v. l. , et al .
2009 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/704/2/l85 [ , 704 , l85 ] cohen , o. , drake , j. j. , kashyap , v. l. , sokolov , i. v. , & gombosi , t. i. 2010 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/2041-8205/723/1/l64 [ , 723 , l64 ] cohen , o. , kashyap , v. l. , drake , j. j. , et al .
2011 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/733/1/67 [ , 733 , 67 ] cohen , o. , ma , y. , drake , j. j. , et al .
2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/806/1/41 [ , 806 , 41 ] cuntz , m. , saar , s. h. , & musielak , z. e. 2000 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/312609 [ , 533 , l151 ] damiani , c. , & lanza , a. f. 2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201424318 [ , 574 , a39 ] donati , j .- f .
, & landstreet , j. d. 2009 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-082708-101833 [ , 47 , 333 ] duling , s. , saur , j. , & wicht , j. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/2013ja019554 [ , 119 , 4412 ] evans , c. r. , & hawley , j. f. 1988 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/166684 [ , 332 , 659 ] fares , r. , donati , j .- f . ,
moutou , c. , et al .
2010 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2010.16715.x [ , 406 , 409 ] ferraz - mello , s. , tadeu dos santos , m. , folonier , h. , et al .
2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/807/1/78 [ , 807 , 78 ] fleck , r. c. 2008 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10509-007-9703-5 [ , 313 , 351 ] goldreich , p. , & lynden - bell , d. 1969 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/149947 [ , 156 , 59 ] goodman , m. l. 1995 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00585-995-0843-z [ , 13 , 843 ] griemeier , j. m. , zarka , p. , & spreeuw , h. 2007 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20077397 [ , 475 , 359 ] guenel , m. , mathis , s. , & remus , f. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201424010 [ , 566 , l9 ] ip , w .- h .
, kopp , a. , & hu , j .- h .
2004 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/382274 [ , 602 , l53 ] jia , x. , walker , r. j. , kivelson , m. g. , khurana , k. k. , & linker , j. a. 2009 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/2009ja014375 [ , 114 , n / a ] kivelson , m. g. , bagenal , f. , kurth , w. s. , et al .
2004 , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/cgi-bin/nph-data_query?bibcode=2004jpsm.book..513k&link_type=abstract [ , 513 ] laine , r. o. , & lin , d. n. c. 2011 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/745/1/2 [ , 745 , 2 ] laine , r. o. , lin , d. n. c. , & dong , s. 2008 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/589177 [ , 685 , 521 ] lanza , a. f. 2010 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/200912789 [ , 512 , 77 ] lanza , a. f. , & shkolnik , e. l. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stu1206 [ , 443 , 1451 ] lecavelier des etangs , a. , sirothia , s. k. , gopal - krishna , & zarka , p. 2013
, http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201219789 [ , 552 , 65 ] llama , j. , vidotto , a. a. , jardine , m. , et al .
2013 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt1725 [ , 2442 ] lovelace , r. v. e. , romanova , m. m. , & barnard , a. w. 2008 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2008.13617.x [ , 389 , 1233 ] mathis , s. , alvan , l. , & remus , f. 2013 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/eas/1362010 [ , 62 , 323 ] matsakos , t. , uribe , a. , & knigl , a. 2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201425593 [ , 578 , a6 ] maxted , p. f. l. , serenelli , a. m. , & southworth , j. 2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201525774 [ , 577 , a90 ] mcquillan , a. , mazeh , t. , & aigrain , s. 2013 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/2041-8205/775/1/l11 [ , 775 , l11 ] merkin , v. g. , & lyon , j. g. 2010 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/2010ja015461 [ , 115 , a10202 ] mignone , a. , bodo , g. , massaglia , s. , et al .
2007 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/513316 [ , 170 , 228 ] miller , b. p. , gallo , e. , wright , j. t. , & pearson , e. g. 2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/799/2/163 [ , 799 , 163 ] moutou , c. , donati , j .- f . ,
lin , d. , laine , r. o. , & hatzes , a. 2016 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stw809 [ , 459 , 1993 ] neubauer , f. m. 1980 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/ja085ia03p01171 [ , 85 , 1171 ] . 1998 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/97je03370 [ , 103 , 19843 ] owen , j. e. , & adams , f. c. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stu1684 [ , 444 , 3761 ] pillitteri , i. , maggio , a. , micela , g. , et al .
2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/805/1/52 [ , 805 , 52 ] pillitteri , i. , wolk , s. j. , sciortino , s. , & antoci , v. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201423579 [ , 567 , a128 ] pont , f. 2009 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2966.2009.14868.x [ , 396 , 1789 ] poppenhaeger , k. , & schmitt , j. h. m. m. 2011 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/735/1/59 [ , 735 , 59 ] poppenhaeger , k. , & wolk , s. j. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201423454 [ , 565 , l1 ] preusse , s. , kopp , a. , bchner , j. , & motschmann , u. 2006 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361:20065353 [ , 460 , 317 ] raeder , j. , berchem , j. , & ashour - abdalla , m. 1998 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1029/98ja00014 [ , 103 , 14787 ] rville , v. , brun , a. s. , strugarek , a. , et al .
2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/814/2/99 [ , 814 , 99 ] saar , s. h. , cuntz , m. , & shkolnik , e. l. 2004 , http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2004iaus..219..355s [ , 219 , 355 ] saur , j. , grambusch , t. , duling , s. , neubauer , f. m. , & simon , s. 2013 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201118179 [ , 552 , 119 ] schrijver , c. , & derosa , m. 2003 , , 212 , 165 shkolnik , e. l. , bohlender , d. a. , walker , g. a. h. , & collier cameron , a. 2008 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/527351 [ , 676 , 628 ] strugarek , a. , brun , a. s. , donati , j .- f . , moutou , c. , & rville , v. 2016 , strugarek , a. , brun , a. s. , matt , s. p. , & rville , v. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/795/1/86 [ , 795 , 86 ] . 2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/815/2/111 [ , 815 , 111 ] trammell , g. b. , li , z .- y . , & arras , p. 2014
, http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/788/2/161 [ , 788 , 161 ] turner , j. d. , smart , b. m. , hardegree - ullman , k. k. , et al .
2013 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/sts061 [ , 428 , 678 ] vidotto , a. a. , fares , r. , jardine , m. , moutou , c. , & donati , j .- f .
2015 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stv618 [ , 449 , 4117 ] vidotto , a. a. , jardine , m. , morin , j. , et al .
2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stt2265 [ , 438 , 1162 ] vidotto , a. a. , opher , m. , jatenco - pereira , v. , & gombosi , t. i. 2009 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/703/2/1734 [ , 703 , 1734 ] . 2010 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/720/2/1262 [ , 720 , 1262 ] yelle , r. , lammer , h. , & ip , w .- h .
2008 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11214-008-9420-6 [ , 139 , 437 ] yokoyama , t. , & shibata , k. 1994 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1086/187666 [ , 436 , l197 ] zarka , p. 2007 ,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.pss.2006.05.045 [ , 55 , 598 ] zhang , m. , & penev , k. 2014 , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0004-637x/787/2/131 [ , 787 , 131 ]
in this appendix we give the critical parameters of all the models and the numerical results of the effective area @xmath24 and normalized poynting flux @xmath90 in table [ tab : tab0 ] .
we recall the reader that the simulated stellar wind is driven by a normalized sound speed @xmath114 corresponding to a coronal temperature of @xmath115 k for a solar - like star .
the rotation rate of the central star is defined by the velocity ratio @xmath116 , and the dipolar magnetic field of the star by a normalized alfvn speed of @xmath117 ( for more details see * ? ? ?
lccccc|cc 1 & & & 14.30 & & & 7.64 , 47.99 & 0.27 , 4.56 + 2 & 3.00 & 0.27 & 57.19 & 0 . & 0 . & 10.09 , 71.45 & 0.30 , 5.74 + 3 & & & 228.77 & & & 15.23 , 105.88 & 0.43 , 6.45 + 4 & & & 20.77 & & & 8.15 , 30.35 & 0.60 , 9.05 + 5 & 5.00 & 0.48 & 83.08 & 0 . & 0 . & 11.67 , 56.54 & 0.86 , 12.00 + 6 & & & 332.30 & & & 18.07 , 87.82 & 1.38 , 19.22 + 7 & & & 63.34 & & & 10.62 , 42.24 & 1.23 , 14.61 + 8 & 6.00 & 0.72 & 253.34 & 0 . & 0 . & 16.17 , 62.26 & 1.87 , 22.51 + 9 & & & 1013.37 & & & 24.77 , 92.80 & 2.99 , 35.01 + 10 & & & & 1.6 10@xmath118 & & 10.65 , 41.51 & 1.38 , 13.93 + 11 & 6.00 & 0.72 & 63.34 & 1.6 10@xmath119 & 0 . & 10.61 , 38.98 & 1.37 , 12.58 + 12 & & & & 1.6 10@xmath120 & & 310.58 , 6.04 & 1.36 , 9.76 + 13 & & & & & 1.6 10@xmath118 & 10.18 , 42.26 & 1.14 , 13.94 + 14 & 6.00 & 0.72 & 63.34 & 0 . & 8.8 10@xmath118 & 10.91 , 45.76 & 0.16 , 9.45 + 15 & & & & & 1.6 10@xmath119 & 10.62 , 46.21 & 0.04 , 7.28 + 16 & & & 153.26 & & & 10.15 , 43.52 & 3.30 , 38.72 + 17 & 7.00 & 1.20 & 613.03 & 0 . & 0 . & 15.46 , 65.58 & 5.52 , 60.06 + 18 & & & 2452.14 & & & 23.50 , 97.20 & 9.89 , 77.87 | planets in close - in orbit interact with the magnetized wind of their hosting star .
this magnetic interaction was proposed to be a source for enhanced emissions in the chromosphere of the star , and to participate in setting the migration time - scale of the close - in planet .
the efficiency of the magnetic interaction is know to depend on the magnetic properties of the host star , of the planet , and on the magnetic topology of the interaction .
we use a global , three - dimensional numerical model of close - in star planet systems , based on the magnetohydrodynamics approximation , to compute a grid of simulations for varying properties of the orbiting planet . we propose a simple parametrization of the magnetic torque that applies to the planet , and of the energy flux generated by the interaction .
the dependancy upon the planet properties and the wind properties are clearly identified in the derived scaling laws , which can be used in secular evolution codes to take into account the effect of magnetic interactions in planet migration .
they can also be used to estimate a potential magnetic source of enhanced emissions in observed close - in star - planet systems , in order to constrain observationally possible exoplanetary magnetic fields . |
the discovery of asymptotic freedom , one of the most significant properties of strong interactions embodied by quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) opened , more than 25 years ago , a new chapter in our understanding of the structure of matter which has has been actively followed by theoreticians and experimentalists ever since .
the short distance structure of hadrons , together with the production of jets in hadronic collisions are paradigmatic among the strong interaction phenomena successfully accounted by qcd and even though the standing of the theory is today well established , further theoretical refinements and the corresponding experimental validation renew constantly the original enthusiasm of the high energy physics community .
these lectures intend to provide an overview of the more recent topics of high energy collisions related in a way or another to perturbative qcd .
first we briefly remind the essentials of qcd , including the main features of partons ( the quarks and gluons ) , which are the true protagonists in the story . then
, we refer to what is known about the partonic structure of three of the main benchmarks of qcd , the proton , the photon , and the singlet colour or pomeron. finally we will try to draw the connections between their corresponding structures which in some way relate the physics made in the three main hep laboratories . as usual , many interesting and highly active topics have been excluded from the lectures in favor of a more detailed analysis of the covered points .
these include , for example , those related to the spin structure of the proton , which have driven an ongoing series of polarized experiments and a great deal of theoretical discussions @xcite ; heavy flavours , which involve very subtle theoretical approaches , and perturbative qcd beyond nlo , which is relevant for the most recent high precision experiments @xcite .
the strong interactions among quarks and gluons are described by quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) , the non - abelian gauge theory based on the gauge group @xmath1 .
each quark flavour corresponds to a colour triplet in the fundamental representation of @xmath2 and the gauge fields needed to maintain the gauge symmetry , the gluons , are in the adjoint representation of dimension 8 .
gauge invariance ensures that gluons are massless .
the qcd lagrangian may be written as _ qcd = - f^a_f^_a + |_i(i^d _ - m)_i where f^a _ = _ g^a _ - _ g^a _ + gf^abcg_bg_c stands for the gluon field tensor , @xmath3 are the quark fields and the covariant derivative is defined by @xmath4 the strong coupling is represented by @xmath5 and indices are summed over @xmath6 and over @xmath7 .
finally , @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the @xmath2 generators and structure constants , respectively , which are related by @xmath10 = i\,f_{abc}\,t^c$ ] . like in quantum electrodynamics ( qed )
, the procedure employed to deal consistently with the divergences that occur in the computation of strong interactions beyond the tree level , shows that the actual strength of the qcd coupling depends on the energy scale of the process .
but in opposition to qed , this renormalized strong coupling is small at high energy ( momentum ) , going to zero logarithmically , i.e. qcd has the property of _
asymptotic freedom_. consequently , in this regime perturbation theory is valid and tests against experimental data can be performed in terms of hadrons .
figure [ fig : pqcd ] summarize the basic qcd perturbative processes appearing in different circumstances .
( 150,50)(0,0 ) ( 44,-100 ) ( -27,-102 ) experiments with @xmath11 colliders provide clean results for qcd tests .
recently , a huge amount of experimental data came from the hera electron - proton collider @xcite and also from the tevatron at fermilab @xcite . in both cases
, there is a hadronic remnant that make the analysis a little more involved . all this experimental evidence support the existence of quarks being colour triplets of spin @xmath12 and of gluons being vector octets .
moreover , the presence of the qcd coupling has manifested itself in different measurements , as well as the above mentioned property of asymptotic freedom .
this information comes mainly from the study of the so called two- and three - jets events @xcite .
when a given process needs a higher order in perturbation theory to be known , it is necessary to compute not only the renormalized strong coupling constant but also the appropriate corrections to the relevant cross - sections . as is usual in quantum field theory ,
a regularization - renormalization procedure is in order , just to absorb divergences into the definition of physical quantities .
this prescription requires the introduction of a new scale @xmath13 , fixing the renormalization point , and all renormalized quantities begin to depend on it .
nevertheless , different prescriptions must end with the same predictions for observables . in order to illustrate how the general procedure works , ending with the renormalization group equations that guarantee that physical observables do not depend on the scale @xmath13 ,
let us show what happens with green functions .
just to remember the procedure , let us begin with a single particle irreducible green function @xmath14 .
in general , to control divergences , one has to introduce an ultra - violet cut - off @xmath15 , or the equivalent dimensional regularization parameter , in the loop momentum integral defining the @xmath14 . in a renormalizable theory , as qcd is , a renormalized green function is defined as @xmath16 where @xmath17 stands for the external particle momenta , @xmath18 and @xmath5 are the bare and the renormalized couplings , respectively .
this @xmath19 is then finite in the limit @xmath20 but it depends on the scale at which the value of the renormalized quantities are fixed , the prescription parameter @xmath13 .
the function @xmath21 is a product of renormalization factors . due to the fact that the unrenormalized @xmath22 is obviously independent of @xmath13
, one has to demand @xmath23 and consequently , the renormalization group equation ( rge ) ( + + ) _
r(p_i , g , ) = 0 has to be verified .
here @xmath24 is the _ anomalous dimension _ , depending on the particular green function under consideration , and the _ beta - function _ is universal = ( g ) = if there is only one large momentum scale @xmath25 , or @xmath26 as it is standard to quote , as it is the case here , one can express all @xmath17 in terms of a fixed fraction @xmath27 of @xmath25 .
then , defining the so called evolution variable t = ( ) it is possible to introduce the momentum dependent , or _ running _ coupling through the integral @xmath28 and the general solution of
the rge reads @xmath29\ ] ] this solution explicitly shows that the @xmath25-scale dependence of @xmath14 arises entirely through the running coupling @xmath30 .
introducing now the usual notation _
s = one can expand the beta - function in a power series in @xmath31 ( _ s ) = = - ^2_s - ^3_s - ... where it results @xcite that @xmath32 here @xmath33 indicates the number of flavours that can be excited ( with mass less than @xmath13 ) at the scale @xmath13 .
it is clear that the solution of the differential equation for @xmath31 introduces a constant , called @xmath34 , which has to be fixed by using experimental data .
the resulting @xmath31 can be written as @xmath35 } { \ln(\mu^2/\lambda_{qcd}^2)}\right\}\ ] ] this expression for the running coupling shows clearly the property of asymptotic freedom of qcd , i.e. , the coupling vanishes when the scale becomes asymptotic , namely @xmath36 .
consequently , in this momentum regime , perturbation theory is valid .
a very clear quantitative test of perturbative qcd is provided by the measurement of @xmath31 in different processes at different scales @xmath26 . in figure
[ fig : alfa ] there is a summary of the various determinations of @xmath31 @xcite .
the present world average @xcite for the coupling at the @xmath37 mass is @xmath38 which implies @xmath39 corresponding to five flavours excited and in the conventional @xmath40 prescription commonly used .
having reviewed the essentials of qcd , we now proceed with the analysis of one of the most rich benchmarks of perturbative qcd which is the short distance structure of the proton .
we start this section giving a set of definitions of the commonly used relativistic invariants related to deep inelastic scattering , dis , one of the fundamental experimental tools for hadron analysis , together with the corresponding formulae for the neutral and charged current cross - sections , where the structure functions are introduced .
these functions will be latter expressed in terms of the quark - parton model including qcd corrections . for a more detailed treatment
see @xcite ( 150,60)(0,0 ) ( 30,-72 ) the scattering of a lepton from a proton ( or in general a nucleon , a hadron or a nucleus ) , at high enough @xmath26 , can be viewed as the ( elastic ) scattering of the lepton from a quark or antiquark inside the proton mediated by the exchange of the corresponding virtual vector boson @xmath41 or @xmath42 .
consequently , when the process is totally inclusive ( one integrates over all final hadronic activity ) , can be fully described by two lorentz invariants . with the momentum assignment of figure [ fig : dis ]
one can construct the following invariants : s = ( p + k)^2 , t = ( p - p^)^2 , w^2 = ( p + q)^2 , q^2 = - ( k^ - k)^2 = - q^2 defined as the centre of mass energy squared , the square of the four - momentum transfer between the proton and the final hadronic state , the invariant mass squared of the final hadronic state , and four momentum transfer squared between the lepton and the proton , respectively .
it is also convenient to introduce dimensionless invariants ( scaling variables ) y = , x = i.e. the inelasticity of the scattered lepton , and fraction of the proton momentum carried by the struck quark , or bjorken variable , respectively .
notice finally that , ignoring masses , q^2 = sxy w^2 = q^2 so that @xmath43 , the center of mass energy squared , and small values of @xmath44 imply increasing @xmath45 .
as we have already said , in principle one is allowed to use any pair of these invariants to describe totally inclusive dis .
usually @xmath44 and @xmath26 are the preferred ones .
another interesting point to remark concerns the resolving power of a dis experiment .
clearly , the size @xmath46 one can resolve inside the nucleon becomes smaller for large photon , or gauge boson in general , virtuality , namely @xmath47 the ` magnifying power ' is then @xmath48 for @xmath49 , and @xmath50 and for @xmath51 .
different dis experiments cover different regions of the kinematical plane ( @xmath52 ) as shown in figure [ fig : kdis ] @xcite .
it is particularly interesting the very extended range covered by hera : @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
the kinematics of the dis events , namely the two invariants required to specify dis processes , can be determined ( particularly at hera ) from measurements on the electron ( the lepton ) alone , on the final hadronic state corresponding to the struck quark alone or on a mixture of both . in general , the preferred method depends on the particular kinematical region of interest , strongly correlated with the detector performance .
the input are the energy @xmath55 of the final electron and the electron scattering angle @xmath56 measured with respect to the proton beam direction ( @xmath57 means zero electron scattering angle ) @xmath58 the input is the hadronic energy @xmath59 and the three - momentum components of the hadronic system .
they are computed as the sum over all final state hadrons @xmath60
@xmath61 this method is also known with the name jacquet - blondel , because these authors were able to show that the contribution from hadrons lost in the beam pipe is negligible .
this method is based on both electron and hadron measurements .
the denominator of @xmath62 is replaced by a sum over all final state particles including the scattered electron ( certainly equal to @xmath63 due to energy - momentum conservation ) .
the name of the method comes from the introduction of the variable @xmath64 that appears in @xmath65 notice that the denominator in @xmath66 is twice the true incident electron energy in the eventual case when the electron radiates photons that are not detected .
there are other more sophisticated methods , well adapted to particular situations , like the so - called double angle method or the pt method used by zeus @xcite .
the fundamental measurement in dis experiments concerns the totally inclusive cross - section for @xmath67 as a function of the kinematical variables defined above . for charged lepton - nucleon scattering mediated by the neutral current ,
the spin averaged cross - section is given in terms of the structure functions @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 @xmath71\end{aligned}\ ] ] here
@xmath72 is the qed coupling constant . for @xmath26 values below the @xmath37 scale ,
the parity violating effects related to @xmath70 are negligible and all the process is due to @xmath73 exchange . remember also that the longitudinal structure function @xmath69 , a qcd correction important for large @xmath74 , is defined in terms of the standard @xmath75 and @xmath68 , related to the transverse and longitudinal @xmath76 cross sections respectively , as f_l(x , q^2 ) = f_2(x , q^2)(1 + ) - 2xf_1(x , q^2 ) and that in the naive quark - parton model , really valid at extremely high @xmath26 , where quarks are considered free , massless , having spin @xmath12 and without any @xmath77 developed , @xmath69 is zero because the callan - gross relation @xmath78 is satisfied . under this assumptions ,
the so called bjorken scaling is fully satisfied , namely , structure functions are only function of the @xmath44 variable .
the ratio @xmath79 is defined by r(x , q^2 ) = = which is obviously zero in the callan - gross limit and can be interpreted as the ratio of cross - sections for the absorption of transversely and longitudinally polarized virtual photons on nucleon .
the differential cross - section ( [ eq : cs ] ) can be rewritten in terms of @xmath80 as @xmath81\,f_2(x , q^2)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the parity violating contribution was discarded .
it is possible to specify the structure function @xmath68 in terms of the partons ( or better quarks ) within the nucleon as follows f_2(x , q^2 ) = x_fe^2_q_f[eq : qqb ] where the sum runs over all momentum distributions of quarks of the different flavours @xmath82 excited ( @xmath83 ) and antiquarks ( @xmath84 ) contained in the nucleon and @xmath85 stands for the the different parton - photon couplings , namely their electric charges .
notice that the previous expression ( [ eq : qqb ] ) is valid only in leading order of perturbation theory .
in fact , there one has included the explicit @xmath26 dependence which is the effect of implementing first order perturbative qcd .
however , there is a particular renormalization and factorization scheme that can be used in higher order qcd , the so called dis - scheme , where one can retain that expression at any order of perturbation theory .
in other schemes , like the usual @xmath40 one , the expressions for the structure functions are more involved , including in general @xmath86 , the gluon density in the nucleon .
let us now refer for a moment to the inclusive reaction that goes via charged current _ + n ^- + x where as usual we write @xmath87 for an isoscalar nucleon . in
the qcd improved parton model , the corresponding cross section reads = ( ) ^2 @xmath88 stands for the charged intermediate boson mass .
@xmath89 is the fermi constant .
the quark and antiquark distribution functions can be written in terms of the corresponding valence and sea flavour distributions in a proton as @xmath90 one can introduce immediately the corresponding structure function @xmath68 for neutrino scattering .
it is of interest to compare this @xmath91 with the one for charged lepton dis written above .
taking into account the sea corrections , the relation between both @xmath68 functions results = ( 1 - ) this relation compares well with experimental data @xcite .
all the functions introduced above include an explicit @xmath26 dependence .
this fact reflects the presence of interactions among partons .
clearly , the parton model , that implies exact bjorken scaling , has to be modified to include these interactions .
moreover , quarks and gluons are finally confined within hadrons by the non - abelian gauge interaction in qcd .
even if qcd is with us for more than 25 years , it has not yet been possible to calculate in detail the structure of hadrons starting from quarks , gluons and their gauge interactions , making compatible the short distance almost free partons with the long distance confinement .
this fact , related to the running character of the strong interaction strength that we have discussed above , is on the origin of our continuous use of structure ( and fragmentation and fracture ) functions in describing dis .
fortunately enough , some _ factorization theorems _ , which are valid in qcd , allows one to split the problem into a perturbative part and a non - perturbative part . in other words ,
the cross - section can be expressed as the folding of the initial parton distribution function @xmath92 , a non - perturbative input given the density of partons @xmath82 in the nucleon , with a lepton - parton cross - section that can be computed by means of perturbation theory inside qcd .
this fact can be schematically written as @xmath93 and consequently , it can be sketched as in figure [ fig : fac ] ( 170,110)(0,0 ) ( 50,-155 ) it is clear that the non - perturbative part , namely , the part related to structure functions , has to be determined by fitting experimental data .
nevertheless , they are universal in the sense that once obtained from a given particular process , they can be used in connection with any other one .
regarding qcd as an improvement of the quark - parton model , we can say that the nucleon is not simply composed of three point - like quarks , the so called _ valence _ quarks but as soon as @xmath26 increases , the vector boson ( @xmath73 , @xmath42 or @xmath94 ) increasingly resolves the composition of the nucleon .
one of the targets that the vector boson could find is one of the quarks , called _ sea _ quarks , which originate from a gluon , namely through @xmath95 being this gluon itself radiated from one of the valence quarks . in other words ,
increasing @xmath26 means that the resolution of our view " of the nucleon increases , so that the effective number of partons sharing the nucleon momentum also increases .
consequently , the probability of finding partons with small @xmath44 has increased while the corresponding one to large @xmath44 has decreased .
this process clearly entails a violation of bjorken scaling through a @xmath26 dependence , that was born from qcd interactions . consequently , to compare experimental data with qcd predictions .
one has to compute perturbative qcd corrections to the fundamental process v^ q q [ eq : vq ] nowadays , these corrections , even if the calculation is very involved , are well known up to order @xmath96 @xcite .
we give here only an introductory discussion of the lowest order corrections .
the relevant diagrams corresponding to the first terms of the perturbative expansion in @xmath31 for the process ( [ eq : vq ] ) are presented in figure [ fig : oas ] ( we have omitted the vertex and self energy gluonic corrections , which are associated to the ultraviolet divergences .
these are removed through coupling constant renormalization , and lead to the running coupling @xmath97 given in equation ( [ eq : al ] ) ) ( 170,155)(0,0 ) ( 40,90 ) ( 100,90 ) ( 190,90 ) ( 70,20 ) ( 160,20 ) because we are considering the inclusive case , the calculation implies phase space integrations which lead to divergent integrals when partons become collinear .
they have to be regularized by means of dimensional regularization @xcite , a cut - off in the transverse momentum of the partons , or giving them masses .
any of these procedures introduce a regulator @xmath98 which has the dimension of the energy scale @xmath26 .
for example , to order @xmath31 , quarks contribute to the structure function @xmath68 through the following convolution integral @xmath99\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath100 is the ` bare ' quark density .
the delta function term comes from the lowest order diagram in figure [ fig : oas ] , and represents the corresponding contribution to @xmath68 as in equation ( 25 ) .
the first term between the curly brackets includes the factor @xmath101 which diverges as the regulator @xmath98 goes to zero and is associated to the collinear gluon emission diagrams , while the second term collects the finite contributions from those diagrams . @xmath102 and @xmath103 are known calculable functions .
the collinear singularities of course threaten the validity of the parton model , however they can be consistently removed from the partonic subprocess absorbing them into the ` bare ' parton densities @xmath100 defining renormalized parton densities @xmath104 where @xmath105 is factorization scale chosen to separate the short distance ( ` partonic ' ) effects from the long distance ( ` hadronic ' ) ones . for the parton model to make sense , the renormalized parton densities must be process independent , i.e. must be the same for dis , drell - yan , and any other process .
fortunately , this proves to be the case to all orders of perturbation theory , and one ends up with an expression for the ( physical , and thus finite ) structure function @xmath106 in terms of a finite renormalized parton density @xmath107 and an also finite partonic cross section @xmath108\end{aligned}\ ] ] at this point , it is customary to chose the factorization scale @xmath105 equal to the energy scale @xmath26 , factorizing the scale dependence of the cross sections into the parton densities .
the crucial observation here is that although perturbation theory can not make an absolute prediction for @xmath109 , from equation ( 25 ) it follows @xmath110\end{aligned}\ ] ] which means that qcd actually gives the @xmath26 dependence of the parton distributions . by means of a similar procedure with the gluon densities ,
one can deal with the divergences in the diagrams initiated by gluons .
however , due to the possibility of gluons emitting quark pairs which then interact with the photon probe , the evolution the evolution of the quark and gluon densities is no longer independent , but coupled .
taking into account all the @xmath111 contributions , we end up with the so called dglap equations ( or altarelli - parisi equations for short ) @xmath112 \nonumber \\ \frac{dg(x , q^2)}{d \ln q^2}&=&\frac{\alpha_s}{2\pi}\int_{x}^{1}\frac{dy}{y } \left[\sum_i q_i(y , q^2)\ , p_{gq}\left(\frac{x}{y}\right ) + g(y , q^2)\ , p_{gg}\left(\frac{x}{y}\right ) \right ] \label{eq : ap}\end{aligned}\ ] ] collecting all the @xmath111 contributions to @xmath106 , we finally arrive to the most usual expression for the structure function : @xmath113 \\ \nonumber & & + c_g(x ) \otimes g(x , q^2)\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath114 indicates a convolution integral and the index @xmath5 refers to gluons .
deep inelastic scattering ( dis ) experiments and hadron - hadron interactions provide information on the parton structure of the nucleon and constraints the dynamics of the quark - gluon interaction given by qcd . in figure
[ fig : kdis ] the kinematic regions in @xmath44 and @xmath26 for cross section measurements in dis @xmath115 scattering , @xmath116 scattering and jets in @xmath117 collisions were presented .
data from the last years @xcite have a clear influence on parton distributions and have motivated the update of parton distribution function analysis .
thes most recent sets are cteq5 @xcite , grv98 @xcite and mrst @xcite .
the data playing a fundamental paper in these updates are the more precise zeus and h1 determinations of @xmath118 including @xmath119 ; the nmc and ccfr final muon - nucleon and neutrino data ; the e866 @xmath120 and @xmath121 lepton pair production asymmetry ; the @xmath45 charge rapidity asymmetry ; the d0 and cdf analysis of inclusive single jet production and the e706 direct photon production .
it should be remarked that both approaches differ in the selection of data for the global analysis that are sensitive to gluons at large values of @xmath44 .
this means that a better understanding of the gluon behaviour at large @xmath44 is in order .
the @xmath68 structure function measurements at hera cover a wide range of five orders of magnitude in both @xmath44 and @xmath26 values as shown in figure [ fig : kdis ] .
one important point established by these data refers to the rise of the structure function with decreasing @xmath44 .
moreover , qcd fits including nlo ( next to leading order corrections ) performed by the experimental collaborations are in very good agreement with the data even at low values of @xmath122 . in figure
[ fig : f2hera ] , @xmath68 is presented as a function of @xmath26 for fixed values of @xmath44 from h1 , zeus and the previous experiments , together with the qcd fit @xcite .
figure [ fig : nuccfr ] presents de neutrino and antineutrino cross section as a function of @xmath74 and different values of @xmath44 @xcite .
data comes from the ccfr fermilab experiment and is presented for @xmath123 .
a good agreement with previous data is observed and the nlo qcd analysis is satisfactory .
we finish this paragraph with a brief comment about some qcd technical details .
the use of the renormalization group result for @xmath31 in the ap approach , specifically the replacement of @xmath31 by @xmath97 in equation ( [ eq : ap ] ) , has an important consequence . for each order of perturbation in @xmath31 where the factorization procedure is performed ,
a whole series of perturbative contributions is efectively re - summed , in addition to the contributions comming form the corresponding diagrams shown in figure [ fig : oas ] .
this kind of contributions are depicted in figure [ fig : ldd ] , the so called _ ladder _ diagrams .
( 150,75)(0,0 ) ( 25,-85 ) it can be shown that the improved ap approach takes into account contributions coming from the sum of all ladder diagrams in which the transverse momenta along the sides of the ladder are strongly ordered , namely : @xmath124 .
this condition , of course implies also a strong ordering for the momenta of the emitted partons .
notice that the calculation of such a n - th order ladder diagram implies integrations over the internal momenta .
this nested integration can be carried out because of the @xmath125 ordering imposed , giving rise to results proportional to powers of @xmath97 and @xmath126 .
now , it is clear that large logarithms in @xmath26 compensate the small values of @xmath97 , that as we have seen , decreases logarithmically .
consequently , all graph with rungs up to @xmath127 would have to be summed up .
the so called _ leading log _ approximation ( lo ) , which is equivalent to follow the renormalization group improved ap approach up to order @xmath31 , collects all the contributions proportional to @xmath128^n\ ] ] while the _ next to leading log _ approximation ( nlo ) , equivalent to the second order extension of the ap approach , also includes contributions proportional to @xmath128^{n-1}\ ] ] the ap approximation is expected to be valid for @xmath26 values sufficiently large but also for @xmath44 not too small , just to ensure that small values of @xmath44 do not give rise to other large logarithms . in other words ,
@xmath129 in is worth remarking that the ap equations can be solved analytically when a strong ordering in @xmath44 is also requiered . in this way
one ends with the _
double leading log approximation _ ,
( dll ) , where the large logarithmic terms are of the form @xcite @xmath130^n\ ] ] this approximation is expected to be valid for large @xmath26 and small @xmath44 . at small values of @xmath44 , the parton content of
the proton is gluon dominated . in this case
the ap dll can be obtained with the result xg(x , q^2 ) x g_0(x , q_0 ^ 2 ) exp [ eq : dll ] that shows that the gluon density increases faster than a power of @xmath131 . in some cases of interest
, @xmath44 is small enough but @xmath26 is not sufficiently large to be inside the dll regime . under these circumstances
, the ap approximation is not more valid .
the bfkl ( balitsky , fadin , kuraev , lipatov ) equation has been proposed to tackle the limit behaviour of large @xmath132 and @xmath26 finite and fixed . in this scheme , the @xmath27 variables in the ladder are stongly ordered , namely : @xmath133 ; while there is no order on @xmath125 imposed .
this approach ends with the so called leading log approximation in @xmath134 .
the region of validity being @xmath135 due to technical reasons , the bfkl equation is written in terms of the function @xmath136 , related to the usual gluon density @xmath86 that dominates at very small @xmath44 by xg(x , q^2 ) = ^q^2_0 dk_t^2 the standard form of the equation is = k_t^2_0^ this approximate bfkl equation can be solved analytically for fixed @xmath31 .
the solution behaves like @xmath137 with = 42 0.5 for @xmath138 and @xmath139 .
consequently , the gluon density rises like a power of @xmath132 for decreasing @xmath44 , namely @xmath140 clearly faster than the ap dll prediction ( [ eq : dll ] ) .
it should be noticed that a running @xmath31 and higher order corrections decrease the value of @xmath141 .
( 150,80)(0,0 ) ( 80,11 ) ( 15,10 ) assuming that gluons dominate at low @xmath44 one can expect an approximate behaviour for the structure function given by @xmath142 figure [ fig : xlambda ] ( a ) shows the values obtained for @xmath143 as a function of @xmath26 from fits to zeus and e665 data .
figure [ fig : xlambda ] ( b ) shows @xmath144 as a function of @xmath44 @xcite . in both figures
qcd and regge inspired fits have been included .
the schematic map of the plane @xmath145 shown in figure [ fig : q2x ] intents to divide the regions where each of the two approaches , dglap and bfkl , are in order @xcite .
( 150,70)(0,0 ) ( 35,12 ) in the figure , a _ saturation _ region is indicated , where one waits the gluon density to be so high as to prevent its continuous growing .
in the analysis of hadron structure , more information can be obtained if one goes one step beyond totally inclusive dis , namely to semi - inclusive dis , where one of the final hadrons is also measured @xmath146 in describing semi - inclusive processes , in addition to quark distributions , the so called _ fragmentation functions _ are necesary .
these functions @xcite describe , or better parametrize , a given parton decay into a final hadron .
it is clear that , in principle , the best process to analyze fragmentation functions is the semi - inclusive @xmath147 annihilation , when a single hadron is fully detected in the final state @xmath148 the corresponding kinematics is depicted in figure [ fig : fra ] .
( 150,60)(0,0 ) ( 15,-92 ) the relevant variables for this case are z = = it is also convenient to introduce @xmath149 that measures the fraction of the parton momentum carried by the final hadron .
the corresponding cross section reads @xmath150 here @xmath151 is the parton @xmath152 production cross - section , that in the parton model results ^i_p(,q^2)= e_i^2(1- ) if @xmath153 and vanishes if @xmath154 .
the function @xmath155 is the _ fragmentation function _ or probability for a parton @xmath152 to decay into a hadron @xmath60 carrying the fraction @xmath149 of the parton momentum .
when qcd corrections are in order , the fragmentation functions acquire a @xmath26 dependence .
the evolution of these functions with the scale t= ( ) is given by the ap - like integrodifferential equations @xmath156 \\
\frac{dd^h_{g}}{dt}(z , t ) & = & \frac{\alpha_s(q^2)}{2\,\pi}\,\int_z^1 \frac{dy}{y}\,\left[d^h_{q}{dt}(y , t)\,p_{qg}(z / y ) + d^h_{g}{dt}(y , t)\,p_{gg}(z / y)\right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] the functions @xmath157 are exactly the same as those appearing in the ap equations for the structure functions ( [ eq : ap ] ) .
the corresponding graphical interpretation in terms of the basic qcd processes is included in figure [ fig : apf ] .
( 150,50)(0,0 ) ( 64,-95 ) ( -2,-95 ) it is worth noticing that the properties of the splitting functions are enough to guarantee the momentum sum rule _
h_0 ^ 1 zd^h_q(z , q^2 ) = 1 and the analogous one for the gluon fragmentation function . to solve the ap equations it is necessary to know the fragmentation functions at some value @xmath158 .
exactly as in the case of structure functions , they have to be obtained from experimental data . in general
one proposes a given form for the initial @xmath159-function , in agreement with data , and then ap equations provide the evolution with @xmath26 . for
those who are not acquainted with fracture functions , let us briefly summarize that the main idea behind fracture functions is the realization that the most familiar perturbative description for semi - inclusive processes , based on parton distributions and fragmentation functions is , at least , incomplete @xcite . in the usual approach to semi - inclusive dis ,
the corresponding cross section is expressed by a convolution between parton distributions and fragmentation functions accounting the process in which the struck parton hadronizes into a detected final state particle .
@xmath160 obviously , this approach only takes into account hadrons produced in the current fragmentation region , and what is more , within this approximation , and in leading order , hadrons can only be produced in the backward direction .
going to higher orders one finds a breakdown of hard factorization , as there are collinear singularities that can not be substracted in the parton distributions or in the fragmentation functions .
all this means that there are additional contributions missing , which are mainly target fragmentation processes and are included in the so called fracture functions @xmath161 , defined by @xmath162 these functions , that can be thought as the probabilities to find a parton of a given flavour in an already fragmentated target , straightforwardly solve the factorization problem and also allow a lo description of hadrons produced in the forward direction .
the only subtlety regarding them is that they obey slightly different evolution equations ; their scale dependence not only depends on their shape at a given scale but also on that of ordinary structure functions and fragmentation functions , reflecting the fact that current and target fragmentation are not truly independent of each other .
this is usually refered to as ` non homogeneus ' evolution @xmath163 as for structure functions in totally inclusive deep inelastic scattering , qcd does not predict the shape of fracture functions unless it is known at a given initial scale . this nonperturbative information have to be obtained from the experiment , and , eventually , can be parametrized finding inspiration in nonperturbative models , as it is the case for ordinary structure and fragmentation functions .
fracture functions have been succesfully applied to the description of leading baryon production @xcite , have been extended to spin dependent processes @xcite , and as we shall see , are relevant for the description of diffractive dis .
it may seem strange that the next step in our study of parton structure relies in a particle , the photon , that it is not a hadron and of course has no structure by itself , as we very well know .
however , a high energy photon can ` develop ' structure when interacting with another object .
in fact , as the electromagnetic field couples to all particles carrying the electromagnetic current , a photon can fluctuate into particle - antiparticle virtual states , particularly into quark - antiquark pairs or even more complex hadronic objects with the same quantum numbers .
as long a the fluctuation time is longer than the interaction time we can talk about the structure of the the photon , and deal with it as a ` very special ' hadron .
notice that at high energies , the fluctuation of a photon into a state of invariant mass @xmath164 can persist for a time of the order of @xmath165 until the virtual state materializes by a collision or annihilation with another system @xcite .
( 150,60)(0,0 ) ( 33,-66 ) there are many reasons for this peculiar hadronic structure to be considered ` matter ' of study .
first of all , it gives the opportunity to study how qcd works in a completely different scenario .
theoretical studies of photonic parton distributions of real , i.e. on shell , photons have a long history initiated by witten s work @xcite .
this description have been well established through measurements in @xmath166 collisions at @xmath167 colliders ( petra , pep , lep ) however , extending the idea of photon structure to high virtualities as in @xmath115 processes like dijet production , a new insight has been gained as we link dis , photoproduction , and @xmath166 interactions @xcite . the concept of photon structure functions for real and virtual photons can be defined and understood in close analogy to deep inelastic lepton nucleon scattering , via the subproccess @xmath168 in @xmath169 as in figure [ fig : e+e- ] , where we denote the probed target photon with virtuality @xmath170 by @xmath171 and reserve @xmath172 for the highly virtual one . the relevant differential cross section can be expressed , as in the hadronic case , in terms of the usual scaling variables @xmath44 and @xmath74 as @xmath173\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath174 denoting the photonic structure functions .
the measured @xmath0 cross section is obtained by convoluting equation([eq : photon ] ) with the photon flux for the target photon @xmath171 @xcite .
the range of photon virtualities explored in the above mentioned experiment is given by @xmath175 where @xmath176 is the mass of the electron , @xmath177 is the square of the c.m.s .
energy , @xmath74 is the energy fraction taken by the photon , and @xmath178 is the maximum scattering angle of the electron in the c.m.s
@xmath179 are further determined by detector specifications and experimental settings .
( 150,55)(0,0 ) ( 7,-60 ) ( 67,-60 ) it is worthwhile noticing that if one could neglect photon fluctuations into complex hadronic states , then the dependence of @xmath174 in both @xmath44 and @xmath26 would be fully predictable in perturbative qcd .
the pointlike process @xmath180 , corrected by gluon radiation effects , yields a definite prediction for @xmath174 .
however , as it was anticipated , this is only the so called ` direct ' contribution to the total process , named in opposition to the ` resolved ' one , where the virtual photon @xmath172 strikes the nonperturbative ` dressing ' of the photon fluctuation ( fig.[fig : dires ] ) .
( 150,88)(0,0 ) ( 30,10 ) qcd corrections to the ` direct ' component not only take into account the splitting of partons into partons as in the ordinary ap evolution equations , but also the possibility of a photon to split into a quark - antiquark pair .
this implies an inhomogeneous term in the evolution equations and leads to a logarithmic enhancement in @xmath174 which means positive scaling violations for all values of @xmath44 ( fig.[fig : phq^2 ] ) @xcite .
the ` resolved ' component obeys the same evolution equations typical of the lepton - hadron interactions . in a vector meson dominance approach for the photon fluctuations ,
the resolved component is expected to vanish like @xmath181 in connection to the vector meson propagator , however it is not clear up to which values of @xmath182 the nonperturbative contributions are relevant . in recent years several sets of parton distributions for real and virtual photons have been proposed @xcite . for virtual photons , different approaches have been followed in lo y nlo global fits to the available lep data ( figure [ fig : f2 g ] ) @xcite .
( 150,110)(0,0 ) ( 25,-10 ) lep data constraint reasonably well the quark distributions in the photon , however , in order to constrain the gluon densitiy it is much more suitable to analyze dijet production processes in @xmath183 collisions as measured at hera .
as we shall see , in this context the picture of ` direct ' and ` resolved ' is also more clearly illustrated . in this kind of process
the parton content of the proton is used to probe the iqi partonic structure of the photon as in a hadron - hadron collision .
the hard scale invoked to allow such inspection and guarantee the validity of a perturbative treatment , is the large transverse momentum of the final state jets .
figure [ fig : dijet ] depicts lo ` direct ' and ` resolved ' contributions to dijet production @xmath183 collisions .
as it can be seen , even at the lowest order , photonic gluons contribute to the cross section , at variance with what happens in @xmath167 collisions .
( 150,55)(0,0 ) ( 7,-60 ) ( 67,-60 ) in leading order the differential cross section for two jet production in @xmath115 collisions takes a very simple form when written in terms of the fraction of the photon energy intervening in the hard process , @xmath184 , the fraction of the proton energy carried by the participating parton , @xmath185 , and that of the electron carried by the photon , @xmath186 @xcite @xmath187 here , @xmath77 is the transverse momentum of the jets , @xmath182 is the photon virtuality , and @xmath26 is the relevant energy scale of the proccess , taken in this case equal to @xmath188 .
@xmath189 represents the hard parton - parton and parton - photon cross sections @xcite .
the functions @xmath190 and @xmath191 denote the parton distribution functions for the photon and the proton , respectively .
the first one reduces to @xmath192 -the probability for finding a photon in a photon- for direct contributions , i.e. those in which the photon participates as such in the hard process .
@xmath193 is the unintegrated weizscker - williams distribution @xcite @xmath194 which has been shown to be a very good approximation for the distribution of photons in the electron , provided the photon virtuality is much smaller than the relevant energy scale @xcite .
( 150,75)(0,0 ) ( 8,12 ) ( 92,13.5 ) the differential cross section in equation([eq : dijeq ] ) can also be written in terms of the parton pseudorapidities @xmath195 and @xmath196 , which are constrained by the experimental settings , and the electron and proton energies @xmath197 and @xmath198 @xcite .
both pairs of variables are related to the energy fractions by @xmath199 kinematical restrictions constrain @xmath200 to lay in the interval @xmath201 $ ] , @xmath185 in @xmath202 $ ] and @xmath186 in @xmath203 $ ] .
( 150,65)(0,0 ) ( 45,-8 ) in the lowest order of qcd the ` direct ' contribution is characterized by @xmath204 , which means that all the energy of the photon participates in the hard interaction .
allowing gluon corrections , ` direct ' contributions may come from @xmath205 , however one should expect them concentrated arround a peak at high @xmath184 .
conversely , ` resolved ' contributions should be more copious al low @xmath184 as for ordinary hadrons .
in fact , this trend is shown by the measurements , as can be seen in figure [ fig : dir / res]a @xcite .
the variable @xmath206 used there to approximate @xmath184 is the jet level equivalent of equation ( [ eq : xg ] ) @xmath207 where @xmath208 and @xmath209 refer to the transverse energies and pseudorapidities of the measured jets instead of those of the partons .
of course , the relative abundance of ` direct ' and ` resolved ' events depends strongly on the virtuality of the photon as can be seen in figure [ fig : dir / res]b in accordance to the expectation about the suppression of the ` resolved ' component as the virtuality increases @xcite .
finally , it is quite instructive to anlyze the relative abundance of quark and gluon initiated contributions as a function of @xmath184 in a typical @xmath210 dijet cross section . in figure
[ fig : q / g ] data obtained by h1 is compared to theoretical expectations based on a montecarlo analysis using grv parton distribution for the photon @xcite and for the proton @xcite .
notice that at large @xmath184 the ` resolved ' component is clearly dominated by quarks , however as @xmath184 decreases , the photonic gluons become dominant .
in this section we draw our attention to a much more unfamiliar object , at least for the younger generation of physicists , although for some of us it may be an old acquaintance .
we are talking about the _ pomeron _ , or in more modern language , about the colour singlet object which is exchanged when particles undergo strong interactions while preserving its nature .
the possibility of studying the partonic structure of this old friend has been made real by a very recent generation of experiments and has added an extra quota of excitement in perturbative qcd .
before we plunge ourselves into the partonic structure of the pomeron , it would be very helpful to first fetch some of the tools used in past to sail in those waters . before the advent of qcd ,
the presence of structures in the differential cross - sections was mainly explained by means of dynamical exchange mechanisms like in the so called
_ peripheral model_. in this approach it is found that there is a clear enhancement near the forward direction whenever the crossed channel of the reaction has the quantum numbers of a known particle . then , peripheralism proposes to express the scattering amplitude as a sum of contributions corresponding to the exchange of a particle .
namely @xmath211 with @xmath212 where it is clear that for small , physical ( negative ) , values of @xmath213 , there are peaks in the corresponding cross - section in s - channel , proportional to @xmath214 .
the indices @xmath215 represent pions , vector bosons , etc . , and their masses hierarchize each contribution .
the explanation of peripheral events can not be found in qcd , since the exchanged particle is not a gauge boson that can be treated perturbatively .
in fact the particles involved are composite objects such mesons or baryons . when the exchanged particle has a spin @xmath216 , the previous expression for the amplitude has to be replaced by @xmath217 and , if one remembers that the scattering angle in the @xmath213-channel reads @xmath218 it is found that the numerator of @xmath219 behaves asymptotically as @xmath220 for fixed @xmath213 .
this is not tenable because the froissart bound is not satisfied for @xmath221 .
moreover , that expression is purely real and does not satisfy the principle of analyticity .
there is a way out of the above mentioned difficulties , while maintaining the spirit of an exchange mechanism , now of an entire family of related particles .
this proposal is based on the regge poles ideas .
these ideas emerge naturally in potential scattering theory through the analyticity properties of the amplitude .
the regge pole model @xcite is based then , upon the assumption of the following behaviour for the scattering amplitude _
s , fixedtf(s , t ) _ i _
i(t)()^_i(t ) here @xmath222 is called the signature of the corresponding regge pole . the functions @xmath223 are called _ regge trajectories _ and @xmath224 residues of the poles that in general factorize between the initial and the final channels .
both functions @xmath223 and @xmath224 are analytic functions of @xmath213 .
the high energy model so introduced is understood as an exchange model where the regge trajectories @xmath223 are such that they pass through the spin values of the particles , or better the resonances , each time positive @xmath213 takes the values of their mass squared . in this way
, the collective effect of the exchange of all members of the family is taken into account .
clearly , the froissart bound ( total cross - sections can not increase faster than @xmath225 ) is satisfied as soon as @xmath226 in the space - like region of negative @xmath213 , relevant for the sacttering process .
let us take as an example the case of pion - nucleon charge - exchange @xmath227 that has always been the paradigmatic case of reggeology .
the @xmath213-channel of this reaction is @xmath228 having the quantum numbers ; @xmath229 , @xmath230 , @xmath231 . @xmath232 that correspond to the well known meson resonances @xmath233 of spin 1 and @xmath234 of spin 3 .
this sequence of resonances defines precisely the meson regge trajectory of isospin @xmath235 , g - parity @xmath236 and positive signature that is noted @xmath237 .
the continuation of this trajectory to negative @xmath213 values , takes us into the physical region corresponding to the @xmath238-channel charge - exchange reaction .
the parameters of a standard linear trajectory are the intercept at @xmath239 and the slope . in the present case , as it is shown in figure [ fig : rho ]
, they are ( 150,50)(0,0 ) ( 15,-95 ) @xmath240 respectively .
consequently , the differential cross section has the behaviour @xmath241 but what happens if the crossed channel of the reaction , and correspondingly the eventual exchanged object , has the quantum numbers of the vacuum ?
the answer arrives in the following paragraphs .
landau and his collaborators , in the fifties , introduced the term diffraction in high energy physics used in complete analogy with the well known phenomenon in optics that occurs when light interacts with obstacles or holes whose dimensions are of the order of the electromagnetic radiation wavelength .
the interaction of a hadron could be think as the absorption of its wave function caused by the different channels open at high energy and consequently the name diffraction seems to be intuitive .
for a recent review of this topic see @xcite . in the fraunhofer limit , namely when
the product of the wave number times the area @xmath242 of the obstacle is of the order of the observation distance , the energy distribution at the observation point , given by the kirchoff formula , can be written as @xmath243 where @xmath244 stands for the impact parameter , @xmath245 is the position of @xmath242 , @xmath246 is the 2-d momentum transfer and the scattering matrix is expressed as @xmath247 in terms of the so called profile function @xmath248 . from the expression for @xmath249 , one can immediately obtain the scattering amplitude f ( ) = d^2b()e^i i.e. : given as the 2-d fourier transform of the profile function .
when the function @xmath14 is spherically symmetric , the integral becomes a bessel transform , namely @xmath250 meaning that if the profile function is merely a disk of radius @xmath79 , the amplitude reduces to the black - disk form @xmath251 the prediction coming from this very simple model is a series of diffractive maxima and minima , entirely similar to the case in optics , and have been clearly observed in several experiments in the specific field of particle physics , diffraction is said to be the dominant process of scattering at high energy if no quantum numbers are exchanged between the colliding particles .
in other words , diffraction dominates asymptotically as soon as the particles in the final state have the same quantum numbers of the incident ones .
this sort of definition of diffraction clearly includes , for the two body scattering , three cases : elastic scattering , single diffraction and double diffraction . in the first process
the outgoing particles are exactly the same as the incident ones . in the second case ,
one incident particles goes out unmodified while the second one gives rise to a resonance , or to a bunch of final particles , with total quantum numbers coincident with its own ones .
finally , when double diffraction occurs , each incident particle gives rise to a resonance , or to a bunch of final particles , with the same quantum numbers of the initial ones .
it is possible to discuss diffraction from the viewpoint of an exchange model , in particular within the framework of reggeology .
remember that we have found precisely that an enhancement in the differential cross section can be expected whenever the quantum numbers of the crossed channel correspond to an existing particle .
however , in the elastic case at high energies , all the hadronic systems show the diffraction peak while the exchange of a given particle gives rise to different contributions in different systems .
moreover , via the optical theorem , the forward elastic amplitude is connected to the total cross section and this fact can not be understood in terms of only one exchange process .
nevertheless , the diffraction peak can be interpreted in terms of a special trajectory that summarizes all the diffractive contributions and has the vacuum quantum numbers : the _ pomeron_. its contribution to the amplitude is f_dif(s , t ) = - _ _
ip(t ) ( ) ^__ip(t ) consequently , the asymptotic behaviour of the total cross section ( via optical theorem ) is given by @xmath252 if the intercept of the pomeron trajectory is the maximum value allowed by the froissart bound , namely @xmath253 .
this fact implies that the total cross section in this approximation behaves asymptotically as a constant .
it is clear that logarithmic corrections are always allowed .
moreover , they are necessary in order to cope with experimental data . the pomeron concept answer the question at the end of the previous section using the reggeon jargon : a diffraction process is dominated by the exchange of a _ pomeron _ , that in fact means exchange of no quantum numbers .
it is interesting to mention that donnachie and landshoff @xcite were able to describe all available total cross section data on @xmath254 , @xmath120 , @xmath255 and @xmath256 by a very simple regge - pomeron inspired parametization of the form @xmath257 where @xmath258 and @xmath259 are reaction dependent parameters .
clearly the first exponent of the center of mass energy squared @xmath238 correspond to a pomeron intercept of @xmath260 , while the second exponent comes from a typical regge intercept @xmath261 .
the successful fit is shown in figure [ fig : dal ] . trying to connect the pomeron with the language and understanding of qcd
, one can imagine it as a colour singlet combination of partons such as the simplest picture of a pair of gluons proposed by low and nussinov @xcite .
two - gluon exchange is compatible with all soft phenomenology except that this simple model gives a constant , not a rising , total cross - section . clearly in order to analyze the parton content of pomeron , a hard or high - momentum transfer interaction analogous to the one used to find the quark - gluon content of the proton is necessary .
this kind of processes is called hard diffraction making reference to the hard scale that ultimately allows the pertubative description .
nowadays , people is trying to go beyond in the understanding of pomeron properties following different theoretical approaches@xcite , although there remain several open questions .
the main point to be solved is related to the precise relation between hard and soft diffraction . as we said , to study the pomeron parton content , small distances and high - momentum transfer are necessary , while the natural environment of the soft pomeron is at large distances and low - momentum transfer . in other words , the clear notion of a pomeron is still missing . most of the recent renewal of interest in diffraction was triggered mainly by a theoretical proposal of bjorken @xcite , who pointed out a new signature of diffraction related to the presence of large rapidity gaps .
these rapidity gaps were found both at hera and at the tevatron .
the presence of diffractive processes at hera should be expected since the photon behaves like a hadron in several circumstances .
in fact , about @xmath262 of the photoproduction events are of diffractive character . in this kind of processes ,
the pomeron is exchanged and the incident proton remains as a proton or is diffractively dissociated in a state with the same quantum numbers .
consequently , as it will be discussed below , there appears a large rapidity gap between the proton , or the diffractive system , and the hadrons coming from the system into which the photon was diffracted .
the quite unexpected fact observed at hera was the presence of large rapidity gap events also in the dis domain @xcite .
the observation that also a highly virtual photon can participate in a diffractive process , opened the road to the analysis of the pomeron structure .
in fact , if @xmath26 , the virtuality of the photon , is larger than say @xmath263 , the scattering @xmath73-pomeron can be treated perturbatively .
the impact of this dis diffractive data is also evident because one is facing in a dis process characterized by a large @xmath26 scale , diffractive properties which were been expected at a soft scale .
as it was predicted by bjorken @xcite , the most evident signal for diffractive physics at high energy , is the presence of large rapidity gaps .
just to get some insight on this jargon , remember that a single inclusive diffractive reaction , noted as @xmath264 implies no exchange of quantum numbers different from those of vacuum . in this inclusive case , at variance with the elastic reaction , besides the two variables ( @xmath265 and @xmath266 or @xmath238 and @xmath213 ) a third variable is needed to describe the process . generally it is used m_x^2 = ( k_a + k_b - k^_a)^2 = e_x^2 - ^2_x or , alternatively , the feynman @xmath267 defined as x_f 1 - another useful variable is rapidity , defined by y = or equivalently , the pseudorapidity which is its limit for large energy = - ( ) in a typical dis event , the struck parton of the proton , emerges forming an angle @xmath268 with the proton remnant direction , as it is shown in figure [ fig : rem ] .
( 150,55)(0,0 ) ( 30,-62 ) this angle can be expressed in terms of the difference in total pseudorapidity @xmath269 between these directions , namely @xmath270 if the center of mass energy squared of the system is @xmath238 , the pseudarapidity interval covered is @xmath271 consequently , @xmath272 where the first term correspond to the pseudorapidity covered by the @xmath273 system and the second to that covered by the @xmath274 system respectively .
clearly @xmath44 is the bjorken variable that measures the amount of momentum of the proton carried by the quark .
the confinement property of qcd can be rephrased by saying that the struck quark and the proton remnant are connected via a colour string in order to end with colourless hadrons .
for this reason , the mentioned pseudorapidity gap @xmath275 is filled with particles during the hadronization process . moreover ,
when the value of @xmath44 decreases , the average hadron multiplicity increases , making less likely the visibility of any rapidity gap in the dis event . in principle
, the rapidity gap between the remnant proton , and the struck quark jet is then exponentially suppressed .
after this kinematical preface , we briefly discuss the so called _ leading particle effect _ , characteristic of high energy hadronic interactions . around @xmath276 of the inclusive hadron scattering events present a lab system configuration where the incident particle flies apart essentially unscattered in almost the forward direction leaving behind a stream of slow moving produced particles .
the experimentally determined cross section looks entirely similar to the elastic case .
namely , between the initial particle and the final fast one , there is no change of quantum numbers and the reaction is clearly of diffractive type .
there is only a minor loss of momentum to produce the slow particles .
this effect requires the fast particle to be exactly the same as the incident one
. when the leading particle , the one we called above @xmath277 , is produced diffractively , and because the process has this characteristic , one has to expect the remaining cluster @xmath258 to be produced at the opposite end of the rapidity spectrum .
that is usually expressed by saying that the reaction presents a large rapidity gap from @xmath277 .
diffraction definition makes evident this concept .
in fact , as @xmath277 has exactly the same quantum numbers as @xmath278 , no quantum numbers at all can be exchanged until @xmath258 is produced .
if a particle were produced in between , it would mean that some quantum number has been exchanged and the process is no longer diffractive .
consequently , in this large rapidity gaps events , as no particle is produced between @xmath277 and @xmath258 , they are clearly separated in rapidity .
large rapidity gap events can be generated in soft processes as elastic and single diffractive hadron - hadron scattering , where the momentum transfer @xmath213 between the scattered particles is small , and the center of mass energy @xmath238 large , i.e. , peripheral scattering .
it should be stressed that nowadays , diffraction is considered synonym of large rapidity gap processes . in other words ,
the evidence of diffractive hadronic events comes mainly from large rapidity gaps as have been observed in d0 and cdf collaborations at the tevatron @xcite . on the other hand ,
at hera , the electron - proton collider , diffraction has also been extensively observed using both the rapidity gap criteria for diffraction and also the detection of final state protons . in semi - inclusive dis , whenever the detected final hadron coincides with the incident one , one is dealing with diffraction . in order to follow the outgoing proton a leading proton spectrometer ( lps )
was designed . before discussing the interesting hera dis diffractive events ,
let us consider the particular semi - inclusive processes where the detected final hadron exactly coincides with the initial one , namely @xmath279 in this case the scattering diagram looks like the one in figure [ fig : lrg ] ( 150,56)(0,0 ) ( 25,-60 ) the process is clearly diffractive since no quantum numbers are exchanged between the @xmath73 and the nucleon @xmath87 . as a consequence ,
one has for the remnant @xmath258 the quantum numbers @xmath280 exactly equal to those of the incoming photon .
notice by the way that the production of any vector boson , the explicit replacement of @xmath258 by any @xmath281 in the reaction above , is a diffractive process because the @xmath281 meson quantum numbers are precisely those of @xmath73 .
the kinematics related to figure [ fig : lrg ] needs further variables to be introduced .
they are usually defined as t = ( k_n - k_n^)^2 , m_x^2 = ( k_n - k_n^ + q)^2 , m_y^2 = k_n^^2 x__ip = = , = = notice that frequently @xmath282 is used instead of @xmath283 and that @xmath284 . clearly , the range of values of @xmath285 and @xmath286 is @xmath287 .
moreover , @xmath286 could be understood as the momentum fraction carried by the parton directly coupled to @xmath73 . in the context of diffractive dis , it is customary to define _ diffractive structure functions _ , in analogy with the ordinary ones , through the expression of the corresponding cross section @xmath288\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath289 it is also of interest the @xmath213-integrated diffractive structure function defined en each case by f_i^d(3)(x__ip , , q^2)=_|t|_min^|t|_max d|t| f_i^d(4 ) ( x__ip , , q^2 , t ) [ eq : fd ] with @xmath290 .
the superindices @xmath291 and @xmath292 refer to the number of variables in the structure functions . in the integral
@xmath293 is the lower kinematic limit of @xmath294 and @xmath295 has to be specified in each case . in the most naive regge inspired approach , the diffractive structure function
is assumed to be given by the product of the probability @xmath296 to find a pomeron in the incoming proton , which only depends on the variables @xmath283 and @xmath213 , and a _ pomeron structure function _
@xmath297 , given by parton densities which are assumed to behave according to altarelli - parisi evolution equations and factorize as ordinary parton distributions @xcite .
in recent years different theoretical approaches have been proposed for the description of hard diffraction and specifically for the diffractive structure functions .
see for example @xcite and references therein .
some of these approaches modelize the diffractive interaction in the proton rest frame as an exchange of two gluons between the proton and the hadronic system into which the photon has evolved as depicted by the upper line diagramas in figure [ fig : gl ] .
others , also in the proton rest frame , evaluate within a semiclassical analysis the effect of the colour field of the proton into the photon hadronic system as in the lower line diagrams of figure [ fig : gl ] .
the main difference between the above mentioned models is that in the former only two gluons are exchanged while in the latter a multiple exchange of soft gluons is assumed @xcite .
( 150,70)(0,0 ) ( 30,10 ) ( 80,10 ) ( 30,40 ) ( 80,40 ) ( 150,50)(0,0 ) ( 10,20 ) ( 90,20 ) ( 70,30 ) a third strategy consists in dealing with the diffractive interaction as a special kinematical limit of a more general semi - inclusive process , i.e. regarding the diffractive structure function just as the low @xmath283 limit of the fracture function of protons into protons @xcite .
doing this , the whole perturbative techniques can be rigurously applied without need to make additional assumptions in a program similar to what has been done for structure and fragmentation functions @xcite .
another advantage of this last strategy is that in this framework the large @xmath283 behaviour of the diffractive structure function can be explored with leading proton production experiments
. the fracture function approach can be in some sense related to the two gluon exchange model by a frame transformation as it is sketched in figure [ fig : trans ] .
a remarkable thing to notice regarding these kinds of models for diffraction and also the factorization approach , is that although they seem to differ in rather strong assumptions , they all give a reasonably good account of the data suggesting a large gluon content in the diffractive structure function with gluons concentrated at high @xmath286 .
( 150,100)(0,0 ) ( 30,-10 ) ( 150,85)(0,0 ) ( 40,-5 ) in figure [ fig : f2d ] measurements of the diffractive structure function @xmath298 as a function of @xmath283 obtained by h1 at hera are compared with the fit coming from a factorization approach @xcite.as for ordinary structure functions , qcd predicts the scale dependence of the diffractive structure function .
figure [ fig : f2dq2 ] shows the agreement between the data and the behaviour expected in the factorization approach .
having established a rigorous and precise description of diffractive dis we can go back to the most naive regge inspired approach and see which of their hypothesis or assumptions may survive .
the first thing to notice is that although in principle diffractive parton distributions or fracture functions obey non homogeneus ap evolution equations , in the low @xmath283 limit the non homogeneus contributions are numerically negligible so the standard assumption is a very good approximation .
instead , what fails , at least in the unrestricted kinematical range accesed by hera , is the flux factorization hypothesis , i.e. the posibility to factorize the @xmath283-dependence of the structure function as a simple power of @xmath283 .
global analysis of the data shows not only deviations form this behaviour , suggesting the admixture of regge exchanges , but also a @xmath286-dependent level of admixture @xcite .
hera also measures other diffractive procceses like diffractive production of vector mesons and diffractive photoproduction of jets @xcite .
this last kind of processes , depicted in figure [ fig : photog ] , is particularly exciting as it represents a combined test of our knowledge of the parton structure of the photon and the colour singlet .
> from the theoretical point of view it is also very important because the resolved photon contribution to the process is in fact a hadron - hadron diffractive process for which hard qcd factorization may be broken .
( 150,55)(0,0 ) ( 60,-60 ) ( -5,-60 ) indeed , although hard factorization can be proven to be valid for diffractive dis , the proof fails for hadron - hadron interactions .
the posibility of soft interactions taking place before the hard scattering occurs may spoil factorization in hadron - hadron collisions@xcite , although there are no model - independent estimates of how large the factorization breaking effects may be or under which circumstances can be found .
hard factorization has been a very active theoretical topic in the three preceding years , and it is particularly relevant for the discussion of tevatron diffractive data .
figure [ fig : photo ] shows a comparison between h1 dijet photoproduction data and the corresponding prediction computed with photonic and diffractive parton distributions @xcite .
the comparison suggests that for diffractive photoproduction the factorization breaking mechanisms are either neglible or beyond the accuracy of the present data .
( 150,90)(0,0 ) ( 40,0 ) as we mentioned earlier , large rapidity gaps in proton - antiproton collisions have been observed by both do and cdf collaborations at tevatron .
the typical rapidity gap events observed at tevatron are classified acording to three categories : hard single diffraction , hard double pomeron exchange , and hard colour singlet .
( 150,50)(0,0 ) ( 33,-47 ) ( -17,-47 ) ( 83,-47 ) in the first case , figure [ fig : tev]a , a large rapidity gap in the forward direction is found between the outgoing antiproton and the debris produced by the proton - pomeron interaction . in the double pomeron exchange ,
figure [ fig : tev]b , both the proton and the antiproton survive the interaction and emerge leaving rapidity gaps between each of them and the debris of the pomeron - pomeron interaction . in the third case ,
both the proton and the antiproton disociate but their corresponding remnants leave a large rapidity gap between them , figure [ fig : tev]c . for a straightforward comparison with hera data
the most simple topology to analyze is hard single diffraction , as the only change to be made in the conceptual framework developed in the previous section is the replacement of the lepton probe ( the positron ) used at hera by an hadronic one ( the proton ) that takes its place at the tevatron .
the diffractive structure function for the antiproton is simply related by charge conjugation to that for the proton , and which is measured at hera .
whithin this topology , several observables can be measured such as dijet , @xmath299 , and @xmath37 production . performing this kind of analysis what has been found
is that even though the tevatron data allow a description in terms of diffractive parton densities , the predictions computed with those coming from hera largely overshot tevatron data signaling a breakdown of factorization @xcite , which remains to be fully understood .
as we have already pointed out in the previous section , the factorization breaking seen tevatron is not at all unexpected , since qcd factorization may be broken in hadron - hadron diffraction due to soft exchanges .
in addition to these , there are also some other effects which conspire against factorization and need some consideration . for
the analysis of these effects it is crucial to take into account that the standard criterium used to identify diffractive events both at hera and at tevatron , and thus the correspoinding contributions to the diffractive parton distributions and the tevatron observables , respectively , is the presence of rapidity gaps of a given size . obviously , changing the size of these rapidity gaps , the number of events selected also changes , effect that in fact has been observed and studied by the different experiments . in figure
[ fig : etamax ] we show as an example dijet photoproduction events generated with a monte carlo in the kinematical regimes of h1 and zeus experiments as a function of the pseudo - rapidity @xmath300 of the most forward particle belonging to the system @xmath258 @xcite .
events to the left of the thick vertical line ( rapidity gap limit ) are those taken into account while those to the right are discarted .
( 100,65)(0,0 ) ( 32,-53 ) it is worthwhile noticing that even for the same kind of process , the different kinematical regimes covered by both experiments given for example by cuts in the transverse energy @xmath301 and pseudo - rapidity @xmath269 of the two most energetic jets , etc .
, yield rather different distributions in @xmath302 and thus , are affected in a different way even for the same pseudo - rapidity gap definition . for zeus ,
approximately 25 % of the total number of events are concentrated at @xmath303 , while for h1 kinematics approximately 10 % of them survives the same constraint . clearly , the situation is much more involved if we try to relate pseudo - rapidity gap data from different processes as we are doing in the hera - tevatron comparison.,in other words , is not evident what is the relation between dis events with a pseudo - rapidity gap of given size , and proton - antiproton events with pseudo - rapidity gaps of a different size , and obtained in a completly different kinematical regime .
it is somewhat paradoxical that the same rapidity gaps that helped so much the development of hard diffraction , seem at this point to be a burden . in any case
, ongoing experimental programs based on the roman pot technique , which allows a positive identification of the final state hadron as signature of the colour singlet exchange , will surely allow a much more deep and complete picture of these exciting phenomena .
throughout the present lectures we have review the most significant features of partons , the fundamental protagonists of qcd , as seen in the three rather different enviroments , the proton , the photon , and the pomeron ( colour singlet exchange ) . as we have seen , and in fact was anticipated in the introduction , these objects , or more precisely the high energy processes involving them , are three of the main benchmarks of perturbative qcd . in the process of developing the predictive power of qcd we have introduced structure , fragmentation , and fracture functions , objects that link intimately both our knowledge and our ignorance about the partonic structure
the fundamental prediction of qcd in these enviroments , the energy scale dependence of the corresponding cross sections or structure functions , is beautifully illustrated in figure [ fig : q2 ] @xcite .
the observed behaviour in each case can be traced back to a basic parton interaction mechanism which alternatively dominates over the others : gluon radiation , quark pair creation from gluons , and from photons , respectively , and to the respective parton compositions . at intermediate @xmath44 , the case in the figure ,
the proton structure function is dominated by valence quarks , however increasing the resolving power of our probe , gluon radiation depletes dramatically these densities through the corresponding term in the ap evolution equation . at variance with this scenario ,
the diffractive structure function is dominated by gluons at intermediate @xmath286 , and consequently our lepton probes mainly quarks produced by pair creation from gluons , and the corresponding evolution .
the logarithmic increase in the photon structure function is caused by quark pair creation from photons , which in the lowest order approximation appears in the ap equations as @xmath26 independent term .
finally , the partonic structure as seen in our benchmarks in some way relate the physics made in the three main high energy physics laboratories .
lep provides us with the most precise determinations of photon structure functions and also fragmentation functions , using electron - positron collisions . tevatron in turn ,
contribute to our understanding of the proton structure and also to diffraction by means proton - antiproton interactions .
positron - proton collisions at hera , not only test the structure of the proton and diffraction by themselves , but also brings toghether the proton and the photon structure functions in inclusive photoproduction , relates the latter with fracture functions in the diffractive photoproduction , and explores the relation between fragmentation and fracture functions in leading baryon production .
for a recent comprehensive review see : b. lampe and e. reya , spin physics and polarized structure functions , hep - ph/9810270 .
see also e. leader et al .
, phys , rep .
261 , 1 ( 1995 ) .
u. bassler et al .
hep - ph/9906027 .
h. abramowicz , a. caldwell , desy 98 - 192 ( 1998 ) .
j. huston , 29th intern .
conf . on high - energy physics , vancouver , canada 1998 , hep - ph/9901352 .
e.leader , e.predazzi , _ an introduction to gauge theories and the new physics _ , cambridge university press ( 1996 ) , f. halzen , a. d. martin , _ quarks and leptons : an introductory course in modern particle physiscs _ , john wiley & sons , ( 1984 ) .
f. j. yndurain , _ the theory of quark and gluon interactions _ springer verlag ( 1992 )
. s. bethke , qcd euroconference 97 , montpelier , 1997 hep - ph/9710030 .
review of particle properties , the european physical journal , c3 , 1 ( 1998 ) .
michael kuhlen , hep - ph/9712505 v. chekelian in 18th international symposium on lepton - photon interactions , hamburg , july 1997 . w. l. van neerven in _ physics at hera _ , f. barreiro , l. hervs , l. labarga , editors .
world scientific ( 1994 ) .
c.g.bollini , j.j .
giambiagi , nuovo cimento 12b , 20 ( 1972 ) , + g. t hooft , m. veltman , nucl .
b44 , 189 ( 1972 ) .
b409 , 271 ( 1997 ) .
lai et al .
hep - ph/9903282 .
m. glck , e. reya , a. vogt , hep - ph/9806404 .
martin et al .
hep - ph/9803445 .
a.d . martin in _ physics at hera _ , f. barreiro , l. hervs , l. labarga , editors .
world scientific ( 1994 ) .
a. t. doyle hep - ex/9812029 r. feynman in photon - hadron interactions , benjamin , new york ( 1972 ) .
l. trentadue and g. veneziano , phys . lett .
* b323 * , 201 ( 1993 ) .
d. de florian and r. sassot , phys . rev . * d56 * , 426 ( 1997 ) .
d. de florian , c. a. garca canal and r. sassot , nuc .
b470 , 195 ( 1996 ) .
s.brodsky , p. zerwas , nucl .
inst . and methods , a355 , 19 ( 1995 ) .
e. witten , nuc .
b120 , 189 ( 1997 ) .
f. barreiro , international europhysics conference on high energy physics , tampere 1999 . c. f. von weizcker , z. phys .
88 , 612 ( 1934 ) , e. j. williams , phys .
45 , 729 ( 1934 ) , s. frixione _ et al .
b319 , 339 ( 1993 ) .
r. nisius , photon 99 , freiburg 1999 hep - ex/9811024 .
m.gluck , e.reya , m.stratmann , phys .
d51 , 3220 ( 1995 ) .
t.uematsu , t.f .
walsh , phys.lett .
b101 , ( 1981 ) 263 , nucl.phys.b199 , ( 1982 ) 93 ; m.drees , r.godbole , phys .
d50 , 3124 ( 1994 ) ; g.schuler , t.sjstrand , z. phys .
c68 , 607 ( 1995 ) , phys .
b376 , 193 ( 1996 ) .
m.drees , r.godbole , phys.rev.d39 , ( 1984 ) 169 .
b.l.combridge et al . , phys .
b70 , ( 1977 ) 234 ; d.w.duke , j.owens , phys.rev.d26 , ( 1982 ) 1600 .
s.frixione , et al .
b319 , ( 1993 ) 339 .
m.klasen , g.kramer , desy 95 - 226 ( 1995 ) .
m. derrick et al .
j. c1 109 ( 1998 ) .
m. glck , e. reya , a. vogt , z. phys .
c67 ( 1995 ) 433 .
h1 collab .
, contribution # 549 to the 29th intern .
conf . on high - energy physics , vancouver , canada ( 1998 ) .
d. b. collins , _ an introduction to regge theory & high energy interactions _ , cambridge university press , cambridge 1977 e. predazzi , hep - ph/9809454 .
a. donnachie , p.v .
landshoff , phys . lett .
b296 , 227 ( 1992 ) f.e .
low , phys .
d12 , 163 ( 1975 ) ; s. nussinov , phys . rev .
lett 34 , 1286 ( 1975 ) . m. diehl , hep - ph/9906518 ; m. wsthoff , a. d. martin , hep - ph/9909362 ; a. hebeker , hep - ph/9905226 j.d .
bjorken , phys .
d47 , 101 ( 1993 ) .
zeus collab .
b269 , 481 ( 1993 ) ; h1 collab .
b429 , 477 ( 1994 ) .
d0 collab .
72 , 2332 ( 1994 ) ; cdf collab .
lett 74 , 855 ( 1995 ) .
t. gehrman and w. j. stirling , z. phys .
* c70 * , 89 ( 1996 ) ; z. kunszt , w. j. stirling hep - ph/9609245 ( 1996 ) .
d. de florian and r. sassot , phys . rev . * d58 * 054003 ( 1998 ) .
d. m. jansen , m. albrow , r. brugnera , hep - ph/9905537 .
r. sassot , phys . rev . * d * ( to be published ) , hep - ph/9908348 j. collins , l. frankfurt , m. strickman , phys . lett .
b307 , 161 ( 1993 ) ; a. berrera , d. e. sopper , phys .
d50 4328 ( 1994 ) ; a. berrera , d. e. sopper , phys .
d53 6162 ( 1996 ) .
l. alvero et al . ,
phys . rev .
* d59 * 074022 ( 1999 ) .
h1 collab . , contribution # 533 and 571 to the 29th intern .
conf . on high - energy physics , vancouver , canada ( 1998 ) . | these lectures include an introduction to the partonic description of the proton , the photon and the ` colour singlet ' , as seen in inclusive and semi - inclusive dis , in @xmath0 collisions , and in diffractive processes , respectively .
their formal treatment using structure , fragmentation , and fracture functions is outlined giving an insight into the perturbative qcd framework for these functions .
examples and comparisons with experimental data from lep , hera , and tevatron are also covered . |
strong decays of @xmath11 to @xmath8 are suppressed , since the reaction violates g - parity conservation . in @xmath12
colliding beam experiments , @xmath8 may also be produced by @xmath13 ( called the `` continuum process '' hereafter ) .
it is expected that the continuum contribution is large and may contribute around 60% of the @xmath8 events at the @xmath11 energy .
this contribution must be removed in determining @xmath14 , as has been described for the @xmath15 decay mode @xcite . in this analysis ,
data samples at the @xmath11 peak ( @xmath16 gev ) and off - resonance ( @xmath17 gev ) are used .
the continuum contribution at the @xmath11 peak is estimated using the off - resonance sample and subtracted to obtain a model independent measurement of the @xmath2 branching fraction .
we also use the samples to obtain the @xmath8 electromagnetic form factor which allows us to calculate the branching fraction based on the theoretical assumption described in ref .
@xcite .
there is a big contribution from @xmath7 in our @xmath2 sample .
this process allows us to measure the branching fraction of @xmath4 .
the advantage of this method is that we need not subtract the continuum contribution for this process .
the existing branching fraction measurement of @xmath2 was done by the mark - i experiment @xcite based on @xmath18 candidate events .
the branching fraction of @xmath4 was also measured by mark - i @xcite with @xmath19 events observed , and there is also a recent result for this decay reported by the babar experiment @xcite .
the data used for this analysis are taken with the updated beijing spectrometer ( besii ) detector at the beijing electron - positron collider ( bepc ) storage ring .
the @xmath11 data are taken at @xmath20 gev with a luminosity of @xmath21 @xcite measured with large angle bhabha events .
the number of @xmath11 events is @xmath22 @xcite as determined from inclusive hadrons .
the continuum data are taken at @xmath23 gev , and the corresponding luminosity is @xmath24 @xcite .
the ratio of the two luminosities is @xmath25 .
the besii detector is a conventional solenoidal magnet detector that is described in detail in refs .
@xcite . a 12-layer vertex chamber ( vc ) surrounding the beam pipe
provides trigger and track information .
a forty - layer main drift chamber ( mdc ) , located radially outside the vc , provides trajectory and energy loss ( @xmath26 ) information for charged tracks over @xmath27 of the total solid angle .
the momentum resolution is @xmath28 ( @xmath29 in @xmath30 ) , and the @xmath26 resolution for hadron tracks is @xmath31 .
an array of 48 scintillation counters surrounding the mdc measures the time - of - flight ( tof ) of charged tracks with a resolution of @xmath32 ps for hadrons .
radially outside the tof system is a 12 radiation length , lead - gas barrel shower counter ( bsc ) .
this measures the energies of electrons and photons over @xmath33 of the total solid angle with an energy resolution of @xmath34 ( @xmath35 in gev ) .
outside of the solenoidal coil , which provides a 0.4 tesla magnetic field over the tracking volume , is an iron flux return that is instrumented with three double layers of counters that identify muons of momentum greater than 0.5 gev/@xmath36 .
a geant3 based monte carlo ( mc ) program with detailed consideration of detector performance ( such as dead electronic channels ) is used to simulate the besii detector .
the consistency between data and monte carlo has been carefully checked in many high purity physics channels , and the agreement is quite reasonable @xcite . in generating mc samples , initial state radiation
is included , and @xmath37 or @xmath38 dependent form factors are assumed where required .
mc samples of @xmath39 , @xmath40 are generated with the correct @xmath41 mass distribution @xcite , and @xmath39 , @xmath5 is generated with the correct @xmath42 angle distribution .
other samples are generated according to phase space .
six charged tracks with net charge zero are required .
each charged track , reconstructed using hits in the mdc , must have a good helix fit in order to ensure a correct error matrix in the kinematic fit .
all six tracks are required to ( 1 ) originate from the beam intersection region , i.e. @xmath43 cm and @xmath44 cm , where @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and @xmath47 are the @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 coordinates of the point of closest approach to the beam axis , and ( 2 ) have @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the polar angle of the track .
a four constraint kinematic fit is performed with the six charged tracks assuming all of them to be pions . if the confidence level of the fit is greater than 1% , the event is categorized as @xmath2 . fig .
[ fig : mpp ] shows the invariant and recoil mass distributions of @xmath41 pairs . if the recoil mass of any @xmath41 pair is between 3.06 and 3.14 gev@xmath53 , the event is considered a @xmath39 , @xmath4 candidate and removed . if the masses of any two @xmath41 pairs is between 0.47 and 0.53 gev@xmath53 , the event is considered as @xmath54 @xmath55 , @xmath56 background and removed .
the @xmath41 invariant and recoil mass distributions of @xmath2 candidates at @xmath16 gev .
the events with two @xmath41 pairs within @xmath57 gev@xmath53 are removed as @xmath58 background . while the events with a @xmath41 pair within @xmath59 gev@xmath53 are removed as @xmath39 background.,height=302 ] applying these criteria to the data collected at @xmath60 gev , 670 events
survive , while for the data collected at @xmath23 gev , 71 events remain .
the efficiencies of these criteria are @xmath61 for @xmath2 and @xmath62 for @xmath63 .
the lower @xmath64 results from the initial state radiation correction ( the maximum radiative photon energy is set to 0.7gev ) in the generator , which reduces the center - of - mass energy for many events generated .
these events can not survive the kinematic fit , which leads to the lower @xmath64 .
remaining backgrounds in the @xmath65 sample include : ( 1 ) residual @xmath58 or @xmath39 events ; ( 2 ) events with kaons or electrons misidentified as pions , and ( 3 ) events with low energy neutral tracks like @xmath66 or @xmath67 .
monte carlo simulations indicate that @xmath68 events of these backgrounds survive the above selection criteria , which will be subtracted from the observed number of events in the calculation of the branching fraction .
background remaining in the continuum data sample is negligible .
[ fig : x2 ] shows the confidence level distribution from the kinematic fitting . the consistency between data and mc is satisfactory except for the first few bins in both figs .
[ fig : x2](a ) and ( b ) .
figure [ fig : x2](a ) is similar to the situation for @xmath4 ( see fig . [
fig : x2_jpsi ] ) . taking into account the similarity between the figures and that we expect little background in fig .
[ fig : x2_jpsi ] , we conclude that the discrepancy is due to the simulation of the error matrix in the track fitting rather than some unknown background , and this is included in the systematic error analysis .
confidence level distribution from the kinematic fitting .
( a ) is for @xmath2 .
the dots with error bars are data .
the blank histogram is mc simulated signal plus the continuum contribution measured with @xmath69 gev data ( hatched histogram ) and the mc simulated background events ( dark shaded histogram ) , after proper normalization .
( b ) is for @xmath63 measured with @xmath23 gev data .
the dots with error bars are data , while the blank histogram is mc simulation .
, height=264 ] to obtain the branching fraction of @xmath2 , we have to subtract from @xmath70 the number of continuum events at 3.686gev .
this number is estimated as @xmath71 , where @xmath72 is the normalization factor : @xmath73 where , @xmath74 is the born order cross section of continuum process , which is @xmath75 dependent and can be expressed in terms of the @xmath8 form factor @xmath76 : @xmath77 where @xmath78 is the qed fine structure constant .
assuming @xmath79 , we get : @xmath80 the branching fraction of @xmath2 can be calculated as @xmath81 & = & \frac{\displaystyle n^{obs}_{3.686}-n^{obs}_{3.650}\times f - n^{bg } } { \displaystyle \varepsilon_{{\psi(2s)}}\times n^{tot}_{{\psi(2s)}}}\\ & = & ( 4.83 \pm 0.38 \pm 0.69 ) \times 10^{-4},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the first error is statistical and the second is systematic .
the values of the variables in the equation are listed in table [ tab : val ] .
.[tab : val]numbers used to calculate @xmath82 $ ] . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] 1 .
for process i , the statistical error of the mc sample is 0.9% , while for process ii , it is 0.7% , including any uncertainties introduced by the fits . 2 .
there are two more tracks in @xmath4 than in @xmath5 , the uncertainty in tracking is dominated by the two extra tracks and is estimated to be about 4% .
3 . fig .
[ fig : jpsires ] shows the @xmath41 mass distributions after all the cuts , where clear @xmath83 and @xmath84 signals can be seen . to estimate the efficiency difference between data and mc simulation ( pure phase space ) , we generate samples with different intermediate states in @xmath4 , e.g. , @xmath83 , @xmath85 , @xmath86 , etc . and find the differences from the pure phase space mc simulation are about 3% , which is taken as the systematic error for the generator .
+ the @xmath41 invariant mass distributions for @xmath4 candidates after applying all the selection criteria .
the dots with error bars are data , while the histogram is mc simulated phase space . the dip at the left side of the @xmath83 peak is due to the @xmath87 mass cut .
there are four entries for each @xmath4 event.,height=302 ] 4 .
the numbers of events obtained from the fits are affected by the background shape , as well as the signal shape . using a linear background yields a change of the branching fraction of @xmath88 , while using direct counting methods to estimate the numbers of events and efficiency results in negligible change in the branching fraction .
the systematic error due to the fitting procedure is taken as @xmath88 .
5 . the systematic uncertainty from the kinematic fit
is estimated the same as that of @xmath2 and is about @xmath89 .
6 . instead of using the muid
, a @xmath42 sample may be obtained by using the energy deposited in the shower counter to remove @xmath90 events and neglecting @xmath91 and @xmath92 which have small branching ratios @xcite . from the number of events obtained with this method
, we find that the error associated with the muid requirement is about @xmath93 . 7 .
background contamination is determined using monte carlo simulation .
the background fractions in both processes are far less than 1% , and the uncertainty of the estimation is at 0.5% level .
adding the systematic errors in quadrature , the total systematic error for @xmath94 $ ] is 7% .
our measurement of @xmath94 $ ] is in good agreement with the existing measurement by mark - i @xcite , which is @xmath95 , based on 76 observed events .
although non resonance continuum @xmath96 production was mentioned in the mark - i paper , it is not clear whether it was removed in evaluating the @xmath97 decay branching fraction .
our result has better precision compared with the mark - i result @xcite .
a recent measurement of this branching fraction using initial state radiation events was reported by the babar experiment @xcite ; the result ( @xmath98 ) agrees with our measurement well but has a larger error .
using 14 m @xmath11 events and 6.42 pb@xmath99 of continuum data at @xmath17 gev , the branching fractions of @xmath2 and @xmath4 are determined to be @xmath100 and @xmath101 , respectively .
the former is larger than the mark - i result using @xmath11 decays @xcite , while the latter is consistent with mark - i measurement @xcite using a @xmath97 decay sample . in both cases ,
our measurements have improved precision . using the above results and @xmath102 $ ] , @xmath103 $ ] from pdg @xcite , we obtain @xmath104 } { \displaystyle { \mathcal{b}}[{j/\psi \rightarrow}3({\pi^+\pi^- } ) ] } = ( 12 \pm 7)\%,\\ q_{h } \equiv \frac{\displaystyle { \mathcal{b}}[{\psi(2s ) \rightarrow } 2({\pi^+\pi^- } ) ] } { \displaystyle { \mathcal{b}}[{j/\psi \rightarrow}2({\pi^+\pi^- } ) ] } = ( 13 \pm 3)\%.\end{aligned}\ ] ] they are consistent with the @xmath105 rule " @xcite expectation within errors .
the bes collaboration thanks the staff of bepc for their hard efforts and the members of ihep computing center for their helpful assistance .
this work is supported in part by the national natural science foundation of china under contracts nos .
19991480 , 10225524 , 10225525 , the chinese academy of sciences under contract no .
kj 95t-03 , the 100 talents program of cas under contract nos .
u-11 , u-24 , u-25 , and the knowledge innovation project of cas under contract nos .
u-602 , u-34 ( ihep ) ; by the national natural science foundation of china under contract no .
10175060 ( ustc ) , and no . 10225522
( tsinghua university ) ; and by the u.s .
department of energy under contract no .
de - fg02 - 04er41291 ( u of hawaii ) . | using data samples collected at @xmath0 gev and @xmath1 gev by the besii detector at the bepc , the branching fraction of @xmath2 is measured to be @xmath3 \times 10^{-4}$ ] , and the relative branching fraction of @xmath4 to that of @xmath5 is measured to be @xmath6 \%$ ] via @xmath7 .
the electromagnetic form factor of @xmath8 is determined to be @xmath9 and @xmath10 at @xmath0 gev and @xmath1 gev , respectively . |
the lattice boltzmann method ( lbm ) has become a popular numerical tool for flow simulations .
it solves the discrete velocity boltzmann equation ( dvbe ) with sophistically chosen discrete velocity set . with the coupled discretization of velocity space and spatial space ,
the numerical treatment of convection term reduces to a very simple _ streaming _ processes , which provides the benefits of low numerical dissipation , easy implementation , and high parallel computing efficiency .
another advantage of lbm is that , the simplified collision term is computed implicitly while implemented explicitly , which allows for a large time step even though the collision term causess stiffness at a small relaxation time .
this advantage makes the lbm a potential solver for high reynolds number flows .
however , the coupled discretization of velocity and spatial spaces limits the lbm to the use of uniform cartesian meshes , which prohibits its applications for practical engineering problems .
some efforts have been made to extend the standard lbm to non - regular ( non - uniform , unstructured ) meshes , and a number of so called off - lattice boltzmann ( olb ) methods have been developed by solving the dvbe using certain finite - difference , finite - volume , or finite - element schemes @xcite .
these olb schemes differ from each other in the temporal and spatial discretizations .
however , a straightforward implementation of the cfd techniques usually leads to the loss of the advantages of standard lbm , especially the low dissipation property and stability at large time step .
for example , in many of the schemes @xcite , the time step is limited by the relaxation time to get an accurate solution , even as the collision term is computed implicitly @xcite .
this drawback makes these olb schemes very computational expensive when simulating high reynolds number flows .
an alternative way to construct olb schemes is to use the time - splitting strategy in solving the dvbe @xcite , in which the dvbe is decomposed into a collision sub - equation and a followed pure advection sub - equation .
the collision sub - equation is fully local and is discretized directly , leading to a collision step the same as the standard lbm ; the collisionless advection subequation is then solved with certain numerical schemes on uniform or non - uniform meshes @xcite , leading to a general streaming step . specifically , the scheme proposed by bardow et al .
( denoted by bkg ) , which combines the variable transformation technique for the collision term and the lax - wendroff scheme for the streaming step , overcomes the time step restriction by the relaxation time .
it was demonstrated that accurate and stable solutions can be obtained even as the time step is much larger than the relaxation time @xcite .
the above olb schemes are developed in the lbm framework , and are limited to continuum flows .
recently , a finite volume kinetic approach using general mesh , i.e. , discrete unified gas kinetic scheme ( dugks ) , was proposed for all knudsen number flows @xcite . in the dugks the numerical flux
is constructed based on the governing equation i.e. , the dvbe itself , instead of using interpolations .
with such a treatment , the time step is not restricted by the relaxation time , and its superior accuracy and stability for high reynolds continuum flows have been demonstrated @xcite . since both the bkg and the dugks methods overcome the time step restriction from different approaches , it is still not clear the performance difference between them , so in this work we will present a comparative study of these two kinetic schemes for continuum flows , even the dugks is not limited to such flows
we will also investigate the link between the two schemes by comparing them in the same finite volume framework .
the remaining part of this paper is organized as follows .
sec . 2 will introduce the dugks and bkg methods and discuss their relation , sec .
3 will present the comparison results , and a conclusion is given in sec .
the governing equation for the olb schemes and dugks method is the boltzmann equation with the bhatnagar - gross - krook collision operator @xcite , @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the distribution function ( df ) with particle velocity @xmath3 at position @xmath4 and time @xmath5 , @xmath6 is relaxation time due to particle collisions , and @xmath7 is the maxwellian equilibrium distribution function . in this article
, we consider the isothermal two - dimensional - nine - velocities ( d2q9 ) lattice model .
the corresponding dvbe is @xmath8 where @xmath9 and @xmath10 are the df with discrete velocity @xmath11 and the corresponding discrete equilibrium df respectively .
the d2q9 discrete velocity set @xmath11 is defined as @xmath12 , \sin[(\alpha-1)\pi/2]\right ) & \text{for } ~ \alpha=1,2,3,4,\\ \sqrt{3rt } \left(\cos[(2\alpha-9)\pi/4 ] , \sin[(2\alpha-9)\pi/4]\right)\sqrt{2 } & \text{for } ~ \alpha=5,6,7,8 , \end{cases}\ ] ] where @xmath13 is the gas constant and @xmath14 is the constant temperature . under the low mach number condition
, the discrete equilibrium df can be approximated by its taylor expansion around zero particle velocity up to second order , @xmath15,\ ] ] where @xmath16 is the lattice sound speed and the weights @xmath17 are @xmath18 the fluid density @xmath19 and velocity @xmath20 are the moments of the df , @xmath21 the shear viscosity of the fluid is related to the relaxation time by @xmath22 which can be deduced from chapman - enskog analysis @xcite .
the conservation property of the collision term is maintained at its discrete velocity counterpart , i.e. , @xmath23 the dugks employs a cell centered finite volume ( fv ) discretization of the dvbe @xcite .
the computational domain is firstly divided into small control volumes @xmath24 . for a clear illustration of the formulas , we denote the volume averaged df with discrete velocity @xmath25 in control volume @xmath24 at time level @xmath26 by @xmath27 , i.e. , @xmath28 then integrating eq . from time @xmath26 to time @xmath29 and applying the gauss theorem we can get @xmath30,\ ] ] where @xmath31 is the numerical flux that flows into the control volume from its faces , and @xmath32 is the time step size . note that trapezoidal rule is used for the collision term .
this implicit treatment of the collision term is crucial for its stability when the time step is much larger than the relaxation time .
this implicitness can be removed in the actual implementation using the following variable transformation technique , which is also adopted by the standard lbm , @xmath33 equation can then be rewritten in an explicit formulation , @xmath34 in the implementation , we track the evolution of @xmath35 instead of the original df . due to the conservation property of the collision term , the macroscopic variables can be calculated by the transformed df , @xmath36 the key merit of dugks lies in its treatment of the advection term , i.e. , the way to construct the numerical flux @xmath31 . in dugks
, the middle point rule is used for the integration of the flux , @xmath37 the integration over the faces is computed by the @xmath38 at the centers of the faces , which are computed using the characteristic solution of the kinetic equation .
supposed the center of a face is @xmath39 , then integrating eq . along the characteristic line in a half time step @xmath40 from @xmath41 to @xmath42 , and applying the trapezoidal rule
, we can get @xmath43 .
\label{eq_charraw}\ ] ] again the implicitness can be eliminated by introducing another two variable transformations , @xmath44 and we can reformulate eq . in an explicit form , @xmath45 for smooth flow
, @xmath46 can be interpolated linearly from its neighboring cell centers . after getting @xmath47
, the original df @xmath48 can be transformed back with the help of eq . .
the macroscopic fluid variable @xmath49 and @xmath50 used by the collision term in eq . are calculated from , @xmath51 to insure the interpolation is stable , the time step is limited by the cfl condition , @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the cfl number and @xmath54 measures the size of the cell . unlike the dugks in which the collision and particle - transport are treated simultaneously , the bkg scheme is a splitting method for eq . , which treats the convection term and collision term sequentially , i.e. , @xmath55 in the collision step , the collision term is integrated using trapezoidal rule @xcite , @xmath56 .
\label{eq : splic_c}\ ] ] using the same notation as used in the dugks , eq . can be rewritten in an explicit formulation , @xmath57 with @xmath58 .
it is noted that this treatment is identical to that of the standard lbm .
then eq . is solved with the lax - wendroff scheme with the initial value @xmath59 or @xmath60 , @xmath61 where the subscripts @xmath62 denote the spatial indices .
equation forms the evolution of the bkg scheme . in the original works @xcite , either finite element ( fe ) or finite difference ( fd )
is employed to discretize the spatial gradients in eq . .
in ref . [ 14 ] , the central finite - difference scheme on a uniform mesh is used , i.e , the first and second order spatial derivatives are computed as @xcite , [ eq : central_schemes ] @xmath63 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the computational stencil for each node is illustrated in fig .
[ fig : fv_stencil ] .
it is noted that if we use the one dimensional lax - wendroff scheme to solve eq . in each discrete velocity direction on a uniform cartesian grid , this characteristic based scheme reduces to the lax - wendroff lbe scheme developed in @xcite . the lax - wendroff scheme eq .
can also be expressed as @xmath64 \\ & \approx \tilde f^{+,n}_\alpha - \delta t \xi_{\alpha i } \frac{\partial}{\partial x_i}\left(\tilde f^{+,n}_\alpha(\bm{x}-\bm{\xi_\alpha}h)\right)\\ & \equiv \tilde f^{+,n}_\alpha - \delta t \xi_{\alpha i } \frac{\partial}{\partial x_i}\left(f^{n+1/2}_\alpha(\bm{x})\right ) .
\end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this means that the bkg scheme can be reformulated as a fv scheme , @xmath65 where @xmath66 with @xmath67 to be more specific , we rewrite eq . in the finite - volume form as @xmath68 - \frac{\xi_{\alpha 2 } \delta t}{\delta x_2 } \left [ f^{n+1/2}_{\alpha , l , m+1/2 } - f^{n+1/2}_{\alpha , l , m-1/2}\right],\ ] ] where @xmath69 and @xmath70 are the dfs at the face - centers of cell @xmath71 at the half time step , which depend on interpolation schemes .
if the distribution function is assumed to be a linear piece - wise polynomial , we can obtain the distribution functions at the cell interfaces , e.g. , @xmath72 - \frac{\xi_{\alpha 1 } \delta t}{2\delta x_1 } [ \tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l , m } - \tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l-1,m } ] \\ & - \frac{\xi_{\alpha 2 } \delta t}{8\delta x_2 } [ \tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l-1,m+1 } + \tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l , m+1 } -\tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l-1,m-1 } - \tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l , m-1 } ] \\ & \approx \tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l-1/2,m } - \frac{\xi_{\alpha1}\delta t}{\delta x_1}\frac{\partial}{\partial x_1}\tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l-1/2,m } - \frac{\xi_{\alpha2}\delta t}{\delta x_2}\frac{\partial}{\partial x_2}\tilde f^{+,n}_{\alpha , l-1/2,m}. \end{split}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one can immediately check the equivalence of eqs . and , after calculating the rest flux terms in a similar way like eq . , and inserting eq . to eq . .
we now analyse the differences between the dugks and the bkg scheme in finite - volume formulation .
this is achieved by analyzing accuracy of the reconstructed distribution function at the cell interface center .
firstly , it is noted that the exact solution of the dvbe at the cell interface center is @xmath73 we can immediately find that if we approximate the integration of the collision term in eq .
explicitly , i.e. , assuming @xmath74 , we get eq . , which is the reconstructed distribution function in the bkg scheme .
on the other hand , if we apply trapezoidal rule to the quadrature , we get eq . ,
i.e. , the reconstructed cell - interface distribution functions in the dugks .
so , in both the dugks and the bkg methods , the flux is determined from the local characteristic solution of the dvbe , and the convection and collision effects are considered simultaneously .
we also indicate that , for those fv / fd schemes that use the simple central difference @xcite or upwind @xcite schemes of traditional cfd methods , the corresponding cell - interface distribution functions are @xmath75 and @xmath76 where the collision effect is totally ignored .
the effects of the different treatments of the integration of the collision term in eq . can be analyzed by using the chapman - enskog expansion method @xcite . by approximating the distribution function by its first - order chapman - enskog solution , @xmath77 with @xmath78 , we have @xmath79 therefore , for continuous flows where @xmath80 , the distribution function at the cell interface reconstructed in either the bkg or the dugks method is a second - order approximation of the exact one . furthermore , with the trapezoidal rule for the collision term
, the dugks is expected to be more accurate than the bkg method which uses a lower order explicit rule . in regions with large velocity gradients , where the collision effect or @xmath81 is important
, the bkg scheme may yield significant error .
more importantly , as the dugks employs an implicit treatment of the collision term in the evaluation of numerical flux , it is expected to be more stable than the bkg scheme .
finally , we shall remark that if the distribution functions at cell interfaces are obtained by direct interpolations , i.e. , neglecting the integral of the collision term in eq . , the leading error of the approximation is @xmath82 . as the integral of @xmath83 on right hand side of eq
. contributes to the diffusive flux , the lack of the collision term is equivalent to introduce a numerical viscosity proportional to @xmath84 @xcite .
this explains why many other fv based lattice boltzmann schemes have to keep the time step much smaller than the collision time to obtain accurate results .
in this subsection , we briefly mention the implementation of no - slip boundary condition for the bkg scheme and dugks methods , the basic idea here is to mimic the half - way bounce - back rule of the standard lbm @xcite by reversing the dfs at boundary faces at middle time steps .
[ fig : boundary_condition ] illustrates a boundary face located at a no slip wall with velocity @xmath85 .
both of the incoming and outgoing dfs at the boundary face at middle time steps have to be provided to update the cell - centered dfs .
we denote the incoming and outgoing dfs by @xmath86 and @xmath87 respectively , where @xmath88 stands for @xmath89 in the dugks and @xmath90 in bkg scheme .
the ghost cell method is used to facilitate the implementation of the no - slip boundary condition .
an extra layer of cells ( ghost cells ) are allocated outside of the wall .
the unknown dfs @xmath91 in the ghost cells are extrapolated linearly from the cell centers of the neighboring inner cells . here
, @xmath91 stands for @xmath92 in the dugks and @xmath93 in the bkg scheme
. then we can compute the @xmath87 normally .
after that , the incoming dfs are calculated in the same way as the half - way bounce - back rule in the standard lbm @xcite , @xmath94 where @xmath95 stands for an outgoing df direction and @xmath96 is its reverse direction .
in this section , we compare the dugks and the bkg scheme in terms of accuracy , stability and computational efficiency by simulating several two dimensional flows .
the first one is the unsteady taylor - green vortex flow which is free from boundary effect , and exhibits an analytical solution exists for this problem , the second test case is the lid - driven cavity flow , which is used to evaluate the accuracy and stability , and the last one is the laminar boundary layer flow problem , which is used to verify the dissipation property of the the dugks and the bkg methods . in all of our simulation , @xmath97 is set to be @xmath98 and the cfl number is set to be 0.5 unless stated otherwise .
this problem is a two dimensional unsteady incompressible flow in a square domain with periodical condition in both directions .
the analytical solution is given by @xmath99 \exp(-16\pi^2\nu t),\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq : tvana ] where @xmath100 is a constant indicating the kinetic energy of the initial flow field , @xmath101 is the shear viscosity , @xmath102 is the velocity , and @xmath103 is the pressure . the computation domain is @xmath104 and @xmath105 with @xmath106 .
we set @xmath107 and @xmath108 .
the corresponding reynolds number and mach number are @xmath109 and @xmath110 , respectively .
the initial distribution function is computed from the chapman - enskog expansion at the navier - stokes order @xcite @xmath111 , \label{}\ ] ] where the equilibrium distribution functions are evaluated from the initial analytical solution .
we first evaluate the spatial accuracy of the dugks and bkg scheme by simulating the flow with varies mesh resolutions ( @xmath112 ) .
as we are analyzing the spatial accuracy , the time step is set to a very small value ( @xmath113 ) to suppress the errors caused by the time step size .
the @xmath114-error of the velocity filed is measured , @xmath115 where @xmath116 and @xmath117 are the analytical solution and numerical solution respectively .
the @xmath114-errors at the half - life time @xmath118 of the two schemes are measured and listed in table [ tab : tv_nerr ] .
the results are listed in table [ tab : tv_nerr ] .
it can be seen that both of the methods are of second order accuracy in space .
but the errors computed from dugks results are smaller than those of the bkg scheme on the same mesh resolutions .
.@xmath114-errors of the velocity filed for the taylor - green vortex flow [ cols="<,>,>,>,>,>",options="header " , ] [ tab : tv_nerr ] since both the dugks and bkg methods can admit a time step larger than the relaxation time , we now investigate their performance at large values of @xmath119 .
we fix the mesh size ( @xmath120 ) and the relaxation time but change the time step .
the @xmath114-errors at @xmath121 are shown in fig .
[ fig : tv_dterr ] , from which we can see that the errors scale almost linearly with the time step size for both methods .
particularly , the two methods still give reasonably accurate results @xmath119 is as large as 50 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : tv_uprofile ] . and
again , the errors of the dugks are smaller than those of the bkg scheme in all cases .
the two methods both blow up as @xmath122 since the cfl number goes beyond 1 at this condition . using varies @xmath123 on a @xmath124 mesh .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] at @xmath121 on a @xmath124 mesh , the time step is @xmath125 .
, scaledwidth=50.0% ] here , we also discuss the computational efficiencies of the dugks and the bkg scheme when implementing both of the schemes in fv framework , their only difference is the computing of numerical flux .
the dugks introduces two sets of additional dfs and macro variables at cell faces are required .
so it can be expected that the dugks s computing cost is obviously higher than that of the bkg scheme .
for example on an intel xeon e5 - [email protected] cpu , the computation times for 10,000 steps of the bkg and the dugks with @xmath124 mesh are 10.5s and 19.7s respectively , meaning the dugks is about one time more expansive than the bkg scheme .
incompressible two dimensional lid - driven cavity flow is a popular benchmark problem for numerical schemes . here , we use it to evaluate the accuracy and stability of the two schemes at different reynolds numbers .
the flow domain is a square cavity with length @xmath126 .
the top wall moves with a constant velocity @xmath127 , while other walls are kept fixed .
the reynolds number is defined as @xmath128 with @xmath101 being the viscosity of the fluid . in the computation , we set @xmath106 , @xmath129 , and the viscosity of the fluid is adjusted to achieve different reynolds numbers .
uniform cartesian meshes with grid number @xmath112 are used in our simulations .
we first simulate the flow at @xmath130 and @xmath131 with different mesh resolutions to compare the accuracy and stability of the dugks and bkg methods .
the velocity profiles at steady states along the vertical and horizontal center lines predicted by the two schemes are presented in figs .
[ fig : cavity_re1000]-[fig : cavity_re10000 ] .
the benchmark solutions @xcite are also included for comparison .
it should be noted that , the grid numbers used in the bkg schemes are doubled from those in the dugks at each reynolds number , in that the bkg computations are unstable at the coarsest meshes used in the dugks . from these results , we can clearly observe that the dugks scheme gives more accurate results than the bkg scheme , especially at large reynolds numbers .
furthermore , the results show that the dugks is insensitive to mesh resolutions , while the bkg scheme is rather sensitive .
generally , much finer meshes should be used in the bkg scheme to obtained accurate results . specifically , the horizontal velocity profiles in the boundary layer of the top wall departure from the benchmark solutions severely at high reynolds numbers ( see figs .
[ fig : cavity_re5000 ] and [ fig : cavity_re10000 ] ) with coarser meshes , which was also observed in @xcite .
contrary to the bkg scheme , the dugks gives surprisingly good results with the same meshes even at @xmath132 . as has been analyzed in sec .
[ sec : numerical ] , the only difference between the dugks and the bkg scheme is the treatment of the quadrature for the collision term in the reconstruction of the cell - interface distribution function , and the difference scales with the time step , which have been confirmed in the test of taylor - green vortex flow .
now we explore the effect of time step on the solution of this steady flow for the bkg scheme .
we simulate the flow at @xmath133 and @xmath131 using various cfl numbers with a fixed grid ( @xmath134 ) .
the calculated velocity profiles are shown in fig .
[ fig : cavity_cfl ] .
we can see that the errors decrease with decreasing cfl number .
but even with cfl=0.1 , the errors are still much larger than those of the dugks .
we also use the cavity flow to assess and compare the stability of the two schemes .
generally , the stability of the numerical schemes for the bgk equation is affected by the treatments of both the advection term and the collision term .
the stability for an explicit discretization of the advection term is controlled by the cfl number , while the stability due to the collision term treatment depends on the ratio of @xmath84 and the collision time @xmath6 , i.e. , @xmath119 .
the maximum values of @xmath119 at varies cfl numbers for a stable computation on the @xmath135 and @xmath124 meshes are measured and presented in fig .
[ fig : cavity_stab ] with error ranges .
it can be seen that there exists a clear distinction between the bkg and the dugks methods . for the bkg scheme ,
the computation is unstable at moderately large @xmath119 even though @xmath0 , while for the dugks , the stability is almost not affected by the cfl number as long as @xmath136 .
this observation confirms to the analysis in sec . [
sec : numerical ] that the numerical stability is also affected by the treatment of the collision term in the evaluation of numerical flux .
computing the collision term implicitly both in eq .
and eq . makes the dugks a rather robust scheme . for stable computations of the cavity flow.,scaledwidth=60.0% ] in the cavity flow
, it is observed that the bkg scheme fails to capture the boundary layer accurately near the top wall of the cavity for large reynolds numbers . in this subsection , we use the laminar flow over a flat plate as a stand - alone case to check this phenomenon and therefore , evaluate the dissipation characteristics of the bkg scheme and the dugks .
the flow configuration of this problem is sketched in fig .
[ fig : bl_mesh ] . a uniform flow with horizontal velocity @xmath100 flows past a flat plate with length @xmath126 .
this steady problem has an analytical self - similar blasius solution .
the reynolds number is defined as @xmath137 , where @xmath101 is the kinematic viscosity . in the simulations , we set @xmath138 , @xmath139 and @xmath140 .
the boundary layer is very thin at such a high reynolds number , so non - uniform structured meshes stretched in the vertical direction are employed ( fig.[fig : bl_mesh ] ) .
the cell size along @xmath141 direction increases with a ratio @xmath142 , and the height of the first layer is @xmath143 . the grid number in the @xmath141 direction
is adjusted according to @xmath143 to make sure the height of the computation domain is right beyond 50 .
the cell size in the @xmath144 direction is refined at the leading edge of the plate , with @xmath145 to account for the singularity of the flow behavior there .
the increasing ratios of the cell size to the downstream and upstream from the leading edge are @xmath146 and @xmath147 , respectively .
the total cell number in the @xmath144 direction is 120 , with 80 cells distributed on the plate .
free stream condition is applied to the left and top boundaries .
outflow boundary condition is applied to the right boundary , and symmetric boundary condition is used at the section before the plate at the bottom boundary .
no - slip boundary condition is imposed at the bottom wall and is realized by the method described in sec .
[ sec : wallboundary ] .
+ we simulate the flow with different mesh resolutions by adjusting the parameter @xmath143 from @xmath148 to @xmath149 .
the cfl number is fixed at 0.5 .
the velocity profiles at @xmath150 and @xmath151 predicted by the bkg and the dugks methods together with the blasius solutions are shown in figs .
[ fig : bl_u]-[fig : bl_v ] .
the horizontal velocity is scaled by @xmath100 , and the vertical velocity is scaled by @xmath152 , where @xmath153 is the local reynolds number defined by @xmath154 .
+ from these results , we can observe that , the boundary layer can be captured accurately by the dugks with the three meshes , particularly , with the coarsest mesh ( @xmath155 ) there are only 4 cells in the boundary layer at @xmath156 .
on the other hand , the bkg scheme ca nt give satisfactory results even with the finest mesh ( @xmath157 ) , as shown in fig .
[ fig : bl_u](a ) , fig .
[ fig : bl_u](b ) , fig .
[ fig : bl_v](a ) and fig .
[ fig : bl_v](b ) .
it is also observed that the results of the bkg scheme are quite sensitive to the mesh employed .
these results suggest again that the dugks is more robust than the bkg scheme . like the cavity flow case
, we reduce the time step in the bkg simulation to examine the effects of time step .
the computation is carried out on the mesh of @xmath155 and the cfl number varies from @xmath158 to @xmath159 .
the velocity profiles are presented in fig .
[ fig : bl_bkg_cfl ] .
it can be seen that the use of a small time step can improve the accuracy , but the deviations from the blasius solution are still obvious even with cfl=0.01 .
in this paper , the performance of two kinetic schemes , i.e. , the bkg scheme and the dugks is compared . both of them can remove the time step restriction which is commonly seen in many off - lattice boltzmann schemes . a theoretical analysis in the finite - volume framework demonstrates that the two methods differ only in the constructions of numerical flux .
the bkg scheme treats the collision integral with the one - point quadrature when integrate the bgk equation along the characteristic line to evaluate the numerical flux , while dugks computes it with the trapezoidal quadrature .
consequently , the dugks is more accurate and stable than the bkg scheme .
the numerical results of three test cases , including unsteady and steady flows , confirm that the the dugks is more accurate and stable than the bkg scheme on the same computing configurations , especially for high reynolds number flows .
it is also observed that the dugks is stable as long as @xmath0 , while the bkg scheme s stability degrades quickly as the cfl number goes beyond 0.5 .
we attribute this to the implicit treatment of the collision term of the dugks when evaluating the numerical flux .
furthermore , the results show that the dugks is more insensitive to mesh resolutions than the bkg method .
numerical results also demonstrate that the bkg scheme is about one time faster than the dugks on a same mesh .
however , it should be noted that the latter can achieve an accurate solution with a much finer mesh , suggesting that it can be more efficient for flow computations than the bgk scheme . in summary ,
the theoretical analysis and numerical results demonstrate that the dugks can serve as an efficient method for simulating continuum flows , although it is not limited to such flow regime .
the authors thank prof .
kun xu for many helpful discussions , and thank dr .
weidong li for providing the benchmark data of the laminar boundary layer .
this study is financially supported by the national science foundation of china ( grant no .
51125024 ) and the fundamental research funds for the central universities ( grant no .
2014ts119 ) .
34 a. bardow , i.v .
karlin , a.a .
gusev , general characteristic - based algorithm for off - lattice boltzmann simulations , europhys . lett . , 75 ( 2006 ) 434 .
guo , k. xu , r.j .
wang , discrete unified gas kinetic scheme for all knudsen number flows : low - speed isothermal case , phys .
e , 88 ( 2013 ) 033305 .
r. mei , w. shyy , on the finite difference - based lattice boltzmann method in curvilinear coordinates , j. comput .
phys . , 143 ( 1998 ) 426 - 448
. g. peng , h. xi , c. duncan , s .- h .
chou , finite volume scheme for the lattice boltzmann method on unstructured meshes , phys .
e , 59 ( 1999 ) 4675 - 4682 .
t. lee , c .-
lin , a characteristic galerkin method for discrete boltzmann equation , j. comput .
phys . , 171 ( 2001 ) 336 - 356 .
t. lee , c .-
lin , an eulerian description of the streaming process in the lattice boltzmann equation , j. comput .
phys . , 185 ( 2003 ) 445 - 471 .
guo , t.s .
zhao , explicit finite - difference lattice boltzmann method for curvilinear coordinates , phys .
e , 67 ( 2003 ) 066709 .
n. rossi , s. ubertini , g. bella , s. succi , unstructured lattice boltzmann method in three dimensions , int .
, 49 ( 2005 ) 619 - 633 .
a. bardow , i.v .
karlin , a.a .
gusev , multispeed models in off - lattice boltzmann simulations , phys .
e , 77 ( 2008 ) 025701 .
patil , k.n .
lakshmisha , finite volume tvd formulation of lattice boltzmann simulation on unstructured mesh , j. comput .
phys . , 228 ( 2009 ) 5262 - 5279 .
patil , k.n .
lakshmisha , two - dimensional flow past circular cylinders using finite volume lattice boltzmann formulation , int .
j. numer . meth .
, 69 ( 2012 ) 1149 - 1164 .
mcnamara , a.l .
garcia , b.j .
alder , stabilization of thermal lattice boltzmann models , j. stat .
, 81 ( 1995 ) 395 - 408 .
guo , c.g .
zheng , t.s .
zhao , a lattice bgk scheme with general propagation , j. sci .
comput . , 16 ( 2001 ) 569 - 585 .
rao , l.a .
schaefer , numerical stability of explicit off - lattice boltzmann schemes : a comparative study , j. comput .
phys . , 285 ( 2015 ) 251 - 264 .
guo , r.j .
wang , k. xu , discrete unified gas kinetic scheme for all knudsen number flows .
ii . thermal compressible case , phys .
e , 91 ( 2015 ) 033313 .
p. wang , l.h .
zhu , z.l .
guo , k. xu , a comparative study of lbe and dugks methods for nearly incompressible flows , commun .
phys . , 17 ( 2015 ) 657 - 681 .
zhu , z.l .
guo , k. xu , discrete unified gas kinetic scheme on unstructured meshes , arxiv preprint arxiv:1503.07374 , ( 2015 ) .
bhatnagar , e.p .
gross , m. krook , a model for collision processes in gases .
i. small amplitude processes in charged and neutral one - component systems , phys . rev .
, 94 ( 1954 ) 511 .
guo , c. shu , lattice boltzmann method and its applications in engineering , world scientific , singapore , 2013 . c. hirsch , numerical computation of internal and external flows : the fundamentals of computational fluid dynamics , second ed .
butterworth - heinemann , burlington , 2007 .
leveque , finite volume methods for hyperbolic problems , cambridge university press , cambridge , 2002 .
kim , h. pitsch , i.d .
boyd , accuracy of higher - order lattice boltzmann methods for microscale flows with finite knudsen numbers , j. comput .
phys . , 227 ( 2008 ) 8655 - 8671
. t. ohwada , on the construction of kinetic schemes , j. comput .
phys . , 177 ( 2002 ) 156 - 175 .
s. chen , k. xu , a comparative study of an asymptotic preserving scheme and unified gas - kinetic scheme in continuum flow limit , j. comput .
, 288 ( 2015 ) 52 - 65 .
k. xu , z. li , dissipative mechanism in godunov type schemes , int .
, 37 ( 2001 ) 1 - 22 .
k. xu , a gas - kinetic bgk scheme for the navier - stokes equations and its connection with artificial dissipation and godunov method , j. comput .
phys . , 171 ( 2004 ) 289 - 335 .
u. ghia , k.n .
ghia , c.t .
shin , high - re solutions for incompressible flow using the navier - stokes equations and a multigrid method , j. comput .
phys . , 48 ( 1982 ) 387 - 411 . | the general characteristics based off - lattice boltzmann scheme ( bkg ) proposed by bardow et al .
, @xcite and the discrete unified gas kinetic scheme ( dugks ) @xcite are two methods that successfully overcome the time step restriction by the collision time , which is commonly seen in many other kinetic schemes . basically , the bkg scheme is a time splitting scheme , while the dugks is an un - split finite volume scheme . in this work ,
we first perform a theoretical analysis of the two schemes in the finite volume framework by comparing their numerical flux evaluations .
it is found that the effects of collision term are considered in the reconstructions of the cell - interface distribution function in both schemes , which explains why they can overcome the time step restriction and can give accurate results even as the time step is much larger than the collision time .
the difference between the two schemes lies in the treatment of the integral of the collision term , in which the bardow s scheme uses the rectangular rule while the dugks uses the trapezoidal rule .
the performance of the two schemes , i.e. , accuracy , stability , and efficiency are then compared by simulating several two dimensional flows , including the unsteady taylor - green vortex flow , the steady lid - driven cavity flow , and the laminar boundary layer problem .
it is observed that , the dugks can give more accurate results than the bkg scheme .
furthermore , the numerical stability of the bkg scheme decreases as the courant - friedrichs - lewy ( cfl ) number approaches to 1 , while the stability of dugks is not affected by the cfl number apparently as long as @xmath0 .
it is also observed that the bkg scheme is about one time faster than the dugks scheme with the same computational mesh and time step . |
symmetries are essential features of quantal systems as they characterize their energetics and provide transition matrix elements of operators with specific selection rules . however , certain emergent phenomena relate to the spontaneous breaking of those symmetries @xcite
. in nuclear systems , such spontaneously - broken symmetries ( i ) relate to specific features of the inter - particle interactions , ( ii ) characterize internal correlations and ( iii ) leave clear fingerprints in the excitation spectrum of the system . in finite systems though , quantum fluctuations can not be ignored such that the concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking is only an intermediate description that arises within certain approximations .
eventually , symmetries must be restored to achieve a complete description of the system .
in wave - function - based methods , the symmetry breaking step , e.g. the symmetry unrestricted hartree - fock - bogoliubov approximation , relies on minimizing the average value of the hamiltonian for a trial wave - function that does not carry good quantum numbers , i.e. which mixes irreducible representations of the symmetry group of interest .
restoring symmetries amounts to using an enriched trial wave - function that does carry good quantum numbers .
one typical approach is to project out from the symmetry - breaking trial state the component that belongs to the intended irreducible representation .
wave - function - based projection methods and their variants are well formulated quantum mechanically @xcite .
on the other hand it is of importance to analyze further their energy density functional ( edf ) counterparts @xcite which have been _ empirically adapted _ from the former to deal quantitatively with properties of nuclei @xcite .
the single - reference ( sr ) edf method relies on computing the analog to the symmetry - unrestricted hartree - fock - bogoliubov energy @xmath0 as an a priori general functional @xmath1 $ ] of the density matrices @xmath2 and @xmath3 computed from the product state @xmath4 . here , the label @xmath5 denotes the parameter(s ) of the symmetry group @xmath6 of interest , e.g. euler angles for @xmath7 or the gauge angle for @xmath8 . the multi - reference ( mr ) edf method , that amounts to restore symmetries broken at the sr level , relies on computing the analog to the non - diagonal energy _
@xmath9 $ ] associated with a pair of product states @xmath10 and @xmath4 as a general functional of the _ transition _ one - body matrices , i.e. @xmath9 \equiv { \cal e}[\rho^{g'g},\kappa^{g'g},\kappa^{gg'\ast}]$ ] . from such a energy kernel , the symmetry - restored energies @xmath11 are obtained through an expansion @xcite over the volume of the symmetry group group associated with particle - number conservation . ]
@xmath12 \ , n[g',g ] & \equiv & \sum_{\lambda ab } c^{\ast}_{\lambda a } \ , c_{\lambda b}\ , { \cal e}^{\lambda } \ ,
s^{\lambda}_{ab}(g\!-\!g ' ) \,\,\ , , \label{ssbnormkernel0 } \\
\label{ssbenergykernel } n[g',g ] & \equiv & \sum_{\lambda ab } c^{\ast}_{\lambda a } \ , c_{\lambda b } \
, s^{\lambda}_{ab}(g\!-\!g ' ) \,\ , \ , , \label{ssbnormkernel}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath13\equiv \langle \phi ( g ' ) | \phi ( g ) \rangle$ ] , while @xmath14 denotes a unitary irreducible representation ( labeled by @xmath15 ) of the symmetry group .
a key point is that , as opposed to wave - function - based approaches , the edf method does _ not _ rely on computing @xmath9 $ ] from the average value of a genuine scalar operator @xmath16 such that all expected mathematical properties of such a kernel are not necessarily ensured a priori .
consequently , one may wonder whether the symmetry constraints imposed on the energy kernel @xmath17 $ ] at the sr level @xcite are sufficient or not to making the mr - edf method well defined ? as a matter of fact , a specific set of constraints to be imposed on the non - diagonal kernel @xmath9 $ ] have been worked out to fulfill basic properties and internal consistency requirements @xcite .
still , refs .
@xcite have shown in the case of the @xmath8 group , i.e. for particle - number restoration ( pnr ) , that such constraints were not sufficient to making the theory well behaved .
in particular , it was demonstrated @xcite that fourier components @xmath18 could be different from zero for a negative number of particles @xmath19 .
contrarily , it can be shown that @xmath20 is zero @xcite for @xmath19 when it is computed as the average value of a genuine operator @xmath16 in a projected wave - function , i.e. in the wave - function - based method . applying the regularization method proposed in ref .
@xcite , the nullity of the non - physical fourier components was recovered @xcite .
the case of @xmath8 was particularly instructive given that clear - cut physical arguments could be used to assess that certain coefficients of the ( fourier ) expansion of the energy kernel should be strictly zero .
such an investigation demonstrated that the mr - edf method , as performed so far , faces the danger to be ill - defined and that new constraints on the energy kernel @xmath9 $ ] must be worked out in order to make the symmetry - restoration method physically sound . the regularization method proposed in ref .
@xcite that restores the validity of pnr can only be applied if the edf kernel @xmath17 $ ] depends strictly on integer powers of the density matrices @xcite , which is an example of such a new constraint . for an arbitrary symmetry group
, the situation might not be as transparent as for @xmath8 .
indeed , it is unlikely in general that certain coefficients of the expansion of @xmath9 n[g',g]$ ] over irreducible representations of the group are zero based on physical arguments .
the challenge we face can be formulated in the following way : although expansion [ ssbnormkernel0 ] underlining the mr - edf method is sound from a group - theory point of view , additional mathematical properties deduced from a wave - function - based method must be worked out and imposed on @xmath9 $ ] to make the expansion coefficient @xmath11 physically sound .
the next section briefly discusses an example of such a property in the case of @xmath7 , i.e. for angular momentum restoration , that could be used to constrain the form of the functional kernel @xmath21 $ ] .
more details can be found in ref .
@xcite .
we omit spin and isospin for simplicity and consider the rotationally - invariant nuclear hamiltonian @xmath22 in which three - nucleon and higher many - body forces are disregarded for simplicity . considering an eigenstate @xmath23 of @xmath24 and @xmath25 , as well as using center of mass @xmath26 and relative coordinates @xmath27 , tedious but straightforward calculations allow one to show that the potential energy takes the form @xcite @xmath28 where the potential energy _ density _
@xmath29 thus defines from the two - body density matrix @xmath30 \
, lmlm}_{\vec{r}\vec{r}}$ ] read @xmath31}_{ll'}(r ) \ , y^{0}_{l'}(\hat{r } ) \,\,\ , .
\label{potentialenergydensity}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the weight @xmath32}_{ll'}(r)$ ] depends on the norm of @xmath33 only and is related to a reduced matrix element of the two - body density matrix operator recoupled to a total angular momentum @xmath34 .
the remarkable mathematical property identified through eq . [ potentialenergydensity ] is that the scalar potential energy @xmath35 is obtained from an intermediate energy density @xmath29 whose dependence on the orientation of @xmath33 is tightly constrained by the angular - momentum quantum number of the underlying many - body state @xmath23 , i.e. its expansion over spherical harmonics is limited to @xmath36 .
such a result is unchanged when adding the kinetic energy ( density ) to the potential energy ( density ) such that we restrict ourselves to the latter for simplicity .
of course , the energy eventually extracts the coefficient of the lowest harmonic , i.e. @xmath37}_{l0}(r)$ ] .
since property [ potentialenergydensity ] is general , it is straightforward to show that it can be recovered within the frame of the wave - function - based symmetry - restoration method @xcite .
the key point to underline relates to the fact that property [ potentialenergydensity ] can not be derived a priori in the edf method .
indeed , the potential energy part of the kernel @xmath21 $ ] is _ not _ explicitly related to the two - body density matrix in such a case .
consequently , there is no reason a priori that the energy density @xmath38 displays property [ potentialenergydensity ] ; i.e. the angular dependence of @xmath38 is likely to display harmonics @xmath39 with @xmath40 .
one might argue that it is not an issue considering that the symmetry - restored potential energy @xmath41 eventually relates to the harmonic @xmath42 only .
however , a formalism that provides @xmath38 with a spurious angular content will certainly also provide the coefficient @xmath43 of the lowest harmonic with unphysical contributions . to state it differently ,
it is likely that constraining the mr - edf kernels @xmath44 $ ] to produce an energy density @xmath45 that fulfils the mathematical property [ potentialenergydensity ] will impact at the same time the value of the weight @xmath46 , and thus the value of @xmath47 .
to some extent , this is similar to the situation encountered with @xmath8 where restoring the mathematical property that fourier coefficients @xmath48 with @xmath19 should be strictly zero impacted the value of all other fourier coefficients @xcite .
we briefly review the notion of symmetry breaking and restoration within the frame of nuclear energy density functional ( edf ) methods .
multi - reference ( mr ) edf calculations are nowadays routinely applied with the aim of including long - range correlations associated with large - amplitude collective motions that are difficult to incorporate in a more traditional single - reference ( sr ) , i.e. `` mean - field '' , edf formalism @xcite .
the framework for mr - edf calculations was originally set - up by analogy with projection techniques and the generator coordinate method ( gcm ) , which are rigorously formulated only within a hamiltonian / wave - function - based formalism @xcite .
we presently elaborate on key differences between wave - function- and energy - functional - based methods .
in particular , we point to difficulties encountered to formulate symmetry restoration within the energy functional approach .
the analysis performed in ref .
@xcite to tackle problems encountered in refs .
@xcite for particle number restoration serves as a baseline . reaching out to angular - momentum restoration
, we identify in a wave - function - based framework a mathematical property of the energy density @xmath49 associated with angular momentum conservation that could be used to constrain edf kernels .
consequently , possible future routes to better formulate symmetry restorations in edf - based methods could encompass the following points . 1 .
the fingerprints left on the energy density @xmath49 by angular momentum conservation in a wave - function - based method could be exploited to constrain the functional form of the basic edf kernel @xmath17 $ ] .
2 . the regularization method proposed in ref . @xcite to deal with specific spurious features of mr - edf calculations should be investigated as to what impact it has on properties of the energy density @xmath45 in the case of angular momentum restoration .
similar mathematical properties extracted from a wave - function - based method could be worked out for other symmetry groups of interest and used to constrain edf kernels .
0 t. duguet , j. sadoudi , j. phys .
37 ( 2010 ) 064009 c. yannouleas , u. landman , rep .
70 ( 2007 ) 2067 and references therein p. ring , p. schuck , the nuclear many - body problem , 1980 , springer - verlag , new - york j. dobaczewski , j. dudek , acta phys .
b27 ( 1996 ) 45 l. m. robledo , int . j. mod .
phys . e16 ( 2007 )
337 j. dobaczewski _
c 76 ( 2007 ) 054315 d. lacroix , t. duguet , m. bender , phys .
c 79 ( 2009 ) 044318 m. bender , t. duguet , d. lacroix , phys .
c 79 ( 2009 ) 044319 t. duguet _
c 79 ( 2009 ) 044320 m. bender _
et al . _ , rev .
phys . 75 ( 2003 ) 121 and references therein d. almehed , s. frauendorf , f. donau , phys .
c63 ( 2001 ) 044311 m. anguiano , j. l. egido , l. m. robledo , nucl .
a696 ( 2001 ) 467 | we review the notion of symmetry breaking and restoration within the frame of nuclear energy density functional methods .
we focus on key differences between wave - function- and energy - functional - based methods .
in particular , we point to difficulties encountered within the energy functional framework and discuss new potential constraints on the underlying energy density functional that could make the restoration of broken symmetries better formulated within such a formalism .
we refer to ref .
@xcite for details . |
since its reintroduction into astrophysics by balbus & hawley ( 1991 ) , the magneto - rotational instability ( mri ) has become an essential ingredient in our understanding of astrophysical fluids in a state of differential rotation . as a result of its action , strong turbulence is created anywhere there is a weak magnetic field in a conducting fluid whose rotation rate decreases away from the rotation axis .
the turbulent magnetic ( and , to a lesser degree , fluid ) stress it creates is the most likely source of angular momentum transport in accretion disks ( balbus & hawley 1998 ) .
the joint action of turbulence and differential rotation can drive a dynamo capable of maintaining the magnetic energy at a few percent of the fluid internal energy .
applications of these mechanisms have been found in a wide range of circumstances , from supernovae ( akiyama et al .
2003 ) to galaxies ( kim et al .
2003 ) .
somewhat paradoxically , it is a condition for growth that the field be weak . to be precise ,
when gas and magnetic pressure combine to support the disk material against the vertical component of gravity , the matter s scale - height is @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the alfven speed , @xmath8 the sound speed , and @xmath9 the local orbital frequency .
because magnetic tension suppresses growth for wavelengths @xmath10 , only if the magnetic energy density is less than the gas pressure ( i.e. , the plasma @xmath11 ) can modes with short enough wavelength to fit in the disk ( @xmath12 ) be unstable . at the same time , although the magnitude of the fastest growing wavelength depends ( linearly ) on the field strength , its growth rate @xmath13 is entirely independent of the field s intensity .
on the other hand , if there were truly zero field , magnetic dynamics would , of course , be irrelevant .
thus , it appears that the nature of the mri in the limit of progressively weaker field is ill - defined , at least within the framework of ideal mhd .
it is the goal of this paper to begin clarifying what happens in this extreme weak - field limit , developing linear theory to account both for growth and damping .
we do so in part to illuminate this point of principle , but we also identify several astrophysical contexts in which the field may be so weak that the special effects we discover in the weak - field limit may be of interest .
these include galaxies so young that their interstellar magnetic fields have not yet grown to interesting amplitude , accretion systems in primordial galaxies where the seed fields may have been very weak , and proto - stellar accretion flows in which the charge resides primarily on massive grains .
some aspects of our work are related to results already in the literature . in particular , there has already been significant study of how the mri operates in media where the magnetic field is weak in a different sense : where the field is considered weak not because it fails to dominate gravity , but because it is not strong enough for the lorentz force it produces to dominate the momentum transfer associated with collisions between charged species and neutrals .
this case is called the hall regime , and has been analyzed by balbus & terquem ( 2001 ) and salmeron & wardle ( 2003 ) .
we uncover hall effects too , but of a different sort ( see [ s : threeregimes ] ) .
similarly , we will be interested in a breakdown of ideal mhd in the sense that the electrons and ions are not tied perfectly to the magnetic field .
a different failure of the mhd approximation in the context of the mri has been examined by quataert , dorland , & hammett ( 2002 ) , sharma , hammett , & quataert ( 2003 ) , and balbus ( 2004 ) , who have explored the implications of collisionless behavior .
they find that anisotropic pressure , anisotropic viscosous transport , and landau damping , none of which is captured by mhd , can be important . in
[ s : damping ] , we argue that all three of these effects are unimportant in the weak - field regime . finally , kitchatinov & rdiger ( 2004 ) have considered the mri in protogalactic disks and estimated the fieldstrength below which the instability is resistively damped .
to explore this new regime , we adopt the simplest non - trivial model that can describe the physics of the weak - field regime : a two - fluid picture of a cold but fully - ionized disk , threaded by a uniform magnetic field @xmath14 , orbiting in a gravitational potential determined by external sources .
the conventional single - fluid mhd limit implicitly assumes that the plasma and the fieldlines are frozen together ; in order to see how they decouple in the limit of weak field , we must follow the dynamics of the positive and negative charge - carriers separately . that is to say ,
we define the system in terms of separate force equations for two incompressible fluids , with no pressure gradients .
the fields are determined by using the currents derived from the velocities of the two charged fluids in the ampre equation and using the changing magnetic fields created by those currents in faraday s law .
we use cylindrical polar coordinates @xmath15 and denote radial derivatives by primes . in the equilibrium state , particles follow circular orbits of radius @xmath16 with angular velocity @xmath17 given by the usual expression @xmath18^{1/2}$ ] .
the particles are prevented from gyrating around the magnetic fieldlines by a radial electric field @xmath19 .
we consider small axisymmetric perturbations of this system , denoting the electric and magnetic field perturbations by @xmath20 and @xmath21 and the perturbations of particle radius and angular velocity by @xmath22 and @xmath23 . in the cold plasma approximation ,
all the particles of a given species have the same perturbed orbits , but the orbits differ between species .
we assume all perturbed quantities depend on time and vertical coordinate @xmath24 as @xmath25 and perform a local analysis in which radial derivatives of the perturbed quantities are dropped .
the linearized equations of motion for particles of charge @xmath26 and mass @xmath27 are @xmath28 @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the cyclotron frequency ( note that the sign of @xmath31 depends on the signs of both @xmath26 and @xmath32 ) . in deriving these equations
we have assumed @xmath33 , which is consistent with the local analysis , and we have used @xmath34 .
we solve equations ( [ e : rmotion ] ) and ( [ e : tmotion ] ) for the perturbed velocity components @xmath35 and @xmath36 in terms of @xmath20 .
the results are @xmath37 @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the squared epicyclic frequency .
although our analysis up to this point has been valid for any gravitational potential , from this point on , we assume a keplerian rotation law , for which @xmath40 and @xmath41 .
the perturbed current density @xmath42 is related to the perturbed velocity components by @xmath43 the summation is over species , and @xmath44 is number density .
we assume two species , of charge @xmath45 and equal density .
the dependence of @xmath46 on @xmath20 follows from eqns .
( [ e : r1 ] ) and ( [ e : t1 ] ) . on the other hand
, @xmath42 is also related to @xmath20 through faraday s law and ampre s law , with the displacement current dropped @xmath47 combining eqns .
( [ e : j1 ] ) and ( [ e : je ] ) and using eqns .
( [ e : r1 ] ) and ( [ e : t1 ] ) gives a dispersion relation , which we write in dimensionless form using the variables @xmath48 the dimensionless growth rate @xmath49 is thus measured in units of the orbital frequency , while the dimensionless wavelength is given by @xmath50 .
the quantity @xmath51 in the definition of @xmath50 is the squared ion plasma frequency , @xmath52 , so @xmath53 .
thus , @xmath50 measures the wavelength in terms of the ion inertial length @xmath54 : @xmath55 . one interpretation of @xmath56 is that it is the larmor radius of an ion traveling at the alfvn speed : that is , @xmath57 . in an electron - proton plasma , @xmath58 cm . in most astrophysical situations
this is much less than the size of the system , so global modes have @xmath59 .
note that with these definitions , @xmath60 .
field strength is described in terms of @xmath4 , where @xmath61 is the hall parameter defined in balbus & terquem 2001 and @xmath62 is the ratio of the mass per electron to the ion mass . in a fully - ionized plasma @xmath63 , but in a state of weak ionization this ratio could be much larger . ] . in the standard theory of the mri , @xmath64 , but we will consider the full range of @xmath65 . in
most of the paper we will set @xmath66 equal to its value in an electron - proton plasma , but in [ s : equalmass ] we will also consider plasmas with equal mass charge carriers , for which @xmath67 . the dispersion relation can be written compactly in terms of the functions @xmath68 and @xmath69 in terms of these two functions , it is @xmath70\left(1+z^2\nu^2f_{\nu}\right)+z^4\nu^2g_{\nu}^2=0.\ ] ] much of the subsequent analysis in this paper is based on eqn .
( [ e : dr ] ) .
it is an 8th degree polynomial equation for @xmath71 . in most of the parameter space that interests us ,
we find that the solutions are positive and negative pairs of either purely real or purely imaginary numbers .
when this is so , solutions of eqn .
( [ e : dr ] ) with @xmath72 correspond to instability , and perturbations are either purely oscillatory or purely exponential in time .
it is likewise clear from the form of eqn .
( [ e : dr ] ) that the magnetic field strength enters only in terms of the parameter @xmath0 .
however , @xmath0 appears sometimes by itself ( representing ions ) and sometimes in a product with @xmath66 ( representing electrons ) .
thus , whether the field is strong or weak depends on whether the cyclotron frequency ( usually of the positive charge carrier ) is large or small compared to the orbital frequency .
we first consider the conventional limit of eqn .
( [ e : dr ] ) : the case of ordinary mhd , in which @xmath76 and the ratio @xmath66 is that of an electron - proton plasma , 1837 . in this limit , the functions @xmath77 and @xmath78 take the asymptotic forms @xmath79 , @xmath80 .
equation ( [ e : dr ] ) becomes @xmath81 equation ( [ e : mhd ] ) is the standard mri dispersion relation for a keplerian disk , albeit written in an unfamiliar form .
there is a positive real root when @xmath82 .
as has been well - known since their original paper ( balbus & hawley 1991 ) , the maximum growth rate occurs for @xmath83 , and @xmath84 = 0.75 .
thus , the maximum growth rate occurs for wavelengths @xmath85 times longer than the minimum wavelength for growth , and @xmath86 for wavelengths much larger than the minimum . in the mhd regime
, both the ions and electrons closely follow the fieldlines , which have the @xmath87 velocity @xmath88 . as @xmath4 decreases and @xmath89 approaches @xmath9 ,
the ions deviate from the fieldlines , while the electrons , due to their much smaller mass , continue to follow them .
this regime of behavior ( i.e. , @xmath90 or less ) is often called the hall regime " of the mri because charge - sign differences lead to noticeable dynamical contrasts .
as we shall see , that is definitely the case here , but with the slight interpretive shift that what really matters is not so much charge - sign _ per se _ as the sense of the larmor orbit for the heavier particle relative to the sense of the gravitational orbits for all particles .
much of the essential behavior of this regime is captured by approximating @xmath77 and @xmath78 by @xmath91 , and @xmath92 .
the resulting dispersion relation , which is valid as long as @xmath93 but @xmath4 is not @xmath73 , is @xmath94 equation ( [ e : postmhd ] ) predicts instability for @xmath95 .
this can occur in either of two ways : in the special range of @xmath0 given by @xmath96 , @xmath97 , and the system is unstable at all wavelengths .
that is , when the larmor frequency and the orbital frequency are comparable in magnitude but have opposite sign for the heavier charged particle , unstable growth occurs at _ all _ wavelengths .
alternatively , whenever @xmath0 is in the range for which the approximations leading to eqn .
( [ e : postmhd ] ) are valid , growth occurs , but only at sufficiently long wavelengths . because @xmath90 , the quadratic character of the expression for the minimum unstable wavelength leads to significant differences between positive and negative @xmath0 : it is longer for positive @xmath0 and shorter for @xmath98 . similarly , the maximum growthrate is @xmath99 for negative @xmath0 , whereas it can be substantially smaller for positive @xmath0 .
when @xmath4 is still smaller , @xmath75 , a different analytic approximation applies : @xmath100 and @xmath101 . in that limit , the dispersion relation becomes @xmath102 where @xmath103 is proportional to the square of the wavelength in units of the electron inertial length @xmath104 : @xmath105 is the natural analog of @xmath106 in a regime where the ions play no role in the dynamics and the mode is carried by electrons .
( [ e : vsmallx ] ) has one solution corresponding to a mode that grows unstably when @xmath107 : @xmath108 . even in this regime ,
the growth rates can be comparable to the rotation rate : the peak growth rate , @xmath109 , occurs for @xmath110 .
however , because @xmath111 cm is so small in most systems of interest , we are primarily interested in the case @xmath112 . in this limit , @xmath113 .
that is , the modes of greatest interest grow very slowly . exact solutions of the full dispersion relation are shown in figures [ fig : posdisperse ] , [ fig : negdisperse ] , and [ fig : smalldisperse ] in order to show the transitions between these regimes and confirm our analytic approximations .
as illustrated in figure [ fig : posdisperse ] , when the field and the rotation rate are aligned , as @xmath0 falls toward @xmath99 and below , the weakening ability of the field to control the ion motion leads both to a narrowing in the range of unstable wavelengths and to a reduction in the maximum growthrate .
when @xmath90 but @xmath114 , as predicted by our analytic approximation , there is rapid growth at short wavelengths even while the same wavelength range is damped for positive @xmath0 ( fig .
[ fig : negdisperse ] ) .
the reason for this contrast is that when @xmath2 , the larmor motion opposes the orbital rotation where the orbital frequency is greater and adds to the orbital rotation where it is smaller , whereas it is the other way around for @xmath3 .
balbus & terquem ( 2001 ) and wardle ( 1999 ) similarly found that disks with field and orbital frequency anti - parallel are more unstable than those in which they are parallel . at somewhat smaller values of @xmath4 ,
the behavior becomes more similar for the two opposite signs .
our analytic approximation for @xmath115 is also confirmed by the full numerical solution ( fig .
[ fig : smalldisperse ] ) , which finds a minimum wavelength for growth @xmath116 , a maximum growthrate at wavelengths a few times longer , and a growthrate that declines @xmath117 for still longer wavelengths . in this regime ,
the field - strength parameter @xmath0 does nt appear explicitly in the dispersion relation , eliminating any dependence on the magnetic field strength .
in other words , when @xmath4 is this small , the instability dynamics are no longer magneto - rotational .
they are better described as the result of current fluctuations that inductively drive electric field fluctuations with the appropriate phase relative to the gravitational force as to cause instability . because @xmath118 |\vec j_1|$ ] , fluctuations on wavelengths that are too short are ineffective , and there is a minimum wavelength for instability .
this minimum wavelength must be of order the characteristic lengthscale , which in this case is the electron inertial length ( @xmath119 ) .
the coupling to gravity makes the characteristic timescale @xmath120 , but only on the short scales @xmath121 .
the instability for @xmath115 can be recovered directly from eqns .
( [ e : rmotion ] ) and ( [ e : tmotion ] ) by dropping the terms in which @xmath31 appears , computing @xmath42 from the electron motion alone , and using eqn .
( [ e : je ] ) .
the resulting dispersion relation is exactly eqn .
( [ e : vsmallx ] ) . in this limit ,
the perturbed electron motion is diagonally across the unperturbed orbit , oriented such that inward radial motion is in the forward azimuthal direction .
this electron motion creates a perturbed oscillating electric field of the same orientation and a perturbed oscillating magnetic field with complementary angle to the orbit and phase offset by @xmath122 .
because the magnetic field is larger in amplitude than the electric field by a ratio @xmath123 , the mean electromagnetic stress is dominated by the magnetic part ; it is @xmath124 , so that it transports angular momentum outward .
it can similarly be shown from eqns .
( [ e : r1 ] ) and ( [ e : t1 ] ) , together with the dispersion relation for unstable modes , that the torque on an electron , @xmath125 , is in phase with the radial displacement @xmath22 .
that is , an outwardly ( inwardly ) displaced electron has a positive ( negative ) angular momentum perturbation , which reinforces the motion .
thus , this mode might fairly be called an electromagnetic - rotational instability " . summarizing these results ,
we have found that the most rapidly growing wavelength has @xmath126 or @xmath127 for all field strengths @xmath128 .
the maximum growth rate @xmath129 when @xmath130 , but is smaller when @xmath131 and @xmath132 .
the magnetic character of instability finally disappears when @xmath115 , leaving an electromagnetic - gravitational mode that is unstable for @xmath133 and grows at a rate @xmath134 on scales of order the electron inertial length @xmath135 , and at much slower rates on global scales . for all cases in which @xmath4 is not @xmath73 , the physical scale of these modes becomes very short compared to any likely structural scale .
for example , if the plasma is located in a geometrically - thin disk that is supported by its own gas pressure against the vertical component of gravity , the wavelength of the most rapidly - growing mode is a fraction @xmath136 of the vertical scale - height ; when the field is very weak , this is likely to be an extremely small fraction .
it is not clear whether such small scale disturbances can play a significant role in either angular momentum transport or dynamo - generation .
they may be damped by other processes ( see [ s : damping ] ) ; even if they are not damped , inverse cascades in the nonlinear regime may be necessary for them to have significant global effect .
therefore , we devote special effort to understanding the nature of instability at long wavelengths , even if the modes are slowly growing . by limiting consideration to large @xmath50 , we can simplify eqn .
( [ e : dr ] ) to the point that we may derive approximately by analytic means some of the numerical results just illustrated . to lowest - order in @xmath137 , eqn .
( [ e : dr ] ) reduces to @xmath138 the solution in this limit is @xmath139 , or stable epicyclic oscillations .
to next lowest - order , we find a low growthrate unstable mode with @xmath140 this solution corresponds to the low growthrate , long wavelength tail seen in figures [ fig : posdisperse ] and [ fig : negdisperse ] .
for @xmath141 , it gives an approximation to the correct scaling , but overestimates the maximum growth rate by @xmath142 .
for a hydrogen plasma , the right hand side of eqn .
( [ e : lownu ] ) is positive , signifying instability for all @xmath0 . in the mhd limit , @xmath143 , and
this approximation holds quite well even for @xmath144 . if @xmath145 , @xmath71 approaches the limiting value @xmath146 , independent of @xmath0 .
thus , although cold plasma theory predicts that there is no minimum magnetic field necessary for instability , the growth rate at macroscopically interesting wavelengths is very slow . in certain circumstances ( e.g. , electron - positron pair plasmas , dust grains as the predominant charge carriers ) ,
the charge / mass ratio for both the positive and negative charges in the plasma may be the same , and therefore both have the same magnitude cyclotron frequency . in that case , the parameter @xmath67 , and the dispersion relation changes form .
we find that there are modest , but interesting , changes in the character of the magneto - rotational instability ( see fig .
[ fig : pairdisperse ] ) .
so long as @xmath0 is greater than a few , the maximum growthrate is @xmath147 and the wavelength of most rapid growth has @xmath148 .
when @xmath149 , growth becomes possible at all wavelengths , not just for those longer than a critical length . at
still smaller @xmath0 , although the maximum growthrate remains @xmath99 , there is once again a minimum wavelength for growth . just as in the ordinary plasma case
, this minimum wavelength is fixed at the inertial length ; here , however , this length is the same for the species carrying both signs of charge .
this behavior sets in at @xmath150 because the ratio @xmath151 .
before considering possible damping mechanisms , we evaluate the efficiency of the mri in the weak - field regime for driving angular momentum transport in disks .
we begin by computing the vertically averaged energy density @xmath152 and shear stress @xmath153 associated with an mri mode : @xmath154 @xmath155 where the angle brackets denote vertical averages and @xmath156 is the mass density . the ratio @xmath157 measures the efficiency of angular momentum transport at fixed mode energy density .
the sign is chosen so as to make @xmath158 positive for mri modes .
the ion velocities can be expressed in terms of the magnetic field fluctuations using faraday s law and eqns .
( [ e : r1 ] ) , ( [ e : t1 ] ) , and ( [ e : vars ] ) as @xmath159 @xmath160 in the mhd limit , the ions follow the fieldlines , and eqns .
( [ e : r1b ] ) and ( [ e : t1b ] ) reduce to @xmath161 @xmath162 substitutings eqns .
( [ e : r1mhd ] ) and ( [ e : t1mhd ] ) into eqns .
( [ e : w ] ) and ( [ e : jflux ] ) and using eqns .
( [ e : vars ] ) gives the energy density and shear stress in the mhd limits @xmath163 @xmath164 the efficiency parameter for mhd modes is @xmath165 equation ( [ e : calemhd ] ) shows that in the mhd limit , the efficiency of angular momentum transport is optimized for @xmath166 .
it follows from eqns .
( [ e : r1 ] ) , ( [ e : t1 ] ) , ( [ e : f ] ) and ( [ e : g ] ) that this ratio is given by @xmath167 in the mhd limit , eqn .
( [ e : brbt ] ) reduces to @xmath168 perturbations at the peak growth rate ( @xmath169 , @xmath170 ) are maximally efficient , with @xmath171 .
the fieldline tilt @xmath172 decreases smoothly with increasing @xmath0 at constant @xmath50 .
stable modes ( imaginary @xmath49 ) do not contribute to transport . at the peak growth rate ,
the fluid contributions to the energy density and torque are 3/5 of the magnetic contributions ( alfvn waves , in contrast , are in exact energy equipartition ) .
the ratio of kinetic to magnetic stress density and energy density increases smoothly with decreasing @xmath0 and fixed wavelength .
we now consider departures from mhd . at large fixed @xmath50 but decreasing @xmath0 ( long wavelength modes in a weak magnetic field ) , the magnetic field becomes tightly wound : @xmath173 , and the efficiency parameter @xmath174 becomes low .
kinetic energy grows to dominate magnetic energy , approaching an asymptotic value of 3/4 the mode energy .
angular momentum is , however , transported efficiently in the weak - field limit by short wavelength modes , with @xmath175 . as we saw in
[ s : results ] , these modes have growth rates of order unity when the field and rotation are anti - parallel , and grow , albeit with reduced rate , when the field and rotation are parallel .
the degree of fieldline winding , efficiency factors , and ratio of kinetic to magnetic energy are all similar to long wavelength modes with the same @xmath176 . in the extreme weak field case ,
@xmath177 , we found that perturbations with @xmath178 are unstable , and that for @xmath112 , @xmath179 .
because these modes grow slowly and have @xmath180 , we expect angular momentum transport to be inefficient .
this expectation is borne out by calculations .
the ions play very little role in the dynamics : the electron kinetic energy and shear stress are larger than their ion counterparts by a factor of @xmath66 . the magnetic stress and energy density are even larger : they exceed the electron reynolds stress and kinetic energy density by factors of @xmath181 and @xmath182 , respectively . and
the field is tightly wound : @xmath183 .
consequently , the efficiency @xmath184 .
to summarize , we find that over the entire range @xmath177 to @xmath64 , angular momentum transport by long wavelength , slowly growing modes is rather inefficient . in the range @xmath185 , angular momentum transport by long wavelength modes decreases in efficiency as @xmath32 decreases , while transport efficiency is roughly constant , and close to maximal , for fixed @xmath176 , at the wavelength of the maximum growth rate .
pressure forces and dissipative processes can modify the mri . although a complete treatment of these effects is beyond the scope of this work , their potential importance warrants a synthesis of what is already known , together with some simple extrapolations and estimates .
thermal effects vary with collisionality .
a perturbation of wavenumber @xmath186 is collisionless if the particle mean free path @xmath187 for species @xmath188 satisfies @xmath189 . in a hydrogen plasma ,
the mean free path to coulomb scattering @xmath190 cm ( all units are in cgs ) .
the dependence of @xmath187 on @xmath191 guarantees that at sufficiently high temperatures , all perturbations are collisionless . in the mhd regime
, thermal pressure has no effect on force balance in the mri because the unstable modes are noncompressive , even when the plasma @xmath192 . in collisionless plasmas ,
the components of the pressure tensor parallel and perpendicular to the magnetic field evolve independently .
quataert , dorland , & hammett ( 2002 ) investigated the mri in this case , but making the usual assumption that @xmath64 .
they found that if the background magnetic field has an azimuthal component @xmath193 , the fastest growing modes are global and vertically propagating ; @xmath194 ; @xmath195 . at high @xmath196 ,
the growth rates are 2 - 3 times larger than in the mhd case .
the persistence of rapidly growing global modes even when @xmath197 is due to the anisotropic pressure associated with magnetic field perturbations in the collisionless regime . however , these effects disappear if the magnetic field is so weak that the ions are unmagnetized , because the ion pressure anisotropy is then reduced .
we therefore expect that a single - pressure description should be satisfactory when @xmath4 is small .
depending on whether @xmath198 is @xmath199 ( the collisional regime ) or @xmath73 ( collisionless ) , different mechanisms are responsible for damping . in the collisionless case , damping occurs when energy is exchanged through a resonance between the wave and those particles with velocity such that the wave is stationary in the particle rest frame . the wave is damped if the slope of the particle distribution function projected along @xmath200 , @xmath201 , is negative .
the damping rate is proportional to @xmath201 , evaluated at the resonant velocity . in a homogeneous , nonrotating plasma the principal resonances are the landau and cyclotron resonances .
the landau resonance corresponds to @xmath202 is complex , so the phase velocity has a real part . ] .
particles exchange energy with the wave through acceleration by the parallel electric field @xmath203 .
landau damping of magnetosonic modes in high @xmath204 plasmas has been considered by foote & kulsrud ( 1979 ) , and landau damping of the mri has been calculated by sharma , hammett & quataert ( 2003 ) .
landau damping of vertically propagating modes is very weak , because @xmath203 is very small if @xmath205 it vanishes exactly , and is nonzero only because of the radial inhomogeneity of the disk . in particular ,
the fastest growing modes of ideal theory , @xmath127 , which have very short wavelength in a weak magnetic field , are only weakly damped .
the ion cyclotron resonance damps through energy exchange with the perpendicular electric field @xmath206 .
the resonance condition is modified by gravitational effects to @xmath207 = 0,\ ] ] which reduces to the standard expression for @xmath208 . in a weak magnetic field ,
resonant particles lie well within the core of the velocity distribution function , where @xmath201 is small and cyclotron damping is weak .
resonant damping of the longer wavelength instabilities presents a somewhat different case . in a homogeneous plasma
, the damping rates would be larger than for the short wavelength modes : landau damping because @xmath203 is relatively larger , and cyclotron damping because the resonant velocity is larger .
however , for global modes the vertical oscillations of the disk particles must be taken into account : the resonance is thereby weakened and the damping reduced ( sharp , berk & nielsen 1979 , koepcke et al 1986 & references therein ) .
although none of the work cited applies directly to the mri , we expect weaker landau damping and cyclotron damping of the global modes than in a homogeneous plasma . altogether then , collisionless damping , at least at linear amplitudes , is probably a weak effect .
the energy of a perturbation with vertical wavenumber @xmath186 is dissipated by viscosity and resistivity at the rates @xmath209 @xmath210 where @xmath211 and @xmath212 are the viscous and resistive diffusivities , respectively .
the viscous diffusivity is related to the ion thermal velocity @xmath213 , collision time @xmath214 , and mean free path @xmath215 by @xmath216 .
the resistive diffusivity is related to the electron inertial length @xmath135 and collision time @xmath217 by @xmath218 .
equation ( [ e : qv ] ) is valid for wavelengths longer than @xmath215 .
equation ( [ e : qr ] ) requires lengthscales longer than both @xmath219 and @xmath135 in order for the form of ohm s law on which it is based to be valid .
if there were no unstable growth , the collisional damping rate @xmath220 could be read off from the wave energy equation @xmath221 substituting eqns .
( [ e : qv ] ) and ( [ e : qr ] ) into eqn .
( [ e : edot ] ) , defining the magnetic prandtl number @xmath222 , and denoting by @xmath223 the fraction of mode energy in magnetic form gives @xmath224\equiv k^2d_{eff}.\ ] ] the @xmath225 dependence of @xmath220 is characteristic of diffusive damping .
the effective diffusion coefficient @xmath226 is a combination of the viscous and magnetic diffusivities , weighted by the fractions of kinetic and magnetic energy in each mode .
the relative importance of viscous and resistive damping is set by @xmath227 . in a hydrogen plasma , @xmath228 .
perturbations in hot , low density disks are damped primarily by viscosity , while perturbations in cold , dense disks are damped primarily by resistivity .
equation ( [ e : gammac ] ) is valid only at wavelengths long enough that eqns .
( [ e : qv ] ) and ( [ e : qr ] ) apply . when @xmath229 , viscous damping saturates at the rate @xmath230 .
resistive damping saturates when @xmath231 .
if @xmath232 , the saturated resistive damping rate @xmath233 , while if @xmath234 , @xmath235 . in subsequent discussions ,
we adopt for simplicity the saturated damping rate @xmath236 equation ( [ e : gammacs ] ) applies when @xmath237 and @xmath238 .
if the ions are magnetized ( @xmath76 ) but collisionless , viscous momentum transport across magnetic fieldlines is drastically reduced ( braginskii 1965 ) .
balbus ( 2004 ) has shown that the resulting anisotropic stresses are destabilizing , much as quataert , dorland , & hammett ( 2002 ) showed that anisotropic pressure is destabilizing .
diffusive damping is still present , but is reduced by a factor of @xmath239 . in order to pull together these ideas
, we perform a thought experiment in which @xmath32 is increased from an arbitrarily small value and follow the damping as a function of fieldstrength .
suppose that at first @xmath240 .
the modes are then sustained by electrons only , the ions having dropped out ( see eqn . [
e : vsmallx ] ) .
therefore we take @xmath241 in eqns .
( [ e : gammac ] ) and ( [ e : gammacs ] ) . at the scale @xmath242 of the fastest growing mode , resistive
damping is saturated . according to eqn .
( [ e : gammacs ] ) , this mode can grow only if @xmath243 .
this criterion is independent of @xmath32 as long as @xmath240 .
however , we admit that it is based upon extrapolation , and is not a rigorous result . moving up in fieldstrength , we consider @xmath244 , but not too large . now
both the electrons and the ions participate , and the fastest growing mode has @xmath245 . because @xmath246 , @xmath247 , and resistive damping is saturated . whether viscous damping is saturated as well depends on @xmath215 . at sufficiently long wavelengths
, the mri growth rate always exceeds the collisional damping rate , because the growth rate is proportional to @xmath186 and the damping rate to @xmath225 . approximating the growth rate by @xmath248 and using eqn .
( [ e : gammac ] ) for the damping rate , we find that the growth rate exceeds damping at wavelengths long enough that @xmath249 .
the growth rate is approximately @xmath250 at the short wavelength end of this range .
this growth rate is generally a small fraction of the orbital frequency ; quantitatively , @xmath251 in some circumstances , there can also be growth for @xmath252 because the damping saturates as a function of @xmath186 at very short wavelengths , where as the growthrate continues to climb @xmath253 for all @xmath254 .
what determines whether there can be growth at short wavelength is the ratio of the maximum ideal growth rate ( @xmath255 ) to the saturated damping rate , @xmath256 .
if @xmath257 exceeds unity , these modes can grow ; otherwise , they are suppressed . because of the form of eqn .
( [ e : gammacs ] ) , this depends on the collisionality in the disk .
if @xmath258 , @xmath259 , while for @xmath260 , @xmath261 . thus , in these two limits
the criterion for growth near @xmath262 is @xmath263 and @xmath264 .
short wavelength growth is therefore more likely to be found in hot , low density disks with a fast rotation rate .
otherwise , for @xmath265 , the mri is limited to long wavelength , slowly growing modes as described by eqn .
( [ e : longgrowth ] )
. even these modes may be suppressed , however , by collisionless damping , although we argued in
[ ss : collisionless ] that collisionless processes are too weak to stabilize the fastest growing , short wavelength modes .
an exception to these remarks occurs in the window @xmath266 ( see eqn . [
e : postmhd ] ) .
in this range , @xmath267 approaches a finite limit , not too different from @xmath9 , as @xmath268 .
these modes are only weakly damped by collisional effects , permitting rapid growth at large scales .
the picture outlined above is also valid for @xmath64 , except that as the wavelength of the fastest growing mode increases , a much larger diffusivity is required to suppress the mri .
if @xmath64 , @xmath269 , and @xmath270 has even a small component in the plane of the disk , stresses associated with anisotropic pressure and viscosity can destabilize the disk ( quataert , dorland , & hammett 2002 , balbus 2004 ) . in a hydrostatic disk ,
the value of @xmath65 at which these effects come into play is of order @xmath271 , which is large except in very hot , low density disks . for this reason ,
these effects are generally unimportant in the weak - field regime , where @xmath4 is not very large .
the analysis presented here is applicable to any situation in which the larmor frequency of a major charged species is not much larger than the dynamical frequency .
it can also be used to analyze the mri in media such as pair plasmas or charged - grain fluids in which the dominant positive and negative species have equal mass .
the primary applications we have in mind involve situations where the field is weak .
how weak is weak ? at the order of magnitude level , it is always possible to estimate the dynamical frequency of orbital motion in terms of the smoothed - out density of mass contained within the orbit : @xmath272 . using that estimate ,
our field - strength parameter @xmath273 may be rewritten in an instructive way : @xmath274 where @xmath275 represents the alfven speed estimated using the smoothed - out density .
when the bulk of the gravitating mass is distributed and has only modest density gradients , @xmath275 is a fair estimate of the actual local alfven speed ; when the gravitating mass is concentrated , @xmath275 is only an indicator of a characteristic speed . in either case , it is clear from the numerical value of the coefficient in equation [ e : alfven ] that the characteristic alfven speed must be truly tiny@xmath276 cm s@xmath277for @xmath278 . before beginning to explore some applications of these ideas
, we briefly summarize our results so far .
we have shown that an ideal plasma with a magnetic field oriented along the rotation axis is always unstable , and there is almost always a mode that grows at a rate comparable to the rotation frequency @xmath9 ( the exception is the range @xmath131 , in which the maximum growth rate is somewhat slower when the field and the angular velocity are in the same direction ) . when @xmath279 , the fastest growing mode has a wavelength on the scale of the electron skin depth @xmath280 km .
the smallness of this scale and the low efficiency at which these modes transport angular momentum leaves their significance open to question . for @xmath265 ,
the instability is sensitive to whether @xmath270 and @xmath9 are parallel or antiparallel , with larger growth rates in the latter case .
this asymmetry is a manifestation of the different charge / mass ratios for charge carriers of opposite sign : the lower - mass charge - carrier remains well - magnetized even while the opposite sign charge - carrier , of opposite charge sign , deviates from the fieldlines .
except for the range @xmath266 , in which growth rates of order @xmath9 persist at arbitrarily long wavelengths , the fastest growing mode is near the wavenumber @xmath281 , and the growth rate scales linearly with @xmath186 for @xmath282 .
this behavior is similar to what is predicted by ideal mhd , even though @xmath283 need not be much greater than the dynamical frequency .
the fastest growing modes are also the most efficient at transporting angular momentum .
thermal effects modify this picture . if @xmath270 has an azimuthal component and the ions are magnetized ( @xmath64 ) but have a long mean free path , there are modes with @xmath284 with growth rates near @xmath9 ( quataert , dorland , & hammett 2002 , balbus 2004 ) .
these effects do not appear if @xmath270 is vertical , but thermal effects are still substantial in that they cause damping .
although collisionless damping appears to be weak , especially for the short wavelength modes , collisional damping both viscous and resistive can be strong .
it increases with wavenumber as @xmath225 until it saturates at the ion mean free path @xmath215 ( viscous damping ) or @xmath285 ( resistive damping ) .
although growth dominates damping at sufficiently long wavelengths , the mri is suppressed at @xmath286 unless the maximum growth rate , @xmath9 , exceeds the saturated damping rate @xmath256 .
this criterion is most easily fulfilled in hot , low density disks in which the particle mean free paths and skin depths are long
. otherwise , the growth rate of the mri peaks at the rather low value given by eqn .
( [ e : longgrowth ] ) .
even this is an upper limit because it neglects collisionless damping .
these results apply to a number of situations in which a seed magnetic field has been generated at early cosmological epochs . for definiteness
we suppose the mechanism of magnetogenesis is the biermann battery . when that is the case , there is a characteristic relation between the operation of the battery and possible mri growth . after developing this relationship
, we briefly address two questions : at what fieldstrength can angular momentum transport by the mri begin to play a role in disk accretion , and at what scales can the mri generate strong magnetic fields ? the biermann battery " ( biermann & schlter 1951 ) depends on misaligned gradients in the electron density and temperature
. field generation by this mechanism occurs at a rate @xmath287 where @xmath288 is boltzmann s constant .
if we define @xmath289 and @xmath290 as the characteristic scales for the density and temperature gradients , respectively , and suppose that there is a sizable angle between the two gradients , the characteristic field amplification time @xmath291 equired to reach a particular value of @xmath0 may be estimated in dimensionless form as @xmath292 where @xmath293 is thermal speed of the ions if @xmath294 .
not surprisingly , the relative importance of the biermann mechanism grows with diminishing @xmath0 .
defining @xmath295 , we find that @xmath296 in a conventional radiative accretion disk , @xmath297 is , of course , the disk thickness @xmath298 because @xmath299 . in the absence of collisional
damping , the characteristic growth time of the mri is @xmath300 , so field amplification by the biermann battery would outstrip the mri until the time when the right hand side of eqn .
( [ e : biermannest ] ) is greater than unity . if the gradient scales are comparable to the characteristic thermal travel distance , the biermann battery field augmentation rate surpasses that of the mri whenever @xmath301 and even to somewhat greater values of @xmath0 when @xmath2 .
however , if one of the gradient scales is @xmath302 , the mri would overtake the battery somewhat sooner , when @xmath303 ( particularly if @xmath3 ) .
on the other hand , collisional damping can in many circumstances substantially reduce the growth rate ( e.g. , as in the case described by eqn .
[ e : longgrowth ] ) .
when that is the case , the biermann battery dominates as long as @xmath304 ) can be much greater than one , because of the smallness of @xmath56 compared to global scales . here
longer collision time leads to a wider range of battery dominance because it also means that the minimum wavelength for growth is greater , and that suppresses the mri growth rate .
the biermann battery can also operate in shock fronts and ionization fronts propagating in structured media .
these contexts can be of interest in cosmological and galactic settings ( kulsrud et al .
1997 , gnedin , ferrara , & zweibel 2000 ) .
one of the lengthscales @xmath289 or @xmath290 is replaced by the thickness of the front , @xmath305 , but the battery operates within each fluid element for only as long as it takes the front to cross it , @xmath306 .
the resulting value of @xmath283 is @xmath307 where @xmath308 is the ( global ) lengthscale on which @xmath309 or @xmath310 varies . in the relevant settings we expect @xmath311 , in which case eqn .
( [ e : omegacf ] ) shows that the ion cyclotron radius @xmath312 is of order @xmath308 , the global gradient scale .
other plasma properties being equal , the fields produced in disks exceed the fields produced in fronts after a time of order @xmath313 .
we now apply these generic results about the complementary relationship between biermann batteries and the mri in some specific settings . at least in these examples , we find that the mri has little impact because collisional damping is so strong when the field is extremely weak . one particular setting in which these effects may act is the initial growth of density perturbations at high redshift .
it is possible that the only magnetic field at that point is the field arising from the biermann battery .
starting from negligible field , after one hubble time we might expect @xmath314 where @xmath315 is the present - day hubble constant , @xmath316 and @xmath317 are the co - moving lengthscales of the density and temperature gradients , and they have been scaled to mpc for the numerical estimate .
thus , under these conditions , any possible mri effects would in fact be in the weak - field regime .
only after the gas temperature has risen considerably ( e.g. , due to shocks in collapsing clouds ) and the relevant gradient scales have become more characteristic of galaxies than of intergalactic gas would the mri operate in the ordinary regime . at the earliest stages of magnetic field amplification , where @xmath115 , there could be growth over all possible wavelengths in the electron - dominated modes
provided it takes place at high enough redshift : @xmath318 .
however , as soon as the modes shift over to the conventional mri , damping restricts the range of growing wavelengths to only those on roughly cosmological scales : @xmath319 moreover , the fastest growing electron modes are probably damped by resistivity .
thus , this appears to be an unpromising venue for significant mri effects .
the magnetic fields generated by the biermann battery operating in cosmological shocks and ionization fronts are of order @xmath320 g , corresponding to @xmath321 s@xmath277 , or less .
if we assume the velocity shear is such that @xmath322 and @xmath323 , an appropriate intergalactic density at @xmath324 , then @xmath325 cm@xmath277 . on the other hand , @xmath327 , so collisional damping has surely saturated and @xmath328 .
the mri can not grow at these scales . on the larger scales
at which it is excited , the growth time exceeds the age of the universe .
the mri appears to be unimportant in the igm at large at all times .
the fully ionized gas in galactic disks has high magnetic prandtl number @xmath227 , meaning that viscous damping dominates resistive damping , and due to the long galactic rotation period is highly collisional@xmath329 .
therefore eqn .
( [ e : longgrowth ] ) applies , and the growth rate of the fastest growing mode is of order @xmath330 s@xmath277 .
this becomes comparable to the galactic rotation rate only for @xmath331 g. such a strong field can not reasonably be generated by a biermann battery on galactic scales .
additional constraints apply to weakly ionized galactic gas , in which the mri is damped by ion - neutral friction .
these results suggest that the mri can not be the primary agent in amplifying seed magnetic fields generated by the biermann battery in galactic disks .
the pivotal role of mri turbulence in accretion motivates this application .
because , as we have just stressed , so little is known about the cosmological history of magnetic field development , it is an interesting question whether the matter accreting onto proto - stars in the first galaxies or black holes in high - redshift quasars contains magnetic fields of the magnitude one might expect in contemporary interstellar gas .
if the seed field in accreting matter then were much weaker than it would be today , the question arises as to whether the mri would successfully amplify the field to the level at which accretion becomes efficient .
indeed , there may be a bootstrap " issue here : it has been suggested that magnetized outflows from early disks could have injected the first significant magnetic field into large portions of the intergalactic medium ( daly & loeb 1990 , kronberg et al .
1999 , furlanetto & loeb 2001 ) . if disks are required to create magnetic fields , what magnetic fields are present in the first disks that allow them to function ? for a semi - quantitative approach to answering this question , consider conditions at the innermost stable circular orbit ( isco ) of a nonrotating black hole of mass @xmath332 . using @xmath333 and assuming a hydrogen plasma , eqn .
( [ e : vars ] ) gives @xmath334 where @xmath32 is given in g. thus , the lower the mass of the compact object , the stronger the field must be to meet the conditions of mhd .
this is , of course , a prime example of where eqn .
( [ e : alfven ] ) is _ not _ a good estimator of the relationship between the alfven speed in the plasma and the @xmath0 parameter . around a non - rotating black hole , @xmath335 . to put this in perspective
, we turn the problem around and ask what value of @xmath0 would be expected in an efficiently - accreting disk .
it is very large : @xmath336 where @xmath337 is the accretion rate in eddington units and @xmath338 is the optical depth through the disk .
this estimate , by the way , is independent of whether the vertical support of the disk is dominated by gas or by radiation pressure ; it assumes only that angular momentum and energy are conserved , dissipated energy is radiated locally , the disk is in a steady - state , and that the disk is optically thick so that the temperature in its interior is @xmath339 times larger than at its surface .
thus , significant accretion rates ( as measured in eddington units ) go hand - in - hand with large @xmath4 unless the stress per unit surface density is so low that the disk accumulates a very large mass .
suppose , then , that a disk is formed , but without any magnetic field , and therefore without any turbulence or inflow .
can it ever work its way to a state of efficient accretion ? in order to avoid a singular state
, we must assume that there is some mechanism ( other than local dissipation associated with accretion ) that heats it .
under almost any circumstances , we expect the disk to be stratified both radially and vertically , and , because of local heating and cooling processes , to be nonbarytropic .
this , too , is a context in which the biermann battery should operate . here
the crossed gradients must be in the radial and vertical directions , so @xmath340 . ) , vertical and radial gradients generate an azimuthal field .
we assume our analysis of the mri for a vertical field applies to this case . ] making use of eqn .
( [ e : biermannest1 ] ) yields @xmath341 explicitly allowing for a possible contrast in ion and electron temperatures and integrating , we find that @xmath342 thus , the ratio of the growth rate due to the battery to that due to mri growth is @xmath343 . in the limit of extremely small @xmath4 , the preceding expression shows that magnetic field growth due to the biermann battery effect is likely to outpace that due to local instability . to the degree that @xmath344 , due either to damping at short wavelength or the slower growth rate found at long wavelengths , this conclusion is strengthened .
the time - dependence of the fluctuation energy density @xmath345 in a large - scale mode with @xmath346 may then be found by combining eqns .
( [ e : lownu ] ) and ( [ e : x ] ) : @xmath347 integrating eqn .
( [ e : growth ] ) over time , we find that for a fluctuation of initial energy @xmath348 @xmath349 according to eqn .
( [ e : amplification ] ) , the fluctuations grow by a factor of @xmath350 in the normalized time @xmath351 @xmath352^{1/2 } \sim ( kh)^{-1 } ( r/\delta_i)^{1/2}(1 + t_e / t_i)^{1/2}.\ ] ] equation ( [ e : timescale ] ) corresponds to a very long amplification time , except for modes very short compared to a disk thickness .
the reason is the extremely large ratio @xmath353 .
little mri growth can be expected , therefore , on scales anywhere approaching the disk thickness . if the disk is turbulent , for example , due to gravitational instability , the battery operates somewhat differently
. a random magnetic field is generated , and the gradient lengthscales in eqn .
( [ e : biermann ] ) are the characteristic turbulent scales .
the operation of the mri in such a field is beyond the scope of this paper .
our last example is neither cosmological nor involves the biermann battery . in this case , we consider how the mri operates when most of the charge in the medium is carried by dust . in many circumstances of high gas density and low temperature such as dense molecular clouds or proto - stellar accretion disks ,
it is possible that most of the charge in the plasma may actually reside on grains rather than ions or electrons ( draine & sutin 1987 , nishi et al .
because the ability of grains to hold charge depends strongly on their size distribution , there are substantial uncertainties regarding the specific parameters of the regimes where this condition may obtain . nonetheless , it is of interest to examine the consequences for the mri wherever this state may exist .
the most direct impact is that the charged species traversing larmor orbits have masses greater than a proton by a factor @xmath354 or more .
consequently , the effective cyclotron frequencies are dramatically depressed . posed in terms of the characteristic alfven speed for a self - gravitating system ( eqn .
[ e : alfven ] ) , @xmath355/@xmath356 s for grain mass @xmath357 and grain charge in electron units @xmath358 . in the context of proto - stellar disks , it is natural to compare the grain larmor frequency to the expected scale of orbital frequencies : @xmath359 , where we have assumed an orbital period of 1 yr and the pressure in the disk is scaled to @xmath360 k @xmath361 .
however , our simple two - fluid theory can not be directly applied to this situation because it assumes the charge carriers account for the bulk of the inertia , an assumption that fails badly when grains are the charge carriers .
an appropriate theory would need to incorporate a third fluid : the neutral background , including its inertia and the rate of momentum exchange between the neutrals and both kinds of charge carriers .
these latter effects were the primary focus of the papers by balbus & terquem ( 2001 ) and salmeron & wardle ( 2003 ) .
in fact , in the limit they considered , the cross - field current was determined by balancing the @xmath362 force with the ion - neutral drag force . on the other hand ,
the estimates of the previous paragraph demonstrate that there may be contexts in which linear theories of the mri that take proper account of resistivity , hall effects , and so on , and yet ignore the dynamical effects of a small ratio of cyclotron frequency to orbital frequency may be equally incomplete . pending a complete investigation of this problem ,
we offer a few rough estimates .
first , we have already noted that our parameter @xmath363 , where @xmath61 is the hall parameter defined by balbus & terquem ( 2001 ) and @xmath62 is the ratio of the mass per electron to the ion mass . when the plasma is strongly - ionized , hall effects go hand - in - hand with weak - field effects ; in a state of weak ionization , hall effects can be important even when @xmath364 .
however , if grains are the charge - carriers , the subscripts e " and i " refer to the negative and positive charge - carrying grains , so that @xmath365 and the regime of hall effects can , as in the strongly - ionized case , be identified with the regime of weak - field effects .
next , let the effective collision frequency between charged grains and the background neutral medium be @xmath366 ( i.e. , this is the neutral - grain collision rate divided by the grain / neutral mass ratio ) .
following balbus & terquem ( 2001 ) , we estimate the relative importance of inductive and ohmic effects by the magnetic reynolds number , which may be written in our notation as @xmath367 where @xmath368 is the ratio of ( charged ) grain mass to neutral mass and must be @xmath369 . in this expression
we have taken the relevant length scale to be @xmath370 . given that @xmath371 in most cases of this sort , small @xmath0 effects will also typically be associated with small magnetic reynolds number , and therefore are likely to occur in the context of strongly damped modes , except for @xmath372 .
we have shown that generalizing from cold single - fluid theory to cold two - fluid theory permits at least an approximate description of how the magneto - rotational instability behaves as the field becomes extremely weak .
weak " in this sense may be parameterized in terms of the ratio between the ion cyclotron frequency and the rotational frequency , the quantity we have labelled @xmath0 .
little in the basic nature of the instability changes so long as @xmath373 , although the characteristic wavelength scale is proportional to @xmath0 , and can therefore become very short compared to other interesting scales .
complications arise when @xmath374 .
hall effects " , dynamical distinctions between the behavior of the two signs of charge , become important .
when the field and the rotation are aligned , so @xmath0 is positive , the maximum growth rate for @xmath0 in that range can be significantly diminished . on the other hand ,
when the field and the rotation are anti - parallel , giving negative @xmath0 , the maximum growth rate , while reduced somewhat , remains closer to @xmath9 . in addition
, unstable growth becomes possible at arbitrarily short wavelengths , even though it is not possible in stronger fields .
the entire character of the modes changes when @xmath4 falls below @xmath375 , the mass ratio between the negative and positive charge carriers , and is better described as electromagnetic - rotational " than magnetic - rotational " . in this regime ,
only the lighter ( usually negative ) species participates . as a result , the characteristic wavelength changes from @xmath376 to @xmath135 , the electron inertial length . just as for the ordinary mri
, there is a minimum wavelength for growth that is comparable to the characteristic wavelength , and the growth rate scales @xmath253 for longer wavelengths .
although the cold fluid approach demonstrates that rapid growth persists to arbitrarily weak field , it also entails a shift of focus to progressively shorter wavelengths .
these are exactly the scales on which thermal effects , not included in the simple fluid picture , might intervene .
a complete account of these effects is beyond the scope of this paper , but simple estimates suggest that , as expected , they are often able to damp all but the longest - wavelength modes .
because the growth rate typically scales @xmath253 for wavelengths longer than the characteristic wavelength , growth can be very slow for even the fastest modes that escape collisional damping .
thus , the ability of the mri to amplify magnetic field may be severely weakened even for values of @xmath4 substantially greater than @xmath74 .
in other words , to answer one of the questions with which we began , the magnetic field becomes too weak to be effective when the preferred scale of instability ( @xmath377 ) is so small that transport - associated dissipation ( resistivity and viscosity ) limits growth .
lastly , we have applied these ideas to a few astrophysical contexts in which extremely weak fields might be expected . on the basis of these estimates ,
we find that it may , for example , be very difficult for accretion disks formed from primordial gas in which no magnetic field has been embedded to bootstrap " themselves from a state of initially weak field to a state in which the field is strong enough to drive rapid accretion . likewise ,
the mri is unlikely to be an efficient mechanism for amplifying battery - generated magnetic fields in the intergalactic medium , or in protogalactic disks ; dynamos in these systems must be driven by other forms of turbulence .
the most favorable bootstrap disk environments appear to be hot , low density disks with short rotation periods . in such systems
collisional damping is relatively weak , and the instability may be driven by anisotropic pressure and viscosity at global scales . on the other hand , because the important parameter is the ratio of cyclotron frequency for the more massive charge carriers to the rotation frequency , proto - stellar accretion disks in which dust grains carry most of the charge may exhibit some of the effects we have pointed out .
the authors are happy to acknowledge the hospitality of the kitp at uc santa barbara , where this work began .
we thank s. balbus , v.v .
mirnov , d. neufeld , p. sharma , and j. stone for useful discussions .
this work was supported in part by the national science foundation under grants phy99 - 07949 , phy02 - 15581 , ast05 - 07367 , ast02 - 05806 , and ast-0313031 . | we investigate the behavior of the magneto - rotational instability in the limit of extremely weak magnetic field , i.e. , as the ratio of ion cyclotron frequency to orbital frequency ( @xmath0 ) becomes small .
considered only in terms of cold two - fluid theory , instability persists to arbitrarily small values of @xmath0 , and the maximum growth rate is of order the orbital frequency except for the range @xmath1 , where it can be rather smaller . in this range ,
field aligned with rotation ( @xmath2 ) produces slower growth than anti - aligned field ( @xmath3 ) .
the maximum growth rate is generally achieved at smaller and smaller wavelengths as @xmath4 diminishes . when @xmath5 , new unstable
electromagnetic - rotational " modes appear that do not depend on the equilibrium magnetic field . because the most rapidly - growing modes have extremely short wavelengths when @xmath4 is small , they are often subject to viscous or resistive damping , which can result in suppressing all but the longest wavelengths , for which growth is much slower . we find that this sort of damping is likely to curtail severely the frequently - invoked mechanism for cosmological magnetic field growth in which a magnetic field seeded by the biermann battery is then amplified by the magneto - rotational instability . on the other hand , the small @xmath4 case may introduce interesting effects in weakly - ionized disks in which dust grains carry most of the electric charge . |
in recent times major advances in the experimental techniques have led to the realization of experiments in which quantum systems in a single particle regime are studied under their controlled interaction with some environment . a paradigmatic example in this context
is given by the motion of a massive test particle in an interferometric setup , which gives rise to interference fringes as typical quantum signatures .
when the coupling with the environment becomes of relevance , such interference fringes are gradually washed out , and a classical dynamics is eventually recovered .
this phenomenon goes under the name of decoherence @xcite .
its understanding and theoretical description require on the one hand a control over the environment , on the other hand a microscopic model for the interaction and the ensuing dynamics . for the case of a tracer particle immersed in a dilute gas
such a microscopic description has been obtained considering the centre of mass degrees of freedom only .
the reduced dynamics is given by a master equation in lindblad form which has been called quantum linear boltzmann equation , since it provides the natural quantum counterpart of the classical linear boltzmann equation ( see @xcite for a recent review and references therein ) .
the microscopic input is given by the complex scattering amplitudes describing the collisions between gas and test particle , while the gas is characterized by its density and momentum distribution .
in this paper we consider an extension of this result , which includes internal degrees of freedom of the tracer particle .
the microscopic derivation is performed along the lines of a general strategy for the derivation of markovian master equations , which relies on a scattering description of the interaction events @xcite . besides the gas properties
, this approach takes as basic input the multichannel complex scattering amplitudes , which describe the influence of the internal states on the scattering events .
indeed , when the scattering cross section does not only depend on the relative motional state between tracer and gas particle , such an extension becomes mandatory in order to correctly describe the dynamics . according to the markovian approximation ,
the obtained master equation is in lindblad form .
this derivation confirms the structure of the dissipative term , which has been heuristically obtained in @xcite , further determining the coherent contribution to the dynamics due to forward scattering .
the latter becomes relevant in the determination of the index of refraction for matter waves .
when either type of degrees of freedom can be described in classical terms , a markovian quantum classical master equation is obtained .
such a result , corresponding to a classical treatment of the motional degrees of freedom , has been considered in @xcite . in that context
the name bloch - boltzmann equation was proposed for the equation , since for a two - level system an extension of the optical bloch equations to include a boltzmann - like collision term is obtained . in the same spirit ,
the name quantum bloch - boltzmann equation can be used to indicate a master equation , which gives a quantum description of both internal and centre of mass state .
an interesting situation appears when in the final detection the internal state of the test particle is not resolved at the output of the interferometer . in this case
the internal degrees of freedom become part of the environment . then a non - markovian dynamics for the motional state appears , which can be described in terms of a coupled set of lindblad equations for the unnormalized statistical operators corresponding to specific internal channels .
this type of non - markovian dynamics can be considered as a generalized non - markovian lindblad structure .
it arises as a mean over a classical index , which can take place e.g. as a consequence of the interaction with a structured reservoir @xcite .
this situation is here considered in the study of the loss of visibility of the interference fringes in an interferometric setup .
the ensuing decoherence effect is generally not described as an exponential loss of visibility depending on the strength of the interaction , as in the usual markovian case .
the paper is organized as follows . in sect .
[ sec : ms ] we consider the expression of the master equation , pointing to the main steps necessary for its derivation and putting into evidence the microscopic quantities determining its explicit form .
a detailed microscopic derivation of the master equation is performed in appendix [ sec : micr - deriv - mast ] .
the master equation is given both in terms of matrix elements of the statistical operator in the momentum and internal energy eigenstates basis , as well as an explicit operator expression , which makes its lindblad structure manifest .
this also allows to easily recover under suitable limits previously considered master equations , which describe either only one of the two kind of degrees of freedom or a hybrid quantum classical description of both . in sect .
[ sec : decoh ] we show how the interplay between internal and motional states can influence the visibility in an interferometric setup for the study of decoherence , leading to a non - markovian behaviour in the reduction of the visibility of the interference fringes .
we first consider the key ingredients and steps which lead to obtain the master equation describing the collisional dynamics of a test particle immersed in a structureless background gas , keeping the internal degrees of freedom of the particle into account .
the task of a full microscopic derivation will be accomplished in appendix [ sec : micr - deriv - mast ] , relying on a method recently introduced for the derivation of markovian master equations , which has been called monitoring approach @xcite . in the monitoring approach the reduced dynamics of a system in contact with some environment
is obtained describing their interaction by means of scattering theory .
the building blocks in such a formulation of the open system dynamics are therefore the s - matrix characterizing the single interaction events and the rate of collisions .
both quantities are given by operators on the tensor product hilbert space of system and environment , which we shall denote by @xmath0 and @xmath1 respectively .
the operator nature of these quantities is crucial in order to keep the gas and test particle state into account in the dynamic description of the collisional interaction .
the markovian master equation for the reduced dynamics is obtained by assuming the various collisions as independent , so that their effect cumulates according to the state dependent scattering rate , and taking the trace over the environmental degrees of freedom .
the formal expression of the master equation reads @xcite @xmath2 + \mathcal{l } \rho + \mathcal{r } \rho \label{eq : qlbefinal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath3 is the free hamiltonian and @xmath4 is the statistical operator of the system . for the case at hand the free hamiltonian of the system
is given by @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the momentum operator of the test particle , @xmath7 its mass and @xmath8 the basis of energy eigenstates in @xmath9 .
the superoperators appearing at r.h.s . of eq .
( [ eq : qlbefinal ] ) are defined according to @xmath10 \mathsf{\gamma}^{1 / 2 } \mathsf{t}^{\dag } \right ) \nonumber\\ & & - \frac{1}{2 } \text{tr}_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{gas } } } } \left ( \mathsf{\gamma}^{1 / 2 } \mathsf{t}^{\dag } \mathsf{t } \mathsf{\gamma}^{1 / 2 } \left [ \rho \otimes \rho_{\text{gas } } \right ] \right ) \nonumber\\ & & - \frac{1}{2 } \text{tr}_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{gas } } } } \left ( \left [ \rho \otimes \rho_{\text{gas } } \right ] \mathsf{\gamma}^{1 / 2 } \mathsf{t}^{\dag } \mathsf{t } \mathsf{\gamma}^{1 / 2 } \right ) \label{eq : ms}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath11 \right ) \label{eq : r}\end{aligned}\ ] ] respectively , where @xmath12 is the single particle statistical operator describing the gas environment .
note that the operators @xmath13 and @xmath14 arise by acting with an operator in lindblad form on a state of system plus gas in factorized form , further taking the partial trace with respect to the gas . while this operation is formally legitimate , and guarantees preservation of trace and hermiticity of the statistical operator describing the test particle , it is generally not true that the resulting dynamics for the reduced system only is given by a master equation in lindblad form , thus granting complete positivity and describing a well - defined markovian dynamics .
indeed this step involves further approximations , which depend in a crucial way on details of system and interaction .
it is well known that by taking the partial trace with respect to the unitary evolution of the overall system one can obtain a markovian dynamics only if further hypotheses hold .
this remains true for the case at hand , despite the fact that important approximations have already been introduced in replacing the hamiltonian dynamics for system plus gas with a lindblad operator only specified by @xmath15 and @xmath1 . the actual proof that a markovian dynamics applies to the situation of interest and the specific expression of the superoperators appearing in eq .
( [ eq : qlbefinal ] ) is obtained through the microscopic calculations performed in appendix [ sec : micr - deriv - mast ] .
relying on the results of appendix [ incoh ] we write the following expression for the contributions in eq .
( [ eq : ms ] ) in the momentum and channel basis @xmath16 @xmath17 \label{eq : rif2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the complex rate functions @xmath18 are given by @xmath19 with the @xmath20 a notational shorthand to indicate that the contribution is different from zero only for @xmath21 , where @xmath22 denotes the difference in energy between internal states , while the @xmath23-integration is restricted to the plane @xmath24 .
the functions @xmath25 are defined according to @xmath26 where @xmath27 denotes the stationary gas distribution , @xmath28 is the density of the gas , @xmath29 the mass of the gas particles , @xmath30 the reduced mass , and @xmath31 denote the multichannel complex scattering amplitudes , which depend on the microscopic interaction potential and describe scattering from an initial momentum @xmath32 and internal state @xmath33 to a final state with momentum @xmath34 and internal state @xmath35 .
moreover , @xmath36 and @xmath37 indicate , respectively , the perpendicular and the parallel component of the momentum @xmath38 with respect to the vector @xmath39 ; while @xmath40 is the the relative momentum between the gas particle momentum @xmath23 and the test particle momentum @xmath41 . exploiting these results we can easily write the master equation eq .
( [ eq : qlbefinal ] ) directly in operator form . in fact using the functions @xmath42 let us introduce the following family of jump operators @xmath43 where @xmath44 and @xmath6 are position and momentum operators of the test particle , while the operators @xmath45 act on the internal degrees of freedom only , since @xmath46 denotes the energy eigenstate with eigenvalue @xmath47 , and the exponential factor describes momentum exchanges according to @xmath48 .
note that the functions @xmath49 essentially depend on the scattering amplitudes and the momentum distribution of the gas , thus keeping into account all the details of the collisional interaction .
these expressions appear operator - valued in the master equation , being evaluated for @xmath50 , so as to take into account the actual momentum of the colliding test particle .
the incoherent contribution @xmath51 in eq .
( [ eq : qlbefinal ] ) finally reads @xmath52 the superoperator @xmath14 of eq .
( [ eq : r ] ) on its turn according to appendix [ coh ] amounts to the commutator with an effective hamiltonian given by @xmath53 \otimes \mathsf{e}_{ij}. \label{eq : hn}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the alternative expression given by eq .
( [ eq : l2 ] ) to define @xmath49 , it is immediately seen that the incoherent term of this master equation confirms the result heuristically obtained in @xcite . in the latter reference
this equation has also been termed quantum bloch - boltzmann equation in that it provides a quantum description of both motional and internal degrees of freedom , thus extending the result of @xcite , where the centre of mass degrees of freedom were treated classically and the name bloch - boltzmann equation was used .
these names should not confuse the reader .
indeed , only for the case of an atom in a two - level approximation undergoing a collisional dynamics this equation refers to an extension of the optical bloch equations with a boltzmann collision term . as a compatibility check of the master equation derived in appendix [ sec : micr - deriv - mast ] , and in order to make contact with previous work , we will now show how in suitable limits it recovers already known equations . since the equation describes the quantum dynamics of a test particle with both internal and translational degrees of freedom immersed in a dilute gas
, natural limiting situations appear considering a structureless test particle or an immobile system .
these situations correspond to the quantum linear boltzmann equation @xcite , and to the master equation for an immobile system interacting through collisions with a background gas @xcite .
another natural limit consists in a hybrid quantum classical description , in which either internal or centre of mass degrees of freedom are treated classically .
the master equation corresponding to this last case has already been considered in @xcite .
a classical treatment of both kinds of degrees of freedom leads to the master equation for a classical markov process , with a probability density depending on both a discrete and a continuous index . [
[ quantum - linear - boltzmann - equation - boltzmann ] ] quantum linear boltzmann equation [ boltzmann ] + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + if the internal degrees of freedom can be disregarded the sum in eq .
( [ eq : diag ] ) has a single non vanishing contribution , so that instead of the multichannel scattering amplitudes @xmath54 there is a single amplitude which can be indicated as @xmath55 .
the incoherent term in the master equation reduces to @xmath56 with @xmath57 while the hamiltonian term reads @xmath58 , where @xmath59 and @xmath60\end{aligned}\ ] ] takes into account the energy shift due to forward scattering .
this result complies with the quantum linear boltzmann equation obtained in @xcite , whose properties have been discussed in detail in @xcite .
[ [ immobile - tracer - particle - bloch ] ] immobile tracer particle [ bloch ] + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we now consider the opposite situation , corresponding to an infinitely massive test particle , so that the dynamics of the translational degrees of freedom can be neglected . to consider this limit it is convenient to come back to the expression eq .
( [ eq : rif2 ] ) of the quantum master equation in terms of the complex rate functions @xmath61 , which in the limit @xmath62 when integrated over @xmath63 reduce to @xmath64 where no dependence on the test particle s momentum is left .
the matrix elements of the incoherent part of the quantum bloch - boltzmann equation are therefore now given by @xmath65 while the coherent part corresponds to a effective hamiltonian whose matrix elements in the energy eigenbasis are given by @xmath66 $ ] , thus confirming the result obtained in @xcite for the case of a non degenerate hamiltonian .
[ [ quantum - classical - description ] ] quantum classical description + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the limiting expressions of the quantum bloch - boltzmann equation , obtained when either the internal or the translational degrees of freedom can be treated as a classical label , correspond to hybrid quantum classical descriptions , which naturally arise when decoherence affects on different time scales the two kind of degrees of freedom .
when the centre of mass degrees of freedom can be treated classically it is convenient to introduce the classical rates @xmath67 with @xmath68 as in eq .
( [ eq : fact ] ) , so that the semiclassical bloch - boltzmann equation reads @xmath69 + \sum_{{\scriptstyle{\begin{array}{c } ijkl \end{array } } } } { \int}{\mathrm{d}}{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \left [ m^{jl}_{ik } \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } ; { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \right ) \mathsf{e}_{ij } \rho ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p}}}-{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } ) \mathsf{e}^{^{\dag}}_{kl } \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left .
- \frac{1}{2 } m^{jl}_{ik } \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p}}}+{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } ; { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \right ) \left\ { \mathsf{e}^{^{\dag}}_{kl } \mathsf{e}_{ij } , \rho ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } ) \right\ } \right ] , \label{eq : ratebis}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath70 is obtained from eq . ( [ eq : hn ] ) with the replacement @xmath71 , and @xmath72 denotes a collection of trace class operators in @xmath9 normalized according to @xmath73 .
if the classical approximation applies for the internal degrees of freedom the incoherent term of the master equation giving a quantum description of the translational dynamics only takes the form @xmath74 + \sum_j { \int}{\mathrm{d}}{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \int_{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q}}}^{\bot } } { \,}{\mathrm{d}}{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } \left [ { \mathrm{e}}^{i{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \cdot \mathsf{x } / \hbar } l_{i j } \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } , \mathsf{p } ; { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \right ) \rho_j l_{i j } \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } , \mathsf{p } ; { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \right)^{\dag } { \mathrm{e}}^{-i{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \cdot \mathsf{x } / \hbar } \right . \nonumber\\ & & \left .
- \frac{1}{2 } \left\ { l_{i j } \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } , \mathsf{p } ; { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \right)^{\dag } l_{i j } \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } , \mathsf{p } ; { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \right ) , \rho_i \right\ } \right ] .
\label{eq : rirate}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath75 , \label{eq : hni}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath76 denotes a collection of trace class operators in @xmath77 normalized according to @xmath78 . for the case in which all the off - diagonal elements with respect to momentum and internal energy eigenvalues vanish , that is to say @xmath79 _ _ or _
_ @xmath80 , the motional state of the test particle is fully characterized by the distribution of the diagonal terms @xmath81 , which is a classical probability density obeying the classical markovian master equation @xmath82 where the positive quantities @xmath83 defined in eq .
( [ eq : clarate ] ) can actually be interpreted as the transition rates from an initial momentum @xmath84 and internal state @xmath33 to a final momentum @xmath41 and internal state @xmath85 .
this classical markovian master equation provides the natural generalization of the classical linear boltzmann equation to a particle with internal degrees of freedom @xcite .
the quantum linear boltzmann equation has proven useful in the description of collisional decoherence , as well as in the evaluation of the index of refraction for matter waves @xcite .
we will now consider the effect of internal degrees of freedom , affecting the collisional interaction between massive test particle and background gas , on the visibility of the interference fringes in a interferometric setup .
in particular we will show that the visibility can exhibit oscillations due to non - markovian effects .
the effect of the entanglement between internal and centre of mass degrees of freedom for the visibility of quantum interference experiments has already been considered in @xcite , in the absence however of decoherence effects .
the quantum master equation eq .
( [ eq : qlbefinal ] ) is in lindblad form : this means that the dynamics of the test particle is markovian when both translational and internal degrees of freedom are described and detected .
a different situation emerges if the translational or the internal degrees of freedom , although influencing the collisional dynamics , are not revealed during the measurement process . in this case
they must be averaged out from the description of the system , by means of the partial trace , thus becoming part of the environment . as well known in the classical case ,
a non - markovian dynamical regime becomes markovian by suitably enlarging the set of degrees of freedom and vice - versa .
indeed , a unitary markovian time evolution for both system and reservoir generally gives a non - markovian reduced dynamics for the system , the degree of non - markovianity of the description also depending on where we set the border between system and environment , which ultimately depends on the physical quantities actually measurable by the experimenter .
a smaller set of observed degrees of freedom , with respect to those actually involved in the dynamics , can lead from a markovian to a non - markovian regime .
a general mechanism describing this passage in quantum systems is presented in @xcite : a lindblad structure on a bipartite system can generate in the two reduced subsystems a generalized lindblad structure , typically describing a non - markovian dynamics . in the situation we are considering ,
the bipartite system is formed by the translational and the internal degrees of freedom of the test particle . if the measurements at the output of the detector can not probe the internal degrees of freedom , the only experimentally accessible quantities are expectations or matrix elements of the statistical operator given by @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the statistical operator describing the full dynamics of the test particle .
it is easy to see that , if the free hamiltonian is non degenerate , the diagonal matrix elements in the energy basis with respect to the internal degrees of freedom of the master equation lead to eq .
( [ eq : rirate ] ) , i.e. a coupled system of equations for the collection @xmath88 of trace class operators on @xmath77 .
this system of equations has a generalized lindblad structure @xcite , and therefore it can also describe highly non - markovian dynamics for the statistical operator @xmath89 given by eq .
( [ eq : varrho ] ) . indeed , there is generally no closed evolution equation for @xmath89 , but from the knowledge of the initial collection @xmath90 the generalized lindblad structure allows to obtain the collection @xmath88 at time @xmath91 and therefore , through eq .
( [ eq : varrho ] ) , also @xmath89 . in the next paragraph
we are going to explicitly point out non - markovian behaviour described by the generalized lindblad structure , which express the effect of correlations between internal and translational degrees of freedom on the visibility of interference fringes for superpositions of motional states .
a complementary situation has been considered in @xcite , where the effect of collisional decoherence on internal state superpositions of a cold gas has been studied in detail . in typical interferometric experiments
the test particle is much more massive than the particles of the background gas .
the dependence on the momentum operator in the lindblad operators describing the collisional dynamics and in the hamiltonian part determining the energy shift can therefore be replaced by a fixed value @xmath92 , which represents the initial momentum of the test particle entering the interferometer . taking the diagonal matrix elements of the general form of the master equation given by eq .
( [ eq : qlbefinal ] ) and specified by eq .
( [ eq : hn ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : diag ] ) , assuming non degeneracy of the internal energy eigenvalues one finally obtains for the collection of operators @xmath93 the following coupled system of equations : @xmath94 + \sum_j \left ( \gamma^{i j}_{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p}}}_0 } \int d{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \mathcal{p}^{i j}_{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p}}}_0 } ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } ) { \mathrm{e}}^{i{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \cdot \mathsf{x } / \hbar } \rho_j ( t ) { \mathrm{e}}^{-i{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{q } } } \cdot \mathsf{x } / \hbar } - \gamma^{j i}_{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p}}}_0 } \rho_i ( t ) \right ) , \label{eq : lgen}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath95 and @xmath96 probability densities and transition rates defined by @xmath97 and @xmath98 respectively .
note that at variance with eq .
( [ eq : rirate ] ) we are now not assuming a classical dynamics for the internal degrees of freedom , we focus on the diagonal matrix elements of the internal states only since the latter are enough to determine the non - markovian dynamics of the motional state according to eq .
( [ eq : varrho ] ) .
the fact that the positive quantities @xmath99 are transition rates implies that @xmath100 can be interpreted as the probability distribution function for a test particle with momentum @xmath41 and internal energy eigenstate @xmath33 to exchange a momentum @xmath63 , and to go into the internal state @xmath85 due to a collision with the gas . on the same footing
, @xmath101 can be interpreted as the total transition rate for a test particle with momentum @xmath41 and internal state @xmath33 to go to a fixed final internal energy eigenstate @xmath85 .
we are now going to describe the visibility reduction predicted by the generalized lindblad structure eq .
( [ eq : lgen ] ) obtained from the quantum bloch - boltzmann equation eq .
( [ eq : qlbefinal ] ) in the limit of a very massive test particle .
to obtain the formula describing the fringes visibility in an explicit way we need to solve the equation of motion in the position representation .
starting from eq .
( [ eq : lgen ] ) and omitting for simplicity the explicit dependence on the classical label @xmath92 denoting the momentum of the test particle , we obtain @xmath102 where @xmath103 denotes the matrix element @xmath104 and @xmath105 is the characteristic function of the probability density @xmath106 @xcite , i.e. its fourier transform @xmath107 we will now consider a few cases in which eq . ( [ eq : rhoixx ] ) can be solved analytically , so as to obtain an exact expression for the visibility , showing up different possible qualitative behaviour .
when the collisions are purely elastic , so that they do not lead to transitions between different internal states , the scattering rates satisfy @xmath108 .
this is the case when the energy exchanges involved in the single collisions are much smaller than the typical separation of the internal energy levels @xcite .
the equations for the different @xmath76 then become uncoupled and take the form @xmath109 the latter equation can be conveniently solved introducing the function @xcite @xmath110 where @xmath44 and @xmath6 as usual denote position and momentum operators of the test particle . in such a way eq .
( [ eq : decouple ] ) leads to @xmath111 \chi_i ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\lambda } } } , { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\mu } } } , t),\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is an equation of first order solved by @xmath112 where the function @xmath113 obeys the free equation @xmath114 .
inverting eq .
( [ eq : chi ] ) by taking the fourier transform with respect to @xmath115 , @xmath116 we obtain the exact solution @xmath117 expressed in terms of an integral of the freely evolved subcollections @xmath118 with a suitable kernel , where we have set @xmath119 and @xmath120 .
the evolution of the statistical operator given by eq .
( [ eq : varrho ] ) is obtained summing the different @xmath103 over the discrete index @xmath85 . for an initial state given by a product state between the translational and the internal part , so that @xmath121 , we finally obtain @xmath122 this result reduces to the standard markovian situation , when either only one @xmath123 is different from zero ( and therefore equal to one ) , or the rates are all equal .
this limiting cases describes situations in which the initial state is in a specific internal state or the collisions do not depend on the internal state of the tracer particle .
for the case of a two - level system a natural situation corresponds to inelastic scattering taking place only when the test particle gets de - excited , so that only one of the two scattering rates is different from zero .
this case can still be treated analytically .
assuming @xmath124 , the equation for @xmath125 gets closed , and is solved by @xmath126 the equation for @xmath127 then reads @xmath128 \chi_1 ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\lambda } } } , { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\mu } } } , t ) + \gamma^{12 } \phi^{12 } ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\mu } } } ) \chi_2 ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\lambda } } } , { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\mu } } } , t ) \label{eq : chi2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and its solution is given by @xmath129 d t ' \phantom{\frac{1}{1 } } \right\ } .
\label{eq : chi3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this formula explicitly shows that @xmath130 depends on the function @xmath131 evaluated over the whole time interval between 0 and @xmath91 , a typical signature of non - markovian dynamics .
assuming once again that the initial state is characterized by @xmath132 , the statistical operator describing the translational degrees of freedom of the test particle is given at time @xmath91 by the expression @xmath133 we can now explicitly present the visibility reduction predicted by the generalized lindblad structure obtained from the quantum master equation for a test particle with internal degrees of freedom .
our aim is to obtain an exact expression for the loss of visibility in a double - slit arrangement as a function of the time of interaction with the environment , and to illustrate by means of example how the presence of the various scattering channels , corresponding to the different internal states , can actually lead to non - markovian behaviours .
in particular we will consider the situation of purely elastic collisions in full generality , also allowing for inelastic scattering in the case of a two - level system .
while the experimental setting is always taken to be the same , the different number of internal degrees of freedom involved and the presence or absence of inelastic scattering events will lead to more or less marked non - exponential behaviours in the reduction of the visibility fringes . we first derive a formula for the visibility reduction in the case of a double - slit experiment in the far field approximation .
a beam of particles moves towards a grating perpendicular to its direction of propagation , and with two identical slits separated by a distance @xmath134 , finally reaching a detector where the fringes of interference are observed . during the flight through the interferometer
the beam particles interact through collisions with the environment in the background , thus undergoing decoherence .
we consider an initial product state , so that in the notation of eq .
( [ eq : lgen ] ) one has @xmath121 , where @xmath135 describes the translational degrees of freedom .
if after the passage through the collimation slits the test particle is described by @xmath136 , then the double - slit grating prepares the initial state @xcite @xmath137 setting @xmath138 |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x } } } \rangle { : = } i \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x } } } \right ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we consider the quantity @xmath139 which describes the reduction of the interference pattern with respect to the free case . exploiting the fact that the time evolution generated by eq .
( [ eq : varrhoxx ] ) is covariant under translations @xcite , so that @xmath140 & = & e^{i \mathsf{p } \cdot { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{a}}}/ \hbar } \mathcal{u}(t ) [ \varrho ] e^{- i \mathsf{p } \cdot { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{a}}}/ \hbar } , \label{eq : cov}\end{aligned}\ ] ] one has , using eq .
( [ eq : cos ] ) , @xmath141 |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}- \frac{1}{2 } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d } } } \rangle | \right.}{\langle { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}- \frac{1}{2 } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}|\mathcal{u}(t ) [ \rho_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{sl } } } } ] |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}- \frac{1}{2 } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d } } } \rangle + \langle { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}+ \frac{1}{2 } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}|\mathcal{u}(t ) [ \rho_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{sl } } } } ] |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}+ \frac{1}{2 } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d } } } \rangle } , \label{eq : v}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where now @xmath91 is the time employed by the test particle to reach the detector .
indeed this result remains true for any translation - covariant time evolution . for an initial factorized state of the test particle we can exploit eq .
( [ eq : varrhoxx ] ) to obtain a closed formula for the time evolution operator @xmath142 depending on the initial internal state , i.e. on the coefficients @xmath123 appearing in @xmath121 : the numerator of eq .
( [ eq : v ] ) then reads @xmath143 |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}- \frac{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}}{2 } + { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{s } } } \rangle e^{- \gamma^{i i } \int^t_0 ( 1 - \phi^{i i } ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{\lambda}}}(t - t ' ) / m ) ) { \ensuremath{\operatorname{dt } } } ' } | , \right . &
\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath144 is the free evolution operator of the translational degrees of freedom , so that @xmath145 |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}- \frac{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}}{2 } + { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{s } } } \rangle & = & \text{$\langle { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}- \frac{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}}{2 } + { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{s}}}| \mathcal{u}_0 ( t ) [ \rho_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{sl } } } } ] |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}+ \frac{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}}{2 } + { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{s } } } \rangle$ } .
\label{eq : xmenod}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the latter expression can also be written @xmath146 |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}+ \frac{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}}{2 } \rangle & = & \left ( \frac{m}{t } \right)^3 e^{- im{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d } } } \cdot { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}/ \left ( \hbar t \right ) } \int \frac{d{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y}}}d{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y}}}'}{(2 \pi \hbar)^3 } e^{im \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y}}}^2 -{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y}}}'^2 \right ) / \left ( 2 \hbar t \right ) } \nonumber\\ & & \times e^{- im{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x } } } \cdot ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y}}}-{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y } } } ' ) / \left ( \hbar t \right ) } e^{im{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d } } } \cdot \left ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y}}}+{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y } } } ' \right ) / \left ( 2 \hbar t \right ) } \langle { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y}}}| \rho_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{sl } } } } |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{y } } } ' \rangle , \label{eq : fraun}\end{aligned}\ ] ] assuming due to symmetry @xmath147 .
this formula enables us to implement the far field approximation .
in fact , let @xmath148 of the two slits , so that the integrand is negligible if @xmath149 ( and similarly for @xmath150 ) takes values outside the support of @xmath136 , then @xmath151 and therefore for a time long enough such that @xmath152 the first exponential can be disregarded .
the same applies for the last exponential if @xmath153 . for times longer than @xmath154 ,
corresponding to the far field approximation , we get @xmath146 |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}+ \frac{{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}}{2 } \rangle & \approx & \left ( \frac{m}{t } \right)^3 e^{- im{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d } } } \cdot { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x}}}/ \left ( \hbar t \right ) } \tilde{\rho}_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{sl } } } } \left ( \frac{m}{t } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x } } } \right ) , \label{eq : approx}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath155 is the distribution function for the momentum of the particle in the state @xmath136 , @xmath156 the equivalence between the assumption @xmath157 and the far field approximation @xmath158 , where @xmath159 is the wavelength associated to the test particle and @xmath160 is the distance between grating and detector , is easily seen from the relation @xmath161 , where @xmath162 is the component along the @xmath163 direction of the massive particle , assumed to be constant . substituting eq .
( [ eq : xmenod ] ) in the numerator of eq .
( [ eq : v ] ) and using the approximation @xmath164 valid because of the localization of the state @xmath136 , we can easily perform the integrals over @xmath165 and @xmath115 , thus finally obtaining @xmath166 for the denominator of eq .
( [ eq : v ] ) one can proceed in an analogous way , using @xmath167 |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x } } } \pm \frac{1}{2 } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{d}}}+{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{s } } } \rangle & \approx & \left ( \frac{m}{t } \right)^3 \tilde{\rho}_{{\ensuremath{\operatorname{sl } } } } \left ( \frac{m}{t } { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{x } } } \right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and performing the integral over @xmath115 , further observing that @xmath168 for the normalization of @xmath169 .
the desired expression for the visibility in the absence of inelastic scattering and for an arbitrary number @xmath170 of channels thus reads @xmath171 where we recall that the probabilities @xmath123 give the weight of the different internal states in the initial preparation .
the dependence on @xmath91 in this formula can be easily made explicit with the change of variable @xmath172 , so that one has @xmath173
plot of the visibility in a double - slit arrangement as a function of the interaction time with the environment , for the case of elastic scattering events only , according to eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) and with growing number of channels from left to right .
the dashed lines represent the markovian exponential decays occurring if a single elastic channel prevails on the others , the one with the highest and lowest decay rate corresponding to lower and upper line respectively . *
( a ) * visibility for @xmath174 elastic channels , according to the expression eq .
( [ eq : v3 ] ) .
it appears a non monotonic decay as a consequence of the interference between the contributions of the two different elastic channels .
the coefficients @xmath175 and @xmath176 defined in eq .
( [ eq : ab ] ) are calculated for two gaussian distributions @xmath177 and @xmath178 of the exchanged momenta .
taking @xmath179 as direction of propagation inside the interferometer we only need to specify the mean and the variance of the exchanged momenta along this axis , respectively @xmath180 and @xmath181 , @xmath182 .
the plot is for @xmath183 , while @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 , @xmath188 in arbitrary units . *
( b ) * visibility for @xmath189 elastic channels according to the general expression eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) .
the characteristic functions @xmath190 are calculated starting from gaussian distributions , assuming equal rates @xmath191 and equal variances @xmath192 in arbitrary units as in ( a ) .
the @xmath123 are uniformly distributed and the means @xmath180 are equally spaced in the range from @xmath193 to @xmath194.,title="fig : " ] plot of the visibility in a double - slit arrangement as a function of the interaction time with the environment , for the case of elastic scattering events only , according to eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) and with growing number of channels from left to right .
the dashed lines represent the markovian exponential decays occurring if a single elastic channel prevails on the others , the one with the highest and lowest decay rate corresponding to lower and upper line respectively . * ( a ) * visibility for @xmath174 elastic channels , according to the expression eq .
( [ eq : v3 ] ) .
it appears a non monotonic decay as a consequence of the interference between the contributions of the two different elastic channels .
the coefficients @xmath175 and @xmath176 defined in eq .
( [ eq : ab ] ) are calculated for two gaussian distributions @xmath177 and @xmath178 of the exchanged momenta .
taking @xmath179 as direction of propagation inside the interferometer we only need to specify the mean and the variance of the exchanged momenta along this axis , respectively @xmath180 and @xmath181 , @xmath182 .
the plot is for @xmath183 , while @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 , @xmath188 in arbitrary units . *
( b ) * visibility for @xmath189 elastic channels according to the general expression eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) .
the characteristic functions @xmath190 are calculated starting from gaussian distributions , assuming equal rates @xmath191 and equal variances @xmath192 in arbitrary units as in ( a ) .
the @xmath123 are uniformly distributed and the means @xmath180 are equally spaced in the range from @xmath193 to @xmath194.,title="fig : " ] from eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) one can easily see the difference between the markovian situation , corresponding to @xmath195 , and the general case .
if there is just one term in the sum , the modulus simply picks out the real part of the characteristic function in the exponential and eq . ( [ eq : vvt ] ) describes an exponential decay in time with a rate @xmath196 .
this can happen if only one internal energy state is populated in the initial preparation or the scattering events are actually independent on the internal state .
if there are at least two terms , the modulus can generate oscillating terms as a consequence of the interference of the different phases arising since the functions @xmath190 are in general complex valued .
even if the imaginary parts of the characteristic functions are zero , i.e. the distribution functions of the exchanged momenta are even , eq . ( [ eq : vvt ] ) can describe highly non - exponential behaviour . in this case in fact
it reduces to @xmath197 i.e. the sum of different exponential functions .
as shown in @xcite this kind of relations can describe behaviour very different from the exponential one .
let us consider in more detail the case of a two - level system . introducing the notation @xmath198 the visibility reduction
is explicitly given by @xmath199\right]^{1/2 } .
\nonumber\\ \label{eq : v3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this formula describes a decrease modulated by the oscillations produced by the cosine function . to illustrate this behaviour in fig .
[ fig:1].a we plot the visibility as a function of time , considering by means of example two gaussian distributions .
note that the appearance of the oscillations depends on a non vanishing mean value for the distribution functions @xmath200 given by eq .
( [ eq : pij ] ) , which describe the state dependent momentum transfers . this feature corresponds to a preferred direction in the net momentum transfer between test particle and environment , as happens e.g. by the interaction with a laser beam @xcite , the asymmetry in the single interaction channel being determined in this case by the direction of propagation .
the behaviour described by eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) for an @xmath170-level system is illustrated in fig .
[ fig:1].b , where we show how the increased number of levels can strongly suppress the oscillations and lead to a reduction of the visibility .
the dashed lines represent the exponential decays pertaining to the markovian situation arising if only one of the internal energy states is initially populated , the one with the highest or lowest decoherence rate corresponding to the lower or upper dashed line respectively .
it appears that with growing @xmath170 the interference between the contributions of the different channels to eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) rapidly determines a decay of the visibility sensibly faster than that occurring for the corresponding markovian single - channel dynamics . indeed in fig .
[ fig:1 ] left and right panel correspond to the same interaction strength but differ in the number of involved degrees of freedom , ranging to @xmath174 to @xmath189 .
relying on the results of sect.[2ls ] one can also obtain an expression of the visibility in the presence of inelastic scattering for a two - level system . indeed starting from eq .
( [ eq : varrhoxx3 ] ) and following the same procedure as above one comes to @xmath201 where for simplicity @xmath202 , and we have taken @xmath203 , so that the oscillations in the visibility can not be traced back to interference among different components .
an illustration of the behaviour of the visibility in this case has been plotted in fig .
[ fig:3 ] , always assuming for the sake of generality a gaussian distribution of momentum transfers . in this case
the dashed line corresponds to the exponential markovian decay occurring if only the elastic channel is involved in the dynamics .
it immediately appears that a non monotonic behaviour in the loss of visibility is observed also in this case , due to the multiple time integration in eq .
( [ eq : varrhoxx3 ] ) .
plot of the visibility in a double - slit arrangement as a function of the interaction time with the environment , for the case in which one of the internal states also undergoes inelastic scattering , according to eq .
( [ eq : inelastic ] ) with @xmath174 .
it clearly appears a non monotonic decay of the visibility as a consequence of the multiple time integration describing the contribution of the inelastic channel .
the distributions of momentum transfers are assumed gaussian , with @xmath204 ; moreover @xmath205 and @xmath206 .
the dashed line corresponds to the markovian dynamics determined by the channel undergoing elastic scattering only . ]
we have here considered the visibility reduction as a function of time . however in typical interferometric experiments the time of flight is fixed , and it is more natural to study the loss of visibility as a function of the strength of the interaction with the environment . in collisional decoherence this depends on the number of collisions , directly proportional to the gas density or equivalently to its pressure for a fixed time of flight . as in the markovian case , we can thus express the visibility as a function of the pressure of the background gas , which is the physical quantity directly tunable in actual experiments @xcite . introducing the effective cross section @xmath207 according to the relation @xcite @xmath208 where the l.h.s .
denotes the classical loss term appearing in eq .
( [ eq : classicaleq ] ) , one has for an ideal gas @xmath209 where @xmath210 is the pressure of the gas and @xmath211 its temperature .
one can thus introduce a family of reference pressures depending on the initial internal state of the particle entering in the interferometer @xmath212 where @xmath91 is the time of flight , so that eq .
( [ eq : vvt ] ) can equivalently be written as a function of the pressure in the interferometer @xmath213 this simply implies that the behaviour of the visibility as a function of time is equivalent to its behaviour with respect to the pressure and therefore the disturbance of the environment .
we have derived the master equation describing the dynamics of a test particle with both translational and internal degrees of freedom , interacting through collisions with a low density background gas .
this has been done building on the so - called monitoring approach @xcite , and confirms a previous heuristic argument put forward by one of us in @xcite .
the present microscopic derivation further allows to determine the energy shift .
as we have checked , the result reduces to known equations in suitable limits : the quantum linear boltzmann equation if the internal degrees of freedom are neglected @xcite , the master equation for an immobile test particle if the translational degrees of freedom are not relevant @xcite , as well as quantum classical markovian master equations if one or both kind of degrees of freedom can be treated as classical .
note that the natural bases in the derivation was given by momentum for the motional degrees of freedom and energy for the internal ones , the latter corresponding to the channel basis of scattering theory . in these cases different channels
are only coupled through the collision term .
if another internal basis can be of interest , also coherent tunnelling effects appear .
+ we have further focused on the situation in which the internal degrees of freedom , in spite of influencing the collisional scattering cross section , are not probed by the measuring apparatus and therefore have to be averaged out from the set of the observed dynamical variables , thus effectively becoming part of the environment .
the equation obtained in this situation is no more of lindblad type , but rather takes the form of a generalized lindblad structure @xcite .
it can therefore describe behaviour quite different from that characterizing a markovian dynamics .
solving these equations in the position representation for an initial factorized state , we have obtained an explicit expression for the visibility reduction in interferometric experiments when internal degrees of freedom are involved .
the behaviour of the visibility can indeed be quite different from the exponential decay corresponding to a markovian dynamics , showing up e.g. oscillations and revivals .
+ the interplay between different degrees of freedom in a bipartite system is a natural source of non - markovian behaviour , when either degrees of freedom can not be controlled , thus acting as an environment .
this scenario has here been studied in a concrete setting , assuming a factorized initial state , and describing the dynamics in terms of a generalized lindblad structure .
such a choice of initial condition is relevant for the considered interferometric setting , it would be however of great importance to consider initially correlated states , which naturally appear when considering a non - markovian dynamics in a strong coupling regime
. it would further be of interest to study whether , instead of using this generalized lindblad structure , one can obtain a closed description of the reduced system dynamics in terms of a master equation with a memory kernel , at least in some simplified situations .
we plan to address these topics in future research work .
we are grateful to ludovico lanz for useful hints along the preparation of the manuscript .
bv would also like to thank klaus hornberger for very helpful discussions and reading of the manuscript .
this work was partially supported by miur under prin2008 .
we here address the derivation of the markovian master equation for the description of the dynamics of the test particle starting from the general expressions eq .
and eq . . the scattering and rate operators appearing in these equations are best expressed using the factorization of the total hilbert space @xmath214 , according to @xmath215 where the hilbert space @xmath9 associated to the internal degrees of freedom is part of @xmath216 @xcite , the notation is the same as in sec .
[ sec : ms ] .
in fact both these operators act in a trivial way on centre of mass coordinates : @xmath217 and @xmath218 . the operator @xmath219 is given by @xmath220 where @xmath221 is the total cross section , depending on initial relative momentum and internal state .
the relation @xcite @xmath222 links the operator @xmath223 to the multichannel complex scattering amplitudes @xmath224 , referring to scattering from an initial momentum @xmath32 and internal state @xmath33 to a final state with momentum @xmath34 and internal state @xmath35 . according to standard usage in scattering theory
we call channels the asymptotically free internal energy eigenstates of the system .
the differential cross section is given by @xmath225 .
[ [ evaluation - of - the - lindblad - structure - in - momentum - and - internal - state - basis ] ] evaluation of the lindblad structure in momentum and internal state basis ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ we now first concentrate on the evaluation of the contribution given by eq .
( [ eq : ms ] ) , which under suitable approximations can be cast in lindblad form , closely following @xcite , where the special case of a test particle without internal structure was dealt with . to this end
we consider the matrix elements of @xmath226 in the momentum and channel basis @xmath227 of the hilbert space @xmath228 associated to the test particle . denoting by @xmath27 the stationary gas momentum distribution and exploiting the relations eq .
( [ eq : gamma ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : t ] ) for the relevant operators we can express the result as is eq . , where the complex rate functions @xmath229 have been introduced , and @xmath230 denotes the volume in which the gas is confined .
note that @xmath231 can be interpreted as classical rates for scattering of the test particle with momentum @xmath84 and internal energy eigenstate @xmath33 to a final state with momentum @xmath41 and internal energy eigenstate @xmath85 .
the contributions at r.h.s . of eq .
( [ eq : rif2 ] ) therefore play the role of quantum gain and loss term also depending on the internal degrees of freedom involved . relying on eq .
( [ eq : rif2 ] ) we can now deal just with the complex rates @xmath232 defined in eq .
( [ eq : rate ] ) . to proceed ,
it is helpful to introduce the following functions of @xmath233 @xmath234 which denote the mean of the pairs of initial and final relative momenta appearing in @xmath232 and which are related by @xmath235 . introducing also @xmath236 the complex functions @xmath237 can be expressed as an average over the gas distribution function @xmath238 of a complex density in the centre of mass frame @xmath239 with @xmath240 evaluating this formula with the expressions eq .
( [ eq : gamma ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : t ] ) for @xmath219 and @xmath223 respectively , we obtain @xmath241 where @xmath242 is the eigenvalue of the operator @xmath219 relative to the state @xmath243 . the expression given by eq .
( [ eq : m ] ) looses its meaning in the infinite volume limit , due to appearance of the arbitrarily large normalization volume .
this point has been extensively discussed in @xcite .
it is to be traced back to the fact that the operator @xmath1 in order to provide the actual rate of collisions should involve a projection on the subspace of incoming wave packets , which is not accounted for in eq .
( [ eq : mijkl ] ) . to do this
, we are going now to evaluate the operator @xmath1 on a properly modified state of the relative motion . before that , it is convenient to focus our attention on the two delta - functions appearing in eq .
( [ eq : m ] ) : employing the relation @xmath244 , we can rewrite them as the product @xmath245 these two constraints ensure that the scattering amplitudes appearing in eq .
( [ eq : m ] ) are evaluated on shell .
the function @xmath246 gives a significant contribution to the integral in eq .
( [ eq : mijkl ] ) when the two energy differences are approximately equal , so that @xmath21 , leading otherwise to rapidly oscillating phases , and this is actually a necessary condition in order to obtain a completely positive time evolution @xcite .
this implies in particular that integrating the generalized function @xmath247 with a function @xmath248 , the contributions deriving from the parallel component of @xmath249 vanish @xmath250 we now therefore evaluate @xmath251 with a properly modified state of relative motion , which takes into account the restriction of the expression to states which actually describe a colliding pair . to this end
we write the complex rate @xmath252 as @xmath253 where @xmath254 denotes an improper state of relative motion @xmath255 since the rate operator @xmath1 should have a vanishing expectation value for those states of the relative motion that are not of the incoming type , we make the replacement @xmath256 this corresponds to a restriction of the wigner function associated to the improper state of relative motion eq .
( [ eq : improper ] ) from the entire normalization volume @xmath230 to a cylinder pointing in the direction @xmath32 , with base surface @xmath257 and height @xmath258 . as in the case without internal degrees of freedom @xmath258 is approximately the distance travelled by the particle between two subsequent collisions , while @xmath257 can now be taken as the geometric mean of the total cross - section of the involved channels @xcite , that is to say @xmath259 and @xmath260 , with @xmath261 the typical time interval between two subsequent collisions .
where we have exploited once again the relation @xmath263 .
we now first perform the integral over @xmath264 , which denotes the component of @xmath265 parallel to @xmath32 , thus evaluating the second delta - function at r.h.s . of the previous equation , so that the dependence on @xmath266 only appears in the term @xmath267 the phase of the integrand varies very quickly for @xmath268 , where @xmath261 is the typical time elapsing between collisions , so that as already discussed its contribution vanishes unless @xmath269 , corresponding to a rotating wave approximation , assuming a separation of time scales between internal and translational dynamics @xcite . further considering the integral over @xmath270 as an approximate expression for @xmath271
we are led to @xmath272 where the @xmath20 act like a kronecker s delta factor , being defined according to @xmath273 in the last two terms we can disregard the dependence on @xmath274 because we expect that a @xmath274-integration will average out the `` far off - diagonal '' contributions with large modulus @xmath275 , where the phases of the two scattering amplitudes are no longer synchronous . in conclusion , we have @xmath276 this relation determines the complex rate functions @xmath277 through eq .
( [ eq : mijkl ] ) , and therefore the dissipative part of the master equation according to eq .
( [ eq : rif2 ] ) . as a last step in the determination of the structure of the master equation
we need to evaluate the contribution given by @xmath278 . in the same notation as above , and within the same approximations ,
we directly obtain @xmath279 \right ) |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } ' , k \rangle\\ & = & \frac{1}{i \hbar } \sum_j \left ( e^{i j}_n ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } ) \langle { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } , j| \rho |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } ' , k \rangle- e^{j k}_n ( { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } ' ) \langle { \ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } , i| \rho |{\ensuremath{\boldsymbol{p } } } ' , j \rangle \right ) , \label{eq : coherent}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath280 .
\label{eq : enij}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is worth noting that for the case of a non - degenerate free internal hamiltonian this formula reduces to @xmath281 with @xmath282 .
\label{eq : eni}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now recast the master equation eq . (
[ eq : qlbefinal ] ) , whose matrix elements are given by eq .
( [ eq : rif2 ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : coherent ] ) , in a way which allows to express it in a representation - independent form .
the key point is to show that @xmath283 can be factorized into two terms , one depending on @xmath41 and the other on @xmath284 . changing the integration variable from @xmath233 to @xmath32 and using the relations eq .
( [ eq : ppi - ppf ] ) to obtain @xmath285 , we have @xmath286 where we replaced @xmath249 by @xmath274 in the arguments of @xmath287 , in accordance with eq .
( [ eq : qperp ] ) . remembering that @xmath235 and @xmath288
, we consider the change of variable @xmath289 to obtain the desired factorization . if we further consider that the delta function @xmath290 restricts the @xmath23-integration to the plane @xmath24 we finally arrive at the expression eq . , with @xmath291 as in eq . , which allows to obtain the operator expression of the master equation given by eq .
( [ eq : diag ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : hn ] ) . if the gas distribution function @xmath238 is given by a maxwell - boltzmann probability density @xmath292 , where @xmath293 is the most probable momentum at temperature @xmath294 , these functions can be expressed in terms of the dynamic structure factor for a maxwell - boltzmann gas @xcite @xmath295 in fact , using the relation @xmath296 with @xmath297 the energy transferred to the centre of mass in a collision changing the momentum of the test particle from @xmath41 to @xmath298 , eq .
( [ eq : l ] ) can be written as @xcite @xmath299 in the latter expression for the lindblad operators , the dynamic structure factor appears evaluated for an energy transfer corresponding to the sum of the contributions for centre of mass and internal state , as naturally expected .
as discussed in @xcite , the dynamic structure factor describes momentum and energy transferred to the test particle when scattering off a macroscopic system , thus allowing for a more transparent physical understanding of the structure of the lindblad operators . | we address the microscopic derivation of a quantum master equation in lindblad form for the dynamics of a massive test particle with internal degrees of freedom , interacting through collisions with a background ideal gas .
when either internal or centre of mass degrees of freedom can be treated classically , previously established equations are obtained as special cases .
if in an interferometric setup the internal degrees of freedom are not detected at the output , the equation can be recast in the form of a generalized lindblad structure , which describes non - markovian effects .
the effect of internal degrees of freedom on centre of mass decoherence is considered in this framework . |
in 1990 , carroll - field - jackiw @xcite have proposed a version of the maxwell electrodynamics corrected by a chern - simons - like term @xmath0 in order to incorporate a lorentz - violating background @xmath1 into the usual electrodynamics .
this term implies a modified theory in which photons with different polarizations propagate with distinct velocities ( birefringence ) .
some years later , colladay & kostelecky @xcite-@xcite have constructed an extension of the minimal standard model , the extended standard model ( sme ) , in which lorentz - violating tensor terms , stemming from a spontaneous symmetry breaking ( ssb ) of a more fundamental theory ( defined at the planck scale ) are properly incorporated in all interaction sectors . the construction of the sme was in part motivated by works demonstrating the possibility of lorentz and cpt spontaneous violation in the context of string theory @xcite-@xcite .
recently , the sme has motivated innumerous interesting works @xcite-@xcite .
one of the most remarkable controversies involving lorentz violation deals with the radiative generation of the carroll - field - jackiw term from the integration on the fermion fields @xcite-@xcite .
lorentz violating theories investigations have also been concerned with the consistency aspects of the carroll - field - jackiw electrodynamics @xcite-@xcite , study of synchrotron radiation , electrostatics and magnetostatics in lorentz - violating electrodynamics @xcite-@xcite , influence of lorentz violation on the dirac equation @xcite-@xcite , cpt - probing experiments @xcite-@xcite , cerenkov radiation @xcite , and general aspects @xcite-@xcite . a theoretical model which provides an attractive electron - electron interaction could work , in principle , as a good framework to properly address the electron - electron pairing in planar systems .
in fact , if an attractive electron - electron interaction is obtained in the context of a particular model , it may be seen as a first connection between such theoretical models and the attainment of electron pairing . in practice , this interplay has begun with the application of the maxwell - chern - simons ( mcs ) theory @xcite-@xcite for evaluating the electron - electron interaction in a planar model . however , it was soon established that the mcs model does not imply an attractive interaction for small topological mass @xmath2 regime compatible with low - energy excitations .
currently it is well known that by including the higgs sector @xcite , @xcite , an attractive interaction can be got , assured it is suitably coupled to the fermion field by a quartic order term - @xmath3 ( that gives rise to the yukawa coupling with the higgs field after ssb ) . on the other hand
, it has been recently verified that the mcs theory may also yield an attractive @xmath4 potential ( in the absence of higgs sector ) provided it is considered in the presence of a fixed lorentz - violating background . specifically , it has been evaluated the electron - electron interaction potential in the context of a planar lorentz - violating maxwell - chern - simons model ( arising from the dimensional reduction of the maxwell - carroll - field - jackiw model ) .
such calculation was carried out both for the case of a purely timelike background @xcite and for a purely spacelike background @xcite , leading to interacting potentials with a well ( attractive ) region .
some years ago , it was argued that there is a relation between lorentz violation and noncommutativity @xcite .
the introduction of noncommutativity in the mcs model @xcite has appeared as a new mechanism able to provide @xmath4 attraction .
in fact , the noncommutative extension of the minimal mcs model has shown to be a suitable framework to provide an attractive electron - electron potential .
specifically , this model yields the same interaction potential attained by georgelin & wallet @xcite considering a non - minimal pauli magnetic coupling .
this puts in evidence the relevance of non usual mechanisms for the attainment of electron - electron attractiveness .
it should be also mentioned that noncommutative chern - simons theories have been applied successfully to describe properties of planar hall systems @xcite-@xcite , one of the points of clear connection of noncommutativity with condensed matter physics .
the large number of applications of noncommutativity to condensed matter physics and the general relation between these mechanisms indicate that applications of lorentz violation to condensed matter systems should be a sensible and feasible issue as well . lorentz violation in the presence of the higgs sector and spontaneous symmetry breaking ( ssb )
was first investigated in the context of the 4-dimensional abelian - higgs carroll - field - jackiw electrodynamics @xcite .
this model , by means of a dimensional reduction procedure , has originated a planar electrodynamics composed of the mcs sector with a higgs field , coupled to a massless klein - gordon mode - @xmath5 ( stemming from the dimensional reduction , @xmath6 ) and to the lorentz - violating background ( @xmath7 @xcite .
the consistency of this model was also set up ( it turned out to be totally causal , unitary and stable ) .
once ssb takes place , the gauge and the klein - gordon fields acquire mass , giving rise to a mcs - proca electrodynamics coupled to the lorentz - violating background .
such a model was already used to perform an investigation concerned with condensed matter physics : the study of vortex - like solutions in a planar lorentz - violating environment @xcite . as a result
, it was shown that it provides charged vortex solutions that recover the usual nielsen - olesen configuration in the asymptotic regime . in the present work ,
the aim is to investigate the electron - electron interaction in the context of the abelian - higgs lorentz - violating planar model previously defined , another issue with possible connection with condensed matter physics .
the lagrangian of ref .
@xcite does not stand for the most general neither the most simple model to perform such a task .
however , there are two good reasons to adopt it : its consistency has been already established ; it is expected that it will provide shielded versions of the mcs lorentz - violating potentials derived in ref .
@xcite ( which present a logarithmically asymptotic behavior ) .
having stated the gauge model , the dirac sector is properly incorporated in it by exhibiting the minimal and the yukawa couplings with the gauge ( @xmath8 and the scalar ( @xmath9 fields , respectively .
one then proceeds to carry out the electron - electron potential for the case of a purely timelike background and to discuss its possible attractiveness .
the procedure is much similar to the one adopted in refs .
@xcite , @xcite : starting from a known planar lagrangian , the mller scattering amplitudes ( for the gauge and scalar intermediations ) are constructed ; next , its fourier transforms are evaluated , leading to the interacting potentials . in the present case ,
the result is a totally screened potential * * ( * * due to the presence of the higgs sector * * ) * * composed of the sum of a scalar and a gauge contribution .
this potential exhibits an attractive behavior even in the presence of the centrifugal barrier and the @xmath10gauge invariant term , thereby confirming its attractive character ( even under a more rigorous analysis ) and its possible relevance to the formation of electron - electron pairs in planar systems .
the results obtained here are compared with the one of ref .
@xcite in order to emphasize the role played by the higgs sector : it transforms logarithmically divergent solutions in entirely shielded ones .
this comparison will be accomplished throughout this work .
another point to be remarked is that the gauge potentials here derived may be attractive while the ones of refs .
@xcite , @xcite are always repulsive , which constitutes a sensitive difference between the results of these works .
this work is outlined as follows . in sec .
ii , the reduced model derived in ref .
@xcite , supplemented by the fermion field , is briefly described . in sec .
iii are presented the spinors which fulfill the two - dimensional dirac equation , which , in its turn , are used to evaluate the mller scattering amplitude associated with the scalar and gauge intermediations . in sec .
iv , the interaction potentials are evaluated by performing the fourier transform of the scalar and gauge scattering amplitudes .
the results are properly discussed . in sec.v
are presented the concluding remarks .
at first , one ought to present the planar model which sets up the theoretical framework for the calculations realized in this work .
the starting point is the ( 1 + 3)-dimensional abelian - higgs maxwell - carroll - field - jackiw ( mcfj ) model @xcite , consisting of the mcfj electrodynamics supplemented with the higgs sector .
@xmath11 where @xmath12 is the lorentz - violating fixed background , @xmath13 runs from @xmath14 to @xmath15 @xmath16 is the covariant derivative and @xmath17 represents the scalar potential responsible for ssb ( @xmath18 and @xmath19 in a previous work , this model had undergone a dimensional reduction procedure in which the third spatial coordinate is frozen , implying : @xmath20 at the same time , the third component of the vector potential becomes a scalar field , @xmath21 whereas the third component of background becomes the topological mass:@xmath22 @xmath23 this process yields a lorentz - violating planar model incorporating the higgs sector @xcite , given as below : @xmath24 where the greek letters now run from @xmath14 to @xmath25 once the planar lorentz - violating model has been established , it is considered the spontaneous symmetry breaking process which provides mass to the gauge and scalar fields @xcite .
relying on a tree - level analysis , one should retain only the bilinear terms , so that the planar lagrangian takes the form : @xmath26 where @xmath27and @xmath28is the vacuum expectation value of the @xmath29 field . here
, one explains the reason for which the higgs field does not appear in the above equation : it only keeps high order couplings with the other fields . as it is well - known , these terms are not taken into account in a tree - level evaluation .
the classical solutions of this planar model were achieved in ref .
@xcite , where the effects of the fixed background on the mcs - proca electrodynamics were exhaustively analyzed .
it was also reported that the scalar potential @xmath30 for a purely timelike background exhibits an attractive behavior , which may be seen as a cue indicating that a similar result may be shared by the gauge electron - electron potential to be evaluated in a dynamic configuration .
now , it is necessary to introduce the spinor field suitably coupled to the gauge @xmath31 and scalar @xmath32 ones . in the absence of sources , the interaction lagrangian is read as : @xmath33 the term @xmath34 sets up the minimal coupling , whereas @xmath35 reflects the yukawa coupling with the scalar field .
the fermion field @xmath36 is a two - component spinor with up spin - polarization , representing the positive energy solution of the dirac equation , @xmath37 here written in momentum space .
the mass dimension of the fields and parameters involved in eq .
( [ l1 ] ) are the following : @xmath38 = \left [ a^{\mu}\right ] = 1/2,\left [ \psi\right ] = 1,\left [ s\right ] = \left [ v^{\mu}\right ] = 1,\left [ e_{3}\right ] = \left [ y\right ] = 1/2;$ ] it is noticeable that both coupling constants , @xmath39 and @xmath40 exhibit @xmath41 ^{1/2}$ ] dimension , a usual result in ( 1 + 2 ) dimensions . in ref .
@xcite , the propagators of the scalar @xmath42 and gauge @xmath31 fields were properly evaluated in the following form : @xmath43 \nonumber\\ & + \frac{i(v\cdot k)s^{2}k^{2}}{(k^{2}-m_{a}^{2})\boxtimes(k)\boxplus ( k)}\left [ \sigma^{\mu\nu}+\sigma^{\nu\mu}\right ] -\frac{is(v\cdot k)}{\boxtimes(k)\boxplus(k)}\left [ \phi^{\mu\nu}-\phi^{\nu\mu}\right ] \biggr\ } , \label{prop_gauge}\]]@xmath44 with : @xmath45 @xmath46 the projector operators are defined as : @xmath47 @xmath48 @xmath49 @xmath50 @xmath51 @xmath52 @xmath53 while it is adopted the ( 1 + 2 ) metric convention : @xmath54 naturally , these expressions are essential for the evaluation of the amplitudes associated with the mller scattering , task developed in the next section .
in the context of a low - energy interaction , the born approximation holds as a good approximation .
consequently , the interaction potential arises as the fourier transform of the two - particle scattering amplitude .
another point is that , in the case of the nonrelativistic mller scattering , it should be considered only the direct scattering process @xcite ( even for indistinguishable electrons ) , since in this limit they recover the classical notion of trajectory . from eq .
( [ l1 ] ) , one extracts the feynman rules for the interaction vertices involving fermions : @xmath55 .
therefore , the @xmath4 scattering amplitudes are read as : @xmath56 \overline{u}(p_{2}^{\prime})(iy)u(p_{2}),\label{a1}\\ -i\mathcal{m}_{a } & = \overline{u}(p_{1}^{\prime})(ie_{3}\gamma^{\mu})u(p_{1})\left [ \langle a_{\mu}a_{\nu}\rangle\right ] \overline{u}(p_{2}^{\prime})(ie_{3}\gamma^{\nu})u(p_{2 } ) , \label{a2}\ ] ] here , @xmath57 and @xmath58 are obviously the scalar and photon propagators given in eqs .
( [ prop_gauge ] ) , ( [ prop_scalar ] ) .
the scattering amplitudes , of eqs .
( [ a1 ] ) and ( [ a2 ] ) , are written for electrons of equal polarization mediated by the scalar and gauge particles , respectively .
the spinors @xmath59 stand for the positive - energy solution of the dirac equation @xmath60 .
the @xmath61 matrices satisfy the @xmath62 algebra , @xmath63 = 2i\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha}\gamma_{\alpha}$ ] , and correspond to the pauli matrices : @xmath64 considering all it , the following spinors @xmath65{c}e+m\\ -ip_{x}-p_{y}\end{array } \right ] , \text { \ \ } \overline{u}(p)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\left [ \begin{array } [ c]{cc}e+m & -ip_{x}+p_{y}\end{array } \right ] , \label{spinor}\ ] ] are explicitly obtained .
they satisfy the normalization condition @xmath66 for @xmath67 .
the mller scattering is easily attained in the frame of the center of mass , where the momenta of the incoming and outgoing electrons are read in the form:@xmath68 the transfer 4-momentum , carried by the gauge or scalar mediators , is : @xmath69 whereas @xmath70 is the scattering angle ( in the cm frame ) . starting from eqs .
( [ prop_scalar ] ) , ( [ a1 ] ) and from the definitions above , the scattering amplitude associated with the scalar intermediation is readily written : @xmath71 in the case of a purely timelike background , @xmath72v@xmath73 , @xmath74 and considering the general expression for the transfer momentum , @xmath75 , this amplitude takes the following form : @xmath76}{[\mathbf{k}^{4}+\left ( 2m_{a}^{2}+s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2}\right ) \mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{4}][\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{2 } ] } , \label{mscalar2}\ ] ] whose fourier transform will lead to the potential that reflects the scalar interaction carried by the @xmath77field .
one the other hand , in the case of the gauge intermediation , the situation is more complicated as a consequence of the eleven terms present in the propagator ( [ prop_gauge ] ) .
however , as a consequence of the current - conservation law ( @xmath78 only six terms of the gauge propagator contribute to the scattering amplitude ( @xmath79 the first two terms provide , in the non - relativistic limit , the maxwell - chern - simons - proca ( mcsp ) scattering amplitude , which leads to mcsp potential .
the non - relativistic current - current amplitudes involving these two terms , @xmath80 are evaluated in refs.@xcite , @xcite,@xcite .
the corresponding scattering amplitude is then given by : @xmath81 \right\ } .\label{mcsp}\ ] ] the current - current amplitude associated with the other terms of the gauge potential are also carried out , assuming the form below : @xmath82;\\ j^{\mu}(p_{1})\text { } ( \lambda_{\mu\nu})j^{\nu}(p_{2 } ) & = \text{v}_{0}^{2};\\ j^{\mu}(p_{1})\text { } ( q_{\mu\nu}-q_{\nu\mu})j^{\nu}(p_{2 } ) & = 2\frac { \mathbf{p}^{2}}{m_{e}}\text{v}_{0}^{2}[1-\cos\theta - i\sin\theta].\end{aligned}\ ] ] these terms lead to the following scattering amplitudes : @xmath83 where @xmath84 @xmath85 is defined in terms of the momenta @xmath86 of the incoming electrons and @xmath87.$ ] the total current - current amplitude mediated by the massive gauge particle corresponds to the sum of four contributions , @xmath88 where the terms @xmath89 and @xmath90 lead tobackground - depending corrections to the mcs - amplitude .
notice that the amplitude @xmath91 was taken as null due to its dependence on @xmath92(working in the nonrelativistic approximation , @xmath93 .
firstly , it is necessary to evaluate the interaction related with the scalar intermediation . according to the born approximation ,
the scalar interaction potential is given by the fourier transform of the scattering amplitude ( [ mscalar2 ] ) , that is:@xmath94}{[\mathbf{k}^{4}+\left ( 2m_{a}^{2}+s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2}\right ) \mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{4}][\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{2}]}\right ] e^{i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{r}}d^{2}\mathbf{k}\ ] ] in this form , this integral can not be exactly solved .
however , it is possible to factorize the integrand in small factors so that an exact integration becomes feasible . in this sense
, it is important to note that : @xmath95=[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{+}^{2}][\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{-}^{2}],$ ] where the constants @xmath96 are given as below . after some algebraic calculations , one obtains @xmath97}{[\mathbf{k}^{4}+\left ( 2m_{a}^{2}+s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2}\right ) \mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{4}][\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{2}]}=-\frac{(g+d)}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{+}^{2}]}+\frac{(g+e)}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{-}^{2}]}+\frac{(1+d - e)}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{2}]},\ ] ] with coefficients and mass parameters given as:@xmath98 , g=\text{v}_{0}^{2}c,\text { \ } d = g\alpha_{+},\text { \ } e = g\alpha_{-},\label{b1}\\ \alpha_{\pm } & = \frac{2m_{a}^{2}}{(s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2})\pm\sqrt { ( s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2})(s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2}+4m_{a}^{2})}},\label{t1}\\ m_{\pm}^{2 } & = \frac{1}{2}\left [ ( s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2}+2m_{a}^{2})\pm\sqrt{(s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2})(s^{2}-\text{v}_{0}^{2}+4m_{a}^{2})}\right ] .
\label{m1}\ ] ] performing the fourier transforms , the expression @xmath99 is straightforwardly obtained .
this result reveals a totally screened potential as a consequence of the massive character of the scalar intermediation . near the origin
, this potential behaves as a pure logarithm , that is : @xmath100 whence one reaffirms its attractive character at the origin .
far from the origin this potential vanishes exponentially , and is the point where it differs from the scalar potential obtained in the lorentz - violating mcs k_{0}(sr)-\frac{s^{2}}{w^{2}}\ln r\right\ } , $ ] whereas the gauge potential derived in this paper is : @xmath101k_{0}(wr)+\left ( \text{v}_{0}^{2}/w^{2}\right ) \ln r$ ] @xmath102 \biggr\}.$ ] ] case @xcite , which exhibits an asymptotic confining logarithmic behavior .
it is well - known that such kind of confining potential can not describe a physical interaction in ( 1 + 2 ) dimensions .
hence , the first advantage arising from the introduction of the higgs sector in this theoretical framework is the transformation of the non physical confining potential of ref .
@xcite in a bessel @xmath103 potential ( entirely suitable for describing a planar interaction ) .
the graphic in fig .
[ scalarplot1 ] illustrates such a change of asymptotic behavior .
[ ptb ] scalarplot1.eps the starting point for the evaluation of the gauge potential is the attainment of the @xmath104potential from the fourier transform of the @xmath105-amplitude .
such fourier transform can not be directly solved from eq .
( [ mcsp ] ) , which then is properly factorized in the form @xmath106}+\frac{a_{-}}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{-}^{2}]}+\left [ \frac { b}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{+}^{2}]}-\frac{b}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{-}^{2}]}\right ] \left ( \frac{\mathbf{k}^{2}}{m_{e}}-\frac{2i}{m_{e}}i\mathbf{k}\times\mathbf{p}\right ) \right\ } , \label{mcsp2}\ ] ] where : @xmath107 .\ ] ] carrying out the fourier transform of eq . ( [ mcsp2 ] ) ,
the following potential turns out : @xmath108k_{0}(m_{+}r)+[a_{-}+\frac{b}{m_{e}}m_{-}^{2}]k_{0}(m_{-}r)-\frac{2bl}{m_{e}r}[m_{+}k_{1}(m_{+}r)-m_{-}k_{1}(m_{-}r)]\biggr\},\ ] ] where @xmath109 is the angular momentum ( a scalar in a two - dimensional space ) .
it is interesting to point out that @xmath110 is exactly the electron - electron mcs - proca potential , obtained firstly in ref .
near the origin , one has : @xmath111 @xmath112 implying the following result:@xmath113\ln r. \label{mcsp_limit}\ ] ] once one works in the limit of small topological mass , @xmath114 this potential exhibits a repulsive behavior near the origin . the interaction potential associated with the amplitudes
@xmath115may be obtained from the fourier transform of the scattering amplitude given in eq .
( [ m2 ] ) ; however , such amplitude must be previously factorized as @xmath116 \frac{1}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{a}^{2}]}-(cn_{+}-hn_{+})\frac{1}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{+}^{2}]}+(cn_{-}-hn_{-})\frac { 1}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{-}^{2}]}\biggr\},\ ] ] with the coefficients given as : @xmath117 the fourier transforms are then performed , leading to a combination of @xmath103 functions , namely : @xmath118
k_{0}(m_{a}r)-(cn_{+}-hn_{+})k_{0}(m_{+}r)+(cn_{-}-hn_{-})k_{0}(m_{-}r)\biggr\},\ ] ] near the origin , this potential vanishes identically , @xmath119 far from the origin , it decays exponentially .
applying the same procedure to @xmath90 , after some algebra , it ends up in : @xmath120}+\frac{c}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{-}^{2}]}+\frac { h}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{+}^{2}]}-\frac{h}{[\mathbf{k}^{2}+m_{-}^{2}]}\right ] ( \mathbf{k}^{2}-2i\mathbf{k}\times\mathbf{p})\biggr\},\ ] ] so that the resulting potential is : @xmath121\nonumber\\ & -c[m_{+}^{2}k_{0}(m_{+}r)-m_{-}^{2}k_{0}(m_{-}r)]+h[m_{+}^{2}k_{0}(m_{+}r)-m_{-}^{2}k_{0}(m_{-}r)]\biggr\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this latter potential exhibits the same behavior of @xmath122 near and far from the origin , that is : @xmath123 the total gauge interaction potential , @xmath124 after some simplifications , assumes the explicit form : @xmath125k_{0}(m_{+}r)\nonumber\\ & + [ s^{2}(cn_{-}-hn_{-})+cm_{-}^{2}s / m_{e}]k_{0}(m_{-}r)+s^{2}\left [ -c(l_{+}-l_{-})+h(l_{+}-l_{-})\right ] k_{0}(m_{a}r)\nonumber\\ & + \frac{2l}{r}\frac{s}{m_{e}}c[m_{+}k_{1}(m_{+}r)+m_{-}k_{1}(m_{-}r)]\biggr\}. \label{vgauge1}\ ] ] this full expression corresponds to the mcs - proca potential ( @xmath126 corrected by the lorentz - violating terms arising from @xmath127 in the limit of a vanishing background ( v@xmath128 one has @xmath129 @xmath130 , remaining only the @xmath110 potential , which shows the consistency of the obtained results .
obviously , this is an expected outcome , since both @xmath129 are potential contributions induced merely by the presence of the background .
far from the origin , this potential vanishes exponentially ( according to the asymptotic behavior of the bessel functions ) , a consequence of the massive character of the physical mediators . in this point
, this outcome differs from the asymptotic logarithmically divergent gauge potential attained in ref .
@xcite ( which is written in footnote 1 ) .
the graph of fig .
[ [ gauge_gauge ] ] shows a simultaneous plot of the gauge potential of eq .
( [ vgauge1 ] ) ( continuos line ) and the one of ref .
@xcite ( dotted line ) , which has a deeper minimum , compared with the former ( for each set of parameters ) .
[ ptb ] gauge_gaugeplot1.eps near the origin , the lorentz - violating contributions of eq .
( [ vgauge1 ] ) tend to zero , so that in this limit the gauge potential is entirely ruled by the @xmath110 contribution , namely : @xmath131\ln r\biggr\}. \label{vgauge2}\ ] ] it is interesting to note that this is the same behavior of the gauge potentials achieved in refs .
@xcite , @xcite .
as already claimed , this potential will always exhibit a repulsive behavior near the origin .
this general behavior is illustrated in fig.[[gauge1plot1 ] ] for four sets of parameters .
[ ptb ] gauge1plot1.eps concerning such a picture , it presents a comparison of the electron - electron mcs - proca potential ( corresponding to the case for which v@xmath132 with the gauge one for three different values of v@xmath73 .
it shows that the gauge potential appreciably deviates from the mcs - proca behavior as the larger is the magnitude of the background ( v@xmath133 , that is , the larger the background modulus the deeper the attractive region of the potential .
the attractiveness of the gauge potential is ascribed to the presence of the well - shaped region ( constituted by a part of decreasing behavior followed by a part of increasing behavior ) , exhibited in the graphics of fig .
2 . in a dynamic perspective
, such a well - shaped curve may be described in terms of a region in which the gradient potential is negative followed by a positive gradient region in the sequel .
another kind of potential curve which implies an attractive behavior is one whose potential gradient is always negative ( but with a decreasing modulus with increasing distance , @xmath134 for @xmath135 this is the behavior exhibited by the scalar potential in fig.[[scalarplot1 ] ] .
the discussion on the attractiveness of the gauge potential must be conducted with caution and can not be based only on the expression contained in eq .
( [ vgauge1 ] ) .
it happens that , specifically in ( 1 + 2 ) dimensions , a tree - level result may be altered by the 1-loop contributions associated with 2-photon diagrams .
this fact was put in evidence by the controversy involving the attractive / repulsive character of the mcs potential @xcite , which has shown that this potential turns out truly repulsive ( instead of attractive ) whenever the 2-photon diagrams that assure its gauge invariance are taken into account . in short , such a discussion has shown that the correct behavior of a ( 1 + 2)- potential can only be achieved if the 2-photons diagrams are considered .
nevertheless , there is a way to circumvent the awkward calculation of such diagrams , which consists in requiring the gauge invariance of the pauli equation , @xmath136 \psi(r,\phi)=e\psi(r,\phi ) , \label{pauli}\ ] ] and keeping it in the non - relativistic limit ( governed by the schrdinger equation ) .
the gauge invariance of pauli equation is assured by the presence of the @xmath10term , which obviously does not appearin the context of a nonperturbative low - energy evaluation ( once it is associated with 2-photon exchange processes ) , but may come to be as relevant as the tree - level ones ( see hagen and dobroliubov @xcite ) in ( 1 + 2 ) dimensions . therefore
, both this term and the centrifugal barrier must be kept as correction terms of the effective potential for the schrdinger equation derived from eq .
( [ pauli ] ) .
it is this effective potential that represents the true electron - electron interaction in the non - relativistivistic limit . in order to obtain such a potential explicitly
, one writes the laplacian operator , @xmath137 , $ ] corresponding to the @xmath138term , whose action on the total wavefunction , @xmath139 generates the repulsive centrifugal barrier term , @xmath140 such a term is then added to @xmath141 , already presented in eq .
( [ pauli ] ) , thus yielding the effective potential : @xmath142 .
the vector potential , @xmath143 , stemming from the planar model described by lagrangian ( [ lagrange3 ] ) , has been already evaluated in ref .
@xcite for the timelike case:@xmath144 \overset{\wedge}{r^{\ast}},\ ] ] whence the effective potential takes the form:@xmath145^{2}. \label{veff}\ ] ] this is the gauge invariant effective potential that comprises the two - photon contribution ( @xmath146term ) and the centrifugal barrier term , leading to the correct low - energy electron - electron interaction .
based upon such full expression , one proceeds to verify whether the electron - electron interaction may come to be attractive in some region by means of the graphical analysis of fig .
[ veffplot1 ] .
[ ptb ] veffplot1.eps the graph in fig.[[veffplot1 ] ] shows that the effective and the gauge potential differ from each other , for the adopted parameter values , by an absolutely negligible amount , because in this case , the graphics come out perfectly superimposed ( revealing that they correspond numerically to the same value ) .
thus , the effective potential also exhibits an attractive behavior , showing that the gauge interaction is really endowed with attractiveness . in the framework of this work ,
the total electron - electron interaction encompasses the gauge and the scalar contributions : * * @xmath147 * * this total potential is attractive whenever * * it presents a well - shaped region .
the shape of the total potential near the origin depends on the value of the constants @xmath148 if @xmath149 the total potential will present a similar behavior to that of the scalar potential of fig .
[ 1 ] , while in the case @xmath150 it will be approximately as the gauge potential of figs.[2 , 3 ] .
as both these forms of potential are endowed with well regions , we conclude that the total potential may always be attractive .
this constitutes a relevant result provided it ensures the possibility of obtaining @xmath4 bound states in the framework of this particular model .
in this work , it was considered the mller scattering in the context of the planar lorentz - violating maxwell - chern - simons - proca electrodynamics , obtained from the dimensional reduction of the abelian - higgs maxell - carroll - field - jackiw model @xcite . for the case of a purely timelike background
, the interaction potential was calculated as the fourier transform of the mller amplitude ( born approximation ) , carried out in the non - relativistic regime .
the attained total potential presents two distinct contributions : the attractive scalar potential ( stemming form the yukawa exchange ) and the gauge one ( mediated by the mcs - proca gauge field ) .
the scalar potential , as expected , is always attractive no matter if it is near or far from the origin , and represents a totally shielded interaction .
such an interaction may be identified with phonon exchange processes , which represent physical excitations in several systems of interest . as for the gauge interaction , it is composed of the repulsive mcs - proca potential @xmath151 corrected by background - depending contributions , which impose relevant physical modifications .
indeed , for larger values of v@xmath152 the gauge potential exhibits a pronounced attractive region .
both the scalar and gauge potentials are entirely screened interactions , a consequence of the massive mediators generated by the higgs mechanism .
this feature , in principle , may turn these potentials suitable for describing real planar systems of condensed matter physics .
this is the main difference between the interaction potentials of this work and the potentials derived in ref .
@xcite , which present a logarithmic asymptotic behavior and are unsuitable for representing a physical interaction in a low - energy planar system .
hence , in an attempt of accounting for a real interaction in a lorentz - violating planar system , one should adopt the potentials here derived instead of the ones of ref .
@xcite . in this work ,
one has argued that the total interaction potential exhibits an attractive region , able to bring about the formation of @xmath153 pairs . as a forthcoming feasible application , one can explicitly evaluate the @xmath4 binding energies by means of the numerical solution of the schrdinger equation written for the potentials here derived .
this may be done by ascribing reasonable values for the free parameters of this model , in a similar procedure to the one of refs .
@xcite , @xcite .
it is expected that a fine tune of the parameters would yield binding energies in the scale of @xmath154 , a typical energy for electron - electron pairing in planar systems .
it is also important to emphasize the difference between the total potential obtained in this work and the ones of ref .
@xcite , which consist of an always repulsive mcs - proca contribution added to an attractive scalar potential . in this latter case ,
the attractive scalar potential arises from the intermediation played by the higgs field , and the total potential exhibits attractiveness only if this scalar contribution overcomes the mcs - proca one .
therefore , the possibility of attaining an attractive interaction depends entirely on the presence of the higgs mode .
this is not the case of the present work , in which the gauge potential itself may be attractive ( even for small values of v@xmath73 compared to the electron rest mass ) - see figs .
[ [ gauge_gauge ] ] , [ [ gauge1plot1 ] ] - an effect of the background on the system .
furthermore , * * the scalar intermediation field is the one stemming from the dimensional reduction ( @xmath155 instead of the higgs field , which now accounts for the screened character of the interactions . * * these are particularities that distinguish the present model from the ones of refs .
@xcite , @xcite,@xcite .
the general connection between noncommutativity and lorentz violation turns a sensible matter the comparison of the ghosh potentials @xcite and the results of ref .
@xcite , in which it was evaluated the lorentz - violating version of the mcs potential .
yet , the expressions of these potentials result to be different . indeed , while the lorentz - violating potentials increase logarithmically with distance ,
the noncommutative potentials exhibit a @xmath156 asymptotic behavior .
so , it is clear that these potentials differ from each other substantially , which justifies this investigation in the presence of both noncommutativity and lorentz violation .
it is instructive to clarify the reason to have adopted a purely timelike background .
this was done for a simplicity issue , since in this case the interaction potential may be exactly solved ( without approximations ) .
the physical interpretation of this background , however , is not a straightforward matter , since v@xmath73 may not be easily associated with any parameter of the system .
some felling can be got observing the effect of the background on the behavior of the system .
as example , it was reported in ref .
@xcite that a purely timelike background modifies drastically the asymptotic behavior of the electrical field of the mcs electrodynamics .
in fact , while the pure mcs solution presents an exponentially decaying solution , the lorentz - violating mcs electric field exhibits an increasing logarithmic behavior . in this case , the background may be seen as a constant field that annihilates the screening of the electric sector of the theory , changing its asymptotic behavior .
this property justifies the asymptotic logarithmic behavior of the potentials of refs .
@xcite , @xcite .
a possible continuation of this work consists in evaluating the electron - electron potential in the case of a purely spacelike background , @xmath157 standing for a privileged direction in space able to bring about anisotropy for the solutions .
the presence of anisotropy in ( 1 + 2 ) dimensions is a factor that can be properly described in the framework of a lorentz - violating background . * * in general , this is a more complicated case in which the potentials may be only obtained within the approximation for * * v**@xmath158 as done in ref .
@xcite . in principle
, this is a case where the background may be more clearly interpreted as an active feature of an anisotropic condensed matter system , whose solutions exhibit an explicit dependence on the direction stated by * v*. h. belich , o. m. del cima , m.m .
ferreira jr . and j. a. helayl - neto , int .
a * 16 , * 4939 ( 2001 ) ; h. belich , o. m. del cima , m.m .
ferreira jr . and j. a. helayl - neto , eur .
j. b * 32 * , 145 ( 2003 ) .
h. christiansen , o. m. del cima .
ferreira jr . and j. a. helayl - neto , int .
a * 18 * , 725 ( 2003 ) ; h. belich , o. m. del cima , m.m .
ferreira jr . and j. a. helayl - neto , j. phys .
g * 29 * , 1431 ( 2003 ) . | a planar maxwell - chern - simons - proca model endowed with a lorentz - violating background is taken as framework to investigate the electron - electron interaction .
the dirac sector is introduced exhibiting a yukawa and a minimal coupling with the scalar and the gauge fields , respectively .
the the electron - electron interaction is then exactly evaluated as the fourier transform of the mller scattering amplitude ( carried out in the non - relativistic limit ) for the case of a purely time - like background .
the interaction potential exhibits a totally screened behavior far from the origin as consequence of massive character of the physical mediators . the total interaction ( scalar plus gauge potential )
can always be attractive , revealing that this model may lead to the formation of electron - electron bound states . |
todos ns j tentmos , numa ou outra ocasio , manter em equilbrio uma vara sobre o dedo indicador ( , resolver o problema do pndulo invertido ) .
por outro lado muito mais difcil , sobretudo se fecharmos os olhos , manter em equilbrio um pndulo invertido duplo .
a teoria do controlo permite faz - lo sob a condio de dispormos de um bom modelo matemtico .
um sistema de controlo um sistema dinmico , que evolui no tempo , sobre o qual podemos agir atravs de uma funo de comando ou controlo .
um computador , que permite a um utilizador efectuar uma srie de comandos , um ecossistema sobre o qual podemos agir favorecendo esta ou aquela espcie , os tecidos nervosos que formam uma rede controlada pelo crebro e realizam a transformao de estmulos provenientes do exterior em aces do organismo , um robot que deve efectuar uma tarefa bem precisa , uma viatura sobre a qual agimos por intermdio de um pedal de acelerao , de travagem e embraiagem e que conduzimos com a ajuda de um volante , um satlite ou uma nave espacial , so todos eles exemplos de sistemas de controlo , os quais podem ser modelados e estudados pela teoria dos sistemas de controlo . a teoria do controlo analisa as propriedades de tais sistemas , com o intuito de os `` conduzir '' de um determinado estado inicial a um dado estado final , respeitando eventualmente certas restries .
a origem de tais sistemas pode ser muito diversa : mecnica , elctrica , biolgica , qumica , econmica , etc . o objectivo pode ser o de estabilizar o sistema tornando - o insensvel a certas perturbaes ( problema de _ estabilizao _ ) ou ainda determinar as solues ptimas relativamente a um determinado critrio de optimizao ( problema do _ controlo ptimo _ ) .
para modelar os sistemas de controlo podemos recorrer a equaes diferenciais , integrais , funcionais , de diferenas finitas , s derivadas parciais , determinsticas ou estocsticas , etc .
por esta razo a teoria do controlo vai beber e contribui em numerosos domnios da matemtica ( , , @xcite ) . a estrutura de um sistema de controlo representada pela interconexo de certos elementos mais simples que formam sub - sistemas .
neles transita _ informao_. a dinmica de um sistema de controlo define as transformaes possveis do sistema , que ocorrem no tempo de maneira determinista ou aleatria .
os exemplos j dados mostram que a estrutura e a dinmica de um sistema de controlo podem ter significados muito diferentes .
em particular , o conceito de sistema de controlo pode descrever transformaes discretas , contnuas , hbridas ou , de um modo mais geral , numa _ time scale _ ou _ measure chain _ @xcite .
um sistema de controlo diz - se _ controlvel _ se o podemos `` conduzir '' ( em tempo finito ) de um determinado estado inicial at um estado final prescrito .
em relao ao problema da controlabilidade , kalman demonstrou em 1949 um resultado importante que caracteriza os sistemas lineares controlveis de dimenso finita ( teorema [ condkalman ] ) .
para sistemas no lineares o problema matemtico da controlabilidade muito mais difcil e constitui um domnio de investigao ainda activo nos dias de hoje .
assegurada a propriedade de controlabilidade , podemos desejar passar de um estado inicial a um estado final minimizando ou maximizando um determinado critrio .
temos ento um problema de controlo ptimo .
por exemplo , um condutor que efectue o trajecto lisboa - porto pode querer viajar em tempo mnimo .
nesse caso escolhe o trajecto pela auto - estrada a1 .
uma consequncia de tal escolha ser o pagamento de portagem .
outro problema de controlo ptimo obtido se tivermos como critrio de minimizao os custos da viagem . a soluo de tal problema envolver a escolha de estradas nacionais , gratuitas , mas que levam muito mais tempo a chegar ao destino ( segundo a informao do stio da internet http://www.google.pt/maps o trajecto pela auto - estrada dura 3h e pela estrada nacional dura 6h45 m ) .
um problema de controlo ptimo pode ser formulado do seguinte modo .
consideremos um sistema de controlo , cujo estado num determinado instante representado por um vector .
os controlos so funes ou parmetros , habitualmente sujeitos a restries , que agem sobre o sistema sob a forma de foras exteriores , de potenciais trmicos ou elctricos , de programas de investimento , etc .
e afectam a dinmica .
uma equao dada , ou tipicamente um sistema de equaes diferenciais , relacionando as variveis e modelando a dinmica do sistema .
depois necessrio utilizar a informao presente e as caractersticas do problema para construir os controlos adequados que vo permitir realizar um objectivo preciso .
por exemplo , quando nos deslocamos na nossa viatura agimos de acordo com o cdigo da estrada ( pelo menos aconselhvel ) e concretizamos um plano de viagem para chegar ao nosso destino .
so impostas restries sobre a trajectria ou sobre os controlos , que imprescindvel ter em considerao .
fixamos um critrio permitindo medir a qualidade do processo escolhido .
este apresenta - se normalmente sob a forma de uma funcional que depende do estado do sistema e dos controlos .
para alm das condies anteriores procuramos ainda minimizar ( ou maximizar ) esta quantidade .
um exemplo j dado anteriormente o de deslocarmo - nos em tempo mnimo de um ponto a outro .
notemos que a forma das trajectrias ptimas depende fortemente do critrio de optimizao .
por exemplo , para estacionar o nosso carro fcil verificar que a trajectria seguida difere se queremos realizar a operao em tempo mnimo ( o que arriscado ) ou minimizando a quantidade de combustvel gasta na operao . a teoria do controlo ptimo tem uma grande importncia no domnio aeroespacial , nomeadamente em problemas de conduo , transferncia de rbitas aero - assistidas , desenvolvimento de lanadores de satlites recuperveis ( o aspecto financeiro aqui muito importante ) e problemas da reentrada atmosfrica , como seja o famoso projecto _ mars sample return _ da agncia espacial europeia ( esa ) , que consiste em enviar uma nave espacial ao planeta marte com o objectivo
de trazer amostras marcianas ( figura [ espaco ] ) .
o clculo das variaes nasceu no sculo dezassete com o contributo de bernoulli , fermat , leibniz e newton .
alguns matemticos como h.j . sussmann e j.c .
willems defendem a origem do controlo ptimo coincidente com o nascimento do clculo das variaes , em 1697 , data de publicao da soluo do problema da braquistcrona pelo matemtico johann bernoulli @xcite .
outros vo ainda mais longe , chamando a ateno para o facto do problema da resistncia aerodinmica de newton , colocado e resolvido por isaac newton em 1686 , no seu _ principia mathematica _ ,
ser um verdadeiro problema de controlo ptimo @xcite .
em 1638 galileu estudou o seguinte problema : determinar a curva sobre a qual uma pequena esfera rola sob a aco da gravidade , sem velocidade inicial e sem atrito , de um ponto @xmath0 at um ponto @xmath1 com um tempo de percurso mnimo ( escorrega de tempo mnimo , ver figura [ pontoaeb ] ) .
trata - se do problema da braquistcrona ( do grego _ brakhistos _ , `` o mais breve '' , e _ chronos _ , `` tempo '' ) .
galileu pensou ( erradamente ) que a curva procurada era um arco de crculo .
observou no entanto , correctamente , que o segmento de linha recta no o caminho de tempo mais curto .
em 1696 , jean bernoulli colocou este problema como um desafio aos melhores matemticos da sua poca .
ele prprio encontrou a soluo , assim como o seu irmo jacques bernoulli , newton , leibniz e o marqus de lhopital .
a soluo um arco de ciclide comeando com uma tangente vertical @xcite . as rampas de skate assim como as descidas mais rpidas dos _ aqua - parques _ , tm a forma de ciclide ( figura [ cicloide ] ) .
a teoria do controlo ptimo surge depois da segunda guerra mundial , respondendo a necessidades prticas de engenharia , nomeadamente no domnio da aeronutica e da dinmica de voo .
a formalizao desta teoria colocou vrias questes novas .
por exemplo , a teoria do controlo ptimo motivou a introduo de novos conceitos de solues generalizadas na teoria das equaes diferenciais e originou novos resultados de existncia de trajectrias .
regra geral , considera - se que a teoria do controlo ptimo surgiu em finais dos anos cinquenta na antiga unio sovitica , em 1956 , com a formulao e demonstrao do princpio do mximo de pontryagin por l.s .
pontryagin ( figura [ pontryagin ] ) e pelo seu grupo de colaboradores : v.g .
boltyanskii , r.v .
gamkrelidze e e.f .
mishchenko @xcite .
pontryagin e os seus companheiros introduziram um aspecto de importncia primordial : generalizaram a teoria do clculo das variaes a curvas que tomam valores em conjuntos fechados ( com fronteira ) .
a teoria do controlo ptimo est muito ligada mecnica clssica , em particular aos princpios variacionais ( princpio de fermat , equaes de euler - lagrange , etc . ) na verdade o princpio do mximo de pontryagin uma generalizao das condies necessrias de euler - lagrange e de weierstrass .
alguns pontos fortes da nova teoria foram a descoberta do mtodo de programao dinmica , a introduo da anlise funcional na teoria dos sistemas ptimos e a descoberta de ligaes entre as solues de um problema de controlo ptimo e os resultados da teoria de estabilidade de lyapunov @xcite .
mais tarde apareceram as fundaes da teria do controlo estocstico e da filtragem em sistemas dinmicos , a teoria dos jogos , o controlo de equaes com derivadas parciais e os sistemas de controlo hbrido algumas de entre as muitas reas de investigao actual @xcite .
a teoria do controlo ptimo muito mais simples quando o sistema de controlo sob considerao linear .
o controlo ptimo no linear ser abordado na seco [ sec : co : nl ] . a teoria linear ainda , nos dias de hoje , a mais usada e conhecida nas reas de engenharia e suas aplicaes .
seja @xmath2 ( denotamos por @xmath3
o conjunto das matrizes @xmath4 de entradas reais ) ; @xmath5 ; @xmath6 um intervalo de @xmath7 ; e @xmath8 uma funo mensurvel ( @xmath9 ) tal que @xmath10 @xmath11 .
o teorema de existncia de soluo para equaes diferenciais assegura a existncia de uma nica aplicao @xmath12 absolutamente contnua ( @xmath13 ) tal que @xmath14 esta aplicao depende do controlo @xmath15 .
ao mudarmos a funo @xmath15 obtemos uma outra trajectria @xmath16 em @xmath17 ( figura [ trajectoria ] ) .
= .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 227,161)(215,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(296,72)(303,66 ) ( 296,66)(303,73 ) ( 299,69)(300.59,69.31)(302.16,69.64)(303.71,69.99)(305.24,70.36 ) ( 306.75,70.75)(308.24,71.16)(309.71,71.59)(311.16,72.04)(312.59,72.51 ) ( 314,73)(315.165,72.925)(316.36,73)(317.585,73.225)(318.84,73.6 ) ( 320.125,74.125)(321.44,74.8)(322.785,75.625)(324.16,76.6)(325.565,77.725 ) ( 327,79)(328.87,80.785)(330.68,82.64)(332.43,84.565)(334.12,86.56 ) ( 335.75,88.625)(337.32,90.76)(338.83,92.965)(340.28,95.24)(341.67,97.585 ) ( 343,100)(343.55,103.205)(344.2,106.32)(344.95,109.345)(345.8,112.28 ) ( 346.75,115.125)(347.8,117.88)(348.95,120.545)(350.2,123.12)(351.55,125.605 ) ( 353,128)(354.91,130.575)(356.84,133)(358.79,135.275)(360.76,137.4 ) ( 362.75,139.375)(364.76,141.2)(366.79,142.875)(368.84,144.4)(370.91,145.775 ) ( 373,147)(375.11,148.075)(377.24,149)(379.39,149.775)(381.56,150.4 ) ( 383.75,150.875)(385.96,151.2)(388.19,151.375)(390.44,151.4)(392.71,151.275 ) ( 395,151 ) ( 299,70)(305.56,68.575)(311.84,67.4)(317.84,66.475)(323.56,65.8 ) ( 329,65.375)(334.16,65.2)(339.04,65.275)(343.64,65.6)(347.96,66.175 ) ( 352,67)(353.69,69.74)(355.56,72.36)(357.61,74.86)(359.84,77.24 ) ( 362.25,79.5)(364.84,81.64)(367.61,83.66)(370.56,85.56)(373.69,87.34 ) ( 377,89)(382.245,90.675)(387.28,92.2)(392.105,93.575)(396.72,94.8 ) ( 401.125,95.875)(405.32,96.8)(409.305,97.575)(413.08,98.2)(416.645,98.675 ) ( 420,99)(423.145,99.175)(426.08,99.2)(428.805,99.075)(431.32,98.8 ) ( 433.625,98.375)(435.72,97.8)(437.605,97.075)(439.28,96.2)(440.745,95.175 ) ( 442,94 ) ( 298,70)(298.35,67.785)(298.8,65.64)(299.35,63.565)(300,61.56 ) ( 300.75,59.625)(301.6,57.76)(302.55,55.965)(303.6,54.24)(304.75,52.585 ) ( 306,51)(308.07,49.755)(310.08,48.52)(312.03,47.295)(313.92,46.08 ) ( 315.75,44.875)(317.52,43.68)(319.23,42.495)(320.88,41.32)(322.47,40.155 ) ( 324,39)(325.29,38.395)(326.56,37.68)(327.81,36.855)(329.04,35.92 ) ( 330.25,34.875)(331.44,33.72)(332.61,32.455)(333.76,31.08)(334.89,29.595 ) ( 336,28)(337.09,26.295)(338.16,24.48)(339.21,22.555)(340.24,20.52 ) ( 341.25,18.375)(342.24,16.12)(343.21,13.755)(344.16,11.28)(345.09,8.695 ) ( 346,6 ) ( 298,70)(296.01,72.105)(294.04,74.12)(292.09,76.045)(290.16,77.88 ) ( 288.25,79.625)(286.36,81.28)(284.49,82.845)(282.64,84.32)(280.81,85.705 ) ( 279,87)(277.3,87.98)(275.6,88.92)(273.9,89.82)(272.2,90.68 ) ( 270.5,91.5)(268.8,92.28)(267.1,93.02)(265.4,93.72)(263.7,94.38 ) ( 262,95)(260.885,95.715)(259.64,96.36)(258.265,96.935)(256.76,97.44 ) ( 255.125,97.875)(253.36,98.24)(251.465,98.535)(249.44,98.76)(247.285,98.915 ) ( 245,99)(242.585,99.015)(240.04,98.96)(237.365,98.835)(234.56,98.64 ) ( 231.625,98.375)(228.56,98.04)(225.365,97.635)(222.04,97.16)(218.585,96.615 ) ( 215,96 ) ( 299,70)(294.86,69.025)(290.84,68)(286.94,66.925)(283.16,65.8 ) ( 279.5,64.625)(275.96,63.4)(272.54,62.125)(269.24,60.8)(266.06,59.425 ) ( 263,58)(259.52,56.525)(256.28,55)(253.28,53.425)(250.52,51.8 ) ( 248,50.125)(245.72,48.4)(243.68,46.625)(241.88,44.8)(240.32,42.925 ) ( 239,41)(238.415,38.665)(237.96,36.36)(237.635,34.085)(237.44,31.84 ) ( 237.375,29.625)(237.44,27.44)(237.635,25.285)(237.96,23.16)(238.415,21.065 ) ( 239,19)(239.715,16.965)(240.56,14.96)(241.535,12.985)(242.64,11.04 ) ( 243.875,9.125)(245.24,7.24)(246.735,5.385)(248.36,3.56)(250.115,1.765 ) ( 252,0 ) ( 290,78)@xmath18 neste contexto , surgem naturalmente duas questes : \(i ) dado um ponto @xmath19 , existir um controlo @xmath15 tal que a trajectria associada a esse controlo liga @xmath18 a @xmath20 em tempo finito @xmath21 ?
( figura [ probcontrolabilidade ] ) este o _ problema da controlabilidade_. = .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 321,90)(176,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(201,11)(206,6 ) ( 200,6)(206,11 ) ( 398,11)(404,6 ) ( 397,6)(404,12 ) ( 203,9)(204.965,8.76)(206.96,8.64)(208.985,8.64)(211.04,8.76 ) ( 213.125,9)(215.24,9.36)(217.385,9.84)(219.56,10.44)(221.765,11.16 ) ( 224,12)(226.355,13.59)(228.72,15.16)(231.095,16.71)(233.48,18.24 ) ( 235.875,19.75)(238.28,21.24)(240.695,22.71)(243.12,24.16)(245.555,25.59 ) ( 248,27)(250.545,28.66)(253.08,30.24)(255.605,31.74)(258.12,33.16 ) ( 260.625,34.5)(263.12,35.76)(265.605,36.94)(268.08,38.04)(270.545,39.06 ) ( 273,40)(275.31,40.815)(277.64,41.56)(279.99,42.235)(282.36,42.84 ) ( 284.75,43.375)(287.16,43.84)(289.59,44.235)(292.04,44.56)(294.51,44.815 ) ( 297,45)(299.285,45.115)(301.64,45.16)(304.065,45.135)(306.56,45.04 ) ( 309.125,44.875)(311.76,44.64)(314.465,44.335)(317.24,43.96)(320.085,43.515 ) ( 323,43)(326.84,42.145)(330.56,41.28)(334.16,40.405)(337.64,39.52 ) ( 341,38.625)(344.24,37.72)(347.36,36.805)(350.36,35.88)(353.24,34.945 ) ( 356,34)(357.965,33.18)(359.96,32.32)(361.985,31.42)(364.04,30.48 ) ( 366.125,29.5)(368.24,28.48)(370.385,27.42)(372.56,26.32)(374.765,25.18 ) ( 377,24)(379.265,22.78)(381.56,21.52)(383.885,20.22)(386.24,18.88 ) ( 388.625,17.5)(391.04,16.08)(393.485,14.62)(395.96,13.12)(398.465,11.58 ) ( 401,10 ) ( 278,54)(280.2,55.005)(282.4,55.92)(284.6,56.745)(286.8,57.48 ) ( 289,58.125)(291.2,58.68)(293.4,59.145)(295.6,59.52)(297.8,59.805 ) ( 300,60)(302.2,60.105)(304.4,60.12)(306.6,60.045)(308.8,59.88 ) ( 311,59.625)(313.2,59.28)(315.4,58.845)(317.6,58.32)(319.8,57.705 ) ( 322,57 ) ( 315.371,61.478)(322,57)(314.043,56.169 ) ( 290,68)@xmath22 ( 409,2)@xmath23 ( 176,-1)@xmath18 \(ii ) assegurada a controlabilidade ( questo anterior ) , existir um controlo que _ minimiza o tempo de percurso de @xmath18 at @xmath20 _ ?
( figura [ probcontroloptimo ] ) temos ento um problema de controlo ptimo ( de tempo mnimo ) .
= .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 321,97)(176,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(201,49)(206,44 ) ( 200,44)(206,49 ) ( 398,49)(404,44 ) ( 397,44)(404,50 ) ( 203,47)(204.965,46.76)(206.96,46.64)(208.985,46.64)(211.04,46.76 ) ( 213.125,47)(215.24,47.36)(217.385,47.84)(219.56,48.44)(221.765,49.16 ) ( 224,50)(226.355,51.59)(228.72,53.16)(231.095,54.71)(233.48,56.24 ) ( 235.875,57.75)(238.28,59.24)(240.695,60.71)(243.12,62.16)(245.555,63.59 ) ( 248,65)(250.545,66.66)(253.08,68.24)(255.605,69.74)(258.12,71.16 ) ( 260.625,72.5)(263.12,73.76)(265.605,74.94)(268.08,76.04)(270.545,77.06 ) ( 273,78)(275.31,78.815)(277.64,79.56)(279.99,80.235)(282.36,80.84 ) ( 284.75,81.375)(287.16,81.84)(289.59,82.235)(292.04,82.56)(294.51,82.815 ) ( 297,83)(299.285,83.115)(301.64,83.16)(304.065,83.135)(306.56,83.04 ) ( 309.125,82.875)(311.76,82.64)(314.465,82.335)(317.24,81.96)(320.085,81.515 ) ( 323,81)(326.84,80.145)(330.56,79.28)(334.16,78.405)(337.64,77.52 ) ( 341,76.625)(344.24,75.72)(347.36,74.805)(350.36,73.88)(353.24,72.945 ) ( 356,72)(357.965,71.18)(359.96,70.32)(361.985,69.42)(364.04,68.48 ) ( 366.125,67.5)(368.24,66.48)(370.385,65.42)(372.56,64.32)(374.765,63.18 ) ( 377,62)(379.265,60.78)(381.56,59.52)(383.885,58.22)(386.24,56.88 ) ( 388.625,55.5)(391.04,54.08)(393.485,52.62)(395.96,51.12)(398.465,49.58 ) ( 401,48 ) ( 409,40)@xmath23 ( 176,37)@xmath18 ( 203,47)(204.4,46.49)(206,45.96)(207.8,45.41)(209.8,44.84 ) ( 212,44.25)(214.4,43.64)(217,43.01)(219.8,42.36)(222.8,41.69 ) ( 226,41)(231.11,39.705)(236.04,38.52)(240.79,37.445)(245.36,36.48 ) ( 249.75,35.625)(253.96,34.88)(257.99,34.245)(261.84,33.72)(265.51,33.305 ) ( 269,33)(271.77,33.255)(274.48,33.52)(277.13,33.795)(279.72,34.08 ) ( 282.25,34.375)(284.72,34.68)(287.13,34.995)(289.48,35.32)(291.77,35.655 ) ( 294,36)(295.675,36.085)(297.4,36.24)(299.175,36.465)(301,36.76 ) ( 302.875,37.125)(304.8,37.56)(306.775,38.065)(308.8,38.64)(310.875,39.285 ) ( 313,40)(315.04,41.595)(317.16,43.08)(319.36,44.455)(321.64,45.72 ) ( 324,46.875)(326.44,47.92)(328.96,48.855)(331.56,49.68)(334.24,50.395 ) ( 337,51)(340.875,51.225)(344.6,51.4)(348.175,51.525)(351.6,51.6 ) ( 354.875,51.625)(358,51.6)(360.975,51.525)(363.8,51.4)(366.475,51.225 ) ( 369,51)(370.79,50.23)(372.56,49.52)(374.31,48.87)(376.04,48.28 ) ( 377.75,47.75)(379.44,47.28)(381.11,46.87)(382.76,46.52)(384.39,46.23 ) ( 386,46)(387.59,45.83)(389.16,45.72)(390.71,45.67)(392.24,45.68 ) ( 393.75,45.75)(395.24,45.88)(396.71,46.07)(398.16,46.32)(399.59,46.63 ) ( 401,47 ) ( 203,47)(203.825,45.1)(204.8,43.2)(205.925,41.3)(207.2,39.4 ) ( 208.625,37.5)(210.2,35.6)(211.925,33.7)(213.8,31.8)(215.825,29.9 ) ( 218,28)(220.595,25.47)(223.28,23.08)(226.055,20.83)(228.92,18.72 ) ( 231.875,16.75)(234.92,14.92)(238.055,13.23)(241.28,11.68)(244.595,10.27 ) ( 248,9)(251.585,7.915)(255.24,6.96)(258.965,6.135)(262.76,5.44 ) ( 266.625,4.875)(270.56,4.44)(274.565,4.135)(278.64,3.96)(282.785,3.915 ) ( 287,4)(291.96,4.665)(296.84,5.36)(301.64,6.085)(306.36,6.84 ) ( 311,7.625)(315.56,8.44)(320.04,9.285)(324.44,10.16)(328.76,11.065 ) ( 333,12)(337.16,12.515)(341.24,13.16)(345.24,13.935)(349.16,14.84 ) ( 353,15.875)(356.76,17.04)(360.44,18.335)(364.04,19.76)(367.56,21.315 ) ( 371,23)(374.36,24.815)(377.64,26.76)(380.84,28.835)(383.96,31.04 ) ( 387,33.375)(389.96,35.84)(392.84,38.435)(395.64,41.16)(398.36,44.015 ) ( 401,47 ) ( 298,87)(306,83)(298,80 ) ( 289,9)(296,5)(289,0 ) ( 279,39)(287,35)(279,32 ) os teoremas que se seguem respondem a estas questes .
as respectivas demonstraes so bem conhecidas e podem facilmente ser encontradas na literatura ( , , @xcite ) .
considerando o sistema linear de controlo comeamos por introduzir um conjunto de grande importncia : _ o conjunto acessvel_. o conjunto dos pontos acessveis a partir de @xmath18 em tempo @xmath24 denotado e definido por @xmath25,i),\\ & \exists x : \r \to \r^n \ , \in ac \text { com } x(0 ) = x_0 , \\ & \forall t \in [ 0 , t ] \ , \ , \dot{x}(t ) = a x(t ) + b u(t ) , \ , \ , x(t ) = x_1 \ } \ , .
\end{split}\ ] ] por palavras , @xmath26 o conjunto das extremidades das solues de em tempo @xmath21 , quando fazemos variar o controlo @xmath15 ( figura [ imgacceset ] ) .
= .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 277,170)(210,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(296,77)(303,71 ) ( 296,71)(303,78 ) ( 299,74)(300.59,74.31)(302.16,74.64)(303.71,74.99)(305.24,75.36 ) ( 306.75,75.75)(308.24,76.16)(309.71,76.59)(311.16,77.04)(312.59,77.51 ) ( 314,78)(315.165,77.925)(316.36,78)(317.585,78.225)(318.84,78.6 ) ( 320.125,79.125)(321.44,79.8)(322.785,80.625)(324.16,81.6)(325.565,82.725 ) ( 327,84)(328.87,85.785)(330.68,87.64)(332.43,89.565)(334.12,91.56 ) ( 335.75,93.625)(337.32,95.76)(338.83,97.965)(340.28,100.24)(341.67,102.585 ) ( 343,105)(343.55,108.205)(344.2,111.32)(344.95,114.345)(345.8,117.28 ) ( 346.75,120.125)(347.8,122.88)(348.95,125.545)(350.2,128.12)(351.55,130.605 ) ( 353,133)(354.91,135.575)(356.84,138)(358.79,140.275)(360.76,142.4 ) ( 362.75,144.375)(364.76,146.2)(366.79,147.875)(368.84,149.4)(370.91,150.775 ) ( 373,152)(375.11,153.075)(377.24,154)(379.39,154.775)(381.56,155.4 ) ( 383.75,155.875)(385.96,156.2)(388.19,156.375)(390.44,156.4)(392.71,156.275 ) ( 395,156 ) ( 299,75)(305.56,73.575)(311.84,72.4)(317.84,71.475)(323.56,70.8 ) ( 329,70.375)(334.16,70.2)(339.04,70.275)(343.64,70.6)(347.96,71.175 ) ( 352,72)(353.69,74.74)(355.56,77.36)(357.61,79.86)(359.84,82.24 ) ( 362.25,84.5)(364.84,86.64)(367.61,88.66)(370.56,90.56)(373.69,92.34 ) ( 377,94)(382.245,95.675)(387.28,97.2)(392.105,98.575)(396.72,99.8 ) ( 401.125,100.875)(405.32,101.8)(409.305,102.575)(413.08,103.2)(416.645,103.675 ) ( 420,104)(423.145,104.175)(426.08,104.2)(428.805,104.075)(431.32,103.8 ) ( 433.625,103.375)(435.72,102.8)(437.605,102.075)(439.28,101.2)(440.745,100.175 ) ( 442,99 ) ( 298,75)(298.35,72.785)(298.8,70.64)(299.35,68.565)(300,66.56 ) ( 300.75,64.625)(301.6,62.76)(302.55,60.965)(303.6,59.24)(304.75,57.585 ) ( 306,56)(308.07,54.755)(310.08,53.52)(312.03,52.295)(313.92,51.08 ) ( 315.75,49.875)(317.52,48.68)(319.23,47.495)(320.88,46.32)(322.47,45.155 ) ( 324,44)(325.29,43.395)(326.56,42.68)(327.81,41.855)(329.04,40.92 ) ( 330.25,39.875)(331.44,38.72)(332.61,37.455)(333.76,36.08)(334.89,34.595 ) ( 336,33)(337.09,31.295)(338.16,29.48)(339.21,27.555)(340.24,25.52 ) ( 341.25,23.375)(342.24,21.12)(343.21,18.755)(344.16,16.28)(345.09,13.695 ) ( 346,11 ) ( 298,75)(296.01,77.105)(294.04,79.12)(292.09,81.045)(290.16,82.88 ) ( 288.25,84.625)(286.36,86.28)(284.49,87.845)(282.64,89.32)(280.81,90.705 ) ( 279,92)(277.3,92.98)(275.6,93.92)(273.9,94.82)(272.2,95.68 ) ( 270.5,96.5)(268.8,97.28)(267.1,98.02)(265.4,98.72)(263.7,99.38 ) ( 262,100)(260.885,100.715)(259.64,101.36)(258.265,101.935)(256.76,102.44 ) ( 255.125,102.875)(253.36,103.24)(251.465,103.535)(249.44,103.76)(247.285,103.915 ) ( 245,104)(242.585,104.015)(240.04,103.96)(237.365,103.835)(234.56,103.64 ) ( 231.625,103.375)(228.56,103.04)(225.365,102.635)(222.04,102.16)(218.585,101.615 ) ( 215,101 ) ( 299,75)(294.86,74.025)(290.84,73)(286.94,71.925)(283.16,70.8 ) ( 279.5,69.625)(275.96,68.4)(272.54,67.125)(269.24,65.8)(266.06,64.425 ) ( 263,63)(259.52,61.525)(256.28,60)(253.28,58.425)(250.52,56.8 ) ( 248,55.125)(245.72,53.4)(243.68,51.625)(241.88,49.8)(240.32,47.925 ) ( 239,46)(238.415,43.665)(237.96,41.36)(237.635,39.085)(237.44,36.84 ) ( 237.375,34.625)(237.44,32.44)(237.635,30.285)(237.96,28.16)(238.415,26.065 ) ( 239,24)(239.715,21.965)(240.56,19.96)(241.535,17.985)(242.64,16.04 ) ( 243.875,14.125)(245.24,12.24)(246.735,10.385)(248.36,8.56)(250.115,6.765 ) ( 252,5 ) ( 290,83)@xmath18 ( 252,5)(257.65,3.78)(263.2,2.72)(268.65,1.82)(274,1.08 ) ( 279.25,.5)(284.4,.08)(289.45,-.18)(294.4,-.28)(299.25,-.22 ) ( 304,0)(307.48,.47)(311.12,1.08)(314.92,1.83)(318.88,2.72 ) ( 323,3.75)(327.28,4.92)(331.72,6.23)(336.32,7.68)(341.08,9.27 ) ( 346,11)(353.51,13.68)(360.64,16.32)(367.39,18.92)(373.76,21.48 ) ( 379.75,24)(385.36,26.48)(390.59,28.92)(395.44,31.32)(399.91,33.68 ) ( 404,36)(406.09,37.2)(408.16,38.6)(410.21,40.2)(412.24,42 ) ( 414.25,44)(416.24,46.2)(418.21,48.6)(420.16,51.2)(422.09,54 ) ( 424,57)(427.375,61.28)(430.4,65.52)(433.075,69.72)(435.4,73.88 ) ( 437.375,78)(439,82.08)(440.275,86.12)(441.2,90.12)(441.775,94.08 ) ( 442,98)(440.885,102.42)(439.64,106.68)(438.265,110.78)(436.76,114.72 ) ( 435.125,118.5)(433.36,122.12)(431.465,125.58)(429.44,128.88)(427.285,132.02 ) ( 425,135)(422.045,137.865)(419.08,140.56)(416.105,143.085)(413.12,145.44 ) ( 410.125,147.625)(407.12,149.64)(404.105,151.485)(401.08,153.16)(398.045,154.665 ) ( 395,156)(393.61,156.85)(391.84,157.6)(389.69,158.25)(387.16,158.8 ) ( 384.25,159.25)(380.96,159.6)(377.29,159.85)(373.24,160)(368.81,160.05 ) ( 364,160)(356.515,160.165)(349.16,160.16)(341.935,159.985)(334.84,159.64 ) ( 327.875,159.125)(321.04,158.44)(314.335,157.585)(307.76,156.56)(301.315,155.365 ) ( 295,154)(288.005,152.015)(281.32,149.96)(274.945,147.835)(268.88,145.64 ) ( 263.125,143.375)(257.68,141.04)(252.545,138.635)(247.72,136.16)(243.205,133.615 ) ( 239,131)(235.51,128.315)(232.24,125.56)(229.19,122.735)(226.36,119.84 ) ( 223.75,116.875)(221.36,113.84)(219.19,110.735)(217.24,107.56)(215.51,104.315 ) ( 214,101)(212.935,97.255)(212.04,93.52)(211.315,89.795)(210.76,86.08 ) ( 210.375,82.375)(210.16,78.68)(210.115,74.995)(210.24,71.32)(210.535,67.655 ) ( 211,64)(211.86,59.77)(212.84,55.68)(213.94,51.73)(215.16,47.92 ) ( 216.5,44.25)(217.96,40.72)(219.54,37.33)(221.24,34.08)(223.06,30.97 ) ( 225,28)(227.06,25.17)(229.24,22.48)(231.54,19.93)(233.96,17.52 ) ( 236.5,15.25)(239.16,13.12)(241.94,11.13)(244.84,9.28)(247.86,7.57 ) ( 251,6 ) ( 399,19)@xmath27 [ thm:1 ] sejam @xmath24 , @xmath6 compacto e @xmath28 .
ento para todo o @xmath29 $ ] , @xmath30 compacto , convexo e varia continuamente com @xmath31 em @xmath32 $ ] .
a soluo de @xmath33 @xmath34 constatamos que se @xmath35 , , se partirmos da origem , ento a expresso de @xmath22 simplificada : @xmath36 linear em @xmath15 .
esta observao leva - nos seguinte proposio .
suponhamos que @xmath35 e @xmath37 .
ento , * @xmath38 um sub - espao vectorial de @xmath17
. alm disso , * @xmath39
. o conjunto @xmath40 o conjunto dos pontos acessveis ( num tempo qualquer ) a partir da origem .
o conjunto @xmath41 um sub - espao vectorial de @xmath17 .
o sistema de controlo @xmath42 diz - se controlvel se para todo o @xmath43 existe um controlo @xmath15 tal que a trajectria associada une @xmath18 a @xmath20 em tempo finito @xmath21 ( figura [ controlabilidade ] ) .
de modo mais formal temos : o sistema de controlo @xmath42 diz - se controlvel se @xmath44 \to i \ , \in l^1\ ] ] @xmath45 \to \r^n \ , \ , | \ , \ , \begin{cases } \dot{x } = ax + bu \ , , \\
x(0 ) = x_0 \ , , \\
x(t ) = x_1 \ , .
\end{cases}\ ] ] = .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 292,40)(165,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(197,12)(202,7 ) ( 196,7)(202,12 ) ( 397,12)(402,7 ) ( 395,7)(403,12 ) ( 199,10)(200.875,9.785)(202.8,9.64)(204.775,9.565)(206.8,9.56 ) ( 208.875,9.625)(211,9.76)(213.175,9.965)(215.4,10.24)(217.675,10.585 ) ( 220,11)(223.005,11.935)(225.92,12.84)(228.745,13.715)(231.48,14.56 ) ( 234.125,15.375)(236.68,16.16)(239.145,16.915)(241.52,17.64)(243.805,18.335 ) ( 246,19)(247.7,19.635)(249.4,20.24)(251.1,20.815)(252.8,21.36 ) ( 254.5,21.875)(256.2,22.36)(257.9,22.815)(259.6,23.24)(261.3,23.635 ) ( 263,24)(263.935,24.47)(265.04,24.88)(266.315,25.23)(267.76,25.52 ) ( 269.375,25.75)(271.16,25.92)(273.115,26.03)(275.24,26.08)(277.535,26.07 ) ( 280,26)(283.49,25.78)(286.96,25.52)(290.41,25.22)(293.84,24.88 ) ( 297.25,24.5)(300.64,24.08)(304.01,23.62)(307.36,23.12)(310.69,22.58 ) ( 314,22)(317.38,21.47)(320.72,20.88)(324.02,20.23)(327.28,19.52 ) ( 330.5,18.75)(333.68,17.92)(336.82,17.03)(339.92,16.08)(342.98,15.07 ) ( 346,14)(348.935,11.52)(351.84,9.28)(354.715,7.28)(357.56,5.52 ) ( 360.375,4)(363.16,2.72)(365.915,1.68)(368.64,.88)(371.335,.32 ) ( 374,0)(376.635,-.08)(379.24,.08)(381.815,.48)(384.36,1.12 ) ( 386.875,2)(389.36,3.12)(391.815,4.48)(394.24,6.08)(396.635,7.92 ) ( 399,10 ) ( 272,30)(278,26)(272,23 ) ( 409,4)@xmath20 ( 165,1)@xmath18 o teorema seguinte d - nos uma condio necessria e suficiente de controlabilidade chamada _ condio de kalman_. [ condkalman ] o sistema @xmath42 controlvel se e somente se a matriz @xmath46 tiver caracterstica completa ( , @xmath47 ) .
comeamos por formalizar , com a ajuda do conjunto acessvel @xmath30 , a noo de tempo mnimo .
sejam @xmath43 .
suponhamos que @xmath20 acessvel a partir de @xmath18 , , suponhamos que existe pelo menos uma trajectria unindo @xmath18 a @xmath20 .
de entre todas as trajectrias que unem @xmath18 a @xmath20 gostaramos de caracterizar aquela que o faz em tempo mnimo @xmath21 ( figura [ tempominimo ] ) .
= .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 321,97)(176,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(201,49)(206,44 ) ( 200,44)(206,49 ) ( 398,49)(404,44 ) ( 397,44)(404,50 ) ( 203,47)(204.965,46.76)(206.96,46.64)(208.985,46.64)(211.04,46.76 ) ( 213.125,47)(215.24,47.36)(217.385,47.84)(219.56,48.44)(221.765,49.16 ) ( 224,50)(226.355,51.59)(228.72,53.16)(231.095,54.71)(233.48,56.24 ) ( 235.875,57.75)(238.28,59.24)(240.695,60.71)(243.12,62.16)(245.555,63.59 ) ( 248,65)(250.545,66.66)(253.08,68.24)(255.605,69.74)(258.12,71.16 ) ( 260.625,72.5)(263.12,73.76)(265.605,74.94)(268.08,76.04)(270.545,77.06 ) ( 273,78)(275.31,78.815)(277.64,79.56)(279.99,80.235)(282.36,80.84 ) ( 284.75,81.375)(287.16,81.84)(289.59,82.235)(292.04,82.56)(294.51,82.815 ) ( 297,83)(299.285,83.115)(301.64,83.16)(304.065,83.135)(306.56,83.04 ) ( 309.125,82.875)(311.76,82.64)(314.465,82.335)(317.24,81.96)(320.085,81.515 ) ( 323,81)(326.84,80.145)(330.56,79.28)(334.16,78.405)(337.64,77.52 ) ( 341,76.625)(344.24,75.72)(347.36,74.805)(350.36,73.88)(353.24,72.945 ) ( 356,72)(357.965,71.18)(359.96,70.32)(361.985,69.42)(364.04,68.48 ) ( 366.125,67.5)(368.24,66.48)(370.385,65.42)(372.56,64.32)(374.765,63.18 ) ( 377,62)(379.265,60.78)(381.56,59.52)(383.885,58.22)(386.24,56.88 ) ( 388.625,55.5)(391.04,54.08)(393.485,52.62)(395.96,51.12)(398.465,49.58 ) ( 401,48 ) ( 409,40)@xmath23 ( 176,37)@xmath18 ( 203,47)(204.4,46.49)(206,45.96)(207.8,45.41)(209.8,44.84 ) ( 212,44.25)(214.4,43.64)(217,43.01)(219.8,42.36)(222.8,41.69 ) ( 226,41)(231.11,39.705)(236.04,38.52)(240.79,37.445)(245.36,36.48 ) ( 249.75,35.625)(253.96,34.88)(257.99,34.245)(261.84,33.72)(265.51,33.305 ) ( 269,33)(271.77,33.255)(274.48,33.52)(277.13,33.795)(279.72,34.08 ) ( 282.25,34.375)(284.72,34.68)(287.13,34.995)(289.48,35.32)(291.77,35.655 ) ( 294,36)(295.675,36.085)(297.4,36.24)(299.175,36.465)(301,36.76 ) ( 302.875,37.125)(304.8,37.56)(306.775,38.065)(308.8,38.64)(310.875,39.285 ) ( 313,40)(315.04,41.595)(317.16,43.08)(319.36,44.455)(321.64,45.72 ) ( 324,46.875)(326.44,47.92)(328.96,48.855)(331.56,49.68)(334.24,50.395 ) ( 337,51)(340.875,51.225)(344.6,51.4)(348.175,51.525)(351.6,51.6 ) ( 354.875,51.625)(358,51.6)(360.975,51.525)(363.8,51.4)(366.475,51.225 ) ( 369,51)(370.79,50.23)(372.56,49.52)(374.31,48.87)(376.04,48.28 ) ( 377.75,47.75)(379.44,47.28)(381.11,46.87)(382.76,46.52)(384.39,46.23 ) ( 386,46)(387.59,45.83)(389.16,45.72)(390.71,45.67)(392.24,45.68 ) ( 393.75,45.75)(395.24,45.88)(396.71,46.07)(398.16,46.32)(399.59,46.63 ) ( 401,47 ) ( 203,47)(203.825,45.1)(204.8,43.2)(205.925,41.3)(207.2,39.4 ) ( 208.625,37.5)(210.2,35.6)(211.925,33.7)(213.8,31.8)(215.825,29.9 ) ( 218,28)(220.595,25.47)(223.28,23.08)(226.055,20.83)(228.92,18.72 ) ( 231.875,16.75)(234.92,14.92)(238.055,13.23)(241.28,11.68)(244.595,10.27 ) ( 248,9)(251.585,7.915)(255.24,6.96)(258.965,6.135)(262.76,5.44 ) ( 266.625,4.875)(270.56,4.44)(274.565,4.135)(278.64,3.96)(282.785,3.915 ) ( 287,4)(291.96,4.665)(296.84,5.36)(301.64,6.085)(306.36,6.84 ) ( 311,7.625)(315.56,8.44)(320.04,9.285)(324.44,10.16)(328.76,11.065 ) ( 333,12)(337.16,12.515)(341.24,13.16)(345.24,13.935)(349.16,14.84 ) ( 353,15.875)(356.76,17.04)(360.44,18.335)(364.04,19.76)(367.56,21.315 ) ( 371,23)(374.36,24.815)(377.64,26.76)(380.84,28.835)(383.96,31.04 ) ( 387,33.375)(389.96,35.84)(392.84,38.435)(395.64,41.16)(398.36,44.015 ) ( 401,47 ) ( 298,87)(306,83)(298,80 ) ( 289,9)(296,5)(289,0 ) ( 279,39)(287,35)(279,32 ) se @xmath21 for o tempo mnimo , ento para todo o @xmath48 , @xmath49 ( com efeito , se assim no fosse @xmath20 seria acessvel a partir de @xmath18 num tempo inferior a @xmath21 e @xmath21 no seria o tempo mnimo ) .
consequentemente , @xmath50 o valor de @xmath21 est bem definido pois , a partir do teorema [ thm:1 ] , @xmath30 varia continuamente com @xmath31 , logo @xmath51 fechado em @xmath7 .
em particular o nfimo em mnimo .
o tempo @xmath52 o primeiro instante para o qual @xmath30 contm @xmath20 ( figura [ tempominimo2 ] ) .
= .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 290,155)(167,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(185,84)(191,77 ) ( 185,77)(191,84 ) ( 181,62)@xmath18 ( 167,81)(167.985,83.61)(169.04,86.04)(170.165,88.29)(171.36,90.36 ) ( 172.625,92.25)(173.96,93.96)(175.365,95.49)(176.84,96.84)(178.385,98.01 ) ( 180,99)(182,99.81)(184,100.44)(186,100.89)(188,101.16 ) ( 190,101.25)(192,101.16)(194,100.89)(196,100.44)(198,99.81 ) ( 200,99)(203.17,97.515)(206.08,95.96)(208.73,94.335)(211.12,92.64 ) ( 213.25,90.875)(215.12,89.04)(216.73,87.135)(218.08,85.16)(219.17,83.115 ) ( 220,81)(220.525,77.69)(220.8,74.56)(220.825,71.61)(220.6,68.84 ) ( 220.125,66.25)(219.4,63.84)(218.425,61.61)(217.2,59.56)(215.725,57.69 ) ( 214,56)(210.225,53.545)(206.6,51.48)(203.125,49.805)(199.8,48.52 ) ( 196.625,47.625)(193.6,47.12)(190.725,47.005)(188,47.28)(185.425,47.945 ) ( 183,49)(180.725,50.445)(178.6,52.28)(176.625,54.505)(174.8,57.12 ) ( 173.125,60.125)(171.6,63.52)(170.225,67.305)(169,71.48)(167.925,76.045 ) ( 167,81 ) ( 204,88)(204.97,90.42)(206.08,92.68)(207.33,94.78)(208.72,96.72 ) ( 210.25,98.5)(211.92,100.12)(213.73,101.58)(215.68,102.88)(217.77,104.02 ) ( 220,105)(223.54,106.36)(226.96,107.44)(230.26,108.24)(233.44,108.76 ) ( 236.5,109)(239.44,108.96)(242.26,108.64)(244.96,108.04)(247.54,107.16 ) ( 250,106)(253.195,103.435)(256.08,100.84)(258.655,98.215)(260.92,95.56 ) ( 262.875,92.875)(264.52,90.16)(265.855,87.415)(266.88,84.64)(267.595,81.835 ) ( 268,79)(268.005,74.29)(267.72,69.96)(267.145,66.01)(266.28,62.44 ) ( 265.125,59.25)(263.68,56.44)(261.945,54.01)(259.92,51.96)(257.605,50.29 ) ( 255,49)(249.315,48.765)(243.96,48.76)(238.935,48.985)(234.24,49.44 ) ( 229.875,50.125)(225.84,51.04)(222.135,52.185)(218.76,53.56)(215.715,55.165 ) ( 213,57)(210.615,59.065)(208.56,61.36)(206.835,63.885)(205.44,66.64 ) ( 204.375,69.625)(203.64,72.84)(203.235,76.285)(203.16,79.96)(203.415,83.865 ) ( 204,88 ) ( 234,91)(235.545,94.89)(237.28,98.56)(239.205,102.01)(241.32,105.24 ) ( 243.625,108.25)(246.12,111.04)(248.805,113.61)(251.68,115.96)(254.745,118.09 ) ( 258,120)(262.435,121.645)(266.84,123.08)(271.215,124.305)(275.56,125.32 ) ( 279.875,126.125)(284.16,126.72)(288.415,127.105)(292.64,127.28)(296.835,127.245 ) ( 301,127)(305.81,126.86)(310.44,126.44)(314.89,125.74)(319.16,124.76 ) ( 323.25,123.5)(327.16,121.96)(330.89,120.14)(334.44,118.04)(337.81,115.66 ) ( 341,113)(345.315,108.26)(349.16,103.64)(352.535,99.14)(355.44,94.76 ) ( 357.875,90.5)(359.84,86.36)(361.335,82.34)(362.36,78.44)(362.915,74.66 ) ( 363,71)(361.22,67.19)(359.28,63.56)(357.18,60.11)(354.92,56.84 ) ( 352.5,53.75)(349.92,50.84)(347.18,48.11)(344.28,45.56)(341.22,43.19 ) ( 338,41)(334.35,38.18)(330.6,35.72)(326.75,33.62)(322.8,31.88 ) ( 318.75,30.5)(314.6,29.48)(310.35,28.82)(306,28.52)(301.55,28.58 ) ( 297,29)(290.145,30.77)(283.68,32.68)(277.605,34.73)(271.92,36.92 ) ( 266.625,39.25)(261.72,41.72)(257.205,44.33)(253.08,47.08)(249.345,49.97 ) ( 246,53)(243.045,56.17)(240.48,59.48)(238.305,62.93)(236.52,66.52 ) ( 235.125,70.25)(234.12,74.12)(233.505,78.13)(233.28,82.28)(233.445,86.57 ) ( 234,91 ) ( 316,103)(318.395,108.6)(321.08,113.8)(324.055,118.6)(327.32,123 ) ( 330.875,127)(334.72,130.6)(338.855,133.8)(343.28,136.6)(347.995,139 ) ( 353,141)(360.86,142.465)(368.44,143.56)(375.74,144.285)(382.76,144.64 ) ( 389.5,144.625)(395.96,144.24)(402.14,143.485)(408.04,142.36)(413.66,140.865 ) ( 419,139)(425.05,135.595)(430.6,132.08)(435.65,128.455)(440.2,124.72 ) ( 444.25,120.875)(447.8,116.92)(450.85,112.855)(453.4,108.68)(455.45,104.395 ) ( 457,100)(456.61,93.965)(456.04,88.16)(455.29,82.585)(454.36,77.24 ) ( 453.25,72.125)(451.96,67.24)(450.49,62.585)(448.84,58.16)(447.01,53.965 ) ( 445,50)(443.305,46.22)(441.32,42.68)(439.045,39.38)(436.48,36.32 ) ( 433.625,33.5)(430.48,30.92)(427.045,28.58)(423.32,26.48)(419.305,24.62 ) ( 415,23)(408.065,21.17)(401.36,19.68)(394.885,18.53)(388.64,17.72 ) ( 382.625,17.25)(376.84,17.12)(371.285,17.33)(365.96,17.88)(360.865,18.77 ) ( 356,20)(350.96,22.155)(346.24,24.52)(341.84,27.095)(337.76,29.88 ) ( 334,32.875)(330.56,36.08)(327.44,39.495)(324.64,43.12)(322.16,46.955 ) ( 320,51)(318.16,55.255)(316.64,59.72)(315.44,64.395)(314.56,69.28 ) ( 314,74.375)(313.76,79.68)(313.84,85.195)(314.24,90.92)(314.96,96.855 ) ( 316,103 ) ( 359,78)(366,72 ) ( 358,72)(367,78 ) ( 372,67)@xmath20 ( 270,45)@xmath27 ( 229,18)(311,18 ) ( 303.482,20.736)(311,18)(303.482,15.264 ) ( 247,-1)@xmath53 por outro lado , temos necessariamente : @xmath54 com efeito , se @xmath20 pertencesse ao interior de @xmath26 , ento para @xmath48 prximo de @xmath21 , @xmath20 pertenceria ainda a @xmath30 pois @xmath30 varia continuamente com @xmath31 . isto contradiz o facto de @xmath21 ser o tempo mnimo .
estas observaes do uma viso geomtrica noo de tempo mnimo e conduzem - nos seguinte definio : seja @xmath55 , i)$ ] .
o controlo @xmath15 diz - se ptimo para o sistema se a correspondente trajectria @xmath56 verifica @xmath57 .
dizer que @xmath15 ptimo dizer que a trajectria associada a @xmath15 une @xmath18 a @xmath20 em tempo mnimo .
o objectivo ento o de determinar os controlos ptimos .
o teorema que se segue d - nos uma condio necessria e suficiente de optimalidade .
[ principiomaxlinear ] considere - se o sistema de controlo @xmath58 seja @xmath24 .
o controlo @xmath55,i = [ -1 , 1])$ ] ptimo se e somente se @xmath59 onde @xmath60 o produto interno em @xmath61 e @xmath62 soluo da equao @xmath63 . a condio inicial @xmath64 depende de @xmath20 .
como ela no directamente conhecida , a utilizao do teorema [ principiomaxlinear ] maioritariamente indirecta .
vejamos um exemplo .
consideremos uma massa pontual @xmath65 ligada a uma mola cujo movimento est restrito a um eixo @xmath66 ( figura [ mola ] ) .
= .25 mm @special[#1 ] killglue ( 239,109)(191,-5 ) = cmbxti10=cmbxti10 scaled 1(200,0)(200,80 ) ( 200,75)(192,70 ) ( 200,66)(192,61 ) ( 199,47)(191,42 ) ( 199,56)(191,51 ) ( 200,38)(192,33 ) ( 200,29)(192,24 ) ( 200,21)(192,16 ) ( 200,13)(192,8 ) ( 200,40)(400,40 ) ( 392.482,42.736)(400,40)(392.482,37.264 ) ( 390,19)@xmath67 ( 200,40)(212,51)(224,28)(236,52)(248,28 ) ( 260,52)(272,28)(284,52)(296,28)(305,40 ) ( 305,40 ) ( 306,46)(306,33 ) ( 327,33)(327,46)(306,46 ) ( 311,15)@xmath65 ( 275,79)(321,79 ) ( 313.482,81.736)(321,79)(313.482,76.264 ) ( 283,87)@xmath68 ( 203,24)@xmath69 a massa pontual sai da origem por uma fora que supomos igual a @xmath70 onde @xmath71 o comprimento da mola em repouso . aplicamos a essa massa pontual uma fora exterior horizontal @xmath72 .
a segunda lei de newton diz - nos que a fora resultante aplicada directamente proporcional ao produto entre a massa inercial e a acelerao adquirida pela mesma , ou seja @xmath73 as leis bsicas da fsica dizem - nos tambm que todas as foras so limitadas .
impomos a seguinte _ restrio _ fora exterior : @xmath74 isto significa que a fora apenas pode tomar valores no intervalo _ fechado _
@xmath75 $ ] .
suponhamos que a posio e a velocidade iniciais do objecto so , respectivamente , @xmath76 e @xmath77 .
o problema consiste em trazer , em _
tempo mnimo _ , a massa pontual posio de equilbrio @xmath78 por escolha adequada da fora externa @xmath79 e tendo em conta a _ restrio _ @xmath80 .
a fora @xmath15 aqui o nosso _
controlo_. dadas as condies iniciais @xmath76 e @xmath77 , encontrar a funo @xmath15 que permite transportar a massa para a sua posio de equilbrio em tempo mnimo .
para simplificar a apresentao , vamos supor @xmath81 , @xmath82 e @xmath83 ( passamos a @xmath84 por translao ) .
a equao de movimento ento equivalente ao sistema diferencial de controlo @xmath85 escrevemos facilmente na notao matricial @xmath86 tomando @xmath87 tendo em mente que estamos na seco de controlo linear fixamos @xmath88 , desprezando efeitos conservativos no lineares ( na seco [ sec : co : nl ] , onde abordamos o controlo ptimo no linear , consideraremos o caso @xmath89 ) .
temos @xmath91 e obtemos o sistema de controlo na forma ( sistema de controlo linear ) .
pretendemos responder a duas questes : * existir sempre , para toda e qualquer condio inicial @xmath76 e @xmath77 , uma fora exterior horizontal ( um controlo ) que permite transportar em tempo finito @xmath21 a massa pontual para sua posio de equilbrio @xmath92 e @xmath93 ? * se a primeira pergunta for respondida positivamente , qual a fora ( qual o controlo ) que minimiza o tempo de transporte da massa pontual sua posio de equilbrio ?
o nosso sistema escreve - se na forma @xmath94 com @xmath95 e @xmath96 .
temos ento @xmath97 e o teorema [ condkalman ] garante - nos que o sistema controlvel ( se @xmath98 ) .
isto significa que existem controlos para os quais as trajectrias associadas unem @xmath18 a @xmath99 .
temos assim resposta afirmativa nossa primeira questo , admitindo que o sistema mantm - se controlvel com controlos que verificam a restrio @xmath100 ( o que ser verificado _ a posteriori _ ) .
esta resposta esperada em termos fsicos .
se no aplicarmos uma fora exterior , , se @xmath101 , a equao do movimento @xmath102 e a massa pontual oscila sem nunca parar , nunca voltando sua posio de equilbrio em tempo finito .
por outro lado , ao aplicarmos determinadas foras exteriores , temos tendncia a amortecer as oscilaes .
a teoria do controlo prev que conseguimos realmente parar a massa em tempo finito .
sabemos que existem controlos que permitem conduzir o sistema de @xmath18 a @xmath99 .
agora queremos determinar , em concreto , qual desses controlos o faz em tempo mnimo .
para isso aplicamos o teorema [ principiomaxlinear ] : @xmath103 onde @xmath104 soluo de @xmath63 .
seja @xmath105 .
ento , @xmath106 e @xmath107 , @xmath108 , ou seja , @xmath109 .
logo @xmath110 .
consequentemente , o controlo ptimo seccionalmente constante em intervalos de comprimento @xmath111 e toma valores alternadamente @xmath112 . * se @xmath113 , obtemos o sistema diferencial @xmath114 * se @xmath115 , obtemos @xmath116 a trajectria ptima unindo @xmath18 a @xmath99 constituda por pedaos de solues de e concatenadas . as solues de e so facilmente obtidas : @xmath117 e conclumos que as curvas solues de so crculos centrados em @xmath118 e @xmath119 de perodo @xmath120 ( com efeito , @xmath121 e @xmath122 ) ; como solues de obtemos @xmath123 e @xmath122 , , as solues de so crculos centrados em @xmath124 e @xmath119 de perodo @xmath120 . a trajectria ptima de @xmath18 at @xmath99 segue alternadamente um arco de crculo centrado em @xmath118 e @xmath119 e um arco de crculo centrado em @xmath124 e @xmath119 .
o estudo detalhado da trajectria ptima e a sua implementao numrica , para todo e qualquer @xmath18 , podem ser encontrados em @xcite .
apresentamos agora algumas tcnicas para a anlise de problemas de controlo ptimo no lineares .
em particular , formulamos o princpio do mximo de pontryagin numa forma mais geral do que aquela que vimos na seco [ sec : cont : linear ] .
o exemplo no linear da massa - mola ser tratado como exemplo de aplicao .
de um ponto de vista global , o problema deve se formulado numa variedade @xmath125 , mas o nosso ponto de vista vai ser _ local _ e trabalhamos sobre um aberto @xmath126 de @xmath17 suficientemente pequeno .
a problemtica geral do controlo ptimo a seguinte .
consideremos um sistema de controlo @xmath127 sobre @xmath126 onde @xmath128 `` suave '' : todos os objectos manipulados so aqui , salvo casos particulares mencionados , @xmath129 .
remetemos o leitor interessado na anlise no - suave para @xcite .
] e o conjunto dos controlos admissveis @xmath130 composto por aplicaes @xmath131 \to \omega \subseteq \r^m$ ] mensurveis limitadas .
dada uma aplicao @xmath132 , denotamos por @xmath133 o custo de uma trajectria @xmath134 associada a @xmath135 e definido sobre @xmath136 $ ] , @xmath137 .
e @xmath139 duas sub - variedades regulares de @xmath126 .
o problema do controlo ptimo consiste em encontrar , de entre todas as trajectrias que unem @xmath138 a @xmath139 , aquelas cujo custo mnimo .
comeamos por restringir - nos ao caso em que @xmath138 e @xmath139 so pontos @xmath140 e @xmath141 de @xmath126 .
sendo o nosso ponto de vista local , podemos sempre supor que @xmath142 .
consideremos para o sistema o seguinte problema de _ controlo _ : dado um ponto @xmath143 , encontrar um tempo @xmath21 e um controlo @xmath15 sobre @xmath32 $ ] tal que a trajectria @xmath144 associada a @xmath15 , soluo de , verifica @xmath145 isto leva - nos a definir : seja @xmath146 . a aplicao entrada - sada em tempo @xmath21
do sistema de controlo inicializado em @xmath99 a aplicao : @xmath147 onde @xmath130 o conjunto dos controlos admissveis .
por outras palavras , a aplicao entrada - sada em tempo @xmath21 associa a um controlo @xmath15 o ponto final da trajectria associada a @xmath15 .
uma questo importante na teoria do controlo estudar esta aplicao @xmath148 , descrevendo a sua imagem , as suas singularidades , a sua regularidade , etc .
a resposta a estas questes depende , obviamente , do espao @xmath130 de partida e da forma do sistema ( da funo @xmath149 ) .
com toda a generalidade temos o seguinte resultado ( , , @xcite ) .
consideremos o sistema onde @xmath149 `` suave '' e @xmath150)$ ] .
ento @xmath148 `` suave '' no sentido @xmath151 .
seja @xmath152 um controlo de referncia . exprimamos a diferenciabilidade ( no sentido de frchet ) de @xmath148 no ponto @xmath15 .
consideremos @xmath153 e @xmath154 .
o sistema @xmath155 chamado _ sistema linearizado _ ao longo de @xmath156 . o diferencial de frchet de @xmath148 em @xmath15 a aplicao @xmath157 onde @xmath125 a soluo matricial de @xmath158 , @xmath159 .
seja @xmath15 um controlo definido sobre @xmath160 $ ] tal que a trajectria partindo de @xmath161 definida sobre @xmath32 $ ] .
dizemos que o controlo @xmath15 ( ou a trajectria @xmath144 ) singular sobre @xmath32 $ ] se o diferencial de frchet @xmath162 da aplicao entrada - sada no ponto @xmath15 no sobrejectiva .
caso contrrio dizemos que @xmath15 regular .
[ propeaberta ] sejam @xmath140 e @xmath21 fixos .
se @xmath15 um controlo regular , ento @xmath148 uma aplicao aberta numa vizinhana de @xmath15 .
o conjunto acessvel em tempo @xmath21 para o sistema , denotado por @xmath163 , o conjunto das extremidades em tempo @xmath21 das solues do sistema partindo de @xmath99 .
por outras palavras , a imagem da aplicao entrada - sada em tempo @xmath21 . o sistema diz - se controlvel se @xmath164 argumentos do tipo do teorema da funo implcita permitem deduzir os resultados de _ controlabilidade local _ do sistema de partida a partir do estudo da controlabilidade do sistema linearizado ( , , @xcite ) .
por exemplo , deduzimos do teorema de controlabilidade no caso linear a proposio seguinte .
consideremos o sistema de controlo onde @xmath165 .
seja @xmath166 e @xmath167 .
se @xmath168 ento o sistema no linear localmente controlvel em @xmath99 .
em geral o problema da controlabilidade difcil .
diferentes abordagens so possveis .
umas fazem uso da anlise , outras da geometria , outras ainda da lgebra .
o problema da controlabilidade est ligado , por exemplo , questo de saber quando um determinado semi - grupo opera transitivamente .
existem tambm tcnicas para mostrar , em certos casos , que a controlabilidade global .
uma delas , importante , a chamada `` tcnica de alargamento '' ( @xcite ) .
para alm de um problema de controlo , consideramos tambm um problema de optimizao : de entre todas as solues do sistema unindo @xmath99 a @xmath141 , encontrar uma trajectria que minimiza ( ou maximiza ) uma certa funo _ custo _
uma tal trajectria , se existir , diz - se _ ptima _ para esse custo .
a existncia de trajectrias ptimas depende da regularidade do sistema e do custo .
para um enunciado geral de existncia , , @xcite .
pode tambm acontecer que um controlo ptimo no exista na classe de controlos considerada , mas exista num espao mais abrangente .
esta questo remete - nos para outra rea importante : o estudo da regularidade das trajectrias ptimas .
francis clarke e richard vinter deram um contributo importantssimo nesta rea , introduzindo o estudo sistemtico da regularidade lipschitziana dos minimizantes no controlo ptimo linear @xcite .
resultados gerais de regularidade lipschitziana das trajectrias minimizantes para sistemas de controlo no lineares podem ser encontrados em @xcite .
dado um problema de controlo ptimo para o qual esto garantidas as condies de existncia e regularidade da soluo ptima , como determinar os processos optimais ?
a resposta a esta questo dada pelo clebre _
princpio do mximo de pontryagin_. para um estudo aprofundado das condies necessrias de optimalidade sugerimos @xcite .
comeamos por mostrar que uma trajectria singular pode ser parametrizada como a projeco de uma soluo de um sistema hamiltoniano sujeito a uma _ equao de restrio_. consideremos o _ hamiltoniano _ do sistema : @xmath170 onde @xmath171 denota o produto escalar usual de @xmath17 .
[ propcontsing ] seja @xmath15 um controlo singular e @xmath67 a trajectria singular associada a esse controlo em @xmath32 $ ] .
ento , existe um vector linha contnuo @xmath172 \to \r^n \backslash \ { 0\}$ ] tal que as equaes seguintes so verificadas para quase todo o @xmath29 $ ] : @xmath173 onde @xmath174 o hamiltoniano do sistema .
por definio , o par @xmath175 singular sobre @xmath32 $ ] se @xmath162 no sobrejectiva .
logo existe um vector linha @xmath176 tal que @xmath177 ) \hspace{0.2 cm } \langle\bar{p } , de_t(u ) \cdot v\rangle = \bar{p } \int_0^t m(t ) m^{-1}(s ) b(s )
v(s ) ds = 0 \ , .\ ] ] consequentemente , @xmath178 \ , .\ ] ] seja @xmath179 , @xmath29 $ ] .
temos que @xmath180 um vector linha de @xmath181 e @xmath182 .
diferenciando , obtemos @xmath183 introduzindo o hamiltoniano @xmath184 conclumos que @xmath185 e @xmath186 a equao de restrio vem de @xmath187 pois @xmath188 .
ao vector linha @xmath189 \to \r^n \backslash \ { 0\}$ ] da proposio [ propcontsing ] chamamos _ vector adjunto _ do sistema .
procuramos condies necessrias de optimalidade .
consideremos o sistema .
os controlos @xmath190 so definidos em @xmath32 $ ] e tomam valores em @xmath191 ( no existem restries aos valores dos controlos ) . as trajectrias associadas devem verificar @xmath76 e @xmath192 . o problema consiste em minimizar um custo da forma @xmath193 onde @xmath194 uma aplicao @xmath129 e @xmath21 est fixo . associamos ao sistema o _ sistema aumentado _
@xmath195 e usamos a notao @xmath196 e @xmath197 .
o problema reduz - se ento procura de uma trajectria soluo de com @xmath198 e @xmath199 de tal modo que a ltima coordenada @xmath200 seja minimizada .
seja @xmath198 fixo .
o conjunto dos estados acessveis a partir de @xmath201 para o sistema @xmath202 .
seja , agora , @xmath203 um controlo e @xmath204 a trajectria associada , soluo do sistema aumentado saindo de @xmath198 .
se @xmath203 ptimo para o critrio , ento o ponto @xmath205 pertence fronteira do conjunto @xmath206 .
com efeito , se assim no fosse existiria uma vizinhana do ponto @xmath207 em @xmath206 contendo um ponto @xmath208 soluo do sistema e tal que @xmath209 , o que contradiz a optimalidade do controlo @xmath203 ( figura [ accessiblesetaumentado ] ) .
consequentemente , o controlo @xmath210 , pela proposio [ propeaberta ] , um controlo singular para o sistema aumentado . ( 0,0 ) ptimo , ento @xmath211.,title="fig : " ] # 1#2#3#4#5 @font ( 12387,8881)(226,-8780 ) ( 11926,-8686)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1501,-211)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4501,-8611)(0,0)[lb ] ( 226,-3961)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5551,-2311)(0,0)[lb ] usando a proposio [ propcontsing ] obtemos o seguinte teorema .
[ teo : hestenes ] se @xmath203 um controlo ptimo , ento existe uma aplicao @xmath212 \to \r^{n+1 } \backslash \ { 0 \}$ ] tal que @xmath213 satisfaz o sistema hamiltoniano @xmath214 e a condio de estacionaridade @xmath215 onde @xmath216 .
o teorema [ teo : hestenes ] tem a sua gnese nos trabalhos de graves de 1933 , tendo sido obtido primeiramente por hestenes em 1950 @xcite .
trata - se de um caso particular do princpio do mximo de pontryagin , onde no so consideradas restries aos valores dos controlos ( , @xmath217 com @xmath218 ) .
escrevendo @xmath219 , onde @xmath220 a varivel dual do custo e @xmath221 , temos que @xmath222 satisfaz o sistema @xmath223 e @xmath224 onde @xmath225 .
repare - se que @xmath226 , isto , @xmath227 constante em @xmath32 $ ] .
como o vector @xmath228 definido a menos de uma constante multiplicativa , escolhe - se normalmente @xmath229 .
uma _ extremal _ do problema de controlo ptimo um terno ordenado @xmath230 soluo das equaes e .
se @xmath231 , dizemos que a extremal anormal .
nesse caso ela no depende
do custo e @xmath232 uma trajectria singular do sistema .
a designao _ anormal _ histrica .
sabe - se hoje que os minimizantes anormais so frequentes e `` normais '' em muitos e variadssimos problemas de optimizao .
ao leitor interessado no estudo de extremais anormais sugerimos o livro @xcite .
o princpio do mximo de pontryagin uma verso forte do teorema [ teo : hestenes ] onde so admitidas restries sobre os valores dos controlos .
a existncia de tais restries imposta pelas aplicaes e altera por completo a natureza das solues .
o princpio do mximo de pontryagin muito mais difcil de demonstrar do que o teorema de hestenes ( , , @xcite ) .
para uma abordagem simples ao princpio do mximo de pontryagin sugerimos dois livros excelentes escritos em lngua portuguesa : @xcite . o enunciado geral o seguinte .
[ thm : pmp ] considere - se o sistema de controlo em @xmath17 @xmath233 onde @xmath234 de classe @xmath235 e onde os controlos so aplicaes mensurveis e limitadas , definidos no intervalo @xmath236 $ ] de @xmath7 .
denotemos por @xmath130 o conjunto dos controlos admissveis
cujas trajectrias associadas unem um ponto inicial de @xmath138 a um ponto final de @xmath139 .
para um tal controlo definimos o custo @xmath237 onde @xmath194 de classe @xmath235 .
se o controlo @xmath152 ptimo em @xmath238 $ ] , ento existe uma aplicao no trivial ( , no identicamente nula ) @xmath239 \to \r^n \times \r$ ] absolutamente contnua , chamada vector adjunto , onde @xmath240 uma constante negativa ou nula , tal que a trajectria ptima @xmath67 associada ao controlo @xmath15 verifica , em quase todos os pontos de @xmath238 $ ] , o _ sistema hamiltoniano _
@xmath241 e a _ condio do mximo _ @xmath242 \
, , \ ] ] onde o _ hamiltoniano _
@xmath174 dado por @xmath243 .
alm disso , tem - se para todo o @xmath244 $ ] que @xmath245 se @xmath138 e / ou @xmath139 so variedades de @xmath17 com espaos tangentes @xmath246 em @xmath247 e @xmath248 em @xmath249 , ento o vector adjunto satisfaz as seguintes condies de transversalidade : @xmath250 no teorema [ thm : pmp ] o tempo final livre .
se impusermos um tempo final fixo igual a @xmath21 , isto , se procuramos , partindo de @xmath138 , atingir o alvo @xmath139 em tempo @xmath21 e minimizando o custo @xmath251 em @xmath32 $ ] ( problema a tempo fixo ) , ento o teorema continua verdadeiro , salvo a condio que deve ser substituda por @xmath252\ ] ] ( com constante no necessariamente nula ) .
o problema de tempo mnimo corresponde ao caso em que @xmath253 .
se o conjunto alvo @xmath139 igual a todo o @xmath17 ( problema com extremidade final livre ) , ento a condio de transversalidade no instante final diz - nos que @xmath254 .
o princpio do mximo de pontryagin um resultado profundo e importante da matemtica contempornea , com inmeras aplicaes na fsica , biologia , gesto , economia , cincias sociais , engenharia , etc .
( , , @xcite ) .
reconsideremos o exemplo ( no linear ) da mola , modelado pelo sistema de controlo @xmath255 onde admitimos como controlos todas as funes @xmath135 seccionalmente contnuas tais que @xmath80 .
o objectivo consiste em levar a mola de uma posio inicial qualquer @xmath256 sua posio de equilbrio @xmath257 _ em tempo mnimo _ @xmath258
. apliquemos o princpio do mximo de pontryagin a este problema .
o hamiltoniano tem a forma @xmath259 se @xmath260 uma extremal , ento @xmath261 notemos que uma vez que o vector adjunto @xmath262 deve ser no trivial , @xmath263 no pode anular - se num intervalo ( seno teramos igualmente @xmath264 e , por anulao do hamiltoniano , teramos tambm @xmath265 ) .
por outro lado , a condio do mximo d - nos @xmath266 em particular , os controlo ptimos so sucessivamente iguais a @xmath112 , isto , verifica - se o princpio _ bang - bang _ ( , , @xcite ) .
concretamente , podemos afirmar que @xmath267 @xmath268 .
invertendo o tempo @xmath269 o nosso problema equivalente ao problema de tempo mnimo para o sistema @xmath270 dadas as condies iniciais @xmath140 e @xmath271 ( posio e velocidade inicial da massa ) , o problema facilmente resolvido . o leitor interessado encontra em @xcite uma resoluo efectuada com o sistema de computao algbrica maple .
sobre o uso do maple no clculo das variaes e controlo ptimo veja - se @xcite .
a teoria matemtica dos sistemas e controlo ensinada nas instituies dos autores , nos departamentos de matemtica da universidade de aveiro e da universidade de orlans , frana .
em aveiro no mbito do mestrado _ matemtica e aplicaes _ , especializao em _
matemtica empresarial e tecnolgica _ @xcite , e no mbito do _ programa doutoral em matemtica e aplicaes _ este ltimo uma associao entre os departamentos de matemtica da universidade de aveiro e da universidade do minho @xcite ; em orlans na opo `` controlo automtico '' do mestrado passion @xcite . o primeiro autor foi aluno de mestrado em aveiro e faz actualmente um doutoramento em aveiro e orlans na rea do controlo ptimo , com o apoio financeiro da fct , bolsa sfrh / bd/27272/2006 .
l. s. pontryagin , v. g. boltyanskii , r. v. gamkrelidze , e. f. mishchenko . _ the mathematical theory of optimal processes _ , translated from the russian by k. n. trirogoff ; edited by l. w. neustadt , interscience publishers john wiley & sons , inc .
new york , 1962 . | neste trabalho so referidas motivaes , aplicaes e relaes da teoria do controlo com outras reas da matemtica .
apresentamos uma breve resenha histrica sobre o controlo ptimo , desde as suas origens no clculo das variaes e na teoria clssica do controlo aos dias de hoje , dando especial destaque ao princpio do mximo de pontryagin .
* palavras chave : * controlo ptimo , princpio do mximo de pontryagin , aplicaes da teoria matemtica dos sistemas de controlo . |
the study of the nuclear equation of state is an important area of research in intermediate energy heavy ion reactions @xcite and results from nuclear multifragmentation reactions are extensively used for such study .
the statistical models are extremely powerful and widely used tools for study of the multifragmentation reactions . in models of statistical disassembly of a nuclear system formed by the collision of two heavy ions at intermediate energy one
assumes that the hot and compressed nuclear system expands and subsequently fragments into composites of different masses depending on the initial conditions .
the fragmentation of the nucleus into available channels ( depends on phase space ) can be solved in different statistical ensembles ( microcanonical , canonical and grand canonical ) . for finite nuclei , in general the results for different observables
differ in different ensembles and they are found to converge under certain conditions @xcite . + isoscaling @xcite and isobaric yield ratio @xcite are two well known methods which are used to study the nuclear eos and to extract liquid drop model parameters ( symmetry energy coefficient for example ) from multifragmentation reactions .
the isoscaling parameters are related to the difference between the chemical potentials of the two fragmenting isotopes and hence provide insight into their symmetry energy .
the isobaric yield ratio method is used to extract the liquid drop model parameters and also the difference in chemical potential between neutrons and protons .
the formulae for both these methods are derived using the framework of the grand canonical model . hence results from this ensemble
agree exactly with those from these equations .
the canonical model is better suited compared to grand canonical model for describing intermediate energy nuclear reactions where baryon and charge numbers are conserved . on the contrary ,
results from the canonical ensemble differ from the formulae based on grand canonical ensemble .
the nature of this deviation depends on the size of the fragmenting systems as well as on the neutron to proton ratio ( asymmetry ) of them .
it is seen that results from both the ensembles differ when the source size is small and asymmetry is large and they come closer when one increases the source size or decrease its asymmetry .
the results of the isoscaling as well as the isobaric yield ratio equations depend on the statistical ensemble used for the calculation .
since the equations for extracting the relevant parameters are derived from the grand canonical framework , hence the results from the canonical model should be carefully analyzed for extraction of different parameters from these methods .
+ the letter is structured as follows . in section
ii , we give a brief introduction to the canonical and the grand canonical models where as section iii contains the theoretical framework of isoscaling and isobaric yield ratio methods from grand canonical ensemble .
the results will be presented in section iv .
finally we shall summarize and conclude in section v. +
in this section we describe briefly the canonical and the grand canonical models of nuclear multifragmentation . the basic output from canonical
@xcite or grand canonical model @xcite is multiplicity of the fragments . after calculating the multiplicities , isoscaling and
isobaric yield ratio parameters can be obtained . by multiplicity
we mean that the average number of fragments produced for each proton number @xmath0 and neutron number @xmath1
. assuming that the system with @xmath2 nucleons and @xmath3 protons at temperature @xmath4 , has expanded to a volume higher than normal nuclear volume , the partitioning into different composites can be calculated according to the rules of equilibrium statistical mechanics .
+ in a canonical model @xcite , the partitioning is done such that all partitions have the correct @xmath5 ( equivalently @xmath6 ) .
the canonical partition function is given by @xmath7 where the sum is over all possible channels of break - up ( the number of such channels is enormous ) satisfying @xmath8 and @xmath9 ; @xmath10 is the partition function of the composite with @xmath1 neutrons & @xmath0 protons and @xmath11 is its multiplicity . the partition function @xmath12 is calculated using a recursion relation @xcite . from eq .
( 1 ) , the average number of composites is given by @xcite @xmath13 it is necessary to specify which nuclei are included in computing @xmath12 . for @xmath14
we include a ridge along the line of stability .
the liquid - drop formula gives neutron and proton drip lines and the results shown here include all nuclei within the boundaries .
+ in the grand canonical model @xcite , if the neutron chemical potential is @xmath15 and the proton chemical potential is @xmath16 , then statistical equilibrium implies @xcite that the chemical potential of a composite with @xmath1 neutrons and @xmath0 protons is @xmath17 .
the average number of composites with @xmath1 neutrons and @xmath0 protons is given by @xcite @xmath18 the chemical potentials @xmath15 and @xmath16 are determined by solving two equations @xmath19 and @xmath20 .
this amounts to solving for an infinite system but we emphasize that this infinite system can break up into only certain kinds of species as are included in the above two equations .
we can look upon the sum on @xmath1 and @xmath0 as a sum over @xmath21 ( @xmath22 ) and a sum over @xmath0 . in principle
@xmath21 goes from 1 to @xmath23 and for a given @xmath21 , @xmath0 can go from 0 to @xmath21 . here for a given @xmath21 we restrict @xmath0 by the same drip lines used for canonical model . + in both the models , the partition function of a composite having @xmath1 neutrons and @xmath0 protons is a product of two parts : one is due to the the translational motion and the other is the intrinsic partition function of the composite : @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the volume available for translational motion .
note that @xmath25 will be less than @xmath26 , the volume to which the system has expanded at break up ( freeze - out volume ) .
we use @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is the normal volume of nucleus with @xmath3 protons and @xmath29 neutrons . in this work the temperature and freeze - out volume are kept constant at 5 mev and @xmath30 respectively .
+ we list now the properties of the composites used in this work .
the proton and the neutron are fundamental building blocks thus @xmath31 where 2 takes care of the spin degeneracy . for deuteron ,
triton , @xmath32he and @xmath33he we use @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the ground state energy of the composite and @xmath36 is the experimental spin degeneracy of the ground state .
excited states for these very low mass nuclei are not included . for mass number @xmath37
we use the liquid - drop formula .
for nuclei in isolation , this reads + @xmath38\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression includes the volume energy [ @xmath39 mev ] , the temperature dependent surface energy [ @xmath40 with @xmath41 mev and @xmath42 mev ] , the coulomb energy with wigner - seitz approximation [ @xmath43 with @xmath44 mev ] and the symmetry energy ( @xmath45 mev ) .
the term @xmath46 ( @xmath47 mev ) represents contribution from excited states since the composites are at a non - zero temperature .
+ in canonical ensemble though chemical potential does not come into picture directly , but we can define them as @xmath48 .
so in our case , @xmath49 @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the total free energy .
substituting @xmath10 from eq . ( 4 ) and eq . ( 5 ) in eq .
( 3 ) , the average multiplicity from grand canonical ensemble can be written as , @xmath52\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath53 , whereas @xmath54 is given by eq .
5 . in isobaric yield ratio method ,
ratio of yields of two different types of fragments having same mass number @xmath21 but different isospin asymmetry @xmath55 and @xmath56 originating from same source @xcite is given by , @xmath57&= & \langle n_{i , a}\rangle_{gc}/\langle n_{i^{'},a}\rangle_{gc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the choice of @xmath58 and @xmath59 the ratio will be @xmath60=\frac{\mu_{n}-\mu_{p}}{t}+\frac{a^{*}_c}{t}a^{2/3}\ ] ] and isoscaling is the ratio of yields of the same type of fragment @xmath61 originating from two sources having different mass number @xmath62 and @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) but same charge @xmath65 . from ( 6 ) ,
@xmath66 in canonical and grand canonical model calculations , @xmath67 is calculated from the ratio of @xmath68 and @xmath69 and then isoscaling parameters @xmath70 and @xmath71 are obtained by linear fitting of @xmath72 with @xmath1 ( at constant @xmath0 ) and @xmath0 ( at constant @xmath1 ) respectively .
since the above formalisms are valid for equilibrium condition @xcite and secondary decay affects the equilibrium scenario @xcite , hence in the entire theoretical calculation secondary decay is not included .
we have studied the dependence of neutron and proton chemical potentials on both source size and source asymmetry and the results are displayed in fig .
1 . in fig .
1(a ) , the variation of both @xmath73 and @xmath74 with source proton number @xmath75 is shown for two values of the asymmetry parameter @xmath76 0.11 and 0.27 .
the source size @xmath77 is varied from 44 to 264 ( @xmath75 from 16 to 96 ) and it is seen that both the neutron and the proton chemical potential remains almost constant as one increases the source size irrespective of the value of @xmath78 . in the same figure results
are shown from both the canonical and the grand canonical models and it is seen that the chemical potentials calculated from both the ensembles are almost equal except for the very small sources where they are slightly different . in fig .
1(b ) , the variation of chemical potentials with the asymmetry parameter @xmath78 is shown where @xmath78 is varied from 0 to 0.33 .
the source size @xmath77 is kept fixed at 60 whereas @xmath75 varies from 20 ( @xmath78=0.33 ) to 30 ( @xmath78 = 0 ) .
the change of @xmath73 and @xmath79 with @xmath78 is almost linear for both the ensembles and also the results from the canonical and the grand canonical ensembles are more or less the same except for higher @xmath78 values where they are slightly different . + ) and neutron chemical potential ( @xmath73 ) with ( a ) source size ( at constant source asymmetry @xmath80 and @xmath81 ) ( b ) source asymmetry ( for fixed source size @xmath82 ) from canonical ( red solid lines ) and grand canonical models ( black dotted lines).,width=268,height=201 ] since it is seen from fig .
1(a ) & 1(b ) that the chemical potentials are almost same for both models for the entire range of source size and source asymmetry , hence for all other results to be presented for these systems , the chemical potentials obtained from grandcanonical model are being used .
+ ( @xmath71 ) with fragment proton number @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) for each pair of sources having same isospin asymmetry @xmath83 and @xmath81 but different charges @xmath84 ( black squares joined by solid lines ) , 24 ( red circles joined by dotted lines ) , 32 ( green circles joined by dashed lines ) 48 ( blue stars joined by dash dotted lines ) and 96 ( magenta pentagons joined by short dotted lines ) from canonical [ 2(a ) , 2(b ) ] and grand canonical [ 2(c ) , 2(d ) ] model . 2(e ) and 2(f ) shows the variation of the isoscaling parameters @xmath70 and @xmath71 respectively with source charge ( @xmath75 ) obtained from canonical model ( red solid lines ) , grand canonical model ( black dotted lines ) and that calculated from the formulae @xmath85 and @xmath86 ( blue stars).,width=268,height=326 ] the isoscaling parameters @xmath70 and @xmath71 ( eq .
11 ) depend only on the difference in chemical potentials of more neutronrich and less neutron rich fragmenting systems and on the temperature at freeze - out . for isoscaling studies a pair of sources with same @xmath75 value is required .
we have kept the asymmetry value of the more neutron - rich source to be 0.27 and that of the less neutron - rich one to be 0.11 .
the study was done for different source sizes ranging from @xmath75 = 16 to @xmath75 = 96 , the y values being the same for each pair . since for a particular pair of reaction
the difference in chemical potentials are the same , therefore it is expected that the isoscaling parameters @xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) would remain constant throughout the entire @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) regime of the fragments .
it can also be concluded from fig .
1(a ) that at constant temperature and same @xmath78 value of the fragmenting sources , @xmath79 and @xmath73 are almost independent of the source size . on the contrary , from theoretical calculation by the canonical model it is observed from fig 2(a ) & 2(b ) that @xmath70 increases with the increase of fragment proton number @xmath0 and @xmath71 decreases with increase of fragment neutron number @xmath1 and
the change is more for smaller fragmenting sources . on the other hand , @xmath70 and @xmath71 values calculated from the grand canonical model ( fig 2(c ) & 2(d ) ) are independent of the fragment size .
the dependence on source size is also very small as compared to the canonical results ( fig 2(a ) & 2(b)).therefore if we take the average of @xmath70 ( or @xmath71 ) in the range of @xmath87 to @xmath88 ( or @xmath89 to @xmath88 ) for each source and compare those with that calculated from the formula @xmath85 or @xmath86 , then it is observed that the average values obtained from canonical and grand canonical model are different for the smaller fragmenting sources and the difference decreases substantially as one increases the source size as seen in fig 2(e ) & 2(f ) ) .
the values of the isoscaling parameter @xmath70 and @xmath71 calculated from the slopes of the ratio @xmath67 of the grand canonical model coincides exactly with those calculated from the formula .
this is seen from the dotted lines and the stars in fig 2(e ) & 2(f ) .
this is what is expected since the formulae connecting the isoscaling parameters with the difference in chemical potentials is deduced from the grand canonical ensemble and hence results from the later exactly coincide with those calculated from the formulae .
+ $ ] with @xmath90 for sources having same isospin asymmetry 0.27 but different charge @xmath84 ( black squares ) , 24 ( red circles ) , 32 ( green circles ) 48 ( blue stars ) and 96 ( magenta pentagons ) from canonical ( a ) and grand canonical ( b ) model . here
the lines connecting the points represent the linear fittings .
( c ) and ( d ) shows variation of the isobaric yield ratio parameters @xmath91 and @xmath92 respectively with source charge ( @xmath75 ) obtained from canonical model ( red solid lines ) , grand canonical model ( black dotted lines ) and that calculated from the formulae @xmath93 and @xmath94 ( blue stars).,width=268,height=268 ] $ ] with @xmath90 for sources having same mass @xmath82 but different isospin asymmetry 0.1 ( black squares ) , 0.17 ( red stars ) , 0.27 ( green circles ) and 0.33 ( magenta triangles ) from canonical ( a ) and grand canonical ( b ) model . here
the lines connecting the points represent the linear fittings .
( c ) and ( d ) shows the variation of isobaric yield ratio parameters @xmath91 and @xmath92 respectively with source isospin asymmetry ( @xmath78 ) obtained from canonical model ( red solid lines ) , grand canonical model ( black dotted lines ) and that calculated from the formulae @xmath93 and @xmath94 ( blue stars).,width=268,height=268 ] in fig .
3(a ) & 3(b ) we show the variation of the isobaric yield ratio @xmath95 $ ] with the fragment sizes where each line represents a particular source having different size but same isospin asymmetry 0.27 . in the isobaric yield ratio method ,
it is observed from eq .
10 that the quantity @xmath95 $ ] calculated for odd @xmath21 nuclei ( since @xmath96 ) , varies linearly with @xmath90 by an equation like @xmath97 with @xmath98 & @xmath93 ( where @xmath43 and @xmath99 ) .
the difference @xmath100 is almost independent of the source size ( fig .
1(a ) ) ; hence c s should be almost equal and m s are exactly equal for all the fragmenting sources .
therefore the plot of the ratio @xmath95 $ ] originating from all the fragmenting sources ( as used in fig .
1(a ) ) should almost coincide .
but from the canonical model , the variation of @xmath95 $ ] with @xmath90 is different for different sources as shown in fig .
the slopes of the lines from different sources vary with the source size although the slope should be exactly equal according to the formula .
this deviation arises because from eq .
10 the slope @xmath94 is derived from the grand canonical model and the same may not hold true for the canonical results .
the results from the grand canonical model are shown in fig .
here it is seen that the slopes are exactly equal irrespective of the source size .
the calculated values of the slope @xmath92 and the y - intercept @xmath91 obtained from linear fitting of the lines from canonical models ( fig .
3(a ) ) and those calculated from formula @xmath93 and @xmath94 are not same for smaller fragmenting sources , but are close for the larger sources .
this is shown in fig .
3(c ) & 3(d ) .
the reason for this deviation is that the formulae are derived using the grand canonical ensemble and hence they are in general not true for the canonical model results . for larger sources
the fragmentation is more , therefore the particle number fluctuation in grand canonical model is very less @xcite . in canonical model , particle number
is strictly conserved and there is no such fluctuation . hence the isoscaling parameters and isobaric yield ratios obtained from canonical and grand canonical model become closer compared to that from the smaller fragmenting sources .
the values of @xmath91 and @xmath92 obtained by fitting the lines from the grand canonical model ( fig .
3(b ) ) coincide exactly with the values given by the formula .
this is shown by the dashed line and the symbols in fig .
3(c ) and fig .
4 we show the effect of variation of the source asymmetry @xmath78 on the isobaric yield ratio parameters . in fig .
4(a ) we plot the ratio @xmath95 $ ] with @xmath90 where @xmath21 is the mass number of the fragment .
the different lines on the plot corresponds to different sources with @xmath78 values ranging from 0.33 to 0 .
the slopes of these lines according to eq .
10 is equal to @xmath94 and hence should not depend on its @xmath78 value .
the value of the y - intercept @xmath91 of these lines will be different since it is equal to @xmath101 which depend on @xmath78 as seen from fig 1(b ) .
it is seen from fig .
4(a ) that the slopes are different for different sources from the canonical model calculation , the deviation being more for the source which is more asymmetric . for the grand canonical model(fig .
4(b ) ) , the slopes are exactly equal for each source as expected from the formulae .
the values of the parameters @xmath91 and @xmath92 are plotted in fig .
4(c ) & 4(d ) respectively .
it is seen that results from the canonical model differs from that of the formulae for higher values of @xmath78 and they become close as @xmath78 value approaches 0 or in other words the source becomes symmetric .
the results from the grand canonical ensemble coincide exactly with that from the formulae .
it has been already studied that results from the canonical and grand canonical models converge more as the fragmenting system becomes more symmetric as the particle fluctuation in grand canonical model becomes less in such cases .
similar effect is obtained earlier for mass distribution @xcite .
isobaric yield ratio method as well as the isoscaling equations connect the liquis drop model parameters to the ratio of fragment yields from break - up of hot nuclei . these relations are deduced using the grand canonical ensemble for calculating the fragment yields . hence results from this ensemble agree exactly with those obtained from the equations of isobaric yield rati and isoscaling . on the contrary ,
results from the canonical ensemble ( which is more suitable for describing finite nculei with conserved mass and charge ) deviate from these equations and this deviation is more pronounced for smaller source size and more asymmtetric nuclei .
this is very much expected since results from both the ensembles differ in general for finite nculei and are found to converge when fragmentation of the nucleus is more and it happens for the sources having larger mass or less asymmetry@xcite .
+ 99 bao - an li , lie - wen chen and che ming ko , phys . rep . *
464 * , 113 , ( 2008 ) .
bao - an li and wolf - udo schroder , _ isospin physics in heavy - ion collisions at intermediate energies _ , nova science pub .
( 2001 ) c. b. das , s. das gupta , w. g. lynch , a. z. mekjian , and m. b. tsang , phys .
rep * 406 * , 1 ( 2005 ) .
j. p. bondorf , a. s. botvina , a. s. iljinov , i. n. mishustin and k. sneppen , phys . rep . * 257 * , 133 ( 1995 ) .
d. h. gross , phys .
rep * 279 * , 119 ( 1997 ) .
s. mallik and g. chaudhuri , phys .
* b 718 * ( 2012 ) 189 . m. b. tsang et .
al . , phys .
lett . * 86 * , 5023 ( 2001 ) .
a. s. botvina et .
al . , phys .
rev . c*65 * 044610 ( 2002 ) .
g. chaudhuri et .
al . , nucl .
a*813 * , 293 - 313 ( 2008 ) .
m. colonna , phys .
lett . * 110 * , 042701 ( 2013 ) .
r. raduta and f. gulminelli et .
al . , phys .
rev . c*75 * 024605 ( 2007 ) .
s. mallik and g. chaudhuri , phys .
* c 87 * 011602 ( r ) ( 2013 ) .
m. huang et .
al . , phys .
rev . c*81 * 044620 ( 2010 ) .
s. r. souza and m. b. tsang , phys .
rev . c*85 * 024603 ( 2012 ) .
chun - wang ma et al . , phys . rev .
* c 83 * , 064620 ( 2011 ) .
g. chaudhuri and s. das gupta , phys .
rev . * c 80 * 044609 ( 2009 ) . f. reif , fundamentals of statistical and thermal physics ( mcgraw hill , newyork , 1965 ) g. chaudhuri and s. mallik , nucl .
phys . * a 849 * , 190 ( 2011 ) . | isoscaling and isobaric yield ratio parameters are compared from canonical and grand canonical ensembles when applied to multifragmentation of finite nuclei .
source dependence of isoscaling parameters & source and isospin dependence of isobaric yield ratio parameters are examined in the framework of the canonical and the grand canonical models .
it is found that as the nucleus fragments more , results from both the ensembles converge and observables calculated from the canonical ensemble coincide more with those obtained from the formulae derived using the grand canonical ensemble . |
studies of the host galaxies of low - redshift quasars can enable us to define the subset of the present - day galaxy population which is capable of producing quasar - level nuclear activity .
this is of obvious importance for constraining physical models of quasar evolution ( small & blandford 1992 ; haehnelt & rees 1993 ; kauffman & haehnelt 2000 ) , and for exploring the connection between black - hole and galaxy formation ( silk & rees 1998 , fabian 1999 , franceschini et al .
1999 , granato et al .
2001 , kormendy & gebhardt 2001 ) .
such observations are also of value for testing unified models of radio - loud agn ( e.g. peacock 1987 , barthel 1989 , urry & padovani 1995 ) , constraining possible evolutionary links between ulirgs and quasars ( sanders & mirabel 1996 ) , exploring the origin of radio - loudness ( blandford 2000 ) , and as a means to estimate the masses of the central black holes which power the active nuclei ( mclure et al .
1999 ) .
our view of low - redshift quasar hosts has been clarified enormously over the last five years , primarily due to the angular resolution and dynamic range offered by the hubble space telescope ( hst ) .
after some initial confusion , recent hst - based studies have now reached agreement that the hosts of all luminous quasars ( @xmath2 ) are bright galaxies with @xmath9 ( bahcall et al .
1997 , mclure et al . 1999 ,
mcleod & mcleod 2001 ) .
however , it can be argued , ( with considerable justification ) that this much had already been established from earlier ground - based studies ( e.g. smith et al .
1986 , vron - cetty & woltjer 1990 , taylor et al . 1996 ) .
in fact , as first convincingly demonstrated by disney et al .
( 1995 ) , the major advance offered by the hst for the study of quasar hosts is that it allows host galaxies to be mapped out over sufficient angular and dynamic range for a de vaucouleurs @xmath10-law spheroidal component to be clearly distinguished from an exponential disc , at least for redshifts @xmath11 .
this is not to suggest that agn host - galaxy morphological discrimination has proved impossible from the ground . indeed for lower - luminosity agn at @xmath12 , such as seyfert galaxies , ground - based imaging has proved perfectly adequate for this task ( e.g. hunt et al . 1999 ) and in fact some early ground - based attempts to determine the morphology of low - redshift quasar hosts have also proved to be robust ( e.g. smith et al . 1986 ) .
however , to ensure an unbiassed comparison of rqq and rlq hosts it is necessary to study host galaxies at @xmath13 and to be able to determine host - galaxy morphologies for quasars with luminosities up to @xmath14 . even by moving to the infrared to minimize nuclear : host ratio , taylor et al .
( 1996 ) found that this could not be reliably achieved with typical ground - based seeing .
nevertheless , great care needs to be taken to extract the full benefit of hst imaging of quasar hosts .
in particular , deep observations are required to detect the extended low surface - brightness emission of even a massive host galaxy at @xmath15 to a radius of several arcsec from the nucleus .
unfortunately however , this inevitably leads to saturation of the nucleus , making accurate characterization of the luminosity of the central source impossible .
this is crucial because , at the depths of interest for reliable host - galaxy characterization , scattered light in the wfpc2 psf still makes a significant contribution to surface brightness out to an angular radius @xmath16 arcsec ( mclure , dunlop & kukula 2000 ) .
as demonstrated by mcleod & rieke ( 1995 ) , these problems of surface brightness bias , saturation , and inadequate knowledge of the large - angle properties of the true wfpc2 psf , can explain much of the confusion produced by the first studies of quasar hosts undertaken after the correction of the hst optics with costar ( e.g. bahcall , kirhakos & schneider 1994 ) .
in this paper we present the final results from our 34-orbit cycle-6 imaging study of quasar hosts , which was carefully designed to avoid these problems .
specifically , we acquired images of each quasar spanning a wide range of integration times ( to allow an unsaturated , high dynamic - range image of each object to be constructed ) and devoted an entire orbit to the construction of the necessary high dynamic - range psf ( via observations of a star of similar colour to the quasar nuclei , imaged at the same location on the same wf chip ) .
results from the first half of this programme were reported in mclure et al .
( 1999 ) , where images for 19 objects from our 33-source sample were presented , modelled and analyzed . here
we present and model the images for the 14 targets which were observed in the latter half of 1998 and in 1999 , and then summarize and discuss the results derived from the analysis of the completed sample .
the results presented in this paper thus complete , extend and in several cases supercede those presented in mclure et al .
( 1999 ) ( e.g. estimated black - hole masses for all objects are now calculated using more recent estimates of the black - hole : spheroid mass relation , yielding significantly lower values than were calculated by mclure et al . based on the relation presented by magorrian et al .
( 1998 ) ) .
several other substantial studies of low - redshift quasar hosts have now been undertaken with the hst ( e.g. bahcall , kirkhados & schneider 1997 ; hooper , impey & foltz 1997 ; boyce et al .
1998 , mcleod & mcleod 2001 ) .
however , one unique feature of the present study is the deliberate focus on a comparison of the hosts of the three main classes of powerful agn , namely radio - quiet quasars ( rqqs ) , radio - loud quasars ( rlqs ) and radio galaxies ( rgs ) .
moreover , we have ensured that this comparison can be performed in an unbiassed manner by confining our sample to a narrow range in redshift ( @xmath17 ) and requiring that the individual sub - samples are matched in terms of their luminosity distributions ( optical luminosity in the case of the rqq and rlq sub - samples , and radio luminosity in the case of the rlq and rg sub - samples - see dunlop et al .
( 1993 ) , mclure et al .
( 1999 ) and section 2 for further details ) .
another strength of this study is the wealth of pre - existing data at other wavelengths , as detailed in section 2 .
this has allowed us to maximise the impact of the hst imaging ( through , for example , the determination of @xmath18 colours for all the host galaxies ) .
finally it is worth emphasizing that in this study we have sought to extract the properties of the stellar population which dominates the mass of the host galaxy .
thus , while we do include a statistical analysis of the prevalence of peculiar features such as tidal tails , we have endevoured to minimize the distorting effect of the more transient activity by insisting on line - free imaging longward of the 4000 break , and masking out obvious assymmetries prior to modelling the host morphology .
this approach , coupled with the careful design of our observations , is the most likely explanation for why the results presented in this paper are generally cleaner , and more homogenous than the results of many other recent studies .
the layout of this paper is as follows . in section 2
we review the main properties of the matched rg , rlq and rqq samples , and summarize the wealth of supporting ground - based multi - frequency data which now exists for these objects . in section 3
we give details of the hst observations and briefly review the process of data reduction and psf determination ( mclure et al .
1999 ; mclure , dunlop & kukula 2000 ) .
then , in section 4 we give a brief description of the new vla observations of the rqqs in our sample which escaped previous radio detection by kukula et al .
( 1998 ) , and present new 5 ghz flux densities and positions . in section 5
we present the new hst data and briefly summarize the approach taken to modelling the wfpc2 images ; the images and 2-dimensional model fits for the 14 new objects are provided in appendix a ( along with brief notes on each source ) , with observed and fitted luminosity profiles presented in appendix b. next , in section 6 we analyze the results of modelling the hst images of the complete sample , and assess the implications of our results for unified models of agn . in section 7
we explore how quasar hosts relate to the general population of massive galaxies , and demonstrate via the kormendy relation that the quasar hosts are drawn from the population of massive ` boxy ' ellipticals which are found predominantly in cluster environments .
we also include a comparison of the environments and interaction statistics for quasar hosts and brightest cluster galaxies . in section 8
we exploit our results to investigate the properties of the central engines which power these luminous agn , deriving estimates of black - hole mass and eddington ratio , and exploring possible clues to the origin of radio - loudness .
finally , in section 9 we briefly discuss the implications of our results for the cosmological evolution of quasars and massive galaxies .
our conclusions are summarized in section 10 .
for ease of comparison with previous work we adopt an einstein - de sitter universe with @xmath19 for the calculation of physical quantities throughout this paper .
the hst imaging observations reported here complete the imaging of the full sample of 33 objects ( 10 rlqs , 13 rqqs and 10 rgs ) defined for this study .
this sample was selected from the slightly larger ( 40-source ) sample imaged in the infrared by dunlop et al .
( 1993 ) and taylor et al .
( 1996 ) through the imposition of the slightly more restrictive redshift limits @xmath17 .
as described in mclure et al .
( 1999 ) , this restriction in redshift range ensures that our @xmath0-band imaging through the f675w filter is not contaminated by the presence of strong emission lines such as [ oiii ] , or h@xmath20 . the main effect of this additional redshift restriction is to exclude a small number of objects from the original sample of dunlop et al .
( 1993 ) which have @xmath21 .
however , this has not significantly compromised the original statistical merits of this sample , namely that the rlq and rqq sub - samples are matched in terms of optical luminosity , and that the rlq and rg samples are matched in terms of radio luminosity and radio spectral index ( dunlop et al .
1993 ) . of the 33 sources in this sample ,
19 were observed during the first year of our cycle 6 allocation .
the observations and analysis of these objects were presented by mclure et al .
the remaining 14 objects for which the observations are presented and analyzed in this paper are listed in table 1 , along with the dates on which they were observed with the hst . also included in this paper are new , deep vla observations of a subset of our rqq sample .
these 4.8 ghz observations , the results of which are presented in section 4 , go a factor of 3 deeper than the observations of kukula et al .
( 1998 ) which were utilised by mclure et al .
the important outcome of these observations is that we have now detected all but one of the rqqs in this sample at radio wavelengths .
these new radio detections , coupled with completion of the hst observations , have allowed us to re - investigate and clarify a number of the relations between optical and radio properties which could only be tentatively explored by mclure et al .
( 1999 ) . .observing dates for the objects presented in this paper .
note that , despite its archive designation as 3c59 , 0204@xmath22292 is in fact now classified as an rqq ( see taylor et al .
1996 , and the radio luminosity quoted in table 3 ) .
[ cols="<,<,^ , < " , ] [ tab1 ] beyond confirming the basic plausibility of the black - hole mass estimates , the most interesting result contained in fig 13 is that , as suggested by the initial results of mclure et al .
( 1999 ) , the black - hole masses in the radio - loud quasars are systematically larger than in their radio - quiet counterparts . in terms of summary statistics of central tendency ,
this difference , although clear , might not appear very dramatic specifically , excluding the two low - luminosity rqqs : @xmath23 = median = 1.3 = ( rg ) + @xmath24 median = 1.4 ( rlq ) + @xmath25 median = 0.8 ( rqq ) however , the difference becomes more striking when one notices that there is an apparent threshold mass of @xmath26 _ above _ which lie 8/10 rgs and 10/10 rlqs , but _ below _ which lie 9/13 of the rqqs . in other words , using the black - hole mass estimation procedure outlined above , at least within this particular sample it appears that a black - hole mass @xmath27 is a necessary ( albeit perhaps not sufficient ) condition for the production of a powerful radio source . as measured via the ks test
, this difference between the black - hole mass distributions of the radio - loud and radio - quiet subsamples is significant at the 3-@xmath28 level , a significance which must be taken seriously given the almost perfect matching of the distributions of nuclear optical output demonstrated in fig 4 .
further support for its reality comes from the @xmath29 study by mclure & dunlop ( 2001 ) already referred to above , in which it was found that 11/13 rlqs had @xmath30 while only 4/18 rqqs had black - hole masses above this threshold .
a similar conclusion was also reached by laor ( 2000 ) from a study of the virial masses of pg quasars .
an inevitable consequence of the matching of nuclear optical luminosities demonstrated in fig 4 , and the systematic offset in black - hole mass described above is that , on average , the black holes at the heart of the rqqs in our sample must , on average , be emitting more efficiently than their radio - loud counterparts .
this is quantified in the last two columns of table 9 which give estimated eddington luminosity ( converted to @xmath0-band absolute magnitude ) and then emitting efficiency @xmath31 .
the potential @xmath32band eddington luminosity of each quasar was derived in the following manner .
initially , the host - galaxy bulge luminosities provided by the two - dimensional modelling were converted into a spheroidal mass estimate using the j@xmath33rgensen et al .
mass - to - light ratio ( eqn 7 ) .
the linear relation between black - hole mass and spheroidal mass ( eqn 8) was then used to estimate the central black - hole mass and resulting bolometric eddington luminosity of each quasar . to calculate the corresponding @xmath32band magnitudes it was assumed that
, on average , the bolometric luminosity of a quasar can be estimated via @xmath34 ( laor et al .
1997 ) , where @xmath35 is the absolute monochromatic luminosity at 5100 .
the resulting estimate of the absolute luminosity at 5100 was then transformed to the central wavelength of the @xmath32 filter ( 6500 ) assuming a power - law quasar spectrum ( @xmath36 ) .
using this prescription , a quasar with a central black - hole mass of @xmath37 will have an eddington - limit absolute @xmath32band magnitude of @xmath38
. observed nuclear @xmath39 is plotted against potential eddington - limited @xmath39 in fig 14 .
as can be seen from this figure , the maximum luminosity produced by any quasar is within a factor of two of the predicted eddington limit , while the majority appear to be radiating at @xmath40 of the eddington luminosity . taken as a group there is a suggestion that the rqqs are radiating at a higher percentage of the eddington limit , but the difference is not formally significant ( ks , @xmath41 ) .
when the matched samples of rlqs and rqqs were first defined , all that was known about the radio properties of the rqqs was that their 5 ghz luminosities were lower than @xmath42 ( dunlop et al . 1993 ) . however , with the completion of the vla detection programme described in section 4 we can now explore how the radio properties of _ all _ the agn in our combined sample relate to their estimated black - hole masses . in fig 15 total radio luminosity , @xmath43 ,
is plotted against estimated black - hole mass for all the objects in our combined sample ( with the single exception of 1549@xmath22203 , which was not observed with the vla to the same depth as the other objects ) .
also included in this diagram are the appropriate points for 8 nearby galaxies taken from franceschini et al .
( 1998 ) , with the milky way and m87 highlighted .
several significant trends are evident in this diagram .
first it can be seen that , within the rqq sample , radio luminosity correlates , albeit weakly , with black - hole mass , although our sample does nt span a wide dynamic range and the correlation is not formally significant . second , and perhaps more interestingly , the rqqs are consistent with the locus described by the nearby galaxies ( for which , of course , the black - hole masses are based directly on stellar dynamics ) .
this simultaneously reinforces the plausibility of our black - hole mass estimates , and suggests a common physical origin for the radio emission from rqqs and nearby optically more - quiescent bulges .
whatever this physical mechanism is , it must explain the observed strong dependence of minimum radio output on black - hole mass , in which the power - law index @xmath44 is at least 2 ( adopting @xmath45 ) . as noted by franceschini et al .
( 1998 ) , @xmath46 is the prediction of adaf models , while @xmath47 is a generic prediction of any mechanism in which radio output is proportional to the area of the accretion disc .
our results therefore provide further support for previous claims that there is a minimum radio output from black holes and that this is a strong function of mass .
however , while this obviously implies that the most massive black holes can never be _ very _ radio - quiet , fig 15 graphically demonstrates that the genuine radio - loud objects lie on a quite distinct relation .
interestingly , our radio - loud sample also displays an ( albeit weak ) internal correlation between @xmath43 and estimated black - hole mass .
either this relationship must be much steeper ( @xmath48 ) than the minimum radio - output relation , or , as illustrated in fig 15 , the black - hole mass dependence of the upper envelope may be consistent with that of the lower envelope but offset by several orders of magnitude .
in fact the findings of lacy et al .
( 2001 ) strongly favour the latter option .
they report a relationship between the logarithm of radio power and black - hole mass which has a slope of @xmath49 .
however , inspection of their fig 2 shows that their data are also consistent with an upper and lower envelope with slope @xmath50 as illustrated here in fig 15 . we note here that it has recently been claimed by oshlack , webster & whiting ( 2001 ) that the radio - loud seyfert galaxy pks 2004@xmath51447 contradicts the existence of such an envelope , and shows that relatively low - mass black holes can produce a powerful radio source .
however , this claim is based on their black - hole mass estimate for this object of @xmath52 and it seems almost certain that this value , derived from the relatively narrow emission lines displayed by pks 2004@xmath51447 , is a serious under - estimate of the true mass .
the reason for this is that since this object displays optically variability and has a compact radio source , it seems very likely that its orbiting broad - line region lies close to plane of the sky .
in this situation ( as found in our own sample for , e.g. 1012@xmath22008 - see table 9 ) the black - hole mass derived from @xmath53 emission - line width can under - estimate the true value by a factor @xmath54 . in fig 15
we have plotted the position of pks 2004@xmath51447 after re - calculating its black - hole mass on the assumption that the orbital plane of its broad - line region is oriented within @xmath55 degrees of the plane of the sky ( see mclure & dunlop 2001 ) .
this increases the estimated black - hole mass to @xmath56 , and moves pks 2004@xmath51447 into complete consistency with the upper envelope delineated by the other available data .
we have not corrected the observed radio emission for doppler boosting - if we did then the this object would simply move downwards in fig 15 .
thus both our own results and other currently available data support the existence of both a lower and an upper envelope to the radio luminosity which can be produced by a black hole of given mass .
indeed fig 15 serves to provide an elegant explanation not only of our own findings , but also of several other well - known results in the literature .
first , because we selected our radio - loud objects on the basis that their radio luminosities were greater than @xmath57 , the form of the upper envelope in these figures can be seen to be perfectly consistent with our finding that virtually all our radio - loud objects have @xmath58 . in the context of this diagram this finding can be seen to be a result of our radio - selection criterion rather than the existence of some critical black - hole mass for the production of relativistic jets within a galaxy mass halo .
second , the steep dependence of this apparent upper envelope on black hole mass means that radio sources up to @xmath59 , consistent with the most luminous 3cr galaxies even at @xmath60 _ can _ be produced by black holes ( and hence hosts ) only a factor of 2 - 3 more massive , and most likely _ will _ be due to the steep high - mass slope of the black - hole mass function .
this provides a natural explanation of why radio galaxies spanning the top two orders of magnitude in radio power all appear to be giant ellipticals with stellar masses which agree to within a factor of @xmath61 ( jarvis et al .
2001 ) .
third , from fig 15 it can be seen that the properties of agn hosts will inevitably become more mixed if the radio - luminosity threshold is move down to , say , @xmath62 .
given the lower boundary in fig 15 , radio sources in this power range can still be produced by black holes as massive as @xmath63 living in giant ellipticals , but it is also clear that black holes with masses as low as 10@xmath64 are capable of producing detectable radio sources at this level . as demonstrated by the properties of the lower - luminosity objects in our own sample , and by the studies of ` normal ' galaxies at low redshift , such black holes can be housed in disc - dominated galaxies as well as discless lower - mass spheroids .
while the broad dependence of radio luminosity on black - hole mass may explain the relative numbers of radio - quiet and radio - loud objects , it is also clear from fig 15 that black hole mass can not be invoked to explain the _ range _ of radio luminosities displayed by quasars of very similar optical luminosity .
specifically it is clear from this figure that objects powered by equally massive black holes can differ in radio luminosity by @xmath65 orders of magnitude .
interestingly fig 15 also allows us to rule out the possibility that the radio output of a black hole of given mass is driven simply by fuel supply .
this is because , while it has long been known that rqqs are not radio silent , it can be seen from fig 15 that several of the rqqs in our sample are in fact as radio - silent as they could possibly be , given their estimated black - hole masses . in other words
at least some of the black holes in rqqs produce as little radio output as their counterparts in completely quiescent nearby galaxies , despite the fact that black holes in quasars are clearly in receipt of sufficient fuel to produce powerful _ optical _ emission .
thus , while the results of this study can not by themselves provide a definitive answer to the long standing question of the origin of radio loudness , they can be used to focus the argument by excluding several possible explanations . in summary ,
our results can be used to exclude host galaxy morphology , black - hole mass , or black hole fueling rate as the primary physical cause of radio loudness .
we are thus forced to the conclusion that the production of powerful relativistic radio jets is driven by some other property of the black hole itself , the most likely candidate being black - hole spin ( e.g. blandford 2000 , wilson & colbert 1995 ) . indeed , following the suggestion by blandford ( 2000 ) , we speculate that the evolutionary track followed by an activated black hole may manifest itself as a near vertical descent in fig 15 , with an active rapidly spinning hole appearing first as a powerful radio source close to the upper envelope in this diagram , and then descending towards the lower envelope as the spin energy of the hole
is exhausted .
one interesting aspect of the different black - hole mass thresholds for rqqs and rlqs uncovered by this study is that this difference of a factor of 2 in minimum black - hole mass provides a natural explanation of why radio - quiet quasars outnumber their radio - loud counterparts by a factor of @xmath16 ( and why this factor may reduce with increasing optical luminosity ; hooper et al .
1995 , goldschmidt et al .
1999 ) .
this is because if our black - hole mass thresholds of @xmath66 for rqqs , and @xmath67 @xmath68 for radio - loud objects are converted back into absolute spheroid magnitudes in the @xmath69-band ( using the absolute @xmath0-band magnitudes given in table 4 , and then converting into @xmath69 adopting @xmath70 as justified by the results in section 6.6 ) we find that rqqs can be hosted by spheroids with @xmath71 while radio - loud objects require a host spheroid with @xmath72 . with reference to the @xmath69-band luminosity function
these absolute magnitude limits correspond to @xmath73 and @xmath74 respectively ( gardner et al .
1997 , szolkoly et al .
1998 , kochanek et al .
2001 ) which leads to the prediction that , in the present day universe there are @xmath75 galaxies per @xmath76 capable of hosting an rqq brighter than @xmath77 , but only @xmath78 galaxies per @xmath76 are capable of hosting an rlq .
this means that , assuming low - redshift quasars arise from a randomly - triggered subset of massive black - holes in spheroids , the factor of two difference in black - hole mass threshold translates into a factor of 10 difference in the number density of rqqs and rlqs due simply to the steepness of the bright end of the spheroid luminosity function .
we can go further and use the above numbers to estimate the activation fraction for massive black holes in the local universe .
first we note that the radio - loud objects in our sample have @xmath80 ( assuming a spectral index @xmath81 ) .
reference to the local radio luminosity function in dunlop & peacock ( 1990 ) , or to the more recent determination at 1.4 ghz from the 2df by sadler et al .
( 2001 ) , indicates that the present - day number density of radio sources above this threshold is @xmath82 .
thus , in the present - day universe we find that 1 in every 1000 black holes more massive than @xmath83 @xmath68 ( or equivalently spheroids more luminous than @xmath84 ) is radio active in the present - day universe . turning to the rqq population
, the present - day number density of quasars with @xmath85 can be estimated by extrapolating the qso olf deduced at @xmath86 by boyle et al .
( 2000 ) back to @xmath87 assuming luminosity evolution @xmath88 .
this produces an estimated number density of @xmath89 @xmath90 , which is at least consistent with the direct determination of the low-@xmath91 olf attempted by londish , boyle & schade ( 2000 ) . boosting this number by a factor of two to allow for obscured quasars ( i.e. adopting an opening angle of @xmath92 for consistency with the correction factor which appears to apply to the radio - loud population ) then leads to the conclusion that 1 in every 1000 black holes more massive than @xmath93 @xmath68 ( or equivalently spheroids more luminous than @xmath94 ) is producing quasar - level optical activity .
thus both these comparisons yield the same result , namely that in the present - day ( @xmath12 ) universe 1 in every 1000 massive black holes is active , and that the reason rqqs outnumber rlqs by a factor of 10 is a direct result of the fact that their respective minimum black - hole masses differ by a factor of two .
we note here that wisotzki , kuhlbrodt & jahnke ( 2001 ) have recently concluded that the present - day black - hole activation fraction is 1 in 10000 , or 1 in 5000 if the quasar lf is boosted by a factor of two as assumed above .
however , reference to their fig 2 shows that this factor results from adopting the spheroid luminosity function of lin et al .
if instead wisotzki et al . were to adopt the kochanek et al .
( 2001 ) luminosity function then it is clear that ( at least for the mass range probed by the present study ) wisotzki et al.s analysis would also yield an activation fraction of 0.1% . at the peak epoch of quasar activity between @xmath96 and @xmath97 ,
the co - moving number density of powerful radio sources with @xmath80 has risen to @xmath98 @xmath90 ( dunlop & peacock 1990 ) while that of optically - selected quasars brighter than @xmath77 is @xmath99 @xmath90 ( warren , hewett & osmer 1995 , boyle et al .
2000 ) . doubling the latter figure to make the same correction for obscured rqqs as applied in the previous subsection at low redshift , leads to the conclusion that ,
as at @xmath100 , rqqs at @xmath101 outnumber their radio - loud counterparts by a factor of @xmath16 .
however , at @xmath101 the co - moving number density of both classes of object is enhanced by a factor of 100 , giving an activation fraction of massive black holes of @xmath16% , assuming that the entire massive black - hole population is in place by that epoch .
a renewed attempt to model the cosmological evolution of agn in the light of our host - galaxy results is obviously beyond the scope of this paper .
however , if one assumes that the same mass thresholds uncovered in our low - redshift study apply at high redshift , then one simple interpretation of the dramatic ( and very similar ) evolution of radio - loud and radio - quiet agn between @xmath101 and the present - day is that it is primarily due to density evolution , with the active fraction of massive black holes dropping from 10% to 0.1% over this period .
there must of course also be an element of luminosity evolution because pure density evolution was excluded long ago as an acceptable representation of the evolving rlf or olf .
however , as suggested by miller , percival & lambert ( in preparation ) if individual quasars produce declining light curves it is inevitable that a larger fraction will be observed closer to peak luminosity as the activation rate rises , and fig 14 indicates that at least some of the host galaxies uncovered in the present study should be capable of producing quasars with @xmath102 if observed while accreting at the eddington limit .
one prediction of this scenario is that , as a larger fraction of massive black holes become more efficiently fueled , the apparent mass difference between rlq and rqq hosts should grow with increasing redshift .
the reason for this is that , if fueling rates are , on average , somewhat higher at high redshift we can expect optically selected qsos of a given luminosity to be produced by black holes with , on average , lower masses than at low redshift .
however , if the @xmath103 mass threshold for powerful radio activity found in this study continues to apply at high redshift , then radio selection will continue to yield only the most massive black holes residing ( presumably ) in the most massive spheroids .
in fact , studies of the hosts of rlqs and rqqs out to @xmath96 are already uncovering evidence of just such a trend .
specifically , kukula et al .
( 2001 ) have used nicmos on the hst to measure the rest - frame @xmath0-band luminosities of the hosts of matched samples of rlqs and rqqs at @xmath104 and @xmath96 .
kukula et al .
find that the hosts of rlqs are essentially unchanged in mass over this redshift range , suggesting that the minimum mass threshold for powerful radio emission indicated by the upper locus in fig 15 applies at all redshifts and is therefore of physical significance .
however , they also find that the average ratio of rlq : rqq host luminosity rises from the value of @xmath105 found here at @xmath106 , to @xmath61 at @xmath104 , and @xmath107 at @xmath96 , suggesting a progressive drop in the average mass of rqq hosts with increasing redshift , a finding supported by the results of other recent studies ( ridgway et al .
2000 , rix et al .
in this paper we have reported the extensive results which follow from completion of our hst imaging programme of the host galaxies of low - redshift radio - quiet quasars , radio - loud quasars , and radio galaxies .
this paper represents the completion of a programme which has spanned most of the last decade , commencing with the deep infrared imaging of the same sample of objects by dunlop et al .
the depth and quality of our hst data have now allowed us to determine accurately all the basic structural parameters of the hosts of these 3 classes of powerful agn .
because of this , and because of the wealth of data now available for this sample at other wavelengths ( including the new deep vla observations also reported here ) , we have been able to address a wide range of issues of which are hopefully of interest to workers in several different areas of extra - galactic research .
consequently we conclude with a detailed summary of the main conclusions of this study , structured to assist the interested reader in moving directly to the sections which may be of most relevance to their own work . from the detailed 2-dimensional modelling of the new hst images presented here in combination with the data reported by mclure et al .
( 1999 ) we find that ( as detailed in sections 5 and 6 ) : * all except the two least luminous rqqs in the sample have bulge - dominated hosts , and in only 2 of the remaining 31 objects ( the rqqs 0052 + 251 and 0157 + 001 ) can we find any evidence for a significant disc component .
thus both radio - loud and radio - quiet quasars live , almost universally , in elliptical galaxies . *
the hosts of all three classes of powerful agn are luminous galaxies with @xmath9 , and almost always @xmath108 .
the average luminosities of the rg and rlq hosts are essentially identical ( consistent with radio - loud unification ) , and equivalent to @xmath109 .
the average luminosity of the rqq hosts is somewhat smaller , equivalent to @xmath110 . *
the hosts of all three classes of powerful agn are large galaxies with typical half - light radii @xmath111 kpc . as with the luminosities , the average values of host - galaxy scale - length for the radio - loud sub - samples are indistinguishable , while the hosts of the rqqs are typically smaller by a modest factor ( @xmath112 ) . * the hosts of all three classes of powerful agn display a surface - brightness scalelength ( kormendy ) relation identical ( in both slope and normalization ) to that displayed by inactive
massive ellipticals predominantly found in clusters .
* the hosts of all three classes of powerful agn display a distribution of axial ratio which is indistinguishable to that which has been long established for normal elliptical galaxies . from a joint analysis of the hst optical images with existing @xmath69-band images of the same sample ( dunlop et al .
1993 , taylor et al .
1996 , mclure , dunlop & kukula 2000 ) we find that ( as detailed in subsections 6.6 and 6.7 ) : * the hosts of all three classes of powerful agn are red galaxies , with typical rest - frame optical - infrared colours @xmath113 .
consistent with the results of nolan et al .
( 2001 ) , these colours are as expected from an evolved stellar population of age @xmath114 gyr , indicating that , as for quiescent massive ellipticals , the stellar mass of an agn host galaxy is dominated by a well - evolved stellar population formed at high redshift ( @xmath115 ) . * the optical - infrared colours of the rqq and rlq nuclei are statistically indistinguishable , and lie in the range @xmath116 . for the rg nuclei ,
the relation between @xmath18 colour and @xmath0-band luminosity is as expected under the assumption that they all contain obscured nuclei with intrinsic optical luminosities comparable to the quasars , reddened by dust with @xmath117 .
this result strongly favours unification of rgs and rlqs via orientation rather than time . from a comparison of our results with those derived from recent studies of the ` normal ' massive galaxy population , and of low - redshift ulirgs and seyferts
, we find that ( as detailed in section 7 ) : * the bulge : disc ratio of agn hosts is a function of agn luminosity , with disc - dominated hosts dying out above the traditional quasar : seyfert boundary at @xmath118 . * in contrast to ulirgs , quasar hosts lie in a region of the fundamental plane ( as judged from the photometric projection of the fp offered by the kormendy relation ) which has been shown to be occupied by the most massive and apparently old population of ellipticals which display ` boxy ' isophotes and distinct kinematic cores .
this provides a strong argument against the possibility that the @xmath10-law luminosity profiles displayed by the vast majority of the quasar hosts in our sample are the result of recent mergers between massive disc galaxies .
this result also offers little support for a strong evolutionary connection between ulirgs and quasars in the low - redshift universe . * the basic structural properties of agn hosts are indistinguishable from those of inactive brightest cluster galaxies .
consistent with the environmental study of mclure & dunlop ( 2000 ) , the largest host galaxies in our sample are of comparable mass to the bcgs found at the heart of abell class 1 or class 2 clusters .
however , the lack of any host galaxies as massive as an abell class 4 cluster bcg is as expected given the relative rarity of such rich environments .
all the evidence considered is consistent with the agn hosts being drawn , essentially at random , from the present - day massive - elliptical galaxy population .
* there is no statistically - significant evidence that agn hosts display more signs of large ( kpc ) scale disturbance , or multiple nuclei than normal comparably - massive quiescent ellipticals . combining our hst data with our new vla data , and utilising recent results on the black - hole : spheroid mass relation in both quiescent and active galaxies
, we find that ( as detailed in section 8) : * estimates of central black - hole mass for the quasars in our sample based on host - galaxy spheroid luminosity agree well with those derived from @xmath53 emission - line width by mclure & dunlop ( 2001 ) . for three objects
the latter technique yields a much lower value , but this is as expected for a small subset of objects if the broad - line region has a predominantly disc - like structure . * based on the relation @xmath119 , we find that all the quasars in our sample are powered by a black - hole of mass @xmath120 , but that the radio - loud objects lie above an even higher mass threshold , with @xmath121 . *
the most efficient rqq in our sample appears to be radiating at @xmath122% of the eddington limit , but the vast majority of these low - redshift agn are emitting at @xmath123% of the eddington limit .
based on these calculations , the most massive objects in this low - redshift sample appear capable ( if fuelled at maximum efficiency ) of producing quasars with @xmath102 , comparable to the most luminous objects known at high redshift . *
the black - hole mass difference between rlqs and rqqs reflects the existence an apparent upper and lower limit to the radio output that can be produced by a black hole of a given mass .
both the upper and lower thresholds on radio luminosity appear to be a strong function of black mass ( @xmath124 ) .
at least some rqqs in our sample appear to be as radio - weak as ` normal ' inactive comparably - massive spheroids found in the low - redshift universe , despite the fact that must be receiving sufficient fuel to power the optical quasar nucleus . * while there is a broad and clear trend for increasing radio luminosity with increasing black - hole mass , it is now clear that host morphology , black - hole mass , and fuel supply can each be excluded as the primary physical explanation of why a subset of quasars are up to 4 orders of magnitude more radio luminous than their ` radio - quiet ' counterparts
. consequently we argue that black - hole spin is the most plausible ( perhaps only ) remaining feasible explanation for the production of a powerful radio source . considering the implications of our results for our understanding of the nature and evolution of agn populations as a function of redshift
, we find that ( as detailed in section 9 ) : * the relative numbers of radio - loud and radio - quiet quasars can be naturally explained by the above - mentioned mass thresholds , combined with the form of the bright end of the elliptical galaxy luminosity function .
* the activation fraction of massive black holes is @xmath6% in the present - day universe , rising to @xmath16% at @xmath125 , corresponding to the peak epoch of quasar activity in the universe . * the black - hole mass threshold for powerful radio activity can explain the trend for a growing gap with increasing redshift between the masses of rlq hosts and rqq hosts uncovered by recent hst - based studies of high redshift quasars .
based on observations with the nasa / esa _ hubble space telescope _ , obtained at the space telescope science institute , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy , inc . under nasa contract
james dunlop , ross mclure and marek kukula all acknowledge the support of pparc through the awards of a senior fellowship , a personal fellowship and a pdra position respectively .
marek kukula also acknowledges support for this work provided by the space telescope science institute under grant numbers 00548 & 00573 . 93 abraham r.g .
, crawford c.s . ,
mchardy i.m . , 1992 ,
apj , 401 , 474 bahcall j.n . , kirhakos s. , schneider d.p . , 1994 ,
apj , 435 , l11 bahcall j.n . , kirhakos s. , saxe d.h . , schneider d.p . , 1997 ,
apj 479 , 642 barnes j.e . , hernquist l. , 1992 , ara&a , 30 , 705 barthel p.d . , 1989 , apj , 336 , 606 blandford r.d . ,
ptrsa , in press ( astro - ph/0001499 ) boyce p. j. , et al . , 1998 , mnras , 298 , 121 boyle b.j .
, shanks t. , croom s.m . , smith r.j . , miller l. , loaring n. , heymans c. , 2000 , mnras , 317 , 1014 brinkmann w. , yuan w. , siebert j. , 1997 , a&a , 319 , 413 canalizo g. , stockton a. , 1997 , apj , 480 , l5 capaccioli m. , caon n. , donofrio m. , 1992 , mnras , 259 , 323 crawford c.s . , fabian a.c . , 1995 , mnras , 273 , 827 croft r.a.c . , dalton g.b
, efstathiou g. , sutherland w.j . ,
maddox s.j . , 1997 , mnras , 291 , 305 de koff s. , et al . , 1996 , apjs , 107 , 621 de vries w.h . , odea c.p . ,
barthel p.d .
, fanti c. , fanti r. , lehnert m.d .
, 2000 , aj , 120 , 2300 disney m.j . ,
et al . 1995 , nature , 376 , 150 dunlop j.s .
, peacock j.a . , 1990 , mnras , 247 , 19 dunlop j.s . ,
taylor g. l. , hughes d. h. , robson e. i. , 1993 , mnras , 264 , 455 faber s.m . , et al . , 1997 , aj , 114 , 1771 fabian a.c . , 1999 ,
mnras , 308 , l39 franceschini a. , vercellone s. , fabian a.c . , 1998 , mnras , 297 , 817 franceschini , a. , hasinger g. , miyaji t. , malquori d. , 1999 , mnras , 310 , l5 fukugita m. , shimasaku k. , ichikawa t. , 1995 , pasp , 107 , 945 gardner j.p .
, sharples r.m . ,
frenk c.s .
, carrasco b.e . , 1997 ,
apjl , 480 , l99 gebhardt k. , bender r. , bower g. , dressler a. , faber s.m . ,
filippenko a.v . , green r. , grillmair c. , ho l.c .
, kormendy j. , lauer t.r . , magorrian j. , pinkney j. , richstone d. , tremaine s. , 2000 , apj , 539 , l13 genzel r. , tacconi l.j .
, rigopoulou d. , lutz d. , tecza m. , 2001 , apj , 563 , 527 goldschmidt p. , kukula m.j . , miller l. , dunlop j.s . , 1999 ,
apj , 511 , 612 granato g.l . , silva l. , monaco p. , panuzzo p. , salucci p. , de zotti g. , danese l. , 2001 , mnras , 324 , 757 haehnelt m.g . , rees m.j . , 1993 , mnras , 263 , 168 hamabe m. , kormendy j. , 1987 , iaus , 127 , 379 hamilton t.s . , casertano s. , turnshek d.a .
, 2002 , apj , 576 , 61 hoessel j.g .
, schneider d.p . , 1985 , apj , 480 , l95 holtzman j.a .
, et al . , 1995 , pasp , 107 , 1065 hooper e.j . ,
impey c.d . ,
foltz c.b . ,
hewett p.c . , 1995 ,
apj , 445 , 62 hooper e.j . ,
impey c.d . ,
foltz c.b . , 1997 ,
apj , 480 , l95 hughes d.h .
, kukula m.j . , dunlop j.s . , boroson t. , 2000 , mnras , 316 , 204 hunt l.k . , malkan m.a . , rush b. , bicay m.d . , nelson b.o
, stanga r.m . , webb w. , 1999 , apjs , 125 , 349 hutchings j.b . ,
neff s.g . , 1992 ,
aj , 104 , 1 hutchings j.b . ,
neff s.g . , 1997 ,
aj , 113 , 550 jarvis m.j . , rawlings s. , eales s. , blundell k.m . , willott c.j . , 2001 , in :
qso hosts and their environments _ , p.333 , eds .
marquez , i. et al .
kluwer ( astro - ph/0103364 ) jorgensen i. , franx m. , kjaergaard p. , 1996 ,
mnras , 280 , 167 kauffmann g. , haehnelt m. , 2000 , mnras , 311 , 576 kirhakos s. , bahcall j.n . , schneider d.p . , kristian j. , 1999 , apj , 520 , 67 kochanek c.s . , pahre m.a . , falco e.e
, huchra j.p . , mader j. , jarrett t.h . , chester t. , cutri r. , schneider s.e . , 2001 , apj , 560 , 566 kormendy j. , 1977 , apj , 217 , 406 kormendy j. , bender r. , 1996 , apj , 464 , l119 kormendy j. , gebhardt k. , 2001 , in _ 20th texas symp . on relativistic astrophysics _ , p.363 , eds . h. martel & j.c .
wheeler , aip ( astro - ph/0105230 ) kukula m.j .
, dunlop j.s . , hughes d.h . ,
rawlings s. , 1998 , mnras , 297 , 366 kukula m.j . , dunlop j.s . ,
mclure r.j . , miller l. , percival w.j . , baum s.a . ,
odea c.p . , 2001 , mnras , 326 , 1533 lacy m. , laurent - muehleisen s.a .
, ridgway s.e . ,
becker r.h . ,
white r.l . , 2001 , apjl , 551 , l17 laor a. , 2000 , apj , 543 , l111 laor a. , fiore f. , elvis m. , wilkes b.j .
, mcdowell j.c . , 1997 , apj , 477 , 93 lin h. , kirshner p.p .
, schectman s.a .
, landy s.d .
, oemler a. , tucker d.l .
, schechter p.l . , 1996 , apj , 464 , 60 lin h. , yee h.k.c . , carlberg r.g . ,
et al . , 1999 , apj , 518 , 533 londish d. , boyle b.j . ,
schade d.j . , 2000 , mnras , 318 , 411 magorrian j. , et al . , 1998 ,
aj , 115 , 2285 mccarthy p.j . , spinrad h. , van breugel w. , 1995 , apjs , 99 , 27 mcleod k.k . , mcleod b.a
. , 2001 , apj , 546 , 782 mcleod k.k . ,
rieke g.h . , 1994 ,
apj , 431 , 137 mcleod k.k . ,
rieke g.h . , 1995 ,
apj , 441 , 96 mclure r.j . ,
kukula m.j . , dunlop j.s . ,
, odea c.p .
, hughes d.h . , 1999 ,
mnras , 308 , 377 mclure r.j . , dunlop j.s . ,
2000 , mnras , 317 , 249 mclure r.j .
, dunlop j.s . , 2001 , mnras , 327 , 199 mclure r.j .
, dunlop j.s . , 2002 , mnras , 331 , 795 mclure r.j . , dunlop j.s . , kukula m.j . , 2000 , mnras , 318 , 693 merritt d. , ferrarese l. , 2001 , mnras , 320 , l30 nolan l.a . , dunlop j.s . ,
kukula m.j .
, hughes d.h . , boroson t. , jimenez r. , 2001 , mnras , 323 , 308 oshlack a.y.k.n . , wenster r.l . ,
whiting , m.t . , 2001 ,
apj , 558 , 578 peacock j.a . , 1987 , in : _ astrophysics jets and their engines _ ,
p.185 , ed .
kundt w. , reidel prestage r.m .
, peacock j.a . , 1988 , mnras , 230 , 131 ridgway s. , heckman t. , calzetti d. , lehnert m. , 2001 , apj , 550 , 122 rix h .- w . , falco e. , impey c. , kochanek c. , lehar j. , mcleod b. , munoz j. , peng c. , 2001 , in : _ gravitational lensing : recent progress and future go _ , asp conf
237 , p.169 , eds .
brainerd t.g . ,
kochanek c.s . , asp ( astro - ph/9910190 ) ryden s. , 1992 , apj , 396 , 445 sandage a.r . ,
freeman k.c . ,
stokes n.r . , 1970 ,
apj , 268 , 831 sanders d.b . ,
mirabel i.f . , 1996 , ara&a , 34 , 749 schade d. , boyle b.j . , letawsky m. , 2000 , mnras , 315 , 498 scoville n.z .
, evans a.s .
, thompson r. , rieke m. , hines d.c .
, low f.j . , dinshaw n. , surace j.a .
, armus l. , 2000 , apj , 119 , 991 silk j. , rees m. , 1998 , a&a , 331 , l1 simpson c. , ward m. , wall j.v .
, 2000 , mnras , 319 , 963 small t.a .
, blandford r.d . , 1992 , mnras , 259 , 725 smith e.p . , heckman t.m . , 1990 , apj , 348 , 38 smith e.p . , heckman t.m .
, bothun g.d .
, romanishin w. , balick b. , 1986 , apj , 306 , 64 stocke j.t .
, et al . , 1983 , apj , 273 , 458 szokoly g.p . ,
subbarao m.u . ,
connoly a.j . ,
mobasher b. , 1998 , apj , 492 , 452 taylor g.l .
, dunlop j.s . , hughes d.h . ,
robson e.i . , 1996 , mnras , 283 , 930 trauger et al . , 1994 ,
apj , 435 , l3 urry c.m . , padovani p. , 1995 ,
pasp , 107 , 803 vron - cetty m. -p .
, woltjer l. , 1990 , a&a , 236 , 69 warren s.j . , hewett p.c . ,
osmer p.s . , 1995 ,
apj , 438 , 506 wilson a.s . ,
colbert e.j.m .
, 1995 , apj , 438 , 62 wisotzki l. , kuhlbrodt b. , jahnke k. , 2001 , in : _ qso hosts and their environments _ , p.83 , eds .
marquez , i. et al . ,
kluwer ( astro - ph/0103112 ) wright g.s .
, james p.a . ,
joseph r.d . ,
mclean i.s . , 1990 ,
nature , 344 , 417 yuan w. , brinkmann w. , siebert j. , voges w. , 1998 , a&a , 330 , 108
the images , two - dimensional model fits , and model subtracted images for the 14 agn for which the new hst data are reported in this paper are presented in this appendix in figs a1 to a14 . a grey - scale / contour image of the final reduced f675w @xmath0-band image of each agn
is shown in the top - left panel ( panel a ) of each figure , covering a region of 12.5 @xmath126 12.5 arcsec centred on the target source .
the surface - brightness level of the lowest contour is indicated in the top - right corner of this panel , and the grey - scale has been chosen to highlight structure close to this limit .
higher surface - brightness contours are spaced at intervals of 0.5 mag .
arcsec@xmath127 , and have been super - imposed to emphasize brighter structure in the centre of the galaxy / quasar .
panel b in each figure shows the best - fitting two - dimensional model , complete with the unresolved nuclear component ( after convolution with the empirical psf described above ) , contoured in a manner identical to panel a. panel c shows the best - fitting host galaxy as it would appear if the nuclear component were absent , while panel d is the residual image which results from subtraction of the full two - dimensional model ( in panel b ) from the raw @xmath0-band image ( in panel a ) , in order to highlight the presence of any morphological peculiarities such as tidal tails , interacting companion galaxies , or secondary nuclei . within each figure
, all four panels are displayed using the same greyscale .
here we provide a brief discussion of each of the 14 new hst images , with reference to other recent hst and ground - based data .
comparably - detailed descriptions of the other 19 objects in the sample can be found in mclure et al .
( 1999 ) and are not repeated here .
additional details on each object , along with a description of the main features of our @xmath69-band images , can be found in dunlop et al .
( 1993 ) and taylor et al .
the results of off - nuclear optical spectroscopy and resulting spectral model - fitting for several of the objects in this sample can be found in hughes et al .
( 2000 ) and nolan et al .
( 2001 ) . * 0230@xmath51027 * ( pks 0230@xmath51027 , od @xmath51050 ) the new @xmath0-band hst image shows this galaxy to be uniform and round with no sign of obvious distortion .
the detail of the wf2 image shown in fig a1 reveals @xmath16 apparent companion objects lying in a roughly circular formation around the galaxy , at a radius of @xmath128 kpc .
the brightest of these companions lies at a projected distance of @xmath129 kpc to the nw .
the full wf2 chip reveals there to be @xmath130 faint companion objects within a radius of @xmath131kpc . *
0307@xmath22169 * ( 3c 079 , 4c @xmath2216.07 ) the @xmath0-band image of this source shown in fig a2 reveals it to be a classic brightest - cluster galaxy ( bcg ) .
two bright companion objects can be seen to the north and south with three or four accompanying tidal arm features emanating from the central galaxy .
the suggestion that this source is in the process of undergoing merger activity is strengthened by the overlying contours which show three distinct cores .
the image of the full wf2 chip reveals several more bright companions within a radius of @xmath132 kpc .
this source has recently been imaged by the hst pc during the 3cr snapshot survey ( de koff et al .
1996 ) through the f702w ( wide @xmath0 ) filter . the 280-second integration presented by de koff et al . confirms the complex multiple structure of this object with the authors noting that the optical and radio axes are aligned to within @xmath133 .
mccarthy et al . ( 1995 ) imaged this source both in the @xmath0-band and through an @xmath134 emission - line filter , detecting a curving filament of extended @xmath134 emission stretching some 12@xmath135 to the nw .
* 1215@xmath51033 * ( pks 1215@xmath51033 ) the @xmath0-band image of this source shows it to be a uniform round galaxy with no obvious signs of interaction or disturbance .
there are two companion objects lying just on the edge of the detail shown in fig a3 , to the sw and ese at projected distances of @xmath136 kpc .
* 1215@xmath22013 * ( pks 1215 + 013 ) the @xmath0-band image of this source shown in fig a4 reveals numerous faint companion objects around the central galaxy , the brightest lying @xmath137 kpc to the south .
the overlying contours for this source suggest some sort of disturbance immediately to the north of the galaxy core .
* 1330@xmath22022 * ( 3c 287.1 , 4c @xmath2202.36 ) numerous companion objects are seen in the new @xmath0-band image of this source shown in fig a5 , the brightest of which can be seen some @xmath138 kpc to the ne .
there is a linear tidal feature @xmath139 kpc to the sw .
the overlying contours for this source show there to be an apparent second nucleus at less than @xmath140 separation to the wnw this object was in the sample imaged in the @xmath0-band during the 3cr snapshot survey ( de koff et al .
the 280-second image presented by de koff et al . confirms the presence of the second nucleus .
3c 287.1 has been shown to have a power - law x - ray spectrum by crawford & fabian ( 1995 ) .
* 1342@xmath51016 * ( pks 1342@xmath51016 , mrc 1342@xmath51016 ) the new hst image shows this galaxy to be large , luminous and uniform .
a bright foreground star is present @xmath141 to the sww , on the edge of the frame shown in fig a6 .
no obvious companion objects are present in the detail shown in fig a6 although the full wf2 chip image shown in fig 13 reveals there to be a large number of companion objects , consistent with a moderately rich cluster .
* 1020@xmath51103 * ( pks 1020@xmath51103 , ut 1020@xmath51103 ) the @xmath0-band image of this source shown in fig a7 reveals it to have a comparatively small and faint host , with an obvious pa of @xmath142 degrees .
there is a triangle of three faint companions directly to the south .
this object was identified as an x - ray source in the rosat all - sky survey ( brinkmann et al .
1997 ) .
* 1217@xmath22023 * ( pks 1217@xmath2202 , on 029 ) the @xmath0-band image of this relatively nuclear - dominated object shown in fig a8 clearly reveals an elliptical - looking host galaxy with an apparent pa of @xmath143 . there is a group of four faint apparent companion objects running north - south at a projected distance of @xmath144 kpc .
* 2135@xmath51147 * ( pks 2135@xmath5114 , phl 1657 ) the image of this source shown in fig a9 shows a large companion galaxy at a projected distance of @xmath137 kpc ese and an apparent close - in companion , or secondary nucleus , at a distance of @xmath145 kpc .
a recent analysis of the spectrum of the close - in companion by canalizo & stockton ( 1997 ) has shown that this object is actually a foreground star .
this object has also been imaged in the @xmath146-band with hst by bks .
their analysis also reveals the underlying host to be best matched by an elliptical galaxy model .
this quasar was identified as an x - ray source in the rosat all - sky survey ( brinkmann et al . 1997 ) .
* 2355@xmath51082 * ( pks 2355@xmath51082 , phl 6113 ) the new @xmath0-band hst image of this source in fig a10 reveals the presence of a apparently early - type host with a pa of @xmath147 . a group of five small companion objects can be seen to the ne .
this object was identified as an x - ray source in the rosat all - sky survey ( brinkmann et al .
1997 ) .
* 0052@xmath22251 * ( pg 0052@xmath22251 ) although not very obvious in the grey - scale representation used in fig a11 , the host galaxy of this quasar can be seen to have clear spiral structure in the raw @xmath0-band image .
there are two spiral arms present to the east and west of the nucleus with the eastern arm being more extended and apparently terminating in a companion object .
the overlying contours for this image reveal it to have a highly - luminous nuclear component .
this object has recently been imaged in the @xmath148-band by mcleod & rieke ( 1994 ) and in @xmath149- , @xmath148- and @xmath69-band by hutchings & neff ( 1997 ) .
hutchings & neff performed an analysis of the numbers , magnitudes and colours of the companion objects of this source , covering an angular extent comparable to the full wf2 image .
they identify some 22 companion objects brighter than @xmath150 , the vast majority of which have colours consistent with mature stellar populations . comparing their near - infrared images with previous optical studies , hutchings & neff note that there is no evidence for tidal structure made up of old stars , but conclude that the host is in a phase of secondary star formation possibly induced by interaction with one of the close group of companions .
0052 + 251 was also included in the @xmath146band hst imaging programme of bahcall , kirhakos & schneider , who list the host morphology as spiral and identify many of the knots seen in the eastern arm with hii regions .
interestingly bahcall , kirhakos & schneider comment that the inner regions of the surface - brightness profile of 0052 + 251 are well matched by an @xmath10 law , consistent with the best - fit elliptical host from the @xmath69-band imaging of taylor et al .
( 1996 ) , and suggestive that there may be a strong bulge component to the host galaxy .
this is of course precisely what we have found through the construction pf a combined disc+bulge model for the galaxy as detailed in section 5 .
despite the fact that the eye is drawn to the high surface - brightness spiral arms in the hst image , we find that in fact 70% of its total @xmath0-band light is contributed by the spheroidal component . finally , we note that this quasar has also been identified as an x - ray source in the rosat all - sky survey ( yuan et al .
1998 ) .
* 0204@xmath22292 * in the new @xmath0-band image of this quasar the host galaxy appears to be elliptical with a well - defined position angle of @xmath151 .
there are two companion objects on the sub - image shown in fig a12 , @xmath152 kpc to the wsw and @xmath153 to the nw respectively .
this quasar was identified as an x - ray source in the rosat all - sky survey ( yuan et al .
1998 ) .
* 1549@xmath22203 * ( lb 906 , 1e 15498@xmath22203 ) it is immediately obvious from the new @xmath0-band image of this object that the host galaxy is small , and relatively faint compared to the nuclear component . using a different grey - scale to that used in fig a13 , there is a suggestion of spiral - like features to the nw and se of the nucleus , with the se arm terminating at the apparent companion object which can be seen @xmath154 kpc to the e of the nucleus .
a large , luminous elliptical galaxy can just be seen on the edge of the frame to the sw , with numerous fainter companions visible inside a radius of @xmath136 kpc . the full wf2 image would appear to show numerous companion objects although , as pointed out by taylor et al .
1996 , the density of the environment of this quasar is uncertain due to the presence of a nearby foreground cluster at @xmath155 ( stocke et al . 1983 ) .
the first electronic images of this quasar were presented by hutchings & neff ( 1992 ) .
they imaged the object in both the @xmath146- and @xmath156-bands , detecting what looked like a bar structure running north - south through the nucleus , while noting that the surface - brightness profile of 1549 + 203 was not exponential .
this quasar was identified as an x - ray source in the rosat all - sky survey ( yuan et al 1998 ) .
* 2215@xmath51037 * ( ex 2215@xmath51037 ) the image of this quasar shown in fig a14 reveals the host to be compact and apparently undisturbed .
a small apparently unresolved companion is detected only @xmath145 kpc to the sw of the quasar nucleus .
a large elliptical galaxy can be seen some @xmath157 kpc to the north with a second apparently unresolved companion @xmath158 kpc to the east .
this object has been previously imaged on the hst pc using the f702w ( wide @xmath0 ) filter by disney et al .
( 1995 ) . using a two - dimensional cross - correlation modelling technique , disney et al . found the host galaxy to be excellently matched by an elliptical galaxy model .
their wide-@xmath0 image confirms the existence of the unresolved companion at @xmath159 separation from the nucleus and suggests that the environment of 2215@xmath51037 resembles a poor cluster .
this suggestion is supported by the image of the full wf2 chips which shows @xmath160 companion objects inside a radius of @xmath161 kpc .
this quasar was identified as an x - ray source in the rosat all - sky survey ( yuan et al .
in this appendix we provide the observed and best - fitting model luminosity profiles for 14 agn for which the new hst data are reported in this paper .
the profiles are followed out to a radius of 10@xmath162 , which is representative of the typical outer radius used in the image modelling . in each figure
the azimuthally averaged data are indicated by circles , the azimuthal average of the best - fitting 2-dimensional model is shown by the solid line , and the dotted line indicates the contribution made to the surface - brightness profile by the point - source component of the model ( after convolution with the psf ) . | we present the final results from our deep hst imaging study of the host galaxies of radio - quiet quasars ( rqqs ) , radio - loud quasars ( rlqs ) and radio galaxies ( rgs ) .
we describe and analyze new wfpc2 @xmath0-band observations for 14 objects which , when combined with the first tranche of hst imaging reported in mclure et al ( 1999 ) , provide a complete and consistent set of deep , red , line - free images for statistically - matched samples of 13 rqqs , 10 rlqs and 10 rgs in the redshift band @xmath1 .
we also report the results of new deep vla imaging which has yielded a 5 ghz detection of all but one of the 33 agn in our sample .
careful modelling of our images , aided by a high dynamic - range point - spread function , has allowed us to determine accurately the morphology , luminosity , scale - length and axial ratio of _ every _ host galaxy in our sample .
armed with this information we have undertaken a detailed comparison of the properties of the hosts of these 3 types of powerful agn , both internally , and with the galaxy population in general .
we find that spheroidal hosts become more prevalent with increasing nuclear luminosity such that , for nuclear luminosities @xmath2 , the hosts of both radio - loud _ and _ radio - quiet agn are virtually all massive ellipticals .
moreover , we demonstrate that the basic properties of these hosts are indistinguishable from those of quiescent , evolved , low - redshift ellipticals of comparable mass .
this result rules out the possibility that radio - loudness is determined by host - galaxy morphology , and also sets severe constraints on evolutionary schemes which attempt to link low - z ulirgs with rqqs . instead
, we show that our results are as expected given the relationship between black - hole and spheroid mass established for nearby galaxies , and apply this relation to estimate the mass of the black hole in each object .
the results agree remarkably well with completely - independent estimates based on nuclear emission - line widths ; all the quasars in our sample have @xmath3 while the radio - loud objects are confined to @xmath4
. this apparent mass - threshold difference , which provides a natural explanation for why rqqs outnumber rlqs by a factor of 10 , appears to reflect the existence of a minimum and maximum level of black - hole radio output which is a strong function of black - hole mass ( @xmath5 ) .
finally , we use our results to estimate the fraction of massive spheroids / black - holes which produce quasar - level activity .
this fraction is @xmath6% at the present day , rising to @xmath7% at @xmath8 .
galaxies : active galaxies : photometry infrared : galaxies quasars : general black hole physics |
it is well - known that the zeta function of a laplacian over a smooth compact manifold , with or without boundary , defines a meromorphic function on @xmath5 with simple poles at prescribed half - integer values depending on the dimension of the manifold @xcite .
( for a manifold with boundary , we put local boundary conditions , e.g. dirichlet conditions . )
these properties have far reaching applications in physics as well as mathematics , e.g. in the context of casimir energies , effective actions and analytic torsion ; see , for example , @xcite .
surprisingly , there is a completely natural example of a zeta function for which the described properties break down and which has no meromorphic extension to @xmath5 .
let @xmath6 be any compact region and take polar coordinates @xmath7 centered at any fixed point in @xmath8 .
then in these coordinates , the standard laplacian on @xmath9 takes the form @xmath10 and the measure transforms to @xmath11 .
a short computation shows that @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the multiplication map by @xmath14 , which is an isometry from @xmath15 to @xmath16 .
hence , the following two operators are equivalent under @xmath13 : @xmath17 in the zero eigenspace of @xmath18 , we obtain the operator of the form @xmath19 .
then this laplace type operator has many different self - adjoint realizations parameterized by angles @xmath20 ; the angle @xmath21 corresponds to the so - called friedrichs realization .
each realization has a discrete spectrum @xcite .
consider any one of the realizations , say @xmath22 , with @xmath23 and form the corresponding zeta function @xmath24 where the @xmath25 s are the eigenvalues of @xmath22 .
the shocking fact is that _ every _ such zeta function corresponding to an angle @xmath20 , except @xmath26 , does not have a meromorphic extension to @xmath5 ; in fact each such zeta function has a logarithmic branch cut with @xmath4 as the branch point .
the properties of the laplace operator considered above boil down to the main object of consideration in this paper , @xmath27 .\ ] ] in section [ sec - maxdom ] we work out an explicit description of the maximal domain of @xmath28 . in order to choose a self - adjoint realization of @xmath28
, we first fix a boundary condition for @xmath28 at @xmath29 ; it turns out that any such boundary condition for @xmath30 must be of the form ( see section [ sec - lagsubsps ] ) @xmath31 in other words , the boundary conditions we can choose at @xmath29 are parameterized by angles @xmath32 .
note that the dirichlet condition is when @xmath33 and the neumann condition is when @xmath34 .
let us henceforth _ fix _ an angle @xmath32 and consider @xmath28 with the condition in . at @xmath35 , the operator
@xmath28 is singular and a limiting procedure @xmath36 must be used to define boundary conditions .
as shown in section [ sec - sae ] ( see also section [ sec - lagsubsps ] ) , the self - adjoint realizations of @xmath28 with the condition are again parameterized by angles @xmath37 ; the article by kochube @xcite is perhaps one of the earliest references to contain such a parameterization .
it turns out that @xmath38 corresponds to the friedrichs realization . as we will show in theorem [ thneed ] , @xmath39 if and only if it can be written in the form @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are constants depending on @xmath43 . in terms of these constants , given angles @xmath44 , we consider the operator @xmath45)\ ] ] where @xmath46 here , the subscript `` @xmath47 '' represents the two - dimensional subspace @xmath48 defined by @xmath49 this vector space is a lagrangian subspace of @xmath50 with respect to a natural hermitian symplectic form intimately related to self - adjoint realizations of @xmath28 ; see section [ sec - sae ] . for general references on this relation see @xcite . for a study of adjoints of `` cone operators '' ( in the sense of schulze @xcite ) see @xcite . for properties of heat kernels and resolvents of cone operators
see , for example , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite .
when @xmath38 ( the friedrichs realization ) , the following properties concerning the resolvent , heat kernel , and zeta function are well known ; see for example , brning and seeley @xcite , falomir _ _ et al.__@xcite , or mooers @xcite . with @xmath51 , the following properties hold : [ thm - known ] fixing a boundary condition at @xmath52 , let @xmath53 denote the corresponding friedrichs realization ( that is , take @xmath54 )
. then 1 .
let @xmath55 be any sector ( solid angle ) not intersecting the positive real axis .
then as @xmath56 with @xmath57 , we have @xmath58 2 . as @xmath59 , we have @xmath60 3 .
the zeta function @xmath61 extends from @xmath62 to a meromorphic function on @xmath5 with poles at @xmath63 for @xmath64 .
these properties are `` usual '' in that they remain valid , with appropriate changes , to laplace - type operators on compact manifolds ( with or without boundary ) ; see for example gilkey s book @xcite for a thorough treatment .
the first result of this paper shows that for _ any _ other realization , these properties are completely destroyed .
[ thm - main ] with any boundary condition fixed at @xmath29 , choose a self - adjoint realization @xmath53 of the resulting operator that is * not * the friedrichs realization .
( that is , take @xmath65 ) .
let @xmath66 where @xmath67 is the euler constant .
then the following properties hold : 1 . let @xmath55 be any sector ( solid angle ) not intersecting the positive real axis .
then as @xmath56 with @xmath57 , we have @xmath68 2 . as @xmath59 , we have ( here @xmath69 denotes `` imaginary part of '' ) @xmath70 3 .
the zeta function @xmath71 can be written in the form @xmath72 where @xmath73 extends from @xmath62 to a holomorphic function on @xmath5 with poles at @xmath63 for @xmath74 .
in particular , @xmath75 has @xmath76 as a logarithmic branch point ! _
the authors have never seen a natural _ geometric _ differential operator with discrete spectrum on a compact manifold having a spectral zeta function with properties of the sort described in this theorem .
_ _ the first term in assertion ( 1 ) can be expanded further if needed . in the formulation of this theorem
we leave it in this more useful compact form .
_ [ rem - exp ] _ the same kind of remark holds for the first term in assertion ( 2 ) .
expanding further we obtain the following expansion : as @xmath77 , we have @xmath78 with the @xmath79 s depending on @xmath80 via ( here @xmath69 denotes `` imaginary part of '' ) @xmath81 the expansion is misleading as written because for @xmath82 , the terms
@xmath83 are sub - leading to any of the inverse log terms .
however , we interpret the first sum in the expansion to mean that for all @xmath84 , we have @xmath85 _ our second result is an explicit formula for a regularized determinant . for concreteness , we shall impose the dirichlet boundary condition at @xmath29 .
that is , given an angle @xmath86 with @xmath23 , we consider the operator @xmath87)\ ] ] where @xmath88 then from theorem [ thm - main ] , the zeta function @xmath89 has the following form @xmath90 where @xmath91 extends from @xmath62 to a holomorphic function on @xmath5 with poles at @xmath63 for @xmath74 . in particular , @xmath92 has the form @xmath93 in particular , @xmath94 so the @xmath95-regularized determinant @xmath96 is _ not _ defined !
however , from , we see that @xmath97 does have a well - defined derivative at @xmath76 . for this reason
, we define @xmath98 in the following theorem , we give a beautiful explicit formula for this regularized determinant .
[ thm - main2 ] for any @xmath20 with @xmath23 , we have @xmath99 we remark that when @xmath21 , the zeta function @xmath100 is regular at @xmath76 and we can also compute the ( usual ) @xmath95-regularized determinant : for @xmath21 , we have @xmath101 a well known result , see e.g. theorem 2.3 of @xcite , proposition 5.2 of @xcite .
we now outline this article . in sections [ sec - maxdom][sec - lagsubsps ]
we study the self - adjoint realizations of our main operator using the hermitian symplectic theory due to gelfand @xcite ; cf .
also @xcite .
although some of this material can be found piecemeal throughout the literature , we present all the details here in order to keep our article elementary , self - contained , and user - friendly " . in sections [ sec - eigen][sec - heat ]
we prove theorem [ thm - main ] in the special case that the dirichlet boundary condition is chosen at @xmath29 and in section [ sec - det ] we prove theorem [ thm - main2 ] , all using the contour integration method developed in @xcite . in section [ sec - bdycond ]
we prove theorem [ thm - main ] in full generality .
finally , in appendix [ sec - appendix ] , we explicitly calculate the resolvent of @xmath22 , which is needed at various places in our analysis .
the authors express their sincere gratitude to the referee for his or her kind suggestions , exhortations , and careful readings , which greatly helped us to improve the exposition and quality of this paper .
our first order of business is to characterize the self - adjoint realizations of the operator in ; for general references on self - adjoint realizations and their applications to physics see , e.g. , @xcite .
to do so , we first need to determine the maximal domain of @xmath28 : @xmath102)\ , |\ , \delta \phi \in l^2([0,r])\ } .\ ] ] for a quick review , @xmath103 is understood in the distributional sense ; thus , @xmath103 is the functional on test functions @xmath104 defined by @xmath105 then @xmath106)$ ] means that the distribution @xmath107 is represented by an @xmath108 function in the sense that there is a function @xmath109)$ ] such that @xmath110 where @xmath111 denotes the @xmath108 inner product ( conjugate linear in the second slot ) on @xmath112)$ ] .
the following theorem is inspired by falomir _
_ ( * ? ? ?
* lem.2.1 ) .
[ thneed ] @xmath30 if and only if @xmath43 can be written in the form @xmath113 where @xmath114 are constants and @xmath115 is a continuously differentiable function on @xmath116 $ ] such that @xmath117 , @xmath118 , and @xmath119)$ ] . since @xmath120 it follows that any @xmath43 of the stated form is in @xmath121 .
now let @xmath30 ; then @xmath122)$ ] .
let us define @xmath123 so that @xmath124
. then @xmath125 after multiplication by @xmath14 , we get @xmath126 since @xmath14 and @xmath127 are in @xmath112)$ ] , by the cauchy - schwartz inequality , we know that @xmath128 is in @xmath129)$ ] , therefore we can conclude that @xmath130 notice that by cauchy - schwartz , @xmath131 thus , the second term on the right in is in @xmath129)$ ] .
therefore , from we see that @xmath132 or , since @xmath124 , we get @xmath133 by , we have @xmath134 from this estimate , it follows that @xmath135 and @xmath136 .
choosing a linear subspace @xmath137 , we say that @xmath138)\ ] ] is _ self - adjoint _ ( in which case @xmath139 is called a _ self - adjoint realization _ of @xmath28 ) if @xmath140 in other words , @xmath28 is symmetric on @xmath141 and adding any elements to @xmath141 will destroy this symmetry . in order to determine
if @xmath28 has any self - adjoint realization , we need to analyze the quadratic form @xmath142 it turns out that this difference is related to finite - dimensional symplectic linear algebra .
let us define @xmath143 by @xmath144 the function @xmath145 is hermitian antisymmetric and non - degenerate ; for this reason , @xmath145 is called a _
hermitian symplectic form_. [ thm - quadform ] let @xmath146 be written in the form , i.e.@xmath147 where @xmath115 is continuously differentiable with @xmath117 , @xmath118 , and @xmath119)$ ] , and with a similar formula holding for @xmath148 . then , @xmath149 where @xmath145 is the hermitian symplectic form defined above and @xmath150 are the vectors @xmath151 we have @xmath152 recall that @xmath153 where @xmath115 and @xmath154 are continuously differentiable functions on @xmath116 $ ] such that @xmath155 @xmath156 @xmath157 , @xmath158 . taking derivatives , we get @xmath159 and similarly for @xmath160 .
it follows that @xmath161 and similarly for @xmath162 .
subtracting , we get @xmath163 combining this with proves our result .
recall that a subspace @xmath48 is called _ lagrangian _ if @xmath164 where @xmath165 is the orthogonal complement of @xmath47 with respect to @xmath145 ; explicitly , @xmath47 is lagrangian means @xmath166 we now have our main result .
[ thm - sae ] self - adjoint realizations of @xmath28 are in one - to - one correspondence with lagrangian subspaces of @xmath50 in the sense that given any lagrangian subspace @xmath48 , defining @xmath167 the operator @xmath45)\ ] ] is self - adjoint and any self - adjoint realization of @xmath28 is of the form @xmath168 for some lagrangian @xmath48 . by definition , @xmath138)\ ] ] is _ self - adjoint _ means @xmath169 by theorem [ thm - quadform ] , we can write this as : @xmath139 is self - adjoint if and only if @xmath170 suppose that @xmath139 is self - adjoint and define @xmath171 ; we shall prove that @xmath47 is lagrangian .
let @xmath172 and choose @xmath173 such that @xmath174 . then by , @xmath175 for all @xmath176 .
therefore , @xmath177 for all @xmath178 .
conversely , let @xmath179 and assume that @xmath177 for all @xmath178
. choose @xmath180 such that @xmath174 ; e.g. if @xmath181 , then @xmath182 will do .
then @xmath177 for all @xmath178 implies that @xmath183 for all @xmath176 , which by , implies that @xmath173 , which further implies that @xmath184 .
now let @xmath48 be lagrangian ; we shall prove that @xmath53 is self - adjoint , that is , holds .
let @xmath185 . then , since @xmath47 is lagrangian , we automatically have @xmath183 for all @xmath186 .
conversely , let @xmath187 and assume that @xmath183 for all @xmath186 . by the construction given any @xmath188 we can find a @xmath30 such that @xmath189 .
therefore , @xmath183 for all @xmath190 implies that @xmath191 for all @xmath178 , which by the lagrangian condition on @xmath47 , implies that @xmath192 .
this shows that @xmath185 and our proof is complete .
the symplectic form @xmath193 defined in is naturally separated into two parts : @xmath194 where @xmath195 the first @xmath196 appearing in corresponds to the singularity at @xmath197 and the second @xmath196 in corresponds to the boundary @xmath29 . for this reason , it is natural to focus on lagrangian subspaces @xmath198 of the form @xmath199 where @xmath200 is lagrangian with respect to @xmath196 . with this in mind , let us characterize all such lagrangian subspaces of @xmath201 .
first , we observe that we can write @xmath202 where @xmath203 denotes the inner product on @xmath201 and @xmath204 .
recalling that @xmath205 is lagrangian means that @xmath206 from this lemma , it is straightforward to show that @xmath207 where @xmath208 is the orthogonal complement of @xmath47 with respect to the inner product @xmath203 . from this , one can easily prove the following main result in this section .
[ thm - ltheta ] @xmath205 is lagrangian if and only if @xmath209 for some @xmath210 where @xmath211 notice that we can restrict to @xmath212 in theorem [ thm - ltheta ] .
let @xmath213 be two such angles and put @xmath214 .
as in , we write @xmath30 as @xmath147 where @xmath115 is continuously differentiable with @xmath117 , @xmath118 , and @xmath119)$ ] . then as a consequence of theorem [ thm - sae ] ,
we know that @xmath215)\ ] ] is self - adjoint , where @xmath46 when @xmath38 , then we are requiring @xmath42 vanish so that near @xmath35 , we have @xmath216 that is , no log terms ; in @xcite , brning and seeley prove that @xmath38 is the friedrichs realization of the operator @xmath28 acting on smooth functions supported away from @xmath35 with the boundary condition @xmath217 at @xmath29 . as seen in theorem
[ thm - known ] in the introduction , this self - adjoint realization gives rise to the `` usual '' resolvent , heat kernel , and zeta function properties .
when @xmath65 , we get very pathological properties as shown in theorem [ thm - main ] . in the following sections we enter in the proof of theorem [ thm - main ] .
as shown in detail in section [ sec - bdycond ] , the strange behaviors depicted in theorem [ thm - main ] do not depend on the choice of the lagrangian @xmath218 ( that is , the choice of boundary condition at @xmath29 ) .
for this reason , we shall use @xmath219 for the lagrangian @xmath218 in ; thus , we shall consider the self - adjoint operator @xmath220)$ ] , where @xmath212 and @xmath23 , and @xmath221 so we are simply imposing the dirichlet condition at @xmath29 .
we now find an explicit formula for the eigenfunctions and a transcendental equation , which determines the spectrum of @xmath22 .
we begin with the following eigenvalue equation : @xmath222 we can turn this into a bessel equation via the usual trick by setting @xmath223 .
then , @xmath224 so @xmath225 or @xmath226 for fixed @xmath227 , the solutions to this equation are linear combinations of @xmath228 and @xmath229 ( with @xmath229 the bessel function of the second kind ) , so @xmath230 using that @xcite @xmath231 where @xmath232 , the form ( [ phic12 ] ) for @xmath233 is obtained by choosing the constants @xmath234 and @xmath235 in such a way that @xmath236 by definition of the bessel function @xcite , we have as @xmath237 , @xmath238 and by , we see that @xmath239 where @xmath240 is a power series in @xmath241 vanishing like @xmath241 as @xmath242 . therefore , by definition of @xmath243 , we have @xmath244 to satisfy the dirichlet condition at @xmath29 , we must have @xmath245 it follows that @xmath246 or @xmath247 .
we summarize our findings in the following proposition .
the transcendental equation @xmath248 determines the eigenvalues of @xmath22 . in the following theorem we state various properties of the eigenvalues of @xmath22 ; note that in @xcite it is stated that there are no negative eigenvalues ; however , it turns out that for example when @xmath249 and @xmath250 , there is _ always _ a negative eigenvalue .
[ thm - eigenv]for @xmath212 with @xmath251 , 1 .
@xmath22 has a zero eigenvalue if and only if @xmath252 .
2 . @xmath22 has a unique negative eigenvalue if and only if @xmath253 . using and the expansion @xmath254 the eigenvalue equation @xmath255 can be written as @xmath256
thus , @xmath257 solves this equation if and only if @xmath258 .
now @xmath22 has a negative eigenvalue means that @xmath259 for @xmath260 real solves : @xmath261 if @xmath262 , then has no solutions because the right - hand side of will be strictly positive for all real @xmath260 while the left - hand side of is nonpositive .
thus , we may assume that @xmath263 .
then we can write as @xmath264 thus , we just have to prove that @xmath265 has a unique solution . to prove this , observe that since the harmonic series @xmath266 diverges , we can choose @xmath267 such that @xmath268 .
we now write @xmath269 where @xmath270 , and note that @xmath265 if and only if @xmath271 where @xmath272 because of the powers of @xmath260 in the denominator the second sum on the right , we see that @xmath273 while because of the first sum on the right , we see that @xmath274 .
in particular , by the intermediate value theorem , @xmath271 for some @xmath275 . since @xmath276 the function @xmath277 is strictly increasing , so there is only one @xmath278 such that @xmath279 .
it follows that @xmath265 for a unique @xmath280 and our proof is now complete .
a graph of @xmath281 for @xmath282 and @xmath283 is shown in figure [ fig - eigengraph ] .
let @xmath212 with @xmath23 .
we now analyze the zeta function using the contour integral techniques developed in @xcite . in appendix
[ sec - appendix ] , theorem [ thm - traceres ] , we have shown that @xmath284 therefore , for @xmath285 , by _ definition _ the zeta function is given by @xmath286 where @xmath67 is a contour in the plane shown in figure [ fig - contstrange1 ] . for the zeta function .
the @xmath287 s represent the zeros of @xmath288 .
the squares of the @xmath287 s on the imaginary axis represent the negative eigenvalues of @xmath22 . here , @xmath3 is on the imaginary axis and is larger in absolute value than the absolute value of the negative eigenvalue of @xmath22 ( if one exists ) .
the contour @xmath289 goes from @xmath3 to @xmath290 . ] to analyze properties of the zeta function , we need the following technical lemma .
[ lem - asympf ] let @xmath212 with @xmath291 and @xmath292 be a sector ( closed angle ) in the right - half plane .
then as @xmath293 with @xmath294 , we have @xmath295 where @xmath296 is a power series in @xmath297 starting from @xmath298 , and @xmath299 with the same meaning for @xmath296 .
finally , @xmath288 is an even function of @xmath227 , and as @xmath300 , we have @xmath301 from , we have @xmath302 where @xmath303 is the modified bessel function of the first kind , and @xmath304 is the modified bessel function of the second kind .
therefore , @xmath305 by @xcite , as @xmath293 for @xmath306 , we have @xmath307 where @xmath296 is a power series in @xmath297 starting with @xmath298 ; furthermore @xcite , as @xmath308 for @xmath294 , @xmath309 therefore , as @xmath293 for @xmath294 , we have @xmath310 which proves . taking logarithms , we see that as @xmath293 for @xmath294 , we have @xmath311 where @xmath312 is a constant . since @xmath313 ,
we have @xmath314 taking the derivative of this we get . to determine the asymptotics as @xmath300 , recalling that @xmath315
, we see that @xmath316 where we used and in passing from the second to the third line . in particular , the second line with and shows that @xmath288 is an even function of @xmath227 .
this completes our proof .
we need one more lemma .
[ lem - logint ] we have @xmath317 where @xmath318 is an entire function of @xmath319 that is @xmath318 at @xmath76 . in the integral
we assume that @xmath320 so that the integral is well - defined . now to analyze this integral we make the change of variables @xmath321 or @xmath322 , and obtain @xmath323 making the change of variables @xmath324 , we get @xmath325 recall that the _ exponential integral _ is defined by ( see ( * ? ? ?
8.2 ) ) @xmath326 therefore , @xmath327 also from @xcite , we have @xmath328 therefore @xmath329 where @xmath318 is an entire function of @xmath319 that is @xmath318 at @xmath76 .
this completes our proof .
we now determine the structure of the zeta function .
[ prop - zeta ] the zeta function @xmath330 can be written in the form @xmath90 where @xmath315 and @xmath91 extends from @xmath62 to a holomorphic function on @xmath5 with poles at @xmath63 for @xmath74 .
in particular , @xmath92 has @xmath331 as a logarithmic branch point ! recalling , we write @xmath332 where @xmath289 is the part of @xmath67 from @xmath3 to @xmath290 , and using that @xmath333 we obtain the integral @xmath334 or , @xmath335 a formula that will be analyzed in a moment .
the second integral here is over a finite contour so an entire function of @xmath336 , so we are left to analyze the analytic properties of the first integral .
to do so , recall from that for @xmath337 , we have @xmath338 for some constants @xmath339 .
since @xmath340 which has poles at @xmath341 for @xmath342 , it follows that the expansion @xmath343 will contribute to the function @xmath91 in the statement of this proposition where @xmath91 extends from @xmath344 to a holomorphic function on @xmath5 with poles at @xmath345 for @xmath64 .
lemma [ lem - logint ] applied to the integral @xmath346 now completes our proof .
the existence of the logarithmic branch point at @xmath4 has been missed in @xcite .
the error occurs in equation ( a13 ) where certain antiderivatives ( specifically @xmath347 and @xmath348 ) were accidentally set equal to zero at @xmath4 .
using the theorem [ thm - traceres ] , we can now prove theorem [ thm - main ] ( 1 ) for @xmath22 .
we have chosen to present the results in a form where the first term has been expanded further ; theorem [ thm - main ] ( 1 ) is contained in equation of the proof and the explanation of the meaning of the expansion is similar to that found in remark [ rem - exp ] .
[ prop - res ] let @xmath23 and @xmath349 , furthermore let @xmath55 be any sector ( solid angle ) not intersecting the positive real axis .
then as @xmath350 with @xmath57 , we have @xmath351 where @xmath352 for @xmath64 ( in particular , @xmath353 ) . setting @xmath354 with @xmath355 a sector in the right - half plane
, it suffices to prove that as @xmath308 with @xmath294 , we have @xmath356 or after multiplication by @xmath357 , we just have to prove that @xmath358 to prove this , we recall from theorem [ thm - traceres ] that @xmath359 by lemma [ lem - asympf ] ( see ) we know that as @xmath360 for @xmath294 , @xmath361 finally , the expansion @xmath362 concludes our result .
as shown in the proof , for @xmath293 with @xmath294 , where @xmath363 is a sector in the right - half plane , we have @xmath364 or with @xmath354 , as @xmath56 with @xmath365 , a sector not intersecting the positive real axis , we have @xmath366 this fact will be used in the next section .
to determine the small - time heat asymptotics , we write @xmath367 where @xmath67 is a counter - clockwise contour in the plane surrounding the eigenvalues of @xmath22 ; see figure [ fig - contstrange ] .
this is the starting point to show theorem [ thm - main ] ( 2 ) for @xmath22 .
again we have chosen to present the results in a form where the first term has been expanded further . this makes the actual structure of the small-@xmath3 expansion more explicit ; theorem [ thm - main ] ( 2 ) is contained in equation of the proof . .
] [ prop - hk ] as @xmath59 , we have @xmath368 with the @xmath79 s depending on @xmath80 via @xmath369 the small - time asymptotics are determined by the large - spectral parameter asymptotics of the resolvent .
now recall from that as @xmath56 with @xmath370 in a sector not intersecting the positive real axis , we have @xmath371 since ( making the change of variables @xmath372 ) @xmath373 the series @xmath374 gives rise to a small time expansion @xmath375 therefore , we just have to analyze the behavior of @xmath376 deforming @xmath67 to the real line , the integral here is , modulo a term that is a smooth function of @xmath3 at @xmath377 , equal to @xmath378 or after simplification , this sum becomes @xmath379 ( the reason we start at @xmath380 is that @xmath381 ) $ ] is not integrable near @xmath382 . ) since for any complex number @xmath383 , we have @xmath384 , we see that modulo a term that is a smooth function of @xmath3 at @xmath377 , @xmath385 where @xmath386 in summary , we have proved that @xmath387 which is exactly the statement of theorem [ thm - main ] ( 2 ) .
we shall compute the asymptotics of @xmath388 as @xmath59 . to do so , observe that @xmath389 now @xmath390 is integrable near @xmath382 , so we can write @xmath391 where @xmath392 note that @xmath393 is smooth at @xmath377 .
we will now determine the asymptotics of @xmath394 near @xmath377 . to this end
, we make the change of variables @xmath395 : @xmath396 since @xmath397 for any @xmath267 , we see that for any @xmath267 , @xmath398 the last integral here is bounded in @xmath3 as @xmath59 .
since @xmath84 is arbitrary , it follows that @xmath399 therefore , since @xmath400 , as @xmath59 we have @xmath401 integrating both sides , using that @xmath402 we get @xmath403 finally , in view of , we see that as @xmath59 , @xmath404
by proposition [ prop - zeta ] , we have @xmath405 where @xmath91 extends from @xmath62 to a holomorphic function on @xmath5 with poles at @xmath63 for @xmath74 . since @xmath406 , it follows that @xmath97 has a derivative at @xmath76 .
therefore , we can define @xmath407 which is computed in this section .
recall that @xmath212 with @xmath291 .
the idea here is to make the first term in @xmath408 regular at @xmath76 , as the second term ( being entire ) is already regular at @xmath76 . in order to analytically continue the first term , we add and subtract off the leading asymptotics of @xmath409 .
thus , recalling lemma [ lem - asympf ] ( see ) @xmath410 where @xmath411 , we consider @xmath412 the second integral can be computed explicitly : @xmath413 therefore , @xmath414 hence , as @xmath415 , we see that @xmath416 by lemma [ lem - logint ] , we have @xmath417 thus , @xmath418 the first integral on the right is regular at @xmath76 due to the asymptotics found in lemma [ lem - asympf ] .
therefore , using that @xmath419 we see that @xmath420 therefore , @xmath421 this formula is derived , a priori , when @xmath3 is on the upper half of the imaginary axis .
however , the right side is a _
holomorphic _ function of @xmath422 , where @xmath141 is the set of complex numbers minus the negative real axis and the zeros of @xmath288 . therefore holds for all @xmath422 . here
, we recall that @xmath289 is any curve in @xmath141 from @xmath3 to @xmath290 . as before
, the trick now is to let @xmath59 in .
first , assume that @xmath423 so that @xmath22 has no zero eigenvalue by theorem [ thm - eigenv ] .
we determine the limit as @xmath59 of the exponential @xmath424 .
let s take @xmath59 in @xmath141 from the upper half plane as shown in figure [ fig - contstrangedeform ] . as we let @xmath59 in @xmath141 from the upper half plane . ] in view of figure [ fig - contstrangedeform ] , it follows that @xmath425 recalling , as @xmath300 , we have @xmath426 in this case @xmath427 . in conclusion , taking @xmath59 in , we see that @xmath428 second , assume now that @xmath429 so that as @xmath300 , we have @xmath430 let us put @xmath431 then @xmath432 is nonzero at @xmath257 with value @xmath433 , and @xmath434 by lemma [ lem - asympf ] ( see ) , we have @xmath435 now following the argument above used to prove , we can show @xmath436 finally , taking @xmath59 as we did before , yields in the @xmath437 case , the result @xmath438
we now prove theorem [ thm - main ] .
let s briefly recall the set - up .
let @xmath439 with @xmath440 and put @xmath214 .
then as a consequence of theorem [ thm - sae ] , we know that @xmath45)\ ] ] is self - adjoint , where @xmath441 the trick to proving theorem [ thm - main ] is to write the resolvent @xmath442 in terms of @xmath443 ( same self - adjoint condition at @xmath35 but with the dirichlet condition at @xmath29 ) .
to do so , let @xmath444 be a non - decreasing function such that @xmath445 for @xmath446 and @xmath447 for @xmath448 .
given any real numbers @xmath449 , we define @xmath450 then @xmath451 on a neighborhood of @xmath452 and @xmath453 on a neighborhood of @xmath454 .
we define @xmath455 let @xmath456 over @xmath457 $ ] with the dirichlet condition at @xmath458 and the condition @xmath459 at @xmath29 ; note that since @xmath460 over @xmath461 $ ] , the operator @xmath462 is a true smooth elliptic operator over this interval with no singularities .
we define @xmath463 it follows that @xmath464 maps into the domain @xmath168 of @xmath53 , and @xmath465 where @xmath466 ( \delta ' - { \lambda})^{-1 } \psi_1 + [ \delta , \varphi_2 ] ( \delta_{\theta_1 } - { \lambda})^{-1 } \psi_2,\ ] ] because the supports of @xmath467 $ ] and @xmath468 , where @xmath469 , are disjoint , using the explicit formula for the resolvent @xmath470 and the properties of the resolvent of @xmath471 found in the work of seeley @xcite it is straightforward to check that @xmath472 is trace - class operator that vanishes to infinite order as @xmath56 for @xmath370 in any sector @xmath473 of @xmath5 not intersecting the positive real axis ; we shall fix such a sector @xmath473 from now on .
in particular , forming the neumann series , it follows that @xmath474 is invertible for @xmath475 large with @xmath57 with @xmath476 where @xmath477 has the same properties as @xmath472 .
thus , multiplying both sides of @xmath478 by @xmath479 , we see that @xmath480 therefore , as @xmath56 for @xmath57 , we see that proposition [ prop - res ] holds also for @xmath481 . now using the resolvent asymptotics
, we can proceed to copy the proofs of proposition [ prop - hk ] and [ prop - zeta ] .
the proof of theorem [ thm - main ] is now complete .
in this appendix , we compute the trace of the resolvent by explicitly finding the schwartz kernel of the bessel function . to do so , recall that the resolvent kernel of the differential operator @xmath483 with given boundary conditions at @xmath197 and @xmath29 can be expressed as follows ( see lemma 4.1 in @xcite or ( * ? ? ?
3.3 ) for an elementary account ) : @xmath484 where @xmath485 and @xmath486 are solutions of @xmath487 satisfying the given boundary conditions at @xmath197 and @xmath29 , respectively , and where @xmath488 is the wronskian of @xmath489 .
recall that the general solution to @xmath490 is @xmath491 to satisfy the boundary condition at @xmath35 , we must have ( see ): @xmath492 thus , we can take @xmath493 and @xmath494 ; this gives @xmath495 where @xmath315 .
to determine @xmath486 we use the less fancy formulation of the general solution : @xmath496 to satisfy the dirichlet condition at @xmath29 , we therefore take @xmath497 the wronskian is easily computed using that @xmath498 ( see @xcite ) : @xmath499 therefore , @xmath500 where @xmath501 and @xmath502 are given in and , respectively , and where @xmath503 we now need to compute @xmath504 ; that is , @xmath505 we next use the indefinite integrals @xmath506 which we need to evaluate between @xmath197 and @xmath507 .
recalling , @xmath508 and @xmath509 vanish at @xmath510 .
also , by @xmath511 also vanishes at @xmath510 .
however , it is a remarkable fact , which may be easily overlooked , that since @xmath512 where we used that @xmath513 and @xmath514 from @xcite , we have @xmath515 therefore , @xmath516 plugging these integrals into and using the identity @xcite @xmath517 to simplify the expression obtained , we eventually arrive that @xmath518 using the fact that @xmath519 and @xmath520 , we can write this as @xmath521 where we recall that @xmath503 since ( see ) @xmath522 we have proved the following theorem , [ thm - traceres ] with @xmath523 , we have @xmath524 this theorem has been used to analyze the zeta function , resolvent , and heat kernel of @xmath525 in sections [ sec - zeta][sec - heat ] .
kk was supported in part by funds from the baylor university research committee and by the max - planck - institute for mathematics in the sciences ( leipzig , germany ) .
j. audretsch , u. jasper , and v. d. skarzhinsky , _ a pragmatic approach to the problem of the self - adjoint extension of hamilton operators with the aharonov - bohm potential _ ,
a * 28 * ( 1995 ) , no . 8 , 23592367 .
h. falomir , m. a. muschietti , and p. a. g. pisani , _ on the resolvent and spectral functions of a second order differential operator with a regular singularity _ , j. math . phys .
* 45 * ( 2004 ) , no . 12 , 45604577 . i. s. gradshteyn and i. m. ryzhik , _ table of integrals , series , and products _ , sixth ed . , academic press inc
, san diego , ca , 2000 , translated from the russian , translation edited and with a preface by alan jeffrey and daniel zwillinger . , _ selfadjoint extensions of schroedinger operators with singular potentials _ , order , disorder and chaos in quantum systems ( dubna , 1989 ) , oper . theory adv .
46 , birkhuser , basel , 1990 , pp . | in this article we analyze the resolvent , the heat kernel and the spectral zeta function of the operator @xmath0 over the finite interval .
the structural properties of these spectral functions depend strongly on the chosen self - adjoint realization of the operator , a choice being made necessary because of the singular potential present . only for the friedrichs realization standard properties
are reproduced , for all other realizations highly nonstandard properties are observed . in particular , for @xmath1 we find terms like @xmath2 in the small-@xmath3 asymptotic expansion of the heat kernel .
furthermore , the zeta function has @xmath4 as a logarithmic branch point . |
the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon @xmath0 is one of the most accurately measured quantities in particle physics , and as such is a very promising signal of new physics if a deviation from its prediction in the standard model is found . the present experimental value for @xmath1 , is given by @xmath2 , as an average of @xmath3 and @xmath4 @xcite .
since statistical errors are the largest source of uncertainties , a proposal to measure it again to a precision of @xmath5 has recently been submitted to fnal @xcite and jparc @xcite , using different experimental techniques . at the level of the experimental accuracy
, the qed contributions has been completed up to the fifth order @xmath6 , giving the qed contribution @xmath7 @xcite , using the rydberg constant and the ratio @xmath8 as inputs @xcite .
also electroweak ( ew ) and hadronic contributions are necessary .
the latter represents the main uncertainty in the standard model in terms of the hadronic vacuum polarization ( hvp ) and the hadronic light - by - light scattering ( hlbl ) .
the present estimates for qed , hvp , hlbl , and ew corrections are collected in table [ smcont ] .
.standard model contributions to @xmath0 . [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] [ t2 ]
the hlbl can not be directly related to any measurable cross section and requires knowledge of qcd at all energy scales .
since this is not known yet , one needs to rely on hadronic models to compute it .
such models introduce some systematic errors which are difficult to quantify . using the large-@xmath9 and the chiral counting , de rafael proposed @xcite to split the hlbl into a set of different contributions : pseudo - scalar exchange ( dominant @xcite ) , charged pion and kaon loops , quark loop , and higher - spin exchanges ( see table [ t2 ] ) .
the large-@xmath9 approach however has at least two shortcomings : firstly , it is difficult to use experimental data in a large-@xmath9 world . secondly , calculations carried out in the large-@xmath9 limit demand an infinite set of resonances .
as such sum is not known , one truncates the spectral function in a resonance saturation scheme , the minimal hadronic approximation ( mha ) @xcite .
the resonance masses used in each calculation are then taken as the physical ones from pdg @xcite instead of the corresponding masses in the large-@xmath9 limit .
both problems might lead to large systematic errors not included so far @xcite . in table [ t2
] , i collect few of the main approaches for the hlbl . among them , the jegerlehner and nyffeler review @xcite together with the _ glasgow consensus _ written by prades , de rafael , and
vainshtein @xcite represent , in my opinion , the two reference numbers .
they agree well since they only differ by few subtleties . for the main contribution , the pseudoscalar exchange , on needs a model for the pseudoscalar transition form factor ( tff ) .
they both used the model from knecht and nyffeler @xcite based on mha , but differ on how to implement the high - energy qcd constrains coming from the vva green s function . in practice , this translates on wether the piece contains a pion pole or a pion exchange .
the former would imply that the exchange of heavier pseudoscalar resonances ( 6th column in table [ t2 ] ) is effectively included in @xcite , while the latter demands its inclusion .
the other difference is wether the errors are summed linearly @xcite or in quadrature @xcite .
neither of both approaches contain systematic errors from chiral and large-@xmath9 limits @xcite . in the large @xmath9
, the mha should be understood from the mathematical theory of pad approximants ( pa ) to meromorphic functions @xcite . obeying the rules from this mathematical framework
, one can compute the desired quantities in a model - independent way and even be able to ascribe a systematic error to the approach @xcite .
interestingly @xcite , given the low - energy expansion of the tff used here , its pa sequence converges much faster than the mha , especially when the qcd behavior is imposed . in principle , one knows then how to incorporate large-@xmath9 systematics , but that task should still be done . on top , with new experimental data , the inputs for models used should be updated . beyond that fact ,
it is common to factorize the tff as a product of a single virtual form factor , effect never considered so far .
all in all , even though the qcd features for the hlbl are well understood @xcite , the details of the particular calculations are important .
considering the drawback drawn here , i think we need more calculations , closer to experimental data if possible .
before going into detail , allow me an excursus on a recent lattice qcd simulation .
et al . _
@xcite proposed a method for simulating the hlbl in a lattice qcd+qed .
they studied a non - perturbative treatment of qed which later on was checked against the perturbative simulation . with that spirit
, they considered that a qcd+qed simulation could deal with the non - perturbative effects of qcd for the hlbl .
unphysical quark and muon masses are used @xcite , and only the single quark - loop diagram is simulated , but still a lattice signal is obtained . due to the finiteness of the volume
, the simulation is not yet at zero momentum as the physical counterpart , but at @xmath10 ( @xmath11 the lattice spacing )
. the next step will be , then , to go for physical values , consider larger volumes and latter on control the extrapolation to the desired zero momentum point .
going back to our data driven approaches , one of the recent progress on the field is the consideration of dispersion relations ( dr ) for calculating the hlbl .
as example , colangelo _
et al . _
@xcite considered a dr for the four - point tensor that leads to the hlbl .
after decomposing it in terms of helicity amplitudes , and consider independently the contributions from scalar qed , one @xmath12 and @xmath13 , they showed that the dr would need the @xmath12 tff and the @xmath14 as input , only .
one expects good precision in the momentum region where such dr is formulated . in this framework
, the tff describes a pion - pole , no intermediate states are considered .
off - shell effects would be included in subtraction constants . for a reliable numerical evaluation
the dr should extended up to infinity .
since the formalism is valid up to momentum of around @xmath15 gev@xmath16 , @xcite will have to consider a matching with a certain model to account for the qcd high - energy behavior .
how such matching should be done , and how model dependent would that be is not yet discussed . and how that would improve on previous results has still to be seen . at least , is a clean way to use experimental information of the @xmath12 tff at low energies .
we do not have such low - energy space - like data yet ( despite significant constraints provided by time - like input , see @xcite ) but kloe , mami , and bes are facilities where it could be in principle measured .
more interesting would be the @xmath17 contribution , since less is known from model calculations ( see the third column on table [ t2 ] ) . here
the complication arises from the nature of the @xmath14 process which , in dr formalism , is pretty involved . without many assumptions ,
one expects a reliable contribution up to @xmath18 gev@xmath16 momentum transfer , i.e. , only @xmath19-wave contribution .
the inclusion of a @xmath20 wave makes the system of coupled dr much more complicated and less user friendly . on top ,
kaon and multi - pion contributions are neglected , and such assumption is difficult to quantify . beyond holographic qcd @xcite or non - local quark model @xcite and dyson schwinger @xcite approaches , the common attempt to calculate
the hlbl is through hadronic models constrained by data . in this framework
it is easier to show the role of experimental data , specially for the pseudoscalar exchange contribution , which is driven by its tff .
the main obstacle when using experimental data is the lack of them , specially on the doubly virtual tff .
fortunately , data on the tff when one of the photons is real is available from different collaborations , not only for @xmath12 but also for @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
it is common to factorize the tff , i.e. , @xmath23 , and describe it based on a rational function .
one includes a modification of its numerator due to the high - energy qcd constraints .
although the high - energy region of the model is not very important , it still contributes around a @xmath24 .
more important is the double virtuality , specially if one uses the same model ( as it should ) for predicting the @xmath25 decay .
current models can not accommodate its experimental value @xcite .
the worrisome fact is that modifying the model parameters to match such decay and going back to the hlbl , would result in a dramatic decrease of the value @xcite and this is not properly discussed yet .
the hlbl is dominated by @xmath26 from @xmath27 to @xmath28 gev@xmath16 , and picked up around @xmath18 gev@xmath16 .
then , good description of tff in such region is very important .
such data are not yet available , but any model should reproduce the available one . that is why the authors of @xcite , in contrast to other approaches , did not used data directly but the low - energy parameters ( lep ) of the taylor expansion for the tff and reconstructed it _ via _ pas .
the lecs certainly know about all the data at all energies and as such incorporates all our experimental knowledge at once .
this procedure implies a model - independent result together with a well - defined way to ascribe a systematic error . in other words , this is the first procedure that can be considered an _ approximation _ , in contrast to the _ assumptions _ considered in other approaches .
the lecs were obtained in @xcite for the @xmath12 and in @xcite for @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
the hlbl value from such approach is quoted under ems in table [ t2 ] .
i want to emphasize the role of experimental data .
let me use the lecs together with the @xmath29 to match the free parameters of the lmd+v model introduced in @xcite , as resonances or @xmath30 .
i obtain @xmath31 which contrasts with the original @xmath32 @xcite . the role of the new experimental data
is then clear , inducing a @xmath24 effect . on top , since the lmd+v is not a pa but a well - educated model , it is difficult to ascribe a systematic error due to the large-@xmath9 approach .
pas already consider such corrections and refs .
@xcite found them to be of the order of @xmath33 less dramatic than the naive @xmath34 from the @xmath9 counting , but still to be taken into account .
the last word is about a complete different approach based on the laporta and remiddi ( lr ) @xcite analytical result for the heavy quark contribution to the lbl .
the idea is to extend the perturbative result to hadronic scales low enough for accounting at once for the whole hlbl .
the free parameter is the quark mass @xmath35 .
the recent estimates using such methodology @xcite found @xmath36 gev after comparing the particular model with the hvp . the value for the hlbl is higher than those shown in table [ t2 ] , around @xmath37 , which seems to indicate that the missing pieces of the standard calculations are not so negligible .
recently , @xcite considered a different approach to the hlbl based also on the quark model .
the lr model for the hlbl does not reproduce the well - known qcd features of symmetry breaking at low - energies ( i.e. , instead of a @xmath38 divergency with @xmath39 a hadronic scale , the lr vanishes as @xmath40 for large @xmath35 , being @xmath41 . ) qcd tells us that the pion contribution and the quark loop would decouple for large @xmath39 . since the hadronic scale turns out to be @xmath42 but not infinity , @xcite searched for the scale where both contribution would coincide through averaging the photon momenta , finding @xmath43 gev .
as such , they could also predict the hvp with great accuracy .
they also found higher hlbl value , @xmath44 .
concluding , the reference numbers @xcite seem robust and the qcd features of the hlbl seem to be well understood but there is _ a but_. the new experimental data seem to reveal larger contributions from pseudsocalar pieces , meaning that the modeling of the tff is more important than expected .
also , systematic errors due to both chiral and large-@xmath9 limits are important and difficult to evaluate , but pas can help . both lattice qcd and dr are promising , but both suffer from different drawbacks . on top , the ballpark predictions coincide on drawing scenarios with larger values , indicating in my opinion the need to better understand the process .
i think there is still a long way to go .
i thank the organizers for the very nice atmosphere during the conference and also s. peris , m. vanderhaeghen , e. ruiz - arriola , w. broniowski , r. escribano , s. scherer , p. roig and p. sanchez - puertas for discussions . supported by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft through the crc 1044 .
10 g. bennett , et al.,phys.rev.lett .
92 ( 2004 ) 161802 ; phys.rev .
d73 ( 2006 ) 072003 .
k. olive , _
et al_. , review of particle physics , chin.phys .
c38 ( 2014 ) 090001 .
r. carey , et al , 2009 .
j - parc e34 conceptual design report , 2011 .
p. masjuan , g. venanzoni , h. czy , a. denig , m. vanderhaeghen , et al .
, arxiv:1306.2045 .
t. blum , p. masjuan , m. vanderhaeghen , _
et al_,arxiv:1407.4021 .
j. bijnens , e. pallante , j. prades , phys.rev.lett . 75 ( 1995 ) 14471450 ; nucl.phys .
b474 ( 1996 ) 379420 ; nucl.phys .
b626 ( 2002 ) 410411 .
m. hayakawa , t. kinoshita , a. sanda , phys.rev.lett . 75 ( 1995 ) 790793 ; phys.rev .
d54 ( 1996 ) 31373153 ; phys.rev .
d57 ( 1998 ) 465477 .
m. knecht , a. nyffeler , phys.rev .
d65 ( 2002 ) 073034 .
k. melnikov , a. vainshtein , phys.rev . d70 ( 2004 ) 113006 .
d. k. hong , d. kim , phys.lett .
b680 ( 2009 ) 480484 .
a. dorokhov , a. radzhabov , a. zhevlakov , eur.phys.j .
c71 ( 2011 ) 1702 .
g. eichmann , c. s. fischer , w. heupel and r. williams , arxiv:1411.7876 [ hep - ph ] .
p. masjuan and p. sanchez - puertas , arxiv:1504.07001 [ hep - ph ] .
p. masjuan , phys.rev.d 86 ( 2012 ) 094021 .
p. masjuan , m. vanderhaeghen , arxiv:1212.0357 .
r. escribano , p. masjuan , p. sanchez - puertas , phys.rev .
d89 ( 3 ) ( 2014 ) 034014 .
r. escribano , p. masjuan and p. sanchez - puertas , arxiv:1504.07742 [ hep - ph ] .
p. masjuan , e. ruiz arriola , w. broniowski , phys.rev .
d87 ( 2013 ) 014005 .
roig , a. guevara , g. l. castro , arxiv:1401.4099 .
e. de rafael , phys.lett .
b322 ( 1994 ) 239246 .
s. peris , m. perrottet , e. de rafael , jhep 9805 ( 1998 ) 011 .
p. masjuan , s. peris , jhep 0705 ( 2007 ) 040 ; phys.lett .
b663 ( 2008 ) 6165 .
b686 ( 2010 ) 307312 .
p. masjuan , arxiv:1005.5683 .
t. blum , _ et al_. , arxiv:1407.2923 .
g. colangelo , _ et al_. , jhep 1409 ( 2014 ) 091 , phys.lett .
b738 ( 2014 ) 612 .
m. hoferichter , b. kubis , s. leupold , f. niecknig and s. p. schneider , eur .
j. c * 74 * ( 2014 ) 11 , 3180 .
l. cappiello , _
et al_. , phys.rev .
d83 ( 2011 ) 093006 .
s. laporta , e. remiddi , phys.lett . b301 ( 1993 ) 440446 .
a. pivovarov , phys.atom.nucl .
66 ( 2003 ) 902913 .
j. erler , g. toledo sanchez , phys.rev.lett .
97 ( 2006 ) 161801 .
r. boughezal , k. melnikov , phys.lett .
b704 ( 2011 ) 193196 .
d. greynat , e. de rafael , jhep 1207 ( 2012 ) 020 . | in this talk i review the recent progress on the numerical evaluation of the hadronic light - by - light contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon and i discuss the role of experimental data on the accuracy of its determination .
anomalous magnetic moment of the muon , hadronic light - by - light contribution |
a _ partition _ of a positive integer @xmath3 is a non - increasing sequence of positive integers whose sum is @xmath3 ; the number of distinct partitions of @xmath3 is traditionally denoted by @xmath4 . a _ sequence _ ( or _
run _ ) in a partition is any subsequence of consecutive integers that appear as parts .
integer partitions without sequences were first studied by macmahon in @xcite .
he described their relationship to partitions with repeated parts , and also determined their generating series .
these partitions were studied more recently by holroyd , liggett , and romik in @xcite , where the authors introduced the general family of _ partitions without @xmath0-sequences _ for any @xmath5 , in which no @xmath0 consecutive integers may all appear as parts .
the number of partitions of @xmath3 without @xmath0-sequences of @xmath3 is denoted by @xmath6 , and the generating function is defined as @xmath7 these partitions were also studied by andrews @xcite , who found a ( double ) @xmath1-hypergeometric series expansion for the generating function . before giving this series , we record the definition for the @xmath1-pochhammer symbol , which is given by @xmath8 andrews showed that @xmath9 both of these earlier papers also addressed the asymptotic behavior of @xmath6 as @xmath10 .
holroyd , liggett , and romik @xcite showed the asymptotic expression @xmath11 andrews @xcite substantially improved this result in the case @xmath12 , proving the asymptotic expression @xmath13 his proof relies on a beautiful and surprising relationship between @xmath14 and one of ramanujan s famous mock theta functions ; we will further discuss this connection below .
the above asymptotic expression is not stated as such in andrews paper .
he instead focused on the asymptotics of the generating series @xmath14 as @xmath15 .
however , his results directly imply upon applying a tauberian theorem ( cf .
section [ s : overpartnasymp ] of this paper ) .
recently was greatly refined by the first and third authors of the present paper in @xcite .
specifically , the latter paper introduced a generalization of the circle method in order to prove a series expansion for @xmath16 involving kloosterman sums , bessel functions , and principal value integrals of modified bessel functions .
in this paper we study a related family of overpartitions .
as introduced by corteel and lovejoy in @xcite , an overpartition is a partition in which the last occurrence of each part may be overlined .
the number of overpartitions of size @xmath3 is denoted by @xmath17 .
an overpartition is said to have a gap at @xmath18 if there are no parts of size @xmath18 .
we define lower @xmath0-run overpartitions to be those overpartitions in which any overlined part must occur within a run of exactly @xmath0 consecutive overlined parts that terminates below with a gap .
more precisely , this means that if some part @xmath19 is overlined , then there is an integer @xmath20 with @xmath21 $ ] such that each of the @xmath0 overlined parts @xmath22 appear ( perhaps together with non - overlined versions ) , while no part @xmath20 ( overlined or otherwise ) appears , and no overlined part @xmath23 appears .
there is a simple bijection between lower @xmath0-run overpartitions and upper @xmath0-run overpartitions , which are defined analogously but with the conditions on parts @xmath20 and @xmath24 reversed ( see section [ s : combinatorial ] ) .
denote the number of lower @xmath0-run overpartitions of size @xmath3 by @xmath25 .
the lower @xmath26-run overpartitions of size @xmath27 are @xmath28 together with the @xmath29 partitions of @xmath27 , so @xmath30 .
the generating function for lower @xmath0-run overpartitions is denoted by @xmath31 our first result is analogous to andrews double - series generating function for partitions without @xmath0-sequences .
[ t : gbarq ] for @xmath32 , @xmath33 our next result is an asymptotic expression for lower @xmath0-run overpartitions that is much stronger than the logarithmic expression in .
[ t : pk ] as @xmath34 , @xmath35 interestingly , our techniques do not apply to the case of partitions without sequences , despite the similarity of and theorem [ t : gbarq ] .
we next focus particularly on certain special cases that are related to ramanujan s mock theta functions .
andrews @xcite showed that the generating function for partitions without @xmath26-sequences may be written as @xmath36 where @xmath37 which is one of ramanujan s third - order mock theta functions .
ramanujan originally introduced the mock theta functions by listing a small collection of examples in his last letter to hardy @xcite .
he justified his own interest by observing their striking asymptotic properties and near - symmetries under modular transformations .
andrews @xcite used some of these properties in order to determine the asymptotic behavior of @xmath14 as @xmath38 , which then implies .
the general theory of mock theta functions has also recently seen great advancements , as zwegers doctoral thesis @xcite has led to a proper understanding of the relationship to automorphic forms @xcite . the case @xmath39 of lower @xmath0-run overpartitions is similarly related to another of ramanujan s third - order mock theta functions from @xcite . in particular
, the mock theta function @xmath40 appears in the following expression for the generating function of lower @xmath2-run overpartitions .
[ p : gbar1 ] for @xmath32 , @xmath41 note that the @xmath39 case of theorem [ t : pk ] states that @xmath42 the remainder of the paper is structured as follows . in section [
s : overpartitions ] , we consider basic combinatorial properties of @xmath0-run overpartitions and derive their generating series . in section [
s : constant ] , we apply the constant term method to determine the asymptotic behavior of the generating series . finally , in section [ s : overpartnasymp ] , we prove the asymptotic expression for @xmath0-run overpartitions found in theorem [ t : pk ] .
in this section we denote the number of lower @xmath0-run overpartitions of @xmath3 by @xmath43 .
we also recall the definition upper @xmath0-run overpartitions as overpartitions in which the overlined parts must occur in consecutive runs of the form @xmath44 , with no overlined parts @xmath45 , and no parts of any kind of size @xmath24 . the number of upper @xmath0-run overpartitions of size @xmath3 is denoted by @xmath46 .
our first observation on @xmath0-run overpartitions is that the lower and upper definitions are in bijective correspondence .
[ p : op-+ ] for all @xmath47 and @xmath48 , @xmath49 we construct a simple bijection between the two sets of overpartitions . in a lower @xmath0-run overpartition , any run of @xmath0 overlined parts occurs at the lower end of some block of consecutive parts , surrounded on both sides by gaps .
that is , for some @xmath20 and some @xmath50 , all the parts @xmath51 appear ( perhaps together with further non - overlined copies of these same values ) , with gaps at @xmath20 and @xmath52 .
we can form a new overpartition by shifting the @xmath0 overlines to the upper end of the block , i.e. , replacing the above parts with @xmath53 applying this transformation to every run of @xmath0 overlined parts results in an upper @xmath0-run overpartition , and this map is clearly bijective .
we henceforth write simply @xmath54 for @xmath55 , and abbreviate the term `` lower @xmath0-run overpartition '' to @xmath0-run overpartition . it will be convenient to work with both the upper and lower definitions in different contexts . in view of proposition [ p : op-+ ] they are interchangeable for purposes of enumeration .
we have the following monotonicity properties for @xmath0-run overpartitions .
[ p : mono ] for any @xmath56 and @xmath48 , 1 .
[ p : mono : n ] @xmath57 2 .
[ p : mono : k ] @xmath58 .
[ p : mono : n ] given an upper @xmath0-run overpartition of @xmath3 , adding a non - overlined part @xmath2 clearly gives an upper @xmath0-run overpartition of @xmath59 , and this map is injective .
[ p : mono : k ] we construct an injection from lower @xmath60-run overpartitions to lower @xmath0-run overpartitions .
if @xmath61 is a @xmath60-run overpartition and @xmath62 is a @xmath60-run , then there are no parts of size @xmath20 , and there can only be non - overlined parts of size @xmath63 . removing the overline on @xmath23 results in a @xmath0-run
satisfying the lower @xmath0-run condition , and applying this to every run gives the required injection .
we note that the partitions without sequences studied in @xcite satisfy the opposite inequality to that in proposition [ p : mono ] [ p : mono : k ] : @xmath64 2 . for any fixed @xmath3
, we have @xmath65 for sufficiently large @xmath0 . in this section
we consider the two - variable generating functions @xmath66 where @xmath67 is defined to be the number of @xmath0-run overpartitions of size @xmath3 and exactly @xmath68 parts .
the main result in this section is a double series expansion for this generating function , which is proven from a @xmath1-difference equation for @xmath69 .
[ t : gbarxq ] for @xmath32 , @xmath70 the generating function @xmath71 satisfies the @xmath1-difference equation @xmath72 which follows from the definition of ( upper ) @xmath0-run overpartitions by separating according to their smallest parts .
the first term corresponds to the overpartitions without an overlined @xmath73 , in which case there is no restriction on subsequent parts ; the second term corresponds to overpartitions that do have the part @xmath73 , and thus also have each of the parts @xmath74 ( and possibly non - overlined parts of these sizes as well ) , followed by no parts of size @xmath75 .
this recurrence is easier to solve after `` re - normalizing '' the equation , which is achieved by setting @xmath76 equation then implies that this normalized function satisfies the @xmath1-difference equation @xmath77 we next write this as a series in @xmath78 , where the coefficients are polynomials in @xmath1 , @xmath79 equation is equivalent to the statement that for all @xmath18 , @xmath80 by , the theorem statement is equivalent to verifying that @xmath81 is equal to the double series @xmath82 it is sufficient to show that this double series satisfies the @xmath1-difference equation , while also checking that the @xmath75 initial @xmath78-powers are compatible .
denote the @xmath83 coefficient in the double series by @xmath84 ; it is clear by definition that @xmath85 and that @xmath86 , and finally @xmath87 note that @xmath0-run overpartitions with at most @xmath88 parts can contain only non - overlined parts , and thus @xmath89 the first term gives all overpartitions with no overlined parts , and the second term gives all overpartitions that consist of a single @xmath0-run of overlined parts .
thus @xmath90 and the initial terms @xmath91 @xmath92 agree with those given for @xmath93 above .
now we verify that the @xmath93 satisfy . temporarily writing @xmath94
we then have @xmath95 and thus @xmath96 \\ & = \sum_{\substack{r , s \geq 0 : \\ kr + ( k+1)s = m - k - 1 } } a_{r , s }
\cdot q^{{\textstyle\frac{k(k+1)(2r + 2s + 1)}{2}}+ ( k+1)(s+1 ) } \\ & \qquad+ \sum_{\substack{r , s \geq 0 : \\ kr + ( k+1)s = m - k } } a_{r , s } \cdot q^{{\textstyle \frac{k(k+1)(2r + 2s + 1)}{2 } } + ( k+1)s } \\ & = q^{m(k+1 ) - \frac{k(k+1)}{2 } } \left(\widetilde{\lambda}_{m - k } - \widetilde{\lambda}_{m - k-1}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the two sums in the second line were shifted by @xmath97 and @xmath98 , respectively .
this completes the proof of the double series formula . in this section
we prove theorem [ p : gbar1 ] .
recall the earlier definition of ramanujan s third - order mock theta function @xmath99 this was proven by fine ( see equation ( 26.32 ) of @xcite ) to have the equivalent form @xmath100 we first describe a family of overpartitions that are in bijective correspondence with lower @xmath2-run overpartitions .
the bijection will be the _ conjugation _ involution .
an overpartition may be represented by a _
ferrer s diagram _ that lists each part as a left - justified row of dots , with the parts listed in decreasing order from top to bottom .
furthermore , since an overlined part is the last occurrence of any part size , we distinguish it by marking the corresponding bottom - right `` corner '' .
the conjugation map then simply interchanges the rows and columns of such a diagram .
under overpartition conjugation , lower @xmath2-run overpartitions map to overpartitions in which overlined parts may not occur alone , except for possibly in the largest part .
in other words , such overpartitions have the property that if @xmath101 and @xmath18 is not the largest part size , then @xmath102 as well
. see figure [ f : conj ] for an example of the conjugate of a @xmath2-run overpartition . by distinguishing the largest part ,
the generating function for such partitions is clearly @xmath103 which is easily seen to be equal to the second factor in .
throughout this section we view @xmath1-series as fourier expansions . in fact
, we will mainly focus on real values of @xmath104 , so we write @xmath105 with @xmath106 consider the double hypergeometric @xmath1-series from theorem [ t : gbarq ] , which we denote as @xmath107 [ p : hkq ] as @xmath108 , @xmath109 the proof follows the _ constant - term _ method , which begins with the observation that @xmath110 can be written as a ( laurent ) coefficient of a two - variable series , namely @xmath111}\left(\ \sum_{n\in{{\mathbb{z}}}}q^{\frac{k(k+1)n^2}{2}}x^{-n } \sum_{r\geq 0}\frac{x^r}{\big(q^k ; q^k\big)_r } \sum_{s\geq 0}\frac{(-1)^s x^s q^{\frac{(k+1)s(s+1)}{2}}}{\big(q^{k+1 } ; q^{k+1}\big)_s } \right).\ ] ] as indicated , the series on the right side of factorizes into three sums ( in @xmath3 , @xmath112 , and @xmath113 ) , and we now express each of the three factors in terms of known number - theoretic functions .
note that all of the summations are convergent for @xmath114 .
the first factor is @xmath115 , where @xmath116 is the _
jacobi theta function_. the second and third summations can both be expressed as infinite products via the following instances of the @xmath1-binomial theorem @xcite : @xmath117 we further rewrite these terms using the _ quantum dilogarithm _ ; this function is defined by @xmath118 the expression in can now be written as @xmath119\bigg ( \theta\left(q^{\frac{k(k+1)}2};x\right)\ , \exp\bigg(\operatorname{li}_2\left(x;q^k\right)-\operatorname{li}_2\left(x q^{k+1 } ; q^{k+1}\right)\bigg)\bigg).\ ] ] applying cauchy s theorem , we recover the @xmath120-coefficient as @xmath121+ic } \theta\left(q^{\frac{k(k+1)}2};e^{2 \pi i u}\right)\ , \exp\bigg(\operatorname{li}_2\left(e^{2 \pi
i u};q^k\right)- \operatorname{li}_2\left(e^{2 \pi i u } q^{k+1 } ; q^{k+1}\right)\bigg ) du,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath122 is a real constant that will be specified later .
the theta function may be transformed using the standard poisson summation formula @xcite , resulting in @xmath123 our integral then transforms to @xmath124+ic } \sum_{n\in{{\mathbb{z } } } } \exp\left(-\frac{2\pi^2 ( n+u)^2}{\varepsilon k(k+1 ) } + \operatorname{li}_2\left(e^{2 \pi i u};q^k\right)-\operatorname{li}_2\left(e^{2 \pi
i u } q^{k+1 } ; q^{k+1}\right)\right ) du \notag \\
\label{e : hkqint } & = \sqrt{\frac{2\pi^2}{\varepsilon k(k+1 ) } } \int_{{{\mathbb{r}}}+ic } \exp\left ( -\frac{2\pi u^2}{\varepsilon k(k+1 ) } + \operatorname{li}_2\left(e^{2\pi iu } ; e^{-k\varepsilon}\right ) -\operatorname{li}_2\left(e^{2\pi iu-(k+1)\varepsilon } ; e^{-(k+1)\varepsilon}\right)\right ) du.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we now apply the _ stationary phase _ method to this integral , which is generally useful for determining the asymptotic behavior of integrals of the form @xmath125 as @xmath108 . if @xmath126 has a critical point at @xmath127 , and both @xmath126 and @xmath128 have taylor expansions around this point , then the dominant asymptotic term of the integral can be described in terms of @xmath129 and @xmath130 .
in order to apply the stationary phase method to , we must first rewrite the integrand in this shape in order to identify the dominant asymptotic terms . if @xmath131 and @xmath132 then the laurent expansion of the quantum dilogarithm begins @xmath133 uniformly in @xmath78 as @xmath134 . here
@xmath135 is the standard dilogarithm function .
using , we study the argument of the exponential in the integrand of , namely @xmath136 in particular , we consider the laurent expansion of and denote the coefficient of the ( leading ) @xmath137 term by @xmath138 we proceed by determining the critical point(s ) of @xmath126 .
its derivative is @xmath139 and the critical point therefore occurs at @xmath140 we denote this critical value of @xmath141 by @xmath142 , which also determines the most appropriate height of the contour ( specifically , @xmath143 ) . at the critical value , the function @xmath126 evaluates to @xmath144 here we used the functional equation @xcite @xmath145 by definition @xmath146 , but the second derivative still makes a contribution to the overall asymptotic behavior , so we calculate @xmath147 we can therefore compute the first terms in the taylor expansion around @xmath148 of . in particular , using the change of variable @xmath149 , this taylor expansion is @xmath150 plugging in the expansions and to the integral , the contour may then be shifted to the real axis , leading finally to the evaluation @xmath151
in this section we use the asymptotic behavior of generating series in order to determine the asymptotic behavior of @xmath25 as @xmath10 . as before , we write @xmath152 . recall that @xmath153 ingham s tauberian theorem relates the asymptotic behavior of such a series to its coefficients .
the following result is a special case of theorem 1 in @xcite .
[ t : ingham ] let @xmath154 be a power series with real nonnegative coefficients and radius of convergence equal to @xmath2 . if there exist @xmath155 , @xmath156 such that @xmath157 as @xmath158 , then @xmath159 as @xmath160 .
the modular inversion formula for dedekind s eta - function ( page 121 , proposition 14 of @xcite ) states that @xmath161 this implies that @xmath162 @xmath163 combined with proposition [ p : hkq ] , this implies that as @xmath164 @xmath165 note that the coefficients of this @xmath1-series are @xmath166 . applying theorem [ t : ingham ] with @xmath167 then gives the stated asymptotic formula for @xmath25 by telescoping . | in this paper we introduce @xmath0-run overpartitions as natural analogs to partitions without @xmath0-sequences , which were first defined and studied by holroyd , liggett , and romik . following their work as well as that of andrews ,
we prove a number of results for @xmath0-run overpartitions , beginning with a double summation @xmath1-hypergeometric series representation for the generating functions . in the special case of @xmath2-run overpartitions
we further relate the generating function to one of ramanujan s mock theta functions .
finally , we describe the relationship between @xmath0-run overpartitions and certain sequences of random events , and use probabilistic estimates in order to determine the asymptotic growth behavior of the number of @xmath0-run overpartitions of size @xmath3 . |
computing invariants of real quadratic fields , in particular the ideal class group and the regulator , has been of interest since the time of gauss , and today has a variety of applications . for example , solving the well - known pell equation is intimately linked to computing the regulator , and integer factorization algorithms have been developed that make use of this invariant .
public - key cryptosystems have also been developed whose security is related to the presumed difficulty of these computational tasks .
see @xcite for details .
the fastest algorithm for computing the ideal class group and regulator in practice is a variation of buchmann s index - calculus algorithm @xcite due to jacobson @xcite .
the algorithm on which it is based has subexponential complexity in the size of the discriminant of the field .
the version in @xcite includes several practical enhancements , including the use of self - initialized sieving to generate relations , a single large - prime variant ( based on that of buchmann and dllman @xcite in the case of imaginary quadratic fields ) , and a practical version of the required linear algebra .
this approach proved to work well , enabling the computation of the ideal class group and regulator of a real quadratic field with a 101-decimal digit discriminant @xcite .
unfortunately , both the complexity results of buchmann s algorithm and the correctness of the output are dependent on the generalized riemann hypothesis ( grh ) .
nevertheless , for fields with large discriminants , this approach is the only one that works .
recently , biasse @xcite presented practical improvements to the corresponding algorithm for imaginary quadratic fields .
these included a double large prime variant and improved algorithms for the required linear algebra .
the resulting algorithm was indeed faster then the previous state - of - the - art @xcite , and enabled the computation of the ideal class group of an imaginary quadratic field with @xmath0 decimal digit discriminant . in this paper
, we describe a number of practical improvements to the index - calculus algorithm for computing the class group and regulator of a real quadratic field .
in addition to adaptations of biasse s improvements in the imaginary case , we have found some modifications designed to improve the regulator computation part of the algorithm .
we also investigate applying an idea of bernstein @xcite to factor residues produced by the sieve using a batch smoothness test .
extensive computations demonstrating the effectiveness of our improvements are presented , including the computation of class group and regulator of a real quadratic field with @xmath0 decimal digit discriminant .
this paper is organized as follows . in the next section
, we briefly recall the required background of real quadratic fields , and give an overview of the index - calculus algorithm using self - initialized sieving .
our improvements to the algorithm are described in section [ sec : improvements ] , followed by numerical results in section [ numerical ] .
we present an overview of required concepts related to real quadratic fields and the index - calculus algorithm for computing invariants .
for more details , see @xcite .
let @xmath1 be the real quadratic field of discriminant @xmath2 where @xmath3 is a positive integer congruent to @xmath4 or @xmath5 modulo @xmath6 with @xmath3 or @xmath7 square - free .
the integral closure of @xmath8 in @xmath9 , called the maximal order , is denoted by @xmath10 an interesting aspect of real quadratic fields is that their maximal orders contain infinitely many non - trivial units , i.e. , units that are not roots of unity .
more precisely , the unit group of @xmath11 consists of an order @xmath12 torsion subgroup and an infinite cyclic group . the smallest unit greater than @xmath13 denoted by @xmath14
is called the fundamental unit .
the regulator of @xmath11 is defined as @xmath15 the fractional ideals of @xmath9 play an important role in the index - calculus algorithm described in this paper . in our setting ,
a fractional ideal is a rank @xmath12 @xmath8-submodule of @xmath16 any fractional ideal can be represented as @xmath17 \enspace,\ ] ] where @xmath18 and @xmath19 the integers @xmath20 @xmath21 and @xmath22 are unique , and @xmath23 is defined modulo @xmath24 the ideal @xmath25 is said to be primitive if @xmath26 and @xmath27 is integral .
the norm of @xmath25 is given by @xmath28 ideals can be multiplied using gauss s composition formulas for indefinite binary quadratic forms .
ideal norm respects ideal multiplication , and the set @xmath29 forms an infinite abelian group with identity @xmath11 under this operation . the inverse of @xmath25 is @xmath30 \enspace.\ ] ] the group @xmath29 is generated by the prime ideals of @xmath31 namely those integral ideals of the form @xmath32 where @xmath33 is a prime that is split or ramified in @xmath16 as @xmath11 is a dedekind domain , the integral part of any fractional ideal can be factored uniquely as a product of prime ideals . to factor
@xmath34 it suffices to factor @xmath35 and , for each prime @xmath33 dividing the norm , determine whether the prime ideal @xmath36 or @xmath37 divides @xmath25 according to whether @xmath38 or @xmath39 modulo @xmath40 the ideal class group , denoted by @xmath41 is the factor group @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the subgroup of principal ideals .
the class group is finite abelian , and its order is called the class number , denoted by @xmath44 by computing the class group we mean computing the elementary divisors @xmath45 with @xmath46 for @xmath47 such that @xmath48 like other index - calculus algorithms , the algorithm for computing the class group and regulator relies on finding certain smooth quantities , those whose prime divisors are all small in some sense . in the case of quadratic fields ,
one searches for smooth principal ideals for which all prime ideal divisors have norm less than a given bound @xmath49 the set of prime ideals @xmath50 with @xmath51 is called the factor base . a principal ideal @xmath52 with @xmath53 that factors completely over the factor base yields the relation @xmath54 the key to the index - calculus algorithm is the fact , proved by buchmann @xcite , that the set of all relations forms a sublattice @xmath55 of determinant @xmath56 provided that the prime ideals in the factor base generate @xmath57 this follows , in part , due to the fact that @xmath58 the integer component of @xmath59 is the kernel of the homomorphism from @xmath60 to @xmath61 given by @xmath62 for @xmath63 if @xmath64 generate @xmath41 then this homomorphism is surjective , and the homomorphism theorem then implies that @xmath65 the main idea behind the index - calculus algorithm is to find random relations until they generate the entire relation lattice @xmath66 let @xmath67 denote the sublattice of @xmath68 generated by the relations that have been computed . to determine whether @xmath69 one computes an approximation @xmath70 of @xmath56 such that @xmath71 the value @xmath70 is obtained by approximating the @xmath72-function @xmath73 where @xmath74 denotes the kronecker symbol @xmath75 and applying the analytic class number formula . if @xmath76 then @xmath77 is a integer multiple of @xmath78 thus , @xmath79 as soon as @xmath80 because @xmath56 is the only integer multiple of itself in the interval @xmath81 as described in @xcite , an adaptation of the strategy used in the self - initialized quadratic sieve ( siqs ) factoring algorithm is used to compute relations .
first , compute the ideal @xmath82 $ ] with @xmath83 let @xmath84 with @xmath85 be an arbitrary element in @xmath86 then @xmath87 where @xmath88 because ideal norm is multiplicative , there exists an ideal @xmath89 with @xmath90 such that @xmath91 thus , finding @xmath92 and @xmath93 such that @xmath94 factors over the norms of the prime ideals in the factor base yields a relation .
such @xmath92 and @xmath93 can be found by sieving the polynomial @xmath95 and a careful selection of the ideals @xmath25 yields a generalization of self - initialization , in which the coefficients of the sieving polynomials and their roots modulo the prime ideal norms can be computed quickly . in practice ,
we use @xmath96 for sieving , so that the algorithm resembles the siqs more closely . for more details , see @xcite or @xcite .
the determinant of the relation lattice @xmath67 is computed in two stages .
the first step is to compute the determinant of the integer part of this sublattice by finding a basis in hermite normal form ( hnf ) .
once @xmath67 has full rank , the determinant of this basis is computed as the product of the diagonal elements in a matrix representation of the basis vectors .
the group structure is then computed by finding the smith normal form of this matrix .
the real part of @xmath97 a multiple of the regulator @xmath98 is computed by first finding a basis of the kernel of the matrix consisting of the integer parts of the relations .
every vector @xmath99 in the kernel corresponds to a multiple of the regulator computed with @xmath100 the `` real gcd '' of the multiples @xmath101 computed from each basis vector of the kernel , defined as @xmath102 is then the real part of @xmath103 an algorithm of maurer @xcite can be used to compute the real gcd efficiently and with guaranteed numerical accuracy given explicit representations of the @xmath104 and the kernel vectors .
as mentioned in the introduction , the correctness of this algorithm depends on the truth of the generalized riemann hypothesis .
in fact , the grh must be invoked in two places .
the first is to compute a sufficiently accurate approximation @xmath70 of @xmath56 via a method due to bach @xcite . without the grh ,
an exponential number of terms in the euler product used to approximate @xmath105 must be used ( see , for example , @xcite ) . the second is to ensure that the factor base generates @xmath57 without the grh , an exponential size factor base is required , whereas by a theorem of bach @xcite the prime ideals of norm less than @xmath106 suffice . in practice ,
an even smaller factor base is often used , but in that case , the factor base must be verified by showing that every remaining prime ideal with norm less than bach s bound can be factored over the ideals in the factor base .
in this section , we describe our practical improvements for computing the class group structure and the regulator of a the real quadratic field .
some of these improvements , such as the double large prime variant and structured gaussian elimination , were used in @xcite for the simpler case of imaginary quadratic number fields . on the other hand ,
the batch smoothness test and system solving based methods for computing the regulator had never been implemented in the context of number fields before .
improving the relation collection phase allows us to speed up every other stage of the algorithm .
indeed , the faster the relations are found , the smaller the factor base can be , thus reducing the dimensions of the relation matrix and the time taken by the linear algebra phase .
in addition , the verification phase also relies on our ability to find relations and therefore benefits from improvements to the relation collection phase . throughout the rest of the paper
, @xmath107 denotes the relation matrix , the matrix whose rows are the integer parts of the relations .
the large prime variants were developed in the context of integer factorization to speed up the relation collection phase in both the quadratic sieve and the number field sieve .
a single large prime variant was described by buchmann and dllman @xcite for computing the class group of an imaginary quadratic field , and adapted to the real case by jacobson @xcite .
biasse @xcite described how the double large prime strategy could be using in the imaginary case , and obtained a significant speed - up .
the idea is to keep relations involving one or two extra primes not in the factor base of norm less than @xmath108 .
these relations thus have the form @xmath109 for @xmath110 in @xmath111 , and for @xmath112 of norm less than @xmath113 .
we will refer to these types of partial relations as 1-partial relations and 2-partial relations , respectively .
keeping partial relations only involving one large prime is the single large prime variant , whereas keeping those involving one or two is the double large prime variant which was first described by lenstra and manasse @xcite .
we do not consider the case of more large primes , but it is a possibility that has been studied in the context of factorization @xcite .
partial relations may be identified as follows .
let @xmath114 be the remainder of @xmath96 after the division by all primes @xmath115 , and assume that @xmath116 .
if @xmath117 then we have a full relation .
if @xmath118 then we have a 1-partial relation .
we can see here that detecting 1-partial relations is almost for free .
if we also intend to collect 2-partial relations then we have to consider the following possibilities : 1 .
@xmath119 ; 2 .
@xmath114 is prime and @xmath120 ; 3 .
@xmath114 is prime and @xmath121 ; 4 .
@xmath114 is composite and @xmath122 . in cases 1 and 2
we discard the relation . in case 3
we have a 1-partial relation , and in case 4 we have @xmath123 where @xmath124 and @xmath125 .
cases 1 , 2 , and 3 can be checked very easily , but if none are satisfied we need to factor @xmath114 in order to determine whether case 4 is satisfied .
we used milan s implementation of the squfof algorithm @xcite based on the theoretical work of @xcite to factor the @xmath114 values produced .
even though we might have to factor the remainder , partial relations are found much faster than full relations .
however , the dimensions of the resulting matrix are much larger , thus preventing us from running the linear algebra phase directly on the resulting relation matrix . in addition
, we have to find many more relations since we have to produce a full rank matrix .
we will see in [ gauss ] how to reduce the dimensions of the relation matrix using gaussian elimination techniques .
after detecting potential candidates for smooth integers via the siqs , one has to certify their smoothness . in @xcite ,
this was done by trial division with the primes in the factor base . the time taken by trial division
can be shortened by using bernstein s batch smoothness test @xcite , which uses a product tree structure and modular arithmetic to factor a batch of residues simultaneously in time @xmath126 where @xmath23 is the total number of input bits .
instead of testing the smoothness of every potential candidate as soon as they are discovered , we rather stored them and tested them at the same time using bernstein s method as soon their number exceeded a certain limit .
this improvement has an effect that is all the more important when the time spent in the trial division is long . in our algorithm
, this time mostly depends on the tolerance value @xmath127 a parameter used to control the number of candidates yielded by the sieve for smoothness testing . as mentioned in [ sieving ] , in order to determine whether the computed relations generate the entire relation lattice , we need to compute the hnf basis of the sublattice they generate .
this can be done by putting the integer components of the relations as rows in a relation matrix , and computing the hnf .
the first step when using large primes is to compute full relations from all of the partial relations .
traditionally , rows were recombined to give full relations as follows . in the case of 1-partial relations , any pair of relations involving the same large prime @xmath128
were recombined into a full relation . in the case of 2-partial relations ,
lenstra @xcite described the construction of a graph whose vertices were the relations and whose edges linked vertices having one large prime in common .
finding independent cycles in this graph allows us to recombine partial relations into full relations . in this paper , we instead follow the approach of cavallar @xcite , developed for the number field sieve , and adapted by the first author to the computation of ideal class group structures in imaginary quadratic number fields @xcite , which uses gaussian elimination on columns .
the ideas is to eliminate columns using structured gaussian strategies until the dimensions of the matrix are small enough to allow the computation of the hnf with standard algorithms .
let us recall a few definitions .
first , subtracting two rows is called _ merging_. if two relations corresponding to rows @xmath129 and @xmath130 share the same prime @xmath128 with coefficients @xmath131 and @xmath132 respectively , then multiplying @xmath129 by @xmath132 and @xmath130 by @xmath131 and merging is called _
pivoting_. finally , finding a sequence of pivots leading to the elimination of a column of hamming weight @xmath133 is a @xmath133-way merge .
we aim to reduce the dimensions of the relation matrix by performing @xmath133-way merges on the columns of weight @xmath134 in increasing order for a certain bound @xmath135 . to limit the growth of the density and of the size of the coefficients induced by these operations , we used optimized pivoting strategies . in what follows
we describe an algorithm performing @xmath133-way merges to minimize the growth of both the density and the size of the coefficients , thus allowing us to go deeper in the elimination process and delay the explosion of the coefficients . as in @xcite
, we define a cost function @xmath136 mapping rows onto the integers .
the one used in @xcite satisfied @xmath137 where @xmath138 and @xmath139 are positive numbers , and @xmath140 $ ] is a row corresponding to @xmath141 .
this way , the heaviest rows are those which have a high density and large coefficients . in our experiments for this work , we used a different cost function , see [ timings ] . then
, to perform a @xmath133-way merge on a given column , we construct a complete graph @xmath142 of size @xmath133 such that * the vertices are the rows @xmath143 and * every edge linking @xmath144 and @xmath145 has weight @xmath146 , where @xmath147 is obtained by pivoting @xmath144 and @xmath145 .
finding the best sequence of pivots with respect to the chosen cost function @xmath136 is equivalent to finding the minimum spanning tree @xmath148 of @xmath142 , and then recombining every row @xmath149 with its parent starting with the leaves of @xmath148 . unlike in @xcite
, we need to keep track of the permutations we apply to the relation matrix , and of the empty columns representing primes of norm less than @xmath150 .
this will be required for the regulator computation part of the algorithm described next . as mentioned in [ sieving ] ,
the usual way to compute the regulator is to find a basis of the kernel of the relation matrix , compute integer multiples of the regulator from these basis vectors , and compute their real gcd using maurer s algorithm @xcite .
if @xmath151 then either the class number or regulator computed is too large , and we need to find extra relations corresponding to new generators , and new kernel vectors involving them . in this section , we describe a way of taking advantage of the large number of generators involved in the different partial relations .
indeed , the dimensions of the relation matrix before the gaussian elimination stage is much larger than in the base scenario and thus involves more generators .
consequently , given a set of @xmath152 kernel vectors @xmath153 , the probability that the corresponding elements @xmath154 where @xmath104 is the generator of the @xmath155-th relation , can be recombined into @xmath156 is much larger . on the other hand ,
the dimensions of the matrix prevents us from running a kernel computation directly after the relation collection phase .
thus , rather than attempting to compute the kernel , we use a method similar to that of vollmer @xcite based on solving linear systems .
the first step of our algorithm consists of putting the matrix in a pseudo - lower triangular form using a permutation obtained during the gaussian elimination phase .
indeed , as part of this computation we obtain a unimodular matrix @xmath157 such that @xmath158{c.c}{c.c } \begin{bmat}[2pt,1cm,1.5cm]{c}{c } a \end{bmat } & \begin{bmat}[2pt,2cm,1.5cm]{c}{c } ( 0 ) \end{bmat } \\
\begin{bmat}[2pt,1cm,2.5cm]{c}{c } ( * ) \end{bmat } & \begin{bmat}[2pt,2cm,2.5cm]{ccc}{ccc } 1 & & ( 0 ) \\ & \ddots & \\ ( * ) & & 1 \end{bmat } \end{bmat } \right).\ ] ] thus , solving a linear system of the form @xmath159 for a vector @xmath160 boils down to solving a system of the form @xmath161 , then doing a trivial descent through the diagonal entries which equal 1 and finally permuting back the coefficients using @xmath162 . to solve the small linear systems
, we used the algorithm ` certsolveredlong ` from the iml library @xcite .
it takes a single precision dense representation of @xmath163 and returns an lll - reduced solution .
once @xmath107 is in pseudo - lower triangular form , we draw a set of relations @xmath164 which are not already rows of @xmath107 , and for each @xmath144 , @xmath165 , we solve the system @xmath166 we then augment @xmath107 with the rows @xmath144 for @xmath165 and the vectors @xmath167 with @xmath22 extra coordinates , which are all set to zero except for the @xmath155-th which is set to @xmath168 .
@xmath169{c}{c.c } \begin{bmat}(e){c}{c } m \end{bmat } \\
\begin{bmat}[2pt,1cm,0.5cm]{c}{c } r_i \end{bmat } \end{bmat } \right ) \ \ x_i ' : = \left ( \begin{bmat}(@)[2pt,3cm,0.5cm]{c.c}{c } \begin{bmat}(e){c}{c } x_i \end{bmat } & \begin{bmat}[2pt,1cm,0.5cm]{ccc}{c } 0\hdots 0 & -1 & 0\hdots 0 \end{bmat } \end{bmat}\right).\ ] ] we clearly have @xmath170 for @xmath171 and the @xmath172 can be used to find a multiple of @xmath173 as described in [ sieving ] .
in this section , we give numerical results showing the impact of our improvements . for each timing , we specify the architecture used . all the timings were obtained with our code in c++ based on the libraries gmp @xcite , ntl @xcite , iml @xcite and linbox @xcite .
all timings are in cpu seconds . the state of the art concerning class group and regulator computation was established in @xcite , where all the timings were obtained with the sparcstation ii architecture .
in addition , most of the code used at the time is unavailable now , including the hnf computation algorithm .
thus , providing a meaningful comparison between our methods and those of @xcite is difficult .
we chose to implement the hnf computation algorithm in a way that resembles the one of @xcite , but takes advantage of the libraries available today for computing the determinant and the modular hnf .
we used this implementation in each different scenario .
the relation collection phase is easier to compare , since our method relies on siqs . in the following
, we will refer to the base case as the strategy consisting of finding the relation matrix without using the large prime variants or the smoothness batch test , and calculating the regulator by computing its kernel with the algorithm ` nullspacelong ` from iml library .
it differs from the 0 large prime case ( 0lp ) where we use the algorithm described in [ kernel ] for computing the regulator , along with a relation collection phase that does not use large primes .
we also denote the 1 large prime scenario by 1lp , the 2 large primes by 2lp and 2lp batch when using batch smoothness test . in table
[ tab : sieve ] , we give the time taken to collect all necessary relations . without large primes , we collected @xmath174 relations , whereas when we allow large primes we need to collect enough relations to ensure that the number of rows is larger than the number of non - empty columns .
we used a 2.4 ghz opteron with 16 gb of memory and took @xmath175 with @xmath176 . for each discriminant
, we used the optimal parameters given in @xcite , including the size of the factor base , even if we tend to reduce this parameter when optimizing the overall time .
the only parameter we modified is the tolerance value for the siqs , as a higher tolerance value is required for the large prime variations .
in each case we took @xmath177 .
it is shown in @xcite that the ratio @xmath178 does not have an important impact on the sieving time .
.comparative table of the relation collection time [ cols= " > , > , > , > , > " , ] table [ overall : tab ] shows that there is an overall speed - up of of a factor of 2 for the smallest discriminants and 4 for the largest .
the base case with the largest discriminants suffers from the necessity of finding some relations in a more randomized way .
this ensures that we can get full rank submatrices of the relation matrix after the gaussian elimination to compute a small multiple of @xmath179 .
matrices produced using the large prime variants do not need this extra step , even with the largest discriminants .
this naturally affects the sieving time , since we can not use siqs for that purpose , but also affects phases relying on linear algebra .
indeed , elimination produces a matrix with larger entries and dimensions .
the improvements we described allow us to compute class groups and regulators of real number fields with larger discriminants than was previously possible .
the key is to parallelize the relation collection and verification phase , while the linear algebra has to be performed the usual way .
these methods were successfully used in @xcite to compute the class group structure of an imaginary quadratic field with a 110-digit discriminant .
we used a cluster with 260 2.4ghz xeon cores to compute a relation matrix corresponding to the discriminant @xmath180 in 4 days .
we allowed two large primes , used a tolerance value of 3.0 , tested batches of 100 residues , took @xmath181 and set @xmath182 .
then , we used three 2.4 ghz opterons with 32 gb of memory each to compute determinants of full - rank submatrices of the relation matrix after the gaussian elimination in 1 day , and one 2.4ghz opteron to compute the hnf modulo the gcd of these determinants in 3 days .
we had to find 4018 extra relations during the verification phase that took 4 days on 96 2.4ghz xeon cores .
we thus obtained that @xmath183 and the corresponding regulator is @xmath184 we estimate that it would take two weeks ( 4000 relations per day ) to complete the relation collection for @xmath185 with the same factor base as @xmath186 , thus requiring a similar time for the linear algebra .
recently , our work has been extended to the problems of principal ideal testing and solving the discrete logarithm problem in the ideal class group @xcite . the double large prime variant and improvements to relation generation translated directly to improvements in this context
. however , hnf computations are not required for this problem , and linear system solving over @xmath8 can be used instead .
the numerical results were used to give estimates for discriminant sizes that offer equivalent security to recommended sizes of rsa moduli .
some possibilities for further improvements remain to be investigated .
for example , a lattice sieving strategy could be used to sieve @xmath187 instead of @xmath188 factor refinement and coprime factorization techniques may be a useful alternative to bernstein s batch smoothness test .
multiple large primes have been successfully used for integer factorization and could also be tried in our context .
there is also still room for improvement to the linear algebra components .
for example , a hnf algorithm that exploits the natural sparseness of the relation matrix , perhaps as a black - box algorithm , would be useful .
if such an algorithm were available , we could reconsider using gaussian elimination techniques since they induce a densification of the matrix .
we could also study the effect of other dense hnf algorithms in existing linear algebra packages such as kash , pari , sage and especially magma which seems to have the most efficient hnf algorithm for our types of matrices . in that case
, we would need the elimination phase regardless of how these algorithms are affected by the density and the size of the coefficients of the matrix .
indeed , we can not afford manipulating a dense representation of the matrix before the gaussian elimination phase .
j. buchmann and s. dllmann , _ distributed class group computation _
, festschrift aus anla des sechzigsten geburtstages von herrn prof .
g. hotz , universitt des saarlandes , 1991 , and teubner , stuttgart , 1992 , pp .
s. cavallar , _ strategies in filtering in the number field sieve _ , ants - iv : proceedings of the 4th international symposium on algorithmic number theory , lecture note in computer science , vol .
1838 , springer - verlag , 2000 , pp .
209232 .
b. dodson , p. c. leyland , a. k. lenstra , a. muffett , and s. wagstaff , _ mpqs with three large primes _ , ants - v : proceedings of the 5th international symposium on algorithmic number theory , lecture note in computer science , vol .
2369 , springer - verlag , 2002 , pp .
446460 .
m. j. jacobson , jr .
, r. scheidler , and h. c. williams , _ the efficiency and security of a real quadratic field based key exchange protocol _ , public - key cryptography and computational number theory ( warsaw , poland ) , de gruyter , 2001 , pp .
89112 .
a. k. lenstra and m. s. manasse , _ factoring with two large primes ( extended abstract ) _ , advances in cryptology - eurocrypt 90 , lecture note in computer science , vol . 473 , springer - verlag , 1991 , pp . 7282 .
u. vollmer , _ an accelerated buchmann algorithm for regulator computation in real quadratic fields _ , algorithmic number theory ants - v , lecture notes in computer science , vol .
2369 , 2002 , pp . 148162 . | we present improvements to the index - calculus algorithm for the computation of the ideal class group and regulator of a real quadratic field .
our improvements consist of applying the double large prime strategy , an improved structured gaussian elimination strategy , and the use of bernstein s batch smoothness algorithm .
we achieve a significant speed - up and are able to compute the ideal class group structure and the regulator corresponding to a number field with a 110-decimal digit discriminant . |
sn1987a neutrino events @xcite prompted many dedicated analyses .
even if the number of detected neutrinos is limited , these analyses provide interesting limits on neutrino properties and clues on the core collapse mechanism .
the question of which likelihood should be adopted for supernova neutrino data analysis will become crucial after the next galactic supernova , when a much larger number of neutrino events will be collected .
these events will carry information on neutrino properties mixed with information about supernova properties , so that we will need to jointly study their energy , time and direction distributions to try to extract all the relevant pieces of information .
therefore it will remain unpractical to bin the events and an event - by - event likelihood will remain the best tool for data analysis .
we present here the likelihood that should be ideally adopted for supernova neutrino data analysis .
our likelihood is more general than those already present in the literature @xcite-@xcite .
moreover , we resolve discrepancies in the previous literature , numerically relevant already in the concrete case of sn1987a data .
we argue , in particular , that the analysis of sn1987a neutrino data by lamb and loredo @xcite ( ll ) , quoted since 2004 in the summary table of the particle data group @xcite , uses a likelihood that incorrectly biases the analysis in favor of low energy events .
we here present the correct likelihood , generalizing the ` traditional ' form , advocated , e.g. , by jegerlehner , neubig and raffelt @xcite .
the structure of this paper is the following . in sect .
[ prim ] we derive the general form of the likelihood .
the application to a specific case of interest is discussed in sect .
[ thir ] . finally , in sect .
[ four ] we compare our likelihood with other forms adopted for the analysis of sn1987a neutrinos , showing how the fitted parameters got biased .
we write the expected event number in the @xmath0-th bin as : @xmath1 where @xmath2 represents the time coordinate , while @xmath3 indicates the set of all other observables ( energy , position , direction , etc . ) which define the properties of the @xmath0-bin .
we suppose that the bin sizes @xmath4 are infinitesimally small so that the condition @xmath5 holds true : therefore the probability that multiple events are collected in one bin is negligible and , thus , observing @xmath6 events corresponds to @xmath6 bins with 1 event , and all other bins with 0 events . according to poissonian statistics ( see e.g. , appendix a of @xcite )
the associated likelihood is : @xmath7 \times \prod_{i=1}^{n_{\rm ev } } n_i , \label{l1}\ ] ] where the sum in the exponent runs over all @xmath8 bins and gives the total number of expected events , while the product runs over all @xmath6 observed events .
as usual , one can convert this into a @xmath9 distribution as @xmath10 .
let us consider the case when the detected events are due to a signal @xmath11 , reprocessed in the detector through a response function @xmath12 , and to a known ( measured ) background process @xmath13 .
we have : @xmath14 the second term in the r.h.s . takes into account that a signal produced at the time @xmath15 and with coordinates @xmath16 , due to detector response , could be observed with a probability @xmath17 at a different time @xmath18 and coordinate @xmath19 . by integrating over all possible detection times and coordinates , we introduce the general form of the detection efficiency : @xmath20 the efficiency obeys the condition
@xmath21 , if we describe a situation when the events can be lost . by factoring out @xmath22
we define the smearing ( or error ) function @xmath23 @xmath24 normalized to unity : @xmath25 the background @xmath13 , the efficiency @xmath22 and the smearing @xmath23 describe the experimental apparatus . assuming that they are known , we can use an experimental result to learn on the signal @xmath11 , by the study of the likelihood function of eq .
( [ l1 ] ) together with ( [ dng ] ) . in the case of interest , it is possible to further simplify the problem by relying on the following assumptions : @xmath26 we assume that the response function factorizes in the time and in the coordinates as follows @xmath27 we introduce the time - independent efficiency in the observables @xmath28 , defined in analogy to eq .
( [ edef ] ) : @xmath29 and the smearing function defined in analogy with eq .
( [ gdef ] ) : @xmath30 again , it is normalized to unity : @xmath31 we will discuss later the specific form of these expressions for sn1987a .
@xmath32 if the time @xmath18 is measured with negligible error , we have @xmath33 possibly multiplied by a window function @xmath34 to account for the dead time @xmath35 after an event , due to supernova or to background ( for example , a muon ) , has been recorded .
concerning sn1987a data , only the _ relative _ time between events of the detectors was measured precisely ; one needs to take into account the uncertainty in the absolute time of the kamiokande - ii and baksan events .
@xmath36 we can finally assume that the background does not depend on the time , namely @xmath37 possibly , multiplied by @xmath34 to take into account for the absence of any events , including those due to background , during dead time .
( [ btdef ] ) implies that the background can be _ measured _ in the period when the signal is absent ( as for sn1987a ) . with these assumptions , eq .
( [ dng ] ) simplifies to : @xmath38 then , assuming that the @xmath6 events @xmath3 have been measured at time @xmath2 , the likelihood in eq .
( [ l1 ] ) becomes : @xmath39 dt_i d\x_i , \end{array } \label{l2}\ ] ] where , in the exponent , we replaced the sum over all infinitesimal bins with an integral and used ( [ petain ] ) . by dropping constant factors , that are irrelevant for estimating the parameters that control the theoretical expression of the signal rate @xmath11 , and replacing @xmath16 with @xmath19
, we get @xmath40 . \end{array }
\label{l3 } \label{alfin}\ ] ] this form of the likelihood is general enough for the purpose of analyzing sn1987a neutrinos .
moreover , this is a generalization of the likelihood advocated in @xcite for the study of radioactive decays , when the time of occurence of each event is measured .
as we already discussed , the dead time can be taken into account by extending the time integral in the exponent only to the time when the detector is on , thereby removing the time intervals where data taking was stopped after each candidate signal event .
as long as @xmath35 is small enough , one can equivalently take into account the dead time due to background events by multiplying the integrand in the exponent of ( [ alfin ] ) by the average live - time fraction , @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the time - averaged background event rate .
compare it with the discussion of @xcite , further elaborated in @xcite .
in order to specify the general formul , we choose a concrete and important example : we discuss the likelihood for the water erenkov detector kamiokande - ii . in this subsection
, we collect some useful definitions .
the variables that characterize an event are : @xmath43 for concreteness , we consider events resulting from the reaction @xmath44 when a positron is detected through its erenkov light ; similar considerations apply to the elastic scattering reaction or the charged current reactions with nuclei . in the construction of the likelihood
3 different directions are relevant : the direction @xmath45 of sn1987a ; the _ reconstructed _ direction @xmath46 of each event ; the _ true _
direction @xmath47 of the positrons produced by the detection process . for each event , the first 2 directions are fixed , while we have to integrate on the true direction of the positron , taking into account the detector response and the reconstructed event direction , as described in eq .
( [ alfin ] ) . to do this , it is convenient to use an `` event - centric '' system in which : + 1 ) the reconstructed positron direction is along the @xmath48 axis , @xmath49 2 ) the true positron direction is in the generic direction : @xmath50 so that @xmath51 thus , @xmath52 is the opening angle around the reconstructed direction and @xmath53 is the azimuthal angle .
the experimental collaborations usually quote the error on the angle @xmath54 between the true and the reconstructed direction for each bin ( rather than the the error on the direction versor @xmath55 itself ) .
+ 3 ) finally , we have the versor @xmath45 pointing in the direction of the supernova .
this , without loosing in generality , can be chosen in the plane @xmath56 : @xmath57 so that @xmath58 in the simplest approximation , we can describe the smearing function by assuming that it factorizes according to : @xmath59 where we denote by @xmath60 a standard gaussian in @xmath61 dimensions .
we include a normalization factor @xmath62 to describe the presence of physical boundaries , like e.g. , the fact that @xmath63 $ ] and @xmath64 $ ] when we integrate over the possible directions of @xmath47 .
the quantities @xmath65 are functions of the variables of eq .
( [ esamp ] ) .
we identify @xmath65 in the point @xmath66 with the error for the @xmath0-th event quoted by the experimental collaborations , e.g. , @xmath67 thus , we further approximate the smearing function : @xmath68 in the vicinity of each point where the likelihood should be evaluated see eq .
( [ alfin ] ) . ,
@xmath69 and @xmath70 , by @xmath71 .
we note , in this respect , that the normalization condition in eq .
( [ norm ] ) is obeyed even in the general case , when the functions @xmath65 vary with the true coordinates of positron , since one integrates over the _ reconstructed _ coordinates . ] the expressions for energy and position smearing functions are essentially standard and do not need particular attention .
the angular distribution requires , instead , a more detailed discussion .
first , we discuss the connection between the error @xmath69 to be inserted into eq .
( [ errors ] ) and the 1-sigma error on angle @xmath72 indicated by the experimental collaborations . in the gaussian assumption
, the function @xmath73 can be written as : @xmath74 where the function @xmath75 , given by : @xmath76 , \label{aaa1}\ ] ] describes the distribution of the angle @xmath77 between the true and the reconstructed direction ; the azimuthal angle @xmath53 is uniformly distributed as appropriate for an unbiased detector .
the normalization factor @xmath78 can be explicitely calculated @xmath79 and it is very close to one for the typical case @xmath80 .
we calculate @xmath69 by requiring that : @xmath81 for the 1 sigma error @xmath54 corresponds to the @xmath82 confidence level . for small @xmath69 , we get easily : @xmath83 typically the first term provides an adequate approximation for the quantity we search , @xmath69 .
now , we discuss a possible improvement of the gaussian assumption for the distribution @xmath73 .
experimental investigations of the super - kamiokande collaboration @xcite have shown that the tails of the angular distribution fall slower than @xmath84 and resemble more closely @xmath85 ; compare also with app .
c of @xcite .
this suggests to release the gaussian approximation for the distribution on the directions and to replace @xmath86 @xmath87 .
thus , the distribution over the cosine becomes : @xmath88 , \label{aaa2}\ ] ] where the proportionality constant @xmath89 is again close to one for small @xmath69 . by imposing the condition ( [ ddd ] ) and considering again the limit of small @xmath69 we calculate the new expression for @xmath69 , obtaining : @xmath90 where , as in eq .
( [ er1 ] ) , the first term is typically sufficient .
the two distributions are depicted in fig .
[ fig1 ] for a specific value of @xmath72 .
it is worthwhile to note various features of eqs .
( [ aaa1 ] ) and ( [ aaa2 ] ) : 1 .
when considered as functions of the direction we see that they both depend only @xmath91 and have a maximum for @xmath92 , as it should be
it is easy to treat them analytically , which is a welcome property to use them in a likelihood .
3 . it is simple to study their limit for small @xmath69 by replacing @xmath93 and @xmath94 , which makes their analytical treatment even simpler . )
coincides with the form commonly used in the literature @xcite and eq .
( [ aaa2 ] ) practically coincides with the form given in @xcite .
in fact , the exponential term in eq .
c1 of @xcite can be neglected in comparison to the linear term @xmath95 for all relevant energies . ]
4 . for a fixed @xmath72
, we see that @xmath69 is smaller in the second case ; thus , the maximum at @xmath96 is higher in the second case . 5 .
the most probable angle is @xmath97 in both cases ; thus it is smaller in the second case . a choice between eq .
( [ aaa1 ] ) and eq .
( [ aaa2 ] ) ( or other reasonable approximations ) is not critical for the analysis of sn1987a in view of the limited event sample .
however , the use of an appropriate distribution is potentially important for the analysis of the elastic scattering events from a future supernova in a water erenkov detector . .
the continuous curves show eq .
( [ aaa1 ] ) and the dashed curves show eq .
( [ aaa2 ] ) .
we here assumed @xmath98 , as appropriate for super - kamiokande @xcite and a typical energy of an elastic scattering event , @xmath99 mev , so that @xmath100 . [ fig1],scaledwidth=40.0% ]
we are now in the position to provide a concrete and useful expression for the likelihood that takes into account the reported information on the data and on the detector response .
we recall that : + 1 ) the signal is expected to be uniformly distributed inside the detector .
the angular dependence of the signal arises from the angular distribution of positrons produced by @xmath44 .
this can be expressed as a function of the angle @xmath101 between the direction @xmath47 of the produced positron and the direction @xmath45 of the sn1987a .
we can thus replace in eq .
( [ alfin ] ) : @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the volume of the detector , the product @xmath101 can be expressed through eqs .
( [ est ] ) and ( [ nst ] ) as : @xmath104 and the factor @xmath105 accounts for the fact that positron directions are uniformly distributed with respect to rotations around @xmath45 .
+ 2 ) we assume that the background does not depend on time , direction and position . we indicate the total background counting rate as a function of the energy with @xmath106 and we replace in eq .
( [ alfin ] ) : @xmath107 3 ) the average efficiency of the detector as a function of the energy @xmath108 is known .
we assume that the efficiency does not depend on time , position and direction , so that we can replace in eq .
( [ alfin ] ) : @xmath109 4 ) the errors on the energy @xmath110 and on the direction @xmath54 in the neighbourhood of the given datum are known .
we additionally indicate by @xmath70 the value of the error on the position , on which we have only limited information , @xmath111 m at 10 mev . at this point
, we have all the elements to write the concrete form of the likelihood . integrating away the gaussian on the positions @xmath112 and omitting the constant factor @xmath113 we get from eq .
( [ alfin ] ) : @xmath114 , \label{prat } \end{array}\ ] ] where eq .
( [ glia ] ) has been rewritten using the intuitive shorthands @xmath115 , @xmath116 , etc .
here , we compare our likelihood , eq . ( [ prat ] ) , with certain other likelihoods present in the recent literature and currently used for the analysis of sn1987a events .
the first likelihood is eq .
( 15 ) of @xcite : @xmath117 this is an approximation of our likelihood , in that the background has been neglected and the time and angular distribution are integrated ( averaged ) over ; in other words , only the energy distribution is considered . however , this expression is in direct correspondence with eq .
( [ prat ] ) , when @xmath118 and @xmath119 , and if we take as the definition of @xmath120 the one given in eqs .
( 18,19,21 ) of @xcite .
furthermore , the expression of @xcite agrees with eq .
( [ l1 ] ) .
the other likelihood that we consider is the one advocated by lamb and loredo @xcite .
this is given by their eq .
( 3.18 ) which , rewritten in our notations , reads @xmath121 , \end{array } \label{lll}\ ] ] where we neglected dead - time , as appropriate for kamiokande - ii , and dropped the information about the angular distribution . quoting @xcite : _
our derivation of the likelihood function reveals errors in previous attempts to account for the energy dependence of the efficiencies of the neutrino detectors ; we show that these errors significantly corrupt previous inferences .
_ indeed , the likelihood advocated by ll has been shown to have an important impact for the analysis of data also by similar and independent analyses of sn1987a observations @xcite .
we would like , however , to draw the discussion on the correctness of the likelihood of ll .
we see that the ll expression , eq .
( [ lll ] ) , coincides with our eq .
( [ prat ] ) _ only if we identify _ the function @xmath122 with the energy response function of the detector : @xmath123 where @xmath124 is the gaussian smearing of eq .
( [ cesent ] ) .
this is not the case for ll who instead claim ( see their eq .
( 3.21 ) ) : @xmath125 where @xmath126 is assumed to be the maximum energy where the efficiency vanishes ( i.e. , the minimum detectable energy ) and @xmath127 is the step function . the only special case in which the ll likelihood coincides with our result is when the average efficiency is assumed to be a step function @xmath128 . in general ,
this is not the case and the efficiency is a continuously growing function of the energy .
the ll likelihood therefore incorrectly biases the analysis in favor of low energy events .
the quantitative effect of this bias on data analysis will be discussed further in sect .
[ qqq ] . the above remarks amount to the consideration that the likelihood of lamb and loredo does _ not _ follow from the formal construction described in sects . [ prim ] and [ thir ] . however , it is instructive to point out more directly the profound principle problem of the ll likelihood .
we begin noting that eq .
( [ lll ] ) has been derived by omitting constant terms from @xmath129 } \times \\ \ \ \
\prod_{i=1}^{n_{\rm ev } } \left [ \int de \mathcal{l}_i(e ) s(e , t_i ) + \bar{b}(e_i ) \right]dt_ide_i , \end{array } \label{pll}\ ] ] which should represents the _ probability _ that a given experimental result is obtained .
this expression is supposed to have a general validity . then consider a simple limiting case : only one bin , with dimension @xmath130 and with energy above @xmath126 ; no background , @xmath131 ; a constant signal , @xmath132 ; a constant efficiency , @xmath133 ; a perfect energy resolution , @xmath134 ; a very small expected number of events , @xmath135 . in these assumptions ,
the most probable outcome is the case @xmath136 , followed by the case @xmath137 ; the probability of other possible results is negligible . from eq .
( [ pll ] ) , we calculate the probabilites of the cases when no event and one event are observed : @xmath138 and @xmath139 respectively .
their sum violates the basic principle according to which the sum of the probability for all possible results should be equal to one .
we comment here on a likelihood that was _ not _ proposed for the analysis of supernova neutrinos , but that it is strictly connected with the previous one . the same position as in eq .
( [ wrong ] ) was made in @xcite , where loredo defines the quantity @xmath140 .
this quantity , that evidently corresponds to the quantity @xmath122 discussed above , is claimed to be independent on the detection efficiency .
this position caused the criticism of loredo @xcite to the likelihood advocated for the analysis of trans - neptunian objects of bernstein _ et al . _
2004 @xcite ( see eq .
( a8 ) of @xcite ) .
again , we find the position of @xcite unjustified , while we agree with @xcite . in particular , eq .
( a4 ) of @xcite expresses the statement that the response function _ does _ contain the detection efficiency ; it corresponds strictly to our eq .
( [ edef ] ) .
finally , in the analyses performed by some of us @xcite , eq . ( [ prat ] ) was used , simplified to the case @xmath141 to take into account the mild angular dependence of the @xmath44 reaction .
this simplification does not affect significantly the analysis of sn1987a events .
the bias implied by the likelihood of ref .
@xcite is numerically important already for the analysis of sn1987a events , as found in @xcite and confirmed by @xcite . in order to illustrate this point better
, we recall certain results obtained in the previous analyses .
let us begin by considering the conventional exponential cooling model , in which the @xmath142 temperature decreases exponentially with the time and the neutrino - radius @xmath143 is constant .
as evident from fig .
[ fig2 ] , the use of eq .
( [ wrong ] ) rather than eq .
( [ right ] ) leads to important differences on the inferred values of the parameters .
we note in particular that the ( well - known ) difference between @xmath143 and the expected size of the neutron star radius , @xmath144 km , is amplified when we adopt eq .
( [ wrong ] ) ( i.e. , when we bias the analysis ) .
this outcome can be easily understood : the bias in favor of low energy events implies that @xmath145 ( that is proportional to the average energy of the electron antineutrinos ) will decrease ; thus , @xmath143 has to increase to keep the number of events constant . and the initial temperature @xmath145 obtained from two analyses of sn1987a data based on the exponential cooling model . when eq .
( [ wrong ] ) is adopted , there is a good agreement between the results of @xcite ( dotted line ) and those of @xcite ( dashed line ) ; the small discrepancies can be ascribed to the different statistical procedures ( bayesian in @xcite and frequentist in @xcite ) and to a different numerical treatment of the data .
the effect of switching from eq .
( [ wrong ] ) ( dashed line ) to eq .
( [ right ] ) ( continuous line ) is much more significant @xcite .
[ fig2],scaledwidth=34.0% ] the bias will be even more important for the analysis of a future galactic supernova , since the number of collected events will be much larger and the errors on the parameters are expected to scale as the square root of the number of the events . indeed , the analysis of the 29 events collected by kamiokande - ii , imb and baksan in an extension of the exponential cooling model leads to @xmath146 km and @xmath147 mev @xcite .
a recent analysis of simulated events from a future supernova , that assumed the same antineutrino emission model ( that includes an initial phase of intense emission ) , the same central values as found from sn1987a ( in particular , @xmath148 km and @xmath149 mev ) , and a supernova located at a distance of 20 kpc ( i.e. , a data set 30 times larger ) , leads to the conclusions that the parameters are correctly reconstructed when we use eq .
( [ right ] ) .
moreover , when we combine the results of the simulations , we can estimate the average values of the parameters and of their expected errors : @xmath150 km and @xmath151 mev @xcite .
the comparison with the values from sn1987a reveals that the errors are expected to decrease by about six times , which is similar to the improvement that we can ascribe to the increased number of data . we are lead to the conclusion that , after a future galactic supernova , the allowed regions in fig .
[ fig2 ] should shrink by a similar factor in linear scale , making the effect of the bias much more important .
we constructed the general likelihood for supernova data analysis , eq .
( [ alfin ] ) , and specified it to the analysis of sn1987a , eq .
( [ prat ] ) .
we have compared this likelihood with other forms advocated in the scientific literature . while our likelihood is a generalization of the likelihoods traditionally adopted for the analysis of sn1987a events ( or in general for the study of rare processes ) , it is in disagreement with other ones .
reasons and consequences of these disagreements are discussed .
we thank a. dighe , e. lisi , d. montanino and f. terranova for useful discussions .
this work was partly supported by high energy astrophysics studies contract number asi - inaf i/088/06/0 ; miur grant for the projects of national interest prin 2006 `` astroparticle physics '' ; european fp6 network `` universenet '' mrtn - ct-2006 - 035863 .
thanks capes ( grant number 3247 - 08 - 2 ) for financial support and infn gran sasso for hospitality .
bionta _ et al . _ phys . rev
. lett . 58 ( 1987 ) 1494 and c.b .
bratton _ et al .
_ , phys .
d 37 ( 1988 ) 3361 ; k. hirata _ et al .
_ , phys .
58 ( 1987 ) 1490 ; k.s . hirata _ et al .
_ , phys .
d 38 ( 1988 ) 448 ; e.n .
alekseev , l.n .
alekseeva , i.v .
krivosheina and v.i .
volchenko , phys.lett.b 205 ( 1988 ) 209 . summary table on `` @xmath152 mass '' of particle data group : s. eidelman _ et al .
b 592 ( 2004 ) , page 439 ; w.m .
yao _ et al .
_ , j. phys .
g 33 ( 2006 ) , page 472 ; c. amsler _ et al .
_ , phys .
b 667 ( 2008 ) , page 517 . | we derive the event - by - event likelihood that allows to extract the complete information contained in the energy , time and direction of supernova neutrinos , and specify it in the case of sn1987a data .
we resolve discrepancies in the previous literature , numerically relevant already in the concrete case of sn1987a data .
preprint : lngs / th-01/09 and cern - ph - th/2009 - 115 |
ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions at sps and rhic energies ( @xmath1 agev ) provided an enormous volume of experimental data on particle production @xcite . the microscopic mechanisms of hadron production are not fully understood and many different descriptions coexist to explain these data .
transverse momentum spectra of produced hadrons have been measured in a wide momentum region ( e.g. @xmath2 gev at rhic ) , and can become a decisive test between different perturbative and non - perturbative models of hadron formation .
investigations of @xmath3 collisions at high energies led to the introduction of chromoelectric flux tube ( string ) models , where these tubes are connecting the quark and diquark constituents of colliding protons @xcite .
strings are good examples of how to convert the kinetic energy of a collision into field energy .
when these flux tubes become unstable , new hadrons will be produced via quark - antiquark and diquark - antidiquark pair production .
such models can describe experimental data successfully at low @xmath0 , @xmath4 gev . at higher @xmath0
perturbative qcd - based models are working @xcite . in heavy ion reactions
finite number of nucleons collide and the number of produced strings scales with the number of participant nucleons . since hadron production at low @xmath0 scales with participant nucleons in a wide energy range , string models could reproduce available data surprisingly well in the soft region at sps energies @xcite .
however , the obtained high density for strings strengthened the idea of string melting and the formation of color ropes @xcite , which fill the finite transverse extension partially or completely . following these ideas ,
measured strangeness enhancement was explained successfully by rope formation @xcite .
this result has indicated the possible formation of extended color fields at sps energies . at rhic and lhc energies
the string density is expected to be so large that a strong gluon field will be formed in the whole available transverse volume .
furthermore , the gluon number will be so high that a classical gluon field as the expectation value of the quantum field can be considered and investigated in the reaction volume .
the properties of such non - abelian classical fields and details of gluon production were studied very intensively during the last years , especially asymptotic solutions @xcite .
fermion production was calculated recently @xcite .
lattice calculations were performed also to describe strong classical fields under finite space - time conditions @xcite .
fermion pair production together with boson pair production were investigated by kinetic models of particle production from strong abelian @xcite and non - abelian @xcite fields .
these calculations concentrated mostly on bulk properties , the time dependence of energy and particle number densities .
our main interest is the transverse momentum distribution of produced fermions and bosons . before performing non - abelian kinetic model calculation , we would like to understand the role of time dependence , the interplay between production and annihilation rates in a kinetic approach and the influence of finite transverse size on the transverse momentum distributions . in this paper
we summarize our results applying a kinetic model with a time - dependent abelian external field characterized by finite transverse geometry .
we concentrate on transverse momentum spectra for produced particles .
section 2 summarizes the field theoretical backgrounds for boson and fermion production in strong abelian field .
the kinetic equation is explained briefly in section 3 . in section 4
the influence of time dependence on fermionic and bosonic transverse momentum spectra is displayed and the obtained results are compared to lattice calculations . in section 5
we discuss our results .
let us consider a massive boson field @xmath5 in an external classical abelian vector field , @xmath6 .
the lagrangian @xmath7 leads to the equation of motion @xmath8 where @xmath9 with bosonic charge @xmath10 .
the bosonic mass is labelled by @xmath11 .
we will choose a longitudinally dominant vector field in hamilton gauge with the 4-potential @xmath12 which is the most appropriate for our investigation in the ultrarelativistic energy region . to imitate confinement properties of yang - mills fields ,
the component @xmath13 is limited in the transverse direction , and a finite flux tube radius @xmath14 is considered .
the external field is cylindrically symmetric .
it vanishes outside the tube , @xmath15 , and it is homogeneous inside the flux tube , @xmath16 @xcite .
the klein - gordon equation ( [ kleing ] ) reads for the boson field @xmath17 as @xmath18 \phi= 0 \ , \label{transkg}\ ] ] where the transverse laplace operator is given by @xmath19 for the bosonic field function in eq.([transkg ] ) we are looking for the following solution : @xmath20 one equation is obtained for the time - dependent part , @xmath21t(t)=0 \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and one for the spatial dependence , @xmath22 here @xmath23 is the separation constant which will be fixed later .
considering flux - tube boundary condition for @xmath24 and the constraint @xmath25 on the surface of the flux tube , the solution for the boson field is @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the @xmath28 zero of the bessel function @xmath29 and the constant @xmath30 appears during the normalization of the field function .
the energy of the bosonic quasiparticles reads @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the kinetic longitudinal momenta and @xmath33 labels the discrete transverse momenta . in section 3 the transverse momenta spectra of the newly produced bosons
will be determined at these discrete transverse momentum values , @xmath33 .
massive fermions ( @xmath34 ) can be described similarly in the presence of the above external classical abelian field @xmath35 . considering the fermionic lagrangian @xmath36 one obtains the corresponding equation of motion @xmath37 the solution of eq .
( [ ferm0 ] ) is wanted in the form of @xmath38 where an auxiliary field @xmath39 was introduced @xcite . in the cylindrically symmetric case ,
one obtains the following equation for @xmath40 : @xmath41 { \widehat \psi}= 0 \ .
\label{transf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we can look for the solution of eq.([transf ] ) in a form similar to eq.([bosona ] ) : @xmath42 eigenvector of matrix @xmath43 is labelled by @xmath44 , @xmath45 . during the solution of eq.([transf ] ) , the radial equation for @xmath46 leads to eq.([kgspace ] ) .
thus , one obtains @xmath47 and the same radial solutions with the same separation constants @xmath48 as above .
the one - particle energy for the auxiliary field is the following : @xmath49 here @xmath50 labels longitudinal time - dependent component @xmath51 satisfies the equation @xmath52 { \widehat t}(t)=0 \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] using eq.([ferm1 ] ) for the solution of the auxiliary field , one can reconstruct the fermion field @xmath53 . the dispersion relation in eq.([dispf ] ) remains valid for these fermions .
the finite radius of the flux tube determines a minimal transverse energy , @xmath54 . for @xmath3 collisions we obtain @xmath55 , for central @xmath56 collisions it is @xmath57 , which are very small , but nonzero values .
the kinetic equation with time - dependent external field can be constructed on the basis of the calculated bosonic and fermionic field functions . using a time - dependent bogoliubov transformation approach
( see e.g. refs .
@xcite ) or a quasiparticle representation approach @xcite , one obtains the following kinetic equation : @xmath58 here @xmath59 .
one - particle distribution functions for bosons(@xmath60 ) and fermions(@xmath61 ) are labelled by @xmath62 .
we note that the measurable longitudinal momentum of the produced particle has the value of @xmath63 .
equation ( [ ke ] ) will be solved at the discrete transverse momenta @xmath48 , which depend on the transverse radius ( @xmath14 ) of the chromoelectric field .
indeed , eq . ( [ ke ] ) can be solved at continuous transverse momenta and the solutions at corresponding @xmath48 will be selected .
the source term @xmath64 contains information about the time evolution of the system and is determined as @xmath65 \cos \left [ { 2 \int\limits_{t ' } ^t { d \tau } \ { \overline \omega}_{\pm}(t , \tau ; k_3)}\right ] \right\ } , \ & & \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath66^{2s_\pm}\ , . \ \ \label{wpm } \end{aligned}\ ] ] overlined notation indicates appropriate asymptotic behavior , namely @xmath67 .
similar asymptotics are valid for @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
the difference in boson and fermion production appears through the spin factor in eq .
( [ wpm ] ) , namely @xmath70 for bosons and @xmath71 for fermions .
now we introduce new auxiliary functions , @xmath72 and @xmath73 , and rewrite the integro - differential eq.([ke ] ) in a more convenient form containing full derivatives : @xmath74 this system of differential equations is solved for all sets of @xmath75 , which correspond to the different transverse and longitudinal momenta .
the functions @xmath76 start with zero initial value , describing a system without any bosons or fermions at the beginning . assuming different time dependences for the external field , @xmath77
, we obtain different particle productions .
we would like to note that produced charged particles generate an inner field which interferes with the external one @xcite .
this effect is neglected here , as well as a possible collision term , @xmath78 , on the right - hand side of eq .
( [ ke ] ) @xcite .
a given external field can mimic a certain self - consistent solution as expansion , collision or back reaction influenced time dependence of the field .
in heavy ion collisions , one can assume three different types of time dependence for the chromoelectric field to be formed : a ) pulse - like field develops with a fast increase , which is followed by a fast fall in the field strength ; b ) formation of a constant field ( @xmath79 ) is maintained after the fast increase in the initial time period ; c ) scaled decrease of the field strength appears , which is caused by particle production and/or transverse expansion , and the decrease is elongated in time much further than the pulse - like assumption .
figure [ etime ] displays three sets for the time dependence of the external field to investigate the above three different physical scenarios numerically : @xmath80 \hspace*{0.6truecm } & \label{ep } \\
% & & \nonumber \\
e_{const}(t ) & = \left\ { \begin{array}{ll } e_{pulse}(t ) & { \textrm at } \
\ { t < 0 } \\ % & \hspace*{1.9truecm } ( b ) \\ e_0 & { \textrm at } \ \ { t \geq 0 } \end{array } \right . \label{ec } \\
e_{scaled}(t ) & = \left\ { \begin{array}{ll } e_{pulse}(t ) & { \textrm at } \ \ { t < 0 } \\ % & \hspace*{1.7truecm } ( c ) \\
\frac{e_0}{(1+t / t_0)^{\kappa } } & { \textrm at } \ \ { t \geq 0 } \end{array } \right . \label{es}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we choose @xmath81 , which corresponds to rhic energies , and @xmath82 to indicate a longitudinally scaled bjorken expansion with @xmath83 .
in fact , the whole time dependence is scaled by @xmath84 .
figures [ bostime ] and [ fertime ] display the obtained transverse momentum spectra in midrapidity at time @xmath85 for bosons and fermions .
pulse - type time dependence leads to exponential spectra ( _ dotted lines _ ) , @xmath86 , where the slope value is @xmath87 for bosons and @xmath88 for fermions . in the other two cases , we obtain non - exponential spectra , which are generated by the long - lived electric field .
the transverse spectra from constant ( _ dashed lines _ ) and scaled ( _ solid lines _ ) fields are close , because the production and annihilation rates balance each other .
slight differences appear because of the fast fall of the scaled field immediately after @xmath89 .
we note here , that indeed we have discrete transverse momenta , @xmath48 , but with such small steps , which allow us to display continuous transverse momentum spectra . comparing the boson and fermion production in midrapidity
, one can recognize the large difference in the production rates and see a clear fermion dominance at all transverse momenta .
the reason of this dominance can be understood from fig .
4 , which displays the longitudinal particle spectra , @xmath90 , at fixed transverse momenta , @xmath91 , and time , @xmath92 . fermion spectra ( thick line ) have a reasonable value around zero longitudinal momenta ( which means midrapidity ) , but boson spectra ( thin line ) display a dip-like structure here .
the presence of this dip is related to the structure of the transition rate @xmath93 in eq .
( [ wpm ] ) and the longitudinal dominance of the electric field defined via @xmath24 : at zero longitudinal momenta ( @xmath63 ) there is no boson production , but fermion production is characterized by a well defined finite value . at extremely high - energy heavy ion collisions
we expect this longitudinal dominance of the chromoelectric field .
if transverse electric field components become comparable to the longitudinal one at lower energies , then the boson yield will be much larger .
the presence of scattering term , @xmath94 , can increase the yield in midrapidity from the neighbouring rapidity cells , where the yield is large , even if a longitudinal field component , @xmath13 , exists alone . in refs .
@xcite transverse momentum spectra for gluons were determined in su(3 ) classical field theory .
comparison between this non - abelian and our abelian calculation can be made , if we fix both field strength at the same value .
the energy density of the classical gluon field is given in refs .
@xcite as @xmath95 , where @xmath96 . in our calculation
, the initial energy density is related to the field strength @xmath97 : @xmath98 .
assuming the same initial energy density in the abelian and the non - abelian case , we obtain @xmath99 .
now we can rescale our transverse momentum spectra from figures [ bostime ] and [ fertime ] - we choose the results with scaled time - dependent field , @xmath100 ( solid lines ) . in figure [ kras ] our results at rhic energies for fermion ( _ thick solid line _ ) and boson ( _ thin solid line _ ) are displayed together with non - abelian result for classical gluons @xcite ( _ open diamonds _ ) .
our fermion spectra and the lattice result on classical gluons overlap in the momentum region @xmath101 .
possible parametrization of the two spectra are very close to each other and display the @xmath102 behavior known from ref .
@xcite and from perturbative qcd @xcite .
an acceptable slight modification of the time evolution in eq .
( [ es ] ) could lead to a full overlap , even at high-@xmath103 .
this can be demonstrated at @xmath104 with @xmath105 for fermion production ( _ thick dashed line _ ) .
in this paper we investigated fermion and boson production from a strong abelian field in a kinetic model . assuming ultrarelativistic limit and a longitudinally dominant external field
, boson production remains relatively weak in the mid - rapidity region .
however , fermion production is not effected by this setup and a fermion dominance appears in our kinetic model . introducing different parametrizations for the time evolution of the external field ,
we obtain different transverse momentum spectra for fermions and bosons .
only time evolution determines if these spectra are exponential or polynomial .
investigating fermion transverse momentum spectra , our results with abelian external field overlap with the spectra obtained in lattice - qcd calculations for classical gluons at the same energy density .
we thank v. toneev and g. fai for stimulating discussions .
this work was supported in part by hungarian grant otka - t043455 , mta - jinr grant , and rfbr grant no .
03 - 02 - 16877 .
quark matter04 conference proceedings ( ed . by h.g . ritter and x.n .
wang ) , j. phys . * g 30 * ( 2004 ) s633 .
b. andersson _
et al . _ ,
phys . rep .
* 97 * ( 1983 ) 31 ; nucl . phys . * b281 * ( 1987 ) 289 ; z. phys .
* c57 * ( 1993 ) 485 .
wang , m. gyulassy , phys . rev .
* d44 * ( 1991 ) 3501 ; comput .
* 83 * ( 1994 ) 307 .
h. sorge , phys . rev .
* c52 * ( 1995 ) 3291 .
field , _ application of perturbative qcd _
, addison - wesley , 1989 .
wang , phys .
* c61 * ( 2000 ) 064910 .
et al . _ , phys .
* c65 * ( 2002 ) 034903 .
et al . _ ,
. phys . * b245 * ( 1984 ) 449 .
mclerran , lecture notes phys .
* 583 * ( 2002 ) 291 ; hep - ph/0402137 , and references therein .
e. iancu and r. venugopalan , hep - ph/0303204 and references therein .
f. gelis , r. venugopalan , phys . rev .
* d69 * ( 2004 ) 014019 .
blaizot , f. gelis , r. venugopalan , nucl . phys .
* a743 * ( 2004 ) 57 .
a. krasnitz , y. nara , and r. venugopalan , phys .
* 87 * ( 2001 ) 192302 .
t. lappi , phys . rev .
* c67 * ( 2003 ) 054903 .
g. gatoff , _ et al .
_ phys . rev . * d36 * ( 1987 ) 114
. y. kluger _
et al . _ ,
* 67 * ( 1991 ) 2427 .
g. gatoff and c.y .
wong , phys .
* d46 * ( 1992 ) 997 .
wong , _ et al .
_ phys . rev .
* d51 * ( 1995 ) 3940 .
eisenberg , phys .
rev . * d51 * ( 1995 ) 1938
vinnik , _ et al .
_ , few - body syst .
* 32 * ( 2002 ) 23 .
pervushin , _ et al .
_ accepted in int .
a. ( hep - th/0307200 ) .
dietrich , phys . rev .
* d68 * ( 2003 ) 105005 .
prozorkevich , s.a .
smolyansky , and s.v .
ilyin , ( hep - ph/0301169 ) .
grib , s.g .
mamaev , and v.m .
mostepanenko , _ vacuum quantum effects in strong external fields _ , ( friedmann laboratory publishing , st .
petersburg , 1994 ) . | we study the transverse momentum spectra of fermions and bosons produced in strong , time - dependent abelian field .
the transverse size of the abelian field is finite , similarly to color strings and ropes .
different time - dependent field strengths are investigated in a kinetic model , and transverse momentum spectra are calculated for fermions and bosons .
these spectra display exponential or polynomial behavior at high @xmath0 , depending on the given time dependence .
we compare our spectra to lattice result for a classical gluon field and obtain surprisingly good agreement in certain cases . |
the purpose of these lectures is to give an introduction to the present _ standard picture of the early universe _ , which _ complements _ the older standard big bang model .
these notes are intended for non - experts on this subject .
they start with a very short introduction to general relativity , on which modern cosmology is based , followed by an elementary review of the standard big bang model .
we then discuss the limitations of this model and enter into the main subject of these lectures : _
inflation_. inflation was initially invented to solve some of the problems of the standard big bang model and to get rid of unwanted relics generically predicted by high energy models .
it turned out that inflation , as it was realized later , could also solve an additional puzzle of the standard model , that of the generation of the cosmological perturbations .
this welcome surprise put inflation on a rather firm footing , about twenty years ago .
twenty years later , inflation is still alive , in a stronger position than ever because its few competitors have been eliminated as new cosmological observations have accumulated during the last few years .
modern cosmology is based on einstein s theory of general relativity .
it is thus useful , before discussing the early universe , to recall a few notions and useful formulas from this theory .
details can be found in standard textbooks on general relativity ( see e.g. @xcite ) . in the framework of general relativity ,
the spacetime geometry is defined by a _
metric _ , a symmetric tensor with two indices , whose components in a coordinate system @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) will be denoted @xmath2 .
the square of the `` distance '' between two neighbouring points of spacetime is given by the expression ds^2=g_dx^dx^. we will use the signature @xmath3 . in a coordinate change @xmath4 ,
the new components of the metric are obtained by using the standard tensor transformation formulas , namely g_=x^x^ x^x^g_. one can define a _
covariant derivative _ associated to this metric , denoted @xmath5 , whose action on a tensor with , for example , one covariant index and one contravariant index will be given by _
t^ _ = _ t^ _ + ^_t^ _ - ^_t^ _ ( a similar term must be added for each additional covariant or contravariant index ) , where the @xmath6 are the _ christoffel symbols _ ( they are not tensors ) , defined by ^_=12g^(_g_+_g_-_g _ ) . [ christoffel ] we have used the notation @xmath7 which corresponds , for the metric ( and only for the metric ) , to the inverse of @xmath2 in a matricial sense , i.e. @xmath8 . the `` curvature '' of spacetime is characterized by the _ riemann _
tensor , whose components can be expressed in terms of the christoffel symbols according to the expression r_^ = _ _ ^-__^+ _ ^_^- _ ^_^. _ einstein s equations _ relate the spacetime geometry to its matter content .
the geometry appears in einstein s equations via the _ ricci tensor _ , defined by r_=r_^ , and the _ scalar curvature _ , which is the trace of the ricci tensor , i.e. r = g^r_. the matter enters einstein s equations via the _ energy - momentum tensor _ , denoted @xmath9 , whose time / time component corresponds to the energy density , the time / space components to the momentum density and the space / space component to the stress tensor .
einstein s equations then read g_r_-12r g_=8 g t _ , [ einstein ] where the tensor @xmath10 is called the _ einstein tensor_. since , by construction , the einstein tensor satisfies the identity @xmath11 , any energy - momentum on the right - hand side of einstein s equation must necessarily satisfy the relation _ t^ _
= 0 , [ dt0 ] which can be interpreted as a generalization , in the context of a curved spacetime , of the familiar conservation laws for energy and momentum .
the motion of a particule is described by its trajectory in spacetime , @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is a parameter . a free particle , i.e. which does not feel any force ( other than gravity ) , satisfies the _ geodesic equation _ , which reads t^_t^=0 , where @xmath14 is the vector field tangent to the trajectory ( note that the geodesic equation written in this form assumes that the parameter @xmath13 is affine ) .
equivalently , the geodesic can be rewritten as + ^_dx^d dx^d=0 .
[ geodesique ] the geodesic equation applies both to * massive particles , in which case one usually takes as the parameter @xmath13 the so - called _ proper time _
so that the corresponding tangent vector @xmath15 is normalized : @xmath16 ; * massless particles , in particular the photon , in which case the tangent vector , usually denoted @xmath17 is light - like , i.e. @xmath18 . einstein s equations can also be obtained from a variational principle . the corresponding action reads = 116gd^4x(r-2 ) + d^4x _ mat .
one can check that the variation of this action with respect to the metric @xmath2 , upon using the definition t^=2(_mat ) , [ def_tmunu ] indeed gives einstein s equations g_+g_=8
g t_. this is a slight generalization of einstein s equations ( [ einstein ] ) that includes a _ cosmological constant _ @xmath19 .
it is worth noticing that the cosmological constant can also be interpreted as a particular energy - momentum tensor of the form @xmath20 . in this subsection
, the foundations of modern cosmology are briefly recalled .
they follow from einstein s equations introduced above and from a few hypotheses concerning spacetime and its matter content .
one of the essential assumptions of cosmology ( so far confirmed by observations ) is to consider , as a first approximation , the universe as being homogeneous and isotropic .
note that these symmetries define implicitly a particular `` slicing '' of spacetime , the corresponding space - like hypersurfaces being homogeneous and isotropic .
a different slicing of the _ same _ spacetime will give in general space - like hypersurfaces that are not homogeneous and isotropic .
the above hypothesis turns out to be very restrictive and the only metrics compatible with this requirement reduce to the so - called _ robertson - walker _ metrics , which read in an appropriate coordinate system ds^2=-dt^2+a^2(t ) , [ rw ] with @xmath21 depending on the curvature of spatial hypersurfaces : respectively flat , elliptic or hyperbolic .
the matter content compatible with the spacetime symmetries of homogeneity and isotropy is necessarily described by an energy - momentum tensor of the form ( in the same coordinate system as for the metric ( [ rw ] ) ) : t^ _ = diag(-(t ) , p(t ) , p(t ) , p(t ) ) .
the quantity @xmath22 corresponds to an energy density and @xmath23 to a pressure .
one can show that the so - called comoving particles , i.e. those particles whose spatial coordinates are constant in time , satisfy the geodesic equation ( [ geodesique ] ) . substituting the robertson - walker metric ( [ rw ] ) in einstein s equations ( [ einstein ] ) , one gets the so - called _ friedmann - lematre equations _ : @xmath24 an immediate consequence of these two equations is the _ continuity equation _
+ 3h(+p)=0 , [ conservation ] where @xmath25 is the
_ hubble parameter_. the continuity equation can be also obtained directly from the energy - momentum conservation @xmath26 , as mentioned before . in order to determine the cosmological evolution ,
it is easier to combine ( [ friedmann ] ) with ( [ conservation ] ) .
let us assume an equation of state for the cosmological matter of the form @xmath27 with @xmath28 constant .
this includes the two main types of matter that play an important rle in cosmology : * gas of relativistic particles , @xmath29 ; * non relativistic matter , @xmath30 . in these cases , the conservation equation ( [ conservation ] )
can be integrated to give a^-3(1+w ) . substituting in ( [ friedmann ] ) , one finds , for @xmath31 , 3a^2a^2=8g_0(aa_0)^-3(1+w ) , where , by convention , the subscript 0 stands for _ present _ quantities .
one thus finds @xmath32 , which gives for the evolution of the scale factor * in a universe dominated by non relativistic matter a(t)t^2/3 , * and in a universe dominated by radiation a(t)t^1/2 .
one can also mention the case of a _ cosmological constant _ , which corresponds to an equation of state @xmath33 and thus implies an exponential evolution for the scale factor a(t)(ht ) . more generally , when several types of matter coexist with respectively @xmath34 , it is convenient to introduce the dimensionless parameters _ ( i)=8 g _ 0^(i)3 h_0 ^ 2 , which express the _ present _ ratio of the energy density of some given species with respect to the so - called _ critical energy density _ @xmath35 , which corresponds to the total energy density for a flat universe .
one can then rewrite the first friedmann equation ( [ friedmann ] ) as ( hh_0)^2=_i_(i ) ( aa_0)^-3(1+w_(i))+_(aa_0)^-2 , with @xmath36 , which implies that the cosmological parameters must satisfy the consistency relation _ i _ ( i)+_=1 . as for the second friedmann equation ( [ friedmann2 ] ) , it implies = -12_i _ ( i)(1+w_(i ) ) .
present cosmological observations yield for the various parameters * baryons : @xmath37 , * dark matter : @xmath38 , * dark energy ( compatible with a cosmological constant ) : @xmath39 , * photons : @xmath40 .
observations have not detected so far any deviation from flatness .
radiation is very subdominant today but extrapolating backwards in time , radiation was dominant in the past since its energy density scales as @xmath41 in contrast with non relativistic matter ( @xmath42 ) .
moreover , since the present matter content seems dominated by dark energy similar to a cosmological constant ( @xmath43 ) , this indicates that our universe is presently accelerating .
an important consequence of the expansion of the universe is the _ cosmological redshift _ of photons .
this is in fact how the expansion of the universe was discovered initially .
let us consider two light signals emitted by a comoving object at two successive instants @xmath44 and @xmath45 , then received later at respectively @xmath46 and @xmath47 by a ( comoving ) observer .
one can always set the observer at the center of the coordinate system .
all light trajectories reaching the observer are then radial and one can write , using ( [ rw ] ) _ 0^r_edr=_t_e^t_odta(t ) .
the left - hand side being identical for the two successive trajectories , the right - hand side must vanish , which yields -t_ea_e=0 .
this implies for the frequencies measured at emission and at reception a redshift given by 1+z = a_oa_e .
to go beyond a simply geometrical description of cosmology , it is very fruitful to apply thermodynamics to the matter content of the universe .
one can then define a temperature @xmath48 for the cosmological photons , not only when they are strongly interacting with ordinary matter but also after they have decoupled because , with the expansion , the thermal distribution for the gas of photons is unchanged except for a global rescaling of the temperature so that @xmath48 essentially evolves as t(t ) .
this means that , going backwards in time , the universe was hotter and hotter .
this is the essence of the hot big bang scenario .
as the universe evolves , the reaction rates between the various species are modified .
a detailed analysis of these changes enables to reconstruct the past thermal history of the universe .
two events in particular play an essential rle because of their observational consequences : * primordial nucleosynthesis + nucleosynthesis occured at a temperature around @xmath49 mev , when the average kinetic energy became sufficiently low so that nuclear binding was possible . protons and neutrons
could then combine , which lead to the production of light elements , such that helium , deuterium , lithium , etc ... within the observational uncertainties , this scenario is remarkably confirmed by the present measurements .
* decoupling of baryons and photons ( or last scattering ) + a more recent event is the so - called `` recombination '' of nuclei and electrons to form atoms .
this occured at a temperature of the order of the ev .
free electrons thus almost disappeared , which entailed an effective decoupling of the cosmological photons and ordinary matter .
what we see today as the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) is made of the fossil photons , which interacted for the last time with matter at the last scattering epoch .
the cmb represents a remarkable observational tool for analysing the perturbations of the early universe , as well as for measuring the cosmological parameters introduced above .
the standard big bang model has encountered remarkable successes , in particular with the nucleosynthesis scenario and the prediction of the cmb , and it remains today a cornerstone in our understanding of the present and past universe . however
, a few intriguing facts remain unexplained in the strict scenario of the standard big bang model and seem to necessitate a larger framework .
we review below the main problems : * homogeneity problem + a first question is why the approximation of homogeneity and isotropy turns out to be so good .
indeed , inhomogeneities are unstable , because of gravitation , and they tend to grow with time .
it can be verified for instance with the cmb that inhomogeneities were much smaller at the last scattering epoch than today .
one thus expects that these homogeneities were still smaller further back in time .
how to explain a universe so smooth in its past ?
* flatness problem + another puzzle lies in the ( spatial ) flatness of our universe .
indeed , friedmann s equation ( [ friedmann ] ) implies -1 - 1=a^2 h^2 . in standard cosmology , the scale factor behaves like @xmath50 with @xmath51 ( @xmath52 for radiation and @xmath53 for non - relativistic matter ) . as a consequence
, @xmath54 grows with time and @xmath55 must thus diverge with time .
therefore , in the context of the standard model , the quasi - flatness observed today requires an extreme fine - tuning of @xmath56 near @xmath57 in the early universe .
* horizon problem + : during standard cosmology , @xmath58 increases ( continuous lines ) , whereas during inflation @xmath58 shrinks ( dashed lines).,width=460 ] + one of the most fundamental problems in standard cosmology is certainly the _ horizon problem_. the ( particle ) _ horizon _ is the maximal distance that can be covered by a light ray . for a light - like radial trajectory @xmath59 and the horizon
is thus given by d_h(t)= a(t)_t_i^tdta(t)=a(t)t^1-q - t_i^1-q1-q , where the last equality is obtained by assuming @xmath60 and @xmath61 is some initial time .
+ in standard cosmology ( @xmath62 ) , the integral converges in the limit @xmath63 and the horizon has a finite size , of the order of the so - called hubble radius @xmath64 : d_h(t)=q1-qh^-1 .
+ it also useful to consider the _ comoving hubble radius _
, @xmath65 , which represents the fraction of comoving space in causal contact .
one finds that it _ grows _ with time , which means that the _ fraction of the universe in causal contact increases with time _ in the context of standard cosmology .
but the cmb tells us that the universe was quasi - homogeneous at the time of last scattering on a scale encompassing many regions a priori causally independent .
how to explain this ?
a solution to the horizon problem and to the other puzzles is provided by the inflationary scenario , which we will examine in the next section .
the basic idea is to invert the behaviour of the comoving hubble radius , that is to make him _ decrease _ sufficiently in the very early universe .
the corresponding condition is that a>0 , i.e. that the universe must undergo a _ phase of acceleration_.
the broadest definition of inflation is that it corresponds to a phase of acceleration of the universe , a>0 . in this broad sense , the current cosmological observations , if correctly interpreted , mean that our present universe is undergoing an inflationary phase .
we are however interested here in an inflationary phase taking place in the very early universe , with different energy scales .
the friedmann equations ( [ friedmann ] ) tell us that one can get acceleration only if the equation of state satisfies the condition p<-13 , condition which looks at first view rather exotic .
a very simple example giving such an equation of state is a cosmological constant , corresponding to a cosmological fluid with the equation of state p=- .
however , a strict cosmological constant leads to exponential inflation _ forever _ which can not be followed by a radiation or matter era .
another possibility is a scalar field , which we discuss now in some details .
the dynamics of a scalar field coupled to gravity is governed by the action [ action_scalar_field ] s_=d^4x(-12^_-v ( ) ) .
the corresponding energy - momentum tensor , which can be derived using ( [ def_tmunu ] ) , is given by t_=__-g _
( 12^_+v ( ) ) .
[ tscalarfield ] if one assumes the geometry , and thus the matter , to be homogeneous and isotropic , then the energy - momentum tensor reduces to the perfect fluid form with the energy density = -t_0 ^ 0=12 ^ 2+v ( ) , where one recognizes the sum of a kinetic energy and of a potential energy , and the pressure p=12 ^ 2-v ( ) . the equation of motion for the scalar field is the klein - gordon equation , which is obtained by taking the variation of the above action ( [ action_scalar_field ] ) with respect to the scalar field and which reads ^_=v , in general and + 3h+v=0 in the particular case of a flrw ( friedmann - lematre - robertson - walker ) universe .
the system of equations governing the dynamics of the scalar field and of the geometry in a flrw universe is thus given by @xmath66 the last equation can be derived from the first two and is therefore redundant . the dynamical system ( [ e1]-[e3 ] ) does not always give an accelerated expansion but it does so in the so - called _ slow - roll regime _ when the potential energy of the scalar field dominates over its kinetic energy . more specifically ,
the so - called _ slow roll _ approximation consists in neglecting the kinetic energy of the scalar field , @xmath67 in ( [ e1 ] ) and the acceleration @xmath68 in the klein - gordon equation ( [ e2 ] ) .
one then gets the simplified system @xmath69 let us now examine in which regime this approximation is valid . from ( [ sr2 ] ) ,
the velocity of the scalar field is given by -v3h .
[ phisr ] substituting this relation in the condition @xmath70 yields the requirement : _
v(vv)^2 1 , [ epsilon ] where we have introduced the _ reduced planck mass _ m_p .
similarly , the time derivative of ( [ phisr ] ) , using the time derivative of ( [ sr1 ] ) , gives , after substitution in @xmath71 , the condition _
[ eta ] in summary , the slow - roll approximation is valid when the two conditions @xmath72 are satisfied , which means that the slope and the curvature of the potential , in planck units , must be sufficiently small .
when working with a specific inflationary model , it is important to be able to relate the cosmological scales observed at the present time with the scales during inflation . for this purpose , one usally introduces the _ number of e - foldings before the end of inflation _
, denoted @xmath73 , and simply defined by n= , where @xmath74 is the value of the scale factor at the end of inflation and @xmath75 is a fiducial value for the scale factor during inflation . by definition , @xmath73 _
decreases _ during the inflationary phase and reaches zero at its end . in the slow - roll approximation , it is possible to express @xmath73 as a function of the scalar field .
since @xmath76 , one easily finds , using ( [ phisr ] ) and ( [ sr1 ] ) , that n()_^_endvm_p^2 vd .
given an explicit potential @xmath77 , one can in principle integrate the above expression to obtain @xmath73 in terms of @xmath78 .
this will be illustrated below for some specific models .
let us now discuss the link between @xmath73 and the present cosmological scales .
let us consider a given scale characterized by its comoving wavenumber @xmath79 .
this scale crossed outside the hubble radius , during inflation , at an instant @xmath80 defined by k = a(t _ * ) h(t _ * ) . to get a rough estimate of the number of e - foldings of inflation that are needed to solve the horizon problem , let us first ignore the transition from a radiation era to a matter era and assume for simplicity that the inflationary phase was followed instantaneously by a radiation phase that has lasted until now .
during the radiation phase , the comoving hubble radius @xmath65 increases like @xmath75 . in order to solve the horizon problem ,
the increase of the comoving hubble radius during the standard evolution must be compensated by _ at least _ a decrease of the same amount during inflation . since the comoving hubble radius roughly scales like @xmath81 during inflation , the minimum amount of inflation is simply given by the number of e - folds between the end of inflation and today @xmath82 , i.e. around 60 e - folds for a temperature @xmath83 at the beginning of the radiation era . as we will see later
, this energy scale is typical of inflation in the simplest models .
this determines roughly the number of e - folds @xmath84 between the moment when the scale corresponding to our present hubble radius @xmath85 exited the hubble radius during inflation and the end of inflation .
the other lengthscales of cosmological interest are _ smaller _ than @xmath86 and therefore exited the hubble radius during inflation _
after _ the scale @xmath87 , whereas they entered the hubble radius during the standard cosmological phase ( either in the radiation era for the smaller scales or in the matter era for the larger scales ) _ before _ the scale @xmath87 . a more detailed calculation , which distinguishes between the energy scales at the end of inflation and after the reheating
, gives for the number of e - folds between the exit of the mode @xmath88 and the end of inflation n(k)62 -+ + + 13 .
since the smallest scale of cosmological relevance is of the order of @xmath57 mpc , the range of cosmological scales covers about @xmath89 e - folds . the above number of e - folds
is altered if one changes the thermal history of the universe between inflation and the present time by including for instance a period of so - called thermal inflation .
it is now time to illustrate all the points discussed above with some specific potential .
we consider first the case of power - law monomial potentials , of the form [ pot_power - law ] v()=p^4 ( ) ^p , which have been abundantly used in the literature .
in particular , the above potential includes the case of a free massive scalar field , @xmath90 .
the slow - roll conditions @xmath91 and @xmath92 both imply p , [ sr_pl ] which means that the scalar field amplitude must be above the planck mass during inflation . after subsituting the potential ( [ pot_power - law ] ) into the slow - roll equations of motion ( [ sr1]-[sr2 ] ) , one can integrate them explicitly to get ^2-p2- _ i^2-p2 = -24-p ^3-p2(t - t_i ) for @xmath93 and = _ ifor @xmath94 .
one can also express the scale factor as a function of the scalar field ( and thus as a function of time by substituting the above expression for @xmath95 ) by using @xmath96 .
one finds a = a_end .
defining the end of inflation by @xmath97 , one gets @xmath98 and the number of e - folds is thus given by [ n_phi ] n()-p4 .
this can be inverted , so that ( n ) , where we have ignored the second term of the right hand side of ( [ n_phi ] ) , in agreement with the condition ( [ sr_pl ] ) . if one considers a potential of the form v = v_0 ( - m_p ) , then it is possible to find an _ exact _ solution ( i.e. valid beyond the slow - roll approximation ) of the system ( [ e1]-[e3 ] ) , with a power - law scale factor , i.e. a(t)t^q .
the evolution of the scalar field is given by the expression ( t)= m_p .
note that one recovers the slow - roll approximation in the limit @xmath99 , since the slow - roll parameters are given by @xmath100 and @xmath101 .
let us now try to summarize in a few lines the history of inflationary models .
the first model of inflation is usually traced back to alan guth @xcite in 1981 , although one can see a precursor in the model of alexei starobinsky @xcite .
guth s model , which is named today _
old inflation _ is based on a first - order phase transition , from a false vacuum with non zero energy , which generates an exponential inflationary phase , into a true vacuum with zero energy density .
the true vacuum phase appears in the shape of bubbles via quantum tunneling .
the problem with this inflationary model is that , in order to get sufficient inflation to solve the problems of the standard model mentioned earlier , the nucleation rate must be sufficiently small ; but , then , the bubbles never coalesce because the space that separates the bubbles undergoes inflation and expands too rapidly .
therefore , the first model of inflation is not phenomenologically viable .
after this first and unsuccessful attempt , a new generation of inflationary models appeared , usually denoted _ new inflation _
models @xcite .
they rely on a second order phase transition , based on thermal corrections of the effective potential and thus assume that the scalar field is in thermal equilibrium .
this hypothesis of thermal equilibrium was given up in the third generation of models , initiated by andrei linde , and whose generic name is _
chaotic inflation _
this allows to use extremely simple potentials , quadratic or quartic , which lead to inflationary phases when the scalar field is displaced from the origin with values of the order of several planck masses .
this is sometimes considered to be problematic from a particle physics point of view , as discussed briefly later . during the last few years
, there has been a revival of the inflation model building based on high energy theories , in particular in the context of supersymmetry . in these models ,
the value of the scalar field is much smaller than the planck mass .
there exist many models of inflation .
as far as single - field models are concerned ( or at least _ effectively _ single field during inflation , the hybrid models requiring a second field to end inflation as discussed below ) , it is convenient to regroup them into three broad categories : * large field models ( @xmath102 ) + the scalar field is displaced from its stable minimum by @xmath103 .
this includes the so - called chaotic type models with monomial potentials v()=^4()^p , or the exponential potential v()=^4 ( / ) , which have already been discussed .
+ this category of models is widely used in the literature because of the computational simplicity .
but they are not always considered to be models which can be well motivated by particle physics .
the reason is the following .
the generic potential for a scalar field will contain an infinite number of terms , v()=v_0 + 12m^2 ^ 2+_33 ^ 3 + _
44 ^ 4+_d=5^m_p^4-d^d , where the non - renormalizable ( @xmath104 ) couplings @xmath105 are a priori of order @xmath57 .
when the scalar field is of order of a few planck masses , one has no control on the form of the potential , and all the non - normalizable terms must be taken into account in principle .
+ in order to work with more specific forms for the potential , inflationary model builders tend to concentrate on models where the scalar field amplitude is small with respect to the planck mass , as those discussed just below . * small field models ( @xmath106 ) + in this type of models , the scalar field is rolling away from an unstable maximum of the potential .
this is a characteristic feature of spontaneous symmetry breaking .
a typical potential is v()=^4 , which can be interpreted as the lowest - order term in a taylor expansion about the origin .
historically , this potential shape appeared in the so - called ` new inflation ' scenario . +
a particular feature of these models is that tensor modes are much more suppressed with respect to scalar modes than in the large - field models , as it will be shown later .
+ * hybrid models ( @xmath107 ) + for hybrid inflation.,width=460 ] + this category of models , which appeared rather recently , relies on the presence of two scalar fields : one plays the traditional rle of the inflaton , while the other is necessary to end inflation .
+ as an illustration , let us consider the original model of hybrid inflation @xcite based on the potential v ( , ) = 12m^2 ^ 2 + 12 ^2 ^ 2 + 14(m^2-^2)^2 . for values of the field @xmath78 larger than the critical value @xmath108 , the potential for @xmath109 has its minimum at @xmath110 .
this is the case during inflation .
@xmath109 is thus trapped in this minimum @xmath110 , so that the effective potential for the scalar field @xmath78 , which plays the rle of the inflaton , is given by v_eff()=v_0 + 12m^2 ^ 2 , with @xmath111 . during the inflationary phase , the field @xmath78 slow - rolls until it reaches the critical value @xmath112 .
the shape of the potential for @xmath109 is then modified and new minima appear in @xmath113 .
@xmath109 will thus roll down into one of these new minima and , as a consequence , inflation will end . + as far as inflation is concerned
, hybrid inflation scenarios correspond effectively to single - field models with a potential characterized by @xmath114 and @xmath107 .
a typical potential is v()=^4 .
once more , this potential can be seen as the lowest order in a taylor expansion about the origin .
+ in the case of hybrid models , the value @xmath115 of the scalar field as a function of the number of e - folds before the end of inflation is not determined by the above potential and , therefore , @xmath116 can be considered as a freely adjustable parameter .
many more details on inflationary models can be found in e.g. @xcite .
so far , we have concentrated our attention on strictly homogeneous and isotropic aspects of cosmology .
of course , this idealized version , although extremely useful , is not sufficient to account for real cosmology and it is now time to turn to the study of deviations from homogeneity and isotropy .
in cosmology , inhomogeneities grow because of the attractive nature of gravity , which implies that inhomogeneities were much smaller in the past . as a consequence , for most of their evolution
, inhomogeneities can be treated as _ linear perturbations_. the linear treatment ceases to be valid on small scales in our recent past , hence the difficulty to reconstruct the primordial inhomogeneities from large - scale structure , but it is quite adequate to describe the fluctuations of the cmb at the time of last scattering .
this is the reason why the cmb is currently the best observational probe of primordial inhomogeneities . for more details on the relativistic theory of cosmological perturbations , which will be briefly introduced in this chapter ,
the reader is invited to read the standard reviews @xcite in the literature . from now on , we will be mostly working with the conformal time @xmath117 , instead of the cosmic time @xmath118 . the conformal time is defined as = so that the ( spatially flat ) flrw metric takes the remarkably simple form ds^2=a^2 ( ) .
[ metric_eta ] let us start with the linear perturbations of the geometry .
the most general linear perturbation of the flrw metric can be expressed as ds^2=a^2\ { -(1 + 2a)d^2 + 2b_idx^id+ ( _ ij+h_ij ) dx^idx^j } [ metpert ] , where we have considered only the spatially flat flrw metric .
we have introduced a time plus space decomposition of the perturbations .
the indices @xmath119 , @xmath120 stand for _ spatial _ indices and the perturbed quantities defined in ( [ metpert ] ) can be seen as three - dimensional tensors , for which the indices can be lowered ( or raised ) by the spatial metric @xmath121 ( or its inverse ) .
it is very convenient to separate the perturbations into three categories , the so - called `` scalar '' , `` vector '' and `` tensor '' modes .
for example , a spatial vector field @xmath122 can be decomposed uniquely into a longitudinal part and a transverse part , b_i=_i b+_i , _
i^i=0 , [ bi ] where the longitudinal part is curl - free and can thus be expressed as a gradient , and the transverse part is divergenceless .
one thus gets one `` scalar '' mode , @xmath123 , and two `` vector '' modes @xmath124 ( the index @xmath119 takes three values but the divergenceless condition implies that only two components are independent .
a similar procedure applies to the symmetric tensor @xmath125 , which can be decomposed as h_ij=2c_ij+2 _
i_j e+2_(ie_j ) + _ ij , [ hij ] with @xmath126 transverse and traceless ( tt ) , i.e. @xmath127 ( transverse ) and @xmath128 ( traceless ) , and @xmath129 transverse .
the parentheses around the indices denote symmetrization , namely @xmath130 .
we have thus defined two scalar modes , @xmath131 and @xmath132 , two vector modes , @xmath129 , and two tensor modes , @xmath133 . in the following
, we will be mainly interested in the metric with only _ scalar _ perturbations , since scalar modes are the most relevant for cosmology and they can be treated independently of the vector and tensor modes . in matrix notation , the perturbed metric will thus be of the form @xmath134 \,.\ ] ] after the description of the perturbed geometry , we turn to the perturbations of the matter in the next subsection .
quite generally , the perturbed energy - momentum tensor can be written in the form @xmath135 \ , , \label{pert_t}\ ] ] where @xmath136 is the momentum density and @xmath137 is the anisotropic stress tensor , which is traceless , i.e. @xmath138 .
one can then decompose these tensors into scalar , vector and tensor components , as before for the metric components , so that q_i=_i q+|q_i , _
i|q^i=0 , [ qi ] and _ ij=_i_j -13 _ ij_k^k+2_(i_j)+|_ij , _
k|^kl=0 , |^k_k=0 .
[ pi_ij ] a widely used description for matter in cosmology is that of a fluid .
its homogeneous part is described by the energy - momentum tensor of a perfect fluid , as seen earlier , while its perturbed part can be expressed as @xmath139 with @xmath138 as before and where @xmath140 is the three - dimensional fluid velocity defined by u^i=1av^i .
it is also possible to separate this perturbed energy - momentum tensor into scalar , vector and tensor parts by using decompositions for @xmath141 and @xmath142 similar to ( [ qi ] ) and ( [ pi_ij ] ) .
another type of matter , especially useful in the context of inflation , is a scalar field .
the homogeneous description has already been given earlier and the perturbed expression for the energy - momentum tensor follows immediately from ( [ tscalarfield ] ) , taking into account the metric perturbations as well .
one finds @xmath143 the last equation shows that , for a scalar field , there is no anisotropic stress in the energy - momentum tensor .
it is worth noticing that there is a fundamental difference between the perturbations in general relativity and the perturbations in other field theories where the underlying spacetime is fixed . in the latter case
, one can define the perturbation of a given field @xmath78 as ( p)=(p)-|(p ) , [ pert ] where @xmath144 is the unperturbed field and @xmath145 is any point of the spacetime . in the context of general relativity
, spacetime is no longer a frozen background but must also be perturbed if matter is perturbed . as a consequence , the above definition does not make sense since the perturbed quantity @xmath78 lives in the perturbed spacetime @xmath146 , whereas the unperturbed quantity @xmath144 lives in _ another spacetime _ : the unperturbed spacetime of reference , which we will denote @xmath147 . in order to use a definition similar to ( [ pert ] )
, one must introduce a one - to - one _ identification _
, @xmath148 , between the points of @xmath147 and those of @xmath146 .
the perturbation of the field can then be defined as ( |p)=((|p))-|(|p ) , where @xmath149 is a point of @xmath147 . however , the identification @xmath148 is not uniquely defined , and therefore the definition of the perturbation depends on the particular choice for @xmath148 : two different identifications , @xmath150 and @xmath151 say , lead to two different definitions for the perturbations .
this ambiguity can be related to the freedom of choice of the coordinate system . indeed ,
if one is given a coordinate system in @xmath147 , one can transport it into @xmath146 via the identification . @xmath150 and
@xmath151 thus define two different coordinate systems in @xmath146 , and in this respect , a _ change of identification _ can be seen as a _ change of coordinates _ in @xmath146 .
the metric perturbations , introduced in ( [ metpert ] ) , are modified in a coordinate transformation of the form x^x^+^ , ^=(^0,^i ) [ transjauge ] .
it can be shown that the change of the metric components can be expressed as ( g_)= -2 _ ( _ ) . where @xmath152 represents the variation , due the coordinate transformation , at the same old and new coordinates ( and thus at different physical points ) .
the above variation can be decomposed into individual variations for the various components of the metric defined earlier .
one finds @xmath153 the effect of a coordinate transformation can also be decomposed along the scalar , vector and tensor sectors introduced earlier .
the generator @xmath154 of the coordinate transformation can be written as ^=(^0,^i+^i ) , with @xmath155 transverse .
this shows explicitly that @xmath154 contains two scalar components , @xmath156 and @xmath157 , and two vector components , @xmath155 .
the transformations ( [ gt1]-[gt3 ] ) are then decomposed into : @xmath158 the tensor perturbations remain unchanged since @xmath154 does not contain any tensor component .
the matter perturbations , either in the fluid description or in the scalar field description , follow similar transformation laws in a coordinate change . in order to study the physically relevant modes and not spurious modes due to coordinate ambiguities ,
two strategies can a priori be envisaged .
the first consists in working from the start in a specific gauge .
a familiar choice in the literature on cosmological perturbations is the _ longitudinal gauge _
( also called conformal newton gauge ) , which imposes b_=0 , e_=0 .
the second approach consists in defining _ gauge - invariant variables _ , i.e. variables that are left unchanged under a coordinate transformation . for the scalar metric perturbations , we start with four quantities ( @xmath159 , @xmath123 , @xmath131 and @xmath132 ) and we can use two gauge transformations ( @xmath156 and @xmath157 ) .
this implies that the scalar metric perturbations must be described by _ two _ independent gauge - invariant quantities .
two such quantities are = a+(b - e)+(b - e ) and = - c -(b - e ) , as it can be checked by considering the explicit transformations in ( [ transfjauge ] ) .
it turns out that , in the longitudinal gauge , the remaining scalar perturbations @xmath160 and @xmath161 are numerically equivalent to the gauge - invariant quantities just defined @xmath162 and @xmath163 . in practice
, one can combine the two strategies by doing explicit calculations in a given gauge and then by relating the quantities defined in this gauge to some gauge - invariant variables .
it is then possible to translate the results in any other gauge . in the rest of these lectures
, we will use the longitudinal gauge . after having defined the metric and the matter perturbations
, we can now relate them via the perturbed einstein equations .
we will consider here explicitly _ only the scalar sector _
, which is the most complicated but also the most interesting for cosmological applications .
starting from the perturbed metric ( [ scalar_pert_metric ] ) , one can compute the components of einstein s tensor at linear order . in the _ longitudinal gauge _ , i.e. with @xmath164 , one finds @xmath165 \\ \label{dg0i } \left(\d g^0_i\right)_\l&= & { 2\over a^2}\nabla_i\left[-\h a_\l+c'_\l\right ] \\ \label{dgij } \left(\d g^i_j\right)_\l&= & { 1\over a^2}\nabla^i\nabla_j\left(-c_\l - a_\l\right ) + { 1\over a^2}\left[-2 c_\l''-4\h c_\l'+\nabla^2 c_\l \right .
\cr & & \left.+2\h a_\l ' + \nabla^2 a_\l+2\left(2\h'+\h^2\right)a_\l \right]\delta^i_j.\end{aligned}\ ] ] combining with the perturbations of the energy - momentum tensor given in ( [ pert_t ] ) , the perturbed einstein equations yield , _ in the longitudinal gauge _ , the following relations : the energy constraint ( from ( [ dg00 ] ) ) 3 ^ 2 a_-3c_+^2 c_=-4 g a^2_ , [ energy ] the momentum constraint ( from ( [ dg0i ] ) ) c_-a_=4 g a^2 q_ , [ momentum ] the `` anisotropy constraint '' ( from the traceless part of ( [ dgij ] ) ) -a_ - c_=8 g a^2 _ , [ anisotropy ] and finally c_+2c_- a_-(2+^2)a_-13 ^ 2(a_+c_ ) = -4 g p_ , [ dynamics ] obtained from the trace of ( [ dgij ] ) .
the combination of the energy and momentum constraints gives the useful relation ^2= 4 g a^2(_- 3q_)4 g a^2 _ c , [ poisson ] where we have introduced the _ comoving _ energy density perturbation @xmath166 : this gauge - invariant quantity corresponds , according to its definition , to the energy density perturbation measured in comoving gauges characterized by @xmath167 .
we have also replaced @xmath161 by @xmath163 .
note that the above equation is quite similar to the newtonian poisson equation , but with quantities whose natural interpretation is given in _
different _ gauges . as mentioned earlier
, a consequence of einstein s equations is that the _ total _ energy - momentum tensor is covariantly conserved ( see eq .
( [ dt0 ] ) ) . for a fluid
, the conservation of the energy - momentum tensor leads to a continuity equation that generalizes the _ continuity equation _ of fluid mechanics , and a momentum conservation equation that generalizes the _ euler equation_. in the case of a single fluid , combinations of the perturbed einstein equations obtained in the previous subsection lead necessarily to the perturbed continuity and euler equations for the fluid . in the case of several non - interacting fluids , however , one must impose _ separately _ the covariant conservation of _ each _ energy - momentum tensor : this is not a consequence of einstein s equations , which impose only the conservation of the _ total _ energy - momentum tensor . in the perspective to deal with several cosmological fluids ,
it is therefore useful to write the perturbation equations , satisfied by a given fluid , that follow only from the conservation of the corresponding energy - momentum tensor , and independently of einstein s equations .
the continuity equation can be obtained by perturbing @xmath168 .
one finds , in _ any gauge _
, +3(+p)+(+p)(3 c + ^2 e+^2v)=0 . dividing by @xmath22 ,
this can be reexpressed in terms of the density contrast @xmath169 : +3(p - w ) + ( 1+w)(^2 v + 3c+^2 e)=0 , [ conserv_pert ] where @xmath170 ( @xmath28 is not necessarily constant here ) . the perturbed euler equation is derived from the spatial projection of @xmath171 .
this gives ( v+b) + ( 1 - 3c_s^2)(v+b ) + a+p+ p+23(+p ) ^2=0 , [ euler_pert ] where @xmath172 is the sound speed , which is related to the time derivatives of the background energy density and pressure : c_s^2=p. there are as many systems of equations ( [ conserv_pert]-[euler_pert ] ) as the number of fluids .
if the fluids are interacting , one must add an interaction term on the right - hand side of the euler equations . finally , let us stress that the fluid description is not always an adequate approximation for cosmological matter .
a typical example is the photons during and after recombination : their mean free path becomes so large that they must be treated as a gas , which requires the use of the boltzmann equation ( see e.g. @xcite for a presentation of the boltzmann equation in the cosmological context ) .
the notion of _ initial conditions _ depends in general on the context , since the initial conditions for a given period in the history of the universe can be seen as the final conditions of the previous phase .
in cosmology , `` initial conditions '' usually refer to the state of the perturbations during the _ radiation dominated era _ ( of standard cosmology ) and on _ wavelengths larger than the hubble radius_. let us first address in details the question of initial conditions in the simple case of a single perfect fluid , radiation , with equation of state @xmath173 ( which gives @xmath174 ) .
the four key equations are the continuity , euler , poisson and anisotropy equations , respectively eqs ( [ conserv_pert ] ) , ( [ euler_pert ] ) , ( [ poisson ] ) and ( [ anisotropy ] ) . in terms of the fourier components , q()=e^-i .
q ( ) , and of the dimensionless quantity xk(during the radiation dominated era @xmath175 ) , the four equations can be rewritten as @xmath176 we have introduced the quantity @xmath177 , which has the dimension of a velocity . since we are interested in perturbations with wavelength larger than the hubble radius , i.e. such that @xmath178 , it is useful to consider a taylor expansion for the various perturbations , for instance = ^(0)+x^(1)+x^22^(2)+ one then substitutes these taylor expansions into the above system of equations . in particular , the poisson equation ( [ ic3 ] ) gives ^(0)=0 , in order to avoid a divergence , as well as ^(1)=14^(0 ) .
the euler equation ( [ ic2 ] ) then gives a^(0)=-12^(0 ) .
the conclusion is that the initial conditions for each fourier mode are determined by a single quantity , e.g. @xmath179 , the other quantities being related via the above constraints . in general
, one must consider several cosmological fluids .
typically , the `` initial '' or `` primordial '' perturbations are defined deep in the radiation era but at temperatures low enough , i.e. after nucleosynthesis , so that the main cosmological components reduce to the usual photons , baryons , neutrinos and cold dark matter ( cdm ) . the system ( [ ic1]-[ic4 ] )
must thus be generalized to include a continuity equation and a euler equation for each fluid .
the above various cosmological species can be characterized by their number density , @xmath180 , and their energy density @xmath181 . in a multi - fluid system , it is useful to distinguish _ adiabatic _ and _ isocurvature _ perturbations .
the _ adiabatic mode _ is defined as a perturbation affecting all the cosmological species such that the relative ratios in the number densities remain unperturbed , i.e. such that ( n_x / n_y ) = 0 .
[ nullratio ] it is associated with a curvature perturbation , via einstein s equations , since there is a global perturbation of the matter content . this is why the adiabatic perturbation is also called _ curvature _ perturbation . in terms of the energy density contrasts ,
the adiabatic perturbation is characterized by the relations _
= 14_=13_b=13 _ c , they follow directly from the prescription ( [ nullratio ] ) , each coefficient depending on the equation of state of the particuler species . since there are several cosmological species , it is also possible to perturb the matter components without perturbing the geometry .
this corresponds to _ isocurvature _ perturbations , characterized by variations in the particle number ratios but with vanishing curvature perturbation .
the variation in the relative particle number densities between two species can be quantified by the so - called _ entropy perturbation _
s_a , b - n_bn_b . when the equation of state for a given species is such that @xmath182 , then one can reexpress the entropy perturbation in terms of the density contrast , in the form s_a , b-_b1+w_b .
it is convenient to choose a species of reference , for instance the photons , and to define the entropy perturbations of the other species relative to it : @xmath183 thus define respectively the _ baryon isocurvature mode _ , the _ cdm isocurvature mode _ , the _ neutrino isocurvature mode_. in terms of the entropy perturbations , the adiabatic mode is obviously characterized by @xmath184 . in summary , we can decompose a general perturbation , described by four density contrasts , into one adiabatic mode and three isocurvature mode .
in fact , the problem is slightly more complicated because the evolution of the initial velocity fields . for a single fluid
, we have seen that the velocity field is not an independent initial condition but depends on the density contrast so that there is no divergence backwards in time . in the case of the four species mentioned above
, there remains however one arbitrary relative velocity between the species , which gives an additional mode , usually named the _ neutrino isocurvature velocity _ perturbation .
the cmb is a powerful way to study isocurvature perturbations because ( primordial ) adiabatic and isocurvature perturbations produce very distinctive features in the cmb anisotropies @xcite . whereas an adiabatic initial perturbation generates a cosine oscillatory mode in the photon - baryon fluid , leading to an acoustic peak at @xmath185 ( for a flat universe ) , a pure isocurvature initial perturbation generates a sine oscillatory mode resulting in a first peak at @xmath186 .
the unambiguous observation of the first peak at @xmath185 has eliminated the possibility of a dominant isocurvature perturbation .
the recent observation by wmap of the cmb polarization has also confirmed that the initial perturbation is mainly an adiabatic mode .
but this does not exclude the presence of a subdominant isocurvature contribution , which could be detected in future high - precision experiments such as planck . in the case of _
adiabatic perturbations _ , there is only one ( scalar ) dynamical degree of freedom
. one can thus choose either an energy density perturbation or a metric perturbation , to study the dynamics , the other quantities being determined by the constraints .
if one considers the metric perturbation @xmath187 ( assuming @xmath188 ) , one can combine einstein s equations ( [ dynamics ] ) , with @xmath189 ( for adiabatic perturbations ) , and ( [ energy ] ) to obtain a second - order differential equation in terms of @xmath190 only :
+ 3(1+c_s^2)+- k^2c_s^2 = 0 . using the background friedmann equations , the sound speed can be reexpressed in terms of the scale factor and its derivatives . for scales larger than the sonic horizon ,
i.e. such that @xmath191 , the above equation can be integrated explicitly and yields = a^2 , where @xmath192 and @xmath193 are two integration constants . for a scale factor evolving like @xmath194 ,
one gets = -p+1 + p t^-p-1 .
they are two modes : a constant mode and a decaying mode .
note that , in the previous subsection on the initial conditions , we eliminated the decaying mode to avoid the divergence when going backwards in time . in a transition between two cosmological phases characterized respectively by the scale factors @xmath195 and @xmath196 , one can easily finds the relation between the asymptotic behaviours of @xmath190 ( i.e. after the decaying mode becomes negligible ) by using the constancy of @xmath192 .
this gives _
2=p_2 + 1p_1 + 1_1 .
this is valid only asymptotically . in the case of a sharp transition
, @xmath190 must be continuous at the transition and the above relation will apply only after some relaxation time . for a transition radiation / non - relativistic matter , one finds [ rad_matt ] _ mat=910_rad . in practice and for more general cases , it turns out that it is much more convenient to follow the evolution of cosmological perturbations by resorting to quantities that are _ conserved on super - hubble scales_. a familiar example of such a quantity is the _ curvature perturbation on uniform - energy - density hypersurfaces _ , which can be expressed in any gauge as = c- .
[ zeta ] this is a gauge - invariant quantity by definition .
the conservation equation ( [ conserv_pert ] ) can then be rewritten as =-+ pp_nad-13 ^ 2(e+v ) , [ zetaprim ] where @xmath197 is the non - adiabatic part of the pressure perturbation , defined by p_nad = p - c_s^2 .
the expression ( [ zetaprim ] ) shows that @xmath198 is conserved _ on super - hubble scales _ in the case of _
adiabatic perturbations_. another convenient quantity , which is sometimes used in the literature instead of @xmath198 , is the _ curvature perturbation on comoving hypersurfaces _ , which can be written in any gauge as -=c++p q. [ r ] it is easy to relate the two quantities @xmath198 and @xmath199 . substituting e.g. @xmath200 , which follows from the definition ( see ( [ poisson ] ) ) of the comoving energy density perturbation , into ( [ zeta ] )
, one finds = -+_c+p . using einstein s equations , in particular ( [ poisson ] ) , this can be rewritten as = --23(+p)(kah)^2 .
the latter expression shows that @xmath198 and @xmath199 coincide in the super - hubble limit @xmath201 .
the quantity @xmath199 can also be expressed in terms of the two bardeen potentials @xmath162 and @xmath190 . using the momentum constraint ( [ momentum ] ) and the friedmann equations , one finds [ r_psi ] = -hh(+h ) . in a cosmological phase dominated by a fluid with no anisotropic stress , so that @xmath202 , and with an equation of state @xmath203 with @xmath28 constant , we have already seen that @xmath190 is constant with time . since the scale factor evolves like @xmath194 with @xmath204 , the relation ( [ r_psi ] ) between @xmath199 and @xmath190 reduces to [ r_psi2 ] = 5 + 3w3(1+w ) . in the radiation era , @xmath205 , whereas in the matter era , @xmath206 , and since @xmath199 is conserved , one recovers the conclusion given in eq .
( [ rad_matt ] ) . during inflation , @xmath207 and w+1=^2 - 23hh^2 so that -h^2h_inf . for a scalar field ,
the perturbed equation of motion reads + 3h+(k^2a^2+v ) = ( + 3)-2v .
in the previous section , we have discussed the _ classical _ evolution of the cosmological perturbations . in the _ classical _ context ,
the initial conditions , defined deep in the radiation era , are a priori arbitrary .
what is remarkable with inflation is that the accelerated expansion can convert _ initial vacuum quantum fluctuations _ into `` macroscopic '' cosmological perturbations ( see @xcite for the seminal works ) . in this sense
, inflation provides us with `` natural '' initial conditions , which turn out to be the initial conditions that agree with the present observations . as a warming - up , it is instructive to discuss the case of a massless scalar field in a so - called de sitter universe , or a flrw spacetime with exponential expansion , @xmath208 . in conformal time , the scale factor is given by a()=-1h .
the conformal time is here negative ( so that the scale factor is positive ) and goes from @xmath209 to @xmath210 .
the action for a massless scalar field in this geometry is given by [ action_ds ] s = d^4x ( -12_^ ) = d d^3x a^4 , where we have substituted in the action the cosmological metric ( [ metric_eta ] ) .
note that , whereas we still allow for spatial variations of the scalar field , i.e. inhomogeneities , we will assume here , somewhat inconsistently , that the geometry is completely fixed as homogeneous .
we will deal later with the question of the metric perturbations .
it is possible to write the above action with a canonical kinetic term via the change of variable u = a . after an integration by parts ,
the action ( [ action_ds ] ) can be rewritten as s=12d d^3x .
the first two terms are familiar since they are the same as in the action for a free massless scalar field in minkowski spacetime .
the fact that our scalar field here lives in de sitter spacetime rather than minkowski has been reexpressed as a _ time - dependent effective mass _
m^2_eff =- aa=-2 ^ 2 .
our next step will be to quantize the scalar field @xmath211 by using the standard procedure of quantum field theory .
one first turns @xmath211 into a quantum field denoted @xmath212 , which we expand in fourier space as [ fourier_quantum ] u ( , x)=1(2)^3/2d^3k \{a_k u_k ( ) e^i k.x + a_k^u_k^ * ( ) e^-i k.x } , where the @xmath213 and @xmath214 are creation and annihilation operators , which satisfy the usual commutation rules [ a ] = = 0 , = ( k - k ) .
the function @xmath215 is a complex time - dependent function that must satisfy the _
classical _ equation of motion in fourier space , namely [ eom_u ] u_k+(k^2-aa)u_k=0 , which is simply the equation of motion for an oscillator with a time - dependent mass . in the case of a massless scalar field in minkowski spacetime , this effective mass is zero ( @xmath216 ) and one usually takes @xmath217 ( the choice for the normalization factor will be clear below ) . in the case of de sitter
, one can solve explicitly the above equation with @xmath218 and the general solution is given by [ general_solution ] u_k = e^-ik(1-ik ) + e^ik(1+ik ) .
canonical quantization consists in imposing the following commutation rules on the @xmath219constant hypersurfaces : = = 0 and [ canonical ] = i(x - x ) , where @xmath220 is the conjugate momentum of @xmath211 . in the present case ,
@xmath221 since the kinetic term is canonical . subtituting the expansion ( [ fourier_quantum ] ) in the commutator ( [ canonical ] ) , and using the commutation rules for the creation and annihilation operators ( [ a ] ) , one obtains the relation u_k u_k^*-u_k^*u_k = i , [ wronskien ] which determines the normalization of the wronskian .
the choice of a specific function @xmath215 corresponds to a particular prescription for the physical vacuum @xmath222 , defined by _
a different choice for @xmath215 is associated to a different decomposition into creation and annihilitation modes and thus to a different vacuum .
let us now note that the wavelength associated with a given mode @xmath88 can always be found _ within _ the hubble radius provided one goes sufficiently far backwards in time , since the comoving hubble radius is shrinking during inflation . in other words , for @xmath223 sufficiently big , one gets @xmath224 .
moreover , for a wavelength smaller than the hubble radius , one can neglect the influence of the curvature of spacetime and the mode behaves as in a minkowski spacetime , as can also be checked explicitly with the equation of motion ( [ eom_u ] ) ( the effective mass is negligible for @xmath224 ) .
therefore , the most natural physical prescription is to take the particular solution that corresponds to the usual minkowski vacuum , i.e. @xmath225 , in the limit @xmath224 . in view of ( [ general_solution ] ) , this corresponds to the choice u_k = e^-ik(1-ik ) , [ u_k ] where the coefficient has been determined by the normalisation condition ( [ wronskien ] ) .
this choice , in the jargon of quantum field theory on curved spacetimes , corresponds to the _ bunch - davies vacuum_. finally , one can compute the _ correlation function _ for the scalar field @xmath78 in the vacuum state defined above .
when fourier transformed , the correlation function defines the _ power spectrum _
@xmath226 : 0| ( x_1 ) ( x_2)|0= d^3 k e^i k.(x_1-x_2 ) _(k)4k^3 .
note that the homogeneity and isotropy of the quantum field is used implicitly in the definition of the power spectrum , which is `` diagonal '' in fourier space ( homogeneity ) and depends only on the norm of @xmath227 ( isotropy ) . in our case ,
we find [ ps_phi ] 2 ^ 2k^-3_= |u_k|^2a^2 , which gives in the limit when the wavelength is _ larger than the hubble radius _ , i.e. @xmath228 , _(k)(h2)^2 ( kah ) note that , in the opposite limit , i.e. for wavelengths smaller than the hubble radius ( @xmath224 ) , one recovers the usual result for fluctuations in minkowski vacuum , @xmath229 .
we have used a quantum description of the scalar field .
but the cosmological perturbations are usually described by _
classical random fields_. roughly speaking , the transition between the quantum and classical ( although stochastic ) descriptions makes sense when the perturbations exit the hubble radius .
indeed each of the terms in the wronskian ( [ wronskien ] ) is roughly of the order @xmath230 in the super - hubble limit and the non - commutativity can then be neglected . in this sense
, one can see the exit outside the hubble radius as a quantum - classical transition , although much refinement would be needed to make this statement more precise .
let us now move to the more realistic case of a perturbed inflaton field living in a perturbed cosmological geometry .
the situation is more complicated than in the previous problem , because einstein s equations imply that scalar field fluctuations must necessarily coexist with _
metric fluctuations_. a correct treatment , either classical or quantum , must thus involve both the scalar field perturbations and metric perturbations . in order to quantize this coupled system ,
the easiest procedure consists in identifying the _ true degrees of freedom _ , the other variables being then derived from them via constraint equations . as we saw in the classical analysis of cosmological perturbations , there exists only one scalar degree of freedom in the case of a single scalar field , which we must now identify .
the starting point is the action of the coupled system scalar field plus gravity expanded up to second order in the linear perturbations .
formally this can be written as s[|+ , g_=|g_+h_]= s^(0)[| , |g _ ] + s^(1 )
[ , h_;| , |g _ ] + s^(2 ) [ , h_;| , |g _ ] , where the first term @xmath231 contains only the homogeneous part , @xmath232 contains all terms linear in the perturbations ( with coefficients depending on the homogeneous variables ) , and finally @xmath233 contains the terms quadratic in the linear perturbations .
when one substitutes the flrw equations of motion in @xmath232 ( after integration by parts ) , one finds that @xmath232 vanishes , which is not very surprising since this is how one gets the homogeneous equations of motion , via the euler - lagrange equations , from the variation of the action .
the term @xmath233 is the piece we are interested in : the corresponding euler - lagrange equations give the equations of motion for the linear perturbations , which we have already obtained ; but more importantly , this term enables us to quantize the linear perturbations and to find the correct normalization .
if one restricts oneself to the scalar sector , the quadratic part of the action depends on the four metric perturbations @xmath159 , @xmath123 , @xmath131 , @xmath132 , as well as on the scalar field perturbation @xmath234 .
after some cumbersome manipulations , by using the flrw equations of motion , one can show that the second - order action for scalar perturbations can be rewritten in terms of a single variable @xcite [ v ] v = a(-c ) , which is a linear combination mixing scalar field _ and _ metric perturbations .
the variable @xmath235 represents the true dynamical degree of freedom of the system , and one can check immediately that it is indeed a gauge - invariant variable .
in fact , @xmath235 is proportional to the comoving curvature perturbation defined in ( [ r ] ) and which , in the case of a single scalar field , takes the form = -c+. note also that , if one can check a posteriori that @xmath235 is the variable describing the true degree of freedom by expressing the action in terms of @xmath235 only ( modulo , of course , a multiplicative factor depending only on homogeneous quantities : the @xmath235 defined here is such that it gives a canonical kinetic term in the action ) , one can identify @xmath235 in a systematic way by resorting to hamiltonian techniques , in particular the hamilton - jacobi equation @xcite . with the variable @xmath235
, the quadratic action takes the extremely simple form s_v=12d d^3x , with [ z ] z = a. this action is thus analogous to that of a scalar field in minkowski spacetime with a time - dependent mass .
one is thus back in a situation similar to the previous subsection , with the notable difference that the effective time - dependent mass is now @xmath236 , instead of @xmath237 .
the quantity we will be eventually interested in is the comoving curvature perturbation @xmath199 , which is related to the canonical variable @xmath235 by the relation v =- z . since ,
by analogy with ( [ ps_phi ] ) , the power spectrum for @xmath235 is given by 2 ^ 2 k^-3p_v(k)= |v_k|^2 , the corresponding power spectrum for @xmath199 is found to be [ ps_r ] 2 ^ 2 k^-3p_(k)= |v_k|^2z^2 . in the case of an inflationary phase in the _ slow - roll _ approximation ,
the evolution of @xmath78 and of @xmath238 is much slower than that of the scale factor @xmath75 .
consequently , one gets approximately , and all results of the previous section obtained for @xmath211 apply directly to our variable @xmath235 in the slow - roll approximation .
this implies that the properly normalized function corresponding to the bunch - davies vacuum is approximately given by v_ke^-ik(1-ik ) .
[ v_k ] in the super - hubble limit @xmath239 the function @xmath240 behaves like v_k- ik i ahk , where we have used @xmath241 . consequently , on scales larger than the hubble radius , the power spectrum for @xmath199 is found , combining ( [ ps_r ] ) , ( [ z ] ) and ( [ v_k ] ) , to be given by _(h^4 ^ 2)_k = ah , [ power_s ] where we have reintroduced the cosmic time instead of the conformal time .
this is the famous result for the spectrum of scalar cosmological perturbations generated from vacuum fluctuations during a slow - roll inflation phase .
note that during slow - roll inflation , the hubble parameter and the scalar field velocity slowly evolve : for a given scale , the above amplitude of the perturbations is determined by the value of @xmath238 and @xmath242 when the scale exited the hubble radius . because of this effect , the obtained spectrum is not strictly scale - invariant .
it is also instructive to recover the above result by a more intuitive derivation .
one can think of the metric perturbations in the radiation era as resulting from the time difference for the end of inflation at different spatial points ( separated by distances larger than the hubble radius ) , the shift for the end of inflation being a consequence of the scalar field fluctuations @xmath243 .
rad~aa~h t , and the time shift is related to the scalar field fluctuations by @xmath244 , which implies _
rad~h^2 , which agrees with the above result since during the radiation era @xmath205 ( see eq .
( [ r_psi2 ] ) ) .
it is also worth noticing that , during inflation , in the case of the slow - roll approximation , the term involving @xmath131 in the linear combination ( [ v ] ) defining @xmath235 is negligible with respect to the term involving @xmath234 .
one can therefore `` ignore '' the rle of the metric perturbations _ during inflation _ in the computation of the quantum fluctuations and consider only the scalar field perturbations .
but this simplification is valid only in the context of slow - roll approximation .
it is not valid in the general case , as can be verified for inflation with a power - law scale factor .
we have focused so far our attention on scalar perturbations , which are the most important in cosmology .
tensor perturbations , or primordial gravitational waves , if ever detected in the future , would be a remarkable probe of the early universe . in the inflationary scenario , like scalar perturbations ,
primordial gravitational waves are generated from vacuum quantum fluctuations .
let us now explain briefly this mechanism .
the action expanded at second order in the perturbations contains a tensor part , which given by s^(2)_g=164gd d^3x a^2 ^_|e^i_j_|e^j_i , where @xmath245 denotes the minkoswki metric .
apart from the tensorial nature of @xmath246 , this action is quite similar to that of a scalar field in a flrw universe ( [ action_ds ] ) , up to a renormalization factor @xmath247 .
the decomposition a|e^i_j=_=+ , v_k,()^i_j(k ; ) e^i k.x where the @xmath248 are the polarization tensors , shows that the gravitational waves are essentially equivalent to two massless scalar fields ( for each polarization ) @xmath249 .
the total power spectrum is thus immediately deduced from ( [ ps_phi ] ) : _
g=2(h2)^2 , where the first factor comes from the two polarizations , the second from the renormalization with respect to a canonical scalar field , the last term being the power spectrum for a scalar field derived earlier . in summary ,
the tensor power spectrum is _
g=2 ^ 2(h)_k = ah^2 , [ power_t ] where the label recalls that the hubble parameter , which can be slowly evolving during inflation , must be evaluated when the relevant scale exited the hubble radius during inflation .
let us rewrite the scalar and tensor power spectra , respectively given in ( [ power_s ] ) and ( [ power_t ] ) , in terms of the scalar field potential only .
this can be done by using the slow - roll equations ( [ sr1]-[sr2 ] ) .
one finds for the scalar spectrum _
= 112 ^ 2(v^3 ^ 6v^2)_k = ah with subscript meaning that the term on the right hand side must be evaluated at _ hubble radius exit _ for the scale of interest .
the scalar spectrum can also be written in terms of the first slow - roll parameter defined in ( [ epsilon ] ) , in which case it reads _
= 124 ^ 2(v^4_v)_k = ah . from the observations of the cmb fluctuations , _
^1/2=12(v^1/2 ^2_v^1/2)510 ^ -5 .
if @xmath250 is order @xmath57 , as in chaotic models , one can evaluate the typical energy scale during inflation as v^1/4~10 ^ -3~10 ^ 15gev .
the tensor power spectrum , in terms of the scalar field potential , is given by _
g=23 ^ 2(v^4)_k = ah .
the ratio of the tensor and scalar amplitudes is proportional to the slow - roll parameter @xmath250 : [ r ] r=16_v .
the scalar and tensor spectra are almost scale invariant but not quite since the scalar field evolves slowly during the inflationary phase . in order to evaluate quantitatively this variation
, it is convenient to introduce a scalar _ spectral index _ as well as a tensor one , defined respectively by n_s(k)-1=d_(k)dk , n_t(k)=d_g(k)dk .
one can express the spectral indices in terms of the slow - roll parameters .
for this purpose , let us note that , in the slow - roll approximation , @xmath251 , so that = h - v3h^2- m_p^2vv , where the slow - roll equations ( [ sr1]-[sr2 ] ) have been used .
therefore , one gets n_s(k)-1=2_v- 6 _ v , where @xmath250 and @xmath252 are the two slow - roll parameters defined in ( [ epsilon ] ) and ( [ eta ] ) .
similarly , one finds for the tensor spectral index n_t(k)=-2_v . comparing with eq .
( [ r ] ) , this yields the relation r=-8 n_t , the so - called _ consistency relation _ which relates purely _ observable _ quantities .
this means that if one was able to observe the primordial gravitational waves and measure the amplitude and spectral index of their spectrum , a rather formidable task , then one would be able to test directly the paradigm of single field slow - roll inflation .
finally , let us mention the possibility to get information on inflation from the measurement of the running of the spectral index . introducing the second - order slow - roll parameter _
v = ^4 , the running is given by = -24 _ v^2 + 16 _ v _ v -2 _ v .
as one can see , the amplitude of the variation depends on the slow - roll parameters and thus on the models of inflation . to conclude ,
let us mention the existence of more sophisticated models of inflation , such as models where several scalar fields contribute to inflation .
in contrast with the single inflaton case , which can generate only adiabatic primordial fluctuations , because all types of matter are decay product of the same inflaton , _ multi - inflaton models _ can generate both adiabatic and isocurvature perturbations , which can even be correlated @xcite .
another recent direction of research is the possibility to disconnect the fluctuations of the inflaton , the field that drives inflation , from the observed cosmological perturbations , which could have been generated from the quantum fluctuations of another scalar field @xcite . from the theoretical point of view
an important challenge remains to identify viable and natural candidates for the inflaton field(s ) in the framework of high energy physics , with the hope that future observations of the cosmological perturbations will be precise enough to discriminate between various candidates and thus give us a clue about which physics really drove inflation .
alternative scenarios to inflation can also been envisaged , as long as they can predict unambiguously primordial fluctuations compatible with the present observations . in this respect
, one must emphasize that the cosmological perturbations represent today essentially the only observational window that gives access to the very high energy physics , hence the importance for any early universe model to be able to give firm predictions for the primordial fluctuations it generates .
i would like to thank the organizers of this cargese school for inviting me to lecture at this very nice village in corsica .
i also wish to thank the other lecturers and participants for their remarks and questions , as well as grard smadja and filippo vernizzi for their careful reading of the draft .
v. f. mukhanov and g. v. chibisov , jetp lett .
* 33 * , 532 ( 1981 ) [ pisma zh .
* 33 * , 549 ( 1981 ) ] ; a. h. guth and s. y. pi , phys .
lett . * 49 * , 1110 ( 1982 ) ; a. a. starobinsky , phys .
b * 117 * , 175 ( 1982 ) ; s. w. hawking , phys .
b * 115 * , 295 ( 1982 ) . | these lectures are intended to give a pedagogical introduction to the main current picture of the very early universe . after elementary reviews of general relativity and of the standard big bang model ,
the following subjects are discussed : inflation , the classical relativistic theory of cosmological perturbations and the generation of perturbations from scalar field quantum fluctuations during inflation .
p l |
the behavior of many quantum systems strongly depends on their interaction with the environment .
it is important to take this interaction into account to realistically describe systems like , e.g. , vibrational levels in a big molecule , the quantized mode of an electromagnetic field , or a trapped ion .
the rapid development of experimental techniques in these and other branches of physics and chemistry leads to an increased interest in theoretical descriptions of possible experiments by numerical calculations . additionally our calculations , which concern such systems , allow us to regard the still existing question about the border between classical and quantum effects from a new point of view .
for the systems , which are described here , the border to disappearance of quantum effects has been estimated .
one of the fundamental questions of quantum physics is to understand why the general principle of superposition works very well in microscopic physics but leads to paradox situations in macroscopic physics such as the schrdinger cat paradox @xcite where the cat can exist in a superposition of the states dead and alive .
one possible explanation of the paradox and the nonobserving of a macroscopic superposition is that @xcite systems are never completely isolated but interact with an environment , that contains a large number of degrees of freedom .
interactions with the environment lead to continuous loss of coherence and drive the system from a superposition into a statistical classical mixture .
the interest in the decoherence problem is explained not only by its relation to the fundamental question : where is the borderline between the macroscopic world of classical physics and microscopic phenomena ruled by quantum mechanics ? , but also by the increasing significance of potential practical applications of quantum mechanics , such as quantum computation and cryptography [ 3 , 4 ] .
there are a number of propositions how to create the superposition states in mesoscopic systems , or systems that have both macroscopic and microscopic features .
representative examples are the superposition of two coherent states of an harmonic oscillator @xmath0 for a relatively large amplitude ( @xmath1 ) . here
, @xmath2 is a coherent state and @xmath3^{1/2}$ ] is a normalization constant .
these states have been observed recently for the intracavity microwave field @xcite and for motional states of a trapped ion @xcite .
additionally , it has been predicted that superpositions of coherent states of molecular vibrations could be prepared by appropriately exciting a molecule with two short laser pulses @xcite and the practical possibilities of realizing such an experiment have been discussed @xcite . in this scheme
the quantum interference would survive on a picosecond time scale , which is characteristic for molecular vibrations . from the theoretical point of view
, quantum decoherence has been studied extensively [ 2 , 9 - 16 ] .
most efforts focused on the decoherence of the harmonic oscillator states due to the coupling to a heat bath , consisting of a large number of oscillators representing the environment .
the system is usually described on the basis of the master equation for a reduced density operator .
there are two general approaches for this method .
one adopts the markov approximation together with the rotating wave approximation ( rwa ) .
that means that all details of the complex system - environment interactions are neglected and relaxation is described by characteristic decay constants .
the system - bath interaction is phase - insensitive because of the rwa . in another approach , according to zurek @xcite , the coupling with the environment singles out a preferred set of states , called the pointer basis .
only vectors of this basis survive the quantum dynamics .
the vectors of the pointer basis are the eigenvectors of operators , which commute with the ( full ) interaction hamiltonian of the system .
this basis depends on the form of the coupling .
very often this pointer basis consists of the eigenstates of the coordinate operator .
the density operator describing the system evolves to diagonal form in the pointer basis , which is usually connected to the disappearance of quantum interference .
the two approaches give different pictures of the same decoherence processes .
one of the goals of this contribution is to present a consistent analysis of the decoherence on the basis of a density matrix approach starting from von neumann s equation for the density matrix of the whole system , i.e. the microscopic quantum system and the macroscopic environment .
let us consider a single molecule vibrating in a one - dimensional harmonic potential .
the molecule interacts with a number of harmonic oscillators modeling the environment . in the interaction hamiltonian @xmath4 @xmath5 ( @xmath6 )
are annihilation ( creation ) operators of molecular vibrations with the frequency @xmath7 , @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) operators for the environmental vibrations having the frequencies @xmath10 .
@xmath11 is the coupling between them .
starting from the von neumann equation @xmath12 , \label{3}\ ] ] where the hamiltonian @xmath13 contains the molecular system @xmath14 and the environment @xmath15 , one can formally rewrite the equation for the reduced density matrix @xmath16 , which is averaged over the environmental states [ 17 , 18 ] @xmath17 + e^{-{i h_{\mathrm{s}}t}/{\hbar}}\dot{d}(t,0 ) \left(d{(t,0)}\right)^{-1 } e^ { { i h_{\mathrm{s}}t}/{\hbar}}\sigma , \label{5}\ ] ] where @xmath18 is an evolution operator , averaged over the initial states of the environment .
@xmath19 \label{7}\ ] ] is the liouville operator in the interaction representation and @xmath20 is the operator of chronological ordering .
supposing that the initial states of the bath oscillators are thermalized ( @xmath21 ) , and restricting a cumulant expansion of @xmath22 to the second order cumulant [ 17 , 18 ] , we obtain the non - markovian master equation @xmath23 + r\sigma , \label{8}\ ] ] where the action of the relaxation operator @xmath24 is defined by @xmath25 % \nonumber \\ & & + \left [ a^{+}+a , \sigma \left ( a_n+a_{n+1}^{+ } \right ) \right ] .
\label{8a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the operators @xmath26 and @xmath27 are defined by linear combinations of the operators @xmath5 and @xmath6 as @xmath28 with the functions @xmath29
@xmath30 @xmath31 @xmath32 note , that @xmath33 and @xmath34 are the correlation functions of the environmental perturbations @xmath35 , where @xmath36 denotes the number of quanta in the bath mode with the frequency @xmath37 . the functions @xmath38 correspond to the friction coefficient in the classical limit .
the first two coefficients @xmath39 and @xmath40 strongly depend on the coupling constant @xmath41 for frequencies @xmath42 and on the number of quanta in the bath modes with the same frequencies , whilst the coefficients @xmath43 and @xmath44 are very small for all frequencies .
the obtained master equation ( [ 8 ] ) describes different stages of vibrational relaxation .
the initial stage is defined by a period of time smaller than the correlation time @xmath45 of the environmental perturbations .
this time can roughly be estimated from the width @xmath46 of the perturbation spectrum @xmath47 , for @xmath48 .
for such small times one can write the master equation in the following form @xmath49 \label{11 } + \gamma \left\ { \left [ \left ( a^{+}+a \right ) \sigma , a^{+}+a \right ] + \left [ a^{+}+a , \sigma\left ( a^{+}+a \right ) \right ] \right\ } , \ ] ] where @xmath50 is a real constant . as follows from eq .
( [ 11 ] ) , the pointer basis for this step of relaxation is defined by the eigenstates of the position operator @xmath51 .
another period of time , for which the form of the relaxation operator @xmath24 according to eq .
( [ 8a ] ) is universal , is the kinetic stage , where @xmath52 and the markov approximation becomes applicable . in this stage
the master equation has the form @xmath53 \label{12 } \\ & & + \gamma \left\ { \left [ \left ( ( n+1 ) a+na^{+ } \right ) \sigma , a^{+}+a \right ] + \left [ a^{+}+a , \sigma \left ( ( n+1 ) a+na^{+ } \right ) \right ] \right\ } , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath54 is the decay rate of the vibrational amplitude .
here @xmath55 , @xmath56 and the density of bath states @xmath57 are evaluated at the frequency @xmath58 of the selected oscillator .
it should be stressed that eq .
( [ 12 ] ) differs from the usual master equation for a damped harmonic oscillator for derivation of which the rwa is applied [ 5 - 8 , 10 - 13 ] .
this phase - sensitive relaxation leads to new effects : classical squeezing and a decrease of the effective harmonic oscillator frequency @xcite . in between
there is a time interval , where relaxation is specific and depends on the particular spectrum of @xmath47 .
the solution of the equation of motion of the reduced density matrix can be conveniently found using the characteristic function formalism , introduced in @xcite , which enables us to use the differential operators @xmath59 and @xmath60 instead of @xmath61 and @xmath62 . multiplying both sides of eq.([8 ] ) with the factor @xmath63 and taking the trace one can rearrange all terms into such a form that @xmath5 and @xmath61 precede the appropriate exponent .
for this operation we change the order of operators using the expression @xmath64 to make the transformation @xmath65 .
after that every term can be represented by the normally ordered characteristic function @xmath66 upon which one of the differential operators acts .
we obtain , e.g. , @xmath67 f \right ) = \left ( \lambda^ * \frac{\partial}{\partial \lambda^ * } - \lambda \frac{\partial}{\partial \lambda } \right ) f $ ] , @xmath68 f \right ) = \lambda^ * \left ( \frac{\partial}{\partial \lambda } - \lambda^ * \right ) f $ ] , and @xmath69 f \right ) = - \lambda^ * \frac{\partial}{\partial \lambda^ * } f $ ] .
such manipulations lead us finally to the @xmath70-valued partial differential equation : @xmath71 \frac{\partial}{\partial \lambda^ { * } } f \nonumber + \left [ i\omega \lambda -\mu^ { * } \left ( \lambda+\lambda ^ { * } \right ) \right ] \frac{\partial}{\partial \lambda } f \nonumber \\ & & - \left ( \lambda + \lambda ^{*}\right ) \left ( \nu \lambda^{*}+\nu^{*}\lambda \right ) f , \label{14}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath72 are relaxation functions .
we can solve eq .
( [ 14 ] ) by using the integral representation for the characteristic function @xmath73 which formally allows us to describe the nondiagonal density matrix . below the notation @xmath74 is adopted .
an initial characteristic function @xmath75 will evolve in accordance with eq.([14 ] ) as @xmath76 we restrict the cumulant expansion to the second order , i.e. @xmath77 . for a wide class of initial states ( coherent , thermal , squeezed , etc . )
high order cumulants vanish and our approximation becomes exact .
the cumulants could hold nondiagonal information , such as the density matrix , in relevant cases we stress it with the upper index @xmath78 or @xmath79 . the functions @xmath80 in eq.([17 ] ) are given by the solutions of the sets of equations @xmath81
@xmath82 k_{11 } + 2 \mu k_{02 } % + 2 \left ( \mu -\nu ^{*}\right ) k_{02 } + 2 \mu^ { * } k_{20 } % + 2 \left ( \mu ^{*}-\nu \right ) k_{20 } , \nonumber \\
\dot{k}_{20 } & = & - \nu^{*}+\mu k_{11 } % \left ( \mu -\nu ^{*}\right ) k_{11 } + 2 \left ( i\omega - \mu^ { * } % + \nu \right ) k_{20 } , \label{19 } \\
\dot{k}_{02 } & = & - \nu + \mu^ { * } k_{11 } % + \left(\mu ^{*}-\nu \right ) k_{11 } - 2 \left ( i\omega - \mu % + \nu^ { * } \right ) k_{02 } , \nonumber % \end{array } % \right .
% \label{19}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the initial values @xmath83 for the special case @xmath84 , these initial conditions represent a coherent state with amplitude @xmath85 .
this solution can be used for the construction of wave packets in different representations . here
, we will discuss the coordinate representation , in particular the dependence of the probability density @xmath86 on the vibrational coordinate @xmath87 and on time @xmath88 where @xmath89 is a characteristic function for the position operator .
evaluating the integral ( [ 21 ] ) we finally obtain @xmath90 where @xmath91 ^ 2 } { 4v\left ( t\right ) } \right\ } \label{24}\ ] ] and @xmath92 for the case @xmath84 the function @xmath93 denotes the expectation values of the coordinate operator of the coherent state , @xmath94 is the broadening of the gaussian packet ( [ 24 ] ) .
the distribution @xmath86 can be used for the investigation of relaxation dynamics for any initial state of molecular vibration , but it is best suited for studying the evolution of states prepared as a superposition of coherent states .
below , we will discuss the relaxation dynamics of initially coherent states and the superposition ( [ 1 ] ) of two coherent states .
because of the importance of this case we will use it to investigate the relaxation dynamics described by the master equation ( [ 8 ] ) . for coherently exited states @xmath95 the initial characteristic function is @xmath96
. thus , the initial values for @xmath97 and @xmath98 are @xmath99 and @xmath100 . in the first stage of relaxation , when @xmath101 , the relaxation functions are @xmath102 , @xmath103 .
therefore , the solution of the system of eqs .
( [ 18 ] , [ 19 ] ) gives @xmath104 even in this early stage there is a small quadratic broadening of the wave packet @xmath105 without changing its mean amplitude . after the intermediate stage of relaxation the solution of
the system goes into the markovian stage of relaxation , where the master equation ( [ 12 ] ) works . for this stage
the solution of eqs .
( [ 18 ] , [ 19 ] ) reads @xmath106 , \label{28}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath107^{-1}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ 29 ] ) demonstrates the decrease of the effective harmonic oscillator frequency due to the phase - dependent interaction with the bath .
the broadening of the wave packet @xmath108 can be also considered as uncertainty of the coordinate .
we would like to discuss both its increase and oscillation , described by eq.(31 ) and displayed in fig .
the increase of @xmath108 appears due to absorbtion of quanta from the heat bath .
such an effect is rather clear and can be obtained already using rwa .
the oscillation of the broadening deserves more intent attention .
some authors [ 21 , 22 ] have predicted the oscillation of second moments , using green functions formalism .
one feature of prediction [ 22 ] is that it assumes initially a squeezed state .
our prediction , represented in explicit form in eq .
( 31 ) goes further .
we would like to underline that in our case such an effect appears even for the usual coherent state as the initial one . in spite of the fact that this oscillation does not present quantum squeezing , because the width is never smaller than the ground state width , we stress the derivation of wave packet broadening oscillation in eq .
( 31 ) as one important achievement of the present paper . for the initial superposition of two coherent states ( [ 1 ] ) the normally ordered characteristic function
consists of four terms : @xmath109 \label{30}\ ] ] with @xmath110 .
the first terms describe the mixture of two coherent states , @xmath111 .
the last two terms correspond to the quantum interference , i.e. , they reflect the coherent properties of the superposition . in accordance with eqs.([18])([25 ] ) and the equation of motion ( [ 11 ] ) of the reduced density matrix this initial state evolves as @xmath112 + p_{int } \left ( q , t \right ) % \label{31 } % \nonumber\ ] ] with the interference term @xmath113 \label{31 } % \nonumber\ ] ] where @xmath114 is given by eq.([24 ] ) with @xmath115 @xmath116 @xmath117 and @xmath118 are defined by eqs.([28 ] , [ 29 ] ) . rewriting the real part of eq.([31 ] )
we finally obtain @xmath119 ^ 2 e^{-2\gamma t } - q^2 } { 4 v(t ) } \right ) \label{34 } \\ & & \times \biggl .
\cos \left ( \phi - q \frac { { \rm i m } ( \alpha z(t ) ) } { v(t ) } e^{-\gamma t } \right ) .
\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] figure 2 illustrates , how the superpositional state ( 1 ) evolves in time in accordance with eq . ( 34 ) .
it follows from eq .
( 38 ) , that the interference term describing quantum coherence in the system is only significant when @xmath120 ^2}{% v\left ( t\right ) } e^{-2\gamma t}\approx 2\left| \alpha \right| ^2 . \label{35}\ ] ] this is true for @xmath121 , and moreover , when the two wave packets of the state ( [ 1 ] ) come close together ( i.e. , at the moment when @xmath122 ) .
expanding eq.([35 ] ) into a series at these points and taking into account @xmath123 , it is easy to see that @xmath124 ^2 } { v \left ( t_i \right ) } \left ( 1 - 2\gamma t_i \right ) \right ) . \label{36}\ ] ] the decoherence is due to two reasons : the spreading @xmath125 of the wave packet due to thermal excitations by the bath , and amplitude decoherence .
the second means , that even for the case @xmath126 and @xmath127 quantum interference disappears exponentially with the rate @xmath128 this result obtained by zurek @xcite is the main reason why quantum interference is difficult to observe in the mesoscopic and macroscopic world .
for example , a physical system with mass 1 g in a superposition state with a separation of 1 cm shows a ratio of relaxation and decoherence time scales of @xmath129 . even if our measuring device is able to reflect the quantum properties of the microsystem
, nevertheless objectification @xcite occurs due to the coupling between the meter and the environment .
the fundamental result of eq.([37 ] ) is obtained no matter which approach is used , e.g. the rwa or zurek s pointer basis approach or the self - consistent description of the present paper .
however , the time dependence of the superposition terms of the distribution of eq.(38 ) differs a little bit , which can be seen in fig .
as quantum interference is more sensitive , we have used it for comparison of three different approaches to the present problem .
figure 3 shows the difference between the time evolutions , which result from eq .
( [ 26 ] ) , from eq.([28 ] ) , and from the corresponding result of the rwa approach .
these differences arise due to the fact that during the relaxation there is no constant pointer basis for all steps of the evolution . as follows from eqs .
( [ 11 ] , [ 12 ] ) , this basis changes from the position eigenstate basis in eq .
( [ 11 ] ) to the more complicated basis in eq .
( [ 12 ] ) .
as mentioned above the interference term ( 35 ) of the wave packet decays inevitably .
however , there exist proposals , how to slow down this process , reducing the consequence of the interaction .
in particular , one can consider a situation , when the majority of the bath modes have an off - resonance frequency in respect to the selected system .
in such a system the processes which are induced by the interaction with bath , namely loss of amplitude and phase must be delayed .
the hope to observe the conservation of a superpositional state as a consequence of the mentioned properties is the reason to put attention on such a system . as a simplest example we take the quantum system surrounded by harmonic oscillators with twice the system frequency @xmath130 .
it provides processes , when the system loses 2 quanta and the bath obtains one quantum . although this is still a resonace situation , we demonstrate below that it leads to unusual behavior compared to the usual situation @xmath131 , discussed above .
describing such a situation in the rwa we rewrite the interaction hamiltonian ( 2 ) in the following form @xmath132 applying then the above mentioned formalism of the evolution operator ( 6 ) we obtain again the equation ( 8) for the reduced density matrix @xmath133 of the selected system , but with some changes of the relaxational part ( 9 ) @xmath134 + \left [ ( a^+)^2 , \sigma a^2 \right ] \right\ } \nonumber \\ & + & \gamma n_\xi \left\ { \left [ ( a^+)^2 \sigma , a^2 \right ] + \left [ a^2 , \sigma ( a^+)^2 \right ] \right\ } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath135 is the decay rate of the vibrational amplitude . here , the number of quanta in the bath mode @xmath36 , the coupling function @xmath41 , and the density of bath states @xmath136 are evaluated at @xmath137 , i.e. , at the double frequency of the selected oscillator . rewritten in the basis of eigenstates @xmath138 of the unperturbed oscillator this master equation contains only linear combinations of such terms as @xmath139 , @xmath140 , and @xmath141 .
it ensures , in effect , a possibility to distinguish even and odd initial states of the system .
the odd excited state @xmath142 can not relax to the ground state @xmath143 , but the even excited state @xmath144 can .
the evolution of the system after preparation under different initial conditions was simulated numerically .
the equations of motion of the density matrix elements are integrated using a fourth order runge - kutta algorithm with stepsize control . to make the set of differential equations a finite one we restrict the number of levels by @xmath145 .
investigating the evolution of the initially coherent state of such a system we have concentrated our attention on some detail , which was not seen before .
one of the representative examples is the behavior of the initially coherent state of the system . for comparison with the usual behavior
we show the time dependence of the mean value of the coordinate in fig .
the mean value in the usual system decreases with a constant rate .
the same initial value of the system coupled to a bath with @xmath137 shows a fast decrement in the first stage and almost no decrement afterwards .
the question about the influence of the type of the bath on the evolution of the superpositional state is of special importance . at a temperature of @xmath146 , corresponding to @xmath147 , we have simulated the evolution of the same superpositional states twice , for @xmath131 and @xmath130 .
the coordinate representation of the wave packets is presented in fig . 4b and 4c . the same value of the relaxation @xmath148 yields , however , different results . in the system
coupled to the usual bath the quantum interference disappears already during the first period , while the amplitude decreases only slightly . in the other case ,
the system coupled to the bath with @xmath130 leaves the interference almost unchanged , although a fast reduction of the amplitude occurs .
therefore , the second system partially conserves the quantum superpositional state .
the experimental investigation of systems displaying such properties [ 2 ] is necessary , both for extracting typical parameter ranges for theoretical models and for practical applications like quantum computation and quantum cryptography .
the described example leads us to the conclusion that the second type of environment is more preferable .
starting from von neumann s equation for a vibrational oscillator interacting with the environment modeled by a set of independent harmonic oscillators we derived a non - markovian master equation , which has been solved analytically . for two types of the bath with maximum of the spectral density near the system frequency and near twice the system frequency and for two different initial states , namely a coherent state and a superposition of coherent states , the wave packet dynamics in coordinate representation have been analyzed .
it has been shown that wave packet dynamics demonstrate either classical squeezing and a decrease of the effective vibrational oscillator frequency due to the phase - dependent interaction with the bath or a time - dependent relaxation rate , distinct for even and odd states , and partial conservation of quantum superposition due to the quadratic interaction with the bath .
the decoherence also shows differences compared to the usual damping processes adopting rwa and to the description using the pointer basis for decoherence processes .
we conclude that there is no permanent pointer basis for the decay .
there are two universal stages of relaxation : the coherence time scale stage and the markovian stage of relaxation , both having different pointer bases .
we believe that the proposed method can be applied for other initial states and different couplings with the environment in real existing quantum systems , which is important in the light of recent achievements in single molecule spectroscopy , trapped ion states engineering , and quantum computation . 99 e. schrdinger , naturwissenschaften * 23 * , 807 ( 1935 ) ; * 23 * , 823 ( 1935 ) ; * 23 * , 844 ( 1935 ) .
zurek , phys .
today * 44 * , no.10 , 36 ( 1991 ) .
di vincenzo , science * 270 * , 255 ( 1995 ) .
i.l . chuang , r. laflame , p.w .
shor , w.h .
zurek , science * 270 * , 1633 ( 1995 ) .
m. brune , e. hagley , j.dreyer , x. maitre , a. maali , c. wunderlich , j.m .
raimond , and s. haroche , phys .
lett . * 77 * , 4887 ( 1996 ) . c. monroe , d.m .
meekhof , b.e .
king , d.j .
wineland , science * 272 * , 1131 ( 1996 ) .
j. jauszky , a.v .
vinogradov , t. kobayashi , and z. kis , phys .
a * 50 * , 1777 ( 1994 ) .
walmsley and m.g .
raymer , phys .
a * 50 * , 681 ( 1995 ) .
zurek , phys .
d * 24 * , 1516 ( 1981 ) ; * 26 * , 1862 ( 1982 ) ; w.g .
unruh , and w.h .
zurek , phys .
d * 40 * , 1071 ( 1989 ) .
a.o . caldeira and a.j .
leggett , phys .
a * 31 * , 1059 ( 1985 ) .
d.f . walls and g.i .
milburn , phys .
a * 31 * , 2403 ( 1985 ) .
l. davidovich , a. maali , m. brune , j.m .
raimond , and s. haroche , phys .
71 * , 2360 ( 1993 ) .
b.r . garraway and p.l .
knight , phys .
rev . a * 49 * , 1266 ( 1994 ) ; * 50 * , 2548 ( 1994 ) .
gerry and e.e .
hack iii , phys .
a * 174 * , 185 ( 1993 ) .
p. goetsch , r. graham , f. haake , phys .
a * 51 * , 136 ( 1995 ) .
poyatos , j.i .
cirac , and p. zoller , phys .
. lett . * 78 * , 390 , ( 1997 ) .
kilin , a.p .
nizovtsev , j. phys .
molec . phys .
* 19 * , 3457 ( 1995 ) ; a.p .
apanasevich , s.ya .
kilin , a.p .
nizovtsev , j. appl .
spectr . * 47 * , 1213 ( 1987 ) .
m. schreiber , d. kilin , in _ _ excitonic processes in condensed matter _ _ , ed .
m. schreiber , dresden university press , dresden ( 1996 ) , p. 331 .
yuen , j. opt .
b * 1 * , 510 ( 1984 ) .
f. haake and m. zukowski , phys .
a * 47 * , 2506 ( 1993 ) .
p. schramm and h. grabert , phys .
a * 34 * , 4515 ( 1986 ) .
h. grabert , p. schramm and g .- l .
ingold , phys . rep . * 168 * , 115 ( 1988 ) . | it is shown that the vibrational wave packet relaxation of initially coherent ( displaced ) states as well as the quantum superposition of coherent states in heat bathes with the different spectral densities exhibit a number of peculiarities compared with the cases of linear phase - sensitive relaxation , quadratic relaxation , and relaxational dynamics described with the use of zurek s environmentally - induced pointer basis .
a strong dependence of the relaxation rate on the position of the spectral density maximum of the bath is found .
the differences can be used for the discrimination of the mechanisms of the molecule - environment interactions .
pacs number(s ) : 82.29.rp , 33.80.be , 32.80.bx , 31.70.hq |
primordial nucleosynthesis provides an interesting testing arena where to analyze the viability of physical theories , particularly , of the statistical description .
it is in this epoch where the earliest bounds upon a given theory with cosmological influence can be imposed .
thermal processes ( see ref .
@xcite , hereafter referred as paper i ) are non - trivially modified by a non - extensive correction to quantum distribution functions .
then , different abundances of light elements are a possible outcome .
some of the predictions for primordial nucleosynthesis in a non - extensive setting have been analyzed before by some of us , using the asymptotic approach of the quantum distribution functions , see refs .
@xcite . here , instead , we shall consistently continue within the formalism given in paper i. since this approach is simpler , we shall obtain analytical results far beyond the point where previous works have reached , see for instance ref .
together with paper i , we shall then provide a complete history of the early universe , accordingly modified taking into account a non - extensive setting . in this paper
, we shall focus on the study of the changes that non - extensive statistics introduces in the principle of detailed balance , for which we provide a detailed analysis , both numerical and analytical .
we shall then enhance the study presented in @xcite , by framing it in a larger picture which encompasses an smaller number of approximations and a larger number of predictions .
primordial nucleosynthesis was recently used as well to demonstrate that macroscopic samples of neutrinos in thermal equilibrium are indeed distributed according to fermi - dirac statistics @xcite .
these latter authors considered that neutrinos were distributed by a bose - einstein statistics , and established bounds ( not very restrictive though ) upon this unexpected possibility .
it is interesting to compare with our case : we assume that neutrinos are indeed 1/2 particles , as a large amount of data coming from particles accelerators show , but that even when continuing being fermions , and fulfilling the pauli s exclusion principle , their distribution functions could slightly deviate from an exact fermi - dirac one . since we have provided a detailed account of non - extensive statistics , and the reasons why we choose the analytical form of the quantum distribution functions we adopted ( together with its derivation ) in paper i
, we shall skip such topics here .
we have also considered in paper i some physical reasons why to expect that boltzmann - gibbs distribution functions could be considered as an approximation .
the same is valid for citations to previous works , for which we adopted here the criterion to quote just those needed for the explicit computations we are carrying on .
this does not mean that our references are the only works in cosmological applications of non - extensivity , but only that for proper citation of some of the others , we refer the reader to paper i. the layout of this work is as follows .
section 2 presents the basics of the neutron to proton ratio in an evolving universe .
this section does not use much the fact that we are immersed in a non - extensive setting , but just presents general results which are valid disregarding the statistical mechanics used .
indeed , the derivation being presented in section 2 was already given by others @xcite , and we provide it here just for the ease of discussion . in sections 3 - 7 we give the details of the analysis of the principle of detailed balance , and show how to obtain a priori results on the possible range of physically admitted values of @xmath0 without the need to compare with experiments .
much of it is done in an analytical form , some is solved numerically . in section 8 , we present a detailed comparison between the two situations ( full and approximate cases ) that we found possible for the principle of detailed balance . towards the end of this latter section
we provide a comparison with the latest data available . in section 9
we compute , for the first time in a non - extensive framework , which is the modified capture time , the time in which neutrons are captured into deuterons . using this result we are able to compute the primordial abundance of @xmath1he with a greater degree of precision than that obtained in all previous works .
we show that there are non - linear effects introduced by the appearance of a slight non - extensivity .
finally , we give some general discussion in our concluding remarks .
we begin by turning again to the issue of the evolution of the neutron abundance as the universe evolves .
we shall base this discussion in the work by , bernstein , brown and feimberg @xcite . as we have done before , we shall denote by @xmath2 the rate for the weak processes to convert protons into neutrons and by @xmath3 the rate for the reverse ones @xcite .
@xmath4 will be , as usual , the number of neutrons to the total number of baryons .
for it , a valid kinetic equation is @xmath5 the solution to it is given by @xmath6 here , @xmath7 is @xmath8 with @xmath9 note that this solution is completely general , and does not depend on the statistical mechanics used , except by the implicit changes introduced in the new reaction rates .
as explained in @xcite , we simplify by taking @xmath10 and omitting the @xmath11 term .
these approximations yield @xmath12 finally , we note that @xmath13 or , equivalently , @xmath14 to compute eq . (
[ eq : xt2 ] ) , we need to know the reaction rates .
let us consider @xmath15 : @xmath16 that are individually given in ref.@xcite : @xmath17 @xmath18 @xmath19 with @xmath20 a constant , fixed by the experimental value of @xmath21 , @xmath22 are the neutrino and electron momenta , and @xmath23 their energies . in the energy domain
we are interested , some approximations are in order , see refs .
@xcite for discussion : 1 ) energy conservation is @xmath24 , to be used in eq .
( [ eq : rnun , pe ] ) and @xmath25 , to be used in eq.([eq : ren , pnu ] ) .
2 ) in eq . (
[ eq : rn , penu ] ) , @xmath26 , with @xmath27mev , from here comes the upper limit of the integration range .
3 ) pauli blocking factors are assumed equal to 1 . since computations will involve the inverse processes of eqs .
( [ eq : rnun , pe ] ) and ( [ eq : ren , pnu ] ) , we shall quote their form below : @xmath28 @xmath29 where @xmath30 for eq .
( [ eq : rep , nnu ] ) and @xmath25 for eq .
( [ eq : rnup , ne ] ) . the lower limit of the integral ( [ eq : rep , nnu ] ) is given by the minimum momentum that electrons must have in order to result @xmath31 , @xmath32 .
on the other hand , the lower limit in the integral ( [ eq : rnup , ne ] ) comes from the constraint @xmath33 , since we suppose that final states are unbounded . as remarked in @xcite , in general
, the electron and neutrino temperatures , @xmath34 and @xmath35 , may differ because at the end of the freezing out period , electrons and positrons annihilate , heating only the photons and maintaining with them thermal equilibrium .
indeed , in paper i we have computed the amount of this deviation for our non - extensive setting .
this difference is , however , small , and we shall follow bernstein et .
al . and set all temperatures equal , @xmath36 . in the standard case
this assumption ensure that the rates for reverse reactions , such as @xmath37 , obey the principle of detailed balance ( pdb ) .
the pdb states that if we know the expression for a reaction rate , say @xmath38 , then this is related with the reaction rate for the inverse reaction by an exponential factor , @xmath39 we shall study what happen in the non - extensive case , by analyzing each reaction appearing in eq .
( [ eq : rnp ] ) in a separate way .
we would like to see what is the relationship between @xmath41 and @xmath42 , with @xmath43 and @xmath44 starting from @xmath41 , and taking into account that @xmath45 , @xmath46 and @xmath47 , it is possible to show that , using changes of variable , @xmath48 in the regime @xmath49 , @xmath50 can be approximated by @xmath51 since during the period of freezing , the temperature @xmath52 is low compared with the energies appearing in the reaction rates , it is a good approximation to neglect pauli factors . then , to analyze the relationship between @xmath53 and @xmath54 it is enough to see how @xmath55 and @xmath56 relate themselves . from eq .
( [ eq : fqi ] ) , and recalling that in the reactions @xmath40 , @xmath46 , we can directly write @xmath55 in terms of @xmath56 .
this yields @xmath57 then , the pdb is no longer valid , since the reaction rates in this case are related by @xmath58 with @xmath46 .
we shall say that we are working within a detailed balance with non - extensive corrections ( bne ) .
it is worth noting that we can obtain an approximate expression among the rates , similar to what one obtains for the standard situation . indeed , using @xmath59 in eq .
( [ eq : fefnurel ] ) , we get @xmath60 what immediately yields @xmath61 we can recover the standard pdb , invoking this additional approximation , what we shall refer as to standard pdb ( bst ) . in what follows ,
we shall show results both in the full bne as in the bst approximation , and we shall discuss the range of validity of eq .
( [ eq : pdbstf ] ) . a similar analysis yields @xmath63 where @xmath64 and we neglected the electron mass with respect to the energies .
in fact , a careful look at eqs .
( [ eq : pdbq1 ] ) and ( [ eq : pdbq2 ] ) show that both integrals are identical . within bst ,
the relationship between the rates again simplifies , to give @xmath65 because of the fact that we have taken @xmath67 as @xmath68 in eq .
( [ eq : rn , penu ] ) , no modification arises in this case : @xmath69 this allow us to determine @xmath20 in terms of a measurable quantity , the neutron mean life @xmath70 , @xmath71 we shall neglect the free decay of the neutron in this section , particularly when computing @xmath38 .
this makes eq .
( [ eq : rnp ] ) to assume the form @xmath72 . neglecting the blocking factors in eqs .
( [ eq : rnun , pe ] ) and ( [ eq : ren , pnu ] ) it is evident that this two terms are identical .
the same happens with eqs .
( [ eq : rep , nnu ] ) and ( [ eq : rnup , ne ] ) , but in this case we have to neglect , in addition , the electron mass in order to have @xmath73 equal to @xmath74 . due to this ,
@xmath75 and @xmath76 . using all previous results ,
the valid relationship between @xmath77 and @xmath78 , both in the bne as in the bst approximation are @xmath79 where we have defined @xmath80 with @xmath81 , for bne , and @xmath82 for the bst .
to compute @xmath77 and @xmath78 , it is clear that we have to know just one reaction rate , for instance @xmath83 , and the value of @xmath84 defined in eq .
( [ eq : i(nu ) ] ) .
we can solve for @xmath83 using eq .
( [ eq : rnbfnun , pe ] ) . with the distribution functions being as in paper
i we obtain @xmath85 these integrals are easily computed changing variables to @xmath86 and using the integral form of the function @xmath87 . noting that @xmath88 for @xmath89 ,
defining @xmath90 , and using ( [ eq : ataurel ] ) , we obtain @xmath91 + \frac{a}{\tau y^5 } ( q-1)\left[180 + 60y + 6y^2\right].\ ] ] these same considerations are valuable to compute @xmath84 .
it is given as @xmath92.\ ] ] we have already mentioned that @xmath93 , i.e. @xmath94 + \frac{a}{\tau y^5 } ( q-1)\left[180 + 60y + 6y^2\right].\ ] ] this equation is valid in both , the full bne and the bst approximation . and @xmath95 .
right : corrections produced by non - extensive statistics , normalized by @xmath0 , using the full bne.,title="fig:",width=302,height=415 ] and @xmath95 .
right : corrections produced by non - extensive statistics , normalized by @xmath0 , using the full bne.,title="fig:",width=302,height=415 ] we use eqs .
( [ eq : pdbq ] ) and ( [ eq : i(y ) ] ) to get , within the full bne , @xmath96.\ ] ] it is also immediate to obtain this rate in the bst , i.e. @xmath97 this last equation was used by torres and vucetich @xcite , where the bst was assumed from the beginning .
it is worth noticing that since @xmath98 and @xmath95 have an asymptotic behavior analogous to that of the standard rates , see fig .
[ fig : tasas ] , also in this case we expect that in the limit of low temperatures ( i.e. @xmath99 ) the neutron abundance behaves as a constant .
that is , for low temperatures , the reaction rates are practically zero and then , processes interchanging neutrons into protons and viceversa are negligible . in this sense ,
@xmath100 stabilizes towards a constant .
the formal solution for the evolution of the neutron abundance is given by eq .
( [ eq : xt2 ] ) .
we shall use the variable @xmath101 , so that @xmath102 and the factor @xmath84 becomes @xmath103 to evaluate the jacobian @xmath104 , we recall that the scale factor , @xmath105 , in a friedmann - robertson - walker metric , goes as @xmath106 , independently of the statistics @xcite . then , @xmath107 , and the rhs is given by einstein equations , @xmath108 here , @xmath109 is the energy density of relativistic species , given in paper i. when the universe is dominated by @xmath110 and @xmath111 , and then @xmath112 , @xmath113 and @xmath114 , we obtain @xmath115 we can now compute @xmath116 , @xmath117 since , @xmath118 , @xmath119 and to first order in @xmath0 , @xmath120.\ ] ] in this sense , we see that @xmath121,\ ] ] where @xmath122 and @xmath123 are given @xmath124 numerical values for these constants can be obtained taking into account that : @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127mev , @xmath128s @xcite and @xmath129 and are @xmath130 and @xmath131 .
this follows the treatment given in ref .
@xcite . using all previous remarks , @xmath132 with @xmath133 given by @xmath134 or , equivalently , using eq .
( [ eq : dt / dy ] ) , @xmath135 we then see that the needed steps to solve for the evolution of @xmath136 as a function of @xmath137 are : 1 ) find the function @xmath133 as in eq .
( [ eq : kqy1 ] ) , 2 ) substitute this result in the expression ( [ eq : iyy ] ) for @xmath138 , and 3 ) finally solve the integral in ( [ eq : xqy1 ] ) .
the complexity of all functions involved requires a numerical procedure .
however , we can do further before going to numerical work , since our aim is to primarily see how the asymptotic value of @xmath139 , @xmath140 , is affected as a function of the parameter @xmath0 , and ultimately , how this asymptotic value changes if one assume the full bne as compared with the approximate bst approach .
in this case , @xmath141 coincides with its standard analogous @xmath142 . indeed , by definition , @xmath143 , and since bst establishes @xmath144 , we obtain @xmath145 .
we can get @xmath133 taking into account that , using eqs .
( [ eq : rnp(y ) ] ) and ( [ eq : rpn(y ) ] ) , @xmath146 + ( q-1)\left[180 + 60y + 6y^2\right].\ ] ] computing the integral in eq .
( [ eq : kqy1 ] ) , @xmath147.\ ] ] with @xmath148\ ] ] and @xmath149,\ ] ] and where the functions @xmath150 are @xmath151 we recognize in eq .
( [ eq : kqy2 ] ) the standard term @xmath152 . the presence of the factor @xmath153 in the jacobian @xmath116 produces the appearance in @xmath154 of a second order term in @xmath0 .
it is important to note that because this function diverges as @xmath155 at the origin , it is not a priori obvious that we can retain ( as was done in @xcite ) , only the term linear in @xmath0 .
this is a key remark , and we shall come back on this later . we shall then try to obtain the whole solution , without linearizing any of the functions involving @xmath0 . having shown that @xmath156 , we can write , using eq .
( [ eq : xqy1 ] ) , the asymptotic value @xmath157 , as @xmath158 this expression allows for an analytical study . based on the divergent behavior of @xmath159 at the origin and because of the good behavior of @xmath160 near zero , it is possible to discard _ a priori _
, i.e. without having the need to compare with any observation , the range of @xmath0-values such that the non - extensive theory , considered within the bst , looses its sense ( i.e. the cases in which the asymptotic values predicted for @xmath136 are out of the interval [ 0,1/2 ] ) . indeed , in order to avoid problems at the origin in eq .
( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) , @xmath133 has to be positive when @xmath161 . using eqs .
( [ eq : kqy2 ] ) , ( [ eq : k1 ] ) and ( [ eq : k2 ] ) , this condition translates immediately into an allowed interval for @xmath0 , since @xmath162,\ ] ] i.e. @xmath163.\ ] ] we see that , to have @xmath164 , @xmath0 must be such that the inequality @xmath165 is fulfilled . recalling that @xmath131 we see that values that do not fulfill the condition @xmath166 must be automatically discarded .
we mention in addition that no matter the sign of @xmath159 , the factor @xmath167 multiplying the integral in eq .
( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) tends to 1 when @xmath168 .
[ fig : int - bst ] shows the behavior of the integrand of eq .
( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) for different @xmath0-values .
note the abrupt change of the plots when @xmath0 is near the extremes of the range given by eq .
( [ eq : rangobst ] ) .
the analytical conclusion is then reinforced by these plots and is completely confirmed when numerical computations are made .
these latter show that the integral ( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) grows without limit when @xmath0 assumes values out of the range given by eq .
( [ eq : rangobst ] ) . for different values of @xmath0 within the bst approach.,width=680,height=982 ]
we have then showed that there exist a range of @xmath0 such that the asymptotic value of @xmath169 has physical sense .
we can now ask if there also exist a range of @xmath170 $ ] such that the @xmath169 obtained to first order in @xmath0 is consistent with the whole computation
. this would be so if we can prove that the first order result do not differ much from the real result that we have already got .
to compute @xmath169 to first order in @xmath0 , we need to write eq .
( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) to first order and neglect quadratic terms in eq .
( [ eq : kqy2 ] ) .
this gives @xmath171 with @xmath172,\ ] ] and @xmath173-ck^{st}.\ ] ] we write @xmath174 to first order as @xmath175.\ ] ] substituting this expansion into ( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) and retaining only the linear term we get @xmath176 with @xmath177 and @xmath178 \frac{e^{y'}}{(1+e^{y'})^2 } dy ' .\ ] ] this integrals can be computed numerically , and the result is @xmath179 where the value @xmath180 is the standard one . as a function of @xmath0 , to first order , and using the full numerical solution , both obtained within the bst approach.,width=415,height=453 ] fig .
[ fig : fit - pdbt ] shows the linear dependence of eq .
( [ eq : xqo(q-1 ) ] ) , together with the full solution given by eq .
( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) .
although within the framework of the asymptotic approach to quantum distribution functions , an analogous equation to ( [ eq : xqo(q-1 ) ] ) was presented already by some of us @xcite , we have now shown , for the first time , what is behind that approach , what sustains it , and the range of its validity .
in this section we shall solve eq .
( [ eq : xqy1 ] ) without approximations . that is
, we shall take for @xmath78 and @xmath77 , the expressions given by ( [ eq : rnp(y ) ] ) and ( [ eq : rpn(y ) ] ) , respectively .
our aim will be to quantify the amount of the deviation that it is produced when the bst , instead of the full bne , is considered . by definition , @xmath181 , adding ( [ eq : rnp(y ) ] ) and ( [ eq : rpn(y ) ] ) we see that @xmath182 is given by the sum of two terms @xmath183,\ ] ] @xmath184 + 30 y \left [ 1 + 5 e^{-y}\right ] + y^2 \left[1 + 21 e^{-y}\right ] + 12 y^3 + y^4 \right].\ ] ] because of the linearity of the integral operator , the same happens to @xmath133 in eq .
( [ eq : kqy1 ] ) . using the previous expressions , we get @xmath185.\ ] ] with @xmath186\ ] ] and @xmath187\ ] ] where @xmath150 were given in ( [ eq : ei ] ) . as before
, we do recognize the standard term @xmath188 . also here , within the bne , it happens that @xmath189 indeed , since within the bne , in the limit @xmath99 we have @xmath190 and @xmath191 , we obtain @xmath192 we then obtain an analogous to eq .
( [ eq : xqinf1 ] ) @xmath193 it is important to note that @xmath133 diverges as @xmath155 at the origin , and as @xmath194 at infinity .
then , first order developments will not do .
the complex dependencies of the integrand of eq .
( [ eq : xqy1 ] ) with @xmath0 makes much harder to a priori analyze the validity range , as done within the bst .
we can , however , make a detailed analysis of the behavior of the derivative of the function @xmath195 and of the integrand of eq .
( [ eq : xqy1 ] ) , for different @xmath0-values .
we show this in figs .
[ fig : dab - real ] and [ fig : int - real ] . for different @xmath0-values within the bne.,width=680,height=982 ] for different @xmath0-values , within the bne.,width=680,height=982 ] from the analysis of these figures we see that the bst and the bne differ in a fundamental way , which translates into the value of @xmath169 . within the bne , and because of the behavior of the derivative of the function @xmath195 for negative values of @xmath0 , it is not guaranteed that the integrand in eq .
( [ eq : xqy1 ] ) is negative .
for @xmath196 the integral of ( [ eq : xqy1 ] ) is positive ( i.e. @xmath197 ) , and this discards values of @xmath198 such that @xmath196 . on the other hand , looking at fig .
[ fig : dab - real ] for positive values of @xmath0 , we see that the upper bound is between 0.19 and 0.2 , in this case similarly to the bst .
then , for the bne , the values for which the theory has physical sense a priori of any experimental comparison are @xmath199 the bne is more restrictive than the bst . out of this range , the physical sense of the description is lost .
we now compare the results obtained in sections [ sec : bst ] and [ sec : bne ] . fig .
[ fig : comp ] shows @xmath169 for different values of @xmath0 , both in the full bne as well as in the bst approximation .
differences are notable , and they grow with increasing values of @xmath200 , as it tends to its limiting values .
table 1 gives the explicit values of @xmath169 obtained using a numerical integration scheme for the bst and for the full bne , and the analytical results of the first order approximation for the bst .
for values of @xmath0 near 0 , the bst numerical computation is perfectly described by the linear approximation . as a function of @xmath0 , both for the full bne and the bst.,width=415,height=453 ] .comparison of @xmath169-values as a function of @xmath0 for the different approaches . [ cols=">,^,^,^ " , ] [ tab : tabla2 ] until now , we have discussed the physical viability of the statistical description , establishing a range of a priori discarded values of @xmath0 both for the full bne case , the real situation , and for the bst approximation .
these values are those for which @xmath169 is @xmath201 or @xmath202 .
this can be done before than the comparison with any given observational data or experiment .
recall that @xmath203 is the neutron to proton ratio , for which clearly , a negative value has no sense .
in addition , @xmath204 is in conflict with the reaction rates dependence with temperature , since @xmath205 is the initial condition for the kinetic equation ( [ eq : dx / dt ] ) when @xmath206 ( i.e. @xmath207 ) . within the range of physical viability
we now look for consistency with observations .
this will further restrict the range of admitted values of @xmath0 . to obtain a direct bound upon @xmath0 using the primordial abundance of @xmath1he
it is necessary to study in detail the free decay of neutrons , happening between the moment of freezing out of the weak interactions ( @xmath208 1 s ) and the moment in which the temperature of the universe is similar to the binding energy of d ( @xmath208 3 minutes ) .
we shall provide , for the first time in a non - extensive setting , a detailed account of this in the following section , but nevertheless , let us give here some preliminary considerations in the sense of ref . @xcite . including the effects of the neutron decay in the equation for the evolution of @xmath209 we have , @xmath210 where @xmath211 is the already obtained ratio and @xmath70 is the neutron mean life . in the capture time , @xmath212 ,
when the temperature is below the d binding energy ( 2.23 mev ) , neutrons are captured into d. then , almost all neutrons present at @xmath212 are converted into @xmath1he . substituting the value of @xmath213 into eq .
( [ eq : xdecay ] ) and using the value of @xmath214 previously found , we shall obtain half of the mass fraction of all @xmath1he primordially produced . for the time being , we shall adopt the standard value for @xmath215 , which is @xmath216 @xcite . with this
we obtain , @xmath217\\ \label{eq : yqp } & = & 0.24 + ( q-1)0.37.\end{aligned}\ ] ] there is no absolute consensus about the observational value of @xmath1he .
the two greatest compilations give @xcite , @xmath218 to consider a typical case , we average over the two mean values and twice the error bar , @xmath219 if at the same time we neglect the difference between the standard theoretical and the observational values , which is given by 0.001 , in order to obtain a first bound , we can get , using eq .
( [ eq : yqp ] ) and asking for @xmath220 , @xmath221 within the most complete treatment of the principle of detailed balance ( bne ) , which accounts for the more in depth analytical study on the influence of a slight non - extensivity in primordial nucleosynthesis , the value of @xmath198 could differ from 1 at the level of a few percent and still be in agreement with current constraints .
see below for a more detailed treatment .
the aim of this section is to show how the capture time @xmath213 is modified in the non - extensive framework . recalling that at early times @xmath222 and @xmath223 after the @xmath224 annihilation , it is straightforward to write @xmath225 where @xmath226 is a constant whose standard value is of the order 2 seconds , see @xcite . in paper
i , it was shown that the energy density could be written as @xmath227 .
taking also into account that the photon and neutrino temperatures are related by @xmath228 t_\nu$ ] , we can solve the definite integral to obtain : @xmath229 + t_0,\ ] ] where @xmath230 .
in equilibrium , neutrons , protons and deuterons behave as free non - relativistic gases , with number densities given by @xmath231.\ ] ] here , the subscript @xmath232 stands for @xmath233 and @xmath234 , for neutrons , protons and deuterons respectively , @xmath235 and @xmath236 are the chemical potentials and masses of the particles . at early times , these gases are in chemical equilibrium , so that @xmath237 .
therefore , @xmath238,\ ] ] with @xmath239 , and where we have made use of the definition , @xmath240 equation ( [ eq : sahad ] ) is the generalized saha equation that describes the deuterium formation ( see paper i for a general derivation ) .
helium appearance is inhibited by the `` deuteron bottleneck '' , represented by the reactions : @xmath241 eq .
( [ eq : sahad ] ) can be given in terms of the normalized abundance fractions @xmath242 .
to this purpose we introduce the baryon to photon ratio @xmath243 and recall that @xmath244(t^3_\gamma/\pi^2)$ ] .
we get for the quantity @xmath245 , to first order in @xmath0 , the following result @xmath246.\ ] ] here , as in paper i , @xmath247 . as in the standard case analyzed in ref .
@xcite , to determine the neutron capture time @xmath213 we need to examine the sequence of reactions ( [ eq : reacd1]-[eq : reacd3 ] ) .
it is convenient to do so in terms of an scaled temperature @xmath248 , so that they involve rate parameters of the form @xmath249 where @xmath250 denotes the thermal average of the relevant cross section times the relative velocity @xcite .
( [ eq : ttrel ] ) and writing the baryon number density in terms of the baryon to photon number density ratio , @xmath251 , we get @xmath252.\ ] ] taking @xmath253 @xcite as a nominal value for @xmath251 and considering @xmath254 @xcite we obtain @xmath255.\ ] ] neutron and proton populations are mainly determined by the kinetic equations @xmath256 , \hspace{2.3 cm } \frac{dx_q^p}{dz}=-r^q_{np}[x_q^n x_q^p - g^q_{np}x_q^d].\ ] ] as in the usual case , if the neutron population is not depleted by other reactions such as eqs .
( [ eq : reacd2]-[eq : reacd3 ] ) , protons , neutrons and deuterons are kept in equilibrium , relationships @xmath257 and @xmath258 being valid . since @xmath259 is very small , the deuterium number density will be also small , and we can write a first approximation as @xmath260 where @xmath261 and @xmath262 are the unperturbed populations , that obey @xmath263 . using this
we now have @xmath264 recalling eq .
( [ eq : gqnp ] ) , one sees that for the @xmath265-values we are interested ( @xmath266 ) , the major @xmath265 dependence of @xmath259 goes as @xmath267 . hence , to first order , @xmath268 adding eqs .
( [ eq : dxqn / dz ] ) and using eq .
( [ eq : xqd1a ] ) we find that @xmath269.\ ] ] when deuterium number density is depleted , its number density will change according to @xmath270- r^q_{dd}[2(x_q^d)^2 - g^q_{dd}x_q^t x^q_p ] + \ldots\ ] ] where @xmath271 is the scaled rate for the reaction ( [ eq : reacd2 ] ) and @xmath272 is the saha factor which gives the equilibrium value for the ratio @xmath273 .
it can be shown that , in contrast to @xmath274 , @xmath275 is always a small number ( see section iii of ref .
@xcite ) . in fact ,
in the standard framework @xmath275 is of order @xmath276
. we shall obviously be safe in considering @xmath277 , and therefore in neglecting it .
we can obtain @xmath278 inserting the value of @xmath279 in eq .
( [ eq : rq ] ) .
the calculation of @xmath279 is a non - trivial task , which involves the use of a phenomenological fit to the cross section plus a thermal average carried out using boltzmann velocity distributions for the deuterons . for the sake of simplicity
, we shall adopt the value of the thermal averaged cross section used by bernstein et al .
this can be written as @xmath280 introducing the nominal value of @xmath281 as we did it when we wrote @xmath282 , we can now write for @xmath278 @xmath283\ ] ] when the deuterium number density decreases enough , the chain of reactions that converts almost all neutrons into helium is initiated .
we may therefore identify the temperature @xmath284 , at which the neutrons are captured , or equivalently , the value of @xmath285 , as in the standard case , by the condition that @xmath286 once we have neglected the factor @xmath272 , the condition stated above , together with eqs .
( [ eq : xqd1a ] ) and ( [ eq : xqd1b ] ) and the approximation @xmath287 , gives @xmath288 in order to solve this equation we proceed as follows .
let us first rewrite the previous equation as @xmath289 note that we can put the rhs in terms of @xmath265 . in section 8
we have already given the asymptotic value of @xmath261 as @xmath290 , and therefore the value of @xmath262 can be found trough the relation @xmath263 .
now , using eq.([eq : rqdd ] ) leads , to first order in @xmath0 , to @xmath291z^{-4/3}e^{-1.44z^{1/3}}.\ ] ] on the other hand , we also have an expression for @xmath292 : it is given by eq .
( [ eq : gqnp ] ) . therefore ,
if we were are able to write eq .
( [ eq : gqnp ] ) in terms of @xmath265 we can equal both expressions and solve for the unknown @xmath293 , which will satisfy the equality for a given value of @xmath0 . unfortunately , this is not easy .
the difficulty is due to the presence of the chemical potentials in @xmath292 in combinations other than the relation @xmath237 . in this sense , we confront here a problem similar to that found in the recombination study of paper i. we shall just mention that it is possible to show that the function @xmath294 has @xmath295 as an upper bound , see appendix for details .
therefore , in the range of @xmath265-values that concerns us , the corrections in @xmath292 due to non - extensivity will be at most of order @xmath296 10 ^ 3 $ ] and we can then write for @xmath297 , @xmath298z^{3/2 } e^{-z}.\ ] ] thus , equating expressions ( [ eq : gqnpz1 ] ) and ( [ eq : gqnpz2 ] ) , and taking @xmath299 , we finally found that @xmath293 must satisfy the following relation , @xmath300 the standard result ( i.e. @xmath301 ) gives @xmath302 .
the numerical solution of this equation for different values of the parameter @xmath0 , and the corresponding capture time , are shown in fig .
( [ fig : zc ] ) .
it is interesting to notice that while values of @xmath303 can be used within the analytical study presented in this section without any limit , this is not the case for values of the parameter such that @xmath304 .
the problem arises in that in these cases , @xmath292 can become negative , what clearly has no sense . in particular , for @xmath305 , the denominator in eq .
( [ ult ] ) is identically zero , while for values of @xmath306 it is negative . although this mines the physical viability of the description for these values of @xmath198 , in the same sense that what was referred before , other assumptions are taken in this section , and only a numerical code can give a more precise answer in either way .
note that to obtain fig .
7 we have made use of the non - extensive time - temperature correction . in fig .
8 ( left panel ) , we show the dependence of the @xmath1he abundance as a function of @xmath0 , taking into the free neutron decay correction . as a function of @xmath0 .
right : capture time as a function of @xmath0 .
both plots are constructed for a nominal value of @xmath307 .
note the asymmetric range of the @xmath0-values considered .
see text for explanation.,title="fig:",width=302,height=415 ] as a function of @xmath0 .
right : capture time as a function of @xmath0 .
both plots are constructed for a nominal value of @xmath307 .
note the asymmetric range of the @xmath0-values considered .
see text for explanation.,title="fig:",width=302,height=415 ] some comments about figs .
7 and 8 are worth doing .
firstly , note that the dependence of the @xmath1he abundance , when neutron free decay is taken into account , is no longer linear as it was before , see for instance eq .
( [ eq : yqp ] ) .
this makes the study of the nucleosynthesis process much more interesting , and the use of the full numerical code a worth doing task .
now we know that even when considering a first ( linear ) order correction in the quantum distribution functions , the final output in the primordial nucleosynthesis can not be reduced to a linear correction in the abundances .
secondly , it appears that for a given value of @xmath308 ( and @xmath309 ) there are two values of @xmath0 that could fit well the observations .
finally note that the y - axis of fig .
8 ( left panel ) is showing variations at the level of less than 1% , and in principle , all values of @xmath0 shown there are admitted by the current constraints on the primordial abundance of @xmath1he .
he abundance as a function of @xmath0 , taking into account neutron decay corrections .
this plot is constructed for a nominal value of @xmath310 .
right : primordial abundance of @xmath1he as a function of @xmath251 .
several @xmath0-values are shown .
two horizontal lines stand for a conservative current constraint on @xmath308.,title="fig:",width=302,height=415 ] he abundance as a function of @xmath0 , taking into account neutron decay corrections .
this plot is constructed for a nominal value of @xmath310 .
right : primordial abundance of @xmath1he as a function of @xmath251 .
several @xmath0-values are shown .
two horizontal lines stand for a conservative current constraint on @xmath308.,title="fig:",width=302,height=415 ] in fig .
8 ( right panel ) we show for the first time the dependence of the @xmath1he abundance as a function of @xmath251 , for different @xmath0-values .
the general trend of an increasing abundance as a function of @xmath309 is maintained , but for different values of @xmath198 , the curves cross the current constraints in different positions .
this plot actually represents a 3d problem , with a two parameter space .
the influence of @xmath309 appears when numerically solving the equation for @xmath293 .
indeed , the computation of the correction to the value of @xmath308 in the full analytical treatment presented here has to take into account different contributions .
a direct linear dependence on @xmath0 is within the time - temperature relationship ( see the first equations in this section , especially eq .
( [ eq : ttrel ] ) ) and in eq .
( [ eq : yqp ] ) .
in addition , we can see that if @xmath293 is smaller than in the standard case , then @xmath311 will be bigger , and @xmath213 will be smaller than their respective standard counterparts .
thus , @xmath312 will in turn be bigger , what happens for instance in the case of a negative value of @xmath0 , and this would provide a bigger @xmath308 . however , the linear correction in eq .
( [ eq : yqp ] ) is competing with that positive deviation ; this is what finally makes the curve to deviate from a straight line .
in this paper , based on previous works ( paper i ) , we have revisited the problem of the primordial genesis of light elements within the framework of non - extensive statistics .
we have particularly paid attention to the form of the principle of detailed balance that is valid in this new setting .
we have shown that its usual form is no longer valid , but instead , that it is just an approximation , dubbed here as the bst .
the full , new form of the principle of detailed balance was derived and named as bne , and we have studied it in detail too . by doing so , we were able to disguise the range of validity of previous approaches to the topic , and to formally see the origin and range of the deviations between the standard and non - extensive scenarios for the primordial production of elements .
we have also analyzed the neutron free decay correction to the capture time , and found that even when considering a first ( linear ) order correction in the quantum distribution functions , the final output can not be reduced to a linear correction in the abundances , as fig .
8 explicitly show . by comparing with the latest observational data , we have obtained a new bound on the upper limit of the parameter @xmath200 .
we think that the bound being presented here ( referring also to figs . 7 and 8)
is obtained within a much more detailed basis than the previous ones , see for instance @xcite , and then that this bound should be considered as the more reliable of them all .
indeed , we believe that the only way to improve it is to go to a direct implementation of the primordial nucleosynthesis code . by doing
so we would have the possibility of studying the modifications to the abundances of all light elements in a simultaneous way .
this further extension is currently under analysis . to have a rough idea of the order of magnitude of the function @xmath294
, we need to compute @xmath313 in the range of temperatures we are interested in , with @xmath314 and @xmath234 .
firstly , we note that for this purpose it is enough to consider the standard values of all these quantities .
this is because non - extensive effects here would introduce only second order corrections in @xmath0 , that we are disregarding in our computation .
recalling the relation @xmath315 , we see that in order to estimate the values of @xmath313 we need to know the abundances @xmath316 . then , to get @xmath294 , we have made the following steps : 1 . using the time - temperature relation
we can put @xmath317 as an explicit function of @xmath52 .
thus @xmath318 follows , as well as @xmath319 .
2 . considering @xmath318 together with the obtainable function @xmath320 ( remember that @xmath321 ) , and imposing the ( approximate ) constrain @xmath322 , we get the values of @xmath323 and @xmath324 .
then , the corresponding values of @xmath325 and @xmath326 can be obtained .
m. e. pessah is supported by fundacin antorchas .
we thank a. lavagno , g. lambiase , p. quarati , and h. vucetich for valuable discussions .
d. f. t. was supported by conicet as well as by funds granted by fundacin antorchas , and acknowledges the hospitality provided by the politecnico di torino , the university of salerno , and the ictp ( italy ) during different stages of this research . | if the universe is slightly non - extensive , and the distribution functions are not exactly given by those of boltzmann - gibbs , the primordial production of light elements will be non - trivially modified .
in particular , the principle of detailed balance ( pdb ) , of fundamental importance in the standard analytical analysis , is no longer valid , and a non - extensive correction appears .
this correction is computed and its influence is studied and compared with previous works , where , even when the universe was considered as an slightly non - extensive system , the pdb was assumed valid .
we analytically track the formation of helium and deuterium , and study the kind of deviation one could expect from the standard regime .
the correction to the capture time , the moment in which deuterium can no longer be substantially photo - disintegrated , is also presented .
this allows us to take into account the process of the free decay of neutrons , which was absent in all previous treatments of the topic .
we show that even when considering a first ( linear ) order correction in the quantum distribution functions , the final output on the primordial nucleosynthesis yields can not be reduced to a linear correction in the abundances .
we finally obtain new bounds upon the non - extensive parameter , both comparing the range of physical viability of the theory , and using the latest observational data .
= 10000 7.0 in -0.5 in -0.5 in -0.5 in |
fe@xmath0te chalcogenides are the parent compounds of the simplest family of iron - based superconductors .
@xcite both the electronic and magnetic properties of fe@xmath0te compounds show strong sensitivity to the amount of non - stoichiometric fe ions . for small values of @xmath3 ,
the low - temperature crystal structure is monoclinic ( @xmath4 ) , and the magnetic order is described by the commensurate propagation vector @xmath5 , corresponding to a double - stripe pattern .
this is remarkably different from feas - based parent compounds , which display an antiferromagnetic order described by @xmath6 or @xmath7 , corresponding to single - stripe patterns , and a crystal structure with orthorhombic symmetry ( @xmath8 ) .
experimentally , it is observed that by increasing the amount of interstitial fe , the magnetic structure of fe@xmath0te becomes an incommensurate spiral .
the incommensurate ordering manifests itself as a shift in the elastic neutron scattering peak with respect to the @xmath5 positions . according to neutron scattering experiments,@xcite in the range of @xmath9
the shift is approximately along the diagonal directions @xmath10 or @xmath11 ; however , @xmath12 does not vary smoothly with @xmath3 .
there have been several theoretical attempts to understand the magnetic properties of fe@xmath0te compounds within the localized spin scenario , @xcite since these materials are known to be more strongly correlated than their arsenide counterparts .
@xcite although the magnetic order at both low and at high levels of fe excess can be successfully described by a @xmath13 super - exchange model , it is clear that the local picture alone can not describe the magnetic properties of fe@xmath0te , as it requires @xmath3-dependent exchange couplings .
alternatively , this property indicates that itinerant electrons are also important to describe the magnetism of these materials , suggesting that hybrid models with coupled localized - itinerant moments are a suitable starting point .
@xcite in this paper , we argue that the evolution of the magnetic interactions due to @xmath3-dependent charge doping is the key to understand the experimentally observed magnetic phase diagram of fe@xmath0te . our study is based on the assumption that , in these particular iron chalcogenides , some of the fe orbitals are almost localized while the other orbitals remain itinerant .
this idea is supported by recent dynamical mean - field theory studies of fete systems @xcite showing that the hund s coupling can promote an orbital - selective localization already in the paramagnetic phase.@xcite here , we demonstrate that the change in magnetic properties observed in the fe@xmath0te compounds can be reasonably well captured by an effective model in which localized spins acquire a long - range rkky - type interaction , @xcite in addition to the @xmath13 heisenberg super - exchange@xcite and biquadratic couplings .
@xcite we note that in refs.@xcite the biquadratic term was calculated on a purely electronic basis , and obtained model gave a good agreement with experimentally measured spin - wave spectrum in several fe - based materials .
another possible origin of the biquadratic terms is due to the magnetoelastic coupling.@xcite the former , mediated by the multi - orbital spin susceptibility of the itinerant electrons , is sensitive to the addition of excess fe @xmath3 , rendering the magnetic ground state of the local spins change as a function of @xmath3 . in particular , we find that the shift in the chemical potential promoted by the excess electrons changes the fermi surface in a way that suppresses the @xmath2 peaks of the itinerant spin susceptibility of the parent compound , promoting at the same time peaks at small - momentum values . as a result ,
the effective exchange interaction @xmath14 is suppressed , @xmath15 is enhanced , and @xmath16 changes sign , favoring a spiral incommensurate state , in contrast to the double - stripe state of the stoichiometric compound .
the outline of the paper is as follows . in sec .
ii , we present an effective super - exchange model describing localized magnetic moments in the multi - band correlated electron sea and argue that this is a suitable minimal microscopic model to describe the magnetism of fe@xmath0te compounds . in sec .
iii , we study the evolution of the fermi surface of fete@xmath0 with increasing level of the fe excess using the tight - binding model ( tbm ) originally proposed by ma _
_ et al__@xcite , which had been later also used by wang _ _ et al__@xcite to explain further resutls in fete@xmath0 .
we show that while the fermi surface at small @xmath3 has both small hole pockets at the @xmath17- and @xmath18-points and elliptical electron pockets at the @xmath19- and @xmath20-points , at large @xmath3 all pockets are electron - like . in sec .
iv , we study spin fluctuations in the correlated multi - band electron system and compute the pauli susceptibility within the random phase approximation ( rpa ) .
we find that at small @xmath3 the itinerant spin susceptibility peaks at @xmath21 and @xmath22 due to the weak nesting between the hole and the electron pockets connected by these momenta .
the @xmath3-dependent charge doping suppresses the @xmath21 and @xmath22 peaks , but it leads to an increase of the spin fluctuation in the central part of the brillouin zone . in sec .
v , we compute the rkky interactions . we first perform a qualitative computation of the rkky interactions using a simple phenomenological model , and then perform a quantitative analysis based on the realistic rpa susceptibility obtained in sec .
iv . in sec .
vi , the classical phase diagram of the effective spin model is presented . in agreement with experimental findings
, the computed phase diagram displays a transition , above a certain level of fe excess , from a commensurate double - stripe phase , characterized by the wave - vectors @xmath23 or @xmath24 , to an incommensurate spiral ( ic ) phase characterized by the wave - vector @xmath25 .
we conclude with a summary in sec .
the paper has two appendices .
appendix a contains the derivation of the biquadratic exchange couplings arising from the magneto - elastic coupling .
appendix b provides the explicit expression of the classical energy of the effective super - exchange model describing fete@xmath0 .
to capture the fact that in fe@xmath0te correlations lead to different levels of itineracy in distinct fe orbitals , @xcite we consider a semi - phenomenological `` hybrid '' model containing both localized and itinerant moments similar in spirit to the models of refs .
@xcite . in particular , we assume that the electrons occupying the @xmath26 and @xmath27 orbitals form local moments with @xmath28 due to the hund s coupling .
the remaining @xmath29 electrons have itinerant character and can be controlled by the concentration of excess fe as @xmath3 increases .
a full derivation of such an effective model from the microscopic hamiltonian is an intricate problem beyond the scope of this work . in most of the paper ,
we assume that each excess fe atom contributes eight electrons , @xcite but our main conclusions do not change if one considers that less electrons are introduced by each fe.@xcite to account for the changes in the fermi surface promoted by these excess fe atoms , we employ a rigid band approximation in which the doping of excess electrons shifts the chemical potential from @xmath30 to positive values .
thus , the microscopic hamiltonian we use is an effective double - exchange model describing localized magnetic moments in the multi - band correlated electron sea , which can be written as @xmath31 the first term describes the interacting itinerant electrons : @xmath32 the non - interacting part @xmath33 is based on the five - orbital tbm @xmath34 where @xmath35 denotes the creation operator for an electron of momentum @xmath36 with spin @xmath37 in the orbital @xmath38 , and @xmath39 are the tight - binding matrix elements . here
, we are interested only in the contribution coming from the @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 orbitals , as explained above . since the other orbitals do not contribute to the fermi surface , the static spin susceptibility , which will give rise to the rkky interactions , is very similar regardless of whether we consider a projected three - orbital model or the actual five - orbital tight - binding model .
the interaction part consists of four terms:@xcite @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the intra - orbital coulomb repulsion , @xmath45 is the inter - orbital coulomb repulsion , @xmath46 is the hund s coupling , and @xmath47 is the pair - hopping term .
hereafter , we set @xmath48 and @xmath49 to ensure the invariance of the hamiltonian under rotations in orbital space
. the second term in eq.([ham1 ] ) describes the interaction between the localized spins : @xmath50 where @xmath51 , and @xmath15 are super - exchange couplings between first- , second- , and third - nearest neighbors . in this work ,
we use the values of @xmath51 , and @xmath15 obtained from the first - principles electronic - structure calculations .
@xcite @xmath52 denote generalized non - heisenberg exchange couplings between first and second neighbors and ring - exchange .
these couplings are predominantly determined by the magneto - elastic coupling , and their derivations are shown in appendix a. in particular , here we consider the first- and second - neighbors biquadratic couplings @xmath53 and @xmath54 , as well as a `` diagonal '' ring - exchange @xmath55 .
the third term @xmath56 describes the coupling between the localized spins , @xmath57 , and the itinerant electrons @xmath58 . here , @xmath57 are the localized spins of electrons on orbitals @xmath26 and @xmath27 , and @xmath59 are the spins of itinerant electrons on orbitals @xmath60 defined as @xmath61 where @xmath62 are the pauli matrices and @xmath63 is the number of lattice sites . for our investigations ,
the sign of @xmath46 is not important , as shown in the following . due to the interaction described by eq.([hamjh ] ) , the itinerant electrons mediate additional exchange couplings between the localized moments : @xmath64 the couplings @xmath65 between localized spins on lattice sites @xmath66 and @xmath67 , known as rkky interactions , can be obtained by integrating out the itinerant degrees of freedom .
in particular , @xmath65 are determined by the static spin susceptibility @xmath68 of the multi - band conduction electron sea : @xmath69 taking into account both heisenberg and rkky interactions , the effective low - energy hamiltonian can then be written as @xmath70 where , for convenience , we defined @xmath71 .
in this section , we discuss how the fermi surface of fe@xmath0te evolves with increasing amount of interstitial fe , @xmath3 . to compute the fermi surface
, we use the tbm , those matrix elements we present in table i. @xmath72 & @xmath73 + @xmath74 & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath74 & @xmath74 & @xmath74 + @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 & @xmath84 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 + @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath84 + @xmath92 & @xmath78 & @xmath93 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 & @xmath94 & @xmath92 & @xmath92 & @xmath95 + @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath82 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath78 & @xmath96 & @xmath100 & @xmath96 + @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath90 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath101 & @xmath101 & @xmath106 + @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath82 & @xmath109 & @xmath110 & @xmath78 & @xmath107 & @xmath111 & @xmath107 + @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath82 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 & @xmath114 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 + @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath118 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 & @xmath78 & @xmath119 & @xmath116 & @xmath120 + @xmath106 & @xmath102 & @xmath121 & @xmath90 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & @xmath106 & @xmath106 & @xmath101 + @xmath115 & @xmath113 & @xmath124 & @xmath78 & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath115 & @xmath112 + @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath82 & @xmath78 & @xmath130 & @xmath78 & @xmath120 & @xmath120 & @xmath119 + @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath131 & @xmath131 & @xmath131 + @xmath137 & @xmath78 & @xmath82 & @xmath78 & @xmath138 & @xmath78 & @xmath137 & @xmath139 & @xmath139 + @xmath140 & @xmath141 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 & @xmath78 & @xmath144 & @xmath140 & @xmath140 & @xmath140 + [ fig2 ] on the concentration of excess iron @xmath3 when each excess iron provides 6 electrons ( orange ) and 8 electrons ( purple ) .
( b ) the orbitally resolved electron occupation numbers @xmath63 as functions of @xmath3 .
the occupation of @xmath27 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , and @xmath26 orbitals are shown by red , green , brown , blue , and black lines , respectively .
the @xmath40 and @xmath41 orbitals have the same electron occupation numbers due to the tetragonal symmetry of the system.,title="fig : " ] on the concentration of excess iron @xmath3 when each excess iron provides 6 electrons ( orange ) and 8 electrons ( purple ) .
( b ) the orbitally resolved electron occupation numbers @xmath63 as functions of @xmath3 .
the occupation of @xmath27 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 , @xmath42 , and @xmath26 orbitals are shown by red , green , brown , blue , and black lines , respectively .
the @xmath40 and @xmath41 orbitals have the same electron occupation numbers due to the tetragonal symmetry of the system.,title="fig : " ] in fig .
1 ( a ) , we show the fermi surface of fete ( @xmath145 ) obtained from the tbm .
since the pockets have predominantly @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 character , we present the fermi surface without projecting out the localized - spin orbitals @xmath26 and @xmath27 .
similar to most iron pnictide parent compounds , the fermi surface is characterized by elliptical electron pockets at the @xmath146 and @xmath147 points and circular hole pockets centered at the @xmath148 and @xmath149 points .
we note a weak nesting between electron and hole pockets connected by the wave vectors @xmath21 and @xmath22 , but no fermi surface nesting associated with the magnetic ordering vector ( @xmath150 ) .
this observation is in agreement with an angle - resolved photoemission ( arpes ) study of the topology of the fermi surface,@xcite which also did not observe nesting corresponding to the magnetic ordering vector .
when the level of interstitial fe increases , the chemical potential shifts up , and the geometry of the fermi surface changes significantly . in figs . 1 ( b ) and ( c ) we plot constant energy cuts which correspond to the chemical potential shifts ( b ) @xmath1510.4 ev and ( c ) @xmath1510.8 ev .
the nesting between electron and hole pockets disappears very quickly as the sizes of the hole and electron pockets change significantly with the shift of the chemical potential @xmath152 .
initially , while the size of the electron pockets is enlarged , the size of the hole pockets is reduced .
the hole pockets disappear completely at @xmath153 ev .
then , at bigger shifts of @xmath152 , the pocket at the @xmath17 point changes its character and becomes electron - like at @xmath154 ev .
this general behavior is also in agreement with arpes measurements in electron - doped iron arsenides.@xcite in order to relate the shift of the chemical potential @xmath152 to the amount of excess iron @xmath3 , in fig.2 ( a ) we plot the dependence of @xmath152 on @xmath3 for two cases , within the rigid band approximation : in the first case , each interstitial fe adds eight electrons ( purple line ) and in the second case @xcite , each excess fe atom has the same valence as the non - interstitial atoms , adding six electrons ( orange line).@xcite of course , the general trends are the same , the differences being in the specific values of @xmath3 correspondent to each chemical potential shift . for instance , a shift of 0.4 ev ( fig . 1 ( b ) ) corresponds to @xmath155 and @xmath156 , if we consider that each interstitial fe adds eight and six electrons , respectively , whereas the shift of 0.8 ev ( fig .
1 ( c ) ) corresponds to @xmath157 and @xmath158 , respectively , for 8 and 6 electrons .
hereafter , all results are computed assuming that each interstitial iron adds 8 electrons into the band . in fig .
2 ( b ) , we show how the electron occupation numbers for different orbitals depend on the concentration of excess fe , @xmath3 .
we see that the occupations of the @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 orbitals change significantly , indicating that the charge doping due to the fe excess goes predominantly to these orbitals .
the occupations of the @xmath26 and @xmath27 orbitals barely change with an increase of @xmath3 , which is consistent with the fact that these orbitals do not contribute to the fermi surface .
notice , that due to tetragonal symmetry , the occupation numbers of @xmath40 and @xmath41 orbitals are exactly the same and the corresponding lines completely overlap .
having established how the low - energy itinerant states change as a function of excess fe , we now discuss in details the form of the multi - orbital spin susceptibility @xmath159 as function of @xmath3 . here
we use the formalism which was originally developed for the five - orbital model for the fe - pnictides in ref.@xcite and later extensively studied for various orbital models in ref.@xcite . in the paramagnetic state
, the spin - rotation invariance requires that transverse and longitudinal components of the spin susceptibility are identical .
thus , we can express @xmath159 only in terms of the components of the transverse susceptibility : @xmath160 .
we note that as we are dealing with multi - orbital systems , the spin susceptibility is a four - index tensor , while the total susceptibility is a sum over all components of this tensor .
[ fig3 ] + in the multi - orbital model under consideration , the matrix elements of the bare spin susceptibility can be calculated from the corresponding matsubara spin - spin correlation function of conduction electrons : @xmath161 where @xmath162 are orbital indices , and the spectral representation of the multi - orbital green s function is given by @xmath163 here , the matrix elements @xmath164 are the components of the eigenvectors resulting from the diagonalization of the five - orbital tbm and @xmath165 are the eigenvalues describing the resulting bands characterized by the band index @xmath166 .
the retarded bare susceptibility is then obtained by summing over the matsubara frequency and setting @xmath167 : @xmath168 where @xmath169 denotes the fermi distribution function . in fig .
3 ( a)-(c ) we show the results for the total bare spin susceptibility @xmath170 where the @xmath26 and @xmath27 orbitals have been projected out by setting all components of the eigenvectors @xmath171 and @xmath172 equal to zero .
we note that the results do not change significantly if these orbitals are included , since they do not contribute to the fermi surface .
the bare susceptibility @xmath173 is overall rather flat with small peaks at @xmath22 and @xmath21 for @xmath145 ( fig .
3 ( a ) ) , almost featureless for @xmath155 ( fig .
3 ( b ) ) , and with a wide region of enhanced fluctuations in the vicinity of the @xmath17 point for @xmath157 ( fig .
3 ( c ) ) .
all these features are displayed in fig .
4 ( a ) , where we plot the bare spin susceptibilities for different values of @xmath3 along the high - symmetry path @xmath174 .
red , green and blue lines correspond to @xmath175 , 0.07 and 0.15 , respectively . as in figs . 3 ( a)-(c ) , we see that for @xmath175 the bare susceptibility shows enhanced fluctuations peaked at the @xmath146 point , whereas for @xmath157 the magnetic spectral weight is shifted to the vicinity of @xmath148 point . for intermediate values of @xmath3 ,
the bare susceptibility is basically featureless .
the effect of correlations among the itinerant electrons on the spin susceptibility can be taken into account in the framework of the rpa .
the rpa spin susceptibility can be obtained using the dyson equation:@xcite @xmath176 where the matrix elements @xmath177 take into account all electron correlations in the rpa .
the interaction parameters which give the strongest contributions are those from the matrix elements @xmath178 , @xmath179 , @xmath180 , and @xmath181 .
all other matrix elements are set to 0 . in our calculations
we have set @xmath182 ev and @xmath183 . both the coulomb repulsion and the hund s coupling are well inside the range of the interaction parameters previously considered in the literature : the lowest estimate of @xmath184 was used in ref.@xcite and the upper limit of @xmath185 was considered in several works , e.g. , in refs.@xcite . selecting @xmath46 inside this range ensures that an electron added to an undoped site pays more energy to coulomb repulsion than it wins from the hund s rule , i.e. , that the onsite interaction energy suppresses charge fluctuations rather than enhancing them.@xcite in figs . 3 ( d)-(f ) , we present the static rpa spin susceptibility for different values of @xmath3 . overall , @xmath186 shows a significant enhancement due to interactions
notice , for instance , the different scales used in figs . 3 ( a)-(f ) .
the rpa susceptibility for @xmath175 is shown in fig .
3 ( d ) . the small peaks at the wave vectors @xmath21 and @xmath22 observed in the bare susceptibility now display a nearly - diverging behavior .
however , similarly to the bare susceptibility , @xmath186 for @xmath175 does not display significant spin fluctuations near the ( @xmath150 ) points , corresponding to the ordering vectors of the experimentally observed magnetic order . with increasing @xmath3 ( see fig .
3 ( e ) and fig . 3 ( f ) ) , we observe significant changes in the overall structure of the spin susceptibility . as it is particularly seen in fig .
4 ( b ) , where we show the rpa spin susceptibility along the main symmetry directions , the susceptibility near @xmath21 and @xmath22 rapidly decreases with increasing @xmath3 , and the dominant magnetic response shifts to the vicinities of the @xmath17 point .
this is consistent with the loss of nesting features in the fermi surface . for @xmath155 ( fig .
3 ( e ) ) , the susceptibility is almost uniform across the whole brillouin zone . for higher values of @xmath3 ( see fig .
3 ( f ) ) , the susceptibility shows dominant but not diverging behavior in the central part of brillouin zone close to the @xmath17 point . [ fig4 ] , 0.07 and 0.15 , respectively .
( b ) cut of the rpa enhanced spin susceptibility along the same high - symmetry path .
the legend provides the @xmath3 values of each line .
we use the following notations : @xmath148 , @xmath146 , and @xmath149 .
the rpa spin susceptibility is calculated for @xmath182 ev and @xmath183.,title="fig : " ] , 0.07 and 0.15 , respectively .
( b ) cut of the rpa enhanced spin susceptibility along the same high - symmetry path .
the legend provides the @xmath3 values of each line .
we use the following notations : @xmath148 , @xmath146 , and @xmath149 .
the rpa spin susceptibility is calculated for @xmath182 ev and @xmath183.,title="fig : " ]
equation ( [ rkkycouling ] ) shows that the rkky exchange integrals @xmath65 are proportional to the static magnetic susceptibility of the multi - orbital conduction electrons .
thus , the changes in the spin susceptibility promoted by the increase in the concentration of interstitial fe discussed in the previous section will lead to changes in @xmath65 and , according to eq . (
[ exchange - model ] ) , to changes in the effective hamiltonian of the localized spins .
[ fig5 ] as shown in fig .
4 ( b ) , one of the main effects of increasing @xmath3 on the spin susceptibility is to suppress the nesting - induced peaks at momenta @xmath187 and @xmath188 . to shed light on how these changes are translated in changes of the rkky exchange interactions , we first consider a simple toy model in which the spin susceptibility is given by the phenomenological expression @xcite : @xmath189}{\chi_{0}\left(1+\frac{3}{4}\alpha\right)}\label{mag_suscep}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here
, @xmath190 sets the overall scale for magnetic fluctuations and @xmath191 is a parameter that controls the height and width of the peaks at @xmath2 .
the overall amplitude of the magnetic susceptibility is kept unchanged by the term @xmath192 in the denominator . in fig . 5 ( a ) we plot this phenomenological static magnetic susceptibility along the @xmath193 direction , @xmath194 for @xmath195 ( magenta ) and @xmath196 ( blue ) , illustrating how the peak at @xmath187 decreases with decreasing @xmath197 .
thus , decreasing @xmath197 mimics the effect of increasing @xmath3 in fig . 4 ( b ) ( at least for small @xmath3 ) .
next we compute the rkky interactions as a function of @xmath197 . taking the fourier transforms ,
we obtain : @xmath198 a straightforward evaluation gives the results shown in fig .
while @xmath199 for all values of @xmath197 , we note that @xmath200 and @xmath201 , with @xmath202 .
as the peak intensity decreases ( i.e. as @xmath197 decreases ) , the absolute values of @xmath203 and @xmath204 decrease strongly .
this behavior can be understood in a straightforward way by noting that only the structure factors of @xmath203 and @xmath204 in eq .
( [ rkky_toy ] ) match the fourier components of the magnetic susceptibility in eq .
( [ mag_suscep ] ) . to make this argument even more transparent ,
consider an even simpler model for the magnetic susceptibility consisting of a constant background plus peaks at @xmath205 and @xmath206 : @xmath207\label{simpler}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is straightforward to obtain : @xmath208 in agreement with fig . 5 ( b ) .
thus , this toy model shows that peaks at @xmath187 and @xmath188 in the itinerant susceptibility induce local - spin interactions only between second and third neighbors , without affecting the first - neighbors interaction .
the latter is , however , very sensitive to the fluctuations peaked at different wave vectors , as we will see in more realistic calculations in the next subsection , in particular to the fluctuations with small-@xmath209 vectors .
[ fig6 ] ( red solid line ) , @xmath203 ( green solid line ) , @xmath204 ( blue solid line ) with increasing concentration of excess of interstitial fe atoms @xmath3 .
the other neighbor interactions are @xmath210 ( brown dashed line ) , @xmath211 ( orange dashed line ) , @xmath212 ( purple dashed line ) .
( b ) the evolution of the effective exchange couplings @xmath213 , where @xmath214 ( red line ) , @xmath215 ( green line ) , and @xmath216 ( blue line ) .
all interactions are given in mev/@xmath217.,title="fig : " ] ( red solid line ) , @xmath203 ( green solid line ) , @xmath204 ( blue solid line ) with increasing concentration of excess of interstitial fe atoms @xmath3 .
the other neighbor interactions are @xmath210 ( brown dashed line ) , @xmath211 ( orange dashed line ) , @xmath212 ( purple dashed line ) .
( b ) the evolution of the effective exchange couplings @xmath213 , where @xmath214 ( red line ) , @xmath215 ( green line ) , and @xmath216 ( blue line ) .
all interactions are given in mev/@xmath217.,title="fig : " ] we now compute the rkky interactions numerically using the results for the susceptibility obtained in sec .
iv . for completeness
, we compute the rkky interactions up to the sixth - nearest neighbors for different concentrations of excess interstitial fe , @xmath3 . in fig . 6 ( a ) we plot @xmath218 , @xmath203 and @xmath204 shown ,
correspondingly , in red , green and blue solid lines and @xmath210 , @xmath211 and @xmath212 shown , correspondingly , in brown , orange and purple dashed lines .
@xmath219 interactions are small almost for almost all values of @xmath3 , except @xmath211 at interstitial concentrations @xmath220 . however , as fe@xmath0te crystals have not been yet grown with @xmath220 , we will not discuss the possible effects of this term . for small but physical values of @xmath3 ,
the largest interactions are @xmath203 and @xmath204 , whereas for intermediate and larger values of @xmath3 , @xmath218 dominates .
because of this , and since in our bare local model ( [ hamloc ] ) only @xmath16 , @xmath14 , and @xmath15 have non - zero values , hereafter we neglect the rkky contributions beyond third - nearest neighbors . much of the behavior of the rkky interactions for small values of @xmath3 can be understood within the toy model discussed in the previous section .
as expected , we obtain large antiferromagnetic @xmath203 and ferromagnetic @xmath204 interactions in the regime where the susceptibility @xmath186 has strong peaks near the @xmath21 and @xmath22 points ( @xmath221 , see fig .
4 ( b ) ) .
as these peaks are suppressed , the absolute values of both interaction parameters are reduced , in agreement with decreasing @xmath197 in fig . 5 ( b ) .
at the same time , the small antiferromagnetic @xmath218 interaction remains nearly unchanged , reflecting the fact that it is unaffected by the fluctuations near @xmath21 and @xmath22 .
in contrast , fluctuations in broader regions of the brillouin zone , such as in the vicinities of the @xmath18 and the @xmath17 points , yield the leading contributions to the @xmath218 interaction . by increasing the concentration of interstitial fe atoms beyond @xmath222 ,
the @xmath218 interaction becomes the dominant one , as the large peaks of the itinerant susceptibility @xmath186 near @xmath21 and @xmath22 quickly disappear , rendering @xmath203 and @xmath204 small .
however , for @xmath223 , the antiferromagnetic @xmath218 interaction starts being suppressed , and eventually changes sign and becomes ferromagnetic for @xmath224 .
comparison to the behavior of the rpa susceptibility in fig .
4 ( b ) reveals that this change can be attributed to the reduction of the broad fluctuations present around the @xmath18 point , followed by the subsequent enhancement of fluctuations near the @xmath17 point .
indeed , according to the form factor of @xmath218 in eq .
( [ rkky_toy ] ) , fluctuations around @xmath225 yield an antiferromagnetic @xmath218 , whereas fluctuations around @xmath226 yield a ferromagnetic @xmath218 . having calculated @xmath65 as function of the fe excess concentration , it is now straightforward to compute the @xmath3-dependent effective couplings @xmath213 between the localized moments in eq .
( [ exchange - model ] ) , whose solution determines the magnetic ground state . to this end
, we first need to establish the bare heisenberg exchange couplings @xmath227 , which do not change with increasing fe excess .
the values of the effective couplings @xmath213 at @xmath228 were computed via first - principles electronic structure calculations by ma _
et al_.@xcite up to the third neighbors , these values normalized on the value of spin @xmath229 are equal to @xmath2302.1 mev/@xmath217 , @xmath23115.8 mev/@xmath217 , @xmath23210.1 mev/@xmath217 . because even for @xmath228 , fe@xmath0te has both itinerant and localized electrons , these effective couplings contain both the @xmath65 interactions and the bare heisenberg exchange couplings @xmath227 .
in order to decompose these contributions , we simply subtract the rkky interactions computed by us at @xmath145 from the values of the super - exchange interactions derived by ma _
et al_. @xcite this procedure yields the bare heisenberg exchange couplings @xmath233 mev/@xmath217 , @xmath234 mev/@xmath217 , and @xmath235 mev/@xmath217 . in fig .
6 ( b ) , we plot @xmath236 as a function of @xmath3 .
we note that the effective couplings @xmath237 and @xmath238 remain antiferromagnetic for all @xmath3 , while @xmath239 changes sign at @xmath240 . as we will show in the next section ,
this change in @xmath239 is the driving force behind the change in the magnetic order that happens in fe@xmath0te above a critical concentration of fe excess .
with the @xmath3-dependent exchange constants shown in fig . 6 ( b ) , we now proceed to the solution of the effective super - exchange model ( [ exchange - model ] ) . we compute the classical phase diagram by numerical minimization of its classical energy with the constraint that all spins have unit length .
our findings are summarized in the classical phase diagram presented in fig .
7 . to look for a wide variety of states ,
we introduce four sublattices , labeled as 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 ( see fig . 8) and perform full minimization of the classical energy .
to each sublattice we associate a local frame given by angles @xmath241 .
we define the global reference frame by setting @xmath242 .
in addition , we consider only spin configurations which can be characterized by a single-@xmath243 spiral , such that after a translation from site to site in the same sublattice , the magnetic moment rotates by an angle @xmath244 , where @xmath245 , @xmath246 and @xmath247 are integers , @xmath248 is the lattice vector .
then , the general expression for the on - site magnetization is given by @xmath249 where @xmath250 is the sublattice index
. substituting @xmath251 into eq.([exchange - model ] ) yields the classical energy @xmath252 .
the explicit expression for the classical energy is rather cumbersome and , for convenience , is given in appendix b. we minimize @xmath253 numerically and for each set of parameters @xmath213 and @xmath52 we find the classical ground state characterized by @xmath254 , and @xmath255 . in our computation
we fix the second - neighbor biquadratic exchange to be equal to @xmath256 mev/@xmath217 , but our results do not depend strongly on this value .
we vary therefore two parameters of the model : the nearest - neighbor biquadratic exchange @xmath53 and the excess iron concentration @xmath3 , which affects indirectly the effective exchange couplings @xmath213 via the rkky interaction . in figs .
8 ( a)-(c ) , we draw the real - space spin configurations presented in the phase diagram of fig . 7 . among all possible states ,
in the parameter space presented in the phase diagram , only three states are realized : the stripe phase characterized by @xmath257 shown in fig . 8 ( a ) , the double stripe phase characterized by @xmath258 shown in fig . 8 ( b ) and the incommensurate spiral ( labeled as ic )
state shown in fig . 8 ( c ) characterized by @xmath259 .
note that in fig .
8 ( c ) we show the ic state with an exaggerated canting angle . to clarify the structure of these different orderings
, we also take the fourier transforms of the ground state spin configuration obtained by the minimization and then compute the corresponding spin structure factor .
as expected , the structure factor exhibits peaks at the following ordering wave - vectors : @xmath7 for the stripe phase , @xmath260 for the bicollinear double - stripe phase , and @xmath10 for the ic phase .
the structure of the phase diagram ( see fig . 7 ) can be summarized as follows . for small values of @xmath3 , there is a thin strip of the single - stripe phase .
this phase is stabilized by a strong @xmath237 coupling ( see fig .
6 ( b ) ) and quickly disappears because @xmath237 decreases rapidly with increasing @xmath3 .
we believe that the stripe phase has not been observed in fe@xmath0te because all known compounds belonging to this family are , actually , nonstoichiometric and have a small amount of interstitial fe significantly larger than the boundary value of @xmath261 below which the stripe phase is stable .
the central region in the phase diagram @xmath262 is occupied by the bicollinear double - stripe state .
this is the state which is experimentally observed in the fe@xmath0te compound with a low level of excess fe . the stability of this phase over a wide range of parameters is explained by the smallness of the effective nearest - neighbor coupling @xmath239 and relatively strong strength of the third - neighbor coupling @xmath238 .
the biquadratic couplings @xmath52 among which the dominating role is played by @xmath54 and @xmath55 ( see appendix a ) , also play an important role in stabilizing this state : except in the region near @xmath240 , a finite value of the nearest - neighbor biquadratic coupling @xmath53 is necessary to stabilize the double stripe phase over the incommensurate spiral state .
the region near @xmath240 is rather peculiar , as there the effective nearest neighbor coupling @xmath239 is equal to zero or is very small compared with the other interactions , making the bicollinear double stripe state the most stable one even in the absence of the biquadratic exchange .
the rest of the phase diagram is occupied by an ic phase ( see , fig .
8 ( c ) ) , which is the @xmath263 spiral state experimentally observed for sufficiently large @xmath3 .
[ fig7 ] ) as a function of fe excess @xmath3 and the ratio between the first- and second - neighbor biquadratic exchanges , @xmath264 , computed with ( in mev/@xmath217 units ) @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 .
the rkky interactions @xmath65 are shown in fig .
we set @xmath268 .
, title="fig : " ] [ fig8 ] in the experiment performed in ref .
@xcite , the phase transition from the bicollinear double stripe to the ic phase was observed approximately for @xmath269 .
this is consistent with our phase diagram presented in fig . 7 if one takes @xmath270 , which seems to be a realistic ratio , since the magneto - elastic coupling favors the biquadratic exchange between second neighbors ( see appendix a for more details ) .
we emphasize that , because our model contains assumptions about the bare values of @xmath227 and the amount of electrons introduced by each excess fe , the precise value of @xmath3 for which the transition takes place is beyond our scope . yet ,
the general tendency of a double - stripe to ic transition for increasing charge doping encoded in the phase diagram of fig .
7 is robust and consistent with the experimental observations .
in summary , we have studied the evolution of the magnetic order in fe@xmath0te as function of @xmath3 . starting with a model containing both localized spins and itinerant electrons , we derived an effective superexchange hamiltonian to describe the magnetic properties of fe@xmath0te which contains both the long - range rkky - type spin - spin interaction mediated by the itinerant electrons and the biquadratic interactions due to magneto - elastic effects .
thus , @xmath3-dependent exchange interactions naturally arise in our model due to changes in the low - energy itinerant electronic states promoted by charge doping . after calculating the classical phase diagram of the @xmath3-dependent effective superexchange model
, we showed that fe@xmath0te has a general tendency for a double - stripe to incommensurate - spiral transition with increasing excess iron concentration .
in particular , for small @xmath3 , the magnetic order is a double - stripe state , arising due to the presence of a significant antiferromagnetic @xmath238 coupling , which has mostly localized origin . beyond a certain critical value of @xmath3 ,
the incommensurate spiral state becomes the most stable .
this transition is driven not only by the suppression of the antiferromagnetic exchanges @xmath238 and @xmath237 , but also by the enhancement ( in absolute value ) and sign change of the nearest - neighbor @xmath239 interaction , which changes from antiferromagnetic to ferromagnetic with increasing @xmath3 .
these changes are caused by the @xmath3-dependent rkky part of the interaction , and ultimately can be attributed to the suppression of the @xmath2 peaks in the itinerant spin - susceptibility and the transfer of magnetic spectral weight from the vicinities of @xmath271 to the vicinities of @xmath272 .
these changes , in turn , are a direct consequence of the changes in the fermi surface of the itinerant electrons caused by the charge doping introduced by the excess fe . experimental data showing the sign of @xmath239 to be dependent on the interstitial fe concentration would be a strong validation of our model . the physics of fe@xmath0te discussed here bares many similarities with extensively studied double - exchange magnets , and in particular with manganites , whose effective coupling constants were shown to be significantly modified by charge doping .
@xcite in both cases , the interplay between local moments and itinerant electrons leads to a rich behavior and to the appearance of new ground states in the classical phase diagram .
_ acknowledgement .
_ we acknowledge useful conversations with a. chubukov , i. eremin , m. gingras , m. imada , d.h .
lee , i. mazin , i. paul , s. and u. roessler and i.zaliznyak .
we especially thank f. wang and z .- y .
lu for providing us with the unfolded five orbital tight - binding model , which we use in this work .
n.b.p . and s. d. are supported by nsf grant dmr-1255544 .
n.b.p . and r. m. f. acknowledge the hospitality of the aspen center for physics , and also nsf grant no.1066293 supporting the center .
there are several microscopic mechanisms which lead to non - heisenberg exchange couplings such as , e.g. , biquadratic and ring exchanges . among all of them ,
one of the most effective ways to induce a fairly strong non - heisenberg exchange is through the coupling to the lattice via the magneto - elastic effect . in the pnictides and chalcogenides , this key role played by the magnetoelastic coupling
was extensively discussed , see refs .
@xcite . here
, we present a brief discussion of the possible magnetoelastic origin of the first- and the second - neighbor biquadratic exchange interactions @xmath53 and @xmath54 in fe@xmath0te .
motivated by the experimentally measured lattice distortions , which are small , we assume a linear regime in which exchange interactions and elastic energies depend only on the distance between lattice sites . as the magneto - elastic hamiltonian involves more than one normal mode of a square lattice , it is convenient to follow the notation of ref .
@xcite and describe the lattice distortions by the strain tensor separated in uniform and non - uniform parts : @xmath273 the most relevant @xmath274 lattice modulation in fe@xmath0te is the monoclinic distortion , given by @xmath275 , and illustrated in fig .
it corresponds to a distortion of the square in a rhombus with a short and a long diagonal .
the most relevant non - uniform lattice modulations are those with modulation vectors @xmath276 , @xmath277 and @xmath278 . to make the notations simpler , we denote @xmath279 , @xmath280 and @xmath281 .
the real space patterns of the first two are shown in figs .
9(b)-(c ) .
the non - uniform mode corresponding to @xmath282 generates a distortion with ladders along the diagonal of short and long nearest - neighbor bonds . on the other hand , the non - uniform mode corresponding to the @xmath283 ( @xmath284 ) distortion has bonds that alternate between short and long in the @xmath285-direction ( @xmath3-direction ) . using this notation ,
the dominant magneto - elastic term is given by @xcite @xmath286\nonumber \\ & + & g_{3}\left[(\mathbf{s}_{2}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3}+\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{1}){u}_{6}^{x}+(\mathbf{s}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{2}+\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3}){u}_{7}^{y}\right].\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath287 are the magneto - elastic couplings .
the spins @xmath288 with @xmath289 correspond to the four spins in the sublattice shown in fig .
8a of the main text .
because the elastic modes are assumed to be non - critical , the elastic energy acquires a harmonic form : @xmath290 where the constants @xmath291 , @xmath292 , and @xmath293 represent the elastic stiffness of the different lattice distortions described by @xmath294 , @xmath282 , and @xmath295 , respectively .
the equilibrium lattice distortions @xmath296 , @xmath297 , @xmath298 , and @xmath284 are found by minimizing the energy : @xmath299 integrating out the lattice distortions , we obtain the following biquadratic hamiltonian : @xmath300\nonumber \\ & - & \frac{g_{3}^{2}}{2\mathbf{\omega}_{2}}[(\mathbf{s}_{2}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3}+\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{1})^{2}+(\mathbf{s}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{2}+\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3})^{2}].\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here it is convenient to rewrite this expression explicitly in terms of the first- and second - neighbor biquadratic interactions @xmath53 and @xmath54 , as well as of the ring exchange interactions @xmath301 and @xmath302 : @xmath303-\frac{g_{1}^{2}}{2c_{66}}[(\mathbf{s}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3})^{2}+(\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{2})^{2}]\\ & & + \left(\frac{g_{2}^{2}}{\mathbf{\omega}_{1}}-\frac{g_{3}^{2}}{\mathbf{\omega}_{2}}\right)[(\mathbf{s}_{2}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3})(\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{1})+(\mathbf{s}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{2})(\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3})]+\frac{g_{1}^{2}}{c_{66}}(\mathbf{s}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3})(\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{2})\nonumber \\ = & & -k_{1}\sum_{\langle ij\rangle}\left(\mathbf{s}_{i}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{j}\right)^{2}-k_{2}\sum_{\langle\langle ij\rangle\rangle}\left(\mathbf{s}_{i}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{j}\right)^{2}-k_{\square}\sum_{\square}(\mathbf{s}_{i}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{j})(\mathbf{s}_{k}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{l})-k_{{\rm diag}}\sum_{\langle\langle ij\rangle\rangle}(\mathbf{s}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{3})(\mathbf{s}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{s}_{2})~,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath304 because we expect the non - uniform strains @xmath282 , @xmath283 , and @xmath305 to have a stronger stiffness than the stiffness of the monoclinic distortion @xmath296 , in our calculations we neglected the ring exchange term @xmath301 and assumed that @xmath306 . furthermore , we used the fact that @xmath55 .
here we present the expression for the classical energy of the local - spin model of eq .
( [ exchange - model ] ) , as function of the local angles @xmath307 and the ordering vector @xmath308 : 10 w. bao , y. qiu , q. huang , m. a. green , p. zajdel , m. r. fitzsimmons , m. zhernenkov , s. chang , m. fang , b. qian , e. k. vehstedt , j. yang , h. m. pham , l. spinu , and z. q.mao , phys .
lett . * 102 * , 247001 ( 2009 ) . | we examine the influence of the excess of interstitial fe on the magnetic properties of fe@xmath0te compounds . because in iron chalcogenides the correlations are stronger than in the iron arsenides , we assume in our model that some of the fe orbitals give rise to localized magnetic moments . these moments
interact with each other via exchange interactions as well as phonon - mediated biquadratic interactions that favor a collinear double - stripe state , corresponding to the ordering vectors @xmath1 .
the remaining fe orbitals are assumed to be itinerant , giving rise to the first - principle derived fermi surface displaying nesting features at momenta @xmath2 .
increasing the amount of itinerant electrons due to excess fe , @xmath3 , leads to changes in the fermi surface and to the suppression of its nesting properties . as a result , due to the hund s coupling between the itinerant and localized moments
, increasing @xmath3 leads to modifications in the local moments exchange interactions via the multi - orbital generalization of the long - range ruderman - kittel - kasuya - yosida ( rkky ) interaction . by numerically computing the rkky corrections and minimizing the resulting effective exchange hamiltonian ,
we find , in general , that the excess electrons introduced in the system change the classical magnetic ground state from a double - stripe state to an incommensurate spiral , consistent with the experimental observations .
we show that these results can be understood as a result of the suppression of magnetic spectral weight of the itinerant electrons at momenta @xmath2 , combined with the transfer of broad magnetic spectral weight from large to small momenta , promoted by the introduction of excess fe . |
the self - assembly of colloidal particles into structures with controlled spatial ordering is of great importance in colloid science , with particular interest in the assembly of photonic crystals @xcite artificially produced periodic dielectric structures designed to control and manipulate light . in this context , a variety of colloidal structures assembled in liquid crystal ( lc ) matrices @xcite , combined with the unique mechanical and electro - optical properties of the lc host @xcite , have proven to be good candidates for the development of colloid crystals with tunable photonic properties . in conventional colloids , in isotropic fluids ,
the colloidal particles interact via van der waals , electrostatic , or steric forces .
these forces are isotropic , and their range does not exceed a few tens of nanometers .
by contrast , when dispersed in a lc , due to its long - range orientational molecular ordering , colloidal particles interact predominantly through long - range anisotropic forces @xcite .
the origin of these effective forces is the elastic distortions of the lc matrix due to the presence of the colloidal particles .
the range of the elastic forces is of the order of several colloidal diameters .
elastic forces drive the particles to self - assemble into linear chains @xcite , periodic lattices @xcite , anisotropic clusters @xcite , and cellular structures @xcite .
a distinctive feature of lc colloids is the presence of topological defects @xcite , that not only determine the symmetry of the long - range colloidal interaction @xcite , but also stabilize the ordered aggregates at short range @xcite , where the elastic interactions are dominated by non - linear effects and render the self - assembly of lc colloids a challenging theoretical problem .
topological defects in nematic liquid crystals ( nlc ) are nucleated due to the mismatch of the global and local ( at the colloidal surfaces ) boundary conditions leading to frustration of the uniform nematic order . small spherical particles ( @xmath0 m ) imposing homeotropic surface anchoring on the nematic director stabilize equatorial saturn - ring defects @xcite , which for larger particles may be stabilized through confinement @xcite , or by external electric fields @xcite .
the far - field distortions have quadrupolar symmetry and the resulting pairwise colloidal interaction is of the quadrupolar type decaying with the distance @xmath1 between the particles as @xmath2 @xcite . larger particles ( @xmath3 m ) ) with homeotropic anchoring induce point - like hedgehog defects @xcite , which lead to a far - field director of dipolar symmetry and a large distance colloidal interaction varying as @xmath4 @xcite . for particles with planar degenerate anchoring , two antipodal surface defects , known as boojums @xcite are nucleated which lead to a far - field director of quadrupolar symmetry .
recent numerical calculations reveal that the cores of nematic boojums can take three different configurations @xcite : single core , double core , or split core .
the single - core boojum is a point - like index @xmath5 defect with azimuthal symmetry , the split - core boojum has two index @xmath6 surface point - like defects connected by a @xmath6 bulk disclination line .
the double - core boojum is an intermediated structure with broken azimuthal symmetry .
the far - field distortions and the resulting asymptotic pair interaction between particles with degenerate planar anchoring are of the quadrupolar type @xcite , as for saturn - ring particles .
recently , a light sensitive coating of colloidal particles was used in order to switch the surface anchoring from homeotropic to planar , reversibly @xcite , providing the means for tuning the colloidal interactions and thus controlling the assembly of the colloidal structures .
direct assembly of two - dimensional @xmath7 crystallites of quadrupolar @xcite , dipolar @xcite , or dipolar and quadrupolar @xcite , spherical particles has been achieved by using laser tweezer techniques .
the crystallites are stabilized by the presence of topological defects , which provide local free energy minima of the order of @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath10 the absolute temperature . by contrast , interacting quadrupolar boojum - particles in three - dimensional systems do not exhibit short - range repulsive behaviour , and the equilibrium configuration corresponds to close contact or coalescence of the particles @xcite . .
@xmath1 is the inter - particle distance and @xmath11 is the polar angle relative to the far - field director . ]
recently , the assembly of @xmath12 colloidal crystallites of spherical particles with two types of anchoring , homeotropic and degenerate planar , dispersed in 5cb has been reported @xcite .
the particles with radius @xmath13 m were confined to a cell of thickness @xmath14 m in order to stabilize the saturn - ring configuration around the particles with homeotropic anchoring .
both types of particles generate quadrupolar nematic distortions , but the corresponding quadrupolar moments have different signs , meaning that the particles attract each other when they are aligned parallel or perpendicular to the far - field director .
this allowed the assembly of @xmath12 square colloidal crystallites . in the following
we shall adopt the notations of ref .
@xcite : a saturn - ring quadrupolar particle will be denoted by `` s '' , and a boojum quadrupolar particle by `` p '' ( planar anchoring ) . in this article , we present the results of a numerical study of the nlc - mediated interaction between s and p particles ( see fig .
[ dx ] ) for a wide range of distances .
we focus on the short - distance regime that determines the final equilibrium configuration and its stability .
the paper is organized as follows : in the next section we introduce the landau - de gennes free energy functional , which we minimize numerically . in sec .
[ sec3 ] we present our results .
we show that the s - p interaction exhibits two local minima for configurations in which particles align either parallel or perpendicular to the far - field director , thus allowing the assembly of square lattices .
we show that the two equilibrium configurations are separated by a free energy barrier of the order of @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the colloidal radius . in sec .
[ conclusions ] we present our conclusions .
phenomenologically , nematic liquid crystals are characterised by a traceless , symmetric tensor order - parameter @xmath17 which can , in general , be written as @xcite @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the uniaxial order parameter , which measures the degree of orientational order along the nematic director @xmath20 , and @xmath21 is the biaxial order parameter , which measures the degree of orientational order along the directions perpendicular to @xmath20 , characterised by @xmath22 and @xmath23 . the corresponding landau - de
gennes ( ldg ) free energy functional is @xcite @xmath24 where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the bulk and elastic free energy densities , given by @xmath27 the first integral in eq.([ldg ] ) is over the volume occupied by the nematic , @xmath28 , and the second is over the surfaces of the colloidal particles , @xmath29 .
the bulk parameter @xmath30 depends linearly on the temperature @xmath10 , with @xmath31 a material dependent constant and @xmath32 the supercooling temperature of the isotropic phase ; @xmath33 and @xmath34 are positive material dependent constants . for a given temperature @xmath10 and in the absence of elastic distortions the free energy density in eq .
( [ f_bulk ] ) is minimized for the ( bulk ) degree of orientational order given by @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the reduced temperature .
@xmath37 controls the stability of the nematic and isotropic phases . for @xmath38
the nematic phase is unstable , while the isotropic phase is unstable for @xmath39 .
the nematic and the isotropic phases coexist at @xmath40 . for simplicity , we consider the one - elastic constant approximation where @xmath41 is related to the frank - oseen ( fo ) elastic constant @xmath42 by @xmath43 @xcite .
we consider the interaction between colloidal particles with homeotropic and degenerate planar anchoring .
we assume rigid homeotropic boundary conditions , while the planar degenerate anchoring is described by the covariant surface anchoring free energy proposed by fournier and galatola ( fg ) : @xmath44 @xmath45 , and @xmath46 is the surface normal .
the quadratic term favours tangential orientation of the director @xmath20 , and the quartic term guarantees the existence of a minimum for the scalar order parameter at the surface equal to its bulk value @xmath47 .
for simplicity we will assume @xmath48 .
the equilibrium surface orientation is determined by the free energy functional minimum that satisfies the far - field @xmath49 boundary conditions .
typical values of bulk parameters for 5cb are @xmath50j / km@xmath51 , @xmath52j / m@xmath51 , @xmath53j / m@xmath51 , @xmath54j / m , and @xmath55k . at the nematic - isotropic coexistence the bulk correlation length @xmath56 nm determines the order of magnitude of the spatial extension of the cores of the topological defects @xcite .
calculations were performed for particles of radius @xmath57m@xmath58 , in a cubic box of length @xmath59 ; the reduced temperature @xmath60 , and the anchoring strength @xmath61 satisfying @xmath62 , which corresponds to the strong anchoring regime .
the landau - de gennes free energy eq.([ldg ] ) is minimized by using finite elements methods , with adaptive meshing .
the surfaces of the spherical particles @xmath63 are triangulated using the open source _ gnu triangulated surface library _ @xcite .
then , the triangulation of the nematic domain @xmath28 is carried out using the _ quality tetrahedral mesh generator _
@xcite , which supports the adaptive mesh refinement .
linear triangular and tetrahedral elements are used in @xmath12 and @xmath64 , respectively .
generalized gaussian quadrature rules for multiple integrals @xcite are used in order to evaluate integrals over the elements . in particular , for tetrahedra a fully symmetric cubature rule with 11 points @xcite is used , and integrations over triangles are done by using a fully symmetric quadrature rule with 7 points @xcite .
the discretized landau - de gennes functional in then minimized using the _ inria _ s _ m1qn3 _ @xcite optimization routine , which implements a limited memory quasi - newton technique of nocedal @xcite .
lets us assume that the far - field director @xmath49 is parallel to the @xmath65axis , and that s , or p particle is placed at the origin of the reference frame . for spherical particles ,
the distortions of the director field @xmath66 are uniaxial , with the symmetry group @xmath67 . at large distances
@xmath68 from the particle , the director exhibits small distortions from its uniform far - field alignment @xmath69 . in the one - elastic constant approximation ,
the transverse components @xmath70 satisfy laplace s equation @xmath71 @xcite , and the asymptotic solution for @xmath72 can be expanded in terms of multipoles . due to the symmetry requirements ,
the quadrupolar term is the lowest - order term in the expansions @xcite , i.e. , @xmath73 and the symmetry of the director requires the quadrupole moment tensor @xmath74 . in ref .
@xcite an explicit expression for @xmath75 in terms of the surface integrals involving @xmath72 has been given .
applying then a superposition approximation , the pair interaction potential between quadrupolar particles is obtained @xcite @xmath76 where the subscript indicates that the interaction is between two uniaxial quadrupoles with quadrupole moments @xmath77 .
the interaction potential in eq .
( [ qq ] ) is repulsive at @xmath78 and @xmath79 , and attractive at intermediate orientations .
the effective interactions between two s , or two p particles have been analysed theoretically beyond the superposition approximation in refs .
@xcite . in both cases ,
significant deviations from the asymptotic quadrupolar behaviour have been found at short distances .
the interaction between s and p particles was measured recently @xcite .
asymptotic analysis suggests that s particles induce elastic quadrupoles with quadrupole moment @xmath80 .
by contrast , p particles are characterised by quadrupole moments @xmath81 @xcite .
the sign of a quadrupole moment can not be obtained from the interaction of like quadrupoles , s - s or p - p , and only its absolute strength can be extracted from such experiments .
different experiments yield a range of values , as presented in table [ table1 ] .
the discrepancies are most likely due to the different conditions ( e. g. geometrical confinement ) under which the experiments were performed @xcite , or to the effects of thermal fluctuations that are important at large distances @xcite .
these factors may limit ( severely ) the range of validity of the asymptotic expression , eq .. m0.38 m0.22 m0.22 m0.1 cell thickness ( @xmath82 m ) & @xmath83 ( @xmath82 m ) & @xmath84 ( @xmath85 ) & ref .
+ 8 & 4.5 & 0.17 & @xcite + 6.58 & 4 & @xmath86 & @xcite + 6 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xcite + 30100 & 3@xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xcite + recent numerical calculations revealed that under certain conditions the boojums of p particles have a split core structure with broken axial symmetry @xcite . in this case , the p particle induces a biaxial quadrupole @xcite thus adding a correction to the asymptotic result , eq .. however , since the core size is of the order of the nematic correlation length , the effects of the biaxiality should be small far away from the particle .
indeed , as we shall demonstrate below , our calculations are in good agreement with eq . indicating that the biaxial contribution is small .
we calculate the two - body effective interaction potential @xmath91 @xcite which is defined by decomposing the excess ( over the free energy of the uniform nematic ) free energy for two particles @xmath92 as follows @xmath93 @xmath94 is the excess free energy calculated independently for an isolated s , p particle , respectively . by definition
, @xmath95 tends to zero when @xmath96 .
figure [ energy ] illustrates the s - p interaction potential @xmath97 for several values of @xmath11 .
by contrast to the s - s and p - p potentials , the s - p interaction is purely attractive at @xmath98 , and repulsive at intermediate orientations , which is consistent with @xmath99 . as shown in fig .
[ energy ] , the asymptotic result eq . is obeyed accurately for @xmath100 . for smaller distances
the superposition approximation is qualitatively wrong , indicating the significance of non - linear effects .
@xmath91 exhibits a local minimum at @xmath101 , corresponding to @xmath79 , and a global minimum at @xmath102 for relative orientation @xmath103 ( see also fig . [ cusp ] ) .
these values are in excellent agreement with the experimental results @xmath104 and @xmath105 @xcite . at @xmath106
, @xmath97 reveals a crossover from repulsive , at large @xmath107 , to attractive behaviour , at smaller @xmath108 .
the crossover is driven by the structural re - arrangement of the defects ( see the configurations in fig . [
cusp]a ) and b ) below ) .
this is similar to the crossover observed in the s - s interaction @xcite at @xmath109 , where the saturn - rings deform from their equatorial position , or for the p - p interaction at @xmath103 , where the inner boojums slide on the colloidal surfaces in opposite directions @xcite . in the s - p interaction potential , however , we observe both the sliding of the inner boojum and the deformation of the saturn - ring , as shown in fig .
[ cusp ] below .
the configuration at @xmath110 does not correspond to a local minimum of the s - p interaction potential .
in fact , @xmath91 in the vicinity of that point has a cusp - like shape in the @xmath111direction ( see fig .
[ cusp ] ) . at very small distances , however , the conflicting anchoring conditions on the particle surfaces lead to a repulsive @xmath97 at any orientation @xmath11 . this can be seen also from the behaviour of the elastic force @xmath112 between the colloidal particles .
figure [ force ] shows the radial @xmath113 and the polar @xmath114 components of the force as functions of @xmath1 for several values of @xmath11 .
it is clear that for the orientations @xmath103 and @xmath109 the interaction is purely attractive at large separations @xmath1 , and that in all directions a strong repulsion appears at very small @xmath1 , stabilizing the dimer at a fixed separation @xmath115 .
moreover , the behaviour of @xmath116 clearly shows that once the particles are oriented along @xmath103 or @xmath109 they will approach each other in this directions under the action of @xmath117 , and will stabilize at @xmath118 or @xmath119 , respectively .
the radial component of the force at @xmath106 is repulsive for large inter - particle distances , and turns into attractive as soon as the defects start to rearrange .
although , the asymptotic result eq . predicts a non - zero @xmath120 at @xmath106 , i.e. , a polar component of the force which tends to align the particles parallel to @xmath49 , it is only when the non - linear elastic effects become important ( @xmath121 ) that @xmath116 increases significantly , and becomes comparable to @xmath117 .
this is in sharp contrast to the p - p interaction force @xcite , where @xmath116 is always two orders of magnitude smaller than @xmath117 .
figure [ cusp ] illustrates the interaction potential @xmath122 for several values of the inter - particle distance @xmath1 . at @xmath123 the interaction potential
is a smooth function of @xmath11 .
it is clear that for this distance the asymptotic result , eq .
, represented in fig .
[ cusp ] using the experimental value @xmath124 , is qualitatively but not quantitatively accurate .
as mentioned previously , the asymptotic result describes the full ldg results quantitatively at distances @xmath125 .
as the distance between the particles decreases , @xmath122 reveals a cusp at some oblique angle @xmath11 .
this corresponds to a structural transition between two different nematic configurations , which `` coexist '' at the orientation corresponding to the cusp .
two representative nematic configurations are shown at @xmath126 in fig .
[ cusp]a ) at @xmath127 and b ) at @xmath128 . when the s and p colloidal particles are at the equilibrium configuration at @xmath103 , increasing @xmath11 forces the inner boojum to slide in the same direction as a result of the repulsion from the disclination ring , which deforms upwards from its equatorial position , as depicted in fig .
[ cusp]a ) .
the s - p system follows the left branch of @xmath122 as @xmath11 increases from zero .
this configuration becomes metastable at the cusp and at a larger value of @xmath129 the repulsion between the inner boojum and the disclination ring renders it unstable .
then , the system jumps to the right branch , and assumes a configuration similar to that depicted in fig .
[ cusp]b ) . on the other hand ,
when the s - p system starts from the local equilibrium configuration at @xmath109 , it follows the right branch of @xmath95 as @xmath11 decreases .
the disclination ring now deforms downwards and pushes one of the boojums away from the @xmath65axis as depicted in fig .
[ cusp]b ) .
it is clear from figs .
[ energy ] and [ cusp ] , that at short - distances @xmath121 the inter - particle interaction deviates significantly from the asymptotic result described by eq .. in fig .
[ loglog ] we plot the absolute value of the s - p interaction potential as a function of @xmath1 for @xmath98 . for large separations ,
@xmath130 , @xmath97 can be described by a power law @xmath131 where both @xmath132 and @xmath133 are fitting parameters .
figure [ energy ] indicates that the asymptotic result is valid for @xmath100 .
thus , in fig . [ loglog ]
we fit eq . to data corresponding to @xmath134 only .
for both values of @xmath11 we find @xmath135 , which is in good agreement with the asymptotic power law @xmath136 . from these fits
we also obtain @xmath137 and @xmath138 for @xmath103 and @xmath109 , respectively .
this is in excellent agreement with the experimental value @xmath139 reported in ref .
recently , a directed assembly of spherical particles dispersed in a nematic host into @xmath12 square crystal - like structures was reported @xcite .
this has been achieved by mixing quadrupolar colloidal particles with distinct anchoring conditions , namely homeotropic and degenerate planar .
the homeotropic anchoring particles nucleate saturn - ring defects , and the planar anchoring particles antipodal boojums . in the linear regime
each of these colloidal particles induce long - range distortions of the nematic director with quadrupolar symmetry @xcite , and as a consequence the long - range pair interaction is of the quadrupolar type . in this paper
we have studied numerically the nematic - mediated interaction between two such particles . for simplicity
we have assumed spherical particles of equal radii .
we have confirmed that the s and p particles have quadrupole moments with opposite signs , @xmath99 .
the asymptotic analysis @xcite suggests that s particles have a positive quadrupole moment , and p particles a negative one . at large distances
the interaction potential @xmath91 behaves as @xmath140 with @xmath135 which is in excellent agreement with the asymptotic result @xmath2 for quadrupolar interactions .
we have also confirmed numerically the experimental values for the product of the quadrupole moments @xmath124 .
note that if the confining surfaces of the experimental setup @xcite had an influence on the pair interaction , there would be a deviation from the power law behaviour that would eventually ( for very strong confinement ) turn into an exponential decay .
since in our calculations the finite size effects are negligible , our results indicate that in the experiment of ognysta et al .
@xcite the confining surfaces played a negligible role . for distances @xmath141 , the asymptotic quadrupolar result eq .
is qualitatively wrong , see fig .
[ energy ] . at such distances
the topological defects start to interact and re - arrange their positions ( see fig .
[ cusp ] a ) , b ) ) , resulting in profound changes of the interaction potential @xmath97 ( see fig .
[ energy ] red squares ) . under some conditions , the p particles nucleate boojums of complex biaxial structure @xcite .
this leads to a biaxial quadrupolar distortion , since it breaks the axial symmetry , and could change the asymptotic uniaxial expression given by eq .
however , since the size of the biaxial regions is of the order of the nematic correlation length , the biaxial perturbation at large distances are negligible , which explains the good agreement between our numerical results and the asymptotic expression for uniaxial quadrupoles .
by contrast to the interaction of particles with identical anchoring conditions ( p - p , or s - s ) , the s - p interaction potential @xmath91 exhibits two minima ( in the first quadrant ) , when the particles are oriented at @xmath103 or @xmath109 relative to the far - field director , and separated by @xmath142 and @xmath143 , see fig .
[ energy ] .
these values are in excellent agreement with those reported experimentally @xcite , @xmath105 and @xmath144 @xcite .
we have also found a strong repulsion at short distances and at any orientation @xmath11 .
these two features of the pair interaction potential are pre - requisites for the assembly of colloidal lattices with rectangular unit cells .
we have calculated the pair elastic force , see fig .
[ force ] .
the polar component @xmath116 is always zero at @xmath145 , and acquires rather large values at oblique orientations @xmath11 , provided that the inter - particle distance is not too large ( @xmath146 , see fig .
[ force ] right panel ) .
the sign of @xmath116 depends on @xmath11 .
@xmath147 for @xmath148 , and it is positive otherwise .
@xmath149 is the angular position of the cusp in the @xmath122 profile , see fig .
[ cusp ] . therefore , there is a strong elastic force which aligns a pair of colloidal particles either parallel ( @xmath148 ) , or perpendicular ( @xmath150 ) to the far - field director .
once the particles are aligned along one of these directions , they move under the action of the radial force @xmath117 towards the global @xmath151 , or the local @xmath152 equilibrium positions .
the presence of a strong aligning force @xmath116 at small - to - intermediate distances is in sharp contrast with the p - p interaction profile @xcite , where the polar component @xmath116 is always two orders of magnitudes smaller than the radial force @xmath117 .
most theoretical studies of the interaction between colloidal particles in nematic liquid crystals focus on particles with the same size .
although this may seem a rather strong simplification , it is justified by the current experimental ability of producing monodispersed colloidal particles .
this seems to be the best choice for the assembly of photonic crystals , but the effect of polydispersity on the stability of such crystals remains an important open question .
we gratefully acknowledge financial support from the portuguese foundation for science and technology ( fct ) through grants nos . pestoe / fis / u10618/2011 , ptdc / fis/098254/2008 , sfrh / bpd/40327/2007 ( nms ) we also acknowledge partial financial support from fct - daad transnational cooperation scheme under the grant no .
50108964 , and the fp7 irses marie - curie grant pirses - ga-2010 - 269181 . | the effective interaction between spherical colloids in nematic liquid crystals is investigated in the framework of the landau - de gennes theory .
the colloids differ through their interaction with the nematic . while both particles induce quadrupolar far - field distortions in the nematic matrix , with unlike quadrupole moments , one favours homeotropic and the other degenerate planar anchoring of the nematic director . in the strong anchoring regime
the colloids with homeotropic anchoring are accompanied by an equatorial disclination line defect , known as `` saturn - ring '' , while the colloids with degenerate planar anchoring nucleate a pair of antipodal surface defects , called `` boojums '' . in the linear ( large - distance ) regime
the colloidal interactions are of the quadrupolar type , where the quadrupoles have opposite signs .
these are attractive when the colloids are aligned either parallel or perpendicular to the far - field director . at short distance , non - linear effects including `` direct '' interactions between defects give rise to a repulsion between the particles , which prevents them from touching .
this finding supports the stability of nematic colloidal square crystallites the assembly of which has been reported recently . |
since cloud computing has become increasingly accepted as one of the most promising computing paradigms in industry @xcite , providing cloud services also becomes an emerging business .
an increasing number of providers have started to supply commercial cloud services with different terminologies , definitions , and goals @xcite .
as such , evaluation of those cloud services would be crucial for many purposes ranging from cost - benefit analysis for cloud computing adoption to decision making for cloud provider selection .
however , evaluation of commercial cloud services is different to and more challenging than that of other computing systems .
there are three main reasons for this : * in contrast with traditional computing systems , the cloud is relatively chaos @xcite . there is still a lack of standard definition of cloud computing , which inevitably leads to market hype and also skepticism and confusion @xcite . as a result , it is hard to point out the range of cloud computing , and not to mention a specific guideline to evaluate different commercial cloud services . consequently , although we have already learned rich lessons from the evaluation of traditional computing systems @xcite , it is still necessary to accumulate evaluation experiences in the cloud computing domain .
* evaluation results could be invalid soon after the evaluation and then not reusable .
cloud providers may continually upgrade their hardware and software infrastructures , and new commercial cloud services may gradually enter the market .
hence , previous evaluation results can be quickly out of date as time goes by . for example
, at the time of writing , google is moving its app engine service from cpu usage model to instance model @xcite ; amazon is still acquiring additional sites for cloud data center expansion @xcite ; while ibm just offered a public and commercial cloud @xcite . as a result
, customers would have to continually re - design and repeat evaluation for employing commercial cloud services . *
the back - ends ( e.g. configurations of physical infrastructure ) of commercial cloud services are not controllable from the perspective of customers .
unlike consumer - owned computing systems , customers have little knowledge and control over the precise nature of cloud services even in the locked downenvironment @xcite .
evaluations in the context of public cloud computing are then inevitably more challenging than that for systems where the customer is in direct control of all aspects @xcite . in fact , it is natural that the evaluation of uncontrollable systems would be more complex than that of controllable ones .
therefore , particularly for commercial cloud services , it is necessary to find a way to facilitate evaluation , and make existing evaluation efforts reusable and sustainable .
this paper suggests an expert system for cloud evaluation to address the aforementioned issues .
this expert system concentrates on processes and experiences rather than results of cloud services evaluation . when it comes to the general implementation process of cloud services evaluation
, we can roughly draw six common steps following the systematic approach to performance evaluation of computer systems @xcite , as specified below and illustrated in figure [ fig>1 ] : general process of an evaluation implementation.,height=245 ] 1 .
first of all , the requirement should be specified to clarify the evaluation purpose , which essentially drives the remaining steps of the evaluation implementation .
2 . based on the evaluation requirement
, we can identify the relevant cloud service features to be evaluated .
3 . to measure the relevant service features , suitable metrics should be determined .
4 . according to the determined metrics , we can employ corresponding benchmarks that may already exist or have to be developed .
5 . before implementing the evaluation experiment , the experimental environment should be constructed .
the environment includes not only the cloud resources to be evaluated but also assistant resources involved in the experiment .
6 . given all the aforementioned preparation ,
the evaluation experiment can be done with human intervention , which finally satisfies the evaluation requirement . through decomposing and analyzing individual evaluation experiments following the six steps , we have collected and arranged data of detailed evaluation processes . based on the primary evaluation data , general knowledge about evaluating commercial cloud services
can be abstracted and summarized .
after manually constructing the _ data / knowledge base _ , we can design and implement an _ inference engine _ to realize knowledge and data reasoning respectively . as such , given particular enquiries , the proposed expert system is not only able to supply common evaluation suggestions directly , but also able to introduce similar experimental practices to users for reference .
the remainder of this paper is organized as follows .
section [ iii ] specifies the establishments of _ data base _ , _ knowledge base _ , and _ inference engine _ in this expert system .
section [ iv ] employs three samples to show different application cases of this expert system , which also gives our current work a conceptual validation .
conclusions and some future work are discussed in section [ v ] .
similar to general expert systems @xcite , the expert system proposed in this paper also comprises an _ interface _ with which users interact , an _ inference engine _ that performs knowledge / data reasoning , and a _ knowledge base _ that stores common and abstracted knowledge about evaluation of commercial cloud services .
however , we did not employ a specific knowledge acquisition module for building up the _ knowledge base _ in this case . at the current stage , instead of obtaining knowledge by interviewing external experts , we extracted cloud evaluation knowledge only from the collected data of published experimental studies . moreover , for the convenience of acquiring experimental references , a _ data base _ is maintained in this expert system to store initially - analyzed details of existing evaluation experiments .
the complete structure of this expert system can be illustrated as shown in figure [ fig>3 ] .
structure of this expert system.,height=170 ] considering the _ interface _ of this expert system can be designed at last in the future , this paper only specifies how we are realizing the _ data / knowledge base _ and _ inference engine_. to collect and initially analyze existing evaluation practices , we employed the systematic literature review ( slr ) as the main approach .
slr is the methodology applied for evidence - based software engineering ( ebse ) @xcite , and has been widely accepted as a standard and systematic way to investigate specific research questions by identifying , assessing , and analyzing published primary studies .
according to the guidelines of slr @xcite , an entire slr instance mainly requires three stages , namely preparation , implementation , and summarization . after adjusting some steps
, here we list a rough slr procedure suitable for this work : + * _ planning review : _ * * justify the necessity of carrying out this slr .
* identify research questions for this slr . *
develop slr protocol by defining search strategy , selection criteria , quality assessment standard , and data extraction schema for conducting review stage . * _ conducting review : _ * * exhaustively search relevant primary studies in the literature .
* select relevant primary studies and assess their qualities for answering research questions . *
extract useful data from the selected primary studies .
* arrange and synthesize the initial results of our study into review notes .
* _ reporting review : _ * * analyze and interpret the initial results together with review notes into interpretation notes . *
finalize and polish the previous notes into an slr report . due to the limit of space ,
the detailed slr process is not elaborated in this paper . with the pre - defined search strategy and rigorous selection criteria ,
we have identified 46 relevant primary studies covering six commercial cloud providers from a set of popular digital publication databases ( the studies are listed online for reference : http://www.mendeley.com/groups/1104801/slr4cloud/papers/ ) .
note that this work focused only on the commercial cloud services to make our effort closer to industry s needs .
moreover , this study paid attention to infrastructure as a service ( iaas ) and platform as a service ( paas ) without concerning software as a service ( saas ) .
since saas is not used to further build individual business applications @xcite , various saas implementations may comprise infinite and exclusive functionalities to be evaluated , which could make our slr out of control even if adopting extremely strict selection / exclusion criteria .
after exhaustively identifying evaluation practices , independent evaluation experiments can be first isolated , and then be broken into atomic components by using the data extraction schema .
for example , more than 500 evaluation metrics including duplications were finally extracted from the identified cloud services evaluation studies . the summarized metrics in turn can help facilitate metric selection in future evaluation work @xcite .
in other words , every single isolated experiment is finally represented as a set of elements , which essentially facilitates knowledge mining among different elements across different evaluation steps .
therefore , the conducting review stage in this slr also indicates the procedure of establishing the _ data base _ of the proposed expert system .
considering that this expert system gives evaluation suggestions according to users inputs , the stored knowledge is suitable to be represented as rules each of which is composed of antecedent ( to meet input ) and consequent ( to be output ) . to efficiently obtain rule - based knowledge from the _ data base _
, we adopted association - rule mining to inspire the method of knowledge mining . by analogy
, we can find that the rule - based knowledge used in this expert system has similar characteristics to association rules . as we know
, different association rules can express different regularities that underlie a dataset @xcite .
in other words , association rules have freedom to use and predict any combination of items in a predefined set . as for the expert system
, it is supposed that users can start from any particular evaluation step , or from any combination of detailed evaluation steps , to enquire about different evaluation experiences . when mining association rules in a dataset , we use predefined _ coverage _ to seek combinations of items that appear frequently , and then use _ accuracy _ to extract suitable rules among each of the identified item combinations @xcite .
note that we name an attribute - value pair as an item in the dataset .
the _ coverage _ of a particular item combination refers to the number of data instances comprising the combination , while the _ accuracy _ of a candidate rule is the proportion of the correctly - predicted data instances to the applied data instances .
similarly , we followed the same rule - induction procedure to mine evaluation knowledge from the collected experiment data .
however , compared with the quantitative and programmable process of rule mining , the knowledge mining in this case has to involve more human interventions .
although some evaluation step details ( e.g. the cloud service features ) can be pre - standardized , most of the experiment data ( e.g. requirement or experimental manipulation ) would be not able to be specified within an exactly same schema from the beginning . as a result , we had to manually extract common knowledge through abstracting specific descriptions of the raw data .
for the convenience of the discussion , we briefly demonstrate the process of knowledge mining only from two - item sets .
suppose the focus is now on the scalability evaluation of cloud services .
we can initially list all the scalability - related two - item combinations , gradually abstract their descriptions , and then rationally classify or unify them into fewer groups . at last
, common knowledge can be sought within each of the combination groups .
here we only list four straightforward pieces of evaluation experience identified in our work . * * if service feature = _
_ scalability__then experimental manipulation = _ varying cloud resource with the same amount of workload _ * ( extracted from the change of cloud resource , without distinguishing that the resource was varied in terms of type or amount ) . * * if service feature = _ _ vertical scalability__then experimental manipulation = _ different types of cloud resource _ * ( extracted from the experiments each of which covers different types of service instances @xcite ) . * * if service feature = _ _ horizontal scalability__then experimental manipulation = _ different amount of cloud resource _ * ( extracted by focusing on the amount of the same type of cloud resource , no matter the resource is cpu core @xcite or service instance @xcite ) . * * if service feature = _ _
scalability__then metric = _ speedup over a baseline _ * ( extracted by summarizing scalability - related metrics like pipeline performance speedup @xcite , computation speedup @xcite , and throughput speedup @xcite ) . in this expert system ,
the _ inference engine _ is associated with both _ knowledge base _ and _ data base_. as such , the _ inference engine _ can not only perform knowledge reasoning but also supply similar experimental cases . 1 .
_ first - order rule reasoning in knowledge base : _ to facilitate the knowledge reasoning process
, we proposed to enrich the representations of knowledge by bridging between some concepts or item combinations .
the bridges can be viewed as common - sense knowledge that supplements the aforementioned , extracted knowledge .
for example , we added two new rules * if service feature = _ vertical scalability _ " then service feature = _ scalability _ " * and * if service feature = _ horizontal scalability _ " then service feature = _ scalability _ " * to the four previous samples .
in fact , the two new rules are always true although they are not generated by knowledge mining . benefiting from the knowledge bridges
, we can employ the algorithm of learning first - order rules @xcite to conveniently reveal underlying rule - based knowledge that does not visibly exist in the _ knowledge base_. in this case , for instance , the expert system can give suggestions of evaluating vertical scalability by using a visible rule * if service feature = _ vertical scalability _ " then experimental environment = _ different types of cloud resource _ " * , and also resorting to the scalability - related knowledge , as shown below .
* experimental manipulation = _ varying cloud resource with the same amount of workload _ " .
* experimental environment = _ different types of cloud resource _ " .
* metric = _ speedup over a baseline _ " .
1 . _ case retrieving in data base : _ as mentioned previously , in addition to evaluation knowledge , this expert system is also able to retrieve experimental cases to users for analogy .
in fact , as one of the basic human reasoning processes , analogy is used by almost every individual on a daily basis to solve new problems based upon past experiences .
the process of analogy generally follows the procedure of the case - based reasoning ( cbr ) , while one general cbr procedure comprises a four - stage cycle @xcite , as shown in figure [ fig>4 ] .
general cyclical case - based reasoning process.,height=226 ] in the general cyclical cbr process , an initial problem is described as a new case . following the new case ,
we can retrieve a case from the previous cases .
the retrieved case is combined with the new case through reuse into a solved case .
the revise process is then used to test the solution for the new case .
finally , useful experience is retained for future reuse , and the dataset of previous cases will be updated by a new learned case , or by modification of some existing cases . when it comes to case retrieving , the essential issue is how to identify rational and similar cases to the new one .
we proposed three modes of case retrieving in this expert system , namely precise mode , heuristic mode , and fuzzy mode .
as the name suggests , under the precise mode , the expert system identifies similar evaluation experiments exactly following users enquiries .
for example , suppose a user is interested in the evaluation experiments with respect to horizontal scalability of cloud services , the expert system will only retrieve the experiment data with service feature = _ horizontal scalability _ " in the worst case of precise mode , there would be no experiment record directly meeting a user s enquiry .
the user can then try the heuristic mode .
the heuristic mode relies on the knowledge reasoning process discussed previously . in detail
, the expert system first explores the _ knowledge base _ to identify the rules with antecedents meeting the user s enquiry , and then retrieves experiment data that include those rules consequents . for example , when retrieving data with inquiry service feature = _ horizontal scalability _ " under the heuristic mode , the expert system will list evaluation experiments having experimental environment = _ different amount of cloud resource _ " ( according to the previous rule * if service feature = _ horizontal scalability _ " then experimental environment = _ different amount of cloud resource _ " * ) . in this case , suppose that even if the retrieved experiments focus on evaluating cost - benefit by using _ different amount of cloud resource _ " , they can still be used to inspire the evaluation of horizontal scalability . in the worst case of heuristic mode
, the expert system could yet retrieve nothing due to lack of data , lack of knowledge , or invalid enquiry .
then , the data retrieving can be switched to the fuzzy mode .
ideally , the fuzzy mode relies on the uncertain reasoning @xcite in the _ knowledge base_. in the current stage , however , we only realize the fuzzy mode to allow the expert system to use sub - content of the enquiry information to explore for useful data . for example , suppose an invalid inquiry includes three elements : service feature = _ horizontal scalability _ " , experimental environment = _ different types of cloud resource _ " , and metric = _ speedup over a baseline _ " . under the fuzzy mode ,
the expert system first removes one of the inquiry elements , and then uses both precise mode and heuristic mode methods to identify similar experimental cases . in this sample , consequently , users can still achieve useful experimental cases after removing the inquiry element experimental environment = _ different types of cloud resource _ " .
note that , since the case retrieving here is based on incomplete enquiry information , the fuzzy mode does not necessarily guarantee that all the retrieved experiments are valuable for users .
ideally , this expert system is supposed to deal with enquiries about any component in evaluation experiments .
for example , given a particular metric , we can ask the expert system for candidate benchmarks supplying the metric ; or given particular experimental operations , we can ask the expert system for what evaluation requirement can be satisfied . therefore , in general practices of cloud services evaluation , the proposed expert system can be applied after planning an evaluation and before designing and implementing the evaluation , as illustrated in figure [ fig>5 ] . in the current stage of our work , we constrain the enquiry condition as : given a particular cloud service feature , we ask the expert system for suitable evaluation scenarios ( the combination of suitable experimental environment and experimental operations ) and evaluation metrics ( also relevant benchmarks ) . here
we use three real examples to show the possible application cases of this expert system .
the three cases can meanwhile be viewed as a conceptual validation of our current work .
note that , to highlight the application flow , the expert system s working mechanism is simplified without elaborating the data / knowledge reasoning procedures .
analytic modeling is a relatively light - weight evaluation technique , which employs approximate calculations to supply quick and rough analysis @xcite .
suppose we decide to adopt analytic modeling to satisfy the requirement about how elastic a particular cloud platform is @xcite .
according to the keywords in the requirement , we can find that the concerned cloud service feature is elasticity in this case .
as such , the requirement is manually translated into elasticity " as the input to the expert system .
the output includes scenarios and metrics for evaluating elasticity , as demonstrated in figure [ fig>6 ] .
the evaluation scenarios and metrics can be further translated into design parameters and variables @xcite by evaluator while performing the modeling work .
the suggested metrics like _ vm boosting latency _ are used to model the cloud platform , while the suggested scenarios like _ workloads rise and fall repeatedly _ are used to model the cloud - hosted workloads .
the complete process of this application case is shown in figure [ fig>6 ] .
real measurement is a relatively effort - intensive evaluation technique , which implements experiments on prototypes or actual computing systems to conduct more accurate analysis @xcite . in this case , suppose we plan to measure how variable the real cloud service performance is @xcite . similarly , the requirement here can be translated into variability " as the input to the expert system , and the output suggests scenarios and metrics for evaluating variability ( cf .
figure [ fig>7 ] ) .
unlike the previous case , however , the suggested scenarios like _ repeat experiment at different time _ are used to prepare and perform experimental environment / operations , while the suggested metrics like _ standard deviation with average value _ are used to measure and display the experimental results .
the application flow of this case is shown in figure [ fig>7 ] .
this application case is essentially an extension of previous two cases .
in fact , suggesting usage strategy of cloud resources is out of the scope of applying this expert system .
this expert system provides suggestions only for cloud services evaluation , without making any decision based on the evaluation result .
nevertheless , since evaluation is the prerequisite of further decision making , this expert system can still be helpful in this case .
suppose there is an evaluation requirement about choosing
alternative architecture for transaction processing in the cloud " @xcite .
this requirement is a typical decision making about alternative strategies of utilizing cloud resources .
given particular cloud service features concerned in the predefined architectures , the expert system supplies suggestions of evaluating those service features ; the evaluation suggestions can then be employed in each experiment for each of the architectures respectively ; the architectures are finally judged through contrasting the evaluation results . in other words
, this application case normally comprises a set of sibling experiments with the same evaluation suggestions , and the application flow is similar to figure [ fig>7 ] . as for the sample @xcite
, this expert system will give suggestions of evaluation scenarios and metrics for the service features storage " and cost " .
+ overall , this section has demonstrated three typical cases of applying the proposed expert system . to better distinguish between these application cases , here we highlight two points : * _ * direct vs. indirect help from the expert system . *
_ when it comes to the application context of this expert system , cases 1 and 2 are in the pure evaluation context , whereas case 3 is in the decision making context . as previously mentioned , this expert system can facilitate but not directly suggest usage strategies of cloud resources .
therefore , the expert system directly helps satisfy the evaluation requirement in the first two cases , while it indirectly helps satisfy the evaluation requirement in the third case . * _ * different usage purpose and sequence of the evaluation suggestions . * _ in application case 1 , the suggestion of evaluation metrics is used before the analytic modeling work . in fact , the suggested metrics are used to design the indicator tradeoffs of the simulated cloud environment . on the contrary , in application case 2 ,
the suggestion of evaluation metrics is used to measure the cloud service indicators and display the result after real experiments .
along with the booming cloud computing in industry , various commercial providers have started offering cloud services .
thus , it is normal and vital to implement evaluations when deciding whether or not to employ a particular cloud service , or choosing among several candidate cloud services .
however , given the rapidly - changing and customer - uncontrollable conditions , evaluation of commercial cloud services are inevitably more challenging than that of traditional computing systems . to facilitate evaluation work in the context of cloud computing in industry , we proposed to accumulate existing evaluation knowledge , and to establish an expert system for cloud services evaluation to make evaluation experiences conveniently reusable and sustainable .
note that the proposed expert system does not work like an automated evaluation tool or benchmark involved in evaluation implementations , but gives evaluation suggestions or guidelines according to users enquiries . the most significant contribution of this work is to help practitioners implement cloud services evaluation along a systematic way .
in fact , it is impossible to require everyone , especially cloud customers , to be equipped with rich knowledge and expertise on cloud services evaluation .
we can find that the current evaluation work is relatively ad hoc in the cloud computing field .
for example , evaluation techniques and benchmarks are selected randomly .
based on the accumulated evaluation experiences , however , this proposed expert system can intelligently supply rational and comprehensive consultation to future evaluation practices , which has been conceptually validated by using three real application cases .
this paper roughly introduces the structure and components of this expert system , and mainly specifies the study methodology we are following . the methodology then reveals and guides our current and future work , such as using the slr to collect and analyze existing evaluation practices , following the procedure of association - rule mining to extract evaluation knowledge , building the _ inference engine _ to conduct knowledge reasoning and data retrieving , and patching a well - designed _ interface _ to complete the expert system .
the prototypes of different function parts will be gradually developed and integrated into an online system . finally , a data maintenance system will be also built up online to collect feedback , update data , and keep all the data versions with time stamps .
the _ data / knowledge base _ of the expert system can eventually be updated regularly through the maintenance system .
this project is supported by the commonwealth of australia under the australia - china science and research fund .
nicta is funded by the australian government as represented by the department of broadband , communications and the digital economy and the australian research council through the ict centre of excellence program .
c. binnig , d. kossmann , t. kraska , and s. loesing , how is the weather tomorrow ? towards a benchmark for the cloud , " _ proc .
2nd int .
workshop on testing database systems ( dbtest 2009 ) in conjunction with acm sigmod / podps int .
management of data ( sigmod / pods 2009 ) _ , acm press , jun .
2009 , pp .
r. buyya , c. s. yeo , s. venugopal , j. broberg , and i. brandic , cloud computing and emerging it platforms : vision , hype , and reality for delivering computing as the 5th utility , " _ future gener . comp .
_ , vol . 25 , no . 6 , jun . 2009 , pp . 599616 . c. evangelinos and c. n. hill , c.n
. cloud computing for parallel scientific hpc applications : feasibility of running coupled atmosphere - ocean climate models on amazon s ec2 , " _ proc .
1st workshop on cloud computing and its applications ( cca 08 ) _ , oct .
2008 , pp .
d. harris , watch out , world : ibm finally offers a real cloud , " _ gigaom - tech news , analysis and trends _ , available at http://gigaom.com/cloud/watch-out-world-ibm-finally-offers-a-real-cloud/ , apr .
2011 .
r. k. jain , _ the art of computer systems performance analysis : techniques for experimental design , measurement , simulation , and modeling_. new york , ny : wiley computer publishing , john wiley & sons , inc .
1991 .
d. kossmann , t. kraska , and s. loesing , an evaluation of alternative architectures for transaction processing in the cloud , " _ proc .
2010 acm sigmod int .
management of data ( sigmod 10 ) _ , acm press , jun .
2010 , pp .
579590 .
j. li , m. humphrey , d. agarwal , k. jackson , c. van ingen , and y. ryu , escience in the cloud : a modis satellite data reprojection and reduction pipeline in the windows azure platform , " _ proc .
23rd ieee int .
parallel and distributed processing ( ipdps 2010 ) _ , ieee computer society , apr .
2010 , pp .
110 .
w. lu , j. jackson , and r. barga , azureblast : a case study of developing science applications on the cloud , " _ proc .
1st workshop on scientific cloud computing ( science cloud 2010 ) _ , acm press , jun .
2010 , pp .
413420 .
r. prodan and s. ostermann , a survey and taxonomy of infrastructure as a service and web hosting cloud providers , " _ proc .
10th ieee / acm int .
grid computing ( grid 2009 ) _ , ieee computer society , oct .
2009 , pp .
1725 .
w. sobel , s. subramanyam , a. sucharitakul , j. nguyen , h. wong , a. klepchukov , s. patil , a. fox , and d. patterson , cloudstone : multi - platform , multi - language benchmark and measurement tools for web 2.0 , " _ proc .
1st workshop on cloud computing and its applications ( cca 08 ) _ , oct .
2008 , pp .
v. stantchev , performance evaluation of cloud computing offerings , " _ proc .
3rd int .
advanced engineering computing and applications in science ( advcomp 09 ) _ , ieee computer society , oct .
2009 , pp . 187192 | commercial cloud services have been increasingly supplied to customers in industry . to facilitate customers decision makings like cost - benefit analysis or cloud provider selection , evaluation of
those cloud services are becoming more and more crucial .
however , compared with evaluation of traditional computing systems , more challenges will inevitably appear when evaluating rapidly - changing and user - uncontrollable commercial cloud services .
this paper proposes an expert system for cloud evaluation that addresses emerging evaluation challenges in the context of cloud computing .
based on the knowledge and data accumulated by exploring the existing evaluation work , this expert system has been conceptually validated to be able to give suggestions and guidelines for implementing new evaluation experiments . as such , users can conveniently obtain evaluation experiences by using this expert system , which is essentially able to make existing efforts in cloud services evaluation reusable and sustainable .
= 5 expert system ; cloud computing ; commercial cloud service ; cloud services evaluation ; evaluation experiences |
stochastic growth models of interfaces have been extensively studied along the years ( see @xcite for reviews ) .
the most studied universality class of critical dynamics behavior of growing interfaces are the ones represented by the edward - wilkinson ( ew ) @xcite and the kardar - parisi - zhang ( kpz ) @xcite models whose dynamical critical exponents are equal to 2 and @xmath3 , respectively . differently from these models , where the absorption and desorption processes are local , the raise and peel model ( rpm ) @xcite ,
although keeping the adsorption process local , the desorption processes is nonlocal .
this model is quite interesting , as it is the first example of an stochastic model with conformal invariance .
the critical properties of the model depend on the parameter @xmath1 defined as the ratio among the adsorption and desorption rates . at @xmath4
the rpm is special , being exact integrable and conformally invariant .
the dynamical critical exponent has the value @xmath5 and its time - evolution operator ( hamiltonian ) is related to the xxz quantum chain with @xmath6-anisotropy @xmath7 ( razumov - stroganov point @xcite ) . for @xmath8 ( desorption rates greater than the adsorption ones ) the model is noncritical , but for @xmath9 the model is in a critical regime with continuously varying critical exponents @xmath10 , that decreases from @xmath11 ( conformally invariant ) to @xmath12 .
the configurations of the growing surface in the rpm are formed by sites whose heights define dyck paths ( restricted solid - on - solid , rsos ) on a lattice with @xmath13 sites and open boundaries . in these surface configurations
there are active sites where adsorption and desorption processes take place , and inactive sites where nothing happens during the time evolution .
an interesting extension of the rpm at @xmath4 , proposed in @xcite , is the peak adjusted raise and peel model ( parpm ) . in this model
an additional parameter @xmath14 that depends on the total number of inactive sites , controls the relative changes of a given configuration .
the model at @xmath15 recovers the rpm .
for @xmath16 the model is not exact integrable anymore but still is conformally invariant @xcite .
the parameter @xmath14 in the parpm has a limiting value ( @xmath17 ) where the configuration with only inactive sites ( no adsorption or desorption ) become an absorbing state .
surprisingly at this point , on spite of the presence of the absorbing state , that should be the true stationary state , the system stays in a quasi - stationary state during a time interval that grows exponentially with the system size @xcite .
this quasi - stationary state has similar properties as the stationary states of the conformally invariant region @xmath18 . motivated by this unusual and interesting behavior we introduce in this paper an extension of the parpm , where the parameter @xmath14 is extended so that when @xmath19 the number of absorbing states increases with the value of @xmath14 . the results presented in this paper shows that a quasi - stationary state , with similar properties as in the conformally invariant region @xmath18 , endures as the true stationary state even when the number of absorbing states is extensively large .
only at @xmath20 the model undergoes a transition to one of the infinitely many absorbing states . in order to check if this unusual behavior is linked to the conformal invariance of the model for @xmath18 we study the parpm in regions where @xmath21 , where the model is either gaped ( @xmath8 ) , or critical but not conformally invariant ( @xmath22 ) .
an overview of our results is given in the schematic phase diagram of the model shown in fig .
[ fig0 ] . and
@xmath1 ( or @xmath23 ) .
the phases are : ( a ) non critical with no absorbing states ; ( b ) critical with no absorbing states ; ( c ) critical with infinitely many absorbing states ( active ) ; ( d ) inactive phase where the system is frozen in one of the infinitely many absorbing states .
( @xmath24 ) : the model has a gap ( massive ) but with a behavior that resembles a critical system ( see section 3 ) .
line @xmath4 ( @xmath25 ) : the model is critical and conformally invariant ( see section 4 ) . line @xmath26 ( @xmath27 ) : the model is related to an extended tasep model with non - local jumps of particles ( see section 5 ) . , scaledwidth=40.0% ] in this paper we are going to restrict ourselves to the representative cases ( red lines in fig .
[ fig0 ] ) , where @xmath4 , @xmath2 ( no adsorption ) and @xmath28 ( no desorption ) , with arbitrary values of @xmath14 .
the rpm although originally defined in an open chain can also be defined in a periodic lattice @xcite . in the periodic chain
the model can be interpreted as a particular extension of the asymmetric exclusion process ( asep ) where the particles ( excluded volume ) are allowed to perform local as well nonlocal jumps .
we are going also to consider in this paper the parpm formulated in periodic lattices .
we verified that when @xmath29 ( only adsorption processes ) the extended parpm is exactly related to a totally asymmetric exclusion process ( tasep ) where the particles jumps only in one direction . at @xmath15 , where the model recovers the rpm , the model is mapped to the standard tasep @xcite , and for @xmath16 it can be interpreted as a tasep whose transition rate to the neighboring sites depend on the total number of particle - vacancy pairs , in the configuration . at @xmath2 ( no adsorption ) the model is gapped but shows interesting properties .
the configuration where there are no sites available for desorption is an absorbing state , since there is not adsorption process .
although gapped the system stays during a large time , that increases polynomially with the lattice size , in a critical quasi - stationary state with dynamical critical exponent @xmath5 .
this phenomena is due to the appearance of an extensive large number of jordan cells ( or jordan blocks ) , that for sufficiently large lattices produces a more important effect than the exponential decay induced by the gap .
for some special initial conditions we are able to obtain analytically the jordan cells and derive the time dependence of some of the observables .
the paper is organized as follows . in the next section
we introduce the extension of the parpm studied in this paper , for open and periodic boundary conditions .
we present our results separately in sections 3 , 4 and 5 for the model with @xmath2 , @xmath4 and @xmath30 , respectively . finally in section 6 we present our conclusions .
the raise and peel model ( rpm ) and the peak adjusted model ( parpm ) are models describing the stochastic time evolution of an interface defined by a set of integer heights in a discrete lattice of size @xmath31 ( even ) .
these heights are @xmath32 and @xmath33 for the case of open and periodic boundary conditions , respectively .
the height configurations satisfy the restricted solid - on - solid conditions [ e2.1 ] |h_i+1-h_i| = 1 , h_i z. the boundary condition imposes the additional constraints : ( a ) for the periodic case @xmath34 ( @xmath35 ) and the configurations @xmath36 and @xmath37 ( @xmath38)are the same , ( b ) for the open case @xmath39 and @xmath40 are non - negative integers ( @xmath41 ) .
the number of profile configurations of the surface is @xcite : [ e2.2 ] z_b(l ) = , where @xmath42 and @xmath43 for the periodic and open cases , respectively .
the configurations have a local minimum ( valley ) or a local maximum ( peak ) whenever @xmath44 or @xmath45 , respectively .
we call for convenience , the configuration with the maximum number of peaks @xmath46 as the substrate , and the configuration with the minimum number of peaks @xmath47 as pyramid . in fig .
[ fig1 ] we show examples of these configurations for the case where the lattice has @xmath48 sites and open boundary conditions .
sites and open boundary conditions .
a ) the pyramid configuration .
b ) the substrate configuration.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] in the dynamics of the rpm each site in a unit of time is visited with equal probability .
the parpm however has the additional parameter @xmath14 that has the net effect of increasing ( @xmath49 ) or decreasing ( @xmath50 ) the visiting probability for the sites with local peaks . for a given configuration the parameter @xmath51 fix the probability that a particular peak is visited as @xmath52 , where @xmath53 for periodic and open ends . if a given configuration contains @xmath54 peaks , the probability @xmath55 that an arbitrary peak is visited is @xcite [ e2.3 ] p_p= n_p p_p = , while the probability that the remaining @xmath56 sites ( sites with no peaks ) are visited is given by [ e2.4 ] p_np=1 - p_p = = q , where the parameter @xmath57 gives the probability that a particular site , which is not a peak , is visited
this is not a new parameter , it depends on the parameter @xmath14 and the number @xmath54 of peaks in the configuration : [ e2.4p ] q=. since the maximum number of peaks is @xmath58 , @xmath14 should be restricted to the values : [ e2.5 ] 0p _ 1 , _ 1 = 2 , ( b=0,1 ) .
for @xmath15 all the sites are visited with equal probability independently of being peaks or not and we recover the standard rpm . for values of @xmath59 ( @xmath50 )
the peaks have a larger ( smaller ) chance to be visited in a time interval . at @xmath60
no peaks are visited in a unit of time . at @xmath61
the visited sites in the configuration with @xmath58 peaks ( substrate ) are only the ones with peaks . in this paper
we generalize the definition of @xmath14 given in ( [ e2.3 ] ) , producing a richer model as we shall see . given a configuration with @xmath54 peaks we now extend ( [ e2.3 ] ) by imposing that in a unit of time
the peaks are visited with probability [ e2.6 ] & & p_p = \ { 1,p } , b=0,1 , where , as before @xmath42 ( @xmath43 ) for periodic ( open ) boundary conditions .
the probability @xmath57 that a particular site that is not a peak is visited is given , using ( [ e2.6 ] ) and ( [ e2.4 ] ) , by [ e2.6p ] q = \ { , 0}. now the parameter @xmath14 can be any non - negative number . for @xmath62 all the configurations with number of peaks @xmath63
will be visited only at the sites containing peaks .
we now define the dynamical rules for the stochastic evolution of the parpm model .
we can imagine a height configuration as a surface separating a solid phase from a gaseous one formed by tilted blocks that hit the surface . in a unit of time
the blocks hit the sites with peaks ( @xmath45 ) , valleys ( @xmath44 ) , positive slope ( @xmath64 ) or negative slope ( @xmath65 ) .
the probability @xmath55 that we hit the sites that have a peak is given by ( [ e2.6 ] ) , while the probability that we reach the other non - peak sites is @xmath66 .
in a unit of time the following processes may occur ( see fig .
[ fig2 ] ) , after a tile hits a site @xmath67 : _ a _ ) if we have a peak ( @xmath45 ) the tile is reflected and the surface is unchanged ( see fig . [
fig2]b ) .
_ b _ ) if we have a valley ( @xmath44 ) , with probability proportional to the adsorption rate @xmath68 , the configuration is changed @xmath69 by adsorbing the tile ( see fig . [
fig2]d ) .
_ c _ ) if we have a positive slope ( @xmath64 ) , with a probability proportional to the desorption rate @xmath70 , the tilted tile is reflected after desorbing ( @xmath71 ) a layer of @xmath72 tiles from the sites @xmath73 , where @xmath74 ( see fig .
[ fig2]a ) .
_ d _ ) if we have a negative slope ( @xmath65 ) , with a probability proportional to the desorption rate @xmath70 , the tilted tile is reflected after desorbing ( @xmath75 ) a layer of @xmath72 tiles from the sites @xmath76 , where @xmath77 ( see fig . [ fig2]c ) . in a continuous time evolution ,
the probability @xmath78 of finding the system in the configuration @xmath79 in a given time is given by the master equation : [ e2.7 ] = - _ ch_c , cp_c(t ) , that can be interpreted as an schrdinger equation in imaginary time .
the above defined stochastic rules give us the matrix elements @xmath80 of the @xmath81-dimensional hamiltonian .
the hamiltonian is an intensity matrix , i.e. , the non - diagonal elements are negative and @xmath82 . this imply that the ground state of the system @xmath83 has eigenvalue 0 and its components give us the probabilities @xmath84 of the configurations in the stationary state , i.e. , = _ cp_c , p_c = _ t p_c(t ) .
the matrix elements @xmath80 are calculated as follows .
only configurations that are connected through adsorption and desorption processes give non - zero values .
this means that apart from a multiplicative constant , that can be absorbed in the time scale , the matrix elements of the hamiltonian is only a function of the ratio @xmath85 .
a configuration @xmath86 with @xmath87 peaks have @xmath88 sites where the desorption or adsorption processes may occur .
each of these @xmath89 sites are reached with probability @xmath90 defined in ( [ e2.6p ] ) .
the non - diagonal elements @xmath80 are given by @xmath91 , @xmath92 , or @xmath93 , if the configuration @xmath86 and @xmath94 are connected by a single adsorption , one , or two distinct desorptions , respectively .
the diagonal elements are calculated from the non - diagonal ones since @xmath95 . as an illustration
let us consider the case of a lattice size @xmath48 with open ends ( @xmath43 ) .
in this case there are @xmath96 configurations @xmath86 ( @xmath97 ) , that are shown in fig .
the number of peaks in each configuration give us , using ( [ e2.6p ] ) : @xmath98_0 $ ] , @xmath99_0 $ ] and @xmath100_0 $ ] , where we denote hereafter the maximum value : [ e2.8 ] [ x]_0 = \{0,x}. sites and open boundary conditions.,scaledwidth=35.0% ] the configuration @xmath101 ( @xmath102 ) with lowest ( largest ) number of peaks is the one we called pyramid ( substrate ) .
the name substrate come from the fact that all the configurations can be obtained from it by the successive additions of tilted tiles .
the configuration @xmath101 is connected to @xmath103 by a desorption at site 2 or 4 .
the configuration @xmath103 is connected to the configuration @xmath101 by an adsorption at site 3 and to the configurations @xmath104 and @xmath105 by a desorption at site 1 and 5 , respectively . following similarly with the other configurations we obtain the @xmath106 hamiltonian : [ e2.9 ] h = - ( c|rrrrr & & & & & + & [ 4u_d]_0 & -[u_a]_0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + & -[2u_d]_0 & [ ( u_a+2u_d)]_0 & -[u_a]_0 & -[u_a]_0 & 0 + & 0 & -[u_d]_0 & [ ( u_a+2u_d)]_0 & 0 & -[u_a]_0 + & 0 & -[u_d]_0 & 0 & [ ( u_a+2u_d)]_0 & -[u_a]_0 + & -[2u_d]_0 & 0 & -[2u_d]_0 & -[2u_d]_0 & [ 2u_a]_0 ) . & & + we observe that for arbitrary values of @xmath107 , when the adsorption ( desorption ) is absent @xmath108 ( @xmath109 ) the matrix elements connecting the configuration @xmath102 ( @xmath101 ) that we called substrate ( pyramid ) are zero .
the configurations @xmath101 and @xmath102 are in this case absorbing states .
this is valid for general lattice sizes .
once the system reaches these configurations it stays on them forever .
the hamiltonian ( [ e2.9 ] ) for @xmath110 and @xmath4 recovers the one in the original formulation of the parpm , introduced in @xcite . in the extended version of the model ( [ e2.9 ] ) we see that for arbitrary values of @xmath1 we have no absorbing states as long @xmath111 . at @xmath112
the configuration @xmath102 ( substrate ) becomes an absorbing state . for @xmath113 ,
the configuration @xmath102 is the single absorbing state . for @xmath114 ,
the configurations @xmath103 , @xmath105 and @xmath104 containing two peaks also become absorbing states . finally for @xmath115
all the configurations are absorbing states . the proliferation of absorbing states when @xmath116 is one of the main feature of the parpm . for arbitrary values of @xmath117 and lattice sizes
@xmath31 , it is convenient to define [ e2.9p ] p_i=2 , i=1,2,
,l/2 , where @xmath53 for periodic and open boundaries . for @xmath118 all the configurations with @xmath119 are absorbing states .
the number of configurations with @xmath120 , grow very fast as @xmath67 increases and we should expect an interesting behavior once @xmath19 . the model at @xmath4 and for @xmath121 is known to be critical and conformally invariant @xcite . at @xmath15 , where the model recovers the standard rpm , the model in non - critical ( gapped ) for @xmath8 and gapless for @xmath122 . for an overview of the phase diagram of the model see fig .
[ fig0 ] . in the next sections we are going to study the model for arbitrary values of @xmath14 , but considering only the three representative cases where @xmath2 , @xmath4 and @xmath28 ( red lines in fig .
[ fig0 ] ) , that we have distinct physical properties . in these sections
we are going to measure several observables . the average height at time @xmath123 is defined as : [ e2.10 ] h_l(t ) = _
i=1^l < h_i(t ) > , where @xmath124 is the average height at the site @xmath67 . in a given configuration ,
we define as contact points the points where the profile touch the substrate . in the open boundaries case their average are : [ e2.11 ] k_l(t)= < _ i=1^l-1 _ h_i(t),0 > , while for the periodic case : [ e2.12 ] k_l(t ) = < _ i=1^l _ h_i(t)-h_,0 > , where @xmath125 is the minimum height in the configuration .
another interesting quantity is the number of peaks and valleys in the configuration .
the related observable is : [ e2.13 ] _
l(t ) = _ i=1^l - b ( 1- ) , b=0,1 .
we consider in this section the limiting case of the parpm where we have no adsorptions , i. e. , @xmath126 . in this case by ordering the configurations according to their number or peaks , i. e. , the first state is the pyramid ( @xmath127 ) and the last one the substrate ( @xmath128 ) , the hamiltonian in the master equation ( [ e2.7 ] ) is a lower triangular matrix .
this happens because we have only desorptions and their effect in the configurations is the increase of the number of peaks .
an example for @xmath48 with open boundary condition ( @xmath43 ) is obtained by setting @xmath108 in ( [ e2.9 ] ) . since @xmath129 is a lower triangular matrix its @xmath81 eigenvalues are given by its diagonal elements @xmath130 ( @xmath131 ) .
the diagonal elements in the parpm are given by [ e3.1 ] h_c , c = ( n_s^(c ) u_d + n_v^(c ) u_a)q(c ) , where @xmath132 and @xmath133 are the number of sites where we have a nonzero slope and valleys , respectively .
the @xmath14-dependent parameter @xmath90 is given by ( [ e2.6p ] ) .
for the case of no adsorption , we then have the eigenvalues [ e3.2 ] e(n_p , p , l , u_d ) = \{0 , u_d(l-2n_p ) } , where we have used ( [ e2.6p ] ) and the fact that @xmath134 .
the present case , where @xmath108 , the results for the periodic case can be obtained from the open boundary case straightforwardly .
we are going , in the rest of this section , to restrict ourselves to the open boundary case where @xmath43 .
it is convenient to label the energies ( [ e3.2 ] ) by the index @xmath135 : [ e3.3 ] e_i= \{0,2i u_d } , i=0,1,
,l/2 let us restrict ourselves initially to the cases where the parameter @xmath136 .
the stationary state of the system is the substrate , being the ground - state ( @xmath137 ) of the hamiltonian . in this
no adsorption case the ground state is also an absorbing state
. if the initial configuration is not the substrate , for sufficiently large times the dynamics will be ruled by the first gap of the hamiltonian @xmath138 , given by ( [ e3.3 ] ) , and since @xmath139 is finite for any @xmath31 , we do expect for any observable an exponential time - decay @xmath140 .
however we need some care in this analysis since the eigenvalue @xmath139 has a degeneracy @xmath141 .
this is the number of configurations with @xmath142 peaks , obtained by adding tiles in the first layer ( @xmath143 ) above the substrate and with the tiles in the closest positions ( no nonzero slopes between the added tiles ) ( see fig .
[ fig4 ] for examples ) . for large @xmath31 the degeneracy grows as @xmath144 and as we shall see , an interesting physical behavior occurs . with @xmath145 peaks obtained by adding , in the substrate configuration , @xmath146 tiles at the closest positions .
the index @xmath147 indicate the valley position in the substrate where the initial tile is added . the substrate configuration @xmath148 is also shown .
, scaledwidth=35.0% ] to simplify our analysis we are going to consider as the initial state , for the evolution of our system , one of the configurations with @xmath149 peaks , and with @xmath146 tiles added in the substrate .
there are @xmath150 configurations of this kind and we denote them as @xmath151 , @xmath152 ; @xmath153 . as an example , we show in fig .
[ fig4 ] some of the configurations for a lattice size @xmath154 , together with the substrate absorbing state @xmath155 . if we chose for @xmath154 the state @xmath156 ( see fig .
[ fig4 ] ) as the initial state , the effective hamiltonian is given by [ e3.4 ] & & h = - ( c|rrrrrrr & & & & & & & + & e_1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + & -e_1/2 & e_1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + & -e_1/2 & 0 & e_1 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + & 0 & -e_1/2 & 0 & e_1 & 0 & 0 & 0 + & 0 & -e_1/2 & -e_1/2 & 0 & e_1 & 0 & 0 + & 0 & 0 & -e_1/2 & 0 & 0 & e_1 & 0 + & 0 & 0 & 0 & -e_1 & -e_1 & -e_1 & 0 + ) , where @xmath139 is given by ( [ e3.3 ] ) .
it is interesting to note that @xmath129 in ( [ e3.4 ] ) has a jordan - cell structure , since although the eigenvalue @xmath139 is 6 degenerated there are only 3 distinct eigenvectors . in the general case , for arbitrary @xmath31 ,
if we start with an configuration with @xmath149 peaks and @xmath146 tiles added in the substrate , we have a jordan - cell structure where instead of @xmath157 eigenvectors with eigenvalue @xmath139 , we have only @xmath146 distinct eigenvectors ( @xmath158 are missing ! ) . if we start , for large @xmath31 , with an initial state where @xmath159 , the jordan - cell will be of dimension @xmath160 .
let us consider , as an example , the probability distribution @xmath161 for the configurations of the @xmath154 system considered in fig .
[ fig4 ] when we take as initial state the configuration @xmath156 . solving the set of coupled linear differential equations derived by inserting the effective hamiltonian ( [ e3.4 ] ) in the master equation ( [ e2.7 ] ) we obtain : [ e3.5 ] & = & ( 1-_k=0 ^ 2 e^-e_1 t ) + + ( e_1t)e^-e_1 t + & & + e^-e_1 t .
we see that the missing 3 eigenvectors of the jordan - cell structure produces besides the exponential decay also a polynomial time dependence .
the configuration with @xmath162 tiles above the substrate has a time dependence @xmath163 .
we can generalize the above solution for @xmath31 arbitrary .
let us consider , as the initial state , one of the configurations @xmath151 ( see fig .
[ fig4 ] ) with @xmath164 peaks and @xmath146 tiles added in the first layer above the substrate .
the probability of finding the system at time @xmath123 in a configuration with @xmath165 tiles is given by : [ e3.6 ] p_k(t ) = e^-e_1 t , 1k n_0 - 1 , while the probability of finding the system in the substrate configuration is given by : [ e3.7 ] p _
= 1-_k=1^n_o-1 p_k(t ) . as a function of time for the parpm with @xmath108 , @xmath60 and lattice size @xmath166 .
the initial configuration is one of the @xmath151 , with @xmath167 ( see fig .
[ fig4 ] for notation ) .
the continuous curve is the prediction given by ( [ e3.10 ] ) , and the discrete points are the results obtained from monte carlo simulations.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] and @xmath168 .
the two set of curves correspond to distinct initial conditions . in the lower
set the initial configuration is @xmath169 ( see fig . [ fig5 ] ) where we have @xmath170 tiles in the first row above the substrate . in the top curves the initial configuration in the one where we have a pyramid whose basis has @xmath170 in the first row , above the substrate configuration .
the parameter @xmath171 was chosen to better present the results and the exponents are @xmath172 .
, scaledwidth=40.0% ] from ( [ e3.6 ] ) and ( [ e3.7 ] ) we can calculate the time dependence of the observables ( [ e2.10])-([e2.13 ] ) .
the average number of peaks and valleys @xmath173 , heights @xmath174 and contact points @xmath175 are given by [ e3.8 ] _
l(t)-_l ( ) = -_k=0^n_0 - 1 e^-e_1 t , [ e3.9 ] ( h_l(t)-h_l())=k_l()-k_l(t ) = e^-e_1t\{_k=0^n_0 - 1(n_0-k ) } , where @xmath176 , @xmath177 and @xmath178 are the values of these quantities at the final substrate configuration . in both expressions , if @xmath179 , i. e. , @xmath180 , we can approximate the sum by @xmath181 .
this is quite interesting since for times up to @xmath182 the exponential decay is totally canceled and the system behaves as if it was gapless . only for
@xmath183 the exponential decay will govern the time decay to the stationary state . in fig .
[ fig5 ] we illustrate this behavior by comparing the average height @xmath174 predicted by ( [ e3.9 ] ) with the results obtained by averaging @xmath184 runs of a monte carlo simulation for the parpm with @xmath166 ( open ends ) , with parameters @xmath185 , @xmath60 and having as the initial state the configuration containing @xmath167 tiles in the first layer above the substrate .
the agreement is excellent , as expected .
we also see in the figure that up to a transient time @xmath186 ( @xmath187 in this case ) , @xmath174 has a linear time dependence , and for @xmath183 the system finally decays to the substrate , where @xmath188 .
this linear behavior is better seen by writing ( [ e3.9 ] ) as [ e3.10 ] < h_l(t)-h_l ( ) > = e^-e_1t\ { ( e_1t)^n_0 - 1 + ( n_0-e_1t)_n=0^n_0 - 2 } , where the linear behavior dominates up to @xmath189 .
let us analize the time behavior for large lattices and @xmath190 . from ( [ e3.3 ] )
the gap is finite and given by [ e3.11 ] e_1=2u_p(2-p + 2(p-1)/l ) . in order to do
the limit @xmath191 is necessary to define what are the initial states , as we change the lattice sizes .
two distinct limits give us quite different behavior .
in the first one we consider a set of initial states where we have a fixed number of tiles @xmath146 above the substrate . in this case
we have the linear time behavior up to the finite time @xmath186 , but for @xmath183 the system exhibits its exponential - law decay . in the second case we consider the set of initial states that @xmath192 is fixed as @xmath193 . in this case @xmath194 , and the system behaves at all times as would not be gapped , similarly as happens in a critical system .
this unusual and surprisingly behavior happens due to the infinite size jordan - cell structure for the eigenvalue @xmath139 of the hamiltonian .
let us now consider the case @xmath195 . in this case
we see from ( [ e3.11 ] ) that the gap vanishes as @xmath196 , when @xmath191 , and the system is critical . in order to see this critical behavior we must consider , as @xmath191 , a sequence of initial states with a fixed number @xmath146 of tiles above the substrate . in fig .
[ fig6 ] we illustrate this critical behavior by considering , for several lattice sizes the average height @xmath174 for two distinct sets of initial conditions . in the first one we take as the initial configurations the configurations @xmath169 given in fig .
[ fig5 ] , where we have @xmath170 tiles added in the first row above the substrate , while in the second one we take as initial configurations the ones where we have a pyramid whose basis contains @xmath170 tiles in the first row above the substrate . as we can see in fig .
[ fig6 ] for both initial conditions , the curves for the several lattice sizes collapse indicating the family - visek scaling behavior @xcite .
[ e3.12 ] -1 = f ( ) , with the dynamical critical exponents @xmath197 . for @xmath198 , the initial states we considered are already absorbing states and the system is already in the stationary state .
it is simple to convince ourselves that even if we consider more general initial states , that are not absorbing states , since we have only desorption , after a relatively short time the system is trapped on one of the absorbing states .
this means that for @xmath126 we have a phase transition in the parpm at @xmath168 , separating phases with single and multiple absorbing states .
@xcite . knowing that @xmath5
, we can write from ( [ e3.11 ] ) the gap @xmath199 , with @xmath200 , @xmath201 , that is similar to the results obtained from the numerical diagonalization of the evolution operator of the contact process @xcite . it is important to mention that although @xmath5 the model at @xmath168 is not conformally invariant . from ( [ e3.3 ] )
we see that , for @xmath191 , the gaps behave as @xmath202 with amplitudes @xmath203 .
these amplitudes does not give the conformal towers that are expected in the finite - size scaling limit of conformally invariant critical systems .
we consider in this section the parpm for the special case where the absorption and desorption rates are equal , i. e , @xmath204 .
for this case the model with open boundary condition was studied in @xcite for the values of the parameter @xmath205 .
the model is conformally invariant for @xmath206 , with a @xmath14-dependent sound velocity . at @xmath61
the substrate configuration becomes an absorbing state and is the stationary state .
however , the system stays during a time interval which grows exponentially with the lattice size , in a quasi - stationary state with the same properties ( @xmath5 ) as the conformal invariant phase @xmath207 of the model .
.5 for the parpm with @xmath208 sites and open boundary conditions .
the curves are for several values of the parameter @xmath14 and @xmath4 .
( b ) same as ( a ) but the time is now scaled by the factor @xmath209 , which is proportional to the sound velocity.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig7a ] .5 for the parpm with @xmath208 sites and open boundary conditions .
the curves are for several values of the parameter @xmath14 and @xmath4 .
( b ) same as ( a ) but the time is now scaled by the factor @xmath209 , which is proportional to the sound velocity.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig7b ] we now consider the case where @xmath19 . in fig .
[ fig7]a we show the time evolution of the average height @xmath174 for the model with open boundary conditions , lattice size @xmath208 and some values of @xmath14 . in fig .
[ fig7]b we show that these curves , similarly as happens for @xmath18 @xcite , are collapsed in a single universal curve by re - scaling the time scale by a factor proportional to the sound velocity of the model @xmath210 .
similar curves are also obtained for the other observables defined in ( [ e2.12])-([e2.13 ] ) .
this is a surprise , since for @xmath19 , as @xmath14 increase the number of absorbing states increases drastically . for @xmath191 , although the system has an infinite number of absorbing states , it stays in a quasi - stationary state with similar properties as the conformally invariant systems ( @xmath211 ) .
the system prefers ( independent of the value of @xmath14 ) to stay in configurations with number of peaks smaller than those of the absorbing states , and the net effect of the parameter @xmath14 is just a change in the time scale . to illustrate , we show in fig .
[ fig8 ] the average distribution of heights @xmath212 at site @xmath213 for the model in the quasi - stationary state .
the data are for @xmath208 sites , open boundary conditions and the values of @xmath214 and @xmath215 .
we see a nice collapse of the curves regardless @xmath18 or @xmath19 .
we also show in the figure ( circles ) the predicted curve @xcite for the standard @xmath4 rpm : @xmath216 + \beta $ ] , with @xmath217 and @xmath218 .
the coefficient @xmath219 can be derived exploiting the conformal invariance of the model @xcite .
we verified that the curves collapse up to @xmath220 . at this point , from ( [ e2.9p ] ) , all the configurations with @xmath221 peaks are absorbing states , and the time scale disappears ( the sound velocity is zero ) . for @xmath222
the system decays , after a short time , in one of the infinitely many absorbing states .
( @xmath223 ) in the stationary state of the parpm with open boundary conditions .
the lattice size is @xmath208 , @xmath4 and the parameters @xmath14 are shown in the figure . the predicted universal curve @xmath224 + 0.77 $ ] is also shown ( circles).,scaledwidth=40.0% ] in order to calculate the decay time of the quasi - stationary state for @xmath225
, we need to evaluate the eigenvalues of the hamiltonian . in fig .
[ fig9 ] we show the lowest 38 eigenvalues of the hamiltonian as a function of @xmath14 , for the model with @xmath226 sites and open boundary conditions .
we see from this figure that at @xmath227 the energy of the eigenstate that is the first excited state for @xmath18 has a large decrease .
it degenerates with the ground state ( @xmath137 ) exponentially with the lattice size , as @xmath228 .
this is due to the appearance of the absorbing state whose configuration is the substrate , with 9 peaks . at @xmath229
additional 36 excited states also degenerate with the ground state , since all the configurations with 8 peaks are also absorbing eigenstates . at @xmath230
additional degeneracies of the ground state happens due to the new absorbing states with 7 peaks .
we also verify in fig .
[ fig9 ] that the lowest gap is much lower in the region @xmath19 as compared with the one in the conformally invariant region @xmath18 . in the region
@xmath18 we verified from a finite - size extrapolation , using lattice sizes up to @xmath231 , that the first excited state , as @xmath191 , is given by @xmath232 where @xmath233 is the sound velocity , in agreement with the prediction in ref .
this value of @xmath139 for @xmath191 is represented as the dashed line in fig .
the fact that even for @xmath19 the system has similar physical properties as @xmath18 is an indication that most probably the lowest gap above the quasi - stationary state is also given by the same last expression @xmath234 . ) and the lowest 37 excited eigenenergies , as a function of @xmath14 , of the hamiltonian of the parpm , with @xmath4 , lattice size @xmath226 and open boundary conditions . in the figure @xmath235 is the sound velocity .
the dashed line is the prediction for the first excited state for @xmath236 when @xmath191.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath237 it is not possible to obtain reasonable estimates for the lowest gap @xmath139 , from direct diagonalizations of the hamiltonian . in this case the finite - size effects are stronger and we need to consider lattices sizes larger than the ones we were able to diagonalize exactly ( @xmath238 ) . in this case
we extract @xmath139 from the time evolution of the average number of peaks and valleys [ e4.1 ] _
l(t)=_l()[1-a(-e_1 t ) ] , where @xmath239 is a constant that depends on the initial condition considered .
in order to test the precision of the estimates obtained from ( [ e4.1 ] ) we compare them with the exact results derived from direct diagonalizations of the hamiltonian with small lattice sizes and @xmath17 . in table 1
we give the estimates obtained from both methods .
as we can see for @xmath240 the difference among the estimated values are less that @xmath241 . in order to estimate @xmath139 using larger lattice sizes we chose , for a fixed value of @xmath242 , a sequence of lattice sizes @xmath243 such that , from ( [ e2.9p ] ) , @xmath244 , with @xmath67 an integer and @xmath42 or 1 for the periodic or open boundary conditions .
for example for @xmath245 the lattice sizes are @xmath246 and @xmath247 for periodic and open boundary conditions .
[ tab1 ] lcccccr @xmath248 & 8 & 10 & 12 & 14 & 16 & 18 + exact & 0.227 & 0.139 & 0.0922 & 0.0636 & 0.04481 & 0.0318 + from ( [ e4.1 ] ) & 0.231 & 0.140 & 0.0920 & 0.0638 & 0.04476 & 0.0320 + in fig .
[ fig10 ] we show the values obtained for the gap @xmath139 , for the case of open ( fig .
[ fig10]a ) and periodic boundary conditions ( fig .
[ fig10]b ) .
the data are for lattice sizes up to @xmath249 .
we see from these figures that the leading finite - size scaling behavior of the gap is given by : [ e4.2 ] e_1 ~f(l^1/ ) , where @xmath250 , with @xmath251 , @xmath252 and @xmath253 .
we also see from the figure that the scaling function @xmath254 and decreases exponentially with the argument .
this imply that the decay time @xmath255 of the quasi - stationary state increases exponentially as the lattice size increases .
for @xmath222 we verified that the quasi - stationary state disappears and the system is trapped in one of the absorbing states .
we then expect that @xmath256 is a critical point .
the parpm with the values @xmath61 and @xmath257 seems to be similar to the bimodal and spinodal limits of metastable systems @xcite .
considering different values of @xmath1 for the parpm we should have as the limiting values @xmath17 and @xmath258 for the region with absorbing sates . for @xmath2 we have seen in sec . 4 that @xmath259 , and in sec . 6
we are going to see that for @xmath29 , @xmath260 .
we can then reach the critical point ( @xmath261 ) at @xmath4 by considering @xmath262 with the parameter @xmath263 fixed ( see fig .
[ fig0 ] ) . in fig .
[ fig11]a this was done for the case of periodic boundaries , and we see that , as in fig .
[ fig10]a , the gap behaves as in ( [ e4.2 ] ) .
these results imply that at @xmath4 and @xmath264 , the energy gap has the @xmath31-dependence @xmath265 , with the dynamical critical exponent @xmath266 . to improve this estimate we consider a sequence of periodic lattices with @xmath267 .
the results are shown in fig .
[ fig11]b and give us @xmath268 .
.5 , for several values of @xmath14 and
lattice sizes @xmath269 ( compare with ( [ e4.1 ] ) ) .
the lattice size values depend on the parameter @xmath14 ( see the text ) .
( a ) open boundary condition .
b ) periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig10a ] .5 , for several values of @xmath14 and lattice sizes @xmath269 ( compare with ( [ e4.1 ] ) ) .
the lattice size values depend on the parameter @xmath14 ( see the text ) .
( a ) open boundary condition .
b ) periodic boundary condition.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig10b ] .5 , as a function of @xmath31 , for the parpm with periodic boundary conditions for the parameter @xmath263 and in the region @xmath122 . ( a ) data collapse using in ( [ e4.2 ] ) @xmath270 , with @xmath271 .
the lattice sizes are @xmath272 .
( b ) power - law behavior for the gap at @xmath4 .
the lattice sizes are @xmath273 ( @xmath274 ) , so that @xmath275.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig11a ] .5 , as a function of @xmath31 , for the parpm with periodic boundary conditions for the parameter @xmath263 and in the region @xmath122 . ( a ) data collapse using in ( [ e4.2 ] ) @xmath270 , with @xmath271 . the lattice sizes are @xmath272 .
( b ) power - law behavior for the gap at @xmath4 .
the lattice sizes are @xmath273 ( @xmath274 ) , so that @xmath275.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig11b ] in summary for @xmath206 the model is conformally invariant with dynamical critical exponent @xmath5 . for @xmath276
the model is in a phase containing multiple absorbing states , but these absorbing states are only reached after a time interval that increases exponentially with the lattice size . in this phase
the system stays in a quasi - stationary state with dynamical critical exponent @xmath5 and similar properties as in the conformally invariant phase @xmath18 .
the sound velocity for @xmath277 is proportional to @xmath278 . at @xmath263
it vanishes and we have a new critical behavior with @xmath279 .
a similar vanishing of the sound velocity happens in the xxz quantum chain when we approach the ferromagnetic point ( @xmath5 ) coming from the anti ferromagnetic conformally invariant phase ( @xmath5 ) @xcite . for values @xmath280 the model is frozen in one of the infinitely many absorbing states .
we consider in this section the parpm in the case we have only adsorptions , i. e. , @xmath109 and @xmath281 . in the stochastic evolution
only the tilted tiles that hit sites with valleys ( @xmath44 ) produce changes in the growing surface ( @xmath282 ) .
this model can be interpreted as a kind of a single step model @xcite without desorption .
( no desorptions ) the only allowed motions for the particles are shown in the figure.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] it is interesting to map the configurations of the parpm in terms of excluded volume particles and holes in the lattice , as in @xcite ( particle - hole representation ) . the particles ( holes ) are defined on the sites @xmath67 where @xmath283 ( @xmath284 ) . in this map
the number of particles and holes are equal ( see fig .
[ fig12 ] , as an example ) .
the adsorptions in the sites with valleys correspond to the motion of a particle to the leftmost lattice position , provided it is empty ( hole ) . for @xmath29 this is the only allowed motion as happens in the totally asymmetric exclusion process ( tasep ) @xcite .
the parpm with the choice @xmath15 recovers the standard rpm . in this case
all the sites during the stochastic evolution are chosen with equal probability and the particle - hole mapping give us the standard tasep model @xcite .
in the case of open boundary conditions the model is noncritical .
the stationary state , that corresponds to the pyramid configuration in the height representation is the configuration where the @xmath285 particles are in the left half of the @xmath31-sites lattice .
however for periodic chains the model is critical and belongs to the kardar - parisi - zhang ( kpz ) universality class , whose dynamical critical exponent @xmath286 . for general values of the parameter @xmath14 the parpm with no desorption ( @xmath109 ) and adsorption rate @xmath68 will be related to a generalized tasep whose transition rates for the particles hoppings depend non locally on the particles positions . as a consequence of our definition ( [ e2.6 ] ) the transition rates depend on the number of peaks ( or valleys ) in the height representation of the model . in the particle - hole representation
this is the total number @xmath287 of hole - particle pairs ( hole in the left and a particle in the right ) , or equivalently is the number of particles s clusters in the configuration . from ( [ e2.6p ] ) the transition rates for the particles in the generalized tasep
is @xmath288 where [ e5.1 ] q_c = \ { 0 , } , where for @xmath15 we have the standard tasep with transition rate @xmath68 . since @xmath289 is the maximum value , for @xmath290 the parameter @xmath14 acts as a nonlocal perturbation in the tasep ( @xmath15 ) .
when @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) the configurations with larger ( smaller ) number of pairs @xmath287 are preferred . for @xmath198 this perturbation introduces a new effect . at @xmath291 the two configurations with @xmath289 ( all the particles occupying the even or odd sites ) become absorbing states .
as we increase @xmath198 , the configurations @xmath292 with density of pairs @xmath293 also become absorbing states .
for @xmath294 and @xmath191 we have then an infinite number of absorbing states in a model with particle number conservation .
this is similar as happen in other models like the manna model , the conserved threshold transfer process ( cttp ) and in the conserved lattice gas ( clg ) @xcite .
however , as we shall see , the phase transition to the frozen state in our model shows a dynamical critical exponent @xmath295 , differently from the values @xmath296 for the manna model and cttp and @xmath297 for the clg @xcite .
as happened in the case @xmath4 our results indicate that for @xmath298 , where the model has no absorbing states the dynamical critical exponent has the same value as in the @xmath15 standard tasep where @xmath286 . in the region @xmath299 the model , although having in the thermodynamical limit an infinite number of absorbing states , stays in a quasi - stationary state with the same critical properties as in the kpz region @xmath300 , i.e. , @xmath286 .
the quasi - stationary state for @xmath301 decays in an absorbing state after a transient time that diverges exponentially with the lattice size of the system .
the net effect of the parameter @xmath14 , for @xmath302 is a change of the sound velocity of the model , that is proportional to @xmath303 .
.5 for the parpm at @xmath29 and the parameter @xmath304 , for several lattice sizes .
the top curves ( bottom curves ) are the ones where the initial configuration is the pyramid ( substrate ) .
the constant @xmath305 was introduced to better represent the data and @xmath306 is obtained as a result of the data collapse of the curves , as the time increases , and by fixing the kpz exponents @xmath286 and @xmath307 .
( b ) probability distribution of the second moment @xmath308 of the height distribution at the stationary ( @xmath309 ) or quasi - stationary state ( @xmath294 ) of the parpm with no desorption ( @xmath29 ) .
it is also included ( crosses ) the theoretical kpz prediction for this distribution @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig13a ] .5 for the parpm at @xmath29 and the parameter @xmath304 , for several lattice sizes .
the top curves ( bottom curves ) are the ones where the initial configuration is the pyramid ( substrate ) .
the constant @xmath305 was introduced to better represent the data and @xmath306 is obtained as a result of the data collapse of the curves , as the time increases , and by fixing the kpz exponents @xmath286 and @xmath307 .
( b ) probability distribution of the second moment @xmath308 of the height distribution at the stationary ( @xmath309 ) or quasi - stationary state ( @xmath294 ) of the parpm with no desorption ( @xmath29 ) .
it is also included ( crosses ) the theoretical kpz prediction for this distribution @xcite.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig13b ] in order to identify the universality class of the parpm for general values of @xmath14 and @xmath109 we calculate the time evolution of the surface roughness [ e5.2 ] w_l(t ) = , where @xmath310 is the average height of the configuration at time @xmath123 . in fig .
[ fig13]a we show the time evolution of the first cumulant of @xmath308 , i. e. , @xmath311 , for the model with @xmath304 .
we consider as the initial conditions the configurations with a single peak ( top curves ) and @xmath58 peaks ( bottom curves ) .
the collapse of the curves in the infinite - size limit [ e5.3 ] < w_l(t ) > ~l^f(t / l^z ) , give us @xmath286 and @xmath307 , indicates that the model belongs to the kpz universality class of critical behavior .
we also consider , for the lattice size @xmath312 , the probability distribution of @xmath308 in the stationary states for @xmath18 , and also for @xmath313 .
this is shown in fig .
[ fig13]b .
we also include in this last figure the theoretical prediction for the kpz model @xcite ( crossed points ) .
we clearly see a nice agreement , indicating that indeed for @xmath314 the model belongs to the kpz universality class , where @xmath286 and @xmath307 . for all cases the probability distribution behaves as [ e5.4 ] p_ll(w_l^2 ) = f ( ) , where @xmath306 is a finite - size correction and @xmath315 is the standard average over the configurations @xcite . .5 for the parpm at @xmath29 with several values of the parameter @xmath14 ( shown in the figure ) and for the lattice size @xmath312 .
as time grows the curves collapse if the time is scaled by the factor @xmath303 .
( b ) finite - size scaling for the gap of the parpm at @xmath30 , for several values of @xmath316 .
the gaps were estimated by fitting ( @xmath317 ) with ( [ e4.2 ] ) and @xmath318 .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] .5 for the parpm at @xmath29 with several values of the parameter @xmath14 ( shown in the figure ) and for the lattice size @xmath312 .
as time grows the curves collapse if the time is scaled by the factor @xmath303 .
( b ) finite - size scaling for the gap of the parpm at @xmath30 , for several values of @xmath316 .
the gaps were estimated by fitting ( @xmath317 ) with ( [ e4.2 ] ) and @xmath318 .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig14b ] we want now to consider the limiting case @xmath319 . in fig .
[ fig14]a we show the time evolution , for several values of @xmath320 , of the average @xmath321 for the lattice size @xmath312 .
we see from the figure that the time scale changes as a function of @xmath322 .
we also notice the existence of a transient regime , that increases as we get closer to @xmath323 .
this is an indication that at @xmath323 the system may have a distinct behavior . in order to verify this possibility we need to evaluate the lowest gap @xmath139 for @xmath320 . as we did in sec .
4 for the case @xmath4 , this gap could be calculated from the large - time dependence of the observable @xmath173 ( see ( [ e4.1 ] ) ) . in fig .
[ fig14]b we show the finite - size scaling obtained for the gap at @xmath30 . in fig .
[ fig15]a we show in a semi - log plot the quantity @xmath324 , starting with the system in the pyramid configuration .
we clearly see from this figure that the exponential time dependence ( [ e4.1 ] ) is only obtained for short times . as we obtained in the @xmath2 case ( see sec .
3 ) , if the eigenvalue @xmath139 has an associated jordan - cell structure we may have instead of a simple exponential decay as in ( [ e4.1 ] ) , the more general time dependence [ e5.5 ] 1- ~t^n ( -e_1 t ) , where @xmath325 is an @xmath31-dependent integer and @xmath139 is the gap . in fig .
[ fig15]b we fit , using ( [ e5.5 ] ) , the results obtained for the lattice @xmath326 .
we obtained a good fitting for @xmath327 giving us the value @xmath328 and @xmath329 .
repeating the same fitting for the lattice sizes @xmath330 , @xmath331 , @xmath332 and @xmath333 we obtain @xmath334 and @xmath335 .
this result indicates that indeed at @xmath256 we have a new critical behavior with the dynamical critical exponent @xmath5 . from fig .
[ fig15]a we see that the simple exponential as in ( [ e4.1 ] ) give us the short - time behavior . extracting the gap from the initial times , assuming ( [ e4.1 ] ) for the small lattices @xmath336 we obtain @xmath337 .
these results together with the ones obtained by using the fitting ( [ e5.5 ] ) for large times are shown in fig .
[ fig16 ] .
there is however an apparent contradiction in these results since the gap calculated from the large time decay is greater than the one governing the short - time behavior .
this is an indication that indeed at large times the lowest gap @xmath139 appearing in ( [ e5.5 ] ) should be replaced by a higher excited state @xmath338 .
this means that the jordan - cell structure dominating the @xmath325-polynomial behavior at large times is not associated to the first excited state , but to a higher excited state .
the large dimension of the jordan cells associated to @xmath339 are enough to kill the exponential decays associated to the smaller gaps . .5 ( red curve),as a function of time , for the periodic parpm with @xmath340 sites , no desorptions ( @xmath29 ) and at the critical point @xmath341 .
the initial state of the system is the pyramid configuration .
the black line is the linear fit obtained for @xmath342 , as expected from ( [ e4.1 ] ) .
( b ) same as in ( a ) with the larger lattice size @xmath326 .
the curve in red is obtained by fitting , according to ( [ e5.5 ] ) , the data for the larger times @xmath343.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig15a ] .5 ( red curve),as a function of time , for the periodic parpm with @xmath340 sites , no desorptions ( @xmath29 ) and at the critical point @xmath341 .
the initial state of the system is the pyramid configuration .
the black line is the linear fit obtained for @xmath342 , as expected from ( [ e4.1 ] ) .
( b ) same as in ( a ) with the larger lattice size @xmath326 .
the curve in red is obtained by fitting , according to ( [ e5.5 ] ) , the data for the larger times @xmath343.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=80.0% ] [ fig15b ] in summary for @xmath28 the parpm is in the kpz universality class ( @xmath344 ) for all the values of @xmath345 . for @xmath346 , although there exist an infinite number of absorbing states , the system stays during a time interval that grow exponentially with the lattice size , in a quasi - stationary state sharing the critical properties of the kpz universality class . for @xmath347
the large - time behavior has a simple exponential decay with a time decay @xmath255 .
however at @xmath319 our results indicate that a jordan - cell structure associate to a higher gap @xmath338 , dominates the large - time behavior . in this case
the system stays in a quasi - stationary state with a dynamical critical exponent @xmath295 . for @xmath222
the model is in a frozen state , i.e. , after a short time decays to one of the infinitely many absorbing states .
$ ] of the parpm with periodic boundaries , @xmath29 and @xmath319 . for @xmath348 the estimates
were obtained from the fitting with ( [ e4.1 ] ) and for large times the fitting was done by using ( [ e5.5]).,scaledwidth=40.0% ]
the peak adjusted raise and peel model ( parpm ) was studied in this paper .
the model can describe the interface fluctuations of a growth model ( height representation ) or the particle density fluctuations in a nonlocal particle - hole exclusion process ( particle - hole representation ) .
the model has two parameters : @xmath1 and @xmath14 .
the parameter @xmath349 controls the ratio between the rates of adsorption and desorption in the height representation , and in the particle - hole representation it gives the relative weight among the local and nonlocal hoppings of the particles .
the parameter @xmath350 distinguish , during the time evolution , the configurations according to the number of peaks , in the height representation , or the number of particle - hole pairs in the particle - hole representation . in the bulk limit ( @xmath191 ) , for any value of @xmath1 and @xmath294
, the model has an infinite number of absorbing states .
an schematic phase diagram of the model is shown in [ fig0 ] .
we study the model with open and periodic boundary conditions by choosing some special values of @xmath1 and general values of @xmath14 .
_ a _ ) at @xmath2 ( sec .
3 ) where we have no desorption in the height representation , the model is gapped for @xmath351 , having an absorbing state as the stationary state . in the bulk limit
the associated hamiltonian has an infinite dimension jordan cell structure associated to the first excited state . starting from some simple configurations we were able to derive the analytical time dependence of some observables for arbitrary time .
interestingly , if we consider in the @xmath228 , a sequence of initial configurations where the density of tiles in the first row is fixed and nonzero , the system stays an infinite time before decaying into the final absorbing state and , does not fell the system s gap . at @xmath291 however , the model is critical with a dynamical critical exponent @xmath5 . for @xmath294 the stationary state
is one of the infinitely many absorbing states . _
b _ ) for @xmath4 we extend the results obtained in @xcite for @xmath136 , where the model is known to be conformally invariant ( central charge @xmath352 and @xmath5 ) .
our results show that for @xmath353 , where the model has an infinite number of absorbing states , it stays in a critical quasi - stationary state during a time interval that grows exponentially with the lattice size .
the quasi - stationary state has the same critical properties as the conformally invariant phase @xmath351 . at @xmath220
our results give us a new critical behavior with dynamical critical exponent @xmath354 . for @xmath280
the system , after a short time , stays inactive in one of the infinitely many absorbing states .
the phase transition at @xmath251 separates an active phase from an inactive phase of a system with an infinite number of absorbing states .
we think that is the first time we see such a phase transition , i.e. , a transition to a frozen inactive state coming from a critical phase , that although having infinitely many absorbing states , is ruled by an active quasi - stationary state .
_ c _ ) for @xmath29 the model has no desorption and it loses part of its non locality , since the adsorptions are local . in the particle - hole representation the model is equivalent to a tasep where we have @xmath285 particles that can hop to the next - neighbor site at the left , provided it is empty ( hole ) . for a given value of the parameter @xmath14 the rate of the hopping process depends on the number of particle - hole pairs in the configuration . in this limit the model is gapped or not depending if the boundary condition is open or periodic , respectively . at @xmath15 the motion of the particles
are independent of the numbers of particle - hole pairs and the model recovers the standard critical tasep with the dynamical critical exponent @xmath286 of the kpz universality class .
our results indicate that for all values @xmath355 , the model has the same critical behavior as the kpz universality class . for @xmath356 ,
similarly as happened in the case @xmath4 , the model although having an infinite number of absorbing states , survives for a time interval that diverges exponentially with the lattice size , in a critical quasi - stationary state whose critical properties are the same as the ones on the region without absorbing states ( @xmath357 ) . at @xmath319 , as in the cases @xmath2 and @xmath4 , the model shows a new critical behavior with dynamical critical exponent @xmath5 .
we also noticed that this new critical behavior is a consequence of large dimension jordan cells associated not to the first excited state , but to a higher excited one .
to conclude it is interesting to see the parpm as a generalized asymmetric exclusion process asep @xcite , with nonlocal jumps of excluded volume particles ( controlled by @xmath1 ) whose rates are biased ( controlled by @xmath14 ) by the number of particle - hole pairs in the configurations .
the parameter @xmath1 is relevant since it changes the critical behavior . the parameter @xmath14 , on the other hand , is irrelevant up to @xmath358 ( @xmath359 ) , although for @xmath360 there exist an infinite number of absorbing states . at @xmath358
the model has a new critical behavior with a @xmath1-dependent critical exponent @xmath10 .
we would like to thank jos abel hoyos and vladimir rittenberg for useful discussions and a careful reading of the manuscript .
this work was support in part by the brazilian funding agencies : fapesp , cnpq and capes .
99 url # 1#1 urlprefix [ 2][]#2 schmittmannb and zia r k p , 1995 _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _
vol 17 , ed c domb and j lebowitz ( london : academic ) + halpin - healyt and zhang y - ch . , 1995
rep _ * 254 * 215 + dor g 2008 _ universality in nonequilibrium lattice systems _
( world scientific ) hinrichsen h 2000 _ advances in physics _ * 49 * 815958 henkel m , hinrichsen h , lbeck s and pleimling m 2008 _ non - equilibrium phase transitions _
vol 1 ( springer ) edwards s f and wilkinson d r , 1982 _ proc .
_ a * 381 * 17 kardar m , parisi g and zhang y - c 1986 _ phys .
lett . _ * 56 * 889 + halpin - healy t and zhang y - c , 1995 _ phys .
_ * 254 * 215 de gier j , nienhuis b , pearce p a and rittenberg v 2004 _ j. stat .
mech . _ * 114 * 135 + alcaraz f c , levine e and rittenberg v 2006 _ j. stat .
mech . _ * p08003 * + alcaraz f c and rittenberg v 2007
_ j. stat .
mech . _ * p07009 * + alcaraz f c , pyatov p and rittenberg v 2008 _ j. stat .
mech . _ * p01006 * razumov a v and stroganov yu g 2001 _ j. phys . a : math .
* 34 * 3185 alcaraz f c and rittenberg v 2010 _ j. stat .
_ * p12032 * alcaraz f c , rittenberg v and sierra g 2009 _ phys .
e _ * 80 * 030102(r ) + alcaraz f c and rittenberg v 2010 _ j. stat .
_ * p03024 * jacobsen j l and saleur h 2008 _ phys
lett . _ * 100 * 087205 alcaraz f c and rittenberg v 2011 _ j. stat .
mech . _ * 2011 * p09030 alcaraz f c and rittenberg v 2013 _ j. stat . mech . _ * 2013 * p09010 derrida b , evans m and mukamel d 1993 _ journal of physics a : mathematical and general _ * 26 * 4911 derrida b and mallick k 1997 _ journal of physics a : mathematical and general _ * 30 * 1031 family f and vicsek t 1985 _ journal of physics a : mathematical and general _ * 18 * l75 debenedetti p g 1996 _ metastable liquids : concepts and principles _ ( princeton university press ) alcaraz f c , barber m n and batchelor m t 1988 _ ann .
phys.(ny ) _ * 182 * 280 barabsi a l and stanley h e 1995 _ fractal concepts in surface growth _ ( cambridge university press )
sasamoto t and spohn h 2010 _ phys .
lett . _ * 104 * 230602 antal t , droz m , gyrgyi g and rcz z 2002 _ phys .
. e _ * 65 * 046140 oliveira t and reis f a 2007 _ phys .
e _ * 76 * 061601 | we study a two parameter ( @xmath0 ) extension of the conformally invariant raise and peel model .
the model also represents a nonlocal and biased - asymmetric exclusion process with local and nonlocal jumps of excluded volume particles in the lattice .
the model exhibits an unusual and interesting critical phase where , in the bulk limit , there are an infinite number of absorbing states . in spite of these absorbing states
the system stays , during a time that increases exponentially with the lattice size , in a critical quasi - stationary state . in this critical phase
the critical exponents depend only on one of the parameters defining the model ( @xmath1 ) .
the endpoint of this critical phase belongs to a distinct universality class , where the system changes from an active to an inactive frozen state .
this new behavior we believe to be due to the appearance of jordan cells in the hamiltonian describing the time evolution .
the dimensions of these cells increases with the lattice size . in a special case ( @xmath2 )
where the model has no adsorptions we are able to calculate analytically the time evolution of some of the observables .
a polynomial time dependence is obtained due to the jordan cells structure of the hamiltonian . |
understanding the mechanism of electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) is one of the most exciting problems facing particle physics today . the standard model ( sm ) , though phenomenologically successful , relies crucially on the existence of a scalar particle , the higgs boson @xcite , which has not been discovered in collider experiments . over the last few years ,
higgsless models @xcite have emerged as a novel way of understanding the mechanism of ewsb without the presence of a scalar particle in the spectrum . in an extra dimensional context , these can be understood in terms of a @xmath1 gauge theory in the bulk of a finite @xmath2 spacetime @xcite , with symmetry breaking encoded in the boundary conditions of the gauge fields .
these models can be thought of as dual to technicolor models , in the language of the ads / cft correspondence @xcite .
one can understand the low energy properties of such theories in a purely four dimensional picture by invoking the idea of deconstruction @xcite .
the `` bulk '' of the extra dimension is then replaced by a chain of gauge groups strung together by non linear sigma model fields .
the spectrum typically includes extra sets of charged and neutral vector bosons and heavy fermions .
the unitarization of longitudinal @xmath3 boson scattering is accomplished by diagrams involving the exchange of the heavy gauge bosons @xcite , instead of a higgs .
a general analysis of higgsless models @xcite suggests that to satisfy the requirements of precision electroweak constraints , the sm fermions have to be ` delocalized ' into the bulk .
the particular kind of delocalization that helps satisfy the precision electroweak constraints , ideal fermion delocalization " @xcite , dictates that the light fermions be delocalized in such a way that they do not couple to the heavy charged gauge bosons . the simplest framework that captures all these ideas , a three site higgsless model , is presented in @xcite , where there is just one gauge group in the bulk and correspondingly , only one set of heavy vector bosons .
it was shown that the twin constraints of getting the correct value of the top quark mass and having an admissible @xmath4 parameter necessarily push the heavy fermion masses into the tev regime @xcite in that model . in this paper
, we seek to decouple these constraints by combining the higgsless mechanism with aspects of topcolor @xcite .
the goal is to separate the bulk of electroweak symmetry breaking from third family mass generation . in this way
, one can obtain a massive top quark and heavy fermions in the sub tev region , without altering tree level electroweak predictions . in an attempt to present a minimal model with these features ,
we modify the three site model by adding a `` top higgs '' field , @xmath5 that couples preferentially to the top quark .
the resulting model is shown in moose notation @xcite in figure 1 ; we will refer to it as the `` top triangle moose '' to distinguish it from other three - site ring models in the literature in which all of the links are non - linear sigmal models , such as the ring model explored in @xcite or bess @xcite and hidden local symmetry @xcite theories .
the idea of a top higgs is motivated by top condensation models , ranging from the top mode standard model @xcite to topcolor assisted technicolor@xcite , to the top quark seesaw @xcite to bosonic topcolor @xcite .
the specific framework constructed here is most closely aligned with topcolor assisted technicolor theories @xcite in which ewsb occurs via technicolor interactions while the top mass has a dynamical component arising from topcolor interactions and a small component generated by an extended technicolor mechanism .
the dynamical bound state arising from topcolor dynamics can be identified as a composite top higgs field , and the low - energy spectrum includes a top higgs boson . the extra link in our triangle moose that corresponds to the top higgs field results in the presence of uneaten goldstone bosons , the top pions , which couple preferentially to the third generation .
the model can thus be thought of as the deconstructed version of a topcolor assisted technicolor model .
we start by presenting the model in section ii , and describing the electroweak sector .
the gauge sector is the same as in bess @xcite or hidden local symmetry @xcite theories , while the fermion sector is generalized from that of the three site model @xcite and the symmetry - breaking sector resembles that of topcolor - assisted technicolor @xcite . in section iii , we compute the masses and wave functions of the gauge bosons and describe the limits in which we work .
we then move on to consider the fermionic sector in section iv . here
, we also explain how the ideal delocalization condition works for the light fermions . in section
v , we compute the couplings of the fermions to the charged and neutral gauge bosons . in section
vi , the top quark sector is presented .
after calculating the mass of the top quark , we describe how the top quark is delocalized in this model by looking at the tree level value of the @xmath6 coupling . in section vii
, we carry out the detailed collider phenomenology of the heavy @xmath7 and @xmath8 quarks . after comparing our phenomenological analysis with others in the literature in section viii ,
we present our conclusions in section ix .
before we present the details of our model , we recall the essential features of the closely related three site model that @xcite pertain to the heavy fermion mass .
the three site model is a maximally deconstructed version of a higgsless extra dimensional model , with only one extra @xmath9 gauge group , as compared to the sm .
thus , there are three extra gauge bosons , which contribute to unitarizing the @xmath10 scattering in place of a higgs .
the lhc phenomenology of these extra vector bosons is discussed in @xcite .
also incorporated in the three site model is a heavy dirac partner for every sm fermion .
the presence of these new fermions , in particular , the heavy top and bottom quarks , gives rise to new one - loop contributions to @xmath0 , where @xmath4 is the ratio of the strengths of the low energy isotriplet neutral and charged current interactions .
precision measurements require @xmath0 to be @xmath11 and this constraint , along with the need to obtain the large top quark mass , pushes the heavy quark mass into the multi tev range , too high to be seen at the lhc .
we seek to reduce this tension by separating the top quark mass generation from the rest of electroweak symmetry breaking in this model , an approach motivated by top - color scenarios .
the electroweak gauge structure of our model is @xmath12 .
this is shown using moose notation @xcite in figure [ fig : triangle ] , in which the @xmath9 groups are associated with sites 0 and 1 , and the @xmath13 group is associated with site 2 .
is embedded as a gauged @xmath14 of @xmath9 see eqn .
( [ eq : sigma12d ] ) below . ] the sm fermions deriving their @xmath9 charges mostly from site 0 ( which is most closely associated with the sm @xmath9 ) and the bulk fermions mostly from site 1 . the extended electroweak gauge structure of the theory is the same as that of the bess models @xcite , motivated by models of hidden local symmetry ( with @xmath15 ) @xcite .
gauge structure of the model in moose notation @xcite .
the @xmath9 coupling @xmath16 and @xmath13 coupling @xmath17 of sites 0 and 2 are approximately the sm @xmath9 and hypercharge gauge couplings , while the @xmath9 coupling @xmath18 represents the bulk gauge coupling .
the left ( right ) handed light fermions are mostly localized at site 0 ( 2 ) while their heavy counterparts are mostly at site 1 .
the links connecting sites 0 and 1 and sites 1 and 2 are non linear sigma model fields while the one connecting sites 0 and 2 is a linear sigma field . , width=192 ] the non linear sigma field @xmath19 is responsible for breaking the @xmath20 gauge symmetry down to @xmath9 , and field @xmath21 is responsible for breaking @xmath22 down to @xmath13 .
the left handed fermions are @xmath9 doublets residing at sites 0 ( @xmath23 ) and 1 ( @xmath24 ) , while the right handed fermions are a doublet under @xmath25(@xmath26 ) and two @xmath9-singlet fermions at site 2 ( @xmath27 and @xmath28 ) .
the fermions @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath26 have @xmath13 charges ( @xmath29 ) typical of the left - handed @xmath9 doublets in the sm , @xmath30 for quarks and @xmath31 for leptons .
similarly , the fermion @xmath27 has a @xmath13 charge typical for the right - handed up - quarks ( @xmath32 ) and @xmath28 has the @xmath13 charge typical for the right - handed down - quarks ( @xmath33 ) ; the right - handed leptons would , likewise , have @xmath13 charges corresponding to their sm hypercharge values . also , the the third component of isospin , @xmath34 , takes values @xmath35 for `` up '' type fermions and @xmath31 for `` down '' type fermions , just like in the sm .
the electric charge assignment follows the relation @xmath36 .
the fermion charge assignments of the quarks are summarized in table [ tab : chargeswredux ] ; leptons follow a similar pattern .
.electroweak charge assignments of the quarks .
leptons follow a similar pattern . [
tab : chargeswredux ] [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] the leptonic @xmath3 decay introduces the usual two fold ambiguity in determining the neutrino momentum and hence , we have performed a transverse mass analysis of the process , defining the transverse mass variable @xcite of interest as : @xmath37 we expect the distribution to fall sharply at @xmath38 in the narrow width approximation , and indeed we find that there are typically few or no events beyond @xmath39 gev in the distributions ( see figure [ fig : single distributions ] ) .
thus , we take the signal events to be those in the transverse mass window : @xmath40 we show a contour plot of the number of signal events for an intergrated luminosity of 100 @xmath41 in figure ( [ fig : single - events ] ) .
it is seen that there are no events in the @xmath42 region because we require the heavy quarks to decay to @xmath43 .
also , in the region of interest , one can see that there is an appreciable number of events . for an integrated luminosity of 100
@xmath44 the shaded region is where @xmath45 and is non perturbative .
one can see there is a considerable number of events in the low @xmath46 region of the parameter space , width=288 ] the sm background for this process , @xmath47 , was calculated summing over the @xmath48 @xmath49 @xmath50 , @xmath51 and gluon jets and the first two families of leptons . since we apply a strong @xmath52 cut on only one of the jets ( unlike in the pair production case ) , there is a non zero sm background .
we show the sm transverse mass distribution in figure [ fig : sm - wzjj ] . , calculated by summing over the @xmath48 @xmath49 @xmath50 , @xmath51 and gluon jets and the first two families of leptons .
the bin size is 20 gev .
, width=384 ] the luminosity necessary for a @xmath53 discovery at 95% c.l . can be calculated by requiring @xmath54 , as per a gaussian distribution .
it is instructive to look at the results of this analysis by combining it with the previous pair production case , as the two cover the @xmath55 and @xmath56 regions of the @xmath57 parameter space respectively .
thus , we present a combined plot of the required luminosity for a @xmath53 discovery of these heavy vector quarks ( at 95% c.l . ) at the lhc in figure ( [ fig : luminosity plot ] ) .
discovery of the heavy vector fermions at the lhc in the single ( blue curves , nearly horizontal ) and pair ( red curves , nearly verticle ) production channels .
the shaded portion is non perturbative and not included in the study .
it is seen that the two channels are complementary to one another and allow almost the entire region to be covered in 300 @xmath44 , width=288 ] one can see that almost the entire parameter space is covered , with the pair and single production channels nicely complementing each other . before we conclude , however , we would like to comment briefly on how our analysis compares with other models with vector quarks .
there are many other theories that feature heavy quarks with vector like couplings , as in the present model . in this section
, we would like to briefly explain how our phenomenological analysis compares with these .
one important feature of deconstructed higgsless models of the kind discussed in this paper is ideal fermion delocalization , which does not allow the heavy charged gauge bosons in the theory to couple to two standard model fermions .
this constrains the @xmath43 to decay only to @xmath3 and @xmath58 , thus providing a tool to distinguish this class of models from others .
there are , however , certain features of this model that are generic , like the vector nature of the heavy quark couplings . in the context of little higgs models
@xcite , there have been studies of the lhc phenomenology of the t - odd heavy quarks @xcite .
the cross sections for the production of heavy t - quark pairs are comparable to the ones in our study . however , in those models , the heavy t - quark necessarily decays to a heavy photon ( due to constraints of conserving t parity ) .
also , in @xcite , the authors study the pair production of heavy partners of the 1st and 2nd generation quarks in the context of the littlest higgs models @xcite .
they consider decays exclusively to the heavy gauge bosons in the theory , which then decay to the standard model gauge bosons plus a heavy photon .
thus , the final state , though still @xmath59 , is kinematically different . in particular , strong cuts on the missing energy are now an important part of the analysis , because part of @xmath60 is due to the heavy photons .
ref.@xcite presents a comprehensive study of the production and decay of heavy quarks by separating out the partners of the 3rd generation from the others and analysing them separately .
the authors let the heavy quark decay to a sm @xmath3 boson and a light quark , but in their analysis , they neglect the mass of the @xmath3 boson compared to its momentum ( since it is highly boosted ) . thus , when the @xmath3 decays to a @xmath61 pair , the direction of the neutrino momentum can be approximated to be parallel to that of the charged lepton , which enables them to recontruct the full neutrino momentum and create an invariant mass peak for the heavy quark ( as opposed to a transverse mass analysis ) . clearly , the final states and/or kinematics in all of these analyses differ significantly from those considered in our analysis .
in the context of the three site model , the authors of @xcite consider the single production of the heavy top quark .
as mentioned before , the heavy top in this model is necessarily around a few tev s and the paper concludes that the most viable channel for detection at the lhc is the subprocess @xmath62 with the @xmath3 decaying leptonically . we have not yet studied heavy top or top - pion phenomenology in our model . ref .
@xcite presents a model independent analysis of the discovery prospects of heavy quarks at the tevatron .
the authors write down generic charged and neutral current interactions mixing the heavy and the light fermions and proceed to analyze both the pair and single production of these heavy quarks , with decays to the sm gauge bosons .
understandably , the tevatron reach is much lower than that of the lhc .
higgsless models have emerged as an alternative to the standard model in explaining the mechanism of electroweak symmetry breaking .
these theories use boundary conditions to break gauge symmetries and can be understood in terms of four dimensional gauge theories via the process of deconstruction . a minimal model along these lines
was recently presented @xcite , which employed just three sites .
a natural feature of this model was the presence of partners to the sm fermions whose masses were of the order of a few tev or more , because of the twin constraints of getting the top quark mass right and having the @xmath4 parameter under experimental bounds . in this paper
, we presented a minimal extension of the three site model that incorporates both higgsless and top - color mechanisms .
the model singles out top quark mass generation as arising from a yukawa coupling to an effective top - higgs , which develops a small vacuum expectation value , while electroweak symmetry breaking results largely from a higgsless mechanism .
an interesting consequence is that there is no longer a conflict between the need to obtain a realistically large value for the top quark mass and the need to keep @xmath0 small enough to conform to experiment . as a result ,
in this model it is possible to have additional vector - like quarks in the model that are light enough to be discovered at the lhc , without affecting the tree level couplings of the three site model too much .
we encoded the model in calchep and analyzed the phenomenology of the heavy quarks .
we first considered pair production ( @xmath63 ) of these heavy fermions .
we found that the 5@xmath64 reach of the pair production channel was @xmath65 1 tev , with the maximum reach in the region where @xmath66 where the heavy quark must decay to a @xmath3 or @xmath58 .
the single production channel ( @xmath67 ) complements this nicely because we can study the decay of the heavy quark to a @xmath43 , and hence are necessarily in the region @xmath55 . by combining both these analyses
, we were able to cover most of the @xmath68 parameter space .
we conclude that the reach at the lhc for a 5@xmath64 discovery at 95% c.l . of the vector quarks in this theory
can be as high as 1.2 tev for an appropriate choice of @xmath46 .
other components of the theory with potentially interesting phenomenology are the heavy partners of the @xmath69 and @xmath70 quarks and the uneaten top pions that arise from the extra link in the moose diagram ( figure 1 ) and couple preferentially to the third generation .
the phenomenology of these states is currently under investigation .
this work was supported in part by the us national science foundation under grant phy-0354226 .
bc acknowledges chuan - ren chen for useful discussions during the initial stages of this project .
ndc would like to thank james linnemann and james kraus for helpful discussions during the final stages of this project .
rsc and ehs gratefully acknowledge the hospitality and support of the aspen center for physics where some of this work was completed .
all the feynman diagrams in this paper were generated using jaxodraw @xcite .
r. casalbuoni , s. de curtis , d. dolce and d. dominici , phys .
d * 71 * , 075015 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0502209 ] .
r. foadi , and c. schmidt , _ an effective higgsless theory : _ phys .
d * 73 * ( 2006 ) 075011 [ arxiv : hep - ph/0509071 ] .
belyaev , r.s .
chivukula , n.d .
christensen , h .- j .
he , m. kurachi , e.h .
simmons , and m. tanabashi , _
@xmath71 scattering in higgsless models : identifying better effective theories _
, in preparation .
june 2009 .
y. nambu , proc .
workshop on new trends in strong coupling gauge theories , nagoya , japan , aug 24 - 27 , 2988 .
v. a. miransky , m. tanabashi and k. yamawaki , phys .
b * 221 * , 177 ( 1989 ) .
v. a. miransky , m. tanabashi and k. yamawaki , mod .
lett . a * 4 * , 1043 ( 1989 ) .
w. j. marciano , phys .
d * 41 * , 219 ( 1990 ) .
w. a. bardeen , c. t. hill and m. lindner , phys .
d * 41 * , 1647 ( 1990 ) .
w. j. marciano , phys .
lett . *
62 * , 2793 ( 1989 ) .
m. b. popovic and e. h. simmons , phys .
d * 58 * , 095007 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9806287 ] .
f. braam , m. flossdorf , r. s. chivukula , s. di chiara and e. h. simmons , phys .
rev . * 77 * , 055005 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0711.1127 [ hep - ph ] ] .
b. a. dobrescu and c. t. hill , phys .
lett . *
81 * , 2634 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9712319 ] .
r. s. chivukula , b. a. dobrescu , h. georgi , and c. t. hill , phys .
d * 59 * : 075003 ( 1999 ) [ hep - ph/9809470 ] .
hong - jian he , yu - ping kuang , yong - hui qi , bin zhang , alexander belyaev , r.sekhar chivukula , neil d. christensen , alexander pukhov and elizabeth h. simmons , _ phys .
rev . _ * d78 * , 031701 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : 0708.2588 [ hep - ph ] ] . n. arkani - hamed , a. g. cohen , and h. georgi , phys .
* b 513 * , 232 ( 2001 ) ; for reviews , see , for example , m. schmaltz and d. tucker smith , ann .
nucl . part .
sci . * 55 * , 229 ( 2005 ) ; m. perelstein , prog . part .
* 58 * , 247 ( 2007 ) and references within . | we present the details of a deconstructed model that incorporates both higgsless and top - color mechanisms .
the model alleviates the tension between obtaining the correct top quark mass and keeping @xmath0 small that exists in many higgsless models .
it does so by singling out the top quark mass generation as arising from a yukawa coupling to an effective top - higgs which develops a small vacuum expectation value , while electroweak symmetry breaking results largely from a higgsless mechanism . as a result ,
the heavy partners of the sm fermions can be light enough to be seen at the lhc .
after presenting the model , we detail the phenomenology , showing that for a broad range of masses , these heavy fermions are discoverable at the lhc . |
there are a few actual problems of nuclear and particle physics which are concerning subject of this report@xcite-@xcite .
these are following : in - medium modification of hadrons , the origin of hadron masses , the restoration of chiral symmetry , the confinement of quarks in hadrons , the structure of neutron stars .
strange multi - baryonic clusters are an exiting possibility to explore the properties of cold dense baryonic matter and non - perturbative qcd .
multi - quark states , glueballs and hybrids have been searched for experimentally for a very long time , but none is established
the full experimental information of more than 700000 stereo photographs are used to select of events by @xmath15 [email protected] momentum resolution charged particles are found to be @xmath162.1 % for stopped particles and @xmath17=9.8 % , for nonstopped particles .
the mean values of measurement errors for the depth and azimuthal angles are equal to @xmath180.5 degrees .
the masses of the identified 8657-events with @xmath19 hyperon 4122-events with @xmath20 meson are consistent with their pdg [email protected] experimental total cross sections are equal to 13.3 and 4.6 mb for @xmath19 and @xmath20 production in the p+c collisions at 10 gev / c .
protons can be identified by relative ionazation over the following momentum range : 0.150@xmath21 0.900 gev / c .
the background has been obtained by methods : polynomial function , mixing angle and by fritiof model @xcite .
the statistical significance of resonance peaks were calculated as np /@xmath22
, where nb is the number of counts in the background under the peak and np is the number of counts in the peak above background .
the @xmath25- effective mass distribution for all 15444 combinations with bin size of 13 mev/@xmath12 in fig.[lpi]a has shown@xcite-@xcite . the resonance with similar decay properties for @xmath26 identified which was a good test for this method .
the decay width is equal to @xmath27 45 mev/@xmath12 .
@xmath28 in range of @xmath29 invariant mass . the cross section of @xmath29 production ( 540 exp .
events ) is approximately equal to 0.9 mb for p+c interaction .
the @xmath30- effective mass distribution for all 6730 combinations with bin sizes of 18 and 12 mev/@xmath12 in fig.[lpi]b,[lp]a has shown .
the solid curve(fig.[lpi]b ) is the sum of the background ( by the polynomial method ) and 1 breit - wigner resonance(@xmath31 ) .
there is significant enhancement in the mass range of 1372 mev/@xmath12 with 11.3 s.d.,@xmath32 = 93 mev/@xmath12 .
the cross section of @xmath33 production ( @xmath14680 events ) is equal to @xmath14 1.3 mb at 10 gev / c for p+c interaction .
the width for @xmath33 observed @xmath142 times larger than pdg value .
one of possible explanation is nuclear medium effects on invariant mass spectra of hadrons decaying in nuclei@xcite .
figure [ lp]a shows @xmath30 effective mass distribution with bin size of 12 mev/@xmath12 , where there are significant enhancements in mass regions of 1345(3.0 s.d . ) and 1480(3.2 ) too .
the solid curve(fig.[lp]a ) is the sum of the background and 1 breit - wigner resonance ( @xmath34 ) .
the background ( dashed ) curve is the sum of the six -order polynomial and 1 breit - wigner function with parameters for identified resonance @xmath33(1385)(fig.[lpi]b ) .
there are negligible enhancements in mass regions of 1410 , 1520 and 1600 mev/@xmath12 .
the cross section of @xmath13- production ( @xmath1460 events ) stopped in nuclear medium is equal to 315 @xmath35b at 10 gev / c for p+propane interaction .
the observed number events with @xmath13 by weak decay channel is equal to 8 ( w=1/@xmath36 = 5.3 , where is a full geometrical weight of registered for @xmath19s)@xcite.then experimental cross section for identified @xmath13 by weak decay channel@xcite is equal to 44@xmath35b and 11.7@xmath35b in p+propane and p+c collisions , respectively , which are conformed with fritiof calculation .
the observed experimental cross section for stopped @xmath13(60 events ) is 8 times larger than the cross section which is obtained by fritiof model with same experimental conditions .
the width of @xmath10 for p+a reaction is two time larger than that presented in pdg.figures shows that there is observed @xmath33(1480 ) correlation which is agreed with report from svd2 collaboration too .
figure [ lp]b ) shows the invariant mass for all @xmath39 13103 combinations with bin size of 15 mev/@xmath40 ( @xcite ) .
there are enhancements in mass regions of 2100 , 2150 , 2225 and 2353 mev/@xmath12(fig.[lp]b ) .
there are many published articles@xcite-@xcitefor the ( @xmath2)invariant mass with identified protons in momentum range of 0.350@xmath41 0.900 gev / c .
there are significant enhancements in mass regions of 2100 , 2175 , 2285 and 2353 mev/@xmath12.their excess above background by the second method is 6.9 , 4.9 , 3.8 and 2.9 s.d .
, respectively .
there is also a small peak in 2225 ( 2.2 s.d . )
mev/@xmath12 mass region .
figure [ lp]c shows the invariant mass of 4011(@xmath39)combinations with bin size 15 mev/@xmath40 for stopped protons in momentum range of 0.14@xmath41 0.30 gev / c.the dashed curve is the sum of the 8-order polynomial and 4 breit - wigner curves with @xmath42 from fits(table [ reslp ] ) .
a significant peak at invariant mass 2220 mev/@xmath12 ( 6.1 s.d . ) , @xmath43 120 mev was specially stressed by professor t. yamazaki on @xmath35cf2007 , dubna , june-19 - 2007 that is conform with knc model@xcite prediction by channel of @xmath44p . the @xmath2 effective mass distribution for 2025 combinations with relativistic protons over a momentum of p @xmath451.65 gev / c is shown in figure [ lp]d .
the solid curve is the 6-order polynomial function(@xmath46/n.d.f=205/73 ) .
there are significant enhancements in mass regions of 2155(2.6 s.d . ) , 2225(4.7 s.d . , with @xmath32=23 mev/@xmath12 ) , 2280(4.2 s.d . ) , 2363(3.6 s.d . ) and 2650 mev / c@xmath47(3.7 s.d . ) . these observed peaks for combinations with relativistic protons p @xmath451.65 gev / c agreed with peaks for combination with identified protons and with stopped protons(table [ reslp ] ) . the @xmath48 effective mass distribution for 3401 combinations for identified protons with a momentum of @xmath490.9 gev / c is shown in figure [ lpp]a)@xcite-@xcite
the solid curve is the 6-order polynomial function(@xmath46/n.d.f=245/58 , fig.[lpp]a ) .
the backgrounds for analysis of the experimental data are based on fritiof and the polynomial method .
there is significant enhancements in mass regions of 3145 mev/@xmath12(6.1 s.d . ) and with width 40 mev/@xmath12 .
there are small enhancements in mass regions of 3225(3.3 s.d . ) , 3325(5.1 s.d . ) , 3440(3.9 s.d ) and 3652mev/@xmath12(2.6 s.d.)(table [ reslp ] ) .
these peaks from @xmath2 and @xmath3 spectra were partly conformed with experimental results from fopi(gsi ) , finuda(infn ) , obelix(cern ) and e471(kek ) .
there is observed significant enhancement in mass region of 2360(4.5 s.d . )
mev/@xmath12 for @xmath50 spectrum in figure [ lpp]b)(137 combination ) .
this peak is conformed with theoretical predictions and with earlier published result from neutron exposure by pbc method with very poor statistics too .
there is small enhancement in mass range of 2525 mev/@xmath12(3.0 s.d . )
too(table [ reslp ] ) .
the ( @xmath52 ) effective mass distribution ( fig . [ lpipi]c ) for 2975 combinations for identified protons in momentum range of p @xmath530.9 gev / c can taken by the 6-order polynomial function which is satisfactory described the experimental data with @xmath54=1 .
but the background by fritiof model do not describe the experimental distribution .
the sum of bw ( with mass 2520 mev/@xmath12 and experimental width 280 mev/@xmath12 ) and fritiof model for @xmath55 effective mass distribution is satisfactory described the experimental data too .
therefore one of probably interpretation of this peak that it can be reflection from phase space distribution too .
earlier published result about observation of resonance with mass 2495 mev/@xmath12 and width 200 mev/@xmath12 for @xmath55 spectrum by pbc method for neutron exposure(7 gev / c ) is not uniquely conformed .
the @xmath57 effective mass distribution for all 3476 combinations with bin size 36 mev/@xmath12 has shown in figure [ lpp]d .
the dashed curve is the the background by the polynomial method.there are significant enhancement in mass region of @xmath58(1600)(5.5 s.d .
, @xmath59=80 mev/@xmath12,@xmath60=25 mev/@xmath12 ) with width 55 ( from pdg ) .
there are small enhancements in mass regions of @xmath61(1520)(3.5 s.d.),@xmath61(1690)(3.8 s.d . ) and @xmath61(1800)(2.8 s.d . )
mev/@xmath12 which are interpreted as a reflection from resonances of @xmath61(1520 ) , @xmath61(1690 ) and @xmath61(1800 ) from pdg .
there are not observed exotic states which were earlier observed and published for @xmath62 spectrum ( in mass ranges of 1704,2071,2604 mev/@xmath12)with small statistic in neutron exposure by pbc method(shakh ) .
@xmath63the invariant mass of @xmath25 , @xmath57 and @xmath64 spectra has observed well known resonances from pdg as @xmath7(1385),@xmath65 and @xmath9 ( 892 ) which are a good test for this method .
+ @xmath63 a number of important peculiarities were observed in pa @xmath66 x reactions in the effective mass spectrum for exotic states with decay modes ( table [ reslp])@xcite-@xcite : 1 ) @xmath67 and @xmath68 .
+ @xmath63 particulary peaks for @xmath69 and @xmath70 spectra are agreed with experimental data from the reports of fopi , e471(kek ) , obelix , finuda collaborations , but there are some inconstancy by widths .
the work was partly supported by the grant of rfbr 07 - 02 - 08644 and org .
committee of international conference hadron , frascati , infn , 8 - 12 october , 2007 .
99 t.yamazaki , y.akaishi,phys.lett .
t.yamazaki , y.akaishi,phys.lett .
b453,p.p.1 - 6,1999 . b.a .
shahbazian et al . , nucl .
physics , a374(1982),p .
m. agnello et al . , phys .
94 , 212303 ( 2005 ) .
m. agnello et al . , arxiv : 0708.3614v1 ( 2007 ) .
t. suzuki et al . , phys.lett .
b 597 , 263 ( 2004 ) . m. iwasaki et al . , arxiv : nucl - ex/0310018v2.t .
suzuki et al . , arxiv : 0709.0996v2 .
n. herrmann , proceedings exa05 ( 2006 ) .
g. bendiscioli et al . ,
phys . a 789 , 222 ( 2007 ) .
aslanyan et al.,phys . of part .
and nuclei letters , vol .
4 , no . 1,pp .
99 - 108 , 2007 .
jinr commun.,e1 - 2005 - 150 , 2005 .
aslanyan , jinr commun.,e-2001 - 265,2002 . p.z .
aslanyan et al . , proc .
conf . on leap05,may 16 - 22 , bonn , 2005 ; aip , v .
796 , p.195 , isbn 0 - 7354 - 0284 - 1 .
aslanyan et al.,physics of particles and nuclei letters , vol .
3 , no . 5,pp .
331 - 334 , 2006.jinr commun.,e1 - 2005 - 149 , 2005 .
aslanyan et .
al . , proc .
xviii ishepp , dubna , september 25 - 30 , 2006 .
, spin06 , october 2 - 7 , kyoto , japan 2006 , isbn 978 - 0 - 7354 - 0423 - 6,aip , v.915.arxiv:hep-ex/0610086v1 .
aslanyan , proc .
iutp07,schladming , austria , 25 - 3 march , 2007 .
aslanyan , proc . on int .
confereence hadron structure , bratislava , 2 - 8 sepember,2007 ; arxiv : hep / ex-0710.4322v2 . | experimental data as a stereo photographs from the 2 m propane bubble chamber lhe , jinr have been analyzed for exotic multibaryon metastable and stable states searches .
a number of peculiarities were found in the effective mass spectra of : 1)@xmath0,@xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4,@xmath5 and @xmath6 subsystems .
the observed well known @xmath7(1385),@xmath8 and @xmath9(892)resonances are good tests for this method . the width of @xmath10 for p+a reaction is two time larger than that presented in pdg . the @xmath11 spectrum observed enhancement in mass range of 1345 mev/@xmath12 which interpreted as a stopped in nucleus @xmath13 .
the cross section of stopped @xmath13 production is @xmath14 8 times larger than obtained by fritiof model with same experimental conditions .
= 11.6pt |
recently @xcite an approach was established to study the ground state properties of algebraic hamiltonians .
this approach follows closely the algorithm established in @xcite . in particular , the approach was applied to describe the ground state of even even nuclei within the interacting boson model @xcite . in quantum optics ,
the procedure was used to determine the phase diagrams of the transitions between the normal regime to the super - radiant behavior of the ground states of two- and three - level systems interacting with a one - mode radiation field @xcite .
this approach evaluates the mean value of the hamiltonian with respect to variational test coherent states associated to the corresponding algebraic structures of the hamiltonian .
there exists a tomographic approach , which also uses mean values of density operators in an ensemble of bases to get information on the state of the system @xcite . for continuous variables ,
the tomographic approach has been introduced in @xcite in the form of optical tomography .
the symplectic tomography is established in @xcite , and a recent review of these tomograms is given in @xcite .
the discrete spin tomography has been introduced in @xcite , while the kernel for product of spin tomograms is presented in @xcite .
the squeezed tomography is discussed in @xcite , which is a fair probability distribution of a discrete random variable .
one of the aims of this work is to extend the approach mentioned above to have information of the complete energy spectrum by considering the mean values of the hamiltonian with respect to extremal density matrices @xcite .
this is achieved by writing the mean value of the hamiltonian as a function of the variables of a general finite - dimensional density matrix @xcite together with the parameters of the hamiltonian . to guarantee the positivity of the density matrix
, we need to include @xmath2 parameters related to the purity of the density matrix @xcite .
another goal of this work is to obtain new inequalities connecting entropy and mean value of energy for this qudit system .
we show that there exists a bound for the sum of energy and entropy determined by the partition function taken for a particular value of its argument .
the method to obtain these inequalities is based on known property of positivity of the relative entropy involving two density matrices of the system states @xcite .
analogous mathematical inequalities have been discussed in @xcite .
the results obtained are valid for generic quantum states ( qudits ) .
the main contribution of our work is to demonstrate the new approach related to the determination of the extremal points of mean values of the hamiltonian by considering a general parametrization of the density matrices for qudit systems and to test the new entropy energy inequality .
this inequality contains the bound determined by the partition function @xcite .
the formulated results can be generalized to study the relations between the entropy and an arbitrary hermitian operator describing an observable .
the hamiltonian operator @xmath3 can be expanded in terms of the set of operators @xmath4 that form a basis of @xmath5 and the identity operator @xmath6 as follows @xcite : @xmath7 with the definitions @xmath8 and @xmath9 .
the generators of @xmath5 satisfy the relations @xmath10 they are completely characterized by means of the commutation and anticommutation relations given in terms of the symmetric and antisymmetric structure constants of the special unitary group in @xmath11 dimensions @xcite . in a similar form
, the density matrix can be expanded , i.e. , @xmath12 because tr@xmath13 , and in this case one defines @xmath14 our purpose is to find the extreme values for the @xmath15 variables of the density matrix by taking the expectation value of the hamiltonian operator . to guarantee the positivity of the density matrix ,
it is necessary to introduce @xmath2 parameters .
therefore , the extremes are obtained by means of the definition of a new function depending on @xmath16 variables with @xmath17 , @xmath18 lagrange multipliers with @xmath19 , @xmath20 parameters of the hamiltonian with @xmath21 , and @xmath22 real constants with @xmath23 characterizing the purity of the density matrix @xmath24 where @xmath25 are nonholonomic constrictions from the characteristic polynomial of @xmath26 , which can be obtained by means of the recursive relation @xcite @xmath27 where @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 .
the parameters @xmath31 are constants . to find the extrema
, we derive the function @xmath32 with respect to @xmath33 obtaining @xmath34 algebraic equations regarding the independent variables of the density matrix . then by substituting expressions ( [ eq : eq1 ] ) and ( [ eq : eq3 ] ) into ( [ eq : eq5 ] )
, one arrives at @xmath35 plus @xmath2 differential equations regarding lagrange multipliers @xmath36 with @xmath37 , @xmath38 , and we have used the properties of the generators @xmath39 of the unitary group in @xmath11 dimensions .
these sets of algebraic equations determine the extremal values of the density matrix , i.e. , @xmath40 and @xmath41 for which the expressions ( [ eq : eq7 ] ) and ( [ eq : eq8 ] ) are satisfied .
one has three generators @xmath39 with @xmath42 , which can be realized in terms of the pauli matrices .
therefore , the density matrix can be written in the form @xmath43 and similarly an arbitrary @xmath44 hamiltonian matrix is given by @xmath45 substituting the last expressions into eqs .
( [ eq : eq5 ] ) , we obtain @xmath46 yielding , by means of expressions ( [ eq : eq7 ] ) and ( [ eq : eq8 ] ) , the system of equations @xmath47 with @xmath48 and @xmath1 . solving this system of equations ,
one obtains the results @xmath49 with @xmath50 and we defined the parameters @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
therefore , we have two solutions and substituting them into the expression for the density matrix , we obtain @xmath53 therefore , the extremal density matrices depend on the parameter @xmath54 whose value is bounded , @xmath55 and , if the density matrix represents a pure or a mixed state , it is determined . for @xmath56 , one has that @xmath57 and the extremal density matrix takes the form @xmath58 corresponding to a mixed state with maximum entropy with the expectation value of the hamiltonian given by @xmath59 . for @xmath60 , one gets @xmath61 and the expectation values of the hamiltonian are given by @xmath62 which corresponds exactly to the eigenvalues of the arbitrary matrix hamiltonian in ( [ eq : eq9b ] ) .
the corresponding pure states are given by the density matrices in eq .
( [ eq : eq15 ] ) replacing the value of the parameter @xmath61 .
they are orthogonal projectors as it can be proved by multiplying the corresponding density matrices and taking the trace operation .
therefore , we have reconstructed the hamiltonian matrix by finding the extremal values of the expectation value of the hamiltonian . in fig .
[ fig1 ] , we plot the general behavior of the expectation value of a given hamiltonian operator @xmath3 as a function of the parameter @xmath54 . notice that if @xmath63 , the mean values of the energy with respect to mixed states are close to the maximum and minimum values of the energy spectra .
additionally , we can observe that for each value of @xmath54 there are two solutions for the expectation values of the hamiltonian , except when @xmath56 , where one gets only one expectation value associated to the mixed state with maximum entropy .
expectation value of the two - level - atom hamiltonian as a function of @xmath54 , with @xmath64 , @xmath65 , @xmath66 , and @xmath67 . ]
this procedure gives the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the hamiltonian and besides one gets information on the mean values associated to mixed states , as function of @xmath54 .
we consider a particular hamiltonian describing a two - mode bose
einstein condensate @xcite , @xmath69 where @xmath70 denotes the @xmath71-th component of the angular momentum operator .
the parameter @xmath72 corresponds to the difference in the chemical potentials between the wells , @xmath73 represents the atom atom interaction , and @xmath74 is related to the atom tunneling parameter . for the qutrit case ,
one substitutes the three - dimensional representation of the angular momentum operators , and the generators @xmath75 , with @xmath76 can be realized in terms of the gell - mann matrices .
thus , an arbitrary density matrix is denoted by @xmath77 and one has a similar expression for the hamiltonian .
comparing with the @xmath78 angular momentum representation , one obtains that the parameters different from zero are @xmath79 substituting the previous expressions for the density matrix and the hamiltonian into eq .
( [ eq : eq5 ] ) , we obtain the function @xmath80 in the form @xmath81 where we define @xmath82 .
the extrema of the previous function with respect to @xmath83 , are obtained numerically by establishing different values of the set of parameters @xmath84 .
notice that the @xmath54 and @xmath85 are not independent parameters , and they are keeping track of the purity of the extremal density matrices .
if we define @xmath86 and @xmath87 , then following @xcite , it is straightforward to get the compatible region of the parameters @xmath88 and @xmath89 . for the set @xmath90
, one gets the extremal density matrix , @xmath91 , for the mixed state with maximum entropy and @xmath92 . to illustrate the procedure , we consider three different choices of the mentioned set of parameters .
the obtained expectation values of the hamiltonian are plotted in fig .
[ fig2 ] as functions of @xmath72 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 .
the pure states are associated to @xmath93 , and we find that there are @xmath1 extremal solutions for the parameters of the density matrix which are indicated by black continuous lines .
comparing these different mean values of the hamiltonian with the corresponding exact diagonalizations , one finds a complete agreement with the energy spectra . for @xmath54 and @xmath85 different from zero ,
additionally one gets information on the mean values of the energy .
we obtain in this case that the number of mean values of mixed states is related to the symmetric group of @xmath1 dimensions ; thus , for @xmath94 , there are @xmath95 colored continuous lines indicating the expectation values of the hamiltonian of the possible mixed states . +
it is known @xcite that for two given density matrices @xmath96 and @xmath97 , the positivity condition for their relative entropy is given by @xmath98 the matrices @xmath96 and @xmath97 satisfy the properties @xmath99 , @xmath100 , @xmath101 , @xmath102 and @xmath103 .
on the other hand , two arbitrary matrices which have these properties satisfy inequality ( [ eq : eq25 ] ) .
we are going to use this inequality considering the hamiltonian matrix @xmath104 of a qudit system , by defining the matrix @xmath105 which has the properties tr @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
let us write the positivity conditions of relative entropy of two matrices @xmath96 and @xmath108 @xmath109 using the definition of the von neumann entropy @xmath110 associated with the density matrix of the state , which reads @xmath111 , one can rewrite inequality ( [ eq : eq28 ] ) in the form @xmath112 where the mean energy is given by @xmath113 . for an arbitrary hamiltonian @xmath104 ,
one introduces the partition function @xmath114 where @xmath115 is interpreted as a temperature , and the matrix @xmath116 can be interpreted as the density matrix of the system in thermal equilibrium state .
it is known that the partition function @xmath117 determines all thermodynamic properties of the system ( cf .
@xcite ) . then inequality ( [ eq : eq30 ] ) can be rewritten in the form @xmath118 thus , we got for an arbitrary quantum system a bound for the sum of the mean energy value and the von neumann entropy , and this bound is determined by the partition function evaluated in a particular value of temperature , @xmath119 .
for example , for a two - level atom in the state determined by the density matrix given in eq .
( [ eq : eq9a ] ) with the condition @xmath120 , and the hamiltonian matrix given in eq .
( [ eq : eq9b ] ) , inequality ( [ eq : eq33 ] ) reads @xmath121 notice that the last expression is invariant under unitary transformations and thus one can write @xmath122 , where the energy levels @xmath123 and @xmath124 are the solutions of the secular equation @xmath125 . for any state , one has that the inequality ( [ eq : eq36 ] ) can be written as follows @xmath126 where we define the function @xmath127 in terms of @xmath128 and @xmath129 . by substituting the extremal parameters of the density matrix given in expression ( [ eq : eq11 ] ) the function @xmath127 takes the form @xmath130 where @xmath131 were defined after eq .
( [ eq : eq11 ] ) . this function
is displayed in fig .
[ fig33 ] as a function of the @xmath132 and @xmath133 .
notice that always it is larger than zero .
the corresponding contour levels are also positive .
the entropy energy inequality ( at the top ) and a contour level plot of this inequality as a function of @xmath133 and @xmath132 ( at the bottom).,title="fig : " ] + the entropy energy inequality ( at the top ) and a contour level plot of this inequality as a function of @xmath133 and @xmath132 ( at the bottom).,title="fig : " ] similar inequalities can be obtained for any hermitian operator , and the obtained result for the pauli matrix @xmath134 with @xmath135 , can be written in the form @xmath136 with @xmath137 .
for @xmath138 , the result is displayed in fig .
[ fig4 ] .
one can obtain another important inequality between the energy and the partition function by considering @xmath139 which can be written for any state @xmath96 in the form @xmath140 also inequality ( [ eq : eq33 ] ) is accompanied by the inequality @xmath141 , which means that the partition function provides the bound for the difference of entropy and energy .
the entropy and @xmath142 inequality ( at the top ) and a contour level plot of the inequality as a function of @xmath143 and @xmath132 ( at the bottom ) .
the expectation value of @xmath142 is evaluated with respect to one extremal density matrix of the general hamiltonian in the two dimensions .
, title="fig : " ] + the entropy and @xmath142 inequality ( at the top ) and a contour level plot of the inequality as a function of @xmath143 and @xmath132 ( at the bottom ) . the expectation value of @xmath142 is evaluated with respect to one extremal density matrix of the general hamiltonian in the two dimensions . ,
title="fig : " ]
we suggested to study the properties of a qudit system considering the mean values of its hamiltonian with respect to a generic density matrix , which includes the special cases of pure states .
the number of parameters which determine the mean values of the hamiltonian in this case is equal to the number of parameters determining the density matrix . due to this
, the information contained in the mean values of the hamiltonian is sufficient to reconstruct the hamiltonian , including both its spectrum and its eigenvectors .
we demonstrated how the hamiltonian spectrum is recovered finding all the extreme density operators which minimize the mean values of the hamiltonian .
the suggested approach for finding all the properties of the hamiltonian has common features with quantum tomography . in the quantum tomography approach
, one determines the density operator by making measures in all the reference frames of the information contained in its mean value .
therefore , the mean values are calculated for an ensemble of basis determined by sufficient number of parameters associated to unitary matrices transforming the density operator ( or equivalently , changing the basis where the means are calculated ) .
thus , we found that the description of the hamiltonian by the mean values approach and the description of density operators by tomographic approach have common features .
we demonstrated that for @xmath0 and 3 ; the hamiltonian spectrum is completely recovered using the mean value approach .
we surmise on the basis of the number of parameters of the test variational density matrix that the complete recovering of the spectrum takes place for arbitrary dimensions .
the previous conjecture is based in the following calculation : for pure states a test density matrix with 4 real parameters can be used and then one can get the exact energy spectrum of the system while with the extremal density matrices associated to the cs one has only approximate results for the energy levels .
the problem of the convenience of our approach in comparison with standard diagonalisation of the hamiltonian has to be clarified .
we point out that our approach can be applied to arbitrary hermitian matrices , i.e. , to arbitrary observables .
the known properties of density matrices and von neumann entropy were used to formulate and verify a new inequality for a qudit system between the energy and the entropy .
we mapped the hamiltonian matrix onto a density - like nonnegative matrix , and applied the property of nonnegativity of relative entropy connecting two density matrices . the obtained result for the sum ( difference ) of entropies and mean value of the hamiltonian
is that this sum ( difference ) is bound .
the bound is determined by the partition function evaluated at a specific value of its argument .
we verified the new inequality on an example of a qubit system .
the obtained result is valid for all the states , including entangled states of multi - qudit systems .
one can get analogous inequalities for other hermitian operators corresponding to physical observables . we will study this aspect of the inequalities in future publications .
this work was partially supported by conacyt - mxico and papiit - unam ( in110114 ) .
10 lpez - moreno e and castaos o , 1996 phys . rev .
c * 54 * 2374 .
castaos o , lpez - pea r , hirsch j g , and lpez - moreno e , 2005 phys .
b * 72 * 012406 .
castaos o , nahmad - achar e , lpez - pea r , and hirsch j g , 2011 phys .
a * 83 * 051601 .
cordero s , castaos o , lpez - pea r , and nahmad - achar e , + 2013 j. phys .
a : math . theor . * 46 * 505302 .
gilmore r 1979 j. math .
* 20 * 891 .
gilmore r 1981 _ catastrophe theory for scientists and engineers _ wiley ( new york ) .
bertrand j and bertrand d , 1987 found .
* 17 * 397 .
vogel k and risken h , 1989 phys .
a * 40 * 2847 .
mancini s , manko v i , and tombesi p , 1996 phys .
lett a * 213 * 1 .
ibort a , manko v i , marmo g , simoni a , and ventriglia f , 2009 phys .
* 79 * 065013 .
castaos o , lpez - pea r , manko m a , and manko v i , + 2004 phys . a : math
. gen . * 37 * 8529 .
dodonov v v and manko v i , 1997 phys .
a * 229 * 335 .
manko v i and manko o v , 1997 j. exp . theor .
phys . * 85 * 430 .
castaos o , lpez - pea r , manko m a , and manko v i , 2003 , j. phys . a : mat .
gen . * 36 * 4677 .
castaos o , lpez - pea r , manko m a , and manko v i , 2003 , j. j. opt .
b : semiclass . opt . * 5 * 227 .
landau l d , 1927 z. physik * 45 * 430 .
von neumann j , 1932 _ mathematische grundlagen der quantenmechanik _ , springer berlin .
t and sudarshan e c g , 2002 j. phys a : math .
gen . * 35 * 10467 .
kimura g , 2003 phys .
a * 314 * 339 .
byrd m s and khaneja n , 2003 phys .
a * 68 * 062322 .
jarlskog c , 2006 j. math .
phys . * 47 * 013507 .
brning e , mkel h , messina a , and petruccione f , 2012 j. mod
. opt . * 59 * 1
. akhtarshenas s j , 2006 opt .
spectrosc . * 103 * 411 .
nielsen m a , and chuang i l , 2010 _ quantum computation and quantum information _
, + cambridge university press .
chernega v n , manko o v , and manko v i , 2014 j. russ .
laser res . *
35 * 278 manko m a , and manko v i , 2014 phys .
* t160 * 014030 .
kubo r , 1965 statistical mechanics : _ an advanced course with problems and solutions _ , + elsevier science .
milburn g j , corney j , wright e w , and walls d f , 1997 phys
a * 55 * 4318 .
prez - campos c , gonzlez - alonso j r , castaos o , and lpez - pea r , + 2010 ann .
( n.y . ) * 325 * 325 .
gerdt v p , khvedlidze a m , and palii yu g , 2014 j. math .
sci . * 200 * 682 . | we establish a procedure to find the extremal density matrices for any finite hamiltonian of a qudit system .
these extremal density matrices provide an approximate description of the energy spectra of the hamiltonian . in the case of restricting the extremal density matrices by pure states ,
we show that the energy spectra of the hamiltonian is recovered for @xmath0 and @xmath1 .
we conjecture that by means of this approach the energy spectra can be recovered for the hamiltonian of an arbitrary finite qudit system . for a given qudit system hamiltonian , we find new inequalities connecting the mean value of the hamiltonian and the entropy of an arbitrary state . we demonstrate that these inequalities take place for both the considered extremal density matrices and generic ones . |
we present in this section the update of the unitarity triangle ( ut ) analysis within the standard model ( sm ) , performed by the utfit collaboration following the method described in refs .
the constraints used in the analysis can be distinguished in side and angle constraints , where the latter do not rely on theoretical calculations of hadronic matrix elements .
the side constraints come from the measurement of direct cp - violation in the kaon sector ( @xmath9 ) , of @xmath3 and @xmath5 mixing ( @xmath10 , @xmath11 ) and of semileptonic b decays ( @xmath12 ) .
the angle constraints are cp - violating measurements for the @xmath3-system , performed with high statistics at b - factories : @xmath13 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 , and @xmath17 . as shown in fig .
[ fig : sm_allconstr ] , the ckm matrix turns out to be consistently overconstraint .
the ckm parameters @xmath18 and @xmath19 result to be accurately determined : @xmath20 , @xmath21 @xcite . , @xmath22 @xcite . ]
the ut analysis has thus established that the ckm matrix is the dominant source of flavour mixing and cp - violation and that new physics ( np ) effects can at most represent a small correction to this picture .
-@xmath19 plane , including both angle and side measurements .
the closed contours at @xmath23% and @xmath24% probability are shown .
the full lines correspond to @xmath24% probability regions for the different constraints.__,title="fig : " ] + due to the redundant experimental constraints , interesting consistency checks can be performed by comparing various ut analyses where different constraints are used .
in particular , the ut analyses based on only angle ( utangle ) or only side ( utside ) constraints , shown in fig . [ fig : sm_anglevsside ] , provide well compatible results @xcite : @xmath25 , @xmath26 and @xmath27 , @xmath28 , respectively .
the @xmath29 difference between the two @xmath18 results is mainly a manifestation of the tension of the @xmath30 inclusive measurement , based on heavy quark effective theory parameters extracted from experimental fits with some model dependence , with the rest of the fit and with the @xmath30 exclusive measurement , relying on semileptonic form factors determined from lattice qcd or qcd sum rules .
in fact , the utangle analysis turns out provide an indirect determination of @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) that is in perfect agreement with the @xmath30 exclusive measurement ( @xmath32 ) , while the utside analysis uses in input the inclusive - exclusive average for @xmath30 that is @xmath33 higher than the utangle indirect determination @xcite . -@xmath19 plane , including only angle ( left ) or side ( right ) measurements .
the closed contours at @xmath23% and @xmath24% probability are shown .
the full lines correspond to @xmath24% probability regions for the different constraints . _ _ ] -@xmath19 plane , including only angle ( left ) or side ( right ) measurements .
the closed contours at @xmath23% and @xmath24% probability are shown .
the full lines correspond to @xmath24% probability regions for the different constraints . _
_ ] the ( overconstraint ) ut analysis also allows to extract some hadronic quantities that can be compared to the results of lattice qcd calculations @xcite .
this comparison is shown in table [ tab : lattice ] for the hadronic parameters describing mixing in the @xmath1- , @xmath3- and @xmath5-meson sectors .
the remarkable agreement between the lattice calculations and the indirect ut analysis determinations provides additional evidence of the sm success in describing flavour physics and of the reliability of lattice qcd calculations .
it is interesting to note that an improvement of the accuracy of the lattice determinations of @xmath34 and @xmath35 would be important to increase the precision of the ut analysis .
.__values of the hadronic parameters that describe @xmath1-@xmath2 and @xmath36-@xmath37 mixing : @xmath34 , @xmath38 and @xmath39 , as obtained from the ut analysis including angle and @xmath40 constraints , and from lattice qcd calculations @xcite . _ _ [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] v. lubicz and c. tarantino , nuovo cim . * 123b * ( 2008 ) 674 [ 0807.4605 [ hep - lat ] ] . m. bona _ et al . _ [ utfit collaboration ] , jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 080 [ hep - ph/0509219 ] .
m. bona _ et al . _
[ utfit collaboration ] , phys .
* 97 * ( 2006 ) 151803 [ hep - ph/0605213 ] .
m. bona _ et al . _
[ utfit collaboration ] , jhep * 0803 * ( 2008 ) 049 [ 0707.0636 [ hep - ph ] ] .
m. ciuchini , e. franco , d. guadagnoli , v. lubicz , m. pierini , v. porretti and l. silvestrini , phys .
b * 655 * ( 2007 ) 162 [ hep - ph/0703204 ] .
a. j. buras and d. guadagnoli , phys .
d * 78 * ( 2008 ) 033005 [ 0805.3887 [ hep - ph ] ] .
t. aaltonen _ et al .
_ [ cdf collaboration ] , phys . rev .
* 100 * ( 2008 ) 161802 [ 0712.2397 [ hep - ex ] ] .
v. m. abazov _ et al . _
[ d0 collaboration ] , phys .
* 101 * ( 2008 ) 241801 [ 0802.2255 [ hep - ex ] ] .
m. bona _ et al . _ [ utfit collaboration ] , 0803.0659 [ hep - ph ] .
the heavy flavour averaging group ( hfag ) , http://www.slac.stanford.edu / xorg / hfag/. g. dambrosio _ et al .
_ , nucl .
b * 645 * ( 2002 ) 155 [ hep - ph/0207036 ] .
a. j. buras _ et al .
_ , phys .
b * 500 * ( 2001 ) 161 [ hep - ph/0007085 ] .
f. j. botella , g. c. branco and m. nebot , 0805.3995 [ hep - ph ] . | we present the update of the unitarity triangle ( ut ) analysis within the standard model ( sm ) and beyond . within the sm , combining the direct measurements on sides and angles , the ut turns out to be overconstraint in a consistent way , showing that the ckm matrix is the dominant source of flavour mixing and cp - violation and that new physics ( np ) effects can appear at most as small corrections to the ckm picture . generalizing the ut analysis to investigate np effects , constraints on @xmath0 transitions
are also included and both ckm and np parameters are fitted simultaneously . while no evidence of np effects is found in @xmath1-@xmath2 and @xmath3-@xmath4 mixing , in the @xmath5-@xmath6 mixing an hint of np
is found at the @xmath7 level .
the ut analysis beyond the sm also allows us to derive bounds on the coefficients of the most general @xmath8 effective hamiltonian , that can be translated into bounds on the np scale .
ckm matrix 12.15.hh |
the study of wave scattering in disordered media is an active field of research , stimulated both by innovative applications in imaging and sensing @xcite and by fundamental questions in mesoscopic physics @xcite . in the last few years
, the possibility to control the propagation of optical waves in complex media in the multiple scattering regime has been demonstrated using wavefront shaping techniques @xcite .
this breakthrough offers new perspectives for imaging and communication through complex media @xcite .
the initial schemes make use of optimization techniques requiring intensity measurements in the transmitted speckle , which in terms of practical applications is a serious drawback .
finding a way to control the transmission and focusing of light through a strongly scattering medium from measurements of the reflected speckle only is an issue of tremendous importance .
progresses have been made recently by taking advantage of the memory effect @xcite , with imaging capabilities limited to relatively small optical thicknesses .
nevertheless , the connection between the reflected and the transmitted speckle patterns generated by a disordered medium in the multiple scattering regime has not been addressed theoretically so far . in this paper
, we make a step in this direction by studying theoretically and numerically the statistical correlation between the intensities measured in the transmitted and the reflected speckle patterns .
the spatial intensity correlation function @xmath0 is defined as @xmath1 where the notation @xmath2 denotes a statistical average over disorder and @xmath3 is the intensity fluctuation .
this correlation function has been extensively studied in the context of wave scattering and mesoscopic physics @xcite .
theoretical approaches often make use of the canonical slab or waveguide geometries ( for a review see @xcite and references therein ) , where either transmitted or reflected intensity is considered , or consider point sources in an infinite or open medium and compute intensity correlations for two points inside or outside the medium @xcite .
it seems that the intensity correlation function for two points lying on different sides of a slab medium has not been studied , and that the existence of a correlation has only been mentionned through passing @xcite . in this work
, we study the correlation between the intensities in the input and output planes of a strongly scattering slab , as sketched in fig .
[ schema ] . using numerical simulations and analytical calculations ,
we show that for optically thick slabs a correlation persists and takes negative values
. moreover , at smaller optical thicknesses , short and long - range correlations coexist , with relative weights that depend on the optical thickness .
we believe these results to be a step forward for the control of transmission through strongly scattering media , thus finding applications in sensing , imaging and information transfer .
the spatial intensity correlation in a speckle pattern can be split into three contributions , historically denoted by @xmath4 , @xmath5 and @xmath6 @xcite , as follows : @xmath7 the first term @xmath4 corresponds to the gaussian statistics approximation for the field amplitude , and is a short - range contribution , whose width determines the average size of a speckle spot @xcite . @xmath5 and @xmath6 are non - gaussian long - range correlations that decay on much larger scales @xcite . in the diffusive regime , and for two observation points lying on the same side of the scattering medium , these three contributions have different weights such that @xmath8 . in the reflection / transmission configuration considered here , and at large optical thickness , we show that an intensity correlation persists and is dominated by @xmath5 because of the short - range behavior of @xmath4 . in this case
, the long - range character of @xmath5 is confered by its algebraic decay with respect to the distance between the two observation points .
moreover , this correlation is negative , a result that may have implications in the context of wave control by wavefront shaping . for smaller optical thicknesses ,
we also show that a crossover can be found between regimes dominated by @xmath4 and @xmath5 , respectively .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ correlation_large_b ]
, we study the reflection / transmission correlation function at large optical thicknesses .
first , we use numerical simulations to compute the correlation function without approximation and to describe its main features .
second , we present the analytical calculation of the @xmath5 contribution to the reflection / transmission correlation function in the multiple scattering regime , for both two - dimensional and three - dimensional geometries , and show that @xmath5 is the leading contribution at large optical thicknesses . in section [ correlation_small_b ] , we study the correlation function at small optical thicknesses , a regime in which the @xmath4 contribution dominates . in section
[ stats ] , as a consequence of the negative value of the correlation that is found in the multiple scattering regime , we describe some peculiarities of the statistical distribution of reflected / transmitted intensities .
finally , in section [ conclusion ] we summarize the main results and discuss some implications for the control of wave transmission through disordered media .
in this section we present exact numerical simulations of wave scattering in the multiple scattering regime .
we restrict ourselves to a 2d geometry for the sake of computer memory and time .
we consider a slab of scattering material , characterized by its thickness @xmath9 and its transverse size @xmath10 ( we keep @xmath11 in order to avoid finite size effects ) , as depicted in fig .
[ schema ] .
our purpose is the calculation of the correlation function @xmath12 , where @xmath13 is a point located on the input surface ( reflection ) and @xmath14 is a point located on the output surface ( transmission ) .
[ c]@xmath10 [ c]@xmath9 [ c]@xmath15 [ c]@xmath13 [ c]@xmath14 [ c]@xmath16 and transverse size @xmath10 is illuminated from the left by a monochromatic plane - wave at normal incidence .
the correlation between the reflected and transmitted speckle patterns is characterized by the correlation function between the intensities at points @xmath13 ( reflection ) and @xmath14 ( transmission).,title="fig : " ] to proceed , we use the coupled dipoles method @xcite to calculate numerically the intensity in the transmitted and reflected speckle patterns . repeating the calculations for a large number of configurations of disorder ( positions of scatterers ) allows us to compute statistics .
the system contains @xmath17 randomly distributed non - overlapping point scatterers , and is illuminated by a plane wave from the left at normal incidence .
we deal with te - polarized waves with an electric field oriented along the invariance axis of the system ( scalar waves ) .
the resonant point scatterers are described by their electric polarizability @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the resonance frequency and @xmath20 the linewidth .
this specific form of the polarizability fulfils the optical theorem ( i.e.energy conservation ) . from the polarizability
the scattering cross section @xmath21 and the scattering mean - free path @xmath22^{-1}$ ] can be deduced , where @xmath23 is the number density of scatterers . in the following ,
we consider scatterers at resonance ( @xmath24 ) in order to reach large optical thicknesses with a reasonable number of scatterers ( typically a few hundreds ) . in the coupled dipoles formalism , the exciting field @xmath25 on scatterer number @xmath26
is written as @xcite @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the 2d free - space green function given by @xmath29 , @xmath30 being the hankel function of first kind and order zero .
equation ( [ linear_system ] ) defines a set of @xmath17 linear equations that are solved by a standard matrix inversion procedure .
once the exciting field is known on each scatterer , the field @xmath31 and the intensity @xmath32 at any position @xmath33 inside or outside the scattering medium can be calculated by a direct summation , using @xmath34 we have carried out numerical simulations in the multiple scattering regime with an optical thickness @xmath35 .
this choice of optical thickness is limited by the number of configurations that can be calculated in a reasonable computer time in order to get a sufficiently accurate statistics to compute averaged values ( requiring typically @xmath36 configurations ) .
the correlation function @xmath37 obtained from numerical calculation is plotted in fig .
[ c_2_large_b ] ( red solid line ) versus the lateral shift @xmath15 between the observation points in the reflected and transmitted speckles ( see the geometry in fig . [ schema ] ) .
[ c]@xmath38 [ c]@xmath39 [ l]@xmath40 [ l]@xmath41 given by the numerical simulations ( red solid line ) and analytical correlation @xmath5 given by eq .
( blue dashed line ) .
multiple scattering regime with @xmath42 and @xmath43.,title="fig : " ] surprisingly an intensity correlation subsists even for large optical thicknesses ( multiple scattering regime ) .
moreover the reflection / transmission correlation function at large optical thickness takes a negative value around @xmath44 .
this means that @xmath45 , showing that the probability to have a dark spot in the transmitted speckle in lateral coincidence with a bright spot in the reflection speckle ( and _ vice - versa _ ) should be substantial .
this property , that might have implications for the control of wave transmission by wavefront shaping , is investigated more precisely in section [ stats ] . to get more insight on the numerical result presented above , we present the calculation of the @xmath5 contribution to the intensity correlation function for scalar waves in both two - dimensional ( 2d ) and three - dimensional ( 3d ) geometries . intuitively , we expected @xmath5 to be the leading contribution at large optical thicknesses , since @xmath6 is always negligible compared to @xmath5 and @xmath4 vanishes exponentially with the optical thickness in this particular reflection / transmission configuration . for a dilute system such that @xmath46 , where @xmath47 with @xmath48 the speed of light and @xmath49 the wavelength in vacuum , the intensity correlation functions can be calculated analytically using a perturbative approach .
since the calculation for reflection - reflection or transmission - transmission correlations is detailed in textbooks or review articles @xcite , we do not give all details here but rather focus on the specificity of the reflection - transmission geometry .
for the analytical derivation , we consider that the transverse size @xmath10 of the slab is infinite .
to compute the correlation function @xmath5 , we first need to compute the average intensity .
the starting point is the bethe - salpeter equation that reads @xcite @xmath50 in this equation , @xmath51 is the average green function that links the average field @xmath52 to a source dipole @xmath53 located at position @xmath54 via @xmath55 the operator @xmath56 is the irreducible vertex that contains all multiple scattering sequences connecting ( @xmath57 , @xmath58 ) to ( @xmath59 , @xmath60 ) .
the exact calculation of this complex object is out of reach , but an approximate expression to first - order in the small parameter @xmath61 and for independent scattering , known as the ladder approximation , can be derived @xcite . omitting the frequency dependence for simplicity in the following , it reads @xmath62 where @xmath63 plugging eq .
( [ vertex ] ) into eq .
( [ bethe - salpeter ] ) yields @xmath64 physically , this closed equation means that only contributions for which @xmath65 and @xmath66 follow the same scattering path have a significant weight in the average intensity ( all cross terms vanish ) .
the first term @xmath67 in eq . is the ballistic ( or coherent ) component of the average intensity and the second term @xmath68 is the diffuse part . in order to get explicit expressions for these two quantities , we need to compute the average green function , or equivalently the average field . as a consequence of the dyson equation @xcite , in the independent scattering limit
, the average green function obeys a propagation equation in an effective homogeneous medium , defined by an effective wavevector @xmath69 .
we have @xmath70 where @xmath71 to first order in @xmath61 and @xmath72 is the coordinate along the direction normal to the slab .
the ballistic intensity is readily deduced : @xmath73.\ ] ] regarding the diffuse intensity @xmath74 , we can rewrite eq . in the following way @xmath75{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}'.\ ] ] an analytical expression of the diffuse intensity can be obtained in the diffusive limit where @xmath76 .
making use of the translational invariance of the medium , the fourier transform of eq . reads @xmath77\ ] ]
where @xmath78 as we consider large distances , we can perform a second order taylor expansion of @xmath79 for @xmath80 which leads in the real space to a diffusion - type equation @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the space dimension . solving eq . in a slab geometry , we obtain @xmath83 -i_0 d\exp\left(-\frac{z}{\ell}\right)\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath84 is the extrapolation length needed to account for the boundary conditions at the input and exit surfaces of the slab @xcite . for a dilute index - matched slab ,
its expression is given by @xcite @xmath85 this expression of the diffuse intensity @xmath68 is _ a priori _ valid for distances @xmath72 such that @xmath86 , for which the diffusion approximation holds , but it surprisingly gives reasonably reliable results even for @xmath87 .
adding the ballistic term , it also gives reliable results for the full average intensity @xmath88 even for relatively small optical thicknesses .
the intensity correlation function is a fourth order correlation in terms of field amplitude .
physically , a correlation is created when the two pairs of fields that constitute the intensities in the correlation function share a common history in the scattering process .
regarding @xmath5 , the crossing occurs during the propagation of the intensities inside the system and is described by a complex object known as a hikami vertex @xcite , and denoted by @xmath89 in the following .
the propagation of the intensity between the slab surfaces and the crossing is described by the ladder operator , denoted by @xmath9 in the following .
the expression of @xmath5 is given by @xcite @xmath90}\int { \mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{1}{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{2}{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{3}{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{4 } \\
\times{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{1 } { \mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{2 } { \mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{3 } { \mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{4 } \lvert{\left\langle}g({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_r,{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{2}){\right\rangle}\rvert^2\lvert { \left\langle}g({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_t,{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{4}){\right\rangle}\rvert^2 \\ \times l({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{2},{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{2 } ) l({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{4},{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{4})h({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{1},{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{2},{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{3},{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{4 } ) \\
\times l({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{1},{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{1 } ) l({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\rho}}}}}}_{3},{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{3 } ) \lvert { \left\langle}e({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{1}){\right\rangle}\rvert^2 \lvert{\left\langle}e({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_{3}){\right\rangle}\rvert^2\end{gathered}\ ] ] which can be rewritten diagrammatically in the following form : @xmath91(0,-9)(6,-9 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,-3)(6,-3 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,9)(6,9 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,3)(6,3 ) } { \psframe[fillstyle = none , dimen = middle](6,-9)(18,-3 ) \setcounter{tempa}{18 } \addtocounter{tempa}{6 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{-3 } \addtocounter{tempb}{-9 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){l } } { \psframe[fillstyle = none , dimen = middle](6,3)(18,9 ) \setcounter{tempa}{18 } \addtocounter{tempa}{6 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{9 } \addtocounter{tempb}{3 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){l } } { \psframe[fillstyle = none , dimen = middle](30,-9)(42,-3 ) \setcounter{tempa}{42 } \addtocounter{tempa}{30 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{-3 } \addtocounter{tempb}{-9 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){l } } { \psframe[fillstyle = none , dimen = middle](30,3)(42,9 ) \setcounter{tempa}{42 } \addtocounter{tempa}{30 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{9 } \addtocounter{tempb}{3 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){l } } { \psframe[fillstyle = vlines , dimen = middle](18,-9)(30,9 ) \setcounter{tempa}{30 } \addtocounter{tempa}{18 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{9 } \addtocounter{tempb}{-9 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){h } } \rput[bl](49,5){${\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_r$ } \rput[bl](49,-7){${\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_t$ } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](42,-9)(48,-6 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](42,9)(48,6 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](42,-3)(48,-6 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](42,3)(48,6 ) } \end{dddiag}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where the hatched box is the hikami vertex and the other boxes are the ladder operators .
thick lines represent the average green function and thick dashed lines stand for the average electric field .
the ladder operator is defined as @xmath92 and is represented diagrammatically as @xmath93(1,-3)(7,-3 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](1,3)(7,3 ) } { \psline(1,3)(1,-3 ) } { \pscircle(1,-3){1 } } { \pscircle(1,3){1 } } { \psline(7,3)(7,-3 ) } { \pscircle(7,-3){1 } } { \pscircle(7,3){1 } } \end{ddiag}+ \begin{ddiag}{14 } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](1,-3)(7,-3 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](1,3)(7,3 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](7,-3)(13,-3 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](7,3)(13,3 ) } { \psline(1,3)(1,-3 ) } { \psline(7,3)(7,-3 ) } { \psline(13,3)(13,-3 ) } { \pscircle(1,-3){1 } } { \pscircle(1,3){1 } } { \pscircle(7,-3){1 } } { \pscircle(7,3){1 } } { \pscircle(13,-3){1 } } { \pscircle(13,3){1 } } \end{ddiag}+\ldots\ ] ] where circles and thick horizontal solid lines represent scattering events and average green functions , respectively , the top line standing for the field amplitude @xmath65 and the bottom line for its complex conjugate @xmath66 .
thin vertical solid lines link scattering events involving identical scatterers .
an analytical expression of the ladder operator can be obtained in the diffusive limit previously used for the computation of the average intensity . making use of the translational invariance along the direction of the slab interface , the fourier transform of the ladder operator with respect to transverse variables
can be obtained from eq . , and reads @xmath94\sinh[k(l+z_0-z_>)]}{\sinh[k(l+2z_0)]}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath95 , @xmath96 .
the hikami box can also be calculated in the limit @xmath97 , and its expression reduces to @xcite @xmath98 where @xmath99 to have an explicit expression of @xmath5 , we first compute the integrals involving @xmath59 and @xmath57 using @xmath100 as we deal with large optical thicknesses , we can replace the average intensity by its diffuse component . regarding the integrals involving @xmath60 and @xmath58
, we assume that the ladder operators vary slowly at the scale of the scattering mean - free path @xmath101 .
this amounts to replacing @xmath60 by @xmath13 and @xmath58 by @xmath14 in the ladder positions .
we end up with an explicit expression of the @xmath5 contribution to the correlation function , given by @xmath102 \\
\times\frac{l^2}{(l+2z_0)^2}\frac{\sinh(qz_0/l)^2}{\sinh[q(1 + 2z_0/l)]^2}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath103 ^ 2 \times\begin{dcases } \frac{16}{\pi k_0\ell}\frac{\cos(q\delta r / l)}{q } & \text{(2d ) , } \\
\frac{27}{k_0 ^ 2\ell l}{\operatorname{j}_0}(q\delta
r / l ) & \text{(3d ) . } \end{dcases}\ ] ] the expression of the @xmath5 contribution to the reflection / transmission correlations function , together with its comparison to full numerical simulations , is the main result of this paper .
the dependence of the amplitude on the system size @xmath9 is approximatively @xmath104 , with @xmath105 the dimension of space .
this shows that even at large optical thicknesses , a correlation subsists between the intensities measured in the transmitted and the reflected speckles , and that this correlation is dominated by a contribution of the @xmath5 type .
it is important to keep in mind that this expression has been derived in the framework of the diffusion approximation ( in particular bulk average green functions have been used ) .
its validity in the geometry considered here where both reflected and transmitted intensities contribute is checked by comparison to full numerical simulations in fig .
[ c_2_large_b ] .
it is interesting to note that the analytical and numerical calculations are in very good quantitative agreement , showing that the diffusion approximation , used to derive the analytical results , is very accurate even for an optical thickness @xmath42 ( that is not very large ) and a geometry involving a reflected intensity ( that always involves short scattering paths ) .
we have seen that @xmath5 decays algebraically with the system size @xmath9 .
thus it is interesting to analyse the behavior of the full correlation function at smaller optical thicknesses , and in the crossover between the multiple and single scattering regimes .
this problem can be addressed numerically , by using the numerical method described previously in various scattering regimes , and is the subject of the following section .
we consider a small optical thickness @xmath106 , corresponding to the single - scattering regime . the reflection / transmission intensity correlation function calculated numerically in this regime
is shown in fig .
[ c_2_small_b ] ( red solid line ) .
the large oscillations observed on a scale on the order of the wavelength are not described by the @xmath5 contribution , and are expected to be a signature of the short - range @xmath4 contribution . to check the validity of this assumption
, we have to compute the @xmath4 contribution to the correlation function . at small optical thickness , a quantitative calculation would require to go beyond the diffusion approximation and to account properly for the boundary conditions @xcite . since our purpose in this section is only to support qualitatively the analysis of the general trends observed in the numerical simulations using a simple model , we keep using the diffusion approximation to estimate the @xmath4 contribution .
[ c]@xmath38 [ c]@xmath39 [ l]@xmath107 [ l]@xmath41 given by the numerical simulations ( red solid line ) and analytical correlation including all terms @xmath107 ( blue dashed line ) .
single scattering regime with @xmath106 and @xmath43.,title="fig : " ] in the scattering sequences picture , the @xmath4 correlation is created by interchanging the amplitudes between two independent ladders at the last scattering event . the @xmath4 contribution reads @xmath108 in terms of diagrams , eq .
can be rewritten as @xmath109(31,-1){${\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_r$ } \rput[bl](25,-1){${\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_t$ } { \psframe[fillstyle = none , dimen = middle](6,-9)(18,-3 ) \setcounter{tempa}{18 } \addtocounter{tempa}{6 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{-3 } \addtocounter{tempb}{-9 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){l } } { \psframe[fillstyle = none , dimen = middle](6,3)(18,9 ) \setcounter{tempa}{18 } \addtocounter{tempa}{6 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{9 } \addtocounter{tempb}{3 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){l } } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](18,-9)(30,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](18,9)(30,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](18,-3)(24,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](18,3)(24,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,-9)(6,-9 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,-3)(6,-3 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,9)(6,9 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,3)(6,3 ) } \end{dddiag}.\ ] ] in eq . , the scattering of both pairs of fields from points @xmath59 to @xmath60 and from @xmath57 to @xmath58 , respectively , is described by a ladder propagator .
the mixing of amplitudes at the last scattering event is represented by four different average green functions .
the integrals in eq .
can be factorized , leading to @xmath110 where @xmath111 equation shows that @xmath4 is the square of the scattered field correlation function .
indeed , @xmath4 can also be seen as the correlation that would be observed for a field with gaussian statistics , for which this factorization holds @xcite .
starting from eqs . and ,
the usual way to derive the analytical expression of @xmath4 consists in replacing @xmath60 by @xmath14 ( for a speckle computed in transmission ) or @xmath60 by @xmath13 ( for a speckle computed in reflection ) in the ladder positions . in the reflection / transmission geometry
, this simplification can not be performed because the relative distance between the points @xmath14 and @xmath13 can be very large compared to the scattering mean - free path @xmath101 . however , in order to get an explicit expression , we can make use of eq . which leads to @xmath112 the integration over @xmath60 is then performed using the residue theorem ( the details are given in appendix [ c_1_calculation ] ) .
this leads to @xmath113}{4(k'^2+k''^2 ) } \\ \times\left[\frac{d\left\{(1+z_0/\ell)m_1+(1-z_0/\ell)\exp(-l/\ell)m_2\right\}}{l+2z_0}\right .
\\ \left.\vphantom{\frac{1}{2}}-(d-1)m_3\right]\frac{{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{k}}}}{(2\pi)^{d-1}}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath114 , @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 are given by eqs . , and and eq . ,
respectively . the last integral over @xmath119 is performed numerically . in the specific geometry considered here
, another contribution has to be added , in which the ballistic intensity contributes as one of the intensities involved in the correlation function @xcite .
indeed , the ladder operator involves at least one scattering event , and does not account for situations in which there is no scattering event before the field interchange .
such contributions to the correlation function can be important for small optical thicknesses , where the ballistic contribution is not negligible .
this leads to a correction to the @xmath4 correlation function , that we denote by @xmath120 , and whose expression is @xmath121 in terms of diagrams , the above expression can be rewritten as @xmath122(31,-1){${\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_r$ } \rput[bl](25,-1){${\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_t$ } { \psframe[fillstyle = none , dimen = middle](6,-9)(18,-3 ) \setcounter{tempa}{18 } \addtocounter{tempa}{6 } \divide \value{tempa } by 2 \setcounter{tempb}{-3 } \addtocounter{tempb}{-9 } \divide \value{tempb } by 2 \pscircle(\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){2 } \rput[c](\value{tempa},\value{tempb}){l } } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](18,-9)(30,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](18,9)(30,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5](18,-3)(24,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](18,3)(24,0 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,-9)(6,-9 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,-3)(6,-3 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,9)(18,9 ) } { \psline[linewidth=0.5,linestyle = dashed](0,3)(18,3 ) } \end{dddiag } + \text{c.c.}\ ] ] making use of the quantity @xmath123 defined in eq .
, we obtain @xmath124 } { { \left\langle}i({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_r){\right\rangle}{\left\langle}i({\boldsymbol{\mathbf{r}}}_t){\right\rangle}}.\end{gathered}\ ] ] it is important to note that the @xmath120 contribution introduced here , and that involves the average field , is not negligible compared to the usual @xmath4 contribution .
this correction should be added to the @xmath4 contribution when the product of the ballistic fields @xmath125 can not be neglected , as in the reflection / transmission geometry at low optical thickness , or in the reflection / reflection geometry at any optical thickness .
we can show from eq . that the @xmath4 and @xmath120 contributions to the correlation function decrease exponentially with the optical thickness @xmath126 .
this behavior explains why @xmath5 dominates at large optical thickness .
but in the single scattering regime , an important contribution of the @xmath127 term is observed .
this is clearly seen in fig .
[ c_2_small_b ] ( blue dashed line ) , in which the sum of the three contributions @xmath107 calculated analytically in the same two - dimensional geometry used for the numerical simulation is plotted .
qualitatively , the behavior observed in the numerical simulation is fairly reproduced by the analytical approach .
moreover , since the @xmath127 contribution decays exponentially with the medium thickness @xmath9 , a crossover is expected towards a regime dominated by @xmath5 when the optical thickness increases .
this also shows that the reflection / transmission geometry studied here may be relevant to put forward experimentally the influence of the @xmath5 contribution ( in the pure reflection or transmission geometries , the @xmath4 contribution is always the leading contribution ) .
analytical and numerical results at large optical thickness have shown that a correlation between reflected and transmitted intensities exists .
surprisingly , this correlation function takes negative values around @xmath44 .
having @xmath45 for @xmath44 qualitatively suggests a high probability to have a bright ( dark ) spot in the transmitted speckle in coincidence with a dark ( bright ) spot in the reflected speckle . in order to address this question in more quantitative terms ,
we have studied the full statistical distribution of the intensities .
more precisely , from the numerical simulations , we have extracted the statistical distributions of the product of the fluctuating part of the intensities at @xmath44 , defined as @xmath128\ ] ] whose average value is the intensity correlation @xmath12 at @xmath44 .
[ c]@xmath129 [ c]@xmath130 at @xmath44 .
multiple scattering regime with @xmath42 and @xmath131.,title="fig : " ] the statistical distribution @xmath130 obtained for @xmath42 and @xmath131 is shown in fig .
[ histo ] .
the distribution exhibits an asymmetric shape , with a most likely value at @xmath132 . due to this asymmetric shape
, the distribution can not be simply characterized by its first moments . in particular , for @xmath42 and @xmath131 , we find that the probability to have transmitted and reflected intensity fluctuations with opposite signs @xmath133 , while we could have expected a much larger value ( above @xmath134 ) from a naive argument based on the negative sign of the correlation @xmath12 .
nevertheless , it is interesting to study statistics under some constraints . in particular
, we have studied the probability of having @xmath135 ( a spot in the transmitted speckle darker than the average intensity ) under the assumption that @xmath136 , with @xmath137 ( i.e.for a coinciding spot in the reflected speckle with increasing brightness ) .
the results are summarized in table [ proba ] .
interestingly , we find that the probability @xmath138 increases substantially with the brightness of the reflected speckle spot , an information that is not contained in the intensity correlation function . in consequence ,
if the reflected intensity in a speckle spot is large compared to the average reflected intensity , the transmitted intensity in the coinciding spot in the transmitted speckle is smaller than the average transmitted intensity with a large probability .
this result may have implications in the context of light focusing through opaque scattering media by wavefront shaping .
indeed , maximizing the intensity in a reflected speckle spot might , with a high probability , leads to a minimization of the intensity in the corresponding transmitted spot . a precise study with optimized wavefronts ( beyond plane - wave illumination )
is left for future work .
.probability of having @xmath139 ( @xmath53 ) , of having @xmath135 ( @xmath140 ) at different optical thicknesses ( @xmath141 ) and under some constraints ( @xmath142 with @xmath143 ) for @xmath44 and @xmath131 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ]
in summary , we have studied analytically and numerically the spatial correlation between intensities measured in the reflected and transmitted speckles generated by a slab of disordered scattering medium .
we have demonstrated the existence of a reflection / transmission correlation . at large optical thicknesses ,
the spatial correlation persists and is dominated by the @xmath5 contribution , thus exibiting a long - range behavior .
interestingly , this correlation takes negative values . at small optical thicknesses ,
the correlation is dominated by a @xmath4-type contribution , which contains the usual @xmath4 term and an additionnal term @xmath120 involving the ballistic intensity .
the statistical connection between transmitted and reflected speckles might be of interest for wavefront shaping methods used to focus and image through scattering media .
since for practical implementations only the reflected speckle can be measured and controlled , a knowledge of the probability to get a bright ( dark ) spot in the transmitted speckle in coincidence with a dark ( bright ) spot in the optimized reflected speckle could be a great advantage .
as a first step towards this goal , we have studied the statistical distributions of reflected and transmitted intensities , and have identified situations in which the probability of coincidence of bright and dark spots on opposite sides of the medium is high . finally , a refinement of the analytical model would be beneficial to deal with optical thicknesses for which the diffusion approximation fails to give quantitative results .
one possibility could be to developp a semi - analytical approach ( coupling analytical expressions and numerical calculations ) based on the radiative transfer equation @xcite that described accuratly short and long scattering paths @xcite .
this work has been initiated by stimulating discussions with demetri psaltis and ye pu . we acknowledge arthur goetschy for illuminating inputs .
the research was supported by labex wifi ( laboratory of excellence within the french program `` investments for the future '' ) under references anr-10-labx-24 and anr-10-idex-0001 - 02 psl*. n.f .
acknowledges financial support from the french `` direction gnrale de larmement '' ( dga ) .
in the reflexion / transmission configuration the usual approximation used to calculate @xmath4 breaks .
indeed in transmission / transmission or in reflexion / reflexion one usually manages to separate in eq .
integrals over @xmath60 and @xmath59 because of the small distance between the two points where we compute the correlation . in our configuration , because of the large distance between these two points , we have to calculate explicitly @xmath123 . using the symmetry of the problem , taking the fourier transform of the two green functions over their transverse coordinates , we simplify eq . the following way : @xmath145 { \mathrm{d}}z_2 \frac{{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{k}}}}{(2\pi)^{d-1}}\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath146 is the depth at which the two fields separate . to calculate the expression of the green function in this mixed domain , one can see that : @xmath147\frac{{\mathrm{d}}k}{2\pi } \\\label{greentf } & = \int\frac{\exp[ikz_2]}{k^2+k^2-k_{\text{eff}}^2}\frac{{\mathrm{d}}k}{2\pi}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation can be calculated using the residue theorem using the fact that @xmath148 and noting that : @xmath149 where @xmath150 is the pole with a positive imaginary part ( i.e.@xmath151 ) .
. can be calculated with the residue theorem by integrating over a contour composed of the real axis and a upper - half - circle the radius of which tends to infinity .
we obtain that @xmath152 following the same steps we can show that @xmath153\ ] ] leading to @xmath154}{4(k'^2+k''^2)}\exp[-ik^*_+l ] \\
\times\exp[-i{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{k}}}\cdot{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{\delta r}}}]{\mathrm{d}}z_2 \frac{{\mathrm{d}}{\boldsymbol{\mathbf{k}}}}{(2\pi)^{d-1}}.\end{gathered}\ ] ] using the expression of the average intensity we have to perform three integrations denoted respectively by @xmath114 , @xmath115 and @xmath116 : @xmath155{\mathrm{d}}z_2 \\\label{m_1 } & = \frac{1 + 2ik'(l+z_0)-\exp[2ik'l](1 + 2ik'z_0)}{4k'^2 } , \\\nonumber m_2 & = \int_0^l(z_0+z_2)\exp[2ik'z_2]{\mathrm{d}}z_2 \\\label{m_2 } & = \frac{2ik'z_0 - 1+\exp[2ik'l][1 - 2ik'(l+z_0)]}{4k'^2 } , \\\nonumber m_3 & = \int_0^l \exp(-\frac{z_2}{\ell})\exp[2ik'z_2]{\mathrm{d}}z_2 \\\label{m_3 } & = \ell \frac{1-\exp[2ik'l]\exp[-l/\ell]}{1 - 2ik'\ell}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] with these expressions , we can rewrite the final expression of @xmath123 as a fourier transform given by eq . . | we study theoretically the spatial correlations between the intensities measured at the input and output planes of a disordered scattering medium .
we show that at large optical thicknesses , a long - range spatial correlation persists and takes negative values . for small optical thicknesses ,
short - range and long - range correlations coexist , with relative weights that depend on the optical thickness .
these results may have direct implications for the control of wave transmission through complex media by wavefront shaping , thus finding applications in sensing , imaging and information transfer . |
quantum systems are usually described by a hilbert space , a state vector , and a hamiltonian .
do these structures alone fully characterize a physical system ? without specifying more information , like a preferred choice of basis , it is difficult to make sense of the hamiltonian or the state .
for example , consider the one - dimensional ising model , with hamiltonian @xmath0 the hamiltonian clearly describes a chain of locally coupled two - level systems .
this interpretation is possible because the expression for the hamiltonian implicitly includes a partition of the total hilbert space into subsystems using a tensor product factorization , @xmath1 this choice of tensor product structure " ( tps ) allows one to write the hamiltonian simply in terms of local operators .
however , if one does not specify a tps but instead writes the hamiltonian as a large matrix in some arbitrary basis , the system becomes difficult to interpret .
is it the one - dimensional ising model , or is it a collection of interacting particles in three dimensions ?
up to a change of basis , different hamiltonians are only distinguished by their energy spectra . moreover , the only canonical choice of basis is the energy eigenbasis .
thus the hamiltonian and state vector alone do not yield an obvious physical description , at least without a choice of tps . we therefore ask , without a preferred choice of basis , is there a natural way to decompose the hilbert space into subsystems ( i.e. tensor factors ) , knowing only the hamiltonian ?
in other words , do the energy eigenspaces and spectrum alone determine a natural choice of tps ?
this is a question that has rarely been addressed in the literature , though it is discussed in a few papers such as @xcite .
more commonly , it has been assumed that a preferred tps must be specified before any further progress can be made in describing the system @xcite . to even attempt finding a natural tps
, one must first specify what constitutes a natural choice . here , we seek a choice of subsystems such that most pairs of subsystems do not directly interact .
that is , we want the hamiltonian to act locally with respect to the chosen tps . the question of finding a natural tps is especially relevant when one considers dualities in quantum systems .
for instance , consider the mapping @xmath2 under which the hamiltonian of the one - dimensional ising model becomes @xmath3 where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are boundary terms .
the mapping demonstrates two different sets of variables , @xmath6 and @xmath7 , which define two different tps s .
the hamiltonian acts locally with respect to both tps s , even though the @xmath6 and @xmath7 operators are non - locally related to each other .
we say that the @xmath6 and @xmath7 descriptions are dual , " providing different local descriptions of the same hamiltonian .
a simple argument in section [ sec : existence ] demonstrates that given a random hamiltonian , there is usually no choice of tps for which the hamiltonian is local .
however , given a generic hamiltonian that is local in _ some _ tps , we can ask whether that is the unique tps for which the hamiltonian is local .
in other words , given a hamiltonian with some local description , is that local description unique ?
we present evidence that generic local hamiltonians have unique local descriptions : that is , dualities are the exception rather than the rule . as a result ,
the spectrum is generically sufficient to uniquely determine a natural choice of tps , whenever such a choice exists .
we formalize a version of this statement and then prove a weaker result .
in particular , we show that by finding a single example of a hamiltonian with a unique local tps , one can then prove that almost all local hamiltonians have a unique local tps .
( by local tps , " we mean a tps in which the hamiltonian is local . )
this genericity result holds for @xmath8-local hamiltonians on systems of any finite size , as well as for several other notions of locality . restricting to the class of translation - invariant , nearest - neighbor hamiltonians on a small number of qubits
, we proceed to numerically find an example of such a hamiltonian with unique local tps .
when combined with the numerical result , the analytic result mentioned above provides an effective proof that there exists a unique local tps for generic local hamiltonians within this restricted class .
we speculate that this conclusion extends to generic local hamiltonians on systems of any finite size .
all results presented are derived for models with a finite number of finite - dimensional subsystems .
such models may be used to approximate regularized quantum field theories , although the results here are not rigorously extended to infinite - dimensional hilbert spaces .
interesting subtleties may exist for infinite - dimensional systems , both due to the possibility of continuous spectra and also due to the breakdown of analyticity , familiar from the study of phase transitions .
however , we speculate that results of a similar spirit would still hold in the large - system limit . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in sections [ sec : tps ] and [ sec :
locality ] , we formalize the notion of tps s and local hamiltonians . in section [ sec : main ] , we address the main question of this paper , providing analytic results .
the proof of theorem [ thrm : constduals ] in section [ sec : constduals ] may be skipped without affecting one s understanding of the remaining sections .
section [ sec : numerics ] explains the numerical examples needed to augment the analytic results . in section [ sec : gauge ] , we discuss generalizations of tps s , needed for fermions and gauge theories . finally , we comment on how our results frame discussions of quantum mechanics and quantum gravity .
here we precisely define the notion of a tensor product structure , or tps .
often , one considers a hilbert space with an explicit tensor factorization @xmath9 where the subsystems have hilbert spaces @xmath10 .
we will usually imagine that the subsystems correspond to spatial lattice sites .
( in few - body quantum mechanics , the subsystems might correspond to distinguishable particles , whereas in many - body physics or regularized quantum field theory , the subsystems might correspond to lattice sites , momentum modes , quasiparticle modes , or some other choice . )
our first task is to define a tps on an abstract hilbert space @xmath11 that is not written as an explicit tensor product .
this formalism will lend precision to the discussion of different tensor product structures on the same hilbert space , the topic at the heart of this paper .
consider a map @xmath12 on a hilbert space @xmath11 which is an isomorphism ( unitary map ) @xmath13 the choice of isomorphism endows @xmath11 with a notion of locality : one can then speak of local operators , subsystems , entanglement , and so on within the hilbert space @xmath11 . for instance , we say the operator @xmath14 on @xmath11 is local to subsystem @xmath15 if @xmath16 is local to @xmath10 .
similarly , the entanglement entropy of a state @xmath17 is defined as the entanglement entropy of @xmath18 .
these notions will remain unchanged if @xmath12 is composed with a map @xmath19 that acts unitarily on each subsystem .
we therefore define a tps as follows : + * definition ( tps ) : * a tps @xmath20 of hilbert space @xmath11 is an equivalence class of isomorphisms @xmath21 , where @xmath22 whenever @xmath23 may be written as a product of local unitaries @xmath24 and permutations of subsystems . + to avoid confusion , note that the usage of local " in the phraselocal unitary " is distinct from its usage in local hamiltonian . " local unitaries are products of unitaries acting on single tensor factors , while local hamiltonians are sums of operators acting on small subsets of tensor factors .
another equivalent and useful way to define a tps involves observables rather than states . in short ,
a tps naturally defines subalgebras of observables local to each subsystem , but we can turn this data around and use the subalgebras to define the tps .
this perspective was developed by @xcite .
let us collect the local observables as a set of mutually commuting subalgebras @xmath25 , where @xmath26 denotes the algebra of operators on @xmath11 , and @xmath27 denotes the algebra of operators of the form @xmath28 i.e. operators that act as the identity on all subsystems except @xmath15 . with this motivation
, we can equivalently define a tps on @xmath11 as a collection of of subalgebras @xmath29 , @xmath30 , such that the following hold : 1 .
the @xmath27 mutually commute , @xmath31=0 $ ] for @xmath32 .
2 . the @xmath27 are independent , @xmath33 .
3 . the @xmath27 generate the whole algebra of observables , @xmath34 .
the above definition is equivalent to the first definition , because a choice of subalgebras subject to the above conditions will uniquely determine an equivalence class of isomorphisms @xmath20 that give rise to the corresponding subalgebras .
( the equivalence of definitions essentially follows from the result stated in @xcite . )
since one can specify a tps either by an equivalence class @xmath20 or a collection of subalgebras @xmath35 , we will switch between these notations freely . for a hilbert space @xmath11 without additional structure like a hamiltonian , no choice of tps is more interesting or meaningful than another . that is , even though two choices @xmath29 and @xmath36 may differ , neither choice is significant on its own because the states and operators of @xmath11 have no identifying structure to begin with
. however , we will be interested in a hilbert space equipped with a hamiltonian @xmath37 , and this additional structure _ does _ distinguish certain states and operators , namely the operator @xmath37 and its eigenvectors .
the choice of tps then acquires more meaning ; for instance , the ground state might be entangled with respect to one tps but separable in another . on the other hand
, certain tps s will be effectively equivalent with respect to a given hamiltonian .
one may think of the operator @xmath38 on @xmath39 as an expression of @xmath37 with respect to tps @xmath20 .
moreover , two operators on @xmath39 describe physically equivalent systems if they are the same up to conjugation by local unitaries , permutation of subsystems , and transposition .
that is , conjugation by local unitaries is merely a re - labeling of the basis within tensor factors , while permutation of subsystems is merely a re - labeling of how subsystems are labeled . and
transposition of the entire hamiltonian , , there exists a unitary operator @xmath40 such that @xmath41 since transposition preserves the spectrum . ]
namely @xmath42 , only corresponds to complex conjugation , or a relabeling of @xmath43 .
we therefore say that two tps s @xmath44 and @xmath45 are equivalent _ with respect to the hamiltonian h _ if the operators @xmath46 and @xmath47 on @xmath39 are the same up to conjugation by local unitaries , permutation of subsystems , and transposition .
the above may be encapsulated by the following definition .
although this definition may appear unnecessarily formal , we hope it will eliminate any vagueness of the discussion , and the definition will not require careful parsing to follow the paper in general .
+ + * definition ( equivalence of tps ) : * two choices @xmath48 and @xmath49 of hilbert space , hamiltonian , and tps are equivalent when there exists a unitary @xmath50 such that @xmath51 or in addition to @xmath51 , one could allow @xmath40 to be an anti - automorphism of the @xmath52-algebra of observables .
automorphisms of the algebra of observables are given by unitary conjugation , while anti - automorphisms ( multiplication - reversing homomorphisms ) are given by the composition of unitary conjugation and transposition .
] @xmath53 , and such that @xmath54 , where @xmath55 is some permutation of @xmath56 .
alternatively , @xmath57 and @xmath58 are equivalent when there exists a unitary @xmath50 such that @xmath51 or @xmath53 , and such that @xmath59=[t'u]$ ] .
+ + we will be most interested in considering the same hilbert space and hamiltonian with different tps s , given by @xmath57 and @xmath60 .
rather than talk about two different tps s @xmath61 for the same hamiltonian @xmath37 , we can often simplify the discussion by talking about two different hamiltonians @xmath62 on the space @xmath63 with fixed tps . both perspectives are equivalent .
this observation will be important and bears repeating .
+ * observation : * it is equivalent to consider either perspective : 1 . a hilbert space @xmath64 with fixed hamiltonian @xmath37 and varying choice of tps @xmath20 or @xmath65 , or 2 . a hilbert space @xmath63 with fixed tps and unitarily varying choice of hamiltonians @xmath66 or @xmath67 with the same spectrum .
for some fixed hamiltonian @xmath37 , questions about the existence of a tps in which @xmath37 is local may then be translated into questions about the existence of local hamiltonians with the same spectrum as @xmath37 .
the notion of duality can also be expressed in either of these perspectives : + * definition ( dual ) : * from the first perspective above , we say that two tps s are dual if the given hamiltonian is local in both tps s and if also the tps s are inequivalent with respect to that hamiltonian . from the second perspective
, we say that two hamiltonians are dual if they are local , have the same spectrum , and can not be related by local unitaries , permutations of subsystems , and transposition .
+ the results of sections [ sec : main ] and [ sec : numerics ] will largely be cast in the second perspective , i.e. as statements about the existence of different local hamiltonians with the same spectrum . however , the results may always be re - cast in the first perspective , as results about the existence of different local tps for the same hamiltonian .
for instance , we can either say that generic local hamiltonians uniquely determine a local tps , or we can say that the spectrum of a generic local hamiltonian will uniquely determine the hamiltonian .
given a hilbert space @xmath11 and hamiltonian @xmath37 , what qualitatively distinguishes different choices of tps ?
most broadly , we might ask whether some tps s yield simpler , more meaningful , or more calculationally tractable descriptions of a system . more specifically , we are interested in tps s for which the hamiltonian appears local , in the sense that it only exhibits interactions among certain collections of subsystems
. we should clarify what it means for a hamiltonian to include an interaction among a given collection of tensor factors .
in general , one can write a hamiltonian on @xmath68 qudits ( i.e. , @xmath68 systems of local dimension @xmath69 ) as @xmath70 where the operators @xmath71 for @xmath72 form an orthogonal basis for single - qudit operators on site @xmath15 .
this decomposition is unique , up to the choice of basis @xmath71 .
the terms @xmath73 , for instance , are considered as interactions between qudits @xmath15 , @xmath74 , and @xmath8 .
the space of operators @xmath26 decomposes into orthogonal sectors , with one sector for each combination of subsystems , and we say that @xmath37 contains an interaction among some subset of qudits if @xmath37 has a nonzero component in the corresponding sector .
qualitatively , we say that a hamiltonian is local when relatively few combinations of subsystems are interacting .
( note that we use local operator " to refer to an operator that is local to a single subsystem or collection of subsystems , while we use local hamiltonian " to refer to a sum of such operators . ) for instance , the ising model only exhibits nearest - neighbor interactions , as do lattice - regularized quantum field theories without higher derivatives .
meanwhile , other models like spin glasses and matrix models exhibit interactions among all particles , but only in groups of fixed size , like two or four .
likewise , non - relativistic electrons have only pairwise interactions , if each electron is treated as a subsystem .. ] to incorporate all these notions of locality , one can use a hypergraph .
first , note that an ordinary graph can be thought of as a collection of vertices @xmath75 , along with a collection of edges @xmath76 , where each edge is written as a pair of vertices , @xmath77 for @xmath78 .
we emphasize that each @xmath79 , called an edge , " is a two element subset of @xmath75 .
a hypergraph is like an ordinary graph with a set @xmath75 of vertices , but the edges " @xmath80 may contain more than two vertices . for convenience , we subsequently refer to a hypergraph as a graph . given a fixed tps and hamiltonian , the associated interaction graph " has vertices corresponding to the subsystems and has ( hyper-)edges corresponding to every combination of subsystems that interact under the hamiltonian .
we say that the hamiltonian is local with respect to some graph @xmath81 if its interaction graph is a subgraph @xmath81 . given a hamiltonian @xmath37 , different choices of tps @xmath20
will give rise to different operators @xmath66 on @xmath39 , with different associated interaction graphs .
we are interested in tps s which give rise to interaction graphs with edges connecting only a small number of sites . as one measure of sparsity or locality , we say that a graph is @xmath8-local if it has edges joining at most @xmath8 vertices .- particle first quantized quantum system , @xmath8-locality with respect to particle subsystems means that the particles only have @xmath8-body interactions .
] likewise , we call a hamiltonian @xmath8-local with respect to some tps if the associated graph is @xmath8-local , and we will also refer to the tps as @xmath8-local . while the study of generic @xmath8-local hamiltonians is important ,- particle first quantized quantum system with @xmath8-body interactions is @xmath8-local with respect to particle subsystems . ] for example in the study of quantum circuits and black holes , generally we are interested in the stronger condition of geometric locality .
this means that each site has edges connecting it to only a small number of other sites .
for example , we are often interested in graphs which form a @xmath69-dimensional lattice with only neighboring lattice sites interacting . such graphs are ubiquitous since they arise in any local spin system or lattice regularization of quantum field theory .
we might even make further constraints such as requiring that the hamiltonian be translation - invariant with respect to the lattice .
all of the analytic results in this paper will be valid for generic hamiltonians within any specified locality class , including all the classes discussed above . specifically , we prove results about the number of duals within a particular locality class of a generic hamiltonian in that same locality class .
for example , we can prove results about the number of translation - invariant duals of a generic translation - invariant hamiltonian .
it is harder to prove results about the number of @xmath8-local duals of generic translation - invariant hamiltonians , since translation - invariant geometrically local hamiltonians are a measure zero subspace of the larger space of @xmath8-local hamiltonians .
however in section [ sec : numerics ] we show that some of our results can be extended to such cases .
first we ask whether a generic hamiltonian has any @xmath8-local tps .
the answer is no , as will be demonstrated .
we restrict our attention to a finite - dimensional hilbert space @xmath11 , @xmath82 , with hamiltonian @xmath37 .
we ask whether there exists a tps with @xmath68 subsystems such that the hamiltonian is @xmath8-local . for @xmath68
sufficiently larger than @xmath8 , we will see that a @xmath8-local tps exists only for a measure zero set of operators in @xmath26 .
recall from the previous section that for a given hamiltonian @xmath37 , a choice of tps @xmath20 produces a hamiltonian @xmath66 on @xmath63 , up to local unitaries and permutations of subsystems .
the operator @xmath66 then defines some associated interaction graph , up to relabeling of vertices .
we call the tps @xmath20 @xmath8-local if it gives rise to a @xmath8-local interaction graph for @xmath66
. note that for any tps @xmath20 , @xmath37 and @xmath66 have the same spectrum .
conversely , if there is some operator @xmath14 on @xmath63 with the same spectrum as @xmath37 , then there exists a tps @xmath83 such that @xmath84 .
so @xmath37 has a @xmath8-local tps if and only if there is a @xmath8-local hamiltonian on @xmath63 with the same spectrum .
the above observation allows a change of perspective , as suggested at the end of section [ sec : tps ] . rather than asking whether generic hamiltonians on an abstract hilbert space @xmath11 have some @xmath8-local tps , we can equivalently ask whether generic hamiltonians on @xmath63 are isospectral to some @xmath8-local hamiltonian .
a simple dimension - counting argument yields the answer .
the space of possible spectra of all hamiltonians is @xmath85 .
meanwhile , examining eqn .
( [ locham1 ] ) , we see that the space of @xmath8-local hamiltonians on @xmath63 will have dimension @xmath86 for @xmath68 subsystems of local dimension @xmath69
. then the space of spectra of @xmath8-local hamiltonians will also have dimension at most @xmath87 .
for @xmath88 , the space of all spectra of @xmath8-local hamiltonians will have positive codimension in the space of all possible spectra .
so for any sufficiently large @xmath68 ( e.g. @xmath89 , for @xmath90 and @xmath91 ) , the set of hamiltonians that are isospectral to a @xmath8-local hamiltonian has measure zero .
in general , the results in this paper will apply to all hamiltonians in some specified subspace , excluding an exceptional set of measure zero . on the other hand , when asking questions of an approximate nature for instance , when asking whether a generic hamiltonian has a tps that is _ approximately _ local the relevant question is not quite does the exceptional set have measure zero ? " but rather what is the volume of an @xmath92-neighborhood of the exceptional set ? "
such questions are more difficult to tackle directly , requiring analysis to augment the linear algebra and algebraic geometry used in this paper .
however , the exceptional sets in question not only have measure zero but also have a codimension that is exponential in the system size , perhaps suggesting that the desired results about @xmath92-neighborhoods would hold .
now we ask , given a hamiltonian @xmath37 with some @xmath8-local tps @xmath20 , is @xmath20 the unique @xmath8-local tps , up to equivalence in the sense of section [ sec : tps ] above ?
we again follow the strategy of reformulating the question on the space @xmath63 , using the observation at the end of section [ sec : tps ] .
recall that two @xmath8-local hamitonians on @xmath63 are called dual if they are isospectral and are not related by local unitaries , permutations of subsystems , or transposition .
now we can reformulate the question of whether a @xmath8-local tps for a hamiltonian is generically unique .
the question becomes , does a generic @xmath8-local hamiltonian @xmath37 on @xmath63 have any duals ?
in other words , can one generically recover a local hamiltonian from its spectrum ?
posed in the latter terms , the question may be interesting for independent reasons .
however , we are motivated by the original question , asking whether a @xmath8-local tps for a hamiltonian is generically unique .
one s initial intuition may suggest that a @xmath8-local hamiltonian may indeed be recovered from its spectrum .
this intuition is due to dimension counting : a @xmath8-local hamiltonian is specified by a number of parameters polynomial in @xmath68 , while the number of eigenvalues is exponential in @xmath68 . in the previous section , this dimension counting was used to rigorously demonstrate that generic hamiltonians have no @xmath8-local tps .
however , the argument here is less immediate .
while the spectrum has more parameters than the hamiltonian , this fact alone does not prevent generic hamiltonians from having duals .
for instance , imagine that we slightly modified the question , instead defining two @xmath8-local hamiltonians to be dual whenever they are not related by local unitaries or permutations , failing to include the possibility of transposition .
then we would discover that all hamiltonians ( except real - symmetric ones ) have at least one dual , given by their transpose .
thus it is not immediately obvious that most @xmath8-local hamiltonians do not have duals .
however , transposition , just like local unitaries and permutations , is a linear map on the space of hamiltonians , and it preserves the subspace of local hamiltonians . a simple check , after dimension - counting , is to ask whether there are any _ other _ linear spectrum - preserving maps that preserve this subspace .
it turns out that no such maps exist .
all linear maps that preserve eigenvalues are generated by transposition and unitaries , and since we already know that taking the transpose preserves locality , we only have to worry about whether other unitaries preserve the subspace .
the proof that the only such unitaries are 1-local or permutations is relatively simple .
suppose there exists a unitary @xmath40 which preserves the space of @xmath8-local hamiltonians and which is not generated by 1-local unitaries and permutations .
then there must be some site @xmath74 whose local hermitian operators are mapped to hermitian operators that sometimes involve at least 2 sites , otherwise it would be generated by 1-local unitaries and permutations .
since it preserves @xmath8-locality , any @xmath8-local operator must be mapped to at most @xmath8 sites .
now consider two sets of @xmath8 sites , whose intersection is only site @xmath74 .
each are mapped to at most @xmath8 sites , which must both contain the two sites to which @xmath74 is mapped .
therefore any operator involving only those @xmath93 sites must be mapped to an operator on only @xmath94 sites . by dimension counting
it is impossible for this to be true for an invertible map , which gives a contradiction .
this proof generalizes to other notions of locality , e.g. the subspace of local lattice hamiltonians for some fixed lattice . as discussed above
, we would like to show that generic @xmath8-local hamiltonians do not have @xmath8-local duals .
however , the statements proven in this paper will be weaker statements . more specifically
, our result will apply to any particular linear subspace of hamiltonians , for a hilbert space of fixed size .
for instance , consider the subspace of all @xmath8-local hamiltonians on @xmath68 qubits .
the result then states : if there exists a single example of a @xmath8-local hamiltonian on @xmath68 qubits without any duals , then almost all @xmath8-local hamiltonians on @xmath68 qubits do not have @xmath8-local duals .
the analogous result applies to systems of qudits rather than qubits ( i.e. using @xmath69-dimensional subsystems )
. or , for instance , consider the linear subspace of all hamiltonians on spin chains with nearest - neighbor couplings .
then the result states : if there exists a single example of a spin chain hamiltonian on @xmath68 spins without any duals that are also spin chains , then the same must hold for almost all spin chain hamiltonians on @xmath68 spins .
of course , these results on their own do not guarantee that almost all @xmath8-local hamiltonians do not have duals .
however , as a proof of principle , we will numerically find an example of a translation - invariant spin chain hamiltonian on 10 spins that does not have any translation - invariant spin chain duals .
combined with the above result , the numerical example effectively proves that almost all translation - invariant spin chain hamiltonians on 10 spins do not have any translation - invariant spin chain duals .
if a family of examples could be generated analytically for systems of different sizes , perhaps using induction in the size of the system , then our result would imply rigorously that almost all @xmath8-local hamiltonians do not have duals .
we suspect that such examples exist , which would imply that the general result holds .
now we begin to formalize the statement .
consider a subspace of hamiltonians , @xmath95 .
for instance , @xmath96 may be the subspace of @xmath8-local hamiltonians on @xmath68 qubits .
for a given local hamiltonian @xmath97 , we are interested in whether @xmath37 has a dual @xmath98 . by dual , we mean a hamiltonian @xmath99 with the same spectrum as @xmath37 , such that @xmath99 is not related by any combination of local unitary transformations , permutations of qubits , or the transpose operation .
let @xmath81 be the subgroup of linear transformations on @xmath96 generated by local unitary operations , permutations of qubits , and the transpose operation .
in addition , let the unitary group @xmath100 act on @xmath101 by conjugation .
note that the orbit @xmath102 is the set of hamiltonians isospectral to @xmath37 .
then the local duals of @xmath37 are precisely the points in @xmath103 that are not in @xmath104 .
note that @xmath105 the statement that @xmath37 has no duals is the statement that @xmath106 this condition says that the only hamiltonians in @xmath96 isospectral to @xmath37 are those related by local unitary operations , permutations of qubits , and the transpose operation .
equivalently , the condition states @xmath97 is uniquely determined by its spectrum , up to the previous operations .
the situation of a hamiltonian with no duals is illustrated in figure 1 on the next page .
[ fig : wacky ] and @xmath102 intersecting in the ambient space @xmath101 .
the hamiltonian @xmath37 is depicted to have no duals .
the orbit intersects @xmath96 in multiple disconnected components , appearing as circles in the diagram .
these disconnected components together make up @xmath107 each disconnected component of @xmath108 contains hamiltonians related by local unitaries ( which are continuous transformations ) , and the sets are related to one another by permutations of qubits and transposition , which are discrete transformations .
alternatively , if the intersection contained points not related to @xmath37 by local unitaries , permutations , or transposition , then @xmath37 would have duals .
the figure is only intended as a schematic representation of the spaces involved.,title="fig : " ] as a first step , we can constrain the answer by counting the dimensions of the spaces involved .
how big is @xmath109 ?
for simplicity , consider the tangent space of @xmath102 at @xmath37 , given by the image of the linear map @xmath110 , taking @xmath111 $ ] .
the kernel of @xmath112 will be the hermitian operators that commute with @xmath37 , i.e. that are diagonal in the energy eigenbasis .
a generic local hamiltonian will have non - degenerate spectrum , so there will be an @xmath113-dimensional space of these operators . hence @xmath112 has rank @xmath114 ( using @xmath115 ) , and likewise @xmath116 .
meanwhile , @xmath117 , so @xmath118 .
this inequality makes it possible for @xmath108 to be empty , because the ambient space @xmath119 is sufficiently large .
we already know @xmath120 , so the intersection is not empty , but we might still expect @xmath121 contains no further points .
concretely , we will consider perturbing a hamiltonian @xmath37 in the subspace @xmath96 by unitary conjugation , such that the perturbed hamiltonian still lies within @xmath96 .
we wish to show that for almost all @xmath37 , such unitary perturbations will either commute with the hamiltonian ( and so have no effect at all ) , or otherwise be local unitary perturbations .
this generically precludes arbitrarily nearby duals in the sense that for almost all @xmath37 in @xmath96 , there is an open set in @xmath96 containing @xmath37 for which there are no duals of @xmath37 . to implement the proof ,
we construct a complex - valued polynomial function of the hamiltonian , @xmath122 , which has roots precisely at the values of @xmath37 that have infinitesimally nearby duals in @xmath96 .
however , any polynomial has the property that either its zeros are a set of measure zero , or the polynomial is identically zero . in our context , this means that either _
almost all _ hamiltonians do not have arbitrarily nearby duals , or _
all _ hamiltonians have arbitrarily nearby duals .
thus , we only need to check if one hamiltonian has no arbitrarily nearby duals to determine which scenario holds for @xmath96 .
and @xmath96 contains both isolated points _ and _ open sets .
the directions of @xmath96 which correspond to local unitary perturbations of the hamiltonian are suppressed.,scaledwidth=65.0% ] figure 2 depicts a scenario we have shown impossible , namely a hamiltonian in @xmath96 which is dual to a proper open subset of @xmath96 .
our theorem is in fact stronger : if a single hamiltonian in @xmath96 does not have arbitrarily nearby duals , then almost all other hamiltonians in @xmath96 have no arbitrarily nearby duals .
indeed , the weaker statement follows since if there were an open set of duals , the number of hamiltonians with no arbitrarily nearby duals would _ not _ be measure zero .
we now proceed with the result : [ finite number of duals ] [ thrm : finiteduals ] suppose that we have a subspace @xmath96 of hermitian matrices @xmath123 together with some subgroup @xmath124 that preserves @xmath96 when acting by conjugation .
moreover suppose that there exists a matrix @xmath125 whose jordan form is the generic jordan form , we mean the unique jordan normal form associated to all operators in a non - empty , zariski open subset of @xmath96 .
for most subspaces @xmath96 of local hamiltonians we are interested in , the generic jordan form will be non - degenerate , but we consider the general case here .
for instance , translation - invariant spin chains with periodic boundary conditions are generically degenerate .
] on @xmath96 , such that if @xmath126 \in s\ ] ] for some hermitian matrix @xmath75 then either @xmath127 = 0 $ ] or @xmath128 , where @xmath129 is the lie algebra of @xmath81 .
( in particular , @xmath129 is equal to the space of 1-local hamiltonians . )
then the same property holds for almost all matrices @xmath97 : if @xmath130 \in s\ ] ] for some hermitian matrix @xmath75 , then either @xmath131 = 0 $ ] or @xmath128 . with the complexification + @xmath132 and replaces @xmath124 with the complexification @xmath133 .
the complexified version of the statement holds by a nearly identical argument , and the complexified statement will be used in the proof of theorem [ thrm : constduals ] . ] in particular , if @xmath96 is some space of local hamiltonians with @xmath81 the group of local unitary operators , then almost all hamiltonians @xmath97 have a finite number of duals . _
proof_. consider the linear map @xmath134 on the space of hermitian matrices , defined by @xmath135\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the projector is onto the orthogonal complement of @xmath96 with respect to the hilbert - schmidt inner product .
then @xmath136 is the space of hermitian matrices @xmath75 such that @xmath137 \in s\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] by construction , @xmath138 and @xmath139 , where @xmath140=0 \}\end{aligned}\ ] ] is the stabilizer of @xmath37 under the adjoint action of the lie algebra @xmath141 of @xmath100 .
so for any @xmath37 , we have @xmath142 also note that @xmath143 and @xmath144 , so @xmath145 we now argue that for almost all @xmath97 , @xmath146 attains its minimal value over @xmath96 , i.e. @xmath147 for almost all @xmath97 .
this fact immediately follows from the lower semicontinuity of the rank of a matrix , but we will elaborate to provide some intuition about the role of polynomials . first , recall that a matrix @xmath148 has rank at least @xmath149 if and only if there exists an @xmath150 matrix minor of @xmath148 with nonzero determinant . now suppose that @xmath151 for some @xmath152 .
if we consider @xmath153 as a matrix , there must exist some matrix minor of @xmath153 with nonzero determinant formed by removing @xmath149 rows and columns from @xmath153
. the determinant will be a polynomial function of the entries of @xmath152 , and because a non - zero polynomial is non - zero almost everywhere , the determinant will be non - zero almost everywhere in @xmath96 .
so for any @xmath125 , and for almost all @xmath97 , @xmath154 now let us assume there exists an @xmath152 satisfying the hypotheses of the theorem , which may be rewritten as @xmath155 , along with the requirement that @xmath152 has the generic jordan form on @xmath96 . combining equation [ eq : loc2 ] with equation [ eq : loc1 ] , we then have that for almost all @xmath97 , @xmath156 because @xmath152 is assumed to have the generic jordan form on @xmath96 , and because the generic jordan form will have the smallest eigenvalue degeneracy , @xmath152 will then have the smallest stabilizer under adjoint action , i.e. @xmath157 meanwhile , @xmath158 where @xmath159 $ ] , so by the exact same argument made below equation [ eq : loc2 ] , @xmath160 for almost all @xmath97 .
plugging equations [ eq : loc3 ] and [ eq : loc4 ] into equations [ eq : loc5 ] and [ eq : loc1 ] , one finds that for almost all @xmath97 , @xmath161 and hence the above is an equality , with @xmath162 which implies @xmath163 because @xmath164 .
finally , the above expression is precisely the desired condition of the theorem . to complete the proof of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] , it only remains to show that the number of duals is finite .
suppose that for some @xmath97 then for any @xmath165 , @xmath166 \in s$ ] implies either that @xmath131 = 0 $ ] or @xmath128 .
then there must exist a finite volume around the identity in @xmath100 within which @xmath167 implies @xmath168 or @xmath169 .
however since the unitary group is compact , this can only be true for every @xmath170 if the set of hamiltonians in @xmath96 with the same eigenvalues as @xmath37 quotiented by the action of @xmath81 by conjugation is finite .
however we have already shown that this exact result is true for almost all @xmath97 .
it follows that for almost all @xmath97 , the set of hamiltonians in @xmath96 with the same eigenvalues as @xmath37 quotiented by the action of @xmath81 is finite , which we defined to be the number of duals . to extend our result to non - infinitesimal unitary transformations , considering the whole orbit @xmath102 rather than just the tangent space at @xmath37
, we make use of more sophisticated mathematical tools than were necessary for the previous results .
the proof consists mostly of classical algebraic geometry , though it makes use of some theorems phrased in the language of schemes .
nevertheless the basic strategy , as well as the result itself , is highly analogous to the previous section .
we show that almost all local hamiltonians have the same number of duals .
that is , the number of duals per hamiltonian is almost everywhere constant over the space of local hamiltonians .
the numerical results in section [ sec : numerics ] will augment the theorem below to show that the number of duals is generically zero ( rather than simply being constant ) , at least for certain small systems .
one main difference from the style of the previous proof is that we must include non - hermitian local hamiltonians when searching for duals , rather than just ordinary hermitian hamiltonians . in other words
, we must consider the orbit of @xmath37 under conjugation with @xmath171 and not just @xmath100 .
similarly , we generalize the equivalence classes associated to a single tps to include the orbit under conjugation by elements of @xmath172 on each subsystem ( analogous to local unitaries ) , as well as the familiar permutation of the subsystems and transposition .
this requirement is particularly important as it means we are working over an algebraically - closed field , the complex numbers . when performing associated numerics , the complexification adds a small amount of numerical difficulty , since we must search a space with twice the number of parameters .
although the proof itself is somewhat technical , the outline is easy to understand .
first we construct the space of orbits of local complex hamiltonians under conjugation by local operators on each subsystem , permutation of subsystems , and transposition .
then we define a map from this space such that two orbits are mapped to the same point if and only if they have the same spectrum and are therefore dual . here
, the complexification of the spaces becomes important .
note that the number of distinct solutions to the complex algebraic equation @xmath173 is the same for almost all values of @xmath8 , although the analogous statement does not hold for real solutions .
similarly , for a class of sufficiently well - behaved maps , the number of points in the fiber will be constant almost everywhere .
[ thrm : constduals ] suppose that we have a complex subspace @xmath174 of matrices @xmath175 that is preserved by transposition , together with some reductive subgroup @xmath176 that preserves @xmath174 when acting by conjugation and is invariant under transposition .
let @xmath81 be the subgroup of @xmath177 whose fundamental representation is generated by transposition and the action of @xmath178 by conjugation .
suppose that almost all matrices in @xmath174 are diagonalizable and moreover that for almost all matrices in @xmath174 , the number of @xmath81-orbits @xmath174 which are similar is finite ; we refer each such orbit as a complex dual . "
then the number of complex duals is constant on a zariski open subset of @xmath174 . _
proof_. we want to define a morphism of varieties for which the domain is the orbits of @xmath174 under @xmath81 and for which the fibers are the sets of duals .
our starting point is the rational map @xmath179 , defined to be the projectivization of the map @xmath180 here @xmath181 can be taken to be the weighted projective space which is the quotient of @xmath182 by the action of the multiplicative group @xmath183 of nonzero complex numbers , taking @xmath184 note that we can identify the quotient of @xmath185 by the permutation group @xmath186 ( acting by permuting indices ) with @xmath185 itself via the map @xmath187 where @xmath188 are the symmetric polynomials of @xmath189 , which may be defined by matching coefficients of the formal power series @xmath190 the elementary symmetric polynomials @xmath191 of @xmath192 can then be identified via newton s identities with the power sum symmetric polynomials @xmath193 .
this gives us an identification of @xmath179 with the map that associates to a matrix @xmath37 its projectivized set of eigenvalues with algebraic ( not geometric ) multiplicities for @xmath37 .
we make use of projective rather than affine spaces in this construction simply because we later need to take advantage of the nicer properties of projective morphisms .
we are assuming that @xmath174 is nonzero and the generic jordan normal form of a matrix in @xmath174 is diagonalizable , so a dense open subset in the projective variety @xmath194 , which is the closure in @xmath181 of the image of @xmath195 , has fibers that are the intersection of an orbit of @xmath171 with @xmath174 , a set of similar matrices .
now we want to quotient @xmath196 by the action of @xmath81 .
since @xmath81 is not compact , the topological quotient of @xmath197 by @xmath81 is not well behaved .
instead we will show that a git ( geometric invariant theory ) quotient exists .
a git quotient of a projective variety is well - defined for a linearized action of a reductive algebraic group .
since @xmath178 was assumed to be reductive and @xmath81 is a finite extension of @xmath178 which acts linearly on @xmath174 we have a linearized action of @xmath81 on @xmath197 and we can construct a git quotient by @xmath81 . a git quotient of a projective variety @xmath198 with a linear action of @xmath81 gives a categorical quotient @xmath199 where @xmath200 are the semistable points of @xmath198 .
a point @xmath37 is semistable if and only if there exists a homogeneous @xmath81-invariant polynomial which is non - zero at @xmath37 . in our case , for any @xmath37 that is not nilpotent
, @xmath201 is @xmath171-equivariant and homogeneous and will be non - zero for some @xmath68 . since a git quotient is a categorical quotient on the category of algebraic varieties , any @xmath81-invariant map will uniquely factor through the quotient . since , for all @xmath68 , @xmath202 is @xmath81-invariant , the restriction of @xmath195 to the semistable points will uniquely factor through a map we shall refer to as @xmath203 .
a git quotient is only a geometric quotient on an open subset known as the stable points , here used in the original mumford sense @xcite[definition 1.7 ] .
however since the number of @xmath81-orbits mapped to a given point in @xmath181 is generically finite , such generic orbits will be stable , because all the orbits in a @xmath81-invariant open neighborhood given by the inverse image under @xmath195 of an open subset of @xmath181 will be closed , as the fibers of @xmath195 will all be closed and the fibers are finite disjoint unions of orbits .
it follows that the open subset of stable points is non - empty and hence dense ( since @xmath204 is irreducible ) . the next step will be to take the projective morphism @xmath205 and base change onto an open subscheme of the image of @xmath205 .
this new morphism will still be projective since projectiveness is preserved under base changes .
we make use of @xcite iii corollary 10.7 which states that if @xmath206 is a morphism of non - singular varieties over an algebraically closed field @xmath8 of characteristic @xmath207 , then there is a non - empty open subset @xmath208 such that @xmath209 is smooth .
this corollary does not directly apply to @xmath205 since @xmath210 is not necessarily nonsingular , but since we have assumed that almost all the fibers are finite , the dimension of the image must be equal to the dimension of @xmath198 .
this means that the image of the singular locus @xmath211 is not dense in the image of @xmath198 and hence the complement of the closure of @xmath212 in the closure of @xmath213 will be an non - empty open subset @xmath214 and have non - singular preimage in @xmath198 . then applying corollary 10.7 to the restriction of @xmath205 to @xmath215 , we learn that there exists an non - empty open subset @xmath216 such that the restriction of @xmath205 to @xmath217 is smooth . if a morphism is smooth , it is also flat ( @xcite iii theorem 10.2 ) .
further , @xmath218 is a noetherian scheme since it is quasi - projective .
this mean that the degree of the fiber , which for finite fibers is just the number of points in the fiber ( counting multiplicities ) is constant everywhere ( @xcite iii corollary 9.10 ) .
now we take the intersection of @xmath217 with the stable points @xmath219 .
the restriction of the morphism @xmath205 to this dense open subset will be a morphism from the geometric quotient by @xmath81 and hence the degree of the fibers will simply count the number of geometric orbits .
we have therefore shown that a dense open subset of local complex hamiltonians have a constant number of complex duals , which completes the proof of theorem [ thrm : constduals ] .
notice that the intersection of any nonempty zariski open with the real subspace of a complex vector space has complement of measure zero in the real vector space , since the zariski open is the complement of the solution space of a set of complex algebraic equations .
when we restrict to the real subspace this becomes the complement of a set of real algebraic equations ( the real and imaginary parts of the original equations ) and all real algebraic equations have measure zero solution except for @xmath220 .
if there exists a zariski open of local complex hamiltonians with no complex duals , then generic local ( real ) hamiltonians have no complex duals , and hence since hermitian duals are simply a subclass of complex duals , they also have no hermitian duals .
we also need to show that the assumptions that we made for @xmath174 and @xmath178 apply for the particular case of a space of local complex hamiltonians with conjugations by local @xmath172 and permutations of tensor product factors .
@xmath174 and @xmath178 are trivially invariant under transposition . to show that @xmath174 is generically diagonalizable we first note that in any zariski closed subspace of @xmath175 , matrices will have the generic jordan form for that space on a zariski open subspace of it .
then exactly the same arguments as above , tell us that , generically , hermitian matrices in @xmath174 will have the generic jordan form for @xmath174 .
since all hermitian matrices are diagonalizable , the generic jordan form for @xmath174 must be diagonalizable . to show that @xmath178 is reductive , we note that the connected component of @xmath178 is the direct product of copies of @xmath172 quotient by a subgroup of the center of the direct product group .
it then follows that since @xmath172 is reductive , so is @xmath178 . finally we need to be able to confirm that any example we might construct ( either numerically or analytically ) with no complex duals , lies in the open subset of local hamiltonians in which the number of duals is constant .
firstly , we note from our proof of theorem [ thrm : constduals ] that if @xmath37 satisfies the conditions in the complex version of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] then it lies in the open subspace of stable points of @xmath174 .
we then simply need to show that @xmath205 is smooth at @xmath37 .
however since the git quotient is locally just a geometric quotient , this will be true so long as the differential of @xmath195 is surjective on the tangent space of @xmath174 quotiented by the tangent space of the orbit of @xmath178 , which is again just a restatement of the conditions for theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] .
finally , again because the differential is surjective , the point in the fiber necessarily has trivial multiplicity . combining theorems [ thrm : finiteduals ] and [ thrm : constduals ] , we have therefore proved analytically that , if we have a single example ( subject to the conditions described above ) in some class of local hamiltonians which has no complex duals , then almost all hamiltonians in that class have a unique tps in which they are local .
in the previous section we showed that for systems of a fixed size , if you can find a single example of a local hamiltonian with a unique local tps , then generic local hamiltonians of that size must also have a unique local tps . in this section ,
we use numerics to demonstrate that such example hamiltonians " exist , at least for a small class of numerically tractable problems .
these numerical examples , when combined with theorems [ thrm : finiteduals ] and [ thrm : constduals ] , amount to a proof of the following statements : 1 .
almost all 2-local hamiltonians on 10 qubits have finitely many ( and possibly zero ) 2-local duals .
almost all nearest - neighbor hamiltonians on 10-qubit spin chains have finitely many ( and possibly zero ) 2-local duals .
the above statements are fully proven , if the associated numerical calculation is robust .
we believe the numerical result that aids the proof ( analogous to numerically calculating that a certain quantity is nonzero ) is robust to finite - precision machine error , although we do not undertake a rigorous analysis of the error . on the other hand , the result below
is only verified in a probabilistic fashion , as elaborated later in the section . 1 . (
_ probabilistically verified _ ) almost all translation - invariant , nearest - neighbor hamiltonians on 6-qubit spin chains have no translation - invariant duals .
the numerical calculations behind these results are discussed below .
first we focus on finding an example of a local hamiltonian with a finite number of duals , or equivalently , a local hamiltonian without infinitesimally nearby duals .
that is , we want a hamiltonian that will satisfy the hypotheses of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] .
the theorem applies within the context of a fixed hilbert space @xmath11 and a fixed subspace @xmath96 of local hamiltonians , such as the subspace of 2-local hamiltonians on 10 qubits ( @xmath8=2 , @xmath69=2 , @xmath68=10 ) .
a valid example hamiltonian " @xmath152 must have non - degenerate spectrum , and it must have the property listed in theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] : for any @xmath221 such that @xmath222 \in s$ ] , either @xmath127=0 $ ] or @xmath128 .
given an example hamiltonian , application of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] implies statement 1 above .
we want to choose a particular hamiltonian @xmath125 and check numerically that the above criterion holds . from the proof of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] , we see that the criterion is equivalent to asking that @xmath223 , provided that @xmath152 has nondegenerate spectrum .
the connected component of @xmath81 is the group of local unitary operators , so @xmath224 .
we will assume that @xmath152 does not commute with any local unitaries besides the identity , which is true for generic local hamiltonians , and which is easy to check for a particular @xmath152 .
then @xmath225 , and the criterion becomes @xmath226 for a particular choice of @xmath152 , one could compute the rank of the operator @xmath153 directly .
however , we will use a more efficient approach to check the above criterion . note that @xmath227 and @xmath228 furthermore , @xmath229 \
, | \ , a \in { \textrm{herm}}({\mathcal{h}})\}$ ] is precisely the set of operators with zero diagonal entries in the eigenbasis @xmath230 of @xmath152 .
that is , @xmath231 so @xmath232 is the set of local operators that have all zero diagonal entries in the eigenbasis of @xmath152 . with this motivation ,
define the matrix @xmath233 where @xmath234 are the eigenvectors of @xmath152 , and @xmath235 in some basis for @xmath96 .
the matrix @xmath148 may be computed somewhat efficiently .
the vectors in @xmath236 correspond to elements of @xmath237 .
( alternatively , it is easy to see that @xmath236 is the set of local operators which , when added to the hamiltonian , do not alter the spectrum to first order in perturbation theory . )
thus @xmath238 , and checking the criterion of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] for @xmath152 only requires computing @xmath239 , with the criterion satisfied if @xmath240 .
although the chosen @xmath152 need not be random , " we may choose @xmath152 by randomly generating a 2-local hamiltonian on 10 qubits ( @xmath8=2 , @xmath69=2 , @xmath68=10 ) .
first we must confirm numerically that the spectrum is nondegenerate .
then we must confirm that @xmath152 does not commute with any local unitary operators besides the identity .
( this condition can be checked analytically for any particular @xmath152 . ) finally , we must calculate @xmath241 .
numerically , we calculated @xmath242 then applying theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] , we have effectively proven that almost all 2-local , 10 qubit hamiltonians have a finite number of 2-local duals ( and possibly no duals ) .
again , the above conclusion only applies to _ almost all _ 2-local hamiltonians , 10-qubit hamiltonians .
any _ particular _
2-local hamiltonian may well have an infinitude of duals , but such hamiltonians are measure zero .
however , we can still make conclusions about more specific classes of hamiltonians .
consider some more narrow subclass of local hamiltonians , given as a linear subspace @xmath243 .
for instance , we might be interested in taking @xmath75 as the subspace of hamiltonians with nearest - neighbor couplings on spin chains , while @xmath96 is still the space of 2-local hamiltonians .
because @xmath75 is measure zero within @xmath96 , the above result still allows the possibility that all hamiltonians in @xmath75 have infinitely many 2-local duals .
however , a simple extension of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] implies that given an example hamiltonian @xmath244 , we can conclude not only that almost all hamiltonians in @xmath96 have finitely many duals , but also that almost all hamiltonians in @xmath75 have finitely many duals , which is a stronger statement .
we randomly generated examples of hamiltonians with nearest - neighbor couplings on 10-qubit spin chains .
these examples satisfied the hypothesis of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] , taking @xmath96 to be the space of 2-local hamiltonians on 10 qubits .
then the above generalization of theorem [ thrm : finiteduals ] implies that almost all 10-qubit spin chain hamiltonians have finitely many 2-local duals .
now we find an example to satisfy the hypotheses of of theorem [ thrm : constduals ] , in order to verify statement 3 above .
that is , we want an example of hamiltonian @xmath125 such that @xmath152 has no duals in @xmath245 , where @xmath245 is the complexification of @xmath96 . because this task is more difficult numerically ,
we choose a smaller subspace for @xmath96 .
in particular , we will consider @xmath96 as the space of translation - invariant , nearest - neighbor hamiltonians on 6-qubit spin chains ; @xmath245 consists of complex linear combinations of these operators .
although the non - hermitian operators in @xmath245 do not correspond to physical hamiltonians , we are interested in checking for complex duals in order to satisfy the hypotheses of theorem [ thrm : constduals ] , which then applies to generic local hamiltonians that _ are _ hermitian . given a randomly generated hamiltonian in @xmath125 , we want to find all possible complex duals by searching over the space @xmath245 for ( non - hermitian ) hamiltonians with the same spectrum .
that is , we want to find solutions @xmath37 to the equation @xmath246 for @xmath247 , where spectrum(@xmath37 ) denotes the list of eigenvalues .
these equations are difficult to solve , and the problem falls in the general class of inverse eigenvalue problems " @xcite .
it is useful to think of the solutions as solving an optimization problem : the duals are given by the set @xmath248 up to equivalence by local unitary operators and translations and reflections of the chain
. any norm may be used ( for instance , the @xmath249norm ) .
the duals will be exact global minima , with @xmath250 . because we only care about finding duals up to conjugation by 1-local operators
, it would be more efficient to search over a quotient of @xmath245 by the action of 1-local operators , rather than searching over the full space @xmath245 .
in fact , such a quotient is easy to define . for simplicity
, we will first describe how to form a quotient of @xmath96 by local unitary operators , rather than a quotient of @xmath245 by general 1-local operators .
moreover , we will consider the case of qubits in a translation - invariant spin chain , but the construction is easily generalized to qudits with any pattern of interactions . by analogy to the language of gauge theory and gauge - fixing , one might say that we want to find agauge - fixed " @xmath251 , where local unitary operators on qubits play the role of the gauge group .
this analogy may be helpful to those familiar ; otherwise , we simply say that @xmath252 should have exactly one representative from each orbit of the group of local unitaries acting on @xmath96 .
we can write @xmath97 as @xmath253 with 12 real coefficients @xmath254 , with pauli operators @xmath255 , with @xmath15 as a site index , identifying @xmath256 .
that is , we take @xmath96 to be the space of translation - invariant , nearest - neighbor hamiltonians on an @xmath68-qubit chain , up to an additive constant @xmath257 , with @xmath258 . because @xmath259 , we have 3 gauge " degrees of freedom , corresponding to local unitary operators in @xmath260 , which act by conjugation on @xmath96 , with the same local unitary acting on each qubit .
we want to find @xmath251 with @xmath261 .
first consider the terms @xmath262 .
there is a local unitary that diagonalizes this sum , which is to say that the terms @xmath262 are unitarily equivalent to the terms @xmath263 for some @xmath264 .
we can then remove the terms @xmath265 from the gauge - fixed subspace @xmath266 , because any @xmath97 is equivalent to some @xmath267 .
acting by conjugation with diagonal matrices in @xmath260 will preserve the @xmath263 term , and it will rotate the @xmath268 and @xmath269 terms between each other . in particular , there exists some diagonal matrix in @xmath260 that acts by conjugation to rotate the two terms @xmath270 into the single term @xmath271 .
then any @xmath97 is equivalent to some @xmath267 , where @xmath75 is of the form of eqn .
( @xmath272 ) , but with @xmath273 , using only 9 coefficients . from dimensional considerations , for almost all @xmath274 , @xmath37 will be isolated point in the intersection of @xmath252 with the orbit of @xmath37 under local unitary conjugation .
in other words , there are no infinitesimally nearby points in @xmath275 that are related by local unitaries . however , the orbit of @xmath37 under local unitary conjugation may intersect @xmath75 in several isolated points .
( in keeping with the analogy to gauge theory , one might say that the gauge - fixing is not global , and there is gribov ambiguity . " ) similarly , the complexification @xmath276 will contain at least one representative of each orbit of @xmath277 under conjugation by 1-local invertible operators .
then we can search for duals by optimizing @xmath278 rather than optimizing over @xmath277 .
it is difficult to perform a global optimization numerically ; that is , it is difficult to know that the minima found by the optimization algorithm are global minima and not just local minima . luckily , we know the value of the global minimum ( zero ) , and we know at least one of the global minima ( i.e. , @xmath152 ) , but we want to find _ all _ global minima .
we perform a gradient - descent - type search over @xmath279 , starting with a random initial point @xmath280 . after finding a global minimum @xmath281 with @xmath282
, we check whether it is related to @xmath152 by some combination of local unitary operations , reflections of the chain , or transposition .
( despite searching over the gauge - fixed " subspace @xmath277 , we must still check whether @xmath37 is related to @xmath152 by local unitaries , due to the imperfect gauge - fixing discussed above . )
if @xmath37 is not related to @xmath152 in this way , it is not a true dual . in practice
, we consistently found that for a randomly generated @xmath152 and randomly generated starting point @xmath283 , the search algorithm found either the global minimum @xmath152 , or some other global minimum @xmath37 related to @xmath152 by local unitaries , reflections , or transpose .
because the starting point @xmath283 was chosen independently of the original point @xmath152 , and because several choices of random initial point consistently led to @xmath152 or some a related hamiltonian , we expect that @xmath152 has no duals .
the more times the search is repeated with different starting points , the more confident one becomes that @xmath152 has no duals .
one might worry that the global minimum @xmath152 sits in a wide basin , i.e. the function @xmath284 is flat around @xmath152 .
then @xmath152 would be found for most starting points , while perhaps the duals of @xmath152 are global minima that sit in narrower basins for some reason , making them difficult to find with a local search algorithm .
if this were the case , consistently finding @xmath152 from a random starting point would _ not _ necessarily be evidence that @xmath152 has no duals . on the other hand
, we can repeat the search for many choices of @xmath152 .
if the latter scenario were true , where @xmath152 sometimes has duals that sit in narrow basins , one would expect that some of these randomly generated @xmath152 actually sit in the narrower basin , in which case the search would find the dual , because the dual would then be in the wider basin .
given 1000 randomly generated @xmath285 , with a randomly generated starting point @xmath283 for each @xmath152 , we found that in all of the trials , the search algorithm identified either the global minimum @xmath152 or another global minimum @xmath37 related by local unitaries , reflections of the chain , or transposition .
we therefore strongly believe that these @xmath152 have no duals , although we do not undertake a rigorous analysis of the efficacy of this probabilistic verification .
however , assuming that these randomly - generated @xmath152 indeed have no duals , we can apply theorem [ thrm : constduals ] to imply that almost all translation - invariant , nearest - neighbor hamiltonians on 7-qubit spin chains have no duals .
alternatively , we have demonstrated that for generic translation - invariant spin chains , the hamiltonian may be uniquely determined from the spectrum .
so far , we have been focused on finding examples to establish that almost all hamiltonians of a given class do not have duals .
however , suppose that we are given a spectrum that _ does _ have duals .
then the algorithms mentioned above can find the dual descriptions . for concreteness ,
consider the one - dimensional ising model , given in eqn .
( [ eq : ising ] ) in the introduction , repeated here : @xmath286 in fact , the ising model is special , and has many duals that are geometrically @xmath287-local plus boundary terms , even when we require that they must be translation - invariant .
we discovered many duals numerically by searching over the relevant class of hamiltonians . to find the particular dual in eqn .
( [ eq : isingdual ] ) , namely @xmath288 we limited our search to a more restricted subspace of hamiltonians which contains our dual of interest .
this subspace is defined by the class of hamiltonians of the form @xmath289 where the @xmath290 terms are possible boundary terms . to be clear , unlike above where we searched over _ all _ hamiltonians of a particular locality class , here we are restricting the search to an essentially arbitrary , smaller ` locality class ' of hamiltonians that was deliberately chosen to contain a particular dual . numerically searching over the class of hamiltonians in eqn .
( [ eq : arbitraryclass ] ) indeed recovered @xmath37 , and also found the desired dual in eqn .
( [ eq : isingdual ] ) .
thus , by using locality to guide our search in the space of hamiltonians , we may search for dualities of a given system if we have reason to believe that such dualities exist .
so far , we have restricted our discussion to finite - dimensional bosonic systems , i.e. hardcore bosons or generalized spin systems .
one desired line of generalization is to consider infinite - dimensional systems , mentioned at the end of the section .
another line of generalization is to consider theories which are qualitatively local , but for which the observables do not form a strict tensor product structure , at least in the sense defined by section [ sec : tps ] .
examples of local theories without strict tps s are fermionic theories and gauge theories . in section [ sec : tps ] , a tps on a hilbert space @xmath11 was defined as a collection of of subalgebras @xmath29 , @xmath25 , such that @xmath31=0 $ ] for @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 .
fermionic lattice theories do not directly fit this description , because fermionic operators at different sites anti - commute .
one might therefore wonder in what sense fermionic theories
local " : is commutation necessary for locality ?
in fact , commutation relations _ are _ generally necessary to prevent signalling between distant locations .
but physical theories with fermions are nonetheless local , because the hamiltonian contains terms with even products of nearby fermion operators , and these terms do commute with each other . by restricting the algebra of observables on the hilbert space to the subalgebra of physical " observables namely , even products of single - fermion operators
we can then arrange the physical algebra into mutually commuting subalgebras associated with spatial regions .
this general notion is captured by a
net of observables , " the basic structure used in algebraic quantum field theory @xcite , and one can easily adapt the field - theoretic definition to discretized lattice systems .
we equip a hilbert space with a set @xmath96 of spatial sites , like the points of a lattice .
crucially , these sites do not correspond to tensor factors of the hilbert space ; they are just abstract labels .
subsets @xmath291 are regions , " and we have * definition ( net of observables ) : * a net of observables on hilbert space @xmath11 is a subalgebra of physical " observables @xmath292 , along with a set of sites @xmath96 , and an assignment of a subalgebra @xmath293 to each region @xmath291
. the subalgebras must satisfy @xmath294 , along with 1 .
@xmath295 for @xmath296 2 . @xmath297=0 $ ] for disjoint regions @xmath298 3 .
@xmath299 for disjoint regions @xmath298 finally , one might also require : 1 .
the map @xmath300 is injective .
this definition is similar to that used by @xcite . in the context of a net of observables ,
a local hamiltonian would be one that may be written as a sum of terms in @xmath301 for small regions @xmath40 , perhaps where @xmath96 has the additional structure of a geometric lattice . as a simple example of a net of observables , consider a hilbert space @xmath302 with an ordinary tps .
then the naturally associated net of observables would be defined by @xmath303 for @xmath304 . however , the purpose of defining a net of observables is that not all nets must be associated with explicit tensor factorizations of @xmath11 .
for instance , given a fermionic theory on a lattice , we would define @xmath301 to be generated by products of even numbers of fermion creation and annihilation operators .
then @xmath305 , i.e. only fermion - even operators are considered physical , and the hilbert space has no natural tps . like fermionic theories
, gauge theories also lack an ordinary tps , at least when restricting to the physical " hilbert space .
but , like fermionic theories , the local structure of gauge theories is suitably generalized by using a net of observables instead . for simplicity , consider two - dimensional @xmath306-lattice gauge theory .
the full , unphysical " hilbert space is the tensor product of qubit degrees of freedom living on the edges of a square lattice .
so the full hilbert @xmath307 space is endowed with a natural tps .
however , the physical hilbert @xmath308 is the proper subspace gauge - invariant physical states , and the physical observables @xmath26 consist of gauge - invariant observables on @xmath307 , restricted to the gauge - invariant subspace . in general
, a subspace of a space with an explicit tps will not inherit the tps in any natural way , so the physical hilbert space will not have a natural tps . on the other hand
, we can construct a net of observables by defining @xmath309 to be the algebra of gauge - invariant observables , with @xmath301 the algebra of gauge - invariant observables local to @xmath40 .
gauge theory does not have the property that @xmath310 for disjoint regions @xmath298 , which would be true for any theory with an ordinary tps , showing that an ordinary tps would not have sufficed to capture the local structure of the theory .
we have seen that nets of observables provide a generalized notion of tps sufficient to capture the local structure of fermions and gauge theory .
do the uniqueness results at the heart of this paper generalize to theories whose local structure is described by a net of observables , rather than a strict tps ? that is , given an abstract hilbert space and hamiltonian , we can ask whether there exists a net of observables on the hilbert space such that the hamiltonian is local . and then , given that such a net exists , we can ask whether it is unique .
questions about nets are harder to tackle than the analogous questions about ordinary tps s .
to see why , let us reconsider a nuance in the discussion of ordinary tps s that we have not addressed .
given some local system of qubits , rather than simply asking whether the system has a dual using a different set of qubit degrees of freedom , we might ask whether there is a dual using qudits .
that is , we may want to consider duals that use different types " of tps s . up to unitary equivalence , a tps on a hilbert space is just characterized by the list of dimensions of the subsystems , and these must multiply to the total dimension , so it is easy to characterize the types " of tps s : qubits , or qutrits , or some combination , etc .
meanwhile , there are many more types of nets .
indeed , on a given hilbert space , there are more possible nets of observables , even up to unitary equivalence .
the net corresponding to fermions is different than the net corresponding to gauge theory , because they use different sorts of algebras @xmath301 , and one could construct nets that do not obviously correspond to bosons , fermions , or gauge theories .
the harder question then becomes : given some hamiltonian @xmath37 that looks local using a given net , does @xmath37 have any duals that not only use different local degrees of freedom but also use a different type of net ? while the above questions are certainly difficult , the following observation suggests they may tractable .
we already know the types of tps are easy to characterize , controlled by the dimension of the hilbert space . given some fixed @xmath311 , the tps can not have too many subsystems , assuming each subsystem has dimension greater than one .
the types of nets are similarly controlled .
as long as one assumes that the algebra @xmath301 is non - trivial for any region @xmath40 larger than some fixed size , then condition ( 4 ) in the definition of a net ensures that @xmath311 will be exponential in the number of sites .
so for given hilbert space @xmath11 , a net can not be constructed with more sites than about @xmath312 , offering some control on the types of nets allowed .
none of the results in this paper directly apply to infinite - dimensional systems .
there are three types of infinities to consider . first
, a theory with non - hardcore bosons will have infinite - dimensional hilbert spaces at each lattice site .
second , in the continuum limit , there are infinitely many lattice sites per fixed volume , associated with uv divergences .
third , in the large system limit , there are infinitely many lattice sites at fixed spacing .
the large - system limit alone may yield interesting complications when attempting to reproduce the finite - dimensional results .
the discussion in section [ sec : main ] relies essentially on the well - behavedness of the map from a hamiltonian to its spectrum .
however , in the large - system limit , the eigenvalues may vary non - analytically with respect to the hamiltonian , leading famously to phase transitions .
another result of non - analyticity is that properties which are true generically for finite - size systems may not be true generic infinite - size systems .
for instance ,
finite - size local hamiltonians are generically non - degenerate ; that is , a random local perturbation of a degenerate local hamiltonian will break the degeneracy .
but certain infinite - size lattice systems have topological order , with a ground state degeneracy that is robust to any local perturbation .
in particular , there exist open neighborhoods in the space of infinite two - dimensional lattice hamiltonians such that all hamiltonians in the neighborhood have degenerate spectrum .
therefore , one can not navely rule out the possibility that there exists a region of nonzero volume in the space of infinite - size local hamiltonians where the hamiltonians all have duals .
we began by formally defining a tensor product structure ( tps ) on a hilbert space , allowing one to pose clear questions about the existence of tps s for which a hamiltonian is local .
first we observed that for some fixed hamiltonian @xmath37 , questions about the existence of a tps in which @xmath37 is local may be translated into questions about the existence of local hamiltonians with the same spectrum as @xmath37 . with this perspective , we showed that almost all hamiltonians do _ not _ have any tps for which the hamiltonian is local .
equivalently , generic hamiltonians are not isospectral to any local hamiltonian .
on the other hand , physical systems are distinguished by the property that they _ are _ local in some tps , or at least approximately so .
we therefore considered hamiltonians known to have some local tps and argued that the local tps is generically unique .
equivalently , a generic local hamiltonian is uniquely determined by its spectrum .
put a third way , generic local hamiltonians do not have duals . "
the argument for this claim involves two parts : first , we proved that if there exists a single example of a local hamiltonian without any duals , then almost all local hamiltonians have no duals .
second , we found numerical examples of local hamiltonians for small systems that do not have any duals , effectively proving that almost all hamiltonians on these systems do not have any duals .
we speculated that these results may be extended to arbitrarily large finite - dimensional systems , with the possibility of interesting subtleties in the infinite - size limit .
finally , we presented a generalization of a tps , suitable for fermions and gauge theories .
further generalizations discussed below address situations where only a subspace of the full hilbert space is equipped with a tps , perhaps with relevance to the bulk side of holographic theories .
in this paper we argue that given the spectrum of a hamiltonian that is local in some tps , then generically the local tps is uniquely determined .
in fact , one can also determine the local tps by merely knowing the time evolution of a single generic state in the hilbert space , without otherwise knowing @xmath37 .
the time evolution of a generic state @xmath313 has the form @xmath314 for each of the eigenstates @xmath315 with energy @xmath316 . taking the fourier transform of @xmath317 with respect to time
, we can determine the spectrum and hence the local tps .
however , even with a known tps , much remains to be understood about the unitary evolution of states .
much research is dedicated to the subject of expressing the wavefunction as a sum of decoherent classical branches @xcite .
this research generally assumes the existence of some underlying tps and it has been recognized that it would be preferable to have the tps emerge naturally in the same way as the branches @xcite ; our results suggest a way to do that . given both a low - energy state and a tps , recent work @xcite suggests one can construct a metric on the discrete sites of the tps .
the distance assigned between sites is dictated by the mutual information between the subsystems , giving a geometry " that depends on the state .
it would be possible to combine this approach with the work in this paper , determining both a tps _ and _ a notion of distance between subsystems , starting from just the spectrum .
first one determines the most local tps , then finds the ground state of the hamiltonian with respect to that tps , and finally uses the mutual information of the ground state to define distances between subsystems . in this paper
, we already associate a graph to the tps , based on which sites are directly interacting under the hamiltonian .
the graph approximately describes the topological structure of the space , while the proposal of @xcite would assign lengths to the edges of the graph , upgrading the topological data to geometric data .
however , when the hamiltonian is already known , it may be more natural to rely on dynamical notions of distance like the light - cone or butterfly velocity , rather than asking about the mutual information of a state at fixed time .
recent progress has been made on the construction of universal quantum simulators @xcite .
in particular , consider a finite lattice system in @xmath69 spatial dimensions , governed by local hamiltonian @xmath37 on hilbert space @xmath11 . then one can always construct a local , two - dimensional spin system with hamiltonian @xmath99 on hilbert space @xmath318 , such that the low energy subspace of @xmath99 reproduces the spectrum of @xmath37 with arbitrary precision .
because the simulator requires many auxiliary degrees of freedom , the number of lattice sites used in @xmath318 will be larger than the number of sites present in the original system @xmath11 , so @xmath319 and the systems are not dual in the strict sense used above .
however , one might consider the notion of a tps for a subspace of the full hilbert space .
restricting attention to the low energy subspace of the device , one could in principle find the tps corresponding to the simulated system .
this situation may be analogous to the ads / cft duality in which the tps of the bulk gravity theory only describes a subspace of the full hilbert space .
this is further discussed in section [ sec : qg ] below . until now
, we have avoided the question of why to prefer one tps over another .
instead , we have simply asserted that we are interested in tps s for which dynamics appear local .
if one treats the wavefunction and its hamiltonian without any preferred basis as the only fundamental data of a quantum system , then _ a priori _ all tps s are equally valid descriptions of the system .
, the radical view would suggest that the tps of the simulated system has the same ontological status as the tps of the simulation device . ] because the world around us has local interactions , it is natural that we are interested in tps s with local dynamics .
however , one might ask why our experience privileges a particular tps for the universe namely , the tps associated with spatial degrees of freedom ?
one possible answer is that local interactions are an essential ingredient for localized observers .
for contrast , consider some randomly chosen tps , in which interactions are non - local .
a hypothetical observer localized " in this tps will quickly become delocalized , so perhaps observers in such a tps can not exist for extended periods . instead , only a tps with local dynamics can naturally describe localized observers , and their experience will privilege that local tps . the existence of localized observers may also require more than just a local tps .
for example , even local interactions may be strongly coupled and chaotic , such that localized objects quickly become maximally entangled with their environment .
one might expect that such dynamics do not allow localized observers , because such observers would quickly become delocalized despite having only local interactions .
a measure of entanglement growth was considered in @xcite as a criterion for choosing a tps , though the author restricted the analysis to tps s related by bogoliubov transformations .
when searching for a tps with slow entanglement growth , one must decide for which class of states to consider the entanglement .
one possibility is to consider random product states @xcite , while another natural choice would be low - energy states .
the computational complexity of a unitary operator the number of local quantum gates needed to contstruct the operator is an important notion in quantum information theory and features in discussions of quantum gravity @xcite .
the complexity of an operator depends crucially on the choice of tps .
given a fixed tps , random unitary operators will have complexity that is exponential in system size , as demonstrated by a dimension - counting argument .
moreover , by an argument similar to that of section [ sec : existence ] , generic unitary operators will have no tps in which they have low complexity .
however , if a hamiltonian is local in some tps , the time - evolution operator @xmath320 will have much smaller complexity in that tps , at least for times sub - exponential in the system size . because the locality of @xmath37 determines the growth rate of complexity of @xmath320 , at least for sufficiently small times , an alternate description of the local tps is the tps in which @xmath320 has minimal complexity at small times .
the most well - known of the dualities in quantum gravity is the ads / cft correspondence between strongly coupled @xmath321 super yang - mills in @xmath322dimensions ( the boundary theory ) and weakly coupled quantum gravity in @xmath323 ( the bulk theory ) @xcite .
this duality is unlikely to satisfy the precise definition of duality used in this paper , even using the generalization of section [ sec : gauge ] . in particular ,
the tps in the bulk is only defined for a subspace of states of the complete hilbert space .
these are states associated with small perturbations of the geometry around a flat ads background @xcite .
however , when the state contains a black hole , for example , it does not make sense to talk about the same approximately - local degrees of freedom that existed in flat space .
the discrepancy is especially manifest in tensor network toy models of ads / cft , where the model of a black hole involves tearing out tensors from the network @xcite .
this model completely removes some of the bulk lattice sites , and instead the ` correct ' tps for the subspace of states containing the black hole consists of the remaining bulk sites , together with new lattice sites at the boundary of the black hole . describing different subsets of states in the hilbert space with different tps s in a coherent way seems to require yet another generalization tensor product structures .
the question of whether the boundary theory or bulk theory is more local `` is somewhat subtle .
the bulk gravitational theory will necessarily have small non - local interactions , but it also has far fewer degrees of freedom at each lattice site '' than does the boundary theory , where there is a large @xmath324 matrix of operators associated to each site .
the bulk tps has a much smaller algebra of local operators , since it divides the hilbert space up into much smaller subsystems .
one might therefore describe the bulk tps as more local than the boundary tps when considering the low energy subspace , even though the hamiltonian is only approximately local with respect to the bulk tps . a toy model for ads / cft
, the sachdev - ye - kitaev model @xcite , is particularly relevant to the discussions in this paper .
the hamiltonian of the theory is comprised of @xmath113 majorana fermions @xmath325 with all - to - all @xmath326-local coupling terms - local , it is completely geometrically non - local , with every site interacting with every other site . ] : @xmath327 the coefficients @xmath328 are sampled from i.i.d .
random gaussians , describing an ensemble of hamiltonians .
since this ensemble is the fermionic analog of a class of bosonic local hamiltonians considered in this paper , we might expect that generic syk hamiltonians would not have any local duals . on the other hand ,
when one disorder - averages the syk hamiltonian and takes the expectation of observables over the probability distribution for @xmath329 , one can remarkably rewrite the theory in terms of degrees of freedom that include a type of einstein - dilaton gravity in @xmath330 dimensions @xcite . as a consequence , one can compute the spectrum of the bulk gravity theory by computing the spectrum of the majorana theory ( in a particular limit ) , which is comparatively easier to treat @xcite . in accordance with our intuition , it is likely that the complete description of the dynamics is not even approximately local at scales smaller than the 1 + 1d ads scale .
nonetheless , it is interesting that this alternative description is able to exist at all , when the hamiltonian itself is generic within some class of local hamiltonians .
there are many open questions about whether our results extend to the generalized notion of tps suitable for fermions and gauge theories discussed in section [ sec : gauge ] , as well as to infinite - dimensional systems or approximately local tps s . furthermore , while we have provided evidence that recovery of the tps from the spectrum of spin chains is generically possible in principle , we have not discussed practical measures to determine whether a local tps exists for a given spectrum or how to find it apart from numerically searching through possible tps s .
it appears that finding the most local tps for a given spectrum is computationally impractical ( using classical computation ) for all but the smallest hilbert spaces , but it is possible that there may be very good heuristic algorithms .
it would be interesting if there was , in contrast , an efficient quantum algorithm to find local tps s .
we would like to thank daniel bump , dylan butson , benjamin lim , edward mazenc , xiao - liang qi , semon rezchikov , leonard susskind , arnav tripathy , ravi vakil , and michael walter for their valuable discussions and support .
we are also especially grateful to patrick hayden and frances kirwan for their valuable insights and feedback , and for reviewing this manuscript .
jc is supported by the fannie and john hertz foundation and the stanford graduate fellowship program .
dr is supported by the stanford graduate fellowship program .
maldacena , juan .
the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity . " _ aip conference proceedings conf-981170_. eds .
ricardo e. gamboa saravi , horacio falomir , and fidel a. schaposnik .
vol . 484 .
1 . aip , 1999 .
a. kitaev , a simple model of quantum holography . "
+ http://online.kitp.ucsb.edu/online/entangled15/kitaev/ + http : //online.kitp.ucsb.edu / online / entangled15/kitaev2/ + talks at kitp , april 7 , 2015 and may 27 , 2015 .
maldacena , juan , douglas stanford , and zhenbin yang .
conformal symmetry and its breaking in two - dimensional nearly anti - de sitter space . "
_ progress of theoretical and experimental physics _ 2016.12 ( 2016 ) : 12c104 . | essential to the description of a quantum system are its local degrees of freedom , which enable the interpretation of subsystems and dynamics in the hilbert space . while a choice of local tensor factorization of the hilbert space is often implicit in the writing of a hamiltonian or lagrangian ,
the identification of local tensor factors is not intrinsic to the hilbert space itself .
instead , the only basis - invariant data of a hamiltonian is its spectrum , which does not manifestly determine the local structure .
this ambiguity is highlighted by the existence of dualities , in which the same energy spectrum may describe two systems with very different local degrees of freedom .
we argue that in fact , the energy spectrum alone almost always encodes a unique description of local degrees of freedom when such a description exists , allowing one to explicitly identify local subsystems and how they interact . in special cases ,
multiple dual local descriptions can be extracted from a given spectrum , but generically the local description is unique .
5cm(12.5cm,-8 cm ) |
paul traps have become essential tools in widely different fields of research ranging from quantum information@xmath0@xcite and quantum simulation@xmath0@xcite to precision metrology@xmath0@xcite and cold collisions between ions and neutrals@xmath0@xcite .
the further development of all these lines of research hinges on continuing improvements of the paul trap architectures and on a better understanding of the current experimental issues .
+ ideally , a single ion in a paul trap is only subjected to the electric fields generated by the voltages applied to the trap electrodes . however , even small spatial variations of the electrode surface potential ( i.e. patch potentials ) in the vicinity of the trap center create stray electric fields which significantly perturb this ideal configuration .
this leads to undesired experimental complications .
quasi - static stray fields lead to positional shifts of the trapped ion@xmath0@xcite and thus to excess micromotion@xmath0@xcite . rapidly fluctuating stray fields
lead to ion heating @xmath0@xcite . for the following discussion
, we will formally group patch potentials into two categories .
+ patch potentials of category 1 can decay via electronic discharge currents , similar to a capacitor that is shorted with a resistor .
thus , their evolution is in general governed by the motion of electrons .
for example , the photoelectric effect can generate charges on the dielectric surfaces of the paul trap .
these surfaces could be the trap mounts but also insulating oxide layers on the trap electrodes .
the photoelectric effect typically appears with light at wavelengths below about 500@xmath0 nm .
as most of the trapped ion species require light at such blue " wavelengths for laser cooling and interrogation , light - induced patch charges will continuously be created while the experiments are carried out .
in addition , patch potentials of category 1 can also be generated in other ways such as the direct deposition of electrons and ions on dielectric surfaces ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
+ patch potentials of category 2 are stable as long as the surface atoms do not move .
they are due to a spatial variation of the material@xmath1s work function which depends on its composition , its crystal orientation and its surface adsorbates @xcite .
surface adsorbates can be elements or compounds which are physically or chemically bound onto the surface .
crystal orientation comes into play for neighboring grains in a polycrystalline structure .
a change in composition comes about e.g. when two different metals are brought into contact .
this gives rise to the contact potential , i.e. the difference of the work functions of the two metals .
ion traps are often loaded from atomic beams which are directed towards the trap center .
if the atomic beam hits the paul trap electrodes , atoms are deposited on the electrode surface , potentially forming contact potentials .
furthermore , as previously mentioned , the formation and deposition of chemical compounds on the trap surface can also create electric stray fields .
+ patch potentials of both categories have been observed to cause deteriorations of paul traps leading to strong ion heating effects@xmath0@xcite .
however , the influence and evolution of the patch potentials of category 2 was often masked by the presence of photo - induced patch potentials .
+ here , we study the long - term dynamics of quasi - static electric fields in a paul trap in an environment where we systematically suppress both continuous surface contamination and continuous photo - induced patch charge build - up .
we observe smooth drifts of the quasi - static electric stray fields on various time scales from days to months .
we interpret these different time scales as indications of different physical and chemical processes that take place .
for example , electric fields induced by the exposure of the trap to laser light typically decay within a few days . fields induced by creating an atomic beam using a barium oven show slower dynamics on the order of months .
after longer time periods without surface contamination and photo - induced charging , the stray electric fields settle smoothly towards a stable value with very small residual drifts as low as 0.03@xmath0v / m per day . + in our setup , we achieve the suppression of surface contamination and photo - induced patch charges as follows .
we create and probe ions ( rb@xmath2 ) in a linear paul trap by using only near - infrared light sources ( @xmath3 = 780@xmath0 nm and 1064@xmath0 nm ) and small clouds of @xmath4 ultracold rb atoms , which have previously been optically transported into the chamber@xmath0@xcite .
thus , the net flux of atoms into the chamber is negligible .
we measure the electric stray fields by applying compensating electric fields until the excess micromotion of the ion is minimized@xmath0@xcite .
[ sec:2 ] the design of our linear paul trap is shown in fig.@xmath0[fig:1 ] .
the effective distance from the trap center to each of the four radiofrequency ( rf ) electrodes is 2.6@xmath0 mm while the distance to the endcap electrodes measures @xmath5 mm . to create radial confinement , a voltage driven at a frequency of @xmath6mhz with an amplitude of @xmath7v
is applied to two of the rf electrodes while the other two are held at ground potential .
axial confinement is generated by applying static voltages of about @xmath8v to the two endcap electrodes . under these experimental conditions ,
a @xmath9rb@xmath2 ion is confined at radial trapping frequencies of about @xmath10khz and an axial trapping frequency of about @xmath11khz .
the total depth of the trap is on the order of 4@xmath0ev and allows for ion storage times of many days , even without any type of cooling .
the paul trap is part of a hybrid atom - ion trap setup that brings the trapped ion into contact with an ultracold cloud of atoms@xmath0@xcite .
ensembles of @xmath9rb atoms are prepared in a separate vacuum chamber and transported into the paul trap using a long - distance optical transport line .
they are then loaded into a crossed dipole trap where further evaporative cooling down to typical temperatures of 700@xmath0nk is performed .
the atom numbers typically range between @xmath12 and @xmath13 atoms .
both the optical transport and the crossed dipole trap are implemented using several w of laser power at a wavelength of 1064@xmath0 nm . to perform absorption imaging of the atoms , resonant laser light at 780@xmath0 nm
after this destructive imaging process , a new atom cloud is prepared within 30@xmath0s for the next measurement . to load an ion ,
a rb atom cloud with a density of several @xmath14 is prepared and positioned at the center of the paul trap .
three - body recombination processes in the atom cloud produce rb@xmath15 molecules which are subsequently ionized by a rempi process using photons from the dipole trap laser@xmath0@xcite .
subsequently , the molecular rb@xmath16 ions quickly dissociate via collisions with neutral atoms and finally yield rb@xmath2 ions .
+ to detect the number of trapped rb@xmath2 ions and measure their micromotion , we employ a sensitive probing scheme using ultracold atomic clouds@xmath0@xcite . for this
, we immerse the ions into clouds consisting of about @xmath12 atoms at densities around @xmath17 .
after a few seconds of interaction time , we detect the final atom number and atom temperature which depend on the number of ions and their micromotion .
this enables us to reliably work with a single ion and , by minimizing its excess micromotion with the help of electric compensation fields , to measure the stray electric fields acting on the ion@xmath0@xcite . due to the production time
required for the atom clouds , an electric field measurement requires about an hour of measurement time , resulting in a limited temporal resolution .
the measurement precision is high and typically ranges around 0.1@xmath0v / m for the results presented here .
as a first step we investigate the susceptibility of our trap setup with respect to laser light at various wavelengths which are available in our lab ( fig.@xmath0[fig:2 ] ) . for these and the following measurements , each laser beam propagates through the center of the ion trap in horizontal direction at an angle of 45@xmath18 with respect to the trap axis .
in particular , the laser beam and its specular reflection from the vacuum windows do not directly impinge on any trap electrode or trap mount .
only some stray scattered light from the windows illuminates the trap parts diffusely and quite evenly .
both the trap electrodes and the trap mounts can be charged up " via the photoelectric effect .
the trap mounts and the mounts for the barium oven are made of machinable glass - ceramic ( macor ) , which is very susceptible for accumulating charges .
charges can also accumulate on the trap electrode surfaces as these often feature undesired insulating coatings such as oxide layers .
as expected , for wavelengths below 500@xmath19 nm we find a sharp increase in light - induced build - up of electric fields ( see fig.2 ) . for 780@xmath0 nm or the even longer wavelength of 1064@xmath0 nm , we did not detect any measurable light - induced electric fields . in general
, we find the photo - induced stray electric fields to be pointing mostly in vertical ( + @xmath20-axis ) and axial ( + @xmath21-axis ) direction .
there might be a number of reasons how this asymmetry in the direction of the electric stray field comes about .
one reason could be that the laser light illuminates the trap setup asymmetrically .
however , we can exclude this possibility as the field direction is quite insensitive to changes in the propagation direction of the laser light , in particular when it is flipped by 90@xmath22 in the horizontal plane .
another possible explanation for the asymmetry could be the presence , e.g. of a single dust particle on the trap electrodes , which is something we can not rule out .
an obvious asymmetry , however , is already inherent in our paul trap setup due to the location of the mount and aperture plate of the barium oven ( see fig.@xmath01 , lower right ) .
indeed , we estimate that these two parts ( which are made of macor ) can lead to significant electric stray fields at the location of the ion . for one , they can potentially be charged to voltages of up to 500@xmath0v , as determined by the amplitude of the rf trap drive .
( the rf fields prevent the patch potentials from saturating at a low voltage , the value of which would be normally set by the difference of the work function and the photon energy . ) secondly , our trap geometry is relatively open such that external electric fields can penetrate quite well to the position of the ion
. we can not deterministically charge the aperture plate or the oven mount to a certain voltage in order to test their effect on the electric field at the position of the ion .
however , we can apply voltages to the ba oven itself which should create electric fields of similar magnitude and orientation .
we find that a voltage of 1@xmath0v on the oven indeed results in a dominant electric field contribution of @xmath23v / m in @xmath20-direction .
the other two field components are each about a factor of 6 smaller ( @xmath24v / m in @xmath25-direction and @xmath26v / m in @xmath21-direction ) .
these values set a lower bound to the expected fields originating from a charged aperture plate which is located closer to the ion than the oven .
next , we start a long - term experiment where we monitor the evolution of all three spatial components of the stray electric field over a time span of about four months ( fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] ) . before the start of these measurements ,
the ion trap was operated with ba@xmath2 ions so that both the barium oven and the necessary lasers were frequently used .
consequently , there is a substantial stray electric field to begin with . during the measurements ( except for two short occasions )
the whole experimental setup is almost entirely shielded from ambient light by means of light - tight protective covers to avoid any patch charge build - up .
all three electric field components ( in @xmath25 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 direction ) show a more or less monotonic decay and converge towards long - term limits which are each set to @xmath27 in the plot .
the solid lines in fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] are double - exponential fits of the form @xmath28 where @xmath29 are the electric field shifts and @xmath30 are the time constants of the exponential decay curves .
for the two radial directions ( @xmath25- and @xmath20-directions ) we find relatively rapid initial decays with time constants @xmath31 days ( see inset of fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] ) and subsequent slow decays with @xmath32 days . in axial direction the time constants are @xmath33 and @xmath34days .
for all three directions the slow decays are dominant as they account for roughly 80 - 95@xmath0% of the electric field shifts ( see table@xmath01 ) .
+ on two occasions ( @xmath35days and @xmath36days ) , the light - tight protective covers around the experimental setup had to be removed for several hours so that the paul trap was subjected ( quite uniformly ) to ambient white light from the fluorescent ceiling lights . as a consequence , the electric field in vertical ( @xmath20 ) direction shows a sharp increase and then decays back towards its long - term behavior within several days .
we investigate this effect in detail below .
+ after about 100 days , the daily drift of the vertical field was below @xmath37v / m yielding extremely stable experimental conditions . in addition , this slow drift allows for a precise prediction of the expected electric fields at a given time so that the field compensation can be adjusted without requiring additional measurements .
after the time period shown in fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] , we make use of the low stray field drift to selectively test the dynamics of photo - induced patch charges . for this measurement
we shine through the chamber about 2.5@xmath0mw of laser power at a wavelength of 413@xmath0 nm ( 3@xmath0ev ) for 4 minutes .
the direction of the laser beam and the conditions with respect to trap illumination are the same as for the measurements in fig.@xmath02 , as discussed in the beginning of section 3 .
the strongest effect is again observed in the vertical electric field component which increases by about 6@xmath19v / m .
the axial field component increases by 1.5@xmath0v / m , the horizontal component by 0.6@xmath0v / m . the laser was then switched off and the decay of the vertical field component was monitored over 5 days ( fig.@xmath0[fig:4 ] ) .
the data is fit by a double - exponential curve with an initial decay on a timescale @xmath38days and a slow decay with @xmath39days .
this slow decay accounts for about 80@xmath0% of the field shift .
the observed initial increase and subsequent decay of the electric field are in rough agreement with the behavior seen in fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] after the paul trap had been subjected to ambient light .
thus , our data in figs . 3 and 4 clearly indicate that photo - induced electric fields decay on typical timescales of a few days .
+ we explain the evolution of the photo - induced stray fields as follows : initially , the photoelectric effect generates charges on electrically isolated surfaces resulting in electric stray potentials . over time these potentials discharge by the finite resistivity of the material . in case of a charging of the aperture plate or the oven
mount we can estimate a timescale for the discharge .
at room temperature , macor has a specific volume resistivity of about 10@xmath40 cm .
the typical resistance of a cm - sized component then is on the order of 10@xmath41 .
the electric capacitance of a @xmath42-sized plate is about 4@xmath43 cm , with @xmath44 denoting the vacuum permittivity .
thus , the decay constant is on the order of 10 hours , which roughly agrees with our observed time scales .
we note that the resistivity of macor is strongly temperature dependent .
we do not have a precise knowledge of the temperature of the mount but from our estimate it is clear that time scales for the discharging of the macor parts should not be much longer than a few days .
the fact that we observe not only a single timescale for the field decay indicates that there is more than one contribution to the stray fields .
a charged up macor part might exhibit a different discharge behavior than a dust particle or an isolated patch on the electrode surface . in any case , the data in fig . 4 and especially in fig .
3 ( at t @xmath45 and t @xmath46 days ) clearly indicate that photo - induced fields always decay on a timescale faster than two weeks .
the question is then how the very slow drift taking place over about 90 days can be explained ( see fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] ) .
our observatios suggest that the electric fields linked to this slow decay have a different origin than the photoelectric effect .
+ we conjecture that the slow drifts originate from the dynamics of potentials of category 2 , e.g. contact potentials .
these potentials may change due to slow chemical reactions in the ultrahigh vacuum environment or by diffusion and migration processes on the electrode surface .
it is known that barium reacts and forms compounds with o@xmath15 , n@xmath15 , co@xmath15 and h@xmath15o . it also acts as a getter material , inclosing non - reactive gases .
thus , the mobility of ba on a surface is sizeable .
( interestingly , the work function of barium is known to remain quite constant ( @xmath47ev ) even when contaminated with other substances . ) diffusion or migration of barium on the electrode surface can coat certain compound layers and set other ones free thus giving rise to slowly changing contact potentials . at room temperature
the vapor pressure of barium is very low .
even at 200@xmath22c it only reaches @xmath48 mbar .
this suggests that barium coatings have a long lifetime at ambient temperatures . [
cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] previous studies have investigated the influence of barium contaminations on paul trap electrodes made of be - cu@xmath0@xcite .
long time scales for the quasi - static electric stray field drifts on the order of months were found , similar to our time constant for the slow drift ( @xmath49days ) in fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] .
furthermore , it was found in@xmath0@xcite that baking out a paul trap with tungsten electrodes that had been coated with ba significantly changed electric stray fields . in order to test our conjecture
, we now investigate the influence of the barium oven ( while keeping any light below a wavelength of 780@xmath0 nm blocked off ) . immediately after the measurements of fig.@xmath04
are completed , the oven is heated to a temperature of more than 600@xmath18c for 10 minutes inducing a drop of the vertical electric field component by about 7.5@xmath19v / m ( fig.@xmath0[fig:5 ] ) .
the horizontal and axial fields each drop by about 2@xmath0v / m ( not shown ) . + this electric field drop may be partially explained by a rapid discharging of left - over light - induced charges on the oven mount caused by the heat dissipated by the oven .
the conductivity of macor increases by more than ten orders of magnitude when heated from room temperature to several hundred @xmath22c .
it can thus be expected that any left - over charges in the vicinity of the oven will be efficiently removed at such high temperatures .
however , the electric field @xmath50 drops much further than the initial value of @xmath51v / m in fig.@xmath04 , namely down to @xmath52v / m .
this additional negative electric field drop can not be explained by the discharge of the charges that were previously produced photoelectrically .
+ one possible explanation for this field contribution is the effect of contact potentials on the trap electrodes . despite the collimation of the atomic beam through the aperture plate
, a fraction of the atoms emerging from the barium oven reaches the rf electrodes close to the trap center .
such a coating of the electrodes might immediately change the distribution of the contact potentials in close vicinity to the ion .
these potentials can be on the order of a few v , as determined by the difference in work function of the metals involved . in our setup
there is a clear asymmetry on how the ba oven may coat the trap electrodes with ba atoms .
the two lower rf electrodes will each be coated only on one side , whereas the two upper electrodes will probably be coated over the full tip .
it is then to be expected that contact potentials of the upper electrodes dominate over the potentials of the lower ones .
as the work function of ba is lower than that of stainless steel , an electric field component should build up which points towards the negative @xmath20-axis .
this is indeed what we observe .
furthermore , there is also an asymmetry in @xmath21-direction , as the atomic beam from the oven passes at an angle of about 45@xmath22 through the blades ( see fig.@xmath01 ) .
this may give rise to an electric stray field component in @xmath21-direction .
+ fig.@xmath05 shows that after the oven is turned off , the vertical electric field component increases by about 0.5@xmath0v / m per day .
such a behavior agrees with the observations at the beginning of the long - term measurements shown in the inset of fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] .
this again supports our interpretation that the 90-day long drift behavior of the electric field in fig.@xmath0[fig:3 ] is a result of initially coating the trap electrodes and mounts with ba which afterwards migrates and undergoes chemical reactions on the surface .
in conclusion , we have investigated the long - term drifts of quasi - static electric stray fields in a linear paul trap .
we find drifts on time scales ranging from about half a day to three months .
we suggest that these different time scales reflect different physical or chemical processes .
light - induced electric fields decay on relatively short time scales on the order of a few days .
this is most probably due to charges located on insulating material which slowly discharge via the high electric resistance .
in contrast , electric fields which are induced by turning on the ba oven exhibit long - term drifts on time scales of up to 90 days . guided by analysis , our interpretation is that the oven coats the trap electrodes or mounts . as a consequence ,
contact potentials appear which give rise to the electric fields .
these fields show long - term drifts possibly due to slow migration or reaction processes taking place on the electrode surface .
+ patch potentials have been identified as the common source of both quasi - static and fluctuating electric fields .
the time scales for the drifts and fluctuations of these fields is reflected by the dynamics taking place on different length scales of the patches .
it has been found that atomic contamination of paul traps lead to both quasi - static and rapidly fluctuating patch fields@xmath0@xcite .
our findings on the evolution and the origins of quasi - static charges may thus provide new insights into mechanisms connected to rapidly fluctuating charges such as anomalous heating effects .
the results presented here are a first investigation with our setup in the direction of surface dynamics of patch potentials . in the future
the experiments can easily be refined to obtain more detailed information and to test hypotheses .
for example , by locally applying laser fields on trap mounts and electrodes ( either to heat them up or to produce photo - induced patch charges in a controlled way ) , we should be able to spatially probe surface properties .
another result of our work is that by systematically avoiding the creation of electric patch potentials we are able to get into a regime of very small and predictable electric stray field drifts as low as @xmath37v / m per day .
such stability of the trap conditions may prove valuable for the future development of precision ion trap experiments .
t. rosenband , d. b. hume , p. o. schmidt , c. w. chou , a. brusch , l. lorini , w. h. oskay , r. e. drullinger , t. m. fortier , j. e. stalnaker , s. a. diddams , w. c. swann , n. r. newbury , w. m. itano , d. j. wineland , and j. c. bergquist .
science , 319(5871 ) , 18081812 , 2008 .
allcock , t.p .
harty , h.a .
janacek , n.m .
linke , c.j .
ballance , a.m. steane , d.m .
lucas , jr .
jarecki , r.l .
habermehl , m.g .
blain , d. stick , and d.l .
moehring . applied physics b , 107(4 ) , 913919 , 2012 . | we investigate the evolution of quasi - static stray electric fields in a linear paul trap over a period of several months .
depending on how these electric fields are initially induced we observe very different time scales for the field drifts .
photo - induced electric fields decay on time scales of days .
we interpret this as photo - electrically generated charges on insulating materials which decay via discharge currents .
in contrast , stray fields due to the exposure of the ion trap to a beam of ba atoms mainly exhibit slow dynamics on the order of months .
we explain this observation as a consequence of a coating of the trap electrodes by the atomic beam .
this may lead to contact potentials which can slowly drift over time due to atomic diffusion and chemical processes on the surface . in order not to perturb the field evolutions
, we suppress the generation of additional charges and atomic coatings in the paul trap during the measurements . for this
, we shield the ion trap from ambient light and only allow the use of near - infrared lasers .
furthermore , we minimize the flux of atoms into the ion trap chamber .
long - term operation of our shielded trap led us to a regime of very low residual electric field drifts of less than 0.03@xmath0v / m per day . |
the mechanism of heavy meson decays is one of the most interesting and challenging fields in particle physics , it involves both strong and weak interactions .
nowadays strong interaction in the non - perturbative region is still an unsolved problem .
compared with hadronic decays , leptonic decay is simpler .
strong interaction only occurs within the initial particle .
pure - leptonic decay of heavy meson can be used to determine the decay constant , which describes the possibility - amplitude for the quark - untiquark emerging at the same point .
the pure - leptonic decay is helicity suppressed .
the decay branching ratio of a pseudoscalar meson @xmath3 with quark content @xmath4 within the standard model is @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the fermi coupling constant , @xmath7 the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa ( ckm ) matrix element , @xmath8 the life time of the meson @xmath3 , and @xmath9 and @xmath10 the masses of the meson @xmath3 and lepton @xmath11 , respectively .
the decay rate is proportional to the lepton mass squared @xmath12 is the consequence of the helicity suppression .
however , the presence of one photon in the final state can compensate the helicity suppression . as a result
, the radiative leptonic decay can be as large as , or even larger than the pure - leptonic decay mode .
it thus opens a window for detecting the dynamics of strong interaction in the heavy meson or studying the effect of strong interaction in the decay .
the radiative leptonic decay rates of the charged @xmath13 and @xmath14 mesons have been studied with various methods in the literature . in ref .
@xcite , @xmath13 and @xmath15 are calculated in a non - relativistic quark model , the branching ratios of the order of @xmath16 for @xmath17 and @xmath18 for @xmath19 are found . in ref .
@xcite with perturbative qcd approach , it is found that the branching ratio of @xmath20 is of the order of @xmath21 and @xmath22 of the order of @xmath16 , while the branching ratio of @xmath23 is at the order of @xmath18 . on the other hand ,
a smaller branching ratio is obtained for @xmath24 within the light front quark model @xcite . smaller result for @xmath25
is also obtained in ref .
@xcite within the non - relativistic constituent quark model , which gives that the branching ratio of @xmath26 is of the order of @xmath18 and @xmath27 of the order of @xmath28 .
the problem of factorization in qcd for @xmath29 is studied in ref .
@xcite . in this work ,
we study the radiative leptonic decays of the charged @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath30 mesons to @xmath31 including both the short and long - distance contributions .
the short - distance contribution is considered at tree level .
the wave function of the heavy meson used here is obtained in the relativistic potential model previously @xcite .
the long - distance contribution is estimated by using the idea of the vector meson dominance ( vmd ) @xcite followed by the transition of the vector meson to a photon .
we find that the long - distance contribution can enhance the decay rates seriously .
the remaining part of this paper is organized as follows . in sec.ii , we present the short - distance amplitude . in sec.iii , the long - distance contribution is considered . the numerical results and discussion
are given in sec.iv .
sec.v is a brief summary .
we use @xmath3 to denote the pseudoscalar meson which is composed of a heavy anti - quark @xmath32 and a light quark @xmath33 , such as @xmath13 and @xmath14 mesons . there are four feynman diagrams contributing to the radiative decays @xmath34 at tree level , which are shown in fig .
[ fig : feynsd ] . however the contribution of fig .
[ fig : feynsd ] ( d ) is suppressed by a factor of @xmath35 , it can be neglected for simplicity .
the effective hamiltonians corresponding to the other three diagrams in fig .
[ fig : feynsd ] can be written as : where @xmath37 is defined as @xmath38 , and @xmath7 represents for the ckm matrix elements . @xmath39 and @xmath40 are the electric charges of the quarks @xmath41 and @xmath33 , respectively .
@xmath42 is the electro - magnetic field .
@xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath45 can be divided into two terms for convenience , according to the numerator of the fermion propagator .
for example , @xmath43 can be written as @xmath46 where @xmath47 with @xmath48 the amplitude of the radiative leptonic decay can be obtained by inserting the operator of the effective hamiltonian between the initial and final particle states .
for example , the contribution of fig .
[ fig : feynsd ] ( a ) is @xmath49 the matrix elements @xmath50 and @xmath51 only depend on the momenta @xmath52 and @xmath53 .
according to their lorentz structure , they can be decomposed as a linear combination of two terms of @xmath52 and @xmath53 @xmath54 \label{eq : six}. \end{split}\ ] ] the coefficients @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath60 , @xmath61 and @xmath62 are all dimensionless constants .
the terms of @xmath56 , @xmath59 and @xmath60 do not contribute to the decay amplitude @xmath63 when substituting the above decomposition into eq.[eq : five ] . therefore these terms can be dropped .
the coefficients can be obtained by the treatment in the following .
multiplying @xmath64 with @xmath65 , we can obtain @xmath55 as @xmath66 similarly , multiplying @xmath67 with @xmath68 , we have @xmath69 multiplying @xmath67 with @xmath70 and @xmath71 , and using @xmath72 , one can get @xmath73\frac{\left(1-{\gamma }
_ 5\right)}{p_q \cdot p_{\gamma}}q\mid p > \label{eq : nine}. \end{split}\ ] ] finally @xmath74 can obtained by multiplying @xmath67 with @xmath75 : @xmath76 the amplitude @xmath77 can be treated in the same way with some coefficients defined as follows @xmath78 \label{eq:11}. \end{split}\ ] ] using the matrix element @xmath79 , the amplitude @xmath80 can be treated simlarly .
finally , the total amplitude can be expressed as @xmath81\left[\left(p_p{\cdot}p_{\gamma}\right)\varepsilon _ { \gamma}^{{\mu}*}-\left(p_p{\cdot}\varepsilon\right)p_{\gamma}^{\mu}\right ]
\right.\\ & \left.-2\left(q_q\frac{p_p{\cdot}\varepsilon}{p_p{\cdot}p_{\gamma}}\right)a_{a2}m_p p_p^{\mu}\right\},\\ & \mathcal{a}_b = \frac{- i e g_f v_{qq}}{2\sqrt{2}}\left(u_l p_{\text { l$\mu $ } } v_{\bar{\nu}}\right)\left\ { -\frac{q_qm_pa_{b1}}{p_p{\cdot}p_{\gamma}}i \epsilon ^{\alpha \beta \mu \sigma}p_{\gamma \beta } \varepsilon ^*_{\gamma \alpha}p_{p\sigma}\right.\\ & \left.+\left[\frac{q_q m_d a_{b1}}{p_p\cdot p_{\gamma}}+\frac{2 q_q e_{b2 } m_p^3}{\left(p_p\cdot p_{\gamma}\right)^2}\right]\left[\left(p_p{\cdot}p_{\gamma}\right)\varepsilon _ { \gamma}^{{\mu}*}-\left(p_p{\cdot}\varepsilon\right)p_{\gamma}^{\mu}\right ]
\right.\\ & \left.+2\left(q_q\frac{p_p{\cdot}\varepsilon}{p_p{\cdot}p_{\gamma}}\right)a_{a2}m_p p_p^{\mu}\right\},\\ & \mathcal{a}_c = \frac{- i e g_f v_{qq}}{2\sqrt{2}}\left(u_l p_{\text { l$\mu $ } } v_{\bar{\nu}}\right)\left\ { \frac{m_pa_{a2}}{p_l{\cdot}p_{\gamma}}i \epsilon ^{\alpha \beta \mu \sigma}p_{\gamma \beta } \varepsilon^ * _ { \gamma \alpha}p_{p\sigma}\right.\\ & \left.+\frac{m_p a_{a2}}{p_l\cdot p_{\gamma}}\left[\left(p_p{\cdot}p_{\gamma}\right)\varepsilon _
{ \gamma}^{{\mu}*}-\left(p_p{\cdot}\varepsilon\right)p_{\gamma}^{\mu}\right ] \right.\\ & \left .
+ \frac{p_l{\cdot}\varepsilon}{p_l{\cdot}p_{\gamma}}a_{a2}m_p p_p^{\mu}\right\ } \label{eq : add1}. \end{split}\ ] ] the above equations show that the contribution of each diagram in fig .
[ fig : feynsd ] is not gauge invariant separately , but the sum of them is indeed gauge invariant , which is given in the following @xmath82 \right.\\ & \left .
+ 2\left[\left(q_q - q_q\right)\frac{p_p{\cdot}\varepsilon}{p_p{\cdot}p_{\gamma}}+\frac{p_l{\cdot}\varepsilon}{p_l{\cdot}p_{\gamma}}\right]a_{a2}m_d p_p^{\mu}\right\}\\ & \times \left(u_l p_{\text { l$\mu $ } } v_{\bar{\nu}}\right ) .
\label{eq:12 } \end{split}\ ] ] this equation clearly shows that the sum of the contributions of all the diagrams in fig .
[ fig : feynsd ] is gauge invariant . in eq.([eq:12 ] ) the factors @xmath83 and @xmath42 are @xmath84 next we shall calculate the coefficients @xmath55 , @xmath57 , @xmath61 and @xmath74 .
the pseudoscalar meson state can be written in terms of the quark - antiquark creation and annihilation operators @xmath85\mid 0 > , \label{eq:14 } \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath86 is the color index , the factor @xmath87 the normalization factor for color indices , and @xmath88 the 3-momentum of the quarks in the rest frame of the heavy meson .
the wave function @xmath89 has been calculated in the relativistic potential model previously , the numerical solution of the wave function can be fitted in the exponential form @xcite @xmath90 the numerical solutions of the parameter @xmath91 for @xmath14 , @xmath30 and @xmath13 mesons are quoted from ref .
@xcite recently @xmath92 with the meson state given in eq .
( [ eq:14 ] ) , the matrix element @xmath93 can be calculated straightforwardly , the result is @xmath94\sqrt{\frac{m_q m_q}{p_q^0 p_q^0 } } , \label{eq:16 } \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath95 is the dirac spinner for the pseudoscalar meson , it can be obtained in the dirac - representation as @xmath96 in this section , we estimate the contributions of long - distance physics . according to the spirt of vector meson dominance model @xcite
, we consider the resonance process @xmath97 , where the intermediate vector resonance @xmath83 can be @xmath98 , @xmath99 and @xmath100 .
the contribution comes from the semileptonic intermediate @xmath101 , followed by the vector resonance turning to an on - shell photon @xmath102 , which is shown in fig .
[ fig : ld ] . the amplitude of the long - distance contribution can be written as for the decays of @xmath14 and @xmath13 mesons , @xmath83 represents for @xmath98 and @xmath99 mesons , while for @xmath30 meson decay , @xmath83 represents for @xmath100 meson .
@xmath104 is the relative phase between the long and short - distance contributions .
the matrix element @xmath105 is used to define the decay constant of the vector meson @xmath106 where the factor @xmath107 s are @xmath108 the vector s decay constant @xmath109 can be derived from the decay rate of @xmath110 . after a short calculation , the decay constants can be related to the vector meson s leptonic decay widths @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the electromagnetic fine structure constant , @xmath113 , @xmath114 and @xmath115 are the charges of the quarks @xmath116 , @xmath117 and @xmath118 , respectively . the hadronic matrix element @xmath119 in eq . ( [ eq:19 ] )
can be decomposed according to its lorentz structure as @xcite @xmath120 where @xmath121 , and @xmath83 , @xmath122 , @xmath123 , @xmath124 and @xmath125 are form factors . to obtain the amplitude gauge invariant , we take the trick used in ref.@xcite in treating the long - distance contribution in the precess @xmath126 via the resonance @xmath127 . with the lorentz decomposition of the hadronic matrix element in eq.([eq:23 ] ) , the product of the two matrix elements in eq.([eq:19 ] ) can be calculated to be @xmath128\right.\\ & \left .- i\left(p_p{\cdot}\varepsilon _ { \gamma}\right)\left[\frac{\left(m_p+m_v\right)p_v^{\mu}}{p_p{\cdot}p_v}a_1\left(q^2\right)\right.\right.\\ & \left.\left.-\frac{\left(p_p+p_v\right)^{\mu}}{m_p+m_v}a_2\left(q^2\right)+\frac{2 m_v q^{\mu}}{q^2}\left(a_3\left(q^2\right)-a_0\left(q^2\right)\right)\right]\right\ } \label{eq:24}. \end{split}\ ] ] in the rest - frame of the heavy meson @xmath3 , the product of the four - momentum of the meson @xmath3 and the polarization vector of the photon satifies @xmath129 .
then the last term in the above equation can be dropped . with @xmath130 , we obtaine @xmath131\right\ } , \label{eq:25 } \end{split}\ ] ] where : @xmath132 the numerical calculation is performed in the center - of - mass frame of the heavy meson , and the momentum of the photon is taken as @xmath133 . for the input parameters , the masses of the quarks are taken as @xmath134 which are taken to be consistent with that used to derive the wave function of the heavy meson in the relativistic potential model in ref .
@xcite .
the infrared divergence appears as the energy of the real photon goes to soft limit or the momentum of the photon is parallel to the momentum of a massless lepton .
this divergence can be canceled when the decay width of the radiative leptonic decay is added with the pure leptonic decay width , in which one - loop radiative corrections are included @xcite .
the radiative leptonic decay with the energy of the photon lower than the experimental resolution can not be distinguished from the pure leptonic decay . only photons with the energy larger than the experimental resolution can be distinguished .
therefore the radiative leptonic decay width depends on the photon energy resolution .
the photon energy resolution can be a few mev in experiment @xcite .
the dependence of the decay width on the resolution @xmath136 is shown in table [ tab : irdiv ] and fig .
[ fig : irdiv ] .
for example , if taking @xmath137 , the decay width and branching ratio of @xmath138 are @xmath139 in the following all the numerical calculation is performed by taking the resolution @xmath137 .
the radiative leptonic decays of @xmath13 , @xmath14 and @xmath141 are studied in this work .
the short - distance contribution is calculated by using the wave functions of the heavy mesons obtained in the relativistic potential model , more details about the quark - momentum distribution are included in this work .
in addition to the short - distance contribution , the long - distance contribution is also estimated in the vector meson dominance model .
the study shows that the long - distance contributions can seriously affect the decay rates .
the branching ratio of @xmath142 can be enhanced to the order of @xmath16 , which should only be at the order of @xmath18 if only considering the short - distance contribution .
this work is supported in part by the national natural science foundation of china under contracts nos .
10575108 , 10975077 , 10735080 , 11125525 and by the fundamental research funds for the central universities no
. 65030021 .
d. atwood , g. eilam , a. soni , mod .
a*11 * ( 1996 ) 1061 .
korchemsky , d. pirjol , t .-
yan , phys .
rev . d*61 * ( 2000 ) 114510 .
geng , c .- c .
lih , w .- m .
zhang , mod .
phys .lett .
a*15 * ( 2000 ) 2087 .
song , phys .
lett . b*562 * ( 2003 ) 75 .
s. descotes - genon and c.t .
sachrajda , nucl .
phys . b*650 * ( 2003 ) 356 .
. yang , eur . phys .
j. c*72 * ( 2012 ) 1880 ( arxiv:1104.3819 )
. j. j. sakurai , ann . of phys .
* 11 * ( 1960 ) 1 .
y. gell - mann and f. zachariasen , phys . rev .
* 124 * ( 1961 ) 953 .
j. j. sakurai and d. schildknecht , phys .
lett . b*40 * ( 1972 ) 121 .
feynman , photon - hadron interaction ( benjamin , new york , 1972 ) .
t. h. bauer et al . , rev .
* 50 * ( 1978 ) 261 .
p. colangelo , f. de fazio , m. ladisa , g. nardulli , p. santorelli , a. tricarico , eur .
j. c*8 * , ( 1999 ) 81 .
m. wirbel , b. stech , and m. bauer , z. phys .
c - particles and fields 29 ( 1985 ) 637 .
d. fakirov , b. stech , nucl.phys . b*133 * ( 1978 ) 315 . n. g. deshpande , x .-
he , and j. trampetic , phys .
lett . b*367 * ( 1996 ) 362 .
k. nakamura et al .
( particle data group ) , j. phys .
g*37 * ( 2010 ) 075021 .
chang et al .
rev . d*60 * ( 1999 ) 114013 .
alice collaboration ( k. aamodt et al . ) , jinst ( 2008)3:s08002 .
p. ball , phys .
rev . d*48 * ( 1993 ) 3190 .
p. ball , r. zwicky , phys .
rev . d*71 * ( 2005 ) 014029 .
du , j .- w .
li , m .- z .
yang , eur .
j. c*37 * ( 2004 ) 173 . | in this work we study the radiative leptonic decays of @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 , including both the short - distance and long - distance contributions .
the short - distance contribution is calculated by using the relativistic quark model , where the bound state wave function we used is that obtained in the relativistic potential model .
the long - distance contribution is estimated by using vector meson dominance model
. 0.25 cm |
free energy is among the most important concepts of thermodynamics since it formalizes the fact that the usability of energy resources depends also on their _ entropy_. roughly speaking
, the idea is that in an energy conversion process the target system should typically be provided with energy without transferring entropy ( like increasing the kinetic of potential energy or a macroscopic body , for instance ) .
therefore , the worth of a system for being an energy source depends on the question to what extent one can extract energy from it without releasing too much entropy @xmath1 since the transfer of the dispensable entropy to the environment requires the additional amount @xmath2 of energy ( here @xmath3 is boltzmann s constant and @xmath4 is the temperature of the heat reservoir where the entropy is transferred to , e.g. , the environment ) . hence the amount of work that can be extracted from a physical system is not given by its inner energy .
instead , it depends also on the entropy and on a fixed reference temperature , namely the temperature of the environment which is potentially used as an entropy sink .
conversely , a system that has no inner energy at all ( like a degenerate two - level system ) can be used to extract energy from the environment if its physical state is not the maximal entropy state . in other words , _ information _ can directly be used to extract work from the surrounding heat bath @xcite .
this fact implies on the other hand that the initialization of bits requires energy resources , an observation which is usually referred to as landauer s principle ( cp .
all these statements can be brought into a consistent picture by the notion of free energy : for instance , the initialization of a non - degenerate two - level system to a well defined pure state increases its free energy and requires therefore resources of free energy . for a quantum system with density operators @xmath5 and hamiltonian @xmath6 one can define ( in analogy to the classical definition , see @xcite ) the free energy by the difference @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the von - neumann entropy with von - neumann entropy in quantum mechanics @xcite .
however , it goes beyond the scope of this article to discuss this issue .
we assume here that the free energy in eq .
( [ free1 ] ) is nevertheless a reasonable quantity for quantum thermodynamics .
] of @xmath5 . since the gibbs state @xmath9 minimizes ( [ free1 ] ) it
is convenient to redefine free energy by @xmath10 implying that @xmath11 if and only if @xmath12 . it is known that no physical process which uses no additional energy resources can convert @xmath5 into a state @xmath13 with @xmath14 .
this follows already from the fact that @xmath15 is up to the constant @xmath16 the kullback - leibler distance between @xmath5 and @xmath17 @xcite and that it is not possible to create non - equilibrium states from @xmath17 without using additional energy resources .
therefore @xmath17 is invariant with respect to all those operations and to increase @xmath18 would mean to increase the distance to @xmath17 in contradiction to the fact that no operation can increase kullback - leibler distances between density operators @xcite . even though the monotonicity of free energy is maybe the most important constraint on the possible operations one should not forget that additional constraints arise in particular for quantum systems .
however , they depend on additional assumptions on the set of physical processes . refs .
@xcite consider work extraction from quantum systems by unitary operations . in these models , the amount of extractable work does not only depend on the inner energy and the entropy of the system .
instead , it can only be calculated from more detailed information on the spectrum of the density operator . in @xcite
we have furthermore considered _ timing information _ as a kind of thermodynamic resource .
the idea was the following . defining a physical system that includes all available clocks ,
no operation on the joint system can increase the information about an externally defined time reference frame .
every quantum state that is prepared in a superposition of different energy eigenstates with well - defined phase with respect to the external reference frame , provides some information on the latter . the impossibility to create information on the external time
can also be interpreted as the impossibility to prepare superpositions of different energy eigenstates with well - defined phase . such kind of coherent superpositions are therefore a special kind of deviation from equilibrium which could be considered as a resource in its own right .
whereas the complexity for communicating reference frames for time , position , and orientation has been extensively studied in the literature ( e.g. @xcite ) and its cryptographic power has been pointed out @xcite , the thermodynamical relevance of reference frames has mainly be considered in @xcite and @xcite . whereas the first article considers the thermodynamic cost of establishing reference frames with classical communication , the authors in @xcite observe that the worth of thermodynamic resources is reduced by missing reference frames .
the latter observation is the venue of this article .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : cov ] we sketch the idea to restrict the set of operations to covariant maps , i.e. , those that can be implemented without refering to an external frame .
we rephrase the idea of vaccaro et al .
@xcite to consider a thermodynamic theory that is modified by the additional constraint of covariance . in section [ sec : split ] we will show explicitly that the covariance condition implies a splitting of free energy into two terms which can not be converted into each other .
we refine this splitting of free energy into arbitrarily many terms reflecting the fact that different kind of timing information that refer to different _ time scales _ can not be converted into each other .
the theory can be generalized to other covariance conditions that may stem , for instance , from missing spatial or rotational reference frames provided that the considered unitary symmetry operation commutes with the hamiltonian . in section [ sec : super ] we argue why the splitting loses its relevance in the macroscopic limit of a large number of identical systems . in section [ sec : appl ] we will show that the results have implications also for situations where reference frames are available .
this is because every covariant operation that decreases one kind of free energy decreases also the total amount of free energy and this loss is clearly irreversible even if a reference frame is available .
we sketch how to apply this idea to time - invariant passive devices ( i.e. devices without energy source ) in optics or in electrical engineering .
then our results imply that a device that causes an indeterministic time delay of the output signal causes necessarily a loss of free energy .
the set of possible operations on a quantum system is given by the set of completely positive trace - preserving maps @xcite .
in @xcite we have argued that not every cp map @xmath19 can be implemented if no time reference frame is available .
consider a quantum system with free evolution @xmath20 assume that the state @xmath5 was prepared at time @xmath21 .
if a person implements an operation @xmath19 at time instant @xmath22 the state of the system after @xmath19 was implemented is described by @xmath23 looking at the system later it is described by the state @xmath24 if @xmath25 is the time that has passed since the system was prepared . if no clock was available during the implementation of @xmath19 , it is implemented at a random time instant @xmath22 .
we may therefore define a cp map @xmath26 that results from averaging ( [ rtime ] ) over all @xmath27 .
if the quantum system has discrete spectrum and @xmath25 is large compared to the time scale given by the inverse of the minimal distance between its energy eigenvalues , @xmath26 satisfies approximatively the covariance condition @xmath28 in @xcite we have therefore assumed that the set of operations which can be performed without additional clock is given by those that satisfy the above covariance condition ( [ cov ] ) . in @xcite we have analyzed this class of cp maps in full detail . with the same arguments one can restrict the set of available operations to those satisfying covariance conditions with respect to other symmetry groups if the corresponding reference frame is not available .
interesting instances are given by the group of space translations or by the rotation symmetry @xcite .
the symmetry is represented by a unitary group @xmath29 acting on the hilbert space of the considered system .
we assume that @xmath30=0 $ ] , otherwise @xmath31 would not be a symmetry group of the hamiltonian and the missing reference frame would even make the definition of @xmath6 impossible .
every transformation is covariant with respect to @xmath0 , i.e. , we can only implement a cp map @xmath19 with @xmath32 it has already been observed in ref .
@xcite that the absence of a reference frame puts thermodynamically relevant constraints on the set of available operations .
the idea is that the system may contain some information that is not accessible without using the frame .
the authors assume that the work extractable from a @xmath33-dimensional system being in the mixed state @xmath5 is usually ( if a reference frame is available ) given by @xmath34 note that this definition of extractable work refers actually to thermodynamics in degenerate systems or the infinite temperature limit , where the hamiltonian of the system is irrelevant and the free energy @xmath15 is given by the difference of the entropy to the maximally mixed state . within this thermodynamic perspective @xcite
all maximally mixed states are free resources whereas usual ( finite temperature and non - degenerate ) thermodynamics assumes all gibbs states to be free and `` worthless '' resources . to consider @xmath18 as defined in eq .
( [ freetotal ] ) as the extractable work is therefore a bit more general
. we will refer to these two points of view as the finite and the infinite temperature picture , respectively .
if no reference frame is available , the extractable work reduces to @xmath35 instead of ( [ free ] ) ( as the authors of @xcite observe ) , where @xmath36 is the average of @xmath5 over the orbit of @xmath0 , where we have implicitly assumed for the moment that @xmath0 is a compact group and denoted its haar measure by @xmath37 .
introducing the reference information by @xmath38 the deficit between the terms ( [ free ] ) and ( [ cofree ] ) is @xmath39 , a term called asymmetry in @xcite .
the asymmetry is non - increasing under covariant operations since no trace - preserving cp map can increase the holevo information .
then the statement follows because no local operation on one system can increase the mutual information @xcite of the joint system . ] . the authors of ref .
@xcite prove that even covariant operations that include measurements can not increase the average asymmetry as long as the probabilities for the measurement outcomes are @xmath0-invariant .
they consider a family @xmath40 of maps where each @xmath40 is a covariant cp map and show that the average asymmetry of the conditional post measurement states @xmath41 with @xmath42 can not exceed the initial asymmetry .
however , this generalization needs not explicitly be made when we include a toy version of a measurement apparatus into the description .
one can check that there exists a covariant map @xmath19 that transfers the state @xmath43 where the state @xmath44 indicates that @xmath45 was measured . assuming that the group acts trivially on the ancilla system , the asymmetry of the state ( [ meas ] ) coincides with the average asymmetry of the ensemble @xmath46 .
since we know that @xmath19 can not increase the asymmetry of ( [ inas ] ) , the average post - measurement asymmetry can not be increased either . in the following section
we will show that the observations of @xcite can be generalized to the finite temperature setting and give rise to two kinds of free energy .
the key statement of this section is that the different components in which we decompose the free energy are independent resources in the sense that no covariant channel can increase them without access to an additional energy resource . to state this formally ,
we will use the notion of a passive channel : a trace - preserving cp map @xmath19 acting on a quantum system with hamiltonian @xmath6 is called passive if @xmath47 with the thermal state @xmath48 as defined in eq .
( [ gibbs ] ) .
we have already seen that passivity implies @xmath49 . to define our decomposition of free energy , we assume for the moment that the considered quantum system has discrete energy spectrum such that the time average @xmath50 exists .
it is then given by @xmath51 where @xmath52 is the family of energy eigenprojections .
we write the free energy @xmath15 as @xmath53 and use the fact that averaging over the time can only decrease the free energy since the energy term in ( [ freetotal ] ) remains the same .
then we have @xmath54 and conclude @xmath55 where we call @xmath56 the _ covariant free energy_. note that @xmath56 can be considered as the natural generalization of the accessible work @xmath57 in eq .
( [ cofree ] ) to our finite temperature setting . to see that @xmath56 is non - increasing
when applying passive channels we observe that a covariant channel @xmath19 that converts a state @xmath5 to another state @xmath58 must necessarily convert @xmath59 to @xmath60 .
the channel @xmath19 is therefore only passive if @xmath61 .
this shows that asymmetry as well as covariant free energy are both non - increasing under passive covariant operations .
we rephrase these observations as a theorem : [ mainvor ] the free energy of a quantum system with discrete energy levels can be decomposed into @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the holevo information of the time orbit and @xmath56 is the free energy of the orbit average .
the terms @xmath64 and @xmath56 are both non - negative and non - increasing with respect to time - covariant passive operations .
theorem [ mainvor ] can be generalized in two respects .
first , we may have an arbitrary group representation instead of the time evolution provided that it leaves the hamiltonian invariant .
then the term @xmath65 is preserved by averaging , too .
second , we need not necessarily consider uniform averaging over the whole group . instead , we can define hierarchies of states , obtained by averaging more and more over the group , and calculate free energy differences between more and less mixed states . by this procedure
, we obtain a splitting of free energy into many independent terms .
we phrase this idea also as a theorem : given a quantum system with hilbert space @xmath66 and hamiltonian @xmath6 .
let @xmath67 with @xmath68 be the unitary representation of a group @xmath0 acting on @xmath66 such that @xmath69=0 $ ] .
let @xmath70 be an @xmath71-tuple of probability measures on @xmath0 such that there exist measures @xmath72 on @xmath0 with @xmath73 , i.e. , @xmath74 is the convolution of measures @xmath75 on @xmath0 is here defined by the probability distribution of @xmath76 if @xmath68 and @xmath77 are independently distributed according to @xmath37 and @xmath78 , respectively ( see @xcite , and adapt def .
19.8 to our setting ) .
] of @xmath79 with a third measure @xmath72 .
let @xmath80 be the dirac measure on the identity .
let @xmath81 be the cp map given by the average @xmath82 then the free energy @xmath15 splits up into the @xmath71 terms @xmath83 with @xmath84 and @xmath85 all terms @xmath86 for @xmath87 are non - negative and non - increasing with respect to passive covariant operations .
[ th : main ] @xmath88 is clearly non - negative . to see that it is non - increasing we observe @xmath89 where the last inequality is due to the monotonicity of usual free energy under passive operations .
the terms @xmath86 for @xmath90 are , up to the constant @xmath91 , given by the entropy difference @xmath92 with @xmath93 this follows easily from @xmath94 .
expression ( [ hola ] ) is for fixed @xmath45 the holevo information @xcite of the ensemble defined by the family of states @xmath95 with @xmath68 according to the probability measure @xmath72 .
it is therefore non - negative . to show that it is non - increasing when applying @xmath19 we observe that the covariance implies @xmath96 and @xmath97 is therefore , up to the constant @xmath16 , the holevo information of the ensemble @xmath98 according to the probability measure @xmath72
. then monotonicity of @xmath86 with respect to @xmath19 follows from the monotonicity of holevo information .
the advantage of theorem [ th : main ] compared to the preceding remarks is not only that it allows a splitting into more than two terms .
it is furthermore important that it allows a splitting for non - compact groups since it does not refer to a uniform average over the whole group .
we will now restrict our attention again to the splitting into two free energy terms like in the beginning of section [ sec : split ] and investigate how these quantities behave when systems are composed to joint systems .
let us consider a two - level system with lower and upper state , denoted by @xmath99 and @xmath100 , respectively .
let @xmath101 denote the energy gap between both levels . if @xmath102 its equilibrium state is almost the maximally mixed state @xmath103 .
the free energy of the state @xmath104 is given by @xmath105 one checks easily that @xmath106 is negligible compared to the first term since @xmath107 and the entropy difference between @xmath108 and @xmath48 is small .
to see the asymptotics of many copies of @xmath109 we observe that the entropy of the time average of @xmath110 is exactly the entropy of the binomial distribution @xmath111 with @xmath112 hence the entropy of the average of @xmath110 increases only with @xmath113 since the measure is supported by only @xmath71 different points . in other words , there are only @xmath71 different eigenspaces of the joint hamiltonian @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the pauli matrix @xmath116 acting on qubit @xmath45 . for the same reasons ,
the covariant free energy of @xmath110 can be bounded from below by @xmath117 .
hence the asymmetry part of the free energy is for large @xmath71 more and more a negligible fraction of the total free energy .
similar arguments apply to the general situation .
this does not mean , however , that the splitting is completely irrelevant for large particle numbers .
instead , the results show that every process that increases the covariant free energy of some of the particles requires interactions between them .
hence the amount of increase of covariant free energy can bound the number of interacting particles from below .
therefore the results imply statements on the _ complexity _ of the considered process .
this kind of complexity issues are related to the questions discussed in @xcite where we have discussed the complexity of molecular heat engines .
the key observation was that the additional constraints for energy conversion processes that arise in simple quantum systems imply statements on the complexity of energy conversion processes in macroscopic ensembles of particles .
for the sake of completeness we sketch the proof of the superadditivity of covariant free energy .
then the subadditivity of the asymmetry term follows because total free energy is additive .
the essential observation is that for two states @xmath5 and @xmath58 with time evolution @xmath118 and @xmath119 , respectively , the entropy of the joint time average @xmath120 can not be greater than the entropy of the tensor product of the averages , i.e. , @xmath121 .
this is because the latter state can be obtained from the former by averaging over all possible _ relative _ time translations @xmath122 .
we have therefore @xmath123
remarkably , the results above have also implications for situations where a reference frame is available since every passive covariant operation that decreases one term @xmath86 necessarily decreases the total free energy since it is unable to convert one kind of free energy into the other .
this can be used to derive lower bounds on the loss of free energy of a physical signal like an electrical pulse or a light pulse when it passes a device such that it degrades the time accuracy of the pulse .
we will explain this idea using a system with discrete energy levels as a toy model for the physical signal .
consider for instance a system which has some integer values @xmath124 as energy spectrum . due to the periodicity , we can restrict its group of time translations to @xmath125 . parameterizing @xmath0 by the interval
@xmath126 $ ] we obtain the unitary representation @xmath127 now we consider an input state @xmath5 which is perfectly distinguishable from its time evolved state @xmath128 for some @xmath129 in the sense that @xmath130 let @xmath19 be a passive time covariant operation that corrupts the timing information of @xmath5 in the sense that the corresponding output density matrices @xmath131 and @xmath132 are not perfectly distinguishable .
then we can use the results of section [ sec : split ] to bound the free energy loss of the channel from below as follows . define a measure on @xmath133 by @xmath134 where @xmath135 and @xmath136 denote the dirac measures at the time instants @xmath21 and @xmath137 , respectively . by applying theorem [ th : main ] using the measures @xmath138 and @xmath139 , the free energy of the input splits up into @xmath140 and for the output into @xmath141 the fact that the output states are not perfectly distinguishable is equivalent to the statement that the holevo information of an ensemble that consists of the states @xmath131 and @xmath142 with probability @xmath143 each is strictly less than @xmath144 , i.e. , @xmath145 .
then the loss of free energy satisfies @xmath146 the intuitive content of this statement is that it provides lower bounds on the free energy loss caused by devices that corrupt the time accuracy of the input signal by generating output signals with stochastic time delay . to consider a more concrete physical situation ,
assume some electrical , acoustical , or optical signal enters a passive device whose input - output behavior is described by the time covariant map @xmath19 .
the time covariance reflects only the fact that the state of the physical device is stationary before the signal enters into it ( see @xcite for details ) .
assume that the channel converts some input signal that can be perfectly distinguished from its time evolved copy that is defined by a time shift @xmath147 in the sense that the quantum states @xmath5 and @xmath148 are mutually orthogonal density operators .
assume that the channel generates an unknown time delay such that the output density operators @xmath131 and @xmath149 are not perfectly distinguishable .
then the fluctuation of the time delay leads necessarily to a loss of free energy .
one may argue that these fluctuations would obviously lead to a loss of free energy of the signal since they increase the entropy of the state .
however , a priori it is not clear whether the channel could change the probability distribution of energy values such that the loss of free energy caused by an increase of entropy is compensated by an increase of the inner energy @xmath65 .
the statement that no covariant channel can do such a compensation is the key statement of this article .
the signal above is assumed to pass the device only once . by applying our results to such a situation with aperiodic dynamics
we have actually ignored the fact that it refers necessarily to continuous spectrum .
otherwise the free evolution of the signal would be quasiperiodic .
we may remove this by letting it oscillate between distant mirrors for obtaining discrete energy spectrum .
the problem with the aperiodic limit is anyway that it refers to an infinite amount of free energy .
this can be seen as follows .
given a density operator @xmath5 such that for some @xmath150 all states @xmath151 for @xmath152 are perfectly distinguishable from @xmath5 .
then one can choose an arbitrary probability measure on @xmath153 by @xmath154 with @xmath155 and observe @xmath156 where @xmath157 denotes the shannon entropy of @xmath158 . by choosing measures @xmath158
with diverging entropy one can show that the free and recalling that @xmath18 is always non - negative , the statement follows .
however , even though the free energy diverges in the aperiodic limit our statement on the free energy _ loss _ still makes sense since the absolute value of the free energy is irrelevant in this context .
j. vaccaro , f. anselmi , h. wiseman , and k. jacobs .
complementarity between extractable mechanical work , accessible entanglement , and ability to act as a reference frame , under arbitrary superselection rules . . | if an absolute reference frame with respect to time , position , or orientation is missing one can only implement quantum operations which are covariant with respect to the corresponding unitary symmetry group @xmath0 . extending observations of vaccaro et al
. , i argue that the free energy of a quantum system with @xmath0-invariant hamiltonian then splits up into the holevo information of the orbit of the state under the action of @xmath0 and the free energy of its orbit average .
these two kinds of free energy can not be converted into each other .
the first component is subadditive and the second superadditive ; in the limit of infinitely many copies only the usual free energy matters . refined splittings of free energy into more than two independent ( non - increasing ) terms can be defined by averaging over probability measures on @xmath0 that differ from the haar measure . even in the presence of a reference frame ,
these results provide lower bounds on the amount of free energy that is lost after applying a covariant channel .
if the channel properly decreases one of these quantities , it decreases the free energy necessarily at least by the same amount , since it is unable to convert the different forms of free energies into each other .
begintheorem#1#2 opargbegintheorem#1#2#3 beginlemma#1#2 opargbeginlemma#1#2#3 begindefinition#1#2 opargbegindefinition#1#2#3 begincorollary#1#2 opargbegincorollary#1#2#3 beginexample#1#2 opargbeginexample#1#2#3 |
there are three main methods to investigate integrable field theories : factorised scattering , lattice discretisations , and perturbations around a cft .
we will be concerned with the latter , building on the approach of @xcite and its formulation and generalisation in terms of perturbed defects in @xcite .
the key ingredient in our construction are one - dimensional objects in the two - dimensional cft called _
defect lines_. at such a defect line , the fields of the cft may have singularities or discontinuities .
for the particular type of defect we are interested in , the so - called _ topological defects _ , the fields may be discontinuous but not singular and the stress tensor remains continuous across the defect line .
consider the cft on a cylinder of circumference @xmath1 and a circular topological defect labelled @xmath2 winding around the cylinder .
this produces an operator @xmath3 on the space of states @xmath4 of the cft on a circle , called the _
defect operator_. since the defect @xmath2 is topological , the operator @xmath3 commutes with the conformal hamiltonian @xmath5 , @xmath6 = 0 \qquad , \quad h_0 = \tfrac{2 \pi}{l}\big(l_0 + \overline l_0 - \tfrac{c+\overline c}{24}\big ) \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we want to find a systematic way to simultaneously perturb the conformal hamiltonian and the topological defect such that their commutator still vanishes .
fix a bulk field @xmath7 in the space of bulk fields @xmath8 .
the perturbed hamiltonian is @xmath9 next consider a field @xmath10 which lives on the defect line @xmath2 , i.e. is an element in the space of defect fields @xmath11 on the defect @xmath2 this is discussed in more detail in section [ sec : cyl+def - field ] . inserting the perturbing term @xmath12 on the defect line @xmath2 results in the perturbed defect operator @xmath13 .
this operator is defined by formally expanding the exponential into a sum of ordered integrals of defect fields , see section [ ssec : pert - def - and - cat ] .
we want to find pairs @xmath7 ,
@xmath10 such that @xmath14=0 $ ] .
this problem has two parts .
the first part is analytic and concerns the definition of the perturbed theory , convergence of the individual integrals in the series defining @xmath13 , convergence of the series itself , the domain and codomain of the resulting operator , etc .
these points will not be addressed here ; in the special case of the free boson , we will return to these questions in @xcite . in the present paper
, we will concentrate on the second and more algebraic part , which we outline next .
the starting point are two categories , * the category of representations of the chiral algebra , which we take to be braided monoidal , as is the case for example in rational cft and for the free boson , * the monoidal category formed by topological defects , or , more precisely , by defects which are transparent to all fields from the holomorphic and anti - holomorphic copy of the chiral algebra . the space of bulk fields @xmath8 and the spaces of defect fields @xmath11
, @xmath15 , carry an action of the holomorphic and anti - holomorphic copy of the chiral algebra and can thus be considered as objects in @xmath16 , where `` @xmath17 '' is the deligne - product and `` rev '' indicates that the braiding in the second copy of @xmath18 is inverted .
the perturbing fields we consider are described as follows .
choose two representations of the chiral algebra , @xmath19 , and fix a vector in each , @xmath20 .
the bulk field @xmath7 is defined in terms of an intertwiner @xmath21 to be @xmath22 the defect fields , on the other hand , are parametrised by intertwiners @xmath23 , where @xmath24 is the vacuum representation .
we set @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the vacuum vector .
one could say that `` the bulk field is split into its holomorphic and anti - holomorphic part , and these two parts serve as perturbing defect fields '' . as explained in section [ ssec : pert - def - and - cat ] , for rational cfts there is a braided monoidal functor @xmath27 from @xmath16 to the monoidal centre @xmath28 of @xmath29 @xcite .
writing @xmath30 for the forgetful functor @xmath31 , the composition @xmath32 has the property that for all @xmath33 , the space of intertwiners @xmath34 is naturally isomorphic to the space of morphisms @xmath35 in @xmath29 . for bulk fields one uses @xmath36 , the tensor unit in @xmath29 describing the trivial defect , since the space of bulk fields satisfies @xmath37 .
let us abbreviate @xmath38 both of which are objects in @xmath28 .
then a morphism @xmath39 describes a bulk field via the above natural isomorphism and , and a morphism @xmath40 describes a defect field via .
since @xmath7 is determined by @xmath41 , we can write @xmath42 instead of @xmath43 . similarly , we will write @xmath44 instead of @xmath13
. the first main result of this paper is the observation that @xmath42 and @xmath44 commute ( assuming existence of the operators ) if @xmath41 and @xmath45 satisfy a simple compatibility condition , which we call the _ commutation condition _ : @xmath46{img / eq_cc_1.pdf } } \quad - \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=.11\textwidth]{img / eq_cc_2.pdf } } \quad = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=.11\textwidth]{img / eq_cc_3.pdf } } \quad - \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=.11\textwidth]{img / eq_cc_4.pdf } } \quad .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we use string diagram notation for morphisms in @xmath29 , the encircled crossings stand for the half - braiding of @xmath47 , and @xmath48 denotes the restriction of @xmath49 to @xmath50 .
the commutation condition is explained in detail in sections [ ssec : pertdefnonlocalconscharges ] and [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] .
it was first found in @xcite for minimal model cfts ; the above formulation generalises to a larger class of models which in particular includes unitary rational cfts . the desired systematic approach to finding joint perturbations of @xmath5 and @xmath2 preserving the vanishing commutator
can thus be phrased as : find pairs @xmath51 and @xmath52 with @xmath40 satisfying the commutation condition .
of course , in order to have an integrable perturbation we need to have a whole family of such pairs @xmath52 for a fixed @xmath41 , such that their defect operators mutually commute . to formulate this in terms of the category @xmath29
, we first endow the category of pairs @xmath52 with a tensor product ( section [ sec : tensor_algebras ] ) and call the resulting monoidal category @xmath53 .
the tensor product in @xmath53 is constructed to be compatible with the composition of defect operators , @xmath54 ( cf .
section [ ssec : tensor - prod - of - pert - def ] ) always assuming that the operators involved exist .
we argue in section [ ssec : op+k0 ] that the defect operator @xmath44 only depends on the class @xmath55 $ ] of @xmath52 in the grothendieck ring @xmath56 .
thus we need to find commuting families in @xmath56 .
indeed , it may happen that @xmath57 but still @xmath55 \,[y , n ] = [ y ,
n ] \,[x , m]$ ] . the category @xmath53 was first constructed in the cardy - case of rational cfts and for @xmath58 in @xcite ; here we generalise it to a larger class of cfts and include the simultaneous treatment of holomorphic and anti - holomorphic defect fields , which is necessary to treat perturbed cfts .
at this point we can forget about the category @xmath18 and about the underlying cft and start directly from @xmath29 , together with objects @xmath47 and a morphism @xmath51 .
the problem we need to solve is _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ find families @xmath59 in @xmath53 which are as large as possible , such that @xmath41 and @xmath60 satisfy the commutation condition for all @xmath61 , and @xmath62 \,[x_v , m_v ] = [ x_v , m_v ] \,[x_u , m_u]$ ] for all @xmath63 . _
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ this specific formulation of the problem is motivated directly from the cft application . in the following
, we will cast it into a more standard mathematical form .
suppose that the tensor algebras @xmath64 and @xmath65 exist in @xmath29 .
we show in section [ sec : tensor_algebras ] that @xmath53 is nothing but the category of modules over @xmath66 in @xmath29 .
since @xmath47 , the tensor algebra @xmath66 is a hopf algebra and so the category of @xmath66 modules is monoidal and in fact monoidally isomorphic to @xmath53 ( proposition [ prop : tensormod ] ) .
the map @xmath41 can be extended to a hopf pairing @xmath67 .
we can now consider the yetter - drinfeld modules for @xmath68 in @xmath29 .
since the standard formulation of yetter - drinfeld modules is done in braided categories @xcite , for these considerations we will restrict ourselves to the case that @xmath29 is braided ( see , however , remark [ rem : d - not - braided ] ) .
yetter - drinfeld modules are @xmath64-left modules and @xmath65-right modules such that the left and right actions satisfy a compatibility condition in terms of @xmath69 , see section [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] .
the second main result of this paper is the insight that giving a pair @xmath52 satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath41 is equivalent to giving @xmath2 the structure of a yetter - drinfeld module for @xmath68 , see theorem [ thm : yd - com - rel - mon ] .
this correspondence is compatible with the tensor product .
we can therefore rephrase the above problem as follows : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ find families @xmath70 in the category @xmath71 of yetter - drinfeld modules , which are as large as possible , such that for all @xmath63 , @xmath72 \,[m_v ] = [ m_v ] \,[m_u]$ ] holds in the grothendieck ring of @xmath71 . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the role of the quantum double of the algebra of non - local conserved currents ( whose modules are yetter - drinfeld modules of that algebra ) in integrable quantum field theory was also emphasised in @xcite .
we will look at the above question in two closely related examples : the uncompactified and the compactified free boson and their perturbations to sin(h)-gordon theories ( sections [ sec : uncompboson ] and [ sec : compboson ] ) .
this allows us to recover some results of @xcite in our formalism . for the category @xmath18
we take the semisimple part of the category of representations of the heisenberg vertex operator algebra ( i.e. the @xmath73-current algebra ) ; this is braided - equivalent to the monoidal category of @xmath74-graded vector spaces with a deformed braiding , see section [ ssec : unc_input - data ] .
the representations @xmath75 are chosen to be both given by @xmath76 where @xmath77 ( the @xmath73-charge of the perturbing field ) and @xmath78 denotes the one - dimensional vector space of grade @xmath79 .
the highest weight vectors in the corresponding representations of the heisenberg voa have conformal weight @xmath80 .
the approach we take is to find a fully faithful exact monoidal functor from the representation category of an appropriate quantum group into the category @xmath71 of yetter - drinfeld modules .
this allows one to transfer results on the product in the grothendieck ring from quantum groups to @xmath71 .
in fact , if , following lusztig @xcite , one divides the tensor algebras @xmath81 and @xmath82 by the kernel of the hopf pairing induced by the morphism @xmath41 in , then yetter - drinfeld modules of the quotients are in one - to - one correspondence with representations of the relevant quantum group ( cf . remark [ rem : lusztig - f ] ) . for the uncompactified free boson
, we will need the quantum group @xmath83 , where @xmath84 denotes the loop algebra of @xmath85 .
it has generators @xmath86 , @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and the brackets @xmath89 $ ] involve @xmath90 for some constant @xmath91 . in theorem [ thm :
exrepcatfuncmon_uncpt1 ] we show that the category of @xmath83-modules on which @xmath86 acts semisimply fully embeds into @xmath71 , provided that we choose ( the sign is a convention ) @xmath92 in the compactified case we have an extra parameter , the compactification radius @xmath93 ( which one may in fact choose complex ) . the charge @xmath79 of the perturbing field is constrained to satisfy @xmath94 we will restrict ourselves to @xmath95 as the treatment simplifies .
the relevant quantum group is now @xmath96 , which has generators @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath97 . the latter are related to the generator @xmath86 of @xmath83 via @xmath98 .
analogously to the uncompactified case , the category of @xmath96-representations on which @xmath99 acts semisimply fully embeds into @xmath71 , provided we choose ( in our convention ) @xmath100 and @xmath101 see theorem [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_cpt1 ] .
one important difference between @xmath83 and @xmath96 is that the latter allows for so - called cyclic representations if @xmath102 is a root of unity .
the corresponding non - local conserved charges behave similar to @xmath103-operators , see section [ ssec : comp - tq_cycl ] .
this paper is organised as follows . in section [ sec : tensor_algebras ] we give the definition of the category @xmath53 and relate it to representations of the tensor algebra .
section [ sec : pertdef2d_ft ] contains the discussion of cft with defects : the relation between @xmath53 and defect perturbations is explained , and the commutation condition for compatible bulk and defect perturbations is derived . in section [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] the commutation condition is reformulated via yetter - drinfeld modules .
the free boson example is treated in sections [ sec : uncompboson ] and [ sec : compboson ] .
we thank anton alekseev , ed corrigan , alexei davydov , christian kassel , shan majid , carlo meneghelli , aliosha semikhatov and jrg teschner for helpful suggestions and discussions .
db is funded by the sfb 676 `` particles , strings , and the early universe '' of the german research foundation ( dfg ) .
in the present section we recall the notion of a tensor algebra @xmath104 for an object @xmath105 in a monoidal category @xmath29 and of modules over @xmath104 .
we also remind the reader that if @xmath105 is equipped with a lift to the monoidal centre @xmath28 of @xmath29 , the tensor algebra @xmath104 carries a hopf algebra structure . in this case
the category of @xmath104-modules is itself monoidal .
notions from categorical algebra such as the monoidal centre , ( hopf ) algebras in monoidal categories , their modules , etc . , are briefly collected in appendix [ appx : alg - etc - in - braided - cats ] . some conventions that we will use in the following are :
the smallest natural number is @xmath106 , i.e. @xmath107 .
vector spaces , algebras , etc .
, will be over @xmath74 ( unless when speaking about algebras in more general monoidal categories ) and @xmath108 denotes the category of ( not necessarily finite dimensional ) complex vector spaces . for the graphical representation of morphisms in braided categories we use notation of e.g. (
* ch.2.3 ) .
in particular , our pictures are read from bottom to top .
for example , a ( generic ) morphism @xmath109 and the braiding @xmath110 are represented by @xmath111{img / eq_morph.pdf } } \qquad \text{and } \qquad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.18\textwidth]{img / eq_braiding.pdf}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] for an object @xmath112 of the monoidal centre the half - braiding @xmath113 will be represented as @xmath114{img / figdz_a.pdf } } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] to exhibit the relation to perturbed defect operators to be described in section [ sec : pertdef2d_ft ] it is helpful to reformulate the category of @xmath104-modules and the tensor product on it in terms of the generator @xmath105 alone .
this reformulation does not rely on the existence of the tensor algebra , which can be an advantage in applications .
when working with tensor algebras , we will assume the following condition : [ cond : councop ] @xmath29 is an abelian monoidal category containing countable direct sums ( coproducts ) preserved by the tensor product in both variables .
fix an abelian monoidal category @xmath115 .
the _ tensor algebra _ of an object @xmath116 is an algebra @xmath104 in @xmath29 and a morphism @xmath117 such that the following universal property holds : for each algebra @xmath118 in @xmath29 and each morphism @xmath119 , there exists a unique morphism @xmath120 of algebras making the following diagram in @xmath29 commute : @xmath121^\iota \ar[dr]_{f|_f } & { { \mathcal t}}(f ) \ar@{-->}[d]^{\exists ! \ , f } \\ & a } \end{aligned}\ ] ] under condition [ cond : councop ] the tensor algebra @xmath104 exists and can be chosen as @xmath122 with unit @xmath123 and multiplication @xmath124 . here , @xmath125 are the canonical embeddings and projections , respectively , and @xmath126 is a composition of associators moving the brackets from @xmath127 to @xmath128 . in the notation
@xmath129 it is understood that the brackets are placed as @xmath130 , see ( * ? ? ?
* ch.vii.3 , thm.2 ) for details .
if @xmath18 is a braided monoidal category with braiding @xmath131 and @xmath132 and @xmath133 are algebras in @xmath18 , then we endow @xmath134 with the algebra structurehere we do not explicitly write out all associators , unit isomorphisms and brackets between tensor products .
this is done to make the expressions easier to read . ]
@xmath135 that we use @xmath136 instead of @xmath137 to move @xmath138 past @xmath118 sets our convention for the product on @xmath139 .
recall the notation @xmath28 for the monoidal centre of @xmath29 and suppose that @xmath140 . then
( assuming condition [ cond : councop ] ) also @xmath141 and @xmath104 carries a hopf algebra structure .
the coproduct @xmath142 , counit @xmath143 and antipode @xmath144 are obtained from the morphisms @xmath145 , @xmath146 and @xmath147 by making use of the universal property ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2 ) ) .
the definition of the coproduct implicitly uses convention for the algebra structure on the tensor product of two algebras . in the remainder of this section , we will give a description of the category of @xmath104-modules which involves just the generator @xmath105 and not the tensor algebra .
we write an object @xmath148 as @xmath149 , where @xmath150 is the underlying object in @xmath29 and @xmath151 is the half - braiding .
[ df : catdf ] let @xmath152 .
the category @xmath153 is given by * objects : pairs @xmath52 consisting of an object @xmath15 and a morphism @xmath154 . *
morphisms @xmath155 : morphisms @xmath156 such that the diagram @xmath157 ^ -{{\ensuremath{\textnormal{id}}}_{\tilde f } { \otimes}f } \ar[d]_{m } & \tilde f { \otimes}y \ar[d]^{n } \\ x \ar[r]^{f } & y } \label{eq : df - morph - diag } \end{aligned}\ ] ] commutes .
composition of morphisms and identity morphisms are those of @xmath29 .
we define a tensor product @xmath158 on @xmath153 by @xmath159 , where ] @xmath160{img / eq_tpmorph_1.pdf } } \
+ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.12\textwidth]{img / eq_tpmorph_2.pdf } } \label{eq : tpmorph } \end{aligned}\ ] ] on morphisms , @xmath158 is just the tensor product of @xmath29 : @xmath161 .
the associators and unit isomorphisms are also those from @xmath29 .
it is easy to see that if @xmath162 satisfy , so does @xmath163 .
the category @xmath153 is a generalisation of the situation treated in @xcite .
specifically , suppose that @xmath29 is braided with braiding @xmath131 .
then there are two braided monoidal functors @xmath164 defined to be identities on hom - sets .
the setting of @xcite amounts to choosing @xmath165 for some @xmath166 in @xmath29 .
many properties of @xmath153 carry over from @xcite to the present more general setting . in the following we will list some properties of @xmath153 and then establish the equivalence with modules over the tensor algebra .
[ lem : exact_iff ] suppose that the functor @xmath167 is right - exact .
then a complex @xmath168 is exact at @xmath169 in @xmath153 if and only if @xmath170 is exact at @xmath171 in @xmath29 .
the proof of ( * ? ? ?
* lem.2.4 ) also works in the present setting and under the weaker assumption that only @xmath172 is right - exact .
( in ( * ? ?
* lem.2.4 ) it is assumed that @xmath173 is itself right - exact ; this enters the proof of ( * ? ? ? * lem.a.2(ii ) ) which however only involves @xmath174 ) .
[ prop : d_f - abelian - etc ] let @xmath175 be in @xmath28
. then 1 .
@xmath176 is a monoidal category .
if @xmath172 is right - exact then @xmath153 is abelian .
if the tensor product in @xmath29 is right - exact , then so is that of @xmath153 .
4 . suppose @xmath172 is right - exact .
if the tensor product in @xmath29 is left - exact , then so is that of @xmath153 .
it is straightforward to check that the associators @xmath27 and unit isomorphisms @xmath177 are isomorphisms in @xmath153 and turn @xmath153 into a monoidal category .
abelianness and the exactness properties follow along the same lines as theorem 2.3 and 2.8 in @xcite . via
the forgetful functor @xmath178 ( which forgets the half - braiding of the monoidal centre ) , an algebra @xmath118 in @xmath28 becomes an algebra in @xmath29 .
for brevity we will denote the category of @xmath179-modules in @xmath29 by @xmath180 instead of @xmath181 .
[ prop : tensormod ] suppose that @xmath29 satisfies condition [ cond : councop ] and that @xmath140 .
then @xmath182 as monoidal categories .
we will make use of the canonical embeddings and projections @xmath183 , @xmath184 as in .
let @xmath185 be the functor given on objects by @xmath186 and which acts as the identity on morphisms . _
@xmath187 is an equivalence : _ actually , @xmath187 is even an isomorphism of categories . to construct its inverse
, we use the following universal property of @xmath188 : for each object @xmath2 in @xmath29 and each morphism @xmath189 , there exists a unique left - action @xmath190 making the following diagram commute in @xmath29 : @xmath191^{\iota_1 { \otimes}{\ensuremath{\textnormal{id}}}_x } \ar[drr]_{m|_f } & & { { \mathcal t}}(f ) { \otimes}x \ar@{-->}[d]^{\exists ! \ , m } \\ & & x } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the action @xmath45 is given by @xmath192 , where the @xmath193 are defined recursively as@xmath194 @xmath195 , @xmath196 .
for morphisms @xmath197 in @xmath153 we need to check that @xmath198 is also a morphism for the associated @xmath104 modules . to this end
, it suffices to show that @xmath199 holds for all @xmath200 .
this is obvious for @xmath201 . for larger @xmath99
we proceed inductively , using the above inductive representation of @xmath45 and @xmath202 , namely @xmath203 .
the uniqueness assertion of the universal property implies that the above construction gives the inverse to @xmath187 on objects . _
@xmath187 is monoidal : _ if @xmath52 , @xmath204 are two @xmath104-modules , then we have @xmath205{img / eq_talg_tpaction_1.pdf } } = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{img / eq_talg_tpaction_2.pdf } } = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{img / eq_talg_tpaction_3.pdf } } + \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.5]{img / eq_talg_tpaction_4.pdf } } = t(m|_f , n|_f ) \ .
\end{gathered}\ ] ] in words , if one restricts the action via the coproduct of @xmath104 on @xmath206 to @xmath105 , one obtains the morphism @xmath207 as defined in .
this shows that @xmath187 becomes monoidal with structure maps @xmath208 and @xmath209 both given by the identity .
in this section we will indicate how the algebraic constructions presented above and those to follow in section [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] are related to so - called non - local integrals of motion in two - dimensional conformal field theory and perturbations thereof .
this is based on the original works @xcite and their reinterpretation and generalisation in terms of perturbed defects in @xcite . as mentioned in the introduction ,
the application to cft is the motivation to develop the present formalism . as
this section is quite long , a reader only interested in the mathematical definitions and theorems might as well skip ahead to section [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] without missing any of the mathematical content .
a conformal field theory with defects assigns correlators ( i.e. multilinear functions on products of vector spaces called `` spaces of states / fields '' ) to two - dimensional riemann surfaces with parametrised boundaries and/or marked points .
the two dimensional surfaces can be decorated by embedded oriented 1-manifolds the `` defect lines '' whose connected components are labelled by a set of `` defect conditions '' .
there is a straightforward extension of the axiomatic description of cft ( as e.g. in @xcite ) to cft in the presence of defect lines , see @xcite for details .
examples can be constructed in rational cft ( at least in genus 0 and 1 ) via its description in terms of three - dimensional topological field theory as developed in @xcite .
we will not review the general formalism but will just pick out the small part of it that we will need .
@xmath210{img / chap23_pic1_1.pdf } } & & \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.48]{img / chap23_pic1_3.pdf } } \\
\text{(b ) } & c_{\varepsilon_1,\varepsilon_2}^{x_1,\ldots , x_n}(x_1,\ldots , x_n ) : = & & \\
& \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.48]{img / chap23_pic1_2.pdf } } \end{array}\end{aligned}\ ] ] three types of surfaces are going to appear below , namely cylinders of circumference @xmath1 with none , one or two defect circles inserted , see figure [ fig : defect - cylinders ] .
to explain these diagrams and what the defect cft assigns to them we need to introduce the space of bulk states , defect conditions and defect changing fields .
_ the space of bulk states _ : a topological vector space @xmath4 which we take to be a hilbert space for concreteness .
we require that @xmath4 contains a dense subspace @xmath8 , the _ space of fields _ , which carries an action of @xmath211 , where @xmath212 denotes the virasoro algebra .
we denote the generators of the first copy of @xmath212 by @xmath213 and those of the second copy by @xmath214 .
we require that @xmath8 is a direct sum of common eigenspaces @xmath215 of @xmath216 and @xmath217 of non - negative eigenvalues , @xmath218 we assume that the eigenspaces @xmath219 of the generator @xmath220 of scale transformations are finite - dimensional , and that @xmath221 act by multiplication by constants @xmath222 ( called the left and right central charge ) .
the requirements listed above are not the most general setting for conformal field theory .
they exclude , for example liouville and other non - compact cfts , or logarithmic and other non - unitary cfts .
but they allow for all unitary rational cfts and are sufficient to illustrate the origin of the formalism developed in the rest of this section .
the _ hamiltionian _ of the cft on a cylinder of circumference @xmath1 is @xmath223 and it acts on @xmath8 . by assumption , @xmath224 extends to a bounded linear operator on @xmath4 for all @xmath225 .
this is the operator the cft assignes to the cylinder @xmath226 in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]a ) : @xmath227 _ the set of defect conditions _ : the defect circles in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]b),c ) carry marked points , which we will call _ field insertion points_. the intervals between two such insertion points are labelled by elements from a set of defect conditions
. we will only consider defect conditions that correspond to _ topological defects _
, which are defects that are transparent to the stress - energy tensor .
it turns out that a cft with defects equips this set of defect conditions with the extra structure of a monoidal category ( more precisely , one passes to lists of defect conditions , see ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2.4 ) for details ) . in the cft context
, the monoidal category @xmath29 in section [ sec : tensor_algebras ] is the category of defect conditions . for this reason
, we will denote the set of defect conditions by @xmath228 ( and assume that @xmath229 is a set ) .
the unit object
@xmath230 corresponds to the `` invisible defect '' in the sense that a defect segment labelled by @xmath24 can be omitted from the surface .
thus , the cylinder in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]a ) is a special case of that in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]b ) when choosing @xmath231 and @xmath24 as defect condition , and figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]b ) in turn is a special case of c ) . _ defect fields and defect changing fields _ : for each pair of defect labels @xmath232 there is a space of _ defect changing fields _ @xmath233 .
fields from @xmath233 can be assigned ( see below ) to a field insertion point between a segment labelled @xmath2 and a segment labelled @xmath234 ; the order is determined by the orientation of the defect circle .
the spaces of defect changing fields are subject to the same conditions as the space @xmath8 of bulk fields above . that the @xmath233 are again @xmath235-modules follows as all defects are topological .
elements of @xmath11 are also called _
defect fields_. defect fields on the invisible defect @xmath24 are nothing but bulk fields : @xmath236 . to the cylinder @xmath237 in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]b )
the cft assigns a multilinear map to the bounded operators on @xmath4 , @xmath238 where the insertion points are ordered as @xmath239 and @xmath240 is the defect label for the segment @xmath241 , @xmath242 , and for the segment between @xmath243 and @xmath244 in the case @xmath245 .
the assignment of operators to cylinders is compatible with composition .
for example , @xmath246 , and composing the two operators which the cft assigns to two cylinders with a single defect circle as in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]b ) gives the operator for a cylinder with two defect circles as in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]c ) . in the case
@xmath231 , i.e. in the absence of insertion points on the defect circle , we can try to define an operator on @xmath4 as the limit @xmath247 this limit may not exist for general defect conditions , but for topological defects the operator @xmath3 is defined at least on @xmath8 , and in fact maps @xmath8 to @xmath8 , and it intertwines the virasoro actions : @xmath248 = 0 = [ \overline l_m , \mathcal{o}(x ) ] \qquad \text{for all } ~~ m \in \mathbb{z } ~,~ x \in { \mathcal d}\ .\ ] ] [ rem : top - def - in - rcft ] let us outline how the category @xmath29 of defect conditions can be realised in rational cft . fix a rational vertex operator algebra @xmath249 ; by `` rational '' we mean that the category of modules @xmath250 is a modular category , see @xcite .
in particular , @xmath18 is braided monoidal , @xmath251-linear and semisimple . in the approach to correlators of rational cft via three - dimensional topological field theory in @xcite , the different cfts with symmetry @xmath252 are described by algebras @xmath253 , more precisely by special symmetric frobenius algebras .
the defects in the cft described by @xmath118 which are transparent to all fields in @xmath252 ( not just to the stress - energy tensor ) are labelled by @xmath254-bimodules .
in fact , in this situation one has @xmath255 as @xmath251-linear monoidal categories . in quantum field theory , a standard method to modify
a given model is `` to add new terms to the action '' .
if expressed via correlators , this amounts to inserting a term @xmath256 , where @xmath257 is some expression in terms of the fields and the exponential is understood as a formal sum whose precise definition depends on the situation .
here we are interested in the case that @xmath258 , where @xmath10 is a defect field on some defect @xmath2 on a cylinder of circumference @xmath1 .
let is explain this in more detail .
pick a defect label @xmath15 and a defect field @xmath259 . in expression , choose all @xmath240 to be @xmath2 and use @xmath10 in each of the @xmath202 arguments to define @xmath260 next we integrate over the insertion points @xmath261 while preserving the ordering , @xmath262 this integral may or may not exist , depending on the choice of @xmath2 and @xmath10 .
we assume that it exists , so that @xmath263 is again on operator on @xmath4 .
we can now state what we mean by `` the defect @xmath2 perturbed by the defect field @xmath10 '' , or , equivalently , what we mean by `` inserting @xmath264 on a defect circle @xmath2 '' .
namely , take @xmath265 to be a formal variable and consider the formal sum ( a path ordered exponential ) @xmath266 the defect operator for the topological defect @xmath2 perturbed by the defect field @xmath10 is defined to be the limit of zero height of the surrounding cylinder : @xmath267 again , existence of the limit ( as an operator on @xmath4 with dense domain ) will in general depend on the choice of @xmath2 and @xmath10 .
the operators @xmath268 are the main object of our interest . for which @xmath269 the @xmath268 exist and what the radius of convergence in @xmath265 is , are difficult questions . in the free boson example , they have been addressed in ( * ? ? ?
* app.3 ) and we will further investigate them in a forthcoming paper @xcite .
a general expectation would be that the integrals and the limit exist if @xmath270 with @xmath271 .
the reason is that the leading singularity of the integrand in the limit of two coinciding points will generically be @xmath272 .
however , one would also expect that some regulator exists to define the integrals for @xmath273 .
defect fields of weight @xmath274 , @xmath275 , @xmath276 are called relevant , marginal , and irrelevant , respectively .
we do not know if there is a generic behaviour to expect regarding convergence of the power series in @xmath265 .
.notation for related objects in the five categories that appear in the application to cft .
starting from the right , @xmath105 is the object in the monoidal centre of the defect category @xmath29 .
this is the datum used to define @xmath153 , see definition [ df : catdf ] . as an element of the monoidal centre
, @xmath105 is a pair @xmath277 with @xmath278 . turning to the left
, @xmath18 stands for the ( braided ) category of representations of the underlying vertex operator algebra @xmath249 and @xmath279 is one such representation . combined representations of the holomorphic and anti - holomorphic copy of the vertex operator algebra ,
i.e. of @xmath280 , correspond to objects @xmath281 .
the functors in allow one to map @xmath16 to @xmath282 and so we can also think of objects @xmath283 as @xmath280-modules .
we will write @xmath284 , where @xmath279 is the underlying object in @xmath18 . finally , the functor @xmath27 defined in maps @xmath282 to @xmath28 , and we write @xmath105 for the image of @xmath285 under that functor . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] to make the connection to the category @xmath153 , we will restrict ourselves to rational cft in the setting described in remark [ rem : top - def - in - rcft ] .
unfortunately , in the application to cft we have to deal with five categories , each of which contain objects related to @xmath105 .
this is described below and it is summarised once more in table [ tab : f - notation ] .
we pick @xmath286 , where @xmath287 is @xmath18 with inverse braiding .
via we have a functor @xmath288 ; if @xmath18 is modular , this functor is an equivalence ( * ? ? ? * thm.7.10 ) .
we write @xmath285 for the image of @xmath289 in @xmath282 .
to @xmath290 we assign the @xmath254-bimodule @xmath105 with underlying object @xmath291 , with left action by multiplication and with right action by first using the half - braiding to move @xmath118 past @xmath279 and then multiplying . in formulas , @xmath292 for @xmath293 let @xmath294 be the morphism in @xmath295 induced by the morphism @xmath296 , @xmath297{img / eq_bimod_halfbraiding.pdf } } \ .
\end{gathered}\ ] ] one verifies that @xmath298 is an isomorphism in @xmath295 . in fact , we have : ( cf .
* prop.3.2 ) ) [ prop : alphaind ] the assignment @xmath299 defines a braided monoidal functor .
[ rem : alpha - frs - relation ] denote the functors @xmath300 by @xmath301 .
there are isomorphisms @xmath302 , where @xmath303 are as in ( * ? ? ?
( 2.17 ) , ( 2.18 ) ) .
the notation @xmath304 is used extensively in @xcite and @xcite and this remark may be useful to compare results . combining the equivalence @xmath288 with @xmath27 from proposition [ prop : alphaind ]
gives a functor @xmath305 which by abuse of notation we also call @xmath27 .
the space of @xmath252-intertwiners from @xmath289 to the space of defect fields @xmath11 is given by ( see @xcite for details ) @xmath306 which defines @xmath11 as the object representing the functor ( in @xmath289 ) on the right hand side .
thus , given @xmath289 and @xmath307 , an object @xmath308 describes a defect field @xmath309 on the defect @xmath2 , obtained by mapping @xmath307 to @xmath11 via the preimage of @xmath45 under the isomorphism .
we will abbreviate the operator in as @xmath310 and it is understood that @xmath289 and @xmath307 are chosen once and for all .
the morphisms in @xmath153 equally have a direct interpretation in terms of defect fields . to prepare this , consider the subspace of scale- and translation - invariant states @xmath311 ( vac for vacuum ) , i.e. implies @xmath312 for all @xmath313 ( and analogously for @xmath314 ) as in this case the vertex operator @xmath315 , where @xmath316 is the virasoro element , generates no negative powers of @xmath317 when acting on @xmath10 . ] @xmath318 by construction of the morphism spaces of the category @xmath29 ( see ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2.4 ) for details ) , we have @xmath319 . the composition in @xmath29 then gives the operator product expansion of the corresponding fields ( translation invariance implies the absence of short - distance singularities ) .
let now @xmath320 be a morphism in @xmath153 .
then we have the identity of operators @xmath321{img / chap23_pic2a.pdf}}\right ) ( \dots , f,\psi^n,\dots ) \nonumber\\ & \qquad = \mathcal{o}\left(\raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / chap23_pic2b.pdf}}\right)(\dots,\psi^m , f,\dots ) \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , the pictures represent a cylinder as in , and the dotted part of the defect circle stands for any arrangement of field insertions common to both sides . in words , the defect changing field
@xmath198 converts the topological defect @xmath2 perturbed by @xmath309 into @xmath234 perturbed by @xmath322 .
the identity is best understood in the tft formulation , see ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3 ) .
p17em|p19em quantities in @xmath29 and @xmath153 & conformal field theory concept + + object @xmath15 & defect condition @xmath2 for which the corresponding defect is topological and transparent to @xmath252 + object @xmath140 & obtained from the representation @xmath289 in which the perturbing field @xmath10 lives via @xmath323 , see + morphism @xmath324 & determines the defect field @xmath325 as the preimage of @xmath10 under + object @xmath326 & determines a topological defect @xmath2 together with a choice of perturbing field @xmath309 on @xmath2 as in + morphism @xmath320 in @xmath153 & a translation invariant field @xmath327 which satisfies the exchange condition the relation between the quantities described above and conformal field theory concepts is summarised in the table [ tab : df - cft - rel ] . while the above discussion is for rational @xmath249
, we believe that this construction applies to a wider class of vertex operator algebras . in a forthcoming paper @xcite
we will investigate the case of the free boson , i.e. of the heisenberg vertex operator algebra , more closely . as already mentioned above , the composition of two operators associated to a cylinder as in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]b ) results in an operator associated to a cylinder as in figure [ fig : defect - cylinders]c ) . as a formula , this reads @xmath328 where @xmath329 , @xmath330 , and @xmath331 , @xmath332 , and where we chose fixed defect conditions @xmath333 on each defect circle .
if @xmath334 for all @xmath335 , we can take the limit @xmath336 on the right hand side of .
the topological defects @xmath2 and @xmath234 `` fuse '' into a new topological defect , which is @xmath337 by construction of the tensor product in the category @xmath29 of topological defect conditions ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2.4 ) .
let @xmath338 . in the above fusion procedure ,
a field @xmath309 inserted on the defect @xmath2 at a point @xmath339 turns into the field @xmath340 inserted at point @xmath339 on @xmath337 , with @xmath341 as given in .
analogously , a field @xmath322 inserted on the defect @xmath234 at a point @xmath342 turns into the field @xmath343 inserted at point @xmath342 on @xmath337 .
these rules are again best understood in the tft formalism , and we refer to ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3 ) . using this ,
it is not hard to see that , if the multiple integrals implicit in the expression below all exist , the operators defined in satisfy @xmath344 the argument for this is the same as in ( * ? ? ?
* thm.3.2 ) .
thus , assuming that also the operators are well - defined for this choice of @xmath52 and @xmath204 , @xmath345 this illustrates that the tensor product in @xmath153 is designed to be compatible with the composition of defect operators .
suppose we are given an exact sequence @xmath347 in @xmath153 .
we claim that if the underlying sequence in @xmath29 splits , the perturbed defect operators satisfy @xmath348 where we assume the existence of the individual operators . in more detail
, we ask that the underlying sequence @xmath349 in @xmath29 splits , i.e. that we can find @xmath350 and @xmath351 such that @xmath352 , @xmath353 , and @xmath354 .
of course , this sequence splits automatically if @xmath29 is semisimple , as is the case in rational cft since then the category of bimodules in is semisimple .
the reasoning behind is actually very simple ( see ( * ? ? ?
* thm.3.2 ) ) . we will verify it on the level of the integrands : @xmath355 in step ( 1 ) , @xmath354 was used to rewrite the right hand side of as a sum of two terms .
the key step is ( 2 ) , where is used to drag @xmath198 and @xmath356 around the defect circle ( in opposite directions ) past all the defect fields @xmath357 . in step ( 3 ) , @xmath352 , @xmath353 is used to remove the additional insertions at @xmath317 and @xmath358 .
this shows that , at least on the semisimple can be weakened by allowing defect fields which are not scale- and translation - invariant to split the underlying sequence in @xmath29 , but we will not go into this here . ]
part of @xmath29 and provided the operators @xmath359 are defined , the assignment @xmath360 factors through @xmath346 .
we will now turn to the question whether the operators @xmath361 can be interpreted as `` non - local conserved charges '' , and if so , which hamiltonian they are conserved charges for . the qualifier `` non - local '' , incidentally , refers to the fact that defect fields are in general not local with respect to each other .
let us start with the perturbed hamiltonian .
given a bulk field @xmath362 and a constant @xmath363 we define @xmath364 where the new interaction is @xmath365 . more specifically , in the notation of section [ sec : cyl+def - field ] we set @xmath366 next , pick fields @xmath367 such that @xmath368 is holomorphic in the sense that @xmath369 , and @xmath370 is anti - holomorphic , i.e. @xmath371 .
then if @xmath368 and @xmath370 are inserted at two neighbouring points @xmath372 on a defect circle , the limit @xmath373 is regular .
suppose that the condition @xmath374{img / chap23_pic3_1.pdf}}\right ) - { \mathcal o}\left(\raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.45]{img / chap23_pic3_2.pdf}}\right ) \right ) \nonumber\\ & = \lim_{{\varepsilon}\to 0 } \left ( { \mathcal o}\left ( \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.45]{img / chap23_pic3_3.pdf } } \right ) - { \mathcal o}\left ( \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.45]{img / chap23_pic3_4.pdf } } \right ) \right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] holds , where the omissions stand for any configuration of defect field insertions on @xmath2 , common to all four cylinders , and we have not spelled out the arguments of @xmath375 . in formulas , the above identity reads @xmath376 here , @xmath377 and @xmath378 for some @xmath99 .
we claim that this condition implies @xmath379 ~=~ 0 \ .\ ] ] in other words , @xmath380 is a conserved charge for a perturbed hamiltonian .
note that this includes the special cases @xmath381 or @xmath382 , where holds for @xmath383 .
thus @xmath384 and @xmath385 are conserved charges for the unperturbed hamiltonian @xmath5 .
the argument leading to is the same as given in ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3.4 ) , but as @xcite is formulated for virasoro minimal models and assumes that the perturbing fields have negative weight , in appendix [ app : comm - der ] we give the argument in the present setting without these restrictions .
finally , we would like a formulation of the commutation condition in terms of the category @xmath153 .
to this end , we once more restrict our attention to rational cft and the setting in remark [ rem : top - def - in - rcft ] .
pick two representations @xmath386 , and pick vectors @xmath387 .
since the space of bulk fields is @xmath236 , the isomorphism becomes @xmath388 where @xmath389 was introduced in remark [ rem : alpha - frs - relation ] .
writing @xmath390 , we see that a morphism @xmath391 in @xmath29 ( rather than in @xmath28 the forgetful functor is implicit ) defines a bulk field @xmath392 via the prescription after . for the defect perturbation
we take @xmath393 and pick an object @xmath326 .
let @xmath394 be the canonical embeddings and set @xmath395 .
then the triple @xmath396 , @xmath397 and @xmath7 satisfies condition if and only if @xmath398{img / eq_cc_1.pdf } } \quad - \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=.11\textwidth]{img / eq_cc_2.pdf } } \quad = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=.11\textwidth]{img / eq_cc_3.pdf } } \quad - \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=.11\textwidth]{img / eq_cc_4.pdf } } \quad .\ ] ] to find this condition one needs to employ the tft formulation and adapt the argument given in ( * ? ? ?
* sect.4.3 ) ; we omit the details .
this completes our overview of the application of the category @xmath153 to the analysis of conserved charges of a perturbed conformal field theory .
as already mentioned , this application is the main motivation for introducing @xmath153 . clearly , the identity or its reformulation in is crucial for this application , as it guarantees that the operator @xmath361 commutes with the perturbed hamiltonian . in the next section
we take a closer look at this condition .
as in section [ sec : tensor_algebras ] , let @xmath115 be an abelian monoidal category .
the following definition is motivated by .
[ df : commcond ] let @xmath399 and let @xmath400 be a morphism in @xmath29 .
an object @xmath401 is said to _ satisfy the commutation condition with @xmath402 _ if @xmath403 where @xmath404 and @xmath405 are the canonical embeddings .
the pictorial representation of condition was already given in .
the right hand side of is in general nonzero since @xmath402 is not required to be a morphism in @xmath28 .
we say that two objects @xmath406 and @xmath407 in @xmath28 are _ mutually transparent _ if their half - braidings satisfy @xmath408 .
if @xmath409 are mutually transparent , the commutation condition is compatible with the tensor product on @xmath153 : [ prop : delta ] suppose that @xmath399 are mutually transparent .
if @xmath52 , @xmath204 @xmath410 @xmath411 satisfy the commutation condition with @xmath400 , then so does @xmath412 . denote the left hand side of by @xmath413 ( respectively @xmath414 for the object @xmath204 ) . with @xmath415 as in we have @xmath416{img / eqdeltamonoidal_1.pdf } } + \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_2.pdf } } \boxed{+ \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_3.pdf } } } + \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_4.pdf } } \nonumber\\ & \phantom{=}~~ - \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_5.pdf } } - \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_6.pdf } } \underbrace{\boxed{- \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_7.pdf } } } } _ { = 0 } - \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_8.pdf } } \nonumber\\[1em ] & = ~ t(\delta(m),\delta(n ) ) + \underbrace{\raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_9.pdf } } - \raisebox{-.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eqdeltamonoidal_10.pdf}}}_{=0 } \quad .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] that the difference of the last two terms is zero follows from the assumption that @xmath417 and @xmath418 are mutually transparent .
denote the right hand side of by @xmath419 . by assumption , @xmath420 and @xmath421 . the proof is thus completed by observing that @xmath422{img / eqtpcommcond_1.pdf } } \
\underbrace{- \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.450]{img / eqtpcommcond_2.pdf } } \ + \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.450]{img / eqtpcommcond_2.pdf}}}_{=0 }
\ - \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.450]{img / eqtpcommcond_3.pdf } } \nonumber\\ & = r_{{b}}(x { \otimes}y ) \ .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ rem : comments - on - comm - cond ] a. if @xmath29 is itself braided , there is a generic class of solutions to the requirement that @xmath423 and @xmath424 must be mutually transparent , namely , @xmath425 and @xmath426 for some @xmath427 , @xmath428 in @xmath29 , where @xmath429 are as in
. more generally , in the setting discussed in section [ ssec : pert - def - and - cat ] and table [ tab : f - notation ] , if @xmath430 and @xmath301 are the functors as introduced after proposition [ prop : alphaind ] , then @xmath431 and @xmath432 are mutually transparent .
b. let @xmath433 , @xmath434 be morphisms in @xmath29 and assume that @xmath401 satisfies the commutation condition with @xmath400 .
then @xmath435 satisfies the commutation condition with @xmath436 .
in particular , if @xmath52 satisfies the commutation condition with @xmath402 , then so does @xmath437 .
suppose that @xmath29 is @xmath74-linear , as is the case in the examples we study in sections [ sec : uncompboson ] and [ sec : compboson ] below . in this case
, for each @xmath52 which satisfies the commutation condition with @xmath402 , the condition also holds for the family @xmath438 , where @xmath439 .
we are now going to relate the commutation condition to yetter - drinfeld modules over tensor algebras .
as yetter - drinfeld modules are defined in braided categories , we restrict ourselves to the case that @xmath29 is braided and comment briefly on the general case in remark [ rem : d - not - braided ] below .
specifically , for @xmath440 the commutation condition in @xmath153 with @xmath441 will turn out to be equivalent to the yetter - drinfeld condition for @xmath442 .
the hopf algebras @xmath442 are understood to both satisfy the bialgebra axiom ( see figure [ fig : alg]b in appendix [ appx : alg - etc - in - braided - cats ] ) with respect to the braiding in @xmath29 . in order to avoid lots of tildes , up to remark [ rem : d - not - braided ] we will depart from our previous notation and write @xmath409 instead of @xmath443 .
that is , @xmath409 are objects in @xmath29 instead of @xmath28 .
@xmath444{img / figduality_b_v1.pdf } } $ } \hspace{5em } \text{(b ) } & \raisebox{-.5\height}{\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / figduality_c_v1_1.pdf } } = \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / figduality_c_v1_2.pdf } } } \end{array } \end{aligned}\ ] ] given objects @xmath232 in a monoidal category and a morphism @xmath445 , we define @xmath446 as in figure [ fig : duality](a ) ( cf .
* sect.2.4 ) ) .
it is understood that @xmath447 is the unit isomorphism .
two morphisms @xmath448 and @xmath449 are said to be @xmath450-_dual _ , if the identity in figure [ fig : duality](b ) holds .
* sect.2.4&def.3.1.2 ) ) in @xcite as a justification to call its objects yetter - drinfeld modules .
] let @xmath451 be hopf algebras in a braided category .
a. a _ hopf pairing _ for @xmath451 is a morphism @xmath452 such that the ( co)algebra structures on @xmath453 and @xmath454 are @xmath450-dual in the sense that @xmath455{img / eq_hopf_pairing_a_v1_1.pdf } } \
= \raisebox{-0.42\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_hopf_pairing_a_v1_2.pdf } } \quad , \qquad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_hopf_pairing_a_v1_3.pdf } } = \raisebox{-0.57\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_hopf_pairing_a_v1_4.pdf } } \end{gathered}\ ] ] and @xmath456{img / eq_hopf_pairing_b_v1_1.pdf } } = \
\raisebox{-0.42\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_hopf_pairing_b_v1_2.pdf } } \quad , \qquad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_hopf_pairing_b_v1_3.pdf } } \
= \raisebox{-0.57\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_hopf_pairing_b_v1_4.pdf } } \end{gathered}\ ] ] hold .
b. let @xmath452 be a hopf pairing .
a _ yetter - drinfeld module _
@xmath457 for @xmath458 is an @xmath453-left module @xmath459 and an @xmath454-right module @xmath460 satisfying the yetter - drinfeld condition : @xmath461{img / eq_yd_cond_bg_v1_1.pdf } } \quad = \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_yd_cond_bg_v1_2.pdf } } \quad .
\end{gathered}\ ] ] denote the category of yetter - drinfeld modules for @xmath458 by @xmath462 .
[ ex : yd - modules ] suppose that @xmath453 and @xmath454 have invertible antipodes and let @xmath2 be an object .
then @xmath463 is a yetter - drinfeld module for @xmath464{img / eq_ydmod_xind_adj_actn.pdf } } \quad , \qquad m_2 = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_ydmod_xind_coreg_actn.pdf } } \ .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , @xmath465 is a yetter - drinfeld module with @xmath466{img / eq_ydmod2_xind_invreg_actn.pdf } } \quad , \qquad \tilde m_2 = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_ydmod2_xind_coadj_actn.pdf } } \ .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] the proof that @xmath463 satisfies the yetter - drinfeld condition is given in ( * ? ? ?
* prop.b.4 & fig.2 ) ( c.4 in arxiv version ) in the case @xmath467 . the proof for @xmath468 and the proof that @xmath469 is a yetter - drinfeld module are analogous .
a related kind of modules is described in ( * ? ? ? * sect.3.3 ) .
[ lem : exthopf ] let @xmath29 be braided and suppose that condition [ cond : councop ] is fulfilled .
let @xmath470 and let @xmath400 be a morphism . then there is a unique degree preserving hopf pairing @xmath471 satisfying @xmath472 .
the hopf pairing @xmath69 is a generalisation of lusztig s pairing , see ( * ? ? ?
* prop.1.2.3 ) . _
existence : _ note that the tensor algebra @xmath473 of an object @xmath474 is ( @xmath475-)graded as a bialgebra .
moreover , it is the free graded bialgebra over @xmath112 in the following sense : given a graded bialgebra @xmath476 in @xmath29 such that @xmath477 and a morphism @xmath478 , there exists a unique map of graded bialgebras @xmath479 with @xmath480 ( cf . the comment above def.2.5 in @xcite ) . here ,
@xmath481 are the canonical embeddings and projections for @xmath482 .
the _ tensor coalgebra _
@xmath483 of @xmath112 is equal to @xmath484 as an object in @xmath29 , but its coproduct is the deconcatenation coproduct @xmath485 , @xmath486 , and its counit is @xmath487 .
the tensor coalgebra has a unique algebra structure with unit @xmath488 turning it into a graded bialgebra .
this is obtained from the universal property of the tensor coalgebra , see ( * ? ? ?
* cor.2.4 ) .
hence , there is a unique map of bialgebras @xmath489 sending @xmath112 to @xmath112 .
it is given by @xmath490 ( * ? ? ?
* thm.2.9 ) , where the @xmath491 s are the braid group symmetrisers as in ( * ? ? ?
* def.2.6 ) .
define @xmath492 by @xmath493 .
observe that @xmath494 satisfies for @xmath495 and @xmath496 , i.e. @xmath497 and the compatibility condition with the counit also holds .
similarly , @xmath494 satisfies for @xmath498 and @xmath499 .
define @xmath69 as @xmath500 let @xmath501 be the @xmath202-th symmetric group , @xmath502 the @xmath202-th artin braid group , let @xmath503 be the matsumoto section ( see @xcite , above def.2.6 ) and @xmath504 be the canonical map @xmath505 induced by the braiding .
one can convince oneself that @xmath506 with @xmath507 being the `` reflection map '' sending @xmath99 to @xmath508 . as @xmath509 , this implies @xmath510 .
it follows that @xmath69 is a hopf pairing @xmath511 , and by its definition it satisfies @xmath472 .
_ uniqueness : _ let @xmath512 be a hopf pairing . by iterating , say , property of the hopf pairing one finds @xmath513 .
here @xmath514 is the @xmath202-fold iteration of the coproduct , giving a map @xmath515 , applied to @xmath516 and then composed with the projection to @xmath424 in each component . by (
* cor.2.8 ) , @xmath517 , completing the argument .
[ thm : comp_eqiv_yd ] let @xmath29 be braided and suppose that condition [ cond : councop ] is fulfilled .
let @xmath140 be of the form @xmath518 for @xmath470 . given a morphism @xmath400 in @xmath29 ,
let @xmath519 be its extension to a hopf pairing via lemma [ lem : exthopf ] .
let @xmath15 and @xmath520 be left-/right - actions of @xmath521 on @xmath2 .
the following are equivalent : a. @xmath522 is a yetter - drinfeld module for @xmath523 b. the object @xmath52 of @xmath153 with @xmath524 satisfies the commutation condition with @xmath402 . ( a)@xmath525(b ) : if @xmath522 is a yetter - drinfeld module , then by @xmath526{img / eq_talgyd_level1_v1_1.pdf } } \quad & = \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_talgyd_level1_2.pdf } } \quad + \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_talgyd_level1_3.pdf } } , \nonumber\\ \nonumber\\ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_talgyd_level1_v1_4.pdf } } \quad & = \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_talgyd_level1_5.pdf } } \quad + \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_talgyd_level1_6.pdf } } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] the commutation condition for @xmath52 with @xmath402 is just the yetter - drinfeld condition restricted to the subobjects @xmath423 and @xmath424 of @xmath527 .
( b)@xmath525(a ) : let @xmath528 , @xmath529 and @xmath530 be morphisms in @xmath29 .
suppose that the yetter - drinfeld condition holds on @xmath531 and @xmath532 .
then it also holds on @xmath533 : @xmath534{img / eq_comp_eqiv_yd_v1_1.pdf } } \quad = \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_comp_eqiv_yd_v1_2_w2.pdf } } \quad = \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_comp_eqiv_yd_v1_3.pdf } }
\nonumber\\ \nonumber\\ & = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_comp_eqiv_yd_v1_4.pdf } } \quad = \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_comp_eqiv_yd_v1_5.pdf } } \quad = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_comp_eqiv_yd_v1_6.pdf } } \ .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] for fixed @xmath535 , and by taking @xmath536 and @xmath537 , an inductive argument now shows that the yetter - drinfeld condition holds on all of @xmath538 .
an analogous argument for @xmath82 then shows that yetter - drinfeld condition follows from the commutation condition for @xmath52 with @xmath402 .
the yetter - drinfeld condition is compatible with the standard braided tensor product for left and right modules , see ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3.3 ) . that is to say , if @xmath539 and @xmath540 are yetter - drinfeld modules for hopf algebras @xmath451 and a hopf pairing @xmath450 , then so is @xmath541 , where @xmath542{img / eq_ydmod_left_actn_on_tp.pdf } } \ , \qquad m_{x { \otimes}y}^2 : = \
\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_ydmod_right_actn_on_tp.pdf } } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this makes the category of yetter - drinfeld modules monoidal ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3.3 ) . refining the above theorem
one obtains : [ thm : yd - com - rel - mon ] with the conditions and notation as in proposition [ thm : comp_eqiv_yd ] , the category @xmath71 and the full subcategory of @xmath153 consisting of objects satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath402 are isomorphic as monoidal categories .
let @xmath543 be the full subcategory of @xmath153 consisting of objects satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath402 .
two inverse functors @xmath544 and @xmath545 are described on objects in proposition [ thm : comp_eqiv_yd ] above and on morphisms they are defined to be the identity .
monoidality may be shown in a similar way as in proposition [ prop : tensormod ] .
the statement of theorem [ thm : yd - com - rel - mon ] is the main observation made in the present paper : in section [ ssec : pertdefnonlocalconscharges ] we linked the existence of non - local conserved charges in a perturbed conformal field theory to the commutation condition in definition [ df : commcond ] .
the above result in turn relates the commutation condition to a standard mathematical object , namely yetter - drinfeld modules , and shows that their tensor products agree with the composition of the corresponding non - local charges . in the following we
will briefly make a connection to the study of nichols algebras and comment on the situation where @xmath29 is not braided .
an object @xmath2 in a monoidal category is said to be ( left-)dualisable if there are an object @xmath546 and morphisms @xmath547 ( _ evaluation _ ) and @xmath548 ( _ coevaluation _ ) , such that @xmath549{img / figduality_a_sn1.pdf } } = \raisebox{-0.6\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / figduality_a_sn2.pdf } } \qquad \text{and } \qquad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / figduality_a_sn3.pdf } } = \raisebox{-0.6\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / figduality_a_sn4.pdf } } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ rem : yd - braided ] if @xmath454 is dual to @xmath453 , i.e. if there is a coevaluation for @xmath450 , then @xmath550 allows for a braiding .
this is because the coevaluation can be used to turn the right - action of @xmath454 into a right - coaction of @xmath453 .
hence , @xmath550 and , with the notation as in @xcite , @xmath551 are monoidally isomorphic . is a bialgebra only in @xmath552 ; we refer to @xcite for details . ]
the latter category is shown to be braided in ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3.4 ) .
tensor algebras typically have no duals because they are infinite direct sums .
nonetheless , it would be desirable to have a braiding on at least part of @xmath71 since this would imply that the corresponding non - local conserved charges mutually commute .
in special cases this can be achieved as follows .
consider yetter - drinfeld modules with the additional property that the radicals of @xmath69 in @xmath81 and @xmath82 act trivially .
in other words , consider yetter - drinfeld modules of the quotients of @xmath81 and @xmath82 by the radicals of @xmath69 .
if @xmath400 is a duality ( as we will assume from here on ) , these quotients are called the _
nichols _ or _ bitensor algebras _
@xmath553 of @xmath409 , see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* def.2.5 & prop.2.9 ) or ( * ? ? ?
* prop.2.10 ) .
the ( graded ) hopf pairing @xmath69 of @xmath81 and @xmath82 descends to a nondegenerate graded hopf pairing @xmath554 of @xmath555 and @xmath556 , where each @xmath557 is a duality ( provided that the @xmath409 themselves sit in some full abelian monoidal subcategory of @xmath29 which has duals ) . for certain choices of @xmath409 and
@xmath41 it may happen that the quotients @xmath553 are `` small enough '' for @xmath558 to be a duality .
by remark [ rem : yd - braided ] , in this case the category @xmath559 is braided and hence provides a full braided subcategory of @xmath71 ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* thm.4.3 ) and references therein for examples where this happens ) .
nichols algebras with duals have recently been studied in a different context , namely in relation to screening operators in conformal field theory @xcite .
a possibility to obtain a braided subcategory of @xmath71 without assuming that @xmath553 have duals is to consider yetter - drinfeld modules for @xmath555 and @xmath556 of the form @xmath560 , where the action is given in example [ ex : yd - modules ] . to see that the subcategory generated by such modules is braided , note that @xmath556 acts `` locally nilpotently '' on modules @xmath560 .
so the infinite sum occuring when writing down the formal coevaluation for @xmath558 actually becomes finite ( cf .
6.6.3 ) for the case of quantum groups ) .
[ rem : d - not - braided]for the discussion of yetter - drinfeld modules we assumed for simplicity that @xmath29 is braided .
let us sketch how the results can be formulated in the more general setting of section [ sec : tensor_algebras ] .
let thus @xmath29 be a monoidal category satisfying condition [ cond : councop ] , let @xmath140 be of the form @xmath561 for some mutually transparent @xmath399 , and let @xmath400 be a morphism in @xmath29 .
let us write @xmath562 instead of @xmath424 when considering @xmath424 as an object in @xmath563 .
the corresponding hopf algebra is @xmath564 .
note that the coproduct on @xmath565 changes when the tensor algebra is taken in @xmath563 instead of @xmath28 .
similar to lemma [ lem : exthopf ] one verifies that @xmath41 extends to a morphism @xmath566 in @xmath29 satisfying the hopf pairing conditions and .
mutual transparency of @xmath423 and @xmath424 is needed for showing that the @xmath202th symmetriser @xmath491 for @xmath538 is @xmath567-dual to the one for @xmath568 .
let @xmath15 and let @xmath569 , @xmath570 be actions in @xmath29 .
then the following are equivalent : a. the morphisms @xmath520 and @xmath69 satisfy : @xmath571{img / eq_rem - nonbraided_l - r_1.pdf } } \quad = \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=0.50]{img / eq_rem - nonbraided_l - r_2.pdf } } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] b. the object @xmath52 with @xmath572 of @xmath153 satisfies the commutation condition with @xmath402 .
this can be proven in a similar manner as in proposition [ thm : comp_eqiv_yd ] , but the assumption that @xmath417 and @xmath418 are mutually transparent is crucial .
one can also check that is compatible with tensor products .
this allows to generalise theorem [ thm : yd - com - rel - mon ] .
in this section we apply our general recipe to the theories considered in @xcite , which motivated our work . , but this does not affect the algebraic properties we discuss . ] we show how to recover a deformed enveloping algebra of the loop algebra @xmath84 as the quantum algebra underlying the integrable structure in those theories . in this section , all vector spaces , algebras , etc .
are over @xmath74 .
we say that an algebra @xmath118 acts _ semisimply _ on a vector space @xmath112 if @xmath112 decomposes into a ( possibly infinite ) direct sum of simple modules .
we denote by @xmath573 the category of semisimple representations . if @xmath574 is a subalgebra , we write @xmath575 for the category of representations of @xmath118 which restrict to semisimple representations of @xmath138
. we will make use of the topological algebras @xmath576 , which we now describe .
let @xmath577 and @xmath2 be either lists of `` generators '' or vector spaces , thought to be spanned by generators .
@xmath576 is a topological completion of the algebra generated by variables @xmath577 and @xmath2 , where the variables from @xmath2 are non - commuting while those from @xmath577 commute among themselves but not with @xmath2 .
the details have been deferred to appendix [ apx : alge ] .
the completion @xmath578 has the property that exponentials @xmath579 of generators @xmath580 are elements of @xmath581 .
we will now restrict our attention to the case of a single generator @xmath86 .
define a coproduct @xmath582 , counit @xmath583 and antipode @xmath584 on @xmath585 by @xmath586 the coproduct @xmath582 is a map into the completed tensor product @xmath587 , where @xmath588 are to be identified with @xmath589 and @xmath590 , respectively .
this equips @xmath585 with the structure of a ( topological ) hopf algebra , which we will abbreviate by @xmath591 . to make @xmath591 quasitriangular
, we fix a complex number @xmath592 and define the r - matrix @xmath593 which is to be seen as an element of @xmath594 .
we then let @xmath595 the r - matrix @xmath596 induces a braiding @xmath131 on @xmath18 , given by @xmath597 for semisimple representations @xmath598 , @xmath599 of @xmath600 and with @xmath601 being the tensor flip in @xmath108 ; since all @xmath591-modules involved are semisimple , @xmath86 acts diagonalisably and so the action of @xmath596 is well - defined
. objects of @xmath18 are just vector spaces together with a diagonalisable endomorphism ( the action of @xmath86 )
. simple objects of @xmath18 consist of a one - dimensional vector space on which @xmath86 acts by multiplication with a complex number .
we denote by @xmath602 the representation of @xmath591 on @xmath74 determined by @xmath603 . by definition of the coproduct on @xmath591 ,
the tensor product of these simple objects satisfies @xmath604 the braiding @xmath131 on two simple objects is computed from the r - matrix to be @xmath605 this completes the description of the braided monoidal category @xmath18 .
the following remark outlines the relation to the free boson .
[ rem : unc - boson cat - voa ] the relevance of @xmath606 to free boson conformal field theories arises as follows .
the heisenberg lie algebra is the lie algebra with generators @xmath607 , @xmath608 and @xmath609 and brackets @xmath610 = m \ , \delta_{m+n,0 } \ , k$ ] and @xmath611 = 0 $ ] ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2.5 ) ) .
to a simple object @xmath602 we associate the highest weight representation @xmath612 of the heisenberg lie algebra with highest weight @xmath27 and with @xmath609 acting as the identity .
this correspondence of simple objects extends to an equivalence of @xmath74-linear categories between @xmath18 and the category of representations of the heisenberg algebra which are bounded below , have a diagonalisable action of @xmath613 , and where @xmath609 acts as the identity , see ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3.5 ) and ( * ? ? ?
* thm.2.4 ) for details . to the highest weight vector of @xmath612 we associate a chiral field @xmath614 , namely the normal ordered exponential ( vertex operator ) @xmath615 here
, @xmath616 is the chiral bosonic field @xmath617 , with @xmath102 being conjugate to @xmath613 , i.e. @xmath618 = i$ ] .
the tensor product @xmath619 in @xmath18 reflects the `` fusion '' @xmath620 the braiding @xmath131 reflects the behaviour of vertex operators under analytic continuation along a specified path exchanging @xmath339 around @xmath342 @xmath621_{\text{anal.\,cont . } } \qquad , ~~ x > y\ . \end{aligned}\ ] ] this agrees with if @xmath592 is set to @xmath622 .
a detailed discussion of how to obtain tensor product , associator and braiding from free boson vertex operators can be found in sections 35 and proposition 6.1 of @xcite ( the conventions there result in the inverse braiding relative to here ) .
next we choose the bulk field @xmath41 to be used to perturb the free boson cft according to the prescription in section [ ssec : pertdefnonlocalconscharges ] .
for the uncompactified free boson , the category @xmath29 of sections [ sec : tensor_algebras][sec : comm_cond_yd ] is given by @xmath18 itself .
we thus need to fix objects @xmath623 and a morphism @xmath391 in @xmath18 ( the forgetful functor @xmath624 is implicit ) .
fix a constant @xmath77 and let @xmath625 and @xmath626 , where @xmath429 are the functors from .
we set @xmath627 let @xmath628 be the canonical identifications @xmath629 determined by @xmath630 . for @xmath631 define the morphism @xmath632 in @xmath18 ( i.e. @xmath633 ) as @xmath634 where we omitted the obvious projections @xmath635 .
note that any morphism @xmath636 is of the form @xmath637 .
[ eq : sin(h)-gorden - uncomp ] the hamiltonian of the two - dimensional massless sine - gordon model on a cylinder is given by @xmath638 , where @xmath5 is the hamiltonian of the ( non - chiral ) free massless boson @xmath639 and @xmath640 are real constants .
the hamiltonian of the sinh - gordon model is given by the same formula but with purely imaginary @xmath79 .
( see e.g. @xcite for a recent treatment and further references . )
the perturbing bulk field is @xmath641 , where @xmath642 is the `` full vertex operator '' @xmath643 . by construction
, the full vertex operator @xmath642 corresponds to the morphism @xmath644 .
thus , choosing the bulk field @xmath645 with @xmath646 will describe the sine - gordon or sinh - gordon model , depending on whether @xmath647 or @xmath648 .
as argued in section [ ssec : pert - def - and - cat ] , defects perturbed by the chiral constituents @xmath417 and @xmath418 of the bulk field @xmath402 are determined by objects of the category @xmath649 with @xmath105 as in , or , equivalently , by modules of the tensor algebra @xmath104 in @xmath18 .
we would now like to describe @xmath650 as a category of representations of an ordinary hopf algebra .
for hopf algebras in the braided category @xmath18 we can , by tannaka - krein reconstruction , describe the category of its modules in @xmath18 as a category of representations of an ordinary hopf algebra .
this algebra can , for instance , be found using the `` bosonisation '' formula in ( * ? ? ? * thm4.11 ) . recall that @xmath104 is a hopf algebra in @xmath282 but not in @xmath18 .
however , one can still describe @xmath650 as a category of representations of an ordinary hopf algebra along the same lines ; this is what we will do next .
let @xmath651 be the ( topological ) hopf algebra given as an associative algebra by @xmath652 ; @xmath653 , @xmath654,@xmath655,@xmath656 modulo @xmath657 = \pm \omega f^\pm \ , \qquad [ h,\bar f^\pm ] = \pm \omega\bar f^\pm \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] equipped with the coproduct given by @xmath658 note that @xmath651 contains the algebra @xmath659 introduced in the previous section as a sub - hopf - algebra .
thus , restricting a representation @xmath660 of @xmath651 to @xmath600 gives a tensor functor from @xmath661 to @xmath662 .
the actions of @xmath663 , @xmath664 give @xmath665 the extra structure of a @xmath104-module and we obtain : [ thm : alga_f ] let @xmath651 be as defined above .
the following categories are monoidally isomorphic : @xmath666 the first isomorphism was the content of proposition [ prop : tensormod ] .
for the second we define a functor @xmath667 as follows : if @xmath598 is an object of @xmath661 , then let @xmath668 be the map @xmath669 where @xmath670 and on the right hand side , @xmath671 are merely considered as complex numbers .
the map @xmath45 is an intertwiner of @xmath600-modules : @xmath672 + \phi^- \cdot [ h , f^- ] + \bar \phi^+ \cdot [ h,\bar f^+ ] + \bar \phi^- \cdot [ h,\bar f^-]).v \nonumber\\ & \qquad\qquad + m(\phi { \otimes}(\rho(h).v ) ) \nonumber\\ & \qquad= \rho(\omega \phi^+ \cdot f^+ - \omega \phi^- \cdot f^-
+ \omega \bar \phi^+ \cdot \bar f^+ - \omega \bar \phi^- \cdot \bar f^-).v + m(\phi { \otimes}(\rho(h).v ) ) \nonumber\\ & \qquad= m(\chi(h).\phi ) { \otimes}v ) + m(\phi { \otimes}(\rho(h).v ) ) = m((\chi { \otimes}\rho)(\delta(h))(\phi { \otimes}v ) ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath673 denotes the representing homomorphism @xmath674 and @xmath675 as above .
hence , @xmath676 is an object of @xmath649 . on morphisms
@xmath677 is the identity . for the converse direction observe that a morphism @xmath668 in particular determines four linear maps on the vector space @xmath112 , namely @xmath678 , etc . together with the action of @xmath86
they determine an action of the free algebra with generators @xmath679 . by proposition [ prop : apx_alge ] and
diagonalisability of the action of @xmath86 , it lifts to a representation of the completion @xmath680 .
then shows that holds .
hence , one obtains an object in @xmath661 .
this shows that @xmath677 is an equivalence . to see monoidality ,
let @xmath681 , @xmath682 be two objects in @xmath661 . write @xmath683 , @xmath684 and @xmath685 , and let @xmath686 be a decomposition of @xmath687 into elementary tensors .
the action of @xmath688 on @xmath689 is given by @xmath690 the last line is precisely @xmath691 , completing the proof of monoidality .
we will need two versions of quantum groups , one which uses the exponential @xmath90 for a number @xmath693 and the generator @xmath86 , and one which uses generators @xmath694 instead .
the former will be used in the treatment of the uncompactified free boson and we recall its definition presently .
the generators @xmath694 appear in the application to the compactified free boson in section [ sec : compboson ] .
for @xmath695 let @xmath696_q : = \frac{q^n - q^{-n}}{q - q^{-1}}$ ] .
[ df : qgrps_uncomp ] let @xmath697 and set @xmath698 .
a. @xmath692 is the topological hopf algebra which is the quotient of @xmath699 modulo the closure of the two - sided ideal generated by the relations @xmath700
= \pm2e^\pm \ , \qquad [ e^+,e^- ] = \frac{e^{\hbar\cdot h } - e^{-\hbar\cdot h}}{e^\hbar - e^{-\hbar } } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] together with the coproduct and antipode given by @xmath701 b. @xmath83 is the topological hopf algebra which is the quotient of @xmath702 modulo the closure of the two - sided ideal generated by the relations ( @xmath703 ) @xmath704 = \pm 2e_i^\pm \ , \qquad [ e_i^+,e_j^- ] = \delta_{i , j}\frac{e^{\hbar\cdot h_i } - e^{-\hbar\cdot h_i}}{e^\hbar - e^{-\hbar } } \ , \\
( e_i^+)^3e_j^+ - [ 3]_{q } ( e_i^+)^2e_j^+e_i^+ + [ 3]_{q } e_i^+e_j^+(e_i^+)^2 - e_j^+(e_i^+)^3 = 0 \ , \label{eq : def - u_a - serre - relns}\nonumber\\ ( e_i^-)^3e_j^- - [ 3]_{q } ( e_i^-)^2e_j^-e_i^- + [ 3]_{q } e_i^-e_j^-(e_i^-)^2 - e_j^-(e_i^-)^3 = 0 \ , \nonumber \end{gathered}\ ] ] together with the coproduct and antipode given by @xmath705 c. denote by @xmath706 the sub(-hopf-)algebras of @xmath83 generated by @xmath707 and @xmath708 , respectively .
below we will relate representations of @xmath83 to the category @xmath649 discussed in the previous section . as argued in section [ sec : pertdef2d_ft ] , the objects in @xmath649 describe non - local conserved charges , and these charges commute if the corresponding elements in the grothendieck ring @xmath709 commute .
in this context , the following theorem will be useful .
[ thm : uqcommgrothunc ] let @xmath91 and assume that @xmath698 is not a root of unity .
the grothendieck ring @xmath710 of the category of finite dimensional @xmath83-modules is commutative .
the proof of this theorem is given in appendix [ apx : b ] .
our proof relates the statement to the known analogous statement on the grothendieck ring of @xmath96 ( see definition [ df : qgrps_comp ] below ) , hence the restriction to the case of @xmath102 being not a root of unity .
[ rem : unc - groth - ring ] note that the grothendieck ring of @xmath711 itself is trivial , as it contains infinite direct sums .
namely , let @xmath112 be a representation of @xmath83
. then so is @xmath712 and we have an exact sequence @xmath713 .
hence , the classes @xmath714,[w ] \in { k_0}(\tilde u_\hbar(l{\mathfrak{sl}}_2))$ ] satisfy @xmath715 = [ v ] + [ w]$ ] , which implies @xmath714 = 0 $ ] . the easiest way to avoid
this is to restrict to finite - dimensional representations .
we come to the main result of this section .
we show that the subcategory of @xmath649 consisting of objects satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath637 and which descend to modules of the nichols algebras of @xmath417 and @xmath418 ( see section [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] ) is isomorphic to the category of representations of the quantum group @xmath83 , at least for generic values of @xmath693 ( cf .
remark [ rem : lusztig - f ] below ) .
the relation between the parameters is @xmath716 where @xmath592 controls the braiding on @xmath18 via the r - matrix and @xmath79 defines the representation of the perturbing fields in @xmath105 as in ; @xmath693 is independent of @xmath717 and the minus sign is a convention .
having in mind our observation in theorem [ thm : comp_eqiv_yd ] relating the commutation condition to the yetter - drinfeld condition , this is not a surprising result mathematically : it was pointed out in @xcite that representation categories of @xmath102-deformed enveloping algebras can be obtained from categories of yetter - drinfeld modules of nichols algebras in some braided categories .
moreover , @xcite constructed the borel - like subalgebras of @xmath102-deformed enveloping algebras by means of nichols algebras in some braided categories , cf .
@xcite .
fix @xmath718 for the remainder of this section .
let @xmath598 be an object of @xmath661 and write @xmath719 for the corresponding object in @xmath649 , where @xmath677 is the equivalence defined in theorem [ thm : alga_f ] .
the commutation condition for @xmath720 and @xmath637 reads @xmath721 for example , the first equation is obtained as follows .
we need to satisfy , which is an equation for @xmath18-homomorphisms @xmath722 , that is , for grade preserving linear maps @xmath722 .
it must hold , in particular , on the vector @xmath723 . on that vector
we calculate for the left hand side of : @xmath724 where we have used @xmath725 and @xmath726 , see the definition of @xmath45 in theorem [ thm : alga_f ] .
the right - hand - side of evaluated on @xmath727 is @xmath728 where we used @xmath729 and @xmath730 , as well as @xmath731 . by acting with @xmath732 on the conditions in one
checks that these conditions can equivalently be obtained by applying @xmath450 to the following expressions in terms of commutators : @xmath733 = \zeta e^{\kappa\omega^2 } \cdot \left ( e^{-\kappa\omega h } - e^{\kappa\omega h } \right ) \ , \\ [ f^- e^{\kappa\omega h } , \bar f^+ ] = \xi e^{\kappa\omega^2 } \cdot \left ( e^{\kappa\omega h } - e^{-\kappa\omega h } \right ) \ , \nonumber\\ [ f^+ e^{-\kappa\omega h } , \bar f^+ ] = 0 = [ f^- e^{\kappa\omega h } , \bar f^- ] \ . \nonumber\end{gathered}\ ] ] define the bialgebra @xmath734 as the quotient of @xmath651 by the relations . by construction
, a representation of @xmath651 satisfies the commutation condition with @xmath637 if and only if it descends to a representation of @xmath734 .
so , pulling back representations along the canonical projection @xmath735 , we can identify @xmath736 with the full subcategory of @xmath737 consisting of objects satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath637 .
this implies , by theorem [ thm : yd - com - rel - mon ] , that we have an isomorphism @xmath738 of monoidal categories .
here , @xmath450 is the hopf pairing @xmath739 induced by @xmath740 according to lemma [ lem : exthopf ] .
we are now going to relate @xmath736 to representations of the quantum group @xmath83 .
define the bialgebra homomorphism @xmath741 as @xmath742 it is easily checked that @xmath10 is compatible with the algebra and coalgebra structures of @xmath651 .
for example , @xmath743 ) & = \frac\omega 2 [ h_0,e_0^+ e^{-\hbar \cdot h_0 } ] \stackrel{\eqref{eq : def - relns - u_a}}= \omega e_0^+ e^{-\hbar \cdot h_0 } = \psi(\omega f^+ ) \ , \\
( \psi{\otimes}\psi)\delta(f^+ ) & \stackrel{\eqref{eq : def - coproduct - a_f}}= ( \psi{\otimes}\psi)(f^+ { \otimes}{\mathbbm 1}+ e^{\kappa\omega h } { \otimes}f^+ ) = e_0^+e^{-\hbar \cdot h_0 } { \otimes}{\mathbbm 1}+ e^{\frac{\kappa\omega^2}2 h_0 } { \otimes}e_0^+e^{-\hbar \cdot h_0 }
\nonumber\\ & = ( e_0^+ { \otimes}e^{\hbar \cdot h_0 } + { \mathbbm 1}{\otimes}e_0^+ ) ( e^{-\hbar \cdot h_0 } { \otimes}e^{-\hbar \cdot h_0 } ) \stackrel{\eqref{eq : def - coalgebra - structure - u_a}}= \delta(e_0^+)\delta(e^{-\hbar \cdot h_0 } ) = \delta\psi(f^+ ) \ . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , @xmath10 respects the relations , e.g. @xmath744 ) \stackrel{\eqref{eq : algaf - pert - bialghomom}}{= } \zeta \frac{e^\hbar - e^{-\hbar}}{e^{2\hbar } } [ e_0^+ e^{-\hbar h_0 } e^{\hbar h_0 } , e_0 ^ - ] \stackrel{\eqref{eq : def - relns - u_a}}{= } \zeta e^{-2\hbar } \left(e^{\hbar h_0 } - e^{-\hbar h_0}\right ) \nonumber \\ & \quad= \zeta e^{\kappa\omega^2 } \psi\big(e^{-\kappa \omega h } - e^{\kappa \omega h}\big ) \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this results in a surjective bialgebra homomorphism @xmath745 .
consequently , the pullback functor @xmath746 where @xmath747 denotes the ( topological ) subalgebra of @xmath83 generated by @xmath748 , is full , faithful , exact and monoidal .
altogether we proved : [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_uncpt1 ] the functor @xmath749 identifies the monoidal category @xmath750 with a monoidal full subcategory of @xmath751 . in the case that @xmath752 is transcendental , we can describe the image of @xmath749 more explicitly in terms of nichols algebras as introduced in the end of section [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] .
this is explained in the next remark .
[ rem : lusztig - f ] following @xcite , consider the field of fractions @xmath753 for a formal variable @xmath754 and let @xmath755 be the free associative algebra over @xmath753 with generators @xmath756 . by assigning degree @xmath757 to @xmath758 and degree @xmath759 to @xmath760 , the algebra @xmath755 may be considered as an algebra object in the braided category @xmath761 of @xmath762-graded vector spaces over @xmath753 .
the braiding on two one - dimensional vector spaces of degrees @xmath763 and @xmath764 is multiplication by the element @xmath765 of @xmath753
. the nichols algebra @xmath766 of @xmath755 is given by the quotient of @xmath755 by the radical of the hopf pairing described in ( * ? ? ?
* prop.1.2.3 ) and lemma [ lem : exthopf ] , see ( * ? ? ?
* ex.3.1 ) .
it was shown in ( * ? ? ?
* thm.33.1.3(a ) ) that the serre relations ( the counterparts for @xmath755 of ) , generate the radical of this pairing .
if @xmath767 is transcendental there is a well - defined embedding @xmath768 sending @xmath754 to @xmath767 . comparing the braiding on @xmath761 to shows that we get an exact , faithful ( but non - full ) braided monoidal functor from @xmath761 into our category @xmath769 taking the simple object @xmath770 to the simple object @xmath771 and taking a morphism acting by multiplication with @xmath772 on a simple object of @xmath761 to a morphism acting by multiplication with @xmath773 on the corresponding simple object of @xmath18 .
it takes @xmath755 to @xmath538 and the ideal generated by the serre relations in @xmath755 to the one generated by the serre relations in for @xmath774 ( which are the same as those for @xmath775 ) . by exactness , the functor takes @xmath766 to the nichols algebra @xmath776 .
analogously , @xmath777 is the quotient of @xmath778 by the ideal generated by the serre relations .
altogether , the functor @xmath749 identifies @xmath750 with the full subcategory @xmath779 of @xmath751 .
set @xmath780 and denote by @xmath781 , @xmath782 , the representation of @xmath692 where @xmath783 act on the vector space @xmath784 by the matrices ( see e.g. ( * ? ? ? * ch .
xvii.4 ) ) @xmath785_q & & & \\ & 0 & [ n{-}1]_q & & \\ & & \ddots & \ddots & \\ & & & 0 & 1 \\ & & & & 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ) , \ , \rho(e^-){=}\left(\begin{smallmatrix } 0 & & & & \\ 1 & 0 & & & \\ & \ddots & \ddots & & \\ & & [ n{-}1]_q & 0 & \\ & & & [ n]_q & 0 \end{smallmatrix}\right ) . \end{gathered}\ ] ] for @xmath786 , the evaluation homomorphism @xmath787 is given by ( see , e.g. @xcite ) @xmath788 for an @xmath692-module @xmath112 , denote by @xmath789 its pullback along the evaluation homomorphism @xmath790 . in remark [ rem : comments - on - comm - cond](ii ) we saw that objects satisfying the commutation condition come in @xmath791-families .
in the present example , this parameter is related to evaluation homomorphisms as follows .
recall the functor @xmath792 from , where the constants @xmath718 give the bulk field morphism @xmath41 via .
let @xmath52 be @xmath793 , considered as an object in @xmath649 via theorem [ thm : alga_f ] , for some evaluation representation @xmath794 of @xmath83 .
then @xmath795 , @xmath796 , is isomorphic to @xmath797 . for @xmath102
not a root of unity , @xmath786 and a positive integer @xmath202 , there is an exact sequence of representations ( * ? ? ?
* sect.4.9 ) @xmath798 for @xmath782 , @xmath786 , let @xmath799 denote the class of @xmath800 in the grothendieck ring @xmath801 . by theorems [ thm : uqcommgrothunc ] and [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_uncpt1 ] , the elements @xmath802 and
@xmath803 commute for each @xmath804 and @xmath805 . from one
obtains the relations @xmath806 this reproduces ( * ? ? ?
* eqn.(4.13 ) ) .
if the operators @xmath807 described in section [ ssec : pert - def - and - cat ] exist , then by the arguments in section [ ssec : op+k0 ] they satisfy the same relations as the @xmath799 do in the grothendieck ring ; in particular they mutually commute .
these are the so - called t - operators
. for @xmath786 , @xmath808 , and @xmath102 not a root of unity , denote by @xmath809 the representation of @xmath810 with basis @xmath811 , @xmath812 , and action @xmath813 these representations are pullbacks of @xmath102-oscillator representations , see eqns .
( 3.8 ) , ( 3.9 ) , ( d.6 ) of @xcite , ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2.3 ) , and ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3.3.5 ) , and they were used in @xcite to construct q - operators .
we have exact sequences @xmath814 & 0 \longrightarrow q_{+,m+1}(zq^{-2 } ) \longrightarrow v_1(z ) { \otimes}q_{+,m}(z ) \longrightarrow q_{+,m-1}(zq^{2 } ) \longrightarrow 0 \ .
\label{eq : unc - q - ex - seq } \end{aligned}\ ] ] these may be obtained from ( * ? ? ?
* prop.2.2 ) noting that @xmath809 is a subrepresentation of the `` @xmath815 analogue '' of @xmath816 as in ( * ? ? ?
* def.2.1 ) .
furthermore , @xmath817 and @xmath818 are isomorphic for @xmath819 ( this can be seen by specialising the universal r - matrix as in ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3.3 ) or ( * ? ? ?
* sect.4.1 ) , or by direct calculation ) .
since @xmath809 is an infinite - dimensional representation , it does not give an element in @xmath820 .
there is no point in passing to the grothendieck ring of all @xmath651-modules since that is trivial ( remark [ rem : unc - groth - ring ] ) .
but if the operator @xmath821 can be defined , one expects from and from the arguments in section [ ssec : op+k0 ] that @xmath822 this reproduces the t - q relation ( * ? ? ?
* eqn.(4.2 ) ) .
does not appear in ( * ? ? ?
* eqn.(4.2 ) ) since there the q - operators are defined in a way which is independent of the particular representation chosen . ]
[ rem : t - vs - q - uncomp ] we stress that the t - operators discussed above arise from representations of the _ full _ quantum group @xmath692 and therefore via theorem [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_uncpt1 ] provide objects in @xmath751 . in terms of perturbed defects as discussed in section [ ssec : pertdefnonlocalconscharges ] , this means that assuming existence
the operators @xmath823 will commute with the perturbed hamiltonian .
the q - operators , on the other hand , are only representations of the borel half @xmath810 and therefore do a priori _ not _ give non - local conserved charges of the perturbed theory .
indeed , it is not clear to us how to define q - operators in the perturbed uncompactified free boson , i.e. in sin(h)-gordon theory , in our formalism .
( however , q - operators are known in a lattice discretisation of sin(h)-gordon theory , see @xcite . )
the theory for a free boson with a circle as target space is more complicated than the uncompactified case since we need to introduce a nontrivial algebra @xmath118 and to describe the category @xmath29 in terms of @xmath254-bimodules , see section [ ssec : pert - def - and - cat ] .
it is possible to carry over results from the uncompactified to the compactified boson ( see proposition [ prop : fccardytoalg ] below ) , but we would like to focus on a new feature : the appearance of the quantum group @xmath96 , rather than @xmath83 which we encountered in section [ sec : uncompboson ] .
the difference between @xmath83 and @xmath96 is that the former is formulated via a generator @xmath86 where the latter involves @xmath694 .
the two quantum groups are related by @xmath824 and @xmath825 . for @xmath102
a root of unity , @xmath96 has so - called cyclic representations ; these are absent for @xmath83 , irrespective of the value of @xmath693 .
the main results of this section are : * cyclic representations lead to non - local conserved charges which behave similarly to the q - operators in the uncompactified boson . *
if @xmath102 is an even root of unity , t- and q - operators do not always commute . in remark [ rem :
top - def - in - rcft ] we stated that a rational cft is described by a choice of a rational vertex operator algebra @xmath249 and of a special symmetric frobenius algebra @xmath118 in @xmath826 .
the defect category in this case is @xmath827 .
the heisenberg vertex operator algebra underlying the free boson is not rational , but we will assume that the categorical description of perturbed defects works analogously .
in section [ ssec : unc_input - data ] we introduced the topological hopf algebra @xmath600 , the simple @xmath600-modules @xmath828 and the canonical identifications @xmath829 . in view of remark [ rem :
unc - boson cat - voa ] we set @xmath830 we fix a nonzero complex number @xmath831 and define an algebra @xmath832 in @xmath18 as follows . as an object in @xmath18 , @xmath833 the multiplication @xmath834 and unit map @xmath835 are given by @xmath123 and @xmath836 , where @xmath837 and @xmath838 are the canonical projection and inclusion maps . as a difference to the rational cft setting we
point out that the algebra @xmath832 can not be frobenius since the underlying object is not self - dual .
we define @xmath839 according to our above assumption on the similarity of the compactified free boson and rational cft , the category @xmath29 is interpreted as describing topological defects of the compactified free boson .
( of course , the algebraic considerations in this section are not affected by the validity of this interpretation . )
it is easy to describe @xmath840-bimodules explicitly .
this is done in the following remark .
[ rem : ar - bimods ] let @xmath841 be an object of @xmath18 with representation @xmath842 and let @xmath843 be invertible and such that @xmath844 commutes with @xmath845 . from this data
we obtain an @xmath840-bimodule @xmath846 as follows .
the underlying object of @xmath18 is @xmath847 of @xmath18 , where @xmath848 is the algebra homomorphism @xmath849 sending @xmath850 to @xmath851 .
let @xmath852 be the shift @xmath853 .
the left and right action of @xmath832 on @xmath846 are @xmath854 it is not hard to see that any @xmath840-bimodule is isomorphic to one of these .
the simple bimodules are of the form @xmath855 for @xmath856 and @xmath857 and we write @xmath858 , for short .
we have @xmath859 furthermore @xmath860 from this we can conclude that the bimodules @xmath861 are group - like and their isomorphism classes are parametrised by the multiplicative group @xmath862 , in agreement with ( * ? ? ?
* sect.4.1 ) ( there , an additional automorphism is allowed , resulting in an extra @xmath863 ) . recall the functor @xmath864 from proposition [ prop : alphaind ] and the resulting two functors @xmath865 given in remark [ rem : alpha - frs - relation ] .
we have @xmath866 where @xmath30 is the forgetful functor @xmath867 . with the detailed understanding of simple @xmath840-bimodules we can now verify that the prescription , originally formulated for rational cfts , correctly recovers the state space of a compactified free boson : [ eq : comp - bulkspace - check ] the space of bulk states
@xmath8 is a representation of two copies of the heisenberg vertex operator algebra . to compute the multiplicity @xmath868 of the highest weight representation @xmath869 ( cf .
remark [ rem : unc - boson cat - voa ] ) in @xmath8 , the prescription instructs us to evaluate @xmath870 . by and , we have @xmath871 and from this we read off @xmath872 according to remark [ rem : unc - boson cat - voa ] , we should choose the constant @xmath592 defining the braiding as @xmath873 .
we obtain the conditions @xmath874 and @xmath875 , which for real @xmath93 and in appropriate conventions
describe the standard charge lattice of a free boson compactified on a circle of radius @xmath93 .
having described the space of bulk states @xmath8 , we now fix the representation of the perturbing field @xmath105 and the bulk field morphism @xmath41 .
we choose @xmath105 to be the same as in the uncompactified case in the sense that @xmath876 here , @xmath877 as in section [ ssec : unc_input - data ] and @xmath878 is the choice for @xmath105 in the uncompactified boson , cf . .
to specify the bulk field morphism @xmath879 , first note that by and we have @xmath880 .
we would like to restrict our attention to @xmath41 s that are non - vanishing only on pairs of `` opposite charge '' , that is , we want @xmath41 to factor through @xmath881 . for there to be a nonzero bimodule map @xmath882 at all , by we must have @xmath883 and we will demand @xmath884 to have a nontrivial perturbation . for @xmath79 of the form , the objects @xmath832 and @xmath885 are _ mutually transparent _ in @xmath18 , i.e. they satisfy @xmath886 because of this , @xmath887 as @xmath840-bimodules in @xmath18 . after this preparation
, we can finally specify our choice for the bulk field morphism @xmath41 : @xmath888 \ , \label{eq : com - b_ze - xi_def}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath889 is the choice of @xmath41 in the uncompactified case .
below , we will skip the initial isomorphism and just write @xmath890 .
the parameter @xmath891 has a straightforward interpretation in the sin(h)-gordon model discussed in remark [ eq : sin(h)-gorden - uncomp ] .
the field @xmath892 is now periodic with period @xmath893 ( cf .
remark [ eq : comp - bulkspace - check ] ) .
the perturbing term @xmath894 must respect this period , and this requires @xmath895 , in agreement with for @xmath896 . since we have chosen @xmath105 and @xmath897 for the compactified boson in the same way as for the uncompactified boson , it is possible to use the functor @xmath27 to transport results from @xmath898 to @xmath153 .
this is made precise by the following proposition whose proof can be found in appendix [ apx : fccardytoalg ] .
we will not elaborate further on this and instead move on to prepare the ground for new features not present in the uncompactified boson .
[ prop : fccardytoalg ] let @xmath18 be an abelian braided monoidal category with right - exact tensor product , let @xmath118 be an algebra in @xmath18 and write @xmath899 .
fix objects @xmath900 such that @xmath901 and @xmath118 are mutually transparent . 1 .
set @xmath902 and @xmath903 .
the functor @xmath904 given by @xmath905 is monoidal .
2 . if @xmath906 is a morphism in @xmath18 , then the functor maps objects satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath907 to objects satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath908 .
3 . if the functor @xmath909 is exact and @xmath910 are right - exact , then the functor is exact . in the following
we will restrict our attention to a full subcategory of @xmath911 which is semisimple and consists of direct sums of simple objects isomorphic to @xmath912 for some @xmath856 .
we will write @xmath913 the reason for this is two - fold : firstly , this subcategory is sufficient to describe the @xmath103-like operators arising from cyclic representations of @xmath96 , and secondly , the associativity isomorphisms can be trivialised on @xmath914 but not on @xmath29 ( or even on the full semisimple subcategory generated by all @xmath861 ) .
the last point is explained in detail in appendix [ apx : fcab ] . in order for @xmath915 to be contained in @xmath914
we will require that @xmath916 continuing along the same lines as in section [ sec : uncompboson ] , we will now express @xmath914 as the ( semisimple part of the ) representation category of an appropriate bialgebra @xmath917 over @xmath74 ; eventually this will play the role of the cartan - like subalgebra of @xmath96 .
the bialgebra @xmath917 is generated as a unital algebra by elements @xmath918 with relations @xmath919 it is equipped with the coproduct , counit and antipode determined by @xmath920 denote by @xmath921 the category of semisimple @xmath917-modules , that is , modules on which @xmath99 acts diagonalisably .
we will define a functor @xmath922 \
, \label{eq : repb-2-amoda - def}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the constituents @xmath923 and @xmath924 will be described momentarily , and we will show that @xmath677 is a monoidal equivalence onto the subcategory @xmath914 .
let @xmath925 ( `` remainder mod @xmath93 '' ) be the map which sends numbers in the class @xmath926 to the unique representative @xmath927 for which the real part of @xmath928 is contained in the interval @xmath929 , i.e. @xmath358 is in the strip @xmath930 .
for some choice of logarithm @xmath931 of @xmath786 define @xmath932 by @xmath933 for another choice of logarithm of @xmath317 , @xmath934 for some @xmath935 , we obtain @xmath936 so that @xmath937 is independent of that choice . the ( non - monoidal ) functor @xmath938
is defined as follows .
a representation @xmath939 in @xmath921 is a direct sum of eigenspaces @xmath940 for eigenvalues @xmath786 of @xmath941 .
define an @xmath600-action @xmath942 on @xmath112 by @xmath943 then @xmath923 sends @xmath944 to @xmath945 and acts as the identity on hom - sets .
next , let @xmath946 be the functor @xmath947 where @xmath948 is the tensor flip , @xmath949 .
this completes the definition of the functor @xmath677 in [ rem : image - of - bimod - functor ] the functor @xmath950 maps a simple object @xmath951 to @xmath952 .
let @xmath953 be the simple object in @xmath921 with @xmath99 acting on @xmath74 by @xmath954 , and let @xmath955 be in the image of @xmath956 and satisfy @xmath957 .
then @xmath958 .
it turns out that the composition @xmath959 in is monoidal , even though @xmath923 is not : [ prop : fcab ] the functor @xmath960 is a monoidal equivalence . for the proof of this proposition
we refer to appendix [ apx : fcab ] .
it is easy to see that @xmath677 is an equivalence of categories and that @xmath961 ; the slightly lengthy part of the proof is to show that the associator can be trivialised on @xmath914 .
our next aim is to find an object @xmath962 corresponding to @xmath140 , together with a full monoidal embedding @xmath963 . for the remainder of this section we fix @xmath964
the object @xmath965 in @xmath966 consists of the @xmath917-module @xmath967 where @xmath968 is as in remark [ rem : image - of - bimod - functor ] , together with the half - braiding @xmath969 where @xmath970 are the canonical projections @xmath971 .
the powers of @xmath972 make sense because in we assumed @xmath891 to be even .
now note that since @xmath973 , by there is an isomorphism @xmath974 of @xmath840-bimodules .
let us fix a choice for the isomorphism @xmath356 for the rest of this section .
[ lem : ffnot ] the diagram @xmath975 ^ -{g^{-1 } { \otimes}_{a_r } { \ensuremath{\textnormal{id } } } } \ar[d]^{\varphi_{f,{{\mathcal i}}(x ) } } & { { \mathcal i}}(u{e } ) { \otimes}_{a_r } { { \mathcal i}}(x ) = { { \mathcal i}}(u{e}{\otimes}x ) \ar[d]^{{{\mathcal i}}(\varphi_{{e},x } ) } \\ { { \mathcal i}}(x ) { \otimes}_{a_r } uf \ar[r]^-{{\ensuremath{\textnormal{id}}}{\otimes}_{a_r } g^{-1 } } & { { \mathcal i}}(x ) { \otimes}_{a_r } { { \mathcal i}}(u{e } ) = { { \mathcal i}}(x { \otimes}u{e } ) } \end{aligned}\ ] ] commutes for every @xmath976 .
it suffices to show commutativity of in the case of @xmath2 being a simple @xmath917-module .
so let @xmath977 for @xmath957 as in remark [ rem : image - of - bimod - functor ] .
then @xmath978 is up to a tensor flip
multiplication with the matrix @xmath979 on @xmath980 ( in @xmath108 ) .
on the other hand , to describe @xmath981 , let us restrict to the @xmath982-summand of @xmath983 ; the others are treated similarly .
recall from proposition [ prop : alphaind ] that @xmath984 is braided monoidal .
now @xmath985 and @xmath986 , so that by definition of the braiding on @xmath282 , the following diagram commutes : @xmath987^\sim \ar[d]^{\varphi_{\alpha^+({\mathbb c}_\omega),{{\mathcal i}}(x ) } } & & { \alpha}\big(({\mathbb c}_{\omega},c ) { \otimes}({\mathbb c}_{\beta},\tau)\big ) \ar[d]^{c_{{\mathbb c}_{\omega},{\mathbb c}_{\beta } } } \\ { { \mathcal i}}(x ) { \otimes}_{a_r } { \alpha}^+({\mathbb c}_\omega ) \ar[rr]^\sim & & { \alpha}\big(({\mathbb c}_{\beta},\tau ) { \otimes}({\mathbb c}_{\omega},c)\big ) } \end{aligned}\ ] ] but @xmath988 and @xmath989 , matching the first entry in .
[ prop : functor - rep(algb)_e - to - d_f ] the functor @xmath677 and the isomorphism @xmath356 induce a full , faithful , exact monoidal functor @xmath990 .
the functor @xmath991 sends an object @xmath52 of @xmath992 to @xmath993 and a morphism @xmath198 to @xmath994 .
this functor is monoidal by lemma [ lem : ffnot ] .
it is exact since a complex in @xmath995 is exact if and only if the underlying complex in @xmath996 is exact ( cf .
lemma [ lem : exact_iff ] ) and since @xmath677 is an exact functor .
we can now `` bosonise '' @xmath992 in very much the same way as in section [ ssec : unc_bosonisation ] .
define @xmath997 as the bialgebra over @xmath74 which , as a unital algebra , is the extension of @xmath917 by @xmath998 with relations ( @xmath102 as in ) @xmath999 together with the coproduct on @xmath918 inherited from @xmath917 , and for the other generators : @xmath1000 then construct a functor @xmath1001 as follows : if @xmath660 is an object of @xmath1002 , then let @xmath1003 be the map @xmath1004 where @xmath1005 .
the functor @xmath1001 maps @xmath660 to @xmath1006 and acts as the identity on hom - sets .
it is in fact an isomorphism , as is seen in very much the same way as in theorem [ thm : alga_f ] .
altogether , we obtain : [ prop : fcalgptbim ] the categories @xmath1002 and @xmath992 are strictly isomorphic as monoidal categories .
in section [ sec : uncompboson ] we considered quantum groups @xmath692 and @xmath83 whose cartan - like subalgebras were generated by a primitive element @xmath86 .
now we use the standard versions of the deformed enveloping algebras of @xmath85 and @xmath84 with a group - like generator @xmath99 , which satisfies the relations of @xmath90 in @xmath692 and @xmath83 , respectively , if @xmath780 .
[ df : qgrps_comp ] ( cf .
@xcite ) , while @xmath96 , as in our definition , is the quotient of @xmath1008 by the hopf ideal generated by @xmath1009 let @xmath695 . a. define @xmath1007 as the hopf algebra , generated as an associative unital algebra by elements @xmath1010 , @xmath99 , @xmath1011 subject to the relations @xmath1012
= \frac{k - k^{-1}}{q - q^{-1 } } \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] together with the coproduct and antipode given by @xmath1013 b. define @xmath96 as the hopf algebra , generated as an associative unital algebra by elements @xmath1014 , @xmath1015 and @xmath1016 , @xmath1017 subject to the relations ( @xmath703 ) @xmath1018 = \delta_{i , j}\frac{k_i - k_i^{-1}}{q - q^{-1 } } \ , \\
( e_i^+)^3e_j^+ - [ 3]_{q } ( e_i^+)^2e_j^+e_i^+ + [ 3]_{q } e_i^+e_j^+(e_i^+)^2 - e_j^+(e_i^+)^3 = 0 \ , \nonumber\\ ( e_i^-)^3e_j^- - [ 3]_{q } ( e_i^-)^2e_j^-e_i^- + [ 3]_{q } e_i^-e_j^-(e_i^-)^2 - e_j^-(e_i^-)^3 = 0 \ , \nonumber \end{gathered}\ ] ] together with the coproduct and antipode given by @xmath1019 denote by @xmath1020 the sub(-hopf-)algebras of @xmath96 generated by @xmath1021 and @xmath1022 , respectively . for @xmath102
not a root of unity the grothendieck ring @xmath1023 of the category of finite dimensional representations of @xmath96 is commutative ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 2 ) . otherwise , if @xmath102 is a root of unity , this may fail , see section [ ssec : comp - tq_cycl ] below . recall the choice of the bulk field morphism @xmath897 made in
we would like to formulate the commutation condition of @xmath153 for @xmath897 in @xmath992 as defined in section [ ssec : comp - bosonisation ] .
to this end write @xmath1024 with @xmath1025 and denote by @xmath1026 for the canonical identifications in @xmath921 determined by @xmath1027 .
set @xmath1028 then @xmath1029 , where @xmath677 was defined in and @xmath356 is the isomorphism from .
if @xmath660 is an object of @xmath1002 , then the commutation condition ( with respect to @xmath1030 ) for its image in @xmath992 under the isomorphism of proposition [ prop : fcalgptbim ] reads @xmath1031 this can be seen in a similar fashion as in section [ ssec : unc_u_h - yd ] . multiplying with @xmath1032 , these relations
may equivalently be written as @xmath1033 ) = \zeta q^{t } \cdot \rho\left ( k^{-t/2 } - k^{t/2 } \right ) \ , \\
\rho([f^- k^{t/2 } , \bar f^+ ] ) = \xi q^{t } \cdot \rho\left ( k^{t/2 } - k^{-t/2 } \right ) \ ,
\nonumber\\ \rho([f^+ k^{-t/2 } , \bar f^+ ] ) = 0 = \rho([f^- k^{t/2 } , \bar f^- ] ) \ . \nonumber\end{gathered}\ ] ] comparing to definition [ df : qgrps_comp](ii ) this shows that for @xmath100 there is a surjective bialgebra homomorphism @xmath1034 given by @xmath1035 as in section [ ssec : unc_u_h - yd ] , one checks that @xmath10 respects the relations .
let @xmath749 be the functor from @xmath1036 to @xmath1002 pulling back representations of @xmath96 along @xmath10 . here
, @xmath1037 stands for the sub(-hopf-)algebra of @xmath96 generated by @xmath99 .
denote by @xmath1038 the full subcategory of @xmath153 satisfying the commutation condition with @xmath897 . combining the functor @xmath749 with previous results , we obtain : [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_cpt1 ]
suppose the parameter @xmath891 in is equal to @xmath1039 .
the monoidal functor @xmath1040{\sim } { \textnormal{rep}_{\textnormal{ss}}}({\ensuremath{\mathcal{b}}})_{{e } } \nonumber\\ & \xrightarrow[\text{\rm prop.\,\ref{prop : functor - rep(algb)_e - to - d_f}}]{{{\mathcal i}}_g } { \mathcal d}_f ' \xrightarrow[\text{\rm thm.\,\ref{thm : yd - com - rel - mon}}]{\sim } { { \mathcal t}}(f^+){\textnormal{-}\mathcal{yd}_{\rho}\textnormal{-}}{{\mathcal t}}(f^-)\end{aligned}\ ] ] identifies @xmath1036 with a full subcategory of @xmath751 . by and
, @xmath102 is a root of unity iff @xmath1041 . in this case
, @xmath96 allows for so - called cyclic representations . according to remark [ rem : unc - boson cat - voa ] , when relating the results in sections [ sec : uncompboson ] and [ sec : compboson ] to the free boson , i.e. when choosing the braided category @xmath18 to be representations of the heisenberg voa , we should take @xmath873
. then the above condition on the existence of cyclic representations requires @xmath1042 .
the conformal weights of the fields in @xmath832 are of the form @xmath1043 for @xmath1044 .
this contains fields of integer weight if and only if @xmath1042 . in these cases
the compactified boson has an extended chiral symmetry and becomes a rational cft .
thus the cyclic representations occur precisely for the rational free boson .
let us now describe the cyclic representations , following @xcite .
to korff s @xmath1007 sending @xmath1045 to @xmath198 , @xmath1046 to @xmath1047 and @xmath99 to @xmath1011 ; and we fix the bialgebra isomorphism from our @xmath96 to korff s @xmath1048 determined by @xmath1049 , @xmath1050 and @xmath1051 ( @xmath1052 ) . ] if @xmath102 is not a root of unity , the centre of @xmath1007 is generated by the quadratic casimir @xmath1053 . for @xmath102 a root of unity , as we assume here , the centre is enlarged by the additional generators @xmath1054 where @xmath1055 is the order of @xmath1056 as a root of unity . an irreducible representation is called _ semi - cyclic _ if @xmath1057 or @xmath1058 act by nonzero endomorphisms and it is called _ cyclic _ if both do .
a cyclic or semi - cyclic irreducible representation @xmath1059 of @xmath1007 is up to isomorphism determined by the eigenvalues @xmath1060 of @xmath1061 . for @xmath439 ,
denote by @xmath1062 the evaluation representation of @xmath1059 , i.e. the pullback of @xmath1059 along the evaluation homomorphism @xmath1063 , defined in a similar way as in section [ ssec : uncomp_tq - op ] .
note that the evaluation homomorphism @xmath1064 in section [ ssec : uncomp_tq - op ] differs from the one in ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2.3 ) . if we denote the latter by @xmath1065 then @xmath1066 .
this implies in particular that korff s @xmath363 , the quotient of the evaluation parameters for a tensor product @xmath1067 , equals @xmath1068 in our conventions . ]
let @xmath1069 denote the fundamental representation of @xmath1007 analogously to section [ ssec : uncomp_tq - op ] .
if @xmath1070 and @xmath102 is an odd root of unity , then we have @xmath1071 .
if @xmath1070 and @xmath102 is an even root of unity , then there is no intertwiner @xmath1072 at all .
denote by @xmath1073 the finite dimensional representations of a given algebra .
one can check that @xmath1067 and @xmath1074 are irreducible in case of @xmath1070 . since the grothendieck ring @xmath1023 is freely generated , as an abelian group , by the classes of simple objects ( jordan - hlder theorem ) , the absence of an intertwiner implies that @xmath1023 is not commutative for @xmath102 an even root of unity . by theorem [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_cpt1 ] , this also implies that the subcategory of dualisable yetter - drinfeld modules in @xmath751 has a non - commutative grothendieck ring .
note , however , that ( semi-)cyclic representations @xmath1062 of @xmath96 are not representations of the nichols algebras of @xmath409 : by definition or by ( * ? ? ?
* thm.2.9 ) , the nichols algebra of @xmath417 is the quotient of @xmath538 by the kernel of the braided symmetriser @xmath1075 , as in lemma [ lem : exthopf ] .
we have @xmath1076_q!\cdot\iota_n\circ\pi_n$ ] , where @xmath696_q ! : = [ 1]_q[2]_q \cdots [ n]_q$ ] . in the root of unity case ,
@xmath696_q = 0 $ ] for @xmath1077 .
hence , representations of @xmath1007 where @xmath1078 acts nonzero can not correspond to representations of the nichols algebra of @xmath417 .
if @xmath1079 , then the tensor products become decomposable and there are exact sequences @xmath1080 \begin{cd } 0 @ > > > v^{p_3}(q^{-1 } w ) @ > > > v_1(w ' ) { \otimes}v^p(w ) @ > > > v^{p_4}(q w ) @ > > > 0 \ , \end{cd } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath1081 the first sequence is a rewriting of the sequence given in ( * ? ? ?
* sect.4 ) . the second sequence may be obtained by dualising the first one . ,
@xmath1082 , @xmath1083 and @xmath1084 , where @xmath584 is the antipode in @xmath1007 .
hence , @xmath1085 , if @xmath1060 and @xmath1086 . also , @xmath1087 . ] denote by @xmath1088 the class of @xmath1089 in the grothendieck ring of @xmath1090 , and by @xmath1091 the class of @xmath1062 .
we distinguish two cases : * @xmath1070 : if @xmath102 is an odd root of unity , @xmath1088 and @xmath1091 commute , and if @xmath102 is an even root of unity they do not commute . *
@xmath1079 : one obtains the @xmath316-@xmath103-like relation @xmath1092 where @xmath1093 . if @xmath102 is an odd root of unity then @xmath1094 because @xmath1095 , and @xmath1088 and @xmath1091 commute .
if @xmath102 is an even root of unity , then @xmath1088 and @xmath1091 do not commute , but `` pulling @xmath1096 past @xmath1097 '' flips the signs of the parameters @xmath372 and @xmath317 .
this concludes our discussion of cyclic representations .
we have seen two new features which arise for the free boson compactified on a circle of rational radius squared .
firstly , non - local conserved charges constructed from quantum group representations no longer necessarily commute , and secondly , there is a _ finite - dimensional _ representation of the _ full _ quantum group ( rather than an infinite - dimensional representation of a borel half , cf .
remark [ rem : t - vs - q - uncomp ] ) which behaves similar to a q - operator .
being representations of the full quantum group , via theorem [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_cpt1 ] and the construction in section [ ssec : pertdefnonlocalconscharges ] , such cyclic representations provide conserved charges for the perturbed compactified free boson .
in order to remind the reader and to fix the notation used in the paper we collect some standard definitions such as the notion of monoidal centre , algebra , hopf algebra , module , bimodule , ... in a ( braided ) monoidal category .
a monoidal category is given by the data @xmath1098 , where @xmath18 is some category , @xmath1099 , @xmath24 is the tensor unit of @xmath18 and @xmath27 , @xmath265 and @xmath450 are natural isomorphisms , @xmath1100 ( called associators ) , @xmath1101 , @xmath1102 ( called unit isomorphisms ) , for @xmath1103 , subject to the usual axioms ( see , e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* ch1.1 ) ) .
if @xmath18 is an abelian monoidal category with exact tensor product , then @xmath1104 denotes its grothendieck ring ( see , e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* ch2.1 ) ) .
@xmath1105{img / figdz_a.pdf } } \ : = \ \varphi_{v , x } & \text{(b ) } \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.18\textwidth]{img / figdz_b_lhs.pdf } } = \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.18\textwidth]{img / figdz_b_rhs.pdf } } \\ & & \\ & \text{(c ) } \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.18\textwidth]{img / figdz_c_rhs.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.18\textwidth]{img / figdz_c_lhs.pdf } } & \text{(d ) } \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.18\textwidth]{img / figdz_d_lhs.pdf } } = \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[height=0.18\textwidth]{img / figdz_d_rhs.pdf } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] * objects : pairs @xmath406 where @xmath112 is an object of @xmath29 and @xmath151 ( the _ half - braiding _ ) is a natural isomorphism @xmath1107 such that for all @xmath333 we have ( see figure [ fig : dz ] ( b ) ) @xmath1108 * morphisms : a morphism from @xmath406 to @xmath407 is a morphism @xmath1109 in @xmath29 such that for each object @xmath15 we have ( see figure [ fig : dz ] ( c ) ) @xmath1110 define a tensor product @xmath158 on @xmath28 by @xmath1111 , where @xmath1112 is given for objects @xmath15 by ( see figure [ fig : dz ] ( d ) ) @xmath1113 define a braiding @xmath131 on @xmath28 by @xmath1114 .
this turns @xmath28 into a braided monoidal category @xcite .
note that the forgetful functor @xmath1115 is strictly monoidal .
next we define ( co-)algebras and modules within a monoidal category .
the tensor algebras @xmath104 used in sections [ sec : tensor_algebras ] and [ sec : comm_cond_yd ] , as well as the frobenius algebras @xmath118 in rational cft ( see e.g. remark [ rem : top - def - in - rcft ] ) are of this kind .
if one applies the definition below to the category of vector spaces one obtains the usual notions of algebras and modules over a field .
@xmath1116{img / figalg_a_mult.pdf } } : = \mu , \qquad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_a_unit.pdf } } \ : = \eta , & \text{(b ) } & \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_b_balg_1.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_b_balg_2.pdf } } \\ \\ & \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_a_ass_1.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_a_ass_2.pdf } } \ , \qquad\raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_a_unit_1.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_a_unit_2.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_a_unit_3.pdf } } & & \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_b_balg_3.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_b_balg_4.pdf } } \ , \quad \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_b_balg_5.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_b_balg_6.pdf } } \\ \\ & & & \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_b_balg_7.pdf } } \ = \ { \ensuremath{\textnormal{id}}}_{{\mathbbm 1 } } \\
\text{(c ) } & \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_c_antip_1.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_c_antip_2.pdf } } \ = \ \raisebox{-0.5\height}{\includegraphics[scale=.5]{img / figalg_c_antip_3.pdf } } \end{array } \end{aligned}\ ] ] a. an _ algebra in @xmath18 _ is a triple @xmath1118 consisting of an object @xmath118 in @xmath18 and morphisms @xmath1119 ( multiplication ) , @xmath1120 ( unit ) , such that ( see figure [ fig : alg](a ) ) @xmath1121 a _ morphism of algebras _ from @xmath132 to @xmath133 is a morphism @xmath1122 such that @xmath1123 and @xmath1124 .
+ the _ opposite algebra _
@xmath1125 has multiplication @xmath1126 .
b. a _ coalgebra in @xmath18 _ is a triple @xmath1127 consisting of an object @xmath118 in @xmath18 and morphisms @xmath1128 ( comultiplication ) , @xmath1129 ( counit ) , such that @xmath1130 a _ morphism of coalgebras _ from @xmath1131 to @xmath1132 is a morphism @xmath1122 such that @xmath1133 and @xmath1134 . c. let @xmath1118 be an algebra in @xmath18 .
@xmath118-(left ) module _ is a pair @xmath1135 where @xmath1136 is an object in @xmath18 and @xmath1137 is a morphism such that @xmath1138 a _ morphism of @xmath118-modules _ from @xmath1135 to @xmath1139 is a morphism @xmath1140 in @xmath18 such that @xmath1141 .
+ similarly , one defines an @xmath118-right module .
tensor algebras in a braided category are algebras and coalgebras simultaneously .
in fact , the tensor algebra becomes a bialgebra and even a hopf algebra .
the definition of bialgebras and hopf algebras involves a choice related to the braiding as we recall now .
a. a _ bialgebra in @xmath18 _ is a tuple @xmath1144 such that @xmath1118 is an algebra and @xmath1127 a coalgebra in @xmath18 and such that @xmath1145 are morphisms of algebras in the sense that the conditions in figure [ fig : alg](b ) hold .
b. a _ hopf algebra _ in @xmath18 is a tuple @xmath1146 , where @xmath1147 is a bialgebra in @xmath18 and @xmath584 is a morphism
@xmath1148 satisfying the conditions in figure [ fig : alg](c ) ( see , e.g. ( * ? ? ?
* sect.2 ) ) . given an algebra @xmath118 in @xmath282 , by a slight abuse of notation we will denote the category of @xmath179-modules in @xmath18 by @xmath1142 , instead of @xmath1149 .
if @xmath1144 is a bialgebra in @xmath28 , then we equip @xmath180 with a tensor product : for @xmath118-modules @xmath1150 , @xmath1151 , define@xmath194 @xmath1152 this turns @xmath180 into a monoidal category
. in rational cft , the category of topological defects is given by the _ category of bimodules _ over an algebra ( see remark [ rem : top - def - in - rcft ] ) .
we need this notion , in particular , in our treatment of the compactified free boson in section [ sec : compboson ] .
let @xmath1117 be a monoidal category and @xmath1118 an algebra in @xmath18 .
@xmath254-bimodule _ is a triple @xmath1153 consisting of an object @xmath2 of @xmath18 and morphisms @xmath1154 and @xmath1155 such that @xmath1156 is a left @xmath118-module and @xmath1157 is a right @xmath118-module and @xmath1158 in other words , @xmath1159 is a left module morphism and @xmath1160 is a right module morphism .
denote by @xmath295 the _ category of @xmath254-bimodules _ in @xmath18 with morphisms given by simultaneous right and left module morphisms .
let @xmath18 be an abelian monoidal category with right - exact tensor product .
then the category @xmath295 is abelian ( this can for example be seen using proposition [ prop : d_f - abelian - etc ] , cf . the proof of proposition [ prop : fccardytoalg ] in appendix [ apx : fccardytoalg ] ) . for @xmath254-bimodules
@xmath1153 and @xmath1161 , let @xmath1162 be a choice of cokernel for the morphism @xmath1163 where @xmath1164 here , @xmath1165 and @xmath1166 are considered as @xmath254-bimodules with actions @xmath1167 , @xmath1168 and @xmath1169 , @xmath1170 .
define associativity constraints @xmath1171 as the unique morphisms making the diagrams @xmath1172^{{\textnormal{cok}}_{x , y } { \otimes}{\ensuremath{\textnormal{id}}}_z } \ar[d]_{\alpha_{x , y , z } } & ( x { \otimes}_a y ) { \otimes}z \ar[r]^{{\textnormal{cok}}_{x { \otimes}_a y , z } } & ( x { \otimes}_a y ) { \otimes}_a z \ar[d]^{\tilde\alpha_{x , y , z } } \\ x { \otimes}(y { \otimes}z ) \ar[r]^{{\ensuremath{\textnormal{id}}}_x { \otimes}{\textnormal{cok}}_{y , z } } & x { \otimes}(y { \otimes}_a z ) \ar[r]^{{\textnormal{cok}}_{x , y { \otimes}_a z } } & x { \otimes}_a ( y { \otimes}_a z ) } \end{aligned}\ ] ] commute .
this turns @xmath295 into a ( non - strict ) monoidal category with right - exact tensor product @xmath1173 .
the monoidal structure is independent of the choices of cokernels up to canonical isomorphism .
since @xmath5 is the generator of translations along the @xmath342-axis , commuting @xmath5 past a defect circle gives a derivative with respect to the position of the defect circle , the commutators involving @xmath5 here and below might be understood as @xmath1175 for all @xmath1176 ( @xmath5 is unbounded , in general ; recall that we supposed that @xmath1177 is bounded ) . ]
@xmath1178 \nonumber\\ & \qquad = \frac{\partial}{\partial \nu } \mathcal{o}\big(c_{{\varepsilon}-\nu,\nu}^{x,\dots , x}(x_1,\dots , x_n)\big)(\psi^{\rho_1},\dots,\psi^{\rho_n } ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath1179 . since @xmath1180 , if @xmath368 is inserted at a point @xmath1181 , then the operator @xmath375 for that cylinder will be annihilated by are orthogonal to the defect line and require a local deformation of the defect line . this
is allowed as the defect line is topological . ] @xmath1182 .
if @xmath370 is inserted at @xmath1181 , the operator @xmath375 will be annihilated by @xmath1183 .
we can therefore trade the derivative with respect to @xmath1184 in for a derivative @xmath1185 for each @xmath368 , and for a derivative @xmath1186 for each @xmath370 .
altogether , @xmath1187 \nonumber\\ & \qquad = \big(i^{\rho_1}\,\tfrac{\partial}{\partial x_1 } + \cdots + i^{\rho_n}\ , \tfrac{\partial}{\partial x_n}\big ) \mathcal{o}(c_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2}^{x,\dots , x}(x_1,\dots , x_n))(\psi^{\rho_1},\dots,\psi^{\rho_n } ) \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] next we look at a regulated version of the multiple integrals .
define , for some @xmath1188 , @xmath1189 now we define the regulated multiple integrals in analogy with , @xmath1190 where @xmath1191 is as in .
of course , by the assumption that the function @xmath1192 be integrable for all @xmath1176 , these integrals are well - defined even if we set @xmath1193 to zero .
however , the right - hand - side of is not integrable , in general . after this preparation
, we can conclude from that @xmath1194 = \sum_{k=1}^n i^{\rho_k } \int_{u(n,\delta ) } \frac{\partial f_{n}^{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n}(x_1,\dots , x_n)}{\partial x_k } \
, d^n{\mathbf}x \ .\ ] ] we note for later use that @xmath1195 = 0 \qquad \text{and } \qquad \lim_{\delta\to0 } [ h_0,e_{1,\delta}^{\rho_1 } ] = 0 \ , \ ] ] where the equality for @xmath231 follows as there are no insertions on the topological defect @xmath2 , and the equality for @xmath1196 is immediate from and periodicity of @xmath1197 . in the following we will assume that @xmath1198 for @xmath1199 let @xmath1200 where we set @xmath1201 , @xmath1202 and where @xmath1203 means omission of the respective element(s ) .
together with we obtain @xmath1204 & = \sum_{k=1}^{n } i^{\rho_k } \int_{u(n , k,\delta ) } f_{n}^{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n}(\dots , x_{k-1},x_{k+1}-\delta , x_{k+1},\dots ) \ , d^{n-1}{\mathbf}x \nonumber\\ & -\sum_{k=1}^{n } i^{\rho_k } \int_{u(n , k,\delta ) } f_{n}^{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n}(\dots , x_{k-1},x_{k-1}+\delta , x_{k+1},\dots ) \ , d^{n-1}{\mathbf}x \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the omissions `` @xmath1205 '' stand for the arguments of @xmath198 which remained unmodified with respect to .
the arguments @xmath1206 and @xmath1207 are absent for @xmath245 and @xmath1208 , respectively .
now , using ( @xmath1209 ) @xmath1210 shift the summation variable @xmath1211 in the second sum of and combine the last term in the first sum and the first term in the second sum .
this yields @xmath1212 \nonumber\\ & = i^{\rho_n } \int_{u(n , n,\delta ) } f_{n}^{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n}(\dots , x_{n-1},l-\delta ) \ , d^{n-1}{\mathbf}x ~-~ i^{\rho_1 } \int_{u(n,1,\delta ) } f_{n}^{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n}(0,x_2,\dots ) \ , d^{n-1}{\mathbf}x \nonumber\\ & \qquad+ \sum_{k=1}^{n-1 } \int_{u(n , k,\delta ) } \left ( i^{\rho_k } - i^{\rho_{k+1 } } \right ) f_{n}^{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n}(\dots , x_{k-1},x_{k+1}-\delta , x_{k+1},\dots ) \ , d^{n-1}{\mathbf}x . \end{aligned}\ ] ] observe that @xmath1213 by invariance of the theory under translations by @xmath1193 in @xmath339-direction . hence , the sum over @xmath1214 of the first two terms in vanishes .
let @xmath1215 , and abbreviate @xmath1216 by @xmath1217 .
consider the sum over @xmath1214 of the integrand in the sum over @xmath99 in . if @xmath1218 the prefactor is zero , so that we are left with @xmath1219 where @xmath1220 are inserted in the @xmath99th and @xmath1221st argument .
the corresponding insertion points are @xmath1222 and @xmath1207 .
these two points approach each other for @xmath1223 .
note that the ope of @xmath368 with @xmath370 is regular .
for this reason we will assume that is dominated , uniformly in @xmath1193 , by an integrable function .
hence , we may interchange integration and the @xmath1223 limit , so that we can apply
. we can now write : @xmath1224 = \lim_{\delta \to 0 } \sum_{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n \in \{\pm1\ } } [ h_0,e_{n,\delta}^{\rho_1,\dots,\rho_n } ] \nonumber\\ & \quad = 2i \lim_{\delta \to 0 } \sum_{k=1}^{n-1 } \int_{u(n , k,\delta)}\big ( \mathcal{o}'(\psi,\dots,\psi,\psi^+,\psi^-,\psi,\dots,\psi ) \nonumber\\ & \quad \hspace{10em } - \mathcal{o}'(\psi,\dots,\psi,\psi^-,\psi^+,\psi,\dots,\psi ) \big ) \ , d^{n-1}{\mathbf}x \nonumber\\ & \quad \overset{\text{\eqref{eq : comm - rel - defect - ops}}}= 2i \lim_{{\varepsilon}\to 0 } \sum_{k=1}^{n-1 } \int_{u_k } \big ( \mathcal{o}(c^{{\mathbbm 1},x}_{{\varepsilon}_1-{\varepsilon},{\varepsilon},{\varepsilon}_2}(x_k;x_1,\dots,\widehat{x_k , x_{k+1}},\dots , x_n))(\phi;\psi,\dots,\psi ) \nonumber\\ & \hspace{7em } \qquad - \mathcal{o}(c^{x,{\mathbbm 1}}_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon},{\varepsilon}_2-{\varepsilon}}(x_1,\dots,\widehat{x_k , x_{k+1}},\dots , x_n;x_k))(\psi,\dots,\psi;\phi ) \big ) \ , d^{n-1}{\mathbf}x \nonumber\\ & \quad = 2i \lim_{{\varepsilon}\to 0 } \int_0^l \hspace{-.5em } dy \int_{u(n-2,0 ) } \big ( \mathcal{o}(c^{{\mathbbm 1},x}_{{\varepsilon}_1-{\varepsilon},{\varepsilon},{\varepsilon}_2}(y;x_1,\dots , x_{n-2}))(\phi;\psi,\dots,\psi ) \nonumber\\ & \hspace{8em } \qquad - \mathcal{o}(c^{x,{\mathbbm 1}}_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon},{\varepsilon}_2-{\varepsilon}}(x_1,\dots , x_{n-2};y))(\psi,\dots,\psi;\phi ) \big ) \ , d^{n-2}{\mathbf}x \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath1225 stands for omitting the @xmath99th and @xmath1221st argument and @xmath1226 under the assumption that the @xmath1227 limit exists , this shows that @xmath1228 = 2i [ h_\mathrm{int } , \lim_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2 \to 0 } e_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2;n-2}^x(\psi ) ] \ , \ ] ] where @xmath1229 was defined in . to complete the argument
that condition implies the commutator , we compute @xmath1230 \nonumber\\ & = \sum_{n=0}^\infty \lambda^n [ h_0 , \lim_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2 \to 0 } e_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2;n}^x(\psi ) ] - 2 i \sum_{n=0}^\infty \lambda^{n+2 } [ h_\mathrm{int } , \lim_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2 \to 0 } e_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2;n}^x(\psi ) ] \\ & \overset{(*)}= 2 i \sum_{n=2}^\infty \lambda^n [ h_\mathrm{int } , \lim_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2 \to 0 } e_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2;n-2}^x(\psi ) ] - 2 i \sum_{n=0}^\infty \lambda^{n+2 } [ h_\mathrm{int } , \lim_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2 \to 0 } e_{{\varepsilon}_1,{\varepsilon}_2;n}^x(\psi ) ] = 0 \ , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where ( * ) follows from and .
let @xmath577 , @xmath2 be finite dimensional vector spaces .
define @xmath1231 as the algebra freely generated by elements of @xmath577 as commuting variables and elements of @xmath2 as non - commuting variables ( modulo linear relations ) , i.e. , @xmath1232 where @xmath1233 denotes the tensor algebra of @xmath1234 and @xmath1235 is the ideal generated by @xmath1236 . fix some norm @xmath1237 on @xmath1234 . for @xmath1238 define @xmath1239 as the norm on @xmath1240 given by @xmath1241 for @xmath1242 , and where @xmath1243 denotes the @xmath1244th tensor factor in a decomposition of the homogeneous component of @xmath342 in @xmath1245 into a sum of @xmath1246 pure tensors .
the norm @xmath1247 can be understood as a weighted sum of projective cross norms .
the algebra @xmath1240 is graded by the number of elements of @xmath2 , i.e. , @xmath1248 let @xmath1249 be the completion of @xmath1250 with respect to the family of norms @xmath1239 , @xmath1238 .
note , for example , that @xmath1251 is bigger than @xmath1252 since it includes convergent sums of the form @xmath1253 for fixed @xmath1254 .
clearly , the completion does not depend on the initial choice of norm @xmath1237 on @xmath1234 : if @xmath1255 are such that @xmath1256 for all @xmath1257 ( all norms on the finite dimensional space @xmath1234 are equivalent ) , then @xmath1258 holds for all @xmath1259 .
define @xmath1260 denote the algebra @xmath1261 by @xmath1262 .
note that the multiplication on @xmath1240 is continuous , since @xmath1263 for all @xmath1264 ( and since it respects the grading @xmath1265 ) .
hence , it extends to a continuous multiplication on the grade - wise completion and turns @xmath576 into a topological algebra .
the above completion may seem artificial , but it is in fact quite natural : the algebra @xmath1266 is isomorphic to the algebra of entire complex analytic functions in @xmath45 variables with the topology of uniform convergence on compact sets . to demonstrate this , we first note two elementary facts . *
an entire complex analytic function is the same as a series @xmath1267 where @xmath1268 and @xmath1269 , such that for all @xmath1270 the series @xmath1271 converges ( here , @xmath1272 ) .
this is because if @xmath1273 for some @xmath1238 , then for each @xmath1274 there is @xmath1275 and @xmath1276 such that @xmath1277 , i.e. , @xmath1278 . hence , the series @xmath1279 does not converge in @xmath74 , a contradiction . *
the topology of uniform convergence on compact sets is induced by the family of norms @xmath1280 , @xmath1238 : from @xmath1281 it follows that @xmath1282 converges uniformly to @xmath198 on the compact set @xmath1283 . on the other hand ,
if a sequence @xmath1282 converges uniformly to @xmath198 on the set @xmath1284 , then for every @xmath1285 there is @xmath1274 such that @xmath1286 for all @xmath1287 . with cauchy s integral formula for the taylor series coefficients @xmath1288 of @xmath1289 , i.e. , @xmath1290 , one sees that @xmath1291 for all @xmath1275 .
this implies @xmath1281
. then denote by @xmath7 the algebra map from @xmath1292 to the algebra of entire complex analytic functions in @xmath45 variables determined by @xmath1293 if we choose the norm @xmath1237 on @xmath577 such that @xmath1294 for all @xmath580 , then by we have @xmath1295 for all @xmath1242 . on the other hand , @xmath1296 , since if @xmath1297 , then @xmath1298 in the second step , submultiplicativity of @xmath1280 was used ( @xmath1299 ) . together with the fact that the algebra of entire complex analytic functions is complete with respect to the topology of uniform convergence on compact sets ( by morera s theorem , uniform limits of holomorphic functions are holomorphic ) , one finds that @xmath7 extends to an isomorphism of topological algebras .
we need the following result only for @xmath577 acting diagonalisably on a vector space @xmath112 .
since it does not make much more effort , we prove it for @xmath577 acting _ locally finitely_. by this we mean that @xmath1301 for each @xmath1302 . [ prop : apx_alge ] let @xmath112 be a representation of @xmath1303 in which @xmath577 acts locally finitely . there exists a unique extension to a representation of @xmath576 such that for all @xmath1304 and @xmath1302 , the function @xmath1305 , @xmath1306 , is continuous .
denote the action of @xmath1240 on @xmath112 by @xmath450 .
we need to define an action @xmath558 of @xmath581 on @xmath112 .
as @xmath581 is the direct sum of @xmath1249 s , it suffices to define @xmath558 for elements of @xmath1249 .
fix @xmath1302 . as @xmath2 is finite dimensional and @xmath577 acts locally finitely ,
the subspace @xmath1307 is finite dimensional .
let @xmath1308 be any norm on @xmath1309 .
there is @xmath1238 such that @xmath1310 holds for all @xmath580 and @xmath1311 and @xmath1312 holds for all @xmath1254 and @xmath1313 .
this is true because @xmath1234 and @xmath1309 are finite dimensional . with it
follows that @xmath1314 for all @xmath1315 and @xmath1311 .
let @xmath1316 be a cauchy net in @xmath1250 approximating @xmath342 .
then @xmath1317 for all @xmath1318 and this means that @xmath1319 is a cauchy net in @xmath112 .
define @xmath1320 .
since @xmath1309 is finite - dimensional it is closed , and hence also @xmath1321 .
continuity of @xmath1322 follows from the continuity of @xmath1323 with respect to the @xmath1308-norm and since @xmath1324 is linear and hence continuous on the finite - dimensional space @xmath1309 .
uniqueness is clear from @xmath1325 together with the fact that on @xmath1309 , the forms @xmath1324 are continuous and separate points .
any linear homogeneous ( with respect to the grading ) map @xmath1332 extends uniquely to a continuous algebra homomorphism @xmath1333 ( which is necessarily grade - preserving ) . to see this ,
let @xmath1334 be the unique extension of @xmath198 to @xmath1240 , choose some norm @xmath1237 on @xmath1234 , let @xmath1270 be a positive real number and let @xmath1335 be such that @xmath1336 holds for all @xmath1257 .
then , by definition of @xmath1239 and @xmath1337 , @xmath1338 holds true for any @xmath1339 .
hence , @xmath1334 is continuous .
the claim follows as @xmath1334 is homogeneous and the homogeneous components of @xmath1340 are complete .
it follows that the coproducts in definition [ df : qgrps_uncomp ] are well - defined continuous homomorphisms @xmath1341 . in order to avoid the effort of introducing @xmath578 for the definition of @xmath1342 ( see definition [ df : qgrps_uncomp ] ) , it would be tempting to work with just @xmath1343 ( see definition [ df : qgrps_comp ] ) , but to be able to consider representations of @xmath1343 as representations of @xmath577 ( e.g. theorem [ thm : exrepcatfuncmon_uncpt1 ] ) , we would need to fix `` logarithms '' for the action of the generator `` @xmath99 '' related to the braiding . as long as one is only concerned with finite dimensional representations , the only eigenvalues of @xmath99 are of the form @xmath1344 for some @xmath935 .
so if @xmath102 is not a root of unity , there is a canonical `` logarithm '' for @xmath99 .
but the representations underlying the `` @xmath103 operators '' are infinite dimensional . also , we do not a priori want to exclude the root of unity case . hence , we prefer choosing a `` logarithm '' for @xmath99 by introducing a generator @xmath86 and letting @xmath1345 ( as done in @xcite ) .
but the exponential series @xmath1346 is not an element of the _ algebra _ generated by @xmath86 .
hence we need to complete with respect to a suitable topology . in (
* ex.6.2 ) , drinfeld defines @xmath815 with primitive cartan - like generators @xmath86 , but with @xmath693 being a formal parameter instead of a complex number . in ( * ? ? ?
* ch.6.2 ) one finds a version of @xmath1343 with @xmath102 being a number and with generators `` @xmath1347 '' , @xmath580 , but without any specified topology ( otherwise @xmath86 should be recovered as a limit ) .
we are not aware of a version of drinfeld s quantum group with numerical parameter in the literature .
note that the only eigenvalues of @xmath1354 in a finite dimensional module are of the form @xmath1344 , @xmath935 .
the functor @xmath187 has a monoidal `` section '' @xmath1355 defined on the tensor subcategory of @xmath1343-modules where @xmath1354 acts diagonalisably : it sends @xmath1356 with diagonalisable @xmath1354-action to @xmath1357 , which is the same vector space as @xmath2 and where the generators @xmath1358 , @xmath1052 , of @xmath1342 act as the corresponding generators of @xmath1343 on @xmath2 , but @xmath748 acts on @xmath1354-eigenvectors @xmath1359 for eigenvalue @xmath1344 by @xmath1360 .
since finite dimensional representations have finite length , @xmath1361 as well as @xmath1362 are freely generated as abelian groups by the classes @xmath1363 $ ] of simple objects @xmath2 .
hence , the functor @xmath1355 descends to a ring homomorphism @xmath1364 satisfying @xmath1365 .
for the same reason , it suffices to show that the classes @xmath1363,[y]$ ] of any two simple objects @xmath1366 commute in @xmath1362 . for @xmath1044 let @xmath1367 be the simple @xmath1342-module which is @xmath74 as a vector space , where @xmath1358 ( @xmath1052 ) act by @xmath106 and @xmath748 acts by multiplication with @xmath1368
. then @xmath1369 ) = 1 $ ] for all @xmath1044 , and we have @xmath1370 , and hence @xmath1371[x ] = [ x][x_m]$ ] , for all @xmath1372 . note that if @xmath1372 is simple , then there is a unique @xmath1044 such that @xmath1363 = [ x_m ] \cdot s(g([x]))$ ] .
so let @xmath1366 be simple and let @xmath1373 be such that @xmath1363 = [ x_m ] \cdot s(g([x]))$ ] and @xmath1374 = [ x_n ] \cdot s(g([y]))$ ] .
then @xmath1375[y ] & = [ x_m][x_n ] s(g([x]))s(g([y ] ) ) = [ x_m][x_n ] s(g([x ] ) g([y ] ) ) \\ & \overset{(*)}= [ x_m][x_n ] s(g([y])g([x ] ) ) = [ y][x ] , \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where in ( * ) the commutativity of @xmath1376 was used .
_ denote the functor by @xmath187 .
since @xmath901 and @xmath118 are mutually transparent , we have @xmath1377 in @xmath1378 .
hence , @xmath1379 is indeed a morphism @xmath1380 in @xmath29 if @xmath1381 .
this shows that @xmath187 is a functor @xmath1382 .
let @xmath52 and @xmath169 be objects of @xmath1383 and write @xmath1384 .
then @xmath1385 for step ( * ) first note that @xmath1386 as morphisms @xmath1387 in @xmath18 . by proposition [ prop :
alphaind ] , @xmath27 is braided , so that this agrees with the half - braiding @xmath1388 of @xmath417 .
the argument for @xmath1389 is analogous , and uses once more that @xmath1377 .
this is a consequence of lemma [ lem : exact_iff ] , regarding @xmath295 as a full abelian ( non - monoidal ) subcategory of @xmath1392 ( use the braiding on @xmath18 to turn the right action of @xmath118 into a left action of @xmath1393 and observe that kernels and cokernels of a bimodule morphism are bimodules ) . _
_ let @xmath1394 be an exact sequence in @xmath18 .
since by assumption @xmath909 is exact , also @xmath1395 is an exact sequence in @xmath18 .
observation [ obs : exact - in - bmod - iff - in - cat ] now implies that @xmath1396 is exact in @xmath295 .
it remains to show that right - exactness of @xmath1397 implies right - exactness of @xmath1398 . with another application of lemma [ lem : exact_iff ] , this will imply that @xmath1399 is exact in @xmath1400 .
so let @xmath1401 be an exact sequence in @xmath1391 and note that , by observation [ obs : exact - in - bmod - iff - in - cat ] , @xmath1401 is exact in @xmath18 .
we have to show that @xmath1402 is exact in @xmath1391 . as there are isomorphisms @xmath1403 , @xmath1404 in @xmath1391 ( cf .
remark [ rem : alpha - frs - relation ] ) we find that it suffices to show exactness of the sequence @xmath1405 in @xmath1391 . by observation [ obs : exact - in - bmod - iff - in - cat ] , this is equivalent to the exactness of @xmath1406 in @xmath18 , which follows from the exactness of @xmath1401 in @xmath18 together with right - exactness of @xmath1397 . before giving the proof of proposition [ prop : fcab ]
, we will compute the 3-cocycle defining the tensor product on the semisimple subcategory of @xmath996 spanned by the simple objects @xmath861 .
for the proof we only need that this cocycle is trivial on the span of @xmath912 , but the general result is of interest on its own .
a _ pointed category _ is a @xmath74-linear abelian semisimple monoidal category with exact tensor product such that the set of isomorphism classes of simple objects forms a group @xmath1407 .
this means that for @xmath1408 and @xmath1409 , @xmath1410 , we have @xmath1411 .
let @xmath1412 be the @xmath74-linear abelian semisimple ( with arbitrarily large direct sums ) category with simple objects @xmath1413 , @xmath1414 , and tensor product @xmath1415 .
this category is a strict version of the category of @xmath1407-graded vector spaces .
given a 3-cocycle @xmath1416 , one obtains a monoidal structure on @xmath1412 by defining associativity constraints @xmath1417 ( the pentagon axiom is equivalent to the 3-cocycle condition , see ( * ? ? ? *
app.e ) or ( * ? ? ?
* sect.3 ) ) . denote this category by @xmath1418 .
cohomologous 3-cocycles yield isomorphic monoidal structures , so that @xmath1418 depends only on the cohomology class of @xmath10 in @xmath1419 .
any pointed category containing arbitrarily large direct sums is monoidally equivalent to some @xmath1418 . the class of the 3-cocycle is uniquely determined by the requirement that the equivalence takes @xmath1413 to an object in the isomorphism class @xmath356 . by remark [ rem : ar - bimods ] , the full subcategory @xmath1420 of @xmath996 formed by arbitrarily large direct sums of simple objects is pointed , with group of simple objects @xmath1421 . for an element
@xmath1422 we pick @xmath1423 as representative of the corresponding isomorphism class .
recall from remark [ rem : ar - bimods ] that @xmath1424 as an object in @xmath769 , where @xmath1425 is the algebra homomorphism @xmath849 sending @xmath850 to @xmath1426 .
we denote by @xmath1427 the canonical embedding of @xmath74 into the @xmath202th summand of the underlying vector space @xmath1428 of @xmath1429 .
the tensor product on @xmath1420 is defined through choices of cokernels @xmath1430 , see appendix [ appx : alg - etc - in - braided - cats ] .
different choices lead to canonically equivalent monoidal structures
. therefore we have the freedom to pick a convenient one . for simple objects @xmath1429 and @xmath1431 with @xmath1432 and @xmath1433 we let @xmath1434 be the map @xmath1435 where @xmath1436 is the 2-cocycle @xmath1437 the addition of @xmath1438 on the right hand side of ensures that @xmath1434 is a morphism in @xmath18 .
the factor @xmath1439 compensates the difference of the right action @xmath1440 of @xmath1441 on the left hand side and @xmath1442 on the right hand side , see , so that @xmath1434 is a morphism of @xmath840-bimodules .
the factor @xmath1439 is also required in order for @xmath1443 to be a cokernel for the morphism @xmath1444 as in . for @xmath1445 , @xmath1446 , @xmath1447 , and writing @xmath1448 , @xmath1449
, we have @xmath1450 and @xmath1451 hence , @xmath1452 where @xmath1453 are the associativity constraints in @xmath18 and @xmath10 is the 3-cocycle @xmath1454 by the definition of associativity constraints in the category of bimodules , see , this shows that the functor sending @xmath1455 to @xmath1429 gives rise to a monoidal equivalence of @xmath1418 and @xmath1420 .
let us just note suppose , to the contrary , that @xmath1456 for some map @xmath1457 .
then for all @xmath1458 we have ( with @xmath1459 the neutral element ) @xmath1460 hence , @xmath1461 .
now fix @xmath1462 .
then we have @xmath1463 , but , with @xmath1464 , @xmath1465 a contradiction .
faithfulness is clear , since @xmath677 acts as the identity on hom - sets .
exactness comes from @xmath677 taking direct sums to direct sums .
as @xmath937 in gives rise to an injective map @xmath1466 , the functor @xmath677 maps non - isomorphic simple object to non - isomorphic simple objects . hence , @xmath677 is full .
let @xmath1467 be the subgroup @xmath1468 .
to see monoidality of @xmath677 , the key point is that @xmath10 restricted to @xmath1469 is trivial , @xmath1470 .
indeed , an exact functor sending @xmath1471 ( @xmath953 as in remark [ rem : image - of - bimod - functor ] ) to @xmath1472 gives rise to a monoidal equivalence of @xmath921 and the subcategory @xmath1473 .
now any choices of isomorphisms @xmath1474 may be used to obtain the structure maps needed to turn @xmath677 into a monoidal functor .
bespalov , _ crossed modules and quantum groups in braided categories _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1023/a:1008674524341[appl .
structures * 5 * ( 1997 ) , 155204 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/q-alg/9510013[[q-alg/9510013 ] ] .
d. bernard and a. leclair , _ the quantum double in integrable quantum field theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0550-3213(93)90515-q[nucl .
b * 399 * ( 1993 ) , 709748 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9205064[[hep-th/9205064 ] ] .
bazhanov , s.l .
lukyanov , and a.b .
zamolodchikov , _ integrable structure of conformal field theory , quantum kdv theory and thermodynamic bethe ansatz _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/bf02101898[commun .
* 177 * ( 1996 ) , 381398 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9412229[[hep-th/9412229 ] ] .
to3em , _ integrable quantum field theories in finite volume : excited state energies _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0550-3213(97)00022-9[nucl .
b * 489 * ( 1997 ) , 487531 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9607099[[hep-th/9607099 ] ] .
to3em , _ integrable structure of conformal field theory .
q - operator and ddv equation _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s002200050240[commun .
* 190 * ( 1997 ) , 247278 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9604044[[hep-th/9604044 ] ] .
to3em , _ integrable structure in conformal field theory iii . the yang - baxter relation _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s002200050531[commun .
* 200 * ( 1999 ) , 297324 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9805008[[hep-th/9805008 ] ] .
a. davydov , l. kong , and i. runkel , _ field theories with defects and the centre functor _ , mathematical foundations of quantum field theory and perturbative string theory ( h. sati and u. schreiber , eds . ) , proc .
pure math .
, vol . 83 , 2011 , http://arxiv.org/abs/1107.0495[[math.qa/1107.0495 ] ] , pp . 71128
. p.i .
etingof , i.b .
frenkel , and a. kirillov jr . , _ lectures on representation theory and knizhnik - zamolodchikov equations _ , mathematical surveys and monographs , vol . 58 , american mathematical society , 1998 . j. frhlich , j. fuchs , i. runkel , and c. schweigert , _ duality and defects in rational conformal field theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2006.11.017[nucl . phys .
* b763 * ( 2007 ) , 354430 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0607247[[hep-th/0607247 ] ] .
j. fjelstad , j. fuchs , and c. stigner , _ rcft with defects : factorization and fundamental world sheets _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2012.05.011[nucl . phys .
* b863 * ( 2012 ) , 213259 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1202.3929[[hep-th/1202.3929 ] ] .
j. fuchs , m.r .
gaberdiel , i. runkel , and christoph schweigert , _ topological defects for the free boson cft _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/40/37/016[j .
a * a40 * ( 2007 ) , 11403 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0705.3129[[hep-th/0705.3129 ] ] .
e. frenkel and n. reshetikhin , _ the @xmath102-characters of representations of quantum affine algebras and deformations of w - algebras _ , contemp .
* 248 * ( 1999 ) , 163206 , http://arxiv.org/abs/math/9810055[[math/9810055 ] ] .
j. fuchs , i. runkel , and c. schweigert , _ tft construction of rctf correlators i : partition functions _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0550-3213(02)00744-7[nucl .
b * 646 * ( 2002 ) , 353497 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0204148[[hep-th/0204148 ] ] .
to3em , _ tft construction of rcft correlators iv : structure constants and correlation functions _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2005.03.018[nucl .
b * 715 * ( 2005 ) , 539638 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0412290[[hep-th/0412290 ] ] .
huang , _ rigidity and modularity of vertex tensor categories _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1142/s0219199708003083[commun .
contemp . math . *
10 * ( 2008 ) , 871911 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/math/0502533[[math.qa/0502533 ] ] . c. korff , _ auxiliary matrices for the six - vertex model at roots of 1 and a geometric interpretation of its symmetries _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0305-4470/36/19/305[j phys a : math gen * 36 * ( 2003 ) , 52295266 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/math-ph/0302002[[math-ph/0302002 ] ] .
d. manolopoulos and i. runkel , _ a monoidal category for perturbed defects in conformal field theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00220-009-0958-2[commun .
* 295 * ( 2009 ) , 327362 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0904.1122[[hep-th/0904.1122 ] ] .
m. mger , _ from subfactors to categories and topology ii . the quantum double of tensor categories and subfactors _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/s0022-4049(02)00248-7[j
* 180 * ( 2003 ) , 159219 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/math/0111205[[math.ct/0111205 ] ] .
g. niccoli and j. teschner , _ the sine - gordon model revisited : i _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/2010/09/p09014[j .
* 1009 * ( 2010 ) , p09014 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0910.3173[[hep-th/0910.3173 ] ] .
i. runkel , _ perturbed defects and t - systems in conformal field theory _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1751-8113/41/10/105401[j .
a * a41 * ( 2008 ) , 105401 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/0711.0102[[hep-th/0711.0102 ] ] .
m. rossi and r. weston , _ a generalized q - operator for @xmath1008 vertex models _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/0305-4470/35/47/304[j .
a : math . gen .
* 35 * ( 2002 ) , 1001510032 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/math-ph/0207004[[math-ph/0207004 ] ] .
a.m. semikhatov and i.yu .
tipunin , _ the nichols algebra of screenings _ , http://dx.doi.org/10.1142/s0219199712500290[commun .
contemp . math .
* 14 * ( 2012 ) , 1250029 ] , http://arxiv.org/abs/1101.5810[[math.qa/1101.5810 ] ] . | in this paper we relate a problem in representation theory the study of yetter - drinfeld modules over certain braided hopf algebras to a problem in two - dimensional quantum field theory , namely the identification of integrable perturbations of a conformal field theory . a prescription that parallels
lusztig s construction allows one to read off the quantum group governing the integrable symmetry . as an example
, we illustrate how the quantum group for the loop algebra of @xmath0 appears in the integrable structure of the perturbed uncompactified and compactified free boson . zmp - hh/12 - 23 + hamburger beitrge zur mathematik 455 3em integrable perturbations of conformal field theories + and yetter - drinfeld modules 2em david bcher and ingo runkel + [email protected] , [email protected] + fachbereich mathematik , universitt
hamburg + bundesstrae 55 , 20146 hamburg , germany 2em november 2012 2em |
searching for the higgs boson is one of the most important tasks in particle physics .
the existence of a relatively light higgs is suggested by high precision fits to the data in the standard model ( sm ) and also is theoretically favored in the minimal supersymmetric standard model ( mssm ) @xcite .
verification of the existence of a light higgs boson at the lhc or tevatron is therefore a very important test for both the sm and the mssm . among the various production channels for a light higgs boson at the hadron colliders
, the production in association with a bottom quark pair , @xmath1 , plays an important role in testing the bottom quark yukawa couplings .
while this process has a small cross section in the sm , in the mssm this production mechanism can be a significant source of higgs bosons since the bottom quark yukawa coupling in the mssm is proportional to @xmath0 ( defined as @xmath2 with @xmath3 being the vacuum expectation values of the two higgs doublets ) and the current analyses favor large @xmath0 .
this process has been studied at next - to - leading order in perturbative qcd @xcite . due to the importance of this production mechanism in testing the bottom quark yukawa coupling in the mssm , the supersymmetry ( susy ) loop effects in this process should also be considered . of course , among the susy loop effects the one - loop susy qcd corrections are the dominant . in the present work
we examine the one - loop susy qcd effects in this process . instead of performing a complete one - loop calculation , which would be quite complicated since it involves many five - point box diagrams , we focus on the so - called susy residual effects , i.e. , the susy effects in the heavy limit ( @xmath4 tev ) of the sparticles involved .
our motivations are the following : * it is possible that all the sparticles except a light higgs boson are too heavy to be directly produced at the lhc and tevatron , such as in the split susy scenario proposed recently by arkani - hamed and dimopoulos @xcite .
although the fermionic partners ( gauginos and higgsinos ) in this scenario are required to be relatively light in order to ensure gauge coupling unification and provide dark matter candidates , they are not necessarily below a tev , as recently shown @xcite .
thus , it is possible for the lhc and tevatron to observe no sparticles except a light higgs boson . in that case a possible way to reveal a hint of supersymmetry is through its residual effects in observable processes . * unfortunately ( or fortunately ) , susy virtual effects decouple in most processes when susy particles become very heavy .
however , we know that the only processes where susy has residual effects are those processes involving higgs - fermion yukawa couplings , as first studied for @xmath5 decay @xcite , and also for certain production processes @xcite . the production reaction @xmath1 at the lhc or tevatron is well suited for revealing susy residual effects since it involves the @xmath6 coupling . compared with @xmath7 ,
this process is also easier to detect since it contains an extra hard @xmath8 jet in the final state .
once the higgs boson ( @xmath9 ) is observed and its mass is measured through other processes such as gluon - gluon fusion , this reaction can be used to measure the bottom quark yukawa coupling and to observe the expected residual effects of susy .
note that the existence of susy residual effects in some higgs process does not mean susy is not decoupling in low energy processes . as shown in previous studies , and also in the following work ,
the residual effects exist when @xmath10 remains light ; when @xmath10 is heavy , together with all other susy masses , the residual effects do vanish .
this paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : calculation ] we present our strategy for the calculation of the one - loop susy qcd corrections . in section [
sec : results ] we perform numerical calculations and obtain the residual effects in the limit of heavy susy masses .
the conclusion is given in section [ sec : conclusion ] and the detailed analytic formulas obtained in our calculations are presented in the appendix .
the production @xmath11 proceeds through the parton - level processes @xmath12 and @xmath13 . the one - loop susy qcd corrections to this process have a huge number of one - loop diagrams ,
including many five - point box diagrams .
however , among all these diagrams only the one - loop diagrams involving the bottom quark yukawa coupling have residual effects as the susy masses become very heavy . therefore , in our calculation we need only consider the loop corrected bottom quark yukawa coupling diagrams shown in fig .
[ fig1 ] and fig .
[ fig2 ] . in our loop calculations we used dimensional regularization to control the ultraviolet divergences and adopted the on - mass - shell renormalization scheme .
each effective @xmath6 vertex in fig.[fig1 ] contains two parts : one is the irreducible three - point vertex loop contributions and the other is the counterterms @xmath14 with @xmath15 denoting the tree - level @xmath6 coupling and @xmath16 is the renormalization constant given by @xmath17 where @xmath18 and @xmath19 are respectively the renormalization constant for the @xmath8 quark field and mass .
they can be extracted from the one - loop self - energies shown in fig .
[ fig2](b ) by using the on - mass - shell renormalization condition .
they are given by @xmath20 \left(m_b^2 , m_{\tilde{g}}^2 , m_{\tilde{b}_i}^2 \right ) \right .
\delta z_r & = & \delta z_l\left \vert_{a_{i}^3\rightarrow -a_{i}^3 } \ , \right . \\ \frac{\delta
m_b}{m_b}&= & \left(\frac{m_{\tilde{g}}}{m_b } a_{i}^2b_0-a_i^1b_1\right ) \left(m_b^2 , m_{\tilde{g}}^2 , m_{\tilde{b}_i}^2\right ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath21 , @xmath22 and @xmath23 with @xmath24 and @xmath25 given in the appendix .
@xmath26 are the 2-point feynman integrals given in @xcite , and their functional dependence is indicated in the brackets following them .
the counterterm is universal for each @xmath6 vertex shown in fig .
however , although the irreducible three - point vertex loops have the same topological structure shown in fig .
[ fig2](a ) , the results are different for different @xmath6 vertices in fig .
[ fig1 ] because they depend on the external momenta .
the results are lengthy and are presented in the appendix .
we have checked that all the ultraviolet divergences do cancel as a result of renormalizability of the mssm . note
that in our calculations we adopted the so - called on - mass - shell scheme , in which the renormalized mass @xmath27 ( @xmath28 is the bare mass ) is the physical mass , i.e. , the pole of the @xmath8-quark propagator @xcite . the main difference of this scheme with the @xmath29 scheme is that in the @xmath29 scheme a running b - quark mass is introduced to absorb the leading part of the corrections ( for example , the large logarithms in qcd corrections ) @xcite . in calculating susy - qcd corrections
, there are no such large logarithms and the on - mass - shell scheme is usually adopted ( an extensive discussion about this issue was provided in @xcite ) scheme in calculating susy - qcd corrections to the @xmath6 coupling , i.e. , define a running b - quark mass to absorb some susy - qcd correction effects , we will obtain the approximately same result for the ratio of the cross sections with and without susy - qcd corrections ( because by doing this we merely relocated some correction effects and the total one - loop susy - qcd correction effects are not changed ) . ] . including the one - loop susy - qcd corrections to the bottom quark yukawa coupling
, the renormalized amplitude for @xmath30 can be written as @xmath31 where @xmath32 and @xmath33 represent the tree - level amplitude and one - loop susy - qcd corrections , respectively . the detailed expression for @xmath33
is given in the appendix . in our calculation
we performed monte carlo integration to obtain the hadronic cross section by using the cteq5l parton distribution functions @xcite with @xmath34 and requiring the transverse momentum of the two b - jets to be larger than 15 gev . to exhibit the size of the corrections we define the ratio @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the tree - level cross section .
before performing numerical calculations , we must choose the parameters involved .
for the sm parameters we used @xmath37 gev , @xmath38 gev , @xmath39 gev , @xmath40 gev , @xmath41 , and the two - loop running coupling constant @xmath42 .
for the susy parameters , apart from the charged higgs mass , gluino mass and @xmath0 , the mass parameters of sbottoms are involved . the mass - squared matrix for the sbottoms takes the form @xcite @xmath43 where @xmath44 here @xmath45 and @xmath46 are soft - breaking mass terms for the left - handed squark doublet @xmath47 and the right - handed down squark @xmath48 , respectively .
@xmath49 is the coefficient of the trilinear term @xmath50 in the soft - breaking terms and @xmath51 is the bilinear coupling of the two higgs doublets in the superpotential .
thus , the susy parameters involved in the sbottom mass matrix are @xmath52 , @xmath53 , @xmath49 , @xmath51 and @xmath0 .
the mass - squared matrix is diagonalized by a unitary transformation which relates the weak eigenstates @xmath54 to the mass eigenstates @xmath55 : @xmath56 with the mixing angle and masses determined by @xmath57 , \\
\tan2\theta_b & = & \frac{2m_bx_b}{m_{{\tilde b}_l}^2-m_{{\tilde b}_r}^2 } \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in addition , we consider the following experimental constraints : * @xmath58 and large @xmath0 , in the range @xmath59 , which are favored by the recent muon @xmath60 measurement @xcite . * the lep and cdf lower mass bounds on gluino and sbottom @xcite @xmath61 next , we present numerical results for lhc ( @xmath62 tev ) and tevatron ( @xmath63 tev ) in two representative cases : * _ case a : all susy mass parameters are of the same size and much heavier than the weak scale , but @xmath10
is fixed at weak scale , _
i.e. , @xmath64 + in this case the mixing of sbottoms is maximal , i.e. , @xmath65 .
[ fig3 ] and [ fig4 ] show the dependence on the susy scale @xmath66 for different values of @xmath0 and @xmath10 .
we see that @xmath67 approaches a non - vanishing constant as @xmath66 becomes large .
the effects are enhanced by @xmath0 . for @xmath68
, the residual effects can be as large as @xmath69 .
[ fig4 ] shows that as @xmath10 becomes large the size of residual effects decrease .
* _ case b : all susy mass parameters , including @xmath10 , are much larger than the weak scale , _
i.e. , @xmath70 this case also gives maximal mixing for sbottoms . in fig .
[ fig5 ] we show the dependence on the mssm mass scale @xmath66 .
this figure explicitly exhibits the decoupling behaviour of susy qcd as @xmath66 becomes large .
the underlying reason for the existence of susy residual effects in fermion yukawa couplings when @xmath10 is fixed at the weak scale is that certain couplings are proportional to susy mass parameters @xcite . as pointed out in @xcite , the susy qcd residual effects in the @xmath71 coupling
are proportional to @xmath0 . for @xmath72 coupling , however , the susy qcd residual effects are proportional to @xmath73 . for the process
@xmath74 the calculation of susy qcd corrections is analogous to the @xmath75 case .
however , we found that the susy residual effects in @xmath74 are quite small , reaching only @xmath76 for @xmath77 and being smaller for larger @xmath0 values .
such a small effect is even less than the next - to - leading - order qcd corrections @xcite and is not likely to be observed at the lhc or tevatron .
note that in our calculations , instead of using the effective @xmath71 vertex @xcite , we performed the complete one - loop calculations for @xmath71 yukawa coupling , which , as pointed out in the paragraph following eq.(4 ) , are dependent on the external momenta of @xmath71 vertex .
we found that when susy mass scale is larger than about 1 tev , using the effective @xmath71 vertex @xcite is a good approximation . as we pointed out in the introduction , we only considered the one - loop susy qcd corrections , which are the dominant part of the susy corrections .
of course , the susy electroweak corrections to @xmath71 coupling also have residue effects , which , however , are obviously suppressed by a factor @xmath78 relative to the susy qcd effects .
since much more parameters are involved in the susy electroweak sector , we did not perform a detailed calculation for the susy electroweak corrections here .
we examined the supersymmetric qcd effects in bottom pair production associated with a light higgs boson at the lhc and tevatron .
we found that when the relevant sparticles are heavy , well above the tev scale , they nevertheless contribute sizable virtual effects in this process . for large @xmath0 , these residual effects can alter the production cross section by as much as 40 percent and thus should be measurable in observations of this process at the lhc or tevatron .
if only one light higgs boson , or perhaps several higgs bosons , are discovered at the lhc or tevatron , it could indicate that the susy scale is quite high ; above the tev scale .
of course , the fine - tuning problem then remains and supersymmetry loses one of its merits . but this might possibly happen since supersymmetry does not have to solve the fine - tuning problem , as argued recently by arkani - hamed and dimopoulos @xcite . in that case , a possible way to reveal a hint of supersymmetry is through its residue effects .
higgs production associated with a pair of bottom quarks is then well suited for such a seeking a clue for supersymmetry .
we thank junjie cao for discussions .
this work is supported in part by the chinese natural science foundation and by the us department of energy , division of high energy physics under grant no .
de - fg02 - 91-er4086 .
the coupling at the vertex @xmath79 is needed in our calculations .
it is given by @xmath80 where @xmath81 with @xmath82 here @xmath83 is the mixing angle between the two neutral cp - even higgs bosons .
then one - loop contributions @xmath84 and @xmath85 are given by @xmath86 } \overline{v}(p_1)\gamma^{\mu}u(p_{2})\overline{u}(k_{2 } ) \left [ ( a_i - b_i\gamma^5)(-\not{k_2}c_{11 } -\not{k_3}c_{12 } + m_{\tilde g}c_0 ) \right .
\nonumber\\ & & \left.\times ( a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij } -g\delta{z}\right ] ( \not{k_2}+\not{k_3}+m_b ) \gamma_{\mu}v(k_{1})(-k_2,-k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_i},m_{\tilde{b}_j } ) \ , \\ % % % \delta{m}_{2}^{q\bar{q}}&=&\frac{ig_st_{ij}^{a}t_{kl}^{a}}{\hat{s}[(k_1+k_3)^2-m_b^2 ] } \overline{v}(p_1)\gamma^{\mu}u(p_{2})\overline{u}(k_{2 } ) \gamma_{\mu}(\not{k_1}+\not{k_3}-m_b ) [ ( a_i - b_i\gamma^5)(\not{k_1}c_{11 } \nonumber\\ & & + \not{k_3}c_{12 } + m_{\tilde g}c_0)(a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij } -g\delta{z}]v(k_{1})(k_1,k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_j},m_{\tilde{b}_i } ) \ , \\ % % \delta{m}_{1}^{gg}&=&\frac{-g_st_{ij}^{c}f_{abc } } { \hat{s}[(k_2+k_3)^2-m_b^2]}\overline{u}(k_{2 } ) [ ( a_i - b_i\gamma^5)(-\not{k_2}c_{11 } -\not{k_3}c_{12 } + m_{\tilde g}c_0)(a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij } \nonumber\\ & & -g\delta{z } ] ( \not{k_2}+\not{k_3}+m_b)\gamma^{\lambda}v(k_{1 } ) f_{\lambda\mu\nu}\varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1 ) \varepsilon^{\nu}(p_2)(-k_2,-k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_i},m_{\tilde{b}_j})\ , \\
% % \delta{m}_{2}^{gg}&=&\frac{g_st_{ij}^{c}f_{abc}}{\hat{s}[(k_2+k_3)^2-m_b^2 ] } \overline{u}(k_{2})\gamma^{\lambda}(\not{k_1}+\not{k_3}-m_b ) [ ( a_i - b_i\gamma^5 ) ( \not{k_1}c_{11}+\not{k_2}c_{12}+m_{\tilde g}c_0 ) \nonumber\\ & & \times ( a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij}-g\delta{z}]v(k_{1 } ) f_{\lambda\mu\nu}\varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1 ) \varepsilon^{\nu}(p_2)(k_1,k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_j},m_{\tilde{b}_i } ) \ , \\ % % \delta{m}_{3}^{gg}&=&\frac{ig_st_{ij}^{b}t_{jk}^{a}}{[(k_2+p_2)^2-m_b^2)][(p_1-k_1)-m_b^2 ] } \overline{u}(k_{2})\gamma_{\nu}(\not{k_2}-\not{p_2 } + m_b)[(a_i - b_i\gamma^5)(\not{k_1}c_{11 } \nonumber\\ & & -\not{p_1}c_{11 } + \not{k_3}c_{12}+m_{\tilde g}c_0 ) ( a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij}-g\delta{z}]\nonumber\\ & & \times ( \not{p_1}-\not{k_1}+m_b)\gamma_{\mu}v(k_{1 } ) \varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1)\varepsilon^{\nu}(p_2)(k_1-p_1,k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_j},m_{\tilde{b}_i } ) \ , \\ % % \delta{m}_{4}^{gg}&=&\frac{ig_st_{ij}^{b}t_{jk}^{a}}{[(k_2+k_3)^2-m_b^2)][(p_1-k_1)-m_b^2 ] } \overline{u}(k_{2})[(a_i - b_i\gamma^5 ) ( -\not{k_2}c_{11}-\not{k_3}c_{12 } \nonumber\\ & & + m_{\tilde g}c_0 ) ( a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij}-g\delta{z } ] ( \not{k_2}+\not{k_3}+m_b)\gamma_{\nu } \nonumber\\ & & \times ( \not{p_1}-\not{k_1}+m_b)\gamma_{\mu}v(k_{1 } ) \varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1)\varepsilon^{\nu } ( p_2)(-k_2,-k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_i},m_{\tilde{b}_j } ) \ , \\ % % % \delta{m}_{5}^{gg}&=&\frac{ig_st_{ij}^{a}t_{jk}^{b } } { [ ( k_2+p_1)^2-m_b^2)][(p_2-k_1)-m_b^2]}\overline{u } ( k_{2})\gamma_{\mu}(\not{k_2}-\not{p_1 } + m_b)[(a_i - b_i\gamma^5)(\not{k_1}c_{11 } \nonumber\\ & & -\not{p_2}c_{11 } + \not{k_3}c_{12}+m_{\tilde g}c_0 ) ( a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij } -g\delta{z}](\not{p_2 } -\not{k_1 } \nonumber\\ & & + m_b)\gamma_{\nu}v(k_{1 } ) \varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1)\varepsilon^{\nu}(p_2 ) ( k_1-p_2,k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_j},m_{\tilde{b}_i } ) \ , \\ % % % \delta{m}_{6}^{gg}&=&\frac{ig_st_{ij}^{a}t_{jk}^{b}}{[(k_2+k_3)^2-m_b^2)][(p_2-k_1)-m_b^2 ] } \overline{u}(k_{2})[(a_i - b_i\gamma^5 ) ( -\not{k_2}c_{11}-\not{k_3}c_{12}+m_{\tilde g}c_0 ) \nonumber\\ & & \times ( a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij}-g\delta{z } ] ( \not{k_2}+\not{k_3}+m_b)\gamma_{\mu } ( \not{p_2}-\not{k_1 } \nonumber\\ & & + m_b)\gamma_{\nu}v(k_{1 } ) \varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1)\varepsilon^{\nu}(p_2)(-k_2,-k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_i},m_{\tilde{b}_j } ) \ , \\ % % % \delta{m}_{7}^{gg}&=&\frac{-ig_st_{ij}^{a}t_{jk}^{b}}{[(k_2-p_1)^2-m_b^2)][(k_1+k_3)-m_b^2 ] } \overline{u}(k_{2})\gamma_{\mu}(\not{k_2}-\not{p_1 } + m_b)\gamma_{\nu}(\not{k_1}+\not{k_3 } \nonumber\\ & & -m_b ) [ ( a_i - b_i\gamma^5)(\not{k_1}c_{11}+\not{k_3}c_{12 } + m_{\tilde g}c_0)(a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij } \nonumber\\ & & -g\delta{z}]v(k_{1 } ) \varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1)\varepsilon^{\nu}(p_2)(k_1,k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_j},m_{\tilde{b}_i } ) \ , \\ % % \delta{m}_{8}^{gg}&=&\frac{-ig_st_{ij}^{b}t_{jk}^{a}}{[(k_2-p_2)^2-m_b^2)][(k_1+k_3)-m_b^2 ] } \overline{u}(k_{2})\gamma_{\nu}(\not{k_2}-\not{p_2 } + m_b)\gamma_{\mu}(\not{k_1}+\not{k_3 } \nonumber\\ & & -m_b)[(a_i - b_i\gamma^5)(\not{k_1}c_{11}+\not{k_3}c_{12 } + m_{\tilde g}c_0)(a_j+b_j\gamma^5)q_{ij } \nonumber\\ & & -g\delta{z}]v(k_{1 } ) \varepsilon^{\mu}(p_1)\varepsilon^{\nu}(p_2)(k_1,k_3,m_{\tilde g } , m_{\tilde{b}_j},m_{\tilde{b}_i } ) \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we defined @xmath87 in the above , @xmath88 and @xmath89 are respectively the momenta of the incoming quark and antiquark , @xmath90,@xmath91 and @xmath92 are respectively the outgoing @xmath8 quark , @xmath93 quark , and the higgs boson momenta , @xmath94 is the mandelstam variable defined by @xmath95 , @xmath96 are the @xmath97 color matrices , @xmath98 are anti - symmetric structure constants of @xmath97 color matrices , @xmath99 with @xmath100 , and @xmath101 and @xmath102 are the 3-point feynman integrals @xcite with their functional dependence indicated in the brackets following them .
99 for a review , see , e.g. , h. e. haber , g. l. kane , phys .
rept . * 117 * , 75 ( 1985 ) .
d. dicus , t. stelzer , z. sullivan , s. willenbrock , 59 , 094016 ( 1999 ) .
c. balazs , h .- j .
he , c. p. yuan , 60 , 114001 ( 1999 ) .
j. campbell , r. k. ellis , f. maltoni , s. willenbrock , 67 , 095002 ( 2003 ) .
s. dittmaier , m. kremer , m. spira , 70 , 074010 ( 2004 ) . s. dawson , c. jackson , l. reina , d. wackeroth,69 , 074027 ( 2004 ) . s. dawson , c. b. jackson , l. h. orr , l. reina , d. wackeroth , hep - ph/0311105 .
d. dicus , s. willenbrock , 39 , 751 ( 1989 ) .
n. arkani - hamed and s. dimopoulos , hep - th/0405159 .
l. senatore , hep - ph/0412103 .
h. e. haber , et al .
, 63 , 055004 ( 2001 ) .
a. dabelstein , 456 , 25 ( 1995 ) ; c. s. li , j. m. yang , 315 , 367(1993 ) ; for a review , see , m. carena and h. e. haber , prog.part.nucl.phys . *
50 * 63 ( 2003 ) .
j. cao , g. gao , r. j. oakes , j. m. yang , 68 , 075012 ( 2003 ) .
g. gao , g. lu , z. xiong and j. m. yang , 66 , 015007 ( 2002 ) .
g. passarino and m. veltman , 160 , 151 ( 1979 ) .
see , for example , e. braaten and j. p. leveille , phys . rev .
* d22 * , 715 ( 1980 ) ; m. drees and k. hikasa , phys .
b*240 * , 455 ( 1990 ) .
m. carena , d. garcia , u. nierste and c. e. wagner,577 , 88 ( 2000 ) ; h. eberl , _ et al .
_ , 62 , 055006 ( 2000 )
. h. l. lai , _ et al . _
( cteq collaboration ) , eur .
j. c*12 * , 375 ( 2000 ) .
j. f. gunion and h. e. harber , 272 , 1 ( 1986 ) .
h. n brown , _
_ , mu g-2 collaboration , 86 , 2227 ( 2001 )
. particle physics group .
j. c*15 * , 274 ( 2000 ) .
for some early discussions , see , e.g , x. y. li , e. ma , j. phys .
g * 23 * , 885 ( 1997 ) .
a. dobado , m. j. herrero , d. temes , 65 , 075023 ( 2002 ) . w. beenakker , _
et al . _ , 87 , 201805 ( 2001 ) .
l. reina and s. dawson , 87 , 201804 ( 2001 ) .
w. beenakker , _ et al .
_ , 653 , 151 ( 2003 ) .
l. reina , s. dawson and d. wackeroth , 65 , 053017 ( 2002 ) .
s. dawson , l. h. orr , l. reina and d. wackeroth , 67 , 071503 ( 2003 ) .
s. dawson , c.jackson , l. h. orr , l. reina and d. wackeroth , 68 , 034022 ( 2003 ) . | if all the supersymmetry particles ( sparticles ) except a light higgs boson are too heavy to be directly produced at the large hadron collider ( lhc ) and tevatron , a possible way to reveal evidence for supersymmetry is through their virtual effects in other processes .
we examine such supersymmetric qcd effects in bottom pair production associated with a light higgs boson at the lhc and tevatron .
we find that if the relevant sparticles ( gluinos and squarks ) are well above the tev scale , too heavy to be directly produced , they can still have sizable virtual effects in this process . for large @xmath0 , such residual effects can alter the production rate by as much as 40 percent , which should be observable in future measurements of this process .
= # 1,nucl . phys .
* b#1 * , # 1,phys .
lett .
b * # 1 * , # 1,phys .
rev .
d * # 1 * , # 1,phys .
rev .
lett . *
# 1 * , # 1,z .
phys .
c * # 1 * , # 1#20.5ex |
countries were selected by data availability . for each country we require availability of at least one aggregation level where the average population per territorial unit @xmath0 . this limit for @xmath1
was chosen to include a large number of countries , that have a comparable level of data resolution .
we use data from recent parliamentary elections in austria , canada , czech republic , finland , russia ( 2011 ) , spain and switzerland , the european parliament elections in poland and presidential elections in the france , romania , russia ( 2012 ) and uganda . here
we refer by `` unit '' to any incarnation of an administrative boundary ( such as districts , precincts , wards , municipals , provinces , etc . ) of a country on any aggregation level .
if the voting results are available on different levels of aggregation , we refer to them by roman numbers , i.e. poland - i refers to the finest aggregation level for poland , poland - ii to the second finest , and so on . for each unit on each aggregation level for each country
we have the data of the number of eligible persons to vote , valid votes and votes for the winning party / candidate .
voting results were obtained from official election homepages of the respective countries , for more details see si tab.s1 .
units with an electorate smaller than 100 are excluded from the analysis , to prevent extreme turnout and vote rates as artifacts from very small communities .
we tested robustness of our findings with respect to the choice of a minimal electorate size and found that the results do not significantly change if the minimal size is set to 500 .
the histograms for the 2d - vote - turnout distributions ( vtds ) for the winning parties , also referred to as `` fingerprints '' , are shown in fig.[figure1 ] . of the winning parties as rescaled distributions with zero - mean and unit - variance @xcite .
large deviations from other countries can be seen for uganda and russia with the plain eye . for more detailed results
see tab.s3.,width=328 ] it has been shown that by using an appropriate re - scaling of election data , the distributions of votes and turnouts approximately follow a gaussian @xcite .
let @xmath2 be the number of votes for the winning party and @xmath3 the number of voters in any unit @xmath4 .
a re - scaling function is given by the _ logarithmic vote rate _
, @xmath5 @xcite . in units where @xmath6 ( due to errors in counting or fraud ) or @xmath7 @xmath8 is not defined , and the unit is omitted in our analysis .
this is a conservative definition , since districts with extreme but feasible vote and turnout rates are neglected ( for instance , in russia 2012 there are 324 units with 100% vote and 100% turnout ) . to motivate our parametric model for the vtd , observe that the vtd for russia and uganda in fig.[figure1 ] are clearly bimodal , both in turnout and votes .
one cluster is at intermediate levels of turnout and votes .
note that it is smeared towards the upper right parts of the plot .
the second peak is situated in the vicinity of the 100% turnout , 100% votes point .
this suggests two modes of fraud mechanisms being present , _ incremental _ and _ extreme _ fraud .
incremental fraud means that with a given rate ballots for one party are added to the urn and votes for other parties are taken away .
this occurs within a fraction @xmath9 of units . in the election fingerprints in fig.[figure1 ] these units are those associated with the smearing to the upper right side .
extreme fraud corresponds to reporting a complete turnout and almost all votes for a single party .
this happens in a fraction @xmath10 of units .
these form the second cluster near 100% turnout and votes for the winning party . ) . for switzerland
the fair and fitted model are almost the same .
the results for russia and uganda can be explained by the model assuming a large number of fraudulent units.,width=328 ] for simplicity we assume that within each unit turnout and voter preferences can be represented by a gaussian distribution with the mean and standard deviation taken from the actual sample , see si fig.s1 .
this assumption of normality is not valid in general .
for example the canadian election fingerprint of fig.[figure1 ] is clearly bimodal in vote preferences ( but not in turnout ) . in this case , the deviations from approximate gaussianity are due to a significant heterogeneity within the country . in the particular case of canada
this is known to be due to the mix of the anglo- and francophone population .
normality of the observed vote and turnout distributions is discussed in the si , see tab.s2 .
let @xmath11 be the number of valid votes in unit @xmath4 .
the first step in the model is to compute the empirical turnout distribution , @xmath12 , and the empirical vote distribution , @xmath13 , over all units from the election data . to compute the _ model _ vtd the following protocol
is then applied to each unit @xmath4 . * for each @xmath4 , take the electorate size @xmath3 from the election data .
* model turnout and vote rates for @xmath4 are drawn from normal distributions .
the mean of the model turnout ( vote ) distribution is estimated from the election data as the value that maximizes the empirical turnout ( vote ) distribution .
the model variances are also estimated from the width of the empirical distributions , see si and fig.s1 for details . *
_ incremental fraud_. with probability @xmath9 ballots are taken away from both the non - voters and the opposition and are added to the winning party s ballots .
the fraction of ballots which are shifted to the winning party is again estimated from the actual election data . * _ extreme fraud_. with probability @xmath10 almost all ballots from the non - voters and the opposition are added to the winning party s ballots .
the first step of the above protocol ensures that the actual electorate size numbers is represented in the model .
the second step guarantees that the overall dispersion of vote and turnout preferences of the country s population are correctly represented in the model . given nonzero values for @xmath9 and @xmath10 , incremental and extreme fraud
are then applied in the third and fourth step , respectively . for a complete specification of these fraud mechanisms ,
see the si .
values for @xmath9 and @xmath10 are reverse engineered from the election data in the following way .
first , model vtds are generated according to the above scheme , for each combination of @xmath14 values , where @xmath9 and @xmath15 .
we then compute the point - wise sum of the square difference of model and observed vote distributions for each pair @xmath14 and extract the pair giving the minimal difference .
this procedure is repeated for 100 iterations , leading to 100 pairs of fraud parameters @xmath16 . in the following
we report the average values of these @xmath9 and @xmath10 values , respectively , and their standard deviations . for more details see si .
fig.[figure1 ] shows 2-d histograms ( vtds ) for the number of units for a given fraction of voter turnout ( x - axis ) and for the percentage of votes for the winning party ( y - axis ) .
results are shown for austria , canada , czech republic , finland , france , poland , romania , russia , spain , switzerland and uganda .
for each of these countries the data is shown on the finest aggregation level , where @xmath0 .
these figures can be interpreted as fingerprints of several processes and mechanisms leading to the overall election results . for russia and uganda
the shape of these fingerprints differ strongly from the other countries .
in particular there is a large number of territorial units ( thousands ) with approximately 100% percent turnout and at the same time about 100 % of votes for the winning party . in fig.[sifigurecoll ]
we show the distribution of @xmath8 for each country . roughly , to first order the data from different countries collapse to an approximate gaussian , as previously observed @xcite .
clearly , the data for russia falls out out of line .
skewness and kurtosis for the distributions of @xmath8 are listed for each data - set and aggregation level in tab.s3 .
most strikingly , the kurtosis of the distributions for russia ( 2003 , 2007 , 2011 and 2012 ) exceed the kurtosis of each other country on the coarsest aggregation level by a factor of two to three .
values for the skewness of the logarithmic vote rate distributions for russia are also persistently below the values for each other country .
note that for the vast majority of the countries skewness and kurtosis for the distribution of @xmath8 are in the vicinity of 0 and 3 , respectively ( which are the values one would expect for normal distributions ) . however , the moments of the distributions do depend on the data aggregation level .
fig.[momentaggregate ] shows skewness and kurtosis for the distributions of @xmath8 for each election on each aggregation level . by increasing the data resolution ,
skewness and kurtosis for russia decrease and approach similar values as observed in the rest of the countries , see also si tab.s3 .
these measures depend on the data resolution and thus can not be used as unambiguous signals for statistical anomalies . as will be shown ,
the fraud parameters @xmath9 and @xmath10 do _ not _ significantly depend on the aggregation level or total sample size .
estimation results for @xmath9 and @xmath10 are given in tab.s3 for all countries on each aggregation level .
they are zero ( or almost zero ) in all of the cases except for russia and uganda . in the right column of fig.[figure2 ] we show the model results for russia ( 2011 and 2012 ) , uganda and switzerland for @xmath17 .
the case where both fraud parameters are zero corresponds to the absence of incremental and extreme fraud mechanisms in the model and can be called the fair election case . in the middle column of fig.[figure2 ] we show results for the estimated values of @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
the left column shows the actual vtd of the election .
values of @xmath9 and @xmath10 significantly larger than zero indicate that the observed distributions may be affected by fraudulent actions . to describe the smearing from the main peak to the upper right corner which is observed for russia and uganda , an incremental fraud probability around @xmath18
is needed for _ united russia _ in 2011 and @xmath19 in 2012 .
this means fraud in about 64% of the units in 2011 and 39% in 2012 . in the second peak close to 100% turnout
there are roughly 3,000 units with 100% of votes for united russia in the 2011 data , representing an electorate of more than two million people .
best fits yield @xmath20 for 2011 and @xmath21 for 2012 , i.e. two to three percent of all electoral units experience extreme fraud .
a more detailed comparison of the model performance for the russian parliamentary elections of 2003 , 2007 , 2011 and 2012 is found in fig.s2 .
fraud parameters for the uganda data in fig.[figure2 ] are found to be @xmath22 and @xmath23 .
a best fit for the election data from switzerland gives @xmath17 .
these results are drastically more robust to variations of the aggregation level of the data than the previously discussed distribution moments skewness and kurtosis , fig.[fraudaggregate ] and tab.s3 . even if we aggregate the russian data up to the coarsest level of federal subjects ( approximately 85 units , depending on the election ) , @xmath10 estimates are still at least two standard deviations above zero , @xmath9 estimates more than ten standard deviations .
similar observations hold for uganda . for no other country , on no other aggregation level , such deviations are observed .
the parametric model yields similar results for the same data on different levels of aggregation , as long as the values maximizing the empirical vote ( turnout ) distribution and the distribution width remains invariant .
in other words , as long as units with similar vote ( turnout ) characteristics are aggregated to larger units , the overall shapes of the empirical distribution functions are preserved and the model estimates do not change significantly .
note that more detailed assumptions about possible mechanisms leading to large heterogeneity in the data ( such as the _ qubcois _ in canada or voter mobilization in the helsinki region in finland , see si ) may have an effect on the estimate of @xmath9 .
however , these can under no circumstances explain the mechanism of extreme fraud .
results for elections in sweden , uk and usa , where voting results are only available on a much coarser resolution ( @xmath24 ) , are given in tab.s4 .
another way to visualize the intensity of election irregularities is the cumulative number of votes as a function of the turnout , fig.[figure3 ] . for each turnout level
the total number of votes from units with this or lower levels are shown .
each curve corresponds to the respective election winner in a different country , with average electorate per unit of comparable order of magnitude .
usually these cdfs level off and form a plateau from the party s maximal vote count on . again
this is not the case for russia and uganda .
both show a boost phase of increased extreme fraud toward the right end of the distribution ( red circles ) .
russia never even shows a tendency to form a plateau .
as long as the empirical vote distribution functions remain invariant under data aggregation as discussed above , the shape of these cdfs will be preserved too .
note that fig.[figure3 ] .
demonstrates that these effects are decisive for winning the 50% majority in russia 2011 .
we demonstrate that it is not sufficient to discuss the approximate normality of turnout , vote or logarithmic vote rate distributions , to decide if election results may be corrupted or not .
we show that these methods can lead to ambiguous signals , since results depend strongly on the aggregation level of the election data .
we developed a model to estimate parameters quantifying to which extent the observed election results can be explained by ballot stuffing .
the resulting parameter values are shown to be insensitive to the choice of the aggregation level .
note that the error margins for @xmath10 values start to increase by decreasing @xmath25 below 100 , see fig.[fraudaggregate]d , whereas @xmath9 estimates stay robust even for very small @xmath25 .
it is imperative to emphasize that the shape of the fingerprints in fig.[figure1 ] will deviate from pure 2-d gaussian distributions also as a result of non - fraudulent mechanisms , but due to heterogeneity in the population .
the purpose of the parametric model is to quantify to which extent ballot stuffing and the mechanism of extreme fraud may have contributed to these deviations , or if their influence can be ruled out on the basis of the data . for the elections in russia and uganda
they can not be ruled out . as shown in fig.s2 , assumptions of their wide - spread occurrences
even allow to reproduce the observed vote distributions to a good degree . in conclusion
it can be said with almost certainty that an election does not represent the will of the people , if a substantial fraction ( @xmath10 ) of units reports a 100% turnout with almost all votes for a single party , and/or if any significant deviations from the sigmoid form in the cumulative distribution of votes versus turnout are observed .
another indicator of systematic fraudulent or irregular voting behavior is an incremental fraud parameter @xmath9 which is significantly greater than zero on each aggregation level .
should such signals be detected it is tempting to invoke g.b .
shaw who held that `` [ d]emocracy is a form of government that substitutes election by the incompetent many for appointment by the corrupt few . ''
we acknowledge helpful discussions and remarks by erich neuwirth and vadim nikulin .
we thank christian borghesi for providing access to his election datasets and the anonymous referees for extremely valuable suggestions .
diamond , m.f .
plattner ( 2006 ) .
electoral systems and democracy p.168 .
johns hopkins university press , 2006 .
f. lehoucq ( 2003 ) , electoral fraud : causes , types and consequences .
_ annual review of political science _ * 6 * , p. 233
alvarez , t.e . hall , s.d .
hyde ( 2008 ) .
election fraud : detecting and deterring electoral manipulations .
brookings institution press , washington d.c . ,
f. benford ( 1938 ) , the law of anomalous numbers . _
proceedings of the american philosophical society _ * 78 * ( 4 ) , p. 551
mebane ( 2006 ) , election forensics : vote counts and benford s law . summer meeting of the political methodology society , uc - davis .
mebane , k. kalinin ( 2009 ) , comparative election fraud detection , apsa 2009 toronto meeting . c. breunig , a. goerres ( 2011 ) , searching for electoral irregularities in an established democracy : applying benford s law tests to bundestag elections in unified germany , _ electoral studies _ * 30 * ( 3 ) , p. 534 - 45 .
f. cantu , s.m . saiegh ( 2011 ) , fraudulent democracy ?
an analysis of argentina s infamous decade using supervised machine learning , _ polit .
_ * 19 * ( 4 ) p. 409 - 33 .
b. beber , a. scacco ( 2012 ) , what the numbers say : a digit - based test for election fraud , _ polit .
* 20 * ( 2 ) p. 211 - 34 .
deckert , m. myagkov , p.c .
ordeshook ( 2011 ) , benford s law and the detection of election fraud , _ polit .
_ * 19 * ( 3 ) p. 245
mebane ( 2011 ) comment on `` benford s law and the detection of election fraud '' , _ polit .
* 19 * ( 3 ) p. 269 - 72 .
mebane , j.s .
sekhon ( 2004 ) , robust estimation and outlier detection for overdispersed multinomial models of count data , _ ajps _ , * 48 * ( 2 ) , p. 392
sukhovolsky , a.a .
sobyanin ( 1994 ) , vybory
i referendom 12 dekabrya 1993 g. v. rossii : politicheskie itogi , perskeptivy , dostovemost rezultatov , moksva - arkhangelskoe .
m. myagkov , p.c .
ordeshook ( 2008 ) , russian election : an oxymoron of democracy .
caltech / mit voting technology project , wp63 .
m. myagkov , p.c .
ordershook , d. shakin ( 2009 ) .
the forensics of election fraud : russia and ukraine .
cambridge university press ; ( 2005 ) fraud or fairytales : russia and ukraine s electoral experience , _ post soviet affairs _ * 21 * ( 2 ) , 91 - 131 .
s. shpilkin ( 2009 ) , statistical investigation of the results of russian elections in 2007 - 2009 , _ troitskij variant . science _
* 21 * ( 40 ) , 1 .
s. shpilkin ( 2011 ) , mathematics of elections , _ troitskij variant . science _ * 25 * ( 94 ) , 2 . d. kobak , s. shpilkin , m. s. pshenichnikov ( 2012 ) , statistical anomalies in 2011 - 2012 russian elections revealed by 2d correlation analysis , _ arxiv preprint _ arxiv : 1205.0741 . c. castellano , s. fortunato , v. loreto ( 2009 ) , statistical physics of social dynamics , _ rev .
phys . _ * 81 * , p. 591 - 646 .
costa filho , m.p .
almeida , j.e .
moreira , j.s .
andrade jr ( 2003 ) , brazilian elections : voting for a scaling democracy , _ physica a _ * 322 * 1 - 4 , p. 698 - 700 .
lyra , u.m.s .
costa , r.n .
costa filho , j.s .
andrade jr ( 2003 ) , generalized zipf s law in proportional voting processes , _ europhys .
lett . _ * 62 * , 131 .
mantovani , h.v .
ribeiro , m.v .
moro , s. picoli jr .
mendes ( 2011 ) , scaling laws and universality in the choice of election candidates , _ europhys . lett . _
* 96 * , 48001 .
s. fortunato , c. castellano ( 2007 ) , scaling and universality in proportional elections , _ phys .
lett . _ * 99 * , 138701 . c. borghesi , j.p .
bouchaud ( 2010 ) , spatial correlations in vote statistics : a diffusive field model for decision - making , _ eur .
j. b _ * 75 * , 395 - 404 . j. agnew ( 1996 ) , mapping politics : how context counts in electoral geography , _ political geography _ * 15 * ( 2 ) , 129 - 46 .
descriptive statistics and official sources of the election results are shown in tab.s1 .
the raw data will be made available for download at http://www.complex - systems.meduniwien.ac.at/. they report election results of parliamentary ( austria , canada , czech republic , finland , russia , spain and switzerland ) , european ( poland ) or presidential ( france , romania , russia , uganda ) elections on at least one aggregation level . in the rare circumstances where electoral districts report more valid ballots than registered voters , we work with a turnout of 100% .
territorial units with an electorate less than hundred are omitted at each point of the analysis , to avoid extreme vote and turnout rates as spurious results due to small communities .
the countries to include in this work have been chosen on the basis of data availability .
a country is included , if the voting results are available in electronic form on an aggregation level where a number of @xmath0 vote eligible persons comprises one territorial unit .
required data is the number of vote eligible persons @xmath3 , the number of valid votes @xmath11 and the number of votes for the winning party / candidate @xmath2 for each unit .
a country is separated into @xmath25 electoral units @xmath4 , each having an electorate of @xmath3 people and in total @xmath11 valid votes .
the fraction of valid votes for the winning party in unit @xmath4 is denoted @xmath26 .
the average turnout over all units , @xmath27 , is given by @xmath28 with standard deviation @xmath29 , the mean fraction of votes @xmath30 for the winning party is @xmath31 with standard deviation @xmath32 .
the mean values @xmath27 and @xmath30 are typically close to but not identical to the values which maximize the empirical distribution function of turnout and votes over all units .
let @xmath33 be the number of votes where the empirical distribution function assumes its ( first local ) maximum ( rounded to entire percents ) , see fig .
s[sifiguremeth ] .
similarly @xmath34 is the turnout where the empirical distribution function of turnouts @xmath35 takes its ( first local ) maximum .
the distributions for turnout and votes are extremely skewed to the right for uganda and russia which also inflates the standard deviations in these countries , see tab .
s2 . to account for this a left - sided ( right - sided ) mean
deviation @xmath36 ( @xmath37 ) from @xmath33 is introduced .
@xmath37 can be regarded as the _ incremental fraud width _ , a measurable parameter quantifying how intense the vote stuffing is .
this contributes to the smearing out of the main peaks in the election fingerprints , see fig.1 in the main text .
the larger @xmath37 , the more inflated the vote results due to urn stuffing , in contrast to @xmath36 which quantifies the scatter of the voters actual preferences .
they can be estimated from the data by @xmath38 similarly the _
extreme fraud width _
@xmath39 can be estimated , i.e. the width of the peak around 100% votes .
we found that @xmath40 describes all encountered vote distributions reasonably well .
for a visualization of @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath39 see fig .
s[sifiguremeth ] .
while @xmath9 and @xmath10 measure in how many units incremental and extreme fraud occur , @xmath37 and @xmath39 quantify how intense these activities are , if they occur . to get an estimate for the width of the distribution of turnouts over territorial unit which is free of possible fraudulent influences , the _ turnout distribution width _
@xmath41 is calculated from electoral districts @xmath4 which have both @xmath42 and @xmath43 , that is @xmath44 .
incremental fraud is a combination of two processes : stuffing ballots for one party into the urn and re - casting or deliberately wrong - counting ballots from other parties ( e.g. erasing the cross ) .
which one of these two processes dominates is quantified by the _ deliberate wrong counting parameter _
for @xmath46 the wrong - counting process dominates , for @xmath47 the urn stuffing mechanism is prevalent . in the following @xmath48
denotes a normal distributed random variable with mean @xmath49 and standard deviation @xmath50 .
the model is specified by the following protocol , which is applied to each district . *
pick a unit @xmath4 with electorate @xmath3 taken from the data . *
the model turnout of unit @xmath4 , @xmath51 , is @xmath52 . * a fraction of @xmath53 people vote for the winning party . * with probability @xmath9
incremental fraud takes place . in this case
the unit is assigned a fraud intensity @xmath54 .
values for @xmath55 are only accepted if they lie in the range @xmath56 .
this is the fraction of votes not cast , @xmath57 , which are added to the winning party .
votes for the opposition are wrong counted for the winning party with a rate @xmath58 ( where @xmath59 is an exponent ) . to summarize , if incremental fraud takes place the winning party receives @xmath60 votes .
* with probability @xmath10 extreme fraud takes place . in this case opposition votes
are canceled and added to the winning party with probability @xmath61 ( i.e. the above with @xmath62 replacing @xmath55 ) .
acceptable values for @xmath62 are again from the range @xmath63 . , @xmath36 , @xmath37 and @xmath39 are estimated from the election results .
@xmath33 is the maximum of the distribution function .
@xmath36 measures the distribution width of values to the left of @xmath33 , i.e. smaller than @xmath33 . the incremental fraud with @xmath37 measures the distribution width of values to the right of @xmath33 , i.e. larger than @xmath33 .
the extreme fraud width @xmath39 is the width of the peak at 100% votes.,width=328 ] the parameters for incremental and extreme fraud , @xmath9 and @xmath10 , as well as the deliberate wrong counting parameter @xmath59 , are estimated by a goodness - of - fit test .
let @xmath64 be the empirical distribution function of votes for the winning party ( the data is binned with one bin corresponding to one percent ) over all territorial units .
the distribution function for the model units @xmath65 is calculated for each set of @xmath66 values where @xmath67 .
we report values for the fraud parameters where the statistic @xmath68 assumes its minimum , averaged over 100 realizations over the parameter space , see tab.s3 for @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
the extreme fraud parameter @xmath10 is zero ( within one standard deviation ) for almost all elections except russia ( 2003 , 2007 , 2011 and 2012 ) and uganda .
for very small @xmath25 ( @xmath69 ) estimates for @xmath10 become less robust .
these are also the only elections where the incremental fraud parameter @xmath9 is not close to zero .
values for @xmath59 for the russian elections are @xmath70 ( 2003 ) , @xmath71 ( 2007 ) , @xmath72 ( 2011 ) , @xmath73 ( 2012 ) , and @xmath74 for uganda .
results for @xmath59 from countries where @xmath9 is close to zero can not be detected in a robust way and are superfluous , since there are ( almost ) no deviations from the fair election case .
special care is needed in the interpretation of @xmath9 and @xmath10 values in countries where election units contain several polling stations .
it may be the case that extreme fraud takes only in a subset of the polling stations within a unit place . in that case
extreme fraud would be indistinguishable from the incremental fraud mechanism .
it is hard to construct other plausible mechanisms leading to a large number of territorial units having 100% turnout and votes for a single party than urn stuffing .
the case is not so clear for the smeared out main cluster . in some cases , namely canada and finland
, this cluster also takes on a slightly different form .
this effect clearly does not inflate the turnout as much as it is the case in russia and uganda , but it is nevertheless present . in canada the distribution of vote preferences
is bimodal , with one peak around 50% and one around 10% ( of the vote eligible population ) , but with similar turnout levels .
this is a result of a large - scale heterogeneity in the data : english and french canada .
votes are shown for the winning conservatives .
looking at their results by province , they tallied 16.5% votes cast in quebec , but more than 40% in eight of the remaining twelve other provinces .
as a consequence the logarithmic vote rate kurtosis becomes inflated .
however , these statistical deviations are perfectly distinguishable from the traces of ballot stuffing , resulting in vanishing fraud parameters on all aggregation levels .
another possible mechanism leading to irregularities in the voting results is successful voter mobilization .
this may lead to a correlation between turnout and a party s votes .
the finland elections , for example , where marked by radical campaigns by the true finns .
they managed to mobilize evenly spread out across the country , with the exception of the helsinki region , where the winning national coalition party performed significantly better than in the rest of the country . | democratic societies are built around the principle of free and fair elections , that each citizen s vote should count equal .
national elections can be regarded as large - scale social experiments , where people are grouped into usually large numbers of electoral districts and vote according to their preferences .
the large number of samples implies certain statistical consequences for the polling results which can be used to identify election irregularities . using a suitable data collapse
, we find that vote distributions of elections with alleged fraud show a kurtosis of hundred times more than normal elections on certain levels of data aggregation . as an example
we show that reported irregularities in recent russian elections are indeed well explained by systematic ballot stuffing and develop a parametric model quantifying to which extent fraudulent mechanisms are present .
we show that if specific statistical properties are present in an election , the results do not represent the will of the people .
we formulate a parametric test detecting these statistical properties in election results .
remarkably , this technique produces similar outcomes irrespective of the data resolution and thus allows for cross - country comparisons .
free and fair elections are the cornerstone of every democratic society @xcite .
a central characteristic of elections being free and fair is that each citizen s vote counts equal .
however , already joseph stalin believed that `` it s not the people who vote that count ; it s the people who count the votes . ''
how can it be distinguished whether an election outcome represents the will of the people or the will of the counters ?
elections can be seen as large - scale social experiments .
a country is segmented into a usually large number of electoral units .
each unit represents a standardized experiment where each citizen articulates his / her political preference via a ballot .
although elections are one of the central pillars of a fully functioning democratic process , relatively little is known about how election fraud impacts and corrupts the results of these standardized experiments @xcite .
there is a plethora of ways of tampering with election outcomes , for instance the redrawing of district boundaries known as gerrymandering , or the barring of certain demographics from their right to vote .
some practices of manipulating voting results leave traces which may be detected by statistical methods . recently
, benford s law @xcite experienced a renaissance as a potential election fraud detection tool @xcite . in its original and naive formulation
, benford s `` law '' is the observation that for many real world processes the logarithm of the first significant digit is uniformly distributed .
deviations from this law may indicate that other , possibly fraudulent mechanisms are at work .
for instance , suppose a significant number of reported vote counts in districts is completely made up and invented by someone preferring to pick numbers which are multiples of ten .
the digit `` 0 '' would then occur much more often as the last digit in the vote counts when compared to uncorrupted numbers .
voting results from russia @xcite , germany @xcite , argentina @xcite and nigeria @xcite have been tested for the presence of election fraud using variations of this idea of digit - based analysis .
however , the validity of benford s law as a fraud detection method is subject to controversy @xcite .
the problem is that one needs to firmly establish a baseline of what the _ expected _ distribution of digit occurrences for fair elections should be .
only then it can be asserted if _ actual _
numbers are over- or underrepresented and thus suspicious .
what is missing in this context is a theory that links specific fraud mechanisms to statistical anomalies @xcite .
a different strategy for detecting signals of election fraud is to look at the distribution of vote and turnout numbers as in @xcite .
this has been extensively done for the russian presidential and duma elections over the last 20 years @xcite .
these works focus on the task of detecting two mechanisms , the stuffing of ballot boxes and the reporting of contrived numbers .
it has been noted that these mechanisms are able to produce different features of vote and turnout distributions than those observed in fair elections . while for russian elections between 1996 and 2003 these features
were `` only '' observed in a relatively small number of electoral units , they eventually spread and percolated through the entire russian federation from 2003 onwards . according to myagkov and ordeshook @xcite `` [ o]nly kremlin apologists and putin sycophants argue that russian elections meet the standards of good democratic practice '' .
this point was further substantiated with election results from the 2011 duma and 2012 presidential elections @xcite .
here it was also observed that ballot stuffing not only changes the shape of vote and turnout distributions , but also induces a high correlation between them .
unusually high vote counts tend to _ co - occur _ with unusually high turnout numbers .
several recent advances in the understanding of statistical regularities of voting results are due to the application of statistical physics concepts to quantitative social dynamics @xcite . in particular several approximate statistical laws of how vote and turnout are distributed have been identified @xcite , some of them are shown to be valid across several countries @xcite .
it is tempting to think of deviations from these approximate statistical laws as potential indicators for election irregularities which are valid cross - nationally .
however , the magnitude of these deviations may vary from country to country due to different numbers and sizes of electoral districts .
any statistical technique quantifying election anomalies across countries should not depend on the size of the underlying sample nor its aggregation level , i.e. the size of the electoral units . as a consequence , a conclusive and robust signal for a fraudulent mechanism , e.g. ballot stuffing ,
must not disappear if the same dataset is studied on different aggregation levels . in this work
we expand earlier work on statistical detection of election anomalies in two directions .
first , we test for reported statistical features of voting results ( and deviations thereof ) in a cross - national setting , and discuss their dependence on the level of data aggregation . as the central point of this work
we propose a parametric model to statistically quantify to which extent fraudulent processes , such as ballot stuffing , may have influenced the observed election results .
remarkably , under the assumption of coherent geographic voting patterns @xcite , the parametric model results do not depend significantly on the aggregation level of the election data or the size of the data sample . |
the microscopic study of nuclear many - body problem and the understanding of the nuclear interactions that reproduce the observed structure and reaction properties are the underlying challenges of low energy nuclear physics . in this context ,
detailed investigations of the fusion process will lead to a better understanding of the interplay among the strong , coulomb , and weak interactions as well as the enhanced correlations present in these many - body systems .
recently , particular experimental attention has been given to fusion reactions involving ca isotopes @xcite .
these new experiments supplemented the older fusion data @xcite and extended it to lower sub - barrier energies .
comparison of the sub - barrier cross - sections with those calculated using standard coupled - channel calculations suggested a hindrance of the fusion cross - sections at deep sub - barrier energies @xcite .
one of the underlying reasons for the failure of standard coupled - channel approach is the use of frozen densities in the calculation of double - folding potentials , resulting in potentials that behave in a completely unphysical manner for deep sub - barrier energies .
while the outer part of the barrier is largely determined by the early entrance channel properties of the collision , the inner part of the potential barrier is strongly sensitive to dynamical effects such as particle transfer and neck formation .
this has been remedied in part by extensions of the coupled - channel approach to include a repulsive core @xcite or the incorporation of neck degrees of freedom @xcite .
more recent calculations @xcite using the coupled - channel approach with a repulsive core have provided much improved fits to the data . a detailed microscopic study of the fusion process for ca based reactions @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 could provide further insight into the reaction dynamics as well as a good testing ground for the theory since these isotopes are commonly used in fitting the parameters of the effective nuclear interactions , such as the skyrme force .
during the past several years , we have developed a microscopic approach for calculating heavy - ion interaction potentials that incorporates all of the dynamical entrance channel effects included in the time - dependent hartree - fock ( tdhf ) description of the collision process @xcite .
the method is based on the tdhf evolution of the nuclear system coupled with density - constrained hartree - fock calculations ( dc - tdhf ) to obtain the ion - ion interaction potential .
the formalism was applied to study fusion cross - sections for the systems @xmath4sn+@xmath5ni @xcite , @xmath5ni+@xmath5ni @xcite , @xmath6o+@xmath7pb @xcite , @xmath8sn+@xmath9zr @xcite , as well as to the study of the entrance channel dynamics of hot and cold fusion reactions leading to superheavy element @xmath10 @xcite , and dynamical excitation energies @xcite . in all cases
, we have found good agreement between the measured fusion cross sections and the dc - tdhf results .
this is rather remarkable given the fact that the only input in dc - tdhf is the skyrme effective n - n interaction , and there are no adjustable parameters .
in section [ sec : formalism ] we outline the main features of our microscopic approach , the dc - tdhf method . in section [ sec : formalism ] we also discuss the calculation of ion - ion separation distance , coordinate - dependent mass , calculation of fusion cross - sections , and giant dipole resonance ( gdr ) formalism . in sec . [
sec : results ] we present interesting aspects of the reaction dynamics and compare our results with experiment and other calculations . in sec .
[ sec : summary ] we summarize our conclusions .
in the dc - tdhf approach @xcite the tdhf time - evolution takes place with no restrictions . at certain times during the evolution the instantaneous density is used to perform a static hartree - fock minimization while holding the neutron and proton densities constrained to be the corresponding instantaneous tdhf densities @xcite .
in essence , this provides us with the tdhf dynamical path in relation to the multi - dimensional static energy surface of the combined nuclear system . the advantages of this method in comparison to other mean - field based microscopic methods such as the constrained hartree - fock ( chf ) method are obvious .
first , there is no need to introduce artificial constraining operators which assume that the collective motion is confined to the constrained phase space : second , the static adiabatic approximation is replaced by the dynamical analogue where the most energetically favorable state is obtained by including sudden rearrangements and the dynamical system does not have to move along the valley of the potential energy surface . in short
we have a self - organizing system which selects its evolutionary path by itself following the microscopic dynamics .
all of the dynamical features included in tdhf are naturally included in the dc - tdhf calculations .
these effects include neck formation , mass exchange , internal excitations , deformation effects to all order , as well as the effect of nuclear alignment for deformed systems . in the dc - tdhf method the ion - ion interaction potential
is given by @xmath11 where @xmath12 is the density - constrained energy at the instantaneous separation @xmath13 , while @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the binding energies of the two nuclei obtained with the same effective interaction .
in writing eq .
( [ eq : vr ] ) we have introduced the concept of an adiabatic reference state for a given tdhf state . the difference between these two energies represents the internal energy .
the adiabatic reference state is the one obtained via the density constraint calculation , which is the slater determinant with lowest energy for the given density with vanishing current and approximates the collective potential energy @xcite .
we would like to emphasize again that this procedure does not affect the tdhf time - evolution and contains no free parameters or normalization .
in addition to the ion - ion potential it is also possible to obtain coordinate dependent mass parameters .
one can compute the `` effective mass '' @xmath16 using the conservation of energy @xmath17}{\dot{r}^{2}}\ ; , \label{eq : mr}\ ] ] where the collective velocity @xmath18 is directly obtained from the tdhf evolution and the potential @xmath19 from the density constraint calculations . in calculating fusion cross - sections this coordinate - dependent mass
is used to obtain a transformed ion - ion potential as described below .
the calculation of the excitation energy is achieved by dividing the tdhf motion into a collective and intrinsic part .
the major assumption in achieving this goal is to assume that the collective part is primarily determined by the density @xmath20 and the current @xmath21 .
consequently , the excitation energy can be formally written as @xcite @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the total energy of the dynamical system , which is a conserved quantity , and @xmath24 represents the collective energy of the system . in the next step
we break up the collective energy into two parts @xmath25 where @xmath26 represents the kinetic part and is given by @xmath27 which is asymptotically equivalent to the kinetic energy of the relative motion , @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is the reduced mass and @xmath13 is the ion - ion separation distance .
the dynamics of the ion - ion separation @xmath13 is provided by an unrestricted tdhf run thus allowing us to deduce the excitation energy as a function of the distance parameter , @xmath30 . in practice
, tdhf runs are initialized with energies above the coulomb barrier at some large but finite separation .
the two ions are boosted with velocities obtained by assuming that the two nuclei arrive at this initial separation on a coulomb trajectory .
initially the nuclei are placed such that the point @xmath32 in the @xmath33 plane is the center of mass . during the tdhf dynamics the ion - ion separation distance is obtained by constructing a dividing plane between the two centers and calculating the center of the densities on the left and right halves of this dividing plane .
the coordinate @xmath31 is the difference between the two centers . the dividing plane is determined by finding the point at which the tails of the two densities intersect each other along the @xmath34-axis . since the actual mesh used in the tdhf calculations is relatively coarse we use a cubic - spline interpolation to interpolate the profile in the x - direction and search for a more precise intersection value . this procedure has been recently described in ref .
@xcite in great detail .
the standard procedure for calculating @xmath31 as described above starts to fail after a substantial overlap is reached ( for @xmath31 values smaller than the ones studied in this manuscript ) .
we have observed that if one defines the ion - ion separation as @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the mass quadrupole moment for the entire system , calculated by using the collision axis as the symmetry axis , and @xmath37 is a scale factor determined to give the correct initial separation distance at the start of the calculations . calculating @xmath31 this way yields almost identical results to the previous procedure until that procedure begins to fail and continues smoothly after that point .
of course the minimum value of @xmath31 calculated this way is never zero but is determined by the quadrupole moment of the composite system .
we now outline the calculation of the total fusion cross section using an arbitrary coordinate - dependent mass @xmath16 . starting from the classical lagrange function @xmath38
we obtain the corresponding hamilton function @xmath39 where the canonical momentum is given by @xmath40 . following the standard quantization procedure for the kinetic energy in curvilinear
coordinates @xcite @xmath41 \ ; , \label{eq : tgen}\ ] ] where @xmath42 denotes the metric tensor and @xmath43 the reciprocal tensor , one obtains the quantized hamiltonian @xmath44 + v(r ) \;. \label{eq : ham2}\ ] ] with the momentum operator @xmath45 .
the total fusion cross cross - section @xmath46 can be obtained by calculating the potential barrier penetrabilities @xmath47 from the schrdinger equation for the relative motion coordinate @xmath31 using the hamiltonian ( [ eq : ham2 ] ) with an additional centrifugal potential @xmath48 \psi_l(r ) = 0 \;. \label{eq : schroed1}\ ] ] alternatively , instead of solving the schrdinger equation with coordinate dependent mass parameter @xmath16 for the heavy - ion potential @xmath19 , we can instead use the constant reduced mass @xmath29 and transfer the coordinate - dependence of the mass to a scaled potential @xmath49 using the well known coordinate scale transformation @xcite @xmath50 integration of eq .
( [ eq : mrbar ] ) yields @xmath51 as a result of this point transformation , both the classical hamilton function , eq .
( [ eq : ham1 ] ) , and the corresponding quantum mechanical hamiltonian , eq .
( [ eq : ham2 ] ) , now assume the form @xmath52 and the scaled heavy - ion potential is given by the expression @xmath53 the fusion barrier penetrabilities @xmath54 are obtained by numerical integration of the two - body schrdinger equation @xmath55\psi=0\ ; , \label{eq : xfus}\ ] ] using the _ incoming wave boundary condition _
( iwbc ) method @xcite .
iwbc assumes that once the minimum of the potential is reached fusion will occur . in practice ,
the schrdinger equation is integrated from the potential minimum , @xmath56 , where only an incoming wave is assumed , to a large asymptotic distance , where it is matched to incoming and outgoing coulomb wavefunctions .
the barrier penetration factor , @xmath54 is the ratio of the incoming flux at @xmath56 to the incoming coulomb flux at large distance . here
, we implement the iwbc method exactly as it is formulated for the coupled - channel code ccfull described in ref .
this gives us a consistent way for calculating cross - sections at above and below the barrier energies .
let us now consider a central collision in @xmath34-direction and introduce the quantity @xmath57\ ] ] which represents the expectation value of the @xmath34-component of the dipole operator @xmath58 taken with the time - dependent tdhf slater determinant @xmath59 .
following the bremsstrahlung approach developed by baran et al .
@xcite we define the dipole acceleration @xmath60 and introduce its fourier transform @xmath61 alternatively , for nearly harmonic vibrations one can use the expression @xmath62 , with @xmath63 the time filtering @xmath64 is used to smooth out peaks coming from finite integration time .
the `` power spectrum '' of the electric dipole radiation is given by @xcite @xmath65 where @xmath66 denotes the fine structure constant .
recently , pre - equilibrium gdr excitation has also been studied in the context of tdhf @xcite .
calculations were done in 3-d geometry and using the full skyrme interaction including all of the time - odd terms in the mean - field hamiltonian @xcite .
the primary skyrme parametrization used was sly4 @xcite but we have also tested the new unedf0 @xcite and unedf1 @xcite parametrizations . for the reactions studied here , the lattice spans @xmath67 fm along the collision axis and @xmath68 fm in the other two directions .
derivative operators on the lattice are represented by the basis - spline collocation method .
one of the major advantages of this method is that we may use a relatively large grid spacing of @xmath69 fm and nevertheless achieve high numerical accuracy .
the initial separation of the two nuclei is @xmath70 fm for central collisions .
the time - propagation is carried out using a taylor series expansion ( up to orders @xmath71 ) of the unitary mean - field propagator , with a time - step @xmath72 fm / c .
we have performed density constraint calculations every @xmath73 time steps .
the accuracy of the density constraint calculations is commensurate with the accuracy of the static calculations . in this subsection
we will present our results for the @xmath74ca+@xmath74ca system .
most of our general discussions will be provided here as they would be the same for other systems .
specific points about individual systems and comparison of results for the three systems will be taken up in the subsequent sections .
( color online ) potential barriers , @xmath19 , for the @xmath74ca+@xmath74ca system obtained from density constrained tdhf calculations using eq .
( [ eq : vr ] ) at three different energies , @xmath75 mev ( black solid curve ) , @xmath76 mev ( red solid curve ) , and @xmath77 mev ( blue solid curve ) .
the three dashed curves correspond to the transformed potential in eq .
( [ eq : urbar ] ) using the coordinate dependent masses . also shown is the point coulomb potential.,width=325 ] in fig . [
fig : fig1 ] we show the microscopic ion - ion potential barriers obtained using eq .
( [ eq : vr ] ) calculated at three different collision energies , @xmath75 mev ( black solid curve ) , @xmath76 mev ( red solid curve ) , and @xmath77 mev ( blue solid curve ) .
we observe a relatively small dependence on the collision energy . at lower energies
the system has more time available for rearrangements to take place through the formation of a neck , whereas this is less and less the case at higher energies and the potential barrier approaches the frozen - density limit @xcite .
this produces the observed trend in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] , where the lowest barrier peak corresponds to the lowest energy and the barrier height increases with increasing collision energy . the barrier heights are @xmath78 , @xmath79 , and @xmath80 mev , respectively .
similar energy dependence was also observed in the dd - tdhf calculations of ref .
@xcite and becomes more prevalent for heavier systems .
similarly , the position of the barrier peak moves toward smaller @xmath31 values , albeit very slowly in this case , with increasing energy .
corresponding @xmath31 values for the barrier maximum are @xmath81 , @xmath82 , and @xmath83 fm .
what is also shown on fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] is the coulomb potential assuming the two nuclei to be point particles with @xmath84 . during the approach phase
the microscopically calculated dc - tdhf potential traces the point coulomb potential , differing by less than @xmath85 kev , which provides a test for the numerical accuracy .
( color online ) coordinate dependent mass @xmath16 scaled by the constant reduced mass @xmath29 , obtained from eq .
( [ eq : mr ] ) , at three different tdhf energies.,width=325 ] the energy dependence of potential barriers can also be understood if we examine the coordinate dependent mass of eq .
( [ eq : mr ] ) shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2 ] for three different energies , @xmath75 mev ( black solid curve ) , @xmath76 mev ( red solid curve ) , and @xmath77 mev ( blue solid curve ) .
the @xmath31-dependence of this mass at lower energies is very similar to the one found in chf calculations @xcite . on the other hand , at higher energies the coordinate dependent
mass essentially becomes flat , which is again a sign that most dynamical effects are contained at lower energies .
the peak at small @xmath31 values is due to the fact that the center - of - mass energy is above the barrier and the denominator of eq .
( [ eq : mr ] ) becomes small due to the slowdown of the ions .
we have used the coordinate dependent masses shown in fig .
[ fig : fig2 ] to obtain the scaled potentials @xmath49 of eq .
( [ eq : urbar ] ) .
these potentials are shown as the dashed curves in fig .
[ fig : fig1 ] . as we see
the coordinate dependent mass only changes the inner parts of the barriers for all energies .
furthermore , the effect is largest for the lowest energy collision and diminishes as we increase the collision energy .
( color online ) total fusion cross section as a function of @xmath86 .
three separate theoretical cross section calculations are shown , based on the energy - dependent dc - tdhf heavy - ion potentials @xmath19 at energies @xmath87 , @xmath88 , @xmath89 mev .
the experimental data ( filled circles ) are taken from ref .
@xcite.,width=325 ] we have obtained the fusion cross sections by numerical integration of eq .
( [ eq : xfus ] ) .
the resulting cross - sections are shown in fig .
[ fig : fig3 ] .
we observe that all of the scaled barriers give a very good description of the experimental fusion cross - sections .
the high energy part of the fusion cross - sections are primarily determined by the barrier properties in the vicinity of the barrier peak .
on the other hand sub - barrier cross - sections are influenced by what happens in the inner part of the barrier and here the dynamics and consequently the coordinate dependent mass becomes very important . as we observe in fig .
[ fig : fig3 ] we get a very good agreement with experiment for the barriers obtained at the lowest two collision energies , whereas the @xmath90 mev curve slightly underestimates the cross - section at lower energies .
although not shown in fig .
[ fig : fig3 ] the cross - sections obtained using the the unscaled potentials @xmath19 and a constant reduced mass @xmath29 also agree well with the data at higher energies but either significantly over - estimate or under - estimate the cross - section at lower energies due to the absence of the coordinate dependent mass . in summary ,
the calculated fusion cross - sections for the @xmath74ca+@xmath74ca system reproduce the experimental cross - sections reasonably well , which is a testament that tdhf with skyrme force provides a good description for this collision .
( color online ) potential barriers , @xmath19 , for the @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca system obtained from density constrained tdhf calculations using eq .
( [ eq : vr ] ) at three different energies , @xmath75 mev ( black solid curve ) , @xmath77 mev ( red solid curve ) , and @xmath92 mev ( blue solid curve ) .
the dashed curves correspond to the transformed potential in eq .
( [ eq : urbar ] ) using the coordinate dependent masses . also shown is the point coulomb potential.,width=325 ] in fig . [
fig : fig4 ] we show the microscopic ion - ion potential barriers for the stable neutron - rich @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca system calculated at three different collision energies , @xmath75 mev ( black solid curve ) , @xmath77 mev ( red solid curve ) , and @xmath92 mev ( blue solid curve ) .
the barrier heights , for increasing collision energy , are @xmath93 , @xmath94 , and @xmath95 mev , respectively , with corresponding @xmath31 values of @xmath96 , @xmath97 , and @xmath98 fm .
the comparison of these barriers with those of the @xmath74ca+@xmath74ca system shows that the barrier heights are reduced by about @xmath99 mev and the location of the barrier maximum is at a slightly larger @xmath31 value .
this is due to the fact that two two @xmath91ca nuclei are larger than the corresponding @xmath74ca nuclei and thus their outer skins come into contact at a larger @xmath31 value .
after this point the nuclear interaction sets in causing the trajectory to deviate from the point coulomb one and producing a peak at a lower energy value .
( color online ) fusion cross sections for the @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca system as a function of @xmath86 .
three separate theoretical cross section calculations are shown , based on the energy - dependent dc - tdhf heavy - ion potentials @xmath19 at energies @xmath87 , @xmath89 , and @xmath100 mev .
the experimental data ( filled circles ) are taken from ref .
@xcite.,width=325 ] figure [ fig : fig5 ] shows the fusion cross - sections for the @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca system calculated using the barriers of fig . [ fig : fig4 ] .
while the overall quality of the agreement with the experimental fusion cross - sections is good , specially for the last two collision energies , the curve corresponding to the lowest collision energy of @xmath101 mev overestimates the experiment for lower @xmath86 values .
this illustrates the sensitivity of the results to the height of the potential barrier , the difference in this case between the two barriers being around @xmath102 mev .
( color online ) total fusion cross section as a function of @xmath86 for two different parametrizations of the skyrme force , sly4 and unedf1 , at the collision energy of @xmath87 . the experimental data ( filled circles ) are taken from ref .
@xcite.,width=325 ] while the quality of the dc - tdhf results for the @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca system is very good for a parameter free microscopic approach , we have decided to investigate this further .
one of the problems is that the skyrme fits do badly in reproducing the single - particle properties @xcite , particularly the neutron single - particle states . for example , with sly4 parametrization the neutron levels @xmath103 , @xmath104 , and @xmath105 in @xmath91ca nucleus are about @xmath106 mev lower in energy than the corresponding experimental values @xcite . in one of the parametrizations of the nuclear density functional , unedf0
, these single - particle energies are raised to values closer to experimental ones .
however , in this case the magic gap at @xmath107 vanishes @xcite .
recently , a new parametrization , unedf1 , was introduced with a better incorporation of large deformations among other improvements @xcite .
another possible advantage of the unedf1 parametrization for tdhf calculations is that no center - of - mass correction term was used in the functional , which is also the case in tdhf .
we have tried this parametrization in our dc - tdhf calculation for the @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca system at @xmath108 mev . in practice
, we had to reduce our time - step from @xmath72 fm / c to @xmath109 fm / c , and our density - constraint convergence parameters by a factor of ten or more .
this is probably due to the larger power of the density in the @xmath110 term of the skyrme interaction .
the peak of the fusion barrier is slightly broader and higher in energy by @xmath111 kev for unedf1 . the use of unedf1 results in an improvement of the fusion cross - sections as shown in fig .
[ fig : fig6 ] .
we have also tried using the parametrization sly5 but this resulted in no appreciable difference from the sly4 case .
( color online ) experimental fusion cross sections as a function of @xmath86 for the three systems studied .
the experimental data are taken from ref .
@xcite.,width=325 ] in this section we will examine the fusion of the asymmetric @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system . for highlighting the differences among all three systems we have plotted only the experimental fusion cross - sections in fig .
[ fig : fig7 ] .
relative to the @xmath74ca+@xmath74ca and @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca systems the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca fusion cross - sections show a different systematic behavior . at higher bombarding energies
the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca cross - sections fall below the @xmath74ca+@xmath74ca data points , whereas at sub - barrier energies they rise above the @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca data . historically , the theoretical description of the fusion cross - sections for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system have been complicated by the couplings to various transfer channels with positive @xmath112 values @xcite . a strong enhancement of fusion cross - sections at lower energies seen in fig .
[ fig : fig7 ] was attributed to this effect @xcite .
( color online ) potential barriers for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system obtained from density constrained tdhf calculations at three different energies , @xmath75 mev ( black solid curve ) , @xmath76 mev ( red solid curve ) , and @xmath92 mev ( blue solid curve ) .
the three dashed curves correspond to the transformed potential in eq .
( [ eq : urbar ] ) using the coordinate dependent masses .
also shown is the point coulomb potential.,width=325 ] in fig .
[ fig : fig8 ] we show the microscopic ion - ion potential barriers for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system calculated at three different collision energies , @xmath75 mev ( black solid curve ) , @xmath76 mev ( red solid curve ) , and @xmath92 mev ( blue solid curve ) .
the barrier heights , for increasing collision energy , are @xmath113 , @xmath114 , and @xmath115 mev , respectively , with corresponding @xmath31 values of @xmath116 , @xmath117 , and @xmath118 fm .
we have used the coordinate dependent masses to obtain the scaled potentials @xmath49 of eq .
( [ eq : urbar ] ) .
these potentials are also shown as the dashed curves in fig .
[ fig : fig8 ] . as before the coordinate dependent mass only changes the inner parts of the barriers for all energies and the effect diminishes as we increase the collision energy .
( color online ) fusion cross sections for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system as a function of @xmath86 .
three separate theoretical cross section calculations are shown , based on the energy - dependent dc - tdhf heavy - ion potentials @xmath19 at energies @xmath87 , @xmath88 , and @xmath100 mev .
the experimental data ( filled circles ) are taken from ref .
@xcite.,width=325 ] figure [ fig : fig9 ] shows the fusion cross - sections for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system calculated using the barriers of fig .
[ fig : fig8 ] .
the observed trend for sub - barrier energies is typical for dc - tdhf calculations when the underlying microscopic interaction gives a good representation of the participating nuclei .
namely , the potential barrier corresponding to the lowest collision energy gives the best fit to the sub - barrier cross - sections since this is the one that allows for more rearrangements to take place and grows the inner part of the barrier .
considering the fact that historically the low - energy sub - barrier cross - sections of the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system have been the ones not reproduced well by the standard models , the dc - tdhf results are quite satisfactory , indicating that the dynamical evolution of the nuclear density in tdhf gives a good overall description of the collision process .
the shift of the cross - section curve with increasing collision energy is typical . in principle
one could perform a dc - tdhf calculation at each energy above the barrier and use that cross - section for that energy .
however , this would make the computations extremely time consuming and may not provide much more insight .
the trend at higher energies is atypical .
the calculated cross - sections are larger than the experimental ones by about a factor of two .
such lowering of fusion cross - sections with increasing collision energy is commonly seen in lighter systems where various inelastic channels , clustering , and molecular formations are believed to be the contributing factors @xcite . in the recent coupled - channel approach
this is solved by the addition of a small imaginary potential near the minimum of the repulsive core @xcite .
such an imaginary part was found not to be necessary for the @xmath74ca+@xmath74ca and @xmath91ca+@xmath91ca systems @xcite . at this time
we do not have access to coupled - channel results for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system .
we have repeated our dc - tdhf calculations using the unedf1 interaction which resulted in a small improvement , reducing the difference with the experimental values to a factor of about @xmath119 .
this issue will be discussed further in the next section where we examine the excitation properties obtained from tdhf calculations .
excitations are believed to have a significant impact on the outcome of the fusion reactions .
the excitations can range from the entrance channel quantal excitations of the projectile and target , as in the coupled - channel approach , to collective excitations of pre - equilibrium system , to compound nucleus excitations .
these can be further influenced by particle transfer , pre - equilibrium emissions , and evaporation , among others .
theoretically such effects are commonly introduced by hand into various reaction models .
however , the influence of excitations on nuclear reaction dynamics remains to be a difficult and an open problem as it combines both nuclear structure and dynamics under nonequilibrium conditions .
( color online ) neutron and proton transfer as a function of ion - ion separation distance @xmath31 for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system .
solid lines denote the particles originally belonging to the @xmath91ca nucleus and dashed lines to the @xmath74ca nucleus .
the dotted vertical line shows the location of the potential barrier peak , @xmath120.,width=325 ] in sec . [
sec : excitation ] we have outlined the calculation of the dynamical excitation energy within the dc - tdhf formalism .
this approach was used to calculate excitation energies for various systems , including the excitation energy of the heavy systems leading to superheavy formations @xcite . here
, we have shown that what is also important is the excitation of the system at the point of capture , which is a deciding factor for forming a composite system or fusion - fission .
this is different than excitation of the compound nucleus , which determines the survival of the system from quasi - fission .
the dynamical excitation energies calculated from dc - tdhf are relative to an unequilibrated composite system rather than a true compound nucleus .
( color online ) excitation energy , @xmath121 , as a function of the ion - ion separation distance , @xmath31 , for the three systems studied here.,width=325 ] the systems studied in this manuscript present interesting target - projectile combinations for studying excitations .
for example , the non - symmetric @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system will have a pre - equilibrium gdr excitation in comparison to the other two symmetric systems , as well as particle transfer .
naturally , some of these effects are included in the fusion barriers obtained via the dc - tdhf method , as they influence the change in the tdhf density used in the density constraint calculation .
the quantity @xmath122 calculated from via tdhf and dc - tdhf represents the average of dynamical excitations present in the mean - field theory , with the exception of excitations not determined by the nuclear density and current ( such as the spin currents ) .
another point to consider is the pairing interaction .
it has been a general consensus that during a heavy - ion collision the effects of pairing are washed away due to the high excitations . in this particular case paring effects are minimal for the initial ca nuclei studied . however , even if the pairing can be ignored during the collision process , in many cases it plays an important role for obtaining good initial hf states as well as obtaining realistic density constraint solutions when a single composite is formed .
fortunately , the latter case corresponds to the region of barrier minimum and not the region around the barrier peak where most fusion cross - sections are measured .
this may in some way explain the success of the dc - tdhf barriers for fusion .
( color online ) time evolution of isoscalar deformation parameter @xmath123 for the head - on collision of all three systems at a collision energy of @xmath75 mev ( top panel ) , and the time evolution of the isovector dipole amplitude @xmath124 for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system ( bottom panel).,width=321 ] in fig .
[ fig : fig10 ] we plot the average number of neutrons and protons transferred during the early stages of the tdhf collision of the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system at @xmath125 mev .
the solid lines denote the neutrons and protons asymptotically belonging to the @xmath91ca nucleus and dashed lines to the @xmath74ca nucleus .
a number of interesting things can be observed from the plot ; first is the fact that most of the transfer seems to start after we pass the potential barrier peak .
this indicates that particle transfer primarily modifies the inner part of the barrier and not so much the barrier height .
the other observation is that on average about three neutrons are transferred from @xmath91ca to @xmath74ca but there is also a small amount of proton transfer in the opposite direction .
( color online ) power spectrum of the isovector dipole amplitude @xmath124 for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system is shown for various time - intervals , width=325 ] figure [ fig : fig11 ] shows the excitation energy , @xmath121 , for the three systems studies here .
the excitation energy was calculated for the same value of @xmath126 mev for all systems , which corresponds to collision energies of @xmath101 , @xmath88 , and @xmath127 mev , respectively .
all curves initially behave in a similar manner , at large distances the excitation is zero , as the nuclei approach the barrier peak the excitations start and monotonically rise for larger overlaps .
the interesting observation is that the excitations for the intermediary @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system start at a slightly earlier time and rise above the other two systems . this may be largely due to the fact that an asymmetric system has some additional modes of excitation in comparison to the other two symmetric systems
. it may be plausible to consider the direct influence of the excitation energy , @xmath121 , on the fusion barriers by making an analogy with the coupled - channel approach and construct a new potential @xmath128 , which has all the excitations added to the ion - ion potential @xmath19 that should be calculated at higher energies to minimize the nuclear rearrangements ( frozen - density limit ) .
the resulting potentials somewhat resemble the repulsive - core coupled - channel potentials of ref .
this approach does lead to improvements in cases where most of the excitation energy is in the form of collective excitations rather than irreversible stochastic dissipation ( true especially for lighter systems ) .
for the cases studied here we do see a small improvement for the fusion cross - sections of the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system .
the viability of this approach requires further examination and will be studied in the future .
one of the excitation modes for the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system , namely the particle transfer , was already discussed above .
the others are various isovector modes such as the pre - equilibrium gdr excitation . in fig .
[ fig : fig12 ] we show the time development of the isoscalar deformation parameter @xmath129 ( top panel ) and the isovector dipole amplitude @xmath124 of eq .
( [ eq : dt ] ) ( bottom panel ) .
the isovector amplitudes for the two symmetric systems would appear as a zero - line on this plot .
we have left out the initial approach phase of the collision ( about @xmath130 fm/@xmath131 ) from these plots .
the time - evolution of the deformation @xmath123 is very similar for all three systems except at larger times the @xmath74ca+@xmath91ca system moves toward smaller deformation in comparison to the other two systems .
this is again most likely due to increased excitations that drive the system toward a more compact shape .
the evolution of the dipole operator @xmath124 shows little damping over a long time interval . the power spectrum associated with this time time - evolution is shown in fig .
[ fig : fig13 ] .
we have evaluated the spectrum for different time - intervals .
the broadest curve corresponds to a very early stage of the collision , @xmath132 fm/@xmath131 , but has the lowest amplitude ( multiplied by @xmath133 in fig .
[ fig : fig13 ] ) . in the second interval , @xmath134 fm/@xmath131
, we see the development of various peaks and an increase in amplitude .
the spectrum for the entire time interval , @xmath135 fm/@xmath131 , is dominated by a sharp peak around @xmath136 mev , which is primarily originating from the later stages of the collision which is evident if one compares it to the spectrum from the interval @xmath137 fm/@xmath131 .
in this manuscript we have provided a microscopic study of ca@xmath138ca fusion using the dc - tdhf approach .
these reactions have recently been of considerable interest for the fusion community with a flurry of phenomenological analyses of the fusion data . here , we have provided a microscopic alternative to this analysis .
we have shown that microscopically obtained ion - ion potentials do give a reasonably good description of the fusion cross - sections . the fully microscopic tdhf theory has shown itself to be rich in nuclear phenomena and continues to stimulate our understanding of nuclear dynamics .
the time - dependent mean - field studies seem to show that the dynamic evolution builds up correlations that are not present in the static theory . while modern skyrme forces provide a much better description of static nuclear properties in comparison to the earlier parametrizations
there is a need to obtain even better parametrizations that incorporate deformation and reaction data into the fit process .
this work has been supported by the u.s .
department of energy under grant no .
de - fg02 - 96er40963 with vanderbilt university .
rk thankfully acknowledges the scientific and technological council of turkey ( tubitak , bideb-2219 ) for a partial support
. 99 a. m. stefanini _
et al . _ ,
b * 679 * , 95 ( 2009 ) .
c. l. jiang _ et al .
c * 82 * , 041601 ( 2010 ) .
g. montagnoli _
et al . _ ,
a * 834 * , 159c ( 2010 ) .
g. montagnoli and a. m. stefanini , epj web conf . * 17 * , 05001 ( 2011 ) .
h. a. aljuwair _
et al . _ , phys . rev .
c * 30 * , 1223 ( 1984 ) .
. miicu and h. esbensen , phys .
lett . * 96 * , 112701 ( 2006 ) .
takatoshi ichikawa , kouichi hagino , and akira iwamoto , phys . rev .
c * 75 * , 057603 ( 2007 ) .
takatoshi ichikawa , kouichi hagino , and akira iwamoto , phys .
c * 75 * , 064612 ( 2007 ) .
h. esbensen _
et al . _ ,
c * 82 * , 054621 ( 2010 ) .
erban miicu and florin carstoiu , phys .
c * 84 * , 051601(r ) ( 2011 ) .
a. s. umar and v. e. oberacker , phys .
c * 74 * , 021601(r ) ( 2006 ) .
a. s. umar and v. e. oberacker , phys .
c * 76 * , 014614 ( 2007 ) .
a. s. umar and v. e. oberacker , phys .
c * 77 * , 064605 ( 2008 ) .
a. s. umar and v. e. oberacker , eur .
j. a * 39 * , 243 ( 2009 ) . v. e. oberacker , a. s. umar , j. a. maruhn , and p .- g .
reinhard , phys .
c * 82 * , 034603 ( 2010 ) .
a. s. umar , v. e. oberacker , j. a. maruhn , and p .-
reinhard , phys .
c * 81 * , 064607 ( 2010 ) .
a. s. umar , v. e. oberacker , j. a. maruhn , and p .-
reinhard , phys . rev .
c * 80 * , 041601(r ) ( 2009 ) .
r. y. cusson , p. -g .
reinhard , m. r. strayer , j. a. maruhn , and w. greiner , z. phys .
a * 320 * , 475 ( 1985 ) .
a. s. umar , m. r. strayer , r. y. cusson , p. -g .
reinhard , and d. a. bromley , phys .
c * 32 * , 172 ( 1985 ) .
kouhei washiyama and denis lacroix , phys .
c * 78 * , 024610 ( 2008 ) .
spiegel , _ vector analysis _ , schaum s outline series , mcgraw - hill ( 1959 ) .
k. goeke , f. grmmer , and p. -g .
reinhard , ann . phys . * 150 * , 504 ( 1983 ) .
g. h. rawitscher , phys .
135 , 605 ( 1964 ) .
k. hagino , n. rowley , and a. t. kruppa , comp .
. comm . * 123 * , 143 ( 1999 ) . v. baran et al .
a * 600 * , 111 ( 1996 ) .
v. baran _ et al .
c * 79 * , 021603(r ) ( 2009 ) . c. simenel , ph .
chomaz , and g. de france , phys .
c * 76 * , 024609 ( 2007 ) .
a. s. umar and v. e. oberacker , phys .
c * 73 * , 054607 ( 2006 ) .
e. chabanat , p. bonche , p. haensel , j. meyer and r. schaeffer , nucl . phys . *
a635 * , 231 ( 1998 ) ; * a643 * , 441(e ) ( 1998 ) .
m. kortelainen , j. mcdonnell , w. nazarewicz , p .-
reinhard , j. sarich , n. schunck , m. v. stoitsov , and s. m. wild , phys .
c ( in press ) ( http://arxiv.org/abs/1111.4344 ) . m. kortelainen , t. lesinski , j. mor , w. nazarewicz , j. sarich , n. schunck , m. v. stoitsov , and s. wild , phys . rev .
c * 82 * , 024313 ( 2010 ) .
m. kortelainen , j. dobaczewski , k.mizuyama , and j. toivanen , phys .
c * 77 * , 064307 ( 2008 ) .
s. landowne , c. h. dasso , r. a. broglia , and g. pollarolo , phys .
c * 31 * , 1047 ( 1985 ) .
h. esbensen , s. h. fricke , and s. landowne , phys .
c * 40 * , 2046 ( 1989 ) .
k. t. r. davies , k. r. s. devi , s. e. koonin , and m. r. strayer , in _ treatise on heavy ion science _ , edited by d. a. bromley , ( plenum , new york , 1985 ) , vol.3 , page 3 .
h. esbensen , phys .
c * 77 * , 054608 ( 2008 ) . | we investigate the fusion barriers for reactions involving ca isotopes @xmath0 , @xmath1 , and @xmath2 using the microscopic time - dependent hartree - fock theory coupled with a density constraint . in this formalism
the fusion barriers are directly obtained from tdhf dynamics .
we also study the excitation of the pre - equilibrium gdr for the @xmath1 system and the associated @xmath3-ray emission spectrum .
fusion cross - sections are calculated using the incoming - wave boundary condition approach .
we examine the dependence of fusion barriers on collision energy as well as on the different parametrizations of the skyrme interaction .
= 10000 = 10000 = 10000 |
left - handed ( lh ) metamaterials are artificial , effectively homogeneous structures , featuring negative refractive index at specific frequency bands where the effective permittivity @xmath0 and permeability @xmath1 are simultaneously negative @xcite .
in fact , all known realizations of lh metamaterials rely on the use of common right - handed ( rh ) elements and , thus , in a realistic situation such a composite material features both a lh and a rh behavior , in certain frequency bands . physically speaking , the difference between the two is that in the lh ( rh ) regime , the energy and the wave fronts of the electromagnetic ( em ) waves propagate in the opposite ( same ) directions , giving rise to backward- ( forward- ) propagating waves .
transmission line ( tl ) theory constitutes a convenient framework for the analysis of lh metamaterials .
such an analysis relies on the connection of the em properties of the medium ( @xmath0 and @xmath1 ) with the electric elements of the tl s unit cell , namely the serial and shunt impedance . as mentioned above , in practice _
composite right / left - handed ( crlh ) _ structures are quite relevant , giving rise to pertinent crlh - tl models .
these models are , in fact , dynamical lattices which can be used for the description of a variety of metamaterials - based devices and systems , such as resonators , directional couplers , antennas , etc @xcite .
nonlinear crlh - tls , with a serial or / and shunt impedance depending on voltages or currents , have also attracted attention .
such structures may be realized by inserting diodes which mimic voltage - controlled nonlinear capacitors into resonant conductive elements ( such as split - ring resonators ) @xcite .
such nonlinear crlh - tl models have been used in various works dealing , e.g. , with the parametric shielding of em fields @xcite , the long - short wave interaction @xcite , or soliton formation @xcite .
experiments in nonlinear crlh - tls have also been performed ( see the review @xcite ) , and formation of bright @xcite or dark @xcite envelope solitons , described by an effective nonlinear schrdinger ( nls ) equation , was reported .
notice that in earlier studies on rh - tl models it was shown that two ( or more ) solitons propagating with the same group velocity , can be described by a system of two ( or more ) nls equations @xcite ( see also @xcite for theoretical as well as experimental results ) .
such coupled nls equations have been studied extensively in nonlinear optics and mathematical physics ; see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite and references therein .
they are well - known to give rise to a variety of vector solitons , including bright - bright , bright - dark , and dark - dark ones . in this work ,
we study analytically and numerically the interaction between backward- and forward - propagating solitons in a nonlinear crlh - tl .
our model is a nonlinear version of a generic crlh - tl model ( see , e.g. , refs .
@xcite ) : the considered nonlinear element in the unit cell of the tl is the shunt capacitor , which simulates the presence of a heterostracture barrier varactor ( hbv ) diode @xcite ( the capacitance of the hbv diode depends on the applied voltage ) .
starting from the discrete lump element model of the crlh - tl , we derive a nonlinear lattice equation .
first , we study the linear regime and show that , for certain frequency bands , rh- and lh - modes can propagate with the same group velocity . next , we treat the nonlinear lattice equation in the framework of the _ quasi - discrete _ ( or _ quasi - continuum _ ) approximation ( see , e.g. , @xcite and @xcite for a review ) : we thus seek for envelope soliton solutions of the nonlinear lattice model , characterized by a _
discrete carrier _ and a _ continuum envelope _ and employ an asymptotic multi - scale expansion method , to derive a system of two coupled nls equations .
each of these equations describes the evolution of the envelope of a backward- ( lh- ) and a forward - propagating ( rh- ) mode .
a systematic analysis of the system of the nls equations reveals the existence in certain frequency bands of three different types of vector solitons : ( a ) a backward - propagating bright soliton coupled with a forward - propagating bright soliton , ( b ) a backward - propagating bright soliton coupled with a forward - propagating dark soliton .
( c ) a backward - propagating dark soliton coupled with a forward - propagating bright soliton , and the above analytical predictions are then tested against direct numerical simulations , which are performed in the framework of the original nonlinear lattice model .
the results of the simulations verify the existence of the aforementioned types of vector solitons in the full tl model , but also offer important information regarding their robustness .
in particular , results of direct simulations performed for long times indicate that bright - bright solitons are the most robust among the members of the vector soliton family .
indeed , the mixed ( dark - bright or bright - dark ) types are found to be less robust ; however , the dark - bright solitons in a specific frequency band , although they are deformed during their evolution , are found to be more robust than those in other bands , as well as the bright - dark solitons , which are destroyed for the same propagation time . in any case , our results indicate the existence of all three types , robustness of bright - bright solitons and partial or substantial deformation of the other types .
we can thus conclude that bright - bright ( lh - rh ) , as well as dark - bright ( lh - rh ) solitons in certain frequency bands , have a better chance to be observed in experiments .
the paper is organized as follows . in section ii
, we introduce the nonlinear crlh - tl model and the pertinent lattice equation , and derive the system of the two coupled nls equations ( relevant details are also appended in an appendix ) . in section iii ,
we present analytical and numerical results for each type of vector soliton .
finally , in section iv , we summarize our conclusions .
we consider a generic crlh - tl , composed by both right- and left - handed elements , as shown in its unit - cell circuit shown in fig .
[ fig : circuitcrlh model ] @xcite .
the ( rh ) elements of this tl are the inductance @xmath2 and capacitance @xmath3 , while the lh ones are the inductance @xmath4 and capacitance @xmath5 .
we assume that the tl is loaded with a nonlinear capacitance ( @xmath6 , while the capacitance @xmath7 will be assumed to be fixed and voltage independent ) .
this can be implemented by proper insertion of diodes in the tl ( see , e.g. , pertinent experiments as well as theoretical work in refs .
@xcite ) ; in other words , we assume that the shunt capacitor @xmath6 is nonlinear ( see details below ) .
let us now consider kirchhoff s voltage and current laws for the unit - cell circuit of fig .
[ fig : circuitcrlh model ] , which respectively read : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the voltage across the capacitance @xmath7 and @xmath10 is the current across the inductor @xmath11 .
the above equations , together with the auxiliary equations @xmath12 and @xmath13 , lead to the following system : @xmath14 to proceed further , we now consider a specific voltage - dependence for the nonlinear capacitance @xmath3 . here
, we will assume that for sufficiently small values of the voltage @xmath15 the function @xmath16 can be approximated as follows , via a taylor expansion : @xmath17 where @xmath18 is a constant capacitance corresponding to the bias voltage @xmath19 , while @xmath20 and @xmath21 also assume constant values , depending on the particular form of @xmath22 .
below , we will further discuss this approximation , in connection with the hbv diode , used in the experiments described in ref .
@xcite ( similar varactor - type diodes were also used in the experiments of ref .
@xcite ) . next , substituting eq .
( [ eq : taylor1 ] ) into eq .
( [ eq : eq01 ] ) and using the scale transformations @xmath23 [ where @xmath24 and @xmath25v_n $ ] , we obtain : @xmath26 where the constant parameters @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath1 are given by : @xmath29 in the above expressions , @xmath30 and @xmath31 denote series and shunt frequencies , while @xmath32 denotes the characteristic frequency related to the rh part of the unit - cell circuit , respectively ; the above frequencies are defined as : @xmath33 note that if @xmath34 , i.e. , @xmath35 , then the crlh - tl is usually referred to as _ balanced _ , in the sense that the characteristic impedances of the purely lh- and rh - tl , defined as @xmath36 and @xmath37 , are equal , i.e. , @xmath38 @xcite . on the other hand , if @xmath39 , i.e. , @xmath40 , the lh part of the tl dominates , in the sense that the tl has a more pronounced lh behaviour ( the serial branch features a capacitive character while the shunt branch an inductive one ) . in the opposite case , @xmath41 , i.e. , @xmath42 , the rh part of the tl dominates and the tl has a more pronounced rh behaviour ( the serial branch features an inductive character while the shunt branch a capacitive one ) .
it is now relevant to adopt physically relevant parameter values for eq .
( [ eq : model ] ) . for applications in the microwave frequency range ( e.g. , for microstrip lines @xcite or coplanar waveguide structures loaded with srrs @xcite cf .
also ref .
@xcite for recent work ) , typical values of the capacitances and inductances involved in the crlh structure are of the order of pf and nh , respectively . here
, we will use the values @xmath43 nh , @xmath44 pf , and @xmath45 nh ; thus , the frequencies in eqs .
( [ eq : freq ] ) take the values @xmath46 ghz , @xmath47 ghz and @xmath48 ghz . on the other hand , as concerns the parameters involved with the nonlinear capacitor @xmath6 , we assume that the pertinent capacitance corresponds to a hbv diode , which is characterized by the following equation @xcite ( see also @xcite , where the same form of @xmath49 is used , but different parameter values ) : @xmath50 where @xmath51 ff/@xmath1m@xmath52 is the capacitance corresponding to bias voltage @xmath53 v , @xmath54m@xmath52 is the device area , @xmath55 v is the breakdown potential , and the exponent @xmath56 results from fitting experimental data .
it is clear that , for sufficiently small @xmath57 , by taylor expanding eq .
( [ hbv ] ) one obtains eq .
( [ eq : taylor1 ] ) , where the constant parameter values involved are @xmath58 pf , @xmath59 pf / v and @xmath60 pf / v@xmath61 . to this end , the values of the normalized parameters @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath1 appearing in eq .
( [ eq : model ] ) take the following values : @xmath62 below , we will use these values for the purposes of our analytical and numerical considerations ( we have checked that other values lead to qualitatively similar results ) . notice that our choice leads to @xmath40 ,
i.e. , we consider the case where the tl has a more pronounced lh character ; however , when considering the linear setting ( see next subsection ) , this parameter will also assume other values , corresponding to the balanced and rh - dominated behaviour as well . [ cols="^,^ " , ] figures [ fig : db13sim1 ] and [ fig : db13sim2 ] show the outcome of the simulations for a dark - bright soliton in bands i and iii ( with @xmath63 and @xmath64 ) , while figs .
[ fig : db23sim1 ] and [ fig : db23sim2 ] correspond to a dark - bright soliton in bands ii and iii ( with @xmath63 and @xmath65 ) .
the parameters used are @xmath66 and @xmath67 , which gives @xmath68 and @xmath69 , in bands i and iii , and @xmath70 and @xmath71 , which gives @xmath72 and @xmath73 , in bands ii and iii , respectively . in the latter case ,
the relatively large values of the number of particles and of @xmath74 used are motivated by the necessity of a vanishing tail for the bright component at the edges of the lattice .
as seen in this set of figures , dark - bright solitons in bands ii - iii and i - iii do exist , as predicted in theory .
furthermore , it is observed that the former are less robust than the latter , as seen both from their stronger deformation and the fact that they `` lose '' their solitary wave character earlier .
this can be observed , e.g. , in the strong fluctuations in the evolution of the soliton center in the bottom left panel of fig .
[ fig : db23sim2 ] , or perhaps most notably in the substantial modification of the wave profile upon long propagation in the top right panel of the same figure . on the other hand , the dark - bright solitons of bands
i - iii seem to essentially preserve their structure even in the long evolution of fig .
[ fig : db13sim2 ] .
in conclusion , we have used both analytical and numerical techniques to study the existence , stability and dynamics of coupled backward- and forward - propagating solitons in a composite right / left - handed ( crlh ) nonlinear transmission line ( tl ) .
the considered form of the tl was a quite generic one , finding applications to the modelling of a wide range of lh systems and devices , with `` parasitic '' rh behavior , such as resonators , antennas , directional couplers , among others @xcite .
our analysis started with the derivation of a nonlinear lattice equation governing the voltage across the fundamental ( unit cell ) element of the transmission line . in the linear regime , we derived the dispersion relation for small - amplitude linear plane waves and showed that they may either propagate in a right - handed ( rh ) high - frequency region , or in a left - handed ( lh ) low - frequency region .
we also identified frequency bands where rh- and lh - modes can propagate with the same group velocity . using the above result
, we then investigated the possibility of nonlinearity - assisted coupling between lh- and rh - modes .
this way , in order to analytically treat the nonlinear lattice equation , we used the so - called quasi - discrete approximation .
the latter is a variant of the multi - scale perturbation method , which takes into regard the discreteness of the system by considering the carrier ( envelope ) of the wave as a discrete ( continuum ) function of space . employing this approach
, we derived , in the small - amplitude approximation and for certain space- and time - scales , a system of two coupled nonlinear schrdinger ( nls ) equations for the unknown voltage envelope functions .
this system was then used to predict the existence of coupled backward- and forward - propagating solitons , of the bright - bright , bright - dark and dark - bright type , respectively .
the above existence results , as well as the propagation properties and the potential robustness of these vector solitons , were then investigated for each of the possible scenarios .
this was done by means of direct numerical simulations of the full crlh - tl nonlinear lattice model , using as initial conditions the analytical forms of solitons predicted by the perturbation theory . in the simulations ,
apart from the evolution of the shape , we also studied the evolution of the center of mass and a power - like quantity of the various solitons .
our numerical results have confirmed the existence of the various types of solitons predicted analytically , but have also revealed their distinct robustness characteristics .
in particular , we found that bright - bright solitons feature a robust propagation over long times . on the other hand , as concerns solitons of the mixed - type ( namely dark - bright and bright - dark ones ) , we found that , in specific frequency bands ( bands i - iii ) , dark - bright solitons are more robust than those in other bands ( i.e. , ii - iii ) or bright - dark solitons : dark - bright solitons in bands ii - iii and bright dark solitons preserve their shape only for finite times and , for sufficiently long evolutions , they are either destroyed ( bright - dark ) or are significantly deformed ( dark - bright ) .
we can thus postulate that from all types of solitons predicted analytically , bright - bright and dark - bright ones ( in bands i - iii ) are the most likely ones to be experimentally observable . in all cases ,
our numerical results were found to corroborate the analytical predictions , at least up to the times during which the solitary waves propagate robustly .
it would be interesting to study other types of nonlinear crlh - tl lattice models modelling realistic structures composed by lh - metamaterials . in that regard
, a pertinent interesting direction would be the investigation of the effects of damping and driving , which may lead to robust nonlinear waveforms which would constitute dynamical attractors in such settings .
additionally , the study of higher - dimensional settings is a particularly challenging problem . in the latter context ,
in addition to simpler ( yet genuinely higher dimensional , or even quasi - one - dimensional ) solitary wave structures , more complex waveforms may be realizable such as vortices .
the exploration of such states and their dynamical robustness will be reported in future publications .
* acknowledgments . *
the work of d.j.f .
was partially supported by the special account of research grants of the university of athens .
j.c . acknowledges financial support from the micinn project fis2008 - 04848 .
pgk acknowledges support from the us - nsf via cmmi-1000337 , and the us - afosr via fa9550 - 12 - 1 - 0332 .
our analytical approximation relies on the use of the quasi - continuum approximation , which is a variant of the method of multiple scales @xcite .
we introduce new independent temporal variables , @xmath75 ( @xmath76 ) , and accordingly expand the time derivative operator @xmath77 as @xmath78 .
next , we seek solutions of eq .
( [ eq : model ] ) in the form : @xmath79 then , we substitute eq .
( [ eq : ansatz01 ] ) into eq .
( [ eq : model ] ) and employ a continuum approximation for the envelope functions @xmath80 ,
i.e. , @xmath81 , where @xmath82 and @xmath83 being the lattice spacing ( the latter parameter does not appear in the results below , as one may readily rescale @xmath84 as @xmath85).furthermore , we introduce the new spatial variables @xmath86 and , thus , @xmath87 . to this end , equating coefficients of like powers of @xmath0 , we obtain the following ( first three ) perturbation equations : @xmath88=0 , \label{eq : terms3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the operators are given by @xmath89 we now seek for a solution of the linear problem , eq .
( [ eq : terms1 ] ) , in the form : @xmath90 where subscripts @xmath91 and @xmath92 correspond to the lh and rh frequency bands , @xmath93 is an unknown complex function , @xmath94 , while the wavenumbers @xmath95 and frequencies @xmath96 satisfy the dispersion relation provided in eq .
( [ eq : linear_disp ] ) . next , substituting eq .
( [ eq : ansatza ] ) into eq .
( [ eq : terms2 ] ) , we obtain the non - secularity condition for @xmath97 : @xmath98\frac{\partial v_j}{\partial x_1}=0 , \label{eq : secular}\ ] ] which suggests that @xmath99 , where @xmath100 , while the group velocities@xmath101 result self - consistently as @xmath102 [ cf .
( [ eq : gvelqc ] ) ] . employing eq .
( [ eq : secular ] ) , we may determine from eq .
( [ eq : terms2 ] ) , for @xmath103 , the unknown field @xmath104 : @xmath105}{{{g_3}(\omega_1+\omega_2,k_1+k_2 ) } } v_1v_2\exp(i(\theta_1+\theta_2 ) \nonumber\\ & & -\frac{2[(\omega_1-\omega_2)^{4}-\delta^2(\omega_1-\omega_2)^{2}]}{{{g_4}(\omega_1-\omega_2,k_1-k_2 ) } } v_1v_2^{*}\exp(i(\theta_1-\theta_2)\nonumber\\ & & -\sum_{j=1}^{2}f_j(x_1,x_2,\cdots , t_1,t_2,\cdots)+{\rm c.c . } , \label{eq : u2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where functions @xmath106 are given by : @xmath107 on the other hand , functions @xmath108 can be derived at the order @xmath109 , by means of the equation : @xmath110 which leads to the result : @xmath111 to this end , we arrive at the following expression for @xmath104 : @xmath112 where @xmath113}{{{g_3}(\omega_1+\omega_2,k_1+k_2)}},\\ c_4&=&\frac{2[(\omega_1-\omega_2)^{4}-\delta^2(\omega_1-\omega_2)^{2}]}{{{g_4}(\omega_1-\omega_2,k_1-k_2)}},\\ c_{0j}&=&\frac{2\omega_j^2\delta^2}{\omega_j^4+\delta^2}. \label{eq : u2par}\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , defining the coefficients : @xmath114 and using the variables @xmath115 and @xmath116 , we derive from the non - secularity condition at @xmath117 the coupled nls equations ( [ eq : mnls1 ] ) .
m. lapine , m. gorkunov , and k. h. ringhofer , phys .
e * 67 * , 065601 ( 2003 ) ; m. lapine and m. gorkunov , phys .
e * 70 * , 066601 ( 2004 ) ; b. wang , j. zhou , t. koschny , and c.m .
soukoulis , opt .
express * 16 * , 16058 ( 2008 ) ; d. a. powell , i. v. shadrivov , and yu . s. kivshar , appl .
. lett . * 95 * , 084102 ( 2009 ) .
fefferman and m.i .
weinstein , arxiv:1202.3839 .
see also arxiv:1212.6072 .
p. g. kevrekidis , d. j. frantzeskakis and r. carretero - gonzlez ( eds . ) , _ emergent nonlinear phenomena in bose - einstein condensates _ ,
( springer - verlag , heidelberg , 2008 ) ; r. carretero - gonzlez , d. j. frantzeskakis , and p. g. kevrekidis , nonlinearity * 21 * , r139 ( 2008 ) . | we study the coupling between backward- and forward - propagating wave modes , with the same group velocity , in a composite right / left - handed nonlinear transmission line . using an asymptotic multiscale expansion technique ,
we derive a system of two coupled nonlinear schrdinger equations governing the evolution of the envelopes of these modes .
we show that this system supports a variety of backward- and forward propagating vector solitons , of the bright - bright , bright - dark and dark - bright type .
performing systematic numerical simulations in the framework of the original lattice that models the transmission line , we study the propagation properties of the derived vector soliton solutions .
we show that all types of the predicted solitons exist , but differ on their robustness : only bright - bright solitons propagate undistorted for long times , while the other types are less robust , featuring shorter lifetimes . in all cases ,
our analytical predictions are in a very good agreement with the results of the simulations , at least up to times of the order of the solitons lifetimes .
= 1 |
the evolution of languages through the interaction of their speakers is a topic of interest to computational linguists and , like many interacting many - body problems , is difficult to study analytically . in this paper
we follow an approach that views languages at the level of syntax , with syntactic structures encoded as a string of binary syntactic parameters , a point of view originating in the principles and parameters model of generative linguistics , @xcite , @xcite ( see also @xcite for a more expository account ) .
it is known that syntactic parameters can change in the course of language evolution .
cases of parameter flipping have been identified in the historical development of some indo - european languages , see for example @xcite . for recent results on language evolution from the point of view of syntactic parameters ,
see @xcite .
we construct a model for language evolution inspired by the physics of _ spin glasses_. these are systems of interacting spin variables , with spins located at the vertices of a graph and with interaction energies along the edges that tend to favor alignment ( ferromagnetic ) or anti - alignment ( anti - ferromagnetic ) of the spin variables at the endpoints of each edge .
the dynamics of the system also depends on thermodynamic temperature parameter , which is a measure of disorder in the system , so that the spin variables tend to be frozen onto the ground state at low temperature , while higher energy states become accessible to the dynamics at higher temperature .
we interpret each syntactic parameter as a spin variable , on a graph representing world languages and their interaction .
we obtain the binary values of the syntactic parameters from the syntactic structures of the world s languages ( sswl ) database , which documents these values for 111 syntactic parameters and over 200 natural languages . to model the interaction strengths between languages , we use data from the mit media lab , by defining the strength of the influence of language a on language b as the likelihood that two languages are to be co - spoken .
in particular , in their database , two languages are connected when users that edit an article in one wikipedia language edition are significantly more likely to also edit an article in another language edition .
the frequency of such occurrences provides an estimate of the strength of the interaction .
the idea of modeling syntactic parameters as spin variables in a statistical mechanical setting is not entirely new to computational linguistics . a model based on this idea
was proposed in @xcite .
the main difference with respect to the approach we follow here is that , in the model of @xcite , the vertices of the graph are individual speakers in a fixed population , rather than languages ( populations of speakers ) as in our model . a statistical physics model of language change based on syntactic parameters
was also constructed in @xcite .
we make a series of simplifying assumptions , to the purpose of obtaining a computationally feasible model
. we will examine the plausibility of these assumptions and their interpretation from a linguistics point of view .
first , we assume that the languages we simulate are sufficiently distinct and never converge and do not concern ourselves with , for example , whether a dialect of language a is truly distinct from language a or whether two closely related languages a and b will at some point just become the same " language .
instead , we assume there exists a definition of a language for which the notion of distinct languages is precise and for which the languages we have identified are always distinct .
the second simplification we make is that for a given syntactic parameter , such as the subject - verb " syntax , a language either has it or does not have it .
one could account for finer syntactical structures by considering syntaxes of arbitrary length , but this would still admit a binary classification over the languages .
a third assumption is that because language interaction occurs microscopically by human interaction , and a foreign language is easier to acquire if its syntax is familiar , interacting languages will generally prefer to align their syntactic parameters . from these assumptions ,
we construct a hamiltonian and evolve the system from its current syntactic parameter state toward equilibrium . considering languages as discrete " objects ( as opposed to a continuum of dialects )
is a rather common linguistic assumption .
alternative models , such as wave models of transmission of linguistic changes are also possible ( see for example @xcite ) , but we will not consider them in this paper
. it would be interesting to see whether statistical physics methods could be relevant to wave models of languages , but that is outside the purpose of our present investigation .
the second assumption listed above is clearly more problematic : it is a drastic simplification , which ignores phenomena of entailment between syntactic parameters .
indeed , it is well known that there are relations between different syntactic parameters , while our assumption leads us to treat them as independent spin variables .
for example , there are pairs of parameters @xmath1 with the property that if @xmath2 then @xmath3 is undefined , while if @xmath4 , then @xmath3 can take either value @xmath5 : see @xcite , @xcite for some explicit examples of this entailment behavior .
thus , in a more refined version of the model , the second assumption above should be modified in two ways : ( 1 ) an additional possible value @xmath6 of the parameters should be introduced , which accounts for the case where a parameter is undefined ; ( 2 ) relations between parameters should be introduced modeling the entailment property described above .
the first modification simply corresponds , in spin glass models , to considering potts models with number of possible spin states @xmath0 , instead of ising models with @xmath7 ( see @xcite for a survey of the mathematical properties and differences between these models ) , while the second modification requires relations ( at the vertices of the graph ) between different spin variables ( syntactic parameters ) and can be modeled on versions of potts models with external magnetic fields , @xcite .
we will first consider the simpler version of the model , with the second assumption as listed above , and then discuss the effect of introducing modifications as indicated here .
the case with entailment of parameters is discussed in [ entailsec ] .
a simple modification of the entailment model of [ entailsec ] also account for variants of the entailment relation ( see @xcite , @xcite ) where @xmath4 implies @xmath3 undefined , and @xmath2 implies @xmath8 , or where the parameter @xmath9 in entailed by more than one parameter .
the latter case requires the coupling at vertices of more than two spin glass models .
we will focus on only one case for simplicity . regarding the third assumption , since our model of interaction energies for the spin glass system
is based on measures of bilingualism , as obtained by media lab , the evolution of syntactic parameters that we describe would be best understood , linguistically , within the context of the theory of bilingual code - switching , @xcite .
for example , as observed in the study of @xcite of english spanish bilingual population , the language spoken by this population acquires " the pro - drop parameter ( which is @xmath10 in spanish but @xmath11 in english ) in the sense that spanish verbs inserted in english sentences retain their pro - drop form from spanish . in the evolution of syntactic parameters we obtain from the spin glass simulation , we see previously inactive @xmath11 parameters switch to the activated form @xmath10 as an effect of ferromagnetic " alignment with the corresponding parameters of nearest neighbor vertices . in a realistic model ,
this should be interpreted ( at least in a first phase of language evolution ) in the sense of code - switching theory , as imported forms from the neighboring languages that are inserted in the original syntactic structure , while retaining their parameters activated .
finally , we should comment on our overall choice of describing languages in terms of syntactic parameters , within the principles and parameters setting of @xcite , @xcite .
while this framework can been criticized , see for example @xcite , it is clear that coding syntactic structures as a string of binary variables makes it extremely suitable for modeling via statistical physics methods , hence it is a very natural setting for our purposes .
we proceed to a more detailed description of the model in the coming section .
the general data of a spin glass model ( potts model ) consist of a finite graph @xmath12 ; a finite set @xmath13 of possible spin states at a vertex , with @xmath14 ; a set @xmath15 of possible states of the system , namely assignments of a spin state in @xmath13 at each vertex in @xmath16 ; a set of interaction energies associated to the edges @xmath17 .
usually the energies are assumed to be equal to zero is the spins at the endpoints @xmath18 are not aligned and equal to a value @xmath19 if they are aligned .
ferromagnetic " case corresponds to the assumption that all @xmath20 and the
antiferromagnetic " case corresponds to @xmath21 .
one often expresses the interaction energies in terms of edge variables @xmath22 , where @xmath23 is a thermodynamic parameter ( an inverse temperature ) . in the ising model case , where spin variables have two possible values @xmath5 ,
a typical form of the hamiltonian of a spin glass model is , for states @xmath24 @xmath25 where @xmath26 is an external magnetic field : the first term measures the degree of alignment between nearby spins and the second the alignment of spins with the direction of the overall external field . when we allow for more general potts model cases , where the spin variables have @xmath27 possible values , hamiltonian is rewritten as @xmath28 the partition function of the system is @xmath29 and the associated gibbs probability measure is @xmath30 for more general cases , and a more detailed mathematical discussion see @xcite , @xcite .
in particular , one can fit into this model the case where there are two different interaction energies @xmath31 associated to the two opposite orientations of @xmath32 , by doubling all edges in the graph , so as to consider both orientations , with respective energies @xmath33 and @xmath34 .
this case will be relevant to our application . with these simplifications and resources ,
the stage is set to map the problem onto a classical statistical mechanics problem .
we identify each language with the vertex of a digraph , and each interaction of the form _ language @xmath35 influences language @xmath36 _ with a directed edge from vertex a to vertex b. such an edge has a weight or interaction strength @xmath37 given by the aforementioned metric used by mit media lab . note that in general , @xmath38 .
we represent the presence or absence of a particular syntactic parameter by associating with each vertex a spin-@xmath39 variable , where a spin of @xmath40 indicates the former and @xmath41 represents the latter . for simplicity , in the following we just use either @xmath10 or @xmath11 for the two possible spin states , as described above , referring to them as `` spin - up '' and `` spin - down '' , respectively , absorbing a factor of @xmath39 into the term @xmath42 .
the physical analog of this setup is the association of a particle with spin attributes to each vertex and inter - particle interactions with the edges , the usual setting of ising models in statistical physics . the full specification of the configuration of the system in the single - particle ( single - language ) basis is then given by @xmath43
, @xmath44 is the set of all parameters , and @xmath45 is the set of all languages . with this picture in mind
, we turn to the evolution . in this tensor product basis
, we can simulate the evolution of each of the 111 syntactic parameters , in the _ independent parameters approximation _
, by endowing the system with an interacting hamiltonian for each syntactic parameter : @xmath46 this hamiltonian is minimized by the alignment of adjacent spins , as @xmath47 .
note that this is not the most general form of spin glass models , where the hamiltonian typically contains additional disorder terms .
we are also not considering here the possible presence of terms playing the role of an external magnetic field b , as in .
we now need to impart dynamics into the model by introducing fluctuations or thermal noise .
continuing in the physical analogy , this system at thermal equilibrium with a heat bath " at temperature @xmath48 will have a distribution of configurations specified by the probability density function @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the normalization or partition function @xmath51 and @xmath52 an inverse temperature parameter ( or @xmath53 in physics , with @xmath54 the boltzmann constant ) .
once again , let us translate this to linguistics .
the temperature @xmath48 defines the extent to which languages are `` noisy '' due to external factors ( the heat bath ) ; if they are individually very noisy , then we can expect that these fluctuations will , on average at equilibrium , result in no overall alignment of a syntactic parameter ( magnetization of zero ) . in this limit , the languages fluctuate independently . on the other hand , at @xmath55 ,
all of the noise is frozen out , so the system will be found only in the configuration with the largest probability as per equation .
that is the ground state , or the state with minimum @xmath56 , in which all languages either possess or lack a given parameter ( magnetization of @xmath57 ) .
we comment more in detail here on the interpretation , in linguistics , of the temperature parameter of the spin glass model . as we mentioned above , we want to interpret that as a heat bath that introduces a certain level of noisiness in the behavior of the parameters . in linguistics , a new probabilistic approach to syntactic parameters was recently developed in @xcite .
it makes a strong case , based on an analysis of treebanks of different sizes for a sample of 20 languages , for viewing the syntactic parameters of a given language not as frozen on the up or down position , @xmath5 , but as a binary probability distribution @xmath58 , which expresses the tendency of the language of have a given syntactic parameter expressed or not .
for example , the case of the head - initial structure is analyzed in @xcite and it is shown that languages typically tend to express elements of both @xmath5 possibilities for this parameters , with a certain probability .
similar results are obtained , in the same paper , for subject - verb , object - verb , and adjective - noun parameters . in the light of this approach
, we can regard each language @xmath59 , and each parameter @xmath60 , as endowed with the additional data of probability distributions @xmath61 , which represent how noisy " the setting of the parameter @xmath60 is in the language @xmath59 . in general
, one expects that the probability distributions @xmath61 will be different for different languages @xmath59 and different parameter @xmath60 .
however , we can assume that they all depend on an overall thermodynamic parameter @xmath23 that can be tuned to increase or decrease the amount of noise .
in first approximation , one can assume for simplicity that all probabilities are the same , with a form like @xmath62 , so that , at zero temperature ( @xmath63 ) the parameter @xmath60 is set to @xmath10 without any noisiness ( or to @xmath11 in the symmetric case ) , while for @xmath64 ( at @xmath65 ) one has the maximum amount of noise , with the uniform distribution @xmath66 assigning equal probability to the two @xmath5 values of the syntactic parameter .
one can consider more general functions @xmath67 , which are continuous and monotonically interpolating between the values @xmath68 and @xmath69 .
for example , one can slightly modify the case discussed above by taking @xmath70 , where the exponents @xmath71 should be fitted to data like those collected in @xcite , so that there is some common value @xmath72 at which the probability distribution @xmath73 match the statistics for specific syntactic parameters in specific languages .
unfortunately , at present , we do not have a sufficiently large set of data , of the type collected in @xcite , to fully implement this analysis , so we only outlined here the general approach . in the form of the spin glass model described here above
, we made the overall simplifying assumption of treating all syntactic parameters as mutually independent and uncoupled .
thus , the spin glass model is simply an uncoupled collection of many independent ising models , with the same underlying graph topology and interaction energies , one for each parameter @xmath60 .
this independent parameters assumption " is the most problematic .
phenomena of entailment of parameters are well known , see @xcite , @xcite for specific examples . in such cases ,
what typically happen is that one or more parameters depend on the setting of another parameter ( or more ) . as a typical example
, we can take the case of two parameters @xmath74 with the property that , if the parameter @xmath75 is activated ( set to @xmath10 value ) in a language @xmath59 , then the second parameter @xmath9 can take either value @xmath10 or @xmath11 , while if @xmath75 is set to @xmath11 , then the parameter @xmath9 is just undefined in that language .
several such examples , in the family of indo - european languages , are reported in the table of syntactic parameters given in table a , figure 1 , in the appendix of @xcite .
we will focus on the analysis of one such example in [ entailsec ] .
in addition to the entailment problem , a more general problem , which is less well understood , is whether there are other dependencies between different syntactic parameters , and what would constitute a minimal number of independent binary variables .
this is part of the general critique that is addressed at the principles and parameters model , @xcite . for the purpose of the present paper
, we will ignore this further problem , and we will assume that , except for the entailment phenomena described above , the syntactic parameters can be considered independent and uncoupled . a statistical physics model of language acquisition and language evolution was developed in @xcite .
their model is also based on the principles and parameters approach .
however , the statistical physics model they construct is significantly different from the one we describe in the present paper .
they are mostly interested in modeling language acquisition .
they model by a gibbs state the probability with which a speaker selects sentences , so that the choice should follow euphonic considerations : how best a given sentence fits the prosodic patterns of the language . to this purpose
, they model prosody as a potential , which defines the hamiltonian of the gibbs state .
the grammar is then estimated by a maximum likelihood argument maximizing the gibbs probability measure .
another linguistic application of statistical physics models , and in particular of the ising spin glass model , occurs in 13.6.213.6.3 of @xcite .
this is a model of language evolution , where the author considers a population of linguistic agents , corresponding to the vertices of the graph , with edges representing the interaction between individual agents .
the model also assumes that there are two distinct languages in the population .
the adoption of one or the other language by a given speaker corresponds to the two possible spin states @xmath5 at that vertex in the spin glass system .
the inverse temperature parameter of the ising model is interpreted as the probability with which speakers of each language produce cues " ( in a cue - based learning algorithm ) .
the behavior of the system then models a situation where , above a certain critical temperature , individual agents behave independently and both languages are equally represented in the population , while below a critical temperature one language becomes dominant . to our knowledge , a model like ours , where the syntactic parameters themselves are treated as spin variables in a spin glass model , and interactions are modeled by bilingualism data , has not been previously considered . of the parameter , red colored vertices ) .
graph built on mit media lab data of language interaction . ]
equilibrium , all of the languages are expected to acquire the subject - verb parameter in the @xmath10 position . ]
equilibrium for the subject - verb parameter , all vertices have local magnetization close to zero , with half of them approaching zero from the positive direction . ]
having established the equilibrium physics expected of a spin glass model of syntax , we seek to explore the evolution of the system computationally . naively exploring the configuration space is computationally too expensive ,
so instead we employed a markov chain monte carlo simulation to propagate stochastically an initial configuration of syntactic parameter values ( as specified by the sswl ) toward equilibrium , through the metropolis algorithm , see for instance @xcite , @xcite .
the algorithm ( see , for instance , 2 and 3 of @xcite ) is based on the detailed balance condition @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the probability of transitioning from a state @xmath78 to a state @xmath79 , represents the condition that @xmath80 is the stationary distribution of a markov process with transition probabilities @xmath77 .
uniqueness of the stationary distribution follows from an ergodicity property of the markov process , usually implied by conditions of aperiodicity and positive recurrence . in the metropolis
hastings algorithm , a markov process with the required properties is constructed by obtaining transition probabilities @xmath77 in terms of acceptance - rejection rates : @xmath81 where @xmath82 is the conditional probability of proposing a state @xmath79 given the state @xmath78 and @xmath83 is the conditional probability of accepting the proposed state @xmath79 given @xmath78 .
the @xmath84 are normalized to add up to one , by requiring that , in the remaining cases the proposed state is @xmath85 .
the usual metropolis
hastings choice of the acceptance distribution is @xmath86 which satisfies the balance condition @xmath87 the selection probabilities @xmath88 in the metropolis hastings algorithm are chosen so that the ergodicity condition holds . in the case where the graph is a lattice , this
is usually achieved by considering single - spin - flip dynamics , where in each allowed transition @xmath89 the final state @xmath79 differs from the initial state @xmath78 by the flipping of a single spin . on these possible states ,
the probability is taken to be uniform , @xmath90 , with @xmath91 the number of allowed states . in the case where @xmath92 is the gibbs measure of a spin glass model ,
a choice of the acceptance probabilities @xmath93 that satisfy the detailed balance condition is given by setting @xmath94 namely , a new state @xmath79 with energy lower than or equal to that of @xmath78 is automatically accepted , while one with a higher energy is accepted with probability @xmath95 . see
3.1 of @xcite for more details .
( left ) and in the high temperature range @xmath96 ( right ) , as a function of the number of steps in the monte carlo simulation . ]
the ergodicity property is necessary for the working of the metropolis
hastings algorithm .
a markov chain is ergodic if and only if it is irreducible and aperiodic .
irreducibility is the condition that the markov process can reach any possible state of the system starting from any given state in a finite number of steps .
a state is periodic if the chain can return to it only at multiples of some period @xmath97 .
aperiodicity is the absence of periodic states ( @xmath98 for all states ) . under the assumption of single - spin - flip dynamics , ergodicity is satisfied for the ising model on a lattice ( see 3.1 of @xcite ) .
the graph we consider here is not a lattice .
however , it makes sense in terms of the linguistic interpretation of the model , to assume a similar type of single - spin - flip dynamics . for similar arguments in favor of single - spin - flip dynamics in models of language acquisition and evolution , see @xcite .
ergodicity of the metropolis hastings algorithm , with the single - spin - flip dynamics , still holds for our graph .
the following simple argument applies more generally .
irreducibility can be checked using the notion of accessibility .
given states @xmath78 and @xmath79 , let @xmath99 denote the minimum number of steps needed for the markov chain to reach @xmath79 starting at @xmath78 .
the state @xmath79 is accessible from @xmath78 if there is a positive probability that @xmath100 .
suppose that the states @xmath78 and @xmath79 differ at a certain set @xmath101 of sites , with @xmath102 and @xmath103 .
then @xmath104 . let @xmath105 be the set of all @xmath106 orderings of the elements of @xmath35 .
for @xmath107 , and @xmath108 , let @xmath109 be the corresponding list of @xmath110 states in @xmath111 , each obtained from the previous one by flipping the spin located at the site @xmath112 .
the probability @xmath113 is then the sum of the products of the probability of obtaining a string @xmath114 in @xmath105 by choosing uniformly randomly a sequence of @xmath110 elements in @xmath16 , times the product of the probabilities of the flipping of the individual spins at the sites @xmath115 for @xmath116 , @xmath117 the precise values of these probabilities depends on the topology of the graph @xmath12 , through the set of edges , that determine the change in energy between successive states , according to .
it is however cleat that @xmath118 , hence all states are accessible from a given one , which is equivalent to the irreducibility condition for the markov chain . for a single parameter ,
the set @xmath119 of possible states has @xmath120 .
the number of states @xmath121 that are accessible from a given state @xmath122 , in a single - spin - flip dynamics , is the number of states that differ from @xmath122 by flipping a single spin at one of the vertices .
hence , for any given @xmath122 , there are @xmath103 accessible states @xmath121 .
the probability of choosing one of these states is uniform @xmath123 . for a given state @xmath122
, we have @xmath124 if and only if all the accessible states @xmath121 with @xmath125 have lower energy , so that all @xmath126 and @xmath127 .
thus , states @xmath128 with @xmath124 are maxima of the energy .
all other states @xmath122 have @xmath129 , hence they are aperiodic states of the markov chain . if a markov chain is irreducible then all states have same period , hence the remaining states must also be aperiodic . together with irreducibility this implies ergodicity .
thus , if we focus on the behavior of a single syntactic parameter , we simply have a ising model on our graph of languages @xmath12 , with given interaction energies , and we apply the metropolis hastings algorithm as above .
when we consider more than one parameter at the same time , so that states are of the form @xmath130 , under the simplifying assumption that different syntactic parameters are independent of each other , we just run the same kind of metropolis
hastings algorithm on each parameter , by each time flipping a single spin @xmath122 of a single parameter @xmath60 .
namely , we proceed as described above , using the metropolis
hastings algorithm with single - spin - flip dynamics .
we propagate a state @xmath131 by proposing a configuration @xmath132 and accepting it , @xmath133 , or rejecting it , @xmath134 , with some probability . to simplify the noise ,
we assume it acts by trying to flip the spin at each vertex independently , although in reality this is more likely to occur in clusters . at each step , the algorithm chooses a vertex at random and tries to flip its spin , accepting or rejecting the flip according to : @xmath135 propagating the state for many steps produces a distribution of configurations that asymptotically approaches equation , allowing one to calculate thermal averages of various functions ( such as magnetization ) by evaluating them on the state at each step and averaging over steps .
we now discuss how one can adapt the previous computational setting to the more refined model that also takes into consideration dependencies and entailment of syntactic parameters .
the first modification in the model consists of the fact that we use , for each parameter , a set of three possible values @xmath136 instead of the binary values @xmath137 , thus allowing for the possibility that a parameter may be undefined ( by effect of the values of other parameters ) .
thus , instead of the ising model , we are looking at a potts model with @xmath0 .
the natural generalization of the metropolis dynamics of the ising model is the wider class of glauber dynamics on graphs , where the single - spin - flip dynamics is replaced by the assumption that each move changes the parameter value at just one vertex , by choosing a possible value uniformly at random .
consider again the situation described in
[ entsec1 ] , where we have two parameters @xmath74 with the property that , if the parameter @xmath138 then the parameter @xmath9 can take values @xmath5 , while if the parameter @xmath139 then @xmath9 is undefined . as before , we associate spin variables @xmath140 and @xmath141 to the two parameters , but now we assume that @xmath140 has two possible spin states @xmath137 , as before , while @xmath141 has three possible spin states , @xmath142 , with @xmath6 for the case when the parameter is undefined . thus , we see that , in order to accommodate the entailment relations , we need to construct a multivariable spin glass model , where some of the spin variables associated to the vertices behave like an ising model ( with number of spin states @xmath7 ) , while other variables behave like a potts model ( with number of spin states @xmath0 ) .
moreover , the entailment relation should be modeled by additional interaction terms in the hamiltonian , that couple the variables @xmath140 and @xmath141 , in such a way that the configurations with @xmath143 and @xmath144 , and with @xmath145 and @xmath146 are favored energetically over all the other possible combinations .
this leads us into a new class of spin glass model , which to our knowledge has not been considered in physics so far , where different spin variables , with different numbers of spin states coexist on the same graph and are coupled with one another .
we describe a possible choice of an interaction term that achieves the desired result .
we focus on a case with only two parameters @xmath147 with an entailment relation as above .
let @xmath148 be the spin variables , as before , where @xmath149 and @xmath150 .
we consider a change of variable for the first spin , with the new variable @xmath151 defined by @xmath152 .
this just corresponds to the two possible choices of representing the group @xmath153 in the additive form @xmath154 or in the multiplicative form @xmath155 .
we also associate to the spin variables @xmath156 a variable @xmath157 .
we then consider a hamiltonian given by the sum of two terms @xmath158 , where the term @xmath159 expresses the edge interactions between different languages , as in , written in the potts model form @xmath160 where we treat the two parameters as independent , while the interaction between the parameters due to the entailment relation is encoded in the @xmath161 term as @xmath162 for @xmath163 , this gives an anti - ferromagnetic pairing between the variables @xmath164 and @xmath165 .
the preferred energy states for the hamiltonian @xmath161 are those where either @xmath166 and @xmath167 , or @xmath168 and @xmath169 , which correspond , respectively , to the entailment relations @xmath170 and @xmath171 , or @xmath172 and @xmath173 .
notice that the size of the parameters @xmath174 in the term @xmath161 in the hamiltonian determine how strongly enforced the entailment relation is in a given language : for @xmath175 , an infinite energy barrier separates the ground states @xmath176 from the excited states @xmath177 , hence the entailment is strongly enforced , while lower values of @xmath174 would imply that the language @xmath59 admits a certain frequency of exceptions to this syntactic rule .
these should be interpreted in the same sense as the probabilistic approach to setting syntactic parameters discussed in @xcite , see also the discussion in [ tempsec ] above .
notice that , if we freeze one of the parameter @xmath75 and only consider the evolution of the second parameter , then the hamiltonian above can be regarded simply as a case of potts model with external magnetic field .
we then run the analog of the metropolis
hastings algorithm for the hamiltonian @xmath178 on the graph of languages and language interactions .
since we now have spin variables with more than two possible states , instead of the single - spin - flip dynamics one uses the appropriate glauber dynamics . for general results about ergodicity and convergence time of glauber dynamics on some classes of graphs ,
we refer the reader to @xcite , @xcite . in the simple case we analyze in [ entailsec ] below
, we will work with a complete graph , so the results of @xcite apply .
part of the implementation consisted of parsing and converting the sswl database of syntactic parameters in a form usable for data analysis .
additionally , discrepancies in nomenclature between the mit media lab topology source and the sswl database had to be identified and manually resolved .
the implementation for the independent parameters simulation was executed in matlab .
the implementation for the entailment of parameters was executed in java .
the source files of the code are available at the github repository : ` https://github.com/pointofnoreturn/spin_glass_model `
as a first simulation , we consider all parameters as independent spin variables , hence we can focus on just one parameter at a time and run a single - parameter simulation .
we report here the case of the subject - verb parameter as an illustrative example : we describe the behavior at low and high temperature @xmath48 , averaging over a million steps .
this is enough to obtain a clear understanding of the phase diagrams of simulations for all of the other parameters , when considered independently .
the code in the github repository can be used to generate analogous simulations for all parameters . here
, when we refer to the `` low '' and `` high '' temperature regimes , we mean the range in which the ratio @xmath179 is very small or , respectively , very large .
the initial state specified by the sswl is given in figure [ init ] , where the vertices are represented as circular nodes colored red if the language possesses the parameter or blue if it lacks the parameter .
the sizes of the vertices do not signify anything in these graphs : variable sizes are only used for ease of visualization .
figure [ init ] suggests that the vast majority of languages currently possess this parameter in the activated form @xmath10 .
evolving this system at very low temperature ( @xmath180 ) , we want to know the local magnetization , or the thermal average of the spin value at each vertex .
since we are in the low temperature regime , we expect that the vertices will tend to orient their spins in the same direction ( either all of the languages will tend to possess the parameter or will lack it ) . marking vertices with @xmath181 red and vertices with @xmath182 blue , we can look at a graph of these languages at equilibrium , given in figure [ smallt ] . as expected , since the system is close to @xmath55 , it is also close to the ground state .
in fact , a configuration randomly sampled from the equilibrium ensemble will also look like figure [ smallt ] nearly 100% of the time , because of how dominant the all - up configuration is : it is nearly impossible at low @xmath48 for the state to propagate to a configuration that is not the ground state . at @xmath55 ,
this is the only configuration in the ensemble . at this low temperature ,
the languages quickly converge during their evolution to a state in which they all acquire the parameter in the activated form @xmath10 . a more physical way to view this is to look at a plot of the average spin as a function of time , as given in the first graph of figure [ avgspinfig ] .
one may wonder why this system always ends up in this `` all - up '' state instead of an `` all - down '' state .
the key is that the initial configuration is dominated by spin - up vertices , so the energy barrier is much higher for a droplet of spin - down to expand and dominate the system than it is for the sea of spin - up to swallow the droplets .
what happens when @xmath48 is very large ?
taking @xmath96 , the local magnetizations approach zero , with exactly half of the vertices approaching zero from the positive direction as in figure [ larget ] .
in fact , the local magnetizations vary with mean @xmath183 and median @xmath184 on the interval @xmath185 $ ] . in this case
, a configuration picked at random from the equilibrium ensemble is most likely to have approximately half of the vertices with spin up .
because @xmath48 is large , a state can propagate to almost any other configuration fairly easily . at equilibrium ,
the languages here evolve approximately independently of each other , so the average ( over vertices ) spin fluctuates about zero , as in the second graph of figure [ avgspinfig ] .
there are then two points to note : the model behaves as predicted , and it is marked by the same symmetry - breaking phase transition observed in the 2d ising ferromagnet at a critical temperature .
this is not surprising , since this model is at its core just a ferromagnet with a more complicated topology .
we consider here a simple case where we focus on two parameters with an entailment relation , over a small set of indo - european languages . in this case , we take the data on the values of the syntactic parameters from @xcite , @xcite , while we still use the same data from the mit media lab database for the interaction strengths between different languages . in this simulation
we used the media lab data based on book translations instead of wikipedia editing .
( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / high energy ( ht / he ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / high energy ( lt / he ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps in the monte carlo simulation.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / high energy ( ht / he ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / high energy ( lt / he ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps in the monte carlo simulation.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / high energy ( ht / he ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / high energy ( lt / he ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps in the monte carlo simulation.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / high energy ( ht / he ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / high energy ( lt / he ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps in the monte carlo simulation.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / low energy ( ht / le ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / low energy ( lt / le ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / low energy ( ht / le ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / low energy ( lt / le ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / low energy ( ht / le ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / low energy ( lt / le ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath186 ( right ) in the high temperature / low energy ( ht / le ) regime ( top ) and in the low temperature / low energy ( lt / le ) regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / he regime ( top ) and the lt / he regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / he regime ( top ) and the lt / he regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / he regime ( top ) and the lt / he regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / he regime ( top ) and the lt / he regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / le regime ( top ) and the lt / le regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / le regime ( top ) and the lt / le regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / le regime ( top ) and the lt / le regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] ( left ) and for @xmath187 ( right ) in the ht / le regime ( top ) and the lt / le regime ( bottom ) , as a function of the number of steps.,title="fig : " ] we consider , for example two parameters @xmath147 expressing definiteness ( respectively , number 7 and 12 in the list in table a of @xcite ) .
the first parameter @xmath75 expresses partial definiteness , while the parameter @xmath9 is definiteness checking .
see for instance @xcite for a discussion of the role of these parameters .
we consider three languages : english , russian , and bulgarian .
we input interaction energies taken from the same mit media lab data graph , and we neglect the effect of interaction with other languages .
the initial configuration of the two parameters , taken from table a of @xcite is according to the following table : [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] these examples are only illustrative and not entirely realistic , because we have singled out a small portion of the language graph that exhibits an interesting configuration of entailed parameters in the initial state , and we have run the simulation neglecting the interactions with all the other languages in the rest of the larger language graphs , which will also affect the behavior of the system . these examples , however , are interesting because they show situations where a configuration of entailed parameters reaches an equilibrium states where parameters of the individual languages have undergone some changes , but have not always converged to a configuration where all the parameters are aligned . while in the first example one obtains complete alignment of all the parameters in the low temperature and low energy regime , in the second example , even in this range , parameters do not fully align .
this shows that the presence of entailment between syntactic parameters can have a substantial effect on the dynamics that differs significantly in outcome from the case where one assumes an independence hypothesis on parameters .
in this paper , we introduced a new tool to study the flow of syntactic parameters by mapping the problem onto a spin glass model .
this tool provides some flexibility , as one could provide any topology and any adjacency matrix .
we have shown that , under a hypothesis of independence between syntactic parameters , in the evolution of the system parameters tend to align to the @xmath10 position .
we related this to linguistic models of bilingual code - switching .
we also showed that , when entailment relations between parameters are taken into account , the uncoupled ising models are replaced by a coupling at the vertices of ising and potts models with same edge interactions .
one obtains then more complicated equilibrium configurations , depending on the entailment energy parameter , which gives the strength of the coupling , and its relation to the temperature " parameter . even in the low energy and low temperature regime
one finds cases that do not yield a complete alignment of parameters . one factor not accounted for in this project was the number of speakers for each language , which could significantly change the interaction strengths .
another interesting scenario would involve disordering terms in which two interacting languages actually prefer to antialign their parameters .
an overall hypothesis of this model is that the interaction energies along the edges , which are modeled on estimates of the size of the bilingual population , remain constant during the evolution . in a realistic model
, the strength of the interaction would also be co - evolving .
it is also likely that factors such as the existence of better and more efficient automated translators will eventually cause drastic changes in the size of human bilingual or multilingual populations , so the feasibility of such models of linguistic evolution may also be altered by external factors of this sort .
this work was performed as part of the activities of the last author s mathematical and computational linguistics lab and cs101/ma191 class at caltech .
the last author is partially supported by nsf grants dms-1201512 and phy-1205440 .
m. cassandro , p. collet , a. galves , c. galves , _ a statistical - physics approach to language acquisition and language change _ , physica a : statistical mechanics and its applications , vol.263 ( 1999 ) 427437 .
a. cornilescu , a. nicolae , _ on the syntax of romanian definite phrases : changes in the patterns of definiteness checking _ , in the noun phrase in romance and germanic " , pp.193221 , john benjamins , 2011 .
sokal , _ the multivariate tutte polynomial ( alias potts model ) for graphs and matroids _ , in surveys in combinatorics 2005 " , 173226 , london math .
lecture note ser . , 327 , cambridge univ . press , 2005 . | using the sswl database of syntactic parameters of world languages , and the mit media lab data on language interactions , we construct a spin glass model of language evolution .
we treat binary syntactic parameters as spin states , with languages as vertices of a graph , and assigned interaction energies along the edges .
we study a rough model of syntax evolution , under the assumption that a strong interaction energy tends to cause parameters to align , as in the case of ferromagnetic materials .
we also study how the spin glass model needs to be modified to account for entailment relations between syntactic parameters .
this modification leads naturally to a generalization of potts models with external magnetic field , which consists of a coupling at the vertices of an ising model and a potts model with @xmath0 , that have the same edge interactions .
we describe the results of simulations of the dynamics of these models , in different temperature and energy regimes .
we discuss the linguistic interpretation of the parameters of the physical model . |
the mechanics and physics of soft materials are intrinsically complex due to the strongly time - dependent and usually non - linear constitutive stress - strain relations that govern their response .
further intricacy is added when soft bodies are brought into contact and the problem is exacerbated by the geometry of the intimately mating surfaces . in the last two decades , the continuously growing technological relevance of engineering applications involving polymeric materials and soft tissues _ _ _ _ has generated enormous interest in the scientific community and has contributed to a leap in the number of publications in the field gorb , bio3,vertebrae ; these span investigations performed across the scales , from macroscopic to atomistic levels , and include analytical hunter , persson2001 numerical @xcite and experimental @xcite studies .
surprisingly , in spite of these vast research efforts , our understanding of soft matter problems is definitely far from being complete . in this paper , we focus our attention on an issue that has been systematically ignored but has a crucial importance : the reciprocating contact of viscoelastic materials , where the relative motion between the contacting bodies is periodically inverted . indeed , researchers have almost universally developed models to investigate unidirectional steady - state sliding between two mating surfaces made of viscoelastic material persson2001,carboneputignano .
however , steady - state assumption can not be considered a universally valid condition .
there is a countless variety of engineering applications , ranging from the macro- to the nano- scales , where a periodic inversion of the motion direction is present . earthquake viscoelastic dampers are a classic example @xcite .
these devices are embedded in civil structures to limit the consequences of earthquakes by introducing a source of damping , that is , beyond the several possible configurations , the hysteretic dissipation occurring when a set of rigid punches deforms a layer of rubber .
currently , the design in this field mostly relies on practical and empirical guidelines , and no tool for quantitative predictions is available .
this lack of a robust theoretical framework involves also very different components , like all the sealing systems in mechanical applications with an alternate motion @xcite . indeed
, enhancing performances and efficiency is infeasible without an accurate knowledge of the interfacial stresses and , consequently , of the dissipated power .
finally , reciprocating contacts have prominence also at different scales and in different contexts , like biology and biotechnology ( @xcite,@xcite ) .
skin , ocular system , joints , spine and vertebrae are some of the examples where viscoelastic soft contact occurs in the human body . as recently suggested in ref .
@xcite , this can be observed up to the cell scale , thus introducing the concept of cell friction .
indeed , ref .
@xcite shows experimental results for reciprocating contact tests on layers of epithelial cells : what is obtained in terms of friction can not be explained with a simple elastic model and needs a specific theory .
the schematic in fig .
[ figure0 ] captures the variety of surfaces whose function and/or performance can be ameliorated by shedding light on the principles governing the problem under investigation . in this work ,
we develop a theoretical approach and a numerical technique that , for the first time , allow studying reciprocating contact mechanics between linearly viscoelastic solids and provide predictions of the response of the contacting surfaces in terms of stresses , strain and friction .
the paper is outlined as follows .
section ii describes the mathematical formulation which the numerical methodology relies on .
section iii focuses on a simple , tough explicative , case , i.e. the reciprocating sliding contact of a sphere over a viscoelastic layer .
final remarks are included to comment on the relevance of the theory and of the results .
appendixes a and b respectively discuss the validity range of the model and provide a comparison with steady - state conditions .
the proposed formulation builds on the strengths of the boundary element method ( bem ) in terms of accurately capturing interfacial stresses and displacements , and , as such , requires the determination of a viscoelastic reciprocating green s function @xmath0 . to this end , let us first assume that the interfacial normal stress distribution obeys the law @xmath1 $ ] , i.e. that the shape of normal stress distribution is fixed but moves on the viscoelastic half - space with a sinusoidal law of amplitude @xmath2 and angular frequency @xmath3 .
the vector @xmath4also identifies the direction of the reciprocating motion .
because of linearity and translational invariance , replacing @xmath5 allows to write the relation between interfacial stresses and displacement as@xmath6 in order to determine @xmath0 , we recall that the general relation between stress and displacement fields is carboneputignano : @xmath7 where @xmath8 and @xmath9 are the elastic green s function and the creep material function respectively .
the symbol ` @xmath10 ' stands for the time derivative . the creep function
is easily linked to the viscoelastic modulus @xmath11 of the material by means of the relation @xmath12 @xcite , where @xmath13 is the imaginary unit and the fourier transform of a function @xmath14 is @xmath15 .
the viscoelastic modulus has the general expression @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is a real quantity corresponding to the elastic modulus of the material at very large excitation frequencies .
@xmath18 is usually defined as the creep spectrum , and @xmath19 is the relaxation time @xcite . in order to find @xmath20 we choose @xmath21 @xmath22 @xmath23 $ ] and , after substituting in eq .
( [ visco_principle ] ) , we obtain@xmath24 \notag \\ & + \int_{-\infty } ^{t}d\tau \mathcal{\dot{j}}\left ( t-\tau \right ) \mathcal{g% } \left [ \mathbf{x-\xi } _ { 0}\sin \left ( \omega \tau \right ) \right ] .
\label{greenfunct}\end{aligned}\]]the term @xmath25 $ ] can be re - written as @xmath26 = \left ( 2\pi \right ) ^{-2}\int d^{2}q\mathcal{g}\left ( \mathbf{q}\right ) e^{-i\mathbf{q}\cdot \left [ \mathbf{x-\xi } _ { 0}\sin \left ( \omega t\right ) % \right ] } , \label{elasticgreen}\]]where @xmath27 is the fourier transform of the function @xmath8 .
now , let us observe that @xmath28 is equal to @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the @xmath31-th order bessel function of the first kind . consequently , eq .
( [ elasticgreen ] ) can be casted as@xmath26 = \sum_{k=-\infty } ^{+\infty } a_{k}\left ( \mathbf{x}\right ) e^{ik\omega t}. \label{elasticgreen_rewritten}\]]in eq .
( [ elasticgreen_rewritten ] ) , @xmath32 can be written as @xmath33 with @xmath34 being equal to @xmath35 .
@xmath36 is the chebyshev polynomial of the first kind and @xmath37 , for @xmath38 and @xmath39 otherwise . substituting ( [ elasticgreen_rewritten ] ) in ( greenfunct ) we obtain : @xmath40 as mentioned above ,
the function @xmath0 has been obtained under the assumption that the shape of the stress field at the interface , whose general form is @xmath41 $ ] , does not change during the reciprocating motion , _
i.e. _ @xmath42 $ ] .
such a condition holds true whenever @xmath43 , where @xmath44 the characteristic dimension of the contact region , and is equivalent to require that @xmath45 ( see appendix a for more details ) .
this assumption is justified in the majority of cases of reciprocating contact , and is satisfied point - wise almost everywhere within the contact area in the analyses presented in this work .
now , to invert the linear operator in eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) we need a numerical approach which consists in discretizing the contact domain in @xmath46 square cells .
indeed , assuming that in each boundary element the normal stress @xmath47 is constant and equal to @xmath48 , the normal displacement @xmath49 at the centre @xmath50 of the @xmath13-th square can be written as : @xmath51 \sum_{k=-\infty}^{+\infty}\frac{e^{ik\omega t}\left ( -i\right ) ^{k}}{e\left ( k\omega\right ) } \cos\left [ k\left ( \frac { 2r-1}{2n}\pi\right ) % \right ] \label{eqfinale}\ ] ] where @xmath52 is related to the love s solution johnson .
it should be observed that eq .
( [ eqfinale ] ) is obtained by applying the chebishev - gauss quadrature rule to the integral term @xmath53 \left ( 1-s^{2}\right ) ^{-1/2}$ ] at @xmath46 nodes , thus making it easier to achieve the numerical convergence of the problem .
( [ visco_principle ] ) can be solved by using the iterative technique developed in ref .
@xcite for elastic contacts , thus providing contact areas , stresses and strains .
it should be noticed that the method does not require any discretization of the time domain as the time @xmath54 is treated as a parameter .
once the solution is known in terms of stresses and strains , following the approach stated in ref .
@xcite , it is straightforward to calculate the viscoelastic friction force as : @xmath55 the friction coefficient is then obtained as @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the external applied load . finally , we conclude noticing that the formulation , in the current form , does not explicitly account for the role of the tangential tractions at the contact interface . indeed , this is out of the scope of our work .
the purpose of the paper is to determine the normal stresses and the normal displacements distribution , and , on this basis , calculate the viscoelastic friction that is proportional to the volume of deformed material .
it is well known that the normal and tangential contact problems have only a very weak coupling , which is normally neglected @xcite .
furthermore , in the case of a rigid body in contact with a soft layer which can be usually assumed incompressible- , it is absolutely rigorous to assert that tractions has no influence on normal pressure and displacements , and , consequently , on the viscoelastic dissipation @xcite .
we study the contact of a rigid sphere of radius @xmath58 undergoing reciprocating sliding against a viscoelastic material characterized by one relaxation time ( being the ratio between the high frequency modulus and the low frequency @xmath59 and the poisson ratio @xmath60 ) .
we assume that the center @xmath61 of the sphere moves on the viscoelastic half - space following the law @xmath62 $ ] .
the dimensionless angular frequency of the reciprocating motion is @xmath63 @xmath64 , being @xmath19 the relaxation time of the viscoelastic material .
figure [ figure1 ] shows the evolution of the dimensionless displacements , @xmath65 , at the centre of the contact as a function of @xmath66 and for a specific dimensionless applied normal load @xmath67 , and @xmath68 .
results are shown for different values of @xmath69 $ ] .
an arrow refers , in each case , to the current position of the sphere . at @xmath70 the sphere
has just reached the left dead - point and starts moving from left to right . upon reversal of the sliding direction , and for @xmath71 , a marked increase of the dimensionless penetration at the center of the sphere is observed .
this is due to the fact that , although the speed is increasing , it is still too low to cause a significant stiffening of the material , and the sphere is also moving over a portion of the viscoelastic half - space that has not yet had the time to relax after the previous contact of the rigid body . as the sliding speed increases , a non negligible stiffening of the material and a marked decrease of the penetration are observed ( see displacement in correspondence to the arrow ) .
this is clearly shown by curves at @xmath72 , which also show additional deformation peaks , one at the left and one to the right of the arrow : this is the result of the interplay between the deformations , induced by the indenter as it moves to the right , and the original not yet fully relaxed footprints left by the sphere at preceding times . for @xmath73 , the sliding speed begins to decrease and the material softens again , thus leading to an increase of penetration .
it is now possible to justify the occurrence of three different deformations peaks within the track when the sphere is moving between the two dead - ends : one corresponds to the current position of the sphere and the other two are located close to the left and right dead - points respectively , and are the result of the material inability to fully recover the viscoelastic deformations during a period of time comparable to the period @xmath74 @xmath75of the reciprocating motion ( recall that the relaxation time is @xmath76 ) .
the merging or separation of the previous and current sphere footprints , which takes place close to the dead - points of the reciprocating motion , has a significant effect on the interfacial normal stress distribution .
this is clearly shown in figure [ figure2 ] , which depicts the evolution of the pressure distribution and shows the shape of the contact area .
let us first observe that at @xmath77 @xmath78 , _
i.e. _ when the sliding speed goes to zero , the contact area as well as the interfacial normal stress distribution are characterized by an asymmetric shape . the observed asymmetry and , in particular ,
the presence of a peak on the left of the contact patch is a consequence of the viscoelastic time - delay which prevents the material to relax immediately when the sliding speed vanishes . as the sphere starts moving to the right
, such a peak can not disappear suddenly but has to show a gradual decrease . at the same time , since the punch is travelling towards the right , as already observed in steady - state viscoelastic contacts moving at constant velocity @xcite , a peak in the pressure distribution has to be originated also at the leading edge .
finally , at the center of the distribution , where we have the maximum of the displacement field in the contact area , the pressure must still resemble the classical elastic hertzian solution .
all this process strongly affects the evolution of the pressure distribution at the interface with the presence of multiple pressure peaks shown by the snapshots taken at @xmath79 ( the reader may refer to appendix b to appreciate the difference with steady - state conditions ) . a single peaked pressure distribution is later recovered : indeed , an asymmetric pressure profile marked by a peak closer to the contact leading edge is visible at @xmath77 @xmath80 .
we may observe that , for a single relaxation time material , in addition to the ratio @xmath81 , the behavior of the reciprocating contact is also governed by other two dimensionless parameters .
the first dimensionless group is @xmath82 @xmath83 , where @xmath84 and @xmath85is the hertzian contact radius .
this parameter can be also interpreted as a dimensionless sliding speed @xcite and compares the relaxation time @xmath19 with the time @xmath86 needed by the sphere to cover a distance @xmath44 .
the second group , @xmath87 , compares , instead , the time @xmath86 with the period @xmath88 of the reciprocating motion . since we have earlier assumed that in our problem @xmath89 , we can focus on observing how the solution is affected by @xmath90 . for extremely small or extremely high values of @xmath91
the response of the system is elastic ( governed by either the high or the low frequency elastic limit of the material ) , and no tangential contact force will be generated . at intermediate values of @xmath92
, viscoelasticity will affect the solution leading to asymmetric contact areas and pressure distributions , and to the generation of tangential contact forces .
in such a case , given the dimensionless parameter @xmath93 , if @xmath94 , the reciprocating motion will occur on time - scales longer than the relaxation time @xmath19 of the material and the system will resemble the steady - state behavior of the contact between a sphere moving on a viscoelastic half - space at constant speed @xcite .
if @xmath95 , as in the case of fig .
[ figure2 ] , a strong interaction will be observed between different viscoelastic regions of the path covered by the sphere during the reciprocating motion .
note that , under the assumption small @xmath96 values ( which has been always adopted in this paper ) , the condition @xmath97 implies @xmath98 , and , in this case , the elastic response of the material will be recovered : the sphere will be just performing very fast oscillations , leading to a local stiffening and , ultimately , to a high frequency elastic behavior . in figure [ figure3 ] ,
the reduced tangential force , @xmath99 , easily calculated once pressures and displacements are known @xcite , is plotted as a function of the dimensionless abscissa @xmath66 , which identifies the position of the sphere along the path , for different values of @xmath100 . for @xmath101 the material has the possibility to relax before a single reciprocating cycle is completed . in this case , as the solution resembles the steady - state viscoelastic sliding contact , the tangential force @xmath99 always opposes the sphere speed at each point along the path .
however , as @xmath100 is increased ( see _ e.g. _ results for @xmath102 presented in figure [ figure3 ] ) the relaxation of the material involves time scales comparable to the time period of the reciprocating motion ; in this case , there exist regions on the sphere track , specifically those close to the dead - points , where @xmath99 has the same direction as the sliding speed .
this is perfectly consistent with the results presented in figure [ figure2 ] .
this work provides the explicit solution , in terms of a fourier series , of the green s function of the reciprocating contact problem between a rigid punch and a linear viscoelastic solid .
the periodic features , intrinsically marking the problem , enables the parametric calculation of the contact solution for each time step without any necessity of employing the solution in the previous time interval . by implementing such a parametrically time - dependent approach
, we obtain the full numerical convergence in each moment of the cycle and , interestingly , also when the punch inverts its motion .
for the simple case of a sphere in contact with a viscoelastic layer , we show that the behavior of the system is completely determined by two parameters , that are @xmath82 @xmath83 and @xmath103 _ . _
depending on these two parameters , the viscoelastic reciprocating contact may present a wide variety of different behaviors , ranging from the case that can be captured by the steady - state solution for viscoelastic sliding to the case where such interactions lead to the formation of a multi - peaked interfacial pressure distribution and tangential contact forces in ( rather than opposing ) the direction of the sliding speed .
this may have important implications in terms of design of materials and solutions for different applications as it would enable to accurately capture deformation rates , stress distributions and viscoelastic friction during reciprocation .
indeed , these are the key quantities to understand cell growth and skin / counterface interactions , as well as to predict frictional energy dissipation in _ e.g. _ mechanical seals and earthquake dampers .
when dealing with materials marked by a linear response , the displacement distribution can be related to the interfacial pressures by means of a convolution integral with a time- and space - dependent function , i.e. the green s function .
we may , then , formulate the general contact problem between a rigid indenter and a linearly viscoelastic slab as : @xmath104 where @xmath105 is the in - plane position vector , @xmath54 is the time , @xmath106 is the normal surface displacement of the viscoelastic slab , @xmath21 is the normal interfacial stress , @xmath8 and @xmath107 are respectively the elastic green s function and the creep material function .
the relevance of such an approach is related to its generality : no assumption is made _ a priori _ on the shape of the contact domain . indeed , the method can be employed for any kind of contact punch and even for rough surfaces : conditions , like periodic boundaries and finite values of contacting layers thickness , can be easily managed carbone2008,putignanoijss2 . furthermore , since the creep function @xmath108 is absolutely general , the approach is capable of dealing with any linearly viscoelastic material , from skin tissues to rubber - based composites .
however , solving directly eq .
( [ general formulaion ] ) may be extremely challenging : due to the necessity of performing discretization both in time and space , the computational cost is huge and often infeasible with the computational technologies currently available .
consequently , when focusing our attention on the reciprocating contacts , our efforts are aimed at reducing the computational complexity of eq .
( [ general formulaion ] ) without loosing its generality in terms of contact geometry and material properties . indeed , by assuming that the shape of the interfacial normal stress distribution does not change , i.e. assuming that it obeys the law @xmath109 $ ] - where @xmath110 and @xmath3 are respectively the amplitude and angular frequency of the sinusoidal law- , eq .
( [ general formulaion ] ) can be re - written in the form stated in eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) .
this expression has a significant advantage : it does not require any discretization of the time domain since @xmath54 is present just as a parameter of the viscoelastic reciprocating green s function @xmath0 .
such a formulation enables us to employ the efficient computational techniques already developed for the purely elastic case @xcite and , therefore , to find the solution for a reciprocating contact .
incidentally , we observe that , from a physical point of view , passing from eq .
( [ general formulaion ] ) to eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) is fully justified recalling the periodic features of the system under investigation . in this paper , we determine @xmath0 and investigate the main peculiarities of the reciprocating contact mechanics .
indeed , when developing the mathematical formulation , we rely on the aforementioned condition of a constant shape of the interfacial stress distribution .
recalling that the total time derivative of pressure field is @xmath111 , the condition implies that , the local rate of change in the pressure @xmath112 , which occurs on time - scales of the order of the period @xmath113 of the reciprocating motion , should be negligible compared to the rate of change of pressure due to the convective term @xmath114 , which occurs on time - scale of @xmath86 , where @xmath86 is the time needed by the sphere to cover a distance of the order of the contact radius @xmath44 .
this then requires that @xmath115 .
this can be easily shown by estimating the local time derivative and the convective term and requiring that @xmath116 , i.e.@xmath117where @xmath118 is the maximum contact pressure and , then , by taking the ratio of the derivative terms , one obtains : @xmath119 at the end of each stroke during reciprocation , the aforementioned condition may look critical since the velocity of the sphere tends to vanish ; however , since the time the sphere spends at the dead points of the cyclic sliding motion is also zero , things have to be observed a bit more carefully .
indeed , we can calculate the time @xmath86 to cover a distance of the order @xmath120 when the sphere starts moving from the dead point : the distance @xmath121 can be estimated as @xmath122 .
one can , then , easily show that @xmath123 ; hence , if @xmath124 , also @xmath125 will be sufficiently small to justify the constant shape assumption also at the dead points .
incidentally , we observe that we have numerically checked the condition @xmath126 for all the cases presented in the main manuscript once the stress distribution was calculated from the solution of eq .
( [ eq1 ] ) .
one of the main purposes of this paper is to shed light on the unique features of the viscoelastic reciprocating contacts . to this aim , it can be useful here to point out the differences between viscoelastic steady - state sliding and reciprocating conditions . from a physical point of view , the two conditions are almost antithetical : in the steady - state case , the punch always meets underformed material @xcite ; on the contrary , as we explain in the main manuscript , when dealing with reciprocating contacts , the rigid punch may deform a region of material that has not yet relaxed . only in the limit case of very small values of the parameter @xmath100 ,
i.e. given a relaxation time @xmath19 for very small frequencies @xmath3 , the reciprocating case tends to a steady - state - like regime , where the material has got time to relax before the punch re - engages with it .
this physical background entails remarkable differences in terms of interfacial pressures , normal displacements and , consequently , friction . in fig .
[ figab ] , we compare the contour plots of the normal pressure for the two cases , i.e. the reciprocating contact conditions and the sliding steady - state contacts . in fig .
( [ figab]a ) , at the inversion point , i.e. when the speed is nominally equal to zero , in the reciprocating case , the pressure still shows a marked asymmetry , that is the consequence of the viscoelastic time - delay which prevents the material to relax immediately when the sliding speed vanishes . on the contrary , in steady - state conditions , the solution at zero speed can not be anything else that the elastic classic hertzian solution with the zero - frequency modulus @xmath127 .
furthermore , given a constant normal load , in this last case , due to the lower modulus , the contact area is much bigger and normal stresses are much smaller .
when the punch starts moving back to the right dead point , we still have remarkable differences in the pressure distributions ( see fig .
( [ figab]b ) .
such differences are also clearly perceived when looking at the normal displacements . upon the motion inversion
, we observe the formation of an additional peak in the displacement distribution : this is impossible in steady - state conditions .
different distributions in terms of pressure and normal displacements lead to a different hysteretic curve ( see figure figure3 in the main manuscript ) , thus highlighting the importance of the unique features that characterize reciprocating contact conditions .
johannessen w. , vresilovic e. j. , wright a. c. , elliott d. m. , intervertebral disc mechanics are restored following cyclic loading and unloaded recovery .
annals of biomedical engineering , 32 , 1 , 70 - 76 , ( 2004 ) .
carbone g. , putignano c. , a novel methodology to predict sliding / rolling friction in viscoelastic materials : theory and experiments . , journal of mechanics and physics of solids , journal of the mechanics and physics of solids , 61 ( 8) , 1822 - 1834 , ( 2013 ) .
dunn a. c. , cobb j. a. , kantzios a. n. , lee s. j. , sarntinoranont m. , tran - son - tay r. , sawyer w. g. , friction coefficient measurement of hydrogel materials on living epithelial cells , tribology letters , 30 , 1,13 - 19 , ( 2008 ) .
putignano c. , afferrante l. , carbone g. , demelio g. , the influence of the statistical properties of self - affine surfaces in elastic contact : a numerical investigation , journal of mechanics and physics of solids , 60 , 5 , 973982 , ( 2012 ) . | a theory of reciprocating contacts for linear viscoelastic materials is presented .
results are discussed for the case of a rigid sphere sinusoidally driven in sliding contact with a viscoelastic half - space .
depending on the size of the contact , the frequency and amplitude of the reciprocating motion , and on the relaxation time of the viscoelastic body , we establish that the contact behavior may range from the steady - state viscoelastic solution , in which traction forces always oppose the direction of the sliding rigid punch , to a more elaborate trend , never observed before , which is due to the strong interaction between different regions of the path covered during the reciprocating motion .
practical implications span a number of applications , ranging from seismic engineering to biotechnology .
pacs numbers : : 62.20.qp , 46.55.+d . , 46.35.+z . |
a set @xmath0 of vertices of an acyclic digraph @xmath1 is _ convex _ if @xmath13 and there is no directed path between vertices of @xmath0 which contains a vertex not in @xmath0 .
a set @xmath0 is _ connected _ if @xmath13 and the underlying undirected graph of the subgraph of @xmath1 induced by @xmath0 is connected .
a set is _ connected convex _ ( a _ cc - set _ ) if it is both connected and convex . in section [ ccsec ] , we introduce and study an algorithm @xmath3 for generating all connected convex sets of a connected acyclic digraph @xmath1 of order @xmath4 .
the running time of @xmath3 is @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the number of connected convex sets in @xmath1 .
thus , the algorithm is ( almost ) optimal with respect to its time complexity .
interestingly , to generate only @xmath14 cc - sets using @xmath3 we need @xmath15 time . in section [ expersec ] ,
we give experimental results demonstrating that the algorithm is practical on reasonably large data dependency graphs for basic blocks generated from target code produced by trimaran @xcite and simplescalar @xcite .
our experiments show that @xmath3 is better than the state - of - the - art algorithm of chen , maskell and sun @xcite .
moreover , unlike the algorithm in @xcite , our algorithm has a provable ( almost ) optimal worst time complexity .
although such algorithms are of less importance in our application area because of wider scheduling issues , there also exist algorithms that enumerate all of the convex sets of an acyclic graph . until recently the algorithm of choice for this problem was that of atasu , pozzi and ienne @xcite
, however the cms algorithm @xcite ( run in general mode ) outperforms the api algorithm in most cases . in section
[ all ] , we give a different algorithm , for enumeration of all the convex sets of an acyclic digraph , which significantly outperforms the cms and api algorithms and which has a ( optimal ) runtime performance of the order of the sum of the sizes of the convex sets .
avis and fukuda @xcite designed an algorithm for generating all connected sets in a connected graph @xmath7 of order @xmath4 and size @xmath12 with time complexity @xmath11 and space complexity @xmath16 , where @xmath9 is the number of connected sets in @xmath7 .
observe that when @xmath7 is bipartite there is an orientation @xmath1 of @xmath7 such that every connected set of @xmath7 corresponds to a cc - set of @xmath1 and vice versa . to obtain @xmath1 orient every edge of @xmath7 from @xmath0 to @xmath17 , where @xmath0 and @xmath17 are the partition classes of @xmath7 .
the algorithm of avis and fukuda is based on a so - called reverse search . applying the approach used to design the algorithm @xmath3 to connected set enumeration , in section [ consec ]
, we describe an algorithm @xmath18 for generating all connected sets in a connected graph @xmath7 of order @xmath4 with much better time complexity , @xmath19 .
this demonstrates that our approach can be applied with success to various vertex set / subgraph enumeration problems .
the space complexity of our algorithm matches that of the algorithm of avis and fukuda .
there is an immediate application for @xmath3 in the field of so - called _ custom computing _ in which central processor architectures are parameterized for particular applications .
an embedded or _
application specific _ computing system only ever executes a single application .
examples include automobile engine management systems , satellite and aerospace control systems and the signal processing parts of mobile cellular phones .
significant improvements in the price - performance ratio of such systems can be achieved if the instruction set of the application specific processor is specifically tuned to the application .
this approach has become practical because many modern integrated circuit implementations are based on field programmable gate arrays ( fpga ) .
an fpga comprises an array of logic elements and a programmable routing system , which allows detailed design of logic interconnection to be performed directly by the customer , rather than a complete ( and very high cost ) custom integrated circuit having to be produced for each application . in extreme cases ,
the internal logic of the fpga can even be modified whilst in operation .
suppliers of embedded processor architectures are now delivering _
extensible _ versions of their general purpose processors .
examples include the arm optimode @xcite , the mips pro series @xcite and the tensilica xtensa @xcite .
the intention is that these architectures be implemented either as traditional logic with an accompanying fpga containing the hardware for extension instructions , or be completely implemented within a large fpga . by this
means , hardware development has achieved a new level of flexibility , but sophisticated design tools are required to exploit its potential . the goal of such tools is the identification of time critical or commonly occurring patterns of computation that could be directly implemented in custom hardware , giving both faster execution and reduced program size , because a sequence of base machine instructions is being replaced by a single custom _ extension _ instruction .
for example , a program solving simultaneous linear equations may find it useful to have a single instruction to perform matrix inversion on a set of values held in registers .
the approach proceeds by first locating the _ basic blocks _ of the program , regions of sequential computation with no control transfers into them . for each basic block
we construct a _ data dependency graph _ ( ddg ) which contains vertices for each base ( unextended ) instruction in the block , along with a vertex for each initial input datum .
figure [ ddg ] shows an example of a ddg .
there is an arc to the vertex for the instruction @xmath20 from each vertex whose instruction computes an input operand of @xmath20 .
ddg s are acyclic because execution within a basic block is by definition sequential .
( 88,66)(0,0 ) ( 2,62)(11,4)[cc]var : a ( 17,62)(11,4)[cc]var : c ( 32,62)(11,4)[cc]int:4 ( 61,62)(11,4)[cc]var : b ( 70,26)(11,4)[cc]root ( 15,27)(11,4)[cc]int:2 ( 10,53)(9,4)[cc]mul ( 22,45)(9,4)[cc]mul ( 10,11)(9,4)[cc]mul ( 53,34)(9,4)[cc]sub ( 70,47)(9,4)[cc]mul ( 66,11)(9,4)[cc]add ( 41,26)(9,4)[cc]neg ( 36,0)(9,4)[cc]dvi ( 13,57)(4,-3)0(7,62)(.04026846,-.03355705)149(1,0).04026846 ( 16,57)(-4,-3)0(23,62)(-.04697987,-.03355705)149(-1,0).04697987 ( 25,49)(3,-1)0(14,53)(.09243697,-.03361345)119(1,0).09243697 ( 28,49)(-2,-3)0(37,62)(-.033707865,-.048689139)267(0,-1).048689139 ( 13,15)(1,-4)0(7,62)(.03370787,-.26404494)178(0,-1).26404494 ( 42,4)(-4,-1)0(71,11)(-.13942308,-.03365385)208(-1,0).13942308 ( 39,4)(4,-1)0(14,11)(.12019231,-.03365385)208(1,0).12019231 ( 76,51)(0,-1)0(67,62)(76.5,59.5)(76,51 ) ( 72,51)(1,-1)0(67,62)(66.5,55.5)(72,51 ) ( 58,38)(-2,-1)0(75,47)(-.063670412,-.033707865)267(-1,0).063670412 ( 27,45)(4,-1)28 ( 75,30)(4,-1)0(58,34)(.14285714,-.03361345)119(1,0).14285714 ( 72,15)(-1,-3)0(76,26)(-.03361345,-.09243697)119(0,-1).09243697 ( 69,15)(2,-1)0(46,26)(.070336391,-.033639144)327(1,0).070336391 ( 46,30)(-2,-3)0(67,62)(-.033707865,-.051364366)623(0,-1).051364366 ( 16,15)(-1,-2)0(21,27)(-.03355705,-.08053691)149(0,-1).08053691 ( 66,22)(19,33)[cc ] ( 65.93,21.93)(.95,0)21 ' '' '' ( 65.93,54.93)(.95,0)21 ' '' '' ( 65.93,54.93)(0,-.97059)35 ' '' '' ( 84.93,54.93)(0,-.97059)35 ' '' '' ( 6,7)(73,12)[cc ] ( 5.93,6.93)(.98649,0)75 ' '' '' ( 5.93,18.93)(.98649,0)75 ' '' '' ( 5.93,18.93)(0,-.9231)14 ' '' '' ( 78.93,18.93)(0,-.9231)14 ' '' '' ( 6,43)(29,16)[cc ] ( 5.93,42.93)(.9667,0)31 ' '' '' ( 5.93,58.93)(.9667,0)31 ' '' '' ( 5.93,58.93)(0,-.9412)18 ' '' '' ( 34.93,58.93)(0,-.9412)18 ' '' '' ( 4,55)(0,0)[cc]*a * ( 88,51)(0,0)[cc]*c * ( 4,15)(0,0)[cc]*b * extension instructions are combinations of base machine instructions and are represented by sets of the ddg . in figure
[ ddg ] , sections a and b are convex sets that represent candidate extension instructions .
however , section b is not connected .
if such a region were implemented as a single extension instruction we should have separate independent hardware units within the instruction .
although this presents no special difficulties , and in section [ all ] we give an optimal algorithm for constructing all such sets , present engineering practice is to restrict the search to connected convex components on the grounds that unconnected convex components are composed of connected ones , and that the system s code scheduler will perform better if it is allowed to arrange the independent computations in different ways at different points in the program . unlike connectivity however , convexity is not optional .
an extension instruction can not perform computations that depend on instructions external to the extension instruction .
this means that there can be no data flows out of and then back into the extension instruction : the set corresponding to an extension instruction must be convex .
thus section c in figure [ ddg ] does not represent a candidate extension instruction since it breaches the ` no external computation rule ' because it is non - convex : there is a path _ via _ the sub node that is not in the set .
ideally we would like to fully consider all possible candidate instructions and select the combination which results in the most efficient implementation . in practice
this is unlikely to be feasible as , in worst case , the number of candidates will be exponential in the number of original program instructions .
however , it is useful to have a process which can find all the potential instructions , even if the set of instructions used for final consideration has to be restricted . in this work we only deal with generation of a set of possible candidate instructions .
interested readers can refer to @xcite .
many other algorithms for special vertex set / subgraph generation have been studied in the literature .
kreher and stinson @xcite describe an algorithm for generating all cliques in a graph @xmath7 of order @xmath4 with running time @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the number of cliques in @xmath10 several algorithms have been suggested for the generation of all spanning trees in a connected graph @xmath7 of order @xmath4 and size @xmath12 .
let @xmath23 be the number of spanning trees in @xmath7 .
the first spanning trees generating algorithms @xcite used backtracking which is useful for enumerating various kinds of subgraphs such as paths and cycles . using the algorithms from @xcite , gabow and myers @xcite suggested an algorithm with time complexity @xmath24 and space complexity @xmath16 .
if we output all spanning trees by their edges , this algorithm is optimal in terms of time and space complexities .
later algorithms of a different type were developed ; these algorithms ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) find a new spanning tree by exchanging a pair of edges . as a result ,
the algorithms of kapoor and ramesh @xcite and shioura and tamura @xcite require only @xmath25 time and @xmath26 space .
the algorithm of shioura , tamura and uno @xcite is of the same optimal running time , but also of optimal space : @xmath27 an out - tree is an orientation of a tree such that all vertices but one are of in - degree 1 .
kapoor , kumar and ramesh @xcite presented an algorithm for enumerating all spanning out - trees of a digraph with @xmath4 vertices , @xmath12 arcs and @xmath23 spanning out - trees .
the algorithm takes @xmath28 time per spanning tree ; more precisely , it runs in @xmath29 , where @xmath30 is the inverse ackermann function .
it first outputs a single spanning out - tree and then a list of arc swaps ; each spanning out - tree can be generated from the first spanning out - tree by applying a prefix of this sequence of arc swaps .
let @xmath1 be a digraph .
if @xmath31 is an arc of @xmath1 ( @xmath32 ) , we say that @xmath33 is an _ out - neighbor _ of @xmath34 and @xmath34 is an _ in - neighbor _ of @xmath33 .
the set of out - neighbors of @xmath34 is denoted by @xmath35 and the set of in - neighbors of @xmath34 is denoted by @xmath36 . for a set @xmath0 of vertices of @xmath1 , its _ out - neighborhood _ ( resp . _ in - neighborhood _ ) is @xmath37 ( resp .
@xmath38 ) .
a digraph @xmath39 is called the _ transitive closure _ of @xmath1 if @xmath40 and a vertex @xmath34 is an in - neighbor of a vertex @xmath33 in @xmath39 if and only if there is a path from @xmath34 to @xmath33 in @xmath41 let @xmath42 be a non - empty set of vertices of a digraph @xmath1 . a directed path @xmath43 of @xmath1 is an @xmath42-_path _ if @xmath43 has at least three vertices , its initial and terminal vertices are in @xmath42 and the rest of the vertices are not in @xmath44 for a digraph @xmath1 , @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) denotes the collection of cc - sets ( convex sets ) in @xmath47 @xmath48 and @xmath49 an ordering @xmath50 of vertices of an acyclic digraph @xmath1 is called _ acyclic _ if for every arc @xmath51 of @xmath1 we have @xmath52 . [ lemma_transitive ]
let @xmath1 be a connected acyclic digraph and let @xmath42 be a vertex set in @xmath1 .
then @xmath42 is a cc - set in @xmath1 if and only if it is a cc - set in @xmath39 .
let @xmath42 be a set of vertices of @xmath1 .
we will first prove that there is an @xmath42-path in @xmath1 if and only if there is an @xmath42-path in @xmath53 since all arcs of @xmath1 are in @xmath39 , every @xmath42-path in @xmath1 is an @xmath42-path in @xmath53 let @xmath54 be an @xmath42-path in @xmath39 .
then there are paths @xmath55 such that @xmath56 is a path in @xmath1 ( @xmath57 must be a path since @xmath1 is acyclic ) .
since @xmath58 and @xmath59 belong to @xmath42 and @xmath60 does not belong to @xmath42 , there is a subpath of @xmath57 which is an @xmath42-path .
if @xmath42 is connected in @xmath1 then it is clearly connected in @xmath39 , which implies that if @xmath42 is a cc - set in @xmath1 then it is a cc - set in @xmath39 .
now let @xmath42 be a cc - set in @xmath39 .
assume that @xmath61 $ ] is not connected and let @xmath34 and @xmath33 be vertices in different connected components in @xmath61 $ ] , but which are connected by an arc in @xmath39 . without loss of generality
@xmath31 is the arc in @xmath39 and @xmath62 is a path from @xmath34 to @xmath33 in @xmath1 .
however as @xmath42 is convex all vertices in @xmath62 also belong to @xmath42 and therefore @xmath34 and @xmath33 belong to the same connected component in @xmath61 $ ] , a contradiction .
it is well - known ( see , e.g. , the paper @xcite by fisher and meyer , or @xcite by furman ) that the transitive closure problem and the matrix multiplication problem are closely related : there exists an @xmath63-algorithm , with @xmath64 , to compute the transitive closure of a digraph of order @xmath4 if and only if the product of two boolean @xmath65 matrices can be computed in @xmath63 time .
coppersmith and winograd @xcite showed that there exists an @xmath66-algorithm for the matrix multiplication .
thus , we have the following : [ remtr ] the transitive closure of a digraph of order @xmath4 can be found in @xmath66 time .
we will need the following two results proved in @xcite .
[ lower_bound ] for every connected acyclic digraph @xmath1 of order @xmath4 , @xmath67 . if an acyclic digraph @xmath1 of order @xmath4 has a hamiltonian path , then @xmath68 . [ upper_bound ]
let @xmath69 , where @xmath70 for every even @xmath4 and @xmath71 for every odd @xmath4 .
for every connected acyclic digraph @xmath1 of order @xmath4 , @xmath72 let @xmath73 denote the digraph obtained from the complete bipartite graph @xmath74 by orienting every edge from the partite set of cardinality @xmath75 to the partite set of cardinality @xmath76 we have @xmath77 provided @xmath78 .
in this section @xmath1 denotes a connected acyclic digraph of order @xmath4 and size @xmath12 .
now we describe the main algorithm of this paper ; we denote it by @xmath79 .
the input of @xmath79 is @xmath1 and @xmath80 outputs all cc - sets of @xmath1 . the formal description of @xmath79 is followed by an example and proofs of correctness of @xmath79 and its complexity . finally , we show that to produce @xmath14 cc - sets @xmath3 requires @xmath81 time .
the algorithm works as follows .
given a digraph @xmath1 on @xmath4 vertices , it considers an acyclic ordering @xmath82 of the transitive closure of @xmath1 . for each vertex
@xmath83 we consider the sets @xmath84 and @xmath85 and call the subroutine @xmath86 which finds all cc - sets @xmath42 in @xmath1 such that @xmath87 . at each step , if possible @xmath86 removes an element @xmath88 from @xmath17 and adds it to @xmath0 .
if @xmath0 has out - neighbors we choose @xmath88 to be the ` largest ' out - neighbor in the acyclic ordering(line 3 ) , otherwise if @xmath0 has in - neighbors we choose @xmath88 to be the ` smallest ' in - neighbor ( line 8) .
then we find the other vertices required to maintain convexity ( line 4 or line 9 ) . if there are no in- or out - neighbors we output @xmath0 , otherwise we find find all the cc - sets such that @xmath89 and @xmath90 ( line 12 ) and then all the cc - sets such that @xmath91 and @xmath92 ( line 13 ) .
step 1 : : : find the transitive closure of @xmath1 and set @xmath93 step 2 : : : find an acyclic ordering @xmath94 of @xmath1 .
step 3 : : : for each @xmath95 do the following . set @xmath96 , @xmath97 and
call @xmath86 .
step 4 subroutine @xmath86 : : : + before proving the correctness of @xmath3 , we consider an example .
let @xmath1 be the graph on the left below in step 1 , we find @xmath98 ( above right ) .
observe that @xmath99 is an acyclic ordering .
we may assume that this is the ordering found in step 2 .
for @xmath100 in step 3 , we have @xmath101 and @xmath102 , and we call @xmath103
. then in step 4 , line 1 , we compute @xmath104 and then , lines 3 and 4 , obtain @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
then , at line 12 , we make a recursive call to @xmath108 . in this call
we have @xmath109 so , at line 10 , the set @xmath110 is output and the recursive call returns , to line 13 of @xmath111 , where we make a call to @xmath112 .
we are now effectively looking at the graph @xmath113 below . in step 4 , lines 1 - 4 ,
we compute @xmath114 and obtain @xmath115 , @xmath116 and @xmath117 . at lines 12 and 13
we make recursive calls to @xmath118 and @xmath119 respectively . in the call to @xmath120 ,
lines 1 - 4 , we obtain @xmath121 and @xmath122 .
this in turn generates calls to @xmath123 , which just outputs @xmath124 and returns , and @xmath125 .
the latter call generates calls to @xmath126 and @xmath127 , which output @xmath128 and @xmath129 , respectively . in the call to @xmath119 ,
where we are effectively looking at @xmath130 above , we obtain @xmath121 and @xmath122 .
this in turn generates calls to @xmath131 , which just outputs @xmath132 and returns , and @xmath133 ( graph @xmath134 above ) .
the latter call generates calls to @xmath135 and @xmath136 , which output @xmath137 and @xmath138 , respectively .
this completes the case @xmath100 in step 3 , and all the cc - sets containing @xmath139 have been output .
now we perform step 3 with @xmath140 , effectively looking at the graph @xmath141 .
the call to @xmath142 generates further recursive calls in the following order + @xmath143 + @xmath144 , output @xmath145 + @xmath146 , output @xmath147 + @xmath148 + @xmath149 , output @xmath150 + @xmath151 , output @xmath152 .
+ thus all the cc - sets containing @xmath153 but not @xmath139 are output .
performing step 3 again with @xmath154 , effectively looking at the graph @xmath155 above , the call to @xmath156 , generates the following recursive calls + @xmath157 + @xmath158 , output @xmath159 + @xmath160 , output @xmath161 + @xmath162 , output @xmath163 + which ouput all the cc - sets containing @xmath164 but not @xmath139 or @xmath153 . for the case @xmath165 in step 3
we get the following calls + @xmath166 + @xmath167 , output @xmath168 + @xmath169 , output @xmath170 + and for @xmath171 we get + @xmath172 , output @xmath173 + after which @xmath3 terminates . [ corlem ] algorithm @xmath3 correctly outputs all cc - sets of @xmath1 .
recall , the convex ( connected ) sets of @xmath1 are precisely the convex ( connected ) sets of @xmath39 .
we prove the result for @xmath39 .
firstly we show that all the sets @xmath0 output by @xmath3 are in @xmath174 .
we will show that within @xmath3 , for any call @xmath86 we have that @xmath175 , @xmath176 is convex and @xmath0 is a cc - set .
this is clearly sufficient as @xmath0 is the only set output .
these properties hold for step 3 when @xmath177 is called as we have chosen an acyclic ordering of the vertices .
thus we assume that the properties hold for the sets @xmath0 , @xmath17 and consider the pairs of sets @xmath178 , @xmath179 and @xmath0 , @xmath180 constructed in @xmath86 . in both cases
clearly the intersections are empty , and since @xmath181 , @xmath178 is connected .
now we will prove that @xmath178 is convex .
suppose that there is a path @xmath182 where @xmath183 .
note that if there exists an @xmath184-path then by transitivity of @xmath39 there exists an @xmath184-path of length two . by convexity of @xmath176
we have @xmath185 . also , @xmath186 as we have chosen @xmath88 to be either the maximal element of @xmath187 or the minimal element of @xmath188 , and @xmath39 is transitive and thus the presence of the arcs @xmath189 and @xmath190 implies the presence of the arc @xmath191 assume that @xmath192 . then @xmath193 .
since @xmath194 and the arc @xmath189 exists , the transitivity of @xmath39 implies that @xmath195 . since @xmath0 is convex it follows that not both vertices @xmath196 can be in @xmath0 and that there is no arc from @xmath187 to @xmath0 .
thus @xmath197 and so @xmath198 . by the transitivity of @xmath39 and
the fact that @xmath190 exists and that @xmath199 we have @xmath200 and thus @xmath201 . similarly if @xmath202 then @xmath203 and by the transitivity of @xmath39 and since @xmath204 we have @xmath205 and thus @xmath206 .
secondly we show that if @xmath207 is cc then @xmath0 is output by @xmath3 . if @xmath42 is a cc - set and @xmath208 then @xmath209 .
thus it is sufficient to show that if @xmath42 is cc and @xmath210 then @xmath86 outputs @xmath42 .
we prove this by induction on @xmath211 . if @xmath212 then , since @xmath42 is connected , @xmath213 and @xmath86 outputs @xmath0 at line 10 .
this proves the result for @xmath214 , and for @xmath215 we may assume that @xmath216 . if @xmath92 then we have @xmath217 and @xmath218 , so by induction the call to @xmath219 at line 13 outputs @xmath42 . if @xmath220 , we have arcs @xmath221 and @xmath222 , for some @xmath223 . thus , if @xmath90 , by convexity of @xmath42 we have @xmath224 . then , since @xmath225 , the call to @xmath226 at line 12 outputs @xmath42 . [ runtlem ] the running time of @xmath3 is @xmath227 note that by theorem [ lower_bound ] and the fact that @xmath1 is connected we have @xmath228 .
therefore the transitive closure of @xmath1 can be found in @xmath229 time , by theorem [ remtr ] .
it is well - known that an acyclic ordering can be found in time @xmath16 , see , e.g. , @xcite , and clearly the sets @xmath230 and @xmath231 can be computed at the start of the algorithm in @xmath232 time , for each @xmath233 .
we will now show that @xmath86 runs in time @xmath234 , where @xmath235 is the number of cc - sets @xmath42 such that @xmath87 and @xmath236 is the sum of the sizes of the sets @xmath42 .
note that @xmath237 returns at line 10 or makes two recursive calls to @xmath237 ( lines 12,13 ) .
if @xmath237 returns at line 10 then we call this a _ leaf _ call otherwise the function call is an _ internal _ call .
all function calls can be viewed as nodes of a binary tree ( every node is a leaf or has two children ) whose leaves and internal nodes correspond to calls to @xmath238 .
it is easy to see , by induction , that the number of internal nodes equals the number of leaves minus one .
it is easy to see , by induction on the depth of the call tree , that @xmath237 outputs each set @xmath42 only once ( @xmath226 and @xmath219 output those that contain @xmath88 and do not contain @xmath88 , respectively ) .
thus we have @xmath235 leaf calls and @xmath239 internal calls .
we assume that the set implementation allows us to find the size of a set and the largest and smallest elements of the set in unit time . then the time taken by a call @xmath86 depends on the time taken to calculate the sets @xmath240 , @xmath241 and @xmath242 .
since @xmath243 , the time to compute @xmath242 is at most @xmath244 .
if we implement @xmath245 so that @xmath246 and @xmath188 are passed in as parameters then the time taken to calculate @xmath240 and @xmath241 is at most @xmath244 . by definition of @xmath242
we have that @xmath247 and @xmath248 provided @xmath249 , and @xmath250 and @xmath251 provided @xmath202 ( and @xmath252 ) .
since @xmath253 , these sets can be computed in @xmath244 time .
if @xmath86 calls @xmath254 then @xmath255 thus a call to @xmath237 at an internal node takes at most @xmath244 time , and a call at a leaf node takes at most @xmath256 time , giving the desired total time bound of @xmath257 .
we let @xmath258 denote the sum of the sizes of all the cc - sets @xmath42 such that @xmath259 , and observe that @xmath260 . finally , by step 3 , we conclude that the total running time is @xmath261 [ maint ] algorithm @xmath3 is correct and its time and space complexities are @xmath262 and @xmath263 , respectively .
the correctness and time complexity follows from the two lemmas above .
the space complexity is dominated by the space complexity of step 1 , @xmath264 since @xmath6 may well be exponential , we may wish to generate only a restricted number @xmath14 of cc - sets .
theorem [ kccsets ] can be viewed as a result in fixed - parameter algorithmics @xcite with @xmath14 being a parameter .
[ kccsets ] to output @xmath14 cc - sets the algorithm @xmath3 requires @xmath81 time .
we may assume that @xmath14 is at most the number of cc - sets containing vertex @xmath139 since otherwise the proof is analogous .
we consider the binary tree @xmath265 introduced in the proof of lemma [ runtlem ] and prove our claim by induction on @xmath14 .
it takes @xmath66 time to perform steps 1,2 and 3 .
it takes @xmath232 internal nodes of @xmath265 to reach the first leaf of @xmath265 and , thus , for @xmath266 we obtain @xmath267 time .
assume that @xmath268 .
let @xmath34 be the first leaf of @xmath265 reached by @xmath3 , let @xmath33 be the parent of @xmath34 on @xmath265 , let @xmath269 be another child of @xmath33 on @xmath265 and let @xmath20 be the parent of @xmath33 .
observe that after deleting the nodes @xmath34 and @xmath33 and adding an edge between @xmath20 and @xmath269 , we obtain a new binary tree @xmath270 . by induction hypothesis , to reach the first @xmath271 leaves in @xmath270 , we need @xmath272 time . to reach the first @xmath14 leaves in @xmath265
, we need to reach @xmath34 and the first @xmath271 leaves in @xmath270 .
thus , we need to add to @xmath272 the time required to visit @xmath34 and @xmath33 only , which is @xmath273 thus , we have proved the desired bound @xmath81 .
it is not hard to modify @xmath3 such that the new algorithm will generate all convex sets of an acyclic digraph @xmath1 in time @xmath274 , where @xmath275 is the number of convex sets in @xmath1 .
however , a faster algorithm is possible and we present one in this section . to obtain all convex sets of @xmath1 ( and @xmath276 , which is not convex by definition ) , we call the following recursive procedure with the original digraph @xmath1 and with @xmath277 .
this call yields an algorithm whose properties are studied below .
a vertex @xmath34 is a _ source _ ( _ sink _ ) if it has no in - neighbors ( out - neighbors ) . in general , the procedure @xmath278 takes as input an acyclic digraph @xmath279 and a set @xmath280 and outputs all convex sets of @xmath1 which contain @xmath281 .
the procedure @xmath278 outputs @xmath282 and then considers all sources and sinks of the graph that are not in @xmath281 . for each such source or sink @xmath283
, we call @xmath278@xmath284 and then add @xmath283 to @xmath281 . thus ,
for each sink or source @xmath285 we consider all sets that contain @xmath283 and all sets that do not contain @xmath283 .
proposition [ prop : convex ] and theorem [ prop : unique ] imply that the procedure @xmath278 is correct .
we first show that all sets generated in line 1 are , in fact , convex sets . to this end , we use the following lemma .
[ lem : delete ] let @xmath1 be an acyclic graph , let @xmath0 be a convex set of @xmath1 , and let @xmath286 be a source or sink of @xmath287 $ ] . then @xmath288 is a convex set of @xmath1 .
suppose that @xmath288 is not convex in @xmath1 .
then there exist two vertices @xmath289 and a directed path @xmath43 from @xmath20 to @xmath88 which contains a vertex not in @xmath288 .
since @xmath0 is convex , @xmath43 only uses vertices of @xmath0 and in particular @xmath290 .
thus , there is a subpath @xmath291 of @xmath43 with @xmath292 .
but since @xmath283 is a source or a sink in @xmath287 $ ] such a subpath can not exist , a contradiction .
now we can prove the following proposition .
[ prop : convex ] let @xmath279 be an acyclic digraph and let @xmath280 .
then every set output by @xmath278(@xmath293 ) is convex .
we prove the result by induction on the number of vertices of the outputted set .
the entire vertex set @xmath282 is convex and is outputted by the procedure .
now assume all sets of size @xmath294 that are outputted by the procedure are convex .
we will show that all sets of size @xmath295 that are outputted are also convex .
when a set @xmath296 is outputted the procedure @xmath278@xmath297,f')$ ] was called for some set @xmath298 .
the only way @xmath278@xmath297,f')$ ] can be invoked is that there exist a set @xmath299 and a source or sink @xmath300 of @xmath301 $ ] with @xmath302 .
moreover @xmath303 will be outputted by the procedure and , thus , by our assumption is convex .
the result now follows from lemma [ lem : delete ] .
[ prop : unique ] let @xmath279 be an acyclic digraph and let @xmath280
. then every convex set of @xmath1 containing @xmath281 is outputted exactly once by @xmath278@xmath304 .
let @xmath296 be a convex set of @xmath1 containing @xmath281 .
we first claim that there exist vertices @xmath305 with @xmath306 and @xmath307 is a source or sink of @xmath308 $ ] for all @xmath309 . to prove the claim we will show that for every convex set @xmath310 with @xmath311 , there exists a source or sink @xmath312 of the digraph @xmath313 $ ] .
this will prove our claim as by lemma [ lem : delete ] @xmath314 is a convex set of @xmath1 and we can repeatedly apply the claim .
if there exists no arc from a vertex of @xmath296 to a vertex of @xmath315 $ ] then any source of @xmath316 is a source of @xmath313 $ ] .
note that @xmath315 $ ] is an acyclic digraph and , thus , has at least one source ( and sink ) .
thus we may assume that there is an arc from a vertex @xmath20 of @xmath296 to a vertex @xmath88 of @xmath316 .
consider a longest path @xmath317 in @xmath315 $ ] leaving @xmath88 .
observe that @xmath318 is a sink of @xmath315 $ ] and , moreover , there is no arc from @xmath318 to any vertex of @xmath296 since otherwise there would be a directed path from @xmath319 to a vertex in @xmath296 containing vertices in @xmath316 which is impossible as @xmath296 is convex .
hence @xmath318 is a sink of @xmath313 $ ] and the claim is shown . next note that a sink or source remains a sink or source when vertices are deleted .
thus when @xmath278@xmath304 is executed and a source or sink @xmath283 is considered , then we distinguish the cases when @xmath320 for some @xmath321 or when this is not the case .
if @xmath320 and we currently consider the digraph @xmath322 and the fixed set @xmath323 , then we follow the execution path calling @xmath278@xmath324 .
otherwise we follow the execution path that adds @xmath283 to the fixed set .
when the last @xmath307 is deleted , we call @xmath278@xmath297,f'')$ ] for some @xmath325 and the set @xmath296 is outputed . it remains to show that there is a unique execution path yielding @xmath296 . to see this , note that when we consider a source or sink @xmath283 then either it is deleted of moved to the fixed set @xmath281 .
thus every vertex is considered at most once and then deleted or fixed .
therefore each time we consider a source or sink there is a unique decision that finally yields @xmath296 .
we assume that the input acyclic digraph @xmath279 is given by the two adjacency lists for each vertex , and the number of in - neighbors and out - neighbors is stored for each vertex .
one can obtain this information at the beginning in @xmath16 time , where @xmath4 ( @xmath12 ) is the number of vertices ( arcs ) of the input connected acyclic digraph @xmath1 .
observe that we output the vertex set of @xmath1 as one convex set .
thus , it suffices to show that the running time of @xmath278@xmath304 without the recursive calls is @xmath326 .
this will yield the running time @xmath327 of @xmath278 by theorem [ prop : unique ] .
since we have stored the number of in - neighbors and out - neighbors for every vertex @xmath328 , we can determine _ all _ sources and sinks in @xmath326 time .
for the recursive calls of @xmath278 we delete one vertex and have to update the number of in- respectively out - neighbors of all neighbors of the deleted vertex @xmath283 .
the vertex @xmath283 has at most @xmath329 neighbors and we can charge the cost of the updating information to the call of @xmath278@xmath284 . moreover we store the neighbours of @xmath283 so that we can reintroduce them after the call of @xmath278@xmath284 . moving the sinks and sources to @xmath281
needs constant time for each source or sink and thus we obtain @xmath326 time in total . in summary
we initially need @xmath16 time , and then each call of @xmath278@xmath304 is charged with @xmath326 before it is called and then additionally with @xmath326 time during its execution . since we output a convex set of size @xmath326 , the total running time is @xmath330 .
since @xmath331 by theorem [ lower_bound ] , the running time of @xmath278 is @xmath327 .
in order to test our algorithms @xmath3 and @xmath278 for practicality we have implemented and run them on several instances of ddg s of basic blocks .
we have compared our algorithm with the state - of - the - art algorithm of chen , maskell and sun @xcite ( the cms algorithm ) using their own implementation , but with the code for i / o constraint checking removed so as to ensure that their algorithm was not disadvantaged . for completeness we have also compared @xmath278 to atasu , pozzi and ienne s algorithm @xcite ( the api06 algorithm ) .
all the algorithms were coded in c++ and all experiments were carried out on a 2 x dual core amd opteron 265 1.8ghz processor with 4 gb ram , running suse linux 10.2 ( 64 bit ) .
our first set of tests is based on c and c++ programs taken from the benchmark suites of mibench @xcite and trimaran @xcite .
we compiled these benchmarks for both the trimaran ( a , b , c , d , e ) and simplescalar @xcite ( f , g , h , i ) architectures .
from here we examined the control - flow graph for each program to select a basic block within a critical loop of the program ( often this block had been unrolled to some degree to increase the potential for efficiency improvements ) .
we considered basic blocks , ranging from 20 to 45 lines of low level , intermediate , code , for which we generated the ddgs .
we then selected , from these ddgs , the non - trivial connected components on which to run our algorithms .
we give some preference to benchmarks which suite the intended application of the research taking our test cases from security applications including benchmarks for the advanced encryption standard ( b , c ) and safety - critical software ( a , e ) .
we also include a basic example from the trimaran benchmark suite : hyper ( d ) , an algorithm that performs quick sort ( f ) , part of a jpeg algorithm ( g ) , and an example from the fft benchmark in mibench containing c source code for performing discrete fast fourier transforms ( h ) . the final example is taken from the standard blowfish benchmark , an encryption algorithm .
the results we have obtained are given in table [ ri : basic ] .
in the following tables nv denotes the number of vertices , ns denotes the number of generated sets , na number of arcs , ct denotes clock time in @xmath332 cpu seconds , and for the benchmark data i d identifies the benchmark .
& 35 & 38 & 139,190 & 170 & 96b & 42 & 45 & 4,484,110 & 5,546 & 3,246c & 26&28&5,891&6&4d & 39&94&3,968,036&4,346&2,710e & 45&44&1,466,961&1,750&1,156f & 24&22&46,694&60&30 g & 20&19&397&0&0h & 20&21&1,916&0&0i & 43&47&10,329,762&13,146&7,210 for examples g and h both algorithms ran in almost 0 time .
for the other examples , the above results demonstrate that our algorithm @xmath333 outperforms the cms algorithm .
we also consider examples with worst - case numbers of cc - sets .
let , as in theorem [ upper_bound ] , @xmath73 denote the digraph obtained from the complete bipartite graph @xmath74 by orienting every edge from the partite set of cardinality @xmath75 to the partite set of cardinality @xmath76 by theorem [ upper_bound ] the digraphs @xmath334 with @xmath78 have the maximum possible number of cc - sets .
our experimental results for digraphs @xmath334 with @xmath78 are given in table [ ri : max ] .
again we see that @xmath333 outperforms the cms algorithm .
32,400 & 30&1616 & 64 & 65,041 & 56&2317 & 72 & 130,322 & 114&6018 & 81 & 261,139 & 240&11319 & 90 & 522,722 & 540&25320 & 100 & 1,046,549 & 1,080&51321 & 110 & 2,094,102 & 2,166&1,04822 & 121 & 4,190,231 & 4,086&2,156 we have compared algorithm @xmath278 with both cms running in ` unconnected ' mode and with api06 .
the examples used are the same as in table 1 , however we do not give results for examples b , d , e and i as these graphs produce an extremely large number of convex sets and as a result , do not terminate in reasonable time .
the results are shown in table [ ri : basicb ] .
we can see that although cms generally out - performs api06 , there are two cases where api06 is marginally better .
however , @xmath278 is consistantly three to five times faster than either of the other algorithms .
( ct)&@xmath278 ( ct)a & 35 & 38 & 1,123,851 & 2,560 & 1,390 & 270c & 26&28&120,411&250&120&40f & 24&22&3,782,820&3,250&3,630&860 g & 20&19&122,111&70&120&30h & 20&21&55,083&110&110&20 for interest we have also compared api06 , cms and @xmath278 on the digraphs that have maximal numbers of cc - sets . the results are shown in table [ ri : maxb ] . again , while cms and api06 are roughly comparable , @xmath278 is a least twice as fast as both of them .
( ct)&@xmath278 ( ct)15 & 56 & 32,768 & 40&40&1016 & 64 & 65,536 & 70&70&3017 & 72 & 131,072 & 140&130&6018 & 81 & 261,144 & 320&320&13019 & 90 & 524,288 & 720&700&32020 & 100 & 1,046,575 & 1,590&1,500&71021 & 110 & 2,097,152 & 3,320&3,010&1,50022 & 121 & 4,194,304 & 7,140&6,310&3,120
let @xmath7 be a connected ( undirected ) graph with vertex set @xmath335 and let @xmath7 have @xmath12 edges . for a vertex @xmath336 and a set @xmath337 , let @xmath338 and @xmath339 the following is an algorithm , @xmath18 , for generating all connected sets of @xmath7 .
step 1 : : : for each @xmath95 do the following . set @xmath96 and @xmath97 .
initiate the set @xmath340 as @xmath341 .
step 2 ( subroutine @xmath342 ) : : : _ comment : @xmath343 finds all connected sets @xmath62 in @xmath1 such that @xmath344_. + ( 2a ) : ; ; if @xmath345 then return the connected set @xmath0 ( and stop ) .
( 2b ) : ; ; if @xmath346 , then let @xmath347 be arbitrary .
( 2c ) : ; ; _ comment : in this step we will find all connected sets @xmath42 such that @xmath348_. + set @xmath349 , @xmath350 and @xmath351 . remove @xmath88 from @xmath17 and @xmath340 , and add it to @xmath0 . for
every @xmath352 check whether @xmath20 has an edge to @xmath88 and if it does then add it to @xmath340 .
+ make a recursive call to subroutine @xmath342
. _ comment : we consider the new @xmath0 and @xmath17_. + change @xmath340 , @xmath0 , and @xmath17 back to their original state by setting @xmath353 , @xmath354 , and @xmath355 .
( 2d ) : ; ; _ comment : in this step we will find all connected sets @xmath42 such that @xmath356 and @xmath357_. remove @xmath88 from @xmath17 and remove @xmath88 from @xmath340 .
+ make a recursive call to subroutine @xmath342 . + change @xmath17 back to its original state by adding @xmath88 back to @xmath17
. also change @xmath340 back to its original state by adding @xmath88 to it .
similarly to theorem [ maint ] , one can prove the following : let @xmath9 be the number of connected sets of a connected graph @xmath7 .
algorithm @xmath18 is correct and its time and space complexities are @xmath19 and @xmath16 , respectively .
our computational experiments show that @xmath3 performs well and is of definite practical interest .
we have tried various heuristic approaches to speed up the algorithm in practice , but all approaches were beneficial for some instances and inferior to the original algorithm for some other instances . moreover
, no approach could significantly change the running time .
the algorithm was developed independently from the cms algorithm .
however , the two algorithms are closely related , and work continues to isolate the implementation effects that give the performance differences . * acknowledgements .
* we are grateful to the authors of @xcite for helpful discussions and for giving us access to their code allowing us to benchmark our algorithm against theirs .
research of gregory gutin and anders yeo was supported in part by an epsrc grant .
research of gutin was also supported in part by the ist programme of the european community , under the pascal network of excellence , ist-2002 - 506778 .
m. r. guthaus , j. s. ringenberg , d. ernst , t. m. austin , t. mudge and r. b. brown , mibench : a free , commercially representative embedded benchmark suite , in _ proceedings of the wwc-4 , 2001 ieee international workshop on workload characterization _ , ( 2001 ) , 314 .
l. pozzi , k. atasu and p ienne , exact and approximate algorithms for the extension of embedded processor instruction sets .
_ ieee trans .
on cad of integrated circuits and systems _ , * 25 * ( 2006 ) , 12091229 .
p. yu and t. mitra , satisfying real - time constraints with custom instructions .
_ codes+isss 05 : proceedings of the 3rd ieee / acm / ifip international conference on hardware / software codesign and system synthesis _ , acm , new york ( 2005 ) , 166171 . | a set @xmath0 of vertices of an acyclic digraph @xmath1 is convex if @xmath2 and there is no directed path between vertices of @xmath0 which contains a vertex not in @xmath0 .
a set @xmath0 is connected if @xmath2 and the underlying undirected graph of the subgraph of @xmath1 induced by @xmath0 is connected .
connected convex sets and convex sets of acyclic digraphs are of interest in the area of modern embedded processor technology .
we construct an algorithm @xmath3 for enumeration of all connected convex sets of an acyclic digraph @xmath1 of order @xmath4 .
the time complexity of @xmath3 is @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the number of connected convex sets in @xmath1 .
we also give an optimal algorithm for enumeration of all ( not just connected ) convex sets of an acyclic digraph @xmath1 of order @xmath4 . in computational experiments
we demonstrate that our algorithms outperform the best algorithms in the literature . using the same approach as for @xmath3
, we design an algorithm for generating all connected sets of a connected undirected graph @xmath7 .
the complexity of the algorithm is @xmath8 where @xmath4 is the order of @xmath7 and @xmath9 is the number of connected sets of @xmath10 the previously reported algorithm for connected set enumeration is of running time @xmath11 , where @xmath12 is the number of edges in @xmath10 |
the _ iras faint source catalog _ ( fsc ; moshir et al .
1992 ) contains 173,044 sources reaching a depth of @xmath70.2 jy at 12 , 25 and 60 @xmath0 .
it is limited to @xmath8 in unconfused regions at 60 @xmath0 . for sources with high - quality flux density ,
reliability is @xmath9 at 12 and 25 @xmath0 and @xmath10 at 60 @xmath0 . around 41@xmath4 of the fsc sources
are detected at 60 @xmath11 m ( fqual @xmath3 1 ) .
the construction of the imperial iras - fsc redshift catalogue ( iifscz ; wang & rowan - robinson 2009 ) was made possible by overlaps ( in terms of depth and area ) with various imaging and/or redshift surveys , such as the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; york et al .
2000 ) , the two micron all sky survey ( 2mass ; skrutskie et al . 2006 ) and the 6df galaxy survey ( jones et al . 2004 , 2005 )
. however , the large positional error of the iras sources has meant in particular that the cross - identification between iras and the deep optical data sdss is very challenging .
the completion and/or release of several major surveys in the last few years , including the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ; wright et al .
2010 ) all - sky survey , the galex all - sky survey source catalog ( gasc ; seibert et al .
, in prep . ) , the 2mass redshift survey ( 2mrs ; huchra et al .
2012 ) , the tenth sdss data release ( dr10 ; ahn et al .
2013 ) and the planck all - sky survey ( planck collaboration i 2013 ) in the microwave and sub - millimetre ( sub - mm ) , has made it imperative to revise the iifscz .
in particular , the imaging depth and sky coverage of wise are such that the wise all - sky source catalogue provides counterparts for the majority of sources in the iifscz and thereby improves the positional accuracy of these sources by a factor of @xmath710 . using the wise positions , cross - identification between iras sources and sources detected at uv , optical and
near - infrared becomes much easier and much more reliable .
the layout of this paper is as follows . in section
[ sec : identification ] , first we cross - identify iras fsc sources with their mid - infrared ( mir ) wise counterparts using a likelihood ratio technique .
then , using their wise positions , we cross - match fsc sources with sources detected in other wavebands including the ultra - violet ( uv ) , optical , near - infrared ( nir ) and sub - mm .
spectroscopic redshifts are collected from a number of databases , e.g. , sdss dr10 , 2mrs and ned . in section 3
, we estimate photometric redshift using a template - fitting method for sources matched with wise , sdss and/or 2mass counterparts but do not have spectroscopic redshifts . in section 4 , infrared templates are fitted to the mid- and far - infrared data from iras and wise as well as sub - mm data from planck for fsc sources with wise and planck associations .
once a best - fit infrared template is found , we make flux predictions at far - infrared and sub - mm wavelengths .
finally , discussions and conclusions of the overall properties of the revised iras - fsc redshift catalogue ( rifscz ) are given in section 5 . throughout the paper ,
we adopt a flat cosmological model with @xmath12 and @xmath13 and a salpeter initial mass function ( salpeter et al . 1955 ) . unless otherwise stated , we use the ab magnitude system , and @xmath14 .
our starting point is the complete sample of galaxies selected at 60 @xmath0 from the iras fsc , presented in wang & rowan - robinson ( 2009 ) . for the sake of completeness , we briefly summarise our selection criteria here : ( 1 ) to ensure reliability , we select sources with fqual @xmath15 and snr @xmath16 at 60 @xmath0 ; ( 2 ) to exclude cirrus , we require @xmath17(s100/s60)@xmath18 if fqual @xmath19 at 100 @xmath0 ; ( 3 ) to discriminate against stars , we firstly require @xmath17(s60/s25)@xmath20 if fqual @xmath19 at 25 @xmath0 and then @xmath17(s60/s12)@xmath21 if fqual @xmath22 2 at 12 @xmath0 . the wide - field infrared survey explorer ( wise ; wright et al .
2010 ) mapped the sky at 3.4 , 4.6 , 12 , and 22 @xmath0 ( w1 , w2 , w3 , w4 ) with an angular resolution of 6.1 , 6.4 , 6.5and 12.0respectively .
the all - sky release includes all data taken during the full cryogenic mission phase and the all - sky source catalog contains the properties of over 563 million point - like and resolved objects . to ensure a high degree of reliability
, sources are required to meet snr @xmath3 5 in at least one wise band and other criteria .
photometry is presented in the form of point source profile - fitting measurement and multi - aperture photometry .
wise 5@xmath6 photometric sensitivity is estimated to be 0.068 , 0.098 , 0.86 and 5.4 mjy at 3.4 , 4.6 , 12 and 22 @xmath0 in unconfused regions on the ecliptic plane ( wright et al .
sensitivity is better in regions at higher ecliptic latitudes with deeper coverage and lower zodiacal background , and worse in regions with high source density or complex background .
wise provides vega magnitudes and we have taken the corrections to ab magnitudes to be 2.683 , 3.319 , 5.242 and 6.604 mags at 3.4 , 4.6 , 12 and 22 @xmath0 .
( dotted line ) , while the radial distribution of the true counterparts follows the rayleigh radial distribution ( solid line ) .
the dashed line corresponds to the sum of the solid line and the dotted line .
the vertical line marks @xmath23 where the radial distribution of the true counterparts peaks .
bottom : the average distribution of the 60-to-3.4 @xmath0 colour of all wise sources within 40 per fsc source ( blue histogram ) compared to that of all wise sources within 40 of a random location ( red histogram ) .
we assume that the colour distribution of the true counterparts can be fit by a gaussian distribution ( dot - dashed line ) and the colour distribution of the random associations can be fit by an exponential function ( dashed line ) .
the solid line is the sum of the dashed line and the dot - dashed line . to avoid incompleteness problems at faint
3.4 @xmath0 fluxes ( i.e. large 60-to-3.4 @xmath0 colour ) , the fitting is carried out at @xmath24.,title="fig:",width=326,height=246 ] ( dotted line ) , while the radial distribution of the true counterparts follows the rayleigh radial distribution ( solid line ) .
the dashed line corresponds to the sum of the solid line and the dotted line .
the vertical line marks @xmath23 where the radial distribution of the true counterparts peaks .
bottom : the average distribution of the 60-to-3.4 @xmath0 colour of all wise sources within 40 per fsc source ( blue histogram ) compared to that of all wise sources within 40 of a random location ( red histogram ) .
we assume that the colour distribution of the true counterparts can be fit by a gaussian distribution ( dot - dashed line ) and the colour distribution of the random associations can be fit by an exponential function ( dashed line ) .
the solid line is the sum of the dashed line and the dot - dashed line . to avoid incompleteness problems at faint
3.4 @xmath0 fluxes ( i.e. large 60-to-3.4 @xmath0 colour ) , the fitting is carried out at @xmath24.,title="fig:",width=326,height=246 ] we use the likelihood ratio technique ( lr ; sutherland & saunders 1992 ; brusa et al .
2007 ; wang & rowan - robinson 2010 ; chapin et al . 2011 ; wang et al . 2013 ) to cross - match fsc sources with counterparts at 3.4 @xmath0 which is the most sensitive wise band .
the lr technique compares the probability of a true counterpart with the probability of a chance association , as a function of 60-to-3.4 @xmath0 flux ratio @xmath25 and radial offset @xmath26 .
assuming the probability of true counterpart and random association is separable in @xmath27 ( or @xmath28 as a shorthand ) and @xmath26 , we can write @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the colour distributions of the true counterparts and random matches respectively , and @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the positional distributions of the true counterparts and random associations respectively . to derive the positional distribution of the true counterparts @xmath32 ,
we assume a symmetric gaussian distribution as a function of orthogonal positional coordinates . therefore , @xmath34 can be written as a rayleigh radial distribution , @xmath35 where the scale parameter of the rayleigh distribution @xmath36 is where @xmath32 peaks and @xmath37 .
the positional distribution of random associations can be written as @xmath38 assuming a constant surface density of random background 3.4 @xmath0 sources uncorrelated with fsc sources . in the top panel in fig .
[ fig : offset ] , we plot the average distribution of radial offsets between fsc and wise sources per fsc source , which contains both the true counterparts and the random associations .
we fit our model @xmath39 to the observed histogram to determine the best - fit parameters to be @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath42 arc sec@xmath43 .
consequently , the best - fit radial distribution of the true counterparts and that of the random associations can be characterised using our model , which are plotted as the thick solid line and the dotted line in the top panel in fig .
[ fig : offset ] . in the bottom panel in fig .
[ fig : offset ] , we plot the average 60-to-3.4 @xmath0 colour distribution of all fsc - wise matches per fsc source and per randomised fsc source .
the former contains both real fsc - wise matches and random associations .
the latter contains only random 3.4 @xmath0 sources uncorrelated with fsc sources .
we generate the randomised fsc catalogue by locally randomising the iras positions and randomly swapping the 60 @xmath0 flux densities .
the colour distribution per randomised fsc source can be characterised by an exponential increase towards larger values of @xmath44 ( fainter 3.4 @xmath0 flux densities ) followed by an exponential decrease due to incompleteness
. the colour distribution per fsc source can be characterised by a gaussian distribution of the true counterparts and the double exponential form of the random associations .
consequently , we fit a gaussian and an exponential function to the colour distribution per fsc source at @xmath24 .
we can now calculate the likelihood ratio for every possible match between fsc and wise sources .
the exact value of the likelihood ratio is not important , only the relative ordering matters . in fig .
[ fig : fid_comp ] , we plot the lr distribution of all matches between fsc and wise ( the solid histogram ) and the lr distribution of all matches between the randomised fsc and wise ( the dashed histogram ) . at @xmath45 ,
the solid histogram becomes indistinguishable from the dashed histogram , which indicates that the vast majority of the real matches between fsc and wise have @xmath45 .
it is clear that real matches between fsc and wise sources form a peak at high lr values .
we select fsc - wise matches with @xmath46 which corresponds to @xmath74% false identification rate . in cases where there are more than one candidate wise source matched to the same fsc source , @xmath47 of them have more than one wise match . however , we emphasise that this percentage depends on the chosen lr threshold . ]
, the one with the highest likelihood ratio is selected . in total , 48,603 iras sources ( @xmath48 of the rifscz catalogue ) are matched with a wise 3.4 @xmath0 counterpart . in fig .
[ fig:2dratio ] , we plot the 2d distribution in @xmath49 and radial offset @xmath26 of all matches between fsc and wise ( left panel ) , all matches between randomised fsc and wise ( middle ) , and the final matched fsc - wise catalogue using the likelihood ratio technique ( right ) .
we can also check the degree of agreement between iras 25 @xmath0 and wise 22 @xmath0 detections . in fig .
[ fig : iras_vs_wise ] , we plot the iras 25 @xmath0 flux density to wise 22 @xmath0 flux density ratio versus the iras 25 @xmath0 flux density for fsc - wise matched sources with snr @xmath3 2 in the wise 22 @xmath0 band and fqual in the iras 25 @xmath0 band = 1 , 2 or 3 . a good agreement between wise and iras can be seen for sources with high quality iras flux density measurements ( fqual @xmath50 ) .
wise fluxes are systematically below the iras fluxes even after taking into account the band difference .
this systematic trend can be removed after making aperture correction at the wise bands ( see section 3.1 ) . a similar comparison between the iras 12 @xmath0 fluxes and the wise 12 @xmath0 fluxes can be made .
however , the number of iras sources with high quality flux measurement at 12 @xmath0 is very small . therefore , we do not show a plot of the 12 @xmath0 flux comparison here . galex has undertaken a number of surveys covering large areas of sky at a variety of depths .
the largest two are the all - sky ( ais ) and medium imaging surveys ( mis ) .
the ais is much shallower than the mis but it covers a much larger area of sky .
the standard galex database contains all of the detected sources which include many duplicate observations of the same source as well as numerous spurious sources . to address these problems , two catalogues of galex measurements , namely the galex all - sky survey source catalog ( gasc ) and the galex medium imaging survey catalog ( gmsc ) ,
have been constructed ( seibert et al . in prep . ) .
sources are selected if they are detected in the nuv with snr @xmath51 .
covering a total of 26,300 deg@xmath52 of sky , the gasc consists of all galex observations reaching a depth of nuv 21 ( ab mag ) and a total of 40 million unique sources .
following budavri et al .
( 2009 ) and heinis et al .
( 2009 ) , we match galex sources with fsc sources which have received accurate positions from wise , using a search radius of 5 . a total of 31,552 matches are found which correspond to 31,537 unique fsc sources .
only about 10 fsc sources have multiple galex matches . for these 10 sources , we simply select the closest galex source as the correct association .
flux density versus wise 22 @xmath0 flux density for fsc - wise matched sources . a good agreement between wise and iras
can be seen for sources with high quality iras flux density measurements ( fqual=3 ) . above the solid red line , sources are below the wise 5@xmath6 photometric sensitivity at 22 @xmath0.,width=331,height=249 ] the original iifscz cross - matched iras fsc with sdss dr6 .
the source identification process was complicated as the probability of chance association is @xmath53 , where n is the number density of background optical objects and @xmath54 is the cross - matching radius .
the positional uncertainty of the fsc sources matched with wise improved drastically thanks to the much higher wise angular resolution . following yan et al .
( 2013 ) , we carried out source matching between iras sources with wise positions and sdss dr10 using a matching radius of 3 .
the sdss photometric dr10 survey has covered a total unique area of 14,555 deg@xmath52 ( ahn et al .
2013 ) . in total , 25,553 sdss sources are found within 3 of the iras sources matched with wise .
only primary sdss objects are selected .
20,277 fsc sources have unique sdss association within 3 , 2,531 fsc sources have multiple sdss matches .
we simply assign the closest sdss object as the correct optical association for fsc sources with multiple sdss matches .
for some large , nearby galaxies this procedure can lead to association with the wrong sdss source .
we have corrected this where possible .
the 2mass survey has imaged the whole sky in the j ( 1.24 @xmath0 ) , h ( 1.66 @xmath0 ) and k@xmath55 ( 2.16 @xmath0 ) near - infrared wavebands ( skrutskie et al . 2006 ) .
the 2mass all - sky release point source catalog ( psc ) contains attributes in the three survey bands for over 470 million sources .
the 2mass all - sky data release extended source catalog ( xsc ; jarrett et al .
2000 ) contains properties for over 1.6 million objects which are resolved relative to a single point - spread - function .
the psc contains point - source processed photometry for almost all of the resolved sources in the xsc .
association information cross - referencing wise sources with the 2mass psc is provided in the wise all - sky source catalog . in total , there are 45,892 sources in the 2mass psc matched to the 48,603 fsc sources which have received wise positions .
we also matched the 48,603 fsc sources with the 2mass xsc . in total , 35,772 out of the 48,603 fsc sources found a 2mass xsc counterpart .
the first public release ( pr1 ) of the planck catalogue of compact sources ( pccs ; planck collaboration xxviii 2013 ) consists of nine single - frequency catalogues of compact sources over the entire sky , covering the frequency range from 30 to 857 ghz ( 10561 to 350 @xmath0 ) .
we cross - match the planck pr1 catalogue at 857 ghz with the iifscz catalogue using a matching radius of 3 .
the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) of the planck beam at 857 ghz is 4.33 .
the 857 ghz catalogue also includes aperture photometry at 217 ( 1382 @xmath0 ) , 353 ( 850 @xmath0 ) and 545 ghz ( 550 @xmath0 ) . in total , there are 4,136 matched sources .
only about 30 planck sources have more than one fsc sources within 3 .
the histogram of positional differences between iras and planck positions peaks at 40 .
the comparison between the planck 857 ghz flux densities and the iras 100 @xmath0 or 60 @xmath0 flux densities exhibits a good general correlation as shown in fig .
[ fig : iras_vs_planck ] .
there are 1,200 iifscz sources with a planck detection better than 5@xmath6 in at least one of the 350 , 550 , 850 or 1382 @xmath0 bands ( and 2,364 sources with a planck detection better than 3@xmath6 ) .
these are the most reliable planck point - sources at @xmath56 , since for planck sources unassociated with an iras extragalactic source there is a strong possibility that the source is due to cirrus .
( top panel ) or 100 @xmath0 ( bottom panel ) flux density versus planck 857 ghz ( 350 @xmath0 ) flux density for fsc - planck matched sources .
a generally good correlation between planck and iras fluxes can be seen.,title="fig:",width=326,height=240 ] ( top panel ) or 100 @xmath0 ( bottom panel ) flux density versus planck 857 ghz ( 350 @xmath0 ) flux density for fsc - planck matched sources . a generally good correlation between planck and iras fluxes
can be seen.,title="fig:",width=326,height=240 ] the sdss spectroscopic dr10 survey has covered a total unique area of 9274 deg@xmath52 ( ahn et al .
we get 11,749 redshift by cross - matching iras sources with wise positions and sdss objects .
the 2mass redshift survey ( 2mrs ; huchra et al .
2012 ) ultimately aims to determine the redshifts of all galaxies in the 2mass xsc to a magnitude of k=12.2 mag and to within 5 deg of the galactic plane .
the second phase of 2mrs is now complete , providing an all - sky survey of 45,000 galaxies to a limiting magnitude of k=11.75 mag .
we retrieve 9 , 264 redshifts by cross - matching iras sources with wise positions and 2mass sources .
an ned all - sky query of fsc sources at @xmath8 with available redshift and s60 @xmath3 0.1 jy returned 64,219 objects .
9,523 new redshifts ( not included in sdss dr10 or 2mrs ) are obtained .
we also managed to get 4,557 spectroscopic redshifts from the psc redshift survey ( pscz ; saunders et al .
2000 ) , the 6df galaxy survey , and the fss redshift survey ( fssz ; oliver , phd thesis ) .
to summarise , we have obtained 33 , 956 spectroscopic redshifts from sdss dr10 , 2mrs , ned , fssz , pscz and 6df , which comprises @xmath1 of our base catalogue .
table 1 shows a breakdown of the multi - wavelength photometric data ( from galex , sdss , 2mass , wise , iras , planck and nvss ) for the rifscz .
table 2 shows a summary of spectroscopic redshift data ( from sdss , 2mrs , ned , fssz , pscz and 6df ) for the rifscz .
.summary of the multi - wavelength photometric data for the revised iras - fsc redshift catalogue .
the statistics shown for the galex and planck data require snr @xmath51 .
the statistics for the iras data require flux density quality @xmath57 . [ cols="<,<",options="header " , ]
we apply a template - fitting method that has been used to construct the swire photometric redshift catalogue ( rowan - robinson et al .
2008 and references therein ) to the revised iifscz galaxies with either optical or near - infrared photometry .
initially we use only a single pass through the data and a resolution of 0.002 in @xmath58 .
we use six galaxy templates ( e , sab , sbc , scd , sdm and starburst ) and three qso templates , as in rowan - robinson et al .
our starting point is the revised iifscz sample of 60,303 sources associated with galex , sdss , 2mass , wise , planck and nvss , and with obvious stars and cirrus sources removed .
33,956 sources now have spectroscopic redshifts through a compilation of several major spectroscopic surveys and the ned database .
we estimate photometric redshifts for the remainder using the available 0.361 - 4.6 @xmath0 photometric data .
we use sdss model magnitudes and 2mass extended fluxes , where available .
[ plot3446galqso6f ] shows the wise [email protected] @xmath0 colour versus 3.4 @xmath0 flux density s3.4 .
there is clearly increased scatter at the faintest 3.4 @xmath0 fluxes .
thus , we only use wise 3.4 and 4.6 @xmath0 fluxes in the photometric redshift estimation if s3.4 @xmath3 1 mjy and s4.6 @xmath3 1 mjy .
we also require s12 @xmath3 1 mjy , s24 @xmath3 5 mjy ( corresponding roughly to the 5-@xmath6 wise limits ) .
flux density ( in mjy ) s3.4 versus the 3.4-to-4.6 @xmath0 flux density ratio @xmath60 , exhibiting increased scatter at s3.4 @xmath61 1 mjy ( below the dashed line ) .
red dots are galaxies and blue dots are quasars in the rifscz.,width=326,height=297 ] the left panel in fig .
[ plotdelmag ] shows the j - band aperture correction ( @xmath62 ) versus ( @xmath63 ) , illustrating that the sdss model magnitudes and 2mass extended magnitudes have well - matched aperture corrections .
however a similar plot for ( @xmath64 ) shows a strong dependence of colour on j - band aperture correction , suggesting that the wise 3.4 and 4.6 @xmath0 magnitudes need to be aperture corrected .
the right panel in fig .
[ plotdelmag ] shows ( @xmath62 ) versus ( @xmath65 ) ) , illustrating that the wise 3.4 @xmath0 magnitudes need an aperture correction = 0.6 @xmath66 the 2mass j - band aperture correction , delmag = @xmath62 .
we have applied this same aperture correction to the wise 4.6 @xmath0 data .
we have also explored whether the wise 12 and 22 @xmath0 fluxes need aperture correction , and found optimum results with @xmath67 and @xmath68 where delmag is the j - band aperture correction , @xmath62 .
the left panel in fig .
[ irasvswise ] shows the iras 12 @xmath0 flux versus the aperture corrected wise 12 @xmath0 flux .
the right panel in fig .
[ irasvswise ] shows the iras 25 @xmath0 flux versus the aperture corrected wise 22 @xmath0 flux .
the agreement is good in both cases , except for a tail of sources where the wise fluxes appear to be underestimated . the alternative interpretation ,
that the iras fluxes are overestimated does not fit in well with sed modelling of these sources . to distinguish reliably between galaxies and qsos without generating excessive aliasing , a measure of stellarity is required .
sdss sources with sdsstyp = star " are given a stellar flag , as are ned sources with nedtp = qso " .
in addition we have assumed that sources with @xmath69 are stellar .
a feature of the codes developed for estimating photometric redshifts for spitzer galaxies ( rowan - robinson et al 2005 , 2008 , 2012 ) is the use of 3.6 and 4.5 @xmath0 data to constrain redshift .
this is very effective in reducing the number of catastrophic outliers .
however it becomes important to identify those galaxies with significant agn dust tori , whether qsos or seyferts , since the dust torus can dominate over starlight ( or agn continuum ) at wavelengths down to 1 @xmath0 .
if we want to use the wise 3.4 and 4.6 @xmath0 fluxes ( and the j , h , and k@xmath70 fluxes ) in the redshift solution , we have to find a way of identifying the agn dust tori .
we have chosen to use a key diagnostic diagram introduced by rowan - robinson and crawford ( 1969 ) , the 12 - 25 - 60 @xmath0 colour - colour diagram .
[ plot122260fssgalqso4 ] shows a plot of @xmath71 versus @xmath72 for the rifscz sample , with 12 and 22 @xmath0 fluxes taken from wise and the 60 @xmath0 flux taken from iras .
sources to the left of the sloping line in fig .
[ plot122260fssgalqso4 ] are assumed to have significant dust tori and these ( together with all sources identified as qsos on the first pass ) go through a second photometric redshift pass in which , following rowan - robinson et al ( 2012 ) , each galaxy or qso template has added to it ten different possible amplitudes of an agn dust torus .
wise 3.4 and 4.6 @xmath0 data are used only in the second pass , for the sources suspected to contain agn dust tori . for galaxies without agn dust tori , the 3.4 and 4.6 @xmath0 did not improve the redshift solution , perhaps because of inadequate aperture correction of extended sources
. flux ratio , @xmath73 , versus the 60-to-22 @xmath0 flux ratio , @xmath74 , with qsos shown in red .
objects to the left of the sloping line are assumed to have significant dust tori and thus go through a second photometric redshift pass.,width=326,height=307 ] the top panel in fig .
[ zplotfssfinal8irb8err3 ] shows a comparison of photometric and spectroscopic redshifts for sources with at least 8 photometric bands and with reduced @xmath75 .
the percentage of catastrophic outliers , i.e. ( @xmath76 ) differs from ( @xmath77 ) by more than 15@xmath4 , is 0.17 , 3.4 and 3.5 @xmath4 for sources with 8 , 5 and 3 photometric bands , respectively .
the rms accuracy , after exclusion of these outliers , is 3.5 , 4.0 and 3.8 @xmath4 for sources with 8 , 5 and 3 photometric bands , respectively .
these represent a good photometric redshift performance ( cf rowan - robinson et al 2008 , 2013 ) .
the bottom panel in fig .
[ zplotfssfinal8irb8err3 ] shows a comparison of spectroscopic and photometric redshifts for qsos with at least 3 photometric bands and reduced @xmath78 .
the approximately power - law form of the optical continua of qsos leads to some redshift aliasing .
to summarise , we have 33,956 spectroscopic redshifts , 15,406 photometric redshifts , 37 sources with photometry but no successful redshift due to inconsistencies among the photometry data , and 10,941 sources with no spectroscopic or photometric redshift . .
the thick diagonal line corresponds to @xmath79 .
galaxies outside the two thin diagonal lines are outliers with @xmath80 ( i.e. @xmath81 ) .
bottom : spectroscopic versus photometric redshift for all qsos with at least 3 photometric bands and reduced @xmath75 .
the thick diagonal line corresponds to @xmath79 .
qsos outside the two thin diagonal lines are outliers with @xmath82 ( i.e. @xmath83).,title="fig:",width=326,height=307 ] .
the thick diagonal line corresponds to @xmath79 .
galaxies outside the two thin diagonal lines are outliers with @xmath80 ( i.e. @xmath81 ) .
bottom : spectroscopic versus photometric redshift for all qsos with at least 3 photometric bands and reduced @xmath75 .
the thick diagonal line corresponds to @xmath79 .
qsos outside the two thin diagonal lines are outliers with @xmath82 ( i.e. @xmath83).,title="fig:",width=326,height=307 ] fig .
[ probfssnewg45sed ] shows seds of galaxies ( and one qso ) which are outliers with @xmath84 ( i.e. @xmath81 ) in fig .
[ zplotfssfinal8irb8err3 ] .
galex data have been used in the sed plots , where available , but not in the photometric redshift solution .
the spectroscopic redshifts , as indicated near each object , look plausible in all cases . the photometric redshift appears to be pulled away from the correct value by small mismatches in the sdss and 2mass aperture corrections , and by aliasing caused by dust extinction . where the aperture corrected sdss and 2mass fluxes are highly discrepant we have used only 2mass fluxes in the redshift solution .
mid- and far - infrared data from iras and wise ( 12 , 22 , 25 , 60 and 100 @xmath0 ) and sub - mm data from planck ( 350 , 550 and 850 @xmath0 ) were fitted initially , following the methodology of rowan - robinson et al ( 2005 , 2008 ) and as in wang & rowan - robinson ( 2009a ) , with a combination of four infrared templates ( cirrus , m82 and arp220 starbursts , or agn dust torus ) .
however while the four standard infrared templates work well for many sources , the 350 - 850 @xmath0 fluxes often require the presence of colder dust than is incorporated into our four basic templates .
the two new templates used here are taken from the range of optically thin interstellar medium ( cirrus " ) templates developed by rowan - robinson ( 1992 ) and efstathiou & rowan - robinson ( 2003 ) .
the key parameter determining the temperature of the dust grains is the intensity of the radiation field , which we can characterise by the ratio of intensity of radiation field to the local interstellar radiation field , @xmath85 .
the standard cirrus template corresponds to @xmath85 = 5 , and this is the value used by rowan - robinson ( 1992 ) to fit the central regions of our galaxy .
@xmath85 = 1 corresponds to the interstellar radiation field in the vicinity of the sun .
we also find that some galaxies need a much lower intensity radiation field than this , with @xmath85 = 0.1 .
the corresponding grain temperatures in the dust model of rowan - robinson ( 1992 ) for the two new template are in the ranges 14.5 - 19.7 k and 9.8 - 13.4 k respectively .
full details of the templates used are given at http://astro.ic.ac.uk/mrr/swirephotzcat/templates/readme .
following the analysis of rowan - robinson & efstathiou ( 2009 ) of the spoon et al ( 2008 ) irs diagnostic diagram , we have also introduced a young starburst ( ysb ) template , more extreme than the arp220 template .
this was found to be necessary by rowan - robinson et al ( 2010 ) in their analysis of the seds of a preliminary sample of 68 lockman - spire sources .
another template considered , following rowan - robinson & efstathiou ( 2009 ) , was an old starburst template , but we found that the sed for this was too similar to a pure cirrus template to be a worthwhile addition .
our automatic sed fitting code uses two cirrus templates ( @xmath85 = 5 , 1 ) , one of three starburst templates ( m82 , arp220 , ysb ) , and an agn dust torus template .
these infrared sed templates provide a good fit to the mid- and far - infrared , and sub - mm , data for most sources .
[ plot256010026ir11ht ] shows the 25 ( or 22 ) - 60 - 100 @xmath0 colour - colour diagram , colour - coded by the infrared template making the dominant contribution to the infrared luminosity .
sources whose seds are dominated by standard cirrus ( @xmath86 ) or cool cirrus ( @xmath87 ) have colder 60 - 100 @xmath0 colours , while starburst or agn dominated sources have warmer 60 - 100 @xmath0 colours .
colour - colour diagram for rifscz sources , colour - coded by the infrared template making the dominant contribution to the infrared luminosity .
location of individual templates in this plot are shown .
it is clear that standard cirrus ( @xmath86 ) or cool cirrus ( @xmath87 ) dominated sources have colder 60 - 100 @xmath0 colours , while starburst or agn dominated sources have warmer 60 - 100 @xmath0 colours.,width=326,height=307 ] fig .
[ plot350550errir6ir11ht ] shows the plankc 350@xmath59500 @xmath0 flux - ratio versus the reduced @xmath88 for the infrared and sub - mm fit .
this illustrates that the reduced @xmath88 is good for most sources , and especially for warmer sources .
we have modelled the seds of all sources with sub - mm data for which @xmath89 . for many cases
the poor @xmath88 is simply due to incorrect aperture corrections , especially for the wise fluxes .
for very large galaxies which are in the iras large optical galaxy catalog ( rice et al 1988 ) , or which have delmag @xmath61 -3 , we do not use the wise fluxes in the redshift or infrared template fit solutions . in most cases
there is a need for the cold cirrus component ( @xmath85 = 0.1 ) , as found previously by rowan - robinson et al ( 2010 ) and planck collaboration xvi ( 2011 ) .
[ probfssnewir ] shows seds for 21 sources with good 350 @xmath0 detections , @xmath90 , 8 optical and near - infrared photometric bands and @xmath91 .
a further 2 ( not shown ) are qsos ( 3c273 , oj287 ) , which we do not expect to be fitted by our templates . for 19 of these sources
the fit is improved by adding a cold cirrus component .
one source ( f01464 + 1954 ) is a candidate to be a lensed galaxy . 550 @xmath0 flux density ratio versus the reduced @xmath88 for the infrared and sub - millimetre fit .
it is clear that the reduced @xmath88 is good for most of the sources and especially for warmer sources.,width=326,height=307 ] there are 1,200 rifscz sources which have been matched to a planck detection better than @xmath92 in at least one of the 350 , 550 , 850 and 1382 @xmath0 bands ( and 2,386 sources with a planck detection @xmath93 in at least one band ) .
they are also of great interest because for these sources we have the strongest constraints on their far - infrared and sub - mm spectrum . the left panel in fig .
[ plot601008506ir11h6pierre ] shows the 60 - 350 - 550 @xmath0 colour - colour diagram ( s350@xmath59s550 versus s60@xmath59s350 ) for 5@xmath6 planck sources , with locations of our infrared model templates indicated .
a further illustration of the need for a cold cirrus component is proved by this figure .
the location of the different templates ( at @xmath94 ) are indicated , together with a mixture line between an m82 starburst and the cold cirrus ( @xmath85 = 0.1 ) template . the right panel in fig .
[ plot601008506ir11h6pierre ] shows s100@xmath59s850 versus s100@xmath59s60 for rifscz galaxies and for a compilation of ground - based 850 @xmath0 detections ( p. chanial personal communication ) , together with model sequences of starburst and cirrus templates .
the group of 6 sources at the bottom of the plot are known blazers .
this figure again illustrates the need for cooler cirrus templates to explain the observed sub - millimetre fluxes .
[ plotirlumzfinal28ir ] shows the infrared luminosity versus redshift for the rifscz sources , colour - coded by infrared template type .
where sources selected cirrus templates with @xmath95 , or have @xmath96 , sources were put through a second pass with such unphysical cirrus luminosities not permitted .
many sources found acceptable fits with other templates .
those that had poor reduced @xmath88 in the infrared template fit may be a consequence of mis - association of the iras source with other catalogues , or of incorrect redshifts , or may be candidate of gravitationally lensed objects .
178 galaxies are found to by hyper - luminous ( @xmath97 ) ( cf rowan - robinson 2000 ) , of which 61 have spectroscopic redshifts .
this is very similar to the 179 found by rowan - robinson & wang ( 2010 ) in the earlier version of the iifscz catalogue
. it would be worthwhile to obtain redshifts for the remaining 118 candidate hyper - luminous objects .
, which are mostly either m82 type or a220 type starbursts .
bottom : close - up for galaxies with redshift @xmath98.,title="fig:",width=328,height=309 ] , which are mostly either m82 type or a220 type starbursts .
bottom : close - up for galaxies with redshift @xmath98.,title="fig:",width=331,height=309 ] we have followed the methodology of rowan - robinson et al ( 2008 ) to calculate stellar masses , star - formation rates ( sfr ) and dust masses for the sources in our catalogue . for the sake of completeness , we briefly summarise our methodology here .
we estimate the rest - frame 3.6 @xmath0 luminosity @xmath99 which is then converted to stellar mass @xmath100 using the ratio @xmath101 derived from stellar synthesis models .
to estimate star - formation rate , we use the conversion recipes of rowan - robinson et al .
( 1997 ) and rowan - robinson ( 2001 ) , @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the fraction of uv light absorbed by dust , taken as 2/3 .
to estimate the approximate dust mass for each galaxy , we use radiative transfer models for cirrus , m82 and a220 starburst components and the recipe @xmath104 where @xmath105 , @xmath106 and @xmath107 for cirrus , m82 and a220 respectively ( a. efstathiou , 2007 , private communication ) .
the left panel in fig .
[ plotsfrmstarmdust ] shows a plot of sfr ( @xmath108 ) versus stellar mass ( @xmath109 ) .
straight line loci correspond to the time - scales to make this mass of stars , forming stars at this rate .
while many galaxies are forming stars at a rate broadly consistent with that required to generate the observed stellar mass over @xmath7 10 gyr , most local galaxies lie to the right of the 10 gyr line and must have formed stars at a higher rate at some time in the past .
the zone occupied by our complete and all - sky sample of local quiescent galaxies , lies to the right of the main - sequence " locus of elbaz et al ( 2011 ) and of the 10 gyr line , consistent with the fact that these galaxies are forming stars at a much lower rate than they did in the past ( at @xmath110 ) .
galaxies in fig .
[ plotsfrmstarmdust ] have been colour - coded by their dominant infrared template type as in fig .
[ plot350550errir6ir11ht ] .
the quiescent , optically thin galaxies , i.e. those whose seds are dominated by cirrus , lie on the right edge of the distribution , while galaxies whose infrared seds are dominated by starbursts lie to the left , with higher specific star - formation rate .
the right panel in fig .
[ plotsfrmstarmdust ] shows dust mass versus stellar mass , with most galaxies having @xmath111 in the range @xmath112 to @xmath113 . galaxies dominated by cool cirrus templates tend to require higher specific dust masses . and @xmath113.,title="fig:",width=331,height=307 ] and @xmath113.,title="fig:",width=331,height=307 ]
to summarise , the rifscz contains a total of 60,303 galaxies , @xmath1 of which have spectroscopic redshifts from ned , fssz , pscz , 6df and the sdss spectroscopic dr10 survey and @xmath2 of which have photometric redshifts from the template - fitting method . at a flux limit of s60 = 0.36 jy which is the @xmath114 completeness limit of the fsc , more than @xmath5 of the galaxies in the rifscz have
either spectroscopic or photometric redshifts.the rifscz covers about @xmath115 of the whole sky . in fig .
[ skydistribution ] , the sky distribution in galactic coordinates is plotted for all galaxies in the rifscz with either spectroscopic or photometric redshift and galaxies without any redshift estimate . the rifscz catalogue represents the best all - sky far - infrared ( 60 @xmath0 ) selected galaxy catalogue with multi - wavelength photometric information . as a result
, several extragalactic science programmes can be carried out with the rifscz dataset .
for example , we can examine the relation between the ratio of the infrared to uv luminosity ( the infrared excess : irx ) and the slope of the uv spectrum ( @xmath116 ) .
this relation is critical to estimating the dust attenuation in galaxies and hence the true star - formation rate . in the top panel in fig .
[ irx_beta ] , we plot irx versus @xmath116 for rifscz galaxies with galex uv detections at snr @xmath117 and the reduced @xmath88 of the infrared sed fit @xmath118 .
the typical statistical error of the infrared luminosity ( @xmath119 ) for these galaxies is about 0.3 dex . in the bottom panel in fig .
[ irx_beta ] , we plot irx versus @xmath116 for a subset of the galaxies in the top panel which are detected at 350 @xmath0 by planck . the typical statistical error of @xmath119 for this subset of galaxies with 350 @xmath0 is around 0.1 dex .
our @xmath116 values are derived using the recipe from kong et al .
( 2004 ) . a compilation of the irx - @xmath116 relations published in the literature is also plotted .
the calzetti et al .
( 2000 ) and overzier et al .
( 2011 ) relations are derived from uv - selected samples .
the boquien et al .
( 2012 ) relation is derived from a @xmath120-band selected sample .
the muoz - mateos et al .
( 2009 ) relation is derived from the sings sample ( kennicutt et al .
2003 ) which consists of 75 local galaxies spanning a large range in morphology , luminosity , sfr and opacity .
the hao et al .
( 2011 ) relation is derived from the sings sample combined with a sample of local galaxies covering the full range of optical spectral characteristics ( moustakas & kennicutt 2006 ) .
it is clear that there is a large dispersion among the different relations derived from samples with different selection criteria and our far - infrared selected sample show a general good agreement with these relations .
in addition , our far - infrared selected sample also seems to cover regions with high irx but low @xmath116 values which are not represented in other relations .
detailed investigations are required to fully understand the causes of the difference between our irx - @xmath116 relation based on far - infrared selection and the other relations .
however , it is beyond the scope of this paper .
we provide a long version and a short version of the rifscz to the public , available from http://astro.ic.ac.uk/public/mrr/fss/readme and http://www.astro.dur.ac.uk/~lwang83/rifscz.tar.gz .
the long version contains all the information ( e.g. positional , photometric or spectroscopic ) we have either assembled or derived in the process of constructing the rifscz .
then short version contains the most important information of the sources in the rifscz and should suffice for most users .
the format of the long and short version of the rifscz catalogue is explained in detail in the appendix .
we have presented the revised iras - fsc redshift catalogue ( rifscz ) .
it contains 60,303 galaxies selected at 60 @xmath0 from the iras faint source catalog , covering around @xmath115 of the whole sky .
the process of retrieving spectroscopic redshifts , multi - wavelength source identification and photometric redshift estimation is described in detail .
users should be aware of issues such as the intrinsic iras fsc completeness limit , the redshift completeness variations across the sky and the varying quality of photometric redshifts derived for different subsets of the catalogue . ) for galaxies in the rifscz catalogue ( top : galaxies with snr @xmath117 uv detections and the reduced @xmath88 of the infrared sed fit @xmath118 ; bottom : a subset of the galaxies in the top panel which are detected at 350 @xmath0 . ) , compared with other relations published in the literature .
the typical statistical error of the infrared luminosity ( @xmath119 ) for galaxies in the top and bottom panel is about 0.3 dex and 0.1 dex respectively.,title="fig:",width=331 ] ) for galaxies in the rifscz catalogue ( top : galaxies with snr @xmath117 uv detections and the reduced @xmath88 of the infrared sed fit @xmath118 ; bottom : a subset of the galaxies in the top panel which are detected at 350 @xmath0 . ) , compared with other relations published in the literature .
the typical statistical error of the infrared luminosity ( @xmath119 ) for galaxies in the top and bottom panel is about 0.3 dex and 0.1 dex respectively.,title="fig:",width=331 ]
lw and pn acknowledge support from an erc stg grant ( degas-259586 ) .
pn also acknowledges the support of the royal society through the award of a university research fellowship .
the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , caltech , under contract with the national aeronautics and space administration .
funding for the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , and the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
the sdss web site is http://www.sdss.org/. the sdss is managed by the astrophysical research consortium ( arc ) for the participating institutions .
the participating institutions are the american museum of natural history , astrophysical institute potsdam , university of basel , university of cambridge , case western reserve university , the university of chicago , drexel university , fermilab , the institute for advanced study , the japan participation group , the johns hopkins university , the joint institute for nuclear astrophysics , the kavli institute for particle astrophysics and cosmology , the korean scientist group , the chinese academy of sciences ( lamost ) , los alamos national laboratory , the max - planck - institute for astronomy ( mpia ) , the max - planck - institute for astrophysics ( mpa ) , new mexico state university , ohio state university , university of pittsburgh , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the united states naval observatory , and the university of washington .
funding for sdss - iii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , and the u.s .
department of energy office of science .
the sdss - iii web site is http://www.sdss3.org/. sdss - iii is managed by the astrophysical research consortium for the participating institutions of the sdss - iii collaboration including the university of arizona , the brazilian participation group , brookhaven national laboratory , carnegie mellon university , university of florida , the french participation group , the german participation group , harvard university , the instituto de astrofisica de canarias , the michigan state / notre dame / jina participation group , johns hopkins university , lawrence berkeley national laboratory , max planck institute for astrophysics , max planck institute for extraterrestrial physics , new mexico state university , new york university , ohio state university , pennsylvania state university , university of portsmouth , princeton university , the spanish participation group , university of tokyo , university of utah , vanderbilt university , university of virginia , university of washington , and yale university .
this publication makes use of data products from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared processing and analysis center / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration and the national science foundation .
this publication makes use of data products from the wide - field infrared survey explorer , which is a joint project of the university of california , los angeles , and the jet propulsion laboratory / california institute of technology , funded by the national aeronautics and space administration .
notes on the catalogue columns for the long version : col 1 - 7 .
iras fsc source name , galex source i d , sdss object i d , 2mass xsc source designation , wise source designation , planck source name and ned source name .
col 8 - 10 .
sdss type , ned type , stellar flag ( 1= galaxy / extended , -1 = stellar / qso , and 0 = unknown ) . col 11 - 22 .
iras fsc positions , sdss positions , 2mass xsc positions , wise positions , planck positions and ned positions .
col 23 - 25 . recommended position and positional flag ( 1=sdss , 2=2mass , 3=wise , 4=ned , 5=fsc and prioritised in the same order ) .
col 26 - 28 .
sdss spectroscopic redshift , 2mrs redshift , and ned redshift .
col 29 - 30 .
recommended spectroscopic redshift and flag ( 1@xmath121sdss , 2@xmath121pscz , 3@xmath121fssz , 4@xmath1216df , 5@xmath121ned and 6@xmath1212mrs ) .
the priority order is ned@xmath3sdss@xmath32mrs@xmath3pscz@xmath3fssz@xmath36df .
template - fitting photometric redshift for sources with optical or near - infrared photometry col 32 .
recommended redshift which is equal to spectroscopic redshift if it is available or photometric redshift if it has optical or near - infrared photometry but without spectroscopic redshift .
col 33 - 37 .
the number of optical and near - infrared bands used in the photometric redshift fit , optical galaxy template type , extinction av from the optical galaxy template fit , reduced @xmath88 of the best redshift fit , and the absolute b magnitude . col 38 - 41 .
galex far - uv flux and error , galex near - uv flux and error . col 42 - 51 .
sdss magnitudes and errors at u , g , r , i , z col 52 - 57 .
2mass psc magnitudes and errors at j , h , k@xmath70 . col 58 - 63 .
2mass xsc magnitudes and errors at j , h , k@xmath70 .
co 64 - 71 .
wise magnitudes and errors at 3.4 , 4.6 , 12 and 22 @xmath0 , col 72 - 79 .
iras fluxes and quality flags at 12 , 25 , 60 and 100 @xmath0 , col 80 - 87 .
planck fluxes and errors at 350 , 550 , 850 or 1382 @xmath0 . col 88 - 89 .
integrated 1.4 ghz flux density and error .
col 90 . aperture correction .
col 91 - 102 .
aperture corrected ugriz , 2mass j , h , and k@xmath70 , and wise 3.4 , 4.6 , 12 and 22 @xmath0 fluxes .
col 103 - 106 .
redshift flag ( 1=spectroscopic redshift , 2=photometric redshift , 3=no redshift ) , infrared template type ( 1=cirrus , 2=m82 , 3=a220 , 4=agn dust torus , 5=young starburst , 6=cool cirrus ) , reduced @xmath88 for the ir template fit , number of photometric bands used in the ir template fit col 107 - 112 .
fraction of contribution at 60 @xmath0 of each of the six ir templates . col 113 - 118 .
fraction of ir luminosity in each of the six ir templates col 119 .
total ir luminosity . col 120 - 133 . predicted infrared and sub - mm fluxes at 12 , 25 , 60 , 90 , 100 , 110 , 140 , 160 , 250 , 350 , 550 , 850 , 1250 and 1380 @xmath0 based on the best - fit infrared template . col 134 - 136 .
stellar mass , sfr , dust mass . col 137 - 221 array of reduced @xmath88 , minimised over all templates , in bins of 0.01 in @xmath58 , from 0 to 0.85 .
notes on the catalogue columns for the short version : col 6 - 7 . recommended spectroscopic redshift and flag ( 1@xmath121sdss , 2@xmath121pscz , 3@xmath121fssz , 4@xmath1216df , 5@xmath121ned and 6@xmath1212mrs ) .
the priority order is ned@xmath3sdss@xmath32mrs@xmath3pscz@xmath3fssz@xmath36df .
col 10 - 14 .
the number of optical and near - infrared bands used in the photometric redshift fit , optical galaxy template type , extinction av from the optical galaxy template fit , reduced @xmath88 of the best redshift fit , and the absolute b magnitude .
col 79 - 82 .
redshift flag ( 1=spectroscopic redshift , 2=photometric redshift , 3=no redshift ) , infrared template type ( 1=cirrus , 2=m82 , 3=a220 , 4=agn dust torus , 5=young starburst , 6=cool cirrus ) , reduced @xmath88 for the ir template fit , number of photometric bands used in the ir template fit | we present a _ revised iras - fsc redshift catalogue _ ( rifscz ) of 60,303 galaxies selected at 60 @xmath0 from the _ iras faint source catalogue _ ( fsc ) .
this revision merges in data from the wise all - sky data release , the tenth sdss data release ( dr10 ) , the galex all - sky survey source catalog ( gasc ) , the 2mass redshift survey ( 2mrs ) and the planck catalogue of compact sources ( pccs ) .
the rifscz consists of accurate position , ultra - violet ( uv ) , optical , near- , mid- and far - infrared , sub - millimetre ( sub - mm ) and/or radio identifications , spectroscopic redshift ( if available ) or photometric redshift ( if possible ) , predicted far - infrared and sub - mm fluxes ranging from 12 to 1380 @xmath0 based upon the best - fit infrared template .
we also provide stellar masses , star - formation rates and dust masses derived from the optical and infrared template fits , where possible .
@xmath1 of the galaxies in the rifscz have spectroscopic redshifts and a further @xmath2 have photometric redshifts obtained through the template - fitting method . at s60 @xmath3 0.36 jy , the 90@xmath4 completeness limit of the fsc ,
@xmath5 of the sources in the rifscz have either spectroscopic or photometric redshifts .
an interesting subset of the catalogue is the sources detected by planck at sub - mm wavelengths .
1200 sources have a detection at better than 5-@xmath6 in at least one planck band and a further 1186 sources have detections at 3 - 5@xmath6 in at least one planck band . catalogues
surveys galaxies : distances and redshifts infrared : galaxies quasars : general large - scale structure of universe . |
stationary spacetimes with angular momentum ( rotation ) are known to exhibit an effect called lense - thirring ( lt ) precession whereby locally inertial frames are dragged along the rotating spacetime , making any test gyroscope in such spacetimes _ precess _ with a certain frequency called the lt precession frequency @xcite .
this frequency has been shown to decay as the inverse cube of the distance of the test gyroscope from the source for large enough distances where curvature effects are small , and known to be proportional to the angular momentum of the source .
the largest precession frequencies are thus expected to be seen very close to the source ( like the surface of a pulsar , or the horizon of a black hole ) , as well as for spacetimes rotating very fast with large angular momenta .
earlier analyses of the lt effect @xcite assume slowly rotating ( @xmath0 is the kerr parameter of the rotating spacetime due to a compact object like a black hole ) spacetime for the test gyroscope @xcite . thus , the rotating spacetime solution is usually approximated as a schwarzschild spacetime , and the effect of rotation is confined to a perturbative term added on to the schwarzschild metric .
this leads to the standard result for lt precession frequency in the weak field approximation , given by @xcite @xmath1 \label{we1}\ ] ] where , @xmath2 is the unit vector along @xmath3 direction . in a recent work reported in ref .
@xcite , an alternative approach based on solving the geodesic equations of the test gyroscope numerically , _ once again _ within the weak gravitational field approximation , is used to compute the frame - dragging effect for galactic - centre black holes . in another very recent related work @xcite , hackman and lammerzahl
have given an expression of lt precession ( orbital plane precession ) valid up to _ first order _ in the kerr parameter @xmath4 for a general axially symmetric plebanski - demianski spacetime .
this is obviously a good approximation for slowly - rotating compact objects .
the lt precession rate has also been derived @xcite through solving the geodesic equations for both kerr and kerr - de - sitter spacetimes at the _ polar orbit _ but these results are not applicable for orbits which lie in orbital planes other than the polar plane .
we understand that observations of precession due to locally inertial frame - dragging have so far focused on spacetimes where the curvatures are small enough ; e.g. , the lt precession in the earth s gravitational field which was probed recently by gravity probe b @xcite
. there has been so far no attempt to measure lt precession effects due to frame - dragging in strong gravity regimes .
two motivating factors may be cited in support of such a contention .
first of all , the near - horizon physics of black holes and that of the outer layers of neutron stars emitting x - rays from their accretion discs also might need to be reanalyzed in view of the nontrivial lt precession of test geodesics in their vicinity . with upcoming x - ray observatories , as well as multi - wavelength strong gravity space probes currently under construction , which envisage to make observations of possible frame - dragging effects in strong gravity situations in the near future , the need to go beyond
the weak field approximation is paramount . a recent work by stone and loeb @xcite has estimated the effect of weak - field lt precession on accreting matter close to compact accreting objects .
while there are claims that what has been estimated in this work pertains more to orbital plane precession , rather than precession of a test gyroscope ( which remains the classic example of lt precession ) , it is obvious that in the vicinity of the spacetime near the surface of pulsars ( respectively , the horizons of black holes ) , the large lt precession of test gyroscopes ought to manifest in changes in the predicted x - ray emission behaviour originating from modifications in the behaviour of infalling timelike geodesics of accreting matter particles due to the lt precession .
thus , there is sufficient theoretical motivation to compute lt precession rates in the strong gravity regime , in a bid towards a prediction that future probes of the inertial frame dragging effect , in such a regime , may correlate with .
the exact lt precession frequency of a test gyroscope in strongly curved stationary spacetimes , analyzed within a ` copernican ' frame , is expressed as a co - vector given in terms of the timelike killing vector fields @xmath5 of the stationary spacetime , as ( in the notation of ref .
@xcite ) @xmath6 where , @xmath7 & @xmath8 denote the one - form dual to @xmath5 & @xmath9 , respectively .
note that @xmath8 vanishes if and only if @xmath10 .
this happens only for a static spacetime . using the coordinate basis form of @xmath11 , the co - vector components are easily seen to be @xmath12 .
thus , the vector field corresponding to the lt precession co - vector can be expressed in coordinate basis as @xmath13 \label{s25}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the remarkable feature of the above equation ( [ s25 ] ) is that it is applicable to any arbitrary stationary spacetime ( irrespective of whether it is axisymmetric or not ) ; it gives us the exact rate of lt precession in such a spacetime .
for instance , a ` non - rotating ' newman - unti - tamburino @xcite ( nut ) spacetime is known to be spherically symmetric , but still has an angular momentum ( dual or ` magnetic ' mass @xcite ) ; we use eq.([s25 ] ) to compute the lt precession frequency in this case as well .
this result is rather general , because , there is only one constraint on the spacetime : that it must be stationary , which is the only necessary condition for the lt precession .
the utility of this equation is that ; if any metric @xmath14 contains all 10 @xmath15 elements non - vanishing , it can be used to calculate the lt precession in that spacetime . in this case , the precession rate depends only on non - zero @xmath16 components , not on any other non - zero off - diagonal components of the metric .
thus , this equation also reveals that the lt precession rate is completely determined by the metric components @xmath17 , and is quite independent of the other components ( in co - ordinate basis ) .
now , we should discuss that why a stationary spacetime shows this frame - dragging effect irrespective of whether it is axisymmetric or not .
a spacetime is said to be stationary if it possesses a timelike killing vector field @xmath18 ; further , a stationary spacetime is said to be static if there exists a spacelike hypersurface @xmath19 which is orthogonal to the orbits of the timelike isometry . by frobenius s theorem of hypersurface orthogonality
, we can write for a static spacetime , @xmath20}=0 \label{ho}\ ] ] if @xmath21 everywhere on @xmath19 , then in a neighbourhood of @xmath19 , every point will lie on a unique orbit of @xmath18 which passes through @xmath19 . from the explicit form of a static metric , it can be seen that the diffeomorphism defined by @xmath22 ( the map which takes each point on each @xmath23 to the point with the same spatial coordinates on @xmath24 ) , is an isometry .
the `` time translation '' symmetry , @xmath25 is possessed by all stationary spacetimes .
static spacetimes on the other hand , possess an additional symmetry , `` time reflection '' symmetry over and above the `` time translation symmetry '' .
physically , the fields which are time translationally invariant can fail to be time reflection invariant if any type of `` rotational motion '' is involved , since the time reflection will change the direction of rotation . for example , a rotating fluid ball may have a time - independent matter and velocity distribution , but is unable to possess a time reflection symmetry @xcite . in the case of stationary spacetimes
, the failure of the hypersurface orthogonality condition ( eq.[ho ] ) implies that neighbouring orbits of @xmath18 `` twist '' around each other .
the twisting of the orbits of @xmath18 is the cause of that _ extra precession _ in stationary non - static spacetimes .
one can now use eq .
( [ s25 ] ) to calculate the precession rate of a test gyroscope in a kerr spacetime to get the lt precession in a strong gravitational field . in boyer - lindquist coordinates ,
the kerr metric is written as , @xmath26 where , @xmath4 is kerr parameter , defined as @xmath27 , the angular momentum per unit mass and @xmath28 now , using eq.([s25 ] ) we can obtain the following expression of lt precession rate in kerr spacetime @xcite @xmath29 this is the lt precession rate where no weak gravity approximation has been made . in slow - rotation limit
@xmath30 , the kerr metric is approximated as a schwarzschild metric with the cross term @xmath31 , that is @xmath32 and eq .
( [ k10 ] ) reduces to eq .
( [ we1 ] ) which is quite well - known to us .
the kerr - taub - nut spacetime is geometrically a stationary , axisymmetric vacuum solution of einstein equation with kerr parameter @xmath33 and nut charge @xmath34 .
if the nut charge vanishes , the solution reduces to the kerr geometry .
the metric of the kerr - taub - nut spacetime is @xmath35 with @xmath36 as the spacetime has an intrinsic angular momentum ( due to the kerr parameter @xmath4 ) , we can expect a non - zero frame - dragging effect which cam be written as @xmath37\hat{r } + \f{a \sin\th}{p } \left[\f{r - m}{\r^2 - 2mr - n^2 } -\f{r}{p^2}\right]\hat{\th } \label{kt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , @xmath38 .
in contrast to the kerr spacetime , where the source of the lt precession is the kerr parameter @xmath4 , the kerr - taub - nut spacetime has an extra somewhat surprising feature : the lt precession does not vanish even for vanishing kerr parameter @xmath39 , so long as the nut charge @xmath40 .
this means that though the orbital angular momentum @xmath41 of this spacetime vanishes , the spacetime does indeed exhibit an intrinsic _ spinlike _ angular momentum ( at the classical level itself ) .
one can show that inertial frames are dragged along this orbitally _ non - rotating _
nut spacetime with the precession rate @xcite @xmath42 vs @xmath43 for @xmath44 & @xmath45,width=182 ] [ fig ] the rotating equilibrium models considered in this paper are stationary and axisymmetric .
thus we can write the metric inside the rotating neutron star as the following komatsu - eriguchi - hachisu ( keh ) @xcite form : @xmath46 where @xmath47 are the functions of @xmath3 and @xmath48 only . in the whole paper
we have used the geometrized unit ( @xmath49 ) .
we assume that the matter source is a perfect fluid with a stress - energy tensor given by @xmath50 where @xmath51 is the rest energy density , @xmath52 is the internal energy density , @xmath53 is the pressure and @xmath54 is the matter four velocity .
we are further assuming that there is no meridional circulation of the matter so that the four - velocity @xmath54 is simply a linear combination of time and angular killing vectors .
in orthonormal coordinate basis , the modulus of the exact lt precession rate inside the rotating neutron star is : @xmath55 ^ 2 + [ r^2\o^2\o_{,\th}\sin^3\th+e^{2\s}(2\o \cos\th+\o_{,\th}\sin\th -2\o\s_{,\th}\sin\th)]^2\right]^{\f{1}{2}}. \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expressions of @xmath56 have been extracted from @xcite and the frame - dragging rates have been calculated using the rotating neutron star rns code @xcite and plotted from the origin to the surface for some pulsars @xcite .
in contrast to most calculations of the lt precession rate in the literature , which focus on the weak - field approximation , this article has discussed in some detail the problem of the exact lt precession formula in any stationary spacetime and derived the exact lt precession formula for full kerr , ktn and other spacetimes .
the weak - field approximation of lt precession ( eq .
1 ) for the kerr spacetime has been then shown to emerge straightforwardly from our general formulation .
interestingly , we have shown that in the _ non - rotating _ and _ spherically symmetric _
taub - nut spacetime the lt precession does not vanish . applying the general lt formula
we have also obtained the exact frame - dragging rate inside the rotating neutron stars .
it is known to us that lynden - bell and nouri - zonoz @xcite first highlighted about the observational possibilities for nut charges or ( gravito)magnetic monopoles and they claimed that the signatures of such spacetime might be found in the spectra of supernovae , quasars , or active galactic nuclei . in our case , the resemblance of the anomalous lt precessions in the ktn spacetimes and the spacetime of the pulsars could be the indirect proof of the existence of the nut charge ( ( gravito)magnetic monopoles ) inside the pulsars and we also suggest that such a signature could be used to identify a role of taub - nut solutions in the astrophysical observations .
though any strong gravity measurement has not been performed till now the analogue models of black holes can offer an alternative option of the indirect measurement of strong gravity lt effect in a comparatively accessible laboratory setup .
we deduce precise estimate @xcite of the angular velocity of the precession of a test spin outside the ergoregion of a fluid mechanical rotating `` dumb hole '' in acoustic spacetimes .
it is our hope that with present technological expertise in manipulating analogue black holes , experimentalists will be able to successfully verify our estimate and hence , more importantly , the predicted strong gravity lt effect .
accretion disk theory and the related astrophysical phenomena have been investigated using newtonian or post - newtonian gravity .
the strong gravity lt effect has not been considered in those calculations .
as the accretion disks extend to the vicinity of black hole horizons associated with the very strong gravity regime , the effect of the frame - dragging may have to be taken into account .
it will be interesting to investigate the changes to the standard accretion disc theory that this inclusion might entail .
the exact frame - dragging rates have already been derived inside and outside of the rotating neutron stars by us .
now , it would be worth to study the quasi - periodic - oscillations ( qpos ) in the case of accreting pulsars .
+ * acknowledgements : * i am highly thankful to the scientific organising committee of 28th texas symposium on relativistic astrophysics for granting me the full financial support to attend this meeting . | the exact frame - dragging ( or lense - thirring ( lt ) precession ) rates for kerr , kerr - taub - nut ( ktn ) and taub - nut spacetimes have been derived .
remarkably , in the case of the ` zero angular momentum ' taub - nut spacetime , the frame - dragging effect is shown not to vanish , when considered for spinning test gyroscope . in the case of the interior of the pulsars , the exact frame - dragging rate monotonically decreases from the center to the surface along the pole and but it shows an ` anomaly ' along the equator . moving from the equator to the pole
, it is observed that this ` anomaly ' disappears after crossing a critical angle .
the ` same ' anomaly can also be found in the ktn spacetime .
the resemblance of the anomalous lt precessions in the ktn spacetimes and the spacetime of the pulsars could be used to identify a role of taub - nut solutions in the astrophysical observations or equivalently , a signature of the existence of nut charge in the pulsars . |
the study of large - scale ( complex ) networks , such as computer , biological and social networks , is a multidisciplinary field that combines ideas from mathematics , physics , biology , social sciences and other fields .
a remarkable and widely discussed phenomena associated with such networks is the _ small world _ property .
it is observed in many such networks , man - made or natural , that the typical distance between the nodes is surprisingly small .
more formally , as a function of the number of nodes , @xmath0 , the average distance between a node pair typically scales at or below @xmath5 . in this work ,
we study the load characteristics of small world networks .
assuming one unit of demand between each node pair , we quantify as a function of @xmath0 , how the maximal nodal load scales , independently of how each unit of demand may be routed . in other words , we are interested in the smallest of such maximal nodal loads as a function of routing , which we refer to as _ congestion _ , that the network could experience .
we show that in the planar small - world network congestion is almost quadratic in @xmath0 , which is as high as it can get , specifically @xmath1 .
in contrast , for some non - planar small - world networks , congestion may be almost linear in @xmath0 , namely @xmath3 for arbitrarily small @xmath4 . since congestion in a network with @xmath0 nodes can not have scaling order less than @xmath6 or more than @xmath7 , we conclude that the small world property alone is not sufficient to predict the level of congestion _ a priori _ and additional characteristics may be needed to explain congestion features of complex networks .
this has been argued in @xcite for the case of intrinsic hyperbolicity , which is a geometric feature above and beyond the small world property . additionally , we investigate what happens to congestion when we change the link metric that prescribes routing .
that is , for a network with edge weight @xmath8 we change the metric by a factor @xmath9 thus assigning each edge @xmath10 a new weight @xmath11 .
we explore the extent to which this change in the metric can change congestion in the network .
we prove that if we allow the weights to get arbitrarily small or large , i.e. when for some edges , @xmath12 approach zero and for some others @xmath12 approach infinity , then considerable changes in congestion can occur . on the other hand ,
if we require the weights to be bounded away from zero and infinity , i.e. when @xmath13 for all edges @xmath10 , then congestion can not change significantly .
these observations quantify the degree to which remetrization in a small world network may be helpful in affecting congestion .
as mentioned in the introduction , the small world property is ubiquitous in complex networks .
formally we say that a graph has the small world property if its diameter @xmath14 is of the order @xmath15 where @xmath0 is the number of nodes in the graph .
it has been shown that a surprising number of real - life , man - made or natural , networks have the small world property , see , for example , @xcite . to be more specific , assume @xmath16 is an infinite planar graph and let @xmath17 be an arbitrary fixed node in the graph that we shall designate as the root .
let us assign a weight @xmath18 to each edge , thus @xmath19 for all edges @xmath10 , and let @xmath20 be the ball of center @xmath17 and radius @xmath21 .
in other words a node @xmath22 belongs to @xmath23 if and only of @xmath24 .
more generally , we can consider weighted graphs where each edge has a non - negative length .
we will further assume that the sub - graphs @xmath25 have exponential growth , which is clearly equivalent to the small world property , as defined above .
more precisely , there exist @xmath26 and @xmath27 such that @xmath28 for all @xmath29 .
assume that for every @xmath21 and every pair of nodes in @xmath25 there is a unit of demand between each node pair .
therefore , the total demand in @xmath25 is @xmath30 where @xmath31 . given a node @xmath32 in @xmath25 we denote by @xmath33 the total flow in @xmath25 routed through @xmath32 .
the load , or congestion , @xmath34 , is the maximum of @xmath35 over all vertices @xmath32 in @xmath16 , which is typically a function of the routing @xmath36 .
the next theorem shows that for a planar graph with exponential growth , there exist nodes with load @xmath1 for @xmath21 sufficiently large regardless of routing .
[ fig1 ] .
right : flows crossing the boundary separating two planar wedges each with @xmath37 nodes .
note that ( red ) geodesic paths may cross the boundary more than once.,title="fig:",width=220 ] .
right : flows crossing the boundary separating two planar wedges each with @xmath37 nodes .
note that ( red ) geodesic paths may cross the boundary more than once.,title="fig:",width=172 ] let @xmath16 be an infinite planar graph with exponential growth .
assume one unit of demand between every pair of nodes in @xmath25 .
then for every @xmath21 there exists a node @xmath38 such that @xmath39 where @xmath40 .
fix @xmath21 and let @xmath41 be the spanning tree of all geodesic ( shortest ) paths with the node @xmath17 as the origin , as shown in figure 1 , left . observe that since @xmath16 is small world , all node pairs have distance @xmath5 and thus each ray from @xmath17 in @xmath41 has length thus bounded .
enumerate all the paths in @xmath41 in clockwise order , possible because of the planarity of @xmath23 .
therefore , @xmath42 and by the small world property each ray @xmath43 .
let @xmath44 , @xmath45 and in general @xmath46 for @xmath47 .
it is clear that for all @xmath48 @xmath49 such that @xmath50 and @xmath51 because addition of each @xmath52 adds at most @xmath5 nodes to @xmath53 , and moreover by inequality ( [ eqq1 ] ) we know that @xmath54 let us consider the set @xmath55 .
it is clear that all the paths between @xmath56 and @xmath55 have to intersect the path @xmath57 .
the traffic between @xmath56 and @xmath55 is equal to @xmath58 .
since @xmath59 which satisfies @xmath60 since this traffic has to pass through @xmath57 at some point then there exists at least one node @xmath32 in @xmath57 with load at least @xmath61 ( see figure 1 , right ) proving our claim .
our first claim follows a corollary of the above theorem .
let @xmath16 be an infinite planar graph with exponential growth .
then for @xmath21 sufficiently large there exists a node @xmath38 such that @xmath62 where @xmath63 is a constant independent on @xmath21 .
it turns out that the planarity property is essential for the existence of highly congested nodes proven above .
we now show that in contrast , when @xmath16 is not planar , congestion can be made to approach @xmath6 .
more explicitly , given @xmath64 there exists infinite graphs with exponential growth with uniformly bounded degree such that for every node @xmath38 and @xmath21 sufficiently large , @xmath65 . before providing such
a construction let us show the following lemma .
let @xmath16 be an infinite graph and let @xmath25 be the ball of radius @xmath21 centered at @xmath66 as before .
assume moreover that @xmath67 .
then for every @xmath38 the following holds @xmath68 where @xmath69 .
let @xmath70 and define @xmath71 .
then it is clear that @xmath72 and moreover @xmath73 .
therefore , @xmath74 where the inequality is coming from the fact that if @xmath75 then the geodesic path between a node in @xmath76 and a node in @xmath77 does not pass through @xmath32 .
hence , @xmath78 we state the following result due to bollobas for completeness .
[ boll ] given @xmath79 for @xmath0 sufficiently large a random @xmath80regular graph @xmath81 with @xmath0 nodes has diameter at most @xmath82 where @xmath63 is a fixed constant depending on @xmath80 and independent on @xmath0 .
now we are ready to show the construction of a small world graph with small congestion .
let @xmath64 and consider @xmath16 a infinite @xmath83-regular tree where the value of @xmath83 will be chosen later .
denote by @xmath17 the root of @xmath16 and @xmath84 as before .
let @xmath85 be the graph constructed by connecting all the nodes in the spheres @xmath86 @xmath87 by a @xmath83-regular random graph for every @xmath88 .
then @xmath89 and it is clear that using theorem [ boll ] we have that @xmath90 note that @xmath91 since we are not adding new nodes .
it is not difficult to see that @xmath92 therefore , using the previous lemma we see that for every node @xmath93 @xmath94 therefore , @xmath95 and hence @xmath96 by taking @xmath83 sufficiently large depending on @xmath4 we see that @xmath65 for @xmath21 sufficiently large .
in @xcite , it has been shown that @xmath97-hyperbolicity implies the existence of a core , that is , a non - empty set of nodes whose load scale as @xmath7 under geodesic routing . in section [ sec2 ]
, we proved that planar graphs with exponential growth can not avoid congestion of order @xmath1 no matter how the routing is performed . on the other hand
, we observed in section [ sec3 ] that exponential growth alone is not sufficient to guarantee the existence of such highly congested nodes .
thus , unlike the small world property , @xmath97-hyperbolicity is a sufficient condition for a network to have highly congested nodes .
the reverse need not be true , however .
it is not difficult to construct non - hyperbolic graphs in which load scales as @xmath7 .
for instance , two square grids in two vertical planes separated by a single horizontal link joining their origins .
it is even possible to construct small world graphs with @xmath7 load which are not hyperbolic .
let @xmath98 be the 3-regular infinite tree and let @xmath99 .
the graph @xmath16 is not gromov hyperbolic since it has @xmath100 as a sub - graph .
yet , @xmath101 has traffic of order @xmath7 where @xmath66 is the root of @xmath102 .
it is interesting to note that even tough the graph @xmath16 is not hyperbolic , it has @xmath102 as a sub - graph .
examples of small world graphs with load of order @xmath7 appear to include hyperbolic sub - graphs .
we do not know if this is always true but it seems likely since exponential growth implies existence of an exponentially growing tree sub - graph ( e.g. , its spanning tree ) .
we next explore what happens to hyperbolicity when we apply remetrization . more specifically , assume a metric graph @xmath16 where each edge @xmath10 has an associated non - negative distance @xmath103 that satisfies the triangle inequality .
we modify each edge distance by a factor @xmath104 so that the new length of the edge @xmath10 is @xmath11 .
we also require that the coefficients @xmath105 are chosen in such a way that the new edge distances continue to satisfy the triangle inequality and thus constitute a metric . to determine if @xmath7 scaling of congestion persists after remetrization , let us start with a @xmath97-hyperbolic graph and modify the edge metric according to the above scheme .
does remetrization ensure another @xmath106-hyperbolic graph ?
we show below that this is not the case and thus remetrization can significantly affect the congestion scaling in the graph , unless the weights @xmath12 are bounded away from zero and infinity .
we shall prove the result for regular hyperbolic grids embedded in @xmath108 and then appeal to the quasi - isometry of all @xmath97-hyperbolic graphs with these reference graphs ( see @xcite ) to complete the proof . to simplify exposition ,
we focus on dimension 2 only , since the argument carries through similarly for higher dimensions .
let @xmath109 be a regular tessellation of the poincre disk with @xmath110 , @xmath111 .
@xmath112 may be viewed as a ( hyperbolic ) grid where each node has ( the same ) degree @xmath113 and each face has ( the same ) @xmath114 sides , figure 2 depicts @xmath115 .
note that in the case that @xmath116 the graph @xmath16 is a @xmath113-regular tree and is thus @xmath117-hyperbolic regardless of any metrization .
let @xmath17 be the node at the center of the disk and let @xmath76 be the set of nodes in @xmath16 at distance @xmath83 from @xmath17 .
note that the sub - graph induced by the set @xmath76 is a cycle @xmath118 with @xmath119 nodes .
let us denote this graph also by @xmath76 .
it is not difficult to see that there exists a sequence @xmath120 such that @xmath121 exponentially fast so that if we remetrize every edge in @xmath76 by the constant @xmath122 then the induced graph is not hyperbolic since it will be quasi - isometric to the euclidean grid @xmath123 .
it was observed in @xcite and then proved in @xcite , that the nodes in @xmath124 have congestion of the order @xmath125 .
therefore , the nodes in the new graph have a congestion of the order @xmath2 .
we observe that the above construction used arbitrarily small weights .
more precisely , given @xmath64 there are infinitely many weights in this construction such that @xmath126 .
it is not hard to see that the same construction is possible with arbitrarily large weights instead of small weights .
however , if we restrict these weights so that there exist positive constants @xmath83 and @xmath127 such that @xmath128 then the original and the remetrized graphs are indeed quasi - isometric .
therefore , by a result of gromov , see @xcite , if one graph is hyperbolic so is the other and thus @xmath7 is unaffected by the said change of metric .
lohsoonthorn , _ hyperbolic geometry of networks _ , ph.d .
thesis , department of electrical engineering , university of southern california , 2003 .
available at http://eudoxus.usc.edu/iw/mattfinalthesis main.pdf . | in this report we show that in a planar exponentially growing network consisting of @xmath0 nodes , congestion scales as @xmath1 independently of how flows may be routed .
this is in contrast to the @xmath2 scaling of congestion in a flat polynomially growing network .
we also show that without the planarity condition , congestion in a small world network could scale as low as @xmath3 , for arbitrarily small @xmath4 .
these extreme results demonstrate that the small world property by itself can not provide guidance on the level of congestion in a network and other characteristics are needed for better resolution . finally , we investigate scaling of congestion under the geodesic flow , that is , when flows are routed on shortest paths based on a link metric . here
we prove that if the link weights are scaled by arbitrarily small or large multipliers then considerable changes in congestion may occur .
however , if we constrain the link - weight multipliers to be bounded away from both zero and infinity , then variations in congestion due to such remetrization are negligible . |
proto - planetary nebulae ( ppne ) are the long - sought - after missing link between the end of the asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) phase and the beginning of planetary nebula phase of stellar evolution . after the _ infrared astronomical satellite _ ( _ iras _ ) mission , a number of objects were proposed as candidate ppne based on their infrared colors and other spectral properties .
these are typically stars of g to b spectral type with significant infrared excesses due to the remnant circumstellar dust shell ejected in the agb phase .
of particular interest among these candidates are a number of carbon - rich objects whose abundances show a strong enhancement of s - process elements , as expected from the dredge - up of material in thermal pulses during the agb evolution @xcite . for other candidates there is some possibility of confusion with massive supergiants , but those in this carbon - rich group are almost certainly bona - fide ppne .
one of these objects is iras 16594@xmath04656 .
it is a bright mid - infrared source which has typical colors of a ppn @xcite .
optically it is associated with a southern emission - line star .
it was found to be of spectral type b7 with v magnitude 14.6 , subject to about 7.5 magnitudes of visual extinction @xcite .
it was not clear from the original _ iras _ spectral observations whether the object was oxygen - rich or carbon - rich , but subsequent _ infrared space observatory _
( _ iso _ ) spectral observations showed that it has carbon - based dust features , including the 21 @xmath1 m feature @xcite .
optical images obtained with the _ hubble space telescope
_ showed that the star has a surrounding reflection nebula with a complex structure @xcite .
the relative faintness of the reflection nebula compared to the star , together with the optical morphology , led @xcite to conclude that the nebula is intrinsically bipolar ( or multi - polar ) viewed at an intermediate angle to the bipolar axis .
both optical and near - infrared spectral observations show emission lines , which are thought to be shock - excited rather than radiatively excited by the star @xcite .
no radio emission has been detected from iras 16594@xmath04656 @xcite .
the distance to this object is uncertain .
the dust shell model of @xcite suggests a distance of 2.6 kpc if the total luminosity of the star is 10@xmath2 @xmath3 .
a slightly smaller estimate of ( [email protected] ) kpc is given by @xcite for the same assumed total luminosity .
most of the luminosity is being emitted in the infrared where extinction effects are smaller than in the optical , so these estimates are not strongly affected by the non - spherical morphology of the dust shell . the optical morphology of the nebula in iras 16594@xmath04656 appears complex , with what appear to be pairs of symmetric structures at multiple position angles , for which it was named the `` water lily nebula '' @xcite .
the optical images also showed several concentric arcs centered on the star @xcite .
however , near - infrared observations with the _ nicmos _ instrument on _ hst _ showed a somewhat simpler morphology , although it was not clear whether this was simply an effect of reduced dynamic range compared to the optical observations @xcite .
an initial n - band observation of iras 16594@xmath04656 with the timmi2 camera on the eso 3.6 m telescope failed to resolve the dust shell @xcite , while more recent timmi2 observations did marginally resolve the structure @xcite .
in this paper we present new , higher sensitivity and higher angular resolution mid - infrared images of iras 16594@xmath04656 which resolve the dust shell in thermal emission .
we present the observations in section 2 .
we then derive a dust color temperature map in section 3 , and compare the morphology as observed in the mid - infrared to that seen at other wavelengths in section 4 .
we give a brief discussion of the results in the final section .
the observations reported here were obtained with the t - recs instrument on gemini south under program gs-2004a - q-56 .
the sky and telescope background were removed by chopping and nodding during the observations .
images of iras 16594@xmath04656 were obtained in three filters . in the n - band window : 360 second ( total on - source exposure times ) images with the `` si-5 11.66um '' filter on 2004 march 11 and with the `` si-6 12.33um '' filter on 2004 may 8 ; and in q - band window : a 600 second image with the `` qa 18.30um '' filter on 2004 may 10 .
these filters will be referred to as the `` si5 '' , `` si6 '' , and `` qa '' filters , respectively .
all these filters have widths @xmath5 .
information about these filters , including the filter profiles , can be found on the gemini observatory public www pages ( see _ http://www.gemini.edu/sciops/instruments/miri/t-recsfilters.html_ ) . on each night ,
standard star observations for flux calibration were carried out immediately after the observation of the science target .
these stars were hd 123139 on march 11 , hd 169916 on may 8 , and hd 175775 on may 10 .
all of these stars are included among the mid - infrared spectrophotometric standards of @xcite .
comparisons of the point - spread functions ( psfs ) of these stars with observations of @xmath6 cen a / b or @xmath6 cma on various nights from december 2003 through may 2004 indicate that these stars are suitable as psf references as well as spectral standards .
the n - band observations were made under good conditions , as judged from the level of sky cancellation obtained while chopping .
the q - band observations were made under marginal conditions ; however iras 16594@xmath04656 is a very bright target at 18 @xmath1 m and it was detected with good signal - to - noise ratio despite the less than ideal conditions .
the image quality was good as estimated from the standard stars .
the full width at half maximum ( fwhm ) was 0@xmath737 for the si5 filter image , 0@xmath739 for the si6 image , and 0@xmath760 for the qa image .
these correspond to strehl values of about 0.6 , fairly typical of better seeing conditions for the n - band filters but somewhat lower than usual for the qa filter .
the raw images on and off of the target were subtracted and then summed to produce raw images of iras 16594@xmath04656 in the three filters .
flux calibration of the images was done in two different ways .
first , the standard star observations were used to find the conversion from in - band counts to jy using the assumed spectral energy distribution from @xcite integrated over the filter profiles , and then these scaling factors were applied to the images of iras 16594@xmath04656 .
the pixel by pixel brightnesses so obtained were then converted to jy / square arc - second using the pixel size of t - recs .
second , the estimated filter flux densities were generated from the _ iso _ spectrum of iras 16594@xmath04656 in the same way as was used to get the expected flux densities in jy for the standard stars .
these values were also used to convert from counts to jy / square arc - second in the images .
it was found that for the si5 filter these two methods agreed within less than 1% .
for the other filters the agreement was poorer . using the _ iso _ spectrum for
the si6 filter estimate gave a value 22% higher than that from the standard star .
this discrepancy is too large to be due to an atmospheric extinction effect , judging from some estimates of the extinction coefficient in this filter made on other nights .
it probably indicates that the sky conditions were not uniform in the directions to the standard star and to our target , as in other observations we have obtained with t - recs the inter - comparison with _ iso _ spectra gives 2% agreement for filters in the n - band window .
the qa brightness calculated from the standard star came out 11% lower than that calculated from the _ iso _ spectrum .
this is probably within the uncertainties caused by the variable sky conditions .
there is also a color effect due to differences in spectral shape between iras 16594@xmath04656 and the standard stars , but since the filters are relatively narrow this is a small correction and it was neglected . in what follows ,
we have chosen to use the _ iso _ spectrum as the basis for creating surface brightness images , since this minimizes the effect of variable sky conditions .
this assumes that the _ iso _ spectrum gives the correct absolutely calibrated total brightness and the t - recs observations give the correct relative brightness distribution , or equivalently that all the atmospheric effects are uniform over the small t - recs field of view .
figure [ fig1 ] shows the three flux - calibrated images in jy / square arc - second .
the region shown in the figure is @xmath8 and contains all the detected emission from iras 16594@xmath04656 .
the total flux density for iras 16594@xmath04656 was calculated to be 44.0 , 56.9 , and 177 jy for the si5 , si6 , and qa filters , respectively . in all three cases ,
the circumstellar shell of iras 16594@xmath04656 appears as a bipolar nebula of dimension about 4@xmath75 @xmath9 2@xmath725 , with a bright central region orientated roughly north - south and two lobes extending east and west .
there is a clear difference in size between the east and west lobes .
the east lobe is about 20% smaller than the west lobe both in width and maximum detected radius from the star in these images .
the optical depth at these wavelengths , especially in q - band , must be small ; thus this size difference must be caused by either a physical size difference between the two lobes or distinctly different projection angles for the two lobes .
the central bright region of the mid - infrared images appears to be some type of thin `` equatorial '' torus , perpendicular to the axis of the two lobes .
the northern end of the this structure is brighter than the southern end in all the images , but the ratio is much closer to 1:1 in the qa image .
this shows that the dust in the torus is cooler in the southern region than in the northern region .
the sharp edge of the torus in the north is particularly striking , as the images are very bright there but there is a sudden edge beyond which no emission is observed along the line of the torus .
lucy deconvolution of the raw images was carried out using the standard star observations as psf templates .
this was done using the stsdas.analysis.restore.lucy task in the stsci reduction package under iraf version 2.12a .
a 61 by 61 pixel box was used to define the psf . pixels outside this psf box but within a 181 by 181 pixel box centered on the star were used to derive the background level , which was subtracted from the stellar profile . it was found that most of the improvement in the image resolution was obtained in the first few lucy iterations , after which there was no significant change in the derived structure , so the deconvolution was stopped after 20 iterations .
the deconvolved images were then re - smoothed with a gaussian of fwhm 0@xmath71 , slightly larger than the original pixel size .
the resulting images are sharpened by about a factor of 3 in psf width compared to the original images .
figure [ fig2 ] shows these sharpened images .
the two n - band images have almost identical structure .
the sharpened q - band image has the same general morphology as the n - band images but both lobes are seen to be smaller by about 0.4 arc - seconds than in the n - band images .
however , we believe that this size difference is not real .
comparison of the raw images in the qa and n - band filters shows that the emission region is just slightly larger for the qa image than for the si5 and si6 filters .
this indicates that the lucy deconvolution for the lobes introduced a small artifact into the image . as the strehl value for the standard star in the qa filter was lower than usual , it is possible that the seeing changed between the target observation and the standard star observation .
there was some indication of variable q - band conditions during these observations .
if the seeing did get worse for the standard star observation , that would explain the decrease in lobe size for the deconvolved image compared to the raw image , although the magnitude of the decrease is larger than one would expect based upon the fwhm value for the standard star qa filter image .
the structure of the brightest regions is similar for all three filters .
the bright part suggests a torus of some sort , and it appears to be thinner at the center than at the edges .
this suggests that the torus is seen nearly edge on .
if it were oriented at some intermediate angle to the plane of the sky , as was earlier asserted based upon the visible images , then one would expect the torus to appear as a small ellipse in these mid - infrared images .
this is clearly not seen . however , if we are indeed viewing the torus edge - on then the visible and mid - infrared images suggest it to be quite asymmetric with position . in each panel of figure
[ fig2 ] , the estimated star position is marked with a small black dot .
this position was found by cross - comparing the t - recs si5 image with an _ hst nicmos _ image taken in the narrow - band filter centered on the h@xmath10 2.12 @xmath1 m line @xcite .
the estimated stellar position is very close to the geometrical center of the bright `` bar '' in the dust emission .
it is located in a region of relatively low brightness in the three filters , especially in the si5 and si6 filters .
this probably means that in the optical images we are seeing the star through some type of hole in the toroid , where little dust is present . from the surface brightness images in two filters it is possible to construct a ratio map , and
if one assumes that the surface brightness is due to optically - thin thermal emission from dust grains of a known type , then the surface brightness ratio can be converted into color temperatures between the two wavelengths . denoting the surface brightness in jy / square arc - second by @xmath11 , the color temperature , @xmath12 ,
is defined by solving @xmath13 for each brightness ratio value in the image .
the optical depth values @xmath14 for the two filters are assumed to be proportional to the absorption cross - sections , so we can replace the optical depths with the actual q@xmath15 values for this calculation .
the scattering component of the dust extinction is expected to be small at these long wavelengths .
the ratio of @xmath14 values is a constant as long as the dust grain properties are uniform in the dust shell , so then the equation gives a one - to - one transformation between surface brightness ratio and @xmath12 .
we have used the si5 and qa images to produce a brightness ratio map , after convolving the si5 image with a gaussian profile of fwhm of 0@xmath7195 to match the angular resolution of the qa image .
regions of the two images which had `` low '' brightness values , taken to be less than 0.1% of the respective peak values , were masked out of the ratio image .
the ratio image was then transformed to dust color temperature , assuming that the dust grains are 0.1 @xmath1 m amorphous carbon grains with the opacity function for ac type 2 grains from @xcite .
these grain properties were the basis of the spectral model for iras 16594@xmath04656 presented by @xcite .
for another assumed dust grain size or type the dust color temperature values would change , but the relative variations over the image should remain the same .
while the @xmath12 values do not indicate the physical temperatures of the dust grains , since they are some type of average along the line of sight for each pixel , they do indicate the global dust temperature variations in the circumstellar shell as long as the dust grains are not drastically different than assumed for the calculation .
the @xmath12 map is shown in the lower right panel of figure [ fig1 ] .
the @xmath12 values are confined to a relatively narrow range .
the bright part of the dust shell has a range of @xmath12 from about 140 k to 160 k. it was found that the @xmath12 map was much the same whether or not the si5 image was convolved to the resolution of the qa image .
the @xmath12 map shows that the region of highest dust color temperature is in the north part of the central bright region , while the color temperature is much lower directly to the south on the other side of the stellar position .
there is also a region of high dust color temperature in the southern wall of the west lobe .
there is a cap at the end of the east lobe that is seen in the color temperature map , which is also apparent in the si5 image .
this cap does not appear to be associated with a higher dust color temperature than elsewhere in lobe , which suggests that the dust optical depth is higher here than for other positions in the lobe .
it is possible that the east lobe is smaller than the west lobe because its expansion is impeded by external material , and that the cap represents a boundary between the lobe and the external medium .
figure [ fig3 ] shows the deconvolved si5 image with overlaid contour plots in the optical i - band ( 0.8 @xmath1 m ; su , hrivnak , & kwok 2001 ) and near - infrared h@xmath10 filter images ( 2.12 @xmath1 m ; hrivnak , kelly , & su 2004 ) .
this allows direct comparison of the morphology of the nebula in these different wavelengths .
the h@xmath10 image was matched to the si5 filter image since they were immediately seen to have very similar morphologies .
this was used to obtain a reasonably accurate estimate of the central star position in the t - recs image .
that position was then used to match the optical image to the mid - infrared image .
the si5 image is plotted in absolute surface brightness units , jy / square arc - second . as shown in the upper right panel of figure [ fig3 ] , there is a close match of features in the lobes between the _ nicmos _ h@xmath10 filter image and the t - recs image .
the bright lobe edges are regions of strong h@xmath10 emission .
the cap in the east lobe is clearly visible in this panel , and it also corresponds to a region of strong h@xmath10 emission .
it is more difficult to determine if any of the mid - infrared bright waist structure is also detected in the h@xmath10 image , because the star is saturated in the h@xmath10 image , but it does not look as if anything but the edges of the lobes are detected in the h@xmath10 image . since the h@xmath10 emission is mainly shock excited @xcite , this raises the possibility that the dust emission from these regions are partially shock - excited .
another possibility that could explain why the dust emission region so closely matches the shock is that the dust grains may be much smaller downstream from the shock than they are before the shock , and that as a result the small grains are transiently heated to relatively high temperatures .
comparison of the t - recs images with the _ hst _ optical images @xcite shows that the two lobes seen in the t - recs images correspond closely to the central brightest part of the reflection nebula .
the total size of the optical reflection nebula is 12.3@xmath16 by 8.8@xmath16 , which is much larger than the size of the n - band or q - band images .
the optical image overlay in the lower left panel of figure [ fig3 ] uses logarithmically spaced contours ranging from 0.0085% of the stellar peak brightness up to the peak brightness , with each contour at a level 2.7 times the previous contour .
the optical reflection nebula is at most about 0.75% of the stellar peak brightness .
the lowest contours show what has been suggested to be point - symmetric morphology , with three pairs of oppositely directed features at position angles of about 40@xmath17 , 57@xmath17 , and 87@xmath17 east of north as can be measured from the i - band image presented in @xcite .
the optical lobes have been suggested to be caused by a rapidly precessing , columnated high - speed wind from the star @xcite .
the t - recs image shows just the two lobes at position angle 75@xmath17 . while there seems to be some very faint mid - infrared emission detected in the si5 filter on a size scale roughly three times that of the main mid - infrared lobes , over - plotting this with the optical image does not show any correspondences with the faint extended optical structure .
in particular , none of this emission is seen just outside the bright torus either to the north or to the south .
kinematic observations of the individual optical lobes is needed to determine if they are distinct structures or not .
if these point symmetric features are not distinct kinematic structures , then perhaps there are just two lobes but the optical appearance is due to structure in the walls of these lobes which make them look more complex .
the optical emission is due to reflection by dust , and so the larger size of the optical images compared to the mid - infrared images shows that the dust shell is much larger than is obvious from the n - band or q - band images .
the dust outside the central bright region delineated by the shocked h@xmath10 emission is clearly much colder than that inside the shocks . at the ends of mid - infrared torus ,
in particular , there must be a large discontinuity in temperature and optical depth so that there is a large change in mid - infrared surface brightness but a much smaller change in the optical brightness of the scattered light .
these mid - infrared images suggest that the torus is perpendicular to the plane of the sky .
this is consistent with recent observations of the bipolar lobes , which indicate that they are nearly in the plane of the sky .
unpublished high resolution long - slit spectra in the near - infrared @xcite have been obtained with the phoenix spectrograph on gemini south .
analysis of these spectra , which map the molecular hydrogen line at 2.12 @xmath1 m for cuts at different position angles through the star and the lobes , shows similar velocities for the two lobes , indicating that they are oriented very close to the plane of the sky .
this was also concluded by @xcite based upon near - infrared polarimetry along with dust shell modeling of the spectral energy distribution of the object .
since the evidence indicates that the nebular axis is oriented very close to the plane of the sky , the east lobe must actually be smaller than the west lobe .
the t - recs images show that the central bright region of the circumstellar dust shell is quite different than that of other well - known bipolar nebulae iras 17150@xmath03224 , iras 17441@xmath02411 , roberts 22 , and hen 3 - 401 , in all of which the dust emission is strongly peaked at the stellar position . for iras
16594@xmath04656 the mid - infrared brightness is at a minimum near the stellar position and is much higher to the north and the south along the central waist .
possibly the torus is of much lower optical depth in this object than in the others , or it is highly asymmetric with a low optical depth along our line of sight . the latter suggestion is consistent with the visibility of the central star .
certainly for iras 17150@xmath03224 and iras 17441@xmath02411 the spectral energy distribution implies a relatively high optical depth along our line of sight to the star , and the star is not seen in visible light .
the spectral type of the star in iras 16594@xmath04656 is much earlier than that in the latter two objects , so it may simply be more evolved and the torus may have had more time to disperse . unlike the hour - glass or open lobes observed in most bipolar planetary nebulae ( e.g. ngc 6302 ) , the bipolar lobes of iras 16594@xmath04656 as shown in figure [ fig2 ] are closed and resemble the lobes seen in the ppn iras 17106@xmath03046 and the young planetary nebula hen 2 - 320 .
the morphology of the lobes clearly shows that the lobes are confined by the circumstellar medium , and the fast collimated outflow which creates the bipolar lobes has not yet broken through the stellar wind of the agb progenitor .
the interaction between the fast and slow winds is clearly delineated by dust distribution in the lobes .
we also note that there is `` bulge '' at the tip of the western lobe , which suggests that the high - velocity flow is on the verge of breaking out .
in contrast to the cap at the tip of the eastern lobe ( which represents a pile - up at the wind interface ) , the western lobe may represent a slightly more advanced stage of the breakout , and therefore explains the difference in sizes between the two lobes . in a few hundred years , we expect that both lobes will open up into butterfly morphology .
we are therefore witnessing a critical phase of morphological transformation of pns .
we have successfully detected the bipolar lobes and a central bright waist in mid - infrared images of iras 16594@xmath04656 .
the bright waist suggests that we are seeing a central torus nearly edge - on . while this is consistent with published polarization and unpublished kinematic results
, it differs from earlier published interpretations of the visible image that concluded that the lobes are seen at an intermediate orientation .
this emphasizes the need for multi - wavelength observations to confidently understand the structure of proto - planetary nebulae .
this result may well be applicable to our understanding of other bipolar phenomenon such as ysos and agns .
b.j.h acknowledges support by the national science foundation under grant no .
this work was supported in part by grants to s.k from the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada .
cohen , m. , et al .
1999 , , 117 , 1864 garca - hernndez , d. , _ et al . _
2004 , in _ asymmetrical planetary nebulae iii _ , eds .
m. meixner , j. h. kastner , b. balick , & n. soker , ( asp : san francisco ) , 367 garca - lario , p. , manchado , a. , ulla , a. , & manteiga , m. 1999 , , 513 , 941 hrivnak , b. j. , kelly , d. m. , & su , k. y. l. 2004 , in _ asymmetrical planetary nebulae iii _ , eds . m. meixner , j. h. kastner , b. balick , & n. soker , ( asp : san francisco ) , 175 hrivnak , b. j. , kwok , s. , & su , k. y. l. 1999 , , 542 , 849 hrivnak , b. j. , kwok , s. , & su , k. y. l. 2001 , , 121 , 2775 hrivnak , b. j. , volk , k. , & kwok , s. 2000 , , 535 , 275 hrivnak , b. j. , et al . , 2006 ,
paper in preparation kwok , s. 1993 , , 31 , 63 rouleau , f. , & martin , p. g. 1991 , apj , 377 , 526 santander - garca , m. , corradi , r. l. m. , balick , b. , & mampaiso , a. 2004 , , 426 , 185 su , k. y. l. , hrivnak , b. j. , & kwok , s. 2001 , , 122 , 1585 su , k. y. l. , hrivnak , b. j. , kwok , s. , & sahai , r. 2003 , , 126 , 848 ueta , t. , murakawa , k. , & meixner , m. 2005 , aj , 129 , 1625 van de steene , g. c. & pottasch , s. r. 1993 , , 274 , 895 van de steene , g. c. , van hoof , p. a. m. , & wood , p. 2000 , , 362 , 984 van de steene , g. c. & van hoof , p. 2003
, , 406 , 773 volk , k. , & kwok , s. 1989 , , 342 , 345 van winckel , h. 2003 , , 43 , 391 | high - resolution mid - infrared images have been obtained in n - band and q - band for the proto - planetary nebula iras 16594@xmath04656 .
a bright equatorial torus and a pair of bipolar lobes can clearly be seen in the infrared images .
the torus appears thinner at the center than at the edges , suggesting that it is viewed nearly edge - on .
the infrared lobes correspond to the brightest lobes of the reflection nebula seen in the hubble space telescope ( _ hst _ ) optical image , but with no sign of the point - symmetric structure seen in the visible image .
the lobe structure shows a close correspondence with a molecular hydrogen map obtained with _
hst _ , suggesting that the dust emission in the lobes traces the distribution of the shocked gas .
the shape of the bipolar lobes shows clearly that the fast outflow is still confined by the remnant circumstellar envelope of the progenitor asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) star .
however , the non - detection of the dust outside of the lobes suggests that the temperature of the dust in the agb envelope is too low for it to be detected at 20 @xmath1 m . |
longitudinal - space - charge - driven micro - bunching instabilities arising in bunch compressors were predicted and observed over the last decade @xcite . it was recently proposed to employ such micro - bunching instability mechanism to form attosecond structures on the bunch current distribution for the subsequent generation of coherent radiation pulses @xcite .
a possible beam line configuration capable of enabling the micro - bunching instability is relatively simple .
it essentially consists of focusing section ( e.g. fodo cells ) where energy modulations due to the lsc impedance accumulate , followed by a longitudinally - dispersive section .
the latter section , by introducing an energy dependent path length , converts the incoming energy modulation into a density modulation .
such an elementary cell is often referred to as a lsc amplifier ( lsca ) .
most of the beamlines studied so far consider a longitudinally - dispersive section arranged as a bunch compression chicane [ or bunch compressor ( bc ) ] ; see fig .
[ lsca - layout ] .
several of these lsca modules are concatenated so to result in a large final density modulation .
we further assume the compression process in the chicane is linear [ the incoming longitudinal phase space ( lps ) does not have any nonlinear correlations ] .
such a modulated beam , when participating in a radiation - generation process , can produce coherent radiation at wavelengths comparable to the spectral range of the final density modulations .
overview of a cascaded longitudinal - space - charge amplifier ( lsca ) composed of several lsca modules .
each lsca module incorporate a focusing channel and a longitudinally dispersive section .
the ( red ) rectangles and ( blue ) ellipses respectively represent dipole and quadrupole magnets . ]
the purpose of this paper is two - fold .
the paper first introduces a fully three dimensional ( 3d ) multi - scale space - charge algorithm adapted from astrophysics @xcite .
the algorithm is used to discuss some limitations of the one - dimensional lsc impedance model commonly employed in lsca investigations . using the latter benchmarked algorithm
, we then investigate a possible lsca beamline configuration similar to the one studied in @xcite .
finally , we estimate the generation of undulator radiation seeded by the lcsa .
in contrast to ref .
@xcite our study consider the case of a @xmath1 a 300-mev electron beam produced in a conventional superconducting linac .
charged - particle beams are subject to self interaction via velocity and radiation fields . in absence of radiation processes
( i.e. acceleration ) , the effect of velocity fields ( i.e. space charge ) dominates and its regime varies with the bunch density . under a simple 1d approximation , a comparison of the debye length @xmath2 to the root - mean - squared ( rms ) transverse beam size @xmath3 and mean inter - particle distance @xmath4 ( where @xmath5 is the electronic density ) provides a criterion to assess the importance of space charge effects on the beam dynamics .
when @xmath6 space charge effects are significant and often computed using the mean - field approximation ( i.e. the space charge force is derived from the electrostatic potential associated to the particle distribution ) commonly implemented in particle - in - cell ( pic ) algorithms . however , when @xmath7 , particle - to - particle `` binary '' interactions play an important role and are needed to be accounted for @xcite . as the beam is accelerated the transverse and longitudinal space - charge forces reduce respectively as @xmath8 and @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the lorentz factor . at the macroscopic level ,
e.g. for spatial scale comparable to the bunch sizes , the space charge can be accurately described by a mean field approach @xcite .
however , in high - brightness beams @xmath11 beams with low fractional momentum spread @xmath11 the weakened longitudinal - space charge ( lsc ) force can still influence the beam dynamics at a microscopic level @xmath11 i.e. for spatial scales smaller than the bunch sizes @xmath11 and small density modulations ( e.g. due to noise or imperfections ) can result in lcs - driven energy modulations . in this latter regime ,
the lsc is generally treated with a one - dimensional ( 1d ) model . to illustrate the main results of the 1-d model
, we consider a simple beam line consisting of a drift with length @xmath12 ( where the beam is transversely contained ) followed by a chicane with longitudinal dispersion @xmath13 .
it is customary to characterize the strength of the micro - bunching instability by associating the density gain defined as @xmath14 where @xmath15 and @xmath16 is the observation wavelength and @xmath17 are respectively the initial and final bunching factors defined as @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the temporal coordinate of the @xmath20-th macroparticle , @xmath0 is the total number of particles and @xmath21 . in the latter equation
we assume the beam s longitudinal density to follow the klimontovich distribution @xmath22 .
the gain for this simple beam line can be shown to be proportional to the impedance @xmath23 @xcite following @xmath24 where @xmath25 ka is the alfvn current , @xmath26 is the rms fractional energy spread , @xmath27 is the chirp , and @xmath28 is the free - space impedance .
the exponential term in eq . [ gaineq ] induces a high - frequency cut - off of the modulation @xmath29 note , that after traveling through a bc , the modulation wavelength will be shortened by a compression factor @xmath30 .
although the impedance @xmath23 is partially determined by the properties of the wakefields inside the bc @xcite , the lsc has much stronger effect in amplifying density modulations @xcite . for a transversely gaussian cylindrically - symmetric beam
the lsc impedance is given by @xcite @xmath31 where @xmath32 is the free - space impedance , @xmath33 , @xmath34 is the rms beam size and @xmath35 .
similar expression for a transversely uniform beam is provided in @xcite . the maximum of the eq .
[ imp_ven ] is achieved at @xmath36 , therefore the optimal wavelength of the density modulation will be located around @xmath37
the nature of space charge forces lies in particle - to - particle coulomb interaction .
direct summation of the forces yields to @xmath38 growth where @xmath0 is the number of macroparticles , which makes it impossible to compute at large @xmath0 .
several approximation techniques can be used : mean - field on a grid approximation @xcite , one - dimensional space charge impedance @xcite , analytical sub - beams or ensembles model @xcite , rigid - slice approximation @xcite .
all of those methods reduce the problem s complexity via some approximations which ultimately limits the maximum attainable spatial resolution .
most recent attempt used a three - dimensional - grid space charge algorithm based on a periodic boundary @xcite . from another point of view
, space charge problem is very similar to the well - known @xmath0-body problem in celestial mechanics .
one of the most effective algorithms for the gravitational @xmath0-body problem is the so called `` tree '' or barnes - hut ( bh ) algorithm @xcite , which scales as @xmath39 . in this paper
we present the results obtained using a modified version of the code available at @xcite .
such approach was successfully employed to simulate early - stage beam dynamics in photocathodes @xcite and laser ion cooling @xcite . in brief
, the bh algorithm initially surrounds the bunch distribution in a cubic cell called a root cell .
the root cell is divided into 8 sub - cells recursively , until it reaches the point where a single sub - cell contains just one particle
. then forces only between nearby cells are calculated directly , and the cells far away from each other are treated as two large macroparticles with the total charge placed in the cell s center of mass .
the process of calculating net forces starts from the root cell and recursively parses the cell hierarchy until it reaches the size of the smallest cell that is predefined as a precision parameter .
thus , the algorithm is significantly faster than a direct summation method
. the bh method does not preserve full hamiltonian , yet for relatively small precision parameter the difference between direct summation is comparably small @xcite . it should be pointed out in the direct summation part ( for neighboring cells ) the bh algorithm also implement a local smoothing of the potential to avoid singularities @xcite . another more efficient fast multipole method ( fmm )
algorithm has been recently developed @xcite and will be eventually used in further refinement of our work .
though fmm algorithms are more sophisticated and precise , still the bh method is comparably accurate and faster than fmm and it can be embedded in time - stepping integrators @xcite .
for the studies detailed in this paper we used the bh algorithm as an external script within the elegant simulations . at a user - specified axial locations along the accelerator beam line , space charge kicks were applied .
our approach is to follow the quasi - static approximation @xcite .
the distribution at the defined axial location is recorded and a lorentz transformation to the bunch s rest frame is performed .
the bh algorithm is then utilized to obtain the 3d electrostatic field @xmath40 in the bunch s rest frame .
we should point out that the bh algorithm returns the field directly evaluated at each macro - paticle locations ( so that there is not need for interpolation as in a grid - based algorithm ) .
the electrostatic field is subsequently transformed in the laboratory frame via a lorentz boost .
the resulting electromagnetic fields @xmath41 in the laboratory frame are used to apply the corresponding lorentz force @xmath42 $ ] on each of the macroparticles [ @xmath43 and @xmath44 are respectively the charge and reduced velocity ( @xmath45 ) of the considered macroparticle ] .
the distribution is finally passed back to elegant and tracked up in the given optical lattice to the next space charge kick where the above process repeats .
we henceforth refer to the combination of the bh algorithm with elegant as `` elegant - bh '' .
our implementation relies on an impulse approximation so that only the momentum , i.e. not the position , of the macroparticles is altered by the space charge kick .
we assumed there is no magnetic field in the rest frame .
although this assumption is not strictly valid , it was shown to hold for beams with low energy spread typically generated from photoinjectors @xcite . in order to gain confidence in the implemented space charge calculation procedure ,
several validation tests were conducted ; see [ app : benchmarks ] .
in this section we only focus on the benchmarking of eq .
[ imp_ven ] with elegant - bh .
we considered initial bunch distributions with modulated current profiles of the form @xmath46,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath47 , @xmath48 and @xmath49 are respectively the modulation amplitude and spatial wavenumber , and @xmath50 and @xmath51 are respectively the nominal longitudinal and transverse beam distributions .
the modulation along the axial @xmath52 direction leads to an energy modulation due to the lsc impedance and eventually produces further current modulation depending on the longitudinal dispersion of the beamline . from the definition of the impedance , and
given the fourier - transformed longitudinal electric field @xmath53 and current distribution @xmath54 , the longitudinal impedance can be recovered as @xmath55 a comparison of the simulated lps ( after one space charge kick with elegant - bh ) with the initial one appears in fig .
[ phasespace](a , b ) and demonstrates the salient features of the modulations and especially the @xmath56 shift between the final energy modulations and the initial density modulations ; see fig .
[ phasespace](c ) .
lps distribution for a density - modulated gaussian beam before ( a ) and after ( b ) the application of one space charge kick . corresponding induced energy modulation ( red solid trace ) computed from image ( b ) and current distribution ( blue dash trace ) obtained from image ( a ) ; lower plot ( c).in the upper images @xmath57 refers to the normalized momentum spread .
] the fourier transform of the initial current distribution was performed using a fast - fourier transform ( fft ) algorithm .
likewise , the mean energy of thin axial slices within the final lps density distribution was computed thereby providing the energy modulation dependence on @xmath52 , @xmath58 .
the extracted energy modulation @xmath58 is fourier transformed to yield @xmath59 from which the axial electric field @xmath60 was inferred .
the resulting impedance evolution as a function of @xmath49 obtained is compared against eq .
[ eq : impedanceretr ] in fig .
[ fig : z ] .
the studies were carried out using different number of macroparticles ( @xmath61\times10 ^ 6 $ ] ) to ensure the convergence and satisfy the statistical limit @xcite .
the number of fft bins @xmath62 was also tuned to minimize discretization effects while varying @xmath49 . as the wavenumber @xmath49 value decreases ,
the bunch duration length was increased to ensure the number of macroparticles per bin remains constant and guarantees a sufficient number of modulations occurs within the bunch . in our simulations we set this ratio to be typically @xmath63 .
comparison of the longitudinal space - charge impedance computed from eq .
[ imp_ven ] ( theory " ) , from eq .
[ imp3deq ] ) ( theory-3d " ) , with the ones retrieved from simulation with elegant built - in lscdrift element ( elegant " ) , and elegant - bh ( elegant - bh " ) . [ fig : z ] ] figure [ fig : z ] points to small differences between the lscdrift element in elegant that assumes transverse distribution to be uniform @xcite and eq . [ imp_ven ] .
the elegant - bh performs full three - dimensional space charge force calculation and therefore inherits both the transverse and longitudinal effects in lsc impedance . such effects were previously recognized @xcite and are attributed to the radial dependence of the axial space charge field conferring a similar dependence on the impedance . to further explore longitudinal space charge impedance radial dependence we performed an analysis over thin radial slices @xmath64 $ ] where @xmath65 .
the results of such an analysis are summarized in fig .
[ fig : z ] , [ impedance_slice ] for a beam following a transverse gaussian distribution of the form @xmath66 $ ] .
figure [ impedance ] compares the numerical results with the expected radial dependence analytically derived in ref .
@xcite ring derived as eq .
( 35 ) of ref .
@xcite and applied the bessel recursive relation to further simplify eq.(35 ) of the paper .
in addition we explicitly wrote the @xmath67 of ref .
@xcite as @xmath68 .
] @xmath69 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath70 is the heaviside step function , @xmath71 and @xmath72 are modified bessel functions , @xmath73 is the distribution function . a noteworthy consequence of the observed strong radial dependence for a gaussian transverse distribution is the effective smearing of the axial modulation which will effectively result in weaker integrated energy modulations . for a fixed value of @xmath49 .
the green and blue traces respectively correspond to the impedance with gaussian transverse distribution from eq .
[ imp3deq ] and elegant - bh .
the parameter @xmath74 is the rms transverse size of the distribution .
[ impedance_slice ] ] as a final note , we point out that in the case of a parabolic @xmath75 and uniform @xmath76 distribution an analytical form of the impedance can be retrieved [ here @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath70 are respectively the radius , normalization factor , and heaviside function ] .
it is especially found that the parabolic transverse distribution yields an impedance with weaker dependence on the radius compared to a gaussian transverse distribution ; see fig .
[ impedance_slice ] .
these observations suggest a possible use of transverse electron - beam shaping @xcite as ways of controlling the micro - bunching instability .
in this section we explore the possible use of a staged lsca beam line to produce micro - bunching structure with spatial scale corresponding to the ultraviolet regime , so @xmath79 nm . for our simulations we considered the configuration available at the fermilab accelerator science & technology ( fast ) facility ( formerly known as asta )
@xcite currently in its commissioning phase at fermilab .
the fast facility is diagrammed in fig .
[ fig : fast ] . in short ,
the beam is produced from a photocathode located in a 1+@xmath80 radiofrequency ( rf ) gun and accelerated to @xmath81 mev by two superconducting tesla accelerating cavities @xcite .
downstream of the accelerating cavities the beam can be manipulated ( e.g. longitudinally compressed ) and diagnosed in a 20-m transport line before being injected in an ilc type accelerating cryomodule composed of eight superconducting cavities .
the beam , with final energies up to @xmath82 mev , then can be directed into a small - footprint ring [ the integrable optics test accelerator ( iota ) ] or transported to experiments arranged along a @xmath83 m transport line .
conversely , the 70-m beamline , with proper optics , could accommodate the formation of broadband density modulation with uv spectral content ; see fig .
[ fig : fast ]
. + overview of fast facility and the proposed lsca .
the legend is as follows : `` cavx '' : accelerating cavities , `` bc '' : magnetic chicane bunch compressor , the thin ( red ) rectangles and ( green ) square symbols respectively represent the quadrupole and dipole magnets . ]
horizontal ( blue ) and vertical ( red ) rms beam size evolution in one lsca module .
the envelopes are obtained in the single - particle dynamics limit .
the green diagram indicates the location of the focusing ( qf ) and defocusing ( qd ) quadrupole magnets while the four smaller rectangles ( at distance @xmath84 m ) represent the chicane dipole magnets . ] a numerical optimization of the electron - beam formation and acceleration to @xmath81 mev was carried out with astra @xcite for various charges .
the results combined with a mild bunch compression in the 50-mev bunch compressor chicane , could produce bunches with peak current on the order of @xmath1 a and slice parameters gathered in table [ tab : parameters ] @xcite .
these parameters were used to generate initial distribution used in all the elegant - bh simulations presented below . for simplicity
we consider all the lsca modules to be similar : they consist of 4 fodo - cell sections each followed by small bending angle chicanes .
the only difference between the modules is the @xmath13 parameters associated to the chicanes as explained below .
the horizontal dispersion introduced by the chicanes is minimal and does not break the periodicity of the fodo cells .
the settings of quadrupole magnets arranged as a fodo cell were optimized using single - particle dynamics simulations .
the corresponding beam size evolution along one lsca module appears in fig .
[ fig : lattice ] .
.[tab : parameters ] beam parameters considered for the lsca simulations using the setup of fig .
[ lsca - layout ] . [ cols="<,^,^",options="header " , ] to quantitatively assess the properties of undulator radiation produced seeded by a lsca - microbunched beam , we employ the program genesis @xcite .
the beam parameters are consistent with the beam parameters generated downstream of the lcsa ; see tab .
[ tab : felinput ] . for our simulation
we rescale the bunching factor obtained with @xmath85 macroparticles , see fig .
[ 3stage ] , to the real number of electron in the considered axial slice @xmath86 following @xmath87 where @xmath88 .
this scaled bunching factor obtained for a specific wavelength is then used as an input in the steady state genesis simulation .
the simulated evolution of the radiation pulse energy along the undulator length appears in fig .
[ fig : radiation ] . in the latter figure we considered a wavelength of @xmath89 nm with a scaled bunching factor of @xmath90 ( i.e. a nominal bunching factor of @xmath91 in fig . [ 3stage ] ) .
our simulations demonstrate that uv pulses with energies on the order of @xmath92 @xmath93j could be reached downstream of a meter - scale section of the undulator three orders of magnitudes above the shot - noise " radiation of 9 nj ( achieved with an initial shot - noise bunching factor of @xmath94 ) .
using a grid - less code adapted from astrophysics we have investigated three - dimensional effects in the lsc ( longitudinal space - charge ) impedance and confirmed that the one - dimensional often used lsc impedance model is a good approximation .
additionally we benchmarked the radial dependence of the lsc impedance with the analytical results developed in ref .
@xcite . finally , we confirmed the possible use of a cascaded lsca ( longitudinal space - charge amplifier ) scheme to produce femtosecond microstructures in the lps ( longitudinal phase space ) with spectral range attaining the ultraviolet domain using electron - beam parameters achievable at fast facility .
we are grateful to dr .
j. barnes ( u. hawaii ) for granting us the use of his open - source version of the bh algorithm and to dr .
m. borland ( anl ) for his help with elegant .
we thank dr .
j. wu ( slac ) for discussing some of the results presented in his paper @xcite , and dr .
r. li ( jlab ) and dr .
v. litvinenko ( bnl ) for their interests and comments on our work .
this work was supported by the us department of energy ( doe ) under contract de - sc0011831 with northern illinois university .
fermilab is operated by the fermi research alliance llc under us doe contract de - ac02 - 07ch11359 .
to gain confidence in the algorithm developed we benchmarked our simulations in the macroscopic regime and rely on both analytical results and simulations carried out with the astra program @xcite .
transverse ( top plot ) and longitudinal ( lower plot ) electric fields experienced by the macropaticle simulated with elegant - bh ( symbols ) and obtained from eq .
[ fieldeqs ] ( lines ) .
, title="fig : " ] + transverse ( top plot ) and longitudinal ( lower plot ) electric fields experienced by the macropaticle simulated with elegant - bh ( symbols ) and obtained from eq .
[ fieldeqs ] ( lines ) .
, title="fig : " ] we first consider a 3d homogeneous ellipsoidal bunch with electric field linearly dependent on the position within the charge distribution as @xcite @xmath95 where @xmath96 , @xmath97 $ ] , @xmath98 are the ellipsoid semiaxes , @xmath99 and @xmath100 is the bunch charge .
comparison of the beam envelope evolution along a 1-m drift .
eq . [ k - v ] solution ( red ) , is compared against astra ( green ) , and elegant - bh simulation ( blue ) .
the magenta line corresponds to no space charge case . ] to assess longer - term tracking , we compared the evolution of the 5 mev , 500 a beam envelope over a drift space . for a stationary uniform beam the transverse envelope evolution
is governed by @xcite @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the rms beam size in @xmath103 , @xmath104 is the corresponding geometric emittance and @xmath105 is a space charge perveance defined ( taken to be an order of @xmath106 ) , for a parabolic current profile , as @xmath107 where @xmath100 is the bunch charge , @xmath108 the peak current , @xmath16 the rf wavelength , and @xmath48 the electron mass .
figure [ envelope ] compares the solution of eq .
[ k - v ] against the beam envelope simulated with elegant - bh .
the geometric emittance was taken to be very low ( @xmath109 m ) for these studies so that when space charge was turned off the beam envelope ( dashed line ) stayed quasi - constant .
finally fig .
[ elastra ] compares the final transverse phase space at @xmath110 m obtained with elegant - bh and astra for the 50 mev , 500 a beam .
these two computer programs despite their very different space charge algorithms are in very close agreement .
the code astra relies on the same quasi - electrostatic approximation as used in elegant - bh but implements a cylindrical - symmetric space charge algorithm using a @xmath111 two - dimensional grid for depositing the charge and solving poisson s equation in the bunch frame @xcite . | longitudinal space charge ( lsc ) effects are generally considered as harmful in free - electron lasers as they can seed unfavorable energy modulations that can result in density modulations with associated emittance dilution .
this `` micro - bunching instabilities '' is naturally broadband and could possibly support the generation of coherent radiation over a broad region of the spectrum . therefore there has been an increasing interest in devising accelerator beam lines capable of controlling lsc induced density modulations . in the present paper
we refine these previous investigations by combining a grid - less space charge algorithm with the popular particle - tracking program elegant .
this high - fidelity model of the space charge is used to benchmark conventional lsc models .
we finally employ the developed model to investigate the performance of a cascaded lsc amplifier using beam parameters comparable to the ones achievable at fermilab accelerator science & technology ( fast ) facility currently under commissioning at fermilab .
linear accelerator , electron beams , space charge , micro - bunching instabilities , @xmath0-body tree algorithm |
the present work deals with the generalized surface quasi - geostrophic equation ( gsqg ) arising in fluid dynamics and which describes the evolution of the potential temperature @xmath1 by the transport equation : @xmath2 here @xmath3 refers to the velocity field , @xmath4 and @xmath5 is a real parameter taken in @xmath60,2[$ ] .
the singular operator @xmath7 is of convolution type and defined by , @xmath8 with @xmath9 where @xmath10 stands for the gamma function .
this model was proposed by crdoba et al . in @xcite as an interpolation between euler equations and the surface quasi - geostrophic model ( sqg ) corresponding to @xmath11 and @xmath12 , respectively .
the sqg equation was used by juckes @xcite and held et al .
@xcite to describe the atmosphere circulation near the tropopause .
it was also used by lapeyre and klein @xcite to track the ocean dynamics in the upper layers .
we note that there is a strong mathematical and physical analogy with the three - dimensional incompressible euler equations ; see @xcite for details . in the last few years
there has been a growing interest in the mathematical study of these active scalar equations .
special attention has been paid to the local well - posedness of classical solutions which can be performed in various functional spaces .
for instance , this was implemented in the framework of sobolev spaces @xcite by using the commutator theory .
wether or not these solutions are global in time is an open problem except for euler equations @xmath11 .
the second restriction with the gsqg equation concerns the construction of yudovich solutions known to exist globally in time for euler equations @xcite which are not at all clear even locally in time .
the main difficulty is due to the velocity which is in general singular and scales below the lipschitz class .
nonetheless one can say more about this issue for some special class of concentrated vortices .
more precisely , when the initial datum has a vortex patch structure , that is , @xmath13 is the characteristic function of a bounded simply connected smooth domain @xmath14 , then there is a unique local solution in the patch form @xmath15 in this case , the boundary motion of the domain @xmath16 is described by the contour dynamics formulation ; see the papers @xcite .
the global persistence of the boundary regularity is only known for @xmath11 according to chemin s result @xcite ; for another proof see the paper of bertozzi and constantin @xcite .
notice that for @xmath17 the numerical experiments carried out in @xcite provide strong evidence for the singularity formation in finite time .
let us mention that the contour dynamics equation remains locally well - posed when the domain of the initial patch is assumed to be multi - connected meaning that the boundary is composed with finite number of disjoint smooth jordan curves .
the main concern of this work is to explore analytically and numerically some special vortex patches called v - states ; they correspond to patches which do not change their shapes during the motion .
the emphasis will be put on the v - states subject to uniform rotation around their center of mass , that is , @xmath18 , where @xmath19 stands for the planar rotation with center @xmath20 and angle @xmath21 the parameter @xmath22 is called the angular velocity of the rotating domain . along the chapter
we call these structures rotating patches or simply v - states .
their existence is of great interest for at least two reasons : first they provide non trivial initial data with global existence , and second this might explain the emergence of some ordered structures in the geophysical flows . this study has been conducted first for the two - dimensional euler equations ( @xmath11 ) a long time ago and a number of analytical and numerical studies are known in the literature . the first result in this setting goes back to kirchhoff @xcite who discovered that an ellipse of semi - axes @xmath23 and @xmath24 rotates uniformly with the angular velocity @xmath25 ; see for instance the references and @xcite . till
now this is the only known explicit v - states ; however the existence of implicit examples was established about one century later .
in fact , deem and zabusky @xcite gave numerical evidence of the existence of the v - states with @xmath26-fold symmetry for each integer @xmath27 ; remark that the case @xmath28 coincides with kirchhoff s ellipses .
to fix the terminology , a planar domain is said @xmath26-fold symmetric if it has the same group invariance of a regular polygon with @xmath26 sides .
note that at each frequency @xmath26 these v - states can be seen as a continuous deformation of the disc with respect to to the angular velocity .
an analytical proof of this fact was given few years later by burbea in @xcite .
his approach consists in writing a stationary problem in the frame of the patch with the conformal mapping of the domain and to look for the non trivial solutions by using the technique of the bifurcation theory .
quite recently , in burbea s approach was revisited with more details and explanations .
the boundary regularity of the v - states was also studied and it was shown to be of class @xmath29 and convex close to the disc .
we mention that explicit vortex solutions similar to the ellipses are discovered in the literature for the incompressible euler equations in the presence of an external shear flow ; see for instance @xcite .
a general review about vortex dynamics can be found in the with regard to the existence of the simply connected v - states for the ( gsqg ) it has been discussed very recently in the papers @xcite . in @xcite , it was shown that the ellipses can not rotate for any @xmath30 and to the authors best knowledge no explicit example is known in the literature . lately , in @xcite the last two authors proved the analogous of burbea s result and showed the existence of the @xmath26-folds rotating patches for @xmath310,1[$ ] .
in addition , the bifurcation from the unit disc occurs at the angular velocities , @xmath32 where @xmath10 denotes the usual gamma function.the remaining case @xmath33 has been explored and solved by castro , crdoba and gmez - serrano in @xcite .
they also show that the v - states are @xmath29 and convex close to the discs . to complete these works we discussed in this work ( which is forwarded in ) some numerical experiments concerning these v - states and their limiting structures when we go to the end of each branch ; new behaviors
will be observed compared to the numerical experiments achieved for euler we want in this chapter to learn more about the v - states but with different topological structure compared to the preceding discussion .
more precisely , we propose to scrutinize rotating patches with only one hole , also called doubly connected v - states .
recall that a patch @xmath34 is said to be doubly connected if the domain @xmath35 , with @xmath36 and @xmath37 being two simply connected bounded domains satisfying @xmath38 this structure is preserved for euler system globally in time but known to be for short time when @xmath00,1[$ ] see @xcite .
we notice that compared to the simply connected case the boundaries evolve through extra nonlinear terms coming from the interaction between the boundaries and therefore the existence of the v - states is relatively more complicate to analyze .
this problem is not well studied from the analytical point of view and recent progress has been made for euler equations in the papers @xcite . in @xcite , the authers proved the existence of explicit v - states similar to kirchhoff ellipses seems to be out of reach .
indeed , it was stated that if one of the boundaries of the v - state is a circle then necessarily the other one should be also a circle . moreover ,
if the inner curve is an ellipse then there is no rotation at all .
another closely related subject is to deal with some vortex magnitude @xmath39 inside the domain @xmath37 and try to find explicit rotating patches .
this was done by flierl and polvani @xcite who proved that confocal ellipses rotate uniformly provided some compatibility relations are satisfied between the parameter @xmath39 and the semi - axes of the ellipses .
we note that another approach based upon complex analysis tools with a complete discussion can be found now , from the equations we may easily conclude that the annulus is a stationary doubly connected patch , and therefore it rotates with any angular velocity @xmath22 . from this obvious fact
, one can wonder wether or not the bifurcation to nontrivial v - states still happens as for the simply connected case .
this has been recently investigated in @xcite for euler equations following basically burbea s approach but with more involved calculations . it was shown that for @xmath40 and @xmath26 being an integer satisfying the inequality @xmath41 then there exist two curves of non - annular @xmath26-fold doubly connected patches bifurcating from the annulus @xmath42 at different eigenvalues @xmath43 given explicitly by the formula @xmath44 ^ 2-b^{2m}}.\ ] ] now we come to the main contribution of the current work .
we propose to study the doubly connected v - states for the gsqg model when @xmath00,1[$ ] . before stating our result we need to make some notation .
we define @xmath45 and @xmath46 where @xmath47 refers to bessel function of the first kind .
our result reads as follows .
[ main ] let @xmath48 and @xmath490,1[$ ] ; there exists @xmath50 with the following property : + for each @xmath51 there exists two curves of @xmath26-fold doubly connected @xmath52-states that bifurcate from the annulus @xmath53 at the angular velocities @xmath54 with @xmath55 ^ 2 - 4b^2\lambda_{m}^2(b).\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ rmw1 ] 1 .
the number @xmath56 is the smallest integer such that @xmath57 this restriction appears in the spectral study of the linearized operator and gives only sufficient condition for the existence of the v - states .
2 . as we shall see later in lemma [ lem1 ] , for @xmath11 we find the result of euler equations established in @xcite and the condition @xmath58 is in accordance with that given by @xmath59 3 .
we can check by using the strict monotonicity of @xmath60 that for any @xmath61 @xmath62 consequently the corresponding bifurcating curves generate close to the annulus non trivial clockwise doubly connected v - states .
this fact is completely new compared to what we know for euler equations or for the simply connected case where the bifurcation occurs at positive angular velocities .
the numerical experiments discussed in section @xmath63 reveal the existence of non radial stationary patches for the generalized quasi - geostrophic equations and it would be very interesting to establish this fact analytically . in a connected subject , we point out that the last author has shown quite recently in @xcite that for euler equations clockwise convex v - states reduce to the discs .
now we shall sketch the proof of theorem [ main ] which is mainly based upon the bifurcation theory via crandall - rabinowitz s theorem . the first step is to write down the analytical equations of the boundaries of the v - states .
this can be done for example through the conformal parametrization of the domains @xmath36 and @xmath37 : we denote by @xmath64 the conformal mappings possessing the following structure , @xmath65 we assume in addition that the fourier coefficients are real which means that we look only for the v - states which are symmetric with respect to the real axis . moreover using the subordination principle
we deduce that @xmath660,1[$ ] ; the parameter @xmath24 coincides with the small radius of the annulus that we slightly perturb . as we shall see later in section [ sec12 ] ,
the conformal mappings are subject to two coupled nonlinear equations defined as follows : for @xmath67 @xmath68 with @xmath69 in order to apply the bifurcation theory we should understand the structure of the linearized operator around the trivial solution @xmath70 , corresponding to the annulus with radii @xmath24 and @xmath71 , and identify the range of @xmath72 where this operator has a one - dimensional kernel .
the computations of the linear operator @xmath73 with @xmath74 in terms of its fourier coefficients are long and tricky .
they are connected to the hypergeometric functions @xmath75 simply denoted by @xmath76 throughout this chapter . to find compact formula we use at several steps some algebraic identities described by the contiguous function relations - .
similarly to the euler equations @xcite the linearized operator acts as a matrix fourier multiplier .
more precisely , for @xmath77 we obtain the formula , @xmath78 where the matrix @xmath79 is given for @xmath80 by @xmath81 therefore the values of @xmath22 associated to non trivial kernels are the solutions of a second - degree polynomial , @xmath82 this can be solved when the discriminant @xmath83 introduced in theorem [ main ] is positive .
the computations of the dimension of the kernel are more complicate than the cases raised before in the references @xcite .
the matter reduces to count the following discrete set @xmath84 note that in @xcite this set has only one element and therefore the kernel is one - dimensional .
this follows from the monotonicity of the `` nonlinear eigenvalues '' sequence @xmath85 which is not very hard to get due to the explicit polynomial structure of the coefficients of the analogous polynomial to .
unfortunately , in the current situation this structure is broken because the matrix coefficients of @xmath86 are related to bessel functions .
therefore the monotonicity of the eigenvalues is more subtle and will require more refined analysis .
this subject will be discussed later with ample details in the subsection [ subsec12 ] . to achieve the spectral study and check the complete assumptions of crandall - rabinowitz s theorem it remains to prove the transversality assumption and check that the image is of co - dimension one .
this will be done in section [ sec45 ] in a straightforward way and without serious difficulties .
we also mention that the transversality assumption is obtained only when the discriminant @xmath87 meaning that there is no crossing roots for the equation .
the proof of the bifurcation will be achieved in section [ sec45 ] .
next , we shall make few comments about the statement of the main theorem .
@xmath88 for the sqg equation corresponding to @xmath12 the situation is more delicate due to some logarithmic loss . the simply connected case has been achieved recently in @xcite by using hilbert spaces where we take into account this loss .
the same approach could lead to the existence of the doubly - connected v - states for the ( sqg ) equation .
for the spectral study , the linearized operator can be obtained as a limit of when @xmath5 goes to @xmath89 more precisely , we get @xmath90 where the matrix @xmath79 is given for @xmath80 by @xmath91 with @xmath92 @xmath93 the boundary of the v - states belongs to hlder space @xmath94 . for euler equations corresponding to @xmath11 ,
we get better result in the simply connected geometry as it was shown the boundary is @xmath29 and convex when the v - states are close to the circle .
the proof in this particular case uses in a deep way the algebraic structure of the kernel according to some recurrence formulae .
the extension of this result to @xmath00,2[$ ] was done in @xcite .
we expect that the latter approach could be also adapted to the model for the doubly connected case .
@xmath95 in the setting of the vortex patches the global existence with smooth boundaries is not known for @xmath310,2[$ ] .
the simply connected v - states discussed in @xcite offer a first class of global solutions which are periodic in time .
we find here a second class of global solutions which are the doubly connected v - states .
the remainder of the chapter is organized as follows . in the next section
, we shall write down the boundary equations through the conformal parametrization . in
we shall introduce and review some background material on the bifurcation theory and gauss hypergeometric functions . in section @xmath96 , we will study the regularity of the nonlinear functionals involved in the boundary equations . in section
@xmath97 we conduct the spectral study and formulate the suitable assumptions to get a fredholm operator of zero index . in section
@xmath98 we prove theorem [ main ] .
finally , the last section will be devoted to some numerical experiments dealing with the simply and doubly connected v - states .
* notation .
* we need to fix some notation that will be frequently used along this chapter . 1 .
we denote by c any positive constant that may change from line to line
. 2 . for any positive real numbers @xmath99 and @xmath100 ,
the notation @xmath101 means that there exists a positive constant @xmath102 independent of @xmath99 and @xmath100 such that @xmath103 .
we denote by @xmath104 the unit disc .
its boundary , the unit circle , is denoted by @xmath105 .
4 . let @xmath106 be a continuous function .
we define its mean value by , @xmath107 where @xmath108 stands for the complex integration .
let @xmath109 and @xmath110 be two normed spaces .
we denote by @xmath111 the space of all continuous linear maps @xmath112 endowed with its usual strong topology .
6 . for a linear operator @xmath113
we denote by @xmath114 and @xmath115 the kernel and the range of @xmath116 , respectively . 7 .
if @xmath110 is a vector space and @xmath117 is a subspace , then @xmath118 denotes the quotient space .
before proceeding further with the consideration of the v - states , we shall recall riemann mapping theorem which is one of the most important results in complex analysis . to restate this result
we need to recall the definition of _ simply connected _ domains .
let @xmath119 denote the riemann sphere .
we say that a domain @xmath120 is _ simply connected _ if the set @xmath121 is connected .
_ riemann mapping theorem .
_ let @xmath104 denote the unit open ball and @xmath122 be a simply connected bounded domain .
then there is a unique bi - holomorphic map called also conformal map , @xmath123 taking the form @xmath124 in this theorem the regularity of the boundary has no effect regarding the existence of the conformal mapping but it contributes in the boundary behavior of the conformal mapping , see for instance @xcite . here , we shall recall the following result . _ kellogg - warschawski s theorem . _
it can be found in @xcite or in ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 3.6 ) .
it asserts that if the conformal map @xmath125 has a continuous extension to @xmath126 which is of with @xmath127 and @xmath128 , then the boundary @xmath129 is a jordan curve of class @xmath130 next , we shall write down the equation governing the boundary of the doubly connected v - states . let @xmath35 be a doubly connected domain , that is , @xmath36 and @xmath37 are two simply connected domains with @xmath131
. denote by @xmath132 and @xmath133 their boundaries , respectively .
consider the parametrization by the conformal mapping : @xmath134 satisfying @xmath135 and @xmath136 now assume that @xmath137 is a rotating patch for the model then according to @xcite the boundary equations are given by @xmath138 where @xmath139 denotes a tangent vector to the boundary @xmath140 at the point @xmath141 we shall now rewrite the equations by using the conformal parametrizations @xmath142 and @xmath143 .
first remark that for @xmath144 a tangent vector on the boundary @xmath145 at the point @xmath146 is given by @xmath147 inserting this into the equation and using the change of variables @xmath148 give @xmath149 with @xmath150 and @xmath151 .
we shall introduce the functionals @xmath152 then equations of the v - states become , @xmath153 now it is easy to ascertain that the annulus is a rotating patch for any @xmath154 .
indeed , replacing @xmath142 and @xmath143 in by @xmath155 and @xmath156 , respectively , we get @xmath157 using the change of variables @xmath158 in the two preceding integrals we find @xmath159 note that each integral in the right side is real since , @xmath160,\quad\overline{\mathop{{\fint}}_\mathbb{t}\frac{d\zeta}{\vert 1-a\zeta\vert^\alpha } } & = & -\mathop{{\fint}}_\mathbb{t}\frac{d\overline{\zeta}}{\vert 1-a\overline{\zeta}\vert^\alpha}\\ & = & \mathop{{\fint}}_\mathbb{t}\frac{d\xi}{\vert 1-a\xi\vert^\alpha}\cdot\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore we obtain , @xmath161 arguing similarly for the second component @xmath162 we get for any @xmath163 @xmath164 which is the desired result .
in this section we shall recall in the first part some simple facts about hlder spaces on the unit circle @xmath105 . in the second part we state crandall - rabinowitz s theorem which is a crucial tool in the proof of theorem [ main ] .
we shall also recall some important properties of the hypergeometric functions which appear in a natural way in the spectral study of the linearized operator .
the last part is devoted to the computations of some integrals used later in the spectral study . throughout this chapter
it is more convenient to think of @xmath165-periodic function @xmath166 as a function of the complex variable @xmath167 . to be more precise ,
let @xmath168 , be a continuous function , then it can be assimilated to a @xmath169 periodic function @xmath170 via the relation @xmath171 hence when @xmath172 is smooth enough we get @xmath173 because @xmath174 and @xmath175 differ only by a smooth factor with modulus one we shall in the sequel work with @xmath174 instead of @xmath175 which appears more suitable in the computations .
+ moreover , if @xmath172 has real fourier coefficients and is of class @xmath176 then we can easily check that @xmath177 now we shall introduce hlder spaces on the unit circle @xmath105 . let @xmath178 .
we denote by @xmath179 the space of continuous functions @xmath172 such that @xmath180 for any integer @xmath181 , the space @xmath182 stands for the set of functions @xmath172 of class @xmath183 whose @xmath184th order derivatives are hlder continuous with exponent @xmath185 .
it is equipped with the usual norm , @xmath186 recall that the lipschitz semi - norm is defined by , @xmath187 now we list some classical properties that will be used later at many places . 1 . for @xmath1880,1[$ ] the space
@xmath182 is an algebra .
2 . for @xmath189 and @xmath190
we have the convolution law , @xmath191 we intend now to recall crandall - rabinowitz s theorem which is a basic tool of the bifurcation theory and will be useful in the proof of let @xmath192 be a continuous function with @xmath109 and @xmath110 being two banach spaces .
assume that @xmath193 for any @xmath194 belonging in a non empty interval @xmath195 whether close to a trivial solution @xmath196 we can find a branch of non trivial solutions of the equation @xmath197 is the main concern of the bifurcation theory .
if this happens we say that we have a bifurcation at the point @xmath196 .
we shall restrict ourselves here to the classical result of crandall and rabinowitz @xcite .
for more general results we refer the reader to the book of kielhfer @xcite .
[ c - r ] let @xmath198 be two banach spaces , @xmath52 a neighborhood of @xmath199 in @xmath109 and let @xmath200 with the following properties : 1 .
@xmath201 for any @xmath202 .
2 . the partial derivatives @xmath203 , @xmath204 and @xmath205 exist and are continuous .
3 . @xmath206 and @xmath207 are one - dimensional .
4 . _ transversality assumption _ : @xmath208 , where @xmath209 if @xmath210 is any complement of @xmath206 in @xmath109 , then there is a neighborhood @xmath211 of @xmath212 in @xmath213 , an interval @xmath214 , and continuous functions @xmath215 , @xmath216 such that @xmath217 , @xmath218 and @xmath219 we shall give a short introduction on the gauss hypergeometric functions and discuss some of their basic properties .
the formulae listed below will be crucial in the computations of the linearized operator associated to the v - states equations .
recall that for any real numbers @xmath220 the hypergeometric function @xmath221 is defined on the open unit disc @xmath104 by the power series @xmath222 here , @xmath223 is the pochhammer symbol defined by , @xmath224 it is obvious that @xmath225 for a future use we recall an integral representation of the hypergeometric function , for instance see @xcite .
assume that @xmath226 then @xmath227 the function @xmath228 refers to the gamma function which is the analytic continuation to the negative half plane of the usual gamma function defined on the positive by the integral representation : @xmath229 it satisfies the relation @xmath230 from this we deduce the identities @xmath231 provided all the quantities in the right terms are well - defined .
later we need the following values , @xmath232 another useful identity is the euler s reflection formula , @xmath233 now we shall introduce the digamma function which is nothing but the logarithmic derivative of the gamma function and often denoted by @xmath234 .
it is given by @xmath235 the following identity is classical , @xmath236 when @xmath237 then it can be shown that the hypergeometric series is absolutely convergent on the closed unit disc and one has the expression,@xmath238 the proof can be found in @xcite ,
now recall the kummer s quadratic transformation @xmath239 next we recall some contiguous function relations of the hypergeometric series , see @xcite .
@xmath240 @xmath241 @xmath242 @xmath243 @xmath244 @xmath245
@xmath246 now we close this discussion with recalling bessel function @xmath47 of the first kind of index @xmath127 and review some important identities .
it is defined in the full space @xmath247 by the power series @xmath248 the following identity called sonine - schafheitlin s formula will be very useful later .
@xmath249 provided that @xmath250 and that the integral is convergent .
a detailed proof of this result can be found in @xcite .
the main goal of this paragraph is to compute explicitly some integrals that will appear later in the spectral study .
[ lem ] let @xmath251 and @xmath127 .
then for any @xmath144 we have the following formulae : @xmath252 @xmath253\notag.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath254\notag.\qquad\qquad\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath255.\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath256.\notag\qquad\quad\end{aligned}\ ] ] to prove the first identity we use successively the change of variables @xmath257 @xmath258 again by the change of variables @xmath259 one gets @xmath260 since @xmath261 then we can use the taylor series @xmath262 consequently , we get @xmath263 we shall now recall the following identity , see for instance @xcite and @xcite , @xmath264 as it was pointed before the gamma function has no real zeros but simple poles located at @xmath265 and therefore the function @xmath266 admits an analytic continuation on @xmath267 apply this formula with @xmath268 and @xmath269 yields , @xmath270 hence , @xmath271 we shall use legendre s duplication formula , @xmath272 which gives @xmath273 therefore using the identity and @xmath274 we find @xmath275 from the elementary fact @xmath276 one deuces @xmath277 by definition of the hypergeometric series we conclude that @xmath278 using kummer s quadratic transformation the last identity becomes @xmath279 this completes the proof of .
we intend now to compute the second integral . to this end
we use the change of variables as before , @xmath280 where @xmath281 it follows from the identity that @xmath282.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , in view of the formula one gets @xmath283 replacing @xmath284 by its expression in we conclude that @xmath285.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we shall now compute the integral .
we write @xmath286 using the identity , @xmath287 can be rewritten as @xmath288 then , in view of the formula we get @xmath289 to compute @xmath290 we first observe that by the change of variables @xmath291 we find @xmath292 which yields in turn @xmath293 consequently , @xmath294 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] concerning the integral we use a change of variable as before in order to get @xmath295 with @xmath296 observe that @xmath297 then , it follows from the formula that @xmath298.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using once again the identity implies @xmath299 plugging the latter expression of @xmath300 into yields @xmath301.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we shall now move to the computation of the last integral , @xmath302 from the identity we may write @xmath303 therefore by the formula we obtain @xmath304 to compute @xmath305 we write through a change of variables , @xmath306 which implies in view of @xmath307 hence we find @xmath308\end{aligned}\ ] ] and therefore the proof of the lemma is now complete .
this section is devoted to the regularity study of the nonlinear functional @xmath309 introduced and which defines the v - states equations .
we shall check the regularity assumptions required by crandall - rabinowitz s theorem .
the computations are vey heavy and can be done in a straightforward way without new difficulties compared to the simply connected case treated in the paper @xcite .
many of the details may be found in that work and will not be reiterated here .
therefore for the sake of concise presentation we shall study the new terms involving the interaction between the boundaries . however , regarding the self - induced terms we only recall the results from the paper @xcite . to begin with ,
we introduce the function spaces that we shall use .
we set , @xmath310 with @xmath311 and @xmath312 for @xmath40 , let @xmath52 denote the product @xmath313 , where @xmath314 is the open ball of @xmath109 with center @xmath199 and radius @xmath315 .
we note that this choice is done in order to guarantee that @xmath316 and @xmath317 are conformal for @xmath318 and to prevent the intersection between the curves @xmath319 and @xmath320 which represent the boundaries of the v - states .
+ now recall from the form of the functional @xmath321 , @xmath322 where @xmath323 is defined by @xmath324 we shall rewrite @xmath325 as follows , @xmath326 with @xmath327 and @xmath328 usually with the notation @xmath316 , @xmath329 .
+ we propose to prove the following result concerning the regularity of @xmath330 [ reg ] the following holds true . 1 .
@xmath331 is well - defined .
@xmath331 is of class @xmath332 3 .
the partial derivative @xmath333 exists and is continuous .
notice that the terms @xmath334 appears modulo the sign of @xmath335 in the simply connected case discussed in the paper @xcite and all the computations were done there .
therefore we shall restrict ourselves to recalling just the results of those computations : 1 .
@xmath336 is well - defined .
@xmath336 is of class @xmath176 .
moreover the differential @xmath337 is given for @xmath338 by @xmath339\phi_j^\prime(\tau)}{\vert \phi_j(w)-\phi_j(\tau)\vert^{\alpha+2}}d\tau\bigg\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in addition , the partial derivative @xmath340 exists and is continuous .
it is given by the formula , @xmath341 if we prove the regularity properties for the second part @xmath342 then we can easily deduce that @xmath343 therefore all the regularity assumptions are satisfied for the terms @xmath344 and to complete the proof of the proposition we should check these assumptions for @xmath342 .
more precisely , we shall prove that @xmath345 is well - defined and is of class @xmath332 @xmath346 first , we shall prove that for @xmath347 we have @xmath348 . because the space @xmath349 is an algebra the problem reduces to show that for @xmath350 , the function @xmath351 belongs to @xmath349 .
this can be deduced easily from the next general result .
let @xmath352 and @xmath316 , @xmath329 and define the operator @xmath353 then @xmath354 the proof of this inequality will be done in a straightforward way since as we shall see the kernel is not singular .
this is due to the fact that the inner and the outer boundaries do not intersect .
indeed , for all @xmath355 we can write@xmath356 the same result remains true if we change @xmath357 by @xmath358 and therefore we get for @xmath350 @xmath359 it follows that @xmath360 which implies that @xmath361 next take @xmath362 . using the inequality gives @xmath363 where we have used in the last estimate the following inequality : for @xmath364 there exists a constant @xmath365 such that @xmath366 finally , using the fact that @xmath367 one can conclude that @xmath368 which is the desired result . now applying to the operator @xmath323 we get @xmath369 to complete the proof of the first point
we shall verify that the fourier coefficients of @xmath370 belong to @xmath371 . from the definition of the space @xmath372 in the mapping
@xmath373 has real fourier coefficients and thus the fourier coefficients of @xmath374 are real too . since this property is stable under the conjugation and the multiplication the problem reduces to prove that the fourier coefficients of @xmath375 are real .
for this last purpose , we take the conjugate and make a change of variables , @xmath376 this proves that the fourier coefficients of the functions @xmath377 are real and the proof of the first part @xmath378 is now achieved .
the strategy to get that @xmath379 is of class @xmath176 on @xmath52 consists first in checking the existence of its gteaux derivative .
second we show that the gteaux derivative is strongly continuous .
this will ensure in the same time the existence of frchet derivative and its continuity .
+ the gteaux derivative of the function @xmath379 at @xmath380 in the direction @xmath381 is given by the formula @xmath382+\lim_{t\to 0}\frac{1}{t}\big[n_{j}(f_1,f_2+th_2)-n_{j}(f_1,f_2)\big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the limits are taken in the strong topology of @xmath110 .
thus we shall first prove the existence of these limit in the pointwise sense , that is for every point @xmath383 and after check that these limits exist in the strong topology of @xmath349 .
let us first check for each point @xmath384 the existence of @xmath385 as a linear and bounded operator , that is , @xmath386 . with the notation @xmath316 and @xmath317
, one has @xmath387 we shall make use of the following identity : let @xmath388 , @xmath389 , @xmath390 and define the function @xmath391 which is smooth close to zero , then we have @xmath392 combining this formula with few easy computations yield @xmath393 \notag\\ \triangleq&-\frac{\alpha}{2}c_\alpha\big [ & & { \overline{h_j(w)}}{a}_{i}\big(\phi_j\big)(w)+{h_j(w)}{b}_{i}\big(\phi_j\big)(w)\big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , @xmath394\bigg\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the algebra structure of @xmath349 combined with the estimate , we get @xmath395 it remains to estimate the terms @xmath396 and @xmath397 .
for the first one , we get by virtue @xmath398 now let @xmath362 , then @xmath399 few easy computations show that @xmath400 concerning the last term we shall use the following inequality whose proof is classical.@xmath401 hence , we get @xmath402 inserting this in the estimate and using the inequality we find @xmath403 now by plugging the latter estimate into one gets @xmath404 which is the desired result .
the estimate of the term @xmath405 can be done in a similar way by observing that @xmath406 consequently , from we deduce that @xmath407 this means that @xmath408 let us now move to the computation of @xmath409 , for @xmath350 when @xmath352 and @xmath410 . from the definition ,
we obtain the formula @xmath411 some easy computations combined with the relation allow to get @xmath412 it follows that , @xmath413\bigg\}.\ ] ] since @xmath349 is an algebra one finds that @xmath414 the estimate of the term @xmath415 follows immediately from and we get , @xmath416 for the terms @xmath417 and @xmath418 we can proceed similarly as for @xmath419 and we find @xmath420 putting together the preceding estimates yields , @xmath421 this shows that @xmath422 to achieve the existence proof of the gteaux derivatives it remains to check that the convergence in occurs in the strong topology of @xmath423 there are many terms to analyze and they can be treated in a similar way .
the computations are straightforward but slightly long and we prefer just to treat a significant term and the remaining ones are quite similar .
for example in the first term of the right - hand side of we need to check @xmath424 to simplify the notation we set @xmath425let @xmath426 such that @xmath427 .
then by we have @xmath428 it follows from the inequalities and that @xmath429 which implies in turn , @xmath430 therefore we get @xmath431 now for @xmath432 , we write by the mean value theorem @xmath433 observe that @xmath434 can be rewritten in the integral form @xmath435 thus , @xmath436 in view of the formula we readily obtain @xmath437.\end{aligned}\ ] ] using straightforward computations combined with the inequality yield for any @xmath438,$ ] @xmath439 hence we get , @xmath440 this implies according to the estimate that @xmath441 and consequently , @xmath442 this concludes the desired result . the next task is to show that the gteaux derivatives are continuous operators from the neighborhood @xmath52 into the banach space @xmath443 .
from the identities and and since @xmath349 is an algebra the problem amounts to showing the continuity of the terms @xmath375 , @xmath444 , @xmath445 , @xmath446 , @xmath447 and @xmath448 .
we shall present here the complete details for the term @xmath375 , with @xmath350 and the other terms can be dealt via straightforward variations .
set @xmath449 with @xmath380 and @xmath450 .
we shall prove the estimate @xmath451 in view of we may write @xmath452 with @xmath453 the estimate of the last term in follows immediately from , that is , @xmath454 to control the remaining term we introduce the functional @xmath455 owing to the inequalities and one has @xmath456 now let @xmath362 , then we have @xmath457 in view of the derivative of @xmath458 with respect to @xmath358 is given by @xmath459 where @xmath460 we shall transform this quantity into , @xmath461 with @xmath462 @xmath463 and @xmath464 for the first and the second terms one readily gets by sobolev embeddings @xmath465 to estimate the last term we shall use the inequality combined with the estimate , @xmath466 and consequently , @xmath467 putting together and we find , @xmath468 therefore @xmath469 inserting this inequality into the estimate we get @xmath470 putting together the last estimate with the estimate , we obtain @xmath471 this concludes the proof of the proposition .
the main goal of this section is to perform a spectral study of the linearized operator of @xmath309 at the annular solution @xmath472 and denoted by the differential @xmath473 . in particular
, we shall identify the values @xmath22 for which the kernel of @xmath474 is not trivial leading to what we call the dispersion relation .
therefore the next step is to look among the `` nonlinear eigenvalues '' @xmath22 those corresponding to one - dimensional kernels which is an important assumption in crandall - rabinowitz s theorem .
this task is very complicate compared to the previous cases discussed in @xcite .
this is due to the multiple parameters @xmath475 and @xmath26 in this problem and especially to the nonlinear and implicit structure of the coefficients appearing in the dispersion relation
. we will be able to validate only a sufficient , but still a satisfactory result compared to euler equation , with a restriction on the symmetry of the v - states .
this will be deeply discussed in the subsection [ subsec12 ] devoted to the monotonicity of the eigenvalues .
we propose to compute explicitly the differential @xmath474 and show that it acts as a fourier multiplier . since @xmath321 then for given @xmath476 we have @xmath477 d_{f_1 } g_2(\omega,0,0)h_1+d_{f_2 } g_2(\omega,0,0)h_2 \end{pmatrix}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we recall the function spaces @xmath478 and @xmath479 putting together the formulas , and with @xmath480 and @xmath481 , where we replace @xmath142 by @xmath155 and @xmath143 by @xmath156 we get @xmath482 @xmath483 with @xmath484 @xmath485}{\vert w-\tau\vert^{\alpha+2}}d\tau\bigg\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath486d\tau}{\vert w - b\tau\vert^{\alpha+2}}\bigg\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath487}{\vert bw-\tau\vert^{\alpha+2}}d\tau\bigg\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we shall now compute the fourier series of the mapping @xmath488 with @xmath489 where @xmath490 and @xmath491 are real for all @xmath492 .
this is summarized in the following lemma .
[ lem0]let @xmath493 and @xmath40 .
we set @xmath494 and @xmath46 where @xmath47 refers to the bessel function of the first kind .
then , we have @xmath495 where the matrix @xmath79 is given for @xmath80 by @xmath496 the determinant of this matrix is given by @xmath497 first we shall compute @xmath498 . for this goal we start with calculating the term @xmath499 of the right - hand side of which is easy compared to the other terms .
thus by straightforward computations we obtain @xmath500 the computation of the second term @xmath501 was done in the paper @xcite dealing with the simply connected domain .
it is given by @xmath502 we shall later establish the identity which gives here @xmath503 to compute the term @xmath504 we first split it into two parts as follows , @xmath505 with @xmath506 and @xmath507 by using the fourier expansions of @xmath508 and @xmath509 we get , @xmath510 then by applying the formula with @xmath511 to the first term and the formula to the second term we find @xmath512\notag\\\triangleq & -\frac{\alpha}{2}b^2\sum_{n\geq 0}\big(\,a_n\gamma_n+&&c_n\delta_n\big)w^{n+1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used in the last equality the notation , @xmath513 and @xmath514 similarly , the second term @xmath515 may be written in the form , @xmath516 using the elementary fact @xmath517 combined with the formulas and we obtain @xmath518\notag\\ = & -\frac{\alpha } { 2}\sum_{n\geq 1}\overline{w}^{n+1}\bigg[&&a_nb^2\frac\alpha2f(\frac\alpha2 + 1,\frac\alpha2 + 1;2;b^2)\notag\\ & & & + c_n\frac{(1+\frac\alpha2)_{n-1}}{(n-1)!}b^{n}\bigg(f\big(\frac\alpha2,n+\frac\alpha2;n+1;b^2\big)-f\big(\frac\alpha2,n+\frac\alpha2;n;b^2\big)\bigg)\bigg].\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus owing to the formula applied with @xmath519 and @xmath520 one gets @xmath521 where @xmath522 and @xmath523 are defined by , @xmath524 and @xmath525 inserting the identities and into we find @xmath526.\end{aligned}\ ] ] to compute @xmath527 we shall use the formula which gives @xmath528 similarly we have @xmath529\end{aligned}\ ] ] and therefore using once again the identity we find @xmath530 consequently the fourier expansion of @xmath531 is described by the formula @xmath532\big(w^{n+1}-\overline{w}^{n+1}\big).\notag\end{aligned}\ ] ] by virtue of the identity we get @xmath533\big(w^{n+1}-\overline{w}^{n+1}\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally inserting , and into we find @xmath534\\ & \times \big(w^{n+1}-\overline{w}^{n+1}\big ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] next , we shall move to the computations of @xmath535 defined in .
the first two terms are done in the preceding step and therefore it remains just to compute the term @xmath536 .
it may be splitted into two terms , @xmath537 with @xmath538 and @xmath539 to compute the first term @xmath540 we write @xmath541 thus applying successively the formula to the first term with @xmath511 and the to the second one we get @xmath542\notag \\ = & -\frac{\alpha } { 2}\,\sum_{n\geq 1}\big(\,a_n&&\tilde{\gamma}_n+c_n\,\tilde{\delta}_n\,\big){w}^{n+1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath543 and @xmath544 as to the term @xmath545 we write @xmath546 owing to and using the formulae and , one gets @xmath547\notag\\ = & - \frac{\alpha } { 2}\sum_{n\geq 1}\big(a_n\tilde{\alpha}_n+c_n\tilde{\beta}_n\big)\overline{w}^{n+1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath548\ ] ] and @xmath549 now inserting the identities and into we find @xmath550\big(w^{n+1}-\overline{w}^{n+1}\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the foregoing expressions for @xmath551 and @xmath552 one may write , @xmath553\\ & = \,\,\frac{(1+\frac\alpha2)_{n-1}}{n!}b^{n}&&\bigg[b^2\frac{\frac\alpha2\big(\frac\alpha2+n\big)\big(\frac\alpha2 + 1+n\big)}{(n+2)(n+1)}f\big(1+\frac\alpha2,n+2+\frac\alpha2;n+3;b^2\big)\\ & & & - nf\big(\frac\alpha2,n+\frac\alpha2;n+1;b^2\big)-\frac\alpha2f\big(1+\frac\alpha2,n+\frac\alpha2;n+1;b^2\big)\bigg].\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence using the formula with @xmath554 and @xmath555 yields @xmath556.\end{aligned}\ ] ] applying the formula with @xmath519 and @xmath555 we get @xmath557 this implies , @xmath558 using the expressions of @xmath559 and @xmath560 combined with the identity applied with @xmath561 and @xmath562 we find the compact formula @xmath563 putting together the preceding identities allows to write @xmath564.\end{aligned}\ ] ] according to the identity we get @xmath565 finaly , inserting the preceding identity and the expressions and into one can readily verify that @xmath566\\ & \times \big(w^{n+1}-\overline{w}^{n+1}\big).\end{aligned}\ ] ] this concludes the proof of the lemma [ lem0 ] .
we shall collect some useful properties on the asymptotic behavior of the sequences @xmath567 and @xmath568 introduced in lemma [ lem0 ] .
the study is done with respect to the parameters @xmath5 and @xmath181 .
this is summarized in the next lemma .
[ lem1 ] let @xmath493 and @xmath40 .
then the following results hold true . 1 . for all @xmath569 , @xmath570 , @xmath571 .
moreover , @xmath572 is strictly increasing , @xmath573 is strictly increasing and @xmath574 is strictly decreasing .
2 . let @xmath575 , then @xmath576 and @xmath577 3 . for @xmath181 sufficiently large , @xmath578 @xmath579 4 .
the determinant of the matrix @xmath580 introduced in satisfies @xmath581 with @xmath582 and @xmath583 with @xmath185 denotes euler constant , @xmath584 is the sum of the series @xmath585 and @xmath586 is the riemann zeta function .
the assertion @xmath587 from the last lemma shows that the spectrum is continuous with respect to @xmath5 . in other words
, we have @xmath588 hence , by the change of variable @xmath589 we can see that @xmath590 is exactly the same matrix obtained in @xcite .
however , for @xmath12 the dispersion relation established in @xcite involves the following matrix @xmath591 this discrepancy with the matrix @xmath592 is due to the parametrization used in @xcite for the interior curve .
indeed , in that paper the perturbation of the interior curve is dilated by @xmath24 .
thus with our parametrization we should multiply the second column of @xmath593 by @xmath24 and the matrix @xmath593 becomes @xmath594 as we can easily see , this matrix has exactly the same determinant of the matrix @xmath592 and therefore we find the same dispersion relations .
let us now prove lemma [ lem1 ] . *
( 1 ) * to study the sign of @xmath595 we shall make use of sonine - schafheitlin s formula leading to the identity @xmath596 which is obviously positive for all @xmath597 .
+ let us now prove that the mapping @xmath598 is decreasing . for this end , we rewrite the hypergeometric series @xmath599 appearing in right - hand side of according to the identity , which yields @xmath600 from the relation we get @xmath601 therefore it is easily seen that @xmath602 is increasing and @xmath603 is decreasing .
this implies in turn that @xmath604 is increasing and thus it should be positive .
notice that these properties can be also proven from the series * ( 2 ) * passing to the limit in the formula defining @xmath605 when @xmath5 goes to one yields @xmath606 as to the second limit , we have @xmath607 since @xmath40 we can use the following identity , @xmath608 whose proof can be found for example in @xcite .
consequently , @xmath609 now to compute the limits of @xmath610 when @xmath5 goes to the values @xmath199 and @xmath71 we shall rewrite @xmath610 by using the identity in the form @xmath611.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this gives in view of the formula and , @xmath612 this expression coincides with the `` eigenvalues '' in the simply connected case , see @xcite .
it follows that , @xmath613 we note that these values coincide with the `` eigenvalues '' for euler equations in the simply connected case . to compute the second limit
, we shall introduce for a fixed @xmath181 the function @xmath614 therefore we obtain according to , and the relation @xmath615 @xmath616 by applying the logarithm function to @xmath617 and differentiating with respect to @xmath5 one obtains the relation @xmath618 now using the fact that @xmath619 combined with the preceding identity and , we find @xmath620 which is the desired result . *
( 3)-(4 ) * the asymptotic behavior of @xmath595 may be easily obtained from the integral formula .
the proof of was done in details in @xcite . finally , by combining , and
the expression of @xmath621 given by one can deduce the identity .
in this section we shall discuss some important properties concerning the monotonicity of the eigenvalues associated to the matrix @xmath622 already seen in lemma [ lem0 ] .
this will be crucial in the study of the kernel of the linearized operator @xmath474 . recall that @xmath623 the determinant of this matrix given by is a second order polynomial on the variable @xmath22 and therefore it has two roots depending on all the parameters @xmath624 and @xmath625 for our deal it is important to formulate sufficient conditions to avoid the eigenvalues crossing in order to guarantee a one - dimensional kernel which is an essential assumption in crandall - rabionwitz s theorem . in what follows
we shall use the variable @xmath626 instead of @xmath22 in the spirit of the work of @xcite .
thus easy computations show that the determinant takes the form , @xmath627 with @xmath628 and @xmath629\theta_n-4b^2\big(\lambda_1 ^ 2(b)-\lambda_n^2(b)\big)\\ - & 2\big(1-b^2\big)\lambda_1(b)+1\notag .
\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the quantities @xmath605 and @xmath610 have been introduced in lemma [ lem0 ] .
it is easy to check through straightforward computations that the reduced discriminant of the second order polynomial appearing in is given by @xmath630 our result reads as follows .
[ lem2c2 ] there exists @xmath631 such that the following holds true . 1 . for all
@xmath632 we get @xmath633 and the equation admits two different real solutions given by @xmath634 2 . the sequences @xmath635 and @xmath636 are strictly increasing and @xmath637 is strictly decreasing .
3 . for all
@xmath638 we have @xmath639 [ rmq1 ] 1 .
the number @xmath56 in @xmath587 of the previous proposition is the smallest integer satisfying , @xmath640 2 . in the known cases like the simply connected case with @xmath641 or the doubly connected case with @xmath11
the analysis is more easier because the dispersion relation is a kind of fractional polynomial but in the present case it is highly nonlinear with respect to the frequencies and the parameters @xmath5 and @xmath642 therefore the program is achieved with only a sufficient condition on the existence of the eigenvalue and which is given by .
this condition coincides with that given in @xcite for @xmath11 . *
( 1 ) * we intend to discuss the conditions leading to the positivity of the discriminant defined in which ensures in turn that the polynomial has two real solutions .
we can see that @xmath643 can be extended to a smooth function defined on @xmath644 as follows @xmath645 it is strictly positive if and only if @xmath646 or @xmath647 remark first that for @xmath648 and @xmath24 verifying the inequality we have @xmath649 . on other hand , from lemma [ lem1 ] one has : for all @xmath40 the mapping @xmath650 is strictly increasing , continuous and satisfying @xmath651 @xmath652 consequently the set @xmath653 is connected and takes the form @xmath6\beta,+\infty[$ ] , with @xmath654 e_b()=0 .
@xmath655 hence the integer @xmath56 is chosen as @xmath656.\ ] ] * ( 2 ) * to prove that @xmath657 is decreasing we shall compute its derivative with respect to @xmath648 .
pain computations give , @xmath658{\partial_x \theta_x}-8b^2\lambda_x(b){\partial_x \lambda_x(b)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath659 is decreasing , @xmath660 is increasing and @xmath661 ( see ( 1 ) from lemma [ lem1 ] ) then we deduce that @xmath662{\partial_x \theta_x}\\ & > 2(b^{-\alpha}+1)e_x(b){\partial_x \theta_x}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , for all @xmath663 we have @xmath664 this shows that @xmath665 is strictly increasing .
+ now , recall that @xmath666 using the fact that @xmath660 is increasing ( according to lemma [ lem1 ] ) combined with the increasing property of @xmath665 we get the desired result .
so it remains to establish that the mapping @xmath667 is strictly decreasing . for this aim
we calculate its derivative with respect to @xmath648 , @xmath668{\partial_x \theta_x}+4b^2{\partial_x \lambda_x(b)}\dfrac{\lambda_x(b)}{\sqrt{\delta_x}}\\ & < & & b^{-\alpha}\big[1-\frac{(b^{-\alpha}+1)\theta_x-\big(1+b^{2}\big)\lambda_1(b)}{\sqrt{\delta_x}}\big]\partial_x \theta_x\\ & & & -\big[1+\frac{(b^{-\alpha}+1)\theta_x-\big(1+b^{2}\big)\lambda_1(b)}{\sqrt{\delta_x}}\big]\partial_x \theta_x.\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used in the last inequality the decreasing property of the mapping @xmath659 and the fact that @xmath661 . now from the inequality @xmath669 and the expression of @xmath670 we deduce that @xmath671 this gives the desired result . *
( 3 ) * this follows easily from ( 2 ) and the obvious fact @xmath672
in this section we shall prove theorem [ main ] which is deeply related to the spectral study developed in the preceding section combined with crandall - rabinowitz s theorem . to construct
the function spaces where the bifurcation occurs we shall take into account the restriction to the high frequencies stated in proposition [ lem2c2 ] and include the @xmath26-fold symmetry of the v - states .
to proceed , fix @xmath673 and @xmath674 , where @xmath56 is defined in and remark [ rmq1 ] .
set , @xmath675 where @xmath676 is the space of the @xmath169periodic functions @xmath677 whose fourier series is given by @xmath678 this space is equipped with its usual norm .
we define the ball of radius @xmath679 by @xmath680 and we introduce the neighborhood of zero , @xmath681 the set @xmath682 is endowed with the induced topology of the product spaces .
+ take @xmath683 then the expansions of the associated conformal mappings @xmath684 outside the unit disc @xmath685 are given successively by @xmath686 and @xmath687 this structure provides the @xmath688fold symmetry of the associated boundaries @xmath319 and @xmath320 , via the relation @xmath689 for functions @xmath690 and @xmath691 with small size the boundaries can be seen as a small perturbation of the boundaries of the annulus @xmath692 set @xmath693 and define the product space @xmath694 by @xmath695 from proposition [ lem2c2 ] recall the definition of the eigenvalues @xmath696 and the associated angular velocities are @xmath697 with @xmath698 and @xmath699 note that @xmath700 and @xmath701 were introduced in lemma [ lem0 ] .
the v - states equations are described in and which we restate here : for @xmath67 , @xmath702 with @xmath703 now , to apply crandall - rabinowitz s theorem it suffices to show the following result .
[ prozq ] let @xmath56 be as in the part @xmath378 of proposition @xmath704 and @xmath705 and take @xmath706 . then , the following assertions hold true . 1 .
there exists @xmath707 such that @xmath708 is well - defined and of class @xmath176 .
the kernel of @xmath474 is one - dimensional and generated by @xmath709 3 .
the range of @xmath474 is closed and is of co - dimension one in @xmath694 .
transversality assumption : if @xmath22 is a simple eigenvalue @xmath710 then @xmath711 * ( 1 ) * compared to proposition [ reg ] we need just to check that @xmath321 preserves the @xmath688fold symmetry and maps @xmath712 into @xmath694 . for this end
, it is sufficient to check that for given @xmath713 , the coefficients of the fourier series of @xmath714 vanish at frequencies which are not integer multiple of @xmath26 .
this amounts to proving that , @xmath715 this property is obvious for the first term @xmath716 .
for the two last terms in the expression of @xmath717 it is enough to check the identity , @xmath718 with @xmath719 this follows easily by making the change of variables @xmath720 and from .
indeed , @xmath721 this concludes the proof of the following statement , @xmath722 we shall describe the kernel of the linear operator @xmath723 and show that it is one - dimensional .
let @xmath724 be two functions in @xmath725 such that @xmath726 recall from lemma [ lem0 ] the following expression , @xmath727 where the matrix @xmath79 is given for @xmath80 by @xmath728 now , if @xmath729 then @xmath730 thus , the kernel of @xmath474 is non trivial and it is one - dimensional if and only if @xmath731 this condition is ensured by the part @xmath378 of the proposition [ lem2c2 ] .
then , @xmath732 is in the kernel of @xmath733 if and only the fourier coefficients in the identity vanish , namely , @xmath734 hence , a generator of ker@xmath735 can be chosen as the pair of functions @xmath736 * ( 3 ) * we are going to show that for any @xmath737 the range @xmath738 coincides with the space of the functions @xmath739 such that @xmath740 where @xmath741 for all @xmath569 and there exists @xmath742 such that @xmath743 for the sake of simple notation we remove in this part the parameter @xmath5 from @xmath744 the range of operator @xmath474 is obviously included in the space defined above which is closed and of co - dimension @xmath71 in @xmath694 .
therefore it remains to check just the converse .
let @xmath745 and @xmath746 be two functions in @xmath349 with fourier series expansions as in and .
we shall prove that the equation @xmath747 admits a solution @xmath748 in the space @xmath749 where the fourier series expansions of these functions are given in .
then according to , the preceding equation is equivalent to @xmath750 for @xmath511 , the existence follows from the condition and therefore we shall only focus on @xmath751 owing to the sequences @xmath752 and @xmath753 are uniquely determined by the formulae @xmath754 by computing the matrix @xmath755 we deduce that for all @xmath756 @xmath757 and @xmath758 therefore the proof of @xmath759 amounts to showing that @xmath760 we shall develop the computations only for the first component and the second one can be done in a similar way .
we set @xmath761 and @xmath762 then in view of the function @xmath763 can be rewritten as follows @xmath764 with @xmath765 and @xmath766 two constants .
the kernels are defined by @xmath767 and @xmath768 the convolution is understood in the usual one : for two continuous functions @xmath769 we define @xmath770 assume for a while that @xmath771 belongs to @xmath772 .
then by virtue of the classical convolution law @xmath773 , it suffices to show that the kernels @xmath774 and @xmath775 belong to @xmath776 .
the second and the third kernels are easy to analyze because the series converge absolutely , @xmath777 similarly , owing to one has @xmath778 and therefore @xmath779 . note that to bound the series we have used the fact that the sequence @xmath780 does not vanish and converges to a strictly positive number @xmath781 defined it remains to show that @xmath782 . for this end we shall use the following estimate : for any @xmath783 latexmath:[\[\label{kern1 } which is true for all @xmath48 and for a proof we can see @xcite . now to complete the reasoning it remains to prove the preceding claim asserting that the function @xmath785 belongs to the space @xmath772 . to prove this we write in view of
, @xmath786 where @xmath39 and @xmath787 are two constants ( depending on @xmath26 ) and@xmath788 this allows to get @xmath789 then one may use the general decomposition : for @xmath790 @xmath791 which yields , @xmath792 since the sequence @xmath793 is bounded then by we obtain @xmath794 thus for @xmath795 large enough we get @xmath796 concerning the estimate of @xmath344 we shall restrict the analysis to @xmath797 and @xmath480 and the higher terms can be treated in a similar way .
we write @xmath798 using the cauchy - schwarz inequality we get @xmath799 by the embedding @xmath800 we conclude that @xmath801 it remains to prove that @xmath802 . for this end
, one needs first to check that we can differentiate the series term by term .
fix @xmath803 and define @xmath804 from cauchy - schwarz inequality we find @xmath805 hence , @xmath806 differentiating @xmath807 term by term one gets @xmath808 put @xmath809 then using the continuity of szeg protection : @xmath810 on hlder spaces @xmath349 for @xmath811 we may conclude that @xmath812 belongs to @xmath349 , ( for more details see for example @xcite ) . by virtue of a classical result on fourier series one
gets @xmath813 and consequently @xmath814 putting together and we deduce that @xmath815 is differentiable and @xmath816 this concludes that @xmath817 now , as before , we can easily get @xmath818 and we shall check that @xmath819 . arguing in a similar way to @xmath815
we can differentiate term by term the series defining @xmath344 leading to @xmath820 note that with the same kernels @xmath821 and @xmath822 as before one can write @xmath823 using the fact that @xmath812 belongs to @xmath349 and @xmath824 we obtain the desired result .
+ let @xmath825 be a simple eigenvalue associated to the frequencies @xmath26 and @xmath826 be the generator of the kernel @xmath474 defined in the part @xmath587 of proposition [ prozq ]
. we shall prove that @xmath827 with @xmath828 differentiating and with respect to @xmath22 we get @xmath829 and @xmath830 hence , @xmath831 this pair of functions is in the range of @xmath474 if and only if the vector @xmath832 is a scalar multiple of one column of the matrix @xmath833 seen in , which happens if and only if @xmath834 combining this equation with @xmath835 we get @xmath836 this yields @xmath837=0\ ] ] which is equivalent to @xmath838 this first possibility is excluded by because @xmath839 and the second one is also impossible because it corresponds to a multiple eigenvalue which is not the case here .
this concludes the proof of proposition [ prozq ] .
even if there is a number of references on the numerical obtention of rotating @xmath52-states for the vortex patch problem ( see for instance @xcite and @xcite , and more recently @xcite ) , up to our knowledge nothing similar has been done for the quasi - geostrophic problem .
therefore , for the sake of completeness , we will discuss in this section the numerical obtention of @xmath52-states for the quasi - geostrophic problem in both the simply - connected case and the doubly - connected case .
since the procedure is very similar to that in the vortex patch problem , we will omit some details , which can be consulted in @xcite .
we gather the main theoretical arguments from @xcite . given a simply - connected domain @xmath14 with boundary @xmath840 , where @xmath841 is the lagrangian parameter , and @xmath842 is counterclockwise parameterized , the contour dynamics equation for the quasi - geostrophic problem is @xmath843 we use a pseudo - spectral method to find @xmath26-fold @xmath52-states from .
we discretize @xmath841 in @xmath56 equally spaced nodes @xmath847 , @xmath848 .
observe that , although and are trivially equivalent , the addition of @xmath849 in the numerator cancels the singularity in the denominator ; indeed , @xmath850 where the mean radius is @xmath71 ; and we are imposing that @xmath854 , i.e. , we are looking for @xmath52-states symmetric with respect to the @xmath648-axis . for sampling purposes , @xmath56 has to be chosen such that @xmath855 ; additionally , it is convenient to take @xmath56 a multiple of @xmath26 , in order to be able to reduce the @xmath56-element discrete fourier transforms to @xmath856-element discrete fourier transforms . if we write @xmath857 , then @xmath858 . remark that , for any value of the parameters @xmath5 and @xmath22 , we have trivially @xmath863 , i.e. , the unit circumference is a solution of the problem .
therefore , the obtention of a simply - connected @xmath52-state is reduced to finding numerically a nontrivial root @xmath864 of .
to do so , we discretize the @xmath865-dimensional jacobian matrix @xmath866 of @xmath867 using first - order approximations .
fixed @xmath868 ( we have chosen @xmath869 ) , we have @xmath870 where @xmath874^{-1}$ ] denotes the inverse of the jacobian matrix at @xmath871 .
this iteration converges in a small number of steps to a nontrivial root for a large variety of initial data @xmath875 .
in particular , it is usually enough to perturb the unit circumference by assigning a small value to @xmath876 , and leave the other coefficients equal to zero .
our stopping criterion is @xmath877 where we have used a conformal mapping .
however , a caveat should be make here . indeed , unlike in the vortex patch problem , given a @xmath52-state @xmath882 , and @xmath883 , @xmath884
is no longer a @xmath52-state , but , from , @xmath885 is .
therefore , since we bifurcate from the unit circumference at a certain angular velocity @xmath886 , we always obtain , by uniqueness , the same @xmath52-states up to a scaling that implies also a modification on @xmath22 , irrespectively of the chosen numerical representation of @xmath842 .
an equivalent observation can be done for the doubly - connected case , etc .
given an @xmath22 slightly smaller than @xmath890 , it is straightforward to obtain the corresponding @xmath52-state with the technique described above .
then , we can use that @xmath52-state as a new initial datum to obtain another @xmath52-state with smaller @xmath22 , and so on .
however , it seems impossible to obtain numerically @xmath52-states for @xmath22 strictly larger than @xmath890 .
this means that the bifurcation is pitchfork and this fact follows from a symmetry argument : if @xmath891 is a solution of then @xmath892 is a solution too .
bearing in mind , we are able to obtain @xmath52-states for an arbitrary large number of symmetries @xmath26 . for instance , in figure [ f : vstate0holealpha0_5omegas ] , we have plotted simultaneously the @xmath52-states corresponding to @xmath893 , @xmath894 , for @xmath895 and @xmath896 . in all the numerical experiments in this section ,
we take @xmath897 nodes . since , according to , @xmath898 , the @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath895 , in black , is practically a circumference , as expected . on the other hand ,
the @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath899 is plotted in red .
observe that we have been unable to obtain the @xmath52-state corresponding to , say , @xmath900 ; this makes us wonder whether the @xmath52-state in red might be close from developing some kind of singularity .
it is an established fact that simply - connected limiting @xmath52-states do exist for @xmath901 , which corresponds to the vortex patch problem .
these @xmath52-states are obtained after bifurcating from the circumference at @xmath902 , which corresponds to evaluated at @xmath901 , and decreasing @xmath22 as much as possible , until corner - shaped singularities appear .
furthermore , it has been proved in @xcite that the angle at the corners is always @xmath903 , irrespectively of the number @xmath26 of symmetries .
therefore , we are interested in understanding what happens when @xmath904 . in figure
[ f : limitingvstates ] , we have plotted @xmath52-states corresponding to @xmath905 ; for the vortex patch problem , and for @xmath906 , @xmath893 , and @xmath907 ( i.e , a value of @xmath5 rather close to zero , an intermediate value , and a value rather close to one ) .
we have used the smallest possible ( four - digit ) values of @xmath22 , which are offered in table [ t : limitingomegas ] , in such a way that the experiments become numerically instable for smaller values of @xmath22 . in order to facilitate the comparison between different @xmath26 , we have plotted @xmath908 ) , rather than @xmath840 .
figure [ f : limitingvstates ] confirms graphically that the angles developed by the five limiting @xmath52-states in the vortex patch problem are identical . on the other hand , when @xmath906 , the @xmath52-states depicted are very similar to the limiting @xmath52-states in the vortex patch problem , whereas , for @xmath893 , and especially for @xmath907 , it is unclear whether any singularity has happened at all . in order to shed some light on this
, we have plotted in figure [ f : bifurcation ] the respective bifurcation diagrams of @xmath909 in with respect to @xmath22 . in the vortex patch problem
, we have a family of monotonic curves already shown in @xcite . when @xmath906 , the curves are very similar to those in the vortex patch problem , but slightly bigger and more spaced
. then , as @xmath5 grows , the curves become bigger and bigger , and more and more spaced . furthermore ,
when @xmath907 , the curves are partially superposed ; for example , there are 2-fold and 3-fold @xmath52-states with the same @xmath22 .
this phenomenon also happens in the last four curves , when @xmath893 . however , the most striking fact from figure [ f : bifurcation ] is that all the fifteen curves , corresponding to @xmath906 , @xmath893 and @xmath907 , lose monotonicity at their left ends .
in fact , especially for @xmath907 , incipient hooks are clearly visible .
this seems to suggest the presence of saddle - node bifurcation points ( see for instance @xcite ) at a certain @xmath910 , which is indeed the case , as we will show in the following lines .
we work with the bifurcation curve corresponding to @xmath907 and @xmath911 in figure [ f : bifurcation ] , because it has the most pronounced hook , but everything that follows is applicable to the other bifurcation curves as well .
we need to estimate the corresponding @xmath912 with enough accuracy . in our case , we have taken @xmath913 .
then , given @xmath914 ( we have taken here @xmath915 ) , we calculate the @xmath52-states corresponding to @xmath916 , @xmath917 , @xmath918 , @xmath919 , and @xmath920 , whose coefficients in are respectively denoted as @xmath921 , @xmath922 , @xmath923 , @xmath924 , and @xmath925 .
the main idea is to introduce a new parameter @xmath194 , instead of @xmath22 , in such a way that @xmath926 corresponds to @xmath927 , and so on .
we set @xmath928 , @xmath929^{1/2}$ ] , @xmath930^{1/2}$ ] , @xmath931^{1/2}$ ] , @xmath932^{1/2}$ ] .
therefore , our problem is reduced to finding the @xmath52-state corresponding to some @xmath194 slightly larger than @xmath933 ; and a fairly good initial guess for that @xmath52-state can be obtained by means of a four - degree lagrange interpolation polynomial .
more precisely , let us define @xmath934 remark that a couple of trials may be needed until a good choice of @xmath940 , and of @xmath194 is found , i.e. , values that enable us to continue the bifurcation curve , and not to come back to some already known @xmath52-state . in our case , we have chosen @xmath194 equal to @xmath933 plus the mean of the four previous increments of @xmath194 , i.e. , @xmath941 after applying this technique just once , we have successfully obtained a @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath942 , i.e. , a @xmath52-state beyond the critical point .
it may be useful ( and sometimes even convenient ) to iterate several times the procedure , after updating @xmath943 , @xmath944,@xmath945 , @xmath946 , and @xmath947 .
in fact , it can be even applied from the very beginning , to obtain all the bifurcation curves in [ f : bifurcation ] in their integrity , with an important spare of computational time . in figure [ f : bifurcation3updated ] , we plot on the left - hand side the completed bifurcation curve until @xmath948 ; the piece of curve beyond the saddle - node bifurcation point , absent in figure [ f : bifurcation ] , is shown in thicker stroke .
it is possible to still continue the bifurcation curve , although the results are to be taken with prudence , because higher spatial resolution is needed .
further numerical experiments , which include the use of alternative parameterizations of @xmath842 , would suggest the eventual formation of cusp - shaped singularities at the corners .
they would also suggest the presence of additional saddle - node bifurcation points , in such a way that the bifurcation curve in [ f : bifurcation3updated ] would show spiral - like structures at its ends .
nevertheless , since our results are still inconclusive , we postpone this challenging issue for the future . on the other hand , based on the previous pages and on additional numerical experiments that we have carried on , we conjecture the existence of saddle - node bifurcation points for all @xmath949 and for all @xmath887 .
however , as @xmath5 decreases , smaller and smaller structures are expected at the ends of the bifurcation curves , until @xmath901 , when they disappear . indeed , in the vortex patch problem ,
as mentioned above , the bifurcation curves are always monotonic .
we can not finish this section , without saying something about the case @xmath950 , which has a pretty different behavior and is interesting per se . in figure
[ f : vstate0holen2alpha0_01omegas ] , we have plotted 2-fold @xmath52-states for @xmath951 and different values of @xmath22 , starting from @xmath952 , which is close to @xmath953 , so the corresponding @xmath52-state , in black , is practically a unit circumference .
since @xmath5 is small , we might expect to have a similar behavior to that in the vortex patch problem , where the @xmath52-states tend to degenerate to a segment as @xmath22 decreases .
however , although this is true for @xmath22 close enough to @xmath954 , there is an instant when convexity is lost , and the @xmath52-states get a more and more pronounced @xmath955-shape , as @xmath22 decreases .
remark that @xmath22 can not be smaller than a certain value , which corresponds approximately to @xmath956 , and whose corresponding @xmath52-state is plotted in red .
let us mention that the situation is very similar for greater @xmath5 , even for those close to 1 . in figure
[ f : vstate0holen2alpha0_01omegas ] , the @xmath52-state in red seems to have developed no singularity .
again , insight into what is happening is given by the bifurcation curve of @xmath909 in with respect to @xmath22 , for @xmath951 , which is plotted in figure . in that figure
, we have also plotted the bifurcation curves for @xmath957 , being the four curves very similar to each other . as with @xmath949 ,
the bifurcation curves suggest the existence of saddle - node bifurcation points . to see whether this is indeed the case , we have used the previously described continuation method for @xmath951 , taking @xmath958 , and @xmath915 .
figure [ f : bifurcation2updated ] confirms our suspicions . on the left - hand side
, we plot the completed bifurcation curve until @xmath959 ; the piece of curve beyond the saddle - node bifurcation point , absent in figure [ f : bifurcation2 ] , is shown in thicker stroke .
remark that , unlike figure [ f : bifurcation3updated ] , a zoom is necessary in order for the hook to be appreciated . on the right - hand side ,
we plot the new @xmath52-state corresponding to a slightly larger @xmath22 , i.e. , @xmath960 ( and such that @xmath961 is unstable ) , with twice as many nodes , i.e , @xmath962 . apparently , a self - intersection has happened ,
although a powerful zoom shows that the distance between the two inner pieces of curve is approximately @xmath963 ; moreover , there are apparently enough nodes in that region , so it seems that we could decrease that distance even further , by increasing the eight decimal of @xmath22 , and so on . even if we rather think that a self - intersection will eventually occur ( see @xcite and @xcite for similar phenomena in the vortex patch problem ) , further study is required here . given a doubly - connected domain @xmath14 with outer boundary @xmath964 and inner boundary @xmath965 , where @xmath841 is the lagrangian parameter , and @xmath966 and @xmath967 are counterclockwise parameterized , the contour dynamics equations for the quasi - geostrophic problem are @xmath968 the doubly - connected domain @xmath14 is a @xmath52-state if and only if its boundaries satisfy the following equations : @xmath969 & = 0 , \\ \label{e : qgcondition2 } \operatorname{re}\bigg[\bigg(\omega z_2(\theta ) - \frac{c_\alpha}{2\pi i}\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{z_{1,\phi}(\phi)d\phi}{|z_1(\phi ) - z_2(\theta)|^\alpha } + \frac{c_\alpha}{2\pi i}\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{z_{2,\phi}(\phi)d\phi}{|z_2(\phi ) - z_2(\theta)|^\alpha}\bigg)\overline{z_{2,\theta}(\theta)}\bigg ] & = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] however , as we did in , it is convenient to rewrite them in the following equivalent form : @xmath970 = 0 , \\ \label{e : qgcondition2a } \operatorname{re}\bigg[\bigg(\omega z_2(\theta ) & - \frac{c_\alpha}{2\pi i}\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{z_{1,\phi}(\phi)d\phi}{|z_1(\phi ) - z_2(\theta)|^\alpha } \cr & + \frac{c_\alpha}{2\pi i}\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{(z_{2,\phi}(\phi ) - z_{2,\theta}(\theta))d\phi}{|z_2(\phi ) - z_2(\theta)|^\alpha}\bigg)\overline{z_{2,\theta}(\theta)}\bigg ] = 0.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we use again a pseudo - spectral method to find @xmath52-states .
we discretize @xmath841 in @xmath56 equally spaced nodes @xmath847 , @xmath848 . since @xmath966 and @xmath967 never intersect , the second integral in and the first integral in can be evaluated numerically with spectral accuracy at a node @xmath851 by means of the trapezoidal rule ; e.g. , @xmath971 in order to obtain doubly connected @xmath26-fold @xmath52-states , we approximate @xmath966 and @xmath967 as in : @xmath973 , \qquad z_2(\theta ) = e^{i\theta}\left[b + \sum_{k = 1}^m a_{2,k}\cos(m\,k\,\theta)\right],\ ] ] where @xmath841 , the mean outer and inner radii are respectively @xmath71 and @xmath24 ; and we are imposing that @xmath974 and @xmath975 , i.e. , we are looking for @xmath52-states symmetric with respect to the @xmath648-axis . again , if we choose @xmath56 of the form @xmath857 , then @xmath858 .
we introduce into - , and approximate the error in those equations by an @xmath859-term sine expansion : @xmath976 = \sum_{k = 1}^m b_{1,k}\sin(m\,k\,\theta ) , \\
\operatorname{re}\bigg[\bigg(\omega z_2(\theta ) & - \frac{c_\alpha}{2\pi i}\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{z_{1,\phi}(\phi)d\phi}{|z_1(\phi ) - z_2(\theta)|^\alpha } \cr & + \frac{c_\alpha}{2\pi
i}\int_0^{2\pi}\frac{(z_{2,\phi}(\phi ) - z_{2,\theta}(\theta))d\phi}{|z_2(\phi ) - z_2(\theta)|^\alpha}\bigg)\overline{z_{2,\theta}(\theta)}\bigg ] = \sum_{k = 1}^m b_{2,k}\sin(m\,k\,\theta ) .
\end{split}\ ] ] remark that , for any value of the parameters @xmath24 , @xmath5 and @xmath22 , we have trivially @xmath979 , i.e. , any circular annulus is a solution of the problem .
therefore , the obtention of a doubly - connected @xmath52-state is reduced to finding numerically @xmath980 and @xmath981 , such that @xmath982 is a nontrivial root of .
to do so , we discretize the @xmath983-dimensional jacobian matrix @xmath866 of @xmath984 as in , taking @xmath869 : @xmath985 then , the sine expansion of gives us the first row of @xmath866 , and so on .
hence , if the @xmath181-th iteration is denoted by @xmath986 , then the @xmath872-th iteration is given by @xmath987^{-1 } , \end{split}\ ] ] where @xmath874^{-1}$ ] denotes the inverse of the jacobian matrix at @xmath986 .
to make this iteration converge , it is usually enough to perturb the annulus by assigning a small value to @xmath988 or @xmath989 , and leave the other coefficients equal to zero .
our stopping criterion is @xmath990 where @xmath878 . as in the vortex patch problem , @xmath991 , so , for the sake of coherence , we change eventually the sign of all the coefficients @xmath980 and @xmath981 , in order that , without loss of generality , @xmath992 and @xmath993 .
as we have seen , the procedure to find doubly - connected @xmath26-fold @xmath52-states is very similar in the vortex patch and in the quasi - geostrophic problems .
however , as evidenced in the simply - connected case , the numerical study of the @xmath52-states for the quasi - geostrophic problem reveals itself as a much richer task .
indeed , unlike in the vortex patch problem , where we had just two parameters @xmath24 and @xmath22 , we have now a third parameter @xmath5 .
furthermore , since and are not homogeneous , choosing the mean outer radius not to be equal to one , as we are doing , would introduce a fourth parameter .
therefore , we will limit ourselves here to exposing a few relevant facts .
the hypergeometric function @xmath599 is commonly implemented in most scientific packages ; for instance , in matlab , @xmath997 can be evaluated by means of the command ` hypergeom([a , b ] , c , z ) ` , so we can find the only value @xmath994 satisfying efficiently and with the greatest possible accuracy , by means a simple bisection technique . in figure
[ f : alphab0 ] , we have plotted @xmath994 against 200 different values of @xmath5 , i.e. , @xmath998 , and @xmath999 . observe that @xmath994 tends very quickly to @xmath71 ; for example , @xmath1000 . on the other hand , @xmath1001 , which is coherent with the vortex patch problem , where there is no lower bound for @xmath24 .
however , we have discovered in our numerical experiments that is not sharp .
indeed , we have been able to find @xmath52-states with @xmath24 much smaller than @xmath994 . in all the numerical experiments in this section ,
we take @xmath1002 nodes . in figure [ f : vstate1holealpha0_9b0_2omegas ] , we have plotted @xmath52-states corresponding to @xmath907 and @xmath1003 , where @xmath1004 . on the left - hand side ,
we have started to bifurcate from @xmath1005 .
observe that @xmath967 is practically a circumference , for all @xmath22 .
moreover , the @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath1006 , in black , is practically a circular annulus , whereas the outer boundary of the @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath1007 , in red , has a marked star shape . for @xmath22
slightly smaller than @xmath1007 , the numerical experiments become instable . on the right - hand side , we have started to bifurcate from @xmath1008 .
the most remarkable fact is that @xmath22 is always negative , i.e , the @xmath52-states rotate clockwise , which is an important difference with respect to the vortex patch problem . on the other hand , @xmath966 is practically a circumference , for all @xmath22 .
the @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath1009 , in black , is practically a circular annulus , whereas the inner boundary of the @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath1010 , in red , has a marked star shape .
for @xmath22 slightly larger than @xmath1010 , the numerical experiments become instable .
figure [ f : vstate1holealpha0_9b0_2omegas ] shows the obvious parallelism with @xcite in the vortex patch problem : as @xmath24 becomes smaller , bifurcating at @xmath1011 yields doubly - connected @xmath52-states closer and closer to simply - connected @xmath52-states ; whereas , bifurcating at @xmath1012 yields double - connected @xmath52-states closer and closer to the unit circumference .
this explains why there are two bifurcation values of @xmath22 in the doubly - connected case , and just one single bifurcation value of @xmath22 in the simply - connected case . nonetheless ,
unlike what would have happened in the vortex patch problem , the @xmath52-states corresponding to @xmath1007 and to @xmath1010 seem to have developed no singularity .
again , as in the simply - connected case , the explanation is given by the loss of monotonicity in the bifurcation curves of @xmath1013 and @xmath1014 in with respect to @xmath22 , plotted in figure [ f : bifurcation1hole ] , which predicts the existence of saddle - node bifurcation points .
observe also that , when we bifurcate from @xmath1015 , @xmath1013 clearly dominates ; whereas , when we bifurcate from @xmath1016 , @xmath1017 dominates and @xmath1013 is of the order of @xmath1018 .
this confirms our previous observations . following the procedure explained in the simply - connected case ( where we set @xmath928 , @xmath1019^{1/2}$ ] , and so on ) ,
we have continued the bifurcation curves at @xmath1020 , and @xmath1021 , until @xmath1022 and @xmath1023 , respectively , as is shown in figure [ f : bifurcation1holeupdated ] .
it is still possible to go a bit further , but , in order not to lose accuracy , a larger number of nodes is convenient .
the pieces of curve beyond the saddle - node bifurcation points are shown in thicker stroke . in figure
[ f : vstate1holealpha0_9b_2 ] , we have plotted the @xmath52-states corresponding to @xmath1024 and @xmath1023 , but beyond the saddle - node bifurcation points . the differences with respect to the @xmath52-states in red from figure [ f : vstate1holealpha0_9b0_2omegas ]
are evident .
it would be interested to calculate which kind of limiting @xmath52-states develops .
finally , whether the lower bound restriction for @xmath24 can be ignored completely or not is another relevant question .
another relevant fact is the possibility to find examples where @xmath52-states exist for all @xmath1025 $ ] ; such situation was also found in the vortex patch problem .
we have considered , for instance , @xmath1026 , @xmath893 , and @xmath1027 , with @xmath1028 and @xmath1029 .
observe that @xmath1030 , so we are violating the restriction on @xmath994 again .
we have computed successfully all the @xmath52-states with @xmath1031 . on the left - hand side of figure
[ f : bifurcation1whole ] , we plot the @xmath52-states corresponding to @xmath1032 .
the @xmath52-state corresponding to @xmath1033 ( in red ) , and to @xmath1034 ( in black ) , are practically circular annuli ( we use no thicker stroke here , because all the @xmath52-states are very close to each other ) . on the right - hand side of figure
[ f : bifurcation1whole ] , we plot the bifurcation curves of @xmath1013 and @xmath1014 in , with respect to @xmath22 . as expected , the curves are closed ; however , the curve corresponding to @xmath1014 is much more symmetrical and reminds us of an ellipse .
let us finish this section by mentioning the existence of stationary doubly - connected @xmath52-states when @xmath904 , i.e. , @xmath52-states with @xmath1035 .
like the examples with @xmath1036 shown above , they have no particularity from a numerical point of view , yet they are a completely new phenomenon with respect to the vortex patch problem . to obtain them ,
it is necessary to choose @xmath26 , @xmath5 and @xmath24 , such that @xmath1037 , but @xmath1038 , since we bifurcate from the annulus at @xmath1039 .
we have chosen @xmath1026 and @xmath893 , as in the last experiment , but with a @xmath24 even smaller , @xmath1040 , in such a way that @xmath1041 .
figure [ f : stationary ] shows the corresponding stationary @xmath52-state .
francisco de la hoz was supported by the spanish ministry of economy and competitiveness , with the project mtm2011 - 24054 , and by the basque government , with the project it641 - 13 .
zineb hassainia and taoufik hmidi were partially supported by the anr project dyficolti anr-13-bs01 - 0003 - 01 .
99 m. h. p. ambaum , b. j. harvey , x. j. carton .
_ instability of shielded surface temperature vortices_. j. atmos .
68 ( 2010 ) 964971 .
m. h. p. ambaum and b. j. harvey , _
perturbed rankine vortices in surface quasi - geostrophic dynamics_. geophysical and astrophysical fluid dynamics , 105 ( 4 - 5 ) ( 2011 ) 377391 .
s. a. chaplygin , _ on a pulsating cylindrical vortex .
_ translated from the 1899 russian original by g. krichevets , edited by d. blackmore and with comments by v. v. meleshko .
chaotic dyn . 12 ( 2007 ) , no .
1 , 101116 .
chemin , _ fluides parfaits incompressibles _
, , astrisque 230 ( 1995 ) ; _ perfect incompressible fluids _ translated by i. gallagher and d. iftimie , oxford lecture series in mathematics and its applications , vol . 14 , clarendon press - oxford university press , new york ( 1998 ) . h.m .
wu , e.a .
overman ii and n.j .
steady - state solutions of the euler equations in two dimensions : rotating and translating v - states with limiting cases i. algorithms ans results _
, j. comput .
53 ( 1984 ) , 4271 . | in this paper , we prove the existence of doubly connected v - states for the generalized sqg equations with @xmath00,1[.$ ] they can be described by countable branches bifurcating from the annulus at some explicit `` eigenvalues '' related to bessel functions of the first kind .
contrary to euler equations @xcite , we find v - states rotating with positive and negative angular velocities . at the end of the paper
we discuss some numerical experiments concerning the limiting v - states . |
a large variety of molecules , including complex organic ones , have been detected in the galactic interstellar medium .
the hydroxyl ( oh ) radical is quite abundant in the galactic plane and has several rotational transitions that are easily observed at microwave frequencies .
these lines are found to originate from thermal processes as well as non - thermal processes ( i.e. maser emission ) .
thermal emission from oh radical was first detected in 1963 ( weinreb et al . 1963 ) .
the thermal lines are observed from extended regions in the galactic plane . on the other hand , maser emission from oh radical
is associated with specific activities in the galaxy .
for instance , oh masers from the ground state rotational transitions with frequencies 1665 and 1667 mhz are mostly associated with star - forming regions , 1612 mhz masers are associated with evolved stars ( elitzur 1992 ; reid & moran 1981 ) and the 1720 mhz masers are associated with shocked regions at the boundaries where supernova remnants interact with molecular clouds ( wardle & yusuf - zadeh 2002 ) . modeling the line emission provides an understanding of the physical conditions and processes that occur in the galactic interstellar medium where oh lines originate . despite the large amount of observational data available and considerable theoretical effort , a clear understanding of the pumping mechanisms that lead to different inversions in oh masers is lacking ( elitzur 1976 , cesaroni & walmsley 1990 ) .
in addition to the microwave lines , the oh radical also has transitions in the meter - wave .
these lines are produced due to transitions between hyperfine levels in the same @xmath3 doublet states ( see section [ sec : ohline ] ) .
the frequencies of these transitions in the ground rotational state are 53 and 55 mhz .
these lines , which have not been observed so far , are expected to have weak line intensities because they are magnetic dipole transitions .
moreover , observations are further complicated due to excessive man - made radio frequency interference ( rfi ) near the line frequencies .
it is owing to severe rfi at this frequency , along with the weak nature of these lines , that attempts to detect these lines were not made earlier ( turner , b. e. personal communication ) . as discussed above , in a variety of astrophysical situations ,
maser emission is observed from the microwave transitions .
therefore , the possibility of maser emission of meter - wave transitions can not be ruled out and may be strong enough to be detected .
the detection of these lines could provide clues to resolve , for example , the pumping mechanism of oh masers observed at microwave frequencies . in this paper
, we present an attempt to detect the 53 mhz oh line by observing with the national mst radar facility ( nmrf ) at gadanki , india , in the receiving mode of the antenna . a brief discussion of the 53 mhz oh line emission is given in section [ sec : ohline ] .
we describe the observing setup and strategy in section [ sec : obs ] and discuss the data analysis in section [ sec : dat ] .
results of the oh line observations are presented in section [ sec : res ] .
in addition to the oh line , carbon recombination lines ( rls ) were also present within the observing band .
the results of the rl observations are also included in section [ sec : res ] .
our conclusion and prospects for future observations are given in section [ sec : con ] .
the energy diagram for the ground state rotational transitions of the oh molecule is shown in fig . [
fig : eng ] .
the rotational ladder of oh is split into @xmath4 and @xmath5 ladders because of the spin - orbit coupling of a single unpaired electron in a 2p orbital on the o atom .
here we consider the ground rotational state , characterized by @xmath6 .
this state is split into two levels as a result of the small difference in moment of inertia when the electron orbital is parallel or perpendicular to the molecule s rotation axis ( @xmath3 doubling ) and further split by the hyperfine interaction between the electron spin and the spin of the proton in the h atom .
the microwave lines of oh at frequencies 1612 , 1665 , 1667 and 1720 mhz arise from transitions between these four @xmath3 doubling states , i.e. , @xmath6 , @xmath7 , where + and @xmath0 indicate the higher and lower @xmath3 doublet states .
( see fig .
[ fig : eng ] ) .
the two magnetic dipole transitions from quantum states @xmath8 and @xmath9 have frequencies near 55 and 53 mhz respectively .
we estimate the thermal line intensity from a cloud with oh column density in the range 10@xmath10 to 10@xmath11 @xmath12 and a typical kinetic temperature of 100 k ( weinreb et al .
1963 , elitzur 1976 , lockett et al .
the line optical depth is estimated using the einstein a coefficient for the 53 mhz transition of @xmath13 10@xmath14 s@xmath15 , the rotational constant of 18.51 cm@xmath15 and considering a typical oh line width of 5 km s@xmath15 ( weaver 1963 , destombes et al .
1977 , turner 1979 ) .
a mean galactic background temperature of 25000 k at 53 mhz is used for the calculation .
this background temperature is obtained by scaling the measured temperature at 34.5 mhz using a spectral index of @xmath02.7 ( dwarakanath & udaya shankar 1990 , salter & brown 1988 ) the expected line brightness temperature is 10@xmath17 and 1 k for column densities 10@xmath10 and 10@xmath11 @xmath12 respectively . due to the high galactic background near 53 mhz ( which dominates the system temperature )
it is not possible to detect the thermal oh line in a reasonable observing time .
however , there exists a possibility of maser emission of the meter - wave transitions ( turner , b. e. personal communication ) . to our knowledge
, there have been no attempts to calculate the line strengths of these maser lines .
we decided to search for 53 mhz maser emission towards direction where oh microwave masers ( as well as thermal lines ) were detected earlier .
the observations presented in this paper are made with the national mst radar facility located at gadanki in andhra pradesh , india ( 13@xmath18@xmath19 @xmath20 , 79@xmath18@xmath21 @xmath22 ) . in this section ,
we briefly describe the radar facility , the back - end used for the observations and the selection of sources for observation . a simplified block diagram of the receiver system of the mst radar facility is shown in fig .
[ fig : mst ] ( see rao et al .
1995 for details ) .
the antenna used for transmission and reception of radar signals is a phased array with 1024 crossed yagi elements , placed in a 32 x 32 matrix .
the array is spread out over an area of 130 m x 130 m and has an effective aperture of @xmath23 m@xmath24 .
the antenna and receiver system are tuned to operate at a center frequency of 53 mhz with a bandwidth of @xmath13 2 mhz .
the two crossed yagi elements , corresponding to the two orthogonal linear polarizations , are oriented along the east - west ( e - w ) and north - south ( n - s ) directions .
the signals from the elements are combined to form beams that can be pointed in steps of 1@xmath18 to a maximum of 20@xmath18 from the zenith along e - w and n - s directions .
the e - w beams are formed in the following way .
the signals of 32 n - s yagi elements , which form a linear sub - array , are combined using passive directional couplers .
such a sub - array is also called a module .
the output of 32 such modules are amplified using low - noise amplifiers and down converted to 5 mhz intermediate frequency ( if ) using a local oscillator ( lo ) of frequency 48 mhz .
these if outputs are combined with appropriate phase gradients to form the e - w beams .
the phase - shifters are placed in the lo path as shown in fig .
[ fig : mst ] .
signals from the yagi elements oriented in the e - w direction are combined in a similar fashion to form the n - s beams .
the half power beam width of the antenna is @xmath133@xmath18 .
the e - w beams can be pointed in steps of 1@xmath18 to a maximum of 20@xmath18 from the zenith . for our observations
, we used the different e - w beams to track the celestial source .
note that the mst array is oriented to the geomagnetic meridian which is oriented 2@xmath18due west with reference to the geographic meridian at gadanki .
this orientation of the array along with the location of the facility at a latitude of @[email protected] makes the source move away from the beam centre while tracking the source using the e - w beams ( see section .
[ sec : obs : strat ] for further discussion ) . the portable pulsar receiver ( ppr ; deshpande et al .
2004 ) developed at the raman research institute was used as the backend for the observations .
the block diagram of the ppr is shown in fig . [
fig : ppr ] . the 5 mhz
if from the radar receiver is mixed with a local oscillator of frequency 15.7 mhz to obtain a second if at 10.7 mhz .
the local oscillator is generated using a synthesizer in the ppr and its frequency can be programmed from the computer used for data acquisition .
the bandwidth of the second if is restricted to @xmath131.3 mhz using a bandpass filter centred at 10.7 mhz .
the if signal is bandpass sampled at 3.3 mhz and converted to 2-bit , 4-level data .
a bit - packing logic then packs consecutive samples into 16-bit words .
this data is acquired and stored using a personal computer .
a marker is also inserted after 4096 data words to identify any loss of samples while analysing data .
the ppr has another synthesizer which we used to generate the first local oscillator signal ( see below ) .
both the synthesizers are locked to a rubidium oscillator .
the existing data acquisition software for the ppr was modified to incorporate a dual - dicke frequency switching scheme for bandpass calibration .
we switched the first local oscillator ( lo1 ) between 47.8948 mhz and 48.0 mhz .
the values of the frequencies were selected so that the 53 mhz line of oh and five rl of carbon be within the @xmath131.3 mhz bandwidth used for observations . the difference between the two frequencies
was chosen based on the expected line width of the rl .
the modified data acquisition software sets the first local oscillator frequency and acquires 640 kbytes of data corresponding to each frequency setting after allowing for settling time of a few msec .
this amount of data will be acquired in about a sec .
thus the frequency switching takes place at 1 sec rate .
the candidate sources towards which the 53 mhz oh line emission is expected are mostly in the galactic plane .
the long integration required for our observations can be obtained if the antenna could track the celestial source .
however , the mst radar facility in its current configuration does not permit tracking of celestial sources .
we adopted a strategy of observing a position in the galactic plane with the different east - west beams of the antenna , thus effectively tracking the position for about 40@xmath18(see section [ sec : obs : mst ] ) .
this position corresponds to the galactic co - ordinates @xmath25 [email protected] and @[email protected] ( ra(2000 ) = 19h25m33.0s , dec(2000 ) = @xmath27@xmath18 06@xmath28 35.2@xmath29 ) .
note that [email protected] is the only position in the inner galaxy that can be tracked for 40@xmath18 in this mode using the present configuration of the mst radar .
microwave masers of oh have been detected within the @xmath30 beam area ( @xmath13 4@xmath18 ; see below ) of the observation centered at [email protected] ( see table [ tab1 ] ) .
most of these masers are associated with the star forming region w51 ( gaume & mutel 1987 ) .
all the four oh lines were detected from this region and typically the main lines ( 1665 & 1667 mhz ) are seen to be bright in emission .
anomalous 1720 mhz oh maser emission associated with shocked molecular gas adjacent to the supernova remnant [email protected] was also present within the beam area ( frail et al.1996 ) .
moreover , roshi & anantharamaiah ( 2000 ) have detected carbon rls towards g50 + 0.0 with a beam of 2@xmath18 .
thus we decided to observe the direction [email protected] with the mst radar facility .
the direction [email protected] was observed in a total of 13 east - west beams separated by the half - power beam - width of 3@xmath18 , resulting in an integration time of approximately 2.5 hours on each observing run . as discussed in section [ sec : obs : mst ] , in this mode of observation , the sky position shifts from the beam center by about @[email protected] in ra and @[email protected] in dec .
thus the effective area observed will be [email protected] @xmath32 [email protected] centered at [email protected] .
as discussed earlier rfi is a major factor in determining the success of observations at this frequency . to minimize man - made interference , observations were to be made during night time
[email protected] could be observed at night with the mst radar during july - august .
we conducted our observations from 30 july to 02 august 2003 between 21:30 and 00:30 hours local time .
while observing , we radiated a tone at frequency 52.6 mhz to make sure that the receiver and data acquisition system were functioning as expected and to confirm that the frequency switching was taking place as desired .
the radiated frequency was chosen to lie outside the frequency range where the oh line and the rls are expected .
.oh maser and rl sources within 4@xmath18 of [email protected] . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ]
we developed software in c / c++ and aips++ ( astronomical image processing system ) to reduce the data .
the data analysis starts with the extraction of the marker , which is inserted along with the data , to check for any loss of data .
if a loss of data was detected , the 2 @xmath32 640 kbytes of data corresponding to the two frequency settings were discarded .
the 2-bit quantized data are then assigned voltage values of @xmath03 , @xmath01 , @xmath331 or @xmath333 as recommended from the hardware specification of the ppr .
a 4096 point fft of these voltages is taken to obtain a 2048 point power spectrum .
the frequency resolution of the spectrum is 807.5 hz which corresponds to @xmath13 4.6 kms@xmath15 .
these power spectra were averaged for about 1 sec .
the spectra obtained when lo1 was set to 47.8948 mhz ( @xmath34 ) and those obtained with 48.0 mhz ( @xmath35 ) were averaged separately .
both averaged spectra were carefully examined for interference . spectra badly affected by interference were discarded .
spectra showing interference in a few channels were edited using a channel weighting scheme . in this scheme ,
the channels affected by interference were given a weight of zero ( roshi & anantharamaiah 2000 ) .
the bandpass calibrated spectra were obtained as @xmath36 . the calibrated spectrum along with the channel weights were weighted averaged to obtain the final spectrum .
this method resulted in slightly different integration times for each channel .
the maximum difference in integration time in the final spectrum was less than 10 percent .
an average spectrum for each day s observation was obtained without shifting the spectra in velocity since the correction for the antenna motion relative to the local standard of rest ( lsr ) during one observing run ( @xmath13 2.5 hours ) was less than the spectral resolution . in the frequency switching scheme ( double - dicke frequency switching )
used for observations , the expected lines are present at two spectral ranges in the calibrated spectrum separated by 105.2 khz .
the average spectrum is obtained by folding these two frequency ranges .
the four such spectra obtained from each day s observing run were then averaged after applying the required correction for the lsr motion of the antenna to get the final spectrum . during data analysis
, we found that most of the interference was internal to the mst radar .
these interference were caused by oscillations from some of the front - end amplifiers . on some occasions ,
the interference was so pronounced that some of the modules of the radar antenna had to be turned off .
there was some interference due to lightning on most days .
external man made rfi was seen to be very low .
the final spectra are in units of @xmath37 , where @xmath38 is the line antenna temperature and @xmath39 is the system temperature .
the system temperature is estimated as follows . the sky background radiation (= 26930 k ) towards the observed position
is obtained after scaling the measured values at 34.5 mhz and using a spectral index of @xmath02.7 ( dwarakanath & udaya shankar 1990 , salter & brown 1988 ) .
the measured receiver temperature of the radar facility is @xmath13 4630k ( damle et al .
thus the total system temperature is @xmath13 31560 k. during our observations interference due to lighting was present , which would have increased the system temperature .
however , this increase in system temperature is not significant since the duration of data affected by lightning is less than a few percent of the total observing time .
the line antenna temperatures obtained from the spectra are converted to units of flux density @xmath40 using the equation @xmath41 , where @xmath42 is the effective area of the antenna .
taking into account the fact that some of the modules were turned off during the observations ( see section [ sec : dat ] ) , we estimated @xmath42 is @xmath13 9060 m@xmath24 .
this effective area is consistent with that obtained from the calibration observation done on virgo a ( 3c274 ) .
the rest frequency of the oh line is 53.1595 mhz . the final spectrum obtained near this frequency range is shown in fig .
[ fig : ohspec ] .
no line was detected to a 3@xmath1 level of 4 @xmath43 in units of @xmath37 .
this corresponds to an upper limit on flux of 39 jy . assuming a typical angular size of @xmath13 100 mas for oh maser emission ( hoffman et al .
2003 ) , the brightness temperature of 53 mhz oh maser line is @xmath44 2 @xmath32 10@xmath45 k. comparing this temperature with the estimated thermal line temperature ( see section [ sec : ohline ] ) , we rule out maser amplification factor @xmath46 a few times 10@xmath45 . five recombination lines of carbon are present within the observed bandwidth ( see fig . [
fig : freqs ] ) .
they are the c501@xmath47(52.1576 mhz ) , c500@xmath47 ( 52.4709 mhz ) , c499@xmath47 ( 52.7867 mhz ) , c498@xmath47 ( 53.1050 mhz ) and c497@xmath47 ( 53.4259 mhz ) transitions . to improve the signal to noise ratio , we averaged the spectral values over the frequency range where these lines are expected . the final spectrum thus obtained is shown in fig .
[ fig : rrl ] .
no line feature was detected to a 3 @xmath1 level of 2 @xmath32 @xmath48 in units of @xmath37 , which corresponds to an upper limit on the flux density of 20 jy .
extensive surveys of carbon rls from the galactic plane have been made earlier near 34.5 and 327 mhz ( kantharia & anantharamaiah 2001 , roshi & anantharamaiah 2000 ) .
these observations were used to determine the physical properties of the carbon line forming region .
partially ionized regions with electron temperature between 20 300 k , electron densities in the range 0.03 0.3 @xmath2 and path lengths between 0.1 170 pc can produce the observed carbon rl intensity at different frequencies ( kantharia & anantharamaiah 2001 ) . the observations at 53 mhz towards [email protected] along with data at other frequencies can be used to constrain the physical properties of the carbon line forming region in this direction .
carbon rl was detected at 327 mhz towards [email protected] with a 2@xmath18 beam .
line was not detected towards g47.8 + 0.0 at 327 mhz implying that the line forming region is less than 4@xmath18 in extent .
the observation towards [email protected] has about 1@xmath18 overlap with the region observed at 53 mhz .
no rl was detected at 34.5 mhz towards g50.0 + 0.0 .
this observation has an angular resolution of 21@xmath32 25@xmath18 . combining these data
, we found that carbon line forming region with physical properties in the range determined by kantharia & anantharamaiah ( 2001 ) is consistent with all the three observations .
observations with similar angular resolutions are needed to better constrain the physical properties .
in this paper , we have presented observations made near 53 mhz with the aim of detecting the 53.2 mhz transition of the oh radical .
this oh line is due to the transition between the hyperfine levels in the same @xmath3 doublet state of lowest energy .
the observations were conducted using the national mst radar facility at gadanki .
no oh line was detected to a 3@xmath1 upper limit of 39 jy . within the observed bandwidth ,
five carbon rls were present .
we have not detected the carbon lines to a 3@xmath1 limit of 20 jy .
external man - made interference is low at gadanki , which is very encouraging for future attempts to search for the oh line in other positions in the galactic plane .
however , currently , a major limitation is the lack of tracking facility for the mst radar antenna .
a tracking facility would allow us to search for oh line at other positions in the galactic plane in a reasonable observing time .
we gratefully acknowledge the help of s. gurushant of raman research institute for helping us set up the ppr as well as for his help with the observations .
we thank prof .
n. udaya shankar for extending the help of the radio astronomy lab at rri for this project .
we are grateful to t. prabu , c. vinutha , b. s. girish and h. n. nagaraj of raman research institute , bangalore for their valuable help in setting up the ppr for our observations .
the ppr was developed by prof .
a. a. deshpande and team at rri .
we are thankful for discussions with prof .
a. a. deshpande that led to the initiation of this project .
we are indebted to g. sarabagopalan of rri for his generous help in contacting nmrf and in planning the observations .
we are extremely grateful to prof .
d. narayana rao , director , nmrf for speedy approval of our observing proposal .
his enthusiastic support was instrumental in the efficient conduct of this project .
it is a pleasure to thank s. kalesha , s. babu and all the staff at nmrf , gadanki for their help with the observations and a memorable stay at gadanki .
smm and dar are grateful to nmrf for providing the observing time at the mst radar and hospitality .
smm wishes to thank rri for hospitality as well as use of resources during the conduct of this project .
he also wishes to thank sudhakara g. , r. samanth , m. raghuprem and p. c. madhuraj of manipal institute of technology , manipal for taking over some academic responsibilities so that the entire vacation could be devoted to this project .
we thank the anonymous referee for his helpful suggestions for the continuation of the work presented in the paper . | we present the results of a search for the ground state hyperfine transition of the oh radical near 53 mhz using the national mst radar facility at gadanki , india .
the observed position was [email protected] near the galactic plane .
the oh line is not detected .
we place a 3@xmath1 upper limit for the line flux density at 39 jy from our observations .
we also did not detect recombination lines ( rls ) of carbon , which were within the frequency range of our observations .
the 3@xmath1 upper limit of 20 jy obtained for the flux density of carbon rl , along with observations at 34.5 and 327 mhz are used to constrain the physical properties of the line forming region .
our upper limit is consistent with the line emission expected from a partially ionized region with electron temperature , density and path lengths in the range 20 300 k , 0.03 0.3 @xmath2 and 0.1 170 pc respectively ( kantharia & anantharamaiah 2001 ) .
[ firstpage ] ism : general ism : lines and bands
ism : molecules radio lines : ism radio lines : general galaxy : general . |
in recent years , diamond as a possible material for particle detectors has been the subject of considerable interest @xcite .
significant progress in the techniques to produce synthetical diamond films of very high quality has been achieved by means of the chemical vapour deposition method ( cvd ) .
a number of commercial manufactures of cvd diamond films @xcite and research institutes @xcite have made systematic studies of the properties of this material feasible .
the main advantage of the material compared to other semiconductor detector materials is its radiation hardness , which has recently been demonstrated to neutron fluences of up to @xmath0@xcite .
the radiation hardness of the material is of strong interest for the detector development at projected experiments where high radiation levels are expected due to the increasing luminosity and energy , as e.g. the experiments at the large hadron collider at cern .
the main problem of using cvd diamond as a detector material are the charge collection properties , since an application as a detector for ionising particles requires that the material response is homogeneous throughout the volume and that a sufficient fraction of the produced charge is collected .
general studies of the cvd diamond growth conditions for detector applications with a large sample are presented in @xcite . in this paper
we present different studies of the charge collection properties of cvd diamond films .
we investigate both the bulk properties of the material and the behaviour of charge produced close to the surface .
one of the aspects which make cvd diamond films an attractive material for the detector development is its very high specific resistivity of @xmath1 .
this allows a very simple construction of a detector as a solid state ionisation chamber ( see fig .
[ fig - detector ] ) . by contacting the material on opposite sides and applying a sufficient potential across the contacts , charges produced in the bulk of the material by an incident charged
particle start to drift towards the electrodes and induce mirror charges .
the ratio of the amount of charge measured , @xmath2 , to the amount of charge produced , @xmath3 , is the collection efficiency @xmath4.\ ] ] the efficiency is below 100% , if trap- or recombination - sites in the material hinder the charge carriers to reach the electrodes , as is the case for diamond .
the mean free path length @xmath5 , also called schubweg @xcite , for each type of charge carriers ( @xmath6 for electrons and holes ) can be expressed as the product of the mobility @xmath7 , the electric field strength @xmath8 and the life - time @xmath9 , as @xmath10 the combined mean free paths of electrons and holes , @xmath11 is the mean distance a hole and an electron can separate .
this distance is referred to as the collection distance @xcite .
the collection distance and the efficiency @xmath12 are related according to ramo s theorem @xcite by @xmath13 with @xmath14 being the detector thickness .
the above discussion holds for uniform ionisation within the detector volume and @xmath15 .
if the charge is created in the vicinity of one electrode ( @xmath16 , with @xmath17 the distance of the charge to the electrode ) the van hecht - equation @xcite relates @xmath12 and @xmath5 as @xmath18 where @xmath19 denotes the schubweg for electrons and holes respectively , depen- + ding on the direction of the electrical field . throughout this paper
, we will use the quantity @xmath12 because the definition of @xmath12 involves fewer assumptions than the charge collection distance .
however , the values are given in collection distance as well where appropriate .
systematic studies of the dependence of @xmath12 on growth parameters have shown that high values of @xmath12 are reached for films produced with slow growth rates @xcite . until now charge collection efficiencies of up to 38% @xcite have been reported .
it is known that the exposure of diamond to ionising radiation and uv - light can substantially increase @xmath12 .
this phenomenon is called priming @xcite .
the passivation of traps by occupation with free charge carriers is the reason for the observed behaviour .
the same mechanism leads to a deterioriation of the signal as for example seen when irradiating diamond with alpha particles or protons at energies corresponding to stopping ranges of a few micron .
the deterioriation is caused by the build - up of space charge and the resulting compensation of the applied field @xcite .
another important issue is the homogeneity of @xmath12 .
it is known that the collection distance ( which relates to @xmath12 by eq .
[ eq - cd ] ) varies with the film thickness , as low values are typically observed on the substrate side and high values on the growth side .
this is due to the fact that polycrystalline cvd diamond films consist of several columnar micro - crystallites .
typically the crystallites are very small at the beginning of the growth process and become larger as the film thickness increases @xcite .
a linear model has been proposed to describe the collection distance as a function of the film thickness @xcite . for an application as a particle detector ,
it is important that the average @xmath12 is constant over the active detector area .
while highly energetic minimum ionising particles yield a rather homogeneous response ( see section [ s - mips ] ) , it has been shown that this is not the case for particles depositing their charge in a thin surface layer @xcite .
thin films for which the stopping range of the ionising particle is of the order of the film thickness seem to exhibit a more homogeneous response @xcite .
we investigate the charge collection properties of cvd diamonds by four different methods .
the response of cvd diamond to homogeneous ionisation densities has been measured with beta particles from a source .
the ionisation density produced by beta particles above @xmath20 is similar to the ionisation density produced by minimum ionising particles ( mips ) , which are to be detected in the application as a vertex detector in a high energy particle physics experiment . by fitting the pulse height distribution
, we obtained information about the homogeneity of @xmath12 . to investigate the priming effect on the cvd diamond samples ,
@xmath12 has been measured with beta particles while the samples were under continuous exposure of ionising radiation . in a second experiment ,
the diamond has been scanned with a beam of 10 kev photons .
the photons ionise via the photo effect and produce when averaged over many events a similar ionisation density distribution as mips . with this method
the local variations of @xmath12 have been measured with a resolution of about @xmath21 .
the results are compared with the data obtained with mips . in contrast , the other two methods described in this paper use radiation which produces charge carriers only in a shallow layer below the surface .
hence , these methods are not measurements of the bulk properties as are the first two .
since all the produced charge is deposited in a surface layer of the detector , they are more sensitive to polarisation effects , as will be discussed in section [ s - conclusion ] .
one method uses alpha particles from an source .
various pulse height spectra have been recorded at different electrical field strengths and polarities in order to extract information about @xmath12 .
the other method uses protons with an energy of 2 mev and allows to do a spatially resolved measurement .
the recorded pulse spectra are mapped onto the diamond surface .
the spatial information has been used to compare the data to sem ( scanning - electron - microscopy ) pictures and to data obtained with the 10 kev photon beam described above .
for the studies presented here , two cvd diamond samples produced by different manufacturers ( sample a from norton @xcite and sample b from fhg @xcite ) have been used .
the sample a was initially grown to a thickness of @xmath22 after which @xmath23 were removed from the substrate side @xcite .
the growth side has been polished to reduce the surface roughness , which has been measured to be smaller than @xmath24 after polishing @xcite .
the grain - size on the growth side is in the order of @xmath21 .
no information is available about the grain size on the substrate side .
the sample size is @xmath25 .
sample b has been grown to a thickness of @xmath26 and is not polished .
the grains have a typical size of @xmath27 on the growth side . from sem
we estimate a surface roughness of below @xmath28 .
the sample has a circular shape and a diameter of @xmath29 .
pole figure measurements @xcite showed no preferred orientation for sample a and a slight ( 111)-texture for sample b. in order to provide electrical contacts , both samples have been metallised on growth and substrate side with layers of ti ( 50 nm ) , pt ( 30 nm ) and au ( 60 nm ) , followed by an annealing step and treatment in oxygen plasma to reduce surface conductivity @xcite .
the quality of the contacts has been checked by measuring the current - voltage ( i - v ) characteristic in darkness at room temperature .
all i - v - curves are symmetric , i.e. independent of polarity , indicating , that front and back - contact are of the same type .
the specific resistivities and some of the properties of the samples are listed in table [ tab - samples ] .
.[tab - samples]properties of the investigated samples .
@xmath30 stands for growth rate , @xmath14 for film thickness and @xmath31 for the specific resistivity .
dcaj stands for _ direct current arc jet process _ and mwp for _ micro wave plasma process_. [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] within the accuracy of the matching of the sem - picture and the @xmath12 map we assigned the highlighted area shown in fig .
[ fig - agathe - sem ] to this hot spot .
the size of the highlighted area includes the estimated error on the matching .
it shows that the hot spot sits most likely on the cloven structure as indicated in the picture .
we also scanned the substrate side of the diamond .
the results of the substrate side gave a similar picture .
again the edges of the metallisation showed significant higher counting rates and hot spots appeared also on the substrate side .
however , the population with hot spots was denser on the substrate side ( spot density of about @xmath32 ) and they were smaller in dimension ( typically @xmath33 to @xmath24 ) than on the growth side .
this can be explained by the fact that the average grain size is smaller on the substrate side than on the growth side @xcite .
furthermore , the existence of hot spots on the substrate side indicates that the surface roughness is not responsible for this phenomenon , since the substrate side was polished .
we tried to correlate @xmath12 maps of the growth side and the substrate side .
if hot spots would appear at the same locations on the growth and on the substrate side it could indicate that continuous crystal columns of high collection efficiency are present at this locations .
however , we could not observe a spatial correlation between the hot spot from the substrate and the growth side .
this indicates that the lattice orientation or the crystal quality of the columnar structured crystallites are not a sufficient condition for a hot spot .
the instability of some hot spots indicate a close link to polarisation phenomena as proposed by @xcite .
the result indicates that the crystallite orientation , quality and size are not sufficient conditions to produce a hot spot .
the results favour the interpretation of a complex polarisation phenomenon at grain boundaries @xcite .
this view is supported by the spatially resolved measurement of @xmath12 with 10 kev photons , which ionise uniformly in the bulk and suppress polarisation .
no enhancement of @xmath12 was seen with photons at the hot spot locations found with protons .
we have presented four experiments using different types of ionising radiation to investigate the charge collection properties of cvd diamond . in particular , we have used beta - particles of up to @xmath34 , a narrow beam of @xmath35 photons from a synchrotron source , @xmath36 alpha - particles and a @xmath37 proton micro - beam .
the samples show an increase of the charge collection efficiency , @xmath12 , when irradiated with beta - particles . the radiation dose needed to achieve saturation of this
so called priming effect is different by a factor 15 between the two investigated samples .
the relative improvements of @xmath12 ( @xmath38 for sample a and @xmath39 for sample b ) are comparable . to obtain information about the lateral distribution of @xmath12 , the signal spectrum recorded with beta particles was fitted with a smeared vavilov - distribution which results in an intrinsic broadening of @xmath12 of @xmath40 for sample a ( see section [ s - mips ] ) .
this value is in good agreement with a direct measurement of the width and the spatial distribution of @xmath12 with a beam of @xmath35 photons , which measures for the same sample @xmath41 in contrast , the response behaviour of the cvd diamond samples to mono - energetic alpha - particle and protons with stopping ranges of a few microns indicates a much higher value for @xmath42 .
the particles produce a very broad pulse distribution with an exponential fall - off towards large pulse - heights .
a strong polarisation build - up decreases the average value of @xmath12 and the counting rate during irradiation .
this confirms observations reported in @xcite .
the spatially resolved measurement of @xmath12 with a proton micro - beam reveals single spots ( hot spots ) in the material with a high response embedded in passive areas , which is in agreement with observation made in @xcite .
the shape of the hot spots and the correlation with sem - pictures indicates that hot spots are bound to the crystallite structure .
since hot spots appear on the growth and on the polished substrate side we conclude that hot spots are neither caused by distinct surface topologies , nor require a certain crystallite size .
the most likely explanation seems to be that particular configurations of grain boundaries in the bulk , which are most likely to possess a high trap density @xcite , influence the polarisation field in the neighbourhood of single crystallites .
the unstable behaviour of some hot spots and the good response on metallisation edges corroborates this assumption . as a result of this proposed complex and non - uniform polarisation , @xmath12 as seen by low energy particles is inhomogeneous .
this is supported by the measurements with alpha - particles .
the pulse distributions obtained with alpha - particles are compatible with the proton micro - beam measurements .
furthermore , the hot spots seen with the proton micro - beam do not show significantly higher values of @xmath12 compared to a @xmath35 photon beam .
this suggests that the existence of hot spots is bound not only to a good crystal quality in this particular spot , but also to distinct features of the polarisation field in this area .
the maps of @xmath12 obtained with a proton micro - beam are highly distorted by the local polarisation fields .
thus this method is not suitable to determine maps of @xmath12 for mips .
the observed increase of @xmath12 under irradiation with mips and the decrease of @xmath12 observed under irradiation with protons and alpha particles is not contradictory . in the former case traps
are filled throughout the bulk thus increasing @xmath12 due to the decrease of active trap levels . however , because of the rather homogeneous distribution of the trapped charge no effective polarisation field is produced . in the latter case the majority of the charge is deposited in a shallow layer . in the electric field
the charge carriers are separated and trapped and thus create a strong polarisation field .
the polarisation is dominating over the increase of @xmath12 from trap passivation . the applicability of cvd diamond as a particle detector depends on the radiation to be detected . for radiation
which deposits charge inhomogeneously as in the case of alpha - particles , whose stopping range is much less than the film thickness , @xmath12 varies strongly and the stability is very poor . for homogeneous ionisation typically produced by mips or synchrotron - radiation at photon energies with @xmath43 ,
@xmath12 is stable if the detector is in its primed state , and a gaussian - like distribution is observed .
thus , we conclude that cvd diamond has the potential of being used as a stable detector for homogeneous ionisation density distributions .
however the relatively high value of @xmath42 might limit the achievable resolution of a position sensitive device .
we would like to thank prof .
h. c. g. lindstrm and dr .
e. fretwurst from the ii .
institut fr experimentalphysik of the univeritt hamburg for their support of the measurements with alpha particles and of the i - v - curves , dr . e. fretwurst and dr .
m. niecke for their support of the measurements with a proton micro - beam , and dr .
t. wroblewski from hasylab for his support of the measurements at the synchrotron facility .
we would also like to thank a. bluhm and dr .
l. schfer from the fraunhofer institut fr schicht- und oberflchentechnik , braunschweig , for the preparation of sample b and m. zeitler of the univesitt augsburg for the pole figure measurements . | the charge collection properties of cvd diamond have been investigated with ionising radiation . in this study two cvd diamond samples , prepared with electrical contacts have been used as solid state ionisation chambers .
the diamonds have been studied with beta particles and 10 kev photons , providing a homogeneous ionisation density and with protons and alpha particles which are absorbed in a thin surface layer . for the latter case a strong decrease of the signal as function of time is observed , which is attributed to polarisation effects inside the diamond .
spatially resolved measurements with protons show a large variation of the charge collection efficiency , whereas for photons and minimum ionising particles the response is much more uniform and in the order of 18% .
these results indicate that the applicability of cvd diamond as a position sensitive particle detector depends on the ionisation type and appears to be promising for homogeneous ionisation densities as provided by relativistic charged particles .
epsf ps .
ps , , , , and cvd diamond , charge collection efficiency . 29.40 |
polymers in solution typically undergo a coil - globule transition from a high temperature ( t ) swollen phase to a low t phase where the polymer assumes compact conformations . in the case of homopolymers , for which all the monomers are identical , this transition is by now well understood
it is known as @xmath0-collapse and has been widely investigated in the past years using various methods such as mean field approximations @xcite , exact enumerations of interacting self - avoiding walks on lattices @xcite , monte carlo @xcite , transfer matrix @xcite and field theoretical calculations @xcite . in two dimensions
the exponents of the @xmath0-collapse have been related to the fractal properties of the percolation cluster and are believed to be known exactly @xcite .
the study of the conformational properties and phase transitions of macromolecules with inhomogeneous or random sequences of monomers is an interesting frontier in nowadays polymer statistics @xcite .
these systems pose new theoretical and numerical challenges , compared to their more standard , homogeneous counterparts .
particularly interesting is in general the possibility that the inhomogeneities along the chain could lead to transitions and universality classes of scaling behavior , which are not realized for homopolymers @xcite .
moreover , the most complex versions of models of this class are also expected to be useful for the description of phenomena like protein folding @xcite , dna denaturation @xcite and rna secondary structure formation @xcite .
thus , an investigation of the universal properties of the simplest among these systems can offer an important gauge of the relevant model ingredients necessary in order to reproduce the basic conformational mechanisms in more sophisticated descriptions .
one of the most elementary conformational transitions ( not realized in homopolymers ) one can try to describe in relatively simple terms is what we call here a _ zipping _ transition . by zipping we mean
a process in which two strands composing the polymer come in contact in such a way as to form a bound double structure , which remains swollen and does not assume compact configurations . in order to induce a transition from unzipped to zipped state
, the minimal inhomogeneity required implies a distinction between the two strands : if the polymer is made of two blocks composed of monomers of different species ( diblock copolymer ) and there is a dominant attractive interaction acting between these different monomers , one would expect such a transition to be possible . of course , the zipping occurring in biomolecules results in general from higher degrees of inhomogeneity than those of a simple diblock copolymer . from a physical point of view one can think to diblock copolymers with oppositely charged monomers in the two blocks ; in the model discussed here the interactions are of short range , and this would correspond to the case of screened coulomb forces .
another possibility is that the attractive interactions between monomers of the two blocks are established through a preferential formation of hydrogen bonds .
the attractive interactions between the two blocks , besides zipping , tend also to produce collapse into a globular compact state , unless some contrasting effect limits the capability of a given monomer to attract monomers of the other block . in a recent paper @xcite , a model of diblock copolymer with some of the features discussed above has been studied in both two dimensions ( 2d ) and 3d . in that model
the two blocks were represented by two halves of a self avoiding walk ( saw ) on hypercubic lattice , and attractive interactions were acting between nearest neighbor sites ( monomers ) visited by the two blocks .
so , apart from the steric constraints , there was no interaction mechanism possibly opposing the tendency of a given monomer to be surrounded by as many as possible monomers of the other block .
the transition of the diblock copolymer from a high t swollen to a low t compact phase , had analogies with both polymer adsorption on a wall , and @xmath0-collapse , but turned out to belong to a universality class different from both @xcite .
an intriguing question remained open concerning the very nature of this transition : indeed , the possibility that a zipped , swollen phase could exist for temperatures just below the transition , could not be excluded . if this were the case , the adsorption - like collapse found in ref .
@xcite would correspond to a zipping and a further transition to the compact globular phase should be expected to take place at a lower t. in the present article we extend the model of ref .
@xcite in 2d to include an interaction among alternating triplets of different monomers .
depending on its sign , this additional interaction can enhance the tendency of the system either to form compact structures , or to take zipped conformations .
we draw an accurate phase diagram for the system , in which a zipping transition line is well - identified and characterized .
our analysis seems to indicate that the adsorption - like collapse of ref .
@xcite belongs to the zipping universality class as well .
specifically , we find that , depending on the triplet interaction energy one has either a continuous swollen - zipped transition followed by a first order collapse into compact conformations , or a direct first order swollen - compact transition .
although we mainly focus on the zipping , it turns out that also the first order collapse has interesting features , since it shows remarkable analogies with that found in homopolymers with orientation dependent interactions , which attracted some attention recently @xcite .
we will argue that the exact exponents for the zipping transition in 2d can be found through an identification between the stochastic geometry of the blocks and that of a percolation cluster backbone @xcite .
a preliminary form of this argument was presented in ref .
the relevant dimensions of the percolation cluster can be identified thanks to some recent results for path - crossing probabilities @xcite .
our numerical estimates for the zipping exponents are in very good agreement with the conjectured values .
the mapping onto percolative stochastic geometry we discuss here is , to our knowledge , the first example of exact results derivation for a genuinely inhomogeneous polymer problem in 2d .
the connection with percolation geometry shows also that the physics of zipping is closely connected with that of the @xmath0-point transition , for which a representation in terms of percolation geometry has been established already long ago @xcite . besides the prototypical importance that zipping acquires here also on the basis of our exact results
, one should realize that many of the conformational transitions occurring in biomolecules show aspects which , to some extent , are reminiscent of zipping .
this is certainly the case for dna , in which , upon lowering temperature below the denaturation one , the conjugate bases form pairs , so that the molecule arranges itself in a double stranded helical structure @xcite .
double stranded , zipped structures appear also in the folding of @xmath1-hairpin peptides @xcite . in the philosophy mentioned at the beginning of this section , one can hope that studies like the one presented here can teach something about how to model properly these more complicated systems .
this paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : pd ] we present the model and the main features of the phase diagram . in sections
[ sec : exact ] and [ sec : mc ] we discuss the numerical results obtained by exact enumerations and monte carlo simulations , respectively . in section [ sec : perco ] , using recent results for crossing probabilities of percolation paths in 2d , we conjecture the exact values of the exponents of the zipping transition . section [ sec : conclusions ] concludes the paper , with a summary of the results and a general discussion .
we model the 2d diblock copolymer by an interacting saw on the square lattice . in the configuration
@xmath2 the saw has @xmath3 vertices ( monomers ) , with @xmath4 even , and consists of @xmath5 consecutive monomers of type a ( @xmath6 ) followed by @xmath5 monomers of type b ( @xmath7 ) .
a pair of vertices @xmath8 form a contact if they are a unit lattice distance apart .
the interaction between the two blocks @xmath6 and @xmath7 is taken into account by assigning an energy @xmath9 ( @xmath10 ) to each @xmath11 contact .
in addition we introduce a second energy parameter @xmath12 , associated with contacts formed by a sequence a - b - a or b - a - b of neighboring monomers on a line .
we refer to these sequences as to _ triple
_ contacts .
the hamiltonian of the system in configuration @xmath2 is given by : @xmath13 where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the number of @xmath11 and of triple contacts , respectively .
for @xmath16 we recover the model introduced in ref .
@xcite ; in the present work we consider both signs of @xmath12 : a positive value of @xmath12 must prevent the polymer from collapse into compact conformations and favor an intermediate zipped phase , while for a negative @xmath12 the tendency to collapse is enhanced .
letting @xmath17 be the number of copolymer configurations with @xmath4 edges , @xmath18 contacts of type @xmath11 and @xmath19 triple contacts , we define the finite-@xmath4 free energy per monomer @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the partition function and @xmath22 @xcite . throughout the rest of the paper we set @xmath23 . by varying @xmath24 and @xmath12
we have explored the phase diagram of the model ( see fig .
[ fig01 ] ) on the basis of exact enumeration and monte carlo simulation results .
0.2truecm as expected , we find a zipped phase in the positive @xmath12 region , while for negative @xmath12 there is a direct transition from the swollen to the compact phase .
the numerical results show that the line ( 1 ) separating the swollen and zipped phases is continuous , while ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) are first order .
unfortunately , the numerical methods at our disposal are not sufficiently accurate to determine the precise location of the intersection point between the lines , nor the character of the phase transition in this point , which could be of special type .
the location of this intersection point seems to fall at slightly negative values of @xmath12 .
it is rather instructive to show some typical equilibrium conformations of the copolymer for various values of @xmath24 and @xmath12 , in the three different phases ( see fig .
[ fig02 ] ) .
the configurations are snapshots obtained by monte carlo simulations : ( a ) and ( b ) are conformations in the swollen high @xmath24 phase , with ( b ) close to the zipping transition .
( c ) and ( d ) are instead zipped configurations , with ( d ) sampled in the vicinity of the transition to the compact state ; notice that the pairing of the two strands in ( d ) follows an opposite orientation with respect to ( c ) .
finally ( e ) and ( f ) are both compact , but of different nature : the latter occurs at @xmath25 where triple contacts are energetically favored . therefore the polymer assumes a spiral - like shape with straight segments turning around the center in order to maximize the number of triple contacts . in the case
( e ) @xmath12 is positive : the configuration is still of spiral type , but in this case the arms of the spiral are oriented preferentially at @xmath26 with respect to the axes of the square lattice , in order to avoid the formation of triple contacts .
one can easily understand now why the lines ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) for large @xmath12 run practically horizontal in the phase diagram of fig .
. in the whole zipped phase triple contacts , which cost an energy @xmath12 , seldom occur ( see fig . [ fig02](c ) ) , therefore the zipping temperature should depend rather weakly on @xmath12 .
in addition the polymer can form compact conformations such as that shown in fig .
[ fig02](e ) , which also avoids this type of contacts . hence ,
also the zipped - compact transition temperature should not depend on @xmath12 , when @xmath12 is positive and large enough . both lines ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) in fig .
[ fig01 ] should be asymptotically horizontal for large @xmath12 . 0.2truecm
exact enumerations of interacting saw s are standard techniques for the study of the homopolymer @xmath0-collapse transition @xcite . in the present calculation we generated all possible configurations for copolymers up to @xmath27
monomers , a length which is already sufficient to characterize rather well the critical behavior of the zipping transition . the occurrence of phase transitions in interacting polymer systems can be detected by studying the large @xmath4 behavior of the canonical average squared radius of gyration @xmath28 \,\ ,
r^2(w ) } { \sum_{w } \exp [ -\beta h(w ) ] } , \label{radius}\ ] ] where the sums extend to all @xmath4-steps configurations , @xmath2 , of the copolymer , with radius @xmath29 relative to the center of mass . indeed ,
in the proximity of a conformational transition temperature @xmath30 we expect that @xmath31 \label{scalr}\ ] ] where @xmath32 and @xmath33 are the exponents characterizing the transition and @xmath34 is a scaling function that is assumed to approach a positive constant if its argument approaches zero .
another important quantity is the specific heat @xmath35 , which for @xmath4 large and @xmath24 close to @xmath36 is expected to obey the scaling : @xmath37 \label{scalc}\ ] ] where @xmath38 is again a suitable scaling function .
figures [ fig03 ] and [ fig04 ] show @xmath39 and @xmath40 as functions of @xmath1 for @xmath16 ( a ) and @xmath41 ( b ) .
as the radius of gyration drops at a transition , its derivative @xmath39 , shows a peak in correspondence to the transition point .
for @xmath41 both quantities have a single isolated peak , indicating that there is a single transition from a swollen to a compact phase . for @xmath16 , instead , the derivative of the radius of gyration has two distinct peaks ( fig .
[ fig03](a ) ) , while the picture emerging from the specific heat ( fig . [ fig03](b ) ) is somewhat more confusing , since the @xmath4-dependence of the peak positions and heights is rather irregular and their extrapolation to @xmath42 becomes impossible .
therefore we focus on the peaks of @xmath43 . extrapolating their positions at @xmath44
we finds the following two estimates of critical temperatures @xmath45 and @xmath46 , which overlap somewhat within error bars . for this reason it is difficult to discern between two separate , but close , transitions , and a single one
however , as @xmath12 is increased , the two sets of peaks get clearly separated and extrapolations yield two distinct transition temperatures . we focus here on the characterization of the high t transition from the swollen to the zipped phase .
the scaling form of eq .
( [ scalr ] ) implies that @xmath47 , the temperature where @xmath39 has a maximum , scales for large @xmath4 as @xmath48 , with @xmath49 a suitable constant .
we calculated both the radius of gyration and specific heat at @xmath47 ; from ( [ scalr ] ) and ( [ scalc ] ) one has : @xmath50 and @xmath51 for the calculation of the critical exponents we formed first the finite @xmath4 approximants , for instance @xmath52 ( here @xmath53 is a shorthand notation for @xmath54 ) and then extrapolated @xmath55 to @xmath42 .
the same procedure was followed for @xmath33 .
the extrapolated values are reported in table [ table01 ] , together with the exponent @xmath56 , which is that associated to the radius of the half - chain , or single block , which at the critical temperature should scale as : @xmath57 0.2truecm the values of the exponents @xmath33 and @xmath32 vary slightly along the line ( 1 ) when @xmath12 is increased , while @xmath56 is rather stable .
we believe that the variation of @xmath32 and @xmath33 is a spurious effect due to the vicinity of an additional transition in the neighborhood of @xmath44 .
it is much more plausible that the exponents are constant along the line ( 1 ) ; the most reliable estimates for @xmath32 and @xmath33 should be those for large @xmath12 , where the lines ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) are clearly separated .
the values of @xmath32 and @xmath56 are consistent ( the former only at large @xmath12 ) with the scaling behavior of a saw , namely , @xmath58 .
the value of @xmath33 is instead consistent with @xmath59 , which was conjectured in ref .
@xcite for the transition at @xmath44 and will be derived in detail in section [ sec : perco ] . as for the transition lines ( 2 ) and
( 3 ) , the exact enumeration analysis is not at all conclusive since the scaling behavior of the peaks with the chain length @xmath4 is rather irregular and precise extrapolations turn out to be impossible .
this issue will be clarified with the use of monte carlo simulations , which allow to achieve much larger copolymer lengths . 0.2truecm
in order to sharpen and extend the results of exact enumerations , in particular concerning the properties of the zipped and collapsed phases , we performed monte carlo simulations for various @xmath4 and @xmath12 and for a wide range of temperatures .
since the simulations considered involve sampling at points which include low values of @xmath24 , a standard markov chain monte carlo approach is unlikely to be successful , being difficult to construct a markov chain sufficiently `` mobile '' at low @xmath24 where the interaction energies become relevant .
instead we use a multiple markov chain technique by which one samples simultaneously at various values of @xmath24 , including @xmath60 where converge is rapid .
most recently this method has been used successfully to investigate collapse transitions in homopolymers @xcite , hetheropolymers @xcite , and adsorption in @xmath0-solvent @xcite .
first one defines a metropolis based markov chain for a temperature @xmath24 .
this procedure makes use of a hybrid algorithm based on pivot @xcite as well as on local moves @xcite .
pivot moves are of global type and operate well in the swollen regime , whereas local moves turn out to be essential in speeding up monte carlo convergence at low temperatures @xcite . in our calculations ,
each monte carlo step consists of o(1 ) pivot moves and o(n ) local moves . in this model
, however , we have to deal also with a zipped phase where the most probable configurations are characterized by having the two blocks a and b paired together , but still not compact ( see fig . [ fig01 ] ( b , c , d ) ) . to increase the mobility of the markov chain in this region we added a set of bilocal moves , such as end - end reptation and kink - end ( and end - kink ) moves @xcite .
these moves are particularly effective for dense chains , and even more effective for the zipped chains , where typically one side of each half - chain is free and can hold a new kink .
the resulting algorithm is a little heavier , but enables the reciprocal sliding of the half - chains and a more efficient exploration of the configuration space .
one may then run in parallel a number @xmath61 ( typically @xmath62 ) of these markov chains at different temperatures .
the sampling at low @xmath24 is then considerably enriched by swapping configurations between markov chains contiguous in @xmath24 .
the whole process is itself a ( composite ) markov chain , obeys detailed balance and is ergodic @xcite .
monte carlo simulations were performed for three distinct values of @xmath12 : @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath44 . as a test of the performance of the multiple markov chain algorithm we compared the monte carlo results with those obtained from the exact enumeration for chains up to @xmath27 monomers . in all cases
analized the agreement turned out to be extremely good ( see , for instance , fig .
[ fig04](a ) ) . in the case
@xmath65 we considered diblocks of lengths up to @xmath66 and sampled at a set of @xmath67 temperatures typically in the range @xmath68 $ ] . in fig .
[ fig05 ] we plot the specific heat as a function of @xmath1 for different @xmath4 values .
clearly each curve displays a double peak structure indicating two subsequent transitions .
we can rule out the possibility that such double peaked structure is a finite size effect by noting that the peaks sharpen and grow with @xmath4 .
let us focus first on the set of peaks at higher temperatures , i.e. on the transition from a swollen to a zipped phase .
the corresponding @xmath36 and @xmath33 could be deduced from the @xmath4 dependence of the height , @xmath69 , and position , @xmath70 , of the peak maxima .
indeed , from the scaling behavior ( [ scalc ] ) we expect , as @xmath4 increases , @xmath71 since a linear least squares fit of @xmath72 vs. @xmath73 gives a very large @xmath74 statistical error , we fit the data with a function @xmath75 where a scaling correction @xmath76 is included .
the least squares fit in this case gives @xmath77 , in agreement with the value @xmath78 conjectured in ref .
@xcite and also with the estimates obtained by exact enumeration . this procedure yields results consistent with a direct extrapolation of effective finite @xmath4 exponents .
we have also tried to fit the data by using the more general scaling correction @xmath79 , but the best fit is obtained for @xmath80 . the estimated value of @xmath33 allowed us to extrapolate @xmath36 by plotting @xmath47 vs. @xmath81 .
this gives @xmath82 ( @xmath83 ) .
0.2truecm the inset of fig .
[ fig05 ] shows a plot of @xmath84 vs. @xmath85 , where we have used @xmath86 and the estimate @xmath87 .
as expected , the high temperature peaks collapse onto a single curve quite nicely . on the contrary
, for the set of peaks at lower temperatures , the same rescaling procedure turns out to be inappropriate .
in particular , by using the rescaled variables adequate for the former set of peaks , the positions of the latter set tend to move away from zero while their heights still increase with @xmath4 : this is only consistent with a scenario in which a new transition , at a lower @xmath88 , exists .
this transition should be also characterized by a crossover exponent greater than @xmath89 .
we have tried to verify this by looking for two new values @xmath90 and @xmath91 that allow a reasonable fit of the scaling behavior of the second set of peaks . in this way we obtained the rough estimates @xmath92 and @xmath93 .
unfortunately the sampling at low temperatures is not good enough to make such estimates sufficiently sharp .
moreover , in the zipped phase the effective size of an @xmath4 monomers system drops to @xmath5 , making the finite size corrections to scaling more pronounced . the different nature of the two transitions can be better detected from the behavior of @xmath94 , the probability distribution of the energy @xmath95 , for a chain of length @xmath4 .
figure [ fig06 ] shows a plot of @xmath94 as a function of @xmath96 for @xmath97 . at sufficiently high temperatures this quantity has a maximum in @xmath98 and decreases rapidly with @xmath96 ( fig .
[ fig06](a ) ) . as the temperature
is lowered the maximum shifts continuously to larger values of @xmath96 ( b , c ) . for lower temperatures @xmath99 develops a double peak structure ( d , e , f ) . in the case ( e )
the peaks have equal height , while at temperatures below or above it one of the two peaks dominates over the other .
this behavior , which persists and becomes more pronounced upon increasing @xmath4 , is an indication of phase coexistence ; hence the transition at lower @xmath24 is of first order type . in terms of specific heat
this would mean @xmath100 as @xmath101 , i.e. @xmath102 . by extrapolating @xmath103 vs. @xmath76 we find @xmath104 .
0.2truecm another way to characterize the different phases of the model consists in looking at the scaling behavior of metric quantities such as @xmath105 defined in ( [ radius ] ) and the mean squared end - to - end distance @xmath106 , where @xmath107 and @xmath108 are the two end - monomers of the copolymer . for large @xmath4
we expect @xmath109 and an interesting quantity to be computed is the ratio @xmath110 , which is expected to be universal @xcite . for non
interacting saw s on a square lattice , exact enumerations and monte carlo simulations give @xmath111 ( see references in @xcite ) .
figure [ fig06 ] shows the ratio @xmath112 as a function of @xmath1 for several @xmath4 .
note that in the range of @xmath113 the curves tend to assume a constant value @xmath114 in agreement with the value expected for non interacting saw s . in the proximity of the zipping transition the curves start to bend downwards and at @xmath115 they cross each other almost in a unique point ( see inset ) . at the crossing point
our estimate of the universal amplitude is @xmath116 which is definitively different from the amplitudes ratio of the saw universality class .
the zipping transition that can not be distinguished from the swollen phase in terms of the @xmath117 exponent , is however characterized by a different value of the universal ratio @xmath118 @xcite .
0.2truecm if the temperature is further lowered the @xmath119 curves reach a minimum value that decreases as @xmath4 increases .
this is an indication that the end - to - end distance in the zipped phase does not scale anymore like the radius of gyration , as assumed in eqs .
( [ re],[rg ] ) . for sufficiently low temperatures ,
@xmath110 starts to grow back indicating that the compact phase is characterized by end - to - end distance and mean radius of gyration that scale in the same way with @xmath4 . as the typical low @xmath24 configurations are of spiral type ( see fig .
[ fig02](e , f ) ) with end - points at opposite sides of the spiral , it is natural to expect that @xmath120 . for @xmath121 triple contacts are favored and we expect ( as the exact enumerations already indicate ) a single transition from swollen directly to compact phase . to investigate the nature of such transition we have performed runs with @xmath41 , for several values of @xmath4 , sampling at @xmath122 different temperatures in the interval @xmath123 $ ] .
as in the case @xmath124 we have examined the probability of finding the copolymer in a configuration with energy @xmath95 , as a function of the temperature . a plot of @xmath99 for @xmath97 and three different temperatures is shown in fig .
[ fig08 ] .
close to the transition temperature @xmath99 has two maxima ( see fig . [ fig08](b ) ) one at @xmath98 and the other at @xmath125 .
this is a clear indication of a first order transition .
the evidence of such a behavior is stronger than in the case @xmath124 since here the coexistence is between two phases ( the swollen and the compact ) with a rather large difference in energy , therefore the double peak structure of @xmath99 can be noticed already for small @xmath4 . from the analysis of the specific heat peaks we find that they become sharper as @xmath4 increases and
their height appears to grow with a power of n slightly exceeding one ( the physical upper limit ) . at the same time , in a plot of energy vs. temperature we see curves that seem to approach step functions .
these data support the idea that the corresponding transition should be of first order . 0.2truecm the more delicate region to be explored in the phase diagram is the neighborhood of @xmath126 , where three transition lines meet each others .
we have chosen in particular the case @xmath126 , since it was considered in ref .
@xcite . in fig .
[ fig09 ] we plot the specific heat as a function of @xmath1 for several @xmath4 values . for the smallest chains ( @xmath127 )
, one observes a peak in the specific heat with a shoulder at smaller @xmath1 .
when the copolymer length is increased the shoulder becomes hardly noticeable . from the specific heat plot one can not rule out the possibility that the shoulder eventually vanishes leaving out a single transition from a swollen to a compact phase .
the other possibility is that there are two separate transitions , but very close in temperature .
the presence of two distinct transitions is suggested by a plot of the temperature derivative of the total radius of gyration , shown for @xmath128 and @xmath97 as thick lines in fig .
[ fig10 ] . in this case
one clearly detects two peaks , which although coming closer to each other as @xmath4 increases are still noticeable and sharp for @xmath4 rather large .
the thin lines in fig .
[ fig10 ] are the temperature derivatives of the radius of gyration of a single block , which show only one peak in correspondence to the low temperature peak of the derivative of the total radius of gyration .
this behavior is consistent with the following picture : coming from the swollen phase ( small @xmath1 ) one has first a zipping transition characterized by a drop of the total radius of gyration , while the radius of gyration of a single block still behaves as a saw and is not sensible to the zipping transition .
however , at lower temperatures , in correspondence to the transition from zipped to compact phase both quantities drop and their derivatives show a peak . 0.2truecm 0.2truecm another quantity which we investigated is the universal amplitude ratio between the end - to - end distance an radius of gyration squared , which is plotted in fig .
[ fig11 ] . here ,
as for the @xmath65 case , this universal quantity takes the saw value @xmath129 at high t and drops in correspondence of the transition .
the fact that we find intersections with @xmath130 ( the same value as for @xmath65 ) strongly suggests the presence of a zipping transition with the same universal properties as that at @xmath65 . unlike from fig .
[ fig07 ] here @xmath131 drops and increases again in a narrow range of @xmath1 values indicating the the zipped phase is restricted to a small temperature interval . in summary , although the numerical evidence is not fully conclusive , our data seem to favor the existence of two separate transitions for @xmath44 . as in the case @xmath65 , it is natural to expect that the low t one ( zipped - collapsed ) is of first order type . 0.2truecm
in this section we present a conjecture on the relation between the statistics of some percolation paths at threshold and the diblock copolymer zipping transition . this conjecture leads to predict exact values for the exponents .
a preliminary , less precise version of the arguments below was given in ref .
@xcite .
it is well - known that , in 2d , the statistics of a ring polymer at the @xmath0-transition is identical to that of the external perimeter , or hull , of a percolation cluster . through this identification
the exact exponents of the @xmath0-transition , @xmath132 and @xmath133 , were derived @xcite . here ,
we show how similar arguments can be invoked for the zipping transition .
the differences are mainly associated to the fact that the relevant percolative set appropriate for the zipping is not the hull , as for the homopolymer @xmath0-point .
like in the @xmath0-point case , here it is convenient to consider site percolation on a triangular lattice .
for this problem the relevant percolation contours , like the hull of a cluster , are in fact strictly self - avoiding paths on the dual , hexagonal lattice .
thus , also the equivalent diblock copolymer problem realized here by percolation paths will be on hexagonal , rather than square lattice . on the basis of universality
we expect our results to extend also to the square lattice case .
0.2truecm let us consider a percolation cluster as sketched in fig .
[ fig12 ] .
its external perimeter is a self - avoiding ring .
the ensemble of all possible conformations of an external hull on the lattice can be regarded as a problem of ring polymer ( grand canonical ) statistics , as discussed in refs .
one further realizes that this effective ring polymer problem is characterized by attractive interactions .
these originate from the fact that , at threshold ( @xmath134 ) , multiple visitations @xcite by the hull of the same occupied , or vacant , hexagon , give higher probability to the realization of a ring configuration .
indeed , when the contour proceeds essentially straight , to each new step corresponds a new hexagon whose state ( occupied or vacant ) has to be determined .
so , each step implies a factor @xmath135 in the probability weight of the whole configuration .
when the contour folds on itself and revisits , after some steps , the perimeter of the same hexagon , the factor @xmath136 does not apply , resulting in higher global probability .
this is equivalent to an attractive interaction favoring the multiple visitations of the same hexagon . it is convenient here to summarize some very recent exact results concerning the fractal dimensions of various percolative sets .
following ref .
@xcite we consider an annular region of the hexagonal lattice delimited by an inner circle of small radius @xmath137 , and an external one , of radius @xmath138 .
two types of paths connecting the two circles are also considered .
these paths are formed by connected and self - avoiding sequences of either occupied , or empty hexagons .
the so - called _ path - crossing _ probability , namely the probability that @xmath139 non - overlapping paths connect inner to outer circles , was found to behave asymptotically as : @xmath140 where : @xmath141 the formula is valid if there is at least a path of each type , and the probability depends only on the total number of these paths , not on their type @xcite .
0.2truecm figure [ fig13 ] shows examples of crossing paths ; without resolving the underlying lattice structure , we draw them as solid lines if they connect filled hexagons , while dashed lines are used for paths connecting empty hexagons . as a first example ( see fig . [
fig13](a ) ) we consider the crossing probability for a continuous and a dashed path , which according to eqs .
( [ crossing],[xl ] ) decays as @xmath142 .
one recognizes immediately that the set of points for which two of such self - avoiding paths can be drawn are those of the external perimeter or hull of the percolative cluster ( see fig .
[ fig13](a ) ) .
this identification allows to derive the fractal dimension of the hull .
since the area enclosed by the annulus is proportional to @xmath143 , the perimeter of the hull enclosed in the annulus must scale as @xmath144 . identifying the external hull as a polymer ring at the @xmath0-point
one then derives that the latter has a fractal dimension @xmath145 . in order to make contact with the diblock copolymer zipping ,
let us now imagine to identify two points , 1 and 2 , dividing the cluster hull in two equally long parts ( see fig .
[ fig14 ] ) . by fixing these two points on the cluster perimeter ,
one automatically defines a backbone as a subset of the whole cluster .
the backbone is the union of all connected paths of occupied hexagons , which are strictly self - avoiding ( i.e. in each path a given hexagon appears at most once ) and join the points 1 and 2 . in force of the definition
, the backbone does not include the so called `` dangling ends '' , i.e. those branches of the cluster connected to the main body by narrow bridges ( i.e. by regions in which only one occupied hexagon is available , making impossible for a self - avoiding path of hexagons to penetrate and exit at the same time ) .
an example of dangling end is also schematically shown as double dashed area in fig . [ fig13](b ) .
0.2truecm the two points we fix on the contour clearly divide into two sides the perimeter of the backbone .
even if in this case it is not possible to give a simple expression of the effective interactions determining the shape of the two backbone sides , we expect them to be essentially local , like in the case of the hull , and to act differently according to whether they involve close encounters of the same side , or between different sides .
this is consistent with the idea that the two sides of the backbone perimeter could represent the statistics of a ring version of the diblock copolymer at the transition , the two parts corresponding , respectively , to blocks a and b. for the calculation of the fractal dimension of the external perimeter of the backbone one can use eqs .
( [ crossing],[xl ] ) taking two continuous paths and a dashed one .
this configuration clearly identifies the perimeter of the backbone .
indeed , the two continuous paths guarantee that occupied hexagons inside the interior circle belong to a whole path connecting two infinitely distant points . at the same time
, a dashed path implies that the vacant hexagons facing the occupied ones belong to the exterior of the cluster , and thus , also of its backbone
. therefore we now take @xmath146 for the exponents defined in eq .
( [ xl ] ) . in this case
we find that the external perimeter of the backbone scales as @xmath147 , which implies a fractal dimension @xmath148 .
this dimension is consistent with that found for the diblock copolymer at the zipping transition .
furthermore , it is natural to associate the switching on of effective attractive interactions between the two backbone sides to the existence of narrow bottlenecks in the backbone itself ( corresponding to only one hexagon ) .
these are the so - called cutting or `` red '' hexagons of the backbone @xcite , which are visited by the two blocks simultaneously . in oder to determine their fractal dimension one has to consider a percolative configuration with two continuous and two dashed paths joining the circles , as sketched in fig .
[ fig13](b ) .
these identify a dimension @xmath149 .
thus , for a backbone with external perimeter equal to @xmath4 and an average of @xmath18 contacts we find @xmath150 and @xmath151 .
consequently , the average number of contacts between the backbone sides grows like @xmath152 . by identifying the external perimeter of the backbone with the ring diblock copolymer at its transition ,
one eventually finds @xmath153 and @xmath89 .
now the numerical determinations of @xmath32 and @xmath33 at the zipping transition are remarkably consistent with these values , making the conjecture extremely plausible @xcite .
in this paper we studied the phase diagram for the collapse transition of a diblock copolymer with attractive interactions between monomers of different species and a triple contact interaction @xmath12 , which according to its sign may either favor , or unfavor , compactification . in the region of negative @xmath12
we find a first order transition from a swollen to a compact , spiral phase , while in the positive @xmath12 region there is a sequence of a continuous zipping transition and a collapse of first order type to compact conformations at a lower temperature .
our exact enumerations and monte carlo simulations yield numerical estimates of the critical exponents @xmath32 and @xmath33 of the zipping transition , which are consistent with those we could conjecture using recent results for the fractal dimensions of the percolation cluster backbone , from which we expect @xmath153 and @xmath154 .
the numerically determined exponents , therefore , are strongly supporting the hypothesis that the transition admits a description in terms of percolative stochastic geometry : the two blocks of the copolymer have the same fractal geometry as the two sides of a cluster backbone , and their contacts correspond to the cutting hexagons , or links of the same backbone .
this is , to our knowledge , the second example of a percolative representation for a polymer conformational transition in 2d , besides that of the @xmath0-point .
the common percolative roots of these transitions suggests the possibility of a deep link between them , which ought to be elucidated by further studies .
the results obtained for the various transitions appearing in the phase diagram help in clarifying the nature of the adsorption - like collapse occurring at @xmath44 and first detected in ref . @xcite . in spite of the fact that most tests are not able to put into clear evidence the existence of two successive transitions , the only multicritical behavior which can be characterized coming from the high temperature region seems to definitely belong to the universality class of the continuous zipping transition identified for positive values of @xmath12 .
besides the compatibility of the exponent estimates , a very strong support to such conclusion comes from our determination of the universal amplitude ratio between squared end - to - end distance and radius of gyration of the polymer .
another interesting aspect of the phase diagram calculated in this paper are the first order swollen - collapsed and zipped - collapsed transitions found , respectively , for negative and positive values of @xmath12 .
in particular the latter resembles the transition from swollen to spiral state found in _ oriented _
polymers @xcite , i.e. chains to which an overall orientation is assigned and where different energies are associated to contacts between parallel or antiparallel segments of the chain .
in fact the analogy between the diblock copolymer in a zipped state and an oriented polymer is very appropriate : in the zipped diblock parallel contacts are of ab type , while antiparallel ones are contacts between monomers of equal type .
different energies are clearly associated with the two types of contacts .
it is worthwhile to recall that simple polymer models with some sort of zipping transition attracted already some attention in the recent literature @xcite , mainly because of the relevance that such transition can have for biopolymers .
@xcite considered a diblock formed by two strands of oppositely charged monomers interacting with each other through long range coulomb forces and found evidence of the existence of a zipping transition followed by a collapse at lower temperatures .
@xcite considered a simple model for the dna denaturation transition , in which only the monomers which are at equal distances along the sequence from the center of the chain interact .
they found evidence of a first order transition , from a swollen to a zipped phase . by its construction
their model has no other transitions to compact state . in their case
the first order zipping seems to be due to the selective interactions of monomers along the chain .
also in our model , if we turn on interactions only between ab monomers at equal distance from the center we find evidence of a first order zipping transition . finally , we point out that there are several possible extensions of this work .
first of all , it would be interesting to generalize the model to three dimensions and to investigate the properties of the zipping transition in that case @xcite .
another open issue is the effect of disorder on the interaction between monomers for the zipping transition , which would allow to understand the behavior of models of polymers more relevant for applications to chemistry or biology than a simple diblock .
p. g. de gennes , _ scaling concepts in polymer physics _
( cornell university press , ithaca , 1953 ) . c. vanderzande , _ lattice models of polymers _
( cambridge university press , cambridge 1998 ) .
j. des cloizeaux and g. jannink , _ polymers in solution _
( oxford , clarendon press 1990 ) .
t. ishinabe , j. phys .
a * 18 * , 3181 ( 1985 ) ; v. privman , j. phys .
a * 19 * , 3287 ( 1986 ) ; d. p. foster , e. orlandini and m. c. tesi , j. phys .
a * 25 * , l1211 ( 1992 ) .
k. kremer , a. baumgrtner and k. binder , j. phys .
a * 15 * , 2879 ( 1981 ) ; h. meirovitch and h. a. lim , j. chem . phys .
* 91 * , 2544 ( 1989 ) ; f. seno and a. l. stella , j. phys .
france * 49 * , 739 ( 1988 )
. b. derrida and h. saleur , j. phys .
a * 18 * , l1075 ( 1985 ) .
b. duplantier , j. phys .
france * 43*,991 ( 1982 ) .
a. coniglio , n. jan , i. majid and h. e. stanley , , 3617 ( 1987 ) ; b. duplantier and h. saleur , , 539 ( 1987 ) ; c. vanderzande , a. l. stella and f. seno , , 2757 ( 1991 ) .
c. d. sfatos and e. i. shakhnovich , phys . rep .
* 288 * , 77 ( 1997 ) .
i. golding and y. kantor , , r1318 ( 1997 ) ; p. monari and a. l. stella , , 1887 ( 1999 ) .
p. monari , e. orlandini , a. l. stella and c. vanderzande , 112 ( 1999 ) . k. a. dill , s. brimberg , s. yue , k. fiebig , k. m. yee , p. d. tomas , and h. s. chan , protein sci . * 4 * , 561 ( 1995 ) ; v. s. pande , a. y. grosberg and t. tanaka rev . of mod
. phys . * 72 * , 259 ( 2000 ) ; c. micheletti , f. seno , a. maritan and j. r. banavar , ann . of combinatorics
* 3 * , 431 ( 1999 ) .
m. peyrard and a. r. bishop , 2755 ( 1989 ) ; d. cule and t. hwa , , 2375 ( 1997 ) ; y. kafri , d. mukamel and l. peliti , cond - mat/0007141 .
r. bundshuch and t. hwa , , 1479 ( 1999 ) ; a. pagani , g. parisi and f. ricci - tersenghi , , 2026 ( 2000 ) .
e. orlandini , f. seno and a. stella , , 294 ( 2000 ) .
g. t. barkema and s. flesia , j. stat .
phys . * 85 * , 363 ( 1996 ) ; a. trovato and f. seno , , 131 ( 1997 ) ; g. t. barkema , u. bastolla and p. grassberger , j. stat . phys . * 90 * , 1311 ( 1998 ) .
d. stauffer and a. aharony , _ introduction to percolation theory _
( taylor and francis , london , 1994 ) . m. aizenman , b. duplantier and a. aharony , , 1359 ( 1999 ) . c. guo , h. levine and d. a. kessler , , 3490 ( 2000 ) .
it is perhaps worth noticing that to prove rigorously the existence of the limit @xmath155 is an open problem since the diblock character of the polymer does not allow to apply in a straightforward manner the concatenation procedure ( see , for instance n. madras and g. slade , _ the self - avoiding walk _ , ( ed .
birkhauser 1993 ) ) usually employed for homopolymers .
m. c. tesi , e. j. janse van rensburg , e. orlandini and s. g. whittington , j. stat .
* 29 * , 2451 ( 1996 ) .
it is interesting to point out that there exists an estimate of @xmath118 for the 2d @xmath0-collapse in p. grassberger and r. egger , j. phys .
i france * 5 * , 597 ( 1995 ) .
although the authors do not mention the value explicitly from their plots one deduces that at the @xmath0-point @xmath156 .
v. privman , p. c. hohenberg and a. aharony in _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ , edited by c. domb and j. l. lebowitz ( academic press , new york , 1991 ) , vol .
14 , p. 1 .
n. madras , a. sokal j. stat .
* 50 * , 109 ( 1988 ) p.
h. verdier and w. h. stockmayer , j. chem .
phys . * 36 * , 227 ( 1961 ) .
t. vrbova and s. g. whittington , j. phys .
a , * 27 * , 3989 ( 1998 ) . s. caracciolo , m. s. causo , g. ferraro , m. papinutto , a. pelissetto , hep - lat/9911031 .
r. brak , a. l. owczarek and t. prellberg , j. phys .
a , * 26 * , 4565 ( 1993 ) .
visitation means here that the hull reaches the hexagon perimeter , or returns to it after having left .
note that in ref .
@xcite an identification with the two halves of the externally accessible hull , rather than the backbone perimeter was proposed .
although this geometrical contour has also a fractal dimension @xmath157 , problems then arise in the discussion of the contacts of these two parts , which are expected to have fractal dimension zero rather than @xmath158 .
the present argument solves this problem and is fully consistent .
j. b. imbert , j. m. victor , n. tsunekawa , y. hiwatari , phys .
a * 258 * , 92 ( 1999 ) .
m. s. causo , b. coluzzi and p. grassberger , cond - mat/9910188 . | using exact enumeration methods and monte carlo simulations we study the phase diagram relative to the conformational transitions of a two dimensional diblock copolymer .
the polymer is made of two homogeneous strands of monomers of different species which are joined to each other at one end .
we find that depending on the values of the energy parameters in the model , there is either a first order collapse from a swollen to a compact phase of spiral type , or a continuous transition to an intermediate zipped phase followed by a first order collapse at lower temperatures .
critical exponents of the zipping transition are computed and their exact values are conjectured on the basis of a mapping onto percolation geometry , thanks to recent results on path - crossing probabilities . 2 |
since the discovery of synchronization in pendulum clocks by huygens , synchronous behavior has been widely observed not only in physical systems but also in biological ones such as pacemaker cells in the heart , chirps of crickets , and fetal - maternal heart rate synchronization @xcite .
such synchronization phenomena have been studied theoretically in terms of nonlinear dynamics , particularly by exploiting oscillator models @xcite . for example , synchronization observed in fireflies can be modeled using nonlinear periodic oscillators and is described as _
phase synchronization_. further , it has been indicated that the notion of phase synchronization can be extended to chaotic oscillators .
this phenomenon is called _ chaotic phase synchronization _ ( cps ) @xcite .
furthermore , synchronization phenomena in neural systems have also attracted considerable attention in recent years . at the macroscopic level of the brain activity
, synchronous behavior has been observed in electroencephalograms , local field potentials , etc .
these observations raise a possibility that such neural synchronization plays an important role in brain functions such as perception @xcite as well as even in dysfunctions such as parkinson s disease and epilepsy @xcite .
in addition , at the level of a single neuron , it has been observed that specific spiking - bursting neurons in the cat visual cortex contribute to the synchronous activity evoked by visual stimulation @xcite ; further , in animal models of parkinson s disease , several types of bursting neurons are synchronized @xcite .
moreover , two coupled neurons extracted from the central pattern generator of the stomatogastric ganglion in a lobster exhibit synchronization with irregular spiking - bursting behavior @xcite .
hence , it is important to use mathematical models of neurons to examine the mechanism of neuronal synchronization with spiking - bursting behavior . as mathematical models that include such neural oscillations , the chay model @xcite and the hindmarsh - rose ( hr ) model @xcite
have been widely used .
these models can generate both regular and chaotic bursting on the basis of _ slow - fast _ dynamics .
the slow and fast dynamics correspond to slow oscillations surmounted by spikes and spikes within each burst , respectively .
the former is related to a long time scale , and the latter , to a short one .
phase synchronization in such neuronal models is different from that in ordinary chaotic systems such as the rssler system , owing to the fact that neuronal models typically exhibit multiple time scales .
however , it is possible to quantitatively analyze the neuronal models by simplification , for example , by reducing the number of phase variables to 1 by a projection of an attractor ( a projection onto a delayed coordinate and/or a velocity space @xcite ) .
recently , a method called _ localized sets _ technique has been proposed for detecting phase synchronization in neural networks , without explicitly defining the phase @xcite . in this paper , we focus on synchronization in periodically driven single bursting neuron models , which is simpler than that in a network of neurons . in previous studies , phase synchronization of such a neuron with a driving force has been considered both theoretically @xcite and experimentally @xcite . in these studies ,
the period of the driving force was made close to that of the slow oscillation of a driven neuron .
on the other hand , in this work , we adopt the chay model @xcite to investigate whether phase synchronization also occurs with the application of a force whose period is as short as that of the spikes .
in particular , we focus on the effect of the slow mode ( slow oscillation ) on the synchronization of the fast mode ( spikes ) .
it should be noted that this fast driven system may be significant from the viewpoint of neuroscience .
in fact , fast oscillations with local field potentials have been observed in the hippocampus and are correlated with synchronous activity at the level of a single neuron @xcite . from intensive numerical simulations of our model , we find that the localized sets technique can be used to detect cps between the spikes and the periodic driving force , even in the case of multiple time scales .
furthermore , we find two characteristic properties around the transition point to cps .
first , the average time interval between successive phase slips exhibits a power - law scaling against the driving force strength .
the scaling exponent undergoes an unsmooth change as the driving force strength is varied .
second , an order parameter @xmath3 , which measures the degree of phase synchronization , shows a stepwise dependence on the driving force strength @xmath4 before the transition . that is , @xmath5 does not increase monotonically with @xmath4 but includes a plateau over a range of @xmath4 ( a step ) , where @xmath3 is almost constant .
both of these characteristics are attributed to the effects of the slow mode on the fast mode and have not been observed in a system with a single time scale .
this paper is organized as follows .
section [ model ] explains the model and describes an analysis method for spiking - bursting oscillations .
section [ result ] presents the results of this study .
finally , section [ summary ] summarizes our results and discusses their neuroscientific significance with a view to future work .
as an illustrative example of a bursting neuron model , we consider the model proposed by chay , which is a hodgkin - huxley - type conductance - based model expressed as follows @xcite : @xmath6.\label{dcdt } \end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ dvdt ] ) represents the dynamics of the membrane potential @xmath7 , where @xmath8 , @xmath9 , and @xmath10 are the reversal potentials for mixed na@xmath11 and ca@xmath12 ions , k@xmath11 ions , and the leakage current , respectively .
the concentration of the intracellular ca@xmath12 ions divided by its dissociation constant from the receptor is denoted by @xmath13 .
the maximal conductances divided by the membrane capacitance are denoted by @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 , and @xmath17 , where subscripts ( i ) , ( k , v ) , ( k , c ) , and ( l ) refer to the voltage - sensitive mixed ion channel , voltage - sensitive k@xmath11 channel , ca@xmath12-sensitive k@xmath11 channel , and leakage current , respectively .
finally , @xmath18 and @xmath19 are the probabilities of activation and inactivation of the mixed channel , respectively . in eq .
( [ dndt ] ) , the dynamical variable @xmath20 denotes the probability of opening the voltage - sensitive k@xmath11-channel , where @xmath21 is the relaxation time ( in seconds ) , and @xmath22 is the steady - state value of @xmath20 . it should be noted that , on the basis of the formulation in @xcite , the variables @xmath18 , @xmath19 , and @xmath22 are described by @xmath23 where @xmath24 stands for @xmath25 , or @xmath20 with @xmath26,\\ \beta_m&=&4\exp[-(v+50)/18],\\ \alpha_h&=&0.07\exp(-0.05v-2.5),\\ \beta_h&=&1/[1+\exp(-0.1v-2)],\\ \alpha_{q}&=&0.01(20+v)/[1-\exp(-0.1v-2)],\\ \beta_{q}&=&0.125\exp[-(v+30)/80].\end{aligned}\ ] ] further , @xmath21 is defined as @xmath27^{-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in eq .
( [ dcdt ] ) , @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 are the efflux rate constant of the intracellular ca@xmath12 ions , a proportionality constant , and the reversal potential for ca@xmath12 ions , respectively . in this study , a sinusoidal driving force with amplitude @xmath4 and frequency @xmath31 is added in eq .
( [ dvdt ] ) as follows : @xmath32 in the following sections , we fix the frequency at @xmath33 and vary the amplitude @xmath4 to investigate the response of the system .
the values of the reversal potentials and the fixed parameters used in our simulation are listed in table [ parameter ] .
the value of @xmath16 significantly influences the dynamics of the system , and a chaotically bursting behavior can be observed in the vicinity of @xmath34 .
we use this value in our simulation .
figure [ fig : fig_attractor.eps ] shows ( a ) the chaotic attractor , ( b ) the time series of @xmath35 , and ( c ) the average power spectrum of the time series for @xmath36 , where the time series includes two time scales one for the spikes within each burst and the other one for the bursts themselves . for discussions in the rest of this paper , we introduce the following terminology for the time series of the chay model : the fast mode describes the spiking oscillation in the dashed rectangles in fig . [
fig : fig_attractor.eps](b ) , whereas the slow mode describes the oscillation in the lower envelope of @xmath35 between the dotted lines , where the dashed - dotted curve shows the slow oscillation .
the variable @xmath13 dominates the slow dynamics with the time constant @xmath37 .
in fact , the decrease in @xmath7 ( i.e. , hyperpolarization ) between the bursts shown in fig .
[ fig : fig_attractor.eps](b ) corresponds to the decrease in @xmath13 shown in fig .
[ fig : fig_attractor.eps](a ) . on the other hand , the increase in @xmath13 shown in fig .
[ fig : fig_attractor.eps](a ) corresponds to the spiking of @xmath7 in fig .
[ fig : fig_attractor.eps](b ) .
hereafter , the period for hyperpolarization of @xmath7 is called the _ quiescent period _ , as indicated in fig .
[ fig : fig_attractor.eps](b ) .
it should be noted that the amplitude of @xmath4 takes small values in our simulation as compared with the change in voltage for a spike , such that the driving force is weak .
a clear peak can be observed in the high - frequency part of the power spectrum ( fig .
[ fig : fig_attractor.eps](c ) ) , corresponding to the fast spiking activity .
additionally , a broadband peak for the slow oscillation is observed in the low - frequency part . in what follows ,
let us investigate the system under force with a frequency close to that of the spiking mode ( i.e. , @xmath38 hz ) , which is the natural frequency of the fast dynamics of the system .
the arrows indicate the direction of the trajectory .
( b ) time series of @xmath35 for the chaotically bursting behavior described by eqs .
( 1)(3 ) .
the terms fast mode and slow mode describe the spiking oscillation and the oscillation in the lower envelope of @xmath35 between the dotted lines ( shown by the dashed - dotted curve ) , respectively .
( c ) power spectrum for time series of @xmath35 .
the spectrum is averaged over 100 time series with a length of @xmath39 , where @xmath40 s is the time step for the numerical integration . ]
the arrows indicate the direction of the trajectory .
( b ) time series of @xmath35 for the chaotically bursting behavior described by eqs .
( 1)(3 ) .
the terms fast mode and slow mode describe the spiking oscillation and the oscillation in the lower envelope of @xmath35 between the dotted lines ( shown by the dashed - dotted curve ) , respectively .
( c ) power spectrum for time series of @xmath35 .
the spectrum is averaged over 100 time series with a length of @xmath39 , where @xmath40 s is the time step for the numerical integration . ]
.parameters used in the numerical simulations . [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] next , in order to investigate phase synchronization between the spikes and the periodic driving force , we consider the phase @xmath41 of the driving force at @xmath42 when the @xmath43th spike occurs in the neuron ( see @xcite ) .
figure [ fig : schematic_phasesets.eps ] illustrates the manner in which the phase variable of the driving force at @xmath44 , which is defined as the moment when @xmath35 exceeds a certain threshold @xmath45 , can be measured . once a sequence of @xmath44 is determined , we can assign points @xmath41 on a unit circle , where each @xmath41 is determined as the phase of the sinusoidal force at time @xmath44 .
we assume that @xmath46 .
we term these points the _ spiking time points _ ( stps ) .
we can detect the cps between the driven system and the driving force as a localization of the stp distribution ; that is , there is an open interval on the unit circle where no spiking time point is detected . in @xcite , such a localization of the stps ( obtained from a sufficiently long time series )
is mathematically described in the following manner .
let the distribution of the stps be included in a set @xmath47 on the unit circle ; @xmath47 is localized if there exist open sets @xmath48 on the circle such that @xmath49 .
it should be noted that only one parameter @xmath45 is required to detect the cps by this algorithm .
in this section , we mainly show the results for the periodic driving force with the frequency at @xmath50 hz .
this value is close to the natural frequency @xmath51 of the fast mode . in this case , the quiescent periods of @xmath7 disappear when the forcing amplitude @xmath4 increases ; that is , @xmath7 exhibits spiking without quiescent periods .
then , we find the cps between the single spikes and the driving force .
moreover , we observe two characteristic phenomena around the transition point to the cps .
one phenomenon shows a power - law scaling against @xmath4 , which is exhibited in the average time interval between successive phase slips .
the scaling exponent undergoes an unsmooth change as @xmath4 is varied .
the other phenomenon shows a stepwise behavior observed in kuramoto s order parameter for the driving force strength before the transition ( shown in fig .
[ fig : worefracop.eps ] ) .
in addition to the results of the case @xmath33 , we also show brief results for the periodic driving force with frequency @xmath52 hz . in this case
, the quiescent periods of @xmath7 do not disappear ( shown in fig .
[ fig : plk302o92.eps ] ) , even if the value of @xmath4 increases to its maximum value of @xmath53 for the case @xmath33 . as will be explained later in detail ,
a stepwise behavior can be observed as well by using another observation variable .
all the characteristic phenomena are inherent to systems with multiple time scales .
( red solid line ) for driving forces ( blue dotted line ) with different amplitudes : ( a ) @xmath54 , ( b ) @xmath55 , ( c ) @xmath56 .
the corresponding stps appear on the unit circle in ( d ) , ( e ) , and ( f ) , respectively .
the length of the time series for plotting the stps is 1000 s. ] ( red solid line ) for driving forces ( blue dotted line ) with different amplitudes : ( a ) @xmath54 , ( b ) @xmath55 , ( c ) @xmath56 .
the corresponding stps appear on the unit circle in ( d ) , ( e ) , and ( f ) , respectively .
the length of the time series for plotting the stps is 1000 s. ] ( red solid line ) for driving forces ( blue dotted line ) with different amplitudes : ( a ) @xmath54 , ( b ) @xmath55 , ( c ) @xmath56 .
the corresponding stps appear on the unit circle in ( d ) , ( e ) , and ( f ) , respectively .
the length of the time series for plotting the stps is 1000 s. ] figures [ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](a)[fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](c ) show the time series of @xmath35 , together with the sinusoidal driving force . for a weak driving force with @xmath54 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](a ) , there is no synchronization between the spikes and the force . on the other hand ,
when @xmath55 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](b ) , the system exhibits phase synchronization , i.e. , a one - to - one correspondence between a single spike and one period of the driving force .
additionally , there are fluctuations in the inter - spike intervals ( isis ) .
therefore , this state is considered to be one that exhibits cps . in the case of a strong driving force with @xmath56 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](c ) , classic phase locking ( cpl ) is observed with two periodically alternating isis .
more precisely , each pair of successive spikes is observed at the same points in the period of the force . while the state shown in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](a ) does not exhibit phase synchronization in terms of stps , the states shown in figs .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](b ) and 3(c ) exhibit phase synchronization .
figures [ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](d)3(f ) show the stps on the unit circle for a certain time interval .
the length of the time series for plotting the stps is 1000 s. this length of the time series is sufficiently long to determine the localization of the distribution of the stps , as mentioned in the definition of the localization of the stps . in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](e ) , when @xmath55 , we can detect cps between the spikes and the force , because the stps are localized yet distributed on the unit circle . as shown in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](f ) , when @xmath56 , the cpl can be detected on the basis of the fact that all the stps are concentrated at two points on the unit circle .
this means that each pair of successive spikes completely synchronizes with two periods of the force .
however , no synchronization can be detected in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](d ) , when @xmath54 , because the stps are not localized . in other words
the entire circle is filled with stps . for @xmath54 ( blue dashed line ) , @xmath57 ( green dotted line ) , @xmath58 ( red solid line ) .
( b ) time series of @xmath35 ( red solid line ) with the periodic force ( blue dotted line ) for @xmath59 .
phase slips are observed in the region indicated by the dashed arrows.,height=188 ] for @xmath54 ( blue dashed line ) , @xmath57 ( green dotted line ) , @xmath58 ( red solid line ) .
( b ) time series of @xmath35 ( red solid line ) with the periodic force ( blue dotted line ) for @xmath59 .
phase slips are observed in the region indicated by the dashed arrows.,height=188 ] to confirm the cps , as shown in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](b ) , from another perspective , let us define the phase difference @xmath60 between the spiking oscillation and the driving force and then observe its time evolution for different values of @xmath4 around the transition point .
suppose that at each instance when the membrane potential exceeds the threshold value , the phase variable of the spiking oscillation , @xmath61 , increases by @xmath62 .
the instantaneous phase variable of the external force , @xmath63 , is determined at the spiking time without taking it to be modulo @xmath62 unlike @xmath41 considered in the case of stps in section [ model ] .
thus , the phase difference is defined as @xmath64 .
it should be noted that @xmath65 phase synchronization between spikes and the external force can be defined as @xmath66 figure [ fig : phaseslip.eps](a ) shows the time evolution of @xmath60 for @xmath54 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 . for @xmath54 ,
the time evolution of @xmath60 shows an oscillation with decreasing tendency . for @xmath59 ,
@xmath60 temporarily fluctuates within a bounded region ( plateau ) but sometimes exhibits a sudden phase slip . finally , for @xmath67
, @xmath60 always fluctuates within a bounded region ; that is , phase slip does not occur .
it should be noted that there exists a transition point to cps near @xmath67 .
therefore , we can confirm that the state shown in fig .
[ fig : noncpsk001o9.eps](b ) represents cps in the sense of the conventional definition , as well , given that @xmath55 is beyond the transition point .
it should also be noted that phase slips occur when the quiescent period of @xmath7 takes a relatively long time .
these slips are indicated by the dashed arrows in fig .
[ fig : phaseslip.eps](b ) . with respect to @xmath4 .
cps and cpl represent chaotic phase synchronization and classic phase locking , respectively.,height=170 ] let us clarify the route to phase synchronization by the dynamics of @xmath41 for the driving force at the @xmath43th spike , which is an angle of the stps on the unit circle . the bifurcation diagram for @xmath41 with respect to @xmath4
is shown in fig .
[ fig : worefractoriness.eps ] . for values of @xmath4 that are relatively small
, @xmath41 can take any value in the range between @xmath68 and @xmath62 , which means that cps does not occur ( a non - cps state ) .
after the first transition at @xmath69 , the value of @xmath41 is confined within a localized region .
first , we examine the system behavior around @xmath70 .
figure [ fig : criseso9.eps ] shows the return plots in the space @xmath71 .
the points shown in fig .
[ fig : criseso9.eps](b ) ( @xmath72 ) are distributed within a limited region , whereas the points shown in fig . [
fig : criseso9.eps](a ) ( @xmath73 ) are distributed throughout the entire space .
therefore , these plots imply that the system undergoes a boundary crisis @xcite . here , the crowding of points shown in fig .
[ fig : criseso9.eps](b ) represents cps ( a cps state ) as in the case of the localization of the stps on the unit circle , implying that phase slip does not occur .
moreover , the second transition at @xmath74 seems to be an interior crisis @xcite , which is indicated by the change between fig .
[ fig : criseso9.eps](c ) ( @xmath75 ) after the crisis and fig .
[ fig : criseso9.eps](d ) ( @xmath76 ) before the crisis . more precisely , the two disconnected attracting sets shown in fig .
[ fig : criseso9.eps](d ) are included in the single attractor shown in fig .
[ fig : criseso9.eps](c ) .
after the second transition , a typical sequence of inverse period - doubling bifurcations occurs . as a result , cpl ( a cpl state )
is observed in the regime where the driven system fires periodically . in the space @xmath71 for ( a ) @xmath73 , ( b ) @xmath72 , ( c ) @xmath75 , and ( d ) @xmath76.,height=245 ] around the phase transition point .
( b ) log - log plot of the average time intervals with respect to the difference between the parameter @xmath4 and its critical value @xmath77 .
the slopes represent the scaling exponents .
the results are averaged over 100 and 1000 different realizations for ( a ) and ( b ) , respectively.,height=188 ] around the phase transition point .
( b ) log - log plot of the average time intervals with respect to the difference between the parameter @xmath4 and its critical value @xmath77 .
the slopes represent the scaling exponents .
the results are averaged over 100 and 1000 different realizations for ( a ) and ( b ) , respectively.,height=188 ] we characterize the average time interval @xmath78 between two successive phase slips ( i.e. , the plateau length ) with respect to @xmath4 around the transition point , as shown in fig .
[ fig : sliploglog.eps](a ) @xcite .
figure [ fig : sliploglog.eps](b ) shows the log - log plot of @xmath79 in dependence on @xmath80 , where @xmath77 is the transition point to cps . here
, @xmath81 is approximately determined by the point at which the distribution of the stps begins to become localized .
we numerically find a power - law scaling @xmath82 , where the scaling constant suddenly changes from @xmath83 to @xmath84 .
although the range of the scaling region is relatively short , this scaling behavior is clearly different from that observed for a system with a single time scale .
the scaling behavior with a single time scale is related to type - i intermittency and is described by @xmath85 @xcite .
in general , for a periodically driven chaotic system with a single time scale and a single rotation center , a simplified mapping model can explain the transition to cps between the system and the driving force .
in the map model , the boundary between the synchronization state and the non - synchronization state is explained by a saddle - node bifurcation of unstable and stable periodic orbits of the map @xcite .
however , in the present system , phase locking can not simply be related to a saddle - node bifurcation , because multiple time scales exist .
that is , the spiking period is characterized by fast oscillations , related to the variables @xmath7 and @xmath20 , and the quiescent period is characterized by slow oscillations , related to the variable @xmath13 .
hence , the dynamics of the system on the threshold , which corresponds to the map model , is affected by both the fast and the slow oscillations .
therefore , the mechanism of a sudden change in the scaling law differs from the case of a single time scale but is still an open problem . as a function of @xmath4 .
the dashed line indicates @xmath81 or the transition point to cps .
( b ) enlargement of ( a ) for @xmath86 .
it should be noted that @xmath87 denotes the step region before the transition to cps .
the results are averaged over 1000 different realizations.,height=170 ] as a function of @xmath4 .
the dashed line indicates @xmath81 or the transition point to cps .
( b ) enlargement of ( a ) for @xmath86 .
it should be noted that @xmath87 denotes the step region before the transition to cps .
the results are averaged over 1000 different realizations.,height=170 ] the distribution of the stps is now used to detect phase synchronization . in order to quantify the degree of phase synchronization , we employ kuramoto s order parameter defined as @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the number of stps @xcite .
the parameter @xmath3 satisfies @xmath90 .
this corresponds to the amplitude of an average of stps .
the more localized the distribution of the stps is , the greater is the value of @xmath3 .
figure [ fig : worefracop.eps](a ) shows the order parameter @xmath3 as a function of @xmath4 , with @xmath3 averaged over 1000 different realizations for a time interval of 1000 s. the transition point @xmath81 to cps is denoted by the dashed line in fig .
[ fig : worefracop.eps](a ) .
we find that a stepwise behavior precedes the transition to cps , with the step region @xmath87 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : worefracop.eps](b ) .
this stepwise behavior indicates that there exists a region between the non - cps state and the cps state , where the degree of synchronization is not sensitive to @xmath4 .
in addition , @xmath3 decreases just before the transition point . to the best of our knowledge ,
such a stepwise behavior in the transition has not been observed for cps in coupled systems with a single time scale . in what follows
, we will explain how the stepwise transition and the decrease in @xmath3 are related to the existence of both the slow and the fast dynamics in the present system .
in particular , we will investigate the probability density distribution of @xmath41 at @xmath91 with @xmath92 , as indicated in fig .
[ fig : worefracop.eps](b ) . figure [ fig : p_theta_o9_2.eps ] shows the shape of the probability density distributions @xmath93 of the stps on the unit circle , i.e. , the distributions of @xmath41 for @xmath94 and for @xmath95 .
it should be noted that cps is not detected in either case ; that is , the points are well distributed around the circle .
however , we can find a peak in the probability density distribution for @xmath96 , whereas the distribution for @xmath97 is almost uniform .
the appearance of the peak , as shown in fig .
[ fig : p_theta_o9_2.eps ] , and a shift in the peak in the step region @xmath87 , as explained in appendix [ mech ] , are two consecutive stages that constitute the entire stepwise phenomenon . in the first stage , with an increase in @xmath4 from zero to a value near @xmath98 , a peak in @xmath93 of the stps emerges near @xmath99 .
then , in the second stage , the position of the peak shifts because of the effect of slow dynamics , i.e. , an increase in the number of short inter - burst intervals . during the shift of the peak ,
@xmath3 does not change very significantly because the value of @xmath4 varies in @xmath87 .
thus , the step region can be observed .
these two stages are investigated in detail in appendix [ mech ] . for @xmath54 ( red solid line ) and
@xmath100 ( green dashed line).,height=170 ] in the above results , we have primarily investigated the @xmath0 phase synchronization between the spikes and each period of the driving force , wherein quiescent periods disappear for the values of @xmath4 after phase synchronization . on the other hand ,
when the frequency of the driving force is @xmath101 hz , the quiescent periods do not disappear even if the amplitude @xmath4 increases to the same level as in the case @xmath102 hz .
it should be noted that the @xmath0 cpl can be observed for a sufficiently large @xmath4 , e.g. , @xmath103 . for values of @xmath104 , @xmath105 phase synchronization can not be clearly observed between the spikes and the driving force .
however , if we define @xmath106 at the time when @xmath7 approaches the minimum voltage in each specific quiescent period , where @xmath7 decreases under the threshold @xmath107 , we can detect cps in the sense of localization of the distribution of @xmath106 on the unit circle .
it is important to note that the change in the order parameter ( derived from @xmath106 ) with respect to @xmath4 does not depend on the value of @xmath108 , sensitively . in other words ,
the value of @xmath108 that is less than approximately @xmath109 causes a stepwise transition in the order parameter for @xmath110 hz using @xmath106 , as shown below .
figure [ fig : wrefractoriness.eps](a ) shows the bifurcation diagram of @xmath106 depending on @xmath4 .
we also observe a stepwise behavior before a transition to the cps in the variation of the order parameter computed from @xmath106 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : wrefractoriness.eps](b ) .
moreover , in the region of cps , fine tuning of @xmath4 yields @xmath1 cpl between a burst and @xmath2 periods of the force , where @xmath111 , etc .
figure [ fig : plk302o92.eps ] shows @xmath112 cpl for @xmath113 . with respect to @xmath4 .
( b ) the corresponding values of the order parameter @xmath3 .
the inset shows a magnified image for @xmath114 .
the results are averaged over 1000 different realizations.,height=170 ] with respect to @xmath4 .
( b ) the corresponding values of the order parameter @xmath3 .
the inset shows a magnified image for @xmath114 .
the results are averaged over 1000 different realizations.,height=170 ]
we have investigated cps in a spiking - bursting neuron model under periodic forcing with a small amplitude but with a frequency as high as that of the spikes .
first , we observed @xmath0 cps between the spikes and the periodic force .
this cps has been detected on the basis of the fact that a set of points , which are conditioned by the phases of the periodic force at each spiking time , was concentrated on a sector of the unit circle .
in addition to cps , we observed two characteristic phenomena around the transition point to cps .
one phenomenon involves a change in the power - law scaling for the average time intervals between phase slips , as shown in fig .
[ fig : sliploglog.eps](b ) .
this scaling behavior is different from that exhibited by the conventional system , i.e. , a chaotic system whose attractor has a single rotation center with only one characteristic time scale . in such a conventional system ,
the scaling exponent for the transition to cps takes a unique value of @xmath115 .
this might be because the phase synchronization in question can not be simply associated with a saddle - node bifurcation , owing to the interaction between the slow and the fast dynamics .
the other phenomenon shows a stepwise behavior before the transition to cps , as shown in fig .
[ fig : worefracop.eps](b ) .
this phenomenon has been found by the observation that the degree of phase synchronization is not sensitive to the amplitude of the force just before the transition point .
moreover , we found that a decrease in the degree of synchronization appears ( at @xmath116 in fig .
[ fig : worefracop.eps](b ) ) even if the amplitude of the force is increased .
the stepwise behavior and this decrease could be induced by the effect of slow dynamics ( see appendix [ mech ] ) . from the viewpoint of neuroscience
, our system might be regarded as a simple model whose fast driving force corresponds to sharp wave - ripples .
this phenomenon involves a very fast oscillation of local field potentials observed in the hippocampus in the brain @xcite .
let us discuss , below , a possible interpretation of our results in terms of synchronization phenomena in real neuronal systems .
first , the observed phenomena in our model , particularly cps with a fast driving force , can be interpreted as a consequence of the interaction between the ripples and the activity of a single neuron .
in fact , it has been experimentally shown that such ripples synchronize in phase with the spikes of a single neuron @xcite .
furthermore , it has been suggested that firing sequences accompanying ripples in the hippocampal network form a representation of stored information .
the replay of the firing sequences during sleep mediates a consolidation of memory for the stored information in the hippocampus and the neocortex @xcite .
in addition , some experimental results have indicated that such a memory replay is conducted on a shorter time scale than the actual experience , where the spatiotemporal structure of the firing sequences plays a key role in the stored information @xcite .
thus , if our spiking - bursting system with a fast driving force can be regarded as a model for such biological neurons , our result would imply that the precision of the temporal structure of the spiking patterns might be enhanced by cps in real neuronal systems .
it should be noticed that cps is not affected even if there exist small fluctuations in isis and that cps extends the detection of the temporal structures of the firing patterns in the short time scale of a spiking - bursting behavior .
additionally , from another point of view , the slow oscillations along the lower envelope of the membrane potential @xmath7 can be considered as transitions between the up and down states in a cortical neuron .
specifically , we focus on the up and down states during the slow - wave sleep . here , the neurons in the up state fire synchronously with higher frequency , whereas the activity of the neurons in the down state is relatively quiescent @xcite . from this perspective , the disappearance of the quiescent periods ( down states ) in the forced spiking in our simulation may be interpreted as a persistently depolarized up state observed for cortical neurons in the awake states . in fact , the prolonged down states during sleep are likely to occur owing to a decrease in the excitatory input @xcite . therefore ,
if this input can be regarded as our sinusoidal driving force , cps may efficiently help a weak input to depolarize a down state into a persistent up one .
_ reported that a neural network model can qualitatively reproduce the experimental results in @xcite using a time - discrete map model , which is simpler than our model @xcite .
therefore , we may infer that our results on cps at high frequency in the simple spiking - busting neuron model provide some suggestions for neuroscience to understand the mechanisms of the abovementioned real neuronal activity , particularly in terms of nonlinear dynamics .
the following topics might be considered from the viewpoint of extending this study .
first , for the future study it would be important to confirm whether our findings can be observed in other slow - fast models such as the hindmarsh - rose model @xcite and other biophysical models @xcite .
a comparison with the other models will provide further insight into slow - fast dynamics in the neuronal spiking - bursting activity .
moreover , it should be important to clarify the general onset mechanism of the observed phenomena using map - based models , as was clarified in @xcite .
it should also be important to investigate the response of coupled bursting systems to sinusoidal forcing in terms of the interaction between the slow and the fast dynamics .
the authors are grateful to prof .
m. tatsuno , prof .
h. hata , prof .
m. baptista , dr .
k. morita , dr .
s. kang , and dr .
g. tanaka for their valuable suggestions .
this work is partly supported by aihara complexity modelling project , erato , jst , and the ministry of education , science , sports and culture , grant - in - aid for scientific research no .
21800089 and no .
20246026 , and the aihara project , the first program from jsps , initiated by cstp , and grants of the german research foundation ( dfg ) in the research group for 868 computational modeling of behavioral , cognitive , and neural dynamics .
in what follows , we explain how @xmath3 increases toward the step region in fig . [
fig : worefracop.eps](b ) and how it does not increase in the step region @xmath87 .
these phenomena can be explained on the basis of the changes in peaks in the probability distribution @xmath93 as follows .
first , we investigate the quiescent periods in terms of the extent in the decrease in @xmath7 , i.e. , the extent of hyperpolarization , with an increase in @xmath4 . as shown in fig .
[ fig : times_relax_o9.eps](a ) , we observe two types of hyperpolarizations in the quiescent periods , namely , shallow and deep hyperpolarizations , when @xmath117 .
shallow hyperpolarizations are observed between @xmath118 and @xmath119 , whereas deep hyperpolarizations are observed below @xmath120 .
therefore , the two types of hyperpolarizations are distinguished by two appropriate thresholds for @xmath7 , i.e. , @xmath121 and @xmath122 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : times_relax_o9.eps](a ) .
the threshold @xmath123 detects both the shallow and the deep hyperpolarizations , whereas the threshold @xmath124 detects only deep hyperpolarization .
figure [ fig : times_relax_o9.eps](b ) shows the ratio of shallow and deep hyperpolarizations over all the hyperpolarizations detected by @xmath123 as a function of @xmath4 , when counted in the interval of @xmath125 s and summed over @xmath126 different realizations . with two thresholds , @xmath121 ( blue dashed line ) and @xmath122 ( green dashed - dotted line ) , for @xmath36 .
( b ) the ratio of shallow ( green dashed - dotted line ) and deep ( blue dashed line ) hyperpolarizations with respect to @xmath4 . the results for ( b ) are averaged over 100 different realizations . also shown
is @xmath3 ( red solid line ) .
, height=170 ] with two thresholds , @xmath121 ( blue dashed line ) and @xmath122 ( green dashed - dotted line ) , for @xmath36 .
( b ) the ratio of shallow ( green dashed - dotted line ) and deep ( blue dashed line ) hyperpolarizations with respect to @xmath4 . the results for ( b ) are averaged over 100 different realizations . also shown
is @xmath3 ( red solid line ) .
, height=170 ] as shown in fig .
[ fig : times_relax_o9.eps](b ) , the number of deep hyperpolarizations ( blue dashed line ) decreases with an increase in @xmath4 .
this implies that the number of longer isis corresponding to deep hyperpolarizations decreases , and this decrease is related to an emergence of a peak in @xmath93 , as explained below .
let @xmath127 be the length of the isi between the @xmath43th spike and the @xmath128th spike .
then , figs .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](a)((c ) ) and ( b)((d ) ) show the time series of @xmath41 and @xmath127 for @xmath36 ( @xmath129 ) , respectively . in fig .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](c ) , we observe gradually shifting envelopes for the oscillations of @xmath41 , as indicated by the dotted rectangles , whereas no such specific tendency is observed in fig .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](a ) .
the gradual shifts in the envelope occur during the time intervals other than those during which deep hyperpolarization is observed , which are indicated by the double - headed arrows in fig .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](d ) .
it should be noted that deep hyperpolarization corresponds to the oscillations of @xmath127 exceeding @xmath130 and that fig .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](b ) shows a greater number of deep hyperpolarizations than those shown in ( d ) .
these observations give rise to a change in the shape of @xmath93 in fig .
[ fig : p_theta_o9_2.eps ] .
that is , @xmath93 is uniformly distributed for @xmath36 , owing to the fluctuation of @xmath41 with a few gradually shifting envelopes , as shown in fig .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](a ) . on the other hand
, @xmath93 has a peak for @xmath129 , attributed to the gradually shifting envelopes , as shown in fig .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](c ) .
the region for the envelopes is around @xmath131 and corresponds to the peak of @xmath93 in fig .
[ fig : p_theta_o9_2.eps ] .
this appearance of the peak in @xmath93 is attributed to the decrease in the number of deep hyperpolarizations , as seen in figs .
[ fig : ts_thetaisik005o9.eps](b ) and ( d ) .
( a)((c ) ) and @xmath127 ( b)((d ) ) for @xmath36 ( @xmath129 ) .
the regions indicated by the double - headed arrows in ( d ) correspond to the bursting periods other than the period of deep hyperpolarizations.,height=188 ] ( a)((c ) ) and @xmath127 ( b)((d ) ) for @xmath36 ( @xmath129 ) .
the regions indicated by the double - headed arrows in ( d ) correspond to the bursting periods other than the period of deep hyperpolarizations.,height=188 ] we explain how @xmath3 as a function of @xmath4 remains flat in @xmath87 . figure [ fig : times_relax_o9.eps](b ) shows that the number of shallow hyperpolarizations increases with an increase in @xmath4 in @xmath87 , as well ( green dashed - dotted line ) . in order to investigate the increase in shallow hyperpolarizations in @xmath87
, we consider the distribution of the isis .
figure [ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](a ) shows the distribution of isis for @xmath135 , and @xmath136 , denoted by @xmath137 , and @xmath138 , respectively . in this figure
, we can observe peaks located at @xmath139}$ ] , as indicated by ( i ) in fig .
[ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](a ) .
these peaks correspond to shallow hyperpolarizations and become prominent at the right edge of @xmath87 .
furthermore , for each @xmath4 , the distribution of isis has two other peaks at smaller values of @xmath127 , as indicated by ( ii ) in fig .
[ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](a ) .
these peaks can be inferred from the time series of voltage @xmath35 for a value of @xmath4 in @xmath87 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : ts_k0063_o9.eps ] . as can be seen in the interval of @xmath140 between @xmath141 s and @xmath142 s , there exists a transient @xmath143 phase synchronization between one burst and three periods of the force .
the peaks located near @xmath139}$ ] in fig .
[ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](a ) correspond to the inter - burst intervals during such a transient phase synchronization .
in contrast , the two other peaks at small @xmath127 indicated by ( ii ) in fig . [ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](a ) correspond to the two isis for the three consecutive spikes in each burst .
we also calculate the corresponding distributions of @xmath41 , as shown in fig .
[ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](b ) . the peaks in the distribution of @xmath127
are related to the peaks in @xmath93 .
the second and the third spikes in each burst during the transient @xmath143 phase synchronization correspond to the peaks in @xmath93 around @xmath144 and @xmath145 ( ( iii ) and ( iv ) in fig .
[ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](b ) ) , respectively .
it should be noted that for @xmath146 , the distribution of @xmath93 is concentrated , with a large peak ( unimodal ) located near @xmath147}$ ] .
then , for @xmath116 , that peak is weakened and other peaks ( multimodal ) appear near @xmath148 and @xmath145 .
the shift in the peak in the distribution of @xmath93 from unimodal to multimodal does not significantly influence the amplitude of the average of the stps whose distribution on the unit circle reflects the shape of @xmath93 .
therefore , the value of the order parameter @xmath3 does not increase in @xmath87 .
however , as @xmath4 increases further , the peak located at @xmath149 becomes higher , while @xmath3 increases steeply , and the transition to cps occurs . finally , looking at figs .
[ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](a ) and [ fig : p_isi_o9_2.eps](b ) in more detail , we find that the peaks in both @xmath150 and @xmath93 for @xmath151 are sharper than those for @xmath152 and @xmath138 .
the sharpness of the peaks corresponds to the duration of the transient @xmath143 phase synchronization .
in fact , the contribution to @xmath3 from the newly emerged peaks in @xmath93 around @xmath153 and @xmath154 is the greatest when @xmath155 . on the other hand ,
the contribution of the first concentrated peak around @xmath156 decreases at that value of @xmath4 . as a consequence ,
even though @xmath4 increases , which would normally cause the degree of synchronization to increase , the value of @xmath3 decreases near @xmath116
. a similar phenomenon has been reported as anomalous phase synchronization , whereby coupling among interacting oscillator systems increases the natural frequency disorder before synchronization @xcite .
we take different realizations in order to smooth out the averaged curves in our numerical simulations , where the different realizations with respect to different initial conditions are statistically equivalent as their long - time average due to the ergodicity . for different realizations ,
we choose random initial values of @xmath7 from the distribution @xmath158 , i.e. , the normal distribution with average @xmath159 and variance @xmath160 , and fixed initial values of @xmath161 , and exclude transient processes for the averaging . by intensive simulations for @xmath79 in the region where parameter @xmath4 is closer to the transition point , we are able to numerically observe another power - law scaling that is similar to the case of the transition to chaotic phase synchronization for a system that has a single rotation center , with only one characteristic time scale
. however , further investigations are needed to confirm whether this scaling corresponds to the conventional case . | we investigate the entrainment of a neuron model exhibiting a chaotic spiking - bursting behavior in response to a weak periodic force .
this model exhibits two types of oscillations with different characteristic time scales , namely , long and short time scales .
several types of phase synchronization are observed , such as @xmath0 phase locking between a single spike and one period of the force and @xmath1 phase locking between the period of slow oscillation underlying bursts and @xmath2 periods of the force .
moreover , spiking - bursting oscillations with chaotic firing patterns can be synchronized with the periodic force .
such a type of phase synchronization is detected from the position of a set of points on a unit circle , which is determined by the phase of the periodic force at each spiking time .
we show that this detection method is effective for a system with multiple time scales .
owing to the existence of both the short and the long time scales , two characteristic phenomena are found around the transition point to chaotic phase synchronization .
one phenomenon shows that the average time interval between successive phase slips exhibits a power - law scaling against the driving force strength and that the scaling exponent has an unsmooth dependence on the changes in the driving force strength .
the other phenomenon shows that kuramoto s order parameter before the transition exhibits stepwise behavior as a function of the driving force strength , contrary to the smooth transition in a model with a single time scale . |
confronting nuclear physics , we should highlight the great importance of the equation of state ( eos ) , for it being significantly important to study the structure of nuclei , the reaction dynamics of heavy - ion collisions , and many issues in astrophysics @xcite .
the nuclear eos consists usually of two ingredients : the energy density for symmetric matter and the density dependence of the symmetry energy . for the former ,
the saturation properties are quite clear nowadays , though its high - density behavior remains to be revealed in more details .
however , the density dependence of the symmetry energy is still poorly known especially at high densities @xcite , and even the trend of the density dependence of the symmetry energy can be predicted to be contrary . while most relativistic theories @xcite and some non - relativistic theories @xcite predict that the symmetry energy increases continuously at all densities , many other non - relativistic theories ( for instance , see @xcite ) , in contrast , predict that the symmetry energy first increases , then decreases above certain supra - saturation densities , and even in some predictions @xcite becomes negative at high densities , referred as the super - soft symmetry energy .
therefore , the experimental extraction is of necessity .
recently , by analyzing the fopi / gsi data on the @xmath0 radio in relativistic heavy - ion collisions @xcite , the evidence for a super - soft symmetry energy was found @xcite .
this finding can result in many consequences , while a direct challenge is how to stabilize a normal neutron star with the super - soft symmetry energy .
conventionally , a mechanical instability may occur if the symmetry energy starts decreasing quickly above the certain supra - saturation density @xcite . to solve this problem , one possible way
is to take into account the hadron - quark phase transition which lifts up the pressure in pure quark matter @xcite , while the transition is expected to occur at much higher densities within a narrow region of parameters .
instead , one may consider the possible correction to the gravity . though the gravitational force was first discovered in the history , it is still the most poorly characterized , compared to three other fundamental forces that can be favorably unified within the gauge theory . for the further grand unification of four forces , the correction to the conventional gravity seems necessary .
the light u - boson , which is proposed beyond the standard model , can play the role in deviating from the inverse square law of the gravity due to the yukawa - type coupling , see refs .
@xcite and references therein .
this light u - boson was used as the interaction propagator of the mev dark matter and was used to account for the bright 511 kev @xmath1-ray from the galactic bulge @xcite . as a consequence of its weak coupling to baryons , the stable neutron star can be obtained in the presence of the super - soft symmetry energy @xcite .
in addition , it is noted that through the reanalysis of the fopi / gsi data with a different dynamical model another group extracted a contrary density dependent trend of the symmetry energy at high densities @xcite .
the solution of the controversy is still in progress . in pursuit of the covariance in addressing neutron stars bound by the strong gravity , the relativistic models are favorable to obtain the eos , though the fraction , arisen from the relativistic effect of fast particles in the compact core of neutron stars ,
is just moderate .
apart from the non - relativistic models to obtain the eos of neutron stars in ref .
@xcite , we will adopt the relativistic mean - field ( rmf ) models in this work . the rmf theory which is based on the dirac equations for nucleons with the potentials given by the meson exchanges achieved great success in the past few decades @xcite .
the original lagrangian of the rmf model was first proposed by walecka more than 30 years ago @xcite .
the walecka model and its improved versions were characteristic of the cancellation between the big attractive scalar field and the big repulsive vector field . to soften the eos obtained with the simple walecka model
, the proper medium effects were accounted with the inclusion of the nonlinear self - interactions of the @xmath2 meson proposed by boguta et .
a few successful nonlinear rmf models , such as nl1 @xcite , nl2 @xcite , nl - sh @xcite , nl3 @xcite , and etc . , had been obtained by fitting saturation properties and ground - state properties of a few spherical nuclei .
later on , an extension to include the self - interaction of @xmath3 meson was implemented to obtain rmf potentials which were required to be consistent with the dirac - brueckner self - energies @xcite . in this direction , besides the early model tm1
@xcite , there were recent versions pk1 @xcite and fsugold @xcite .
although various rmf models reproduce successfully the saturation properties of nuclear matter and structural properties of finite nuclei , the corresponding eos s may behave quite differently at high densities especially in isospin - asymmetric nuclear matter .
it was reported in the literature @xcite that the light u - boson can significantly modify the eos in isospin - asymmetric matter .
however , the further systematic work to analyze the effect of the light u - boson on various nuclear eos s is still absent . in this work
, we will investigate in detail the effect of light u - boson on the eos and properties of neutron stars with various rmf models .
in particular , we will address the difference of the effects induced by the u - boson in various rmf models .
the paper is organized as follows . in sec .
[ rmf ] , we present briefly the formalism based on the lagrangian of the relativistic mean - field models . in sec . [ results ] , numerical results and discussions are presented .
at last , a summary is given in sec .
[ summary ] .
in the rmf approach , the nucleon - nucleon interaction is usually described via the exchange of three mesons : the isoscalar meson @xmath4 , which provides the medium - range attraction between the nucleons , the isoscalar - vector meson @xmath5 , which offers the short - range repulsion , and the isovector - vector meson @xmath6 , which accounts for the isospin dependence of the nuclear force .
the relativistic lagrangian can be written as : & = & [ i_^-m+g_-g _ _
^-g___3 b_0^ ] + & & - f_f^+ m_^2_^ - b _ b^ + m_^2 b_0 b_0^ + & & + ( _ ^-m_^2 ^ 2 ) + u_eff ( , , b_0)+l_u , [ eq : lag1 ] where @xmath7,@xmath6 are the fields of the nucleon , scalar , vector , and neutral isovector - vector mesons , with their masses @xmath8 , and @xmath9 , respectively .
@xmath10 are the corresponding meson - nucleon couplings . @xmath11 and @xmath12 are the strength tensors of @xmath5 and @xmath13 mesons respectively , @xmath14 the self - interacting terms of @xmath2 , @xmath5 mesons and the isoscalar - isovector coupling are given generally as u_eff(,^ , b_0^)&=&-g_2 ^ 3-g_3 ^ 4 + c_3(_^)^2 + & & + 4_vg^2_g_^2 _ ^b_0b_0^. [ eq : u ] here , the isoscalar - isovector coupling term is introduced to modify the density dependence of the symmetry energy @xcite .
in addition , we include in lagrangian @xmath15 for the u - boson that is beyond the standard model .
a very light u - boson can be utilized to interpret the deviation from the newton s gravitational potential which is usually characterized in the form @xcite : v(r)=-(1+e^-r/ ) [ grav]where @xmath16 is the universal gravitational constant , @xmath17 is a dimensionless strength parameter with @xmath18 and @xmath19 being the boson - nucleon coupling constant and baryon mass , respectively , and @xmath20 is the length scale with @xmath21 being the boson mass . according to the conventional view , the yukawa - type correction to the newtonian gravity resides at the matter part rather than the geometric part .
thus , following the form of the vector meson , @xmath15 is written as : _ u&=&-g_u_u^-u
_ u^ + m_u^2u_u^ , with @xmath22 the field of u - boson .
@xmath23 is the strength tensor of u - boson , @xmath24 with the standard euler - lagrange formala , we can deduce from the lagrangian the equations of motion for the nucleon and mesons .
they are given as follows : = 0 ( _ t^2-^2+m_^2)&=&g_-g_2 ^ 2-g_3 ^ 3 , + ( _ t^2-^2+m_^2)_&=&g__- c_3_^3 + & & -8_v g_^2g_^2b_0 b_0^ _ , + ( _ t^2-^2+m_^2)b_0&=&g _ _ _ 3 + & & -8_v g_^2g_^2 _ ^b_0 , + ( _ t^2-^2+m_u^2)u_&=&g_u_. in the mean - field approximation , all derivative terms drop out and the expectation values of space - like components of vector fields vanish ( only zero components survive ) due to translational invariance and rotational symmetry of the nuclear matter .
in addition , only the third component of isovector fields survives because of the charge conservation . in the mean - field approximation ,
after the dirac field of nucleons is quantized @xcite , the fields of mesons and u - boson , which are replaced by their classical expectation values , obey following equations : m_^2&=&g__s - g_2 ^ 2-g_3 ^ 3 , + m_^2_0&=&g__b - c_3_0 ^ 3 - 8_v g_^2g_^2b_0 ^ 2_0 , + m_^2b_0&=&g__3 - 8_v g_^2g_^2 _ 0 ^ 2b_0 , + m_u^2u_0&=&g_u_b , where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the scalar and baryon densities , respectively , and @xmath27 is the difference between the proton and neutron densities , namely , @xmath28 .
the set of coupled equations can be solved self - consistently using the iteration method . with these mean - field quantities ,
the resulting energy density @xmath29 and pressure @xmath30 are written as : & = & _ i = p , n^k_f_i d^3k e^*_i+ m_^2_0 ^ 2+_b^2 + & & + m_^2_0 ^ 2+m_^2 b_0 ^ 2 + g_2 ^ 3+g_3 ^ 4 + & & + c_3_0 ^ 4 + 12_vg^2_g_^2 _ 0 ^ 2 b_0 ^ 2,[eq : e ] + p&=&_i = p , n^k_f_i d^3k + m_^2_0 ^ 2 + _
b^2 + & & -m_^2_0 ^ 2+m_^2 b_0 ^ 2 -g_2 ^ 3-g_3 ^ 4 + & & + c_3_0 ^ 4 + 4_vg^2_g_^2 _ 0 ^ 2 b_0 ^ 2 , [ eq : p]with @xmath31 .
given above is the formalism for nuclear matter without considering the @xmath32 equilibrium . for asymmetric nuclear matter at @xmath32 equilibrium ,
the chemical equilibrium and charge neutrality conditions need to be additionally considered , which are written as : _
n&=&_p+_e , + _ e&=&_p , + _ b&=&_n+_p , where @xmath33 are the chemical potential of neutron , proton and electron , respectively , and @xmath34 is the number density of electrons . in neutron star matter , the eos is obtained by adding in eqs.([eq : e ] ) and ( [ eq : p ] ) the contribution of the free electron gas .
the neutron star properties are obtained from solving the tolman - oppenheimer - volkoff ( tov ) equation @xcite : @xmath35[m(r)+4\pi r^3 p(r ) ] } { r(r-2m(r))},\label{eq : tov1}\\ m(r)&=&4\pi\int^r_0d\!\tilde{r}\tilde{r}^2 \vep(\tilde{r}),\label{eq : tov2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath36 is the radial coordinate from the center of the star , @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the pressure and energy density at position @xmath36 , respectively , and @xmath39 is the mass contained in the sphere of the radius @xmath36 . note that here we use units for which the gravitation constant is @xmath40 .
the radius @xmath41 and mass @xmath42 of a neutron star are obtained from the condition @xmath43 . because the neutron star matter , consisting of neutrons , protons , and electrons ( npe ) at @xmath44 equilibrium in this work , undergoes a phase transition from the homogeneous matter to the inhomogeneous matter at the low density region , the rmf eos obtained from the homogeneous matter does not apply to the low density region . for a thorough description of neutron stars ,
we thus adopt the empirical low - density eos in the literature @xcite .
among a number of nonlinear rmf parametrizations , we select several typical best - fit parameter sets , for instance nl1 @xcite , nl - sh @xcite , nl3 @xcite , tm1 @xcite and fsugold @xcite , to investigate the effects of the u - boson on the eos of isospin - asymmetric nuclear matter and properties of neutron stars .
the nonlinear rmf models usually include the nonlinear self - interactions of the @xmath2 meson to simulate appropriate medium dependence of the strong interaction .
this is typical in rmf parameter sets nl1 , nl - sh and nl3 .
in addition to the nonlinear @xmath2 meson self - interactions , in tm1 and fsugold the nonlinear self - interaction of the @xmath3 meson is also included .
parameters and saturation properties of these parameter sets are listed in table [ t : t1 ] . [
cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] ( upper panel ) and pressure p ( lower panel ) as a function of density with various rmf parameter sets , nl3 , nl1 , nl - sh , tm1 , and fsugold in npe matter at @xmath32 equilibrium .
[ f : rho],width=321,height=321 ] in fig .
[ f : rho ] , the energy density and pressure of npe matter at @xmath32 equilibrium are shown as a function of nucleon density for various models without the inclusion of the u - boson .
it is seen that the eos with parameter sets tm1 and fsugold is clearly softer than that with the nl1 , nl - sh and nl3 with the increase of the density .
the softening stems from the inclusion of the nonlinear self - interaction of the @xmath5 meson that lowers the repulsion provided by the @xmath3 meson at high densities , while the excess softening with the fsugold as compared to that with the tm1 can be attributed dominately to the larger parameter @xmath45 in fsugold
. equilibrium with various rmf models .
[ ep0],width=321,height=321 ] shown in fig .
[ ep0 ] is the correlation between the pressure and the energy density given in fig .
[ f : rho ] .
this correlation is usually regarded as the eos that is used as the input of the tolman - oppenheimer - volkoff ( tov ) equation @xcite for the evaluation of the neutron star properties .
once again , we see the large deviations in the eos with different rmf models especially at high densities . in the following
, it is thus interesting to see how the u - boson affects the eos produced by various rmf models that differs largely at high densities . in units of @xmath46 .
[ epnl],width=321,height=385 ] but for the rmf models tm1 and fsugold.[eptf],width=321,height=321 ] in the rmf approximation , the contribution of the u - boson in a linear form is just decided by the ratio of the coupling constant to its mass , i.e. , @xmath47 , as seen in eqs.([eq : e ] ) and ( [ eq : p ] ) . in figs .
[ epnl ] and [ eptf ] , the eos s with various models are depicted for a set of ratios @xmath48 .
it is shown in figs .
[ epnl ] and [ eptf ] that the inclusion of the u - boson stiffens the eos .
this is physically obvious since the vector form of the u - boson provides an excess repulsion in addition to the vector mesons , whereas an interestingly large difference appears for different types of models . as shown in figs .
[ epnl ] and [ eptf ] , the eos s with the tm1 and fsugold acquires a much more apparent stiffening than that with the nl1 , nl - sh and nl3 by including the u - boson .
this phenomenon can be understood by the inherent feature of these models . in models
nl1 , nl - sh and nl3 , the repulsion is quadratic in the density because the nonlinear self - interaction of the @xmath5 meson is not considered . with the increase of the density , the repulsion provided by the @xmath3 meson dominates the attraction provided by the @xmath2 meson .
the cancellation between the repulsion and attraction in the pressure ( see eq.([eq : p ] ) is not prominent at high densities so that the u - boson plays a similar role in the energy density and pressure .
thus , these eos s are just moderately modified by the u - boson , as shown in fig .
[ epnl ] . for models
tm1 and fsugold that feature a clearly softer eos at high densities , the cancellation between the repulsion and attraction becomes significant and thus sharpens the importance of the u - boson in the pressure .
comparing to the addition of the big repulsion and attraction in the energy density , the u - boson just plays a marginal role in modifying the energy density .
thus , the u - boson can modify appreciably the correlation between the pressure and energy density in the high - density region in favorably softened models , for instance , the tm1 and fsugold , as shown in fig .
[ eptf ] . because in tm1 and fsugold the nonlinear term of the @xmath5 meson plays a decisive role in softening the eos , the larger the parameter @xmath45 , the more apparent the modification , as shown comparatively in the upper and lower panels of fig .
[ eptf ] .
but to exhibit the difference between the cases with and without the modification to the symmetry energy . left panels represent the results with the nl3 and nl3@xmath49 , and right panels are the results with the tm1 and tm1@xmath49 .
different density dependencies of the symmetry energy are drawn in the insets of upper panels , while given in the insets of lower panels are the eos of two cases in the absence of the u - boson .
[ epnl3],width=321,height=321 ] in addition , it is interesting to examine whether the significant difference in the u - boson - induced modification to the eos can be created by softening the symmetry energy .
the symmetry energy is softened by including the isoscalar - isovector coupling term in rmf models ( see eq.([eq : u ] ) ) . in fig .
[ epnl3 ] , we depict the eos without ( upper panels ) and with ( lower panels ) the softening of the symmetry energy in nl3 and tm1
. however , no visible difference in two cases with the nl3 is observed , and with the tm1 the difference is not significant .
this observation seems to show a contrast with that in ref .
@xcite where the fluffy eos due to the super - soft symmetry energy can be lifted up by the u - boson to support a normal neutron star . in deed , the magnitude of the modification to the eos caused by the u - boson relies on the softness of the eos .
as long as the eos is modified significantly by softening the symmetry energy , the stiffening role of the u - boson in the eos can be considerably enhanced accordingly .
given that the stiff eos with the nl3 is little modified by softening the symmetry energy , as shown in the inset of the left lower panel in fig .
[ epnl3 ] , the softening of the symmetry energy can scarcely affect the role of the u - boson . for models with a softer eos
, the situation can turn out to be different when the eos is modified appreciably by softening the symmetry energy .
indeed , the vital role of the u - boson in the eos of the non - relativistic mdi model with a super - soft symmetry energy @xcite is a typical case that the role of the u - boson can be largely amplified due to the softening of the symmetry energy . in rmf models , for instance ,
the tm1 whose eos is softer than that with the nl3 , the softening of the symmetry energy can also result in some visible difference in the eos and thereby the role of the u - boson , as shown in right panels of fig .
[ epnl3 ] .
.[mr],width=321,height=302 ] next , we turn to the consequences in hydrostatic neutron stars with the eos modified by the u - boson . using eqs.([eq : tov1 ] ) and ( [ eq : tov2 ] ) , the mass and radius of hydrostatic neutron stars can be obtained with the given eos . in fig .
[ mr ] , the mass - radius ( m - r ) relation of neutron stars is depicted with different ratio parameter @xmath48 for the u - boson in various models . with the inclusion of the u - boson
, we can see that both the maximum mass and radius of neutron stars increase significantly .
it is clearly seen that the star maximum mass with the soft eos is modified more significantly by the u - boson .
this is consistent with the corresponding modification to the high - density eos caused by the u - boson , as shown in figs .
[ epnl ] and [ eptf ] .
the consistency is established on the fact that the maximum mass of neutron stars is dominated by the high - density behavior of the eos . in the past
, a few neutron stars with large masses around @xmath50 had been observed @xcite .
though it can have improvements in experimental aspects , the observation of neutron stars with large masses is not so scarce .
recently , the mass of the lmxb 4u1608 - 52 is measured to be 1.74@xmath51 @xcite , and most recently a @xmath50 neutron star j1614 - 2230 was measured through the shapiro delay @xcite .
note that the model fsugold which is well consistent with the nuclear laboratory constraints just produces a maximum mass about 1.7@xmath51 for the neutron star without hyperons , whereas the hyperonization can further reduce the maximum mass to a value below @xmath52 . in this case , the role of the u - boson is constructive in increasing the maximum mass of neutron stars , either as the eos is softened by the creation of new degrees of freedom , or the eos is too soft to obtain a large maximum mass .
on the other hand , the radius of neutron stars is primarily determined by the eos in the lower density region of @xmath53 to @xmath54 , see refs.@xcite and references therein .
because the symmetry energy in this density region offers the most important ingredient of the pressure in pure neutron matter , the density dependence of the symmetry energy plays a crucial role in determining the radius of neutron stars .
while in the present case the pressure in the lower density region is increased appreciably by the u - boson , it is not surprising that the sensitive variation of the neutron star radius is obtained accordingly .
this is similar to the non - relativistic case in ref .
in fact , the radius of neutron stars relies sensitively on the stiffness of the eos .
thus , the stiffening of the eos caused by the u - boson gives rise to a significant increase of the radius .
concretely , we can see from fig .
[ mr ] that the larger rise of the radius comes up with the more apparent stiffening role of the u - boson in softer models .
it is known that the radius of neutron stars extracted from the observation can have a wide range due to the uncertainties of the distance measurement and theoretical models used for the spectrum analyses @xcite .
a more precise extraction of the neutron star radius , probably through the coincident measurements , thus becomes very significant , because it can test the non - newtonian gravity due to its promising sensitivity to the star radius .
( left panel ) and the @xmath55 ( right panel).[mr100],width=321,height=264 ] to stress the role of the u - boson in the maximum mass and radius of neutron stars , we depict in fig .
[ mr100 ] the m - r relation for various models with and without the u - boson . here , for the case with the inclusion of the u - boson ,
the calculation is performed with @xmath56 .
it is seen clearly that the large difference in maximum masses with various types of models can be reduced largely by the u - boson with suitable parameter @xmath57 .
we can see once again that the reduction of the difference is mainly attributed to the role of the u - boson in the models featuring much softer eos s .
interestingly , we see that the uncertainty of the radius for a canonical neutron star ( with the mass @xmath52 ) can also be reduced by the u - boson . in view of interesting and significant roles of the u - boson
, we may say that the task to look for the u - boson and further confirm the non - newtonian gravity is also confronted .
the recent experimental constraints on the relationship between parameters @xmath58 ( @xmath18 ) and @xmath59 ( @xmath21 ) can be found in ref .
@xcite . to recover the stability of neutron stars using the eos constrained by the fopi / gsi data @xcite , the ratio @xmath60 was found to be needed @xcite . in this work
, the effect of the u - boson is investigated within the parameter region @xmath61 . to avoid the visible effect beyond low energy constraints in finite nuclei , with these values of the ratio parameter we may estimate that the mass of the u - boson should be of order below @xmath62 with the coupling strength being almost or at least three orders less than the fine - structure constant , while these estimated orders can be compatible with parameter regions allowed by a few experimental constraints , see ref .
we expect that more precision experiments will be performed to better determine or exclude the parameter regions for the non - newtonian gravity .
at last , it is interesting to discuss the relevance between the parameters of the non - newtonian gravity touched upon in this work and the solution to the dark matter problem . in order to explain the flatness of the rotational curve of galactic spirals
, one needs to assume the non - luminous dark matter being the additional gravitational source .
alternatively , the newtonian gravity that was well tested in the solar system may be assumed to fail at the large distance scales of galaxies , and hence the newtonian gravity should be modified to be the non - newtonian one @xcite .
the yukawa - type modification to the newtonian gravity due to the boson exchange may possibly be considered as a candidate to solve the dark matter problem . in this work , the vector coupling of the u - boson that is restrained by the u(1 ) symmetry produces a repulsion other than the anticipated attraction .
we may thus suppose to solve the dark matter problem through the introduction of light scalar bosons .
however , since the flatness of the rotational curve requires a supplemental force roughly linear inversely in the distance from the center of the galaxy , even if the light scalar boson is assumed to provide the needed attraction in one region , the exponential suppression factor of the yukawa - type potential ( see eq.([grav ] ) ) actually inhibits the reproduction of the rotational curve in other regions . in deed , in addition to the introduction of the light scalar boson , more considerations are necessary to solve the dark matter problem @xcite . on the other hand
, we may explore the constraints from the effect of the u - boson on the dark matter .
however , the coupling of the u - boson with the dark matter candidates should be assumed to be much stronger than that with the normal particles to explain the @xmath63 @xmath1-ray observation while simultaneously compatible with the low - energy constraints @xcite . to sum up
, we are presently not able to restrain the parameters of the non - newtonian gravity originated from the u - boson exchange in this work directly by using the effect of the u - boson on the dark matter and/or the solution to the dark matter problem with the modified newtonian dynamics .
nonetheless , this deserves further exploration .
for instance , the further first - principle understanding of the underlying origin of the difference in the u - boson couplings to normal and dark matter particles may open possibility to extract constraints on the parameters of the non - newtonian gravity .
we have studied in this work the effects of the u - boson in rmf models on the equation of state and subsequently the consequence in neutron stars .
all rmf models are chosen to have similarly nice reproduction of saturation properties and ground - state properties of finite nuclei , whereas they can give rise to a significantly large difference in eos s at high densities and mass - radius relations of neutron stars .
interestingly , we find that the u - boson in models with much softer eos plays a much more significant role in increasing the maximum mass of neutron stars .
the distinction can be attributed analytically to the different modification caused by the u - boson in soft and stiff models to the pressure .
thus , the inclusion of the u - boson may allow the existence of the non - nucleonic degrees of freedom in the interior of large mass neutron stars initiated with the favorably soft eos of normal nuclear matter .
in addition , it is worth notifying that the radius of canonical neutron stars in all models can be sensitively modified by the u - boson due to its stiffening role in the eos .
meanwhile , the difference in the mass - radius relations predicted by various models can favorably be reduced by increasing the coupling strength between the u - boson and baryons . at last ,
constraints on the parameters of the non - newtonian gravity are discussed .
presently , we have not found the direct relevance between the parameters of the non - newtonian gravity originated from the u - boson exchange and its effect on the dark matter concerning the dark matter problem .
together with the future coincident measurements and more precise extraction of the mass and radius of neutron stars , the sensitive role of the u - boson in the m - r relation may be helpfully used to test the physics beyond the standard model and consequently the existence of the non - newtonian gravity in the dense neutron star .
authors thank professors de - hua wen , lie - wen chen and bao - an li for useful discussions .
the work was supported in part by the srtp grant of the educational ministry of china , the national natural science foundation of china under grant no .
10975033 , the china jiangsu provincial natural science foundation under grant no.bk2009261 , and the china major state basic research development program under contract no .
2007cb815004 .
99 j. m. lattimer and m. prakash , phy . rep . *
333 * , 121 ( 2000 ) ; astrophys .
j. * 550 * , 426 ( 2001 ) ; science * 304 * , 536 ( 2004 ) ; phy .
rep . * 442 * , 109 ( 2007 ) . c. j. horowitz and j. piekarewicz , phy .
lett . * 86 * , 5647 ( 2001 ) .
d. j. nice , i. h. stairs , and l. e. kasian , 2008 , in aip conf .
983 , 40 years of pulsars : millisecond pulsars , magnetars and more , ed . c. bassa , z.wang , a. cumming , and v. m. kaspi ( aip : new york ) , 453 | we investigate the effects of the light vector u - boson that couples weakly to nucleons in relativistic mean - field models on the equation of state and subsequently the consequence in neutron stars .
it is analyzed that the u - boson can lead to a much clearer rise of the neutron star maximum mass in models with the much softer equation of state .
the inclusion of the u - boson may thus allow the existence of the non - nucleonic degrees of freedom in the interior of large mass neutron stars initiated with the favorably soft eos of normal nuclear matter .
in addition , the sensitive role of the u - boson in the neutron star radius and its relation to the test of the non - newtonian gravity that is herein addressed by the light u - boson are discussed . |
in a recent study @xcite we successfully calculated the mass of the @xmath1 meson using staggered fermions . according to conventional lore
, the @xmath1 receives a large portion of its mass from instanton effects . at the fermionic level
, this would mean receiving contributions from zero modes of the dirac operator .
these zero modes come with a definite chirality in the continuum and are associated with the topological charge ( @xmath2 ) of a gauge configuration via the index theorem : @xmath3 where @xmath4 and @xmath5 are respectively the number of right and left - handed zero modes . at finite lattice spacing ,
@xmath6 and @xmath7 do not exactly anti - commute , so there are no exact chiral zero modes and nor is the topological charge of gauge configurations well defined .
nevertheless , one might expect to find a few low lying eigenmodes carrying chiral charge .
smit and vink @xcite verified this sort of behavior for @xmath8 gauge theory in 2 dimensions . in this work , we set out to study the extent to which the lattice `` zero modes '' reproduce the continuum picture for qcd .
accordingly , we have constructed the lowest few eigenmodes of staggered @xmath7 on both quenched and dynamical @xmath0 gauge configurations ( 83 samples each ) of size @xmath9 corresponding to a lattice spacing of 0.1fm .
we have used the subspace iterations method @xcite to compute the eigenmodes .
the eigenvalues that we obtain have relative errors in the range @xmath10 for the smallest through @xmath11 for the highest .
the lattice analog of the @xmath8 axial anomaly equation gives @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the fermion propagator .
the mode by mode contribution to @xmath14 on all the dynamical configurations is shown in figure [ dg5 ] .
it appears to diminish as @xmath15 increases which can be verified quantitatively by calculating the width , shown in the bottom part of figure [ dg5 ] .
this behavior is consistent with the continuum where @xmath16 for all the non zero eigenvalues .
figure [ qg5 ] shows a similar set of plots for the quenched ensemble .
although both @xmath17 and its width show qualitatively similar behavior as before , they seem to drop more slowly with increasing @xmath15 .
the solid line present in all the figures shown so far represents the minimum value of the 32nd eigenvalue in the ensemble , ie .
the line below which we are sure to have found 100% of the modes .
[ dg5 ] [ qg5 ] = 2.5 in the sum in eqn([trg5sf1 ] ) for @xmath18 and 32 modes at @xmath19 on a typical dynamical configuration is shown in figure [ q05 ] .
the plateau in @xmath2 as the number of modes increases implies that the contribution of the higher modes to the sum in eqn [ trg5sf1 ] is becoming negligibly small .
although , the plot shown here is for one configuration , a similar behavior is seen on all the configurations , quenched and dynamical . in figure
[ q05 ] , the isolated point represented by a square is the value of @xmath2 obtained from pseudofermions .
the `` true '' value obtained by averaging over 82 copies of noise lies within the band marked by the dashed lines .
since the plateau in @xmath2 lies within this band it is a very good indication that these lowest modes are the topological zero modes which make the dominant contribution to the sum in eqn [ trg5sf1 ] .
we have compared @xmath2 obtained from pseudofermions and modes on all the dynamical configurations and find that both agree within errors .
on the quenched ensemble , the difference between the two estimators appears to be statistically significant .
this simply reinforces the inference reached by comparing figures [ dg5 ] and [ qg5 ] that more than 32 lowest eigenvalues are required to identify an upper limit for the number of shifted zero modes on the quenched configurations .
calculation of hadron correlators on the lattice normally involves inverting @xmath20 to obtain the quark propagator .
when resolved in terms of the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of @xmath7 , on a fixed background gauge field , it takes the form @xmath21 comparing the full propagator obtained using standard inversion procedures like cg , with that constructed out of the sum above with the available eigenmodes gives an insight into the role of the eigenmodes in determining hadronic quantities .
the @xmath1 meson , being a flavor singlet , has both connected and disconnected contributions to its correlator .
the discussion in section 2 suggests an extension of the analysis to the @xmath1 disconnected correlator which is given by @xmath22 .
we calculate this quantity using pseudofermions and with the available 32 modes .
the ratio @xmath23 of disconnected to the connected correlator for @xmath19 is shown in fig [ r01 ] .
for the connected correlator , we use the full result available from our previous study @xcite . on the dynamical configurations , @xmath23 is fit to the form @xcite @xmath24 $ ] . for staggered fermions , @xmath25 ,
the number of valence fermions equals 4 while @xmath26 .
it is evident from the figure that @xmath23 data with 32 modes agree within error with the full result .
= 3.1 in we find similarly good agreement with only 24 modes though 16 appears to be not quite enough .
the pattern is the same at the heavier quark masses , 0.02 and 0.03 .
we note that this behavior is not automatic as 32 modes are insufficient to yield a good approximation to the true quark propagator .
we find , for example , that the pion is off by a large factor .
based on our knowledge of the staggered eigenvalue spectrum and on recent work done by negele _
et al . _
@xcite with wilson fermions , one might expect that 100 - 200 modes would be needed to reproduce the pion propagator .
thus the @xmath1 is special in exhibiting an extraordinary sensitivity to the lowest few modes .
the quark propagator , constructed out of the available 32 modes , can be used as a starting seed for calculating @xmath27 using cg . [ residue ]
the benefit of using such approximate solutions as a starting iterate in the cg procedure is illustrated in figure [ residue ] .
the number of cg iterations required for the residual to converge to a given tolerance drops by more than @xmath28 at @xmath19 . at higher quark masses , this effect is not so pronounced owing to the fact that the lowest 32 eigenvalues are smaller than the quark mass itself .
these conclusions hold only for delta function sources or gauge fixed wall sources built out of delta functions .
quark propagators from noisy sources are dominated by short distance modes and hence there is virtually no improvement in the cg convergence rate when the starting seed is built out of long wavelength modes .
we find that it is possible to identify the shifted zero modes on the lattice since they make the dominant contribution to @xmath29 and @xmath30 . on our dynamical configurations , it seems that the number of topological zero modes must be less than 32 while on the quenched configurations the data indicates that there are more than this number . for most hadronic quantities ,
the approximate propagator constructed out of these topological zero modes is not accurate enough to be useful .
however , a remarkable result of our study is that we find that the @xmath1 flavor singlet interaction on the dynamical configurations is dominated entirely by the quasi - zero modes of @xmath7 .
9 l. venkataraman , g. kilcup and j. grandy , nucl .
( 1997 ) 259 .
b. bunk , nucl .
( 1997 ) 987 .
j. smit and j. c. vink , nucl .
b286 ( 1987 ) 485 . t. l. ivanenko and j. w. negele , this proceedings . | we have constructed the lowest few eigenvectors of the staggered dirac operator on @xmath0 gauge configurations , both quenched and dynamical .
we use these modes to study the topological charge and to construct approximate hadronic correlators . |
rapid progress in detecting thermal emission from isolated neutron stars ( nss ) with a new generation of orbital and ground - based observatories ( e.g. , refs .
@xcite ) stimulates active theoretical studies of cooling isolated nss .
it is well known that cooling history of nss depends on physical properties of matter of supranuclear density in ns cores .
these properties ( composition of matter , equation of state eos , critical temperatures of various superfluids , etc . )
are largely unknown : they can not be reproduced in laboratory or unambiguously calculated ( because of the lack of exact manybody theory for describing the systems of particles interacting via strong forces ) .
however , they may be constrained by comparing cooling calculations with observations of isolated nss ( e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) .
we will focus on the theoretical interpretation of observations proposed recently in refs .
@xcite , @xcite ( hereafter kyg ) , and @xcite .
the authors restricted themselves to model eoss in the ns cores in which the presence of muons was neglected . in the present paper
we show that the effect of muons on the cooling may be important . for the observational basis
, we take the same isolated middle - aged nss as kyg , but exclude rx j1856 - 3754 . the age of this intriguing radio - quiet ns has recently been revised @xcite ; the present value @xmath0 yrs is lower than the former one , @xmath1 yrs , and the source has become less restrictive for cooling theories ( cf .
kyg and ref .
in addition , there are indications that the emission from the entire ns surface is obscured by the emission from a hot spot on the surface of the ns ; if so the surface temperature is poorly determined from the present observations ( e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) .
the effective surface temperatures , @xmath2 , redshifted for a distant observer , and ages @xmath3 of seven isolated nss are taken from table 3 of kyg and displayed in figs . 2 and 3 below . the three youngest objects , rx j082243 @xcite , 1e 120752 @xcite , and rx j0002 + 62 @xcite , are radio - quiet nss in supernova remnants . the other objects , vela ( psr 083345 ) @xcite , psr 0656 + 14 @xcite , geminga ( psr 0633 + 1748 ) @xcite , and psr 105552 @xcite , are observed as radio pulsars .
the adopted values of @xmath2 are inferred from the observed spectra using various models of stellar emission described in kyg .
recently , the values of @xmath2 for some of the sources have been revisited in refs .
@xcite , @xcite @xcite .
since the new data are basically in line with those used in kyg , we do not introduce the corresponding changes ; they are insignificant for our analysis .
as shown in kyg , the observations can be explained using the models of nss with the cores composed only of neutrons , protons , and electrons , and assuming the presence of nucleon superfluidity with the density dependent critical temperatures @xmath4 .
following kyg we consider superfluidities of three types produced by : ( 1 ) singlet - state pairing of protons in the ns core ( @xmath5 ) ; ( 2 ) singlet - state pairing of free neutrons in the inner crust ( @xmath6 ) ; and ( 3 ) triplet - state pairing of neutrons in the core ( @xmath7 ) . owing to a large scatter of microscopic theoretical models of @xmath4 ( e.g. ref .
@xcite ) , we treat @xmath4 as free parameters .
kyg considered cooling of nss with rather strong pairing of protons and weak pairing of neutrons in the core , and with a strong pairing of neutrons in the crust . they found that cooling middle - aged nss can be divided into three types .
@xmath8 : : type i nss are low - mass nss which show slow cooling with ( modified or direct ) urca processes of neutrino emission strongly suppressed by proton superfluidity .
the cooling curves , @xmath9 , are insensitive to ns mass , eos in the core , and proton superfluidity ( i.e. , to @xmath10 ) as long as the latter is sufficiently strong .
kyg interpreted rx j082243 , and psr 105552 as low - mass nss .
@xmath8 : : type ii nss are medium - mass nss which show moderately fast cooling regulated by direct urca process partly reduced by proton superfluidity in the ns central kernels .
the cooling curves are sensitive to ns mass , eos , and especially the @xmath11 profiles in the ns kernel .
if the eos and @xmath11 are fixed , the effective surface temperature decreases smoothly with increasing @xmath12 , and one can measure the mass ( ` weigh' medium - mass nss ) using the observed limits on @xmath9 .
kyg treated 1e 120752 , rx j0002 + 62 , vela , psr 0656 + 14 , and geminga as medium - mass nss .
@xmath8 : : type iii nss are massive nss which show rapid cooling via direct urca process in the ns kernels , almost unaffected by proton superfluidity .
the surface temperatures of these nss are low ( a few times @xmath13 k for @xmath14 yrs ) , being not too sensitive to the ns structure .
no ns of such type has been observed so far .
we use the same cooling code as in kyg and modify the physics input in the ns core to include the effects of muons .
first , we have included muons in the eos .
we use a stiff eos proposed in ref .
@xcite , the model i of the symmetry energy of nucleon matter with the compression modulus of saturated nuclear matter @xmath15 mev .
the _ same model of nucleon - nucleon interaction _ was adopted by kyg ( eos a in their notations ) who , however , artificially suppressed the presence of muons .
now we include the muons and obtain eos a@xmath16 .
we will compare the results obtained with eoss a and a@xmath16 . for eos a@xmath16
, the muons appear at @xmath17 g @xmath18 ( when the electron chemical potential exceeds the muon rest energy ) . their fraction is lower than 10% everywhere in the ns core .
their appearance slightly softens the eos , slightly increases the fraction of protons and decreases the fraction of electrons .
these changes weakly affect the ns internal structure , reducing the maximum ns mass by 1.4% .
the masses @xmath12 , central densities @xmath19 , and radii @xmath20 of two ns configurations for eoss a and a@xmath16 are given in table 1 .
the first configuration corresponds to a maximum - mass ns .
the second corresponds to the onset of powerful direct urca neutrino emission @xcite in the ns kernel ( @xmath21 , @xmath22 ) .
.ns models employing eoss a and a@xmath16 ( without and with muons ) [ cols="<,<,<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] another modification of the cooling code consists of incorporating the heat capacity of muons .
it is straightforward ( e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) and has no noticeable effect on the ns cooling .
finally , we have modified the emissivities of neutrino reactions in the ns cores ( as described in ref .
the main effect of muons is to _ lower the threshold density @xmath23 of onset of direct urca process _ ( table 1 ) .
the lowering is associated with the changes of the fractions of neutrons , protons , and electrons in muonic matter which relaxes the onset condition . at @xmath24 , modified urca process is basically the leading one . at @xmath25 ,
two new branches of this process appear , the neutron and proton branches , where the muons participate instead of the electrons . however , these new branches have little effect on the cooling because their emissivity is comparable to the emissivity of the ordinary modified urca process .
the ordinary direct urca process operates at @xmath26 . at still higher density @xmath27 ( @xmath28 g @xmath18 , for eos a@xmath16 )
another direct urca process is open , where the muons participate instead of the electrons .
we have included it into the code but , again , it has little effect on the cooling because its emissivity is comparable to the emissivity of the ordinary direct urca process .
now we describe our models of superfluidity in nss . as in kyg
, we assume that the triplet - state pairing of neutrons in the ns cores is weak ( maximum @xmath29 k ) and can be ignored .
otherwise , a strong neutrino emission due to cooper pairing of neutrons would accelerate the cooling and hamper the interpretation of observations of older nss .
the singlet - state pairing of neutrons in the crust controls the neutrino luminosity of low - mass nss and has no direct relation to the presence of muons in the ns core . while exploring the effects of muons we ignore this pairing
( see also sect .
thus , we focus on the proton superfluidity in the core .
we parameterize the dependence of @xmath10 on the proton fermi wavenumber @xmath30 ( @xmath31 being the proton number density ) by the same expression as eq .
( 1 ) in kyg and consider two models of superfluidity , 1p and 2p , employed by kyg .
the corresponding @xmath11 profiles are plotted in fig .
the maximum of @xmath11 is about the same ( @xmath32 k ) for all models , but superfluidity 2p extends to a higher densities than 1p . since we use the _ same model of nucleon interaction _ for eoss a and a@xmath16 , we have the _ same dependence of _ @xmath10 _ on _ @xmath33 ( but different dependences of @xmath10 on @xmath34 because the proton fractions are different for eoss a and a@xmath16 ) . the curves in fig .
1 are typical of the microscopic calculations ( e.g. , ref .
@xcite ) . as discussed above , the muons shift both the direct urca threshold and the @xmath11 profile to lower values of @xmath34 .
the latter shift , due to the increase in the proton fraction , is bigger .
for instance , @xmath11 for model 1p of proton superfluidity vanishes below the direct urca threshold in the muonic matter , but persists above the direct urca threshold in the matter without muons .
the results of the cooling calculations are illustrated in figs .
[ fig2 ] and [ fig3 ] , which also show the observational data . according to our models ,
the cooling curves of low - mass nss with and without muons are almost indistinguishable .
the neutron superfluidity in the crust can affect the cooling of these stars in exactly the same way as discussed in ref .
@xcite and kyg for the nss without muons .
the calculations also show that muons have almost no effect on rapid cooling of massive nss .
however the effect of muons on moderately fast cooling of medium - mass nss is substantial .
figure 2 corresponds to model 1p of proton superfluidity . without muons ,
the @xmath11 profile extends above the direct urca threshold ( fig . 1 ) .
accordingly , we have a representative class of medium - mass nss ( dashed curves ) .
by varying the mass @xmath12 from 1.36 @xmath35 to 1.465 @xmath35 we can explain the observations of the five sources ( 1e 120752 , rx j0002 + 62 , vela , psr 0656 + 14 , and geminga ) by the cooling of medium - mass nss , and thus ` weigh' these nss ( ref .
@xcite , kyg ) . in the presence of muons ,
the proton critical temperature @xmath11 drops to zero below the direct urca threshold , @xmath23 ( fig . 1 )
, i.e. , the proton superfluidity disappears in the centers of nss with masses somewhat lower than the threshold mass @xmath36 .
the transition from slow to fast cooling occurs in a very narrow mass range , from 1.249 m@xmath37 to 1.264 m@xmath37 , so we have no representative class of medium - mass nss .
the proposed interpretation of the five sources as medium - mass nss containing muons becomes unlikely ( just as in the absence of superfluidity , see kyg ) .
figure 3 is the same as fig . 2 but for model 2p of proton superfluidity .
this superfluidity extends above @xmath23 with and without muons ( fig . 1 ) .
therefore , we have representative classes of medium - mass nss and we can weigh our five medium - mass sources in both cases . without muons , as in kyg , we obtain the masses from 1.49 m@xmath37 to 1.60 m@xmath37 . with muons ,
we obtain significantly lower ( and narrower ) mass range for the same sources , from 1.27 m@xmath37 to 1.34 m@xmath37 .
the inferred mass range changes in the presence of muons because they lower the threshold density @xmath23 of direct urca process and shift the decreasing slope of the @xmath11 profile to an even lower density ( fig . 1 ) .
accordingly , direct urca process becomes stronger at lower @xmath34 and this accelerates the cooling of lower - mass nss .
therefore , the mass range of medium - mass nss shifts to lower @xmath12 .
we have simulated the cooling of superfluid nss with and without muons .
the inclusion of muons does not violate the main results of refs .
@xcite@xcite on the existence of three types of cooling superfluid nss . as in kyg
, we can interpret rx j082243 , and psr 105552 , as low - mass nss , and 1e 120752 , rx j0002 + 62 , vela , psr 0656 + 14 , and geminga , as medium - mass nss .
this interpretation requires strong singlet - state proton pairing and weak triplet - state neutron pairing in the ns cores .
muons do not change the hydrostatic structure of nss .
the muon heat capacity and direct / modified urca processes involving muons have almost no effect on ns cooling .
the cooling curves of low - mass and high - mass nss are insensitive to the presence of muons .
however , muons _ do affect _ the cooling of medium - mass nss and the associated ` weighing' of observed nss proposed in ref .
@xcite and kyg . for the same nucleon - nucleon interaction model and the superfluid properties of ns cores ,
we obtain noticeably lower masses of nss with muons than without muons ( fig . 3 ) .
therefore , one should take muons into account for a correct interpretation of observations .
it is remarkable that muons _ affect the cooling by their mere existence , as passive particles_. we could switch off all neutrino reactions and heat capacity associated with muons ( i.e. , retain the ` old' physics input in the ns core ) but employ the fractions of neutrons , protons and electrons in the eos modified by the presence of muons .
the cooling curves obtained in this numerical experiment would almost coincide with the exact ones .
this means that _ the effects of muons can be accurately incorporated by renormalizing the ns models containing no muons at all_. in other words , any model of a cooling ns with muons is equivalent to a certain model of a cooling ns without muons .
clearly , the muons will have similar effects in the presence of hyperons in supranuclear matter .
this circumstance may be helpful in constructing the codes to simulate cooling of nss containing hyperons .
the existence of three types of cooling nss is effectively regulated by two factors .
the first is the onset of the powerful direct urca process of neutrino emission at densities @xmath26 ; the second is the strong proton superfluidity extending at @xmath26 .
the latter suppresses the direct and modified urca processes at or just above the critical density @xmath23 but opens them at higher @xmath34 . in this way
the superfluidity smears out the sharp transition between the slow and rapid cooling regimes and creates a representative class of medium - mass nss , favorable for the interpretation of observations .
these conditions may be also realized in ns cores containing hyperons , pion or kaon condensates , or quark matter .
we will analyze different models of ns cores in future publications .
we are grateful to g.g .
pavlov for encouragement , to d. page for criticism , and to p. haensel and a.d .
kaminker for careful reading of the text .
the work was partially supported by rfbr ( grant no .
00 - 07 - 90183 ) and kbn ( grant no .
5p03d.020.20 ) .
pavlov , g. g. , zavlin , v. e. , & sanwal , d. , _ proc . of 270 heraeus seminar on neutron stars , pulsars and supernova remnants _ ,
w. becker , h. lesh , & trmper , mpe , garching ( 2002 ) submitted [ astro - ph/0206024 ] yakovlev , d. g. , gnedin , o. y. , kaminker , a. d. , & potekhin , a. y. _ proc . of 270 heraeus seminar on neutron stars , pulsars and supernova remnants
_ , eds .
w. becker , h. lesh , & trmper , mpe , garching ( 2002 ) submitted [ astro - ph/0204226 ] sanwal , d. , pavlov , g. g. , kargaltsev , o. y. , garmire , g. p. , zavlin , v. e. , burwitz , v. , manchester , r. n. , dodson , r. , _ neutron stars in supernova remnants _ , eds .
o. slane , b. m. gaensler , _ asp conf .
( 2002 ) [ accepted , astro - ph/0112164 ] | we extend our modeling of cooling of superfluid neutron stars by including the production of muons in the core , in addition to neutrons , protons , and electrons .
the results are confronted with observations of middle - aged isolated nss .
muons have little effect on the hydrostatic structure of nss , on the slow cooling of low - mass nss ( rx j082243 and psr 105552 in our model ) and on the rapid cooling of massive nss .
they affect , however , the moderately fast cooling of medium - mass nss ( 1e 120752 , rx j0002 + 62 , psr 0656 + 14 , vela , and geminga ) and shift appreciably the mass range of these nss to lower masses , which is important for correct interpretation of the observations . moreover , the effects of muons can accurately be reproduced by a simple renormalization of ns models with no muons in the ns cores . |
the formation and evolution of galaxies has been one of the primary topics in cosmology ever since their diverse appearance was first observed .
naive interpretations of the hubble sequence of galaxies and of the hierarchical nature of dark matter halos in cdm models naturally lead to scenarios in which smaller galaxies , predominantly spirals , form first and then merge to form the massive spheroidal systems .
the variation of the star formation rate density as a function of redshift ( lilly et al .
1996 , madau et al.1996 ) shows that almost half of the stellar mass in galaxies was formed between @xmath6 so that it is obviously vital to study this epoch to understand galaxy evolution .
the gdds survey ( abraham et al . 2004 ) , through preselection criteria applied to a deep infrared survey of galaxies , was specifically designed for this purpose .
the photometric and spectroscopic results that emerged from the gdds galaxy sample reveal a very consistent picture ; one in which star formation activity was initially concentrated in very massive galaxies at very high redshift resulting in old , red and dead " galaxies at redshifts @xmath7 , and the activity has progressively moved to lower and lower mass systems . here
we summarize some of the highlights that lead to this conclusion .
the chief observational hurdle to overcome was : a ) the extreme faintness of the passively evolving galaxy population ; b ) the relatively featureless spectra ( since all strong features were redshifted out of the detector passband ) ; c ) the very bright night sky emission . before techniques like nod and shuffle ( see below ) were implemented , it was extremely difficult to obtain sufficiently good spectra for redshift determination in the range @xmath8 and so this became known as the redshift desert " .
given the observational challenges , transforming the redshift desert into the
redshift dessert " requires extremely long exposures .
the basic goals and parameters of the gdds survey can be summarized as follows : - construct the largest mass - limited sample of galaxies in the @xmath6 range with no bias toward emission line systems .
in fact , bias the sample toward early - type red and dead " galaxies using vrizjhk colours . the sample was drawn from the las campanas ir imaging survey ( mccarthy et al .
1999 ; chen et al . 2002 ) and the gdds subsample covered 121 square arcminutes in 4 different sightlines .
- go deep enough ( @xmath9 ) to pick up m * galaxies out to z=1.8 .
this requires up to 30 hour integrations with gmos , the gemini multi - object spectrograph ( hook et al .
2003 ; crampton & murowinski 2004 ) and implementation of a nod & shuffle " mode ( cuillandre 1994 , glazebrook & bland - hawthorn 2001 , and the appendix to abraham et al .
2004 ) to enable sky subtraction to 0.1% accuracy .
the resulting relatively high signal - to - noise spectra that were free of artifacts resulting from poor subtraction of the strong night sky emission lines enabled redshift determination for a high perecentage of the original galaxy sample , even from spectra of galaxies containing primarily old stars with no , or weak , emission features .
spectroscopic redshifts were derived for 221 galaxies , 163 of which are in the redshift interval @xmath10 .
- construct the mass function of galaxies and connect this to the star - formation history of the universe ( ideally , using only self - consistent data internal to the survey ) .
connect mass - assembly to the hubble sequence .
the gdds catalogue and the spectra are described in detail in abraham et al .
( 2004 ) and are all publicly available at http://www.ociw.edu/lcirs/gdds.html .
abraham et al . also describe the sampling strategy and how a weighting scheme was devised to deal with the complications arising from the preselection criteria .
as outlined in glazebrook et al . ( 2004 ) , masses for galaxies in the gdds sample were derived from their spectral energy distributions which in turn were determined from @xmath11 colours . as figures 1 and 3 of glazebrook
show , high mass galaxies were abundant up to redshifts @xmath7 , and the decline in mass density falls much more slowly with redshift than predicted by standard semi - analytic models ( e.g. , cole et al . 2000 ) .
almost half of the mass density at @xmath12 is contained within galaxies with @xmath13 and the spectra show that these are galaxies containing populations of old stars rather than being reddened by interstellar absorption .
furthermore , hst acs imaging of a representative subsample of these galaxies shows that more than 90% have early - type morphology ( abraham et al . 2005 ) .
a representative spectrum and direct image of one of these galaxies is shown in the middle panel of figure 1 .
the most massive galaxies are generally spectroscopically and morphologically early type systems . however , there are also lots of massive star - forming galaxies at @xmath14 that presumably become all the post - starburst galaxies that are observed at @xmath4 ( see below )
. a preliminary analysis by mccarthy et al . ( 2004 ) of the spectra of galaxies at redshifts from 1.3 to 2.2 whose integrated light is dominated by evolved stars shows that they must have formed at very high redshifts .
conservative best - fit and minimum ages were derived from both the spectra and the broad band colors .
_ minimum _ formation redshifts @xmath15 are inferred for several of the galaxies and _ best - fit _ formation redshifts @xmath16 for 20% of the objects .
these early - forming galaxies are major contributors to the stellar mass density at @xmath6 and are likely progenitors of a significant fraction of present day massive elliptical galaxies .
mccarthy et al . argue that the mostly likely progenitors of these systems are higher redshift analogs of the massive starburst galaxies seen in the sub - mm with scuba and similar instruments , and can not be descendants of the @xmath17 lyman break galaxies .
another interesting point is that the spectra are best fit by models with solar or even higher metallicity indicating that very significant metal enrichment occurred very early .
the interstellar medium of star - forming galaxies in this same redshift range is also apparently chemically evolved . a composite spectrum derived from a subsample of 13 gdds galaxies at @xmath12 by savaglio et al .
( 2004 ) shows surprisingly strong interstellar lines , much stronger than observed in local starbursts ( tremonti , 2003 ) .
an example of the spectra of one of these active starburst galaxies at @xmath18 is shown in the top panel of figure 1 .
thus , both the interstellar medium and the stars in these relatively high redshift galaxies have already been enriched to approximately solar values .
rapid enrichment in these massive galaxies must occur very early in the history of the universe .
prominent among the gdds spectra are several dramatic examples of post - starburst galaxies , i.e. , spectra with very strong balmer absorption lines but weak or absent emission features ( see the bottom panel of figure 1 ) . by comparing the gdds data with that from the sloan digital sky survey , le borgne et al .
( 2005 ) were able to quantify the dramatic decline in the abundance of post - starburst galaxies from @xmath19 to the present .
spectral synthesis models of the gdds post - starburst galaxies show that they must be the products of massive bursts of star formation @xmath20 gyr prior to the epoch of observation .
the models show that these must have been rapid mass - building events rather than a continual series of small events .
the bright star - forming galaxies in the gdds sample at @xmath3 are probably examples of this activity .
the most likely local counterparts of these post - starburst galaxies at @xmath4 are massive ellipticals in the field or in small groups .
another ubiquitous feature of the gdds spectra is the presence of relatively strong emission lines , much stronger than in lower redshift samples , e.g. , cfrs .
[ oii ] emission lines , indicative of star formation activity , are , of course , strong in the galaxies with late - type morphologies but in the gdds sample they are also frequently visible even in spectra that appear to arise mostly from evolved populations . in addition , higher ionization emission lines ( e.g. , [ ne iii ] , [ ne v ] ) are evident in several of the most active galaxies ( for details , see abraham et al .
juneau et al .
( 2005 ) measured the strengths of the [ oii ] emission lines in all the gdds spectra of galaxies with @xmath22 and used these , along with measurements of the rest - frame uv continuum ( derived from photometry ) for galaxies with @xmath23 to derive star formation rates for the gdds sample . as expected , given the appearance of the spectra , the rates are much higher on average than at @xmath24 .
the availability of the mass estimates for the gdds galaxies allowed juneau et al .
to add another dimension , however .
figure 2 , adapted from juneau et al .
, demonstrates that the star formation rate history is a strong function of the stellar mass in a galaxy . for the most massive galaxies , the star formation rate was six times higher at @xmath7 than at @xmath24 and it declined rapidly between @xmath6 .
the star formation activity in the lower mass galaxies peaked at lower redshifts so that for systems with @xmath25 the star formation activity peaks closer to @xmath4 and then declines rapidly to @xmath24 . through a comparison of the star formation rate density to the stellar mass density juneau
et al . were able to demonstrate that star formation in the most massive galaxies transitioned from a very active burst mode to a quiescent mode near @xmath26 , whereas this transition occured later , at lower redshifts , for less massive galaxies .
thus , measurements of the star formation rate point to the same picture as was derived from analysis of the ages of the populations from their spectra : the most massive galaxies formed early . in fact , the most massive galaxies formed their stars in the first 3 gyr of cosmic history .
all of the key results from the gdds spectra and colours that are described in this section strongly support the downsizing " concept for galaxy evolution : rapid star formation occurred very early at high redshift in the most massive systems and then subsided in these while the activity proceeded to lower and lower mass systems with decreasing redshift .
savaglio et al . ( 2005 ) were able to measure metallicities for 56 galaxies with @xmath27 for which masses could also be estimated from the gdds and cfrs surveys .
careful attention was paid to minimizing systematic and possible aperture effects as well as the effects of extinction .
a nice mass - metallicity relationship emerged for these galaxies at a mean redshift @xmath5 , a relationship that is considerably tighter than the luminosity - metallicity relationship .
furthermore , the relation is displaced from that derived from the sdss galaxies at @xmath28 ( tremonti et al .
2004 ) in the expected direction : present - day galaxies of a given mass have a higher metallicity . evidence from @xmath29 galaxies compiled by shapley et al .
( 2004 ) indicates that this trend continues to higher redshifts .
savaglio et al .
show that all these observations can be fitted by a simple redshift - dependent mass - metallicity relationship .
both masses and metallicities evolve more slowly in lower mass galaxies compared to their higher mass counterparts .
the variation can be explained by a simple closed - box model in which the e - folding time for star formation is longer for less massive galaxies .
thus the picture that emerges from considerations of the mass - metallicity relation also supports the downsizing " scenario . an aside is that the mass - metallicity relationship predicts that low metallicity galaxies such as the dla systems all have masses @xmath30 .
hammer ( elsewhere in these proceedings , and see liang et al .
2005 ) also reported detecting redshift evolution in the mass - metallicity relationship of galaxies at similar redshifts to those discussed by savaglio et al .
the gdds survey targeted @xmath6 galaxies , emphasizing those red and dead " systems containing old , evolved , stellar populations . as expected , the results demonstrate that uv - selected surveys are not complete and miss important segments of the galaxy population .
the gdds spectra have sufficient signal - to - noise for these optically extremely faint galaxies that it is possible to distinguish the evolved populations from galaxies that are red because they are dusty .
in addition , @xmath31 imaging confirms that almost all the spectroscopically red and dead " systems have morphologies characteristic of early - type galaxies .
the abundance of massive galaxies declines at @xmath32 but the decline is slower than that predicted by most models and there is still a significant population of very high mass galaxies at @xmath2 .
the gdds observations indicate that half the stellar mass in these galaxies was formed in very active bursts of star formation at @xmath33 .
high redshift sub - mm scuba " sources ( chapman et al . 2005 ) are the most plausible counterparts of these active systems .
at much lower redshifts , @xmath4 , there is a significant population of post - starburst galaxies that appear to be the descendants of the active star - forming galaxies at @xmath8 .
measures of star formation activity in gdds galaxies at various redshifts as a function of the stellar mass complement these other results , demonstrating that the peak of the star formation activity began in the highest mass galaxies at high redshifts and then progressively moved to lower mass galaxies at lower redshifts .
this scenario , called downsizing " by cowie et al .
( 1994 ) , is thus supported by several results emerging from the gdds survey .
the redshift - evolution of a mass - metallicity relation that was detected in the gdds and cfrs galaxies is also consistent with downsizing in that star formation appears to proceed more slowly , for a longer period of time , in less massive galaxies .
interestingly , a naive closed - box model in which the e - folding time for star formation is longer in less massive galaxies fits the observations quite well ( savaglio et al .
2005 ) . in summary ,
observations of galaxies in the redshift desert give strong support for the downsizing scenario of galaxy evolution .
physical processes must make the formation of stars much more efficient in high mass systems at earlier times than suggested by most theoretical models , and then turn it off quickly .
abraham et al .
2005 , in preparation , gdds paper viii abraham , r.g . ,
glazebrook , k. , mccarthy , p.j . , crampton , d. , murowinski , r. et al .
, 2004 , , 127 , 2455 .
gdds paper i chapman , s.c . , blain , a.w . , smail , i. & ivison , r.j .
2005 , ap .
j. , 622 , 772 .
chen , h .- w .
, mccarthy , p.j . , marzke , r.o . ,
wilson , r.g . ,
carlberg , r.g .
2002 , , 570 , 54 .
cole , s. , lacey , c.g . ,
baugh , c.m .
& frenk , c.s .
2000 , mnras , 319 , 168 .
cowie , l.l . ,
gardner , j.p . , hu ,
e.m . , songaila , a. , hodapp , k.w . ,
wainscoat , r.j .
1994 , ap .
j. , 434 , 114 .
crampton , d. & murowinski , r. 2004 , spie , 5492 , 181 .
cuillandre , j.c . ,
1994 , a&a , 281 , 603 .
glazebrook , k. , abraham , r.g . ,
mccarthy , p.j .
et al . , 2004 ,
nature , 430 , 181 .
gdds paper iii .
glazebrook , k. & bland hawthorn , j.2001 , pasp , 113 , 97 .
hook , i.m . , jrgensen , i. , allington - smith , j.r . ,
davies , r.l . ,
metcalfe , n. , murowinski , r.g .
& crampton , d. 2004 , pasp , 116 , 425 juneau , s. et al .
2005 , ap .
j. , 619 , 135 .
gdds paper v. le borgne , d.et al .
2005 , ap .
j. , in press . gdds paper vi .
liang , y.c . ,
hammer , f. et al .
2005 , astro - ph/0501529 .
lilly , s.j . , le fevre , o. , hammer , f. & crampton , d. 1996 , , 460 , l1 .
madau , p. , fergusson , h.c . ,
dickinson , m.e . ,
giavalisco , m. , steidel , c.c . & fruchter , a. , 1996 , , 283 , 1388 .
mccarthy , p.j .
2004 , ap .
j. , 614 , l9 .
gdds paper iv mccarthy , p. j. , marzke , r.o . , chen , h .- w . , persson , e. , oemler , a. et al . 1999 , bull .
aas , 195 , 5701 .
savaglio , s. , glazebrook , k. , abraham , r.g . , crampton , d. , chen , h .- w . , mccarthy , p.j.p .
, et al . 2004 , , 602 , 51.gdds paper ii savaglio , s. et al . 2005 , ap . j. , in press , gdds paper vii , astro - ph/0508407 shapley , a.e . ,
erb , d.k . ,
pettini , m. , steidel , c.c . & adelberger , k.l .
2004 , ap .
j. , 612 , 108 .
tremonti , c.a .
2003 , ph d thesis tremonti , c.a .
2004 , ap .
j. , 613 , 898 . | the gemini deep deep survey , gdds , produced several significant results relating to the evolution of galaxies .
all of these results are consistent with the downsizing " concept of galaxy formation and evolution , i.e. , that the active periods of star formation moved progressively from very massive galaxies at high redshift to much lower mass galaxies at the present epoch .
spectra of massive red galaxies at z @xmath0 1.7 demonstrates that they contain old stellar populations and hence must have formed their stars in the first @xmath1gyr of cosmic history ; indicators of star formation activity show that the star formation rate in the most massive galaxies was much higher at @xmath2 than today , that the activity in intermediate mass galaxies peaked near @xmath3 , while , since @xmath4 the activity is primarily confined to lower mass galaxies .
the gdds also uncovered a relatively high percentage of post - starburst galaxies at @xmath4 , a result that is anticipated given all the activity seen at higher redshifts .
measurements of the strengths of metal lines of a subsample of the gdds and cfrs galaxies at @xmath5 reveal that , at a given mass , they had lower metallicities than at present .
the evolution in the mass - metallicity relation is consistent with a model in which star formation lasts longest in less massive galaxies , again an expected result in the downsizing scenario . |
the hadronic decays of @xmath0 mesons have provided us with a good place to study cp violation in particle physics . in particular
, the detection of direct cp violation in a decay process requires that there exist at least two contributing amplitudes with different weak and strong phases .
the direct cp - violating effect in the @xmath0 system has finally been observed in the @xmath6 decay at the @xmath0-factories @xcite , proving the existence of nontrivial strong phases in @xmath0 decays .
it is therefore of consequence to find out the patterns of final - state strong phases for a wider set of decay modes . since the ckm factors involved in charmed @xmath0 meson decays are purely real to a good approximation , the phases associated with the decay amplitudes thus have the origin of strong interactions .
such final - state rescattering effects have been noticed from data in these decays @xcite , and estimated to be at 15 - 20% level @xcite .
unfortunately , no satisfactory first - principle calculations can yield such strong phases @xcite . in ref .
@xcite , we performed an analysis based upon the experimental data available at that time .
a few theoretical and experimental questions are left unanswered .
as more decay modes have been observed and others are measured at higher precisions , it becomes possible for us to look at and answer those questions . in this paper ,
flavor su(3 ) symmetry is employed to relate different amplitudes and strong phases of the same topological type .
moreover , we will take a different approach by fitting theoretical parameters to all available branching ratios simultaneously .
an advantage of this analysis is that the parameters thus obtained are insensitive to statistical fluctuations of individual modes .
this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : decomp ] , we give the amplitude decomposition of modes under flavor su(3 ) symmetry and the current branching ratio data .
theoretical parameters involved in our analysis are defined . in section [ sec : phases ] , we consider three sets of charmed decay modes : @xmath7 , @xmath8 , and @xmath2 , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 denote charmless pseudoscalar and vector mesons , respectively .
a summary of our findings is given in section [ sec : summary ] .
in the decomposition of decay amplitudes , relevant meson wave functions are assumed to have the following quark contents , with phases chosen so that isospin multiplets contain no relative signs : * _ beauty mesons : _
@xmath9 , @xmath10 , @xmath11 . *
_ charmed mesons : _
@xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , with corresponding phases for vector mesons . *
_ pseudoscalar mesons @xmath3 : _
@xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , @xmath18 , @xmath19 , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 , assuming a specific octet - singlet mixing @xcite in the @xmath24 and @xmath25 wave functions . ) * _ vector mesons @xmath4 : _
@xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , @xmath34 .
the amplitudes contributing to the decays discussed here involve only three different topologies
@xcite : 1 . _
tree amplitude @xmath35 : _ this is associated with the transition @xmath36 ( cabibbo - favored ) or @xmath37 ( cabibbo - suppressed ) in which the light ( color - singlet ) quark - antiquark pair is incorporated into one meson , while the charmed quark combines with the spectator antiquark to form the other meson .
_ color - suppressed amplitude @xmath38 : _ the transition is the same as in the tree amplitudes , namely @xmath39 or @xmath37 , except that the charmed quark and the @xmath40 combine into one meson while the @xmath41 or @xmath42 quark and the spectator antiquark combine into the other meson .
_ exchange amplitude @xmath43 : _ the @xmath44 quark and spectator antiquark exchange a @xmath45 boson to become a @xmath46 pair , which then hadronizes into two mesons by picking up a light quark - antiquark pair out of the vacuum .
after factoring out the ckm factors explicitly , we obtain the flavor amplitude decomposition of the charmed @xmath0 decay modes in tables [ tab : dp ] , [ tab : dstp ] , and [ tab : dv ] . in these tables , we introduce positive @xmath47 s to parameterize the flavor su(3 ) breaking effects .
this symmetry is respected between strangeness - conserving and strangeness - changing amplitudes when @xmath47 s are taken to be unity .
as we will discuss in the next section , @xmath47 s will be allowed to change in order to test the assumption . using the wolfenstein parameters @xcite , the relevant ckm factors are : @xmath48 none of which contain a weak phase to the order we are concerned with . in the following analysis , we take the central values @xmath49 and @xmath50 quoted by the ckmfitter group @xcite .
since only the relative strong phases are physically measurable , we fix the tree ( @xmath35 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 ) amplitudes to be real and pointing in the positive direction .
we then associate the color - suppressed and exchange amplitudes with the corresponding strong phases explicitly as follows : @xmath53 the magnitude of invariant decay amplitude @xmath54 for a decay process @xmath55 is related to its partial width via the following relation : @xmath56 with @xmath57 where @xmath58 are the masses of @xmath59 , respectively . to relate partial widths to branching ratios
, we use the world - average lifetimes @xmath60 ps , @xmath61 ps , and @xmath62 ps computed by the heavy flavor averaging group ( hfag ) @xcite .
.branching ratios and flavor amplitude decomposition for @xmath63 decays .
data are quoted from refs . @xcite [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] @xmath64 gev can be extracted from the @xmath65 mode using the u - spin symmetry and taking @xmath66 .
this is slightly larger than our fit result in scheme 2 . directly from the @xmath67 mode , we have only a poor upper bound of @xmath68 gev on @xmath69 .
the observable @xmath70 has the largest contribution to the total @xmath71 .
from table [ tab : dv ] , we observe that the area of the triangle formed from the @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath74 decays is very small , while that of the triangle formed from the @xmath75 , @xmath76 and @xmath77 modes is not .
this is the reason why the global @xmath78 fits in the @xmath2 sector are not as satisfactory as those in the @xmath7 and @xmath79 sectors . in ref .
@xcite , we noted that @xmath80 extracted from @xmath81 was inconsistent with @xmath82 extracted from a combination of the @xmath83 and @xmath84 modes .
currently , the former is @xmath85 gev if we take @xmath86 , and the latter is @xmath87 gev .
there is still a discrepancy at the 1.7@xmath88 level , or this discrepancy implies that the su(3 ) breaking factor @xmath89 should be greater than about @xmath90
. a determination of @xmath91 and better measurements of related modes will be very useful in providing further insights into this problem .
= 1 ( pink , solid ) and 2.30 ( blue , dotted ) contours on the @xmath92-@xmath93 , @xmath94-@xmath95 , and @xmath95-@xmath93 planes in scheme 3.,title="fig:",height=170 ] = 1 ( pink , solid ) and 2.30 ( blue , dotted ) contours on the @xmath92-@xmath93 , @xmath94-@xmath95 , and @xmath95-@xmath93 planes in scheme 3.,title="fig:",height=170 ] = 1 ( pink , solid ) and 2.30 ( blue , dotted ) contours on the @xmath92-@xmath93 , @xmath94-@xmath95 , and @xmath95-@xmath93 planes in scheme 3.,title="fig:",height=170 ] in fig . [ fig : dv2ce ] ,
we show the @xmath96 and @xmath97 contours on the @xmath92-@xmath93 , @xmath94-@xmath95 , and @xmath95-@xmath93 planes in scheme 3 , respectively .
we find that @xmath98 and @xmath99 .
we see that the magnitude of @xmath51 is larger than @xmath35 and @xmath52 , resulting in a more hierarchical structure among @xmath100 , @xmath80 and @xmath69 .
another result of the large @xmath51 is reflected in the bigger branching ratio prediction for the most dominant @xmath101 mode .
as in the @xmath79 sector , the central value of @xmath94 is non - zero , but is still consistent with zero within the 68.3% cl region .
the ratio of the two effective wilson coefficients can be extracted as @xmath102 where @xmath98 as obtained from the @xmath78 analysis in scheme 3 . in ref .
@xcite , it is estimated that @xmath103 at the 1 @xmath104 level using the data of the @xmath72 , @xmath73 and @xmath105 modes . finally , we summarize our findings in fig . [
fig : amps ] .
these diagrams are constructed by taking the central values of the fitted parameters in each category using scheme 3 .
they illustrate the sizes and relative phases among the tree , color - suppressed , and exchange amplitudes
. decays ; ( b ) : @xmath79 decays ; and ( c ) : @xmath2 decays . [ fig : amps],title="fig:",height=113 ] + ( a ) + decays ; ( b ) : @xmath79 decays ; and ( c ) : @xmath2 decays .
[ fig : amps],title="fig:",height=113 ] + ( b ) + decays ; ( b ) : @xmath79 decays ; and ( c ) : @xmath2 decays . [ fig : amps],title="fig:",height=113 ] + ( c ) +
we have used the @xmath78 fit approach to re - analyze the two - body charmed @xmath0 meson decays in the flavor su(3)-symmetric formalism , taking into account different symmetry breaking schemes as well . in the @xmath7 and @xmath8
decays , there are significant improvement in the @xmath78 minimum between scheme 1 and scheme 2 , but not much between scheme 2 and scheme 3 .
this shows that the major su(3 ) breaking effect can be accounted for by the decay constant ratio @xmath106 , as demanded for example by naive factorization . the same feature ,
however , is not observed in the @xmath2 sector , where the corresponding decay constant ratio is approximately one . in our analysis ,
the fit results are generally consistent with those extracted from individual modes .
we have found that the color - suppressed amplitudes are enhanced in the @xmath7 and @xmath79 sectors , but not in the @xmath2 sector .
this strongly suggests that non - factorizable effects or final - state rescattering effects can not be neglected in the former two sectors . in the @xmath2 sector
, it is observed that the cabibbo - suppressed @xmath107 yields a @xmath80 that exceeds the bound @xmath108 given by a combination of the @xmath109 and @xmath110 branching ratios at @xmath111 level , or @xmath89 should be greater than about @xmath90 .
we urge the measurement of @xmath112 for a direct determination of the exchange amplitude , which may provide a possible solution to this problem .
finally we note that the exchange diagrams are at least an order of magnitude smaller than the dominant tree topologies in these decays .
consequently , it is difficult to determine their phases , particularly in the @xmath79 and @xmath2 sectors , unless data precision can be significantly improved in the future .
c. would like to thank the hospitality of the national center for theoretical sciences in taiwan and the institute of theoretical physics at univ . of oregon during his visit where part of this work was initiated and carried out .
this research was supported in part by the national science council of taiwan , r.o.c . under grant no .
nsc 95 - 2112-m-008 - 008 .
99 b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 131801 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0407057 ] .
y. chao _ et al . _
[ belle collaboration ] , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 191802 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0408100 ] ; k. abe _ et al .
_ , arxiv : hep - ex/0507045 . h. y. cheng , phys
. rev .
d * 65 * , 094012 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0108096 ] . c. k. chua , w. s. hou and k. c. yang , phys . rev .
d * 65 * , 096007 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0112148 ] ; c. k. chua and w. s. hou , phys .
d * 72 * , 036002 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0504084 ] .
fayyazuddin , jhep * 0209 * , 055 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206164 ] ; phys .
d * 70 * , 114018 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0402189 ] .
l. wolfenstein , phys . rev .
d * 69 * , 016006 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0309166 ] ; arxiv : hep - ph/0407344 . c. w. chiang and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 67 * , 074013 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0212274 ] .
l. l. chau , h. y. cheng , w. k. sze , h. yao and b. tseng , phys .
d * 43 * , 2176 ( 1991 ) [ erratum - ibid .
d * 58 * , 019902 ( 1998 ) ] .
m. gronau and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 53 * , 2516 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9509325 ] ; a. s. dighe , m. gronau and j. l. rosner , phys .
b * 367 * , 357 ( 1996 ) [ erratum - ibid .
b * 377 * , 325 ( 1996 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - ph/9509428 ] .
d. zeppenfeld , z. phys .
c * 8 * , 77 ( 1981 ) ; m. j. savage and m. b. wise , phys .
d * 39 * , 3346 ( 1989 ) [ erratum - ibid .
d * 40 * , 3127 ( 1989 ) ] ; m. gronau , o. f. hernandez , d. london and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 50 * , 4529 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9404283 ] ; m. gronau , o. f. hernandez , d. london and j. l. rosner , phys . rev .
d * 52 * , 6356 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9504326 ] ; m. gronau , o. f. hernandez , d. london and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 52 * , 6374 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9504327 ] .
l. wolfenstein , phys .
lett . * 51 * , 1945 ( 1983 ) .
j. charles _ et al .
_ [ ckmfitter group ] , eur .
j. c * 41 * , 1 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0406184 ] .
updated results may be found on web site http://ckmfitter.in2p3.fr/. updated results and references are tabulated periodically by the heavy flavor averaging group : http://www.slac.stanford.edu/xorg/hfag/rare .
w. m. yao _ et al . _
[ particle data group ] , j. phys .
g * 33 * , 1 ( 2006 ) .
[ cdf - run ii collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0610045 .
b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d * 74 * , 031101 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0604016 ] .
b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0604012 . f. j. ronga _ et al . _ [ belle collaboration ] , phys .
d * 73 * , 092003 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0604013 ] .
b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , phys .
d * 73 * , 111104 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0604017 ] .
s. blyth _ et al .
_ [ belle collaboration ] , phys .
d * 74 * , 092002 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0607029 ] .
b. aubert _ et al . _ [ babar collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0609033 .
b. aubert [ babar collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0610027 .
a. kuzmin [ belle collaboration ] , arxiv : hep - ex/0611054 .
the decay constants of @xmath113 and @xmath114 are extracted using the method given in the appendix of ref .
@xcite and the updated branching ratios given in ref .
@xcite . c. w. chiang and j. l. rosner , phys .
d * 65 * , 074035 ( 2002 ) [ erratum - ibid .
d * 68 * , 039902 ( 2003 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - ph/0112285 ] . c. s. kim , s. oh and c. yu , phys . lett .
b * 621 * , 259 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0412418 ] .
colangelo and r. ferrandes , phys .
b * 627 * , 77 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0508033 ] .
h. y. cheng , c. k. chua and c. w. hwang , phys .
d * 69 * , 074025 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310359 ] .
y. y. keum , t. kurimoto , h. n. li , c. d. lu and a. i. sanda , phys .
d * 69 * , 094018 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0305335 ] .
m. neubert and b. stech , adv .
high energy phys . * 15 * , 294 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9705292 ] . | the charmed @xmath0 decays , @xmath1 and @xmath2 , are re - analyzed using the latest experimental data , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 denote the pseudoscalar meson and vector meson , respectively .
we perform global fits under the assumption of flavor su(3 ) symmetry .
the size of the decay amplitudes and the strong phases between the topologically distinct amplitudes are studied .
predictions of the related @xmath5 decay rates are made based upon the fitted results .
we also note a serious su(3 ) symmetry breaking or inconsistency in the @xmath2 sector .
-1 cm |
let @xmath0 be a real hyperplane arrangement which is stable under the action of a coxeter group @xmath1 .
then @xmath1 acts naturally on the set @xmath9 of chambers of @xmath0 .
we want to find the number of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath9 .
a particular case of this problem was considered in the authors previous paper ( kamiya , takemura and terao @xcite ) and the present paper is motivated by an open problem left in section 6 of @xcite . by the general results of the present paper , we give the affirmative answer to the open problem in theorem [ thm : affirmative ] .
suppose throughout that @xmath10 , where @xmath2 is the coxeter arrangement of @xmath1 . in this paper
, we will show that the orbit space of @xmath9 is in one - to - one correspondence with the set of chambers @xmath11 of @xmath4 which are contained in @xmath12 , @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is an arbitrary chamber of @xmath15 .
from this fact , we find that the number of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath9 is given by @xmath16
. on the other hand , we will also study the set of chambers @xmath17 which are contained in a chamber @xmath18 of @xmath0 , @xmath19 .
we will prove that the cardinality of this set is equal to the order of the isotropy subgroup @xmath8 of @xmath7 .
moreover , we will investigate the structure of @xmath8 .
kamiya , takemura and terao @xcite tried to find the number of `` inequivalent ranking patterns generated by unfolding models of codimension one '' in psychometrics , and obtained an upper bound for this number .
it was left open to determine whether this upper bound is actually the exact number .
the problem boils down to proving ( or disproving ) that the orbit space of the chambers of the restricted all - subset arrangement ( @xcite ) @xmath0 under the action of the symmetric group @xmath20 is in one - to - one correspondence with @xmath21 for a chamber @xmath22 of the braid arrangement @xmath23 .
the results of the present paper establish the one - to - one correspondence .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : main ] , we verify our main results .
next , in section [ sec : example ] , we illustrate our general results with five examples , some of which are taken from the authors previous studies of unfolding models in psychometrics ( @xcite , @xcite ) . in section [ sec : example ] , we also solve the open problem of @xcite ( theorem [ thm : affirmative ] ) using our general results in section [ sec : main ] applied to one of our examples .
in this section , we state and prove our main results .
let @xmath24 be a euclidean space . consider a coxeter group @xmath1 acting on @xmath24 .
then the coxeter arrangement @xmath2 is the set of all reflecting hyperplanes of @xmath1 .
suppose that @xmath0 is a hyperplane arrangement which is stable under the natural action of @xmath1 .
we assume @xmath25 and define @xmath26 let @xmath27 , @xmath9 and @xmath28 denote the set of chambers of @xmath15 , @xmath0 and @xmath6 , respectively . define @xmath29 by @xmath30 for @xmath31 .
note that the coxeter group @xmath1 naturally acts on @xmath27 , @xmath9 and @xmath28 .
[ lemma:1 ] @xmath32 and @xmath33 are both @xmath1-equivariant , i.e. , @xmath34 for any @xmath35 and @xmath17 .
the proof is easy and omitted .
the following result is classical ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ?
theorem 1 ( iii ) ) ): [ theorem:2 ] the group @xmath1 acts on @xmath27 effectively and transitively .
in particular , @xmath36 . using theorem [ theorem:2 ] , we can prove the following lemma .
[ lemma:3 ] the group @xmath1 acts on @xmath28 effectively . in particular , each @xmath1-orbit of @xmath28 is of size @xmath37 . if @xmath38 for @xmath39 and @xmath40 , then we have @xmath41 which implies @xmath42 by theorem [ theorem:2 ] .
+ for @xmath43 , define the isotropy subgroup @xmath44 .
then we have the next lemma . [ lemma:4 ] for @xmath18 ,
the group @xmath8 acts on @xmath45 effectively and transitively .
the effective part follows from lemma [ lemma:3 ] , so let us prove the transitivity .
let @xmath46 .
define @xmath47 let us prove that there exists @xmath39 such that @xmath48 by an induction on @xmath49 .
when @xmath50 , we have @xmath51 and @xmath52 .
thus we may choose @xmath42 .
if @xmath53 is non - empty , then there exists @xmath54 such that @xmath55 contains a wall of @xmath56 .
let @xmath57 denote the reflection with respect to @xmath55 .
then @xmath58 by the induction assumption , there exists @xmath59 with @xmath60 .
. then @xmath62 and @xmath63 , which implies that @xmath64 is not empty .
thus @xmath65 and @xmath66 .
+ the following lemma states that the @xmath1-orbits of @xmath28 and those of @xmath9 are in one - to - one correspondence .
[ lemma:5 ] the map @xmath67 induces a bijection from the set of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath28 to the set of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath9 . for @xmath43 and @xmath31
, we denote the @xmath1-orbit of @xmath7 and the @xmath1-orbit of @xmath11 by @xmath68 and by @xmath69 , respectively .
it is easy to see that @xmath70 by lemma [ lemma:1 ] .
thus @xmath33 induces a map from the set of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath28 to the set of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath9 .
we will show the map is bijective .
_ surjectivity _ : let @xmath68 be an arbitrary orbit of @xmath9 with a representative point @xmath18 . take an arbitrary @xmath71 . then @xmath72 which shows the surjectivity .
_ injectivity _ : suppose @xmath73 .
set @xmath74 for @xmath75 .
we have @xmath76 so we can pick @xmath39 such that @xmath77 . then @xmath78 therefore , both @xmath79 and @xmath80 lie in @xmath81 . by lemma [ lemma:4 ]
, we have @xmath82 + we are now in a position to state the main results of this paper .
[ theorem:6 ] the cardinalities of @xmath83 for @xmath84 are given as follows : 1 .
for @xmath85 , we have @xmath86 , we have @xmath87 part 2 follows from lemma [ lemma:4 ] , so we will prove part 1 . since the map @xmath88 is @xmath1-equivariant ( lemma [ lemma:1 ] ) , we have for each @xmath35 a bijection @xmath89 sending @xmath90 to @xmath91 .
thus every fiber of @xmath92 has the same cardinality because @xmath1 acts transitively on @xmath27 ( theorem [ theorem:2 ] ) .
the cardinality is equal to @xmath93 by lemma [ lemma:3 ] , we have @xmath94 finally , lemma [ lemma:5 ] proves the last equality .
+ by part 2 of theorem [ theorem:6 ] , we can write @xmath95 as @xmath96 where @xmath97 denotes the number of elements of @xmath9 fixed by @xmath98 . in the case of the catalan arrangement ,
is stated in @xcite .
next , let @xmath99 .
let @xmath18 denote the unique chamber that contains @xmath100 .
define the average @xmath101 of @xmath100 over the action of @xmath8 : @xmath102 then it is easily seen that @xmath101 lies in @xmath7 because of the convexity of @xmath7 , and that the map @xmath103 is @xmath1-equivariant .
concerning the structure of @xmath8 , we have the next proposition .
[ prop : w_b = w_z ] the following statements hold true : 1 . for any @xmath18 ,
the set @xmath104 is equal to the set of all @xmath8-invariant points of @xmath7 .
2 . for any @xmath105 , the isotropy subgroup @xmath106 of @xmath101 is equal to @xmath107 , where @xmath18 is the unique chamber that contains @xmath100 .
in particular , @xmath106 depends only on the chamber @xmath43 containing @xmath100 .
\1 . by the linearity of the action of @xmath1 on @xmath24 ,
the average @xmath108 of @xmath109 is @xmath107-invariant : @xmath110 .
conversely , the average of any @xmath107-invariant point of @xmath7 is the point itself .
. then @xmath112 , which implies @xmath113 .
since @xmath7 and @xmath114 are both chambers , they coincide : @xmath65 .
thus @xmath66 and we obtain @xmath115 we also have the reverse inclusion because the average @xmath101 is @xmath107-invariant by the statement 1 . +
when @xmath1 is the symmetric group @xmath116 , we have the following obvious fact ( proposition [ prop : w_b ] ) .
define @xmath117 the group @xmath118 acts on @xmath119 or @xmath120 by permuting coordinates . when @xmath118 and @xmath119 or @xmath120 , we agree that this action is considered . [ prop : w_b ] let @xmath118 and @xmath119 or @xmath120
. then we have @xmath121 where @xmath122 ( @xmath123 ) are defined by @xmath124 for @xmath125 , and a permutation @xmath126 .
[ rem : conjugacy - injection ] consider the map @xmath127 from @xmath9 to the set of subgroups of @xmath1 .
since @xmath128 , this induces a map @xmath129 from the set of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath9 to the set of conjugacy classes of subgroups of @xmath1 : @xmath130 , \quad b \in { { \rm \bf ch}}({\mathcal{b}}),\ ] ] where @xmath131:=\ { w w_b w^{-1 } \mid w \in w\}$ ] .
this map @xmath129 is not injective in general .
see remarks [ rem : non - unique - example - semiorder ] and [ rem : non - unique - example ] .
in this section , we examine five examples . the first example ( subsection [ subsec : catalan ] ) is the catalan arrangement , which has been well studied as a deformation of the braid arrangement .
the catalan arrangement is related to the semiorder introduced by luce @xcite in economics and mathematical psychology as a preference order that accounts for intransitive indifference .
the next three examples are taken from problems in psychometrics the arrangements in subsections [ subsec : a+r - allsubset ] and [ subsec : a+u - allsubset ] ( the braid arrangement in conjunction with the all - subset arrangement ) appear naturally in the study of ranking patterns of unfolding models of codimension one ( kamiya , takemura and terao @xcite ) , while the mid - hyperplane arrangement in subsection [ subsec : mid - hyper ] is needed in examining ranking patterns of unidimensional unfolding models ( kamiya , orlik , takemura and terao @xcite ) .
in all four examples in subsections [ subsec : catalan][subsec : mid - hyper ] , the coxeter group @xmath1 is of type @xmath132 . in subsection [ subsec : signed - allsubset ]
, we provide an illustration with the coxeter group of type @xmath133 .
we also solve the open problem of @xcite in subsection [ subsec : a+r - allsubset ] .
let @xmath118 and @xmath120 .
then @xmath2 is the braid arrangement in @xmath134 , consisting of the hyperplanes defined by @xmath135 .
all the @xmath136 hyperplanes form one orbit under the action of @xmath1 on @xmath15 . now , as a chamber of @xmath15 , let us take @xmath14 defined by @xmath140 : @xmath141 for this @xmath12 , we have always @xmath142 for @xmath143 , so the elements of @xmath144 are determined by the sets of pairs @xmath145 such that @xmath146 , or equivalently the sets of maximal intervals @xmath147:=\ { i , i+1 , \ldots , j\ } \
( i < j)$ ] such that @xmath146 , for @xmath143 .
it is well known ( ( * ? ? ? * ( 1.1 ) ) , @xcite ) that the number @xmath148 is equal to the catalan number @xmath149 thus @xmath150 besides , from @xmath151 , the characteristic polynomial @xmath152 of @xmath6 ( ( * ? ? ?
* definition 2.52 ) ) can be calculated as @xmath153 ( ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.18 ) ) .
the @xmath1-orbits of @xmath28 are given as follows .
let @xmath154 , be the chambers of @xmath6 which are contained in @xmath12 in : @xmath155 .
as was mentioned earlier , each @xmath156 , can be indexed by the set of maximal intervals @xmath147\subseteq \ { 1,\ldots , m\ } \ ( i < j)$ ] such that @xmath146 .
the set @xmath157 is a complete set of representatives of the @xmath1-orbits of @xmath28 , i.e. , @xmath28 has exactly @xmath158 orbits @xmath159 , under the action of @xmath1 . next ,
consider the chambers of @xmath0 .
the elements of @xmath9 are in one - to - one correspondence with the set of semiorders on @xmath160 .
recall that a partial order @xmath161 on @xmath160 is called a _
semiorder _ ( or a _ unit interval order _ ) if and only if the poset @xmath162 contains no induced subposet isomorphic to @xmath163 or @xmath164 , where @xmath165 stands for the disjoint union of an @xmath166-element chain and a @xmath167-element chain .
the scott - suppes theorem ( @xcite ) states that a partial order @xmath161 on @xmath160 is a semiorder if and only if there exist @xmath168 such that @xmath169 , where @xmath170 now , a bijection from @xmath9 to the set @xmath171 of semiorders on @xmath160 is given by @xmath172 , where @xmath161 is the partial order determined by with an arbitrary @xmath173 .
( the surjectivity of this map follows from the `` distinguishing property '' of @xmath171 ( ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 5.1 ) , ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 7.35 ) ) . )
the number of chambers of @xmath0 is obtained as follows .
let us denote ( only in this paragraph ) our @xmath0 and @xmath6 as @xmath174 and @xmath175 , respectively .
postnikov and stanley ( * ? ? ?
* lemma 7.6 ) proved that @xmath176 , where @xmath177 is the number of cycles of @xmath178 .
thus is written as @xmath179 in this case ( ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 7.1 ) , ( * ? ? ? * solution to exercise 6.30 ) ) , where @xmath180 is the signless stirling number of the first kind .
because of ( * ? ? ?
* proposition 1.4.1 ) , equation is equivalent to @xmath181 where @xmath182 is the stirling number of the second kind .
the number of semiorders , @xmath183 , in was first obtained by chandon , lemaire and pouget ( * ? ? ? * proposition 12 ) .
in addition , by and @xmath184 ( @xcite ) , we obtain @xmath185 ( ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 7.1 ) , ( * ? ? ?
* corollary 5.12 ) , ( * ? ? ?
* exercise 6.30 ) ; cf .
* table on p. 79 ) ) , where @xmath186 ( @xcite ) . by and @xmath187 ( ( * ? ? ?
* theorem 4.3.1 ) ) , we can also get @xmath188 the arrangement @xmath15 consists of three lines in @xmath192 , each of which is defined by one of the following equations : @xmath193 and @xmath0 comprises six lines : @xmath194 figure [ fig : catalan - m=3 ] displays @xmath15 and @xmath0 in @xmath120 .
let @xmath14 be as in : @xmath195 ( @xmath12 is shaded in figure [ fig : catalan - m=3 ] ) .
this chamber @xmath12 of @xmath15 contains exactly five @xmath196 chambers @xmath197 of @xmath6 : @xmath198 .
these five chambers @xmath197 are indexed by the following sets of maximal intervals @xmath147 $ ] such that @xmath146 : @xmath199\ } , \\ & & c_2 : \ , \emptyset , \\ & & c_3 : \ { [ 2,3]\ } , \\
& & c_4 : \ { [ 1,2 ] , \ , [ 2,3]\ } , \\ & & c_5 : \ { [ 1,3]\}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that @xmath200 and @xmath201 are obtained from each other by changing @xmath202 to @xmath203 .
since @xmath14 consists of @xmath204 chambers @xmath197 of @xmath6 , we have @xmath205 , and @xmath28 has exactly five @xmath1-orbits @xmath206 . in @xmath207\}$ ] , we have @xmath208 and @xmath209 , so the semiorder corresponding to @xmath210 is @xmath211 .
( recall that for the @xmath12 in , and hence for any @xmath17 contained in @xmath12 , we have never @xmath212 for @xmath213 . ) by similar arguments , we can also obtain the semiorders corresponding to @xmath214 for @xmath215 : @xmath216 see figure [ fig : catalan - m=3-b ] .
again , @xmath217 and @xmath218 are obtained from each other by the above - mentioned rule .
the chamber @xmath219 is divided by the line of @xmath15 defined by @xmath220 into two chambers of @xmath6 , @xmath221 .
the @xmath222-invariant points @xmath103 of @xmath217 are @xmath223 , so we have @xmath224 . in a similar manner , @xmath225 is not divided by any line in @xmath15 ; @xmath218 is divided by the line @xmath226 into two ; @xmath227 is not divided by any line ; and @xmath228 is divided by the three lines @xmath229 into six .
the isotropy subgroups @xmath8 and the @xmath8-invariant points @xmath103 of @xmath7 for @xmath230 are given in table [ table : w_b - z - for - semiorder ] .
[ rem : non - unique - example ] in table [ table : w_b - z - for - u - all - subset ] , we find that @xmath238 are all conjugate to one another , although @xmath239 are on different orbits .
we have @xmath240 ) = \ { { \mathcal{o}}(b_1 ) , { \mathcal{o}}(b_3 ) , { \mathcal{o}}(b_4)\},\ ] ] so @xmath129 is not injective .
the chambers @xmath239 are triangular cones ( triangles in figure [ fig : braid+unrestricted - m=3-b ] ) cut by a single plane ( line ) @xmath241 from the braid arrangement .
however , these chambers are easily seen to be on different orbits , since their three walls ( edges ) are of different combinations of orbits of @xmath0 . for @xmath242 , we computed @xmath243 using the finite - field method , and obtained the numbers of @xmath1-orbits of @xmath9 as follows : latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } m=3 : \quad \chi({\mathcal{c}},t ) & = ( t-1)(t-4)(t-5 ) , \quad |{{\rm \bf ch}}({\mathcal{c}})|=60 , \quad
let @xmath118 and @xmath120 , so @xmath2 is the braid arrangement in @xmath134 .
we take @xmath247 so that @xmath4 is an essentialization of the mid - hyperplane arrangement ( kamiya , orlik , takemura and terao @xcite ) .
we have @xmath248 , and the action of @xmath1 on @xmath0 is transitive .
the elements of @xmath15 are the six planes in @xmath250 , defined by the equations in , whereas those of @xmath0 are the three planes defined by the following equations : @xmath251 figure [ fig : mid - hyper - m=4 ] shows the intersection with the unit sphere @xmath252 in @xmath134 .
let us take @xmath14 defined by @xmath253 ( @xmath12 is shaded in figure [ fig : mid - hyper - m=4 ] ) .
then @xmath254 , where @xmath255 note that @xmath256 is obtained from @xmath11 by changing @xmath257 to @xmath258 .
we have @xmath259 and @xmath260 .
the chamber @xmath261 is @xmath262 which is divided by the three planes @xmath263 into six chambers ( figure [ fig : mid - hyper - m=4-b ] ) .
we find the @xmath8-invariant points @xmath103 of @xmath7 to be @xmath264 , so @xmath265 and @xmath266 .
let @xmath1 be the coxeter group of type @xmath133 , i.e. , the semidirect product of @xmath20 by @xmath275 : @xmath276 .
then @xmath1 acts on @xmath119 by permuting coordinates by @xmath20 and changing signs of coordinates by @xmath275 .
the coxeter arrangement @xmath2 consists of the hyperplanes defined by @xmath277 we have @xmath278 .
moreover , the number of orbits of @xmath15 under the action of @xmath1 is two : one consisting of the @xmath279 hyperplanes in and the other made up of the @xmath280 hyperplanes in . in this case , @xmath15 comprises the nine planes in @xmath286 defined by @xmath287 with each line corresponding to one orbit , and @xmath0 consists of one orbit containing the four planes defined by @xmath288 figure [ fig : signed - m=3 ] shows the intersection with the unit sphere in @xmath286 .
( in figure [ fig : signed - m=3 ] , the planes in , and are drawn in blue , black and purple , respectively . ) the chambers @xmath293 , are @xmath294 ( figure [ fig : signed - m=3-b ] ) .
the chamber @xmath217 is divided by the three planes @xmath295 into six chambers , and @xmath225 is divided by the four planes @xmath296 into eight .
we see @xmath297 is the coxeter group of type @xmath298 ( the @xmath222-invariant points @xmath103 of @xmath217 are @xmath299 ) , and that @xmath300 is the coxeter group of type @xmath301 ( the @xmath302-invariant points @xmath103 of @xmath225 are @xmath303 ) .
hence latexmath:[$|w_{b_1}|=3!=|\varphi_{{\mathcal{b}}}^{-1}(b_1)| , \
the authors are very grateful to an anonymous referee for valuable comments on an earlier version of this paper .
the example of the catalan arrangement in subsection [ subsec : catalan ] was suggested by the referee .
h. kamiya , a. takemura , h. terao , the characteristic quasi - polynomials of the arrangements of root systems and mid - hyperplane arrangements , in : f. el zein , a. i. suciu , m. tosun , a. m. uluda , s. yuzvinsky , ( eds . ) , arrangements , local systems and singularities , cimpa summer school , galatasaray university , istanbul , 2007 , progress in mathematics 283 , birkhuser verlag , basel , 2009 , pp . 177190 .
r. p. stanley , an introduction to hyperplane arrangements , in : e. miller , v. reiner , b. sturmfels , ( eds . ) , geometric combinatorics , ias / park city mathematics series 13 , american mathematical society , providence , ri , 2007 , pp . | let @xmath0 be a real hyperplane arrangement which is stable under the action of a coxeter group @xmath1 .
then @xmath1 acts naturally on the set of chambers of @xmath0 .
we assume that @xmath0 is disjoint from the coxeter arrangement @xmath2 of @xmath1 . in this paper , we show that the @xmath1-orbits of the set of chambers of @xmath3 are in one - to - one correspondence with the chambers of @xmath4 which are contained in an arbitrarily fixed chamber of @xmath5 .
from this fact , we find that the number of @xmath1-orbits of the set of chambers of @xmath0 is given by the number of chambers of @xmath6 divided by the order of @xmath1
. we will also study the set of chambers of @xmath6 which are contained in a chamber @xmath7 of @xmath0 .
we prove that the cardinality of this set is equal to the order of the isotropy subgroup @xmath8 of @xmath7 .
we illustrate these results with some examples , and solve an open problem in [ h. kamiya , a. takemura , h. terao , ranking patterns of unfolding models of codimension one , adv . in appl .
math .
47 ( 2011 ) 379400 ] by using our results .
_ keywords : _ all - subset arrangement , braid arrangement , catalan arrangement , characteristic polynomial , coxeter arrangement , coxeter group , finite - field method , mid - hyperplane arrangement , semiorder , symmetric group .
_ msc2010 : _ 20f55 , 32s22 , 52c35 . |
to study the linear polarization of asteroids and other point source objects , the dual - beam imaging polarimeter ( dbip ) was commissioned in march of 2007 @xcite . in august of 2007 we expanded dbip s capabilities to include analysis of circular polarization with the addition of a quarterwave plate . typically , the most important quantities for analysis are the fractional polarizations @xmath1 , @xmath2 , and @xmath3 , expressed as percentages , and in the following text we will deal with these quantities when we refer to polarization measurements . here
we present our subsequent calibration and determination of systematic errors which were found to be comparable to statistical errors for typical observing situations : @xmath4 polarization .
the original setup of dbip was a serial arrangement of a halfwave plate in an encoded rotation stage , a filter and a double - calcite savart plate placed between the telescope and the @xmath5 tektronix ccd camera . to extend dbip to full - stokes sensitivity , a quarterwave plate in a rotation stage
was placed ahead of the halfwave plate .
this setup allows for simultaneous measurement of linear and circular polarization , though at the potential cost of increased crosstalk between polarizations , which is discussed further in [ jrm_crosstalk ] figure [ jrm_fig.optics ] , modified from @xcite , shows a schematic representation of the new optical path with the quarterwave plate added .
as with any optical system , misalignments and imperfections in the components will lead to errors in measurement . in the case of dbip , the waveplates are the most sensitive components to these errors , as they are the only moving parts and require precisely determined angular zero - points .
errors in angular alignment of the waveplate or tilt with respect to the optical axis as well as chromatic retardance or fast - axis angle variations will show up in our system as variations in measured position angle of polarization , depolarization of the signal , or crosstalk between linear and circular polarization . to minimize and quantify these errors we performed an extensive calibration campaign .
our first step of calibration was to determine the alignment of the waveplate zero - points using known standard stars .
having already aligned the halfwave plate against standards before the installation of the quarterwave plate @xcite , we were able to re - observe one of the same polarization standards ( ngc 2024 - 1 ) in full - stokes mode to align the quarterwave zero - point while confirming that we could reproduce the linear polarization results for this target .
the set of observations of ngc 2024 - 1 , both before and after the addition of the quarterwave plate , are listed in table [ jrm_tab.stds ] , where a circular polarization value of `` '' indicates a measurement taken before the installation of the quarterwave plate .
ccccccc name & obs date & @xmath6lin pol@xmath7 & @xmath8 & @xmath6lin pol@xmath9 & @xmath10 & @xmath6circ pol@xmath9 + bd-12 5133 & 3/24/07 & @xmath11 & @xmath12 & @xmath13 & @xmath14 & + ngc 2024 - 1 & 3/24/07 & @xmath15 & @xmath16 & @xmath17 & @xmath18 & + ngc 2024 - 1 & 1/17/08 & @xmath15 & @xmath16 & @xmath19 & @xmath20 & @xmath21 + ngc 2024 - 1 & 3/12/08 & @xmath15 & @xmath16 & @xmath22 & @xmath23 & @xmath24 + bd-13 5073 & 5/14/08 & @xmath25 & @xmath26 & @xmath27 & @xmath28 & @xmath29 + bd-12 5133 & 5/14/08 & @xmath11 & @xmath12 & @xmath30 & @xmath31 & @xmath32 + bd-12 5133 & 6/11/08 & @xmath11 & @xmath12 & @xmath33 & @xmath34 & @xmath35 + vi cyg 12 & 6/11/08 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 & @xmath38 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 + [ jrm_tab.stds ] cccccc name & obs date & @xmath6lin pol@xmath7 & @xmath6lin pol@xmath9 & @xmath10 & @xmath6circ pol@xmath9 + hd 64299 & 03/23/07 & @xmath41 & @xmath42 & @xmath43 & + wd 1615 - 154 & 03/24/07 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & & + wd 1615 - 154 & 03/12/08 & @xmath44 & @xmath46 & & @xmath47 + wd 1615 - 154 & 05/14/08 & @xmath44 & @xmath48 & & @xmath49 + wd 1615 - 154 & 06/11/08 & @xmath44 & @xmath50 & @xmath51 & @xmath52 + bd+28d4211 & 08/29/07 & @xmath44 & @xmath45 & & @xmath53 + wd 2149 + 021 & 08/30/07 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & & @xmath53 + g191b2b & 01/17/08 & @xmath56 & @xmath48 & & @xmath57 + [ jrm_tab.unpol ] in order to test for instrumental polarization or depolarization , we have observed polarized and unpolarized standard stars over a @xmath58 month baseline . tables [ jrm_tab.stds ] and [ jrm_tab.unpol ] give our measured polarizations and position angles for polarized and unpolarized standard stars , respectively , as well as literature values for these objects from @xcite , @xcite and the keck / lrisp standards .
our measurements for both polarized and unpolarized standards agree within @xmath59 of the literature values , confirming that instrument systematics are less than a @xmath60 effect .
the only exceptions to this are the observations of bd-13 5073 and wd 1615 - 154 .
bd-13 5073 clearly shows evidence of variation in the amplitude and direction of polarization from the literature values over only a few years , showing it can not be depended upon as a polarized standard .
our observation of wd 1615 - 154 on 6/11/08 shows
anomalously high polarization compared to literature values and our previous observations at the @xmath61 level . with the current data it is unclear if the polarization properties of the object have changed or if this measurement is just an outlier .
instrumental crosstalk between stokes vectors is one of the more subtle errors that can affect polarization measurements and quantifying its magnitude is a critical step toward obtaining high precision polarimetry .
crosstalk between linear stokes vectors ( @xmath62 to @xmath63 or @xmath63 to @xmath62 ) happens when the zero - point location of the halfwave retarder is offset from the defined @xmath62 direction , and is easily corrected by aligning the waveplate , as discussed above in
[ jrm_align ] crosstalk from circular to linear and back ( @xmath64 to @xmath65 or @xmath65 to @xmath64 ) can be caused by waveplate offsets or by variations in retardance of the wave - plates as a function of wavelength , position on the plate , etc . to fully determine the instrumental crosstalk , light with a known polarization
must be sent through the instrument and measured upon exiting .
it is possible to do this by installing polarizers just in front of the instrument during observations ( recent examples include * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* etc . ) , however due to limited observing time and space in the optical path this was not a feasible calibration method for dbip . instead , we performed lab bench calibrations to quantify instrumental crosstalk . to measure @xmath65 to @xmath64 crosstalk we sent a collimated light source through a linear polarizer into dbip and measured one of the two exiting beams with a precision photodiode .
by stepping the angular position of the input linear polarizer , we were able to fully characterize this linear - to - circular crosstalk . to measure @xmath64 to @xmath65 crosstalk a fixed quarterwave plate was installed after the linear polarizer . by stepping the linear polarizer again
, we were able to vary the input polarization from circular to linear and back and characterize this circular - to - linear crosstalk .
figure [ jrm_fig.crosstalk ] shows our measured polarization state for both setups as the input linear polarizer was stepped through @xmath66degrees .
sinusoids describe the behavior of the polarization vectors in both setups and were fit with a chi - squared minimizer to the data to determine percentage crosstalk as well as any depolarization from the optics .
we find that the circular polarization measured when inputing pure linearly polarized light had an amplitude of @xmath67 and an offset of @xmath68 , with crosstalk preferentially occurring when both q and u are positive ( around @xmath69 on our plot ) .
we measure a depolarization of both linear signals varying from @xmath70 near @xmath69 to @xmath71 near @xmath72 .
since these crosstalk errors are only a few percent of the input signal , for sources with `` typical '' polarizations ( i.e. @xmath73 ) the crosstalk error is comparable to the desired statistical errors of @xmath4 polarization , as we measured for our polarized and unpolarized standards . for the measurement of circular - to - linear crosstalk , we find a small amount of linear @xmath74 polarization generated from a purely circularly polarized input beam , preferentially when @xmath75 is input .
note that the phased oscillation of @xmath76 and @xmath74 indicate a small misalignment of the quarterwave plate axes with the instrument - defined @xmath62 orientation , while it is the slight phase offset between @xmath77 and @xmath78 that is produced by the crosstalk .
we also see clear evidence for a depolarization of the circularly polarized signal at the level of @xmath71 of the input polarization . for targets with total circular polarizations less than a few percent
these errors should be comparable the @xmath60 noise error typically obtained in our observations .
we have presented the results of our extended commissioning of dbip into full - stokes mode .
crosstalk values are shown to be small and can be ignored for objects with `` typical '' ( i.e. @xmath79 ) polarizations . with errors well constrained
dbip is now available for scientific studies of linear and circular polarization of point sources in the optical .
dbip has already been successfully used to characterize the polarization - phase curves of asteroids with some of the most pristine compositions in the inner solar system @xcite and a number of other programs to study small solar system bodies are currently under way .
jm would like to thank robert jedicke and colin aspin for providing funding to attend the astronomical polarimetry 2008 conference .
jm was partially funded under nasa past grant nng06gi46 g .
the authors wish to recognize and acknowledge the very significant cultural role and reverence that the summit on mauna kea has always had within the indigenous hawaiian community .
we are most fortunate to have the opportunity to work with telescopes located on this sacred mountain . | in our previous paper @xcite we presented the design and initial calibrations of the dual - beam imaging polarimeter ( dbip ) , a new optical instrument for the university of hawaii s @xmath0 m telescope on the summit of mauna kea , hawaii . in this followup work
we discuss our full - stokes mode commissioning including crosstalk determination and our typical observing methodology . |
a new renormalizable gravity theory in four dimensions , proposed by hoava @xcite , may be regarded as a uv complete candidate for general relativity . at large distances
the theory reduces to einstein gravity with a non - vanishing cosmological constant in ir , but with improved uv behavior . as discussed in ref .
@xcite , from the ir - modified hoava action , which reduces to the standard einstein - hilbert action in the ir limit , one obtains the analogue of the standard spherically symmetric schwarzschild-(a)ds black - hole solution .
in this paper we employ such a class of black holes by starting with two copies thereof and constructing a traversable thin - shell wormhole by means of the cut - and - paste technique @xcite . to compare and contrast the two gravitational theories , we discuss various aspects of these wormholes , such as the location of the event horizons , the energy density of the thin shell , the violation of the weak energy condition at the junction surface , the amount of exotic matter required , and the equation of state . our final topic is the question of stability to a linearized spherically symmetric perturbation .
consider the static and spherically symmetric line element @xmath0 the modified hoava action mentioned above is @xmath1,\end{gathered}\ ] ] where @xmath2@xcite . here
@xmath3 and @xmath4 are dimensionless coupling constants , while the constants @xmath5 and @xmath6 are dimensionful .
the case @xmath7 , which reduces to the standard einstein - hilbert action in the ir limit @xcite , yields @xmath8}.\ ] ] here @xmath9 is an integration constant . by considering @xmath10 and @xmath11 ,
this reduces to the solution given by lu , mei , and pope ( lmp ) @xcite : @xmath12 if @xmath13 and @xmath14 in eq .
( [ e : gtt ] ) , one obtains the kehagias - sfetsos ( ks ) black - hole solution @xcite : @xmath15 finally , since @xmath7 , we now have @xmath16 the kehagias - sfetsos solution is the only asymptotically flat solution in the family of solutions ( [ e : gtt ] ) .
we will therefore use the kehagias - sfetsos solution for constructing the thin - shell wormhole from hoava - lifshitz black holes .
it is to be noted that there is an outer ( event ) horizon @xmath17 , and an inner ( cauchy ) horizon @xmath18 of the kehagias - sfetsos black - hole solution for @xmath19 at @xmath20,\ ] ] compared to @xmath21 for the schwarzschild case , i.e. , in einstein gravity .
this spacetime comes back to the schwarzschild black hole for @xmath22 , so that @xmath23 finally , observe that @xmath24 \\
< r _ + ( ks ) = m\left [ 1+\sqrt{1-\frac{1}{2wm^2}}~\right ] < 2m= r_+(schwarzschild).\end{gathered}\ ] ] the event horizons for various values of @xmath25 and their relationship to the schwarzschild case can be seen in fig . 1 . using various parameters .
the dotted , dashed , long dashed , and chain curves correspond to @xmath26 , respectively .
the thick solid lines corresponds to the schwarzschild case .
the blue , black , red and brown colors represent @xmath27 , respectively.,scaledwidth=50.0% ]
the mathematical construction of a thin - shell wormhole , when first proposed by visser @xcite , used a flat minkowski space as a starting point .
the construction itself , however , relies on a topological identification of two surfaces and is not confined to a particular type of geometry .
so we can safely start with two copies of a kehagias - sfetsos black hole and remove from each the four - dimensional region @xmath28 we assume that @xmath29 , the larger of the two radii .
the construction proceeds by identifying ( in the sense of topology ) the timelike hypersurfaces @xmath30 denoted by @xmath31 .
thanks to the asymptotic flatness referred to above , the resulting manifold is geodesically complete and consists of two asymptotically flat regions connected by a throat , namely @xmath32 .
our main goal is to compare various characteristics of hoava - lifshitz gravity and einstein gravity , such as the surface stress - energy tensor and the basic question of stability .
a complete analysis would require , as always , a detailed knowledge of the junction conditions , but the traditional method , using the lanczos equations , does not automatically carry over to kehagias - sfetsos black holes without an additional assumption .
so let us return to eq .
( [ e : eventhorizons ] ) and fig .
1 , neither of which depends on the junction conditions , to gain an overview : the effect of the convergence to the schwarzschild case can be clearly seen for the event horizons .
but the convergence of the ks solution to the schwarzschild solution is true in general and never depends on the junction conditions . from this standpoint
, all well - constructed plots can be expected to show certain trends that allow a comparison between the two gravitational theories . indeed
, all the plots to follow show the gradual departure from the schwarzschild limit as @xmath33 decreases .
the ability to make the relevant comparisons justifies the assumption that the thin - shell formalism is at least _
qualitatively _ acceptable , given that the use of plots is essentially qualitative in nature .
for example , fig .
7 shows that the amount of exotic matter required is _ less _ for the ks case than for the schwarzschild case , which is indeed a qualitative statement .
( this point will be reiterated from time to time when making the comparisons . ) a final observation in fig .
1 is that the plot for @xmath34 starts taking on a very different form from that of the schwarzschild case for small values of @xmath32 , enough to cast some doubt on the validity .
this suspicion is readily confirmed by the fact that in some cases the results are actually unphysical for sufficiently small values of @xmath33 ; such values may therefore be disregarded as meaningless . with these caveats in mind
, we will proceed with the assumption that the induced metric on @xmath31 is given by @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the proper time on the junction surface .
it follows from the lanczos equations @xcite , @xmath37 -\delta^i_{\phantom{i}j}[k]\right),\ ] ] that the surface stress - energy tensor is @xmath38 , where @xmath39 is the surface energy density and @xmath40 is the surface pressure .
the lanczos equations then yield @xmath41\ ] ] and @xmath42 + [ k^\theta_{\phantom{\theta}\theta}]\right).\ ] ] following ref .
@xcite , a dynamic analysis can be obtained by letting the radius @xmath32 be a function of time . as a result , @xmath43 and @xmath44 where the overdot and prime denote , respectively , the derivatives with respect to @xmath36 and @xmath33 . here
@xmath45 and @xmath46 obey the conservation equation @xmath47 or @xmath48 for a static configuration of radius @xmath33 , we need to assume that @xmath49 and @xmath50 . from eqs .
( [ e : s ] ) and ( [ e : p ] ) we have @xmath51 in hoava - lifshitz gravity and @xmath52 in einstein gravity .
eq.([e : sigmaks ] ) shows that the energy density of the shell is negative in the ks case , just as it is in the schwarzschild case .
we can see from fig .
2 that in the ks case the energy density of the shell tends to be well below that of the schwarzschild case , as long as @xmath33 is not too small , which is a considerable advantage from the standpoint of wormhole design . as @xmath33 gets large , however , @xmath53 approaches vs. @xmath33 for various parameters .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=40.0% ]
@xmath54 , as expected from the discussion in sec .
[ s : hlbh ] .
qualitatively , fig .
3 shows a similar advantagious behavior for the lateral pressure @xmath55\ ] ] in hoava - lifshitz gravity and @xmath56\ ] ] in einstein gravity .
once again , the differences are greatest for somewhat smaller values of @xmath33 .
( figs . 2 and 3 also show the effect of having different event horizons . ) vs. @xmath33 for various parameters .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=40.0% ]
since the shell is infinitely thin , the radial pressure is zero .
so the matter on the shell violates both the weak and null energy conditions .
let us suppose that the eos at the surface @xmath31 is @xmath57 . from eqs .
( [ e : sigmaks ] ) -([e : pressures ] ) , @xmath58\ ] ] in hoava - lifshitz gravity and @xmath59\ ] ] in einstein gravity .
even though @xmath60 , @xmath61 extends into the phantom - energy regime ( less than @xmath62 ) , but in both cases , @xmath63 from below as @xmath64 , as shown in fig .
the positive values are unphysical , corresponding to locations well inside the event horizon . vs. @xmath33 for various parameters .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=40.0% ]
another property worth checking is the traceless surface stress - energy tensor @xmath65 , i.e. , @xmath66 .
the reason is that the casimir effect with a massless field is of the traceless type . from this equation
we find that @xmath67\\ + a \left
[ 4aw-4aw\sqrt{1 + \frac{4m}{wa^3}}+\frac{6m}{a^2 } \frac{1}{\sqrt{1 + \frac{4m}{wa^3}}}+ \frac{2}{a}\right ] = 0\end{gathered}\ ] ] in hoava - lifshitz gravity and @xmath68 in einstein gravity . cut the @xmath33-axis at points less than the horizon @xmath17 .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig .
1.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] we can see from fig .
5 that the values of @xmath33 satisfying these equations lie inside the event horizon , ensuring that this situation can not occur when dealing thin - shell wormholes .
in this section we study the attractive or repulsive nature of our wormhole . to this end , we calculate the observer s four - acceleration @xmath69 where @xmath70 it follows from eq .
( [ e : gtt ] ) that the only nonzero component is given by @xmath71 where @xmath72 in hoava - lifshitz gravity and @xmath73 in einstein gravity .
a test particle moving radially from rest obeys the geodesic equation @xmath74 it is true in general that a wormhole is attractive whenever @xmath75 and repulsive whenever @xmath76 . according to fig .
6 , the wormholes are attractive in both gravitational theories , vs. @xmath33 for various parameters .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig . 1 . ,
scaledwidth=40.0% ] since the negative values in the ks case are well within the event horizon .
continuing the qualitative theme for small values of the throat radius , the acceleration is less for the ks case , which is an advantage for a traveler through the wormhole .
an important consideration in wormhole physics is the total amount of exotic matter on the thin - shell .
this total can be quantified by the integral @xcite @xmath77\sqrt{-g}d^3x.\ ] ] by introducing the radial coordinate @xmath78 , we get @xmath79\sqrt{-g}\,dr\,d\theta\,d\phi.\ ] ] since the shell is infinitely thin , it does not exert any radial pressure , while @xmath80 .
so @xmath81 \right|_{r = a}d\theta\,d\phi=4\pi a^2\sigma(a)\\ = -2a \sqrt{1+wa^2- wa^2\sqrt{1 + \frac{4m}{wa^3}}}\end{gathered}\ ] ] in hoava - lifshitz gravity and @xmath82 in einstein gravity .
according to fig .
7 , for small @xmath33 the amount of exotic matter required is considerably less and may even be very much less for the ks than for the schwarzschild case , which may be viewed as the most and @xmath83 for various parameters .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=40.0% ]
important difference between the two gravitational theories from the standpoint of wormhole design .
( once again , both figs . 6 and
7 suggest that @xmath33 must not be too small . )
in this section we turn to the question of stability of the wormhole under small perturbations around a static solution @xmath84 . it must be emphasized , however , that the analysis is subject to the same limitations already discussed in sec .
[ s : thin - shell ] and , as will be seen , clearly parallels our earlier findings . rearranging eq .
( [ e : s ] ) , we obtain the equation of motion of the thin shell : @xmath85 where the potential @xmath86 is defined as @xmath87 ^ 2.\ ] ] following ref .
@xcite , if we expand @xmath86 around @xmath88 , we obtain @xmath89,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the prime denotes the derivative with respect to @xmath33 .
linearizing around @xmath90 requires that @xmath91 and @xmath92
. the configuration will be in stable equilibrium if @xmath93 . as suggested in ref .
@xcite , the subsequent analysis will make use of a parameter @xmath94 , which is usually interpreted as the subluminal speed of sound and is given by the relation @xmath95 to determine the conditions that yield @xmath96 , it is convenient to start with eq .
( [ e : conservation ] ) and first deduce that @xmath97 . also , @xmath98 returning to eq .
( [ e : potential ] ) , we now readily obtain @xmath99 and @xmath100.\ ] ] by direct computation we can now check the required conditions @xmath101 and @xmath102 . the stability condition @xmath96 then yields the intermediate result @xmath103 recall that @xmath39 is negative . if @xmath104 is also negative , then the sense of the inequality is retained in the next step .
if @xmath104 is positive , then the sense of the inequality is reversed .
( see fig . 8 . )
in the former case we get vs. @xmath33 for various parameters .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=50.0% ]
@xmath105}\ ] ] and in the latter case @xmath106}.\ ] ] for these inequalities , @xmath107 @xmath108 and @xmath109 in the ks case and @xmath110 @xmath111 and @xmath112 in the schwarzschild case . vs. @xmath88 for various parameters .
the description of the curves is the same as in fig . 1 . , scaledwidth=40.0% ]
9 shows the region of stability for both the ks and schwarzschild cases . according to eqs .
( [ e : less ] ) and ( [ e : more ] ) and fig . 8 , the respective regions of stability are below the curves on the right and above the curves on the left . under ordinary circumstances
, @xmath94 represents the velocity of sound , since @xmath113 is the square of the rate of change of distance with respect to time .
so , ordinarily , @xmath114 . for the schwarzschild case @xcite , the minimum value is @xmath115 .
according to fig .
9 , for the ks case , the region of stability involves values of @xmath116 that are even larger .
( of course , for the region on the right , @xmath116 is negative . )
so by this criterion , there are no stable solutions for either type of wormhole .
all these interpretations are valid as long as @xmath94 is indeed the speed of sound . as discussed extensively in ref .
@xcite , this assumption should be treated with caution when dealing with exotic matter . in this paper
we have the additional complication that the ks case is based on a nonrelavistic gravitational theory .
so we can not exclude the possibility that @xmath116 is just a convenient parameter .
this paper discusses a new class of thin - shell wormholes from black holes in hoava - lifshitz gravity by employing the asymptotically flat kehagias - sfetsos ( ks ) solution with various values of the coupling constant @xmath25 and the mass @xmath117 . in all cases
the radius of the outer event horizon in the ks case turns out to be less than that in the schwarzschild case .
a wormhole designer from an advanced civilization would find several advantages in the ks case over the schwarzschild case : for small values of the throat radius @xmath32 , the negative energy density of the thin shell is well below that in the schwarzschild case .
the lateral pressure is also less .
a particularly interesting finding is that for small values of @xmath33 , the amount of exotic matter required can be much less for a ks than for a schwarzschild wormhole , a considerable advantage given the problematical nature of exotic matter .
as @xmath33 gets large , however , the properties of the ks wormhole approach those of the schwarzschild wormhole .
a similar conclusion holds for the equation of state , assumed to be of the form @xmath118 : while @xmath119 for small @xmath33 , in both gravitational theories @xmath63 as @xmath120 . while both types of wormholes are attractive , the acceleration toward the center is less for the ks case than for the schwarzschild case , a particular advantage for a traveler .
the final topic is a discussion of the stability to linearized radial perturbations in terms of a parameter @xmath94 , normally interpreted as the speed of sound , but which may be just a convenient parameter .
it was found that stable solutions exist in the ks case for values of @xmath94 that are similar to the values in the schwarzschild case .
p. hoava , arxiv:0811.2217 [ hep - th ] ; p. hoava , jhep * 903 * , 20 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0812.4287 [ hep - th ] ] ; p. hoava , phys .
d * 79 * , 084008 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0901.3775 [ hep - th ] ] ; p. hoava , arxiv:0902.3657 [ hep - th ] .
mu - in park , jhep * 09 * , 123 ( 2009 ) .
e. poisson and m. visser , phys .
d * 52 * , 7318 ( 1995 ) .
a. kehagias and k. sfetsos , phys .
b * 678 * , 123 ( 2009 ) .
h. lu , j. mei and c. n. pope , arxiv:0904.1595 [ hep - th ] .
m. visser , nucl .
b 328 , 203 ( 1989 ) .
f.s.n . lobo and p. crawford , class .
* 21 * , 391 ( 2004 ) .
lobo , class .
* 21 * , 4811 ( 2004 ) .
eiroa and g. romero , gen .
. grav . * 36 * , 651 ( 2004 ) .
eiroa and c. simeone , phys .
d * 70 * , 044008 ( 2004 ) .
eiroa and c. simeone , phys . rev .
d * 71 * , 127501 ( 2005 ) .
m. thibeault , c. simeone , and e.f .
eiroa , gen .
. grav . * 38 * , 1593 ( 2006 ) .
f.s.n . lobo , phys .
d * 71 * , 124022 ( 2005 ) .
f. rahaman et al .
. grav . * 38 * , 1687 ( 2006 ) .
eiroa and c. simeone , phys .
d * 76 * , 024021 ( 2007 ) .
f. rahaman et al .
d * 16 * , 1669 ( 2007 ) .
f. rahaman et al .
* 39 * , 945 ( 2007 ) .
f. rahaman et al . ,
chin . j. phys . * 45 * , 518 ( 2007 ) arxiv:0705.0740 [ gr - qc ] m. g. richarte and c. simeone , phys .
d * 76 * , 087502 ( 2007 ) .
j. p. s. lemos and f.s.n .
lobo , phys .
rev d * 78 * , 044030 ( 2008 ) .
f. rahaman et al .
, acta phys . polon .
b * 40 * , 1575 ( 2009 ) arxiv : gr - qc/0804.3852 .
f. rahaman et al . ,
a * 24 * , 53 ( 2009 ) arxiv : gr - qc/0806.1391 .
eiroa , phys .
d * 78 * , 024018 ( 2008 ) .
eiroa , m.g .
richarte , and c. simeone , phys .
a * 373 * 1 ( 2008 ) .
f. rahaman , k a rahman , sk.a rakib , peter k.f .
kuhfittig , int .
49 * , 2364 ( 2010 ) .
e - print : arxiv:0909.1071 [ gr - qc ] a.a .
usmani , z. hasan , f. rahaman , sk.a .
rakib , , saibal ray , peter k.f .
kuhfittig , gen .
. gravit . * 42 * , 2901 ( 2010 ) e - print : arxiv:1001.1415 [ gr - qc ] m. visser , _
lorentzian wormholes@xmath121from einstein to hawking _
( american institute of physics , new york , 1995 ) . | in this paper we have constructed a new class of thin - shell wormholes from black holes in hoava - lifshitz gravity .
particular emphasis is placed on those aspects that allow a comparison of hoava - lifshitz to einstein gravity .
the former enjoys a number of advantages for small values of the throat radius .
pac numbers : 04.40.nr , 04.20.jb , 04.20.dw |
the possible multiferroicity - or , more precisely , magnetoelectricity - of bimno@xmath0 ( bmo ) , namely the simultaneous occurrence of ferroelectric ( fe ) and ferromagnetic ( fm ) long - range order in this simple perovskite , has been long discussed in the literature @xcite .
such interest is justified by its potential applications , which may span from giant electric transformers and multiple - state memory elements , to spintronics , magnetoelectric sensors , electric - field controlled ferromagnetic devices , and variable transducers @xcite
. indeed , on one hand bimno@xmath0 is ferromagnetic below @xcite @xmath1 100 k , due to superexchange along the mn@xmath5-o@xmath6mn@xmath5 chains , with a maximum reported magnetization of 3.92 @xmath7 per formula unit @xcite .
on the other hand , the bi@xmath5 ( 6s@xmath8 ) lone pair could experience a repulsion from the 2p orbitals of neighboring oxygen ions , leading to a permanent electric dipole and a ferroelectric distortion of the perovskite unit cell .
however , both the detection of ferroelectricity , and the observation of such distortion have been long controversial , also for the difficulty to grow single crystals @xcite of bmo , being it metastable at ambient pressure @xcite .
indeed , the observation of ferroelectricity has been reported for thin films only @xcite , where moreover the results strongly depend on their thickness and oxygen stoichiometry @xcite .
concerning bulk bmo , it has two structural phase transitions @xcite , at 470 k from monoclinic to monoclinic , and at 770 k from monoclinic to orthorhombic .
both first - principle calculations @xcite and an experimental study @xcite supported the fe hypothesis and were consistent with early diffraction studies , which identified a non - centro - symemetric c2 space group symmetry @xcite . however , recent experimental studies agree that the symmetry of the whole monoclinic phase at ambient pressure is the centro - symmetric c2/c @xcite .
this excludes a ferroelectric phase for bmo , of the displacive type @xcite at least .
however , according to a recent model , inversion symmetry breaking might occur also in the c2/c structure , due to some antiferromagnetic order hidden within canted ferromagnetism @xcite .
finally , it was found that , for increasing pressure , in single crystals the symmetry evolves to the monoclinic @xmath9 at 1 gpa , and to the orthorhombic @xmath10 at 6 gpa @xcite .
valuable information on the crystal symmetry of an insulator can also be provided by optical studies ( raman , and/or infrared ) of its phonon spectrum .
a factor group analysis gives for c2 the representation 29 @xmath11 + 31 @xmath12 , where 57 phonons are both ir and raman active while one a and two b vibrations are acoustic . in the space group c2/c , instead , the representation is 14 @xmath13 + 14 @xmath14 + 16 @xmath15 + 16 @xmath16 where , due to the inversion symmetry , all the @xmath13 and @xmath15 modes are raman active , the 13 @xmath14 and 14 @xmath16 modes are infrared active , and the remaining ones are acoustic .
previous infrared measurements of the bmo phonon spectrum @xcite were fit to the sum of 32 lorentzian modes . this number is higher than that predicted for the c2/c space group ( 27 ) , even if still much lower than that expected for the c2 symmetry ( 57 ) .
= 100 k.,width=302 ] to check and possibly solve this apparent contradiction we have investigated the far - infrared reflectivity of a bimno@xmath0 mosaic of small single crystals between 10 and 300 k. the resulting optical conductivity could be very well fit at 10 k to a sum of 25 lorentzians , thus reconciling the results of infrared spectroscopy with a centro - symmetric structure for bmo .
moreover , we have taken raman spectra on a single crystal belonging to the same mosaic , finding out that most of the 16 lines observed therein do not coincide with the infrared ones .
this provides further support to centro - symmetric structure c2/c , which is also consistent with the observation that no infrared line softens appreciably for @xmath3 , as it would occur in displacive ferroelectrivity .
finally , we observe a remarkable increase in the infrared oscillator strength for lowering temperature , which causes the extrapolated relative premittivity to increase smoothly from 18.5 at 300 k to 45 at 10 k.
the bimno@xmath0 sample was grown and characterized as described in ref . .
the compound was synthesized by solid state reaction of bi@xmath17o@xmath0 ( aldrich 99.99 % ) and mn@xmath17o@xmath0 ( aldrich 99.999 % ) , with the latter one in slight excess , at 4 gpa and 1073 k , using a high - pressure multi - anvil apparatus to stabilize the phase .
we thus obtained a mosaic , whose dimensions are about 5 @xmath18 4 @xmath18 1.5 mm , made of single crystals too small to be used individually for the far - infrared measurements . some of them
were then extracted to perform the structural and magnetic measurements , while the rest of the batch was polished with powders having grain size down to 0.5 @xmath19 m for the infrared experiment .
typical magnetization curves in field cooling ( fc , 100 oe ) and zero - field cooling ( zfc ) are shown in fig .
[ magnet ] .
they display a single and sharp fm transition at 100 k , which demonstrates the good chemical quality of the sample .
the sample reflectivity @xmath20 was measured by an interferometer bruker 66v , coupled to an infrared labs .
liquid - he cooled bolometer , a hg - cd - te detector , or a si photodiode , depending on the spectral range , with a spectral resolution of 2 @xmath21 in the phonon region .
the radiation was unpolarized : even if the whole sample were a single crystal , the monoclinic structure of bmo would prevent to obtain more meaningful information by polarized radiation .
the sample temperature was regulated between 10 and 300 k with a thermal stability and accuracy of @xmath22 k. the reference was a golden mirror close to the sample and oriented by a he - ne laser parallel to it . even if the region of interest is limited here to 50 @xmath23 700 @xmath21 , the spectral range was extended from 30 to 10000 @xmath21 in order to obtain accurate kramers - kronig ( kk ) transformations @xcite.the extrapolation from @xmath24 = 30 @xmath21 to @xmath24 = 0 was performed by a constant @xmath20 , as usual for good insulators , that to @xmath25 by a @xmath26 power law @xcite .
the raman spectra were measured with a horiba labram hr evolution micro - spectrometer in backscattering geometry .
the samples were different small crystals belonging to an unpolished area of the same mosaic where the infrared spectra were measured .
they were excited by the 632.8 nm radiation of a he - ne laser with 30 mw output power .
also the raman spectra , as the infrared ones , were taken in unpolarized configuration .
the detector was a peltier - cooled charge - coupled device ( ccd ) and the resolution 1 @xmath21 , thanks to a 1800 grooves / mm grating with 800 mm focal length .
measurements were performed with a 20x objective ( numerical aperture na=0.35 ) .
ccccccc @xmath27 & @xmath28(10 k ) & @xmath29(10 k ) & @xmath30(10 k ) & @xmath28(300 k ) & @xmath29(300 k ) & @xmath30(300 k ) + 1 & 68 & 39000 & 6 & 72 & 19000 & 8 + 2 & 75 & 30000 & 10 & & & + 3 & 92 & 21000 & 9 & 92 & 20000 & 16 + 4 & 101 & 60000 & 12 & 105 & 16000 & 11 + 5 & 115 & 100000 & 23 & 117 & 50000 & 24 + 6 & 143 & 54000 & 21 & 139 & 44000 & 31 + 7 & 159 & 26000 & 16 & 157 & 19000 & 20 + 8 & 196 & 57000 & 22 & 192 & 17000 & 18 + 9 & 219 & 49000 & 17 & 216 & 32000 & 24 + 10 & 237 & 12000 & 10 & 235 & 3000 & 12 + 11 & 261 & 78000 & 29 & 260 & 39000 & 32 + 12 & 284 & 178000 & 30 & 280 & 42000 & 31 + 13 & 308 & 115000 & 22 & 304 & 76000 & 38 + 14 & 321 & 90000 & 18 & 321 & 80000 & 24 + 15 & 345 & 230000 & 30 & 346 & 120000 & 50 + 16 & 369 & 110000 & 31 & 371 & 100000 & 44 + 17 & 407 & 7500 & 12 & & & + 18 & 426 & 56000 & 34 & 421 & 40000 & 46 + 19 & 463 & 80000 & 28 & 462 & 39000 & 30 + 20 & 486 & 110000 & 35 & 489 & 60000 & 45 + 21 & 508 & 48000 & 38 & & & + 22 & 541 & 47000 & 22 & 545 & 46000 & 25 + 23 & 561 & 125000 & 35 & 565 & 122000 & 39 + 24 & 604 & 3000 & 46 & & & + 25 & 628 & 18000 & 26 & 629 & 10000 & 28 + [ table i ] the reflectivity of bimno@xmath0 is shown in fig .
[ r ] in the far infrared range at all temperatures and is basically similar to that reported in ref .
, including a strong increase of the intensity of some lines for @xmath31 0 .
above that range , r(@xmath24 ) looks flat and basically independent of temperature within the errors .
the optical conductivity @xmath32 extracted by the kk transformations from @xmath20 is shown in fig .
[ sigma ] .
the phonon parameters were obtained by fitting @xmath32 to the sum of lorentzian oscillators @xmath33 where the factor 1/60 allows for @xmath34 being measured @xcite in @xmath35 @xmath21 . here ,
@xmath36 and @xmath30 are the peak frequency and the linewidth of the @xmath27-th transverse optical mode , respectively , in @xmath21 , and @xmath37 is the oscillator strength in @xmath38 .
the fitting parameters are listed in table i for both the highest and the lowest temperature .
excellent fits ( like that the inset of fig .
[ sigma ] ) were obtained at 10 , 100 , and 150 k for @xmath39 = 25 oscillators , confirming the diffraction result that no structural change is associated with the fm transition . at 300 k , due to line broadening which superimposes some modes , only 21 oscillators were necessary . as already mentioned , in ref .
, the infrared phonon spectrum was fit using instead @xmath39 = 32 modes , a value not compatible with the centro - symmetric c2/c .
this discrepancy was tentatively explained by the authors in terms of overtones or combination bands - which however should have intensities much lower than the main lines , for the usual values of the anharmonic potential .
the fact that here we get accurate fits down to 30 @xmath21 for @xmath39 = 25 , a number of modes smaller than the 27 predicted for the centro - symmetric structure c2/c , makes our results consistent with those of diffraction @xcite .
according to well known selection rules , the modes which are infrared - active in a centro - symmetric structure are not raman active , and vice versa .
therefore , to further check the bmo cell symmetry , we examined the raman spectra of three micro - crystals , which gave the same results .
the experiment was done at room temperature , considering that diffraction data exclude phase transitions below 300 k @xcite , and that neither the raman lines in ref .
, nor the infrared modes in table i display major frequency shifts down to the lowest temperatures . a typical raman spectrum is shown in fig . [ raman ] , where sixteen lines are observed , out of the predicted thirty .
three out of them , at or above 400 @xmath21 , are poorly resolved .
the data are very similar to those reported for room temperature in ref . , but
thanks to a somewhat larger experimental range we observe an additional sharp line at 51 @xmath21 . in the same fig .
[ raman ] we report also the best resolved infrared spectrum of the mosaic in fig .
[ sigma ] , that at 10 k. the two spectra look quite different and , except for a few features where the finite linewidths do not allow for a certain claim , the raman lines do not coincide with the infrared ones .
the raman phonon frequencies and widths , obtained by fitting to data a sum of lorentzians , are listed in table ii , which allows also for a comparison with the ir frequencies in table i at 300 k. these results provide further support to our previous conclusion that the ions of bmo vibrate in a centro - symmetric cell . another interesting feature of the spectra in fig .
[ sigma ] is their temperature dependence .
the frequencies do not change appreciably with @xmath40 , and no phonon softening is observed which may indicate displacive ferroelectricity - not even incipient as in srtio@xmath0 @xcite .
moreover , we do not observe any appreciable shift in the @xmath41 s around or below the fm transition . in ref .
, a low - frequency shift was reported for the raman bands at 513.8 @xmath21 and 637.4 @xmath21 below @xmath4 .
the authors attribute this observation to a spin - phonon coupling which is switched on by the fm transition .
the absence of a corresponding effect in the present infrared data indicates that such interaction , if may be able to change the raman polarizability , does not affect appreciably the first - order interaction of the radiation with the lattice dipole moment . however , as we already mentioned and is evident in table i , the oscillator strengths @xmath37 of some lines ( with @xmath27 = 1 , 4 , 5 , 8 , 11 , 12 , 15 , 20 , 25 ) increase by about a factor of two , or even more , from 300 to 10 k , an effect that can be observed also in fig . 2 of ref . .
fits to our data at all temperatures show that the intensity of those phonons linearly increases for decreasing temperature , as shown in fig .
[ s ] , and is insensitive to the fm transition at @xmath4 .
similar effects have been observed in several insulating oxides with high polarizability @xcite and often attributed to the so called `` charged phonon '' effect @xcite by which phonons acquire an anomalously large spectral weight due to a redistribution of electronic charge , within the cell , associated with their displacement pattern .
such increase of spectral weight in the far - infrared region causes the failure of the @xmath42-sum rule @xmath43 if @xmath44 does not include the regions where the transferred spectral weight comes from , presumably the electronic bands in the visible and the uv , which are out of the present measuring range .
anyway , checking such assumption would be a very hard task , given the small width of the fir range ( where the spectral weight in eq .
[ sum ] increases for lowering temperature ) with respect of the spectral regions where it should decrease . the same holds for the weak band partially shown in fig .
[ sigma ] , at frequencies higher than the phonon range .
it can either result from an admixture of phonon overtones and combination bands , consistently with its low intensity , or have a polaronic origin , namely , to come from excess charges self - trapped in the lattice .
those charges could be related to oxygen non - stoichiometry , which is likely to occur in this oxide @xcite . in both cases
the band intensity will increase for t @xmath45 0 : in the former one because it will follow the strengthening of the individual phonons , in the latter one because , at low @xmath40 , more quasi - free charges will self - trap in the local distortions @xcite .
ccc phonon ( @xmath27 ) & @xmath28 ( 300 k ) & @xmath30 ( 300 k ) + 1 & 50 & 2 + 2 & 74 & 1 + 3 & 84 & 1 + 4 & 93 & 1 + 5 & 99 & 1 + 6 & 133 & 6 + 7 & 180 & 9 + 8 & 211 & 9 + 9 & 242 & 10 + 10 & 278 & 15 + 11 & 347 & 15 + 12 & 400 & 15 + 13 & 424 & 12 + 14 & 440 & 17 + 15 & 530 & 12 + 16 & 635 & 14 + [ table i ] together with the optical conductivity , which is related to the imaginary part of the dielectric function @xmath46 , the kk transformations provide its real part @xmath47 , that is shown in fig .
if one assumes the absence of strong modes at frequencies lower than the limit of this experiment ( 30 @xmath21 ) , its extrapolation to zero frequency gives the relative permittivity @xmath48 , which can be thus be determined vs. temperature without any metal deposition and contacts on the sample , which may affect the measurement .
as shown in the inset of the same figure , due to the above described growth of several phonon intensities at low @xmath40 , it increases smoothly from 18.5 at 300 k to 45 at 10 k. these rather low values support once again the absence of a ferroelectric phase in bimno@xmath0 down to 10 k.
in order to further investigate the possible occurrance of ferroelectricity in bimno@xmath0 , we have measured the infrared phonon spectrum of a mosaic of small single crystals from 300 to 10 k. we find that at the lowest @xmath40 it can be accurately fit by using only 25 lorentz oscillators , out of the 27 predicted for the c2/c symmetry that has been attributed to bimno@xmath0 by the most recent diffraction experiments . to further check the conclusion that the bmo cell is centro - symmetric we have measured the raman spectrum at 300 k of three single crystals belonging to the mosaic , and we have observed sixteen phonon lines out of the thirty predicted for c2/c .
most of them are definitely different from the infrared lines , while for a few others , the finite linewidths in both spectra do not allow for an unambiguous conclusion .
this is consistent with a centro - symmetric structure like c2/c while , in case of broken inversion symmetry , the raman and infrared combs should substantially coincide .
if one adds that our data do not show any appreciable phonon softening , the present results point consistently toward the absence of ferroelectricity - and therefore of multiferroicity - in bimno@xmath0 down to 10 k , at least of displacive type .
however , we observe a regular increase of the oscillator strength in several modes of bimno@xmath0 for lowering temperature .
this causes the extrapolation to zero frequency of the real part of the dielectric function , namely , the relative permittivity , to increase from 18.5 at 300 k to 45 at 10 k. across the ferromagnetic transition at @xmath1 100 k we do not detect any major anomaly in the oscillator strength , nor in the phonon frequency . therefore , we conclude that the phonon - spin interaction recently invoked to interpret the behavior of a few raman phonon lines does not affect the dipole moment which interacts at first order with the radiation field .
n. hur , s. park , p. a. sharma , s. guha , and s .- w .
cheong , phys .
* 93 * , 107207 ( 2004 ) .
l. c. chapon , g. r. blake , m. j. gutmann , s. park , n. hur , p. g. radaelli , and s .- w .
cheong , phys .
lett . * 93 * , 177402 ( 2004 ) .
m. fiebig , th .
lottermoser , d. frohlich , a. v. goltsev , and r. v. pisarev , nature ( london ) * 419 * , 818 ( 2002 ) .
m.grizalez , g.a.mendoza , and p.prieto , j. phys .
series * 167 * , 012035 ( 2009 ) .
lottermoser , th .
lonkai , u. amann , d. hohlwein , j. ihringer , and m. fiebig , nature ( london ) * 430 * , 541 ( 2004 ) .
c. binek and b. doudin , j. phys . : condens .
matter * 17 * , l39 ( 2005 ) .
n. a. hill and k. m. rabe , phys .
b59 , 8759 ( 1999 ) .
w. eerenstein , n. d. mathur , and j. f. scott , nature ( london ) * 442 * , 759 ( 2006 ) .
a.a.belik,j.solid state chem .
* 195 * , 32 ( 2012 ) .
m. fiebig , j. phys .
d * 38 * , r123 ( 2005 ) .
s. w. cheong and m. mostovoy , nat .
* 6*,13 ( 2007 ) .
f. sugawara , s. iiida , y .
syono , and s. akimoto , j. phys .
. jpn . * 25*,1553 ( 1968 ) .
t. kimura , s. kawamoto , i. yamada , m. azuma , m. takano and y. tokura , phys .
b * 67 * , 180401(r ) ( 2003 ) .
e. montanari , g. calestani , l. righi , e. gilioli , f. bolzoni , k s. knight and p g. radaelli , phys .
b * 75 * , 220101 ( 2007 ) .
p. toulemonde , c. darie , c. goujon , m. legendre , t. mendonca , m. lvarez - murga , v. simonet , p. bordet , p. bouvier , j. kreisel , and m. mezouar , high press .
29 * , 600 ( 2009 ) .
a. moreira dos santos , s. parashar , a. r. raju , y. s. zhao , a. k. cheetham and c . n. r. rao , solid state commun . * 122 * , 49 ( 2002 ) .
a. sharan , j. lettieri , y. f. jia , w. tian , x. q. pan , d. g. schlom , and v. gopalan , phys .
b * 69 * , 214109 ( 2004 ) .
e. montanari , l. righi , g. calestani , a. migliori , e. gilioli , f. bolzoni , chem .
17 , 1765 ( 2005 ) .
a. m. dos santos , a. k. cheetham , t. atou , y. syono , y. yamaguchi , k. ohoyama , h. chiba , and c. n. r. rao , phys .
b * 66 * , 064425 ( 2002 ) .
t. atou , h. chiba , k. ohoyama , y. yamaguchi , and y. syono , j. solid state chem.*145 * , 639 ( 1999 ) .
a. a. belik , s. iikubo , t. yokosawa , k. kodama , n. igawa , s. shamoto , m. azuma , m. takano , k. kimoto , y. matsui and e. takayama - muromachi j. am .
chem . soc . * 129 * , 971 ( 2007 ) .
p. toulemonde , p. bordet , p. bouvier , and j. kreisel phys .
b * 89 * , 224107 ( 2014 ) . g. calestani , f. orlandi , f. mezzadri , l. righi , m.merlini , and e. gilioli , inorg . chem . * 53 * , 8749 ( 2014 ) .
j. f. scott , rev . mod .
phys . * 46 * , 83 ( 1974 ) .
i. v. solovyev and z. v. pchelkina , phys .
b * 82 * , 094425 ( 2010 ) .
v. goian , s. kamba , m. savinov , d. nuzhnyy , f. borodavka , p. vank , and a. a. belik , j. appl . phys . * 112 * , 074112 ( 2012 ) .
m. dressel and g. grner , electrodynamics of solids , cambridge univ . press , cambridge ( uk ) , 2002 , p. 56 .
j. yang , j. hwang , t. timusk , a. s. sefat , and j. e. greedan , phys .
b * 73 * , 195125 ( 2006 )
. t. timusk and t. tanner , _ infrared properties of high @xmath4 superconductors _ ,
, in _ physical properties og high @xmath4 superconductors _ , ed .
by d. m. ginsberg , world scientific , singapore , 1989 .
a. yamanaka , m. kataoka , y. inaba , k. inoue , b. hehlen , and e. courtens , europhys .
lett . * 50 * , 688 ( 2000 ) , and references therein .
m. j. rice , solid state commun .
31 , 93 ( 1979 ) .
c. c. homes , t. vogt , s. m. shapiro , s. wakimoto , and a. p. ramirez , science * 293 * , 673 ( 2001 ) . c. c. homes , t. vogt , s. m. shapiro , s. wakimoto , m. a. subramanian , and a. p. ramirez , phys .
b * 67 * , 092106 ( 2003 ) .
p. calvani , m. capizzi , s. lupi , and g. balestrino , epl * 31 * , 473 ( 1995 ) .
a. nucara , w. s. mohamed , l. baldassarre , s. koval , j. lorenzana , r. fittipaldi , g. balakrishnan , a. vecchione , and p. calvani , phys .
b * 90 * , 014304 ( 2014 ) .
d. w. boukhvalov and i. v. solovyev , phys .
b * 82 * , 245101 ( 2010 )
. a. j. millis , r. mueller , and boris i. shraiman , phys .
b * 54 * , 5405 ( 1996 ) .
p. calvani , riv .
nuovo cimento * 24 * , 1 ( 2001 ) . | bimno@xmath0 ( bmo ) , ferromagnetic ( fm ) below @xmath1 100 k , was believed to be also ferroelectric ( fe ) due to a non - centro - symmetric c2 structure , until diffraction data indicated that its space group is the centro - symmetric c2/c . here
we present infrared phonon spectra of bmo , taken on a mosaic of single crystals , which are consistent with c2/c at any @xmath2 10 k , as well as room - temperature raman data which strongly support this conclusion .
we also find that the infrared intensity of several phonons increases steadily for @xmath3 , causing the relative permittivity of bmo to vary from 18.5 at 300 k to 45 at 10 k. at variance with fe materials of displacive type , no appreciable softening has been found in the infrared phonons .
both their frequencies and intensities , moreover , appear insensitive to the fm transition at @xmath4 . |
the temperature fluctuations in the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) are gaussian to a high degree of accuracy @xcite .
non - gaussianity , if any , enters at a highly subdominant level
. it could be either primordially generated along with gaussian fluctuations by exotic inflationary models , and/or it could arise from secondary anisotropies , such as gravitational lensing , sunyaev - zeldovich ( sz ) , or sachs - wolfe ( sw ) effects . quantifying the degree and nature of non - gaussianity in the cmb
constrains specific inflationary models , as well as enhances our understanding of the secondary processes the cmb underwent beyond the surface of last scattering .
interpretation of any such measurement is complicated by the fact that systematics and foreground contaminations might also produce non - gaussian signatures .
given the nearly gaussian nature of the cmb , @xmath0-point correlation functions , and their harmonic counterparts , polyspectra , are the most natural tools for the perturbative understanding of non - gaussianity .
if it were generated by inflationary models admitting a @xmath7 term , the leading order effect would be a @xmath8-point function .
on the other hand some secondary anisotropies , such as lensing , are known to produce 4-point non - gaussianity at leading order @xcite .
the skewness ( or integrated bispectrum ) was measured by @xcite and @xmath8-point correlation function by @xcite .
many alternative statistics have been used to investigate non - gaussianity in cmb .
a partial list includes wavelet coefficients @xcite , minkowski functionals @xcite , phase correlations between spherical harmonic coefficients @xcite , multipole alignment statistics @xcite , statistics of hot and cold spots @xcite , higher criticism statistic of pixel values directly @xcite .
most of these measurements are consistent with gaussianity , although some claim detections of non - gaussianity up to 3-@xmath3 level .
these alternative statistics , albeit often easier to measure , typically depend on @xmath0-point functions in a complex way , thus they can not pin - point as precisely the source of non - gaussianity . among the three - point statistics , there is a perceived complementarity between harmonic and real space methods .
the bispectrum can be relatively easily calculated for a full sky map @xcite , although the present methods have a somewhat slow @xmath9 scaling @xcite .
methods put forward so far use the `` pseudo - bispectrum '' , ignoring the convolution with the complicated geometry induced by galactic cut and cut - out holes .
in contrast with harmonic space , the corresponding pixel space edge effect corrections are trivial @xcite , since the window function is diagonal .
unfortunately , simple methods to measure three - point clustering exhibit a prohibitive @xmath2 scaling if the full configuration space is scanned .
to remedy the situation , most previous measurements of the @xmath8-point function only deal with an ad - hoc sub - set of triangular configurations @xcite .
both of these papers covered the full configuration space on small scales ; the former paper also appears to have estimated most configurations on large scales , missing intermediate configurations with mixes scales .
this work presents a novel method , which , at a given resolution , scans the full available configuration space for @xmath8-point level statistics using realistic computational resources .
we find that the resulting configuration space itself is overwhelming to such a degree that interpretation of the results also requires novel methods .
we introduce false discovery rate ( fdr ) technique as a tool to interpret three - point correlation function measurements .
the next section introduces our algorithm to measure the @xmath8-point correlation function ,
3 illustrates it with an application to the wmap first year data release , and 4 introduces the fdr method and applies it to our results .
we summarize and discuss our results in 5 .
the three point correlation function ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) is defined as a joint moment of three density fields @xmath10 at three spatial positions . for cmb studies
@xmath11 denotes temperature fluctuations at position @xmath12 on the sky , and @xmath13 stands for ensemble average . if the underlying distribution is spatially isotropic , @xmath14 will only depend on the shape and size of a ( spherical ) triangle arising from the three positions .
a number of characterizations of this triangle are possible and convenient .
the most widely used are the sizes of its sides ( measured in radians ) , or two sizes and the angle between them .
this latter angle is measured on the spherical surface of the sky .
one can use the ergodic principle of replacing ensemble averages with spatial averages to construct a nearly optimal , edge corrected estimators with heuristic weights @xcite @xmath15 where we symbolically denoted a particular triangular configuration with @xmath16 ( any parametrization would suffice ) , and @xmath17 if pixels @xmath18 , and @xmath19 otherwise .
we also defined a multiplicative weight @xmath20 for each pixel : this is @xmath19 if a pixel is masked out , and it could take various convenient values depending on our noise weighting scheme if the pixel is inside the survey ; e.g. , in the case of flat weights it is simply @xmath21 .
this simple estimator has been widely used in large scale structure , and it is nearly optimal with appropriate weights .
( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
it is entirely analogous to the successful estimators used for the measurements of the @xmath22 s for the cmb ( up to harmonic transform , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
the naive realization of equation [ eq : estimator ] has a prohibitive @xmath2 scaling if one needs to scan through triplets of pixels and assign them to a particular bin .
the summation can be restricted and thus made faster if one restricts the number of configurations and the resolution ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , or it can be sped up by using tree - data structures @xcite .
neither of these methods is able to scan through all possible configurations in megapixel maps with reasonable amount of computing resources .
here we propose a new method which uses both hierarchical pixelization and fourier methods motivated by @xcite to scan through all the triangles simultaneously .
note that @xcite comes closest to our aims , but their simple two - step approach is not systematic enough to cover all possible triangles at a given resolution , and it is not fast enough for massive monte carlo simulations . in the following
we will choose a parametrization of the triangle @xmath16 using two of its sides @xmath23 , and the angle @xmath24 between them .
we define the configuration space as a set of ( logarithmic ) bins for the sides , and linear bins for the angle in their full possible range , i.e. , @xmath25 ( remember that the sides of the triangle on the sky are also measured in radians ) .
the given resolution is determined by the number of bins for @xmath26 , and the number of bins for @xmath24 .
note that a particular triangle might appear more than once in this scheme , albeit with different resolutions .
different triangular bins of the three - point function are strongly correlated anyway , and the correlation from duplicating triangles can be taken into account in the general statistical framework over correlated bins . given a triangular configuration , and a pixel @xmath12 , all other pixels which enter the summation in equation [ eq : estimator ] are located on two concentric rings of size @xmath27 and @xmath28 . as a consequence , the summation over fixed @xmath24 can be thought of as an unnormalized ( raw ) two - point correlation function between two rings . to obtain three - point correlation function ,
one has to multiply this two - point correlation function with the value of the center pixel @xmath12 and finally sum over @xmath12 .
calculating the two - point correlation function of rings can be fast if one repixellizes the map ( c.f .
[ fig : rings ] ) into rings with sizes matching the binning scheme for @xmath29 , and uniform division in @xmath24 .
such a repixellization , resulting in ring - pixels as shown in fig .
[ fig : rings ] , would take only @xmath0 steps even in a naive way ; the healpix hierarchical scheme allows it to be done in @xmath30 time .
we use the following algorithm : let us start a recursive tree walk at the coarsest map , @xmath31 in the healpix scheme . for each pixel in this map ,
we determine , using its center , which ring - pixel it would belong to . if the size of the pixel is much smaller than this ring - pixel ( how much smaller is a parameter of our algorithm : in this paper we used the condition that the pixel has to be smaller then @xmath32 the bin width which is also the approximate size of the ring - pixels ) , we record it . if not , algorithm splits the quad - tree , and calls itself recursively for each four sub - pixels .
this procedure ends at the latest when the highest resolution ( i.e. the one of the underlying map ) is reached .
if the bins are chosen appropriately such that large ring - pixels are set up for large triangles , for many pixels it will finish earlier .
as noted above , the map has to be regridded around each pixel into rings of ring - pixels . in total , this takes @xmath33 time . calculating the two - point correlation function between rings
speeds up using fast fourier transform ( fft ) methods , such as those put forward in @xcite .
the recipe is the following .
first , fft every ring @xmath12 to obtain complex coefficients @xmath34 ; then calculate for every pair of rings @xmath35 the `` pseudo power spectrum '' @xmath36 , where @xmath37 means complex conjugate . due to the u(1 ) symmetry of the ring
an inverse @xmath38 transform will give the ( raw ) two - point correlation function between the two rings ( c.f . * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
if we have @xmath39 rings , each of them @xmath40 ring - pixels , each fft can be done in @xmath41 time , and there is @xmath42 cross correlations to be calculated for a full scan of configurations . all the above needs to be performed for each pixel as a center point .
the total scaling ( including the initial regridding ) takes @xmath43 , where we took into account that the two opposite pixels can be handled in one go if a symmetric set of bins around @xmath44 are used for @xmath29 .
while the above procedure to calculate raw ( unnormalized ) correlation functions appears somewhat complex , we have checked with direct calculation that it gives numerically the same result as calculating correlations on the rings in a naive way . in order to obtain normalized correlation functions
, the same procedure has to be followed for the rings associated with weights / masks .
each configuration of the raw three - point function is divided with the mask / weight three - point function for the final result .
for many realizations with the same mask , such as in the case of massive monte carlo simulations , the mask correlations need to be estimated only once , representing negligible cost .
the above abstract scheme and calculation will be illustrated and further clarified with a practical application to wmap next .
we demonstrate our method to calculate the three - point correlation function with an application to wmap .
we downloaded first year foreground cleaned maps from lambda website@xcite .
there are total 8 maps for 8 differencing assemblies ( da ) in q , v and w bands : q1 , q2 , v1 , v2 , w1 , w2 , w3 , and w4 , already in healpix format .
following the two - point analysis of wmap @xcite , we only used cross correlations , i.e. three - point correlation functions calculated from three different das .
we produced 100 ( gaussian ) simulations with synfast in healpix package .
the input power spectrum , also from the lambda website , was taken from @xmath6cdm model using a scale - dependent ( running ) primordial spectral index which best fits the wmap , cbi and acbar cmb data , plus the 2df and lyman - alpha data .
every simulation consists of 8 assembly maps as the data @xcite .
these 8 maps were generated with a same random seed , representing the same primordial cmb , but 8 different beam transfer functions .
then different simulated noise maps from lambda web @xcite were added to the synfast output maps . since the non - gaussian signal is exceedingly small , and on the smallest scales the data are noise dominated , we degraded all maps ( simulations and data ) to @xmath45 after applying the kp2 mask .
more precisely , we added up pixel and weight values for each map ; our two weighting schemes are presented in the next subsection . at the heart of our algorithm
is the regridding of figure [ fig : rings ] which matches our binning of the triangles .
we chose 19 rings for half of the sphere surface , and the same bins are repeated on the other half symmetrically around @xmath44 . the 19 bins are chosen to be uniformly distributed in logarithm between @xmath46 and @xmath47 .
the number 19 was chosen such that @xmath48 , which gives a logarithmic resolution of @xmath49 .
every ring was divided to 20 ring - pixels in @xmath24 .
this number renders the resulting ring - pixels fairly compact , and it is also convenient for our chosen implementation of fft ( fftw , * ? ? ?
weight maps were constructed using the kp2 mask and the noise profile of the maps .
we used two weighting schemes : flat weighting where @xmath20 is 1 or 0 depending on the mask , and ( inverse ) noise weighting ; for the latter @xcite we used the effective number of observations of the pixel .
the weights need to be determined only up to multiplicative factor , as their overall normalization cancels from the algorithm .
the average noise level @xmath50 for each da is used when combining @xmath14 over different cross correlations .
the total number of triangular configurations in @xmath51 rings with @xmath52 possible values of @xmath24 ( angles large than @xmath53 count to @xmath54 ) is @xmath55 for autocorrelations .
the same number is valid for a cross correlations ( which we will be exclusively doing ) of 3 das .
we introduce the notation ( da1 , da2 , da3 ) , for the central pixel , the first ring and the second ring sampled from the three da in this order .
in addition we restrict the `` first ring '' has @xmath26 no larger than that of the `` second ring '' .
then the total number of cross correlations between the 8 da s is @xmath56 .
effectively , each triangle is calculated six times for a given triplet of da s due to the possible 6 permutations .
however , each sample has a different resolution , therefore we opt to keep all possibilities .
the resulting correlations are taken into account when dealing with correlated bins in general . in total
, there are about @xmath57 triangular configurations for each data or simulation set .
note that the total number of triplets of ring - pixels examined is @xmath58 more , or @xmath59 .
this is still a lot smaller than checking @xmath60 triplets of pixels naively in an @xmath61 map .
these numbers suggest that our algorithm even without fft should take order of days , while the naive algorithm would need over 200 years of cpu . for a batch of @xmath62 simulations ( comprising of @xmath63 da maps ) ,
the calculation of the full three - point function in all the configuration takes about 90 hours on an intel xeon 2.4ghz cpu .
this means each cross - correlation takes only about @xmath64 minutes on average !
about 10 hours are saved by batch processing 10 sets of simulations : to estimate @xmath14 in the data alone ( one set of 8 da files ) took 10 hours .
clearly , the given resolution does not extract all the information from the data , as there are approximately @xmath65 distinct configurations of the bispectrum or three - point function .
however , it surely must be redundant to extract more configurations than the amount of data .
the ratio of data points vs. configurations is about @xmath66 for our chosen bins .
it is unlikely that it were fruitful to push this number towards much smaller values , although the speed of our algorithm would allow higher resolution .
figure [ fig : zeta ] shows a typical set of @xmath14 measurements for the ( w2,w3,w4 ) da cross - correlation .
the results from wmap lie comfortably in the 68% range of results from gaussian simulations .
similar results are found for the other da combinations , or when all the 24 possible w - only da results are averaged .
although different combinations have different effective beam , full averaging is meaningful on large scales .
we checked that averaging all 336 possible combinations is also consistent with gaussian .
finally , repeating all the measurement with noise weighting produced no obvious departure from gaussianity either .
at the same time , the scatter in the simulations , i.e. , the probability density function ( pdf ) of @xmath14 from 100 simulation , shows a slightly non - gaussian signature .
for ( w2,w3,w4 ) , figure [ fig : hist ] shows a histogram derived from all simulated @xmath14 values normalized by their measured median and 68% levels .
slight deviations from gaussian distribution are evident : student distribution of degree 3 fits better the overall distribution .
this same distribution produces lower @xmath67 when applied to _ individual _ triangular configurations according to the inset , i.e. it is a ( marginally ) better fit than gaussian .
we fully take this into account in our hypothesis testing which is described next .
our goal is to test the null - hypothesis of gaussianity against our measurements by means of comparing the @xmath14 values measured from the data with the corresponding probability distribution function ( pdf ) determined from gaussian simulations .
a crucial step in the traditional @xmath67 method appears to be computationally infeasible due to the large number of configurations : calculation of the ( pseudo ) inverse of an @xmath68 matrix for @xmath69 , the total number of our highly correlated configurations .
moreover , as seen above , the underlying pdf marginally violates gaussian assumption , even for gaussian simulations . even if it were possible to calculate the inverse of the covariance matrix , and we were to accept the accuracy of the gaussianity in pdf of the individual bins , it is not possible to determine the underlying covariance matrix with sufficient accuracy .
in fact , one would need ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) at least ( and likely much more than ) 2.6 million simulations for that purpose . @xcite
have shown that using simulations with uncorrelated noise might result in spurious detection of non - gaussianity .
therefore we chose to use only the wmap supplied correlated noise simulations , of which 110 is available at present .
it is straightforward to test the null - hypothesis with a single configuration : we can calculate a @xmath70-value from the best fit student distribution from our simulations .
the @xmath70-value is defined as the probability of obtaining a @xmath14 value that is at least as extreme as the one measured from wmap . for a threshold @xmath71
, the null - hypothesis is rejected at @xmath72 level if the @xmath70-value of the datum is smaller than @xmath71 .
a problem arises from combining 2.6 million tests when all the data are used .
for instance , even if the hypothesis were true , about 260 bins would still be rejected at the @xmath73 level ( ignoring the correlations in the data ) .
fortunately a robust and simple method exists for massive hypothesis testing , which is insensitive to correlations between the tests , and makes no assumption on the gaussianity of the underlying error distribution : the method of false discovery rate ( fdr ) @xcite . in astronomy , it has been successfully applied in the context of image processing and finding outliers by @xcite , which can be consulted for a more detailed introduction .
the fdr method combines the same @xmath70-value as defined above for individual tests using a threshold for rejecting the null hypothesis .
this combination is insensitive to correlations and has more statistical power than naive combination .
our goal is to adapt this powerful method for hypothesis testing of three - point correlation function measurements with overwhelming number of configurations .
the fdr method gives a simple prescription for finding a threshold for rejection .
in particular , the recipe suggests that we choose a threshold such that we control the rate of _ false rejections _ or fdr .
the parameter , taking a similar role to the confidence interval in more traditional tests , is the maximum rate of fdr .
if we fix an @xmath24 such that @xmath74 , the fdr procedure will guarantee @xmath75 in ensemble average .
next we describe the recipe to control fdr ; more details can be found in @xcite .
let @xmath76 denote the @xmath70-values calculated from the measurements of @xmath0 configurations , _ sorted _ from smallest to largest .
let @xmath77 where @xmath78 is a constant depending on the level of correlations between different configurations . for uncorrelated data @xmath79 ; while @xmath80 can be used for correlated data @xcite .
note that technically one would have to adjust @xmath78 to the degree of correlations in the data .
the suggested value for correlated data is extremely conservative , and should be considered as a strong upper limit . even using this conservative
adjustment decreases the statistical power of the technique only logarithmically ; the final results are expected to be robust regardless of the degree of correlations .
if configurations with @xmath81 are rejected , equation [ eq : fdr ] will hold @xcite , i.e. the fdr is controlled according to our preset parameter @xmath24 .
the procedure is represented graphically on figure [ fig : fdr ] : @xmath82 is plotted against @xmath83 superposed with the line through the origin of slope @xmath84 .
all @xmath70-values reject the null hypotheses which are to the left from the last point at which @xmath82 falls below the line .
these might include some false discoveries which are guaranteed to be a smaller fraction than @xmath24 in ensemble average .
we have applied the fdr recipe to all of our individual cross - three point functions , as well as our full data set .
since @xmath78 is a constant , initially we kept @xmath79 . for a fixed @xmath24 ,
the results can be subsequently reinterpreted in terms of any @xmath85 . for da combination ( w2 , w3 , w4 )
, there is no rejection for @xmath86 , i.e. , allowing as high as 81% false rejections , not a single configuration rejected our gaussian null hypothesis .
correlations might increase @xmath78 , but it must be @xmath87 .
the true @xmath24 , when correlations are taking into account , can only be larger than our effective @xmath24 for @xmath79 . in other words ,
the data are fully consistent with gaussianity . as a sanity check
, we repeated the fdr analysis in our simulations as well . by scanning through different @xmath24 values from 0 to 1
, we find that 50 out of 100 simulations have rejections with @xmath86 .
this means that the wmap measurements are fully consistent with gaussianity at a level better than 1-@xmath3 in the traditional sense . in summary , at the three - point level , scanning all configurations , we did not find any significant non - gaussianty which would be localized in pixel space triangular configurations .
we performed fdr analysis on all @xmath88 measurements individually , as well as on the combination of all those measurements with @xmath89 million configurations in total .
none of these cases produced credible evidence for non - gaussianity and all of them were fully consistent with our null hypothesis at @xmath90 .
we presented a new method to measure angular three - point correlation functions on spherical maps .
we achieve an unprecedented @xmath1 scaling with a combination of hierarchical and fourier algorithms .
the speed of our technique allows a systematical scan of the full available configuration space at a given resolution .
such speed is especially useful for cross correlations and monte carlo simulations , where a vast number of configurations and measurements need to be performed .
we have achieved a speed of about @xmath64 minutes per cross correlations , when 336 cross - correlations have been estimated simultaneously in @xmath45 healpix maps using a single intel xeon 2.4ghz cpu .
this is to be contrasted with a naive approach , which would have taken about 200 years per cross - correlations ; a @xmath91 million fold speed up . as a first application of our code we analyzed the first year wmap data along with 100 realistic simulations .
we have calculated cross - correlations for about @xmath92 triangular configurations , or about @xmath59 triplets in total in maps of @xmath45 corresponding the @xmath93 da s .
the ratio of pixels / configurations is about 50 for each measurement .
comparing our measurements from 100 gaussian simulations with realistic correlated noise , we found wmap to be comfortably within the 68% percent range for most configurations . any significant departure from gaussianity at the three - point level ,
even if localized in particular triangular configurations , would have shown up clearly in our full scan of the available configuration space .
our main result is that there is no credible evidence of non - gaussianity at the three - point level at any of the triangular configurations we examined . as a consequence ,
if the tentative detection of non - gaussianity claimed in previous works holds up , it should correspond to either 4-point or higher order correlations , or to spatially localized features which break rotational invariance ( e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
in contrast with our measurements , all previous studies of higher order statistics used autocorrelations .
comparison of our errorbars with that of @xcite appears to show that this increases the errors by a factor of two ( see the discussions below ) .
in addition , many measurements used uncorrelated noise simulations . according to the findings of @xcite , this might increase the likelihood of finding spurious non - gaussianity .
analysis of our gaussian simulations revealed that there is a slight non - gaussianity in the error distribution of individual configurations .
this is not surprising , since three - point correlation function is a non - linear construction of the gaussian random variables ( c.f .
the error distribution is well fit by a student distribution with 3 degrees of freedom .
to quantify any possible departure of the overall data set from gaussianity , we introduced a new technique , fdr , to interpret three - point statistics .
this corresponds to an optimized multiple hypothesis testing , and it is insensitive to the unavoidable correlations in the data . all of our fdr tests , whether applied to any of the 336 cross correlations , or the combined data set , were fully consistent with gaussianity with better then 1-@xmath3 .
this quantifies our previous assertion based on examination of the individual configurations under the assumption of statistical isotropy .
the above model independent tests showed that there is no credible evidence of any non - gaussianity in the data .
next we illustrate how our measurements yield constraints on specific non - gaussian models .
we choose a simple phenomenological model corresponding to the quadratic expansion of the density field in terms of one parameter , @xmath4 , as put forward by @xcite : @xmath94 to obtain constraints on this parameter , we construct an estimator for @xmath4 @xmath95 where @xmath14 is our measurement in data or simulation maps .
we calculated the two - point correlation function @xmath96 analytically , to avoid any bias from the non - linear construction ( c.f .
we used the same best fit power spectrum as for the simulations , as well as taking into account beam and pixel window functions .
since previous measurements already established the weakness of non - gaussianity , our gaussian simulations should be accurate enough to calculate the variance @xcite .
applying the same estimator to our 100 simulations , we obtained error bars for @xmath4 estimated from each particular configuration .
the simplicity of the phenomenological model lies in the fact that a constant value of @xmath4 is assumed .
we do not attempt to combine our estimates optimally , instead we use simple considerations .
the signal increases towards small scales in this model , while noise dominates on the smallest scales .
since we already discarded the smallest scales when using @xmath61 , it is intuitively clear that most signal pertaining to this model will be concentrated in the small fraction of the triangles corresponding to small scales , in particular the skewness . to confirm this we generated and analyzed a set of non - gaussian simulations according to equation [ eq : nong ] , with @xmath4 equal to 1000 , 2000 , 3000 , 4000 , and 6000 .
inspection of the configurations together with the errorbars from the gaussian simulations confirmed the above idea .
therefore we decided to use the skewness , which corresponds to giving zero weight to all other configurations when combining our @xmath4 estimators . from these
we obtain @xmath97 where the errorbar was estimated from the gaussian simulations .
@xcite quotes similar constraints for a low quadrupole cdm model , but their errorbars are a factor of two larger for a @xmath6cdm model similar to the one we use . the fact that we obtained a factor of two tighter constraints than @xcite suggests that using cross - correlations is superior to auto - correlations for three - point statistics of wmap as a sanity check , we calculated the mean value of the skewness estimator for 100 gaussian simulations ; it yields about @xmath98 . on the other hand ,
we also demonstrate that we can recover @xmath4 from the non - gaussian simulations .
all the simulations have the same underlying gaussian signal and noise , the only difference is the value of @xmath4 .
according to figure [ fig : fnlt ] the errors might be underestimated when @xmath99 , and/or there might be a small low bias , but it is clear from the figure that we could detect non - gaussianity if it were present . a suboptimal combination of @xmath4 estimates from all configurations weighted by their inverse variance yields about @xmath100 , a significantly weaker result , confirming the intuitive idea that most of the signal is concentrated on small scales . some of the results in this paper have been derived using the healpix @xcite package .
we acknowledge the use of the legacy archive for microwave background data analysis ( lambda ) .
support for lambda is provided by the nasa office of space science .
the authors were supported by nasa through aisr nag5 - 11996 , and atp nasa
nag5 - 12101 as well as by nsf grants ast02 - 06243 , ast-0434413 and itr 1120201 - 128440 . | we present a new method to estimate three - point correlations in cosmic microwave background maps .
our fast fourier transform based implementation estimates three - point functions using all possible configurations ( triangles ) at a controlled resolution .
the speed of the technique depends both on the resolution and the total number of pixels @xmath0 .
the resulting @xmath1 scaling is substantially faster than naive methods with prohibitive @xmath2 scaling . as an initial application ,
we measure three - point correlation functions in the first year data release of the wilkinson anisotropy probe .
we estimate 336 cross - correlations of any triplet of maps from the 8 differential assemblies , scanning altogether 2.6 million triangular configurations .
estimating covariances from gaussian signal plus realistic noise simulations , we perform a null - hypothesis testing with regards to the gaussianity of the cosmic microwave background .
our main result is that at the three - point level wmap is fully consistent with gaussianity . to quantify the level of possible deviations , we introduce false discovery rate analysis , a novel statistical technique to analyze for three - point measurements
this confirms that the data are consistent with gaussianity at better than 1-@xmath3 level when jointly considering all configurations .
we constrain a specific non - gaussian model using the quadratic approximation of weak non - gaussianities in terms of the @xmath4 parameter , for which we construct an estimator from the the three - point function .
we find that using the skewness alone is more constraining than a heuristic suboptimal combination of all our results ; our best estimate is @xmath5 assuming a @xmath6cdm concordance model . |
one hundred years after einstein , the theory of general relativity ( gr ) is still our best theory of gravity . in the framework of gr
, the standard model of cosmology ( @xmath4 ) provides a successful description of the universe . in this model , the same fluctuations which give rise to the observed small variations in the temperature of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb )
grow under the force of gravity , and eventually form observed galaxies and other nonlinear structures such as filaments , voids , groups and clusters of galaxies . according to the model , only @xmath5 of the density in the universe is provided by normal baryonic matter @xcite .
the @xmath4 model requires two additional components : a non - baryonic cold dark matter ( cdm ) , which contributes about 30% of the average density of the universe , and an even more mysterious dark energy , which makes up the rest @xcite .
the model is remarkably successful on scales larger than a few megaparsecs .
it predicted the amplitude and the spectrum of angular fluctuations in the cmb and in the distribution of galaxies @xcite that were later confirmed by observations @xcite .
however , the @xmath4 model faces challenges on smaller scales .
the most difficult ones are related with the rotation in the inner parts of spiral galaxies .
it seems that the theory predicts too much dark matter inside @xmath6 1kpc from the centers of galaxies @xcite . while there are some possible solutions of the problem @xcite , the problems on small scales are the strongest challenge the standard model has encountered .
when compounded with the fact that there is no direct evidence of dark matter or dark energy , the current problems of the standard cosmological model have encouraged a small but growing community of physicists to propose alternative theories of gravity to avoid the need for dark matter .
this is the case for modified newtonian dynamics ( mond ) , proposed by @xcite to explain the rotation of galaxies without dark matter . according to mond
, the rotation curves in the outer regions of galaxies do not decline because the force of gravity is significantly stronger than for newtonian gravity . at early times
mond s main appeal was its simplicity : there is no need to make the assumption that the universe is filled with particles that nobody has seen .
additional motivation came later from difficulties with explaining anomalies in the trajectories of the pioneer 10 and 11 space missions @xcite . yet , for a long time mond was not more than a conjecture . only recently , bekenstein proposed a relativistic version named tensor vector scalar theory ( teves ) @xcite .
this alternative theory of gravity provides a framework to make predictions of numerous important observational phenomena , which @xmath4 has already done : the temperature fluctuations seen in the cmb , gravitational lensing , and the large scale structure of the universe . with maturity
came problems .
rotation curves of some galaxies the initial strong argument for mond can not be explained by mond . in about 1/4 of galaxies considered by proponents of mond
the predicted velocities are well above the observations in the very central regions @xcite .
rms velocities of stars in some dwarf spheroidal galaxies @xcite also present problems .
so far , the most severe challenges for mond are coming from clusters of galaxies .
dynamics of galaxies in clusters can not be explained by mond and requires introduction of dark matter , possibly in the form of a massive ( @xmath7ev ) neutrino @xcite .
we do not know whether this modification can explain some properties of clusters of galaxies such as the `` bullet cluster '' , where the baryonic mass ( galaxies and gas ) is clearly separated from the gravitational mass , as indicated by gravitational lensing @xcite . in any case
, for mond to survive too it must invoke dark matter in the form of massive neutrinos and dark energy in the form of an arbitrary constant added to a combination of two scalar fields used in teves mond @xcite .
there is no doubt that alternative theories of gravity represent a challenge to the standard model of cosmology and gr .
any theory or model must respond to these challenges . here
we present a number of observations to test gravity and dark matter in the peripheral parts of galaxies at distances 50 - 500 kpc from the centers of galaxies .
these scales can be tested by studying the motion of satellites of galaxies .
this is a relatively old field in extragalactic astronomy and historically it was one of main arguments for the presence of dark matter @xcite .
the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 , we present the observational results drawn from the sdss and the predictions from the standard model of cosmology .
predictions from mond are computed and discussed in section 3 .
finally , conclusions are given in section 4 .
we use the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; www.sdss.org ) the largest photometric and spectroscopic astronomical survey ever undertaken of the local universe to study the motion of satellites . as of data release four ( dr4 ) @xcite , imaging data are available over 6670 deg@xmath8 in five photometric bands .
in addition to the ccd imaging , the sdss 2.5 m telescope on apache point , new mexico , measured spectra of galaxies , providing distance determinations .
approximately half million of galaxies brighter than @xmath9 over 4700 deg@xmath8 have been targeted for spectroscopic observations as part of sdss and are included in dr4 .
redshift accuracy is better than 30 km / s and the overall completeness is @xmath690% . for our study
we compute rest frame absolute magnitudes in the g - band from the extinction - corrected apparent magnitudes assuming a @xmath10 cosmology with a hubble constant @xmath11 ( @xmath12 = @xmath13 ) .
galaxies are split into red ( early - types ) and blue ( late - types ) populations based on the bimodality observed in the @xmath14 color distribution ( * ? ? ?
the local minima between the peaks of the color distribution occur near @xmath15 .
all magnitudes and colors are k - corrected to @xmath16 . because calculations of mond gravity for non - spherical objects are complicated
, we restrict our analysis only to red galaxies , the vast majority of which are either elliptical galaxies or are dominated by bulges .
our galaxy sample was selected from the full redshift sample by taking all galaxies with recession velocity 3000 km / s @xmath17 km / s .
the total number of selected galaxies is about 215,000 .
the sdss heliocentric velocities were converted to the local group standard of rest before computing distances .
we select our host galaxies as galaxies with absolute g - band magnitude brighter than @xmath18 and isolated : a galaxy must be at least 4 times brighter than any other galaxy within a projected distance @xmath19 mpc and a line - of - sight velocity difference @xmath20 km / s .
we define satellites as all galaxies being at least 4 times fainter than their hosts and found within a projected distance @xmath21 kpc and velocity difference @xmath22 km / s with respect to their hosts .
typically we find about 1.5 satellites per host .
in total we have 9500 satellites with a mean luminosity of about @xmath23 .
we bin the host galaxies by luminosity and collect information about the distribution of relative velocities @xmath24 and the number of satellites as the function of projected distance @xmath25 .
figure 1 presents the observational results for primaries , which are at least 6 times brighter than any satellite .
we also used primaries , which are 4 times brighter , and primaries , which are 10 times brighter than their satellites .
we do not find any trend with the primary - satellite magnitude gap : results are nearly the same ( see section 3 for details ) .
the only difference is the statistics , and , thus , the error - bars .
the distribution of line - of - sight velocities ( top right panel ) clearly shows a two - component structure : a homogeneous background of interloper galaxies ( dwarfs which happen to lie along the line - of - sight , with large physical distances from the host galaxies but small projected and velocity differences , but which are not associated with the host ) and a nearly gaussian component .
the surface density of the satellites also shows the same structure : at large separations the number density goes to a constant due to interlopers .
we subtract the background and plot the surface density of satellites in the bottom right panel . in order to study the velocity dispersion of satellites @xmath26 as a function of projected distance @xmath25 we use a maximum likelihood method to approximate the number of satellites @xmath27 per unit projected area and per unit velocity difference @xmath24 using an 9-parameter function in the form of a constant plus a gaussian distribution with variable velocity dispersion and normalization : @xmath28/\sqrt { 2\pi}\sigma+ n_0 , \label{eq : delta}\ ] ] where the surface number - density of satellites @xmath29 and the rms line - of - sight velocity @xmath30 are 3th order shifted chebyshev polynomials of the first kind .
the parameter @xmath31 is a constant representing the background of interlopers .
the left panel in figure 1 shows the resulting rms velocity of satellites for three magnitude bins . in order to estimate statistical uncertainties
, we run monte carlo simulations using the same number of hosts and satellites as in the corresponding magnitude bin in figure 1 .
note that the data points are correlated .
we use monte carlo simulations to test statistical significance that the observed velocities are declining with distance : data for each magnitude bin reject a constant @xmath32 at about @xmath33 confidence level .
we also studied blue galaxies and find declining velocities for them .
these results are in agreement with previous estimates @xcite , but we now can exclude constant rms velocities much more reliably .
in order to compare observational results with the @xmath4 predictions , we use high - resolution cosmological n - body simulations @xcite , which we then treat as if they are the observational data .
the simulations were done for the standard @xmath4model with parameters @xmath34 , @xmath35 , @xmath11 , @xmath36 .
we use two simulations .
both simulation had @xmath37 particles .
one simulation had the computational box 120 @xmath38mpc box , mass resolution @xmath39 and force resolution 1.8 @xmath38kpc .
the second simulation has the computational box 80 @xmath38mpc box , mass resolution @xmath40 and force resolution 1.2 @xmath38kpc .
we do not find any differences between the simulations and decided to present results of the larger simulation , which provides better statistics of halos .
we select isolated halos as halos , which within projected distance of 715 kpc and within relative velocity difference 1000 km / s do not have halos or subhalos with maximum circular larger than 1/2 of the halo s circular velocity .
this corresponds to the mass ratio of a factor ten for distrinct halos .
circular velocities are better characteristics of subhalos , which have poorly defined masses .
although we resolve subhalos , we dicided to use dark matter particles as proxies for satellites . at distances larger than a fraction ( 1/4- 1/3 ) of a virial radius from center of a halo satellites
trace the motion and the spacial distribution of the dark matter ( e.g. * ? ? ?
results presented in figures 1 and 2 show that all three characteristics of observed satellites are reproduced by the model .
note that we actually do not make fits .
results from simulations have only one parameter : the maximum circular velocity of the dark matter halo .
we just plot what we obtain from the simulations .
once we fix the maximum circular velocity , the results are fairly insensitive to parameters of the cosmological model .
two factors may affect the shape of the theoretical v - r diagram : the halo concentration and the velocity anysotropy .
the halo concentrations @xmath41 are in the range @xmath42 for halos ( @xmath43 ) and normalization @xmath44 cosidered in this paper @xcite .
( here @xmath45 is the virial radius and @xmath46 is the characteristic radius of the nfw profile ) . for virial radii in the range @xmath47 kpc
, the exact value of the halo concentration affects only the central region @xmath48 kpc .
the average halo concentration depends weakly on the amplitude of the perturbations @xmath44 .
existing observational data leave only very narrow range for variation of @xmath49 , which also limits the range of concentrations .
the velocity anisotropy is less certain , but it is not large .
n - body simulations indicate that @xmath50 is slightly positive and has a tendency to increase with the distance for radii smaller than the virial radius ( e.g. * ? ? ?
* ) with typical values @xmath51 for halo masses considered in this paper . at larger distances
@xmath50 declines and goes to zero @xcite . in order to demonstrate that our results of n - body simulations are robust and reliable , we use solutions of the jeans equation , which we obtain for parameters compatible with numerous previous simulations . once a solution for the radial velocity dispersion is obtained ,
we integrate it along a line of sight with appropriate corrections for the velocity anisotropy . for the density use the nfw profiles with concentration @xmath52 . for the sake of completeness , we add the cosmological background density , which has only a small effect at large distances . for @xmath50
we use approximation given by eq .
( [ eq : betb ] ) with parameters chosen in such a way that @xmath53 and at @xmath54 kpc @xmath55 .
we use the same range of circular velocities as in figure [ fig : two ] . for more massive halos we use @xmath56 and @xmath57 . for less massive halos we adopted @xmath58 and @xmath59 .
results presented in figure [ fig : jeans ] clearly indicate that very simple stationary models can accurately reproduce results of simulations .
the situation is different for mond because there are no predictions on the same level of sophistication as for @xmath4 . in principle
, those predictions can be made , but at this moment they have not been yet made .
thus , we have only one option : solve the jeans equation for spherical systems .
when doing so , we have a freedom of choosing two functions : the number - density profile of satellites and the velocity anisotropy @xmath60 .
we also have two free parameters : stellar mass @xmath61 and the magnitude of external force ( see below for details ) .
the predictions are constrained by two functions @xmath29 and @xmath62 .
the velocity distribution function also gives constraints , but those are relatively weak .
only the models with a large @xmath63 can be excluded .
the stellar luminosity and colors constrain the stellar mass . roughly speaking we have two arbitrary functions to fit two observed functions .
it should not be difficult given that the model is viable . in our case
the jeans equation for the radial velocity dispersion @xmath64 can be written in the form : @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the velocity anisotropy and @xmath67 is the gravitational acceleration . the formal solution of the jeans equation can be written in the form : @xmath68 @xmath69 .
\label{eq : jeanschi}\ ] ] it is convenient to chose forms of @xmath70 and @xmath50 such that the integral in eq.([eq : jeanschi ] ) is taken in elementary functions .
we used the following approximations : @xmath71 @xmath72 @xmath73^{2\beta_1 } \label{eq : betb}\ ] ] @xmath74^{2\beta_1 } \left[\frac{1}{1+(\frac{r}{r_b})^2}\right]^{\beta_1 } \label{eq : betc}\ ] ] in the case of newtonian gravity the acceleration @xmath75 , where the mass @xmath76 includes both normal baryonic mass and dark matter .
for mond the acceleration of spherical systems @xmath77 is given by the solution of the non - linear equation @xmath78 where @xmath61 is the mass of only baryons and @xmath79 .
the term @xmath80 is the external constant gravitational acceleration .
it formally breaks the spherical symmetry .
thus , the eq .
( [ eq : gmond ] ) is only an approximation valid for small external force .
here we use the same approximation as eq .
( 10 ) in @xcite , which we average over angles between a constant external acceleration @xmath80 and internal radial acceleration @xmath77 .
the function @xmath81 can have different shapes .
we tried the originally proposed form @xcite @xmath82 , but accepted and used for all our analysis the function @xmath83 , which gives slightly better results .
the function @xmath84 is limited by the observations presented in figure 1 .
the velocity anisotropy @xmath60 is a free function , but there are constraints .
asymptotically @xmath50 goes to zero at large distances where gravitational effect of the central galaxy diminishes .
ideally the velocity anisotropy at small distances also should be declining .
there are different arguments why this should be the case .
( 1 ) the tangential velocities of few satellites of the milky way , for which the proper motions are measured , strongly reject radial orbits @xcite .
there is no reason to believe that our galaxy should be special in this respect .
( 2 ) experience with gravitational dynamical systems indicate that in dynamically relaxed systems @xmath85 .
numerous simulations of cosmological models illustrate this : @xmath50 is small in the central region and increases to @xmath86 at the viral radius @xcite .
note that we should distinguish the velocity anisotropy and the orbital eccentricity . for centrally concentrated objects , which we are dealing with here ,
already isotropic velocities imply typical peri-/apocenter ratios of 1:4 - 1:5 .
if eccentricity is larger , a significant fraction of satellites comes too close to the central @xmath87 kpc region where the satellites are destroyed by tidal forces .
the term @xmath88 in eq.([eq : gmond ] ) describes the effect of external gravitational field .
it is specific for mond . in newtonian dynamics
a homogeneous external gravity does not affect relative motions inside the object . because the mond gravity is nonlinear , the internal force is affected by the external field ( note that this is not the tidal force ) .
this external effect is quite complicated .
the magnitude of the external force is substantial for the motion of the satellites .
@xcite point out that in mond numerous sources and effects generate about equal magnitude of @xmath89 .
for example , 600 km / s motion of the local group relative to the cmb implies acceleration of 600 km / s@xmath90 gyrs@xmath91 . here
we assume that the acceleration is constant over the whole age of the universe .
if @xmath89 increases with time , as it may be expected , then the acceleration is even larger .
infall with @xmath92 km / s in the direction of virgo gives about half of the value .
m31 produces about the same magnitude of the acceleration .
while the acceleration in mond does not add linearly , it is reasonable to assume that @xmath93 .
we will explore the effect the external field later . in order to make mond predictions , we must estimate the stellar mass for galaxies in our analysis . for two subsamples presented in figure [ fig : tuned ]
we use the magnitude bins @xmath94 ( 2400 satellites ) and @xmath95 ( 2700 satellites ) .
the average luminosities of galaxies in the bins are @xmath96 and @xmath97 .
when estimating the luminosities , we assume @xmath98 @xcite . using measured @xmath99 colors we estimate the stellar masses of galaxies @xcite : @xmath100 and @xmath101 for the two luminosity bins .
this implies the mass - to - light ratios are nearly the same for the bins : @xmath102 .
these @xmath103 estimates are close to predictions of stellar population models . in our case , the galaxies are red ( @xmath104 ) , old mostly ellipticals , for which we expect nearly solar metallicity .
indeed , @xcite gives @xmath105 for the kroupa imf for stellar population 10 gyrs old .
adjusting for the 0.4 mag difference between b and g bands , we get @xmath106 ( the salpeter imf gives @xmath107 ) .
larger metallicity is highly unlikely ( the galaxies are not really massive ellipticals ) and it does not make much difference : 10 percent increase if we take twice the solar metallicity . using different functional forms for @xmath60 , we solve the equations numerically and then integrate the solution along the line - of - sight to get a prediction for @xmath108 .
figure 2 presents results for the two different magnitude ranges and for different parameters @xmath109const and @xmath110const .
mond definitely has problems fitting the data because for any constant @xmath50 it predicts a sharply declining rm velocity at small distances followed by nearly flat velocities at large distances .
the data show just the opposite behavior .
it is easy to understand why predictions of mond has this shape . at large distances
the newtonian acceleration is very small and the acceleration is strongly dominated by the mond correction : @xmath111 . in this case , the solution of eq.(1 ) gives @xmath112const for _ any _ constant value @xmath50 and @xmath70 .
we can try to salvage mond , but so far there is no simple way of doing it .
@xcite find that the way to improve the situation is to have a model with variable slope @xmath70 and with extremely radial orbits .
we also tried different functional forms and numerous combinations of parameters . while the parameters , which fit the surface density and the rms velocities vary , they all give the same answer : density slope in the central 40 kpc should be @xmath113 and the velocity anisotropy at large distances should be @xmath114 . figure [ fig : tuned ] shows ( dashed curves ) the results for the same set of parameters as in @xcite : @xmath115 , @xmath116 , @xmath117 kpc , @xmath118 kpc , @xmath119 and @xmath120 .
here we use the approximation given in eq.([eq : betb ] ) .
the solution is very contrived : relatively small deviations from the best behavior ( small slope in the center and radial orbits in the outer radii ) result in failed fits .
the full curves in the figure show what happens when the velocity anisotropy gets less radial : @xmath121 .
even this fine - tuned solution fails unless the mass - to - light ratio for the larger magnitude bin is arificially increased by a factor of two : @xmath122 , which gives @xmath123 .
@xcite also found the same trend , but they made two mistakes , which did not allow them to clearly see the problem .
first , the solar mass - to - light ratio was used for the b band instead of the g band .
second , the width of the magnitude bin is presented as an error in m / l giving impression of very large uncertainties in m / l .
this is not correct : the statistical uncertainty of the average luminosity of galaxies in each bin is very low and can be neglected .
it should be noted that there is nothing special about the galaxies , which are used here .
the average luminosities differ by a factor 1.7 .
so , it is not a large difference .
colors of the galaxies are practically the same , which then gives the same m / l if we use stellar population models .
the rms velocities are also perfectly consistent with simple scaling .
for example , the ratio of rms velocities at the same projected distance of 70 kpc is 1.3 implying simple scaling @xmath124 . roughly speaking , we double the luminosity and that doubles the stellar mass
. this does not work for mond : it needs twice more stellar mass .
this is definitely a problem because there is no justification why galaxies with the same colors , with the same old population and practically the same luminosity should have dramatically different imf .
the differences are very large : most of the stellar mass in the more luminous bin should be locked up in dwarfs with @xmath125 , while there is relatively little of those in the lower bin , which is consistent with the kroupa imf . in order to make the argument even more clear , we make analysis of velocities in a different way .
this time we split the sample by stellar mass , but we still keep only red primaries with @xmath126 .
we make the analysis twice : for satellites 4 times and for satellites 10 times less bright than the primary galaxy .
there is no systematic difference between the two isolation conditions : within @xmath127 the results are the same .
figure [ fig : stmass ] illustrates this point .
we select primary galaxies to have the stellar mass in the range @xmath128 .
the average stellar mass is @xmath129 , and the average luminosity is @xmath130 .
there is a hint that more isolated primaries have slightly _ larger _ velocities of satellites .
still , the differences are not statistically significant : for radii larger than 50 kpc the differences are smaller than 10 km / s .
then we take the observed stellar mass and use it for mond models and apply the best tuned parameters .
we find that parameters suggested by @xcite ( @xmath131 kpc , @xmath132 , @xmath120 ) improve the fits as compared with a constant @xmath50 models .
still , they are not acceptable . for example , at @xmath133 kpc the mond model is a @xmath134 deviation .
we found a better solution ( @xmath135 kpc and other parameters the same ) , which places mond `` only '' at @xmath136 . in order to envestigate what stellar mass
is needed for mond , we split the sample of red primaries into 5 mass bins ranging from @xmath137 to @xmath138 .
we chose the less stringent isolation condition because it gives typically 2 - 2.5 time more satellites resulting in smaller statistical errors .
each bin has a large number of satellites : @xmath139 .
we then run a grid of mond models with different masses and select models , which make best fits .
just as the mond models in figure [ fig : tuned ] , there are models , which marginally fit the data . for each model
we get stellar mass required by mond and compare it with the stellar mass estimated by the stellar population models .
results are presented in figure [ fig : mondmass ] . for smaller masses mond
gives masses , which are compatible with actual stellar mass observed in the galaxies .
the plot clearly shows the problem with massive galaxies : mond requires increasingly more mass than observed in the galaxies ending up in large ( @xmath140 ) disagreement with the observations . the external gravity force @xmath89 is another mond component .
it must exist on the level of @xmath141 .
figure [ fig : tunedext ] shows what happens to the models when we add the external force . as the starting models we use the best fits shown in the figure [ fig : tuned ] as dashed curves .
the models with the external force make the fits much worse .
taken at face value , the models with realistic @xmath142 can be rejected .
again , we can make the model work if we increase m / l by a factor @xmath143 .
yet , this will make the situation with stellar masses even worse , than what we already have .
using the sdss dr4 data we study the distribution and velocities of satellites orbiting red isolated galaxies .
we find that the surface number - density of the satellites declines almost as a power law with the slope @xmath144 .
the distribution of the line - of - sight velocities is nearly a perfect gaussian distribution with a constant component due to interlopers .
the rms velocities are found to gradually decline with the projected distance .
the constant rms velocity ( isothermal solution ) can be rejected at a 10 @xmath145 level .
observational data strongly favor the standard cosmological model : all three major statistics of satellites
the number - density profile , the line - of - sight velocity dispersion , and the distribution function of the velocities agree remarkably well with the theoretical predictions .
thus , the success of the standard model extends to scales ( 50 - 500 ) kpc , much lower than what was previously considered .
mond fails badly in cases with any acceptable power- law approximation for the number - density of satellites and a constant velocity anisotropy by producing sharply declining velocities at small distances followed by nearly flat velocities at large distances just the opposite of what is observed in real galaxies .
models may be made to fit the satellites data only when all the following conditions are fulfilled : 1 .
the slope of the density in the central 50 kpc is less then -2 .
satellite velocities are nearly radial in outer regions ( @xmath146 at @xmath3 kpc ) .
mass - to - light ratio increases from @xmath147 at @xmath148 to @xmath149 ( @xmath150 ) at @xmath151 .
external force of gravity is smaller than the expected value of @xmath89 @xmath91 .
the negative effect of the external force can be removed by additionally increasing the m / l ratios .
we find that the later three conditions are difficult to realize in nature .
satellites do not fall in to their parent galaxies with zero tangential velocities .
the velocities are induced by other neighboring galaxies and by large - scale structures such as filaments . to some degree , it is similar to the tidal torque , which is responsible for the origin of the angular momentum of galaxies . yet , the interactions are more efficient for providing random velocities
. measurements of peculiar velocities of galaxies the local volume ( 3 - 5 mpc around the milky way ) found deviations from the hubble flow that about 70 - 80 km / s @xcite . at these distances
the gravitational pull of other large galaxies in the aria is larger than that of the milky way and we expect that the same deviations exist for the perpendicular velocity components .
when a satellite with 70 - 80 km / s falls falls from 1 mpc and gets to 400 kpc from mw its tangential velocity increases few times ( conservation of the angular momentum ) .
so , we expect @xmath152 .
we have the same measurements for the satellites in sdss .
when we look at distances 0.81 mpc , we find that the rms velocities hardly correlate with the luminosity and are about 100 km / s .
note that @xmath4perfectly fits the constraint : at these distances it predicts @xmath153 .
thus , mond assumption of very radial orbits does not agree with the observations .
the large m / l ratios is another problem for mond .
so far m / l was treated almost as a free parameter @xcite .
this is not correct .
it should be reminded that observationally there are no indications of large variability of imf for vastly different stellar ages and metallicities .
the imf shows similar flattening for masses smaller than @xmath154 in the solar neighborhood and in the spheroid @xcite , in the galactic bulge @xcite , and in the ursa minor dwarf spheroidal galaxy @xcite .
the galactic bulge has parameters similar to the red galaxies studied in this paper : very old ( on average ) stellar population with nearly solar metallicity .
@xcite give the @xmath155 , which corresponds to @xmath156 .
this is close to what we found for the red galaxies in sdss . in the case
studied here , mond requires that m / l changes by a factor 2 - 2.5 when there is no change in colors and the absolute magnitude changes only by @xmath157 .
there is no justification for this to happen .
the situation is similar to what @xcite found for early type large spirals where mond models fail for any imf discussed in recent 20 years .
only the salpeter imf gives better results .
even in this case the models deviate by a factor of two around the stellar population predictions .
the combination of all these problems makes mond a very implausible solution for the observational data on satellites of galaxies .
there is one significant difference between mond and @xmath4 .
the latter makes predictions for the distribution of mass and velocities for isolated galaxies and those predictions match the observational data .
there are no theoretical predictions for mond .
what we conveniently called `` mond predictions '' were actually _
requirements_. for example , mond must produce the radial velocities of satellites or shallow slope of the number - density in the central region .
we thank s. mcgaugh for challenging us to do mondian analysis of the satellite motion .
we are grateful to j. holtzman for numerous comments and suggestions and thank j. betancort - rijo for comments .
we are especially grateful to angus et al for providing us with the draft of their paper and for extensive discussions .
we still have different ways of looking at the situation with mond .
still , these productive discussions resulted in improvements in their and our papers .
we acknowledge support by the nsf grant ast-0407072 to nmsu and thank the spanish mec under grant pnaya 2005 - 07789 for their support .
computer simulations used in this research were conducted on the columbia supercomputer at the nasa advanced supercomputing division and on seaborg at the national energy research scientific computing center ( nersc ) . | the motion of satellite galaxies around normal galaxies at distances 50 - 500 kpc provides a sensitive test for the theories .
we study the surface density and the velocities of satellites around isolated red galaxies in the sloan digital sky survey .
we find that the surface number - density of satellites declines with the projected distance as a power law with the slope @xmath0 .
the rms velocities gradually decline : observations exclude constant velocities at a @xmath1 level .
we show that observational data strongly favor the standard model : all three major statistics of satellites the number - density profile , the line - of - sight velocity dispersion , and the distribution function of the velocities agree remarkably well with the predictions of the standard cosmological model .
thus , that the success of the standard model extends to scales ( 50 - 500 ) kpc , much lower than what was previously considered .
mond fails on these scales for models which assume any single power - law number - density profile of satellites and any constant velocity anisotropy by predicting nearly constant rms velocities of satellites .
satellite data can be fit by fine - tuned models , which require ( 1 ) specific non - power - law density profile , ( 2 ) very radial orbits at large distances ( velocity anisotropy @xmath2 at @xmath3 kpc ) , and ( 3 ) 2 - 2.5 times more stellar mass than what is found in the galaxies .
the external gravity force a necessary component for mond makes the situation even worse .
we argue that a combination of satellite data and observational constraints on stellar masses make these models very problematic . #
1to 0pt#1 |
population iii stars formed in the early universe at redshift @xmath5 with a top - heavy initial mass function ( e.g. see @xcite ) are expected to leave at the end of their lives intermediate mass black remnants of the order of @xmath6 .
these seeds , formed within dark matter halos of mass @xmath7 , may be the starting points for accretion that will lead to supermassive black holes ( @xmath8 ) , which are considered to power the luminosity of qsos , observed in the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) at @xmath9 when the universe was less than one billion years old ( e.g. see @xcite ) .
these bright qsos are extremely rare objects ( one object per about 200 deg@xmath10 in sdss , see @xcite ) , so we expect on average one per 1gpc@xmath11 comoving . within this volume
the qso may either be the descendant of the first intermediate mass black hole seed left from the _ first _ popiii star , which would therefore give the most time for mass accretion , or sit at the center of the most massive structure at @xmath1 .
of course these two alternatives are in principle mutually non - exclusive , as the remnants of the first popiii stars could end up in the most massive dark matter halos at @xmath12 .
this possibility seems to be implied by a number of recent papers , where the progenitor halos of bright quasars are traced back in time and identified as the first dark matter halos formed in the universe ( e.g. see @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) .
however these works either do not have the mass resolution to identify the dark matters halos hosting the first generation of popiii stars or rely on multiple mesh refinements of a small region centered around the largest halos identified at z=0 in order to resolve scales down to @xmath13 . to properly address the link between bright quasars and popiii stars it is necessary to resolve a dynamic range in mass of more than @xmath14 : a simulation box of 1 gpc@xmath11 contains a mass larger than @xmath15 and within this box dark matter halos below @xmath16
need to be identified .
therefore we have adopted an original approach ( see @xcite ) , broadly based on the tree method by @xcite .
the idea is based on coupling a numerical simulations of structure formation to identify dark matter halos at @xmath17 with a monte carlo method to sample subgrid fluctuations of the initial gaussian random field of density fluctuations at the mass scale typical of halos hosting popiii .
this allows us to attach to every particle in the simulation , which has typically a mass in excess of @xmath18 , the formation time of its first popiii star progenitor .
the details of the method are presented in detail in @xcite along with an extensive set of tests to validate our innovative approach . here
we focus instead on summarizing the main results from our investigation .
in particular we show that the first popiii progenitor of a @xmath3 bright qso , while born at @xmath19 well within the early era of popiii formation , it is not the first popiii in the typical gpc@xmath11 volume occupied by the qso , but it is rather preceded by about @xmath20 other popiii stars .
a qualitative understanding can be reached from simple considerations based on the properties of gaussian random fields deriving from the spectrum of primordial density perturbations : small mass dark matter halos are sensitive to higher frequency in the density fluctuations spectrum than their higher mass counterparts .
therefore the first @xmath13 dark matter halos formed at @xmath21 in a simulation box will not in general evolve to become the first @xmath22 dark matter halos formed at @xmath12 . in terms of intermediate mass black hole growth from popiii
this result implies that there are a number of seeds formed in the early universe before the one that will become the bright z=6 qso .
all these seeds have enough time , if accreting at eddington limit with accretion efficiency @xmath23 to become supermassive ( @xmath24 ) by z=6 .
we follow their evolution and we show with a simple accretion model that the gas supply available for growth is limited for most of these seeds , so that the qso luminosity function derived in our framework is consistent with the slope of the observed qso luminosity function
. for the oldest popiii progenitor ( with @xmath25 ) of the most massive halo ( black line ) and averaged over the 10 most massive halos ( red line ) at @xmath3 in the @xmath26 box simulation .
the blue line represents the collapse redshift of the _ first _ popiii star perturbation , while the dotted green line refers to the collapse redshift of the 100th popiii in the box . ]
we identify the largest dark matter halos at @xmath3 in three cosmological simulations with @xmath27 particles and different box sizes : a large ( edge @xmath28 mpc / h ) , a medium ( edge @xmath29 mpc / h ) and a small ( edge @xmath30 mpc / h ) box .
the simulations have been carried out with the public version of the tree - pm code gadget2 @xcite and a cosmology based on third year wmap data @xcite : @xmath31 , @xmath32 , @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is the total matter density in units of the critical density ( @xmath35 ) with @xmath36 being the hubble constant ( parameterized as @xmath37 ) and @xmath38 the newton s gravitational constant .. @xmath39 is the dark energy density . in generating the initial density field
we use a scale invariant long - wave spectral index ( @xmath40 ) of the power spectrum of density fluctuations and @xmath41 or @xmath42 ( the root mean squared mass fluctuation in a sphere of radius @xmath43 extrapolated at @xmath44 using linear theory ) .
as described in @xcite , the initial density field is then used as input in our monte carlo code to obtain the formation redshift of the first popiii progenitor of each particle in the simulation box .
in the @xmath26 box simulation . ] under the assumption that the first popiii stars in the universe have formed in @xmath13 halos cooled by molecular hydrogen , the progenitor of the most massive @xmath3 halo ( the one assumed to host the bright qso ) in our large box simulation is born at @xmath45 , while the first popiii in the volume is already present at @xmath46 ( see fig . [
fig : red720 ] ) . by the time the qso progenitor is born , there are on average 8000 other popiii stars formed in the simulation ( see fig . [
fig : card720 ] ) , with a typical popiii star formation rate , as obtained from our method , shown in fig .
[ fig : sfr ] .
if popiii stars reside in halos of different mass and/or if the value of @xmath47 is different , there will be a shift on the formation time of these first stars ( that is on the scale of the x - axis in figs .
[ fig : red720]-[fig : sfr ] ) , but the relative ranking between the _ first _ popiii star in the box and the popiii that is the qso progenitor remains essentially unchanged ( e.g. see fig . 3 in @xcite ) . ) per unit redshift versus redshift for @xmath48 as measured by means of our mc code . ]
the relation between popiii and qsos can be easily understood in terms of the statistics of gaussian random fields ( see fig . [
fig : pdf ] ) .
in fact , the most massive @xmath3 halo in the simulation box ( with mass @xmath49 ) originates from a @xmath50 peak in the density perturbation field . if we know consider a random volume in the simulation box with mass @xmath51 , we find that the distribution for the maximum peak at the mass scale of a popiii halo ( @xmath13 ) inside this volume is in the range @xmath52 \sigma(m_{qh})$ ] at the 90% confidence level .
this is essentially because ( i ) we are at a smaller mass scale , so there is additional power in the density fluctuations field and ( ii ) we are considering here the first popiii halo formed in the @xmath51 volume , that is the maximum among @xmath53 fluctuations .
the probability distribution for the peak associated to the first popiii progenitor of the qso ( green dashed line in fig .
[ fig : pdf ] ) is then given by combining the probability distribution of the qso overdensity with that of the first popiii halo of a random cell . from fig .
[ fig : pdf ] it is immediately apparent that the advantage of sitting at the top of the qso overdensity is not sufficient for the first popiii in this volume to beat all other popiii in the box .
still one in about @xmath54 popiii progenitors of random @xmath51 cells in the ( 720 mpc / h)@xmath11 box is formed before the qso progenitor .
as there are @xmath55 cells of mass @xmath51 in this volume , we expect from this simple consideration that the popiii progenitor of the qso will be formed when already @xmath56 other popiii stars are present in the box , in excellent agreement with the detailed results from the numerical simulation ( see fig . [
fig : card720 ] ) .
this result is essentially given by the fact that bright qsos at @xmath3 are very rare objects . if fact , if we consider a smaller cosmic volume ( e.g. a box of edge @xmath30 mpc / h ) and repeat the experiment of studying the formation time of the first popiii progenitor of the most massive @xmath3 halo , we find different results ( see fig .
[ fig : red60 ] ) . in this case
the cosmic volume considered is significantly smaller , so sitting at the top of the most massive @xmath3 halo gives a significant relative advantage to popiii formation at @xmath57 : the popiii progenitor of the most massive halo is typically within the first 10 to 100 popiii in the box . for the maximum @xmath58 of @xmath59 random gaussian fluctuations representative of mass scale for halos hosting @xmath3 qso candidates ( red curve ) and popiii stars ( black curve ) . to compute @xmath60 for qso hosting halos
we have assumed a box of @xmath61 and a mass scale of @xmath62 which implies @xmath63 .
this curve represents the probability distribution for a sigma peak that at @xmath64 leads to one of the most massive halos in the simulation volume .
the curve associated to first light perturbations ( solid black , with @xmath65 ) is derived using @xmath66 and @xmath67 : it represents the probability distribution for the maximum of the sub - grid scale fluctuations at the @xmath68 scale within one cell of the @xmath69 volume .
the dashed green line represents the probability distribution of the density fluctuation associated to the first popiii progenitor of a @xmath70 peak .
@xmath58 is given in units of @xmath71 . ] , but for a smaller box simulation , with volume of @xmath72 and @xmath73 .
given the limited volume available sitting on the top of the overdensity that will collapse to the largest @xmath3 halo gives a significant advantage to popiii halos formed at @xmath57 , which are typically within the first 100 formed in the box . ]
from our investigation it is clear that , before the first popiii progenitor of the most massive halo at @xmath3 is born , several thousands of intermediate mass ( @xmath74 ) black hole seeds are planted by popiii stars formed in a cosmic volume that will on average host a bright @xmath3 quasar .
here we investigate with a simple merger tree code what is the fate of the black holes seeds formed up to the formation time of the quasar seed and what are the implications for the observed quasar luminosity function .
we assume eddington accretion for the bh seeds , so that the evolution of the bh mass is given by : @xmath75},\ ] ] where @xmath76 is the mass at formation time @xmath77 and @xmath78 is the salpeter time @xcite : @xmath79 where @xmath80 is the radiative efficiency . if @xmath23 there has been enough time to build up a @xmath12 supermassive black hole with mass @xmath81 starting from a popiii remnant formed at @xmath19 .
this highlights that only a minor fraction of the popiii bh seeds formed before @xmath82 can accrue mass with high efficiency , otherwise the number density of supermassive black holes at low redshift would greatly exceed the observational constraints .
the first bh seeds in the box are distant from each other , so they evolve in relative isolation , without possibly merging among themselves .
therefore other mechanisms must be responsible for quenching accretion of the first bh seeds .
interestingly if we were to assume that accretion periods are poisson distributed in time for each seed , we would not be able to explain the observed power law distribution of bh masses at @xmath83 around the high mass end .
a poisson distribution would in fact give too little scatter around the median value and a sharp ( faster than exponential ) decay of the displacements from the mean accreted mass .
an exponential distribution of the accretion efficiency is instead required to match the observed bh mass function .
in addition , it is necessary to assume that the duty cycle of the bh accretion is roughly proportional to the mass of the halo it resides in . to explore this possibility
we follow the merging history of popiii halos formed at @xmath82 by means of a merger - tree code .
we implement a bh growth based on eq .
[ eq : accr ] , but at each step of the tree we limit the bh mass to @xmath84 , where @xmath85 is the total baryon mass of the halo that hosts the bh . if @xmath86 ( like in @xcite ) , then we obtain an expected mass for the bh powering bright @xmath3 quasar of @xmath87 , which is in agreement with the observational constraints from sdss quasars @xcite . by fitting a power law function to the bh mass function in the range @xmath88\cdot 10^{10 } m_{\odot}$ ]
we obtain a slope @xmath89 , while the slope is @xmath90 in the mass range @xmath91 \cdot 10^{10 } m_{\odot}$ ] , a value that is consistent within the @xmath92 error bar with the slope of the bright end of the quasar luminosity function measured by @xcite .
we study the link between the first popiii halos collapsed in a simulation box and the most massive structures at @xmath17 , with the aim of establishing the relationship between the first intermediate mass black holes created in the universe and the super - massive black holes that power the emission of bright @xmath3 quasars .
we show that almost no correlation is present between the sites of formation of the first few hundred @xmath93 halos and the most massive halos at @xmath94 when the simulation box has an edge of several hundred @xmath95 . here
the popiii progenitors ( halos of mass @xmath96 ) of massive halos at @xmath97 formed from density peaks that are @xmath98 more common than that of the _ first _ popiii star in the ( 720 mpc / h)@xmath11 simulation box .
these halos virialize around @xmath99 , to be compared with @xmath100 of the _ first _ popiii halo .
this has important consequences .
we show that , if bright quasars and supermassive black holes live in the most massive halos at @xmath101 , then their progenitors at the @xmath13 mass scale are well within the popiii era , regardless of the popiii termination mechanism . on the other hand ,
if the @xmath102 relationship is already in place at @xmath3 , then bright quasars are not linked to the remnants of the very first intermediate mass black holes ( imbhs ) born in the universe , as their imbh progenitors form when already several thousands of popiii stars have been created within the typical volume that hosts a bright @xmath3 quasar .
the imbh seeds planted by this very first popiii stars have sufficient time to grow up to @xmath103 \cdot 10^{10 } m_{\odot}$ ] by @xmath3 if we assume eddington accretion with radiative efficiency @xmath104 . instead , quenching of the bh accretion is required for the seeds of those popiii stars that will not end up in massive halos at @xmath3 , otherwise the number density of supermassive black holes would greatly exceed the observational constraints .
one way to obtain growth consistent with the observations is to limit the accreted mass at a fraction @xmath86 of the total baryon halo mass .
this gives a slope of the bh mass function @xmath105 in the bh mass range @xmath106 \cdot 10^{10 } m_{\odot}$ ] , which is within the @xmath92 uncertainty of the slope of the bright end of the @xmath3 quasar luminosity function ( @xmath107 ) measured by @xcite .
another important point highlighted by this study is that rich clusters do not preferentially host the remnants of the first popiii stars .
in fact the remnants of the first 100 pop - iii stars in our medium sized simulation box ( volume of @xmath108 ) end up at @xmath44 on halos that have a median mass of @xmath109 .
this suggests caution in interpreting the results from studies that select a specific volume of the simulation box , like a rich cluster , and then progressively refine smaller and smaller regions with the aim of hunting for the first lights formed in the whole simulation ( see e.g. , @xcite ) . only by considering refinements over the complete volume of the box the rarity and the formation ranking of these progenitors can be correctly evaluated . | we discuss the link between dark matter halos hosting the first popiii stars formed at redshift @xmath0 and the rare , massive , halos that are generally considered to host bright @xmath1 quasars .
we show that within the typical volume occupied by one bright high - z qso the remnants of the first several thousands popiii stars formed do not end up in the most massive halos at @xmath1 , but rather live in a large variety of environments . the black hole seeds planted by these very first popiii stars
can easily grow to @xmath2 by @xmath3 assuming eddington accretion with radiative efficiency @xmath4 .
therefore quenching of the accretion is crucial to avoid an overabundance of supermassive black holes .
we implement a simple feedback model for the growth of the seeds planted by popiii stars and obtain a @xmath1 bh mass function consistent with the observed qso luminosity function .
address = space telescope science institute , 3700 san martin drive baltimore md 21218 usa address = space telescope science institute , 3700 san martin drive baltimore md 21218 usa , altaddress = department of physics and astronomy , johns hopkins university , baltimore , md 21218 usa |
neutron stars ( ns ) are among the densest of massive objects in the universe . a hot neutron star is born following the gravitational collapse of the core of a massive star just after the supernova explosion .
the interior temperature of a neutron star at its birth is of the order @xmath0 @xcite .
as we go from the surface to the center of a neutron star , at sufficiently high densities , the matter is expected to undergo a transition from hadronic matter where the quarks are confined inside the hadrons to a state of deconfined quarks , with up , down and strange quarks in the quark matter .
other quarks have higher masses and do not appear in this state .
glendenning has shown that a proper construction of the hadron - quark phase transition inside the neutron stars implies the coexistence of nucleonic matter and quark matter over a finite range of pressure .
therefore , a mixed hadron - quark phase exists in the neutron star where its energy is lower than that of the quark matter and the nucleonic matter over a finite rang of pressure @xcite .
this shows that we can consider a neutron star to be composed of a hadronic matter layer , a mixed phase of quarks and hadrons and , in the core , quark matter .
the deconfined quark phase is treated within the popular mit bag model @xcite . in this model ,
the total energy density is the sum of a nonperturbative energy shift @xmath1 ( the bag constant ) and the kinetic energy for noninteracting quarks .
the bag constant @xmath2 can be interpreted as the difference between the energy densities of the perturbative vacuum and physical ones , which has a constant value such as @xmath3 and @xmath4 in the initial model of mit , recently it is constrained to be compatible with the recent experimental results obtained at cern on the formation of a quark - gluon plasma .
the resulting picture is the following : during the early stages of the heavy - ion collision , a very hot and dense state ( fireball ) is formed whose energy materializes in the form of quarks and gluons strongly interacting with each other , exhibiting features consistent with expectations from a plasma of deconfined quarks and gluons @xcite . in general , it is not obvious if the informations on the nuclear eos from high energy heavy ion collisions can be related to the physics of neutron stars interior .
the possible quark - gluon plasma produced in heavy ion collision is expected to be characterized by small baryon density and high temperature , while the possible quark phase in neutron stars appears at high baryon density and low temperature .
however , if one adopts for the hadronic phase a non - interacting gas model of nucleons , antinucleons and pions , the original mit bag model predicts that the deconfined phase occurs at an almost constant value of the quark - gluon energy density , irrespective of the thermodynamical conditions of the system @xcite .
burgio et al . have investigated the structure of neutron stars with a quark core at zero @xcite and finite temperatures @xcite , using the brueckner - bethe - goldstone formalism to determine the equation of state of the hadronic matter .
we have calculated the structure properties of the cold neutron star by considering a quark phase at its core @xcite and compared the results with our previous calculations for the neutron star without the quark core @xcite . in these works , we have employed the lowest order constrained variational ( locv ) method for the hadronic matter calculations .
recently , we have calculated the structure of a hot neutron star with a quark core with a fixed bag constant ( @xmath5 ) @xcite . in the present paper
, we intend to extend these calculations to hot neutron stars with a quark cores by considering a density dependent bag constant .
in this section , we calculate the equation of state of a neutron star composed of a hadronic matter , a mixed phase of quarks and hadrons and a quark core as follows . in our calculations , the equation of state of hot nucleonic matter is computed using the lowest order constrained variational ( locv ) method @xcite .
the details of our calculations for the hadronic phase has been fully discussed in @xcite .
we use the mit bag model for the quark matter . in this model ,
the energy density is the sum of kinetic energy of quarks and a bag constant ( @xmath2 ) which is interpreted as the difference between energy densities of non interacting quarks and interacting ones @xcite , @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the kinetic energy per volume of particle @xmath8 , the kinetic energy of quarks has been discussed in @xcite and the bag constant @xmath2 , can be interpreted as the difference between the energy densities of the noninteracting quarks and interacting ones , which has constant values such as @xmath9 and @xmath10 in the initial model of mit .
but the density of quark matter is not uniform , therefor we can consider a density dependent @xmath2 .
we try to determine a range of possible values for @xmath2 by exploiting the experimental data obtained at the cern sps , where several experiments using high - energy beams of pb nuclei reported ( indirect ) evidence for the formation of a quark - gluon plasma @xcite . according to the analysis of those experiments , the quark - hadron transition takes place at about seven times normal nuclear matter energy density @xmath11 . in the literature , there are attempts to understand the density dependence of @xmath1 @xcite .
however , currently the results are highly model dependent and no definite picture has come out yet .
therefore , we attempt to provide effective parametrization for this density dependence .
our parametrization are constructed in such a way that at asymptotic densities @xmath2 approaches a finite value @xmath12 .
for the bag constant ( @xmath2 ) , we use a density dependent gaussian parametrization @xcite , @xmath13\ ] ] with @xmath14 and @xmath15 . we know
that the value of the bag constant ( @xmath2 ) should be compatible with empirical results .
the experimental results at cern - sps show a proton fraction @xmath16 @xcite .
therefore , for calculation of @xmath12 , we employ the equation of state of the asymmetric nuclear matter as follows .
first , we use the equation of state of asymmetric hadronic matter characterized by a proton fraction @xmath16 and the uv14 + tni potential . by assuming that the hadron - quark transition takes place at the energy density @xmath17 , we find that the hadronic matter baryonic density is @xmath18 ( transition density ) and at values lower than @xmath19 , the quark matter energy density is higher than that of nuclear matter , while by increasing the baryonic density , the two energy densities become equal at this density , and after that , the nuclear matter energy density remains always higher . energy density equation of quark matter with two flavors u and d reduces to @xmath20 beta - equilibrium and charge neutrality conditions lead to the following relation for the number density of quarks , @xmath21 we determine @xmath22 by putting quark energy density and hadronic energy density equal to each other at any temperature .
later we can calculate the energy density and determine pressure and the equation of state for quark phase such as determined in @xcite . for mixed phase , where the fraction of space occupied by quark matter smoothly increase from zero to unity
, we have a mixture of hadrons , quarks and electrons . according to the gibss equilibrium condition ,
the temperatures , pressures and chemical potentials of both phases are equal @xcite .
calculation of equation of state of mixed phase has been fully discussed in @xcite .
our results for the energy densities corresponding to different phases i.e. hadronic matter , pure quark matter and a mixed phase of quarks and hadrons , are given in fig .
[ en1hmq ] at two temperatures .
it can be seen that at low densities there is a pure hadronic phase .
we have found that a mixed phase exists at higher densities up to @xmath23 .
it is obvious that a pure quark phase emerges by increasing the density .
the energy density for neutron star with density dependent and density independent @xmath2 are shown in fig .
[ en1f , n ] .
it is clear that for a density dependent bag constant , the energy density is smaller than that of the independent one .
we have calculated the equation of state ( the pressure versus baryon density ) for the neutron star with the quark core using the density dependent and independent bag constants .
[ pn1f , n ] shows the relevant results at two temperatures .
these equations of state are used as an input into the general relativistic equation of hydrostatic equilibrium .
the equilibrium energy density distribution of slowly rotating spherical star is determined by the tolman - oppenheimer - volkoff equation ( tov ) @xcite , @xmath24 [ m(r)+\frac{4\pi r^3 p(r)}{c^2}]}{r^2 [ 1-\frac{2gm(r)}{rc^2}]},\ ] ] @xmath25 @xmath26 is the pressure and @xmath27 is the total energy density . for a given equation of state in the form @xmath28 , the tov equation yields the mass and radius of star as a function of central energy density . in our calculation for the hot neutron star with quark core , we use the following equation of state : ( i ) below the density @xmath29 , we use the equation of state calculated by baym @xcite .
( ii ) for the hadron phase , from the density of @xmath29 up to the density where the mixed phase is started , we use the equation of state which is calculated in section [ hadron phase ] .
( iii ) in the range of densities in mixed phase , we use the equation of state calculated in section [ mixed phase ] .
( iv ) for quark phase , we use the equation of state calculated in section [ quark phase ] . using the above equations of state
, we integrate the tov equation numerically and determine the structure of this star .
all calculations are done for the density dependent bag constant ( @xmath30 ) at two different temperatures @xmath31 and @xmath32 .
our results are as follows .
the gravitational mass versus the central mass density for a hot neutron star with quark core for two different temperatures has been presented in fig .
[ mass10 ] .
we can see there is the limiting mass for hot neutron star and this mass increases when we consider a density dependent bag constant in mit model .
this is reasonable because when a density dependent bag constant is considered , the equation of state is softer as this is seen in fig .
[ pn1f , n ] for two temperatures .
the radius as a function of central mass density for hot neutron star with quark core for two different temperatures has been presented in fig .
[ radius10 ] .
the radius of star decreases when the bag constant is density dependent .
our results for the maximum gravitational mass of the hot neutron star with the quark core and the corresponding values of radius and central mass density have been given in tables 1 and 2 for two different temperatures .
the structure of hot neutron star with a quark core using a density dependent bag constant has been investigated . from the surface toward the center of hot neutron star , a pure hadronic matter , a mixed phase of quarks and hadrons in a range of densities determined by employing the gibbs conditions , and a pure quark matter in the core , have been considered .
we have employed the locv method at finite temperature to get the equation of state of hot hadronic matter . the mit bag model with the density dependent bag constant obtained by using the recent experimental results of cern sps on the formation of a quark - gluon plasma has been applied to compute the equation of state of hot quark matter .
we have solved the tov equation by a numerical method to determine the structural properties of hot neutron star with the quark core at t = 10 and 20 mev .
the results have been compared to those for the hot neutron star with @xmath5 .
we have found that a density dependent bag constant leads to a higher mass and a lower radius for the neutron star in comparison to the case in which the constant @xmath5 has been used .
we wish to tank the research council of islamic azad university , bafgh branch .
g. h. bordbar wishes to thank the research institute for astronomy and astrophysics of maragha and shiraz university research council for financial support .
a. burrows and j. m.lattimer , _ apj _ * 307 * , 178 ( 1986 ) n. k. glendenning , _ phys .
rev . _ * d46 * , 1274 ( 1992 ) a. chodos , r.l .
jaffe , k. johnson , c. b. thorn and v. f. weisskopf , _ phys .
rev . _ * d9 * , 3471 ( 1974 ) . j. rafelsky and b. muller , _ phys .
lett . _ * 48 * 1066(1982 ) t. matsuiand and h.satz , _ phys .
_ * b178 * , 416(1986 ) j. cleymans , r.v .
gavai and e. suhonen , _ physics rep .
_ * 130 * , 217 ( 1986 ) .
g. f. burgio , m. baldo , p. k. sahu and h .- j .
schulze , _ phys .
rev . _ * c66 * , 025802(2002 ) g. f. burgio , m. baldo , o. e. nicotra and h .- j .
schulze , _
ap&ss _ * 308 * , 387(2007 ) g. h. bordbar , m. bigdeli and t. yazdizadeh , _ int . j. mod .
phys . _ * a21 * , 5991 ( 2006 ) g. h. bordbar and m. hayati , _ int . j. mod .
phys . _ * a21 * , 1555 ( 2006 ) t. yazdizadeh and g.h .
bordbar , _ res .
astron . astrophys _
* 11 * , 471(2011 ) g. h. bordbar and m. modarres , _ j. phys .
* 23 * , 1631(1997 ) g. h. bordbar and m. modarres , _ phys .
_ * c57 * , 714.(1998 ) m. modarres and g. h. bordbar , _ phys .
rev . _ * c58 * , 2781(1998 ) g. h. bordbar and m. bigdeli , _ phys .
_ * c75 * , 045804(2007 ) g. h. bordbar and m. bigdeli , _ phys .
rev . _ * c76 * , 035803(2007 ) g. h.bordbar and bigdeli _ phys .
rev . _ * c77 * , 015805(2008 ) g. h.bordbar and bigdeli _ phys .
_ * c78 * , 054315(2008 ) m. bigdeli , g. h. bordbar and z. rezaei , _ phys .
rev . _ * c80 * , 034310 ( 2009 ) .
e.farhi , r. l. jaffe , _ phys .
_ * d30 * , 2379(1984 ) u.heinz and m. jacobs , nucl - th/0002042 .
u.heinz , _ nuch .
* a685 * , 414(2001 ) c. adami and g.e .
brown , _ phys .
_ * 234 * , 1(1993 ) d. blaschke , h. grigorian , g. poghosyan , c.d .
roberts and s. schmidt , _ phys .
lett . _ * b450 * , 207(1999 ) m. baldo , g. f. burgio and h .- j .
schulze , _
_ superdense qcd matter and compact stars nato science series__*volume 197 , part ii * , 113 ( 2006 ) g. f. burgio , m. baldo , p. k. sahu , a. b. santra and h .- j .
schulze , _ phys .
lett . _ * b526 * , 19 ( 2002 ) s. l. shapiro and s. a. teukolski , 1983 , _ black holes , white dwarfs and neutron stars _
( new york ) .
n. k. glendenning , _ compact star , nuclear physics , particle physics , and general relativity _
( springer , new york ) , 2nd ed.(2000 ) f. weber , _ pulsars as astrophysical laboratories for nuclear and particle physics _ ( institute of physics , bristol)(1999 ) g. baym , c. pethick and p. sutherland , _ astrophys
. j. _ * 170 * , 299(1971 ) | as we go from center toward the surface of a neutron star , the state of baryonic matter changes from the de - confined quark - gluon to a mixed phase of quark and hadronic matter , and a thin crust of hadronic matter . for the quark matter , within mit bag model , the total energy density of the system is the kinetic energy for non - interacting quarks plus a bag constant . in this article
first we have considered a density dependent bag constant obtained using the recent experimental results of cern sps on the formation of a quark - gluon plasma . for calculations of the hadron phase
, we use the lowest order constrained variational method .
the equation of state of mixed phase has been determined using gibbs conditions . finally , we have calculated the structure of a hot neutron star with quark core employing tov equation .
our results show that a density dependent bag constant leads to a higher mass and lower radius for the hot neutron star with respect to the case in which we use a fixed bag constant . |
today s global economy is more interconnected and complex than ever , and seems out of any particular institution s control .
the diversity of markets and traded products , the complexity of their structure and regulation , make it a daunting challenge to understand behaviours , predict trends or prevent systemic crises . the neo - classical approach , that aimed at explaining global behaviour in terms of perfectly rational actors , has largely failed @xcite .
yet , persistent statistical regularities in empirical data suggest that a less ambitious goal of explaining economic phenomena as emergent statistical properties of a large interacting system may be possible , without requiring much from agents rationality ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
one of the most robust empirical stylised fact , since the work of pareto , is the observation of a broad distribution of wealth which approximately follows a power law .
such a power law distribution of wealth does not require sophisticated assumptions on the rationality of players , but it can be reproduced by a plethora of simple models ( see e.g. @xcite ) , in which it emerges as a typical behaviour i.e. as the behaviour that the system exhibits with very high probability within quite generic settings .
the debate on inequality has a long history , dating back at least to the work of kutznets @xcite on the u - shaped relationship of inequality on development .
much research has focused on the relation between inequality and growth ( see e.g. @xcite ) .
inequality has also been suggested to be positively correlated with a number of indicators of social disfunction , from infant mortality and health to social mobility and crime @xcite .
the subject has regained much interest recently , in view of the claim that levels of inequality have reached the same levels as in the beginning of the 20th century @xcite .
saez and zucman @xcite corroborate these findings , studying the evolution of the distribution of wealth in the us economy over the last century , and they find an increasing concentration of wealth in the hands of the 0.01% of the richest .
figure [ fig : data ] shows that the data in saez and zucman @xcite is consistent with a power law distribution @xmath0 , with a good agreement down to the 10% of the richest ( see caption ref .
@xcite reports the fraction @xmath1 of wealth in the hands of the @xmath2 and @xmath3 richest individuals . if the fraction of individuals with wealth larger than @xmath4 is proportional to @xmath5 , the wealth share @xmath1 in the hands of the richest @xmath6 percent of the population satisfies @xmath7 ( for @xmath8 ) .
hence @xmath9 is estimated from the slope of the relation between @xmath10 and @xmath11 , shown in the inset of fig .
[ fig : data ] ( left ) for a few representative years .
the error on @xmath9 is computed as three standard deviations in the least square fit . ] ) .
the exponent @xmath9 has been steadily decreasing in the last 30 years , reaching the same levels it attained at the beginning of the 20th century ( @xmath12 in 1917 ) .
of the wealth distribution ( left y - axis ) as a function of time .
both time series refer to the us .
the data on the money velocity is retrieved from @xcite , the data on the wealth distribution is taken from @xcite .
inset : relation between the fraction @xmath1 of wealth owned by the @xmath6 percent wealthiest individuals , and @xmath6 for the years 1980 , 1990 , 2000 and 2010 ( see footnote [ foot : beta fit ] ) . right : mzm velocity of money ( mzmv , central y - axis ) as a function of @xmath9 , for the same data .
liquidity , defined as the probability that a unit - money random exchange takes place , ( right y - axis ) as a function of @xmath9 , in the synthetic economy described by our model ( see eq .
[ def : pavg ] and figure [ fig : k10_ps_beta ] for details on the numerical simulations).,scaledwidth=100.0% ] rather than focusing on the determinants of inequality , here we focus on a specific consequence of inequality , i.e. on its impact on liquidity .
there are a number of reasons why this is relevant .
first of all , the efficiency of a market economy essentially resides on its ability to allow agents to exchange goods .
a direct measure of the efficiency is the number of possible exchanges that can be realised or equivalently the probability that a random exchange can take place .
this probability quantifies the `` fluidity '' of exchanges and we shall call it _ liquidity _ in what follows .
this is the primary measure of efficiency that we shall focus on .
secondly , liquidity , as intended here , has been the primary concern of monetary polices such as quantitative easing aimed at contrasting deflation and the slowing down of the economy , in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis . a quantitative measure of liquidity is provided by the _ velocity of money _
@xcite , measured as the ratio between the nominal gross domestic product and the money stock and it quantifies how often a unit of currency changes hand within the economy .
as figure [ fig : data ] shows , the velocity of money has been steadily declining in the last decades .
this paper suggests that this decline and the increasing level of inequality are not a coincidence .
rather the former is a consequence of the latter . without clear yardsticks marking levels of inequality that seriously hamper the functioning of an economy , the debate on inequality runs the risk of remaining at a qualitative or ideological level .
our main finding is that , in the simplified setting of our model , there is a sharp threshold beyond which inequality becomes intolerable .
more precisely , when the power law exponent of the wealth distribution approaches one from above , liquidity vanishes and the economy halts because all available ( liquid ) financial resources concentrate in the hands of few agents .
this provides a precise , quantitative measure of when inequality becomes too much .
our main goal in the present work is thus to isolate the relation between inequality and liquidity in the simplest possible model that allows us to draw sharp and robust conclusions .
specifically , the model is based on a simplified trading dynamics in which agents with a pareto distributed wealth randomly trade goods of different prices .
agents receive offers to buy goods and each such transaction is executed if it is compatible with the budget constraint of the buying agent .
this reflects a situation where , at those prices , agents are indifferent between all feasible allocations .
the model is in the spirit of random exchange models ( see e.g. @xcite ) , but our emphasis is not on whether the equilibrium can be reached or not .
in fact we show that the dynamics converges to a steady state , which corresponds to a maximally entropic state where all feasible allocations occur with the same probability .
rather we focus on the allocation of cash in the resulting stationary state and on the liquidity of the economy , defined as the fraction of attempted exchanges that are successful .
we remark that since the wealth distribution is fixed , the causal link between inequality and liquidity is clear in the simplified setting we consider . within our model ,
the freezing of the economy occurs because when inequality in the wealth distribution increases , financial resources ( i.e. cash ) concentrate more and more in the hands of few agents ( the wealthiest ) , leaving the vast majority without the financial means to trade .
this ultimately suppresses the probability of successful exchanges , i.e. liquidity ( see figure [ fig : data ] , right ) .
this paper is organised as follows : we start by describing the model and its basic characteristics in section [ sec : modeldescription ] , providing a quick overview of the main results and features of the model in section [ sec : main_features ] . in section
[ sec : solutionsnumerical_and_analytical ] we explain in more detail how these features can be understood by an approximated solution of the master equation governing the trading dynamics .
details on the analytical derivations and monte carlo simulations are thoroughly presented in the appendices .
we conclude with some remarks in section [ sec : con ] .
the model consists of @xmath13 agents , each with wealth @xmath14 with @xmath15 .
agents are allowed to trade among themselves @xmath16 objects .
each object @xmath17 has a price @xmath18 .
a given allocation of goods among the agents is described by an @xmath19 allocation matrix @xmath20 with entries @xmath21 if agent @xmath22 owns good @xmath23 and zero otherwise .
agents can only own baskets of goods that they can afford , i.e. whose total value does not exceed their wealth .
the wealth not invested in goods @xmath24 corresponds to the cash ( liquid capital ) that agent @xmath22 has available for trading .
the inequality @xmath25 for all @xmath22 indicate that lending is not allowed .
therefore the set of feasible allocations
those for which @xmath25 for all @xmath22 is only a small fraction of the @xmath26 conceivable allocation matrices @xmath20 .
starting from a feasible allocation matrix @xmath20 , we introduce a random trading dynamics in which a good @xmath23 is picked uniformly at random among all goods .
its owner then attempts to sell it to another agent @xmath22 drawn uniformly at random among the other agents . if agent @xmath22 has enough cash to buy the product @xmath23 , that is if @xmath27 , the transaction is successful and his / her cash decreases by @xmath18 while the cash of the seller increases by @xmath18 .
we do not allow objects to be divided .
notice that the total capital @xmath14 of agents does not change over time , so @xmath14 and the prices @xmath18 are parameters of the model .
the entries of the allocation matrix , and consequently the cash , are dynamical variables , which evolve over time according to this dynamics .
this model belongs to the class of zero - intelligent agent - based models , in the sense that agents do not try to maximize any utility function .
an interesting property of our dynamics is that the stochastic transition matrix @xmath28 is symmetric between any two feasible configurations @xmath20 and @xmath29 : @xmath30 .
we note that any feasible allocation @xmath20 can be reached from any other feasible allocation @xmath29 by a sequence of trades .
this implies that the dynamics satisfies the detailed balance condition , with a stationary distribution over the space of feasible configurations that is uniform : @xmath31 .
alternative choices of dynamics which also fulfil these conditions are explored in appendix [ app : rules_enumeration ] .
in particular , we focus on realisations where the wealth @xmath14 is drawn from a pareto distribution @xmath32 , for @xmath33 for each agent @xmath22 .
we let @xmath9 vary to explore different levels of inequality , and compare different economies in which the ratio between the total wealth @xmath34 and the total value of all objects @xmath35 is kept fixed .
we use @xmath36 so as to have feasible allocations .
we consider cases where the @xmath16 objects are divided into a small number @xmath37 of classes with @xmath38 objects per class ( @xmath39 ) ; objects belonging to class @xmath40 have the same price @xmath41 .
if @xmath42 is the number of object of class @xmath40 that agent @xmath22 owns , then takes the form @xmath43 .
the main result of this model is that the flow of goods among agents becomes more and more congested as inequality increases until it halts completely when the pareto exponent @xmath9 tends to one from above .
the origin of this behaviour can be understood in the simplest setting where @xmath44 , i.e. all goods have the same price @xmath45 ( we are going to omit the subscript @xmath46 in this case ) .
figure [ fig : picturesque_richpoor_transition_beta ] shows the capital composition @xmath47 for all agents in the stationary state , where @xmath48 is the average number of goods owned by agent @xmath22 .
the population of agents separates into two distinct classes : a _ class of cash - poor _ agents , who own an average number of goods that is very close to the maximum allowed by their wealth , and a _ cash - rich class _ , where agents have on average the same number of goods .
these two classes are separated by a sharp crossover region .
the inset of figure [ fig : picturesque_richpoor_transition_beta ] shows the cash distribution @xmath49 ( where @xmath50 represents the number of goods they are able to buy ) for some representative agents .
while cash - poor agents have a cash distribution peaked at @xmath51 , the wealthiest agents have cash in abundance .
agents , @xmath52 , @xmath53 and @xmath54 .
points @xmath47 denote the average composition of capital for different agents obtained in monte carlo simulations .
this is compared with the analytical solution obtained from the master equation ( green dashed line ) given by eq .
( [ eq : me_solution_1good ] ) .
the vertical dashed line at @xmath55 indicates the analytically predicted value of the crossover wealth that separates the two classes of agents .
insets : cash distributions @xmath56 of the indicated agents . ]
these two observations allow us to trace the origin of the arrest in the economy back to the shrinkage of the _ cash - rich class _ to a vanishingly small fraction of the population , as @xmath57 . as we ll see in the next section , when @xmath9 is smaller than @xmath58 the fraction of agents belonging to this class vanishes as @xmath59 . in this regime ,
not only the wealthiest few individuals own a finite fraction of the whole economy s wealth , as observed in ref .
@xcite , but they also drain all the financial resources in the economy .
these findings extend to more complex settings .
figure [ fig : k10_ps_beta ] illustrates this for an economy with @xmath60 classes of goods ( see figure caption for details ) and different values of @xmath9 . in order to visualise the freezing of the flow of goods we introduce the success rate of transactions for goods belonging to class @xmath40 , denoted as @xmath61 .
figure [ fig : k10_ps_beta ] shows that , as expected , for a fixed value of the pareto exponent @xmath9 the success rate increases as the goods become cheaper , as they are easier to trade .
secondly it shows that trades of all classes of goods halt as @xmath9 tends to unity , that is when wealth inequality becomes too large , independently of their price . [ cols="^,^ " , ] the decrease of @xmath61 when inequality increases ( i.e. as @xmath9 decreases ) is a consequence of the concentration of cash in the hands of the wealthiest agents .
this can be observed in the right panel of figure [ fig : k10_ps_beta ] , which shows the average cash of agents with a given wealth , for different values of @xmath9 .
the freezing of the economy when @xmath9 decreases occurs because fewer and fewer agents can dispose of enough cash ( i.e. have @xmath62 ) to buy the different goods ( prices @xmath41 correspond to the dashed lines ) .
note finally that @xmath61 quantifies liquidity in terms of goods . in order to have an equivalent measure in terms of cash that can be compared to the velocity of money , we average @xmath63 over all goods @xmath64 this quantifies the frequency with which a unit of cash changes hand in our model economy , as a result of a successful transaction .
it s behaviour as a function of @xmath9 for the same parameters of the economy in figure [ fig : k10_ps_beta ] is shown in the right panel of figure [ fig : data ] .
in order to shed light on the findings described above , in this section we describe how to derive them within an analytic approach .
we start by dealing with the simpler case where all the goods in the system have the same price @xmath65 , @xmath66 ( i.e. @xmath44 ) . a formal approach to this problem consists in writing the complete master equation that describes the evolution of the probability @xmath67 to find the economy in a state where each agent @xmath68 has a definite number @xmath69 of goods .
taking the sum over all values of @xmath70 for @xmath71 , one can derive the master equation for a single agent with wealth @xmath14 .
the corresponding marginal distribution @xmath72 in the stationary state can be derived from the detailed balance condition @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the maximum number of goods which agent @xmath22 can buy with wealth @xmath14 and @xmath75 is the probability that a transaction where agent @xmath22 sells one good ( i.e. @xmath76 ) is successful .
( [ eq : mastereq3_1good_1guy ] ) says that , in the stationary state , the probability that agent @xmath22 has @xmath77 objects and buys a new object is equal to the probability to find agent @xmath22 with @xmath78 objects , selling successfully one of them .
the factor @xmath79 enforces the condition that agent @xmath22 can afford at most @xmath80 goods and it implies that @xmath81 for @xmath82 .
exchanges are successful if the buyer @xmath83 does not already have a saturated budget @xmath84 . so the probability @xmath75 is also given by @xmath85 where the last relation holds because when @xmath86 the dependence on @xmath77 becomes negligible .
this is important , because it implies that for @xmath13 large the variables @xmath69 can be considered as independent , i.e. @xmath87 , and the problem can be reduced to that of computing the marginals @xmath88 self - consistently . the solution of eq .
( [ eq : mastereq3_1good_1guy ] ) can be written as a truncated poissonian with parameter @xmath89 @xmath90 \theta\left(m_i - z \right ) \label{eq : me_solution_1good}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath91 is a normalization factor that can be fixed by @xmath92 .
finally , the value of @xmath75 or equivalently of @xmath93 can be found self - consistently , by solving eq .
( [ eq : ps_1guy ] ) .
notice that the most likely value of @xmath77 for an agent with @xmath94 is given by @xmath95 this provides a natural distinction between cash - poor agents those with @xmath96 that often can not afford to buy further objects , and cash - rich ones those with @xmath97 who typically have enough cash to buy further objects .
this separation into two classes of agents was already pointed out in figure [ fig : picturesque_richpoor_transition_beta ] . in terms of wealth ,
the poor are defined as those with @xmath98 whereas the rich ones have @xmath99 , where the threshold wealth is given by @xmath100 .
notice that when @xmath101 , a condition that occurs when the economy is nearly frozen ( @xmath102 ) , the distribution @xmath72 is sharply peaked around @xmath103 so that its average is @xmath104 .
then the separation between the two classes becomes rather sharp , as in figure [ fig : picturesque_richpoor_transition_beta ] . in this regime
, we can also derive an estimate of @xmath75 in the limit @xmath105 , for @xmath8 .
indeed , we have @xmath106 for @xmath107 , so a rough estimate of @xmath108 is given by @xmath109 .
taking the average over agents , as in eq .
( [ eq : ps_1guy ] ) , and assuming a distribution density of wealth @xmath110 for @xmath111 and @xmath112 for @xmath113 , one finds ( see appendix [ app : otherderivationofps_using_balanceinthemastereqfashion ] ) @xmath114^{1/(1 - \beta ) } , \label{eq : c1_correct } \\ p^{(\text{suc } ) } & = \frac{m}{n \lambda } \simeq \frac{\pi}{c } \frac{{\mathbb{e}\left [ c \right ] } } { c^{(1)}}. \label{eq : ps_correct}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath115 } = \beta/(\beta-1)$ ] is the expected value of the wealth .
notice that @xmath115 } $ ] diverges as @xmath116 , but also that within this approximation the threshold wealth @xmath117 diverges much faster , with an essential singularity .
more precisely , we note that @xmath118 , so that @xmath119 is a number smaller than 1 ( yet positive ) . from eq .
( [ eq : c1_correct ] ) , we have @xmath120 .
therefore the liquidity @xmath75 vanishes as @xmath116 .
for finite @xmath13 , this approximation breaks down when @xmath9 gets too close to or smaller than one .
also , @xmath115 } $ ] is ill - defined and in eq .
( [ eq : ps_correct ] ) it should be replaced with @xmath121 , which strongly fluctuates between realizations and depends on @xmath13 .
an estimate of @xmath75 for finite @xmath13 and @xmath122 can be obtained by observing that the wealth @xmath117 marking the separation between the two classes can not be larger than the wealth @xmath123 of the wealthiest agent . by extreme value theory ,
the latter is given by @xmath124 , with @xmath125 .
therefore the solution is characterised by @xmath126 .
furthermore , for @xmath122 the average wealth is dominated by the wealthiest few , i.e. @xmath127 and therefore @xmath128 .
in other words , in this limit the cash - rich class is composed of a finite number of agents , who hold almost all the cash of the economy .
figure [ fig : summary_section_one_object ] ( left ) shows that the rough analytical estimate of eq .
( [ eq : ps_correct ] ) is in good agreement with monte carlo simulations .
the analysis carries forward to the general case in which @xmath37 classes of goods are considered , starting from the full master equation for the joint probability of the ownership vectors @xmath129 for all agents @xmath68 . for the same reasons as before
, the problem can be reduced to that of computing the marginal distribution @xmath130 of a single agent .
the main complication is that the maximum number @xmath131 of goods of class @xmath40 that agent @xmath22 can get now depends on how many of the other goods agent @xmath22 owns , i.e. @xmath132 , where @xmath133 .
the detailed balance condition @xmath134 again yields the stationary state distribution ( for @xmath86 ) . on the left we have the probability that one of the @xmath135 objects of type @xmath40 of agent @xmath22 is picked for a successful sale ( here @xmath136 is the vector with all zero components and with a @xmath137 component equal to one , and
@xmath61 is the probability that a sale of an object of type @xmath40 is successful ) .
this must balance the probability ( on the r.h.s . )
that agent @xmath22 is selected as the buyer of an object of type @xmath40 , which requires that agent @xmath22 has less than @xmath138 objects of type @xmath40 , for the transaction to occur ( here @xmath139 is the probability that an object of type @xmath40 is picked at random , and @xmath140 is the probability that agent @xmath22 is selected as the buyer ) .
it can easily be checked that the solution to this set of equations is given by a product of poisson laws with parameters @xmath141 , with the constraint eq .
( [ eq:1 ] ) , @xmath142 \theta\left(c_i - \sum_k^{k } z_k \pi_{(k)}\right)\ , , \label{eq : me_solution_2goods}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath91 a normalization factor obeying @xmath143 . here
the @xmath144 corresponds to the acceptance rates of transactions of goods of class @xmath40 and are given by @xmath145 as in the case with @xmath146 , the values of the @xmath61 need to be found self - consistently , which can be complicated when @xmath37 and @xmath16 are large . when the total number of objects per agent is large for any class @xmath40 , we expect that @xmath147 , and then the values of @xmath42 are close to their expected values .
this implies that the population of agents splits into @xmath37 classes , where agents with wealth @xmath148 $ ] have their budget saturated with goods of class @xmath149 and can not afford more expensive objects ( here @xmath150 , @xmath151 and @xmath152 ) .
an estimate for the thresholds @xmath153 can be derived following the same arguments as for @xmath44 , by observing that when analysing the dynamics of goods of type @xmath40 , all agents in class @xmath154 are effectively frozen and can be neglected . combining this with the conservation of the total number of objects of each kind , we obtain a recurrence relation for @xmath153 .
we refer the interested reader to the appendix [ app : recurrence ] for details on the derivation , and report here the result in the case of goods with @xmath155 , @xmath156 large enough , with @xmath8 and in the limit @xmath157 : @xmath158 ^{\frac{1}{1-\beta } } , \label{eq : ps_and_ck_generalcaseanymathcalm1 } \\
p_k^{(\text{suc } ) } & = \frac{m_k}{n \lambda_k } \simeq \frac{\pi}{k c } \frac{{\mathbb{e}\left [ c \right ] } } { c^{(k)}}. \label{eq : ps_and_ck_generalcaseanymathcalm2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the limit @xmath116 of large inequality , close inspection . ] of eq .
( [ eq : ps_and_ck_generalcaseanymathcalm1 ] ) shows that @xmath159 , which implies that all agents become cash - starved except for the wealthiest few . since @xmath160 } /c^{(k)}$ ]
, this implies that all markets freeze : @xmath161 .
the arrest of the flow of goods appears to be extremely robust against all choices of the parameter @xmath41 , as @xmath162 is an upper bound for the other success rates of transactions @xmath61 .
these conclusions are fully consistent with the results of extensive numerical simulations ( see figure [ fig : summary_section_one_object ] in appendix [ app : derivationofps ] ) .
in this paper we have introduced a zero - intelligence trading dynamics in which agents have a pareto distributed wealth and randomly trade goods with different prices .
we have shown that this dynamics leads to a uniform distribution in the space of the allocations that are compatible with the budget constraints .
we have also shown that when the inequality in the distribution of wealth increases , the economy converges to an equilibrium where typically ( i.e. with probability very close to one ) the less wealthy agents have less and less cash available , as their budget becomes saturated by objects of the cheapest type . at the same time
this class of cash - starved agents takes up a larger and larger fraction of the economy , thereby leading to a complete halt of the economy when the distribution of wealth becomes so broad that its expected average diverges ( i.e. when @xmath57 ) . in these cases , a finite number of the wealthiest agents own almost all the cash of the economy .
the model presented in this paper is intentionally simple , so as to highlight a simple , robust and quantifiable link between inequality and liquidity .
in particular , the model neglects important aspects such as _ i ) _ agents incentives and preferential trading , _ ii ) _ endogenous price dynamics and _ iii ) _ credit .
it is worth discussing each of these issues in order to address whether the inclusion of some of these factors would revert our finding that inequality and liquidity are negatively related .
first , our model assumes that all exchanges that are compatible with budget constraints will take place , but in more realistic setting only exchanges that increase each party s utility should take place . yet
if the economy freezes in the case where agents would accept all exchanges that are compatible with their budget , it should also freeze when only a subset of these exchanges are feasible .
also the model assumes that all agents trade with the same frequency whereas one might expect that rich agents trade more frequently than poorer ones .
could liquidity be restored if trading patterns exhibit some level of homophily , with rich people trading more often and preferentially with rich people ?
first we note that both these effects are already present in our simple setting .
agents with higher wealth are selected more frequently as sellers as they own a larger share of the objects . in spite of
the fact that buyers are chosen at random , successful trades occur more frequently when the buyer is wealthy .
so , in the trades actually observed the wealthier do trade more frequently than the less wealthy , and preferentially with other wealthy agents .
furthermore , if agents are allowed to trade only with agents having a similar wealth ( e.g. with the @xmath163 agents immediately wealthier or less wealthy ) it is easy to show that detailed balance still holds with the same uniform distribution on allocations . as long as all the states are accessible , the stationary probability distribution remains the same changes , in particular for goods more expensive than @xmath164 , the seller is typically cash - rich and thus its neighbours are too .
this can induce to have a liquidity of expensive goods higher than that of cheaper ones .
however in the limit @xmath57 , it is still true that cash concentrates in the hands of a vanishing fraction of agents , and there is still a freeze of the economy . ] .
therefore , our conclusions are robust with respect to a wide range of changes in our basic setting that would account for more realistic trading patterns .
secondly , it is reasonable to expect that prices will adjust
i.e. deflate as a result of a diminished demand caused by the lack of liquidity . within our model ,
the inclusion of price adjustment , occurring on a slower time - scale than trading activity , would reduce the ratio @xmath165 ( between total value of goods and total wealth ) , but it would also change the wealth distribution .
since the freezing phase transition occurs irrespective of the ratio @xmath165 , the first effect , though it might alleviate the problem , would not change our main conclusion .
the second would make it more compelling , because cash would not depreciate as prices do , so deflation would leave wealthy agents who hold most of the cash even richer compared to the cash deprived agents , that would suffer the most from deflation .
so while price adjustment apparently increases liquidity , this may promote further inequality , that would curtail liquidity further .
finally , can the liquidity freeze be avoided by allowing agents to borrow ?
access to credit , we believe , will hardly improve the situation .
] , in line with the results of ref .
@xcite and for similar reasons .
credit may mitigate illiquidity in the short term , but cash deprived agents should borrow from wealthier ones . with positive interest rates , this would make inequality even larger in the long run . so credit is likely to make things worse , in line with the arguments in @xcite .
therefore , even though the model presented here can be enriched in many ways , we do nt see a way in which the relation between inequality and liquidity could be reversed .
corroborating the present model with empirical data goes beyond the scope of the present paper , yet we remark that our findings are consistent with the recent economic trends , as shown in figure [ fig : data ] . for example
, it is worth observing that , alongside with increasing levels of inequality , trade has slowed down after the 2008 crisis .
more generally , avoiding deflation -or promoting inflation- has been a major target of monetary policies after 2008 , which one could take as an indirect evidence of the slowing down of the economy .
furthermore , the fact that inequality hampers liquidity and hence promotes demand for credit suggests that the boom in credit market before 2008 and the increasing levels of inequality might not have been a coincidence .
an interesting side note is that the concentration of capital in the top agents goes hand in hand with a flow of cash to the top .
indeed , in our model an injection of extra capital in the lower part of the wealth pyramid the so - called _ helicopter money _ policy is necessarily followed by a flow of this extra cash to the top , via many intermediate agents , thus generating many transactions on the way . this _ trickle up _
dynamics should be contrasted with the usual idea of the _ trickle down _ policy , which advocates injections of money to the top in order to boost investment . in this respect , it is tempting to relate our findings to the recent debate on quantitative easing measures , and in particular to the proposal that the ( european ) central bank should finance households ( or small businesses ) rather than financial institutions in order to stimulate the economy and raise inflation @xcite .
clearly , our results support the helicopter money policy , because injecting cash at the top does not disengages the economy from a liquidity stall .
extending our minimal model to take into account the endogenous dynamics of the wealth distribution and of prices , accounting for investment and credit , is an interesting avenue of future research , for which the present work sets the stage . in particular
, this could shed light on understanding the conditions under which the positive feedback between returns on investment and inequality , that lies at the very core of the dynamics which has produced ever increasing levels of inequality according to @xcite , sets in .
jpj thanks fapesp process number 2014/16045 - 6 for the financial support and the abdus salam ictp for the hospitality .
ipc thanks the abdus salam ictp for the hospitality and also thanks javier toledo marn for the work done during some stages of the research presented here .
mm thanks arnab chatterjee for discussions at an earlier stage of this project and davide fiaschi for interesting discussions and comments .
the detailed balance condition is a useful criterium to find the stationary state in stochastic processes . given a dynamics formulated in terms of the transition rates
@xmath166 between configurations @xmath167 and @xmath168 , if one can find a measure @xmath169 over configurations that satisfies the detailed balance condition @xmath170 and if the system is ergodic and @xmath168 there is a path of a finite number of intermediate configurations @xmath171 with non - zero rate @xmath172 , ] , then @xmath173 is the unique stationary distribution .
the detailed balance property corresponds to a local balance of the flux between any pair of configurations .
the simplest way to have detailed balance property is to use symmetrical transfer rates : @xmath174 . in that case ,
one automatically gets a uniform distribution over the space of configurations : @xmath175 .
the flux @xmath176 is then also uniform .
it is clear that the dynamics defined in this paper has this property , because for any two configurations that differs by the ownership of one object , the rate of the process linking them is equal to @xmath177 in both directions . what about the rules providing detailed balance , but without symmetry of the rates ? in that case
, one would need to explicitly find the probability density over the configurations . since the resulting density would be non - uniform
, it would be more difficult to link dynamical observables ( rate of money transfer , etc . ) to static variables ( number of neighbouring configuration to a given configuration ) .
we do not explore these cases .
what are the rules that give symmetrical transfer rates ?
we define time such that at each time step , a single object is picked and there is a single attempt at selling it to another agent ( not the current owner ) . in this paper
, we consider the simplest case where objects are picked independently of their price .
this still leaves us several choices .
there are @xmath178 rules which yield symmeteric rates ( and thus respect detailed balance ) .
the generic case is the following , with @xmath179 : * rule @xmath180 : the integer @xmath181 is fixed .
select @xmath181 distinct agents at random .
select one object among the set of all the objects they ( collectively ) own .
this object will be sold ( if possible ) by the owner to a randomly selected agent among the @xmath182 remaining agents in the set of selected agents . * rule @xmath183 : select two distinct agents at random
. select one object among the set of all the objects they ( collectively ) own .
this object is sold ( if possible ) by the owner to the other agent .
* rule @xmath184 : pick an object at random .
the owner is then the seller .
select a buyer at random amongst the @xmath178 remaining agents .
note that the rule @xmath185 does not make sense , so that there are indeed @xmath178 different rules . in this paper
, we always use the rule @xmath184 , i.e. simply pick the object at random . as all these rules produce an ergodic dynamics , and since the probability distribution of configurations is the same for all rules ( it is @xmath186 ) , it does not matter at all which of these dynamical rules we picked .
we do not claim that these rules are the only ones providing symmetric rates , or even that this property is necessary for interesting dynamics .
we simply point out that the detail of the choice of the dynamical rule is not crucial , as long as we as we have a simple zero - intelligent dynamics which generates symmetric transition rates .
we now give a few examples of rules that are either identical to those above , or do not yield symmetrical probabilities of transfer : * select one seller among the n agents by using weighted probabilities : each agent @xmath22 is affected a weight @xmath187 where @xmath187 is the number of objects owned by agent @xmath22 . pick an object from this agent at random .
it will be sold to an agent picked uniformly among the @xmath178 remaining agents .
this rule is actually exactly the rule @xmath184 .
* the following rule does not yield symmetrical probabilities of transfer : select a buyer at random . select any object not already owned by him at random .
the owner of that object sells it to the buyer .
the problem is that if the buyer has more objects than the seller , the inverse transaction has smaller probability to occur than the direct one .
* the following rule very clearly breaks symmetry : select one seller at random . select an object in his set at random .
select a buyer among the @xmath178 remaining agents at random .
naively , this rule could be named @xmath188 , but it clearly breaks symmetry .
( the transaction from a hoarder to an agent with few objects has much smaller probability to occur than the inverse transaction . ) [ [ app : otherderivationofps_using_balanceinthemastereqfashion ] ] derivation of @xmath75 and @xmath117 in the large @xmath93 limit for 1 type of good . ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ as discussed in the main text , we can compute @xmath75 using @xmath190 approximating the probability to be on a threshold @xmath191 by @xmath192 the first case can be understood by noting that @xmath193 where the approximation is valid in the limit @xmath194 . assuming this approximation to be valid in all the range @xmath195 is clearly a bad assumption for all agents with @xmath80 close to @xmath93 .
however the wealth is power law distributed , and so the weight of agents with @xmath196 is negligible in the sum over all agents , eq . ( [ eq : app_ps_analytic0 ] ) .
the accuracy of this approximation increases when the exponent of the power law @xmath9 decreases . when @xmath199 this expression can be expressed to be realization - independent , using @xmath200 } } { c^{(1)}},\ ] ] where @xmath115 } = \beta/ ( \beta - 1)$ ] is the expected value of the wealth per agent .
we also use the fact that we fill in the system a number @xmath16 of goods in such a way to have a fixed ratio @xmath201 . performing the integral on the r.h.s of eq .
( [ eq : app_ps_analytic1 ] ) gives an equation for @xmath117 : @xmath202 } } { c^{(1 ) } } = { c^{(1)}}^{-\beta } \left ( \frac{1}{1-\beta }
\right ) - \frac{\beta}{1 - \beta } \frac{1}{c^{(1)}},\ ] ] that simplifies into : @xmath203^{1/(1 - \beta)}.\ ] ] [ [ app : recurrence ] ] derivation of @xmath144 and @xmath153 in the large @xmath93 limit for several types of good .
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ an analytic derivation for the @xmath144 and @xmath153 can be obtained also for the cases of several goods , but only in the limit in which prices are well separated ( i.e. @xmath204 ) and the total values of good of any class is approximately constant ( we use @xmath205 ) . in this limit
we expect to find a sharp separation of the population of agents into classes .
this is because @xmath206 implies that the market is flooded with objects of the class @xmath58 , which constantly change hands and essentially follow the laws found in the single type of object case .
on top of this dense gas of objects of class @xmath58 , we can consider objects of class @xmath207 as a perturbation ( they are picked @xmath208 times less often ! ) . on the time scale of the dynamics of objects of type @xmath207 ,
the distribution of cash is such that all agents with a wealth less than @xmath209 have their budget saturated by objects of type @xmath58 and typically do not have enough cash to buy objects of type @xmath207 nor more expensive ones .
likewise , there is a class of agents with @xmath210 that will manage to afford goods of types @xmath58 and @xmath207 , but will hardly ever hold goods more expensive that @xmath211 . in brief
, the economy is segmented into @xmath37 classes , with class @xmath40 composed of all agents with @xmath212 who can afford objects of class up to @xmath40 , but who are excluded from markets for more expensive goods , because they rarely have enough cash to buy goods more expensive than @xmath41 .
this structure into classes can be read off from figure [ fig : k10_ps_beta ] , where we present the average cash of agents , given their cash in a specific case ( see caption ) .
the horizontal lines denote the prices @xmath41 of the different objects , and the intersections with the horizontal lines define the thresholds @xmath153 .
agents that have @xmath14 just above @xmath153 are cash - filled in terms of object of class @xmath40 , but are cash - starved in terms of objects @xmath213 .
the liquidities @xmath75 can be given by the following expression @xmath214 according to the previous discussion of segmentation of the system into @xmath37 classes , and using the same approximation for this threshold probability discussed in the case of 1 type of good , we assume @xmath215 then @xmath216 in this case now we have @xmath217 } } { c^{(k)}}\ ] ] with similar calculations to the ones showed for the previous case , one can easily get to the recurrence relation : @xmath218 ^{\frac{1}{1-\beta}}.\ ] ] iterating , we explicit this into : @xmath219 ^{\frac{1}{1-\beta}},\ ] ] a comparison between the analytical estimate and numerical simulations , presented in figure [ fig : summary_section_one_object ] , shows that this approximation provides an accurate description of the collective behaviour of the model . as a function of the pareto exponent @xmath9 .
comparison between numerical simulations and analytical estimates for one class of goods ( left panel ) and two classes of goods ( right panel ) .
the blue solid circles are the result of monte carlo simulations performed for @xmath220 agents and averaged over 5 realizations . here
the error bars indicate the min and max value of @xmath189 over all realizations ( we used the `` adjusted pareto '' law for the right panel , see appendix [ app : adjusted_pareto_capital_distribution ] ) .
the red lines are the analytic estimates according to eq .
( [ eq : ps_correct ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : ps_and_ck_generalcaseanymathcalm1 ] ) for left and right panels , respectively .
the green crossed lines correspond to numerically ( see appendix [ app : iterativemethoddetailexplained ] ) solving the analytical solution for a population composed of @xmath221 ( kind of ) agents .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] as a function of the pareto exponent @xmath9 .
comparison between numerical simulations and analytical estimates for one class of goods ( left panel ) and two classes of goods ( right panel ) .
the blue solid circles are the result of monte carlo simulations performed for @xmath220 agents and averaged over 5 realizations . here
the error bars indicate the min and max value of @xmath189 over all realizations ( we used the `` adjusted pareto '' law for the right panel , see appendix [ app : adjusted_pareto_capital_distribution ] ) .
the red lines are the analytic estimates according to eq .
( [ eq : ps_correct ] ) and eq .
( [ eq : ps_and_ck_generalcaseanymathcalm1 ] ) for left and right panels , respectively .
the green crossed lines correspond to numerically ( see appendix [ app : iterativemethoddetailexplained ] ) solving the analytical solution for a population composed of @xmath221 ( kind of ) agents .
, title="fig:",scaledwidth=50.0% ] see also in fig .
[ fig : gini_intro ] how the liquidity over - concentrates ( with respect to capital concentration ) .
there , we compare the liquid and capital concentrations , measured via their gini coefficients , for various values of @xmath9 in the system of fig .
[ fig : k10_ps_beta ] ( @xmath222 ) . of the cash distribution ( liquid capital ) in the stationary state of the model as a function of the gini @xmath223 of the wealth distribution .
the dashed line indicates proportionality between cash and wealth , in which case the inequality in both is exactly the same .
the wealth follows a pareto distribution with exponent @xmath9 that tunes the degree of inequality ( the higher is @xmath9 , the more egalitarian the distribution).,width=302 ] in particular , note that the limit @xmath224 is singular , as @xmath225 reaches one around @xmath226 , with smaller @xmath9 yielding also @xmath227 .
this is an alternative way to see how the concentration of capital generates an over - concentration of liquidities .
we perform our monte carlo simulations of the trading market for @xmath220 agents .
prices generally start from @xmath164 and increase by a factor @xmath228 between each good class .
the minimal wealth is @xmath229 .
the ratio @xmath230 is fixed as indicated in captions , and most importantly is kept constant between different realizations .
as the total wealth fluctuates , so does the total number of goods .
there are no peculiar difficulties with the numerical method ( apart from the large fluctuations in the average wealth , addressed below ) .
the only thing one has to be careful with is to ensure that the stationary state has been reached , i.e. that all observables have a stationary value , an indication that the ( peculiar ) initial condition has been completely forgotten .
the codes for this monte carlo simulation are available online @xcite . for @xmath231 we have predictions for the @xmath232 regime , in which the average wealth is particularly fluctuating from realization to realization .
because the value of @xmath115 } $ ] controls the number @xmath16 of objects introduced in the market , this in turns produces large fluctuations in the values of the @xmath189 which can make it difficult to have robust results .
more importantly , the typical value of the ( empirical ) average wealth @xmath233 is usually quite different from its expectation value @xmath115 } $ ] . this effect is well known and well documented for power laws , but we present a concrete example of it in figure [ fig : nonconvergencelargen ] to emphasize its intensity . for the sample size that is typically manageable in our simulations ,
i.e. @xmath220 , the typical value for the average value of the wealth ( using e.g. @xmath226 ) is of the order of the half of its expected value : @xmath234 } /2 $ ] .
this indicates that @xmath220 is ( by far ) an insufficient size to correctly sample a power - law with exponent @xmath226 . of power laws depending on their sample size @xmath13
( from top to bottom , @xmath235 ) for 1000 realizations each ( @xmath236 ) , using an exponent @xmath226 .
the dashed line indicates the expectation value @xmath115 } = c_{\min } \beta/(\beta-1)$ ] .
we see that even for huge samples , the typical @xmath237 s are significantly smaller than the expected @xmath115 } $ ] .
[ fig : nonconvergencelargen ] , scaledwidth=50.0% ] to circumvent this problem , we introduce the `` adjusted '' pareto distribution .
the idea is to draw numbers from a power law distribution as usual , and then to adjust the value of a few of them so that the empirical average matches the expected one .
the algorithm is the following : start from a true random pareto distribution . *
if @xmath238 } $ ] , we select an agent at random and increase its wealth until we have exactly @xmath239 } $ ] .
* if @xmath240 } $ ] , we select the wealthiest agent and decrease its wealth until we have exactly @xmath239 } $ ] , or until its wealth becomes @xmath241 .
if we reach the latter case ( it is quite unlikely ) , then we perform the same operation on the second - wealthiest agent , and so on until @xmath239 } $ ] .
as can be seen in figure [ fig : nonconvergencelargen ] , the most common case is the first one .
the corresponding adjustment is equivalent to re - drawing the wealth of a single agent until it is such that @xmath239 } $ ] .
this is a weak deviation from a true pareto distribution .
the second case is more rare , and mostly consists also in a correction on the wealth of a single agent .
agents , green crosses are an example of staircase - like distribution ( a useful approximation of a pareto law that we use elsewhere ) and the black dashed line is the law itself ( blue dots converge to it in the @xmath105 limit ) . left : probability distribution , with shifts up and down for clarity ( i.e. , it is not normalized ) right : wealth @xmath14 of each agent , sorted by the rank @xmath22 .
note that the wealth of the wealthiest agents ( low rank ) fluctuates a lot from realization to realization . ]
this change in the wealth distribution is very efficient at reducing the variability between different realizations of the same @xmath9 value .
furthermore it ensures that we can compare our numerical results at finite @xmath13 with the predictions that implicitly assume @xmath242 , since we now have @xmath239 } $ ] .
it is quite crucial to use this `` adjusted '' pareto law for the small @xmath9 s ( i.e. for @xmath243 ) .
see figure [ fig : various_capital_distro ] to have an idea of what this modified distribution means : the only changes in the two sample shown would be in the values of the wealthiest agent .
here we describe the algorithm used to converge to a self - consistent set of values for @xmath245 , i.e. solving eq .
( [ eq : ps_kobjs ] ) for @xmath246 ( or more simply eq .
( [ eq : ps_1guy ] ) in the case of a single type of goods ) .
it can be generalized straightforwardly to @xmath247 , although it may become numerically extremely expensive ( see also our code , @xcite ) .
the results ( green crosses ) presented in figure [ fig : summary_section_one_object ] were obtained using the method described here . for each agent
there is a constant @xmath248 to be determined self - consistently .
this presents a technical difficulty , as for a true power - law distribution , each agent gets a different wealth and thus the number of constants to compute is @xmath13 . a way to tackle
this difficulty is to consider a staircase - like distribution of wealth , where agents are distributed in groups with homogeneous wealth @xmath249 and where the number of agents per group is @xmath250 , so that individual agents approximately follow a power law with exponent @xmath9 .
see figure [ fig : various_capital_distro ] ( green crosses ) to have an idea of what this modified distribution means concretely .
this kind of staircase distribution is not a true power - law , in particular because its maximum is always deterministic and finite .
however , as we now have @xmath251 , we can numerically solve the @xmath252 equations and thus find the exact value of @xmath75 .
of course , the value of @xmath75 found in this way perfectly matches with monte carlo results if and only if we use the exact same distribution of wealth and goods in the simulation .
this is not surprising at all , and merely validates our iterative scheme .
however , we note that staircase - like wealth distributions turn out to be very good approximations of true power laws , when the wealth levels @xmath249 are sufficiently refined and the number of classes @xmath253 sufficiently large . in particular , using @xmath254 with a base @xmath255
, it can be seen that for large enough @xmath253 , the average wealth @xmath233 converges to a value very close to the expected one @xmath115 } $ ] ( and no longer depends on @xmath253 ) . for large @xmath9 , typically @xmath256
, convergence is reached rather fast ( @xmath257 is enough ) , and the iterative method can be used ( see for instance figure [ fig : staircase_convergence_ok]a ) . under these conditions ,
the observables ( e.g. @xmath75 ) have the same values for a true power law and the corresponding staircase - distribution ( see figure [ fig : staircase_convergence_ps]b ) .
however for smaller values of @xmath9 , convergence is very slow and one needs at least @xmath258 to converge ( see figure [ fig : staircase_convergence_not_working_ok]c ) .
the maximum wealth is then very large , which makes the iterative method useless for practical purposes ( overflow errors arise , and the number of terms in the sums to be computed explodes exponentially , along with the computational cost ) . dependence on @xmath253 for a staircase distribution , using @xmath259 and @xmath260 .
black dots : average computed ( exactly ) for the staircase distribution . dashed
black : expectation value for the corresponding true power law .
convergence is reached as soon as @xmath261 .
[ fig : staircase_convergence_ok ] + ( b ) : dependence on @xmath253 of the @xmath262 computed from the iterative method , using a staircase - like distribution of wealth ( green crosses ) .
as soon as @xmath263 , it approaches its `` true '' value , i.e. the value obtained for a true power - law with exponent @xmath259 ( dashed blue line ) .
we used @xmath260 .
[ fig : staircase_convergence_ps ] + ( c ) : average wealth @xmath264 dependence on @xmath253 for a staircase distribution , using @xmath226 and @xmath260 .
black dots : average computed ( exactly ) for the staircase distribution . dashed black : expectation value for the corresponding true power law .
it takes very large @xmath253 to converge .
[ fig : staircase_convergence_not_working_ok ] ] see also our mathematica code , @xcite .
the idea is the following .
we define `` old '' and `` new '' values for each of the variables @xmath265 and for @xmath266 . for @xmath267 , we define only the `` current '' values , and have `` target '' values .
we start with an initial guess , e.g. that all the @xmath268 and @xmath269 ( which is not consistent , of course ) .
then we use the new values of the @xmath75 to compute the new normalization factors .
these are used to compute the `` target '' @xmath75 , i.e. to know if the @xmath75 should be increased or decreased .
new values of @xmath75 are again used to recompute the normalizations , and so forth . to be more precise , here
is the pseudo code we used .
we start with some guess values for the @xmath75 , e.g. @xmath270 .
let the variables @xmath271 be set to @xmath272 .
the function @xmath273 uses @xmath274 as normalization factor , and the current values of the @xmath75 ( since the term @xmath275 is ubiquitous in the expression of @xmath276 ) .
* compute the new @xmath265 using the @xmath189 : @xmath277 * compute @xmath278 . *
set @xmath279 .
* compute the target values of the @xmath75 : @xmath280\end{aligned}\ ] ] and symmetrically for @xmath281 . * for each @xmath40 ,
compute @xmath282 $ ] . * for each @xmath40 , if @xmath283 , set @xmath284 to @xmath285 .
* for each @xmath40 , set @xmath189 to @xmath286 . *
if the @xmath75 obtained is smaller than @xmath51 , set it to @xmath287 and divide @xmath284 by @xmath207 . *
if the @xmath75 obtained is larger than @xmath58 , set it to @xmath58 . *
loop until all the @xmath284 are smaller than the predefined allowed error and/or the @xmath288 is close enough to @xmath58 .
typically , the @xmath253 that is sufficient to achieve a reasonable approximated convergence can be estimated by taking a quick look at how much the @xmath289 is close to the @xmath115 } $ ] . running this algorithm at different values of @xmath253 , one can directly probe the convergence : when increasing @xmath253 does not change the values of the @xmath75 more than the errorbar allowed , then one considers the method to have converged . in practice , it is fairly fast to converge for large @xmath9 s , and the number of operations exponentially explodes as @xmath9 is decreased towards @xmath58 . | inequality and its consequences are the subject of intense recent debate . using a simplified model of the economy , we address the relation between inequality and liquidity , the latter understood as the frequency of economic exchanges . assuming a pareto distribution of wealth for the agents , that is consistent with empirical findings
, we find an inverse relation between wealth inequality and overall liquidity .
we show that an increase in the inequality of wealth results in an even sharper concentration of the liquid financial resources .
this leads to a congestion of the flow of goods and the arrest of the economy when the pareto exponent reaches one . |
in @xcite , jonathan smith introduced a general commutator theory for algebras belonging to congruence permutable varieties that generalized the commutator theory for groups . in @xcite , joachim hagemann and christian hermann
extend the domain of applicability of the commutator to congruence modular varieties .
these developments precipitated the discovery of new structure theorems for algebras in congruence modular varieties , see for instance @xcite and @xcite . in @xcite ,
heinz peter gumm presents the commutator from a geometrical perspective by drawing an analogy between congruence classes and affine subspaces of a vector space . in @xcite , ralph freese and ralph mckenzie define the commutator by a term condition and prove its equivalence to the definition of hagemann and hermann .
emil kiss showed in @xcite that the binary commutator can also be defined by a two term condition in congruence modular varieties .
the strength of a two term commutator is that symmetry is inherent and that a two - term condition is often more useful . in @xcite ,
andrei bulatov defines a commutator of any arity greater than equal to @xmath0 by generalizing the term condition given in @xcite .
this higher commutator is the same as the binary commutator when the arity is taken to be @xmath0 . in @xcite , erhard aichinger and neboja mudrinski
develop several properties of these higher commutators for congruence permutable varieties . in @xcite
, jakub opral provides a relational description for the higher commutator that is the analogue of the approach taken by hagemann and hermann for the binary commutator . in this article
we extend the domain of applicability of higher commutators from congruence permutatable varieties to congruence modular varieties .
our method of proof uses the day terms for whatever congruence modular variety @xmath1 is under consideration .
we also show that the higher commutator is equivalent to a two term higher commutator for a congruence modular variety .
we begin with the term condition definition of the @xmath2-ary commutator as introduced by bulatov . the following notation is used .
let @xmath3 be an algebra with @xmath4 .
a tuple will be written in bold : @xmath5 .
the length of this tuple is denoted by @xmath6 . for two tuples @xmath7 such that @xmath8 we write @xmath9 to indicate that @xmath10 for @xmath11 , where @xmath10 indicates that @xmath12 .
[ bulcen ] let @xmath3 be an algebra , @xmath13 , and choose @xmath14 .
we say that * @xmath15 centralize @xmath16 modulo @xmath17 * if for all @xmath18 and tuples @xmath19 from @xmath3 such that 1 .
@xmath20 for each @xmath21 2 .
if @xmath22 for all @xmath23 we have that @xmath24 this condition is abbreviated as @xmath25 .
it is easy to see that if for some collection @xmath26 we have @xmath27 , then @xmath28 . we therefore make the following [ bulcomm ] let @xmath3 be an algebra , and let @xmath29 for @xmath30 .
the * @xmath2-ary commutator of @xmath31 * is defined to be @xmath32 = \meet \{\delta : c(\alpha_0,\dots,\alpha_{k-1 } ; \delta ) \}\ ] ] the following properties are immediate consequences of the definition : 1 .
@xmath33 \leq \meet_{0\leq i \leq k-1}\alpha_i$ ] 2 . for @xmath34 in @xmath35 , we have @xmath36 \leq [ \beta_0 , \dots , \beta_{k-1}]$ ] ( monotonicity ) 3 . @xmath37 \leq [ \alpha_1 , \dots , \alpha_{k-1}]$ ] we will demonstrate the following additional properties of the higher commutator for a congruence modular variety @xmath1 , which are developed for the binary commutator in @xcite 1 .
@xmath38 = [ \alpha_{\sigma(0 ) } , ... , \alpha_{\sigma(k-1)}]$ ] for any permutation of @xmath39 of the congruences @xmath40 ( symmetry ) 2 .
@xmath41 = \join_{i\in i } [ \gamma_i , \alpha_1 , ... , \alpha_{k-1}]$ ] ( additivity ) 3 .
@xmath42 \join \pi = f^{-1}([f(\alpha_0 \join \pi ) , ... , f(\alpha_{k-1 } \join \pi))])$ ] , where @xmath43 is a surjective homomorphism with kernel @xmath44 .
( homomorphism property ) 4 .
kiss showed in @xcite that for congruence modular varieties the binary commutator is equivalent to a binary commutator defined with a two - term condition .
this is true for the higher commutator also .
the following classical results about congruence modularity are needed .
for proofs see @xcite , @xcite and @xcite .
[ prop : day ] a variety @xmath1 is congruence modular if and only if there exist term operations @xmath45 for @xmath46 satisfying the following identities : 1 .
@xmath47 for each @xmath48 , 2 .
@xmath49 , 3 .
@xmath50 , 4 .
@xmath51 for even @xmath52 , and 5 .
@xmath53 for odd @xmath52 [ prop : shift ] let @xmath1 be a variety with day terms @xmath54 for @xmath46 .
take @xmath4 and assume @xmath55 . for a tuple
@xmath56 the following are equivalent : 1 .
@xmath57 2 .
@xmath58 for all @xmath46 [ prop : shiftlemma ] let @xmath1 be a congruence modular variety , and take @xmath59 .
take @xmath60 and @xmath61 .
suppose @xmath62 are such that @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 .
then @xmath66 .
pictorially , @xmath67 \ar@{-}_{\theta_2}[d ] & b\ar@{-}[d ] \ar@{-}@/^/ ^\gamma[d]\\ c \ar@{-}[r ] & d } \textnormal { \emph{implies } } \xymatrix { a \ar@{-}^{\theta_1}[r ] \ar@{-}_{\theta_2}[d ] \ar@{-}@/^/ ^\gamma[d ] & b\ar@{-}[d ] \ar@{-}@/^/ ^\gamma[d]\\ c \ar@{-}[r ] & d } \ ] ] for the remainder of this article a variety @xmath1 is assumed to be congruence modular .
take @xmath59 and @xmath68 .
the development of the binary commutator in @xcite relies on a so - called term condition that can be defined with respect to a subalgebra of @xmath69 , the subalgebra of @xmath70-matrices .
we will now generalize these ideas to the higher commutator . to motivate the definitions , we state them for the binary commutator .
[ fmmat ] take @xmath59 , and @xmath71 . define @xmath72 : t\in \operatorname{pol}(\a ) , \textbf{a}_0 \equiv_{\theta_0 } \textbf{b}_0 , \textbf{a}_1 \equiv_{\theta_1 } \textbf{b}_1 \right\}\ ] ] it is readily shown that @xmath73 is a subalgebra of @xmath69 , with a generating set of the form @xmath74 : x\equiv_{\theta_0 } y \right\ } \union \left\ { \left [ \begin{array}{cc } x & y\\ x & y\\ \end{array}\right ] : x\equiv_{\theta_1 } y \right\}\ ] ] the notion of centralization given in definition [ bulcen ] with congruences @xmath75 can be easily pictured with @xmath70-matrices .
this is shown in figure [ fig : bincen ] .
for @xmath4 the following implications pictured below hold for all @xmath76 \in m(\theta_0 , \theta_1)\ ] ] where @xmath17-pairs are connected by a curved line .
it is easy to generalize the idea of matrices to three dimensions . for congruences @xmath77 the condition
@xmath78 is equivalent to the following diagram holding for all @xmath79 and @xmath80 , @xmath81 .
the main arguments in this paper are essentially combinatorial and rely on isolating certain squares and lines in matrices . in the case of the above matrix
we identify the squares shown in figure [ fig : pivsquare1 ] , which we label as @xmath82-supporting and pivot squares ( see definition [ supportpiv ] ) .
notice that both squares are @xmath70-matrices , where the supporting square corresponds to the polynomial @xmath83 and the pivot square corresponds to the polynomial @xmath84 we also identify the lines shown in figure [ fig : pivsquare1 ] , which are labeled as either a @xmath85-supporting line or a @xmath85-pivot line ( see definition [ supportpiv ] ) .
notice that each line corresponds to a polynomial @xmath86 , where @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
notice that @xmath89 is equivalent to the statement that if every @xmath85-supporting line of such a matrix is a @xmath17 pair , then the @xmath85-pivot line is a @xmath17-pair .
[ tmatrix ] we therefore require for a sequence of congruences @xmath90 the notion of a matrix , as well as a notation to identify a matrice s supporting and pivot squares and lines . let @xmath91 be a sequence of congruences of @xmath3 .
a pair @xmath92 is called a * @xmath93-matrix label * if 1 .
@xmath94 2 .
@xmath95 is a sequence of pairs @xmath96 such that @xmath97 let @xmath98 be a @xmath93-matrix label . from the above examples , we see that @xmath99 can be used to construct a @xmath2-dimensional cube whose vertices
correspond to evaluating each variable tuple @xmath100 in @xmath101 at one of the tuples belonging to @xmath102 .
we also need to identify the squares and lines of this matrix , which are in fact @xmath0 and @xmath103-dimensional matrices . as in the above examples , these objects correspond to the evaluation of some of the @xmath100 at tuples in @xmath104 .
we introduce notation to identify which of the @xmath100 in @xmath105 are being evaluated and which variable tuples @xmath100 remain free .
let @xmath106 .
denote by @xmath107 the subsequence @xmath108 of congruences from @xmath93 that is indexed by @xmath109 . for a function @xmath110 let @xmath111 be the @xmath107-matrix label such that 1 .
@xmath112 with 1 .
@xmath113 is the collection of variable tuples indexed by @xmath109 2 .
@xmath114 if @xmath115 3 .
@xmath116 if @xmath117 4 .
@xmath118 if @xmath119 2 .
@xmath120 is the subsequence @xmath121 of pairs of tuples from @xmath104 that is indexed by @xmath109 .
if we wish to evaluate each @xmath100 we therefore consider @xmath122 for some @xmath123 .
choose @xmath124 .
let @xmath125 be a sequence of congruences of @xmath3 .
let @xmath92 be a @xmath93-matrix label .
a * @xmath93-matrix * is an element @xmath126 such that @xmath127 for all @xmath128 .
we say in this case that @xmath129 is * labeled * by @xmath99 .
denote by @xmath130 the collection of all @xmath93-matrices .
if @xmath131 is a sequence of congruences of @xmath3 then @xmath130 and @xmath132 denote the same collection .
if we consider the set @xmath2 as a set of coordinates , the set of functions @xmath133 can be viewed as a @xmath2-dimensional cube , where @xmath134 is connected to @xmath135 by an edge if @xmath136 for all @xmath137 for some coordinate @xmath138 .
each @xmath93-matrix @xmath129 labeled by @xmath99 is therefore a @xmath2-dimensional cube , with a vertex @xmath139 for each @xmath123 .
moreover , if @xmath139 and @xmath140 are connected by an edge where @xmath136 for all @xmath141 for some coordinate @xmath138 , then @xmath142 . as noted in the case of the binary commutator , the collection of @xmath143-matrices is a subalgebra of @xmath69 and is generated by those @xmath144 that are constant across rows or columns .
these facts easily generalize to the collection of @xmath93-matrices .
[ tmatrixlem ] let @xmath125 be a sequence of congruences of an algebra @xmath3 .
the collection @xmath130 forms a subalgebra of @xmath145 , and is generated by those matrices @xmath146 that depend only on one coordinate .
we now define the ideas of a cross - section square and a cross - section line .
let @xmath147 be a sequence of congruences and @xmath146 be labeled by @xmath92 .
choose two coordinates @xmath148 with @xmath149 .
for @xmath150 let @xmath151 be the @xmath152-matrix labeled by @xmath153 .
we call @xmath154 the * @xmath155-cross - section square * of @xmath129 at @xmath156 .
similarly , for a coordinate @xmath157 and @xmath158 let @xmath159 be the @xmath160-matrix labeled by @xmath161 .
we call @xmath139 in this case the * @xmath162-cross - section line * of @xmath129 at @xmath134
. a typical @xmath155-cross - section square @xmath154 will be displayed as @xmath163 = \left [ \begin{array}{cc } r_{f^ * } & s_{f^*}\\ u_{f^ * } & v_{f^*}\\ \end{array } \right]\ ] ] and a typical @xmath162 or @xmath164-cross - section line of @xmath129 is a column or row , respectively , of such a square .
we set @xmath165 @xmath166 to be the collections of all @xmath155-cross - section squares and @xmath162-cross - section lines of @xmath129 , respectively .
[ supportpiv ] let @xmath167 , and take @xmath168 .
choose @xmath148 such that @xmath169 .
let @xmath170 , @xmath171 and @xmath172 be the constant functions that take value @xmath103 on their respective domains .
we call the @xmath155-cross - section square of @xmath129 at @xmath173 the * @xmath155-pivot square*. all other @xmath155 cross - section squares of @xmath129 will be called * @xmath155-supporting squares*. similarly , we call the @xmath162 cross - section square of @xmath129 at @xmath174 the * @xmath162-pivot line * , and all other @xmath162 cross - section lines will be called * @xmath162-supporting lines*. we now reformulate definition [ bulcen ] with respect to these definitions . [
def : cen ] we say that * @xmath93 is centralized at @xmath138 modulo @xmath17 * if the following property holds for all @xmath93-matrices @xmath146 : 1 . if every @xmath162-supporting line of @xmath129 is a @xmath17-pair , then the @xmath162-pivot line of @xmath129 is a @xmath17-pair .
we abbreviate this property @xmath175 .
[ def : commutator ] we define @xmath176_j = \bigwedge \{\delta : \mathcal{c}(t , j ; \delta ) \}$ ] [ diffcomm ] notice that @xmath176_j = [ \theta_{i_0 } , \dots , \theta_{i_{k-2 } } , \theta_j]$ ] for any permutation of the @xmath177 congruences that are not @xmath178 , where the left side is given by definition [ def : commutator ] and the right is given by definition [ bulcomm ] .
we conclude this section with a general picture of the @xmath155-supporting and pivot squares of a @xmath93-matrix @xmath129 labeled by some @xmath92 , a @xmath93-matrix label for a sequence of congruences @xmath179 .
the conditions @xmath180 and @xmath181 are pictured in figure [ fig : supppivsquares ] , respectively .
in this section we will show that the commutator of definition [ bulcomm ] is symmetric .
we fix @xmath59 , with @xmath1 a congruence modular variety with day terms @xmath54 for @xmath182 . for @xmath183
let @xmath167 be a sequence of congruences of @xmath3 .
we wish to show that @xmath184 = [ \theta_{\sigma(0 ) } , \dots , \theta_{\sigma(k-1)}]$ ] for any permutation @xmath39 of the elements of @xmath2 . by remark [ diffcomm ]
it will suffice to show that @xmath176_j = [ t]_l$ ] for all @xmath148 .
this will imply that @xmath184 = [ \theta_{\sigma(0 ) } , \dots , \theta_{\sigma(k-1 ) } ] = [ t]_j = [ t]_l$ ] for all permutations @xmath39 of @xmath2 and all @xmath185 .
we begin with the following [ lem : newop ] let @xmath1 be a congruence modular variety with day terms @xmath54 for @xmath182 , and let @xmath59 .
let @xmath186 .
for each choice of @xmath187 such that @xmath149 and @xmath182 there is a map @xmath188 with the following properties : 1 . if @xmath189 has the set of @xmath155-cross - section squares @xmath190 :
f^ * \in 2 ^{k \setminus\{j , l\ } } \right\}\ ] ] then @xmath191 has the set of @xmath155-cross - section squares @xmath192 @xmath193 : f^ * \in 2 ^{k \setminus\{j , l\ } } \right\}\ ] ] 2 . if every @xmath162-supporting line of @xmath194 is a @xmath17-pair , then every @xmath164-supporting line of @xmath191 is a @xmath17-pair .
3 . suppose the @xmath162-supporting line belonging to the @xmath155-pivot square of @xmath194 is a @xmath17-pair .
the @xmath162-pivot line of @xmath194 is a @xmath17-pair if and only if the @xmath164-pivot line of @xmath191 is a @xmath17-pair for all @xmath46
. the map @xmath195 will be called * the @xmath196th shift rotation at @xmath155*. let @xmath197 be labeled by @xmath92 , where @xmath198 and @xmath199 with @xmath200 .
fix @xmath148 with @xmath149 and take @xmath182 .
let @xmath201 where @xmath202 and @xmath203 , @xmath204 are concatenations . for each @xmath205
, define a pair of tuples @xmath206 as follows : 1 .
@xmath207 if @xmath208 2 .
@xmath209 3 .
@xmath210 let @xmath211 , and set @xmath212 .
define @xmath213 to be the @xmath93-matrix labeled by @xmath214 .
we now compute @xmath215 , the set of @xmath155 cross - section squares of @xmath191 .
take @xmath216 .
consider the @xmath155 cross - section square of @xmath194 at @xmath156 : @xmath217\ ] ] by the definitions given above we therefore compute @xmath218\\ = & \left [ \begin{array}{cc } m_e(s_{f^ * } , u_{f^ * } , u_{f^ * } , s_{f^ * } ) & m_e(s_{f^ * } , v_{f^ * } , v_{f^ * } , s_{f^*})\\ m_e(s_{f^ * } , r_{f^ * } , u_{f^ * } , v_{f^ * } ) & m_e(s_{f^ * } , s_{f^ * } , v_{f^ * } , v_{f^*})\\ \end{array } \right]\\ = & \left [ \begin{array}{cc } s_{f^ * } & s_{f^*}\\ m_e(s_{f^ * } , r_{f^ * } , u_{f^ * } , v_{f^ * } ) & m_e(s_{f^ * } , s_{f^ * } , v_{f^ * } , v_{f^*})\\ \end{array } \right]\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the final equality follows from identity ( 1 ) in proposition [ prop : day ] .
this proves ( 1 ) of the lemma .
we now prove ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) . a picture is given in figure [ fig : shiftrot ] , where a typical @xmath155-supporting square and the @xmath155-pivot square are shown for both @xmath194 and @xmath191 . supporting lines are drawn in bold . indeed ,
any constant pair @xmath219 is a @xmath17-pair , so the top row of any @xmath155-cross - section square of @xmath191 is a @xmath17-pair .
that the other @xmath164-supporting lines of @xmath191 are @xmath17-pairs follows from proposition [ prop : shift ] .
finally , proposition @xmath220 shows that the @xmath162-pivot line of @xmath194 is a @xmath17-pair if and only if for every @xmath46 the @xmath164-pivot line of @xmath191 is a @xmath17-pair , which is indicated in the picture with dashed curved lines .
this proves ( 3 ) .
[ prop : centraliff ] let @xmath221 .
suppose that for @xmath4 that @xmath222 holds for some @xmath223 .
then @xmath224 holds for all @xmath205 .
choose @xmath169 .
by definition [ def : cen ] , it suffices to show that for each @xmath197 that if each @xmath162-supporting line of @xmath194 is a @xmath17-pair then the @xmath162-pivot line of @xmath194 is a @xmath17 pair . for @xmath46
consider the @xmath52th shift rotation at @xmath155 of @xmath194 .
by @xmath225 of [ lem : newop ] , each @xmath164-supporting line of @xmath191 is a @xmath17-pair .
we assume that @xmath181 holds , therefore the @xmath164-pivot line of @xmath195 is a @xmath17-pair . because this is true for every @xmath182 , @xmath226 of [ lem : newop ] shows that the @xmath162-pivot line of @xmath194 is a @xmath17-pair .
we therefore conclude that @xmath180 holds .
@xmath176_j = [ t]_l$ ] for all @xmath148 .
@xmath176_j = \bigwedge \{\delta : \mathcal{c}(t ; j ; \delta ) \ } = \bigwedge \{\delta : \mathcal{c}(t ; l ; \delta ) \ } = [ t]_l$ ] .
we can now omit the coordinate @xmath138 when stating @xmath227 or referring to @xmath176_j$ ] , writing @xmath228 and @xmath176 $ ] instead .
in this section we construct for a sequence of congruences @xmath221 a set of generators @xmath229 for @xmath176 $ ] .
the idea of the construction is to consider all possible sequences of consecutive shift rotations for an arbitrary @xmath93-matrix @xmath194 .
each such sequence will produce a @xmath93-matrix that is constant on all @xmath230-supporting lines .
the @xmath230-pivot line of such a @xmath93-matrix must belong to any @xmath17 such that @xmath228 holds .
this is illustrated for @xmath231-dimensional matrices in figure [ fig : gen1 ] , where constant pairs are indicated with bold . as usual
, let @xmath1 be a congruence modular variety with day terms @xmath54 for @xmath46 , and let @xmath232 for @xmath233 . for a @xmath93-matrix @xmath194 we will apply a composition of @xmath177 many shift rotations , first at @xmath82 , then at @xmath234 , ending at @xmath235 . for each stage
there are @xmath236 many choices of day terms , each giving a different shift rotation .
it is therefore quite natural to label these sequences of shift rotations with branches belonging to the tree of height @xmath2 with @xmath236 many successors of each vertex .
set @xmath237 where for @xmath238 , we have @xmath239 if @xmath240 extends @xmath241 .
note that @xmath242 has the empty sequence @xmath243 as a root .
[ lem : pairseq ] let @xmath1 be a variety with day terms @xmath54 for @xmath244 .
let @xmath232 .
let @xmath197 be labeled by @xmath92 .
set @xmath245 .
for each non - empty @xmath246 there is a @xmath93-matrix @xmath247 labeled by some @xmath248 such that 1 .
@xmath249 , where @xmath250 is the predecessor of @xmath251 .
2 . let @xmath252 be such that @xmath253 for some @xmath254 .
then the @xmath255-supporting line of @xmath256 at @xmath134 : @xmath257\ ] ] is a constant pair .
the lemma is trivially true for @xmath258 .
suppose it holds for @xmath250 and let @xmath251 be a successor of @xmath250 .
let @xmath252 be such that @xmath253 for some @xmath254 .
we need to establish that the supporting line @xmath257\ ] ] is a constant pair .
let @xmath259 be the restriction of @xmath134 to @xmath260 .
we treat two cases : 1 .
suppose @xmath261 , and for no other @xmath254 does @xmath253 .
consider the @xmath262-cross - section square of @xmath263 at @xmath156 : + @xmath264\ ] ] + by [ lem : newop ] , the @xmath262-cross - section of @xmath265 at @xmath156 is : @xmath266\ ] ] the @xmath255-supporting line of @xmath256 at @xmath134 is the top row of the above square , that is , @xmath267\ ] ] 2 .
suppose that @xmath268 for some @xmath269 .
in this case the inductive assumption applies to @xmath263 , so columns of the @xmath262-cross - section of @xmath263 at @xmath156 are therefore constant : @xmath270\ ] ] we therefore compute the @xmath262-cross - section of @xmath271 at @xmath156 as : + @xmath272 = \left [ \begin{array}{cc } s_{f^ * } & s_{f^*}\\ s_{f^ * } & s_{f^*}\\ \end{array } \right]\ ] ] the @xmath255-cross - section line of @xmath256 at @xmath134 is either the top or bottom row of the above square , if @xmath117 or @xmath119 respectively
. therefore @xmath267\ ] ] let @xmath273 be a leaf of @xmath242 . by [ lem : pairseq ] ,
all @xmath230-supporting lines of @xmath256 are constant pairs @xmath219 .
if we assume that @xmath274 holds then the @xmath230-pivot line of @xmath265 must belong to @xmath17 .
that is , @xmath275 for any @xmath197 and any leaf @xmath276 .
set @xmath277 .
we have just observed that [ genincen ] let @xmath167 for @xmath59 , where @xmath1 is congruence modular .
suppose that @xmath4 is such that @xmath278 holds
. then @xmath279 .
in particular , @xmath280 $ ] by induction over @xmath242 we now demonstrate the following [ ceningen ] let @xmath281
. then @xmath274 holds .
in particular , @xmath176 \leq \operatorname{cg}(x(t))$ ] .
take @xmath282 . by symmetry
, it suffices to consider that all @xmath283-supporting lines of @xmath194 are @xmath17-pairs .
we need to show that the @xmath283-pivot line of @xmath194 is also a @xmath17-pair . by a repeated application of ( 2 ) of lemma [ lem : newop ] , each @xmath255-supporting line of @xmath256
is a @xmath17-pair , where @xmath284 .
take @xmath285 , and suppose that for all successors @xmath286 of @xmath250 that the @xmath255-pivot line of @xmath256 is a @xmath17-pair . applying ( 3 ) of lemma [ lem : newop ]
yields that the @xmath287-pivot line of @xmath263 is a @xmath17-pair . because @xmath288 , the @xmath230-pivot line of @xmath256 is a @xmath17-pair for any @xmath276 that is a leaf . by induction
it follows that the @xmath283-pivot line of @xmath194 is a @xmath17-pair , as desired .
the following hold : 1 .
@xmath176 = \operatorname{cg}(x(t))$ ] 2 .
@xmath274 if and only if @xmath176 \leq \delta$ ]
we are now ready to show that the commutator is additive and is preserved by surjections .
we begin by example , demonstrating additivity for the @xmath231-ary commutator .
let @xmath289 be a collection of congruences of @xmath3 .
we want to show that @xmath290 = \join_{i\in i } [ \theta_0 , \theta_1 , \gamma_i]$ ] .
it is immediate that @xmath290 \geq \join_{i\in i } [ \theta_0 , \theta_1 , \gamma_i]$ ] , because of monotonicity . to demonstrate the other direction
, it suffices to show that @xmath291 holds , where @xmath292 $ ] .
let @xmath293 be labeled by @xmath294 .
suppose that each @xmath85-supporting line of @xmath194 is an @xmath295-pair .
we need to show that the @xmath283-pivot line of @xmath194 is also an @xmath295-pair . because @xmath296 , there exist tuples @xmath297 such that @xmath298 this sequence of tuples produces the sequence of cross - section squares shown in figure [ fig : add1 ] .
each square is a @xmath70-matrix labeled by @xmath299 , for @xmath300 a tuple from @xmath297 .
each consecutive pair of squares labeled by @xmath301 are the @xmath0-cross - section squares of a @xmath302-matrix . as usual , @xmath295-pairs are indicated with curved lines . to show that the @xmath85-pivot line of @xmath194 is an @xmath295-pair it suffices to show that @xmath303 for all @xmath182 .
therefore , we consider for each @xmath182 the @xmath52-th shift rotation at @xmath82 of the above sequence of matrices .
this is shown in figure [ fig : add2 ] .
constant pairs are indicated with bold . because @xmath304 \leq \alpha$ ] for all @xmath305 , we have that @xmath306 holds .
because each cube in the above sequence is a @xmath307-matrix for some @xmath308 , it follows by induction that @xmath309-pivot line of @xmath310 is an @xmath295-pair , as desired . to show the additivity of a commutator of any arity
, the same argument is used .
for @xmath282 we consider all @xmath256 for any @xmath311 that is a predecessor of a leaf . by [ lem : pairseq ] ,
all @xmath312-supporting lines that do not belong to the @xmath235-pivot square of @xmath256 are constant pairs .
the argument is then essentially the same as the @xmath231-ary example above , complicated slightly by an induction over the tree @xmath313 .
[ additivity ] let @xmath314 for @xmath308 be a collection of congruences of @xmath3 .
set @xmath315 and @xmath316 , where @xmath317 .
then @xmath176= \join_{i\in i } [ t_i]$ ] . by monotonicity , @xmath318
\leq [ t]$ ] . set @xmath319 $ ] .
we need to show that @xmath320 holds .
let @xmath197 be labeled by @xmath321 , where @xmath104 is a sequence of pairs of tuples @xmath322 .
suppose that every @xmath283-supporting line of @xmath194 is a @xmath295-pair .
we will show that the @xmath283-pivot line of @xmath194 is an @xmath295-pair also .
here we have that @xmath323 .
we illustrate the @xmath324-dimensional matrix @xmath194 as the product of two @xmath2-dimensional matrices in figure [ fig : add3 ] , given by evaluating @xmath325 at either @xmath326 or @xmath327 .
these two matrices are called @xmath328 and @xmath329 respectively . notice that the @xmath85-pivot line of @xmath194 is equal to the @xmath85-pivot line of @xmath329 . by an induction identical to that given in the proof of lemma [ ceningen ] it therefore suffices to show that the @xmath230-pivot line of @xmath330 is an @xmath295-pair , for each @xmath331 that is a leaf . because @xmath323 , there exist tuples @xmath297 such that @xmath332 evaluating @xmath325 at each of the @xmath300 gives the sequence of matrices shown in figure [ fig : add3 ] , each consecutive pair determined by @xmath333 forming a @xmath334-matrix which we call @xmath335 .
now , take @xmath276 to be a leaf .
notice that @xmath336 also , and that @xmath251 is a predecessor of a leaf in this tree . for each @xmath337 in the above sequemce , consider the @xmath334-matrix @xmath338 .
this gives the final sequence of matrices shown in figure [ fig : add3 ] . by lemma [ lem : pairseq ] , every @xmath230-supporting line that does not belong to
a @xmath339-pivot square is a constant pair .
these are drawn with bold .
the sequence of @xmath339-pivot squares is drawn underneath the constant supporting lines .
as in the 3-dimensional example , we observe that @xmath340 holds .
it follows from induction that the @xmath230-pivot line of @xmath330 is an @xmath295-pair , as desired .
let @xmath341 be a surjective homomorphism with kernel @xmath44 .
abusing notation , we denote by @xmath342 the sequence of congruences @xmath343 , and by @xmath344 the sequence of congruences @xmath345 .
we then have the following let @xmath341 be a surjective homomorphism with kernel @xmath44 .
then @xmath176 \join \pi = f^{-1}([f(t \join \pi)])$ ] .
we argue by generators again . by proposition [ additivity ]
we have that @xmath176 \join \pi = [ t \join \pi ] \join \pi$ ] .
we therefore assume without loss that @xmath346 for @xmath347 .
notice that @xmath176 \join \pi = \operatorname{cg}(x(t ) \union \pi)$ ] and that @xmath348 .
but @xmath349 = \operatorname{cg}(x(f(t))$ ] , so @xmath350 \join \pi ) = [ f(t)]$ ] as desired .
kiss showed in @xcite that the term condition definition of the binary commutator is equivalent to a commutator defined with a two term condition .
the method of proof uses a difference term .
we begin this section be examining the binary case .
the equivalence of the commutator defined with the term condition to the commutator defined with a two term condition can be shown using day terms .
this approach easily generalizes to the higher commutator .
recall that for a matrix @xmath351 and @xmath123 we denote by @xmath352 the vertex of @xmath194 that is indexed by @xmath134 .
( binary two term centralization ) let @xmath1 be a congruence modular variety and take @xmath59 . for @xmath353
we say that * @xmath295 two term centralizes @xmath354 modulo @xmath17 * if the following condition holds for all @xmath355 , where we assume @xmath194 and @xmath135 are respectively labeled by @xmath356 @xmath357 proposition [ prop : shift ] show that @xmath389 because @xmath390 and @xmath391 are @xmath17-pairs .
we assume that @xmath365 holds , so @xmath392 .
this holds for all @xmath182 so applying proposition [ prop : shift ] again shows that @xmath393 .
let @xmath1 be a congruence modular variety and take @xmath59 .
for @xmath167 and @xmath4 we say that * @xmath93 is centralized at @xmath138 modulo @xmath17 * if the following condition holds for all @xmath394 : suppose @xmath398 holds . to show that @xmath399 holds , take @xmath282 with @xmath85-supporting lines @xmath400 for @xmath401 and @xmath85-pivot line @xmath402 .
suppose that each @xmath85-supporting line @xmath400 is a @xmath17-pair .
there is a @xmath403 with @xmath85-supporting lines @xmath404 for @xmath405 and @xmath85-pivot line @xmath406 .
we have that @xmath395 for all @xmath396 except possibly the constant function with value @xmath103 .
the assumption that @xmath398 implies that @xmath395 for all @xmath396 .
in particular , @xmath407 .
suppose that @xmath194 and @xmath135 are labeled by @xmath409 @xmath410 respectively .
choose @xmath205 .
figure [ fig : twoterm4 ] shows the @xmath411-cross - section lines of @xmath194 and @xmath135 , with vertices that are @xmath17-pairs connected by curved lines .
we label the @xmath411-pivot line of @xmath194 as the pair @xmath412 and the @xmath411-pivot line of @xmath135 as the pair @xmath413 . for a function @xmath414 the supporting lines @xmath352 and @xmath415 are named @xmath416 and @xmath417 respectively .
we want to show that @xmath418 . by proposition [ prop :
shift ] , it suffices to show that @xmath419 for all @xmath182 .
this will follow from the assumption that @xmath399 holds and the existence of a @xmath93-matrix @xmath387 with the @xmath411-cross - section lines shown in figure [ fig : twoterm5 ] .
let @xmath430 be labeled by @xmath431 . by proposition [ prop :
shift ] , every @xmath411-supporting line of @xmath387 is a @xmath17-pair .
we assume that @xmath399 holds , so the @xmath411-pivot line of @xmath387 is a @xmath17-pair .
this holds for all @xmath182 , so @xmath418 as desired . | we develop the basic properties of the higher commutator for congruence modular varieties . |
from the history of fundamental science everybody knows that cosmic rays physics as a part of astrophysics and particle physics especially based on accelerator studies have many common roots .
in particular , many discoveries early in particle physics have been done in the study of cosmic rays .
it is enough to remind that the researches in cosmic rays resulted in the discovery of such elementary particles as the positron @xmath0 in 1932 , the muon
second charged lepton @xmath1 in 1937 , the charged and neutral pions @xmath2 , @xmath3 , the strange particles kaons @xmath4 , @xmath5 , @xmath6 and @xmath7-hyperon in 1947 , the antiproton , @xmath8 and @xmath9 in 1952 - 1955 . in the very beginning of the second half of xx century
a period of divergence between cosmic rays physics and particle physics , both in methodology and in the places of interest , has been started .
particle physicists have taken the path of building the big accelerators and large detectors .
the experiments at the serpukhov accelerator , the isr and the s@xmath10s at cern , the tevatron collider at fnal allowed to learn the hadron interaction properties at high energies .
the accelerator experiments together with theoretical efforts resulted in the construction of the `` standard model '' with clear understanding and power predictions at least in the electro - weak sector and with a number of new open questions .
it is believed that new collider experiments such as the lhc project at cern and others might help to find the answers to the open questions in particle physics . at the same time it is quite clear that the new measurements at the accelerator experiments would be of great importance for cosmic rays physics .
this is because high energy cosmic rays are usually measured indirectly by investigating the air showers they produce in the atmosphere of the earth . a correct interpretation of the air shower measurements with a necessity requires an improved understanding of the hadron interaction properties , explored by the accelerator experiments .
there is a clear necessity to measure at accelerators the global characteristics of the high energy hadron interactions with a high accuracy , in order to accurately interpret the existing and newly data on the measurements of the highest energy air showers .
certainly , this request , addressed to the physicists working on the hadron accelerators , is clearly and strongly motivated .
the progress in cosmic rays physics during `` accelerator era '' has been less substantial compared to particle physics .
probably the main reason of that is owing to above mentioned divergence between two branches in fundamental science .
however , the recent results in cosmic ray studies and new astrophysical observations open a new page in particle physics .
one of the most interesting results is the detection of cosmic ray particles with energies exceeded @xmath11ev .
@xcite is the first article where the detection of a cosmic ray with energy @xmath12 ev has been published ( the volcano ranch experiment ) . at present time the total number of detected air showers with energy higher than @xmath12 ev is about 20 @xcite .
the existence of cosmic ray particles with energies above @xmath13 ev has been confirmed by all experiments , regardless of the experimental technique used .
why this result is so interesting for particle physics ?
it is well known that soon after the discovery of the cosmic microwave background radiation ( cmbr ) by penzias and wilson @xcite almost simultaneously greisen in the usa @xcite and zatsepin&kuzmin @xcite in the ussr predicted that above @xmath12 ev the cosmic ray spectrum will steepen abruptly ( gzk effect ) .
the cause of that catastrophic cutoff is the intense isotropic cmbr which is really a 2.7k thermal blackbody radiation produced at a very early stage of the universe evolution and confirmed by measurements of roll and wilkinson @xcite .
cmbr photons with a 2.7k thermal spectrum fill the whole universe with a number density of @xmath14 400 @xmath15 .
the physical mechanism of the gzk cutoff is quite clear , it is based on the interactions of ultra - high energy cosmic ray ( uhecr ) particles with cmbr photons . protons , photons , electrons , neutrinos , nuclei etc might be as such uhecr particles .
mainly the process that cause the energy loss of uhecr particle , say proton , is the photo - production of pions on cmbr photons : @xmath16 .
the threshold center of mass energy for photoproduction of one pion is @xmath17 1073 mev . in the cosmic rest frame ( crf , defined as the frame in which the cmbr is represented as isotropic photon gas )
one can estimate the proton threshold energy for pion photoproduction @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the proton energy in the cosmic rest frame .
taking the average energy @xmath20 ev , the proton threshold energy is @xmath21ev . on the other hand , in the rest frame of a cosmic ray proton ( prf projectile rest frame ) a substantial fraction of the cmbr photons will look as @xmath22rays with energy above the threshold energy for pion photoproduction @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the cmbr photon energy in the projectile rest frame .
the photoproduction cross section as a function of projectile photons for stationary protons is very well measured and studied at accelerator experiments @xcite .
there is a detail information that is shown in fig . 1 .
at low energies the cross section exhibits a pronounced resonance associated with the @xmath25 decaying into @xmath26 mode ; here the cross section exceeds 500 @xmath27b at the peak . the complicated range beyond the @xmath25resonance is essentially dominated by the higher mass resonances associated with multiple pion production @xmath28 .
the whole resonance range is followed by the long tail with approximately constant cross section about 100 @xmath27b with a slow increase up to 1 tev .
the photo - pion production cross section for neutrons is to a good approximation identical . as seen from fig . 1 at half - width of the @xmath25 resonance peak the total cross section @xmath29 300 @xmath27b = 3@xmath30 .
taking into account the number density of the cmbr photons @xmath31 400 @xmath15 , for the mean free path @xmath32 in the cmbr photon gas one obtains @xmath33 the next important parameter is the proton inelasticity @xmath34 defining the fraction of energy that a proton loses in one collision . at threshold in each collision
protons lose about 18% of their energy , and this energy loss fraction increases with increase of energy . in that way the energy loss length @xmath35 is estimated about a few tens mpc for protons with energy higher than @xmath13 ev .
apart from photo - pion production , the process of pair production @xmath36 should be considered as well .
while this process has a smaller threshold by a factor @xmath37 , it has a smaller cross section .
thus , the estimated energy loss length @xmath38 is about @xmath39 mpc .
nevertheless , this process might be important at sub gzk energies .
the detailed analysis of the energy loss length of protons in interactions with the cmbr photons is presented in fig . 2 . for neutrons with @xmath40 ev , the dominant loss process is @xmath41decay @xmath42 .
the neutron decay rate @xmath43 , with the laboratory lifetime @xmath44 sec , gives the neutron energy loss length @xmath45 obviously , uhecrs nuclei are expose to the same energy loss processes as uhecrs protons . so that , the respective threshold for the photo - pion production reaction , in particular , @xmath46 , is given by change of @xmath47 with the mass of the nucleus in eq .
[ gzkproton ] @xmath48 from eq .
[ gzknucleus ] it follows that the gzk cutoff energy for nuclei is shifted to larger values for heavier nuclei .
however , it turns out that the dominant energy loss process for nuclei is photodisintegration , typically @xmath49 , happening due to giant resonances at about the same primary energy .
in fact , here we have another excellent example of intersection between nuclear&particle physics and high - energy cosmic rays physics .
recent detailed studies reveal that photodisintegration for nuclei leads to energy loss length of @xmath1410 mpc at energy @xmath50 ev , which is comparable with the energy loss length for nucleons .
well , to resume the gzk effect physically means that isotropic cmbr photon gas makes the universe opaque to uhecrs particles whose energy is greater than @xmath13 ev . in terms of the energy loss length
the gzk cutoff looks like a suppression of the uhecrs flux due to restriction of the propagation distance to a few tens of mpc . in that sense
a notion of the gzk sphere arises : simply it is a sphere with the radius @xmath51 mpc within which a source has to locate to be the origin of the uhecrs particles with energy @xmath52 ev .
as mentioned above the cosmic ray particles with energies exceeded @xmath13 ev have been detected .
the data on the uhecrs spectra measured by fly s eye , agasa , hires i , and hires ii collaborations are collected and shown in fig
. 3 . extracted from ref .
@xcite ( see references therein ) . as seen from fig .
3 the combined uhecr spectrum does not exhibit the gzk cutoff at all , many events with @xmath53 ev have been observed .
the strongest evidence for trans - gzk events comes from the agasa observations .
the agasa group reported the detection of up to 17 events with energy @xmath54 ev and claimed that gzk cutoff effect is not observed . now a non - observation of the gzk effect is known as the gzk puzzle .
of course , the gzk puzzle results in uncommonly profound consequences , raising questions to the nature of the primary uhecrs particles and their sources as well as the physical mechanisms responsible for endowing cosmic ray particles with such enormous energies or even to the particle physics in itself .
that s why the gzk puzzle and all around of that are the targets of wide discussions in the literature at present time . many ideas and different models as solutions
have been suggested @xcite , however , the true solution of the gzk puzzle is unknown so far .
looking at figure 3 , one can see that the uhecr spectrum exhibits a dip structure at the energy about @xmath13 ev , i.e. the spectrum really has a minimum just at the gzk cutoff energy .
thus the gzk puzzle ( irrespective of the source and accelerating mechanism for cosmic rays particles ) is transformed into the questions : what is the origin of this minimum , and how could one explain an appearance of the minimum in the uhecr spectrum in the framework of fundamental dynamics in particle physics . here
we suggest a conjecture that the minimum in the uhecr spectrum might be related with nontrivial structure of the inelastic defect of total cross sections in scattering from nuclei . this point will be discussed in a more detail below .
in the middle of xx century experimental and theoretical studies of high - energy particle interaction with deuterons have shown that even in the range of asymptotically high energies the total cross section in scattering from deuteron can not be treated as a simple sum of the proton and neutron total cross sections .
glauber was the first to explain why a simple addition of the elementary free nucleon cross sections might be failed . using the methods of diffraction theory , the quasiclassical picture for scattering from composite systems and eikonal approximation for high - energy scattering amplitudes
, he found fifty years ago @xcite that the deuteron total cross section can be expressed by the formula @xmath55 where @xmath56 here @xmath57 are the total cross sections in scattering from deuteron , proton and neutron , @xmath58 is the average value for the inverse square of the distance between the nucleons inside a deuteron , @xmath59 is the glauber shadow correction describing the effect of eclipsing or the screening effect in the recent terminology .
the glauber shadow correction has quite a clear physical interpretation .
this correction originates from elastic rescattering of an incident particle on the nucleons in a deuteron and corresponds to the configuration when the relative position of the nucleons in a deuteron is such that one casts its shadow " on the other .
it is a genuine analog of the effect known for astronomers ; the decrease in luminosity of binary star systems during eclipses @xcite . soon after it was understood that in the range of high energies the shadow effects may arise due to inelastic interactions of an incident particle with the nucleons of a deuteron .
therefore , an inelastic shadow correction had to be added to the glauber one . a simple formula for the total ( elastic plus inelastic ) shadow correction had been derived by gribov @xcite in the assumption of pomeron dominance in the dynamics of elastic and inelastic interactions @xmath60 where @xmath61 is the deuteron ( charge ) formfactor
, @xmath62 is the sum of cross sections of all processes which take place in interaction of incident hadron with the nucleon at fixed transfer momentum @xmath63 .
however , it was observed later on that the calculations performed by the gribov formula did not meet the experimental data : the calculated values of the shadow correction overestimated the experimental measurements . in that case
the idea , that the pomeron dominance is not justified at the accelerator energies , becomes clear .
it was believed sometime that the account of the triple - reggeon diagrams for six - point amplitude in addition to the triple - pomeron ones would allow to obtain a good agreement with the experiment .
but careful analysis has shown that discrepancy between theory and experiment could not be eliminated by taking into account the triple - reggeon diagrams : in fact , it is needed to modify the dynamics of the six - point amplitude with more complicated diagrams than the triple regge ones @xcite .
this indicates that up to now there is no a clear understanding , in the framework of regge phenomenology , the shadow corrections in elastic scattering from deuteron . the main difficulty , which the regge phenomenology faced with , was the problem to describe the cross section of the single diffraction dissociation processes . the latest experimental measurement of @xmath64 single diffraction dissociation at c.m.s .
energies @xmath65 and @xmath66 , carried out by the cdf group at the fermilab tevatron collider @xcite , has shown that the most popular model of supercritical pomeron does not describe the existing experimental data .
recent experimental results from hera @xcite lead us to the same conclusion .
the soft pomeron phenomenology as currently developed can not incorporate the hera data on structure function @xmath67 at small @xmath68 and total @xmath69 cross section from @xmath67 measurements as a function of @xmath70 for different @xmath71 .
such situation might be qualified as a `` super - crisis '' for the supercritical pomeron model .
figure 1 extracted from paper @xcite demonstrates the `` super - crisis '' ( see details in ref .
@xcite ) .
meanwhile it s quite clear that the theoretical understanding of the shielding effects in scattering from any composite system is of fundamental importance , because the structure of shadow corrections is deeply related to the structure of the composite system itself . at the same time
the structure of the shadow corrections displays new aspects for the fundamental dynamics . in the second half of 1970th
we have concerned in the study of dynamics in three particles scattering in some details ( see recent review article @xcite and references therein ) .
the bethe - salpeter - type equations reduced to one time have been used as an implement in our study of a dynamics for the three - body systems .
it turned out that the three - body dynamics , under a consistent consideration of three - body problem in the framework of local quantum field theory , with a necessity contained new fundamental forces which the three - body forces are .
the three - body forces in relativistic quantum theory appear as an inherent connected part of total three particle interaction which can not be represented by the sum of pair interactions .
an existence of the three - body forces might be established even in the perturbation theory expansions .
single - time formalism in quantum field theory used allows one to give a constructive definition of the three - body forces beyond the perturbation theory . on this way it was established that the fundamental three - body forces are related with specific inelastic interactions in two - body subsystems of the three - body system , and they govern the dynamics of special inelastic processes known as one - particle inclusive reactions . at the rather common assumptions we managed to calculate the contribution of the three - body forces to the deuteron total cross section and to derive the new , extremely simple and refined formula for defect of total cross section in scattering from deuteron with clear and transparent physical interpretation .
the obtained structure of the shadow corrections to the deuteron total cross section has revealed new fundamental scaling laws @xcite in interaction of composite nuclear systems . here
i would like to concern this point in a more detail . in our approach the defect of the deuteron total cross section
is represented by the sum of two items @xmath72 where @xmath73 is elastic defect , and @xmath74 is inelastic one . for the elastic and inelastic defects one obtains @xmath75 where @xmath76 as seen from eq .
[ partdef ] the elastic defect is proportional to the total elastic cross section , but the inelastic defect is proportional to the total single diffraction dissociation cross section in scattering from nucleon . the proportionality factors @xmath77 and @xmath78 are called the elastic and inelastic structure functions of a deuteron correspondingly . here @xmath79 is the deuteron radius defined by the deuteron formfactor , and scale variables @xmath80 and @xmath81 are defined through the slope of forward diffraction cone in elastic scattering @xmath82 and in single diffraction dissociation @xmath83 which are simply related to the effective radii of two - body @xmath84 and three - body @xmath85 forces . of course , it is supposed , that both at elastic and at inelastic interactions with nucleons of a deuteron , proton and neutron are dynamically indistinguishable , i.e. appropriate dynamic characteristics for a proton and neutron are identical @xmath86 , @xmath87 etc .
such assumption is quite justified at enough high energies .
structure functions have clear and quite a transparent physical meaning .
the function @xmath88 is some kind of `` counter '' , which measures out a portion of events related with elastic rescattering of incident hadron on nucleons of a deuteron among of all the events during the interaction with a deuteron as whole , and this function attached to the total probability of elastic interaction of an incident particle with a separate nucleon in a deuteron .
this function depends on a variable , which is effective radius of elastic interaction with a nucleon measured with the help of `` scale rule '' with a scale defined by the radius of a deuteron . at each value of this variable
( at a given value of energy ) the number of the function @xmath88 determines a weight , which the total cross section of elastic interaction with a nucleon at given energy enters the defect of the deuteron total cross section with .
the same physical interpretation with obvious changes in the terms is transferred on the inelastic structure function .
the function @xmath89 also represents some kind of `` instrument '' , but another , which count out a relative portion of other events among of possible interactions with a deuteron as a whole related with processes of inelastic interaction with nucleons inside a deuteron of inclusive type in the region of diffraction dissociation .
the inelastic structure function depends on another scale variable , which is effective radius of inelastic interaction with a nucleon measured with the help of `` scale rule '' with the same scale defined by the radius of a deuteron .
the number of the function @xmath89 at given value of energy determines a weight , which the total single diffraction dissociation cross section on a nucleon at the same energy enters the defect of the deuteron total cross section with . formulas ( [ defect ] ) and ( [ partdef ] ) may serve as toolkit for experimental study of structure functions @xmath88 and @xmath89 by measurement of the defect for total cross section in scattering from deuteron with usage of the experimental information about elastic cross section and total cross section of single diffraction dissociation on a nucleon .
for these purposes , however , it would be extremely important to have a reliable substantiation of these formulas .
it is remarkable that such theoretical substantiation can be really obtained .
the formalism , which we have used , allowed us to carry out analytical calculations completely , if for these purposes to take advantage of the parameterizations , trustworthy established on experiment , for differential elastic cross sections and for one - particle inclusive cross sections in the range of diffraction dissociation @xmath90 , \qquad \frac{2s}{\pi}\frac{d\sigma_n^{sd}}{dtdm_x^2 } = a(s , m_x^2)\exp[b(s , m_x^2)t].\ ] ] in this way we managed to get the extremely simple formulas for structure functions @xmath77 and @xmath78 , which look like @xmath91 it should be especially emphasized once more an important element in our approach which consists that the inelastic defect in the deuteron total cross section appears as manifestation of the fundamental three - body forces , and at the same the three - body forces determine the dynamics of one - particle inclusive reactions .
formula relating the three - body forces amplitude with the one - particle inclusive cross section has been derived as well ; see details in refs . @xcite and references therein .
outcome of functions evaluations ( [ a ] ) and analysis of these functions , however , are worthy of separate discussion . at first , being returned to the formula ( [ defect ] ) , we shall remark that the glauber formula is followed if in this formula to neglect inelastic defect and for the elastic structure function to take approximation @xmath92 justified at @xmath93 , and to take into account that @xmath94 .
secondly , it is necessary to pay attention that the structure functions @xmath77 and @xmath78 have quite different behavior : @xmath95 is the monotonic ( increasing ) function when argument vary on a semi - infinite interval @xmath96 , and the range of its values is limited to an interval @xmath97 , while the function @xmath78 at first increases , reaches a maximum at @xmath98 , and then decreases , disappearing at infinity , thus the range of its values is an interval @xmath99 . certainly , that such distinction in behavior of structure functions @xmath100 and @xmath101 results in far - reaching physical corollaries .
for example , at superhigh energies corresponding @xmath102 , we discover the effect of weakening the inelastic screening i.e. the inelastic defect disappears ( taking into account that @xmath103 ) , the elastic defect tends to doubled value of the nucleon total elastic cross section , and the deuteron total cross section comes nearer to doubled value of the nucleon total absorption cross section .
therefore , at superhigh energies the @xmath104dependence of the total cross sections in scattering from nuclei should be recovered with that only by odds that the fundamental value , standing at @xmath104 , is not the nucleon total cross section but the nucleon total absorption one .
this means that the total absorption ( inelastic ) cross section manifests itself as a fundamental dynamical quantity for the constituents in a composite system at superhigh energies . of course
, without any doubt , matching of the obtained theoretical outcomes with available experimental data on total cross sections in scattering of protons and antiprotons from deuterons represented for us the special interest . in figures 5 and 6 the preliminary results of such matching are shown .
the curves in these figures correspond to the total cross sections in scattering of protons and antiprotons from deuterons calculated by the formulas ( [ sigmad ] , [ defect ] , [ partdef ] , [ a ] ) .
there the global descriptions of @xmath105 and @xmath106 total cross sections ( see figs .
7,8 ) as well as of total single diffraction dissociation cross section in view of the latest experimental data obtained by cdf collaboration at fnal @xcite , made by us earlier @xcite , have been used .
besides in the given occasion it should be necessary still to emphasize , that the matching with experimental data on total cross sections in scattering of protons and antiprotons from deuterons was carried out , as it were , in two stages . at the first stage
the theoretical calculations were compared to experimental data on the antiproton - deuteron total cross section on the supposition , that @xmath107 is the single free parameter , which value should be determined from the fit to experimental data . as a result of a statistical analysis
the following value for the @xmath108 was obtained : @xmath109 . here
pertinently to pay attention to the following circumstance .
the last experimental measurements of the deuteron matter radius testify @xmath110 @xcite whence follows that @xmath111 .
the obtained value for @xmath112 satisfies equation @xmath113 . for entirety ,
the outcomes of theoretical calculations are represented in fig .
7 up to energies of tevatron at fnal . at the second stage
the experimental data on the proton - deuteron total cross section were compared to theoretical calculations , in which the value of @xmath108 was fixed on the numerical value , which was obtained at the first stage from the analysis of the data on @xmath114 total cross section .
in other words , the curve in fig . 8 corresponds to theoretical calculations made with the help of the formulas ( [ sigmad ] , [ defect ] , [ partdef ] , [ a ] ) , in which there was no free parameter . in this figure
the outcomes of theoretical calculations are also represented up to energies of tevatron at fnal . as is seen
, the figures 7 and 8 testify to the excellent agreement between the theory and experiment . in addition figures
9 and 10 demonstrate our global description of the proton - proton total cross section from the most low energies up to energies reachable in cosmic rays . in figure 11
the outcomes of the theoretical calculations of elastic and inelastic defects of total cross section in scattering of ( anti)protons from deuterons in energy range @xmath115 gev have been depicted .
it follows from these calculations that the value of elastic defect makes about 10% from the value of nucleon nucleon total cross section , and the value of inelastic defect makes about 10% from the value of elastic defect i.e. approximately 1% from the value of nucleon nucleon total cross section .
figuratively expressing , it would be possible to tell that if the elastic defect represents a fine structure of total cross section in scattering from deuteron then the inelastic defect should be referred to a hyperfine one . in our approach the inelastic defect is related to manifestation of fundamental three - body forces , therefore in this sense the three - body forces play a role of `` fine tuning '' in the dynamics of the relativistic three - particle system .
it is necessary to render homage to the physicists - experimenters creating setups with the accuracy of measurements permitting to discriminate inelastic defects in total cross sections of particles scattering at high energies . in this connection
the further experimental precise measurements of the hadron
deuteron total cross sections at high energies seem to be extremely important as it was already mentioned above the maximum value of inelastic defect is achieved at @xmath116 ( @xmath117 ) . or
else , the value of energy corresponding to maximum value of the inelastic defect is defined from the equation @xmath118 .
the calculations made in view of our analysis of existing experimental data give @xmath119 . reevaluating c.m .
energy @xmath120 to the lab .
system one obtains @xmath121 .
it is obvious , that such values of energies are not accessible on current and design accelerators
. however it would be extremely interesting to look for manifestations of the given effect in phenomena related with extremely high energy cosmic rays .
the theoretically calculated inelastic defect in the region of a maximum is shown in figure 12 . as it follows from eq .
( [ sigmad ] ) a maximum of the inelastic defect corresponds to a minimum of the total cross section .
we have plotted in figure 13 the ( anti)proton deuteron total cross section scaled by the factor @xmath122 in the region of a maximum of the inelastic defect .
the scale factor is selected _ ad arbitrium _ for a goal of illustration only to discern a minimum in the total cross section .
let s remark , however , that the value @xmath123 has clear physical meaning , it separates two ranges on energy : the range of energies @xmath124 , at which effective radius of three - body forces does not exceed size of a deuteron or more exactly @xmath125 , and the range of energies @xmath126 , at which effective radius of three - body forces becomes more than size of a deuteron @xmath127 .
the existence of boundary @xmath128 , since which there is a suppression of inelastic defect , seems to be the extremely important characteristic of fundamental dynamics . here
we would like to make a conjecture that the observed structures in the cosmic rays spectra , in particular a minimum in the uhecr spectrum , might be related with the existence of such boundary . from the glauber formula ( [ deltasigmag ] ) it follows , that with decrease of inter - nucleon distance in a deuteron the value of elastic defect grows .
but the configurations with small inter - nucleon distances in a deuteron are most favorable for a manifestation of purely three - particle interaction .
when effective interaction radius of an incident hadron with a nucleon becomes comparable with inter - nucleon distance , the pattern of elastic rescattering on nucleons of a deuteron ceases to be adequate to complete pattern of interaction with a deuteron . in this case
it is also necessary to take into account purely three - particle forces .
it is obvious , that in a deuteron the configurations are dynamically probable , when the nucleons are close from each other , but the glauber theory does not allow to take into account such configurations .
account of such configurations demands a more detailed study of the dynamics of processes of scattering from a deuteron .
the technique of the dynamic equations in a quantum field theory , which we have used , just allows to carry out such detailed investigations .
once again it should be emphasized , that the important role in our researches was assigned to conceptual notion of fundamental three - body forces which with necessity arise by consistent consideration of the dynamics of three particles system within the framework of a relativistic quantum theory .
the relation of fundamental three - body forces with dynamics of one - particle inclusive reactions represents the important outcome obtained , as it were , by the way .
this outcome especially is important , that can form the basis both for elaboration of methods of analytical calculations and for a different sort of phenomenological analysis . the comparison of the theory with experimental data on ( anti)proton deuteron total cross sections made shows , that for the description of particles scattering from a deuteron at high energies it is enough to take into account only nucleon degrees of freedom in a deuteron .
the weakly bounded two - nucleon system the deuteron looks so , that the clusterization of quarks in nucleons is not broken even then , when the nucleons approach closely to each other .
nucleons , being close from each other in a deuteron , do not lose of the individuality and consequently there is no necessity to introduce the six - quark configurations depersonalized in a deuteron .
the structure derived for the defect of total cross section in scattering from a deuteron corresponds to such pattern .
we managed to show , that the general formalism of quantum field theory admits a possibility of representation of dynamics of a particle scattering from composite system through the fundamental dynamics of a particle scattering from isolated constituents and structure of the composite system itself .
though the dynamics of a particle scattering from two - particle bound system a deuteron was considered in details , the general formalism used admits a natural generalization and extension to more complex multiparticle compound nuclear systems . certainly , the complexity of consideration , at that , substantially increases .
really , to consider the problem of scattering from nucleus consisting of @xmath104 nucleons we have to solve many - body problem for ( @xmath129)particle system .
however , instead of solving this very complicated problem one could use a powerful reduction method .
for this goal let s consider a nucleus consisting of @xmath104 nucleons as a bound system of one nucleon and nucleus consisting of ( @xmath130 ) nucleons .
in that case the problem of scattering from a nucleus with @xmath104 nucleons is reduced to the problem of scattering from a two - body bound system which has been previously solved .
of course such supposition is not unique and should be considered as a some sort of simplification . in the other way one could suppose that a nucleus consisting of @xmath104 nucleons may be represented as a two - body bound system of a nucleus with @xmath131 nucleons and other nucleus with @xmath132 nucleons so that @xmath133 . by this way the problem of scattering from a nucleus with @xmath104 nucleons is also reduced to the problem of scattering from a `` deuteron '' previously solved . anyway continuing a reduction in both cases
we will come at a final stage to the expression for total cross section in scattering from a nucleus in terms of fundamental dynamics in scattering from a nucleon and the structure of a nucleus .
formula ( [ sigmad ] ) for total cross section in a case of scattering from any nucleus with @xmath104 nucleons can be rewritten in the form @xmath134 where @xmath135 is the total cross sections in scattering from nucleon .
the defect @xmath136 , in general , also contains two parts as in eq .
( [ defect ] ) @xmath137 where @xmath138 is elastic defect , and @xmath139 is inelastic one . from general point of view , as presented above , for the elastic and inelastic defects one can write @xmath140 where @xmath141 the functions @xmath142 and @xmath143 are called the elastic and inelastic structure functions of a nucleus . here
we have included the combinatorial factors in the definition of the structure functions .
@xmath144 is the nucleus radius defined by the nucleus formfactor .
the scaled variables @xmath145 and @xmath146 are defined as @xmath80 and @xmath81 above but with another scale factor @xmath144 which is the radius of a nucleus as it should be .
it is obviously that formulas ( [ defectnucl ] ) and ( [ partdefnucl ] ) may serve as a base to experimentally study the structure functions @xmath142 and @xmath143 by measuring the defect of total cross section in scattering from nuclei with using the experimental information about elastic cross section and total cross section of single diffraction dissociation in scattering from a nucleon . to calculate the structure functions @xmath142 and @xmath143 is a task of any theory or theoretical model . as mentioned above the calculation of the structure functions @xmath142 and @xmath143 in quantum field theory is a very complicated problem
however , it would reasonably to use our experience acquired in solution of this problem for deuteron case . really , it seems to a good approximation , one could use the following expressions for the structure functions @xmath142 and @xmath143 of any nucleus @xmath147 here we have applied the identity @xmath148 and supposed that any many - fold rescattering in a nucleus feels one and the same structure function like for two - fold rescattering .
it is clear that this supposition is a strong enough simplification , however , it might be precise one at ultra - high energies . at any rate , it would be very desired to test such simple pattern in ultra - high energy cosmic rays . for the effective radius of three - nucleon forces obtained in our previous investigations one can write the following analytical expression @xmath149\ , { \rm gev}^{-2},\quad ( { s_0})^{1/2}=20.74 \,{\rm gev}.\ ] ]
then the equation @xmath150 , defining a value of energy at a maximum of the inelastic defect , has an obvious solution @xmath151^{1/2}.\ ] ] further , if we put as @xmath152 , then eq . ( [ smax_a ] ) can be rewritten in the form @xmath153^{1/2}\,{\rm gev},\ ] ] where the value for the deuteron radius @xmath154 mentioned above has been used . from eq .
( [ smax_an ] ) one obtains @xmath155 here , it is interesting to note that the gzk cutoff value @xmath156 gev appears for c.m .
energy corresponding to maximum of the inelastic defect in a case of scattering from helium nucleus .
the @xmath104-dependence in position of a maximum of the inelastic defect in scattering from nuclei may have a direct link to the question on chemical composition of the cosmic rays .
an information about chemical composition of the cosmic rays can be elicited from detailed study of air showers development .
it is quite clear , for instance , that air showers produced by heavy nuclei start the development in the earth atmosphere earlier compared to protons as primaries .
the cosmic rays composition is often investigated by fitting the energy dependence of the depth into the atmosphere of maximum @xmath157 of the uhecrs - generated air showers .
in fact , @xmath157 is the atmospheric depth at which the number of particles in a shower reaches its maximum .
this quantity strongly depends on the primary energy and composition , that s why @xmath157 if often considered as the most useful observable of the air showers . at ground array detectors @xmath157 is mainly provided by measuring the muon content or more exactly the ratio of electrons to muons in air shower . in other case ,
optical fluorescent detectors allow to directly observe air shower development .
just to say qualitatively , it should be mentioned that for a given primary energy a heavier nucleus creates air shower with a higher muon content and @xmath158 is higher up in the atmosphere compared to those for a proton - generated air shower .
the higher muon content of air shower produced by heavy nucleus can be understood by the fact that it is relatively easier for charge pions to decay to muons before interacting with the medium when the shower develops higher up in the less dense atmosphere .
besides , a less energetic pions generated from heavy nucleus have a higher decay probability , therefore the muon fraction is higher in air showers produced by heavy nuclei as well by this reason .
this is clearly demonstrated in fig .
14 where the results of the kascade air shower experiment have been fitted , using the qgsjet model generator , with a composition dominated by helium nuclei and smaller contributions of proton , @xmath159o and @xmath160fe .
as can be seen from figure 15 , the iron fraction gradually decreases when changing the energy from @xmath161 to @xmath13 ev , but the fraction of lighter nuclei increases in the same interval of energies i.e. there is trend from heavy toward lighter composition in the measurements of @xmath162 .
it seems , the recent studies indicate that at the highest energies @xmath163 ev there is a significant fraction of nuclei with charge greater than unity , and less than 50% of the primary cosmic rays can be photons . in another words ,
the existing experimental data suggest that uhecrs are predominantly protons or light nuclei as for cosmic rays at much lower energies . however , due to poor statistics and large fluctuations from shower to shower the definite conclusions on the composition of the uhecrs have to await data from next generation experiments . here , we would like to emphasize that the simulation of shower development depends on the event generator used containing some model of hadronic interaction which results in further complication of data interpretation .
the major uncertainties in air shower simulation stem from the hadronic interaction models which are usually represented by empirical parameterizations , and therefore almost all hadronic models are purely phenomenological .
this is because one can not calculate soft hadronic interaction cross sections or hadronic multiparticle production within qcd from first principles .
the second major source of uncertainty is the large extrapolation ( over 6 orders of magnitude in energy ) from accelerator experimental data to the uhecrs ones . in this place
the reliable model and the precise accelerator data on fundamental , for example hadron - proton , total cross sections as well as on total cross sections in scattering from nuclei are needed to constrain uncertainties in the interpretation of cosmic rays data to accurately determine the energy spectrum and the composition of the uhecrs .
additionally , theoretical understanding and description of the diffractive dissociation processes are of special importance for nuclei interactions and consequently for air shower development too .
the most popular model which has been used to simulate interactions of nucleons and nuclei is based on regge phenomenology with the super - critical pomeron exchange . however , as mentioned above , this model faced with a serious difficulties in description of single diffractive dissociation in @xmath10 collisions .
moreover , the super - critical pomeron model breaks the fundamental principles of relativistic quantum theory such as unitarity , and this fact is often overlooked .
but only this pathology of the super - critical pomeron model is enough to reject the model from consideration .
recent accurate and complete analysis of experimental data on hadron total cross sections rejects this model from statistical point of view .
another , and sometime neglected , source of uncertainties is uncertainty provided by the measurements of @xmath10 total cross sections performed at tevatron .
really , the cdf collaboration @xcite obtained @xmath164 mb which is considerably greater than those reported by e710 ( @xmath165 mb ) @xcite and e811 ( @xmath166 mb ) @xcite .
such difference in the measurements permits of a wide range of different extrapolations .
of course , the arising uncertainty directly transfers to predictions for air showers .
namely , the main source of uncertainty of air shower predictions comes from differences in modelling hadronic interactions which can not be eliminated by existing accelerator data . that is why an accurate measurement of the @xmath105 total cross section at lhc is of great importance since it would allow to discriminate the different extrapolations and to make a selection among currently used models .
the study of @xmath167 ( proton - nucleus ) collisions for the light nuclei at lhc is also of greatest interest , of course , not only for fundamental particle physics but for air shower physics as well .
at the same time it s quite clear , that quantum field theory provides a sound theoretical basis with a definite guidelines how the fundamental interactions evolve with energy . in this respect the discussed here global description of the hadron total cross sections performed in the framework of general structures of local quantum field theory keeps a preferable place .
thus an incorporation of the global pattern of hadronic interactions in generally used generators of events would be extremely desired .
the next widely discussed subject is the question of origin of cosmic rays .
although cosmic ray particles were discovered almost one hundred years ago since the first announcement of their observation in 1912 @xcite , the problem of origin of cosmic rays especially of uhecrs particles has no solution so far . the total cosmic rays spectrum is shown in fig . 16 .
the commonly accepted point of view is that at energies below 1 gev the cosmic rays spectrum is dominated by particles coming from the sun because the intensities at such energies are correlated with the solar activity . at higher energies between 1 gev and up to the knee region ( see fig .
16 ) there are several arguments including energetics that an origin of the cosmic rays is outside the solar system but confines yet to the galaxy . at still higher energies between the knee and the ankle , and
finally , beyond @xmath168 ev the situation becomes unclear , although the uhecrs are generally expected to have an extragalactic origin due to apparent isotropy , and the ankle is sometimes interpreted as a cross over from galactic to extragalactic component . at any rate
, it is generally believed that the bulk of the cosmic rays observed at the earth is of extra - solar origin .
here we would like to suggest quite another new idea that the bulk of the cosmic rays observed at the earth is of solely solar origin .
in particular , the uhecrs particles coming to the atmosphere of the earth might be produced by reaction @xmath169 where we have used the notations : @xmath170 for galactic or extra - galactic uhecrs particle , @xmath171 for the sun , @xmath172 for uhecrs particle coming to the atmosphere of the earth from the sun .
due to reaction ( [ uhecrprod ] ) almost all energy of @xmath170 particle is transferred to @xmath172 particle .
the idea is based on the fact that the cross section of reaction ( [ uhecrprod ] ) is in 4 orders greater than the cross section of direct interaction of @xmath170 particle with the earth .
of course , we did not concern of what is the source of the uhecrs in the universe , one only claims that uhecrs particles coming to the atmosphere of the earth are produced on the sun . in this respect
we would like to remind an old idea suggested in @xcite to consider the virgo cluster as a source of the uhecrs . according to this idea the uhecrs particles , generated in m87 galaxy in virgo cluster , diffuse from the center of virgo in a postulated extragalactic field with the energy dependent diffusion coefficient , and they are focusing to the sun by galactic magnetic field .
it is remarkable that there is no gzk cutoff , and there is no large anisotropy in the model .
recently a new revival of this very interesting idea has been proposed . introducing a simple galactic wind in analogy to solar wind
it has been shown @xcite that back - tracing the orbits of the highest energy cosmic rays events suggests that they may all come from the virgo cluster , probably from the active radio galaxy m87 .
figure 17 shows the directions of the cosmic rays events at that point when they leave the halo of our galaxy in polar projection . in fig .
17 the direction to the active galaxy m87 ( virgo a ) , which is the dominant radio galaxy in the virgo cluster , is pointed out as well for reference .
the two highest energy events are shown in fig .
17 twice : in assuming ( i ) that they are protons , and ( ii ) that they are helium nuclei ( filled black symbols ) . the shaded band in fig
. 17 corresponds to the supergalactic plane .
a remarkable observation made in the model calculations is that the directions of all tracks point north @xcite . with exception of two events with highest energy ,
all other 11 events can be traced to within less @xmath173 from virgo a. considering the uncertainty of the actual magnetic field distribution , it was found that all events are consistent with arising originally from virgo a. besides , if the two highest energy events are really helium nuclei , then all 13 events point within 20 degrees of virgo a. of course , it is very interesting that the simple model for a galactic wind rather similar to the solar wind may allow particle orbits at @xmath13 ev to be bent sufficiently to allow `` trans - gzk '' particles to arrive to the sun from virgo from different directions in agreement with the apparent isotropy in arrival directions .
if the model assumptions might be confirmed then all powerful radio - galaxies might be considered as sources of the uhecrs . in that case
the fantastic idea arises to use the powerful radio - galaxies as gigantic accelerators to set up particle interaction experiments in the sky @xcite .
the sun may be used as a target , the atmosphere of the earth as a calorimeter to detect the highest energy events .
we did not intend in this article to present a full understanding the cosmic rays observations .
really we have only concerned very special but at the same time quite intriguing observation related to absence ( gzk puzzle ) of the predicted catastrophic cutoff ( gzk effect ) of the uhecrs spectrum at energy value about @xmath13 ev . without any doubt , an observation of a significant flux of uhecrs particles with energy above the expected gzk cutoff value is of great interest , and many attempts have been undertaken to explain the existence of such particles . as mentioned above an explanation of these particles requires the existence of extremely powerful sources within so called gzk sphere with the radius about a few tens mpc .
there is evidence that such powerful radio - galaxies may really exist although this fact should be clearly confirmed by future experiments with the higher statistics .
it should be fair to note that there is a controversial point of view which means that there are no particles with energy above the gzk cutoff value , but the present results of agasa and others , where such particles have been observed , are artefact of a combination of incorrect energy calibration , larger than predicted fluctuations in shower development , non gaussian tail in measurements etc .
we did not touch this point of view at all .
but here it should be pointed out the recent article of the hires collaboration @xcite where the hires measurement of the flux of ultrahigh energy cosmic rays with fluorescence technique shows a suppression at an energy of @xmath174ev , exactly the expected cutoff energy . the statistical significance of the break in the spectrum identified with the gzk cutoff is @xmath175 .
the measured energy of the cutoff is @xmath176ev , where the first uncertainty is statistical and the second is systematic . at the same time
teshima ( for agasa collaboration ) @xcite presented at the international conference on high energy physics ichep2006 ( moscow , russia , july 26august 2 , 2006 ) a new ( preliminary ) agasa reanalysis with recent corsika m.c . in which the number of events above @xmath13ev was reduced from 11 to 5@xmath146 , and the flux difference between agasa and hires became less significant .
nevertheless the main conclusion in summary of the talk given by teshima has been unchanged : `` super gzk particles exist '' .
this means that the gzk puzzle exists as well .
in fact , the new ( preliminary ) agasa data extend beyond the gzk cutoff energy with no apparent suppression and probably without dip and bump .
however , it should be noted that the combined agasa&hires data presented in fig .
18 ( fig . 3 from ref .
@xcite ) clearly show the dip structure at the gzk cutoff energy as mentioned in the introduction .
we also did not concern any exotic models to explain the existence of `` trans - gzk '' particles . among them
there are the so called `` z - burst '' scenario , top - down models , and even super - exotic explanation due to violation of lorenz invariance ; see e.g. excellent review article @xcite and references therein .
our conjecture is the attempt to find the solution of the gzk puzzle in the fundamental dynamics of scattering from nuclei .
certainly , it needs to do much work else to convert the conjecture into strong statement . at the same time
it is expected that next generation experiments in astrophysics , especially in cosmic rays physics , will be able to yield significant new information about fundamental processes in particle physics . here
the measurement of the uhecrs spectrum beyond the gzk cutoff is of great importance because such measurements being a grand element of cosmic rays physics has a very deep relation with particle physics .
it seems the upcoming researches of particle interactions ( in the sky and on the earth ) promise to represent the near future as an exciting epoch in science when the three branches of science cosmology , astrophysics and particle physics are very probably to be combined into unique common fundamental science such as cosmoastropartphysology or casp - physics .
certainly , we believe in it . * * j. linsley , phys .
lett . , * 10 * , 146 ( 1963 ) m. takeda _ et al . _ , astropart . phys .
* 19 * , 447 ( 2003 ) a.a . penzias , r.w .
wilson , astrophys .
j. * 142 * , 419 ( 1965 ) k. greisen , phys .
* 16 * , 748 ( 1966 ) g.t .
zatsepin , v.a .
kuzmin , jetp lett .
* 4 * , 78 ( 1966 ) p.g .
roll , d.t .
wilkinson , phys .
lett . , * 16 * , 405 ( 1966 ) review of particle physics , phys . lett .
b*592 * , 320 ( 2004 ) t. stanev , arxiv : hep - ph/0411113 ( 2004 ) .
stecker , j. phys .
g*20 * , r47 ( 2003 ) ; arxiv : astro - ph/0309027 .
tkachev , j. mod .
a*18 * , 91 ( 2003 ) .
glauber , phys .
rev . * 100 * , 242 ( 1955 ) ; lectures in theoretical physics , interscience , new york , v. 1 , p. 315
- 414 , 1959 .
gribov , sov .
jetp , * 56 * , 892 ( 1969 ) .
g. alberi , f. baldracchini , nucl .
b*138 * , 164 ( 1978 ) ; preprint ref.th.2443-cern .
et al _ ( cdf ) , phys .
rev . d*50 * , 5535 ( 1994 ) .
a.m. cooper - sarkar et al . , preprint desy 97 - 226 , arxiv : hep - ph/9712301 .
k. goulianos , j. montanha , phys .
rev . d*59 * , 114017 ( 1999 ) ; arxiv : hep - ph/9805496 .
e. gostman , e.m .
levin , u. maor , phys .
d*49 * , r4321 ( 1994 ) .
arkhipov , _ what can we learn from the study of single diffractive dissociation at high energies ? _ talk presented at the international conference on elastic and diffracrive scattering , protvino , russia , june 28july 2 , 1999 , in proceedings of viiith blois workshop , p. 109
, world scientific , singapore , 2000 ; preprint ihep 99 - 43 , protvino , 1999 ; arxiv : hep - ph/9909531 ( 1999 ) .
arkhipov , _ fifty years of the glauber diffraction theory _ ,
arxiv : physics/0512254 .
arkhipov , _ diffraction 2000 : new scaling laws in shadow dynamics _ , nucl .
* 99a * , 72 ( 2001 ) ; arxiv : hep - ph/0011220 .
arkhipov , _ three - body forces , single diffraction dissociation and shadow corrections in hadron - deuteron total cross sections _ , preprint ihep 2000 - 59 , protvino , 2000 , available at http://dbserv.ihep.su/ pubs / prep2000/ps/2000 - 59.pdf ; arxiv : hep - ph/0012349 ( 2000 ) ; in proceedings of xvth workshop on high energy physics and quantum field theory , tver , russia , september 7 - 13 , 2000 , eds
. m. dubinin , v. savrin , institute of nuclear physics , moscow state university , russia , 2001 , pp .
241 - 257 .
f. schmidt - kaler et al . , phys .
rev . lett . * 70 * , 2261 ( 1993 ) .
arkhipov , _ proton - proton total cross sections from the window of cosmic ray experiments _ , preprint ihep 2001 - 23 , protvino , 2001 ; e - print hep - ph/0108118 ; in proceedings of ixth blois workshop on elastic and diffractive scattering , pruhonice near prague , czech republic , june 9 - 15 , 2001 , eds .
v. kundrat , p. zavada , institute of physics , prague , czech republic , 2002 , pp .
293 - 304 .
arkhipov , _ on a manifestation of dibaryon resonances in the structure of proton - proton total cross section at low energies _ , preprint ihep 2001 - 44 , protvino , 2001 ; e - print hep - ph/0110399 ; in proceedings of the ninth international conference on hadron spectroscopy , protvino , russia , 25 august-1 september , 2001 , eds .
d. amelin et al . , melville , new york , 2002 , aip conference proceedings , vol .
771 - 776 .
f. abe et al . , ( cdf collab . ) phys .
rev . d*50 * , 5550 ( 1994 ) .
amos et al . , ( e710 collab . ) phys .
b243 , 158 ( 1990 ) .
c. avila et al . ,
( e811 collab . )
b445 , 419 ( 1999 ) .
hess , phys .
z. * 13 * , 1804 ( 1912 ) .
cronin , t.k .
gaisser , s.p .
swordy , sci .
* 276 * , 44 ( 1997 ) .
j. wdowczyk , a.w .
wolfendale , nature * 281 * , 356 ( 1979 ) ; + m. giller , j. wdowczyk and a.w .
wolfendale , j. phys .
* 6 * , 1561 ( 1980 ) .
eun - joo ahn et al . , _ the origin of the highest energy cosmic rays : do all roads lead back to virgo ? _ , arxiv : astro - ph/9911123 ; + nucl .
b(proc . suppl . )
* 87 * , 417 ( 2000 ) .
abbasi et al . , ( hires collab . ) _ observation of the gzk cutoff by the hires experiment _ , arxiv : astro - ph/0703099 ( 2007 ) ; see also g. thomson talk presented at the international conference on high energy physics ichep2006 , moscow , russia , july 26august 2 , 2006 , available at + http://ichep06.jinr.ru/reports/50_1s4_16p50_thomson.ppt .
m. teshima , _ ultra high cosmic rays observed by agasa _ talk presented at the international conference on high energy physics ichep2006 , moscow , russia , july 26august 2 , 2006 , available at + http://ichep06.jinr.ru/reports/49_1s4_16p30_teshima.ppt .
p. bhattacharjee , g. sigl , phys .
* 327 * , 109 ( 2000 ) ; arxiv : astro - ph/9811011 .
vs @xmath177 compared with the predictions of the renormalized pomeron flux model of goulianos @xcite ( solid line ) and of the model gostman , levin and maor @xcite ( dashed line , labelled glm).,title="fig:"][fig4 ] ( 288,188 ) ( 15,10 ) with the cosmic - ray data points from akeno observatory and fly s eye collaboration .
solid line corresponds to our theory predictions @xcite.,title="fig:"][fig9 ] ( 144,0)@xmath178 ( -5,95 ) | the conjecture that the gzk puzzle might be related with nontrivial structure of the inelastic defect of total cross sections in scattering from nuclei has been suggested . *
the gzk puzzle and fundamental dynamics * + a. a. arkhipov + _ state research center
institute for high energy physics " + 142281 protvino , moscow region , russia _ + |
in nano - electronics , quantitative evaluation of impurity effects is crucial because device properties are strongly influenced by or even built on such effects .
experimentally , the impurities exist and can be doped in nano - devices without knowing their exact locations , so theoretically it is important to predict the averaged transport quantities such as conductance over impurity configurations . the most direct way to obtain the averaged conductance is to generate many different configurations , then calculate the conductance for each configuration , and finally take the mean value .
such a brute - force method is usually used in the mesoscopic systems from diffusive regime to localized regime because it is an exact calculation .
but in order to get good statistics , huge number of configurations has to be generated making it very time - consuming especially for the calculation of conductance fluctuation . when the disorder strength is weak , it is not necessary to use the brute - force method since some analytic approximate method is superior in speed while maintaining the same accuracy . for
this purpose considerable effort has been made to develop approximate techniques , within which the most widely used technique is the coherent potential approximation ( cpa ) , which is a useful tool to evaluate the configurational averaged one - electron green s function@xcite @xmath6 , and has also been extended to determine the so - called
vertex corrections"@xcite for quantities involving two green s functions .
cpa approach has been implemented in the korringa - kohn - rostoker@xcite and linear muffin - tin orbital@xcite for first principles calculations and has many successful applications@xcite .
the central idea of cpa is to find a
coherent potential " such that the one - electron green s function evaluated under such potential approximately equals the configurational averaged green s function . as an extension , cpa can also be used to determine the so - called
vertex corrections"@xcite for the product of two green s functions .
later , levin _ et al _ also proposed an elegant diagrammatic method to evaluate the hall coefficient which relates to the direct multiple of three green s functions@xcite .
importantly , the cpa approach and its extensions can be combined with local - orbital based dft to calculate the physical properties , such as the band structure and the density of states , of realistic materials .
one example is the development of the so called kkr - cpa " , used to study the band structure and density of states of cu - ni@xcite , ag - pd@xcite , and cu - pd@xcite alloys .
the linear muffin - tin orbital ( lmto ) method has also been proposed@xcite and used to study the electronic structures of metal alloys@xcite .
cpa combined with lmto works very well and has many successful applications .
examples are the investigation of transport properties in disordered magnetic multilayers@xcite , structure of sn - ge alloys@xcite , the electronic structure of non - stoichiometric compounds@xcite , and doped semiconductors@xcite .
the latest development of cpa extended its range of application to non - equilibrium quantum transport problems where impurity average has to be performed .
one prominent work is the non - equilibrium vertex correction " ( nvc ) discussed in ref .
. it has been shown by zhuravlev _
_ et al.__@xcite that this nvc formalism can be interpreted in terms of the bttiker voltage - probe model so that it is not merely a correction to the electronic structure.@xcite generally speaking , this site - oriented algorithm to evaluate the average conductance is well developed and adopted by different groups.@xcite in the presence of disorder cpa - nvc approach allows one to calculate non - equilibrium transport properties such as i - v curve and other quantities involving two green s functions .
however , it can not be applied directly to investigate equilibrium transport properties involving four green s functions such as conductance fluctuation and shot noise . since the fluctuation of transport properties of nano - devices , known as `` variation '' of nano - devices , is a very important quantity in nano - electronics and it provides the information on how much the specific device configuration could deviate from the mean value .
we notice that a quantified experiment has been reported to measure such kind of fluctuation@xcite recently .
therefore , it is timely to develop a theoretical formalism that is capable of treating disorder average of four green s functions . to the best of our knowledge , so far this is still an outstanding problem yet to solve based on cpa approach .
one possible reason is that , the nvc could be regarded as a perturbation expansion approach based on cpa to evaluate the conductance by including the ladder diagrams . for conductance fluctuation ,
however , such a partial summation is not good enough . in this paper
, we develop a direct perturbation expansion with respect to the single - site - t - matrix " up to a given order which is a good approximation for weak disorder strength or small doping concentration .
we carry out benchmark calculation of average conductance , shot noise , and conductance fluctuation using the direct expansion method on a graphene system and a two - dimensional lattice model with anderson impurities as well as random dopants .
we have compared our results with the brute - force calculation .
we find that a six - order expansion can give very good results for conductance fluctuation and shot noise when disorder strength @xmath0 is comparable to the hopping strength @xmath2 , @xmath7 . in the presence of doping
, our results also show good agreement with that obtained from brute - force method at low doping concentration .
we note that our method can be easily implemented in the first principles transport calculation in nanostructures .
the rest of this paper is organized as the following . in section
ii , we briefly revisit cpa formalism and introduce our direct expansion approach to calculate disorder average of four green s functions . an expansion view on nvc method
is also provided . in section iii ,
we compare our results with that obtained from the brute - force method on a graphene system and square lattice of size @xmath8 for two types of disorder : anderson disorder and different doping concentration .
the results for average conductance , shot noise@xcite , and the conductance fluctuation are also presented .
finally we conclude our work in section [ conclusion ] .
we consider a tight - binding mode on a square lattice model described by the following hamiltonian : @xmath9 where @xmath2 is the nearest neighbor hopping energy and @xmath10 and @xmath11 are electron annihilation and creation operators on atomic site @xmath12 respectively .
we choose @xmath13 as the energy unit .
the on - site energy chosen as @xmath14 is a convention that the energy bottom of the 2d band structure to be zero .
we also assume that the structure of the left and right leads has a similar interaction .
the effect of leads can be taken into account by self - energy@xcite @xmath15 for the left and @xmath16 for the right .
the self - energy of leads can be calculated numerically@xcite .
although the hamiltonian in eq.([h_cent ] ) is very simple , our direct expansion in principle can handle more complicated hamiltonians as long as it only contains single particle interactions .
it is also straightforward to generalize our approach to the case of multi - orbital per site .
here we consider diagonal disorder"@xcite with disorder strength @xmath17 on @xmath12th atomic site .
different types of disorder can be described by introducing a probability function " for @xmath17 .
we consider two different types of disorder .
one is anderson disorder " with the probability function given by @xmath18 where @xmath19 is called the strength of anderson disorder .
another is to dope the system with different type of atom : @xmath20 here @xmath21 is the doping concentration , and @xmath22 is the energy difference between the dopant and the original atom . in the theoretical formalism we can general types of diagonal disorder including these two types of disorder . in this subsection
, we revisit the well - developed single - site cpa " , because this is the starting point of our direct expansion approach .
cpa is an approximation to evaluate the averaged single - particle retarded or advanced green s function ( @xmath23 or @xmath24 ) , and it is known to be good in homogeneous ensembles@xcite . in realistic nano - devices with small concentration
, it has been shown that the nvc which based on cpa also works very well.@xcite . in cpa approximation ,
the disorder effect renormalizes the on - site energy by adding a coherent potential " @xmath25 on each atomic site , such that @xmath26 where @xmath27 denotes equilibrium green s function in the absence of disorder and can be expressed as @xmath28^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] in which @xmath29 is the total self - energy due to the leads , and @xmath30 is a infinitesimal positive number . for a given disorder configuration , the green s function @xmath31 is related to @xmath27 by a
t - matrix " , @xmath32 in which the t - matrix " is used to describe one specific disorder configuration , and it can also be understood as the irreducible " self - energy induced by the disorder . taking configurational average on both sides , and compare with eq.([cpa_equation ] ) , we require @xmath33 however , to implement cpa , we need a further approximation , which is usually referred as weak overall scattering approximation " or single - site approximation " , and either of them can lead to the cpa condition : @xmath34 where @xmath35 is a matrix with only one non - vanishing element @xmath36 and @xmath37^{-1}-(g_e^r)_{ii}\}^{-1}$ ] . taking average on t - matrix
, we have @xmath38^{-1}-g_{e , ii}^r}=0\ ] ] from which the self - consistent equation for @xmath39 can be obtained @xcite @xmath40}.\ ] ] this equation is easy to converge . with the definition of the linewidth function , @xmath41 , we can define the transmission matrix @xmath42 .
the averaged conductance ( set @xmath43 ) is defined as @xmath44 , and the averaged dc shot noise is proportional to @xmath45 , while the conductance fluctuation reads @xmath46 ^ 2\rangle-\langle\mathrm{tr}(\mathcal{t})\rangle^2}$ ] .
the averaged conductance is usually calculated within the nvc approximation .
while the shot noise and conductance fluctuation involve four green s function and nvc approach can not apply here .
our direct expansion approach is to expand them according to eq.([tmat ] ) , together with the t - matrix expansion with respect to single - site - t - matrix @xmath35 as the following : @xmath47 notice that the multiple summation in eq.([tmat_expansion ] ) requires that the successive index should not be the same . plugging this expansion into the expression of conductance fluctuation or shot noise and
generate all the diagrams up to a certain order in @xmath48 and then store them once for all .
here we think @xmath48 is a natural expansion parameter because it describes the on - site scattering and it is a small quantity under small disorder strength and low doping concentration .
with all the diagram generated , the average value of shot noise and conductance fluctuation can be calculated for different systems numerically .
considering the @xmath49 term in the dc shot noise that involves the average of four green s functions @xmath50 , we substitute eq.([tmat ] ) into this expression and it generates several terms up to the fourth order in t - matrix . the terms with only one t - matrix vanish due to eq.([general_cpa_condition ] ) . in the following
we illustrate how to use direct expansion method to generate diagrams for the other terms involving multi - t - matrices . as an example
, one typical term containing three t - matrices is @xmath51 .
we focus on the average part @xmath52 , where @xmath53 and @xmath54 are independent of randomness .
we expand this average using eq.([tmat_expansion ] ) and truncate the resulting series to a certain order in @xmath48 ( we have obtained 8th order ) .
for this three t - matrices term the lowest order in @xmath48 is three because there is no zero - order term in eq.([tmat_expansion ] ) , and all higher order terms ( we will call them diagrams from now on ) in @xmath48 up to our target order can be generated .
_ symbolically _ , we write @xmath55 = \sum_{n , m , l } c_{n , m , l } ( t_i^r)^n ( t_j^a)^m ( t_k^r)^l\ ] ] this equation is symbolic so there is no summation over site indices i , j , and k. here @xmath56 represents all the diagrams with the same order of @xmath57 in @xmath58 ( @xmath59 ) contributed from different site indices i , j , k .
since @xmath48 is a matrix and does not commute with @xmath60 , we have to keep both indices @xmath61 .
obviously , we need to find two things : ( 1 ) how many combinations of @xmath57 we have ; ( 2 ) how many diagrams are there for a particular @xmath57 due to different site indices @xmath62 . for instance
, up to the 6th order ( @xmath63 ) , we have @xmath64 , @xmath65 along with all their permutations and @xmath66 , totally 10 different combinations .
@xmath56 can be calculated by counting different combinations of @xmath62 and for @xmath67 it is obtained from the following expression , @xmath68\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is a six - multiple summation and can be handled using single - site cpa .
the evaluation of disorder average of eq.([expand_2 ] ) seems to be impossible .
however , we note that each @xmath48 is a matrix with only one matrix element ( it becomes a diagonal block matrix in the multi - orbital case , e.g. , if spin - orbit interaction is considered ) , as in eq.([ti_component ] ) .
this simplifies calculation drastically .
in addition , the cpa condition eq.([cpa_condition ] ) , indicates that if the summation index appears only once , the average vanishes .
so we have to find out all possible combinations of those six site indices , and there are many possibilities .
for example , we can have @xmath69 , and this combination gives the following contribution to eq.([expand_2 ] ) @xmath70\rangle \nonumber \\ & & = \sum'_{ijk}(x_1)_{ii } ( g_e^a)_{ij } ( g_e^a)_{jk } ( x_2)_{kk } ( g_e^r)_{kj } ( x_3)_{ji } \nonumber \\ & & \times \langle\tau_i^r\tau_i^a\rangle\langle \tau_j^r\tau_j^a\rangle\langle\tau_k^r\tau_k^a\rangle,%|i\rangle\langle j|,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the prime on top of @xmath71 means the indices in the summation are mutually different and @xmath72 is defined after eq.([ti_component ] ) .
another possible combination is @xmath73 which gives @xmath74 alternatively , we can have a much simpler diagrammatic representation of our expansion on the averaged shot noise .
this representation is very similar to that of levin @xcite . as an example , eq.([t3_eg1 ] )
can be diagrammatically expressed as fig.[diagram_shotnoise](a ) while the diagram corresponding to eq.([t3_eg2 ] ) is shown in fig.[diagram_shotnoise](b ) .
the thick lines in diagrams of fig.[diagram_shotnoise ] represent the known matrix @xmath75 , and the black dots represent the single site t - matrix @xmath48 .
diagrammatically , expansion up to sixth order means that we only take into account those diagrams with the number of such black dots less than six .
the thin line between two black dots represents either @xmath27 or @xmath76 , depending on the configuration .
the site indices such as @xmath12 , @xmath77 and @xmath78 should be different one from another , and we should also keep in mind that the indices of two ends of a thin line can not be identical , from eq.([tmat_expansion ] ) .
furthermore , we have to connect the repeated site indices with the dashed lines , like fig.[diagram_shotnoise](d ) when we have four t matrices . by constructing such a diagrammatic rule ,
our expansion can be carried out by finding all the topologically distinct diagrams in which the number of black dots(single site t - matrix ) is not more than six .
numerically , this procedure can be implemented by computer from which we can calculate the average conductance and shot noise . ) .
( b ) the diagram corresponding to eq.([t3_eg2 ] ) .
( c ) examples of other sixth order diagrams on @xmath79 terms .
( d ) examples of sixth order diagrams on @xmath80 terms .
, width=288,height=172 ] comparing with the averaged shot noise discussed in the last subsection , the calculation of conductance fluctuation is different .
this is because the shot noise contains one trace while the conductance fluctuation has two traces as can be seen below , @xmath81 ^ 2\rangle = \langle\mathrm{tr}[g^r\gamma_l g^a\gamma_r]\mathrm{tr}[g^r\gamma_l g^a\gamma_r]\rangle.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we still use the same idea as that of shot noise , we will find the calculation becomes more complicated because we can only write the above equation as @xmath81 ^ 2\rangle = \sum_{ij}\langle(g^r\gamma_l g^a\gamma_r)_{ii}(g^r\gamma_l g^a\gamma_r)_{jj}\rangle\notag\\ = \sum_{ij}\langle\mathrm{tr}[g^r\gamma_l g^a\gamma_r p^{ij } g^r\gamma_l g^a\gamma_r p^{ji}]\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] in which the matrix @xmath82 is the extremely sparse matrix with only one non - zero element , @xmath83 .
it turns out that the mean value of @xmath84 will cost a factor of @xmath85 to the time scale as to evaluate shot noise .
even if we take into account from physics the propagation modes@xcite , @xmath86 , we still have @xmath87 ^ 2\rangle \notag \\ = & & \sum_{mn}\langle\mathrm{tr}[g^r\gamma_l g^a s^{mn } g^r\gamma_l g^a ( s^{mn})^\dagger]\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath88 represents the @xmath89th non - evanescent mode of right lead and @xmath90 is defined as @xmath91 . in this case , the factor of the computational cost is the square of the number of the non - evanescent modes , still difficult .
however , in our direct expansion approach , we can get rid of this difficulty by taking the advantage of the property of @xmath48 , eq.([ti_component ] ) , see below . as before ,
we substitute eq.([tmat_expansion ] ) into the above equation and expand it in terms of t - matrix . here
we take the term involving four t - matrices as an example , which is @xmath92\mathrm{tr}[g_e^rt^rg_e^r\gamma_l g_e^at^ag_e^a\gamma_r]\rangle\\ & & = \langle\mathrm{tr}[t^r x_1 t^a x_2]\mathrm{tr}[t^r x_1 t^a x_2]\rangle.\end{aligned}\ ] ] up to the sixth - order in @xmath48 , there are many diagrams with different ways of contraction for site indices . now considering a particular diagram ( 12,21 ) where the first two indices are in the first trace and the second two are in the second trace and a specific index contraction @xmath93 as an example , fig.([fluct_diagram_1221 ] )
, whose contribution is @xmath94\mathrm{tr}[t_k^r g_e^r t_j^r x_1 t_k^a x_2]\rangle \nonumber \\ = & & \sum'_{ijk}(x_1)_{ii}(g_e^a)_{ij}(x_2)_{ji}(g_e^r)_{kj}(x_1)_{jk}(x_2)_{kk } \nonumber \\ \times & & \langle\tau_i^r\tau_i^a\rangle\langle\tau_j^r\tau_j^a\rangle\langle\tau_k^r\tau_k^a\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used eq.([ti_component ] ) to deal with two traces . in order to calculate the conductance fluctuation ,
we need to evaluate both @xmath95 ^ 2\rangle$ ] and @xmath95\rangle$ ] .
we notice that @xmath95\rangle$ ] can be calculated accurately using nvc while @xmath95 ^ 2\rangle$ ] can only be obtained in direct expansion .
to make sure the accuracy of conductance fluctuation , we have to treat these two terms on the equal footing and use direct expansion on both terms . as an example , if we expand @xmath96 to sixth order but still use cpa+nvc to evaluate @xmath97 , the fluctuation obtained is not very accurate . in fig.[fig1](d ) , at @xmath98 , we get @xmath99 from sixth - order expansion and @xmath100 from cpa+nvc , the fluctuation evaluated from these results is then larger than @xmath101 , which deviates from the exact result @xmath102 quite a lot
. however , our sixth - order cumulant expansion directly on fluctuation gives the result @xmath103 , better agreement compared with the exact one .
actually , in order to get the conductance fluctuation , a better way is to do cumulant expansion , which discards all the disconnected diagrams " @xcite .
the advantages of such
cumulant expansion " include the following separate aspects : 1 .
we can directly attack the fluctuation instead of expand both @xmath96 and @xmath97 , so the computational cost is reduced to nearly a half .
2 . in this way
we can naturally evaluate @xmath96 and @xmath97 on the same footing without to evaluate either of them , and also avoid the error stated in the above paragraph .
this cumulant expansion only include connected diagrams , making the physical meaning more clear because that the connected diagrams only contributes to @xmath104 , which is never needed when we concentrate on the conductance fluctuation . in our case , in one specific index combination ,
if the indices in the first trace do not connect to those in the second trace , then it is a disconnected terms .
for example , in the decomposition ( 11,22 ) , one disconnected term is @xmath105 , while @xmath106 is a connected term . to a certain order ,
the sum of all the connected terms give the square of the conductance fluctuation .
with anderson disorder and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=115 ] with anderson disorder and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=115 ] + with anderson disorder and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=115 ] with anderson disorder and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=115 ] + with @xmath4 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=111][fig2a ] with @xmath4 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=111][fig2b ] + with @xmath4 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=111][fig2c ] with @xmath4 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=111][fig2d ] + before we show the numerical results we wish to mention the computational cost of our approach .
as we can see from the algorithm , first we need to generate all the topologically inequivalent diagrams of @xmath48 up to certain order .
secondly we have to generate all the possible index contractions for a given diagram . as we go to higher order , both number of @xmath48 and the number of contractions for each @xmath48 grow exponentially .
note that due to the cpa condition , eq.([cpa_condition ] ) , a diagram does not contribute if an index appears only once .
hence each index has to appear at least twice in the summation .
thus , up to the @xmath108th order , the largest number of different indices in the summation is @xmath109 which dominates the computational cost . in general
an additional index will cost about @xmath110 times computational time , with @xmath110 being the number of atoms .
for this reason , although we have generated all the diagrams up to the 8th order in @xmath48 , we can only apply our approach to a small sized system such as a 10-by-10 system in 2d in a reasonable amount of cpu time . in this paper
, we apply our formalism to 40-by-40 and 60-by-60 systems in 2d up to 6th order in @xmath48 . below we show the results of conductance , shot noise , and conductance fluctuations where we consider anderson disorder with different disorder strength and doping with low ( 1% ) and high ( 10% ) doping concentrations .
fig.[fig1 ] - fig.[fig11 ] depict our results .
each figure has four panels . in panel
( a ) , we compare our result of average conductance expanded at different orders with that of the brute - force method ( blue circle ) . in the panel ( b )
, we compare our result up to the 6th order with results obtained from the brute - force method as well as the nvc method .
the panel ( c ) and ( d ) show the averaged shot noise and the conductance fluctuation , respectively , where we compare our results with that of brute - force method . in the brute - force calculation , we have collected @xmath111 random configurations for each data point on the curve . with @xmath112 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=113 ] with @xmath112 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=113 ] + with @xmath112 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=113 ] with @xmath112 doping concentration and fixed energy @xmath107 . ( a )
conductance , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion at different orders vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=113 ] + in fig.[fig1 ] we show the results on @xmath8 square lattice with anderson disorder .
we have fixed the fermi energy to @xmath107 where we have twenty incoming channels .
we see from fig.[fig1](a ) that up to the 4th or 5th order , our expansion result agrees with that of the brute - force method for disorder strength up to @xmath113 . for the 6th order ,
the good agreement is extended to @xmath114 .
we note that up to @xmath115 the method of nvc and brute - force give the same result ( fig.[fig1](b ) ) . for the shot noise ( fig.[fig1](c ) ) ,
the 4th and 5th orders seems to give almost the same result and up to @xmath116 good agreement is reached . for the 6th order expansion the agreement is better for @xmath0 up to 0.5 .
we see that the direct expansion method underestimate the conductance and overestimate the shot noise . for the conductance fluctuation
, the situation is different . from fig.[fig1](d ) we see that the conductance fluctuation is of order @xmath117 which is a well known result in mesoscopic physics .
it is interesting to see that the 4th order expansion is better than 5th and 6th orders .
the range of @xmath0 to have good agreement is @xmath113 .
one thing to note .
although here we benchmark our result on the lattice model with anderson disorder , the previous knowledge such as anderson localization , the universal conductance fluctuation and the percolation theory can not be expected from our approach because those physics require that the strength of disorder large enough and the system enters diffusive and even localization region , but our method can not reach that region due to its perturbative nature .
now we dope the system with a fixed impurity strength @xmath0 and two different doping concentrations .
for @xmath4 doping ( fig.[fig2 ] ) , very good agreement can be obtained for conductance among three methods : nvc , brute - force , and direct expansion up to 6th order in the window of @xmath118 .
for the shot noise and conductance fluctuation , 6th order expansion can give good agreement for @xmath0 up to 1 .
when we increase the doping concentration , our results deviate from that of the brute - force . at @xmath5 doping concentration ( fig.[fig3 ] )
we find that for average conductance , the range of @xmath0 decreases to @xmath119 while for shot noise and conductance fluctuation the agreement is not good beyond @xmath120 .
one word on the computational time . in our proposed expansion method ,
the time cost is dominated by solving the cpa self - consistent equation . as an example , for 2d 40 by 40 lattice model , 10% doping case , we need 11 steps to obtain the cpa solvent and each step 2.5 seconds .
after that , we spend approximately 40 seconds to obtain the fluctuation .
however , this time used together can only be used to calculate approximately 50 configurations , from which even the mean value can not be surely given .
as the system goes larger , our time advantages becomes more obvious .
we have also studies the average conductance , shot noise , and conductance fluctuation in a disordered graphene ribbon system of size @xmath121 with hard - wall boundary condition perpendicular to the transport direction .
here we use the simplest non - spin tight - binding hamiltonian on the honeycomb lattice , which is @xmath122 in graphene , the nearest hopping energy is @xmath123 , and we set @xmath13 as the energy unit , then both the fermi energy and and the disorder strength are measured according to it .
besides , in the above hamiltonian , @xmath124 denote the nearest neighbor hopping , with the nearest - neighbor unit vector @xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127 , and the lattice constant @xmath128 nm . in the following calculation , we fix the fermi energy @xmath129 where there are 15 incoming channels . for anderson disorder , we see from fig.[fig9 ] that for average conductance good agreement is obtained for disorder strength up to @xmath116 . for shot noise ,
however , the deviation can be seen when @xmath120 . to our surprise , the conductance fluctuation from direct expansion method is good for @xmath0 as large as 0.4
. for low doping concentration at @xmath4 , fig.[fig10 ] shows that good agreement between our method and brute - force method can be reached for average conductance and shot noise with disorder strength up to @xmath115 while for conductance fluctuation reasonable agreement is obtained for @xmath0 up to @xmath130 . for larger doping concentration ,
the agreement is good for smaller disorder strength .
for instance at @xmath5 doping ( fig.[fig11 ] ) , the average conductance is good up to @xmath131 while for shot noise and conductance fluctuation @xmath0 is about 0.4 for a reasonable agreement compared with brute - force method . .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] + .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] + .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] + .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] + .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] + .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ] .
( a ) conductance , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( b ) conductance , direct expansion up to 6th order vs brute force vs nvc .
( c ) averaged shot noise , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force .
( d ) conductance fluctuation , direct expansion up to different order vs brute force.,title="fig:",height=114 ]
in this paper , we have developed a direct expansion approach to deal with the average shot noise and the conductance fluctuation for disordered systems .
two kinds of disorder were considered : anderson disorder and the random dopant .
we have bench marked our results on a graphene system and a two dimensional square lattice model .
our results can be summarized as follows .
we find that our expansion method up to the 6th order is comparable , although not as good as nvc method for the calculation of averaged conductance .
up to the sixth order , our results of shot noise and conductance fluctuation agree well with the brute - force method for anderson impurities with disorder strength up to @xmath132 for the square lattice and @xmath133 for the graphene system . in the presence of dopant at small doping concentration ( 1% ) our results are good when @xmath0 is around 0.9 . in general ,
up to the same order of expansion , average conductance gives better result than the shot noise and conductance fluctuation while the shot noise is the least accurate quantity .
one can improve the accuracy by going to higher order expansion at the expenses of more cpu time .
since our method is an expansion approach , it can not deal with large disorder strength and high doping concentration .
our formalism can be combined with lmto type of first principles calculation , which can give quantitative prediction to the conductance fluctuation for nano - devices . in the realistic device calculations , such comparisons with brute force method
are also in principle available .
for example , in the realistic doping devices , one can generate a large number of random configurations at the given concentration , and the averaged shot noise as well as conductance fluctuation can be exactly evaluated .
thus our method is controllable and should be successful as long as cpa itself is valid .
the authors would like to thank l. zhang , g. b. liu , y. wang , y. zhu , and h. guo for their helpful discussions .
we gratefully acknowledge the support from research grant council ( hku 705611p ) and university grant council ( contract no .
aoe / p-04/08 ) of the government of hksar .
this research is conducted using the hku computer centre research computing facilities that are supported in part by the hong kong ugc special equipment grant ( seg hku09 ) .
p. soven , phys . rev . * 156 * , 809 ( 1967 ) .
b. velick , s. kirkpatrick , and h. ehrenreich , phys . rev . * 175 * , 747(1968 )
. w. m. temmerman , b. l. gyorffy and g. m. stocks , j. phys .
f * 8 * , 2461 ( 1978 ) .
g. m. stocks and h. winter , z. phys , b * 46 * , 95 ( 1982 ) . n. stefanou , r. zeller , and p. h. dederichs , solid state commun . * * ( * * 62 ) , 735 ( 1987 )
. i. turek _
et al . , electronic structure of the disordered alloys , surfaces and interfaces _ ( kluwer , boston , 1997 ) .
j. kudrnovsk and v. drchal , phys .
b. * 41 * , 7515 ( 1990 ) .
j. kudrnovsk , v. drchal , and j. masek , phys .
b * 35 * , 2487 ( 1987 ) .
m. a. korotin , n. a. skorikov , v. m. zainullina , e. z. kurmaev , a. v. lukoyanov , and v. i. anisimov , jetp lett . ,
* 94 * , 806 ( 2012 ) .
j. j. pulikkotil , a. chroneos , and u , schwingenschloegl , journal of applied physics , * 110 * , 036105 ( 2011 ) .
k. carva , i. turek , j. kudronovsk , and o. bengone , phys .
b * 73 * , 144421 ( 2006 )
. k. levin , b. velick , and h. ehrenreich , phys .
b. * 2 * , 1771(1970 ) .
y. wang , f. zahid , y. zhu , l. liu , j. wang , and h. guo , applied physics letters * 102 * , 132109 ( 2013 ) .
m. csar , y. ke , w. ji , h. guo , and z. mi , appl . phys .
98 , 202107 ( 2011 ) .
y. ke , k. xia , and h. guo , phys .
lett . * 100 * , 166805 ( 2008 ) and its supplementary material .
zhuravlev , a. v. vedyayev , k. d. belashchenko , and e. y. tsymbal , phys .
b * 85 * , 115134 ( 2012 ) .
a. v. kalitsov , m. g. chshiev , and julian p. velev , phys . rev .
b * 85 * , 235111(2012 ) .
l. tang , mod .
lett b * 26 * , 1250205 ( 2012 ) .
z. bai , y. cai , l. shen , m. yang , v. ko , g. han , and y. feng , appl .
lett * 100 * , 022408 ( 2012 ) .
yang , j - r .
hwang , h - m .
chen , j - j .
shen , s - m .
yu , y. li , and d. d. tang , in vlsi technol .
symp . dig .
208 , june ( 2007 ) .
m. blanter , and m. bttiker , phys .
336 , 1 ( 2000 ) .
s. datta , electronic transport in mesoscopic systems ( cambridge university press , cambridge ) .
d. h. lee and j. d. joannopoulos , phys . rev .
b 23 , 4997 ( 1981 ) . m. p.
lopez sancho et al .
, j. phys .
f 14 , 1205 ; 15 , 851 ( 1985 ) .
p. sheng , _ introduction to wave scattering , localization and mesoscopic phenomena _
( springer , new york , 2006 ) .
y. zhu , l. liu , and h. guo , unpublished ( 2012 ) .
r. kubo , j. phys .
jpn , * 17 * , 1100 ( 1962 ) . | we report the investigation of conductance fluctuation and shot noise in disordered graphene systems with two kinds of disorder , anderson type impurities and random dopants . to avoid the brute - force calculation which is time consuming and impractical at low doping concentration
, we develop an expansion method based on the coherent potential approximation ( cpa ) to calculate the average of four green s functions and the results are obtained by truncating the expansion up to 6th order in terms of single - site - t - matrix " .
since our expansion is with respect to single - site - t - matrix " instead of disorder strength @xmath0 , good result can be obtained at 6th order for finite @xmath0 .
we benchmark our results against brute - force method on disordered graphene systems as well as the two dimensional square lattice model systems for both anderson disorder and the random doping .
the results show that in the regime where the disorder strength @xmath0 is small or the doping concentration is low , our results agree well with the results obtained from the brute - force method .
specifically , for the graphene system with anderson impurities , our results for conductance fluctuation show good agreement for @xmath0 up to @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the hopping energy . while for average shot noise
, the results are good for @xmath0 up to @xmath3 .
when the graphene system is doped with low concentration @xmath4 , the conductance fluctuation and shot noise agrees with brute - force results for large @xmath0 which is comparable to the hopping energy @xmath2 . at large doping concentration @xmath5
, good agreement can be reached for conductance fluctuation and shot noise for @xmath0 up to @xmath1 .
we have also tested our formalism on square lattice with similar results .
our formalism can be easily combined with linear muffin - tin orbital first - principles transport calculations for light doping nano - scaled systems , making prediction on variability of nano - devices . |
galaxy collisions and mergers have long been known to influence star formation in galaxies ( see , e.g. , the review by struck 1999 and references therein ) and likely play a fundamental role in the transformation of the population of gas - rich spiral galaxies at high redshift into the spheroidal and elliptical galaxies that dominate dense galaxy groups and clusters at the present epoch .
probing the details of the gravitational and hydrodynamical processes that affect star formation during these collisions has only recently become possible with the advent of high spatial resolution observations that are capable of resolving star - forming complexes within nearby galaxies across the full electromagnetic spectrum ( radio to x - ray ) , and that allow us to measure the thermodynamic properties of cold and hot gas in and around these galaxies .
early studies of star formation in interacting galaxies were based primarily on observations in the optical and far - infrared wavebands .
these studies focused on global star formation properties and correlations between observable star formation indicators .
for example , kennicutt et al .
( 1987 ) found that h@xmath9 emission and far - infrared to blue luminosity ratios were enhanced in interacting galaxies compared to galaxies in non - interacting samples .
more recent optical studies using large area redshift surveys suggest h@xmath9 equivalent widths may be correlated with galaxy pair separation ( e.g. , barton et al .
2000 using the second cfa redshift survey ; lambas et al .
2003 using the 2df survey ; nikolic , cullen & alexander 2004 using the sdss survey ) . however , extinction in the optical wavebands and dust heating by evolved agb stars in the far - infrared made global star formation activity in galaxies difficult to measure , and contributed to the large scatter in these relationships .
studies of individual star - forming regions within interacting galaxies were largely limited to optical wavebands , because of the low spatial resolution of the far - infrared data . from these optical studies , the spatial distributions and masses of star forming clumps were found to be diverse . while star formation was often enhanced in the nuclear region of the dominant galaxy of an interacting galaxy pair , star formation was also prevalent at large radii in extended tidal features .
masses of these star - forming clumps span more than six orders in magnitude , from young ( @xmath10myr old ) @xmath11 star associations , that may rapidly dissolve ( werk et al .
2008 ) , to bound @xmath12 systems , with masses similar to globular clusters ( trancho et al .
2007 ) , and @xmath13 systems , sometimes called tidal dwarf galaxies . with the launch of the spitzer space telescope ( werner et al .
2004 ) , high spatial resolution mid - infrared imaging and spectroscopy of star - forming regions within nearby galaxies became possible .
using mid - infrared luminosities and colors , nonstellar emission from polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon ( pah ) molecules , excited by newly formed stars in dusty regions , could be separated from the diffuse starlight and the silicate emission expected from evolved stars , thus completing the census of global star formation in the galaxy . with the high angular resolution of the _ spitzer _ infra - red array camera ( irac ; fazio et al .
2004 ) , subtle differences in the star - forming clumps could be probed as a function of their spatial distribution within the interacting system .
most recent mid - infrared studies of interaction - induced star formation have focused on interacting galaxy pairs in isolation from their environment .
galaxies in the largest such study , the spitzer spirals , bridges and tails interacting galaxy survey ( ssb&t ; smith et al .
2007 ) , were optically selected from the arp catalog of interacting galaxies ( arp 1966 ) to include only nearby , isolated galaxy pairs that exhibited tidal features , and specifically excluded triple and higher multiple galaxy systems and merger remnants .
smith et al .
( 2007 ) compared the mid - infrared properties of interacting galaxies in the ssb&t sample , as a whole , to those of normal , noninteracting spiral galaxies drawn from the spitzer infrared nearby galaxy survey ( sings ; kennicutt et al .
2003 ) . on average
, they found that interacting galaxy pairs have redder mid - infrared colors , and that star formation is enhanced and more centrally concentrated in the dominant spiral galaxy of the interacting pair than in normal spiral galaxies .
no evidence was found for a correlation between mid - infrared colors and galaxy pair separation in the interacting galaxies , as might have been expected from the optical data .
also , no strong differences were found between the mid - infrared colors in the interacting galaxies stellar disks and those measured in their tidal bridges and tails .
however , since the study averaged over interactions with different orbital characteristics and galaxy masses , subtle differences related to the details of the interaction could be washed out . individual case studies of a handful of isolated , interacting galaxy pairs , using ultraviolet , optical and mid - infrared data , suggested that interaction - induced star formation occurs in clumpy bursts .
the ages and spatial distribution of the star - forming clumps may reflect the stage and orbital parameters of the collision , as inferred from numerical simulations of the collision ( e.g. wang et al .
2004 for ngc4038/4039 ; smith et al .
2005a for arp 107 ; elmegreen et al . 2006 for ngc2207 ; hancock et al .
2007 for arp 82 ) .
results from the deep2 galaxy survey show that the fraction of blue , star - forming galaxies is rapidly changing between redshifts @xmath14 , and that galaxy evolution at these redshifts occurs not in isolated galaxy pairs , but predominantly in moderately massive galaxy groups with @xmath15 galaxy members and velocity dispersions @xmath16kms@xmath4 ( gerke et al .
2005 ; cooper et al .
2006 ) . thus understanding how the group environment affects star formation in interacting galaxies is vital to understanding how dusty
, blue star - forming disk galaxies evolve into the early - type galaxies , hosting little or no ongoing star formation , that dominate groups and rich clusters today . by including x - ray observations with the other traditional ( optical and infrared ) tracers of star formation activity
, we have direct observational constraints on the temperature and density of the intragroup gas ( igm ) surrounding these galaxies , and on the three - dimensional motions of the interacting galaxies with respect to the group igm ( see , e.g. merrifield 1998 ; vikhlinin et al .
2001 ; machacek et al . 2005a , 2005b ) .
- ray observations also help identify nuclear activity and hot gas flows that might trigger or quench subsequent star formation . inch schmidt telescope , of galaxies near the core of the pavo group .
, width=288,height=227 ] the pavo galaxy group is an important nearby laboratory to study the evolution of galaxies within their group environment , because it shares many properties with the high redshift galaxy groups found in the deep2 galaxy survey . like those galaxy groups ,
the pavo group is moderately massive with a velocity dispersion , derived from its @xmath17 member galaxies , of @xmath18kms@xmath4 , and contains a gas - rich spiral galaxy ( ngc6872 ) interacting with its environment . yet , at @xmath19mpc , the pavo group is close enough for star - forming clumps with typical separations of @xmath20kpc ( elmegreen & efremov 1996 ) to be resolved in _
chandra _ x - ray and _ spitzer _ mid - infrared images , as well as in the optical bands .
the pavo group is dynamically young .
it hosts a variety of galaxy and group interactions expected to be important at high redshift . in figure [ fig : pavodssgrp ] we show a bj band image of the two brightest galaxies in the pavo group : the elliptical galaxy ngc6876 at the center of the group and the large , tidally distorted sab(rs)c spiral galaxy ngc6872 located @xmath21 to the northwest . the large spiral galaxy , ngc6872 , and its spheroidal companion galaxy , ic4970 , located @xmath22 to the north near a break in ngc6872 s northern tidal arm , have long been known to be a tidally interacting galaxy pair ( vorontsov - velyaminov 1959 ) , and are well - studied in the optical ( mihos et al .
1993 ; bastian et al .
2005 ) and radio ( horellou & booth 1997 ; horellou & koribalski 2003 ; 2007 ) wavebands .
the stellar bridge pointing from the northern tidal arm of ngc6872 to its less massive companion ic4970 indicates the tidal interactions between these two galaxies are ongoing . the @xmath23kms@xmath4 radial velocity differencehuchra / zcat . ] between ngc6872 and ic4970 suggest that these galaxies form a spiral dominated subgroup .
_ xmm - newton _ x - ray observations revealed a @xmath24kpc long x - ray trail of hot ( @xmath20kev ) gas linking , in projection , ngc6872/ic4970 to ngc6876 , the dominant pavo group elliptical galaxy .
the properties of the x - ray gas in the trail , coupled with the large @xmath25kms@xmath4radial velocity difference between ngc6872 and ngc6876 , provide dramatic evidence for the highly supersonic passage of the ngc6872/ic4970 subgroup through the dense @xmath26kev igm gas in the pavo group core ( machacek et al .
although difficult to identify today , such interactions would likely have been frequent at high redshift , when galaxy groups and clusters were forming at the intersections of large scale filaments . the dominant elliptical galaxy , ngc6876 , also shows evidence for recent interactions .
hubble space telescope observations of the inner @xmath27 of ngc6876 show a depressed central surface brightness distribution surrounded by a stellar torus , suggesting the presence of a binary black hole from a previous merger ( lauer et al .
. the companion elliptical galaxy , ngc6877 , ( @xmath28 to the east with radial velocity difference of @xmath29kms@xmath4 ) may be in an early premerger phase with ngc6876 .
important questions concerning the evolution of galaxies in the galaxy group environment remain poorly understood . among these
are : 1 .
how do galaxy interactions influence nuclear activity and black hole growth in interacting galaxies in galaxy groups ? 2 .
what are the patterns of star formation in interacting galaxies ?
3 . how do we observationally constrain the kinematics of galaxy - group interactions , such as the high velocity passage of ngc6872 past ngc6876 in the pavo group core , and how do these interactions influence the hydrodynamical state of both the group igm and the hot x - ray emitting gas in the galaxies ? in a series of three papers we address these questions for the dominant interacting galaxies in the pavo group . in a previous paper , we used _
mid - infrared and _ chandra _ x - ray images to analyze the role of the ic4970/ngc6872 collision on the nuclear activity in the less massive galaxy , ic4970 , arguing that it hosts a highly - obscured active galactic nucleus ( agn ) fueled by cold gas driven into the nucleus by the interaction ( machacek et al .
2008a ) . in the current paper
, we analyze _ spitzer _ mid - infrared observations of the dominant pavo group galaxies , ngc6876 and ngc6872 , and _ chandra _ observations of bright x - ray point sources found associated with the spiral galaxy ngc6872 , to investigate the impact of galaxy interactions on star formation in these systems . the detailed analysis of our _ chandra _ observations of diffuse gas in and around these galaxies , that probes the impact of high velocity group - galaxy interactions on the hydrodynamical state and evolution of the pavo group igm , will be reported in a forthcoming paper ( machacek et al . 2008b , in preparation ) .
this paper is organized as follows : in [ sec : obs ] we briefly review the observations and our data reduction and processing procedures . in [ sec : irac ] we present our irac mid - infrared results , constructing flux density and nonstellar emission images of the ngc6876/ngc6877 and ngc6872/ic4970 galaxy pairs in the pavo group , along with irac band color maps of the more strongly interacting galaxy pair , ngc6872/ic4970 . in [ sec : xray ] we compare the properties of the x - ray point source population with the distribution of star forming regions identified in
[ sec : irac ] and with existing optical observations of young star clusters and radio observations of the distribution of hi gas
. we also comment on the relationship of extended x - ray emission , observed with _
chandra _ in ngc6872 , with these star formation tracers in other wavebands .
we briefly summarize our findings in [ sec : conclude ] . unless otherwise indicated
, uncertainties correspond to @xmath30 confidence levels on spectral parameters and @xmath31 uncertainties on x - ray counts and count rates .
wcs coordinates are j2000 . adopting a @xmath32cdm cosmology with @xmath33 kms@xmath4mpc@xmath4and @xmath34 from the three year wmap results ( spergel et al .
2006 ) and taking the redshift of the central group elliptical galaxy ngc6876 ( @xmath35 ) as representative of the redshift of the pavo group , we find a luminosity distance of @xmath19mpc for galaxies in the pavo group core .
one arc second corresponds to a distance of @xmath36kpc .
our mid - infrared results are based on the analysis of a @xmath37s observation of ngc6876 and ngc6872 ( _ spitzer _ pid 20440 ) taken on 2005 september 18 in the @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and @xmath0 wavebands using the irac camera on board the _ spitzer _ space telescope .
we used two irac pointings , one with aim point centered on the dominant pavo group elliptical galaxy ngc6876 ( @xmath41 , @xmath42 , ned ) and the other centered on the spiral galaxy ngc6872 ( @xmath43 , @xmath44 , ned ) . for a detailed discussion of our mid - infrared data reduction and mosaicing procedures , please see machacek et al .
( 2008a ) .
we obtained good coverage with @xmath45 basic calibrated data ( bcd ) frames in all irac wavebands in and near the bright galaxies , ngc6876 and ngc6872 .
however , coverage of the region midway between ngc6876 and ngc6872 was sparse ( @xmath46 bcd frames ) .
the bcd frames were super - boresight corrected and registered on the same sky grid , such that astrometric uncertainties were @xmath47 .
our x - ray data are from a @xmath48ks observation , taken in two segments on 2005 december 14 - 15 ( obsid 7248 ) and 2005 december 16 - 17 ( obsid 7059 ) with the advanced ccd imaging spectrometer imaging array ( acis - i ; garmire et al . 1992 ; bautz et al .
1998 ) on board the _ chandra _ x - ray observatory . a detailed discussion of these _ chandra _ x - ray observations , x - ray backgrounds and our data cleaning procedures , that resulted in useful exposure times of @xmath49s and @xmath50s for obsid 7248 and obsid 7059 , respectively , are also reported in machacek et al .
( 2008a ) .
point sources were identified in four x - ray energy bands , i.e. soft ( @xmath51kev ) , medium ( @xmath52kev ) , hard ( @xmath53kev ) , and broad @xmath5kev energy bands , using both ciao tool wavdetect with a significance threshold of @xmath54 and a multiscale wavelet decomposition algorithm ( wvdecomp ) with @xmath55 detection threshold .
we found no significant differences between the two methods .
in addition to x - ray emission from the central regions of the galaxies ngc6876 , ngc6877 , ngc6872 , ic4970 , and pgc06443 ( shown in fig .
[ fig : pavodssgrp ] ) , we find @xmath56 x - ray point sources to a @xmath5kev flux limit of @xmath57ergs@xmath4@xmath58 in a @xmath59 field of view .
we further checked our x - ray source identification algorithms by comparing the number of sources we detect to this flux limit with that expected from the cosmic x - ray background .
we detect @xmath60 x - ray sources in a @xmath61 radius circle chosen on the acis - i field of view to exclude known galactic sources , in excellent agreement with the @xmath62 cosmic x - ray background sources expected in this region to this flux limit ( brandt et al .
2001 ) . both segments of our _ chandra _ observation ( obsid 7248 and obsid 7059 ) placed the acis - i aimpoint near the spiral galaxy ngc6872 to achieve optimal angular resolution close to the spiral galaxy , where effects of ngc6872 s interactions are expected to be most prominent . however , this placed both the elliptical galaxies ngc6876 and ngc6877 @xmath63 off axis , close to the edge of the i3 ccd , where the mirror point spread function broadens and encircled energy radii become azimuthally asymmetric .
thus x - ray point sources , such as low - mass x - ray binaries that may be associated with ngc6876 or ngc6877 are difficult to distinguish from the elliptical galaxies hot diffuse x - ray gas halos .
we found no additional x - ray point sources associated with either ngc6877 or ngc6868 .
therefore , in this paper ( [ sec : xray ] ) , we discuss only the properties of the @xmath64 point sources likely associated with the spiral galaxy ngc6872 .
the properties of the active nucleus and near - nuclear point source in ic4970 ( ngc6872 s companion galaxy ) are the subject of machacek et al .
( 2008a ) .
we compare our _ spitzer _ mid - infrared and _ chandra _ x - ray results with existing hi ( horellou & koribalski 2007 ) , vlt b - band ( bastian et al . 2005 ) , and h@xmath9 ( mihos et al .
1993 ) observations from the literature .
in figures [ fig : n6876mosaics ] and [ fig : n6872mosaics ] we present background - subtracted mosaics of the dominant pavo group galaxy pairs ngc6876/ngc6877 and ngc6872/ic4970 , respectively , in the four irac wavebands .
the @xmath65 and @xmath66 wavebands ( upper panels ) are dominated by light from an old population of stars .
emission in the @xmath40 and @xmath0 bands is more complicated , containing possible contributions from pahs and dust in young star - forming regions , silicates ejected from the outer atmospheres of agb stars , or agn accretion disks , as well as starlight .
we separate the nonstellar from the stellar components at these wavelengths following the method of pahre et al .
specifically , a model for the @xmath40 and @xmath0 stellar emission is constructed by averaging background - subtracted @xmath38 and @xmath66 flux density mosaics that have first been aperture corrected , using the irac extended ( infinite ) aperture corrections provided by the _
spitzer _ science center , and then scaled to the appropriate waveband ( @xmath1 or @xmath0 ) using the approximate mid - infrared colors of an m0 iii star ( @xmath67-[4.5]=-0.15 $ ] , @xmath68-[5.8 ] = 0.11 $ ] , @xmath69-[8.0 ] = 0.04 $ ] ) .
this stellar model is then subtracted from the background - subtracted , aperture - corrected , observed @xmath1 and @xmath0 mosaics to produce the nonstellar emission maps , shown in the lower panels of figures [ fig : n6876mosaics ] and [ fig : n6872mosaics ] . below
we discuss our mid - infrared results for elliptical galaxies ngc6876 and ngc6877 ( [ sec : n6876iracflux ] ) and spiral galaxy ngc6872 ( [ sec : n6872iracflux ] ) . the mid - infrared results for ngc6872 s companion galaxy ic4970 were presented in machacek et al .
( 2008a ) and will not be repeated here .
figure [ fig : n6876mosaics ] shows that the surface brightness distributions in all four irac wavebands are similar for ngc6876 and for ngc6877 . for ngc6876 , we find no evidence in the @xmath40 and @xmath0 surface brightness maps for dust features that deviate from the stellar light distribution in the elliptical galaxy .
we present the nonstellar emission maps for ngc6876 and ngc6877 in the lower panels of figure [ fig : n6876mosaics ] .
nonstellar emission is seen in the central region of the nearby elliptical galaxy ngc6877 , but the apparent lack of nonstellar emission in ngc6876 is striking .
however , this result should be interpreted with care , because irac aperture corrections for the @xmath40 and @xmath0 wavebands are strongly dependent on the size of the emission region and use of the limiting ( large scale ) aperture correction may underestimate the true flux by as much as @xmath70 in these wavebands , if the emission is concentrated in smaller regions .
conservatively , the nonstellar emission maps for ngc6876 ( lower panels of fig . [ fig : n6876mosaics ] ) suggest that dust emission , if present in the dominant group galaxy , is weak and likely follows the galaxy s distribution of highly evolved stars .
we used fixed - aperture photometry in each irac waveband to investigate the possibility of dust emission in the elliptical galaxies ngc6876 and ngc6877 more quantitatively . our results and a complete description of the source and background apertures used in the analysis are summarized in table [ tab : n6876phot ] for ngc6876 and table [ tab : n6877phot ] for its companion elliptical galaxy ngc6877 .
the mid - infrared colors for both galaxies are listed in table [ tab : n6876colors ] .
we define apertures for each galaxy as a whole ( labeled ` full ' in tables [ tab : n6876phot ] and [ tab : n6877phot ] ) , based on the respective @xmath71mjysr@xmath4surface brightness contours in the @xmath65 emission map ( upper left panel of fig . [
fig : n6876mosaics ] ) .
the background regions were taken to be concentric elliptical annuli immediately outside the source regions . contaminating point sources , identified in the @xmath65 map ,
were excised from both the source and background maps for each waveband .
the measured integrated flux densities for the ` full ' regions were aperture corrected using correction factors for each aperture s effective circular radius ( @xmath72 and @xmath73 for ngc6876 and ngc6877 , respectively ) calculated from fits to the irac extended source calibration curves supplied by the _ spitzer _ science center .
nonstellar emission , when present in elliptical galaxies , is often centrally concentrated ( pahre et al .
2004 ) , and may be masked by the more dominant stellar emission when averaged over the whole galaxy .
for example , when averaged over the full galaxy , neither the @xmath1 nor the @xmath0 nonstellar flux densities , listed in table [ tab : n6876phot ] for ngc 6876 are greater than the @xmath74 uncertainties .
we thus use circular apertures with radii of @xmath75 and @xmath76 ( labeled ` center ' in tables [ tab : n6876phot ] and [ tab : n6877phot ] ) to measure the mid - infrared flux densities in the central regions of ngc6876 and ngc6877 , respectively . for such small apertures ( i.e. radii @xmath77 ) ,
point source aperture corrections appropriate for the chosen aperture size ( irac data handbook version 3.0 ) were applied to the background - subtracted integrated flux densities to compute the ` true ' flux densities .
corresponding magnitudes for all cases were calculated using the vega relative zeropoint magnitudes from reach et al .
( 2005 ) .
the mid - infrared colors for ngc6876 , as a whole , are broadly consistent with the mid - infrared colors for an old ( m0-k0 ) population of stars , as expected
. however , our results for the @xmath40 and @xmath0 integrated flux densitites from the ` full ' aperture are lower than those previously reported for ngc6876 in nearby wavebands by ferrari et al .
( 2002 ) using observations from the infrared space observatory ( iso ) . to check whether this discrepancy is due to differences in the chosen apertures and/or the presence of point sources , excluded from our analysis , that were unresolved in the iso data , we measured the total integrated @xmath40 and @xmath0 fluxes in a @xmath78 square aperture centered on ngc6876 ( based on the iso field of view ) , without excising point sources , and with aperture corrections appropriate for the @xmath79 aperture effective radius . at @xmath1
we find an integrated flux for this larger region of @xmath80mjy , in good agreement with the @xmath81mjy observed at @xmath82 by ferrari et al . ,
given the @xmath83 calibration uncertainties in the iso data .
however , for @xmath0 we find an integrated flux in this larger aperture of @xmath84mjy , still a factor @xmath85 below the @xmath86mjy measured by ferrari and collaborators in the @xmath87 waveband
. this may be further evidence , as suggested by ferrari et al .
( 2002 ) , that the excess emission at @xmath88 is due to warm silicate grains from the atmospheres of old agb stars , and not pah emission from young star forming regions .
such an interpretation would be consistent with results for elliptical galaxies in richer environments , such as the virgo cluster , where @xmath89 of the @xmath90 early type galaxies studied by bressan et al .
( 2006 ; 2008 ) with iso mid - infrared spectroscopy showed silicate emission . while the @xmath67-[4.5]$ ] and @xmath68-[5.8]$ ] colors for the central region of ngc6876 ( labeled ` center ' in table [ tab : n6876colors ] ) are again broadly consistent with an old population of stars , the @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] color is redder than expected .
however , after subtracting our stellar model to isolate the nonstellar contribution to these central flux densities , we do not find a statistically significant ( @xmath91 ) contribution to the flux from nonstellar emission in the @xmath1 band , and find only a weak ( @xmath92 ) contribution from nonstellar emission in the @xmath0 band .
this is again consistent with the interpretation that the excess @xmath0 flux is due to leakage from the broad @xmath93 emission feature expected for warm silicate dust grains into the @xmath0 bandpass . in normal star - forming galaxies the star formation rate
is correlated with the @xmath0 emission from warm dust by the expression ( wu et al .
2005 ) @xmath94 using equation [ eq : sfr ] , we find an upper limit on star formation in ngc6876 of @xmath95 .
figure [ fig : n6876mosaics ] does show nonstellar emission in the central region of ngc6877 , the companion galaxy to ngc6876 .
in particular , the @xmath67 - [ 8.0]$ ] color for ngc6877 ( expected to be close to zero for old stars ) is @xmath96 , too red to be caused by any stellar population ( pahre et al .
2004 ) . after subtracting the contribution from our stellar model
, we find that nonstellar emission contributes @xmath97 ( @xmath98 ) of the @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) flux densities , respectively , in the central region of ngc6877 .
the nonstellar @xmath69 - [ 8.0]$ ] color of @xmath99 in the central region is similar to the @xmath69 - [ 8.0]$ ] nonstellar colors ( @xmath100 ) found in star - forming regions in m81 ( willner et al .
2004 ) and in dusty e / s0 galaxies ( pahre et al .
2004 ) and is consistent with that expected from pah molecules and dust in star - forming regions ( li & draine 2001 ) .
however , the observed ( stellar plus nonstellar ) @xmath67-[4.5]$ ] and @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] colors for the central region of ngc6877 place the galaxy close to normal s0/sa galaxies in the color - color diagram of stern et al .
( 2005 ) , such as for ngc4429 in which star formation rates are low . using the @xmath101 nonstellar flux density for ngc6877 in equation [ eq : sfr ] , we estimate a star formation rate of @xmath102 . thus , as in ngc4429 , star formation in the central region of ngc6877 , while likely present , is weak . from figure
[ fig : n6872mosaics ] we see that the surface brightness distribution in the @xmath65 and @xmath66 wavebands , that trace the distribution of starlight in ngc6872 , are very different from the @xmath1 and @xmath0 surface brightness maps of the large spiral galaxy .
the @xmath65 and @xmath66 maps ( upper panels ) show a bright nucleus , clear bar and two tidally distorted spiral arms , similar to the bj - band image shown in figure [ fig : pavodssgrp ] .
in contrast , the @xmath0 and @xmath1 emission in the spiral galaxy ngc6872 ( middle panels ) is concentrated in an outer ring and along both tidal tails . as shown in the lower panels of figure [ fig : n6872mosaics ] , these longer wavelength bands are dominated by nonstellar emission .
this nonstellar emission tends to be clumpy , with clump sizes ranging from those unresolved by irac , i.e @xmath103kpc in diameter , to complexes @xmath104kpc across . along the northern tidal arm , bright nonstellar emission
is found concentrated between the ring and the break in the arm , along the bridge connecting the break to the companion galaxy ic4970 , in a bright two - tailed knot east of the break , and in faint patches extending out @xmath105 to the full extent of the northern tidally distorted stellar tail ( see also fig . [ fig : nonstellarcompare ] ) .
nonstellar emission is found in the southern tidal arm in bright @xmath52kpc long beads west of the ring and again in fainter patches out to the end of the southern tidal tail .
since the same emission features that are seen in the nonstellar @xmath0 map of ngc6872 also appear in the corresponding @xmath1 map ( albeit with lower signal to noise ) , the observed flux is likely the result of pah and dust emission from young , dust - enshrouded star - forming regions in the spiral galaxy .
we test the hypothesis that the observed nonstellar emission is from pah molecules and warm dust by using mid - infrared color maps to study the properties of the mid - infrared emission throughout the spiral galaxy and its tidal features .
we show three representative color maps in figure [ fig : colormaps ] .
the background - subtracted mosaics in each waveband were cross - convolved with a gaussian representation of the irac point spread function in the other waveband before division to mitigate light scattering effects .
we estimated the uncertainties in the color maps by comparing the colors of ngc6872 s nucleus obtained directly from the color maps to those calculated from the flux densities measured by fixed aperture photometry in [ sec : nuclearphot ] and find that the flux ratios ( colors ) obtained from figure [ fig : colormaps ] differ from those obtained from fixed aperture photometry by @xmath106 ( @xmath107mag ) , comparable to the calibration uncertainties ( @xmath108 ) for these wavebands . in the central region and along the bar of the spiral galaxy ,
the @xmath65 to @xmath66 flux density ratio is @xmath109 to @xmath110 , corresponding to @xmath67-[4.5]$ ] colors of@xmath111 to @xmath112 , respectively .
these colors are consistent with that expected for an old population of stars .
the bright nonstellar emission regions , that are particularly visible in the southern arm of ngc6872 in the lower right panel of figure [ fig : n6872mosaics ] and in figure [ fig : colormaps ] , have @xmath113 , lower than elsewhere in the galaxy .
the corresponding @xmath67-[4.5]$ ] color ( @xmath114 ) is in agreement with the colors of star - forming clumps in the spiral and tidal bridge of ngc2536 ( hancock et al .
depressed @xmath115 flux ratios were also found by elmegreen et al .
( 2006 ) in star - forming clumps in the ngc2207/ic2163 interacting galaxy pair .
they suggested that the low @xmath115 ratio may be due to an excess of h br@xmath9 emission at @xmath66 caused by the ionization of gas by hot , bright stars inside the star - forming clumps , such as found in rcw 49 , one of the most luminous hii regions in the milky way ( whitney et al .
2004 ) .
the @xmath116 flux ratio ( @xmath68-[5.8]$ ] color ) for ngc6872 provides a measure of the relative number of young to old stars in the region ( smith et al .
this flux ratio ( color ) increases ( reddens ) from @xmath117 ( @xmath118 mag ) in the central region of the galaxy , consistent with an old population of stars , to @xmath119 ( @xmath120 mag ) in the outer ring , indicating a younger stellar population and/or more interstellar dust .
the bright nonstellar emission regions are redder still , with @xmath121 ( @xmath68-[5.8 ] > 1.7 $ ] ) for clumps embedded in the tidal arms and bridge , and @xmath122 ( @xmath68-[5.8 ] \sim 1.9 $ ] ) in the bright knot east of the break in the northern arm .
these colors are consistent with those found in star - forming regions in other interacting galaxies ( smith et al .
2005 ; hancock et al . 2007 ; elmegreen et al .
2006 ) .
-[3.6 ] = 0.30 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath123 ( cyan ) , @xmath124 ( green ) , @xmath125 ( yellow ) , @xmath126 ( orange ) , @xmath127mag .
( red ) ; ( middle ) @xmath128-[5.8 ] = 0.35 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath129 ( cyan ) , @xmath130 ( green ) , @xmath131 ( yellow ) , @xmath99 ( orange ) , @xmath132mag .
( red ) ; ( lower ) blue ( green ) correspond @xmath133-[8.0])_{\rm nonstellar } = 2.1 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath134mag ( green ) .
, title="fig:",width=288,height=189 ] -[3.6 ] = 0.30 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath123 ( cyan ) , @xmath124 ( green ) , @xmath125 ( yellow ) , @xmath126 ( orange ) , @xmath127mag .
( red ) ; ( middle ) @xmath128-[5.8 ] = 0.35 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath129 ( cyan ) , @xmath130 ( green ) , @xmath131 ( yellow ) , @xmath99 ( orange ) , @xmath132mag .
( red ) ; ( lower ) blue ( green ) correspond @xmath133-[8.0])_{\rm nonstellar } = 2.1 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath134mag ( green ) .
, title="fig:",width=288,height=189 ] -[3.6 ] = 0.30 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath123 ( cyan ) , @xmath124 ( green ) , @xmath125 ( yellow ) , @xmath126 ( orange ) , @xmath127mag .
( red ) ; ( middle ) @xmath128-[5.8 ] = 0.35 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath129 ( cyan ) , @xmath130 ( green ) , @xmath131 ( yellow ) , @xmath99 ( orange ) , @xmath132mag .
( red ) ; ( lower ) blue ( green ) correspond @xmath133-[8.0])_{\rm nonstellar } = 2.1 $ ] ( blue ) , @xmath134mag ( green ) .
, title="fig:",width=288,height=189 ] the @xmath135 flux ratio ( @xmath67-[8.0]$ ] color ) , shown in the upper panel of figure [ fig : colormaps ] , provides a measure of the star formation rate per unit stellar mass throughout the galaxy .
the @xmath135 flux ratios in the southern tidal arm and bridge ( @xmath136 ) and in the bright nonstellar emission knot in the northern tidal arm east of the bridge ( @xmath137 ) are a factor @xmath138 higher than that found at the center of ngc6872 ( see table [ tab : n6872col ] ) .
these flux density ratios correspond to @xmath67-[8.0]$ ] colors of @xmath139 , and @xmath140 , respectively , approaching the theoretical prediction of @xmath141 for interstellar dust ( li & draine 2001 ) , and lie at the upper end of the distribution for @xmath67-[8.0]$ ] colors in tidal features and m51-like disks observed in the ssb&t sample ( smith et al . 2007 ) .
the @xmath142 flux ratio ( @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] color ) , shown in the middle panel of figure [ fig : colormaps ] , probes the properties of the emitting dust . in the southern tidal arm , in the northern tidal arm near the break and in the bridge , where there is good signal - to - noise
, we find @xmath143 ( @xmath69-[8.0 ] \sim 1.8 $ ] ) similar to that observed in other interacting systems ( see , e.g. , the antennae galaxies ngc4038/ngc4039 , wang et al . 2004 ;
ngc2536 , hancock et al . 2007 ;
ngc2207/ic2163 , elmegreen et al . 2006 ; arp 107 , smith et al . 2005a ; and m51-like disks and tidal features in the ssb&t sample , smith et al . 2007 ) .
once the stellar component is removed ( see the lower panel of fig . [
fig : colormaps ] ) , the @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] color of the nonstellar emission in these regions is @xmath144 , in excellent agreement with the theoretical prediction of @xmath145 for pure pah emission ( li & draine 2001 ) . taken together these maps show a consistent picture of pah and warm dust emission from interaction induced star formation occuring in clumps or knots extending out to @xmath146kpc from the nucleus to the northeast and southwest along the tidal tails , but avoiding the nucleus and central @xmath2kpc of ngc6872 .
regions of intense star formation , with mid - infrared colors similar to those observed in other interacting galaxies , are found both in the northern arm and bridge , near the ongoing interaction with ic4970 , and in the southern tidal arm , on the side of ngc6872 farthest from the present interaction .
these features are strongly correlated with h@xmath9 emission in ngc6872 and , like the h@xmath9 emission , are bright where the stellar velocity dispersion is high , further evidence that star formation in this system is collisionally induced ( mihos 1993 ) .
we see no strong differences in the mid - infrared colors of the star - forming regions in ngc6872 as a function of their position relative to the companion galaxy ic4970 . although strong nonstellar emission is found in the nuclear region of the companion galaxy , ic4970 , consistent with the presence of a highly obscured agn ( machacek et al .
2008a ) , nonstellar emission from the nucleus of the primary galaxy in the collision , ngc6872 , is weak . from the color maps in figure [ fig : colormaps ] we see that , in the central region of ngc6872 , the @xmath142 flux ratio ( @xmath147 ) and corresponding @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] color ( @xmath148 ) are modestly higher than expected for a population of old stars . as in [ sec : n6876iracflux ] we use fixed aperture point source photometry of ngc6872 s nucleus using a @xmath76 circular source aperture centered at the peak of the @xmath65 emission ( @xmath149 , @xmath150 , j2000 ) with a concentric background annulus with inner ( outer ) radii of @xmath76 ( @xmath151 ) , respectively , to measure the fluxes and colors of ngc6872 s nucleus and isolate any possible contribution from dust .
our results for the fluxes are presented in table [ tab : n6872phot ] . in table
[ tab : n6872col ] we list our photometric results for the mid - infrared flux ratios and colors of ngc6872 s nuclear region and compare them to the flux ratios and colors obtained from the color maps in figure [ fig : colormaps ] .
we find excellent agreement between the colors determined by the two methods .
the mid - infrared colors fall in the region of the color - color diagrams of lacy et al .
( 2004 ) and stern et al .
( 2005 ) populated by normal ( nonactive ) galaxies that are dominated by starlight .
the @xmath67-[4.5]$ ] and @xmath68-[5.8]$ ] colors for the nuclear region of ngc6872 are consistent with those expected for an old population of stars .
the @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] color ( @xmath148 ) is modestly higher suggesting the presence of dust . subtracting a stellar model ( as in [ sec : n6876iracflux ] ) , we find that the remaining nonstellar component contributes @xmath152 ( @xmath153mjy ) of the total emission in the @xmath1 band , i.e. consistent with zero within calibration uncertainties , and @xmath154 ( @xmath155mjy ) of the total emission in the @xmath101 band . if , instead , we model the distribution of stars using the @xmath65 data alone , the nonstellar contribution at @xmath1 increases modestly to @xmath156 , while the nonstellar contribution at @xmath101 is not significantly changed . from equation
[ eq : sfr ] , we find an upper limit to the star formation rate in the central @xmath7kpc of ngc6872 of @xmath157 . in both the @xmath0 total and nonstellar emission maps of figure [ fig : n6872mosaics ]
, we find a faint stream of mid - infrared emission winding @xmath158kpc ( @xmath159 ) from the northwest edge of ngc6872 s ring south to the spiral galaxy s central bar and along the bar to ngc6872 s nucleus ( see also fig . [
fig : n6872centercomp ] ) . in the @xmath0 nonstellar emission map ,
the surface brightness of the stream is a factor @xmath160 larger than that found elsewhere in ngc6872 s central region .
there is no statistically significant evidence for the stream feature in either the @xmath1 total emission or nonstellar emission maps , where emission instead follows the stellar bar .
the stream may be interstellar gas and dust that is being funneled into ngc6872 s nuclear region by the bar .
numerical simulations of interacting galaxies often predict that gas and/or dust will be driven into the inner disk of the more massive galaxy , possibly inducing a circumnuclear starburst ( see , e.g. noguchi 1988 , hernquist & mihos 1995 , mihos & hernquist 1996 ) .
simulations of the ngc6872/ic4970 interaction , in isolation from its group environment , predict a central concentration of dense gas in the spiral galaxy ( mihos et al . 1993 ; horellou & koribalski 2007 ) and @xmath161 of molecular gas is observed in co observations of the central @xmath162 of the galaxy ( horellou & booth 1997 ) .
our _ spitzer _ observations show that , despite the concentration of molecular hydrogen at the center and the stream of interstellar matter observed in @xmath101 leading from the ring to the nucleus , there is little photometric evidence for pah or warm dust emission from recent star formation in the nuclear region of ngc6872 .
this is in agreement with the h@xmath9 intensity maps of the central region of ngc6872 by mihos et al .
( 1993 ) , that also indicated little evidence for recent nuclear or circumnuclear star formation
. however , the stream may signal the transport of interstellar matter into the nuclear region , as predicted by simulations , and may be a prelude to a future episode of nuclear star formation or agn activity in the primary galaxy .
detailed studies of nearby normal spiral galaxies , e.g. the milky way ( sazonov et al
. 2006 ; revnivtsev et al . 2006 ) and m31 ( li & wang 2007 ; bogdan & gilfanov 2008 ) , indicate that the x - ray emission from spiral galaxies is strongly correlated with their stellar populations , and is dominated by the integrated emission from resolved and unresolved point sources . in the upper left panel of figure [ fig : n6872xray ] , we superpose contours from a background - subtracted , exposure - corrected @xmath163kev chandra x - ray image of the ngc6872/ic4970 interacting pair , after smoothing with a @xmath164 gaussian kernel , on the @xmath65 irac mosaic tracing the population of old stars .
in addition to emission from the nucleus , x - ray emission is found correlated with the @xmath65 stellar map along the central stellar bar , in the southern spiral arm , and in the northern spiral arm before the break . in the central region of the galaxy ,
the x - ray emission is most likely the integrated emission from old stars , including coronally active low mass binaries , cataclysmic variable stars , and white dwarf accretors at the faint end of the x - ray luminosity function , as well as the more luminous neutron star and black hole binaries ( lmxb s ) .
x - ray emission from regions in the spiral arms may also have contributions from young stellar objects , young stars , and high mass x - ray binaries ( hmxb s ) associated with ongoing star formation . in table
[ tab : xraysrclist ] we list the positions , observed x - ray source counts from the combined @xmath165ks _ chandra _ observation , and intrinsic @xmath5kev luminosities for ngc6872 s nucleus ( n ) and @xmath166 x - ray point sources , in and near the spiral galaxy .
we expect only @xmath7 cosmic x - ray background source in a @xmath167 rectangular region containing the main portion of ngc6872 ( brandt et al .
2001 ) , confirming that the x - ray sources listed in table [ tab : xraysrclist ] are most likely associated with the spiral galaxy .
x - ray colors for these sources using the @xmath51kev ( s ) , @xmath52kev ( m ) , and @xmath53kev energy bands are also listed in table [ tab : xraysrclist ] for completeness .
however , since the uncertainties in these colors are large due to the low count rates in each band , we adopt a standard power law spectral model with photon index @xmath168 , representative for luminous x - ray point sources in galaxies ( colbert et al .
2004 ; swartz et al .
2004 ) , and galactic hydrogen absorption ( @xmath169@xmath58 ) to calculate the intrinsic luminosities for these sources .
guided by the x - ray evidence for ngc6872 s recent passage through the pavo group core ( machacek et al .
2005 ) , we adopt @xmath19mpc , the luminosity distance to the central pavo group galaxy ngc6876 , as the luminosity distance to ngc6872 .
the @xmath5kev luminosities of these sources , other than the nucleus of ngc6872 , range from @xmath170ergs@xmath4to @xmath171ergs@xmath4 , spanning the luminosities characteristic of the bright end of the hmxb luminosity function to those associated with ultra - luminous x - ray sources ( ulxs ) .
these x - ray sources are typical of bright x - ray sources in other systems , where the number and luminosity of ultra - luminous x - ray sources are found to be correlated with galaxy interactions , mergers , and recent star formation ( swartz et al .
2004 ) . in the upper right panel of figure [ fig : n6872xray ]
, we overlay the @xmath172 wavdetect elliptical source regions ( detect reference manual ) for these x - ray sources on the irac @xmath101 nonstellar emission map of ngc6872/ic4970 .
the @xmath0 image has been smoothed with a @xmath173 kernel to highlight the faint nonstellar emission extending to the ends of ngc6872 s tidal tails .
x - ray sources other than the nucleus are found in or near star - forming regions mapped by the nonstellar ( pah and dust ) @xmath0 emission . since we have neglected intrinsic absorption , which may be significant in dusty star - forming regions , the x - ray luminosities , given in table [ tab : xraysrclist ] ,
should be considered lower limits on the true intrinsic x - ray luminosities of these sources . in the lower left panel of figure [ fig : n6872xray ]
we add the locations of young star clusters ( green x s ) in ngc6872 ( bastian et al .
2005 ) to the @xmath0 nonstellar image . throughout the following discussion ,
all star cluster identification numbers , ages and masses are from bastian et al .
please see bastian et al .
( 2005 ) for the full u , b , v , and i photometric results for these clusters and a complete discussion of the star cluster age and mass modeling . in the lower right panel of figure [ fig : n6872xray ] , we add @xmath174 cm emission contours from horellou & koribalski ( 2007 ) , that map the distribution of atomic hydrogen in the galaxy .
the star clusters follow closely the distribution of nonstellar @xmath0 emission .
this correspondence with @xmath0 nonstellar emission extends to the very ends of both the northern and southern tidal tails .
for example , a very young star cluster ( no . @xmath175 ) , with an age of only @xmath176myr and mass of @xmath177 coincides with the bright @xmath101 emission knot found @xmath178kpc from the nucleus of ngc6872 just east of the break in the northern tidal tail ( see the lower right panel of fig .
[ fig : n6872mosaics ] ) , and three young ( @xmath179myr ) clusters ( no . @xmath180 , @xmath181 , and @xmath182 ) coincide with the @xmath101 nonstellar emission double knot , @xmath183kpc from the center of the spiral galaxy in the southern tidal tail .
star clusters are also found in faint @xmath101 nonstellar emission clumps trailing the galaxy to the southeast . the concentration of five star clusters ( nos .
@xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 , and @xmath188 ) located @xmath189kpc southeast from ngc6872 s center , as shown in the lower left panel of figure [ fig : n6872xray ] , have low to moderate masses ( @xmath190 ) and are also very young , with ages between @xmath191 to @xmath192myr .
these latter star clusters may have formed from cooled gas , stripped from ngc6872 by tidal and turbulent - viscous forces caused by the collision of ic4970 with the spiral galaxy coupled with the high velocity passage of the ngc6872/ic4970 galaxy pair through the pavo group core , and may ultimately contribute to the pavo intragroup stellar light .
young star clusters are also highly concentrated along the bridge of nonstellar emission extending from the break in the northern arm to the companion galaxy ic4970 .
all but a handful of young star clusters , as well as the bright x - ray sources and @xmath0 nonstellar emission , coincide with regions rich in cold hi gas .
this spatial distribution of star - forming regions and young clusters along ngc6872 s tidal tails and bridge connecting ic4970 to ngc6872 strongly suggests that star formation has been influenced , if not triggered , by the galaxies interactions , and that the star clusters have only recently emerged from their dusty stellar nurseries .
it is interesting to note , however , that , unlike the young star clusters , the bright x - ray sources do not uniformly follow the @xmath0 nonstellar distribution .
while two x - ray sources are found in the northern tidal arm east of the break ( x - ray source @xmath7 at the eastern tip of the arm and x - ray source @xmath193 in the middle ) , most of the bright x - ray sources are clustered to the south in ngc6872 , and are seen to avoid the highly disrupted bridge region close to the interacting companion ic4970 , despite the high concentration of young star clusters and strong nonstellar emission there . as shown in figure [ fig : n6872centercomp ] , five x - ray sources ( no .
@xmath194 , @xmath195 , @xmath196 , @xmath197 , and @xmath166 ) are found in the southern spiral arm and tidal tail .
three of these x - ray sources ( no . @xmath194 , @xmath196 and @xmath166 ) are coincident or nearly coincident with the brightest @xmath0 nonstellar emission clumps in the southern arm , and may be multiple x - ray sources associated with these compact star - forming regions .
x - ray sources @xmath8 and @xmath2 trail the southern arm of ngc6872 by @xmath198kpc ( @xmath199 ) and @xmath193kpc ( @xmath200 ) , respectively , and are the only two x - ray sources coincident with optically identified sources ( star clusters @xmath201 and @xmath202 , respectively ) from bastian et al . (
2005 ) . if these optical sources are star clusters associated with the galaxy , and not foreground stars or background agn , the x - ray luminosities ( @xmath203ergs@xmath4and @xmath204ergs@xmath4 , respectively ) of their associated x - ray sources are high , characteristic of ultra - luminous x - ray sources . in table
[ tab : starclusters ] , we list the v and b band absolute magnitudes , internal extinction factors , cluster masses and ages from bastian et al .
( 2005 ) for the two star clusters coincident with the bright x - ray sources @xmath8 and @xmath2 .
these two young , moderately massive star clusters , i.e. with ages @xmath205myr , and masses @xmath206 , are similar in age and mass to star clusters found throughout the tidal tails and outer parts of ngc6872 , and in the interaction region between ngc6872 and ic4970 ( bastian et al . 2005 ) .
x - ray - to - optical flux ratios have long been used to gain insight into the nature of x - ray emitting sources that have possible optical counterparts .
( see , e.g. bradt & mcclintock 1983 ; maccacaro et al .
1988 ; stocke et al . 1991 ; hornschemeier et al .
2001 ) . in table
[ tab : xor ] we present three measures of the relative x - ray to optical emission between the two ultra - luminous x - ray sources ( @xmath8 and @xmath2 ) and their optical hosts ( star clusters @xmath201 and @xmath202 , respectively ) .
they are as follows : 1 . the v - band x - ray - to - optical flux ratio ( maccacaro et al
. 1982 ) , given by @xmath207 where @xmath208 is the @xmath209kev x - ray flux ( in ergs@xmath4@xmath58 ) and @xmath210 is the extinction - corrected v - band magnitude , 2 . the b - band x - ray - to - optical flux ratio ( van paradisj & mcclintock 1995 ) , defined as @xmath211 where @xmath212 is the extinction corrected b magnitude and @xmath213 is the @xmath214kev x - ray flux averaged over the @xmath214kev energy band ( in @xmath215jy ) , and 3 . the v - band to @xmath7kev two point spectral index , assuming a flux density of the form @xmath216 .
we use a power law spectral model with photon index @xmath168 and galactic absorption to convert the observed x - ray count rates to x - ray flux in the appropriate energy bands . from table
[ tab : xor ] we see that the v - band x - ray - to - optical ratio ( xor@xmath217 ) for x - ray source @xmath2 is larger than expected ( @xmath218 ) for any population of foreground stars , and , although xor@xmath219 for x - ray source @xmath8 is compatible with the upper end of the m star range for this ratio , the extinction corrected ( b - v)@xmath220 color of @xmath221 for that source is too blue to be an m star ( stocke et al .
thus neither source is a foreground star .
the v - band x - ray - to - optical ratios for the optical counterparts of x - ray sources @xmath8 and @xmath2 lie in the range ( @xmath222 to @xmath223 ) observed for luminous young star clusters hosting ulxs in ngc4038/ngc4039 ( zezas et al .
2002 ) and ngc7714/ngc7715 ( smith et al .
similarly , the v - band absolute magnitude ( @xmath224 ) of star cluster @xmath201 ( associated with x - ray source @xmath8 ) is similar to the absolute v magnitude ( @xmath225 ) of the near - nuclear young star cluster hosting a bright x - ray source in interacting galaxy ngc7714 ( smith et al .
2005b ) , and the absolute v magnitude ( @xmath226 ) of star cluster @xmath202 ( associated with x - ray source @xmath2 ) is comparable to absolute v magnitudes ( @xmath227 to @xmath228 ) of star clusters associated with ulxs in ngc4038/ngc4039 ( zezas et al .
also the v - i colors for star clusters @xmath201 and @xmath202 are blue , @xmath229 and @xmath230 , respectively ( bastian et al . 2005 ) , similar to colors of star - forming dwarf galaxies in other nearby loose groups ( carrasco , de oliveira & infante 2006 ) .
the b - band x - ray - to - optical ratios ( @xmath231 and @xmath232 for sources @xmath8 and @xmath2 , respectively ) are similar to those observed for hmxbs ( van paradijs & mcclintock 1995 ) . however , since stars or accreting binaries are optically too faint to be individually detected at the luminosity distance of ngc6872 , these b - band x - ray to optical ratios likely reflect the presence of hmxbs in and the young age of the x - ray sources star cluster hosts . taken together , these properties suggest that x - ray sources @xmath8 and @xmath2 reside in young star - forming clusters associated with the interacting galaxy ngc6872 in the pavo group ( bastian et al .
however , since the v - band x - ray - to - optical ratios and the two - point v - band to @xmath7 kev spectral indices are also consistent with those observed from agn ( stocke et al .
1991 , landt et al .
2001 ) , we can not rule out the possibility that one or both of these sources may be background agn . optical spectra and redshifts are needed to determine whether these x - ray sources are , indeed , ulxs associated with the ngc6872/ic4970 interacting galaxies in the pavo group .
( upper ) @xmath65 irac image of ngc6872 s central region showing a stellar bar just south of x - ray sources @xmath233 and @xmath234 ( see table [ tab : xraysrclist ] ) and strongly correlated with @xmath194 star clusters .
( lower ) the @xmath101 nonstellar image of the same region showing the stream of emission ( originating just south of a star cluster in the ring and north of x - ray sources @xmath233 and @xmath234 ) winding south to the bar and then along the bar to the nucleus .
the image uses square root scaling .
bright regions have been overexposed to highlight the faint nonstellar stream .
, title="fig:",width=288,height=215 ] superposed .
( upper ) @xmath65 irac image of ngc6872 s central region showing a stellar bar just south of x - ray sources @xmath233 and @xmath234 ( see table [ tab : xraysrclist ] ) and strongly correlated with @xmath194 star clusters .
( lower ) the @xmath101 nonstellar image of the same region showing the stream of emission ( originating just south of a star cluster in the ring and north of x - ray sources @xmath233 and @xmath234 ) winding south to the bar and then along the bar to the nucleus .
the image uses square root scaling .
bright regions have been overexposed to highlight the faint nonstellar stream .
, title="fig:",width=288,height=215 ] two x - ray sources ( sources @xmath233 and @xmath234 ) are found west of ngc6872 s nucleus on the western edge of the ring just north of the stellar bar ( see upper panel of fig .
[ fig : n6872centercomp ] ) . in the lower panel of figure
[ fig : n6872centercomp ] , we see that the two western x - ray sources lie at the base of the stream of interstellar matter , seen in @xmath101 nonstellar emission , that may be feeding the nucleus .
four star clusters ( green x s ) also are observed in this region : star cluster @xmath235 to the northwest at the inner edge of the ring , star clusters @xmath236 and @xmath237 displaced @xmath238kpc from x - ray source @xmath234 , and star cluster @xmath239 in the bulge .
the northwest and bulge star clusters trace the northern edge of the stream , while x - ray sources @xmath233 and @xmath234 and nearby star clusters lie at the stream s southern base .
the two star clusters close to x - ray source @xmath234 , as well as the star cluster located to the northwest just inside the @xmath101 emission ring , are more massive ( @xmath240 ) and older ( @xmath20gyr ) than most of the star clusters in the tidal features . however , the inner star cluster near the bulge on the northern edge of the stream is young ( @xmath85myr ) .
stellar winds and supernovae from these clusters , along with existing interstellar material and dust funneled to the center by the bar , may contribute to the warm dust and gas found in the stream .
kev x - ray image of ngc6872 ( see upper left panel of fig .
[ fig : n6872xray ] with x - ray point sources ( ellipses as in fig .
[ fig : n6872xray ] ) and young star clusters ( x s ) superposed .
the x - ray image is background - subtracted , exposure corrected and smoothed with a @xmath241 gaussian .
( lower ) @xmath163kev _ chandra _ x - ray image of the core of the pavo group , confirming the excess x - ray emission ( trail ) , found in _ xmm - newton _ images ( machacek et al .
2005b ) , between the dominant elliptical galaxy ngc6876 and the spiral galaxy ngc6872 .
image has been background subtracted , exposure corrected and smoothed with an @xmath242 gaussian kernel . , title="fig:",width=288,height=188 ] kev x - ray image of ngc6872 ( see upper left panel of fig .
[ fig : n6872xray ] with x - ray point sources ( ellipses as in fig .
[ fig : n6872xray ] ) and young star clusters ( x s ) superposed .
the x - ray image is background - subtracted , exposure corrected and smoothed with a @xmath241 gaussian .
( lower ) @xmath163kev _ chandra _ x - ray image of the core of the pavo group , confirming the excess x - ray emission ( trail ) , found in _ xmm - newton _ images ( machacek et al .
2005b ) , between the dominant elliptical galaxy ngc6876 and the spiral galaxy ngc6872 .
image has been background subtracted , exposure corrected and smoothed with an @xmath242 gaussian kernel .
, title="fig:",width=288,height=236 ] the upper left panel of figure [ fig : n6872xray ] shows x - ray emission that deviates strongly from the underlying distribution of stars in ngc6872 .
diffuse x - rays in normal , non - interacting spiral galaxies are expected to arise from two principal sources : a soft ( @xmath243kev ) thermal component from winds of ionized gas ejected from evolved stars and type ia supernovae and a hard component from core collapse supernovae , associated with star - forming regions ( bogdan & gilfanov 2008 ) .
since these components are associated with outflows , they need not be correlated with the stellar distribution . for interacting spiral galaxies , gas may be stripped and/or heated by the interaction itself , and , especially when the interacting partner is an early type galaxy such as ic4970 , hot gas may be stripped from the hot halo of the interacting companion into the space between the galaxies and/or transferred onto the massive spiral galaxy .
thus the presence of diffuse hot gas with disturbed morphologies in the ngc6872/ic4970 interacting pair is not a surprise . in the lower panel of figure [ fig : nonstellarcompare ]
we show the background subtracted , exposure corrected @xmath163kev _ chandra _ image of x - ray emission in the ngc6872/ic4970 interacting galaxy pair , after smoothing with a @xmath164 gaussian kernel . as in fig .
[ fig : n6872xray ] we overlay the positions of young star clusters as green x s and x - ray point sources as ellipses .
we see bright x - ray emission and a sharp surface brightness edge leading the stellar distribution and young star clusters in ngc6872 s southern spiral arm .
x - ray emission is truncated just west of the stellar tidal bridge leading from ngc6872 s northern spiral arm to ic4970 , and then turns sharply in a bright @xmath138kpc long filament to the southeast in the direction of ngc6876 .
faint diffuse emission is also seen extending @xmath189kpc behind the galaxy to the southeast of ngc6872 s nucleus .
while young star clusters are strongly correlated with the nonstellar @xmath0 emission in ngc6872 and trace the tidally distorted spiral arms and bridge to ic4970 ( see fig .
[ fig : n6872xray ] ) , they avoid the bright regions of hot diffuse x - ray gas , and are found instead bordering the diffuse x - ray emission in the x - ray filaments and the fainter patches of x - ray emission in the tidal arms and trailing ngc6872 to the southeast .
this suggests that star clusters formed in the tidal debris from gas , previously stripped by the interactions of the spiral galaxy with ic4970 and the pavo group , that has since cooled .
these clusters may ultimately contribute to the pavo group s intergalactic stellar light . in this paper
we have limited our discussion of the diffuse x - ray gas to comparisons with star formation tracers in ngc6872 . however , the hot gas to the east in ngc6872 , is highly disturbed , bending sharply to the south , away from the eastern tidal tail , and extending to the southeast of ngc6872 s stellar distribution until it merges into the x - ray trail ( see fig .
[ fig : nonstellarcompare ] and machacek et al .
this disturbed morphology signals the importance of hydrodynamical forces , such as ram pressure or turbulent viscosity , that are caused by high velocity interactions between the galaxies and the ambient group igm .
these interactions act strongly on the diffuse hot galaxy gas , but are ineffective at disturbing the stars .
we discuss the detailed thermodynamic properties of the hot gas in and around the dominant pavo galaxies ( ngc 6876 and ngc 6872 ) , the signatures of the supersonic passage of ngc 6872 through the core of the pavo group that are imprinted on that gas , and the impact of these galaxy - group interactions on the hydrodynamical state of the pavo igm in a forthcoming paper ( machacek et al . 2008b , in preparation ) .
the dominant galaxies in the pavo galaxy group core , i.e. the large spiral galaxy ngc6872 , central group elliptical ngc6876 , and their companion galaxies ic4970 and ngc6877 , provide an ideal nearby laboratory to study the combined effects of galaxy - galaxy tidal interactions and high velocity galaxy - igm interactions on star formation and galaxy evolution . in this paper
we present results from _ spitzer _
mid - infrared observations of these galaxies in the @xmath38 , @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and @xmath0 irac bands , and _
chandra _ x - ray observations of the x - ray point source population and hot gas in the spiral galaxy ngc6872 .
we combined these results with archival optical and hi data to study the properties of interaction - induced star formation in and near the large spiral galaxy .
we find the following : excess @xmath101 emission in ngc6876 , the central pavo group elliptical galaxy , is weak and follows the distribution of starlight . in the central @xmath168kpc ( @xmath75 ) of ngc6876 , @xmath244 of the @xmath0 emission is ` nonstellar ' ( as defined in
[ sec : irac ] and pahre et al .
2004 ) , while we find no statistically significant nonstellar emission at @xmath1 .
this suggests that the nonstellar @xmath0 flux may reflect leakage of the broad @xmath93 emission feature , produced by warm silicate dust grains ejected from the atmospheres of evolved agb stars , into the @xmath0 bandpass .
nonstellar emission , with mid - infrared colors consistent with emission from pah molecules and a warm dust continuum , contributes @xmath245 ( @xmath98 ) of the total @xmath0 ( @xmath1 ) emission in the central @xmath7kpc of ngc6877 , the elliptical companion galaxy to ngc6876 , and suggests the presence of warm dust irradiated by recent star formation in ngc6877 s nuclear region . in the spiral galaxy ngc6872 , @xmath0 and @xmath1 nonstellar emission , with mid - infrared colors
consistent with emission from pah molecules and warm dust , is found concentrated in clumps in a @xmath2kpc radius outer ring about the center of the spiral galaxy , in a bridge of emission connecting ngc6872 s northern spiral arm to ic4970 , and @xmath146kpc northeast and southwest of the nucleus along the full extent of ngc6872 s tidal arms .
the mid - infrared colors in ngc6872 are consistent with those found in star - forming regions in other interacting galaxies .
the @xmath115 flux ratio ( @xmath246 ) in the bright nonstellar emission regions is depressed relative to elsewhere in the galaxy .
the @xmath68-[5.8]$ ] color reddens from @xmath118 in the inner @xmath2kpc of the galaxy , where there is little nonstellar emission , to @xmath247 in the ring and @xmath248 in the bright nonstellar emission clumps in the bridge and the tidal arms , indicating a younger stellar population and/or more interstellar dust in these features . the @xmath135 flux ratio , a measure of the star formation rate per unit mass , is as much as a factor @xmath138 higher in the bright nonstellar emission clumps in the tidal features in ngc6872 than in the spiral galaxy s center .
the @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] color of the nonstellar emission in the bright clumps is @xmath249 , in excellent agreement with the theoretical prediction for emission from pah emission and warm dust .
we find no strong differences in the mid - infrared colors of the star - forming regions in the spiral galaxy ngc6872 as a function of their position relative to the tidally interacting companion galaxy ic4970 .
young star clusters are strongly correlated with the regions of intense nonstellar emission in the bridge and tidal arms .
the brightest nonstellar emission clumps and most of the star clusters also correspond to regions rich in hi gas .
eleven x - ray sources with luminosities @xmath250ergs@xmath4are found strongly correlated with non - stellar @xmath101 emission and young star clusters in ngc6872 , suggesting that these sources , while near ulx luminosities , may be bright hmxb s .
most of these bright sources are clustered to the south in ngc6872 , and avoid the highly disrupted bridge region close to the tidally interacting companion ic4970 , despite a high concentration of young star clusters and strong nonstellar @xmath0 emission in that region .
the nucleus of ngc6872 is a weak x - ray point source with @xmath5kev luminosity of @xmath6ergs@xmath4 .
mid - infrared colors of the nuclear region of ngc6872 are consistent with normal ( nonactive ) galaxies dominated by starlight . statistically significant ( @xmath251 or @xmath247mjy )
nonstellar emission is observed at @xmath0 , but not in the @xmath1 ( @xmath252 ) bandpass .
thus , while dust is present , there is little evidence in the inner @xmath7kpc ( @xmath76 ) of ngc6872 for pah emission from recent star formation or nuclear activity .
we observe a @xmath8kpc ( @xmath159 ) stream of interstellar matter at @xmath196micron , that extends from ngc6872 s ring to the galaxy s nuclear region and is bordered by three young star clusters and two x - ray sources .
the @xmath0 nonstellar surface brightness in the stream is a factor @xmath253 greater than in the surrounding central region of ngc6872 .
this stream may signal the transport of matter along ngc6872 s central bar into the nucleus , as predicted by simulations , and may be a prelude to a future nuclear starburst or episode of strong agn activity in the primary galaxy .
mid - infrared nonstellar ( pah and dust ) emission clumps and young star clusters are found in ngc6872 s bridge , tidal arms and trailing the spiral galaxy to the southeast , bordering regions of diffuse x - ray gas .
this may suggest that stars form as gas stripped by the interaction cools .
support for this work was provided , in part , by the national aeronautics and space administration ( nasa ) through _ chandra _ award number go6 - 7068x issued by the _
chandra _ x - ray observatory center , which is operated by the smithsonian astrophysical observatory for and on behalf of nasa under contract nas8 - 03060 , by nasa through an award issued by jpl / caltech , and by the smithsonian institution .
this work is based in part on observations made with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa .
this work made use of the irac post - bcd processing software `` iracproc '' developed by mike schuster , massimo marengo and brian patten at the smithsonian astrophysical observatory , and also data products from the two micron all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and the infrared data analysis and processing center / california institute of technology , funded by nasa and the national science foundation , and has used the nasa / ipac extragalactic database ( ned ) , which is operated by jpl / caltech , under contract with nasa has also been used .
we especially thank massimo marengo for help with iracproc , and cathy horellou and brbel koribalski for use of their hi maps of ngc6872 .
arp , h. 1966 , , 14 , 1 athey , a. , bregman , b. , bregman , j. , temi , p. & sauvage , m. 2002 , , 571 , 272 bradt , h.v.d . & mcclintock , j. e. 1983 , , 21 , 13 barton , e.j . ,
geller , m.j .
, & kenyon , s.j .
2000 , , 530 , 660 bastian , n. , hempel , m. , kissler - patig , m. , homeier , n. & trancho , g. ( 2005 ) , a&a , 435 , 65 bautz , m.w .
, et al . 1998 , in proceedings of the spie , 3444 , x - ray optics , instruments and missions , ed .
hoover & a.b .
walker , 210 bogdan , a. & gilfanov , m. 2008 , , submitted , eprint arxiv:0803.0063 brandt , w.r .
et al .
2001 , aj , 122 , 2810 bressan , a. et al .
2006 , , 632 , l55 bressan , a. et al .
2008 , aspc , 381 , 12 buckalew , b.a .
et al .
2006 , , 162 , 329 calzetti , d. et al .
2005 , , 633 , 871 carrasco , e. , de oliveira , c.m . &
infante , l. 2006 , , 132 , 1796 colbert , e. , heckman , t.m . , ptak , a. & strickland , d.k .
2004 , cooper , m.c .
et al .
2006 , , 370 , 198 davis , j.e .
2001 , , 562 , 575 elmegreen , d.m . ,
elmegreen , b.g . ,
kaufman , m. , sheth , k. , struck , c. , thomasson , m. , & brinks , e. 2006 , , 642 , 158 elmegreen , b.g . & efremov , y.n .
1996 , apj , 466 , 802 fazio , g. et al .
2004 , apjs , 154 , 10 ferrari , f. , pastoriza , m.g . ,
macchetto , f.d . ,
conatto , c. , panagia , n. & sparks , w.b .
2002 , a&a , 389 , 355 garmire , g.p .
et al .
1992 , aiaa , space programs and technologies conference , march 24 - 27 , 1992 ( paper 92 - 1473 ; new york : aiaa ) gerke , b.f .
et al .
2005 , , 625 , 6 gerke , b.f .
et al .
2007 , , 376 , 1425 hancock , m. , smith , b.j . , struck , c. , giroux , m.l . , appleton , p.n . ,
charmandaris , v. & reach , w. t. 2007 , , 133 , 693 hernquist , l. & mihos , c. 1995 , , 448 , 41 horellou , c. & booth , r. 1997 , a&as , 126 , 3 horellou , c. & koribalski , b. 2007 , a&a , 464 , 155 hornschemeier , a. et al .
2001 , , 554 , 742 kennicutt , r.c . ,
jr.,roetigger , k.a . , van der hulst , j.m . , & hummel , e. 1987 , , 93
, 101 kennicutt et al .
2003 , pasp , 115 , 928 lauer , t. et al .
2002 , , 124 , 1975 lacy , m. et al .
2004 , apjs , 154 , 166 lambas , d.g . ,
tissera , p.b . ,
alonso , m.s . ,
coldwell , g. 2003 , , 346 , 1189 landt , h. , padovani , p. , perlman , e. , giommi , p. , bignall , h. , & tzioumis , a. 2001 , , 323 , 757 li , a. & draine , b.t .
2001 , , 554 , 778 li , z. & wang , q.d .
2007 , , 668 , 826 maccacaro , t. et al . 1982 , , 253 , 504 maccacaro , t. , gioia , i.m . ,
wolter , a. , zamorani , g. & stocke , j.t . 1988 , , 326 , 680 machacek , m. , dosaj , a. , forman , w. , jones , c. , markevitch , m. , vikhlinin , a. , warmflash , a. & kraft , r. 2005a , , 621 , 663 machacek , m.e . , nulsen , p.e.j . , stirbat , l. , jones , c. & forman , w.r .
2005b , , 630 , 280 machacek , m.e . , kraft , r.p . ,
ashby , m.l.n . ,
evans , d. , jones , c. & forman , w.r . 2008a , , 674 , 142 machacek , m.e . ,
kraft , r.p . ,
jones , c. & forman , w.r .
2008b , in prep .
mihos , c. , bothun , g. & richstone , d. 1993 , , 418 , 82 mihos , c. & hernquist , l. 1996 , , 464 , 641 merrifield , m.r .
1998 , , 294 , 347 nikolic , b. , cullen , h. & alexamder , p. 2004
, , 355 , 874 noguchi , m. 1988 , a & a , 203 , 259 pahre , m. , ashby , m.l.n , fazio , g.g .
, & willner , s.p .
2004 , , 154 , 229 reach , w.t . et al . 2005 , pasp , 117 , 978 revnivtsev , m. , sazonov , s. , gilfanov , m. , churazov , e. & synyaev , r. 2006 , a&a 452 , 169 sazonov , s. , revnivtsev , m. , gilfanov , m. , churazov , e. , & sunyaev , r. 2006 , a&a 450 , 117 smith , b.j . , struck , c. , appleton , p.n .
, charmandaris , v. , reach , w. & eitter , j.j .
2005 , , 130 , 2117 smith , b.j . , struck , c. & nowak , m.a .
2005b , , 129 , 1350 smith , b.j .
, struck , c. , hancock , m. , appleton , p.n . , charmandaris , v. & reach , w.t .
2007 , 133 , 791 spergel , d.n .
et al .
2006 , astro - ph/0603449 stern , d. et al .
2005 , , 631 , l163 stocke , j.t .
et al .
1991 , , 76 , 813 swartz , d. , ghosh , k.k .
, tennant , a.f . & wu , k. 2004 , , 154 , 519 trancho , g. , bastian , n. , schweizer , f. & miller , b.w .
2007 , , 658 , 993 vorontsov - velyaminov , b. 1959 , atlas and catalog of interacting galaxies , sternberg institute , moscow : moscow university wang , z. et al .
2004 , , 154 , 193 werk , j.k . ,
putman , m.e . ,
meurer , g.r . ,
oey , m.d . , ryan - weber , e.v .
, kennicutt jr , r.c . , &
freeman , k.c .
2008 , , 678 , 888 van paradijs , j. & mcclintock , j.e .
1995 in x - ray binaries , ed . w.h.g .
lewin , j. van paradijs , & e.p.j .
van den heuvel ( cambridge : cambridge univ .
press ) , 58 werner , m.w .
et al .
2004 , apjs , 154 , 1 whitney , b.a . et al .
2004 , apjs , 154 , 315 willner , s.p .
et al .
2004 , , 154 , 222 wu , h. , cao , c. , hao , c .-
n . , liu , f .- s . ,
wang , j .- l . , xia , x .- y . , deng , z .- g . , & young , c. k .- s .
2005 , , 632 , l79 zezas , a. , fabbiano , g. , rots , a. & murray , s.s .
2002 , , 142 , 239 lccc full & & & + & @xmath38 & @xmath254 & @xmath255 + & @xmath39 & @xmath256 & @xmath257 + & @xmath40 & @xmath258 & @xmath259 + & @xmath260 & @xmath261 & @xmath262 + full ns & & & + & @xmath40 & @xmath263 & + & @xmath260 & @xmath264 & + center & & & + & @xmath38 & @xmath265 & @xmath266 + & @xmath39 & @xmath267 & @xmath268 + & @xmath40 & @xmath269 & @xmath270 + & @xmath260 & @xmath271 & @xmath272 + center ns & & & + & @xmath40 & @xmath273 & + & @xmath260 & @xmath274 & @xmath275 + lccc full & & & + & @xmath38 & @xmath276 & @xmath277 + & @xmath39 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 + & @xmath40 & @xmath280 & @xmath281 + & @xmath260 & @xmath282 & @xmath283 + full ns & & & + & @xmath40 & @xmath284 & @xmath285 + & @xmath260 & @xmath286 & @xmath287 + center & & & + & @xmath38 & @xmath288 & @xmath289 + & @xmath39 & @xmath290 & @xmath291 + & @xmath40 & @xmath292 & @xmath293 + & @xmath260 & @xmath294 & @xmath295 + center ns & & & + & @xmath40 & @xmath296 & @xmath297 + & @xmath260 & @xmath298 & @xmath299 + lccc ngc6876 & & & + full & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath302 + center & @xmath303 & @xmath304 & @xmath305 + ngc6877 & & & + full & @xmath306 & @xmath304 & @xmath307 + center & @xmath308 & @xmath309 & @xmath310 + lccc all & & & + & @xmath38 & @xmath311 & @xmath312 + & @xmath39 & @xmath313 & @xmath314 + & @xmath40 & @xmath315 & @xmath316 + & @xmath260 & @xmath317 & @xmath318 + nonstellar & & & + & @xmath40 & @xmath153 & + & @xmath260 & @xmath155 & @xmath319 + ccc @xmath115 & @xmath320 & @xmath321 + @xmath67-[4.5]$ ] & @xmath322 & @xmath303 + & & + @xmath116 & @xmath323 & @xmath324 + @xmath68-[5.8]$ ] & @xmath114 & @xmath325 + & & + @xmath135 & @xmath326 & @xmath327 + @xmath67-[8.0]$ ] & @xmath328 & @xmath329 + & & + @xmath142 & @xmath323 & @xmath324 + @xmath69-[8.0]$ ] & @xmath96 & @xmath330 + ccccccccc @xmath7 & @xmath331 & @xmath332 & @xmath333 & @xmath334 & @xmath335 & @xmath336 & @xmath337 & @xmath338 + @xmath193 & @xmath339 & @xmath340 & @xmath341 & @xmath342 & @xmath343 & @xmath344 & @xmath345 & @xmath346 + @xmath194 & @xmath347 & @xmath348 & @xmath349 & @xmath350 & @xmath351 & @xmath352 & @xmath353 & @xmath354 + @xmath8 & @xmath355 & @xmath356 & @xmath357 & @xmath358 & @xmath359 & @xmath360 & @xmath361 & @xmath345 + @xmath2 & @xmath362 & @xmath363 & @xmath364 & @xmath365 & @xmath366 & @xmath367 & @xmath300 & @xmath368 + n & @xmath369 & @xmath370 & @xmath371 & @xmath372 & @xmath373 & @xmath374 & @xmath375 & @xmath376 + @xmath195 & @xmath377 & @xmath378 & @xmath379 & @xmath380 & @xmath381 & @xmath382 & @xmath308 & @xmath383 + @xmath233 & @xmath384 & @xmath385 & @xmath386 & @xmath387 & @xmath388 & @xmath389 & @xmath390 & @xmath337 + @xmath196 & @xmath391 & @xmath392 & @xmath393 & @xmath394 & @xmath395 & @xmath396 & @xmath397 & @xmath398 + @xmath197 & @xmath399 & @xmath400 & @xmath401 & @xmath402 & @xmath403 & @xmath404 & @xmath405 & @xmath406 + @xmath234 & @xmath407 & @xmath408 & @xmath409&@xmath410 & @xmath411 & @xmath412 & @xmath413 & @xmath414 + @xmath166 & @xmath415 & @xmath416 & @xmath417&@xmath418 & @xmath419 & @xmath420 & @xmath421 & @xmath422 + | we combine _ spitzer _ irac mid - infrared and _ chandra _ x - ray observations of the dominant galaxies ngc6872 and ngc6876 in the pavo group with archival optical and hi data to study interaction - induced star formation
. in the spiral galaxy ngc6872 , @xmath0 and @xmath1 nonstellar emission having colors consistent with polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons ( pahs ) is concentrated primarily in clumps in three regions : in a @xmath2kpc radius outer ring about the center of the spiral galaxy , in a bridge of emission connecting ngc6872 s northern spiral arm to ic4970 , and along the full extent of both ngc6872 s tidal arms .
pah emission is correlated with young star clusters and dense hi regions .
we find no strong differences in the mid - infrared colors of the star - forming regions in the spiral galaxy ngc6872 as a function of position relative to the tidally interacting companion galaxy ic4970 .
we find eleven very luminous x - ray sources ( @xmath3ergs@xmath4 ) clustered to the southwest in ngc6872 , near bright star - forming regions . in ngc6872
s tidal features , young star clusters form at the boundaries of diffuse x - ray gas , suggesting that stars form as gas stripped by the interactions cools .
the nucleus of ngc6872 is a weak x - ray point source with @xmath5kev luminosity of @xmath6ergs@xmath4 , but there is little evidence in the inner @xmath7kpc of ngc6872 for pah emission from recent star formation or nuclear activity .
however , a @xmath8kpc ` stream ' , leading from the outer ring of ngc6872 to the nucleus , may signal the transport of interstellar matter into ngc6872 s nuclear region .
nonstellar emission , consistent with pah emission , is also found in the central region of elliptical galaxy ngc6877 , companion to the dominant pavo group elliptical galaxy ngc6876 .
however , in the central region of ngc6876 , the dust emission is more likely due to silicate emission from old agb stars . |
ngc 5694 is a bright ( @xmath8 ) and remote ( @xmath9 kpc ) old and metal - poor galactic globular cluster ( gc ) , located in the hydra constellation .
first discovered by w. herschel in 1784 , it has been recognised as a gc by @xcite .
because of its distance and low apparent magnitude , the first photometric studies of giant stars in this cluster have been conducted only in relatively recent epoch @xcite .
after the first integrated spectroscopic studies ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ) spectroscopy of individual red giant stars in ngc 5694 have been carried out by @xcite and , more recently , by @xcite .
the latter derived the chemical composition for one bright giant of the cluster from a high - resolution spectrum and found an abundance pattern different from ordinary stars and clusters in the galactic halo , more similar to those displayed by stars in dwarf spheroidal galaxies .
the accretion of globular clusters into the halo of giant galaxies during the disruption of their parent dwarf galaxy is now established to have occurred in the milky way ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) and in m31 @xcite .
dense nuclei of stripped dwarf satellites can also appear as massive gcs at the present epoch ( see * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* for references and discussion ) .
chemical tagging is one of the main technique to identify otherwise ordinary gcs as accreted from a former , and now fully disrupted , galactic satellite . to follow - up the intriguing finding by @xcite we started a multi - instrument observational campaign that allowed us ( a ) to trace the surface brightness ( sb ) profile of the cluster down to @xmath10 mag / arcsec@xmath11 , finding that it extends smoothly much beyond the tidal radius of the best - fitting @xcite model and that it can not be adequately fit neither by a @xcite , @xcite nor @xcite model ( * ? ? ?
* c11 hereafter ) , and ( b ) to perform accurate abundance analysis from high - resolution spectra for _ six _ cluster giants , fully confirming that the cluster has a chemical pattern different from the galactic halo , with nearly solar [ @xmath12/fe ] ratio and anomalously low abundances of y , ba , la and eu , at [ fe / h]@xmath13 ( * ? ? ?
* mu13 hereafter ) . here
we present a study of the kinematics of the cluster , based on a large sample of medium - resolution spectra of stars selected to lie on the red giant branch ( rgb ) in the color magnitude diagram of the cluster .
the plan of the paper is the following : in sect . 2 we present our observations and we describe the data reduction . in sect . 3 and 4
we describe how we derived our estimates of the radial velocity and metallicity , respectively , from the available spectra . in sect .
5 we present our criteria to select cluster members and the analysis of the cluster kinematics , including estimates of the dynamical mass . finally in sect .
6 we briefly summarise and discuss the results of the analysis .
the data have been acquired with the multi - object facility flames@vlt @xcite in the combined medusa+uves mode , allowing the simultaneous allocation of 8 uves high - resolution fibres and 132 medusa mid - resolution fibres .
for the uves spectra , discussed in details in mu13 , we employed the 580 red arm set - up , with spectral resolution @xmath1440000 and wavelength coverage @xmath1548006800 .
the giraffe targets have been observed with the hr21 setup , with a resolving power of @xmath1516000 and a spectral coverage between @xmath1584809000 .
this grating was chosen because it includes the prominent ca ii triplet lines , which are ideal to measure radial velocities ( rv ) also in spectra of faint stars and to derive an estimate of their metallicity .
two configurations of target stars have been used .
a total of 4 exposures of 46 min each for each configuration has been secured in service mode during the period between april and july 2012 .
a small overlap between the two configurations ( 12 stars ) has been secured in order to cross - check the stability of the rv when measured with different fibres .
the target selection has been performed with the b , v photometric catalog by c11 obtained by combining vimos@vlt and wfpc2@hst data .
we selected stars along the rgb with v@xmath1620 .
stars with close ( within 2 arcsec ) companion stars of comparable or brighter magnitude have been discarded , to avoid spurious contaminations in the fibre .
about 15 - 20 fibres in each configuration have been dedicated to sample the sky background , because this spectral range is affected by prominent @xmath17 and oh sky emission lines .
[ cmd ] shows the ( v , b - v ) colour - magnitude diagram of ngc 5694 with with giraffe targets marked as red circles and the uves ones as blue asterisks .
the spatial distribution of the targets with respect to the cluster center is shown in fig .
[ map ] ; a circle with radius equal to the cluster tidal radius of the k66 model providing the best - fit to the sb profile of ngc 5694 , as derived in c11 , is also plotted , for reference . ) with respect to the cluster center by @xcite .
the black circle indicate the tidal radius of the k66 model providing the best - fit to the sb profile of ngc 5694 ( from c11).,width=317 ] the data reduction has been performed using the last version of the eso pipeline , including bias - subtraction , flat - fielding , wavelength calibration with a standard th - ar lamp and spectral extraction .
the accuracy of the zero - point of the wavelength calibration has been checked by measuring the position of several sky emission lines and comparing them with their rest - frame position taken from the sky lines atlas by @xcite . for each star the average difference between the measured and reference line positions is always smaller than 0.02 , corresponding to less than one half of a pixel .
these shifts turns out to be compatible with 0 within the quoted uncertainties .
hence , no relevant wavelengths shift is found .
each individual stellar spectrum has been subtracted from the sky by using a master sky spectrum obtained as a median of the different sky spectra observed in that exposure .
then the proper heliocentric correction has been applied .
finally , individual spectra of the same target have been combined together .
the typical snr per pixel ( measured at @xmath158550 @xmath18 ) is of @xmath15150 for the brightest targets ( v@xmath1516 ) and of @xmath1510 for the faintest stars ( v@xmath1520 ) .
some targets have been discarded because of the poor quality of their spectra or due to some residuals of the sky lines that can affect the correct rv measurement . finally , the following analysis is based on 165 stars with reliable rv and metallicity estimates .
rvs have been measured with the standard cross - correlation technique of the observed spectrum against a template of known rv , as implemented in the iraf task fxcor . as template
, we adopted a synthetic spectrum calculated with the code synthe , adopting the entire atomic and molecular line - list by kurucz and castelli and a atlas9 model atmosphere calculated with the metallicity of the cluster , [ fe / h]@xmath152.0 dex and the typical atmospheric parameters of a giant star ( @xmath19= 4500 k , log(g)= 1.5 ) .
uncertainties in the rv have been computed by fxcor according to @xcite , by taking into account the height and width of the cross - correlation function and the mean distance between its main peak and the nearest secondary peaks ( eq . 24 by * ? ? ?
* ) . as an additional sanity check
, the rvs of the 12 stars observed in both configurations have been measured individually .
the two sets of rv agree very well each other , with a mean difference of @xmath20 km / s , fully compatible with a null difference .
[ rvdist ] shows the rv distribution of the entire sample of giraffe targets .
the distribution ranges from 171 km / s to + 231 km / s , with a dominant peak around at @xmath15140 km / s and corresponding to the cluster stars ( the average rv derived from the 6 uves targets is of [email protected] km / s ) .
the inset panel shows a zoomed view of the region around the main peak of the rv distribution , with marked as a reference the average rv obtained from the uves targets ( red solid vertical line ) .
abundances for all the target stars have been obtained by using the strength of the ca ii triplet lines as a proxy of the metallicity .
the lines of the ca ii triplet lines have been fitted with a voigt profile , in order to reproduce the prominent pressure - broadened line wings , and then their equivalent widths ( ews ) obtained by direct integration of the best - fit profile .
the metallicities have been obtained by adopting the calibration by @xcite and assuming @xmath22= 18.5 mag @xcite .
uncertainties in the measured ews of the ca ii triplet lines have been estimated by employing monte carlo simulations .
a synthetic spectrum has been re - sampled at the pixel - size of the giraffe spectra ( 0.05 /pixel ) and then poissonian noise corresponding to four values of snr ( namely 10,50,100,150 ) has been injected in order to simulate the noise conditions of the observed spectra . for each value of snr ,
1000 synthetic spectra have been generated following this approach , the ews of the ca ii triplet lines have been measured and then the metallicity estimated as done for the observed spectra . for each snr ,
the uncertainty has been computed as 1@xmath23 of the derived [ fe / h ] distribution ; the abundance uncertainty is of 0.13 dex for snr= 10 and 0.01 dex for snr= 150 .
a relation that provides @xmath24}$ ] as a function of snr has been derived and used to estimate the uncertainty in [ fe / h ] of all the targets interpolating at their value of the snr .
additional sources of uncertainty are the error in v-@xmath22 ( a variation of @xmath210.05 mag translates in a variation in [ fe / h ] of @xmath250.01 dex ) and the uncertainty in the @xmath26[fe / h ] linear fit ( @xmath23= 0.08 dex , as quoted by * ? ? ?
the distribution of the [ fe / h ] abundance ratios as derived from ca ii triplet lines is shown in fig .
[ iron ] as an empty histogram . for 19 targets ,
the quality of the spectra ( snr@xmath2740 ) allows to determine the iron abundance directly from the measure of fe i lines .
we identify a ten of fe i lines , unblended at the hr21 setup resolution and at the atmospheric parameters and metallicity of the targets ( see mu13 , for details ) .
ews measurements have been performed by using the code daospec @xcite , iteratively launched by means of the package 4dao@xcite that allows an analysis cascade of a large sample of stellar spectra and a visual inspection of the gaussian fit obtained for all the investigated lines .
the iron abundance has been derived with the package gala @xcite , by matching the measured and the theoretical ews .
atmospheric parameters have been derived by using the b , v photometry by c11 .
@xmath19 have been computed by means of the @xmath28@xmath19 transformation by @xcite based on the infrared flux method ; the de - reddened color @xmath28 is obtained adopting a color excess e(b - v)= 0.099 mag ( c11 ) and the extinction law by @xcite .
surface gravities have been computed with the stefan - boltzmann relation , assuming the photometric @xmath19 , the distance modulus of [email protected] mag ( c11 ) and an evolutive mass of 0.75 @xmath29 , according to an isochrone from the basti dataset @xcite with age of 12 gyr , z= 0.0003 and a solar - scaled chemical mixtures .
the bolometric corrections are calculated according to eq .
( 17 ) of @xcite .
micro - turbulent velocities can not be estimated from these spectra because of the small number of available lines and we adopted for all the targets the average value obtained by the uves spectra , @xmath30= 1.8 km / s .
the average iron abundance of these 19 stars is [ fe / h][email protected] dex , in reasonable agreement with the value derived by the uves spectra , [ fe / h][email protected] dex ( mu13 ) .
also , we highlight the good agreement between the abundances derived from ca ii triplet and from fe i lines : the average difference of the iron abundances for the 19 stars in common is @xmath31_{cat}-[fe / h]_{fe}=+0.02\pm 0.01 $ ] dex ( @xmath23= 0.08 dex ) . fig .
[ iron ] shows the distribution of the 19 stars as a grey histogram , while the inset panel shows the difference between [ fe / h ] from fe i lines and from ca ii lines .
we consider together the 25 stars for which a direct fe abundance has been derived , 19 giraffe and 6 uves targets .
the mean abundance , together with the intrinsic spread @xmath32 and their uncertainties , have been calculated with the maximum likelihood algorithm described in @xcite .
we obtain an average value of [ fe / h][email protected] dex ( @xmath32= [email protected] dex ) that we recommended as the final value for the fe abundance . in comparison ,
the same algorithm applied on the [ fe / h ] derived from ca ii triplet lines of the 83 member stars provides [ fe / h][email protected] dex ( @xmath32= [email protected] dex ) .
distribution of the targets as obtained from the ca ii triplet lines ( empty histogram ) and from the direct measurement of fe i lines ( uves+giraffe , grey - shaded histogram ) . the inset panel show the difference between the iron content from fe i lines and from ca ii triplet lines as a function of @xmath31_{fei}$ ] for 19 target stars observed with flames . the typical uncertainty in the difference
is shown as the error - bar of the empty circle in the lower - right corner of the inset.,width=317 ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in the lower panel of fig .
[ disp ] we superimpose to the data the predictions of three models that fits the observed sb profile of the cluster ( at least in the innermost regions , see c11 and fig
. [ sbprof ] ) .
the models have been normalised to best fit the observed velocity dispersion profile .
the first two models are the single - mass isotropic ( * ? ? ?
* k66 hereafter ) and ( * ? ? ?
* w75 ) models that were proposed in c11 .
in addition to these we adopt also a _ darkexp _ model ( * ? ? ?
* hw10 ) that is shown , in fig .
[ sbprof ] , to provide a reasonable fit of the sb profile over the whole extension of the cluster , in particular in the outermost region of the profile where k66 , w75 and @xcite models fail ( see c11 ) .
darkexp models are theoretically derived maximum entropy equilibrium states of self - gravitating collision - less systems ( hw10 ) . @xcite
have shown that in many cases ( including ngc 5694 ) they provide a better fit to the observed profiles of gcs , with respect to k66 models .
the main difference between k66/w75 models and darkexp models is in the assumed distribution function ( df ; @xmath33 ) .
k66 and w75 models adopt a df from the family of lowered maxwellian distributions , which reproduces the trend toward an isothermal condition driven by collisions .
darkexp models , instead , adopt a df such that the corresponding energy distribution ( n(e)=@xmath34 ) is a lowered maxwellian distribution , with a proper treatment of the low - occupation - number regime ( see * ? ? ?
* for details and discussion ) . the comparisons displayed in the lower panel of fig .
[ disp ] clearly show the inadequacy of k66 models to describe the kinematics of ngc 5694 .
this is due to the tidal truncation that is built - in in k66 models : the sb profile is unable to fit the extended @xmath35 outer profile of the cluster and , consequently , it lacks sufficient mass in the outer regions to sustain a ( nearly ) flat dispersion profile beyond @xmath36 .
the lack of a tidal truncation may be related to the fact that the cluster is under - filling its roche lobe by a significant amount ( see c11 and sect .
[ sum ] , for further discussion ) . on the other hand both the w75 and darkexp models , that have much more extended sb profiles ,
provide a fair representation of the cluster kinematics .
the central dispersion estimate by @xcite appears slightly low with respect to our innermost point and the extrapolation of all best - fitting models .
it would be valuable to have an independent estimate of the dispersion in the innermost regions based on the velocities of individual stars , to obtain a robust validation of the estimate by @xcite from integrated spectroscopy .
moreover , it has to be recalled that in this comparison we considered only isotropic single - mass and non - collisional models . in the innermost regions of the cluster collisional processes
can be important and mass - segregation , as well as anisotropy , is expected to contribute in shaping the overall line - of - sight velocity dispersion profile . to explore the possible role of orbital anisotropy and mass segregation in the dynamics of ngc 5694 we compare , in fig .
[ aniso ] , the observed sb and @xmath23 profiles of the clusters with the predictions of a model including radial anisotropy , two multi - mass models and one multi - mass anisotropic model .
the continuos lines in both panels of fig .
[ aniso ] correspond to a single - mass king - michie ( k - m * ? ? ?
* ) model with the maximum degree of radial anisotropy that still ensures stability ( see * ? ? ?
* for a thorough discussion of this family of models ) . in these models
, orbits are isotropic in the center and becomes radially biased at a characteristic radius @xmath37 .
a rough criterion for stability is represented by the so - called fridman - polyachenko - shukhman parameter @xmath38 ( friedman & polyachenko 1984 ) , where @xmath39 and @xmath40 are the radial and tangential component of the kinetic energy tensor : a fully isotropic model have @xmath41 , while models with @xmath42 undergo bar instability on timescales of few tens of dynamical times ( nipoti et al . 2002 ) , where @xmath43 and @xmath44 are the tangential and radial components of the velocity , respectively , is not particularly informative for k - m models , since , by construction , they have @xmath45 at their center and @xmath46 in their outermost region , the shape of the distribution of @xmath47 being characterised by the anisotropy radius @xmath48 ( see * ? ? ?
* and references therein ) .
the maximum degree of radial anisotropy of the considered k - m model ( @xmath49 ) is required to obtain a reasonable reproduction of the extended outer branch of the sb profile .
the velocity dispersion profile provides a good description of the nearly - flat branch of the observed profile but it fails to fit the central point by more than six times the error on the central dispersion by @xcite .
it is interesting to note that excluding the central point to the best - fitting of the velocity normalisation leads to a nearly perfect fit to the profile , for @xmath50 , but , in this case , the predicted value of the central dispersion is as high as 14.0 km / s . ;
continuous line ) , and with the predictions for the distribution of star in the largest mass bin ( approximately corresponding to cluster giants ) of two multi - mass king models computed following g79 .
the dotted lines correspond to a model with a single power law mf with index @xmath51 ; the short - dashed lines correspond to a model with @xcite mf . finally , the long - dashed dark grey lines correspond to a multi - mass model with @xcite mf and radial anisotropy .
all the models have been normalised to best fit the observed velocity dispersion profile.,width=317 ] in real clusters formed by stars with a mass spectrum and where the effects of collisions in the cluster center are non negligible , the density and velocity dispersion profiles are different for stars of different mass . broadly speaking , massive stars tend to transfer kinetic energy to less massive stars thus becoming kinematically cooler and sinking in the innermost region of the cluster on less energetic orbits .
the amount of kinetic energy transferred by a given star is a function of the contrast between its mass and the average mass of cluster stars , therefore depending on the mass function ( mf ) .
the three king multi - mass models shown in fig . [ aniso ] as dotted , dashed and dot - dashed lines have been computed following ( * ? ? ?
* g79 hereafter ) assuming 8 mass bins ( all covering equal - mass intervals at different ranges ) between 0.1 and 0.8 @xmath29 populated according to different assumption on the mf and degree of radial anisotropy : the dotted lines correspond to an isotropic model with a single power law mf ( in the form @xmath52 ) , with index @xmath51 , the short - dashed lines correspond to an isotropic model with a @xcite mf and the long - dashed lines correspond to a radially anisotropic model ( @xmath53 ) with a @xcite mf .
dark remnants have been added to the original mf following the prescriptions by sollima , bellazzini & lee ( 2012 ) . since our sb profile , and especially the velocity dispersion profile
, are mainly based on giant stars we derived the best - fit by comparing them with the predictions for the most massive mass bin .
while both the isotropic multi - mass models fails to reproduce the outer branch of the sb profile , they provide a good fit to the dispersion profile over the whole radial range .
an even better fit is provided by the anisotropic model ( with @xmath54 ) which well reproduce the shape of both the sb and the velocity dispersion profile along their entire extent .
a gentler decline of the velocity dipersion curve with respect to isotropic k66 models is also predicted in the framework of the modified newtonian dynamics @xcite .
however in this case one would expect a convex shape of the velocity dispersion profile in contrast with our data , unless a high degree of radial anisotropy is present ( i.e. , higher than that assumed here for king - michie models in newtonian dynamics , see * ? ? ? * ) .
in general , given the good fit provided by darkexp and multi - mass anisotropic models described above , we conclude that there is no need to invoke a modification of the newtonian gravity to explain the observed structure and kinematics of this cluster .
it is interesting to note that the masses of the three best - fitting isotropic single - mass models are fully consistent . for the k66 model
we obtain @xmath55 , for the w75 model @xmath56 , and for the darkexp model @xmath57 , corresponding to @xmath58 .
these values are in excellent agreement with the only previous dynamical mass estimate that can be found in the literature , i.e. , @xmath59 by @xcite , based on the central velocity dispersion from a preliminary analysis of the data of @xcite .
the agreement is good also with the non - dynamical estimates by @xcite , who found @xmath60 for both k66 and w75 models , adopting @xmath61 and a total v luminosity lower than that estimated by c11 and used here ( @xmath62 instead of @xmath8 ) . on the other hand , anisotropic and
multi - mass models suggest a slightly larger mass , due to the fact that these models have a significant fraction of their kinetic energy in motions that are not accessible to a sampling of line - of - sight velocities of giants .
the single - mass k - m anisotropic model gives @xmath63 , the isotropic multi - mass models give @xmath64 and @xmath65 for the power - law mf with @xmath51 and the kroupa ( 2002 ) mf , respectively , and the anisotropic multi - mass model gives @xmath66 . using the anisotropy - independent estimator of the mass enclosed within the half light radius by @xcite , integrating over the observed sb profile and interpolating the dispersion profile with a spline , we obtain @xmath67 .
since in a star cluster the mass should approximately follow light ( modulo the mass segregation ) the total mass should be @xmath68 , also in reasonable agreement with the model - dependent estimates .
we obtained rv and [ fe / h ] estimates from medium - resolution giraffe spectra for 165 stars selected to lie on the rgb of the remote globular cluster ngc 5694 . using both rv and [ fe / h ] we selected a sample of 89 bona - fide cluster members , 83 from the giraffe sample and six from the uves sample presented in mu13 .
based on these data we derived a mean cluster metallicity of [ fe / h]@xmath69 , an intrinsic metallicity dispersion of @xmath70 dex and a systemic radial velocity of @xmath71 km / s .
the cluster kinematics is characterised by a very weak systemic rotation , fully consistent with the _ rotation - metallicity _ and _ rotation - hb morphology _ relations derived by @xcite .
the velocity dispersion profile flattens out at large radii .
this is incompatible with isotropic single - mass k66 models but is reasonably reproduced by both w75 and darkexp models .
however , w75 models provide an unsatisfactory fit to the the cluster sb profile , that , on the other hand is well reproduced by darkexp models over its whole extent . while anisotropic single - mass k - m models and multi - mass isotropic king models seem unable to provide an overall good representation of the structure and kinematics of the cluster , we showed that this result can be attained with multi - mass models including anisotropy .
different models / mass estimators consistently converge on a mass between @xmath72 , and @xmath73 corresponding to @xmath74 quite typical for gcs @xcite .
the two models providing the best representation of both the sb and the @xmath23 profiles lie at the extremes of this range , the darkexp isotropic non - collisional model at the lower end and the multi - mass anisotropic model ( g79-a ) at the upper end .
the anisotropy - independent mass estimator by @xcite is in better agreement with the darkexp model , thus favouring mass ( and mass - to - light ) values toward the lower end .
low values of the mass - to - light ratio ( @xmath75 ) are also in agreement with the predictions of population synthesis models , as derived by @xcite .
we do not report the uncertainties on the individual mass estimates ( due to the errors in the input parameters , like , e.g. , distance , radii , etc . ) since they are significantly smaller than the the factor of @xmath76 systematic uncertainty that is associated to the choice of a given model ( darkexp or g79-a , in particular ) .
lines at fixed @xmath77 ratio are also plotted for reference .
ngc 5694 is plotted as an empty triangle when the k66 tidal radius is adopted , and as a filled triangle when the radius of the outermost point of our sb profile is adopted instead .
the shaded area correspond to the region of over - filling clusters .
, width=317 ] as noted in c11 and clearly illustrated in fig .
[ underf ] ( produced with the same assumptions as c11 , adopting @xmath78 , and taking tidal radii , total luminosities and galactocentric distances from @xcite ) ngc 5694 is largely under - filling its roche lobe , having a ratio between jacoby radius and tidal radius @xmath79 , independently on the actual assumption on the limiting radius ( i.e. , the tidal radius of the best - fitting k66 model or the outermost point of the observed profile ) .
this holds also if the criterion by @xcite , based on the ratio between half - light radius and jacoby radius ( @xmath80 ) , is adopted : ngc 5694 has @xmath81 .
these authors find that tidally under - filling clusters form a distinct family ( compact clusters ) with respect to tidally filling ones and concluded that they were likely born compact .
the smooth nature of both the sb and the velocity dispersion profiles of ngc 5694 suggest that indeed it may be tidally undisturbed and may represent the typical status of a compact globular cluster evolved in isolation .
this condition would also favour the permanence of an original radial anisotropic bias in the velocity distribution of cluster stars . in this context , it is interesting to note that ( a ) virtually all the clusters shown in fig .
[ underf ] and having @xmath79 display sb excesses in their outer regions , with respect to k66 models ( see , e.g. * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* ) , and , in particular ( b ) many of the brightest among these clusters ( @xmath82 ) display smooth power - law profiles incompatible with k66 models in their outskirts , similar to ngc 5694 ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ?
* ; * ? ? ?
* for ngc 7006 , ngc 6229 , and ngc 5824 , respectively ) .
deeper and more thorough analyses of the structure and kinematics of these clusters , extending into their low sb outskirts , seems timely .
the study of a sample of distant _ compact _ clusters ( in the sense defined by * ? ? ?
* ) may provide precious insight on the initial conditions of gcs whose evolution should be only weakly influenced by the interaction with the milky way .
we are grateful to an anonymous referee for useful comments and suggestions .
m.b . and a.s .
acknowledges the financial support from prin miur , project : _ the chemical and dynamical evolution of the milky way and local group galaxies _ , prot .
2010ly5n2 t , ( pi f. matteucci ) .
support for m.c .
, p.a . , and c.c .
is provided by the ministry for the economy , development , and tourism s programa iniciativa cientfica milenio through grant ic120009 , awarded to the millennium institute of astrophysics ( mas ) .
m.c . also acknowledges support by proyecto basal pfb-06/2007 and by fondecyt grant # 1141141 . | we present a study of the kinematics of the remote globular cluster ngc 5694 based on giraffe@vlt medium resolution spectra .
a sample of 165 individual stars selected to lie on the red giant branch in the cluster color magnitude diagram was considered . using radial velocity and metallicity from calcium triplet
, we were able to select 83 bona - fide cluster members .
the addition of six previously known members leads to a total sample of 89 cluster giants with typical uncertainties @xmath0 km / s in their radial velocity estimates .
the sample covers a wide range of projected distances from the cluster center , from @xmath1 to @xmath2 half - light radii ( @xmath3 ) .
we find only very weak rotation , as typical of metal - poor globular clusters .
the velocity dispersion gently declines from a central value of @xmath4 km / s to @xmath5 km / s at @xmath6 , then it remainins flat out to the next ( and last ) measured point of the dispersion profile , at @xmath7 , at odds with the predictions of isotropic king models .
we show that both isotropic single - mass non - collisional models and multi - mass anisotropic models can reproduce the observed surface brightness and velocity dispersion profiles .
[ firstpage ] ( galaxy : ) globular clusters : individual : ngc 5694 stars : abundances |
soon after the discovery of the luminous infrared galaxies ( lirgs ) , whose bolometric luminosities are dominated by the infrared part of their spectral energy distributions ( seds ) ( @xmath27@xmath2810@xmath2l@xmath23 ) ( e.g. soifer et al .
1987 ) , single dish and interferometric co j=10 , 21 line observations were used to determine their total molecular gas mass and its distribution ( sanders et al .
1988a ; tinney et al . 1990 ; wang et al .
1991 ; sanders et al . 1991 ; solomon et al . 1997 ; downes & solomon 1998 ; bryant & scoville 1996 , 1999 ) .
these efforts were paralleled by several investigations of the so - called @xmath4=m(h@xmath29)/@xmath30(10 ) factor and its dependance on the average ism conditions both theoretical ( dickman et al . 1988 ; maloney & black 1988 ; wolfire et al . 1993 ; sakamoto 1996 ; bryant & scoville 1996 ; wall 2007 ) and observational ( e.g. israel 1988 , 1993 , 1997 ; solomon et al .
1997 ; downes & solomon 1998 ; yao et al .
the average molecular gas conditions in lirgs used in such studies have been typically constrained using co(21)/(10 ) and co/@xmath20co j=10 , 21 line ratios ( e.g. braine & combes 1992 ; horellou et al 1995 ; aalto et al .
1995 ; papadopoulos & seaquist 1998 ) . higher - j transitions ( j=32 and higher ) were used only sporadically and mostly for star - forming galactic nuclei ( e.g. devereux et al .
1994 ; white et al . 1994 ; gsten et al . 1996 ; nieten et al .
1999 ; mauersberger et al . 1999 ; dumke et al . 2001
; yao et al . 2003 ) .
this was a result of the larger difficulties such observations pose in terms of available submm receivers , their sensitivity , and the dry weather conditions needed ( especially for @xmath31@xmath25460ghz , co j=43 ) .
receiver sensitivity limitations also hindered large multi - j line surveys of the much fainter lines from heavy rotor molecules such as hcn that probe higher density gas ( @xmath3210@xmath14@xmath15 ) except in nearby galactic nuclei ( jackson et al .
1995 ; paglione et al .
1997 ) and a few luminous ulirgs ( e.g. gracia - carpio et al .
2008 ) .
such limitations will soon be overcome after the ongoing commissioning of the atacama large millimeter array ( alma ) is completed
. then routine multi - j observations of co and heavy rotor molecules will yield unhindered view over the entire range of physical conditions in molecular clouds , from their quiescent and low - density phase ( @xmath33@xmath34(10@xmath12 - 10@xmath35)@xmath15 , @xmath36@xmath8(10 - 15)k ) to the dense and warm gas intimately associated with star formation ( @xmath37@xmath38(10@xmath14 - 10@xmath39)@xmath15 , @xmath40@xmath38(30 - 150)k ) .
the power of interferometric multi - j line imaging in revealing the mass distribution of dense warm sf gas in lirgs has already been demonstrated by pioneering sma observations ( sakamoto et al .
2008 ; wilson et al . 2009 ; iono et al .
2007 , 2009 ) , while in the grand spiral m51 co line ratio imaging at high resolution revealed agn - excited gas in its nucleus ( iono et al .
the influence of the high - excitation conditions found in sf regions gas on the @xmath4 in galaxies may not necessarily be strong since dense and warm sf gas amounts to only @xmath21(0.5 - 3)% of typical giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) mass .
even smaller fractions of the total molecular gas in spirals disks resides in their centers ( @xmath21(0.1 - 1)% ) where strong tidal fields , high cosmic ray energy densities and/or agn can drive a high molecular line excitation .
nevertheless this may no longer be true for the merger - driven starbursts in ulirgs where a dense sf gas phase can contain the bulk of their total molecular gas mass ( e.g. solomon et al .
1992 ; gao & solomon 2004 ) .
moreover , cases of agn - driven mechanical and radiative feedback affecting the bulk of the molecular gas of the host galaxy and the corresponding co sleds have now been identified ( papadopoulos et al .
2008 ; van der werf et al .
these systems along with ulirgs , yield a nearby glimpse of ism conditions that could be prevelailing in the distant universe . in the present work we examine the influence of the average molecular gas conditions found in lirgs ( papadopoulos et al 2011 , hereafter paperi ) on the @xmath4 factor .
we do so by using the largest combined database of lirgs / co transitions for which such a study has been conducted , while discussing also the limitations and potential biases of past theoretical and observational studies .
we then outline methods that could be employed in the upcoming era of alma , and the special role the herschel space observatory ( hso ) can play , towards improved total molecular gas mass estimates , especially for ulirgs ( @xmath27@xmath32@xmath41@xmath42 ) . several such galaxies whose co line ratios indicate extreme ism conditions ( see paperi ) are now studied individualy , their impact on the @xmath4 values examined in detail . throughout this paper
we adopt a flat @xmath43-dominated cosmology with @xmath44=71kms@xmath11mpc@xmath11 and @xmath45=0.27 .
the formal dependance of the @xmath19 factor on the average density , temperature , and kinematic state of large molecular cloud ensembles ( where the statistical notion of @xmath4 remains applicable ) is explored in several papers ( e.g. dickman et al .
1986 ; young & scoville 1991 ; bryant & scoville 1996 ; solomon et al . 1997 ; papadopoulos & seaquist 1999 ; downes & solomon 1998 ; yao et al .
co and @xmath20co lines can yield constraints on these ism properties , and thus on the corresponding @xmath4 , via radiative transfer models ( e.g. mao et al .
2000 ; weiss et al .
2001 ) . in this regard low - j co sleds ( up to j=32 ) with @xmath46@xmath47(400@xmath1510@xmath48)@xmath15 and @xmath49@xmath47(5.533)k
are adequate for determining the average state of the molecular gas and thus the appropriate @xmath4 , provided that most of its mass is distributed in ordinary gmcs .
the low - j co sled segment and its modeling can then in principle yield the mass normalization for the entire co or of any other molecular line sled ( e.g. of hcn ) typically emanating from much smaller mass fractions . for several ulirgs in our sample
whose co sleds will be extended up to j=1312 using the hso this normalization is especially important as it allows determining the mass of the highly - excited molecular gas emitting the very high - j lines , and setting important constraints on the energy source responsible for its excitation ( van der werf et al .
2010 ; rangwala et al .
2011 ) .
there are currently only three major observational studies of @xmath50 using co lines for substantial lirg samples ( solomon et al .
1997 ; downes & solomon 1998 ; yao et al .
2003 ) . for the highly turbulent molecular gas in ( u)lirgs these typically find @xmath50=(1/101/3)@xmath51 , with the low values attributed mostly to non self - gravitating gas distributions . for sf spiral disks
a @xmath52@xmath53(4 - 5)@xmath54=m@xmath23 ( kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 ] remains applicable as most of their molecular gas is found in cool , low - density , self - gravitating gmcs as those in the milky way , pockmarked by sf `` spots '' of warm and dense gas with also nearly galactic @xmath50 ( e.g. young & scoville 1991 ) . in isolated spirals
low @xmath50@xmath21(1/201/5)@xmath51 values can be found only in their nuclei ( 2r@xmath56100200pc ) ( regan 2000 ) , but involve only small fractions of the total molecular gas reservoirs .
thus for the metal - rich environments of lirgs current observational work points to a bimodal @xmath4 distribution , with near - galactic values for all isolated spiral disks , and @xmath57@xmath38(1/4 - 1/5)@xmath58@xmath59 in the merger - driven starbursts of ulirgs . this view has even been widely adopted even for high - z star - forming lirgs where only sparse sampling of their co sleds exists ( e.g greve et al .
2005 ; tacconi et al . 2006 ; dannerbauer et al .
it is worth noting that the claimed bimodality of the schmidt - kennicutt star formation relations ( linking sfr and molecular gas supply ) between disks and mergers ( daddi et al .
2010a ; genzel et al .
2010 ) is nearly equivalent to such an @xmath50 bimodality ( narayanan et al .
2010 and references therein ) . nevertheless much of the aforementioned observational work contains some serious methodological limitations borne out from the limited molecular line data available per object and specific assumptions made about the radiative transfer models .
these are : * setting @xmath60=@xmath61 in the co line radiative transfer models used to constrain @xmath19 even though photoelectric , turbulent , or cosmic - ray heating can easily induce @xmath60@xmath62@xmath61 . * using a constant dv / dr ( usually 1kms@xmath11pc@xmath11 ) in the large velocity gradient ( lvg ) radiative transfer models that interpret co line ratios even if : a ) virial gas motions alone correspond to @xmath218 - 10 times higher values for the dense gas ( @xmath63@xmath6410@xmath26@xmath15 ) that may be dominant in ulirgs , and b ) stellar mass concomitant with molecular gas and/or tidally - induced velocity fields can easily yield much larger dv / dr values . * the use of empirical relations and object - specific assumptions for obtaining @xmath4 expressions that can account for the potentially significant stellar mass concomitant with the molecular gas , an issue that arises especially in ulirgs . *
the molecular lines used in such studies ( low - j co lines ) are insensitive to the properties of the gas with densities @xmath65@xmath3210@xmath35@xmath15 .
the last two set the most serious methodological limitations on the very influential study of @xmath19 in ulirgs by downes & solomon 1998 ( herafter ds98 ) , whose results are widely used for presumably similar systems at high redshifts . in
that study models of the co j=10 , 21 interferometric images of 5 ulirgs were used to deduce @xmath19@xmath21(1/5 - 1/6)@xmath59 , attributing these low values to a continous molecular gas distribution encompassing large fractions of stellar mass and thus velocity fields determined by the total ( gas)+(stellar ) mass ( see also downes et al . 1993 ; solomon et al .
the use of empirical relations ( e.g. @xmath66=200@xmath67(kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 ) , and setting a @xmath68=@[email protected] mass ratio of newly formed stars ( @xmath70 ) to those in an old stellar bulge ( @xmath71 ) in the pre - merger spirals make the computed @xmath19 _ specific to the few ulirgs studied _ and certainly not automatically applicable to other ulirgs in the local or the distant universe . moreover `` freezing '' dv / dr to 1kms@xmath11pc@xmath11 renders such models incapable of constraining the average dynamical state of the gas and thus exploring its effect on @xmath4 in a straightforward way ( see section 2.2 ) .
furthermore , while the ds98 formalism can be generalized to arbitary @xmath72 values , it remains impractical for the dusty gas - rich systems at high redshifts where stellar populations are heavily dust - enshrouded .
finally an @xmath19 factor deduced solely from co j=10 , 21 line emission models may be inapplicable for a much denser gas phase ( n(h@xmath29)@xmath6410@xmath48@xmath15 ) .
this will yield a small error when such a phase represents only a few% of the total mass per typical gmc ( as is the case in spiral disks ) , but to a potentially much larger error if the dense gas dominates the molecular gas mass budget .
these difficulties are compounded by setting dv / dr=1kms@xmath11pc@xmath11 , which while justified by the sole co(2 - 1)/(1 - 0 ) line ratio available in the ds98 study , may be partly responsible for the contradictory results obtained for the average gas density and co line excitation .
indeed while hcn and high - j co observations indicate much of the gas in some ulirgs to be very dense ( @xmath37@xmath3210@xmath48@xmath15 ) , radiative transfer models of co j=10 and j=21 interferometric images of some of the same ulirgs ( e.g. arp220 ) become incompatible with these images already for n@xmath6410@xmath73@xmath15 ( ds98 ) .
velocity gradients of @xmath74@xmath621kms@xmath11pc@xmath11 ( expected for the highly turbulent gas disks of ulirgs ) and high temperatures for the dense gas can much reduce line optical depths and the emergent co line emission possibly aleviating these discrepancies . in summary
all current observational studies of @xmath4 in lirgs , leave its range and dependance on the average density , temperature and kinematic state of the molecular gas still largely unexplored .
the small lirg / co line datasets used in such studies , and the aforementioned limitations of the analysis methods , limits their applicability to other such systems in the local or the distant universe .
our dataset of total co lines luminosities for a substantial sample of lirgs provides a good opportunity for exploring the @xmath4 dependance on the average ism state in vigorously star - forming systems .
the average dv / dr for the gas is now a free parameter to be constrained by lvg radiative transfer models along with the density and temperature .
this provides an extinction - free and straightforward method for determining the effects of stellar mass concomitant with molecular gas and/or tidal disruption of molecular clouds on @xmath4 . to place our discussion regarding molecular gas mass estimates in lirgs in an autonomous context we reproduce the @xmath19 factor ( see appendix ) as @xmath75 where @xmath76=0.552.4 depending on the assumed cloud density profile ( see bryant & scoville 1996 , eqs a11 , a17 ) , and @xmath33 , @xmath77 are the average gas density and co j=10 brightness temperature of the molecular cloud ensemble .
the parameter @xmath78 is given by @xmath79}{\sqrt{\alpha}\lambda _ { co}}\left(\frac{n(h_2)}{10 ^ 3\ , cm^{-3}}\right)^{-1/2},\ ] ] ( with @xmath80/(dv / dr$ ] being one of the outputs of a typical lvg model ) , and determines the average dynamic state of the molecular gas , with @xmath81@xmath3813 for the ( mostly ) self - gravitating gmcs in the galactic disk ( and @xmath78@xmath821 corresponding to dynamically unattainable gas motions ) . for a typical value of @xmath76=1.5 equation 1
becomes @xmath83 which we use in the present work . for ordinary gmcs with @xmath33@xmath38500@xmath15 , @xmath77@xmath2110k , and @xmath84@xmath381 - 2 the latter yields @xmath19@xmath21(3 - 6)@xmath85 ( where @xmath86=@xmath87(kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 ) .
the optically thin limit for co j=10 line emission is often adopted to provide a lower limit on the total molecular gas mass ( e.g. bryant & scoville 1996 ; solomon et al .
the availability of several co lines allows a more robust such limit without assuming lte : @xmath88 \left(\frac{m_{\odot}}{k\,km\,s^{-1}\,pc^2}\right),\ ] ] ( see appendix ) , which makes obvious that , unless the co line ratios become significantly larger than unity ( which they can in optically thin emission ) , most of the contributions come from the low j levels .
the lte expression is : @xmath89 \left(\frac{m_{\odot}}{k\,km\,s^{-1}\,pc^2}\right),\ ] ] which gives a higher ( and less reliable ) lower limit since the lte partition function can be significantly larger than the non - lte one .
the optically thin approximation can be used also for the realistic case of significant co line optical depths as long as large velocity gradients keep the photon escape probability local throughout the bulk of the molecular gas mass .
then equation 4 is modified to @xmath90 \nonumber \rm \left(\frac{m_{\odot}}{k\,km\,s^{-1}\,pc^2}\right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91=@xmath92/\tau_{j+1\,j}$ ] is the photon escape probability ( see appendix ) .
the last equation provides a more robust lower limit than equation 4 , as it accounts for finite line optical depths ( computed from radiative transfer models ) .
if enough line ratios are available , the estimate from equation 6 will approach that of equation 3 as long as one average gas phase dominates the emergent co line emission . in figure 1
we show the @xmath4 and @xmath93(lte ) distributions , computed from equations 3 and 5 and the results of one radiative transfer models for the co sleds and @xmath20co lines for all the lirgs in our sample ( see paperi ) .
most @xmath4 values are @xmath941.5@xmath54 , with @[email protected]@xmath96 obtained for the main distribution ( excluding the few outliers beyond 3@xmath54 ) .
the @xmath97(lte ) distribution gives similar results , indicating that most of the states compatible with the co sleds have optically thin or moderately optically thick co j=10 line ( @xmath98@xmath3813 ) .
this has been noted in the past in the context of a two - phase ism model and attributed to the high temperatures of a turbulent `` envelope '' phase in molecular clouds ( aalto et al .
1995 ) .
the @xmath4 range obtained using our one - phase models of global co sleds is similar to that reported by ds98 and yao et al .
moreover in figure 2 the distribution of @xmath99 demonstrates that unlike often stated , the effects of density and temperature do not always cancel out but are responsible for much of the @xmath19 variations over different ism environments ( compare figure 2 , with the @xmath100 distribution in figure 1 ) .
nevertheless the average dynamical state of the gas ( i.e. @xmath84 ) remains the most important factor affecting the average @xmath6 .
this is shown in figure 3 where the @xmath19 distributions for virial / near - virial and unbound average gas dynamical states are shown . in the merger - driven starbursts of ulirgs highly non - virial gas velocities
can be caused by significant amounts of stellar mass concomitant with a continous molecular gas distribution as noted by ds98 ( see also solomon et al .
1997 ) , albeit without using radiative transfer models to constrain @xmath78 .
strong tidal fields acting on gmc cloud envelopes and/or a diffuse intercloud molecular gas distribution whose velcity field traces the combined potential of the surviving dense gmc cores as well as stars will both raise the average @xmath101 , and further reduce the corresponding @xmath4 ( equation 3 ) . in figure 4 the distribution of @xmath102 computed from equation 6
is shown which , unlike that deduced from equation 3 , uses the co line ratios explicitely .
this makes it more suitable when fully - sampled co sleds from j=10 up to high - j ( e.g. j=65 , 76 ) are available , and when the turbulent models of the hierarchical density structures of molecular clouds ( e.g. ossenkopf 2002 ) become refined enough to provide global co and @xmath20co sleds as well as the corresponding @xmath103 values per density `` sub - phase '' . for well - sampled @xmath20co sleds the @xmath104 expression ( using the appropriate @xmath105 $ ] abundance )
is even more useful as @xmath106(@xmath20co)@xmath211 . in our current study using the output @xmath107 values from our one - phase models in equation 6 yields an @xmath108 distribution similar to that of @xmath4 from equation 3 .
interestingly the @xmath19 distributions , while concentrated within @xmath21(0.31.5)@xmath96 , do extend out to galactic values @xmath21(2.5 - 6)@xmath96 .
these are found for disk - dominated lirgs ( e.g. ngc157 and mrk1048 ) , ( u)lirgs with unexpectedly `` cold '' co ratios ( e.g. iras05189 - 2524 ) where cool ( @xmath2115k ) gas with low / modest densities ( @xmath38(10@xmath1210@xmath35)@xmath15 ) dominates their average ism state .
surprisingly , _
galactic @xmath16 values can be found also in some ulirgs , _ whose `` hot '' co ratios ( e.g. iras08572 + 3915 ) indicate a dominant warm ( @xmath21(100150)k ) and dense ( @xmath21(3@xmath5810@xmath4810@xmath109)@xmath15 ) phase , or other evidence ( e.g. multi - j hcn lines ) suggest a massive dense , gas phase ( e.g. mrk231 ) .
thus large @xmath19 values are possible for both high and low excitation gas phases and thus can not be used as indicators of galaxy - type ism conditions in distant star forming disks ( e.g. daddi et al .
this also suggests that in many local ulirgs and similar systems at high redshifts _ the widely adopted @xmath110@xmath38(0.8 - 1)@xmath111 values understimate their molecular gas mass .
_ recent studies of sf feedback suggest a maximum @xmath112=@xmath113@xmath38500@xmath114 for the dense and warm gas @xmath115 near sf sites in galaxies as a result of strong radiation pressure from the nascent o , b star clusters onto the concomitant dust of the accreted gas fueling these sites ( scoville 2004 ; thompson et al . 2005 ; thompson 2009 ) .
thus , provided that average dust properties ( e.g. its effective radiative absorption coefficient per unit mass ) remain similar in metal - rich star - forming systems such as lirgs , a near - constant @xmath112 is expected among them .
a value of @xmath116@xmath21500@xmath117 is actually measured in individual sf sites of spiral disks such as m51 and entire starbursts such as arp220 ( scoville 2003 ) , while @xmath17(@xmath118)@xmath117 is obtained for cs - bright star - forming cores in the galaxy ( shirley et al .
further evidence for a near - constant @xmath119 is the tight linear @xmath120-hcn(1 - 0 ) correlation found for individual gmcs up to entire ulirgs ( wu et al .
2005 ) with hcn j=10 used as a dense gas mass tracer .
however the intermitency expected for galaxy - sized molecular gas reservoirs ( i.e. at any given epoch of a galaxy s evolution some dense gas regions will be forming stars while others will not ) will lower the global @xmath121 to @xmath381/3 - 1/2 of the eddington value ( andrews & thompson 2011 ) .
similar @xmath122 values can be obtained without explicit use of the eddington limit ( and the detailed dust properties it entails ) , but from the typical @xmath123 in young starbursts where @xmath70 is the mass of the new stars and @xmath124 their bolometric luminosity ( @xmath21@xmath125 for the deeply dust - enshrouded sf sites ) . for @xmath126=@xmath127 $ ] as the sf efficiency of the dense gas regions where the new stars form
it is @xmath128 for @[email protected] typical for dense sf regions , and @xmath130=(300400)@xmath131 ( downes & solomon 1998 and references therein ) , equation 7 yields @xmath132@xmath8(130400)@xmath133 .
here we choose @xmath134=250@xmath135 , close to the average values from equation 7 and the black body limit deduced for compact co line emission concomitant with an optically thick ( @xmath136@xmath321 ) dust emission ( solomon et al .
eddington - limited star formation in lirgs implies _ a minimum molecular gas mass @xmath137=@xmath138 fueling their observed star formation rates . _ in figure 5 we show the @xmath137 distribution which , for the ulirgs in our sample , reaches up to @xmath215@xmath5810@xmath22@xmath139 i.e. surpassing the total molecular gas reservoirs of typical spirals . in some cases where one - phase lvg models of global co line ratios of lirgs do not converge to a well - defined range of physical conditions ,
a simple two - phase model can be used to examine the underlying ism conditions and the corresponding @xmath19 factors .
the total co j=10 luminosity can then be expressed as @xmath141 where ( h ) and (
l ) indicate the high and the low excitation phases , @xmath142 is the co - h@xmath29 conversion factor for the former , and @xmath116=250(@xmath143 ) .
this assumes that the high excitation phase fuels eddington - limited star formation . for any other transition @xmath144 r^{(h ) } _ { j+1\,j } + l^{(l)\ , ' } _ { co , j+1-j},\ ] ] the molecular gas near hii regions and interfaces between molecular clouds and o , b stellar associations is an obvious choice for obtaining template high - excitation co sleds .
the beam - matched co line survey of the orion a and b gmcs found @xmath145=1.21.3 and @xmath146=10 ( the co/@xmath20co j=21 ratio ) in such `` hot '' spots ( sakamoto et al .
these ratios along with @xmath60@xmath147100k ( expected from the high co line brightness temperatures in such sf spots ) set as constraints to a one - phase lvg model yield : @xmath60=(125150)k , @xmath148=3@xmath14910@xmath26@xmath15 , @xmath150=7 , and corresponding line ratios : @xmath151(3)=1.35 , @xmath152=1.33 , @xmath153=1.30 , @xmath154=1.27 , @xmath155=1.25 , and @xmath156=1.22 . for this lvg solution set we compute ( equation 3 ) @xmath157 @xmath212.2@xmath54 , and from equations 8 and 9 the co line ratios of the low - excitation ( l)-phase . these can then be used as constraints on 1-phase lvg models to obtain the average ism conditions and @xmath158 .
for such a 2-phase decomposition the effective @xmath159 factor would be @xmath160 with @xmath161=@xmath162 . using the eddington - limit normalization for @xmath163 yields @xmath164 when
lines such as higher - j co transitions ( j=43 , 65 ) and/or heavy rotor molecular lines ( e.g. hcn ) are available , they are used to set constraints on the ( h)-phase , @xmath165 , and @xmath166 without assuming the ( h)-phase co sled and @xmath167 deduced from the orion gmc star - forming `` spots '' .
the average ism conditions deduced using the co lines available per lirg ( see paper i ) encompasses the @xmath169 $ ] parameter space where most of the mass is expected to reside in ordinary gmcs .
thus the narrow @xmath6 distribution around @[email protected]@xmath54 ( figs 1 , 4 ) , does not seem as the result of an excitation bias induced by the particular molecular lines used .
this is not to say that other high - j co or e.g. hcn line luminosities are expected to be compatible with the average ism states deduced from our current co line dataset but rather than that such lines with their higher critical densities will probe much smaller gas mass fractions per typical gmc to be of any consequence when it comes to the global @xmath4 .
it is tempting to consider the aforementioned picture as complete .
it is certainly compatible with models of supersonic turbulence in ordinary gmcs where most molecular gas mass is found at densities @xmath17110@xmath14@xmath15 , its conditions thus `` accessible '' to the co , @xmath20co lines used to constrain them ( and @xmath19 ) in our study . in the merger - driven starbursts of ulirgs however gmcs may be far from ordinary . stripping of their outer envelopes by strong tidal fields and/or the large pressures from a hot ionized gas phase resulting from hi cloud collisions , both expected in merger environments ( e.g. solomon et al .
1997 ) , can dramatically alter the m(h@xmath29)-n(h@xmath29 ) distribution towards most mass being at @xmath33@xmath2410@xmath48@xmath15 .
this actually occurs in the galactic center ( e.g. gsten & philipp 1994 ) , and in ulirgs it can involve their entire molecular gas reservoirs . in such cases
, @xmath20co lines are no longer sensitive to the average ism conditions and may thus yield inaccurate `` corrections '' to the global @xmath6 factor with respect to its galactically calibrated value . the high pressures in the highly turbulent gas disks in ulirgs ( ds98 ) will : a ) result to much larger average gas densities at all scales , and b ) `` relocate '' large mass fractions of their gmcs to densities @xmath172@xmath3210@xmath48@xmath15 .
the latter can be easily shown from the probability distribution function ( pdf ) of the density in supersonically turbulent clouds .
this is well - approximated by a log - normal distribution with a dispersion : @xmath173^{1/2},\ ] ] where m=@xmath174 is the average 1-dim mach number ( padoan & nordlund 2002 ) . the mass fraction contained in cloud structures with overdensities x@xmath13@xmath175 ( x=@xmath176 )
is then given by @xmath177.\ ] ] the high velocity dispersions @xmath178@xmath8(30140)kms@xmath11 measured in the molecular disks of ulirgs ( ds98 ; see also swinbank et al .
2011 for a recently discovered such disk at [email protected] ) versus those in spiral disks ( @xmath8(510)kms@xmath11 ) correspond to m(ulirgs)@xmath21(330)@xmath179m(spirals ) . for m(spiral)=10
then @xmath180(spirals)@xmath82 , while @xmath181(ulirgs)@xmath532.55 - 3.33 , which dramatically extends the gas density pdf expected in ulirgs towards high values where much of the gas mass will now lie .
indeed for the gmcs in spiral disks only @xmath213% of the mass will be found at overdensities of x@xmath32@xmath175=500 ( = 5@xmath14910@xmath48@xmath15 for typical gmc with @xmath182=100@xmath15 ) while for ulirgs this is @xmath2145% ( figure 6 ) .
this difference can be even larger since the _ average _ molecular gas density in disks is lower ( @xmath183@xmath21(100 - 500)@xmath15 ) than in ulirgs where it can reach up to at least @xmath2110@xmath14@xmath15 ( greve et al . 2009 ) .
thus gas at n@xmath1845@xmath58@xmath185@xmath15 corresponds to an overdensity of @xmath175=100 - 500 ( containing @xmath18610% of gas mass ) for gmcs in spirals , and only @xmath187=5 ( and 90% of the mass ) for gmcs in ulirgs .
the typical co sled available for lirgs in our sample ( j=10 , 21 , 32 ) would then be insensitive to the state of the molecular gas in ulirgs and thus unable to constrain the corresponding @xmath4 factor , while it would remain adequate for such a task for the molecular gas in isolated spirals .
interestingly the few cases of near - galactic @xmath19 in ulirgs were found when either higher - j co lines were available or when a dense and warm gas phase was massive enough to be obvious even in low - j co sleds ( paper i , and section 4 ) .
the @xmath19 for such dense gas can be high , approaching and even surpassing galactic values .
indicatively , for n=5@xmath18810@xmath48@xmath15 and warm gas with a thermalized co j=10 line @xmath77@xmath38@xmath40@xmath38(100 - 150)k , it is : @xmath19@xmath38(4 - 6)@xmath189@xmath96 ( eq .
3 ) , which for self - gravitating gas ( @xmath78=1 ) corresponds to galactic values . moreover , for the highly turbulent , high - pressure ism environments in ulirgs the notion of molecular gas reservoirs reducible to ensembles of dicrete gmcs may no longer apply , with much of the gas in the pre - merger gmcs redistributed in continous disks of @xmath8(100 - 300)pc diameter ( ds98 ; sakamoto et al .
2008 ) . a warm , low - density , molecular gas phase , with large @xmath78 ( @xmath3210 ) can then be generated , _ alongside _ the denser one , by the tidal disruption of gmc `` envelopes '' in merger environments , the high pressures turning intercloud cnm hi into h@xmath29 , and the effects of supersonic turbulence driven at the largest scales ( e.g. ossenkopf 2002 ) .
such a diffuse phase , even if containing little mass , can easily dominate the emergent global co j=10 , 21 line emission of ulirgs , yielding `` cold '' co(2 - 1)/(1 - 0 ) ratios and low @xmath4 factors ( a result of its low densities , high temperatures , and large @xmath101 values ) .
these low @xmath4 values , _ while appropriate for the diffuse gas mass , may not be so for the bulk of the molecular gas that now resides at much higher densities .
_ thus in the very turbulent molecular gas reservoirs of ulirgs a combination of : a ) most of their mass residing at high densities ( with potentialy large @xmath19 factors ) , and b ) the existence of a diffuse , warm , and unbound phase with little mass ( and low @xmath6 ) dominating low - j co sleds ( and the average @xmath19 determined from them ) , can easily result to _ a systematic underestimate of their total molecular gas mass .
_ all current observational studies likely suffer from this bias , expected to be most prominent in ulirgs with high molecular gas surface densities .
this includes the present study as mostly low - j co sleds ( up to j=32 ) are typically available per lirg .
the only exceptions are the few ulirgs for which , a highly excited co j=32 line , co j=43 , 65 lines , and/or hcn lines from the literature allowed the revealing of their massive dense gas reservoirs ( see section 4 ) .
studies of @xmath6 in similar systems at high redshifts ( e.g. tacconi et al .
2008 ) will be similarly affected . only molecular sleds with high critical densities can overcome such an @xmath4 bias in ulirgs and see how many actually lie on the high end of the @xmath4 distributions shown in figures 1 and 4 . recently gmc - sized numerical simulations that include h@xmath29 and co formation / destruction and radiative transfer in mhd turbulent models where used to explore @xmath4 and its dependance on average ism conditions ( shetty et al .
2011a , b ) .
these simulations also include chemistry and thermodynamical effects but not sf - driven heating ( via photons or crs ) or turbulent heating which could dominate in ulirgs .
currently such studies explore galactic - type gmcs whose @xmath4 values they found similar to the one observed .
extending such numerical models to ism conditions expected in ulirgs is not straightforward as gmc boundary conditions such as ambient radiation fields , surface pressure , external gravitational field and its tidal terms ( important for galactic centers of spirals and ulirgs ) are set constant in gmc - sized simulations or , in the case of tidal fields , are omitted altogether . nevertheless in any realistic setting of gmcs in galaxies these boundary conditions
do change , sometimes faster than internal cloud evolutionary timescales , and especially so in ulirgs .
galaxy - sized numerical studies of @xmath19 in disks and mergers recently presented by narayanan et al .
2011 address the aforementioned important point of coupled gmc - galaxy evolution by tracking the evolution of gmc boundary conditions , but do so by necessarily adopting some subresolution methods to follow in - cloud physics and keep the problem computationally tractable .
they recover galactic @xmath19 values for disks , but @xmath215 - 10 times lower ones in mergers , with a large spread that makes a single ulirg - appropriate @xmath4 factor impractical . nevertheless , for ulirgs in particular , these simulations do not have ( and could not have ) the resolution necessary to track gas with n@xmath2810@xmath48@xmath15 ( where most of their gas mass resides ) . resolving the all - important kinematic state of such a dense gas component ( self - gravitating or not ? ) within their compact gas reservoirs ( @xmath8(100 - 300)pc ) is currently impossible with galaxy - sized simulations , as is the explicit tracking of the large turbulence - regulated range of densities expected in ulirgs .
there the _ average _ densities can surpass @xmath2110@xmath48@xmath15 , while the high levels of turbulence will maintain @xmath2560% of the mass at n@xmath2410@xmath26@xmath15 ( figure 6 ) . with the @xmath190 values computed in such simulations likely to be
lower limits ( as cr and mechanical snr - driven heating are omitted ) , gas densities and the corresponding kinematic states remain the only parameters affecting the average @xmath6 in metal - rich environments that can push its values either way . indeed while additional heating can only raise @xmath60 and thus the co j=10 brightness temperature ( reducing @xmath4 ) , high densities ( @xmath3210@xmath48@xmath15 ) and self - gravitating states ( @xmath78@xmath211 ) will act to raise @xmath4 .
gmc - sized simulations of the much more turbulent and denser molecular gas in ulirgs are necessary for computing the corresponding @xmath6 but these must now use new initial conditions with : a ) much higher volumed - averaged gas densities ( current ones use @xmath8150@xmath15 ) , b ) higher velocity dispersions ( current ones use @[email protected]@xmath11 ) , and c ) higher background cr energy densities ( and thus non - negligible cr gas heating ) . such simulations and their emergent line intensities can be compared to much richer molecular sleds available now than in the past .
these include the typical co lines from j=10 up to j=43 observed from the ground , rising up to j=1312 using the herschel space observatory ( van der werf et al .
2010 ) , further complemented by multi - j observations of heavy rotor molecules like hcn , hco@xmath192 , cs ( e.g. greve et al . 2009 ) as sensitivities vastly improve in the era of alma .
thus , rather than simply trust the @xmath4 yielded by gmc - sized simulations as is currently done , these simulations will yield @xmath4 values as a by - product of the much more difficult task of reproducing relative strengths of molecular line luminosities with critical densities ranging from @xmath21100@xmath15 up to @xmath810@xmath193@xmath15 .
these encompass the entire range of hierarchical structures in turbulent gmcs , from a highly turbulent low - density possibly non self - gravitating `` gmc - envelope '' phase at large scales up to self - gravitating compact dense gas cores with dissipated supersonic turbulence ( e.g. ossenkopf 2002 ) .
gmc - sized numerical simulations exploring a dense grid of ulirg - type gmc boundary conditions and determining the corresponding @xmath4 grid can then be used to inform galaxy - sized numerical simulations where such boundary conditions are tracked , while resolving the hierarchical structures of individual gmcs ( and thus determining @xmath194 from the simulations ) remains out of reach . as discussed in the previous sections , by relying on low - j co sleds , most observational studies of @xmath19 may have imparted a bias towards low values in ulirgs .
nevertheless past observations of heavy rotor molecules such as hcn j=10 have given early hints of a large scale m(h@xmath29)-n(h@xmath29 ) redistribution in these merger systems , which placed large fractions ( @xmath6450% ) of their total molecular gas mass at much higher densities ( @xmath19510@xmath48@xmath15 ) than in isolated gas - rich disk systems ( e.g. solomon et al .
1992 ; gao & solomon 2004 ) .
however a single transition of a heavy rotor molecule can not set constraints on the gas temperature and density ( let alone on its average dynamical state ) useful enough to constrain the corresponding @xmath196 factor well .
thus these early estimates of the dense molecular gas mass in ulirgs are necessarily very uncertain as they relied on an @xmath197 factor derived for n@xmath21@xmath198[hcn(1 - 0 ) ] , self - gravitating gas , and hcn j=10 brightness temperatures typical of the ir color temperatures of sf galaxies ( e.g. gao & solomon 2004 ) .
indicatively for @xmath37=5@xmath18810@xmath48@xmath15 , @xmath77(hcn)=40k and @xmath101=1 equation 3 applied for hcn j=10 yields @xmath199=15@xmath200 , which can be higher still for higher gas densities , as indicated by multi - j hcn , cs and hco@xmath192 line observations of arp220 and ngc6240 and where @xmath197@xmath21(20 - 35)@xmath96 ( greve et al . 2009 ) . for such high @xmath197 values and @xmath201=1/4 - 1/6 observed in ulirgs ( e.g. solomon et al .
1992 ; gao & solomon 2004 ; gracia - burillo et al . 2012 ) it is easy to show that @xmath202 ( equation 10 ) will yield near - galactic or higher values in such systems . indeed , assuming that the only contribution to the ( h)-phase in equation 10 comes from the hcn - bright gas ( i.e. the hcn emission from the low - excitation ( l ) phase is neglible ) we can determine @xmath203 from @xmath204 where @xmath205=@xmath206 in ulirgs(=4 - 6 ) , and @xmath207 that of the ( h)-phase . the latter can be found using a radiative transfer model for densities typical of hcn - bright gas , an assumed gas temperature , and setting @xmath208=1 . for n=10@xmath26@xmath15 , and @xmath40=100k using an lvg model for hcn and co lines we compute @xmath209=41k and @xmath210=96k .
thus @xmath211=2.34 , while @xmath197@xmath2120@xmath96 and @[email protected]@xmath96 , with @[email protected] - 1.56 .
setting @xmath213=0.5@xmath96 ( figs . 1 , 4 ) for the low - excitation ( co - bright but hcn - dark ) phase , we obtain @xmath214@xmath53(4 - 5)@xmath54 , i.e. galactic values
. these are now due to much higher fractions of dense hcn - bright gas than in the galaxy , with large @xmath197 ( and @xmath167 ) .
if such @xmath159 values are the norm in the high - pressured turbulent gas disks of ulirgs , _ their dynamical masses would be dominated by the molecular gas _ , quite unlike isolated sf spirals .
indeed for all the ulirgs in the ds98 study whose dynamical mass is reasonably well - constrained ( with both co 1 - 0 and 2 - 1 imaging ) galactic @xmath4 values would yield @[email protected] - 1 , and compatible with the obvious limitation of @xmath216@xmath2171 within the observational uncertainties of @xmath218 estimates . regarding the latter it is is worth pointing out that low s / n for extended co line emission regions in current interferometric maps as well as dynamically unrelaxed , non - circular , molecular gas motions ( expected in strong mergers ) typically cause _ underestimates _ rather than overestimates of the actual @xmath218 . surprisingly such a bias was deduced even for gas - rich but otherwise isolated disks with numerical simulations showing an observationally - determined @xmath219 to be typically be @xmath2130% less than the actual value ( daddi et al .
needless to say this state of affairs becomes worse still of co - imaged systems at high redshifts .
multi - j observations of heavy rotor molecules and/or high - j co lines in ulirgs can produce dense gas mass estimates via a ( radiative transfer model)-constrained @xmath196 factor . however the few such studies available ( papadopoulos 2007 ; papadopoulos et al . 2007 ;
krips et al . 2008 ; gracia - carpio et al . 2008 ; greve et al .
2009 ) are a testimony of how hard it is to overcome the degeneracies inherent in radiative transfer models of optically thick line emission from heavy rotor molecules .
the @xmath63-@xmath60 solution degeneracies of the large velocity gradient ( lvg ) radiative transfer models typically used in such studies translate to a wide range of @xmath199 factors , ranging from @xmath2110@xmath54 and reaching up to @xmath8(50 - 90)@xmath220 ( krips et al .
2008 ; gracia - carpio et al .
tellingly even the two studies with the largest number of dense gas tracer lines available per ulirg , that of mrk231 ( papadopoulos et al .
2007 ) and of arp220 , ngc6240 ( greve et al . 2009 ) can not overcome such degeneracies , and yield lvg solutions that produce @xmath221@xmath53(10 - 20)@xmath220 and @xmath8(17 - 37)@xmath54 respectively .
nevertheless most @xmath199 values deduced in such studies are high enough to yield dominant amounts of dense gas mass in ulirgs , with a near - galactic or even larger than galactic @xmath159 .
this apparent contradiction of the low @xmath4 factor advocated for ulirgs by past low - j co line studies ( e.g. solomon et al .
1997 ; ds98 ; yao et al .
2003 ) , and the larger effective @xmath222 implied by heavy rotor molecular line emission ( mostly hcn ) in such galaxies has not been much noted in the literature . in the rare cases where this discrepancy was discussed , the argument went for a downward revision of @xmath197 by @xmath211/5 rather than a boost of the widely adopted ulirg - value of @xmath19@xmath211@xmath96 ( e.g. papadopoulos et al . 2007 ) .
it must be noted however that the possibility of hcn - based molecular gas mass estimates raising the effective @xmath19 in ulirgs is mentioned in the seminal interferometric work by ds98 .
lower @xmath197 values than those reported in existing studies are possible if higher gas temperatures and/or unbound gas motions ( @xmath84@xmath321 ) prevail for the bulk of the dense gas in ulirgs . in the most detailed such study greve et al .
( 2009 ) do find warm and non - virial lvg solutions for the hcn - bright gas in arp220 and ngc6240 with @xmath223=3@xmath149@xmath224@xmath15 , @xmath40=(45 - 120)k ( arp220 ) and @xmath225=(60 - 120)k ( ngc6240 ) while @xmath78@xmath382 , 5 for arp220 and ngc6240 respectively .
choosing @xmath60=100k as indicative for both systems ( for a given density and @xmath78 high @xmath60 s yield small @xmath226 s ) , we find @xmath227(arp220)@xmath2160k , @xmath228(arp220)@xmath896k and @xmath209(ngc6240)@xmath2140k , @xmath229(ngc6240)@xmath3886k ( for their corresponding @xmath84 values ) . then from equation 3 : @xmath197@xmath2112@xmath85 , @[email protected]@xmath96 for arp220 and @[email protected]@xmath96 , @[email protected]@xmath85 for ngc6240 . thus using @xmath231=5.9(arp220 ) , 12.5(ngc6240 ) , and the lvg - computed : @[email protected](arp220 ) , 2.15(ngc6240 ) , we find @[email protected](arp220 ) , 4.81((ngc6240 ) .
then from equation 10 and the aforementioned numbers ( and setting @xmath234=0.5@xmath54 ) it is : @xmath202(arp220)@xmath82.4@xmath54 and @xmath235(ngc6240)@xmath211@xmath85 . in the aforementioned example the warm `` end '' of a degenerate range of lvg solutions to a multi - j heavy rotor molecular line dataset yields an @xmath4@xmath21(1/5)@xmath51 for ngc6240 while reducing that of arp220 to @xmath38(1/2)@xmath52 .
nevertheless such sets of solutions , with @xmath101@xmath321 and @xmath40 significantly higher than @xmath61 are not typically considered optimal in most studies .
indeed @xmath101@xmath211 is often used as a constraint on the lvg solution range of molecular lines tracing dense gas ( e.g. hcn , cs ) while solutions with @xmath40@xmath21@xmath236 are considered as more appropriate for such a gas component since gas - dust thermal coupling is expected to be strong ( e.g. see the dense gas model in mrk231 by papadopoulos et al .
2007 ) . on the other hand recent theoretical and observational work
has shown that in ulirgs large temperatures with @xmath40@xmath32@xmath61 are possible even with most of the gas mass at high densities ( n@xmath2410@xmath26@xmath15 ) because of dominant cr and/or turbulent heating , both powered by the large snr number densities in these galaxies ( papadopoulos 2010 ; paperi ; rangwala et al .
nevertheless , while high @xmath190 certainly contributes in lowering @xmath142 of the dense gas phase , it is the high @xmath78 values that are mostly responsible for this , a result noted also by previous studies ( e.g. ds98 ) . indeed , setting @xmath78=1 for the aforementioned lvg solutions for the dense gas phase in arp220 and ngc6240 brings their @xmath202 factors back up to @xmath384.5@xmath237(arp220 ) and @xmath83.3@xmath96(ngc6240 ) .
clearly good constraints on the dynamical state of the dense gas in ulirgs is of utmost importance since while @xmath101@xmath211 may be a safe assumption for the sf - fueling dense gas component of individual gmcs in typical spirals , it may not be so for the extreme ism environments of ulirgs .
strong tidal fields and/or `` bottom''-stirred ism by strong sf feedback ( via multiple snr shocks and the radiative feedback implied by eddington - limit - regulated sfrs ) could induce @xmath78@xmath321 even for the dense gas in such systems ( see paperi ) , lowering @xmath197 and hence the corresponding @xmath159 factor .
gas - rich disks containing a starburst in their central @xmath238(1 - 2)kpc , but also large amounts of sf - quiescent ism at larger galactocentric radii are often found in lirgs with @xmath239@xmath17110@xmath240l@xmath23 , and such configurations are even expected for weakly perturbed systems ( e.g. maiolino et al .
1997 and references therein ) .
large amounts of cold ( @xmath238(10 - 15)k ) molecular gas beyond a warm component ( @xmath238(35 - 40)k ) confined within a star - forming central @xmath211kpc has been shown as a general feature of lirgs using co j=21 , 10 lines ( papadopoulos & seaquist 1998 ) .
sensitive dust submm continuum and co j=10 imaging in individual lirgs found cold dust and concomitant molecular gas with low co j=10 brightness extending out to radii of at least @xmath213kpc ( papadopoulos & seaquist 1999 ; papadopoulos & allen 2000 ) .
submm continuum and hi imaging studies of nearby spirals also suggest cold molecular gas as a general feature of their disks at large galactocentric distances ( thomas et al .
2004 ) . extended , sf - quiescent , molecular gas reservoirs in the disks of lirgs can be undetected because of low co j=10 line brightness and/or lack of co in the lower metallicity environments found at large galactocentric distances .
two sf - idle gmcs with n@xmath4710@xmath12@xmath15 and potentially very low kinetic temperatures ( @xmath385k ) have been found in m31 ( allen & lequeux 1993 ; loinard et al .
1995 ; allen et al .
for @xmath78@xmath471 - 2 ( i.e. self - gravitating or nearly so ) such clouds will have @[email protected] and a corresponding @xmath242@xmath2119@xmath96 . in the global co sleds of lirgs
such a cold sf - idle component , even if massive , it will be completely inconspicious , outshined by the much more co - luminous sf molecular gas where typical @xmath243@xmath2415k .
the global @xmath4 of a lirg , computed using models of its global co sled , will then invariably be biased by the average ism properties of its central starburst , often having a genuinely low @xmath244@xmath21(1/3 - 1/5)@xmath51 factor ( e.g. papadopoulos & seaquist 1999 ; papadopoulos & allen 2000 ) .
thus its adoption for the entire lirg can much underestimate the contribution from a massive cold , sf - quiescent component where a galactic @xmath4 applies , as indicated by submm , hi and co j=10 imaging for such galaxies .
we can compute an indicative @xmath159 in such a lirg for a given @xmath245 by setting @xmath242=@xmath52 for the cold , extended , sf - quiescent component , and @xmath246=(1/5)@xmath247 for the warm , nuclear , star - forming one . using the results by papadopoulos & seaquist ( 1998 ) where `` stacked '' co(21)/(10 ) ratios for lirgs were used to determine a generic warm versus cold molecular gas distribution in their disks ( their figure 6 ) we set @[email protected] as the diameter of the warm sf component and @xmath249@xmath2120kpc as that of the entire co - bright gas distribution in the `` average '' lirg . with a warm / cold co brightness temperature ratio of @xmath250=@xmath251@xmath213
it is : @xmath252=(1/@xmath253)@xmath58@xmath254$]@xmath38164 .
thus @xmath235@xmath21@xmath255=@xmath256 , i.e. dominated by the cold disk component .
given that @xmath165 can very greatly among lirgs , it is instructive to also obtain @xmath159 in a lirg where the relative distributions of the warm sf versus the cold sf - idle gas are well known . for the sy2 ngc1068 : @[email protected] and @xmath258@xmath386kpc ( papadopoulos & seaquist 1999 ) , while @xmath259@xmath385 .
thus @[email protected] and @[email protected]@xmath262 , which is @xmath383x higher than @xmath263 ( that would be deduced from its global co sled ) .
highly turbulent molecular gas in the merger - driven starbursts of ulirgs , and extended , cold , sf - quiescent gas in the disks of isolated or slightly perturbed lirgs represent the two extremes where current co line studies may systematically underestimate the total molecular gas mass . in both cases
global co sleds often show a low - excitation component , seen as small co j=10 , 21 line flux `` excess '' ( often with a subthermal co ( 21)/(10 ) ratio ) on top of the dominant co line emission of a warm and dense sf gas phase with high co line excitation to much higher j levels . in ulirgs
such a diffuse low - excitation phase is typically unbound , warm , and contains little mass . in the disks of lirgs
it consists of sf - quiescent , gravitationally bound ( or nearly so ) , galaxy - type gmcs extending beyond a central starburst . in the latter case spatially resolving the co sleds and/or dust emission of the nuclear sf region versus the extended cold disk can yield proper molecular gas mass estimates not dominated by the ( usually ) low @xmath264 of the co - bright nuclear sf region . in practice co and @xmath20co j=10 , and j=21 imaging of those sf and sf - idle areas of lirgs is adequate to determine the nature of the residing ism ( sf : @xmath265@xmath211 , @xmath266@xmath23810 - 15 , sf - quiescent : @[email protected] , @xmath268@xmath213 - 6 , the corresponding @xmath19 values , and the areas over which they apply . in the upcoming era of alma such spatial separations of sf and non - sf ism in lirg disks along with estimates of the corresponding molecular line ratios and @xmath19 values will be straightfoward . for ulirgs
though the low - density and the high density gas components can be concomitant or very closely associated , especially if the former is the outcome of the disruption of gmc outer layers .
thus high resolution co observations , even with alma , may be unable to separate their distributions and their corresponding co line ratios , leaving their @xmath19 factors still uncertain .
in such galaxies , with the bulk of the molecular gas mass at n@xmath2510@xmath48@xmath15 , observations of rotational transitions of heavy rotor molecules such as hcn are of paramount importance , even without spatial information .
for example a high global hcn / co j=10 brightness temperature ratio of @xmath211/4 - 1/6 would immediately indicate an unsually high @xmath269 , contrasting the @xmath2110@xmath188 lower such ratio in disk gmcs .
then multi - j observations of heavy rotor molecules can be used to determine the corresponding @xmath196 , @xmath142 factors and eventually @xmath270 .
high resolution interferometric imaging of at least two rotational transitions of a heavy rotor molecule ( e.g. hcn j=10 , 32 ) along with at least one of its isotopologues ( e.g. h@xmath20cn j=10 ) remains an invaluable resource for better determining the distribution and mass of the dense gas in the compact disks of ulirgs .
this can be achieved using radiative transfer models of the emergent hcn line emission as a function of position within these disks , as done earlier for the co j=10 , j=21 interferometric study by ds98 .
the focus will now be on the dense gas where much of the molecular gas mass resides , while its all - important average dynamical state ( i.e. the @xmath78 ) will be determined as part of the modeling .
imaging of the rare isotopologues can much reduce the radiative transfer modeling degeneracies affecting @xmath271 , and yield improved constraints on the dense gas surface densities @xmath272 of the gas disks in ulirgs .
their total gas mass can then be determined from integrating the resulting @xmath273 over the best - fit disk models . here
we must note that any molecular line observations that involve the @xmath274 $ ] isotope ratio such as co/@xmath20co or hcn / h@xmath20cn , while necessary for reducing lvg modeling degeneracies and better constraining @xmath78 , they involve the additional assumption of the @xmath275 $ ] abundance ratio ( which we assumed to be 50 in our lvg models ) .
the latter can be particularly uncertain in ulirgs where their large co/@xmath20co line ratios have also been attributed to a higher @xmath275 $ ] abundance than in spiral disks , a result of early starburst ages and/or accretion of relatively unprocessed ( by star - formation ) molecular gas ( henkel & mauersberger 1993 ) . if enhanced @xmath275 $ ] abundances are indeed the norm in ulirgs this will have the general effect of _ increasing the various x@xmath276 , x@xmath277 factors _ since the deduced @xmath78 values per gas phase can now be lower .
this will be so simply because larger @xmath275 $ ] abundances rather than low co line optical depths ( and thus high @xmath78 , see equation 11 in paper 1 ) can be also responsible for the observed high co/@xmath20co line ratios in ulirgs . in ulirgs a massive , warm , and dense gas phase can have a luminous co sled that remains prominent up to very high - j rotational transitions . since j=10 , 21 transitions can have significant contributions from a low - excitation diffuse gas component containing small fraction of the total molecular gas mass , this leaves only j=32 and higher - j co lines as useful probes of the bulk of the molecular gas mass and its properties .
the spire / fts aboard the hso can provide access to co lines from j=43 up to j=1312 for local luminous ulirgs ( e.g. van der werf et al .
2010 ; rangwala et al .
2011 ) and thus yield a critical dataset for obtaining better total molecular gas mass estimates in such systems .
once a fully - sampled global co sled from j=10 up to j=1312 is available , a multi - component analysis can decompose it into a series of gas components , constraining their properties , and using them to obtain the corresponding @xmath19 factors .
such multi - phase models could eventually be produced by theoretical advancements in gmc - sized numerical simulations ( see 3.1.1 ) .
thus hso observations of high - j co lines will allow better inventories of molecular gas mass in ulirgs since much of that mass resides in a dense , and presumably sf and warm phase .
we note however that serious degeneracies will remain , especially regarding the all - important dynamical state of each gas component upon which the corresponding @xmath19 factor strongly depends .
multi - j observations of the much fainter ( especially in ulirgs ) @xmath20co isotopologue lines , necessarily using the much larger mm / submm telescopes available from the ground ( and thus limited by the atmosphere up to j=65 , 76 ) are important for reducing those degeneracies , and better constraining @xmath78 , or equivalently ( for a given density and temperature ) , the escape probabilities @xmath278 per gas component that enter the expressions of the @xmath4 factors ( equations 3 and 6 ) .
several ( u)lirgs in our sample merit an individual study either because a larger than average number of available co lines permits it ( see table 7 in paperi ) , and/or because very high line excitation make their co sleds irreducible to superpositions of star - forming and ( non - sf ) molecular gas ( see also paperi for a discussion on the implication about ism power sources ) .
finally there are lirgs whose global co(j+1-j)/(1 - 0 ) ratios suggest the cold sf - quiescent clouds found at large galactocentric distances in the galaxy and the disk of m31 .
such globally `` cold '' yet star - forming galaxies are very few , as expected for an ir - selected ( and thus sfr - selected ) lirg sample , and thus also deserve a closer look as they represent the low - excitation range in lirgs .
the detailed model(s ) per galaxy and the associated discussion are in the appendix , while here we summarize the most important findings . the extreme range of co sleds found for the molecular gas reservoirs of lirgs discussed in paperi is now marked by individual objects . on the high end
are galaxies like iras00057 + 4021 , arp299 , iras12112 + 305 and others whose extremely high co line excitation implies large amounts of very dense ( @xmath53(1 - 3)@xmath179(10@xmath48 - 10@xmath109)@xmath15 _ and _ ( often ) very warm ( @xmath40@xmath280100k ) gas .
the large @xmath281=m(n@xmath2810@xmath48@xmath15)/m@xmath282(h@xmath29 ) deduced for such ( u)lirgs independently recovers , using mid / high - j co lines , a well - known result for merger - driven starbursts obtained using the hcn / co j=10 ratio as an @xmath283 proxy ( gao & solomon 2004 ) . these earlier studies ( see also gracia - carpio et al .
2008 ; krips et al . 2008 ) found @xmath3810 times higher dense gas mass fractions in ulirgs than in isolated spirals .
isofar as the dense molecular gas phase closely tracks the dense and warm gas associated with sf sites , the mid - j / high - j co lines of ulirgs are also expected to show clear indications of a high @xmath284 , as it is indeed found , and quite unlike what is expected from typical gmcs ( @[email protected] - 0.03 ) . furthermore , the very warm and strongly unbound ( @xmath84@xmath1320 ) states uncovered for the massive dense gas reservoirs of some lirgs can make their global co sleds surpass even those expected for sf `` hot''-spots in the orion a and b clouds . while in some distinct cases this can be due to strong agn feedback ( e.g. mrk231 ) , for all other galaxies with such extreme ism conditions ( e.g. iras00057 + 4021 , iras08572 + 3915 , iras23365 + 3604 )
the cause is unclear .
it remains to be explored whether the much higher sfr _ densities _ of the compact sf regions of ulirgs ( e.g. sakamoto et al . 2008 ) can create such extraordinary ism states where turbulence - injection by snrs no longer remains confined in small regions but encompasses much more molecular gas mass ( see discussion in paperi ) .
this , along with crs ( also snr - generated ) may set up powerful global mechanisms that can volumetrically heat large amounts of gas , unhindered by the large dust extinctions and high average gas densities that will keep pdrs very localized around sf sites
. on the low excitation end only a few cases of low global co line ratios are found ( e.g. iras051892524 , iras03359 + 1523 ) .
this is expected for ir - selected ( and thus sfr - selected ) galaxies ( see dunne et al .
2000 on the limitations of such samples in finding ( cold - ism)-dominated systems ) . in arp193 a low - excitation ism state and the lack of large amounts of dense and warm gas
is actually suggested by hcn rather than co lines .
indeed despite the presence of a young merger with substantial ir luminosity and a significant hcn / co j=10 line ratio , its global hcn line emission is consistent with the absence of a dense gas phase , possibly a case of strong sf feedback momentarily dispersing its dense gas supply ( papadopoulos 2007 ) .
such ir - luminous/(dense - gas)-deficient galaxies will be rare ( see discussion in b.17 ) and thus valuable for studying the effects of sf feedback onto the dense ism where the initial conditions of star formation are set .
the case of iras051892524 on the other hand stands out as one where a massive cold molecular gas - rich disk is implied but unlike other lirgs ( e.g. izw1 ) there are no morphological indications whatsover for the presence of such a disk in this very compact ulirg / agn system
. moreover its `` warm '' co(6 - 5)/(3 - 2 ) ratio , warm ir `` colors '' , and compact size in cm , near - ir , and optical wavelengths would argue for the presence of only a warm , dense , sf gas phase , and thus this object represents a cautionary tale about such conclusions drawn for similar high - z ulirg / agn systems using only high - j co lines ( e.g. tacconi et al .
2006 ) .
we note that massive cold molecular gas disks are implied for other lirgs as well ( e.g. izw1 , viizw031 , ngc7469 ) but without strongly affecting their global co sleds or co/@xmath20co line ratios which remains dominated by the warm sf phase .
this simply mirrors , for molecular lines , a result well - known for dust continuum emission , though in practice global co sleds are somewhat more sensitive to the presence of cold diffuse gas than the global dust seds are to the concomitant cold dust mass ( papadopoulos & allen 2000 ) . in table 1
we tabulate the total molecular gas mass estimates as produced by equations 3 , 10 , the corresponding @xmath4 factors , the minimum molecular gas mass implied for eddington - limited star formation ( section 2.3 ) , and the mass of the high - excitation ( h)-phase when a 2-component model is used to interpret the co , @xmath20co lines ( see appendix ) . a mere inspection of the third column demonstrates than in several galaxies ( @xmath5340% ) _ significantly larger @xmath16 factors than the so - called ( u)lirg values of @xmath21(0.6 - 1)@xmath111 may apply . _ for ulirgs
this is due to large and even dominant fractions of their molecular gas mass being at much higher densities than in disk - dominated lirgs while for the latter because extended cold molecular disks ( with a galactic @xmath19 ) can contain much of the molecular gas mass while remaining incospicious in the global co sleds used to constrain the global @xmath4 . for ulirgs this low - mass bias includes some
very well - known systems such as mrk231 and arp220 . for lower ir luminosity galaxies underestimates of their total molecular gas by the @xmath4 deduced from one - phase radiative transfer models of their co sleds can be important in disk - dominated systems ( e.g. ngc7469 ) , but also in seemingly compact star - forming galaxies that nevertheless have `` cold '' co sleds and galactic @xmath4 values ( iras051892524 ) .
the computed @xmath235 and @xmath286 in table1 also make clear that in the case of ulirgs global molecular line sleds can reveal the aforementioned mass bias , provided that they include mid / high - j co and/or heavy rotor molecular lines ( e.g. hcn ) . for less ir - luminous galaxies with nuclear starbursts and cold sf - quiescent gas - rich disks global sleds can not easily identify the presence of the latter except in a few cases ( e.g. iras05189 - 2524 ) .
this becomes possible only when additional spatial information ( e.g. co 1 - 0 , submm dust continuum , or cm imaging ) is available for such a disk ( e.g. ngc7469 ) . in the absence of such information even good one - phase models of global co sleds for a ( starburst)+(cold disk ) system may be unable to reveal the disk component leaving the deduced average @xmath100 dominated by the starburst phase ( e.g. iras02483 + 4302 ) . in the era of alma routine
co multi - j and @xmath20co line imaging will provide much better molecular gas mass estimates for disk - dominated lirgs with strong ism excitation gradients ( see 3.4 ) .
for ulirgs on the other hand multi - j observations of heavy rotor molecules ( e.g. hcn , cs ) and their rare isotopologues are necessary for confirming the high total @xmath4 and molecular gas masses implied by our results in table 1 , by constraining the all - important dynamic state of the massive dense gas phase as discused in 3.2.1 .
in this work our large co , @xmath20co line survey of luminous infrared galaxies ( lirgs ) detailed in paperi ( papadopoulos et al .
2011 ) is used to examine the impact of the wide range of average ism conditions found for these galaxies on their total molecular gas mass estimates via the so - called @xmath19=m(h@xmath29)/@xmath287 factor .
our sample includes some of the most prominent local ulirgs ( e.g. arp220 , mrk231 , iras172080014 ) , often used as templates for merger - driven starbursts at high redshifts , as well as less ir luminous disk - dominated galaxies .
we find that one - phase radiative transfer models of the global co , @xmath20co line ratios yield @xmath288@xmath289([email protected])m@xmath23(kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 , similar to that obtained by past studies .
the average gas temperature and density strongly influence @xmath4 , but the gas average dynamical state is the most important influencing factor with unbound gas corresponding to low @xmath4 values while self - gravitating gas to higher ones . nevertheless higher @xmath291@xmath8(2 - 6)m@xmath23(kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 values are deduced for ( u)lirgs whenever adequate molecular line data exist to determine the mass contribution of gas at densities n@xmath2810@xmath48@xmath15 ( high - j co lines from our survey and/or hcn lines from the literature ) .
theoretical expectations for the highly turbulent molecular gas in the merger - induced starbursts of ulirgs indicate that , with most of the gas at such high densities , the aforementioned large @xmath4 values maybe the rule rather than the exception in such systems .
past observational studies were unable to determine this , yielding instead much lower @xmath19 values ( and often considered as ulirg - appropriate standard ones ) , because the molecular lines used ( mostly co j=10 , 21 ) could not constrain the properties of the dominant ( i.e. the dense ) gas phase in ulirgs .
our results indicate that only high - j co lines and multi - j observations of heavy rotor molecules ( e.g. hcn , cs ) can overcome this mass bias , placing the herschel space observatory and alma front and center in the quest for improved molecular gas mass estimates in ulirgs in the local and the distant universe .
of particular importance are good constraints on the dynamical state of the dense molecular gas in such systems ( self - gravitating or not ? ) since strongly unbound states for this phase seem to be the only possible way that @xmath4 in ulirgs could be much lower than a galactic value .
observations of high - density tracing rare isotopologues ( e.g. high - j @xmath20co , h@xmath20cn ) will be of crucial importance in yielding such constraints .
on the theoretical front , gmc - sized numerical simulations of the turbulent molecular gas with ulirg - type of boundary conditions are needed in order to obtain the dense gas mass fraction and its temporal evolution .
this in turn can inform galaxy - sized simulations of merger systems which recently have included molecular gas , but can not track the dynamical state and mass of the dense gas .
we also find lirgs where underestimates of their total molecular gas are the result of a massive , cold , gas - rich , disk existing beyond their central starburst .
in such cases the global co sled , and the @xmath19 factor determined from it , remains dominated by the central starburst and its often low @xmath4 .
spatially resolving the co , @xmath20co line and dust continuum emission of such disks in lirgs with strong ism excitation gradients is indispensible in accounting for their total molecular gas mass . in such cases ,
provided that adequate resolution is employed to separate the cold gas disk from the nuclear starburst , even low - j co and @xmath20co lines ( j=10 , 21 , 32 ) are adequate to yield much improved molecular gas mass estimates .
finally our study unfolds the wide range of the global co sleds of lirgs presented in paperi over a subsample of individual systems .
we find galaxies whose extreme co sleds indicate ism conditions that surpass those expected for star - forming regions and suggest ism energy sources other than photons from pdrs ( as already discussed in paperi ) . these can be agn , extreme turbulence , and/or very large cosmic ray energy densities .
moreover we find lirgs where extreme sf feedback may have momentarily fully disrupted their dense molecular gas reservoirs , and lirgs where large amounts of cold sf - quiescent molecular gas are present despite the absence of an extended disk , their compact near - ir / cm emission size , and `` warm '' co ( 6 - 5)/(3 - 2 ) ratios
. the latter type of objects can be particularly worrying if encountered at high redshifts where such characteristics can readily lead towards large underestimates of their total molecular gas mass .
the wide range of the average ism conditions and the intriguing possibilities that may lie behind it , make our subsample of individually - studied lirgs an excellent target for future alma and noema ( for the northern objects ) molecular line imaging observations leading towards a complete picture about ism energetics , agn and sf feedback on the molecular gas in galaxies .
we would like to thank the referee santiago burillo for his comments , and particularly for bringing into our attention two important issues namely , the uncertainties of [ co/@xmath20co ] abundance ratio in ulirgs , and the reliability of dynamical mass estimates , which resulted in our corresponding clarifications included in this paper .
padelis p. papadopoulos would like to dedicate this long - coming work to his 10-month old son @xmath292-@xmath293 , for late night inspirations , and to his wife @xmath294 for her enduring support .
the project was funded also by the john s. latsis public benefit foundation .
the sole responsibility for the content lies with its authors .
the co j=10 line luminosity @xmath295(10 ) ( in kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12 , see equation 5 , paperi ) can be re - expressed as @xmath296 \,da\,dr\ ] ] where any given velocity v is assumed to correspond uniquely to a source surface @xmath297 , emitting at @xmath298 . in turn
this can be parametrized by a `` depth - in - the - source '' parameter r(v ) so that these iso - velocity surfaces completely scan the entire source volume for a range @xmath299 ( which corresponds to the fwzi of the source velocity field ) , and without any radiative coupling ( the lvg assumption ) .
the latter implies that the line luminosities emanating from these surfaces simply add up .
thus we can write @xmath300 where @xmath301 denotes averaging over the entire source volume @xmath302 , and for an assumed constant velocity gradient . thus for @xmath303 and @xmath304=@xmath305 ( @xmath306=1.36 accounts for the he mass ) equations a1 , a2 , and a3 along with subsituting astrophysical units yield for the @xmath307 factor @xmath308 the last expression ( used in the main text with the averaging symbols omitted for simplicity ) for @xmath76=1.5 becomes identical to that derived by solomon et al
. 1997 ( their equation 21 for f=1 ) . for virialized gas motions ( @xmath101=1 ) , and typical conditions in galactic gmcs with @xmath309=(100 - 500)@xmath15 and @xmath77=10k yields @xmath310@xmath38(3 - 6)@xmath311 , in good accord with the average galactic value and its uncertainties .
finally , expression a4 is valid for any optically thick molecular line emission used as a mass tracer of a particular gas phase ( e.g. hcn j=10 tracing dense gas with @xmath148@xmath3210@xmath48@xmath15 ) , while multi - j observations of the particular molecule and its isotopologues can be used to constrain @xmath312 , @xmath313 , and @xmath78 . from standard formalism the integrated line luminosity for an optically thin co j+1@xmath314j line , omitting the cmb for simplicity ,
is given by @xmath315 where @xmath316 is the total number of co molecules at the j+1 state and @xmath317 is the einstein coefficient of the j+1@xmath318j transition .
this line luminosity can be re - expressed in terms of @xmath319 ( in @xmath320=kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12 units , see a1 ) using @xmath321 which combined with a5 yields @xmath322 the total molecular gas mass is then given by @xmath323 where @xmath324=@xmath325$]=@xmath326 is the co abundance and @xmath306=1.36 accounts for he mass .
the molecule population at the j=0 level obviously can not be estimated from a line transition , and we thus compute it from @xmath327=@xmath328 n_1 $ ] where @xmath329=@xmath330 denotes the j - state degeneracy factor , @[email protected] , and @xmath333 is the excitation temperature of the co j=10 transition . substituting this in a8 yields @xmath334 which after substituting the expressions from a7 yields @xmath335\ ] ] where @xmath336 are the @xmath337(j+1-j)/@xmath337(1 - 0 ) ratios observed ( equations 5 , 6 ) .
the einstein coefficients scale as a function of j as @xmath338 while @xmath339=@xmath340 .
thus equation a10 finally becomes @xmath341.\ ] ] substituting the various physical constants and introducing astrophysical units yields , @xmath342 \left(\frac{m_{\odot}}{k\,km\,s^{-1}\,pc^2}\right).\ ] ] in the literature the lte approximation is often used by setting @xmath343=@xmath344/g@xmath345n@xmath345 and @xmath344@xmath21@xmath346=@xmath347 $ ] in equation a8 , which then yields @xmath89 \left(\frac{m_{\odot}}{k\,km\,s^{-1}\,pc^2}\right).\ ] ] for optically thick co emission where the optical depths arise in small gas cells with respect to molecular cloud sizes co line emission remains effectively optically thin ( i.e. traces the entire emitting gas mass ) but with @xmath348@xmath349@xmath350 in all the previous equations , with @xmath351=@xmath352/\tau_{ik}$ ] being the photon escape probability ( for a spherical cloud ) .
in such a case equation a10 can be trivialy modified for finite co line optical depths to yield @xmath353 \nonumber \rm \left(\frac{m_{\odot}}{k\,km\,s^{-1}\,pc^2}\right ) .
\end{aligned}\ ] ]
here we describe the radiative transfer models in selected galaxies from our sample .
the details of the large velocity gradient ( lvg ) radiative transfer code used , and the parameter space explored by its @xmath354 $ ] variables can be found in paperi . in the several cases where a one - phase gas lvg model manifestly fails to reproduce the available line ratios we use a two - phase approximation ( see 2.4 ) to better represent the underlying average molecular gas properties , and compute the corresponding @xmath214 ( equation 10 ) .
the ( h)-phase properties and its @xmath142 are constrained using co j=43 , 32 and @xmath20co lines , with the 65 transition placing constraints as a lower limit of the true emergent line luminosity ( see paperi ) , with higher co j=65 luminosities typically yielding even denser gas lvg solutions with larger @xmath355 .
the `` residual '' co line ratios ( determined from equations 8 , 9 ) are used as inputs into our lvg radiative transfer code in order to constrain the physical properties and corresponding @xmath356 factor of the low - excitation ( l)-phase . in the cases where a two - phase ism model is necessary but inadequate co line observations
exist to constrain the ( h)-phase , we assume one based on the model defined by the orion star - formation `` hot - spots '' , their sled , and molecular gas mass normalization ( see 2.4 ) . finally in the very few cases where heavy rotor molecular lines ( mostly hcn transitions ) exist , they are often used to determine the ( h)-phase . for all
the lirgs studied , their measured co line ratios , computed sf - powered ir luminosities @xmath357 , and the dust temperatures used to constrain the lvg model ( i.e. @xmath358@xmath641 ) can be found in paperi .
there are only a few studies of this lirg , and the only available co j=10 interferometric map shows a very compact nearly face - on source with most of the gas in a @xmath359 ( @xmath21864pc ) core ( ds98 ) .
its luminous co j=43 line emission can not be accounted by one - phase lvg models , with the best such model : @xmath225=90k , @xmath33@xmath332@xmath360@xmath15 , @xmath101=1 , reproducing well the observed @xmath145 , @xmath361 and the @xmath146 lower limit , but yielding @xmath362=0.48 , which is @xmath81/3 of the observed value .
moreover the fact that @xmath363@xmath32@xmath364(orion ) ( see 2.4 ) and @xmath363@xmath32@xmath361 , makes obvious that a superposition of low - excitation ( sf - quiescent ) and high - excitation orion - type sf `` hot '' spots can not produce such a highly - excited global co sled , and that even extreme gmcs consisting solely of such `` hot '' spots are inadequate .
thus the _ average _ state of the molecular gas in iras00057 + 4021 `` out - excites '' even the sf regions in orion a and b. the existence of such ulirgs , and the implications for an ism energy input other than far - uv / optical / ir photons from sf sites ( i.e. turbulent and/or cr heating ) has already been noted in paperi ( see also rangwala et al .
2011 ) .
using @xmath365-@xmath366=0.89 along with the other co line ratios still does not yield an average ism state that can reproduce them .
the best lvg solution ranges then are : @xmath60=(35 - 65)k , @xmath33=@xmath367@xmath15 , @xmath81@xmath531 - 4 , and @xmath40=(70 - 150)k , @xmath37=@xmath360@xmath15 , @xmath84@xmath381 .
these reproduce the observed @xmath368 , @xmath369 and the @xmath370 lower limit , but yield @xmath371(lvg)@xmath380.45 - 0.50 , i.e. still significantly lower than @xmath365-@xmath366 . a 2-phase model using an orion - defined ( h)-phase ( and sled )
gives @xmath372=0.91 , @xmath373=0.53 , @xmath374=0.83 ( equations 8 , 9 ) , and remains unable to fit these residual line ratios , failing to account for the j=43 line ( @xmath375(lvg)@xmath210.3 - 0.4 ) .
using only the j=32 , j=43 transitions as constraints ( @xmath376=@xmath377 ) of the ( h ) phase and restricting lvg solutions with @xmath60@xmath28@xmath236(=37k ) and @xmath101@xmath3781 , yields @xmath40@xmath6495k , @xmath37=@xmath379@xmath15 , and @xmath84@xmath2120 .
the fit yields no upper limit on @xmath60 , as expected since the maximum possible @xmath380 ( attained for optically thin thermalized co lines ) is ( 4/3)@xmath12@xmath381=1.77@[email protected] for @xmath383@xmath3840 . using the lower @xmath376=1.26 value ( = ( observed)@xmath385 ) as input in the lvg code yields identical results . thus _
a very warm , dense , and strongly kinematically stirred gas phase is present in iras00057 + 4021 . _
an estimate of its mass can be obtained from the measured @xmath386=(@xmath387)@xmath388 , and @xmath389 = @xmath390@xmath149@xmath391 , where @xmath392=3.4 is the average co(43)/(10 ) ratio computed from the range of lvg solutions compatible with the observed one .
thus for @xmath393=(@xmath394)@xmath388 , and @[email protected]@xmath220 ( computed from the lvg solutions compatible with @xmath380 ) it is @[email protected]@xmath39710@xmath398@xmath399 , comparable to the total ( hi+h@xmath29 ) gas mass of the milky way and the minimum @xmath400=@[email protected]@xmath179@xmath402m@xmath23 expected for `` fueling '' star formation in this lirg . in table 1
we comprehensively list all these gas mass estimates for iras00057 + 4021 , along with @xmath403 computed using 1-phase and 2-phase lvg models ( eqs 3 and 10 ) .
we must note however that for iras00057 + 4021 and most ( but not all ) lirgs where 2-phase models are used , the large degeneracy that exists for lvg solutions of the `` residual '' co line ratios of the ( l)-phase ( cool and near - virial versus warm and strongly gravitationally unbound states ) translates to a large range of @xmath158 , and thus @xmath159 , values ( table 1 ) .
this in effect is the low - j co sled degeracy described in 3.4 , which the global co sleds available in our study can not `` break '' .
the high - excitation ( h)-phase in iras00057 + 4021 contains @xmath47(20 - 50)% of @xmath404 ( table 1 ) , which is at least @xmath4710@xmath58 larger than what would be expected if its ism was reducible to typical galactic gmcs .
moreover its @xmath405(lvg)@xmath212.5 , @xmath406(lvg)@xmath2123 ratios ( for @xmath190=100k , @xmath148=3@xmath149@xmath407@xmath15 , and @xmath78=22 ) are higher than those in the orion sf `` hot - spots '' near hii regions and o , b star associations ( sakamoto et al .
this further corroborates the irreducibility of the observed co sled of iras00057 + 4021 to ordinary photon - powered ism states .
one the other hand strong mechanical feedback from snr - driven shocks could in principle yield such highly excited co sleds ( arikawa et al . 1999 ; bolatto et al .
2003 ) , but just like radiative feedback from o , b stars , such snr - driven `` hot '' spots involve only small fractions of a typical gmc mass .
indicatively , in the galactic snrs w44 and ic443 a warm , dense , and very kinematically stirred component with @[email protected] ( seta et al .
1998 ) involves only @xmath471% of the impacted gmcs , with negligible effect on their global co line ratios ( @[email protected] ) .
we must also note however that iras00057 + 4021 is a seyfert2 and its agn , if x - ray luminous , can induce such extreme conditions to a large molecular gas mass , if distributed close to it ( schleicher et al .
2010 ) .
this lirg hosts an optically and x - ray luminous qso in the center of a molecular gas - rich disk , the site of a vigorous circumnuclear starburst ( barvainis et al .
1989 ; eckart et al .
1994 and references therein ) .
the latter has been imaged interferometrically ( schinnerer et al . 1998 ; staguhn et al . 2004 ) revealing a disk of @xmath8@xmath409-@xmath410 ( @xmath33212 - 14kpc ) with cold ism but increasing ism excitation towards its central @xmath38@xmath411 ( @xmath212kpc ) sf circumnuclear ring . in terms of global co line excitation
while its @xmath145=@xmath412 ratio can be ( barely ) compatible with that of a sf - quiescent disk like the milky way ( @xmath380.6 ) , its luminous j=32 line with @xmath361=@xmath413 is clearly dominated by much higher ism excitation , typical of a sf phase ( even @xmath361-@xmath366=0.76 is 2.5x higher than @xmath361=0.3 typical for sf - quiescent ism ) .
a one - phase lvg model yields an acceptable fit within the measurement uncertainties , with @xmath265(lvg)@xmath211 , @xmath361(lvg)@xmath80.90 - 0.95 , and @xmath414@xmath218 , @xmath146@xmath385 - 7 while @xmath78@xmath211 - 2 ( a result of the modest @xmath415 and @xmath416 ) .
the best one - phase lvg solutions yield @[email protected]@xmath54 ( equation 3 ) , and a total molecular gas mass @[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
the minimum dense gas mass fueling an eddington - limited sf is @xmath418(h@xmath29)=4@xmath17910@xmath419m@xmath23 , which only @xmath535% of the @xmath420(h@xmath29 ) and typical for ordinary sf gmcs found in galactic disks .
thus izw1 stands as an example of a lirg with star formation occuring in an isolated gas - rich disk , fueled by ordinary molecular clouds .
the reasonable 1-phase lvg fit of the observed global co line ratios in izw1 make a 2-phase decomposition unnecessary .
nevertheless the available observational information on the presence of a cold molecular gas - rich disk and a circumnuclear ring starburst allow such a decomposition as a useful test on the limitations of global co sleds and their fit by a single average ism state , to yield reliable total molecular gas mass estimates . using the co j=32 , 65 and @xmath20co j=10 lines to constrain the ( h)-phase we find the best lvg solution range at @xmath225=(65 - 75)k , n=@xmath185@xmath15 and @xmath84=13 that yield @xmath142=0.65@xmath96 . adopting a galactic @xmath213=5@xmath96 for the computed residual co j=10 emission , which we attribute to the extended gas disk , yields @xmath202=1.65@xmath96 ( equation 10 ) , similar to that computed from the one - phase lvg model .
we caution however that the co j=65 line luminosity is highly uncertain and along with it the current 2-phase decomposition .
this is a disturbed spiral galaxy with a prominent dust lane and h@xmath421 emission in its center and two sources symmetricaly around the center source along the major axis ( hattori et al . 2004 ) .
vla imaging of its cm continuum emission show it elongated along the disk , as would be expected for star formation , with no signs of agn activity such as a radio core or jets ( parma et al .
its single dish co j=10 detection showed abundant molecular gas ( sanders et al . 1986 ) while subsequent interferometric co 1 - 0 imaging with ovro recovered all the single dish flux and showed it to be extended @xmath810@xmath422@xmath18820@xmath422 ( @[email protected] ) with the longest dimension lying along the optical disk ( wang et al .
the same study obtained a dynamical mass of @xmath423@xmath384@xmath17910@xmath424m@xmath23 within a co disk radius of 3.9kpc ( for the adopted cosmology ) .
however at @xmath214@xmath422 ( 1.4kpc ) south - east of its nucleus the co - derived velocity field deviates from that of a normal rotating spiral , possibly indicating the presence of another molecular gas concentration brought in as part of a merger ( wang et al .
1991 ) .
the available co lines are consistent with a star - forming disk with a well - excited co j=32 line ( @[email protected] , paperi ) but whose modest @xmath414=10@xmath4262 and @xmath370=12@xmath4263 ratios indicate that any merger activity has not disturbed the average dynamical state of the molecular clouds .
this is reflected in the one - phase lvg solutions found for @xmath60@xmath37835k which invariably have @xmath101@xmath382 - 4 .
these solutions remain highly degenerate however with @xmath36=(35 - 50)k , n=@xmath367@xmath15 , and @xmath78@xmath384 almost as good as @xmath40=(55 - 150)k , n=3@xmath179@xmath427@xmath15 , and @xmath78@xmath3322 .
the corresponding @xmath6@xmath53(0.8 - 1.1)@xmath428 , yields @xmath429@xmath8(4.6 - 6.3)@xmath5810@xmath22m@xmath23 , while @xmath430@xmath83@xmath43110@xmath419m@xmath23 is necessary to fuel an eddington - limited star formation .
thus the dense and warm gas fueling sf sites in this low ir luminosity galaxy will amount to only @xmath215%-6.5% of the total molecular gas mass , consistent also with its small hcn / co j=10 ratio of @xmath432=0.022 ( gao & solomon 2004 ) .
nevertheless global co sled can still be easily dominated by even small amounts of star forming gas whose often modest @xmath4 may be much smaller than that of an incospicious sf - quiescent cold gas reservoir . for ngc828
there is apriori knowledge of an extended molecular gas disk with @xmath388kpc diameter .
however a 2-phase fit with an assumed ( h)-phase sled and mass normalization ( see 2.4 ) leaves the ( l)-phase properties largely undetermined with @xmath433@xmath8(0.7 - 2.5)@xmath96 ( @xmath21@xmath202 since the ( l)-phase co j=10 luminosity dominates ) , and @xmath434@xmath21(4 - 14)@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 .
this two - nuclei system is a gas - poor / gas - rich merger of an elliptical ( nucleus a ) going through the disk of a former spiral containing nucleus b ( kollatschny et al .
1992 ) and all of the molecular gas detected in a co j=10 interferometer map ( ds98 ) .
the optically bright nucleus a hosts an agn with a sy2 spectrum , and is located 3.8@xmath422 ( @xmath213.76kpc ) to the west of nucleus b. the latter is where star formation occurs in this system , `` activated '' by the merger event which also likely triggered the qso activity in the gas - poor merger progenitor .
its co line ratios up to j=32 can be well - fitted by a wide range of conditions with even a cold @xmath190=15k but highly unbound ( @xmath101=22 ) phase yielding a good fit .
most solutions are found at warmer temperatures though with @xmath60=(35 - 55)k , and @xmath435=(90 - 120)k , low densities of n@xmath8(3@xmath14910@xmath12 - 10@xmath35)@xmath15 , and strongly unbound states @xmath84=7 - 40 .
such a wide degeneracy of lvg solutions representing the average conditions of the molecular gas in iras02483 + 4302 is typical for lirgs where @xmath436@xmath1711 , and no co/@xmath20co ratios are available to constrain line optical depths ( and thus @xmath84 ) . for this lirg
a lower limit of @xmath415@xmath6413 is not enough to eliminate the aforementioned degeneracy , though it does preclude sf - quiescent _ and _ virialized states . for for all the lvg solutions
compatible with its global line ratios we obtain @xmath6=(0.250.70)@xmath220 ( equation 3 ) . restricting the admissible range of lvg solutions with @xmath437@xmath641 , and @xmath101@xmath5620 yields @[email protected]@xmath96 and a total molecular gas mass @[email protected]@xmath179@xmath402m@xmath23 , similar to that obtained using the optically thin , lte , approximation @xmath438@xmath382@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 ( equation 5 for @xmath60=55k ) a result of the low / moderate optical depths of the lvg solutions used to deduce @xmath4 in this lirg .
the minimum gas mass for an eddington - limited star formation in iras02483 + 4302 is @xmath439(h@xmath29)@xmath171.4@xmath179@xmath402m@xmath23 , which is @xmath3890% of its total molecular gas mass ( for @xmath4=0.45@xmath96 ) .
this is rather puzzling as the sf phase , with its expected high densities ( @xmath2810@xmath14@xmath15 ) and near gravitationally bound states ( @xmath84@xmath381 - 5 ) can easily have co lines thermalized and with substantial optical depths up to at least j=32 .
thus if the sf phase indeed dominates the total molecular gas mass in this ulirg , one would expect @xmath440@xmath441m(h@xmath29 ) rather than @xmath442@xmath21m(h@xmath29 ) as the latter implies small / moderate optical depths for the bulk of the molecular gas mass .
moreover the physical states compatible with the global co line ratios of iras02483 + 4302 while highly degenerate , are hardly indicative of a dense sf gas phase dominating its total molecular gas mass .
it is also telling that all one - phase lvg solutions fail to reproduce the co j=65 line luminosity of this lirg , indicating the presence of another , potentially massive , gas component whose higher co line excitation becomes prominent beyond j=32 . using only its co j=32 , 65 , and the upper limits on the @xmath20co j=10 , 21 lines as constraints of the ( h)-phase in a 2-phase model still yields a significant range of solutions though all have n@xmath8(10@xmath48 - 10@xmath26)@xmath15 with @xmath60@xmath2460k , typical of a dense and warm sf - related phase .
most ( but not all ) have virial states ( @xmath101@xmath381 ) with @xmath355@xmath8(1.5 - 2.5)@xmath54 . from the corresponding @[email protected] and @[email protected]@xmath237 we obtain @xmath445=1.5@xmath44610@xmath398@xmath447 , and @xmath448=3.3@xmath18810@xmath398@xmath139 .
higher co j=65 line luminosities will only make this mass larger ( both via a higher @xmath449 and a higher deduced @xmath450 ) .
the `` residual '' global co line ratios of the ( l)-phase in this lirg can not distinguish between a cold , sf - quiescent gas at near virial dynamical states ( and galactic @xmath451 ) versus a warm and highly unbound phase expected in the highly turbulent environments of mergers ( and with a low @xmath158 because of the high @xmath84 ) .
thus for @xmath452=1.43 computed from our 2-phase model , @xmath157=2.2@xmath54 and @xmath234=(0.5 - 2.5)@xmath428 , we obtain @xmath453=(1.2 - 2.4)@xmath54 .
higher , near - galactic , values remain possible if high resolution co imaging were to reveal the ( l)-phase as an extended cold , sf - quiescent gas reservoir , something that global co sleds can not easily do .
two interacting galaxies @xmath3810@xmath422 ( @xmath216.9kpc ) apart can be discerned in optical images , with only the eastern source being bright in radio wavelengths ( condon et al .
1990 ; goldader et al .
1997 ) and containing most ( @xmath2575% ) of the co j=32 emission ( leech et al .
2010 , paperi ) .
this system has the lowest co(32)/(10 ) ratio ( = [email protected] ) indicating the lowest - excitation global co line excitation in our sample , though we can not exclude the possibility that significant co j=32 flux was `` missed '' by the 2-point observations of this two - nuclei system .
the best lvg solution indicates sf - quiescent gas ( @xmath60=15k n=3@xmath5810@xmath12@xmath15 and @xmath101@xmath212 ) , yielding @[email protected] and @xmath370@xmath2118 which is somewhat higher than the observed value ( = @xmath455 ) .
the corresponding @[email protected]@xmath54 gives @[email protected]@xmath17910@xmath424m@xmath23 , while the lte approximation for @xmath40=15k gives @xmath457=1.8@xmath17910@xmath22m@xmath23 , which is @xmath3810@xmath188 smaller than @xmath420 as expected given the large co line optical depths ( @xmath458@xmath2514 ) of the corresponding lvg solution .
the sf - related molecular gas mass @xmath459(h@xmath29)=8.2@xmath17910@xmath460m@xmath23 amounts to only @xmath384% of m(h@xmath29 ) , consistent with the low average co line excitation of this system and ensembles of ordinary gmcs .
this galaxy has one of the highest co j=10 luminosities in our sample and while early ground - based images were suggestive of an elliptical system ( sanders & mirabel 1996 ) , near - ir nicmos images clearly show a spiral disk with very bright asymmetric arms tightly around its nucleus over scales of r@xmath38(1 - 1.4)kpc ( half - light radii ) , with numerous star clusters on its disk ( scoville at al .
this is one of the few lirgs where there is no evidence of what has triggered its starburst activity , namely neither a nearby companion system ( indicating an early merger stage ) , nor tidal tails ( signs of an advanced or post - merger system ) .
high resolution interferometric imaging indicates a nearly face - on source with a rapidly rotating gaseous ring on scales of few hundred parsecs ( ds98 ) .
the low - j co sled with @[email protected] and @[email protected] indicate rather low average line excitation , compatible even with sf - quiescent ism ( @[email protected] - 0.6 , @[email protected] - 0.30 ) . a radiative transfer model of only the co j=10 , 21 , 32 , and @xmath20co j=10 , 21 lines yields @xmath40=(30 - 65)k , n=3@xmath43110@xmath12@xmath15 and @xmath84@xmath212 ( near - virial ) .
the corresponding @[email protected]@xmath428 factor yields @xmath462=1.5@xmath17910@xmath424@xmath399 while the minimum molecular gas mass needed to fuel an eddington - limited star formation in this lirg is : @xmath463@xmath382@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 . on the other hand a luminous co j=43 with @[email protected] ( paperi )
is highly excited , and the reason why one - phase lvg solutions , while reproducing the observed @xmath464 and @xmath465 line ratios within their measurement uncertainties , they yield @[email protected] - 0.26 , i.e. @xmath386 - 7 times lower than observed .
the co j=65 line luminosity with @[email protected] is also much higher than predicted by these models ( @xmath468=0.01 - 0.02 ) .
interestingly the @xmath20co j=10 , 21 lines , with modest @xmath469@xmath1710 and @xmath369(@xmath20co)@xmath380.72 ratios , also indicate a low / average excitation state .
thus only the co j=43 and j=65 line luminosities signify the presense of another potentially massive warmer and denser gas phase , demonstrating once more the importance of high - j co line measurements . moreover , the @xmath363@xmath32@xmath368 inequality sets the global co sled of viizw031 apart from those reducible to a mixture of a dense and warm gas phase ( with a co sled typical of orion hot - spots ) , and a cooler , diffuse one associated with non - sf gas and a low - excitation sled . as in iras00057
+ 4021 , this implies large amounts of hot _ and _ dense gas , maintained in a strongly unbound dynamical state as to keep the average optical depth of even high - j co lines below unity ( see also discussion in paperi ) .
we note however that in viizw031 the co j=32 line luminosity is highly uncertain because of the large system temperature , though even a 3@xmath149 stronger co j=32 line would maintain the aforementioned inequality and its implications for extraordinary ism conditions in this galaxy .
we use the co ( 4 - 3)/(3 - 2 ) ratio @xmath470 to constrain the ( h)-phase in a 2-phase model while using the co j=65 luminosity only as a lower limit .
we also assume the minimum @xmath470=(@xmath471-@xmath366)/(@xmath472+@xmath366)=1.67 value consistent within the measurement uncertainties in order to place limits on the lowest possible average excitation level for the ( h)-phase .
this will still be high as even that minimum value is close to the theoretical maximum of ( 4/3)@xmath12 , attained only for a hot gas phase with fully optically thin and thermalized co lines .
we find good solutions only for @xmath60@xmath2495k which keep improving up to the maximum @xmath60=150k considered , while n=3@xmath17910@xmath48@xmath15 and @xmath101=22 .
no good solutions can be found for lower temperatures as these have unphysical @xmath84@xmath1711 values . over the good solution
range the corresponding @xmath473=3.4 and @xmath474@xmath12 .
the corresponding @xmath475=0.9@xmath85 , and from @xmath476=@xmath477@[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath398@xmath320 ( we used the co(4 - 3)-@xmath479 value ) we estimate : @xmath448=3.1@xmath39710@xmath398m@xmath23 .
as expected , with a @xmath20co(2 - 1)/(1 - 0 ) ratio of @xmath210.73 ( subthermal ) , an ( h)-phase model can not successfuly include the @xmath20co lines , while their modest global @xmath465@xmath2110 ( table 8 , paperi ) are typical of disk gmcs rather than of those in starbursts ( where @xmath480@xmath37815 ) .
this along with the fact that there is very little co j=21 and 32 emission left after subtraction of the corresponding ( h)-phase line emission suggest a cold disk - like ( l)-phase . assuming an @xmath451=4.5@xmath54 ( i.e. galactic ) , and for @xmath161=2.34 , we obtain @xmath166=3.4@xmath54 and a total gas mass of @xmath481=3.9@xmath18810@xmath424m@xmath23 .
thus despite its prominence in co j=43 and 65 lines , the high - excitation component amounts to only @xmath218% of the total molecular gas mass in viizw031 .
interestingly , the co j=21 interferometric map by ds98 resolves out half of the 30-m single dish flux , indicating extended emission beyond the @xmath212@xmath422(2kpc ) nuclear region where the bright co j=10 emission is distributed .
indeed in the ds98 interferometric image faint co j=10 emission can be seen out to a radius of @xmath214@xmath422 ( 4kpc ) .
new sensitive co and @xmath20co j=10 and 21 interferometric observations with similar u - v coverage ( and thus enabling reliable line ratio maps ) can be used to discern the existence of such a massive cold molecular gas disk in this intriguing object .
this is sy2 galaxy that appears to be a late stage merger with a very red compact nucleus and a tidal tail , ( farrah et al .
2003 ; veilleux et al .
this ( u)lirg is the most compact and has the warmest mid - ir colors ( @xmath482=0.25 ) out of a nearly complete ulirg sample selected for their `` warm '' mid - ir colors ( @[email protected] ) . such systems are are thought to represent a critical stage in the so - called ulirg@xmath349(optically luminous qso ) transition scenario ( sanders et al .
1988b , c ) .
the agn in this ulirg is x - ray luminous with @xmath484(2 - 10kev)@xmath381.3@xmath5810@xmath485ergss@xmath11 ( dadina 2007 ) .
nicmos near - ir imaging reveals an unresolved nucleus in all three near - ir bands , with a half light radii of @xmath21(100 - 140)pc while co j=10 observations show large amounts of molecular gas ( sanders et al . 1991 ) but no interferometric co images are available yet for this southern ulirg . unlike all other mergers / starbursts
, iras051892524 has a small @xmath370=@xmath486 ratio , typical of the self - gravitating ( or nearly so ) gmcs in spiral disks . as a result
all lvg solutions within the expected temperature range ( i.e. @xmath487@xmath641 ) have @xmath101@xmath381 - 2 , indicating virialized gas motions , quite unlike the much higher @xmath78 found in merger / starbusts .
the observed @xmath145=@xmath488 together with the modest @xmath416 are actually perfectly compatible with a sf - quiescent phase ( where @[email protected] ) , although a sf - active one ( @[email protected] - 1 ) is certainly not excluded within the measurement uncertainties .
the best lvg solutions converge towards conditions typical of galactic gmcs but at elevated temperatures with @xmath489=(30 - 55)k , @xmath37=@xmath360@xmath15 , and @xmath84@xmath531 and yielding @xmath267=0.86 - 0.91 , @xmath461=0.50 - 0.67 , @xmath365=0.30 - 0.40 and @xmath370=9 .
using values within the @xmath490 range as constraints does not change the basic picture of low - density , somewhat warm gas , in a virialized or nearly so dynamical state . for the best solution
it is : @[email protected]@xmath428 , which yields @xmath492=1.37@xmath149@xmath493m@xmath23 .
denser and warmer gas must of course be present , associated with the vigorous star formation in iras051892524 and the minimum mass needed to fuel it of @[email protected]@xmath49510@xmath22@xmath139 .
the co j=65 line also indicates gas with significantly higher excitation than that indicated by the lower - j co lines since , for the optimal lvg solutions for the low - j co sled segment : @xmath496(lvg)@xmath210.01 - 0.05 , much lower than the observed @xmath467=@xmath497 . using a 2-phase model with an orion - derived sled and an eddington - limit mass normalization for the ( h)-phase ( see 2.4 ) yields ( l)-phase ratios of @xmath498=0.45 , @xmath499=0.28 and @xmath500=3.5 with the best lvg solution being @xmath60=15k , n@xmath501@xmath502@xmath15 and @[email protected] , i.e. typical of sf - quiescent gmcs found in the disk of the galaxy .
the corresponding @xmath451=2.5@xmath237 , which for a computed @xmath503=2.3@xmath5810@xmath398@xmath504 , yields a total mass of cold sf - quiescent molecular gas of @xmath3326@xmath39710@xmath398m@xmath23 . for the estimated @xmath505=1.43 and @xmath142=2.2@xmath96 ( see 2.4 ) we find @[email protected]@xmath200 and a @[email protected]@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 with @xmath2165% of this gas mass in a cold sf - quiescent phase .
this merger ulirg / agn with its large molecular gas reservoir , nearly - galactic @xmath19 ( @xmath3323 - 6 times higher than the so - called ulirg - values of @xmath21(0.6 - 0.8)@xmath96 ) , and most of its molecular gas mass in a cold reservoir , stands as the clearest counter - example to standard views regarding this class of galaxies in the local universe .
moreover , unlike izw1 ( another prominent `` warm '' lirg considered midway in a supposed ulirg@xmath507(optical qso ) transition ) whose known spiral disk can be the repository of its large sf - quiescent molecular gas reservoir , the very compact size of iras05189 - 2524 in cm continum , near - ir , and optical wavelengths ( condon et al . 1990 ; scoville et al . 2000 ; surace et al . 1998 ) seems to preclude such a configuration .
this compactness along with a `` warm '' co(65)/(32 ) ratio of @xmath470.63 ( i.e. dominated by the sf phase ) in a ulirg / agn whose molecular gas reservoir is dominated by a cold sf - quiescent component offer a cautionary tale regarding similar ulirg / agn objects at high redshifts where such charecteristics were often used ( and still are ) to argue for the presence of only a dense and warm sf gas reservoir ( tacconi et al .
future alma observations of this southern ulirg and similar objects would thus be very interesting for revealing the distribution of their large molecular gas reservoir and especially of their cold phase .
this lirg is one of the very few ( =3 ) appearing as a single undistorted nucleus in a large near - ir ( 2.2@xmath508 m ) and optical imaging survey of 56 ulirgs selected from the iras 2jy sample ( murphy et al .
its co line ratios reveal a low average excitation state but lack of @xmath20co observations permit a very wide range of conditions to reproduce its low global @xmath361 and @xmath369 ratios . in turn
these conditions yield a large range of @xmath6 values , from @[email protected]@xmath54 ( for @xmath40=15k , n@xmath21300@xmath15 and @xmath78@xmath211 ) , to @xmath509@xmath510(1.5 - 1.7)@xmath511 ( for @xmath40=(55 - 90)k ) , n@xmath21100@xmath15 and @xmath78@xmath81 ) and also down to @[email protected]@xmath96 ( for @xmath40=[20k , ( 40 - 50)k ] , n@xmath38[10@xmath35 , 300@xmath15 ] and @xmath78@xmath38[13 , 7 ] respectively ) . for a set of very warm ( @xmath190=(95 - 130)k ) and
strongly unbound ( @xmath78=22 ) diffuse gas ( n=3@xmath188@xmath427@xmath15 ) solutions the @xmath4 factor can become as low as @xmath380.3@xmath96 . it is worth remembering that such gas may indeed exists in most ulirgs as an `` envelope '' phase of a much denser dense phase , a result of disrupted gmcs during a strong merger .
its high brightness in low - j co lines ( a result of its high @xmath190 and @xmath101 values ) is responsible for the low @xmath4 deduced for such systems ( which nevertheless can have most of their molecular gas mass in a much denser phase with high @xmath4 , see discussion in 3.2 ) .
demonstrating the importance of @xmath20co line measurements we note that the co/@xmath20co j=10 ratio changes dramatically among the aforementioned lvg solutions groups , from @xmath415@xmath385 for cold virialized gas , to @xmath414@xmath2130 for the warm highly non - virial ism states .
neverthelesss lack of such measurements makes it impossible to constrain the lvg solution groups and thus @xmath6 in this ulirg .
values as low as @xmath4=0.3@xmath96 are likely excluded however as they yield @xmath456@xmath83@xmath14910@xmath398m@xmath23 , comparable to @xmath513(h@xmath29)=2.4@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
in such a case the global co sled would be that of dense warm sf gas ( i.e. highly excited ) rather than of low - excitation .
this is another prominent ulirg from the `` warm '' ulirg sample ( sanders et al .
1988c ) consisting of a close pair of interacting spirals with their nuclei separated by 5@xmath422 ( @xmath385.6kpc ) and clearly discernible in cm , near - ir and optical images ( condon et al .
1990 ; scoville et al .
2000 ; surace et al .
its nw nucleus is unresolved in near - ir and is the only one detected in co j=10 interferometer maps where it appears unresolved with @[email protected]@xmath422(@xmath212.3kpc ) ( evans et al .
mid - ir ( 12 - 25@xmath516 m ) imaging showed all the mid - ir emission also emanating from the nw nucleus and a region @xmath56330pc in diameter ( soifer et al .
2000 , and for the adopted cosmology ) .
the discovery of very luminous co j=65 emission towards the nw nucleus ( paperi , figure 2 ) , corresponds to second highest @xmath517 ratio in our entire sample ( @xmath211 ) , indicating extreme ism excitation conditions , with average gas densities of @xmath332(10@xmath26 - 10@xmath109)@xmath15 , and lvg fits that keep improving past @xmath190=150k .
the 3@xmath479 upper limit on @[email protected] is certainly compatible with such conditions , albeit not imposing any useful additional constraints ( high @xmath518 because of @xmath519(3 - 2 ) near the 325ghz atmospheric absorption feature prevented sensitive co j=32 observations of this system ) .
the high @xmath467 ratio measured for the nw nucleus of this ulirg is actually perfectly compatible with a pure orion `` hot - spot '' co sled ( see 2.4 ) , further emphasizing the truly extraordinary levels of ism excitation .
the corresponding molecular gas mass is at least @[email protected]@xmath14910@xmath398m@xmath23 ( assuming an eddington - limited sf ) . _ a galactic @xmath521@xmath510(3 - 6)@xmath522(kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 factor
is deduced _ from the lvg solutions with @xmath60@xmath2465k , which corresponds to @xmath304@xmath38(4.89.6)@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
thus @[email protected] - 0.81 , among the highest such fractions for the individualy - studied lirgs ( see table 1 ) .
this is another clear merger having double nuclei as iras08572 + 3915 , but more widely separated ( @xmath3812@xmath422 , 9.3kpc ) seen in radio continuum maps ( condon et al .
1990 ) as well as optical and co j=10 interferometric maps ( sanders et al . 1988 ) .
a tidal tail emerging from the eastern nucleus ( also the most gas - rich one ) is clearly visible in h@xmath76 emission ( hattori et al .
the two nuclei have been separately detected in co j=32 ( leech et al .
2010 , paperi ) while the ne nucleus may have been tentatively detected also in co j=65 ( paperi ) , with an implied high co(65)/(32 ) brightness temperature ratio of @xmath524=0.75 indicating a highly excited molecular ism phase . on the other hand
the global hcn / co j=10 brightness temperature ratio is @xmath380.03 ( gao & solomon 2004 ) , typical of the molecular gas found in isolated spiral disks and quite unlike the much higher such ratios in merger / starbursts .
using the global @xmath145 and @xmath361 , along with the lower limit on the co/@xmath20co j=21 ratio ( see paperi ) yields a large range of possible average ism states , all with n@xmath21(1 - 3)@xmath17910@xmath35@xmath15 and most with surprisingly large @xmath101 ( @xmath2170 - 126 ) . restricting @xmath78 to values @xmath21740 yields a much narrower range of solutions with @xmath60=(45 - 70)k and corresponding @xmath4@xmath38(0.25 - 0.8)@xmath96 .
this still considerable @xmath100 range yields @xmath429@xmath8(2.9 - 9.2)@xmath39710@xmath398m@xmath23 , while @[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
the latter is @xmath211/101/3 of the total molecular gas mass , leaving ample room for a sf - quiescent molecular gas reservoir . in arp55
however sf - quiescent is not the cool and mostly gravitationally bound gas found in the gmcs of isolated disks .
indeed the large temperatures and @xmath101 values needed to fit its highly - excited co lines and @xmath146@xmath113 suggest warm and strongly unbound gas which , unlike in most other ulirgs , contains most of the molecular gas mass .
the low hcn / co j=10 ratio then may not be due to the prevelance of galactic - type sf - quiescent gmcs rather than to a disrupted ism state that has , momentarily , a low ( dense)/(total ) molecular gas mass fraction .
short periods during which the dense gas reservoir of a lirg can be strongly disrupted by sf feedback while its ir luminosity remains intact are expected in strongly evolving mergers ( loenen 2009 ) . in such a scenario arp55 would be one of the few mergers `` caught '' in a very short act ( see also arp193 ) .
interestingly its hcn(32)/(10 ) ratio is @xmath1710.3 ( juneau et al .
2009 ) , much lower than in some classical ( u)lirgs such as arp220 and ngc6240 ( greve et al .
more sensitive @xmath20co and higher - j hcn observations of arp55 are necessary to confirm such a tantalizing picture of global ism dynamics .
near - ir nicmos observations show a single extremely red and unresolved nucleus with @[email protected]@xmath422 ( @xmath21170pc ) , surrounded by a strongly perturbed spiral structure ( scoville at el . 2000 ) with a tidal tail and a large ring seen in the optical ( sanders et al .
1988b ) . the half - light source radius at 2@xmath306 m is @xmath332450pc while an interferometric co j=32 image reveals a gas distribution of @xmath212@xmath422(1.5kpc ) in size ( wilson et al .
its disturbed morphology is interpreted as the result of an interaction with another gas - rich spiral ( sanders et al .
1988b ) and even with a gas - poor dwarf galaxy 17@xmath422 to the southeast ( majewski et al .
this ulirg contains an agn luminous in hard x - rays ( imanishi et al .
2003 ) and is deeply dust - enshrouded along most lines of sight , with n(h)@xmath3210@xmath527@xmath528 ( imanishi et al .
2001 ) .
its co sled betrays the presence of a high - excitation gas component already from the low - j lines with @xmath265=1.23 and @xmath461=0.93 ( paperi ) .
these ratios along with the high co/@xmath20co j=21 ratio of @xmath146=18 can be well - fitted by two ranges of lvg solutions , namely : @xmath225=(35 - 65)k , n=3@xmath14910@xmath35@xmath15 , @xmath150=22 , and @xmath40=(100 - 130)k , n=10@xmath35@xmath15 , @xmath101=4 .
the corresponding average @xmath19 factors are @[email protected]@xmath54 and @[email protected]@xmath54 respectively .
we note that a small range of solutions with @xmath60=(25 - 30)k , n=@xmath185@xmath15 and @xmath78=40 also exists but are unlikely to be good representation of the average ism state in this ulirg since @xmath529@xmath1711 ( considered unlikely , see paperi ) .
moreover their very large @xmath101 make it even less likely that these modest gas temperatures can correspond to such highly unbound dynamical states where the molecular gas can be significantly heated by the dissipated supersonic turbulence ( see paperi ) . nevertheless adopting this narrow cooler gas solution range would not make much difference when it comes to the corresponding @xmath19 factor which is @xmath210.5@xmath96 .
the corresponding total molecular gas mass then is @xmath530@xmath34(1.92.9)@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 while @[email protected]@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 .
the large fraction of sf gas mass in ugc05101 ( @xmath21(55 - 84)% ) is further corroborated by the high hcn / co j=10 brightness temperature ratio of @xmath380.2 ( gao & solomon 2004 ) ( for typical spiral disks this ratio is @xmath380.02 - 0.03 ) isofar as hcn j=10 is a linear proxy for dense gas mass and most of that gas is involved in star formation .
this dense gas reservoir is likely confined into the small ( near - ir)-bright nucleus fueling a compact starburst .
such compact , @xmath332100pc - sized gas - disk / starburst configurations have been revealed for arp220 ( sakamoto et al .
2008 ; mathushita et al 2004 ) where extremely high extinctions ( @xmath531@xmath14710@xmath532@xmath15 ) correspond to significant dust optical depths even at submm wavelengths ( sakamoto et al .
2010 , papadopoulos et al .
. these can be responsible for compton - thick agn , and a surpression of high - j co lines in such systems
. this may be the case also for ugc05101 as indicated by its low co(6 - 5)/(1 - 0 ) yet high hcn / co j=10 ratio ( see figure 11 , papadopoulos et al .
2010b ) .
despite the good one - phase fit obtained for the global co sled ( and @xmath146 ) of this ulirg , the observed co line emission may still be dominated by a phase that does not contain the bulk of its molecular gas mass . indeed ,
neither the modest densities nor the potentially highly unbound average dynamical states implied by the one - phase lvg fits would be typical of the hcn - bright star - forming phase .
as discussed in 3.2 the @xmath4 obtained from the global low - j co sled may thus be suitable only for a gas phase that does not contain much of the molecular gas mass . using the observed @xmath205=5 in the context of a 2-phase model along with @xmath533=2.34 ( see 3.2 ) yields @xmath534=1.136 ( eq .
14 ) . in the absence of multi - j hcn observations that could constrain @xmath199 we set @xmath535=10@xmath96 , the smallest value produced by such studies ( e.g. papadopoulos 2007 ; gracia - carpio et al .
thus @xmath536=@xmath537@[email protected]@xmath96 , and for @xmath158=0.5@xmath96 it would be @xmath538=2.3@xmath220 , which is @xmath501(4 - 6)@xmath188 higher than that deduced from one - phase lvg models of the low - j co sled .
multi - j observations of hcn or other heavy rotor molecules ( e.g. cs , hco@xmath192 ) can confirm such potentially high masses of molecular gas at high densities .
the young and intense star formation activity of this uv - bright galaxy is on par with m82 , and the likely result of a recent merger with a smaller galaxy ( balick & heckman 1981 ; concelice et al .
2000 ; elmegreen et al .
its gas and dust are warmed and disrupted by the presence of the starburst in its central 1 - 2 kpc .
tidal hi tails , unusually large hi velocity dispersions ( @xmath4740kms@xmath11 ) for a spiral galaxy ( kregel & sancisi 2001 ) , and large velocity offsets ( up to 150kms@xmath11 ) between molecular cloud and adjacent hii regions ( kikumoto et al .
1993 ) provide further evidence for a dynamically disturbed gas typical of mergers .
this galaxy has been extensively studied by zhu et al .
2009 as a template of a highly - excited ism , indicated by @xmath539@xmath321 ratios and warm ir `` colors '' ( @xmath540=1.28 ) . despite its low ir luminosity ( @[email protected]@xmath17910@xmath424l@xmath23 , paperi )
its global @xmath265=1.47 and @xmath361=1.21 ratios surpass those of orion cloud sf `` hotspots '' , and are among the highest observed in our sample .
its proximity allowed spatially resolved studies of its molecular gas with single - dish telescopes obtaining beam - matched observations of the co(32)/(10 ) ratio ( see zhu et al .
2009 for details ) . these high global co line ratios of ngc3310 can be fitted well by a single phase provided @xmath60@xmath37835k ( @xmath21@xmath61 ) , but remain highly degenerate over the @xmath354 $ ] domain up to the highest temperature searched ( 150k ) .
interestingly for @xmath190=(35 - 50)k a class of dense ( n@xmath38(1 - 3)@xmath17910@xmath48@xmath15 ) _ and _ strongly unbound ( @xmath101@xmath820 - 40 ) states are possible , though only higher - j and/or @xmath20co line observations could reduce the wide degeneracy of the lvg solutions and designate such phases as those most likely representing the actual ism conditions .
other solution ranges are : @xmath40=(70 - 90)k , n=3@xmath43110@xmath35@xmath15 and @xmath84=22 while near - virial solutions can be found at high temperatures @xmath542=95k , ( 140 - 145)k , n=(1 - 3)@xmath14910@xmath48@xmath15 and @xmath101=4 , 2.2 .
the large degeneracy of possible average ism conditions translates to a significant one for the @xmath4 factors , ranging from @xmath80.4@xmath220 ( for the highly unbound states with @xmath84=22 - 40 ) and up to @xmath38(1.2 - 2.2)@xmath220 ( for the near - virial states with @xmath78=4 , 2.2 ) . for @xmath19=(0.4 - 2.2)@xmath220
the corresponding @xmath420=(0.3 - 1.5)@xmath54310@xmath460m@xmath23 while @xmath513=1.1@xmath5810@xmath419@xmath15 .
the latter seems to rule out the lowest @xmath4 values while even for the highest ones it is : @xmath418/@[email protected] , i.e. most of the molecular gas in ngc3310 is directly involved in star formation ( for an eddington - limited sf process ) , leaving little room for a massive low - excitation molecular gas reservoir .
interestingly the lvg solutions corresponding to the highest @xmath4 values are those indicative of a sf phase with n@xmath383@xmath18810@xmath48@xmath15 , @xmath101=2.2 and large @xmath60=(140 - 145)k .
we caution though that all this pertains only to the inner @xmath2140@xmath422 of this galaxy where the starburst takes place , a massive molecular gas reservoir with low densities , highly unbound gas motions , and low co line excitation can still exist beyond it , a situation actually encountered in m82 in the form large scale molecular gas outflows ( weiss et al .
2005 ) .
this is a ulirg with hii region - type line ratios ( armus , heckman , & miley 1989 ) implying an optical spectrum dominated by young stars rather than an agn .
nevertheless a weak contribution from an agn seems necessary in order to fit its ir / submm dust continuum sed ( farrah et al .
early r - band ( 6550 ) imaging has shown this object to be a possible triple merger galaxy system ( murphy et al .
1996 ) , while near - ir imaging with the hst nicmos camera shows a luminous primary galaxy interacting with a much fainter one @xmath88@xmath422 ( @xmath216.7kpc ) to the southeast ( scoville et al .
the primary galaxy is compact with a half - light source diameter at 2@xmath544 m of @xmath21650pc , and the only source where luminous co j=10 line emission is detected ( ds98 ) with a diameter of 1.5@xmath422 ( 1.25kpc ) .
moreover this ulirg along with viizw031 and arp193 are the only galaxies where kinematic models of the co emission indicate a rotating ring rather than a filled disk gas distribution ( ds98 ) .
its low - j co lines ( j=10 , 21 , 32 ) indicate a well - excited low - j co sled ( @xmath265=1.06 , @xmath368=0.80 ) expected for a starburst while the large @xmath415=15 and @xmath146@xmath6418 are typical for merger systems .
two ranges of one - phase lvg solutions that can be found for @xmath529@xmath3781 ( with @xmath545=40k ) namely : @xmath546$]=@xmath547 $ ] and @xmath548$]=@xmath549 $ ] , with the best ones obtained for @xmath40=45k and 115k respectively .
both also reproduce the co j=65 line luminosity with @[email protected] ( observed value : [email protected] ) .
the resulting @xmath4 factors are : @xmath4=0.75@xmath96 ( for @xmath225=45k ) and 0.60@xmath220 ( for @xmath40=115k ) , yielding a total molecular gas mass of @xmath420=(3.8 - 4.80)@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
the minimum such mass needed for eddington - limited sf is @xmath430=2.6@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 , which is @xmath3854%-68% of @xmath434 . as in ugc05101 the aforementioned large fraction of molecular gas mass directly involved in star formation in iras10565 + 2448
is corroborated by a high hcn / co j=10 brightness temperature ratio of @[email protected] ( gao & solomon 2004 ) .
however all the 1-phase lvg solutions obtained are hardly representative of a dominant dense and self - gravitating gas phase but more typical of the `` cloud - envelope '' warm and diffuse gas often found in the ism of mergers .
moreover all one - phase lvg fits fail to reproduce the @xmath416@xmath6418 lower limit , with @xmath552=12 being the highest value obtained ( for the @xmath60=115k solution ) . a 2-phase model with an assumed ( h)-phase aleviates this and yields an ( l)-phase with @xmath190=65k , n=@xmath367@xmath15 , and @xmath84=13 that has @xmath553@xmath3820 and @xmath554=0.4@xmath54 .
the computed @[email protected]@xmath96 is within the range of the one - phase values , a result of the low @xmath158 , the large luminosity contribution of the ( l)-phase ( @[email protected] ) , and the modest @xmath142=2.2@xmath96 of the ( h)-phase ( see 2.4 ) .
setting constraints on the ( h)-phase and @xmath142 by using the observed co j=32 , 65 and @xmath20co j=10 lines ( assumed emanating mostly from that phase ) , does not change the aforementioned picture , at least when it comes to the values of @xmath556 . indeed
while the corresponding lvg models do recover dense gas solutions ( n@xmath3810@xmath48@xmath15 ) , substantial @xmath78 values ( @xmath33213 ) keep the corresponding @xmath246 well below galactic . in this model the ( l)-phase contribution , and thus the influence of @xmath158 on the @xmath159 , is negligible .
we must stress however that other high - j co line observations , and crucially multi - j hcn observations are necessary to confirm this picture .
if luminous such lines were to be discovered for this ulirg , they could substantially raise @xmath157 and thus @xmath159 as discussed in 3.2 .
this is a spectacular merger of two galaxies , ic694 and ngc3690 , with luminous co j=10 emission detected in the nuclei of both ( which are 22@xmath422 4.4kpc , apart ) , and the interface between them ( sargent et al .
1987 ; sargent & scoville 1991 ) .
a long hi tidal tail is also seen extending out to @xmath21180kpc ( hibbard & yun 1999 ) . along with the antennae galaxy this
( u)lirg has been considered an early template for mergers , documenting their ability to rapidly funnel the gas in the disks of the progenitors into compact regions ( sargent & scoville 1991 ) .
indeed the two nuclei in arp299 contain @xmath3880% of its molecular gas reservoir , fueling intense star - formation , while the nucleus of ic694 contains also an agn ( sargent & scoville 1991 and references therein ) , and is the primary source of the bolometric luminosity of this spectacular system ( charmandaris et al .
the most detailed molecular line study of this template merger system is the interferometric study of co , @xmath20co and hcn j=10 line emission by aalto et al .
1997 which finds most of the hcn - bright emission located in compact regions ( @xmath557310pc ) in the two nuclei of the merging galaxies , and unusually large co/@xmath20co line ratio variations ( from @xmath3860 in the ic694 nucleus , to @xmath3325 - 10 in its disk ) .
actually the state of the gas in the ic694 nucleus with the largest hcn / co _ and _ co/@xmath20co ratios _ exemplifies the effects of highly turbulent environments found in mergers , _ with much of the molecular gas mass `` resettled '' at high densities ( boosting the hcn / co ratio ) while the violent disruption of gmcs creates a diffuse warm and highly unbound `` envelope '' phase dominating the low - j co lines ( boosting the co/@xmath20co ratios ) .
while we have no co j=65 measurements for this galaxy ( too extended for the narrow jcmt beam at 690ghz ) our co j=32 and j=43 measurements indicate high co line excitation .
a one - phase lvg model of the global co ( 32)/(10 ) , ( 43)/(10 ) and co/@xmath20co j=10 line ratios gives the best fit for @xmath225=30k , n=10@xmath48@xmath15 and @xmath101=40 which indicates strongly unbound gas motions .
other average gas states are also possible ( e.g. @xmath225=40k , n=3@xmath39710@xmath35@xmath15 and @xmath84=22 ) but all have @xmath78@xmath6422 .
the corresponding @xmath100 factor over the lvg solution range is @xmath6=(0.35 - 0.42)@xmath96 , with the largest value corresponding to the dense gas solution .
these yield @xmath456@xmath8(1 - 1.2)@xmath39710@xmath22m@xmath23 while @[email protected]@xmath5810@xmath22m@xmath23 , which clearly favors the higher @xmath4 values and indicates that @xmath21100% of the molecular gas mass is associated with sf sites .
larger values of @xmath4 ( and @xmath434 ) remain possible however if most of the molecular gas mass in arp299 is contained in the hcn - bright phase with large @xmath197 factors .
multi - j co , @xmath20co and hcn , h@xmath20cn line imaging would be ideal in determining this as a function of position within a template merger whose ism conditions seem to encompass the full range possible , from quiescent disks to compact starburst nuclei .
this ulirg consists of a strongly interacting pair of galaxies whose nuclei are @xmath382.9@xmath422 ( @xmath214kpc ) apart ( carico et al .
1990 ; scovile et al .
2000 ) , while tidal tails and `` plumes '' are visible both in optical ( surace et al . 2000 ) and near - ir ( scoville et al . 2000 ) wavelenghts .
co j=10 interferometry finds the bulk ( @xmath875% ) of the emission emanating from the ne nucleus of this system ( evans et al .
2002 ) , which is unresolved with a size of @xmath562@xmath422 ( @xmath562.7kpc ) , and also the only one tentatively detected in co j=65 ( see paperi ) .
thus our one - phase lvg radiative transfer modeling pertains only to the ne nucleus of this strongly interacting system .
the observed @xmath361=1.58 ratio is the second highest in our sample ( the highest one found in another double nuclei system : iras22491 - 1808 ) and indicates the presence of high - excitation molecular gas .
this surpasses the corresponding ratio of the sf `` hot - spots '' in the orion molecular cloud , while the @xmath461@xmath32@xmath267 inequality is another indication of a qualitatively different co sled , irreducible to a mixture of sf and sf - quiescent gas ( see paperi ) .
all one - phase lvg solutions for iras12112 + 0305 indicate average gas states with n@xmath53(3@xmath43110@xmath48 - 10@xmath558)@xmath15 .
nevertheless lack of @xmath20co line observations leaves serious degeneracies with e.g. @xmath559$]=[60 , 10@xmath26 , 13 ] , [ 125 , 10@xmath48 , 1 ] being nearly equivalent .
the corresponding @xmath19@xmath38(1.5 - 5.3)@xmath54 , with _ galactic values of @xmath38(4 - 5)@xmath111 obtained for the warmest ( = ( 120150)k ) and densest ( = ( 10@xmath26 - 10@xmath109)@xmath15 ) states_. the presense of such high densities is corroborated by a high hcn / co j=10 ratio of @xmath551=0.16 ( hcn from gracia - carpio et al .
2008 , co from paperi ) , though without offering any constraints on the temperatures of the dense gas or its all - important kinematic state .
however even the warmest and densest one - phase solutions remain rather poor fits of the `` hot '' @[email protected] and comparatively `` cooler '' @[email protected] ratio .
indicatively such a solution ( n=10@xmath109@xmath15 ) with @xmath190=150k and @xmath78=4 yields @xmath368@xmath21@xmath145@xmath211 as the high density , and modest @xmath78 act to keep the co lines well - thermalized but also optically thick up to high - j levels . a two - phase model of the global co line ratios in this intriguing ulirg can not use an orion - derived ( h)-phase co sled as the observed @xmath368@xmath32@xmath560(orion ) . using only the co ( 3 - 2)/(2 - 1 ) ratio @xmath561=@xmath562 to constrain the high - excitation ( h)-phase yields : n=3@xmath18810@xmath48@xmath15 , @xmath84=22 , and @xmath190@xmath64140k ( for @xmath60=140k , @xmath563=1.28@xmath38@xmath561-@xmath366 ) , with a fit that keeps improving past @xmath190=200k ( where @xmath564=1.41 ) .
this is expected since @xmath565@xmath321 indicates a thermalized j=32 line ( and thus n@xmath1@xmath566@xmath3810@xmath48@xmath15 ) , with low / modest optical depths ( ensured in part by the large @xmath78 ) , _ and _ warm enough gas to populate the j=3 level .
the molecular gas mass of this phase can be estimated from @xmath567=@xmath568@xmath569@xmath214@xmath18810@xmath398@xmath320 ( where @xmath570@xmath214 ) and the computed @xmath571@xmath211@xmath54 , thus @xmath572(h@xmath29)@xmath214@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 , and similar to that needed to fuel an eddington - limited sf in this ulirg of @xmath513(h@xmath29)@xmath3325@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
for the ( l)-phase @[email protected]@xmath39710@xmath398@xmath574 luminosity there are no constraints on its corresponding @xmath234 factor . setting @xmath158=(0.5 - 5)@xmath96 yields @xmath235=(0.7 - 3.4)@xmath96 and a corresponding @xmath420@xmath38(7.1 - 34.3)@xmath18810@xmath22m@xmath23 .
multi - j hcn and h@xmath20cn as well as @xmath20co line observations are critical for reducing the degeneracies of the radiative transfer models for the dense and the low - excitation gas , and their @xmath4 factors .
this is an archetypal ulirg / qso and the most ir luminous galaxy in the revised iras bright galaxy survey ( rbgs ; sanders et al .
it has a compact nucleus , surrounded by irregular incomplete rings of star formation along with a small tidal arm that contains numerous blue star - forming knots ( farrah et al .
2003 and references therein ) .
it has large amounts of molecular gas in a compact ( 0.85@xmath422 , 700pc ) nearly face - on disk ( bryant & scoville 1996 ; ds98 ) which allows nearly unobscured view towards an optically luminous agn which classifies this object also as a seyfert1 galaxy .
mrk231 was also the first ulirg for which high - j co lines ( j=43 , 65 ) were detected ( papadopoulos et al .
2007 ) while recent spire / fts observations with the hso revealed luminous high - j co lines up to j=1312 emanating from agn - induced x - ray dissociated regions ( xdrs ) ( van der werf et al .
its well - excited high - j co lines , the largest hcn / co j=10 ratio ( @[email protected] ) observed among ulirgs ( papadopoulos et al . 2007 ) , and a very high co/@xmath20co j=21 ratio exemplify the extraordinary _ average _ molecular gas states possible in such systems ( similar to the ic694 core in the arp299 merger system ) . finally the availability of hcn j=43 , 10 measurements along with the high - j co lines allowed a detailed study of its dense gas phase ( papadopoulos et al .
2007 ) , and make mrk231 a good case study for the effects of the large m(n@xmath3210@xmath48@xmath15)/m@xmath576 fractions on the global @xmath6 of ulirgs .
a one - phase lvg fit predictably fails to converge on any average state as it can not accomodate both the high densities needed to excite the co j=32 , 43 , and 65 lines _ and _ maintain the very low optical depths needed for reproducing the very large @xmath577=47 ratio .
indicatively the best one - phase lvg solutions : @xmath60=(115 - 150)k , n@xmath21(300 - 10@xmath35)@xmath15 and @xmath578=7 - 40 yield @[email protected] - 1.1 ( [email protected] ) , @[email protected] - 0.7 ( [email protected] ) , @[email protected] - 0.3 ( [email protected] ) and @[email protected] ( [email protected] , but not used for the lvg fit ) , while @xmath585=25 - 32 ( obs=47@xmath42616 ) .
thus the average ism state deduced by a one - phase lvg model can be responsible for up to j=32 ( and the @xmath20co j=21 ) line emission but severely underpredicts the co j=43 , and 65 line luminosities .
the corresponding @xmath50@xmath38(0.25 - 0.45)@xmath54 is low but within what was thought as the ulirg - appropriate range ( for mrk231 ds98 give @xmath50@xmath21(0.7 - 0.8)@xmath96 ) .
these yield @xmath434@xmath47(1.8 - 3.2)@xmath39710@xmath398m@xmath23 , but a minimum @xmath586=5.5@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 clearly favors the higher @xmath456 ( and @xmath19 ) among those computed with the one - phase model .
for a 2-phase model we use the results by papadopoulos et al .
2007 of warm ( @xmath38(85 - 140)k ) , diffuse gas ( @xmath21300@xmath15 ) that is highly unbound ( @xmath101@xmath621 ) , and dense gas ( @xmath47(1 - 3)@xmath54310@xmath48@xmath15 , @xmath36=(40 - 70)k ) responsible for the bright co j=65 , hcn j=10 , 43 lines .
the latter phase is virialized with @xmath199@xmath21(10 - 25)@xmath587 ( for our numerical factor in equation 3 rather than the one in papadopoulos et al .
2007 ) and @xmath588@xmath212 - 2.54 ( high value corresponding to the lower @xmath199 values ) .
thus @xmath589=(1/@xmath588)@xmath199@xmath47(3.94 - 12.5)@xmath54 while for the diffuse and hcn - dark phase : @xmath158@xmath21(0.4 - 1)@xmath54 .
for an @xmath590=3.45 we then find @[email protected] - 0.73 ( yielding @xmath142=(3.94 - 12.5)@xmath96 ) , and an @xmath202@xmath38(3 - 7)@xmath96 ( for the smallest @xmath451 ) .
thus _ a galactic @xmath4 factor applies in mrk231 , _ a result of a large mass of dense gas with high @xmath142 values , themselves a result of the high gas densities _ and _ their virial dynamical states .
this galaxy is a template of a young merger - induced starburst with an age of few@xmath14910@xmath193yr and near - ir imaging showing a highly dust - enshrouded nucleus , and tidal tails ( smith et al . 1995 ) .
a disturbed highly inclined disk is also seen in nicmos near - ir imaging with reddening increasing towards the nw within the disk ( scoville et al .
2000 ) , and a similar extinction distribution implied by a co j=10 interferometer map ( bryant & scoville 1999 ) .
extended radio continuum emission ( @xmath383@[email protected]@xmath422 ) is seen at cm wavelengths with two nuclei @xmath211@xmath422 apart and a spectral index of @[email protected] ( @xmath592@xmath593@xmath594 ) , consistent with sf - related non - thermal synchrotron emission ( clements & alexander 2004 ) .
the latter study also finds significant decoupling of the hi and co - bright h@xmath29 gas motions and distributions .
the young age of this disk - disk merger / starburst is corroborated by several extra - planar highly luminous star clusters ( scoville et al .
2000 ) and many bright hii regions ( clements & alexander 2004 ) . high s / n co j=10 and
21 interferometric imaging confirmed a highly inclined 2.8@[email protected]@xmath422 ( @[email protected] ) gas disk whose co emission is best fit by a molecular ring ( ds98 ) .
a compact southeast co source coinciding with the secondary cm continuum emission peak in arp193 has the properties of a giant molecular core , and is much warmer and denser than the rest of the disk .
along with a region in mrk273 , and the western nucleus of arp220 ( ds98 ) , it is one of the most extreme sf regions in the local universe , forming stars very near or at the eddington - limit set by the radiation pressure from young massive stars on the dust of the dense molecular gas ( i.e. @xmath595(sf - region)@xmath8(250 - 500)l@xmath23/m@xmath23 ) .
one - phase lvg solutions to its co line ratios yield low - density solutions with n@xmath21(1 - 3)@xmath17910@xmath35@xmath15 but large temperature degeneracies with @xmath40=40k , ( 60 - 75)k , ( 80 - 115)k and corresponding @xmath84=22 , 4 and 13 values .
warmer solutions with @xmath40=(120 - 150)k and even larger @xmath101(=40 ) values also exist . considering only the gas states with @xmath101@xmath5620 yields @xmath100@xmath17(0.35 - 0.75)@xmath220 and @xmath420@xmath21(1.6 - 3.5)@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 , with the highest @xmath4 ( and @xmath434 ) values corresponding to the states with the smallest @xmath78 .
the minimum molecular gas mass for an eddington - limited star formation is @[email protected]@xmath179@xmath402m@xmath23 .
a young starburst and the strong sf feedback expected in such extreme sf events could be responsible for arp193 being the only lirg where , despite a large sf - powered ir luminosity ( @xmath5012.2@xmath18810@xmath2l@xmath23 ) and hcn / co j=10 ratio ( @xmath5010.044 , with hcn j=10 from carpio - et al .
2008 , and co j=10 from paperi ) , the average state of its molecular ism , is compatible with a complete absence of a dense molecular gas reservoir ( papadopoulos 2007 ) .
this is indicated by its low hcn ( 43)/(10 ) and ( 32)/(10 ) line ratios of @[email protected] ( 3@xmath366 ) and @[email protected] ( papadopoulos 2007 ; gracia - carpio et al .
2008 ) . using them as constraints
yields a narrow temperature range of dense gas solutions with @xmath190=(50 - 60)k , n=3@xmath18810@xmath48@xmath15 and @xmath78=14 ( rather large for a dense gas phase ) .
the widest range of solutions is at : @xmath596=(65 - 95)k , n=3@xmath43110@xmath35@xmath15 and @xmath597@xmath381 . unlike the former set of solutions the latter reproduces also the co(3 - 2)/hcn(1 - 0 ) line ratio of @xmath2117@xmath4264 ( which can be reasonably assumed as an additional constraint on the denser sf gas phase ) . using the upper limit of the hcn(43)/(10 )
ratio as a detection ( as to obtain the densest possible lvg solutions ) only pushes the aforementioned set of dense gas solutions to @xmath596=(90 - 105)k , while the lower density / virial ones are now found at @xmath60=(110 - 150)k ( both sets of solutions can now reproduce the co(3 - 2)/hcn(1 - 0 ) ratio ) . for a 2-phase model where the hcn - bright gas is set as the ( h)-phase we obtain @xmath235@xmath21(0.70 - 1.75)@xmath54 ( with the low values corresponding to the dense / unbound solutions ) .
this is is @xmath53(0.9 - 2)@xmath58@xmath19(ds98 ) , and yields @xmath420@xmath38(3.3 - 8.1)@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
thus arp193 stands as a case where multi - j line observations of high - density tracers such as hcn do not significantly change the picture obtained by the low - j co lines regarding the global @xmath4 factor
. this may be because this lirg is a rare merger , `` caught '' in the act of having momentarily dispersed / consumed its dense gas mass while still having large sf - powered ir luminosities , a brief state of affairs expected because of sf - feedback during the evolution of merger starbursts ( loenen 2009 ) .
we note however high - resolution co imaging revealing the `` excess '' co j=10 line emission of the ( l)-phase to be a cold sf - quiescent phase can still push the global @xmath4 towards near - galactic values via a higher @xmath158 .
optical and near - ir _ hst _ observations reveal this sy2 galaxy to be a grand design spiral with star formation across its arms but being most intense in its central @xmath211kpc ( martini et al .
the inner 1.6kpc is also where most of its cm radio continuum emerges ( condon et al .
optical and uv studies by gonzalez delgado et al .
( 1998 ) reveal a young nuclear starburst with gas likely provided by a bar instability .
its hcn / co j=10 line ratio of @xmath210.087 ( gao & solomon 2004 ) , while not as high as in ulirgs , it is nevertheless @xmath38(3 - 4)@xmath188 higher than in spiral disks .
this indicates a significant dense gas mass fraction , even in the absence of a strong merger and/or galaxy interaction .
lack of the latter makes the large @xmath415=26 and @xmath415=13 measured in ngc5135 an exception as these are typical mostly in mergers .
interestingly this galaxy is known for powerful gas outflows of hundreds of km / s , driven by its young starburst ( gonzalez delgado et al .
1988 ) .
one - phase models of its co line ratios yield @xmath598$]=@xmath599 $ ] , with warmer ( but also more degenerate ) solutions such as : @xmath600 $ ] also remaining possible . for the entire range of solutions the corresponding @xmath601@xmath21(0.35 - 0.45)@xmath85 , similar to @xmath602(lte ) for @xmath40=(30 - 70)k ( the temperatures of the best solutions ) , as expected for the low / modest optical depths of the lvg solutions . for these @xmath491 values @xmath603=(1.1 - 1.4)@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 while @xmath418=3@xmath18810@xmath419m@xmath23 , which corresponds to @xmath2120%-30% of the total molecular gas mass .
nevertheless , with the distribution of the molecular gas unknown , a galactic @xmath4 for disk - distributed gas not intimately involved with star - formation remains a distinct possibility .
in such a case the true @xmath4 and @xmath434 can easily be @xmath21(10 - 15 ) times higher , reducing @xmath604 to only few% , and more typical of spiral disks . as described in 3.4 co line imaging observations rather than global co sleds can be used to determine the existence of such a cold molecular gas disk .
this extraordinary ulirg shows up as a double - nuclei system in nicmos near - ir observations where the nuclei are only @xmath211@xmath422 ( 740pc ) apart ( scoville et al .
2000 ) . a strikingly long tidal tail ( @xmath81@xmath605 , 44kpc ) as well as a decoupling of stellar and gas motions ( tacconi et al .
2002 ) are the telltale signatures of a strong merger .
its northern nucleus contains a compact hard x - ray luminous sy2 agn ( xia et al .
2002 ) , but the dust emission sed of this ulirg is dominated by a starburst ( farrah et al .
this galaxy actually contains the most extreme starburst region among all ulirgs imaged in the ds98 study , with an ir luminosity of @xmath386.7@xmath17910@xmath2l@xmath23 emanating from its core of only @xmath80.35@xmath422@xmath431(@xmath1710.2@xmath422 ) ( 260pc@xmath431(@xmath171149pc ) ) diameter .
this makes the compact nuclear co line source of mrk273 akin to the west nucleus of arp220 , and along with arp193 these three ulirgs host the most prodigious sf events in the local universe ( ds98 ) . for the core of mrk273
the ir brightness is : @xmath606@xmath34@xmath607/(@xmath608@xmath810@xmath20l@xmath23kpc@xmath609 , i.e. the eddington limit for radiation - pressure - regulated star formation ( thompson 2009 ) . in the framework of
an eddington - limited sf this makes the compact nuclear starburst in mrk273 a maximal sf event , and its astounding co linewidth of @xmath211060kms@xmath11 ( ds98 ) may be a direct outcome of radiation pressure becoming dynamically important as to affect bulk gas motions . the global co line ratios , while typical of a star - forming ism they are not typical of an extreme starburst as mrk273 certainly is .
the @xmath146=@xmath610 ratio in particular is low , found mostly for gmcs in sf - quiescent spirals ( @xmath370@xmath2420 is observed for extreme starbursts ) .
the compact starburst core of mrk273 is surrounded by extended co line emission ( @xmath213@xmath422 - 7@xmath422 , i.e. ( 2.2 - 5.1)kpc , ds98 ) where
ordinary star - forming and even sf - quiescent ism could be containing significant fractions of the total molecular gas mass .
the optimum lvg solutions obtained for the global co ratios are : @xmath611$]=[30 - 70,3@xmath149@xmath427 , 1 ] . apart from the elevated temperatures such conditions are typical of galactic gmcs , while the @xmath6@xmath382@xmath54 of the best lvg solution ( at @xmath40=45k ) is higher than the so - called ulirg value ( @xmath80.8@xmath428 ) .
the corresponding @xmath603@xmath810@xmath424m@xmath23 while a minimum mass of @[email protected]@xmath43110@xmath398m@xmath23 is needed to fuel an eddington - limited star formation in this system .
the total molecular gas mass of mrk273 can be higher still if the mass contributions of a colder low - density and sf - quiescent phase , and a warmer denser sf one are accounted separately . a clear indication of a highly - excited sf gas phase is given by the co j=65 line which , while not as bright as in some other ( u)lirgs ( e.g. mrk231 , ngc6240 ) , yields a @xmath496 that is @xmath215@xmath58 higher than that anticipated from the best lvg fit of the lower - j co lines
. a high hcn / co j=10 ratio of @xmath612=0.14 ( using the co j=10 value from paperi and the hcn j=10 from carpio et al .
2008 ) and a well - excited hcn j=32 line with @xmath461(hcn)[email protected] ( gracia - carpio et al .
2008 ) offer more evidence for the presence of a dense gas phase . a two - phase decomposition using only the co 3 - 2 , 6 - 5 and @xmath20co j=21 lines to constrain the high - excitation phase yields @xmath613(h@xmath29)@xmath86@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 , and an effective @[email protected]@xmath428 . the latter yields @xmath420(h@xmath29)=1.3@xmath5810@xmath424m@xmath23 , of which @xmath853% correspond to the low co brightness ( l)-phase . thus despite its spectacular starburst
, mrk273 is an example of a ulirg that contains also large amounts of cooler low co - excitation gas .
use of the two available hcn lines to determine the propreties of the ( h)-phase does not change this picture , and can actually raise @xmath159 up to @xmath21(4 - 5.5)@xmath96 .
this powerful radio galaxy was the first f - rii source ( i.e with edge - brightened radio lobes , see fanaroff & riley 1974 ) to be detected in co locally ( z=0.046 ) , revealing large amounts of molecular gas distributed in a rotating disk of 7@xmath422 ( @xmath216.2kpc ) centered in its nucleus , and with a large co linewidth of @xmath8900kms@xmath11 ( evans et al .
its disturbed morphology maybe due to an interaction with a companion galaxy @xmath840@xmath422(35kpc ) to the southwest , while a powerful optical / ir - luminous jet interacts with the ambient ism ( floyd et al .
the sf efficiency of the galaxy is low ( @xmath88l@xmath23/m@xmath23 ) and along with a sfr@xmath8(6 - 7)m@xmath23yr@xmath11 it is typical of ordinary spirals .
the modest global co @xmath265=0.74 and @xmath368=0.44 ratios ( paperi ) are also consistent with a sf - quiescent ism .
thus the high excitation levels of the co j=43 , and 65 discovered in this system were certainly a surprise .
their interpretation as due to an agn - driven jet - ism interaction provided the first known example where `` mechanical '' agn feedback globally affects galaxy - size molecular gas reservoirs ( papadopoulos et al .
2008 , 2010b ) , though similar examples with lower - power agn and much smaller molecular gas reservoirs have been reported much earlier ( matsushita et al .
2004 ) . the physical conditions compatible with the luminous co j=43
, 65 lines were studied in detail by papadopoulos et al .
2010b ( see their table 4 ) where dense ( @xmath383@xmath188(10@xmath48 - 10@xmath26)@xmath15 ) , warm @xmath190@xmath53(75 - 300)k and strongly unbound @xmath84@xmath2115 - 50 states have been deduced .
the corresponding @xmath167@xmath21(0.8 - 1.5)@xmath54 , with computed @xmath615=2 - 3.2 and @xmath616=(1/@xmath617)@xmath179@xmath618=(1.46 - 2.33)@xmath5810@xmath398@xmath388 .
this agn - excited gas will have @xmath572@xmath38(1.1 - 3.5)@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 , much higher than the @xmath418@xmath215@xmath17910@xmath193m@xmath23 of warm and dense gas expected fueling its star formation . setting a galactic @xmath158=5@xmath54 for the remaining ( l)-phase co j=10 luminosity of the sf - quiescent disk phase yields an effective @xmath202=(2.9 - 3.9)@xmath85 , which are near - galactic values .
indicatively , a one - phase fit of only the co 10 , 21 , and 32 lines ( any lvg fit including the co j=43 and/or j=65 predictably fails ) yields maximum values of @xmath4=(1.2 - 1.6)@xmath96 , obtained for the solutions with the lowest @xmath78 values ( @xmath212 - 4 ) , but values as low as @[email protected]@xmath96 also probable .
this is an impressive ulirg / merger of two gas - rich spirals with their two nuclei 3.4@xmath422 ( 5.2kpc ) apart , and clear indications of tidal features and strongly disrupted disks seen in _
hst _ optical and near - ir nicmos images ( evans et al .
2000 ; scoville et al .
interferometric imaging of co j=10 has shown that both nuclei contain copious amounts of molecular gas but remain unresolved with size @xmath1862.5@xmath422 ( 3.8kpc ) ( evans et al .
2000 ) . using radio continuum measurements to obtain size estimates for the two star - forming cores of this ulirg yields very compact regions with diameters of d@xmath21200pc ( condon et al . 1991 ) , similar to the compact molecular gas disks found in arp220 and mrk231 ( ds98 ) .
the observed co j=10 , 21 , 32 and @xmath20co j=21 lines ( paperi ) are compatible with a wide range of conditions having @xmath40@xmath28035k with the best ones found for @xmath40=(40 - 85)k , n=10@xmath35@xmath15 , and @xmath101=4 . quite unlike most merger / ulirgs
, all good lvg solutions correspond to @xmath84@xmath381 - 4 .
nevertheless @xmath19@xmath21(0.65 - 1)@xmath85 , i.e. much lower than galactic .
the corresponding @xmath420@xmath38(1.1 - 1.74)@xmath5810@xmath424m@xmath23 while the minimum mass needed for eddington - limited star - formation is @[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 , which amounts to @xmath830%-50% of the total molecular gas mass . in iras14348 - 1447 , as in other ulirgs , such high mass fractions of what is presumably a dense and warm gas phase are not reflected by the global co sled and @xmath20co lines available , dominated by lower - density gas .
unfortunately neither high - j co nor hcn line observations exist for this ulirg to set independent constraints on the mass and physical properties of its dense sf molecular gas .
a 2-phase model with an assumed ( h)-phase co sled ( section 2.4 ) , while not necessary in this case ( as a wide range of good one - phase fits exist ) , can be used to assess the impact of a massive dense gas phase on @xmath4 . apart from n@xmath18610@xmath35@xmath15
the ( l)-phase remains essentially unconstrained ( as expected ) , with @xmath619@xmath8(0.5 - 1.12)@xmath96 .
for the computed @xmath203=0.85 this yields @xmath159=(1.4 - 1.7)@xmath96 .
this galaxy has a sf - powered @[email protected]@xmath179@xmath621@xmath622 typical for sf spiral disks ( e.g. ngc7469 ) and is one of the lowest ir luminosity galaxies in the iras _
bgs_. nicmos near - ir imaging with the _ hst _ indeed show a highly inclined disk - dominated system with a heavily dust - enshrouded nucleus ( scoville et al .
2000 ) . despite its disk - like appearance
its near - ir emission is better fitted by a @xmath623 rather than an exponential disk profile ( scoville et al . 2000 ) , while its @xmath624 ratio is almost as extreme as the much more ir - luminous arp220 ( planesas et al .
early interferometric images of co j=10 found large molecular gas mass within a 1.3kpc - sized region ( planesas et al .
1991 , for the cosmology adopted here ) .
its co sled remains well excited up to j=43 and also has substantial j=65 emission ( see paperi ) while both its @xmath20co j=10 , 21 lines are detected and yield @xmath414@xmath5316 and @xmath416@xmath3824 , typical of merger - driven starbursts rather than disk - dominated lirgs .
one - phase lvg models reproduce all co , @xmath20co line ratios up to co j=43 though they still underpredict the luminosity of the latter by @xmath381.2@xmath366 . unfortunately , even with this large set of lines significant degeneracies remain .
indicatively the two best solutions : @xmath625$]=@xmath626 $ ] , @xmath627 $ ] yield co line ratios : @xmath628_{lvg}$]=[1.05 , 0.75 , 0.41 , 0.05 , 22 , 21 ] , [ 1.05 , 0.76 , 0.40 , 0.02 , 21 , 16 ] .
much warmer gas with @xmath629$]=@xmath630 $ ] is also possible and yields : @xmath631_{lvg}$]=[1.06 , 0.86 , 0.60 , 0.17 , 14 , 13 ] , now in better agreement with the observed @xmath467 ( even if not used in the fit ) but a rather worse fit of @xmath370 .
nevertheless the corresponding @xmath4 values span a rather narrow range @xmath8(0.35 - 0.6)@xmath96 , yielding @xmath434@xmath21(3 - 5.2)@xmath179@xmath632m@xmath23 .
this is comparable to the minimum molecular gas mass required for eddington - limited star formation of @[email protected]@xmath5810@xmath419m@xmath23 , yet all the densities deduced from the lvg solutions of the global co sled are far from being representative of what is typically a much denser sf phase with small / modest @xmath78 values . a two - phase decomposition of the average ism state using the co j=32 , 43 , 65 and the @xmath20co transitions to determine the ( h)-state converges to @xmath633$]=@xmath634110 - 140,10@xmath35,4@xmath635 $ ] , with @xmath190=140k corresponding to the best solution ( and @xmath142=0.6@xmath85 ) .
higher density solutions with n=@xmath185@xmath15 exist over @xmath60=(40 - 65)k but represent poorer fits and correspond to unbound states with @xmath78@xmath3813 .
this is a general aspect of all ( h)-phase lvg solutions ( e.g. even if only the co j=43 , 6 - 5 and @xmath20co lines are used ) , namely the best fits occur at higher temperatures , lower densities , and more gravitationaly bound states .
high density solutions ( @xmath3810@xmath48@xmath15 ) and thus more typical for the presumably star forming ( h)-phase are found at lower temperatures ( @xmath21(35 - 70)k ) , and strongly unbound states ( @xmath84@xmath2113 - 40 ) , but yield poorer fits .
moreover the high @xmath84 of the denser / cooler lvg solutions yield similarly low @xmath167 ( e.g. for @xmath60=50k , n=@xmath185@xmath15 and @xmath78@xmath2113 it is @xmath142=0.7@xmath96 ) .
it is the combination of weak @xmath20co j=10 , 21 and well - excited high - j co lines that nevertheless still have @xmath636@xmath1711 which forces lvg solutions to a parameter space with low co line optical depths and modest gas densities .
this is why @xmath78 is high towards the low-@xmath60/high - n domain ( as to keep co line optical depths low ) , and why the need for high @xmath101 s is relaxed towards higher @xmath225 which now becomes partly responsible for the low optical depths .
average gas densities towards the high @xmath60 regime can not be high as this would yield @xmath637@xmath321 in the optically thin domain .
if we omit the co j=65 line from the fit ( as its luminosity can be highly uncertain ) and also leave out the @xmath20co j=10 line ( which may have a larger contribution from a cooler disk phase ) we obtain lvg solutions with densities of @xmath21(1 - 3)@xmath5810@xmath48@xmath15 that are more typical of sf gas , yet with high enough @xmath78@xmath2113 - 22 that still yield a low corresponding @xmath638@xmath8(0.65 - 0.75)@xmath96 .
moreover , with an essentially unconstrained ( l)-phase , and no evidence for a cold disk , a 2-phase gas would yield @xmath159 similar to that obtained from 1-phase model . thus the molecular gas reservoir in this lirg
is expected to be dominated by its sf component , yet neither the average densities nor the strongly unbound dynamical states deduced from its available global co sled are typical of the latter . if this is confirmed by future hcn or other heavy rotor molecular line observations ( or more high - j co and @xmath20co transitions ) it may come to resemble the average ism state deduced for arp193 .
these are the two ( u)lirgs in our sample that currently have the best molecular line data tracing their dense gas ( i.e. multi - j hcn , cs , hco@xmath192 lines ) , which are used in a detailed study of its physical conditions ( greve et al .
the presence of a massive dense gas phase in both of them is well - established with large hcn / co j=10 line ratios ( @xmath530.19(arp220 ) , @xmath530.08(ngc6240 ) ) , well - excited hcn and cs higher - j lines , yet also the large co/@xmath20co line ratios typical for merger - driven extreme starbursts ( @xmath3843 - 45 for j=10 ) .
the latter implies very low co line optical depths , and thus runs counter what is expected for dominant high - density molecular gas reservoir ( @xmath639(co)@xmath6401 ) , necessitating the 2-phase models used in such systems ( aalto et al .
1995 ; papadopoulos & seaquist 1998 ; this work ) .
predictably one - phase models of the co and @xmath20co lines ( see paperi ) fail to converge on any good set of solutions for both galaxies , yielding @xmath641$]=@xmath642 $ ] ( arp220 ) and @xmath354$]=@xmath643 $ ] ( ngc6240 ) . for arp220 even the co j=10 , 21
, 32 lines are impossible to fit with one phase since @[email protected] ( see paperi ) indicates a diffuse gas phase that leaves even the j=21 line subthermally excited , while @[email protected] marks the emergence of another , denser and warmer phase from j=32 and higher .
the corresponding one - phase @[email protected]@xmath54 for both systems , a low value due to the very large @xmath78 values `` forced '' by the extreme large co/@xmath20co line ratios obtained for these systems .
this is comparable to @xmath93(lte ) ( for the @xmath60=(30 - 40)k range of one - phase lvg solutions ) , as expected for optically thin co line emission .
this low @xmath4 factor yields @[email protected]@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23(arp220 ) and @xmath6442.5@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23(ngc6240 ) , while the minimum molecular gas mass needed for fueling eddington - limited sf in these extreme merger / starbursts is @xmath645@xmath5104@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23(arp220 ) and @xmath6441.5@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23(ngc6240 ) .
given that @[email protected] , and in the case of arp220 actually @xmath321 , it becomes obvious , even in the absence of heavy rotor molecular line observations that the true @xmath4 factor for these two galaxies must be higher . from the analysis
detailed in 3.2.1 the multi - j hcn lvg solutions in a 2-phase lvg model yield : @xmath159@xmath21(2.4 - 4.5)@xmath85(arp220 ) and @xmath538@xmath53(1 - 3.3)@xmath85(ngc6240 ) with the high values corresponding to virial dynamical states for the dense gas .
the new @xmath456 estimates are : @xmath8(1.5 - 2.8)@xmath431@xmath493m@xmath23(arp220 ) and @xmath8(0.8 - 2.8)@xmath58@xmath493m@xmath23(ngc6240 ) . in the case of
arp220 these amount to @xmath2140%-77% of the dynamical mass of its molecular gas disks ( @xmath218 from ds98 ) , while for ngc6240 it surpasses the total mass contained within its central radius of r@xmath5571@xmath422 ( 480pc ) and argues for significant molecular gas mass corresponding to the co line emission seen beyond its central co j=21 peak ( see tacconi et al .
1999 for co j=21 for a high resolution interferometry map ) . in the latter case
the deduced molecular gas mass may actually dominate the mass distribution out to much larger radii than deduced by tacconi et al .
multi - j hcn line interferometric maps , along with at least one h@xmath20cn transition , at resolutions of @xmath1861@xmath422 , will be valuable in determining the @xmath197 , the effective @xmath142 , and @xmath159 of these template merger systems .
this classic ulirg is the most luminous in our sample , it has a compact gas - rich nucleus ( planesas et al . 1991 ; ds98 ) , a very disrupted disk , and tidal tails indicating a merger ( murphy et al .
1996 ; scoville et al . 2000 ) . in the interferometric study by ds98
this is the ulirg whose compact gas disk ( @xmath211.4kpc ) has the largest face - on velocity dispersion of @xmath646@xmath8150kms@xmath11 , indicating a highly turbulent gas environment .
this is also suggested by the large @xmath146@xmath6435 ratio , expected in the high - pressure , highly turbulent ism environments of strong mergers ( aalto et al .
its co sled is highly excited up to co j=43 while the weak co j=65 reported in paperi is most likely due to pointing offsets as zeus measurements at the cso indicate a much stronger line ( stacey 2011 ) .
no reasonable one - phase lvg fits were found for this source while attempts to fit the co j=10 up to j=43 and @xmath146=35 yield highly unbound states ( @xmath78@xmath2113 - 70 ) .
the best such fit : @xmath647$]=@xmath63470,10@xmath35,13@xmath635 $ ] , yields @xmath369=0.96 , @xmath368=0.64 , @xmath363=0.32 , the latter being @xmath213@xmath188 smaller than observed .
the large @xmath357 of this system corresponds to @xmath430(h@xmath29)@xmath386@xmath17910@xmath398m@xmath23 . on the other hand @[email protected]@xmath85 computed from the best lvg solution yields @[email protected]@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 , and
thus even the minimum mass expected for a dense and warm sf - fueling phase will dominate @xmath456 , as computed by a one - phase @xmath19 factor .
one - phase lvg solutions with their low densities , highly unbound dynamical states certainly do not hint this , while their poor fit of the global co line ratios of this ulirg suggest that at least two main gas phases are necessary to represent the average ism state in this system .
the presence of a massive gas phase much denser than those implied by one - phase lvg fits is further corroborated by an @xmath648=0.14 ( hcn j=10 from gracia - carpio et al .
2008 , co 1 - 0 from paperi ) and an hcn(32)/(10 ) ratio of @xmath361(hcn)=0.39 ( gracia - carpio et al .
2008 ) . using only co
j=43 , 32 , and @xmath146=35 ( the lower limit ) to constrain the ( h)-phase in a 2-phase model yields only warm @xmath596=(90 - 150)k and dense n@xmath501(3@xmath14910@xmath48 - 10@xmath26)@xmath15 gas phases with @xmath597@xmath2113 - 22 , and @[email protected] - 1.40 ( high values for the denser gas solutions ) .
these solutions yield @[email protected] - 3 for j+1=2,3,4 indicating co lines with small / moderate optical depths , a result of the high temperatures and large @xmath78 values which , along with the high densities , are necessary for well - excited co lines up to high - j levels _ and _ a high global @xmath146 ratio . the mass of such high - excitation gas can be computed from @xmath616=@xmath650@xmath651=(4 - 4.4)@xmath49510@xmath398@xmath652 which yields @xmath653(h@xmath29)@xmath501(3.4 - 6)@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
thus , as in some other ( u)lirgs studied here ( e.g. iras00057 + 4021 ) , this galaxy contains large reservoirs of dense gas in thermal and dynamical states much more extreme than those expected for dense gas in sf regions . as detailed in paperi these could be indicative of other power sources such as turbulent heated regions ( thrs ) or cr - dominated regions ( e.g. papadopoulos 2010 ) .
future high resolution high - j co , @xmath20co imaging of this system with alma would be very valuable for confirming and quantifying such mechanisms via determining the level of turbulence present in its disk ( i.e. measuring @xmath654(*r * ) and the average cr energy density permeating its ism . despite the prominence of the dense highly - excited phase in the j=32 , 43 lines , the ( l)-phase remains the main contributor of co j=10 line luminosity in iras17208 - 0014 , with @xmath655@xmath21(8.7 - 9)@xmath5810@xmath398@xmath504 ( @xmath38(66 - 68)% of the observed one ) .
lvg fits of the corresponding `` residual '' ratio @[email protected] , while @xmath60-degenerate ( as expected ) , all indicate low gas densities n@xmath38(1 - 3)@xmath17910@xmath12@xmath15 and a wide range of @xmath78@xmath211 - 70 .
the coresponding @xmath158@xmath38(0.5 - 3)@xmath96 ( over the @xmath101=1 - 20 range of lvg solutions ) remains essentially unconstrained , with the lowest values corresponding to the most dynamically unbound states as expected .
thus for @xmath657=1.4@xmath54 ( densest gas lvg solutions ) we find @xmath658@xmath21(0.752.5)@xmath96 . using the states compatible with the hcn(32)/(10 ) ratio in iras172080014 to define the ( h)-phase leads to even higher @xmath658@xmath38(2.5 - 5.9)@xmath96 , with larger still @xmath448 ( see table 1 ) .
these correspond to a high - density ( @xmath8(3@xmath5810@xmath48 - 10@xmath26)@xmath15 ) phase with @xmath78@xmath81 - 6 ( unphysical solutions with @xmath81@xmath1711 were not considered ) .
nevertheless , for @xmath60=(75 - 105)k , lvg solutions with high - density gas ( @xmath2110@xmath26@xmath15 ) but @xmath78=20 are also possible .
these strongly unbound dense gas solutions yield @[email protected]@xmath54 and similarly low @xmath659 values ( unless cold ( l)-phase solutions corresponding to a sf - quiescent disk are considered )
. observations of more hcn lines and , crucially , of at least one h@xmath20cn line can determine whether such extraordinary dynamical states are possible for the hcn - bright dense gas phase ( see 3.4 ) . this is a ulirg with a spectacular morphology involving two nuclei separated by 1.6@xmath422 ( @xmath212.3kpc ) ( carico et al .
1990 ) , two tidal tails and numerous sf knots embedded in them ( scoville at el .
2000 ) indicating an advanced merger .
it is also one of the very few ulirgs where an agn contributes more than half of the total ir luminosity ( farrah et al .
2003 ) . in our sample
it stands out as the galaxy with the most highly excited co j=32 line with @xmath361=1.88 , though a large applied correction makes this value somewhat uncertain ( see paperi ) .
all one - phase lvg solutions correspond to dense gas @xmath660=(10@xmath48 - 3@xmath14910@xmath26)@xmath15 , with the best fits obtained for @xmath60@xmath2440k .
unfortunately lack of more co line ratios and especially at least one @xmath20co line measurement permits a wide range of @xmath641 $ ] states up to @xmath40=150k and @xmath101@xmath3321 - 20 to fit the observed ratios .
the one - phase @xmath19 values remain essentially unconstrained with @xmath4@xmath21(0.7 - 2.4)@xmath96 and the low values associated with strongly unbound states ( @xmath78@xmath813 - 22 ) , while the low values with states that have @xmath78@xmath81 - 7 .
the corresponding molecular gas mass is @xmath456@xmath8(6.3 - 22)@xmath39710@xmath398m@xmath23 while @[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
another extraordinary aspect of iras224911808 is that many of the conditions compatible with its global co line ratios indicate dense gas ( @xmath213@xmath18810@xmath26)@xmath15 ) with temperatures @xmath40=(100 - 130)k , significantly larger than those of the dust ( @xmath61=(32 - 49)k for emissivity of @xmath661=1.5 , 2 ) .
such potentially strong decoupling of gas and dust temperatures , especially at high gas densities where @xmath60@xmath314@xmath61 is expected , are another indicator of other dominant power sources than pdr photons .
turbulent and cr heating are capable of driving large @xmath437@xmath321 inequalities even for the very dense gas mass reservoirs found in ulirgs ( paperi , papadopoulos 2010 ) .
these mechanisms can easily dominate when strong gas - rich / gas - rich spiral galaxy interactions drive the bulk of the molecular gas into compact regions in the two nuclei of the progenitors .
this will inject large amounts of gas kinetic energy into @xmath332100pc - sized regions fueling extreme turulence , while high sfr densities will establish extreme crdrs .
interestingly two other double - nuclei systems , iras12112 + 305 and iras08572 + 3915 , also show very highly excited ( i.e. @xmath336@xmath321 ) co lines .
the iras22491 - 1808 and similar systems are thus excellent cases for studying extreme ism conditions and their drivers using alma .
such observations will be crucial for : a ) inferring cr energy densities ( by finding starburst region sizes ) , b ) measuring velocity dispersions and the turbulence levels of molecular gas disks and c ) directly providing key molecular line diagnostics for the presense of cr - dominated regions ( crdrs ) and/or turbulent - heated regions ( thrs ) ( papadopoulos 2010 ; bayet et al .
2011 , meijerink et al .
2011 ) .
this is a well - studied sy1 spiral galaxy whose agn is surrounded by a nearly complete ring of powerful starburst activity contributing @xmath212/3 of its @xmath27 ( genzel et al .
1995 ; riffel et al .
2006 and references therein ) .
interferometric co j=10 imaging found its central starburst to be very gas - rich ( meixner et al .
1990 ; tacconi & genzel 1996 ) .
its starburst is thought triggered by an interaction with a neighboring galaxy ic5283 that lies 83@xmath422 ( @xmath827kpc ) away ( projected distance ) .
a @xmath4@xmath21(1/5)@xmath662 was inferred for its inner @xmath381kpc , and attributed to the effects of strong sf feedback on molecular clouds ( genzel et al .
1995 ) . a small @xmath4 for the starburst region of the disk in ngc7469 is indeed corroborated by co j=32 , 10 observations and 850@xmath306m/450@xmath508 m dust continuum imaging ( papadopoulos & allen 2000 ) .
however the same observations also revealed faint co j=10 and 450@xmath306 m dust emission extending well beyond the staburst region , and containing a massive sf - quiescent , cold dust and gas reservoir with a galactic @xmath4 .
these two ism components make a good one - phase lvg fit impossible for the `` cold '' @xmath265=0.75 and the `` warm '' @xmath363=0.83 , @xmath467=0.22 ratios observed .
the best such solution with @xmath663=70k , @xmath37=@xmath367@xmath15 , @xmath101=4 yields : @xmath664=0.97 , @xmath665=0.75 , @xmath666=0.48 , @xmath550=0.08 , and @xmath667=11 . the first two are higher than those observed ( @xmath3322@xmath366 higher in the case of @xmath265 ) , while for ( 43)/(10 ) and ( 65)/(10 ) the lvg - computed ratios are @xmath471.7 and @xmath382.75 times smaller than observed .
the @xmath50=0.72@xmath96 value computed from the optimal one - phase lvg fit to the global co sled is dominated by the sf phase , and corresponds to @[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
the minimum sf gas mass expected on the other hand is @xmath586=6.5@xmath18810@xmath419m@xmath23 . using only the co j=32 , 43 , 65 and the @xmath20co j=21 lines to constrain the high - excitation ( h)-phase in a 2-phase models yields a typical lvg solution for @xmath663=60k , @xmath37=@xmath185@xmath15 , and @xmath78=13 with a corresponding @xmath157=0.66@xmath96 . from this solution
we compute @xmath668=2.51@xmath66910@xmath398@xmath388 , and @xmath670=0.97@xmath66910@xmath398@xmath504 which yield @[email protected] . then using the galactic @xmath158=5@xmath96 deduced for the extended co j=10 and submm continuum dust emission of the disk in ngc7469 ( papadopoulos & allen 2000 )
, we obtain @[email protected]@xmath96 , which is @xmath212.6@xmath149 higher than that obtained by the one - phase lvg fit of the global sled .
thus the cold extended disk of ngc7469 , despite containing @xmath5013@xmath188 more molecular gas mass than its central starburst , is nearly incospicious in the global co sled , resulting to a significant underestimate of the total molecular gas mass in this galaxy .
only the available spatial information about its presence could rectify this , a state of affairs mirrored in other such systems ( e.g. ngc1068 ) . for disk - dominated lirgs with strong excitation gradients induced by the presense of central starbursts
only co , @xmath20co line and dust continuum imaging of their ism can avoid such pitfals ( see 3.4 ) .
this is quite unlike ulirgs where it is the low - excitation `` cloud - envelope''-phase that contains the smaller mass fraction and is concomitant or closely follows the distribution of a massive much denser gas component .
near - ir imaging of this lirg reveals tidal tails indicating a merger , and a single nucleus embedded into a nearly face - on disk that is nearly @xmath2120kpc ( 17.3@xmath422 ) in diameter , and shows disturbed spiral structure ( surace et al .
the nucleus is classified as a liner ( veilleux et al .
the gas dynamics as revealed by co j=10 interferometry ( ds98 ) is strongly decoupled from stellar dynamics ( genzel et al .
2001 ) , another hallmark of strong mergers .
its molecular gas disk is compact with @xmath381.2kpc diameter , and a face - on velocity dispersion of @xmath21100kms@xmath11 ( ds98 ) .
its co sled has a `` cool '' co(21)/(10 ) ratio ( = 0.75 ) but a well - excited co j=32 line with a `` warm '' co(3 - 2)/(1 - 0 ) ( = 0.82 ) , while its large @xmath146(=17 ) is typical for mergers .
one - phase lvg models yield moderately good but rather degenerate fits with @xmath671$]=[30 - 65 , 10@xmath35 , 13 ] and [ 70 - 150,3@xmath18810@xmath12 , 2.2 ] being the optimal solution ranges .
the best solutions are obtained for @xmath190=50k , 70k with corresponding line ratios : @xmath672=0.88 , 0.84 , @xmath673=0.56,0.55 , @xmath674=0.24 , 0.27 and @xmath552=20 , 16 .
these are compatible with the measured values though the models typically yield `` warmer '' @xmath145 and `` cooler '' @xmath361 ratios than observed , in the latter case by @xmath211.1@xmath366 .
the corresponding @xmath4@xmath21(1 - 1.3)@xmath54 , which gives @xmath434@xmath8(7.3 - 9.5)@xmath18810@xmath22@xmath399 , while @[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath398@xmath139 .
the latter represents a substantial fraction of the total molecular gas mass where much higher gas densities must be prevailing . a clear indication of another highly - excited denser gas phase is provided by co j=65 line which is @xmath219 - 16 times more luminous than expected from the best lvg solutions .
the presence of a dense gas phase able to emit such high - j co lines is also indicated by a high hcn / co j=10 line ratio of @[email protected] ( hcn from gracio - carpio et al .
2008 , co from paperi ) . using the co j=32 , j=43 ( upper limit ) , j=65 and @xmath20co j=21 lines to constrain the high - excitation phase yields : @xmath676$]=[40 - 80 , 10@xmath48 , 40 ] as the optimum solution range , with @xmath60=60k being the best .
the corresponding co sled has @xmath677=1.94 , @xmath678=1.90 , @xmath679=1.50 , and @xmath680=0.45 , typical of low / modest optical depths ( indicatively @[email protected] , @[email protected] ) , a result of the exceptionally large @xmath78 .
a less optimal solution range with lower densities and more modest ( but still high ) @xmath101 values does exists @xmath683$]=[90 - 150 , 3@xmath14910@xmath35 , 22 ] , but could not reproduce the high hcn(1 - 0)/co(6 - 5 ) ratio of @[email protected]@xmath4260.18 observed for this galaxy as such a low - density phase would hardly emit any hcn j=10 ( @[email protected] ) .
the mass of the dense , warm , and strongly unbound phase can be found from @[email protected]@xmath220 ( for @xmath40=60k ) , and @xmath685=@xmath686@[email protected]@xmath5810@xmath398@xmath504 , which yields @[email protected]@xmath5810@xmath398m@xmath23 .
this large gas mass with such high @xmath78 _ and _ high densities is rather surprising since such strongly unbound states are associated with cloud - envelopes or intercloud diffuse molecular gas whose @xmath688@xmath18610@xmath73@xmath15 .
the remaining co j=10 luminosity of the ( l)-phase on the other hand is @[email protected]@xmath18810@xmath22@xmath574 with an essentially unconstrained @xmath690 . setting @xmath691=(0.5 - 5)@xmath96 to encompass the range from a warm , diffuse and unbound gas component to an underlying cold , self - gravitating
, disk phase yields @xmath202@xmath21(0.5 - 3)@xmath96 and @xmath434@xmath21(3.7 - 22)@xmath18810@xmath398@xmath139 .
the low @xmath692 ( and thus @xmath434 ) values are more probable because of the negligible co j=21 luminosity of the ( l)-phase ( a cold , self - gravitating , phase would have higher j=21 luminosities ) . using the snr - gmc interfaces as benchmark entities for dense yet highly unbound ( due to the kinetic energy injected by snr shocks ) molecular gas phase
makes clear that a mass fraction of @[email protected] - 0.38 exceeds that expected per gmc for a snr - impacted gas phase ( @xmath381% of a gmc s mass ) .
it is worth noting that only in the powerful radio galaxy 3c293 galaxy - sized molecular gas reservoirs at high densities were inferred to be at such strongly gravitationally unbound states , likely caused by the powerful jet - ism interaction .
while no such agn influence on the ism is apparent in iras23365 + 3604 it is interesting to note that it is one of the 3 ulirgs ( the others being arp220 and mrk273 ) where molecular gas velocity fields decoupled from those of stars and ionized gas are found , with molecular gas having @xmath3322 times larger linewidths ( colina et al . 2005 ) .
high - j co , @xmath20co and hcn and h@xmath20cn line observations are necessary for confirming such extraordinary dynamical states for the massive dense gas reservoir residing in iras23365 + 3604 and similar systems . aalto s. , booth r. s. , black j. m. , & johansson l. e. b. 1995 a&a , 300 , 369 aalto s. , radford s. j. e. , scoville n. z. , & sargent a. i. 1997 , apj , 475 , l107 allen r. j. , & lequeux j. 1993 , apj , 410 , l15 allen r. j. , le bourlot j. , lequeux j. , pineau des forts g. , roueff e. 1995 , apj , 444 , 157 andrews b. h. , & thompson t. a. 2011 , apj , 727 , 97 arikawa y. , tatematsu k. , sekimoto y. , & takahashi t. 1999 , pasj , 51 , l7 armus l. , heckman t. m. , & miley g. k. 1989 , apj , 347 , 727 barvainis r. , alloin d. , & antonucci r. 1989 , apj , 337 , l69 balick b. , & heckman t. m. 1981 , a&a , 96 , 271 bayet e. , williams d. a. , hartquist t. w. , viti s. 2011 , mnras , 414 , 1583 bolatto a. d. leroy a. , israel f. p. & jackson j. m. 2003 , apj , 595 , 167 braine j. , & combes f. 1992 , a&a , 264 , 433 bryant p. m. , & scoville n. z. 1996 , apj , 457 , 678 bryant p. m. , & scoville n. z. 1999 , aj , 117 , 2632 carico d. p. , sanders d. b. , soifer b. t. , matthews k. , & neugebauer g. 1990 , aj , 100 , 70 colina l. , arribas s. , & monreal - ibero a. 2005 , apj , 621 , 725 condon j. j. , helou g. , sanders d. b. , & soifer b. t. 1990 , apjs , 73 , 359 conselice c. j. , gallagher john s. , calzetti d. , homeier n. , & kinney a. 2000 , aj , 119 , 79 clements m. s. , & alexander p. 2004
, mnras , 350 , 66 charmandaris v. , stacey g. j. , & gull g. 2002 , apj , 571 , 282 daddi e. , elbaz d. , walter f. , et al . 2010a , apj , 714 , l118 daddi e. , bournaud f. , walter f. , et al . 2010b , apj , 713 , 686 dadina m. 2007 , a&a , 461 , 1209 dannerbauer h. , daddi e. , riechers , d. et al .
2009 , 698 , l178 devereux n. , taniguchi y. , sanders d. b. , nakai n. , & young j. s. 1994 , aj , 107 , 2006 dickman r. l. , snell , r. l. , schloerb , f. p. 1986
, apj , 309 , 326 downes d. , solomon , p. m. & radford , s. j. e. 1993 , apj , 414 , l13 downes d. , solomon , p. m. 1998 , apj , 507 , 615 dumke m. , nieten ch .
, thuma g. , wielebinksi r. , & walsh w. 2001 , a&a , 373 , 853 dunne l. , eales s. , edmunds m. , ivison r. , alexander p. , & clements d. l. 2000 , mnras , 315 , 115 eckart a. , van der werf p. , hofmann r. , & harris i. 1994 , apj , 424 , 627 evans a. s. , sanders d. b. , surace j. a. , & mazzarella j. m. 1999 , apj , 511 , 730 evans a. s. surace j. a. , & mazzarella j. m. 2000 , apj , 529 , l85 evans a. s. , mazzarella j. m. , surace j. a. , & sanders d. b. 2002 , apj , 580 , 749 farrah d. , afonso j. , efstathiou a. , rowan - robinson m. , fox m. , & clements d. 2003 , mnras , 343 , 585 fanaroff b. l. , & riley j. m. 1974 , mnras , 167 , 31 floyd d. j. e. , perlman e. , leahy j. p. et al .
2006 , apj , 639 , 23 gao y. , & solomon p. m. 2004 , apj , 606 , 271 genzel r. , weitzel l. , tacconi - garman l. e. blietz m. , cameron m. , krabbe a. 1995 , apj , 444 , 129 genzel r. , tacconi l. j. , rigopoulou d. , lutz d. , & tecza m. 2001 , apj , 563 , 527 genzel r. , tacconi l. j. , gracia - carpio j. , et al .
2010 , mnras , 407 , 2091 goldader j. d. , joseph r. d. , doyon r. , & sanders d. b. 1997 , apjs , 108 , 449 gonzlez delgado r. m. , heckman t. , leitherer c. et al .
1998 , apj , 505 , 174 gsten r. , philipp s. d. 2004 , in _ the dense interstellar medium in galaxies _ proceedings of the 4th cologne - bonn - zermatt symposium , zermatt , switzerland , s.pfalzner , c. kramer , c. staubmeier , and a. heithausen ( eds ) springer proceedings in physics , vol . 91 .
gsten r. , serabyn e. , kasemann c. , et al .
1996 , apj , 402 , 537 greve t. r. , bertoldi f. , smail i. , et al .
2005 , mnras , 359 , 1165 greve t. r. , papadopoulos p. p. , gao y. , & radford s. j. e. 2009 , apj , 692 , 1432 graci - carpio j. , garci - burillo s. , planesas p. , fuente a. , & usero a. 2008 , a&a , 479 , 703 garci - burillo , s. , usero a. , alonso - herrero a. et al .
2012 , a&a , 539 , 8 henkel c. & mauersberger r. 1993 , a&a , 274 , 730 hattori t. , yoshida m. , ohtani h. et al .
2004 , aj , 127 , 736 horellou c. , casoli f. , combes f. , & durpaz c. 1995 , a&a , 298 , 743 hibbard j. e. , & yun m. s. 1999 , aj , 118 , 162 iono d. , ho p. t. , yun m. s. , matsushita s. , peck b. a. , & sakamoto k. 2004 , apj , 616 , l63 imanishi m. , dudley c. c. , & maloney p. r. 2001 , apj , 558 , l93 imanishi m. , terashima y. , anabuki n. , & nakagawa t. 2003 , apj , 596 , l167 iono d. , wilson c. d. , takakuwa s. et al .
2007 , apj , 659 , 283 iono d. , wilson c. d. , yun m. s. et al .
2009 , apj , 695 , 1537 israel f. p. , 1988
, in _ millimetre and submillimetre astronomy _ , r. d. wolstencroft and w. b. burton eds .
kluwer academic publishers , p. 281
israel f. p. , et al .
, 1993 , a&a , 276 , 25 israel f. p. , 1997 ,
a&a , 328 , 471 israel f. p. , 1999 , in _
h@xmath29 in space _ , f. combes , g. pineau des forts eds .
cambridge university press , astrophysics series jackson j. m. , paglione t. a. d. , carlstrom j. e. , & rieu n .- q 1995 , apj , 438 , 695 juneau s. , narayanan d. t. , moustakas j. 2009 , apj , 707 , 1217 kikumoto t. , taniguchi y. , suzuki m. , tomisaka k. 1993 , aj , 106 , 466 kregel m. , & sancisi r. 2001 , a&a , 376 , 59 krips m. , neri r. , garcia - burillo s. , martn s. , combes f. , graci - carpio j. , & eckart a. 2008 , apj , 677 , 272 krips m. , martn s. , eckart a. et al .
2011 , apj , 736 , 37 kollatschny w. , dietrich m. , borgeest u. , & schramm k .- j .
1991 , a&a , 249 , 57 kutner m. l. , & ulich b. l. 1981 , apj , 250 , 341 leech j. , isaak k. , papadopoulos p. p. , gao y. , & davies g. r. 2010 , mnras , 406 , 1364 loenen e. 2009 , phd thesis , university of groningen , pg .
115 loinard l. , allen r. j. , & lequeux j. 1995 , a&a , 301 , l68 krips m. , neri r. , graci - burillo s. , martin s. , combes f. , graci - carpio j. , & eckart a. 2008 , apj , 677 , 262 mao r. q. , henkel c. , schulz a. , et al . 2000 , a&a , 358 , 433 mao r. q. , schulz a. , henkel c. , mauersberger r. , muders d. , & dinh - v - trung 2011 , apj , 724 , 1336 maloney p.
m. , & black j. h. , 1988 , apj , 325 , 389 majewski s. r. , hereld m. , koo d. c. , illingworth g. d. , & heckman t. m. 1993 , apj , 402 , 125 martini p. , regan m. w. , mulchaey j. s. , & pogge r. w. 2003 , apjs , 146 , 353 maiolino r. , ruiz m. , rieke g. h. , & papadopoulos p. 1997 ,
apj , 485 , 552 matsushita s. , sakamoto k. , kuo c .- y . , et al .
2004 , apj , 616 , l55 matsushita s. , iono d. , petitpas g. et al .
2009 , apj , 693 , 56 mauersberger r. , henkel c. , walsh w. , & schulz a. 1999 , a&a , 341 , 256 mazzarella j. m. , graham j. r. sanders d. b. , & djorgovski s. 1993 , apj , 409 , 170 meier d. s. , turner j. l. , & crosthwaite l. p. & beck s. c. 2001 , aj , 121 , 740 meijerink r. , spaans m. , loenen a. f. , van der werf p. p. 2011
, a&a , 525 , 119 meixner m. , puchalsky r. , blitz l. , wright m. , & heckman t. 1990 , apj , 354 , 158 murphy t. w. jr . , armus l. , matthews k. , soifer b. t. , mazzarella j. m. , shupe d. l. 1996 , aj , 111 , 1025 narayanan d. , krumholz m. , ostriker e. c. , & hernquist l. 2010 , mnras , 418 , 664 nieten ch . , dumke m. , beck r. , & wielebinski r. 1999 , a&a , 347 , l5 ossenkopf v. 2002 , a&a , 391 , 295 padoan p. , & nordlund a. 2002 , apj , 576 , 870 papadopoulos p. p. & seaquist e. r. 1998 , apj , 492 , 521 papadopoulos p. p. & seaquist e. r. 1999 , apj , 516 , 114 papadopoulos p. p. & allen m. l. 2000 , apj , 537 , 631 papadopoulos p. p. 2007 ,
apj , 656 , 792 papadopoulos p. p. , isaak k. g. , & van der werf p.
p. 2007 , apj , 668 , 815 papadopoulos p. p. , kovacs a. , evans a. s. , & barthel p. 2008 , a&a , 491 , 483 papadopoulos p. p. , isaak k. g. , & van der werf p.
, apj , 711 , 757 papadopoulos p. p. , van der werf p. p. , isaak k. g. , & xilouris e. m. 2010b , apj , 715 , 775 papadopoulos p. p. , van der werf p. p. , xilouris e. m , isaak k. g. , gao y. & muehle s. 2011 , mnras , ( submitted , arxiv:1109.4176 ) parma p. , de ruiter h. r. , fanti c. , & fanti r. 1986 , a&as , 64 , 135 paglione t. a. d. , jackson j. m. , & ishizuki s. 1997 , apj , 484 , 656 petitpas g. r. , & wilson c. d. 1998 , apj 503 , 219 planesas p. , mirabel i. f. , & sanders d. b. 1991 , apj , 370 , 172 rangwala e. , maloney p. r. , glenn j. et al .
2011 , apj , 743 , 94 regan m. w. 2000 , apj , 541 , 142 riffel r. , rodrguez - ardila a. , & pastoriza m. g. 2006 , a&a , 457 , 61 sakamoto s. , 1996 , apj , 462 , 215 sakamoto s. , hayashi m. , hasegawa t. , handa t. , & oka t. 1994 , apj , 425 , 641 sakamoto s. phd thesis , 1994 , university of tokyo , pasp 106 , 1112 sakamoto k. , wang j. , wiedner m. , et al .
2008 , apj , 684 , 957 sanders d. b. , scoville n. z. , young j. s. , soifer b. t. , schloerb f. p. , rice w. l. , & danielson g. e. 1986 , apj , 305 , l45 sanders d. b. , scoville n. z. , sargent a. i. , & soifer b. t. 1988a , apj , 324 , l55 sanders d. b. , soifer b. t. , elias j. h. et al . 1988b , apj , 325 , 74 sanders d. b. , soifer b. t. , elias j. h. , neugebauer g. , & matthews k. 1988c , apj , 328 , l35 sanders d. b. , scoville n. z. , & soifer b. t. 1991 , apj , 370 , 15 8 sanders d. b. , & mirabel i. f. 1996 , ara&a , 34 , 749 sanders d. b. mazzarella j. m. , kim d .- c . , surace j. a. , & soifer b. t. 2003 , aj , 126 , 1607 sanders d. b. , & ishida c. m. 2004 , in the neutral ism in starburst galaxies , eds .
s. aalto , s. httemeister , & a. pedlar , asp conference series 320 , p. 230
sargent a. i. , sanders d. b. , scoville n. z. , & soifer b. t. 1987 , 312 , l35 sargent a. i. & scoville n. z. 1991 , apj , 366 , l1 schinnerer e. , eckart a. , & tacconi l. j. 1998 , 500 , 147 scoville n. z. , sanders d. b. , sargent a. i. , soifer b. t. , & tinney c. g. 1989 , apj , 345 , l25 scoville n. z. 2004 , evans a. s. , thompson r. , rieke m. , hines d. c. , f. j. , dinshaw n. , surace j. a. , & armus l. 2000 , aj , 119 , 991 scoville n. z. 2004 , in the neutral ism in starburst galaxies , eds .
s. aalto , s. httemeister , & a. pedlar , asp conference series 320 , p. 253 schleicher d. r. g. , spaans m. , & klessen r. s. 2010 , a&a , 513 , 7 seta m. , hasegawa t. , dame t m. et al .
1998 , apj , 505 , 286 shetty r. , glover s. c. , dullemond c. p. & klessen r. s. 2011a , mnras , 412 , 1686 shetty r. , glover s. c. , dullemond c. p. , ostriker e. c. , harris a. i. , & klessen r. s. 2011b , mnras , 415 , 3253 shirley y. l. , evans n. j. ii .
, young k. e. , knez c. , & jaffe d. t. 2003 , apjs , 149 , 375 smith d. a. , herter t. , haynes m. p. , beichman c. a. , & gautier t. n. iii .
1995 , apj , 439 , 623 soifer b. t. , sanders d. b. , madore b. f. , et al .
1987 , apj , 320 , 238 soifer b. t. , boehmer l. , neugebauer g. , & sanders d. b. 1989 , aj , 98 , 766 soifer b. t. , & neugebauer g. 1991 , aj , 101 , 354 solomon p. m. , radford s.j.e . , & downes d. 1990 , apj , 348 , l53 solomon p. m. , downes d. , & radford s.j.e .
1992 , apj , 387 , l55 solomon p. m. , downes d. , radford s.j.e .
, & barrett j. w. 1997 , apj , 478 , 144 solomon p. m. , & vanden bout p. a. , 2005 , ara&a , 43 , 677 staguhn j. g. , schinnerer e. , eckart a. , & scharwchter j. 2004 , apj , 609 , 85 surace j. a. , sanders d. b. , vacca w. d. , veilleux s. , & mazzarella j. m. 1998 , apj , 492 , 116 surace j. a. , sanders d. b. , & evans a. s. 2000 , apj , 529 , 179 tacconi l. j. , & genzel r. 1996 in _ science with large millimetre arrays _ proceedings of the eso - iram - nfra - onsala workshop , garching , germany , peter a. shaver ( ed . )
springer - verlag , p.125 tacconi l. j. , genzel r. tecza m. , gallimore j. f. downes d. , & scoville n. z 1999 , apj , 524 , 732 tacconi l. j. , genzel r. , lutz d. , et al .
2002 , apj , 580 , 73 tacconi l. j. , neri r. , chapman s. c. , et al .
2006 , apj , 640 , 228 tacconi l. j. , genzel r. , smail i. , et al .
2008 , apj , 680 , 246 thomas h. c. , alexander p. , clemens m. s. , green d. a. , dunne l. , & eales s. 2004 , mnras , 351 , 362 thompson t. a. , quataert e. , & murray n. 2005 , apj , 630 , 167 thompson t. a. 2009 , astronomical society of the pacific conference series , 408 , 128 tinney c. g. , scoville n. z. , sanders d. b. , & soifer b. t. 1990 , apj , 362 , 473 veilleux s. , kim d .- c . , sanders d. b. , mazzarella j. m. , & soifer b. t. 1995 , apjs , 98 , 171 veilleux s. , kim d .- c . , & sanders d. b. 2002 , apjs , 143 , 315 wall , w. f. 2007 , mnras , 379 , 674 wang z. , scoville n. z. , & sanders d. b. 1991 , apj , 368 , 112 weiss a. , neininger n. , httemeister s. , & klein u. 2001 , a&a , 365 , 571 weiss a. , walter f. , & scoville n. z. 2005 , a&a , 438 , 533 white g. j. , ellison b. , claude s. , dent w. r. f. , matheson d. n. 1994 , a&a , 284 , l23 wilson c. d. , petitpas g. r. , iono d. et al .
2008 , apjs , 178 , 189 wu j. , evans n. j. ii . ,
gao yu . , solomon p. m. , shirley y. l. , & vanden bout p. a. 2005 , 635 , l173 xia x. y. , xue s. j. , mao s. , boller th . , deng z. g. , & wu h. 2002 , apj , 564 , 196 yao l. , seaquist e. r. , kuno n. , & dunne l. 2003 , apj , 588 , 771 young j. s. & scoville n. z. 1991 , ara&a , 29 , 581 zhu m. , seaquist e. r. , & kuno n. 2003 , apj , 588 , 243 zhu m. , papadopoulos p. p. ,
xilouris e. m. , kuno n. , & lisenfeld u. 2009 , apj , 706 , 941 lllccl iras00057 + 4021 & 4.5 ( 1.1 ) & 3.4 - 8.2(0.83 - 2.0 ) & 1.2 & 1.6 & degenerate @xmath694 values + izw1 & 8.6 ( 1.5 ) & 9.5 ( 1.65 ) & 0.4 & 2.8 & galactic @xmath694 adopted + ngc828 & 4.6 - 6.3 ( 0.8 - 1.1 ) & 4 - 14 ( 0.7 - 2.5 ) & 0.3 & 0.3 & degenerate @xmath158 + iras02483 + 4302 & 1.6 ( 0.45 ) & 4.3 - 8.6 ( 1.2 - 2.4 ) & 1.4 & 3.3 & degenerate @xmath694 values + iras03359 + 1523 & 22 ( 2.5 ) & & 0.8 & & sf - quiescent ism + viizw031 & 14.5 ( 1.25 ) & 39 ( 3.4 ) & 2.0 & 3.1 & cold extended disk ?
+ iras051892524 & 13.7 ( 3.5 ) & 9.4 ( 2.4 ) & 3.6 & 3.6 & ( h)-phase sled assumed + iras08030 + 5243 & 14.3 - 42.9 ( 1.5 - 4.5 ) & & 2.4 & & degenerate 1-phase solutions + iras08572 + 3915 & 4.8 - 9.6 ( 3 - 6 ) & & 3.9 & & highly excited co j=65 line + arp55 & 2.9 - 9.2 ( 0.25 - 0.8 ) & & 0.9 & & degenerate 1-phase solutions + ugc05101 & 1.9 - 2.9 ( 0.4 - 0.6 ) & & 1.6 & & + ngc3310 & 0.03 - 0.15 ( 0.4 - 2.2 ) & & 0.1 & & degenerate @xmath4 values + iras10565 + 2448 & 3.8 - 4.8 ( 0.6 - 0.75 ) & 4.8 ( 0.75 ) & 2.6 & 2.6 & ( h)-phase sled assumed + arp299 & 1.2 ( 0.42 ) & & 1.9 & & + iras12112 + 0305 & 15.2 - 53.5 ( 1.5 - 5.3 ) & 7.1 - 34.3 ( 0.7 - 3.4)&4.8&4 & unconstrained @xmath158 + mrk231 & 1.8 - 3.2 ( 0.25 - 0.45 ) & 21 - 49 ( 3 - 7 ) & 5.5 & 8 - 25 & co 6 - 5 , hcn lines used in 2-phase model + arp193 & 1.6 - 3.5 ( 0.35 - 0.75 ) & 3.3 - 8.1 ( 0.7 - 1.8 ) & 0.9 & 1.7 - 7.1 & co 32 , hcn lines used in 2-phase model + ngc5135 & 1.1 - 1.4 ( 0.35 - 0.45 ) & & 0.3 & & + mrk273 & 10.4 ( 2.0 ) & 13 ( 2.5 ) & 3.3 & 6 & cold extended disk ? + 3c293 & 2.3 - 7.4 ( 0.5 - 1.6 ) & 13.4 - 18 ( 2.9 - 3.9 ) & 0.05 & 1.1 - 3.5 & galactic @xmath158 adopted + iras143481447 & 11 - 17 ( 0.65 - 1 ) & 24 - 30 ( 1.4 - 1.7 ) & 5.6 & 5.6 & degenerate ( l)-phase + zw049.057 & 0.30 - 0.52 ( 0.35 - 0.6 ) & & 0.47 & & + arp220 & 1.85 ( 0.30 ) & 14.7 - 27.5 ( 2.4 - 4.5 ) & 4 & 12.6 - 25.2 & hcn lines used in 2-phase model + ngc6240 & 2.5 ( 0.30 ) & 8.4 - 27.8 ( 1 - 3.3 ) & 1.5 & 4.9 - 24.5 & hcn lines used in 2-phase model + iras172080014 & 5.2 ( 0.40 ) & 9.8 - 33 ( 0.75 - 2.5 ) & 6.2 & 3.5 - 6 & degenerate @xmath694 values + @xmath695 @xmath695 & @xmath695 & 34 - 77 ( 2.6 - 5.9 ) & @xmath695 & 27 - 70 & hcn lines used in 2-phase model + iras224911808 & 6.3 - 22 ( 0.70 - 2.4 ) & & 5.2 & & degenerate @xmath4 values + ngc7469 & 2.5 ( 0.72 ) & 6.5 ( 1.88 ) & 0.65 & 1.65 & cold extended disk present + iras23365 + 3604 & 7.3 - 9.5 ( 1 - 1.3 ) & 3.7 - 22 ( 0.5 - 3 ) & 2.5 & 1.4 & unconstrained @xmath158 + | in this work we conclude the analysis of our co line survey of luminous infrared galaxies ( lirgs : @xmath0@xmath110@xmath2l@xmath3 ) in the local universe ( paperi ) , by focusing on the influence of their average ism properties on the total molecular gas mass estimates via the so - called @xmath4=@xmath5 factor .
one - phase radiative transfer models of the global co spectral line energy distributions ( sleds ) yield an @xmath6 distribution with : @xmath7@xmath8@xmath9@xmath10(kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 over a significant range of average gas densities , temperatures and dynamical states .
the latter emerges as the most important parameter in determining @xmath4 , with unbound states yielding low values and self - gravitating states the highest ones .
nevertheless in many ( u)lirgs where available higher - j co lines ( j=32 , 43 , and/or j=65 ) or hcn line data from the literature allow a separate assesment of the gas mass at high densities ( @xmath1310@xmath14@xmath15 ) rather than a simple one - phase analysis we find that _ near - galactic @xmath16@xmath17(3 - 6)@xmath18(kkms@xmath11pc@xmath12)@xmath11 values become possible .
_ we further show that in the highly turbulent molecular gas in ulirgs a high - density component will be common and can be massive enough for its high @xmath4 to dominate the average value for the entire galaxy . using solely low - j co lines to constrain @xmath6 in such environments ( as it has been the practice up to now )
may have thus resulted to _
systematic underestimates of molecular gas mass in ulirgs _ as such lines are dominated by a warm , diffuse and unbound gas phase with low @xmath4 but very little mass .
only well - sampled high - j co sleds ( j=32 and higher ) and/or multi - j observations of heavy rotor molecules ( e.g. hcn ) can circumvent such a bias , and the latter type of observations may have actually provided early evidence of it in local ulirgs . the only way that the global @xmath19 of such systems could be significantly lower than galactic is if the average dynamic state of the dense gas is strongly gravitationally unbound .
this is an unlikely possibility that must be nevertheless examined , with lines of rare isotopologues of high gas density tracers ( e.g. h@xmath20cn , high - j @xmath20co lines ) being very valuable in yielding ( along with the lines of the main isotopes ) such constraints . for less ir luminous , disk - dominated systems , we find that the galaxy - averaged @xmath4 deduced by one - phase models of global sleds can also underestimate the total molecular gas mass when much of it lies in a sf - quiescent phase extending beyond a central star - forming region .
this is because such a phase ( and its large @xmath6 ) remain inconspicious in global co sleds .
finally detailed studies of a subsample of galaxies finds ulirgs with large amounts ( @xmath2110@xmath22m@xmath23 ) of very warm ( @xmath24100k ) _ and _ dense gas ( @xmath2510@xmath26@xmath15 ) that could represent a serious challenge to photon - dominated regions as the main energy portals in the molecular ism of such systems . |
after extracting the names of proteins occurring in a particular life stage of _ caenorhabditis elegans _ , experimentally verified protein - protein interactions are collected from various bioinformatics repositories @xcite .
next , six different ppi networks are constructed by treating each life stage as a layer of the multilayer ppi network ( fig .
[ fig1 ] ) . for each layer , all the proteins are enlisted and these proteins are occurring for their functional or structural activities in that life stage .
the proteins are the nodes and connections are assigned if a pair of proteins @xmath5 and @xmath6 has an interaction between them .
thus , six different sub - networks for multilayer ppi network are obtained .
the adjacency matrix of each layer of the multilayer network is denoted as @xmath7 and elements are defined as , @xmath8 all the adjacency matrices are symmetric ( _ i.e. , _
@xmath9 = @xmath10 ) where @xmath11 .
the most basic structural parameter of a network is the degree of a node ( @xmath12 ) , which is defined as a number of edges connected to the node ( @xmath13 ) .
the degree distribution , @xmath14 , is calculated which is the probability that a randomly chosen node has @xmath15 connections .
the second parameter , the clustering coefficient @xmath16 , is the ratio of the number of interactions a neighbor of particular node is having and the possible number of connections the neighbors can have among themselves .
further , the network diameter ( @xmath17 ) is defined as the longest of the shortest paths between all the pair of nodes in a network @xcite .
another property of the network which turns out to be crucial in distinguishing the individual layer of the multilayer ppi network is the pearson degree - degree correlation ( @xmath18 ) , which measures the tendency of nodes with the similar numbers of edges to connect .
it can be defined as @xcite , @xmath19 - [ \frac{1}{m } \sum_i \frac{1}{2}(j_i + k_i)^2 ] } { [ \frac{1}{m } \sum_{i } \frac{1}{2 } ( j_i^2 + k_i^2 ) ] - [ \frac{1}{m } \sum_i \frac{1}{2}(j_i + k_i)^2 ] } \label{assortativity}\ ] ] where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the degrees of the nodes connected through the @xmath22 edge , and @xmath23 is the number of edges in the network .
the value of @xmath18 being zero corresponds to a random network where as the negative(positive ) values correspond to dis(assortative ) networks .
further , correlation between link betweenness centrality and overlap of the neighborhood of two connected nodes , is calculated .
link betweenness centrality ( @xmath24 ) is defined for an undirected link as , @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the number of shortest paths between @xmath27 and @xmath28 that contain @xmath29 , and @xmath30 is the total number of shortest paths between @xmath27 and @xmath28 .
the overlap of the neighborhood ( @xmath31 ) of two connected nodes @xmath5 and @xmath6 is defined as , @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the number of neighbors common to both nodes @xmath5 and @xmath6 @xcite . here
@xmath12 and @xmath34 represent the degree of the @xmath22 and @xmath35 nodes .
further , pearson correlation coefficient ( @xmath36 ) of @xmath31 and @xmath24 can be defined as , @xmath37 in particular , negative value of @xmath36 coefficient suggests the importance of weak ties , a concept borrowed from social sciences into the network analysis .
the eigenvalues of the adjacency matrix are denoted by @xmath38 , i = @xmath39 such that @xmath40 . the duplicated nodes in a network can be identified from corresponding adjacency matrix in the following manner . when ( i ) two rows ( columns ) have exactly same entries , it is termed as the complete row ( column ) duplication
_ i.e. _ @xmath41 , ( ii ) when a combination of rows ( columns ) have exactly same entries as another combination of rows ( columns ) then it is termed as the partial duplication of rows ( columns ) , for example @xmath42 .
satisfying any one of the conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) lowers the rank of the matrix exactly by one .
in addition , the rank is also lowered if ( iii ) there is an isolated node .
all these conditions lead to the zero eigenvalues in the matrix spectra @xcite .
since there is no isolated node in the network , ensured in the beginning itself by considering only the largest connected cluster for this analysis , conditions ( i ) and ( ii ) are the only conditions responsible for occurrence of the zero degeneracy .
further , the von neumann entropy @xmath43 of the graph @xmath44 is calculated as , @xmath45 $ ] where @xmath46 is the combinatorial laplacian matrix @xcite and d is the diagonal matrix of the degrees re - scaled by @xmath47 .
formally , @xmath48 has all the properties of a density matrix _ i.e. , _ it is positive semi - definite and @xmath49 @xcite .
therefore , @xmath43 can be written as , @xmath50 the maximum entropy , a network of size @xmath51 can achieve , is @xmath52 .
further , the network properties are compared between ppi layers and corresponding erds r ' enyi ( er ) random networks @xcite .
this allows to estimate the probability that a random network with certain constraints has of belonging to a particular architecture , and thus assess the relative importance of different network architecture and help discern the mechanisms responsible for given real - world networks @xcite .
c c c c c c c c c c c layer & @xmath51 & @xmath53 & @xmath17 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 & @xmath18 & @xmath56 & @xmath57&@xmath58 & @xmath59 + blastula & 2876 & 22880 & 12 & 16 & 0.24 & 0.24 & 812(28.2 ) & 716(24.9 ) & -0.39 & 9.68 + gastrula & 2848 & 22802 & 12 & 16 & 0.25 & 0.24 & 791(27.7 ) & 692(24.3 ) & -0.39 & 9.73 + embryo & 3568 & 25741 & 12 & 14 & 0.23 & 0.27 & 1144(32.1 ) & 1025(28.7 ) & -0.37 & 9.18 + nematode & 4755 & 35708 & 12 & 15 & 0.33 & 0.16 & 2087(43.9 ) & 1928(40.5 ) & -0.30 & 9.99 + primeadult & 3112 & 24126 & 12 & 16 & 0.24 & 0.26 & 926(29.8 ) & 833(26.8 ) & -0.38 & 9.59 + lifecycle & 3415 & 25255 & 12 & 15 & 0.23 & 0.27 & 1057(30.9 ) & 937(27.4 ) & -0.36 & 9.33 + [ table1 ] first , the structural properties of ppi networks are analyzed for six developmental stages .
the average degree , which gives a measure of the average connectivity of individual network , remains same for all the layers of the multilayer ppi network ( table [ table1 ] ) .
this indicates that though there are differences in the number of nodes participating in each layer as well in the connections _
i.e. , _ the average connectivity is conserved across all life stages .
further , the network diameter indicates how much far are the two most distant nodes in a network .
the diameter being small for all the layers suggests that all the nodes are in proximity and the graph is compact @xcite .
the diameter , and thus the compactness , of a ppi network , can be interpreted as the overall easiness of the proteins to communicate or influence their reciprocal function .
further , an intriguing observation of degree distribution is found which follows two distinct fitting scales in all the layers _
i.e. , _ two power law in each layer ( fig .
[ fig2 ] ) .
many network studies have reported an absence of the perfect power law for the overall range of the degree .
various real systems show power law in the central part of data only and deviation from it in the small or the large scale .
furthermore , the value of first power law exponent @xmath60 is lower than the second one in all the layers .
several models have been used to explain the origin of two power laws found in many systems .
the models include , the geometric brownian motion model , the preferential attachment model and the generalized model of the creation of new links between old nodes which increases with evolution time @xcite .
these models suggest that the evolution of a network is characterized by two parts _ i.e. , _
( i ) a leading ingredient of a network and ( ii ) fluctuations within existing connections between nodes , being one of the reasons to lead the double power law nature of degree distribution . here
, the power law nature of ppi layer implicates that robustness of a network is maintained not only by acquisition of new interactions by hub proteins but also by contribution of new or altered interactions within existing proteins for ease of pathway processes @xcite which might have arisen due to the presence of internal physiological and external environmental factors during the development of an organism @xcite . ''
refers to the exponent of power law.,width=453,height=264 ] what follows that the individual network exhibits overall similar statistics for widely investigated structural properties _
i.e. , _ smaller diameter , and larger average clustering coefficient than the corresponding random networks as well as existence of two power law but the crucial differences among them , are revealed through the analysis of the degree - degree correlation and spectral properties .
all the network layers show overall positive degree - degree correlation ( table [ table1 ] ) . though most of the biological networks exhibit disassortative nature @xcite , a positive degree - degree correlation is observed in many other biological networks @xcite .
it is reported that assortative networks are strongly clustered and can have functional modules @xcite .
a high value of @xmath18 here suggests the presence of functional modules as functional areas of ppi network , but there is lack of clear evidence to prove whether a functional area forms a functional module @xcite .
the corresponding random networks have @xmath18 value close to zero ( table [ table2 ] ) .
this is not surprising as the networks with the same average degree and size may still differ significantly in various network features since the nodes are randomly connected and the value of assortativity coefficient of a network is determined by degrees of interacting nodes @xcite .
the assortativity observed in ppi networks implicates that overall interaction patterns of nodes having similar degree is conserved in all the layers .
next , blastula and gastrula ppi layer have same @xmath18 value which is not surprising as a large number of proteins and , hence their interactions are common in these two layers .
further , though all ppi layers show @xmath18 value close to each other , the @xmath18 value of nematode is lower than other ppi layers as well as the difference in the @xmath18 value from that of other layers is very high .
it suggests that nematode ppi layer is not as assortative as other layers which implicates in the presence of less structural modules in nematode as of other layers .
further , @xmath18 values close to zero of the random networks suggest that the network with random interactions tend to have less @xmath18 values .
all these suggest that nematode ppi layer is more random than the other layers .
c c c c c c c | c network & @xmath55 & @xmath17 & @xmath18 & @xmath61 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & @xmath52 + blastula & 0.005 & 5 & 0 & 0 & -0.1 & 11.43 @xmath620.02 & 11.49 + gastrula & 0.005 & 5 & 0 & 0 & -0.1 & 11.39 @xmath620.04 & 11.48 + embryo & 0.005 & 4 & 0 & 0 & -0.1 & 11.39 @xmath620.04 & 11.80 + nematode & 0.006 & 5 & 0 & 0 & -0.11 & 12.12 @xmath620.04 & 12.21 + prime adult & 0.005 & 5 & 0 & 0 & -0.09 @xmath620.04 & 11.34 @xmath620.04 & 11.60 + life cycle & 0.006 & 5 & 0 & 0 & -0.13 & 11.81 @xmath620.04 & 11.74 + [ table2 ] to get deeper insights into the organization of connections in ppi networks , these networks are further analyzed with the weak ties hypothesis . here
, the links having low overlap in their end nodes are termed as the weak ties and links having high link betweeness centrality are the ones known to be stronger as they help in connecting in different modules @xcite .
all the network layers exhibit the negative value of @xmath36 correlation coefficient ( table [ table1 ] ) which suggests the presence of weak ties in ppi network .
it is suggested that the complete architecture of ppi network is composed of different biological pathways and metabolic cycles , and a protein involved in particular pathway plays role in regulating other pathways as well , termed as cross talk between pathways @xcite .
the corresponding random networks exhibit negative @xmath36 value ( table [ table2 ] ) , but ppi layers have more negative @xmath36 value than the corresponding random networks .
it implicates that the network with random interactions tends to have more @xmath36 value .
therefore , the highest @xmath36 value in nematode suggests that nematode ppi layer is more random than the other layers .
nevertheless , understanding of the evolution of embryogenesis in _ c. elegans
_ is still fragmentary , more randomness shown by the less value of assortativity coefficient , and high value of @xmath36 coefficient than other layers may suggest that the presence of more randomness in this layer .
it is reported that the processes of cellular diversification plays vital role in the larval nematode development @xcite , which may be the reason for more randomness in this network layer .
so far the study is focused on various structural aspects of all the layers which have demonstrated distinguishable structural features of the nematode from other layers .
further , the spectra of these networks are analyzed since spectra is known to be fingerprint of corresponding network @xcite .
the network spectra not only provide insight to functional modules @xcite and randomness in the connection architecture @xcite , but also relate with the dynamical behavior of the system as a whole @xcite .
it is observed that the spectra of all the ppi layers have high degeneracy at the zero eigenvalue .
the occurrence of degeneracy at zero eigenvalue for ppi layers is not surprising here as many biological and technological networks are known to exhibit high degeneracy at zero eigenvalue @xcite .
interestingly , the number of zero eigenvalue has direct relation with complete and partial duplication of nodes @xcite as discussed in material and methods section .
the number of complete duplicates @xmath63 which contributes to the same number of zero eigenvalue ( @xmath64 ) , is listed in table [ table1 ] .
the appearance of duplicate nodes in biological networks have been emphasized to be arising due to the gene duplication process as a consequence of evolution @xcite .
the corresponding random networks do not exhibit degeneracy at zero eigenvalue , indicating that this count of duplicate nodes in ppi layers reside not only in the sheer number of proteins and interactions taking part in particular layer , but also in how individual ppi layer is evolved or designed to fulfill the cellular functions .
an important observation is that despite overall similar spectral properties _
i.e. _ degeneracy at zero eigenvalue as well as shape of eigenvalue distribution @xcite , the height of the peak at zero eigenvalue differs in all the layers .
since size of the networks differ at different life stages , in order to take care of the impact of size on the occurrence of the zero degeneracy , the count of zero eigenvalues are normalized by dividing with @xmath51 and find that these normalized values also differ in ppi layers ( table [ table1 ] ) .
what is important here is that the genome of an organism remains same in all the life stages , still there is occurrence of different count of duplicate nodes in ppi layers . in ppi network ,
gene duplication is understood as duplication of protein since the duplicated protein is the expressed product of the duplicated gene as well as it is the identical copy of the parent one .
the duplicated protein initially shares common function as of the parent protein which results in the same interaction partners , later it functionally diversifies to acquire different interaction partners @xcite .
since every protein contributes to the specific physiological and developmental process , and different physiological and developmental processes in each life stage would require different set of proteins , may result in different count of duplicate nodes .
taken together , it suggests that there may be the role of specific biological responses at each developmental stage in the process of gene duplication .
further , nematode ppi layer exhibits more number of zero eigenvalues than other layers .
it is reported that nematode is a crucial stage for cellular diversification and organogenesis , as well as there are developmental transitions during continuous and interrupted larval nematode development @xcite , which might result in more duplicates in nematode than other life stages .
furthermore , the von neumann entropy of all the layers are calculated and observed that there are different @xmath59 values in each ppi layer ( table [ table1 ] ) . to get more insights on this , entropy @xmath59 of each ppi layer
is compared with the maximum entropy @xmath65 of that layer , also with @xmath59 of the corresponding random network .
firstly , ppi layers as well as random networks display lesser entropy than corresponding maximum entropy which is quite intuitive , since any network with @xmath51 size can have maximum @xmath65 entropy .
secondly , corresponding random networks display higher entropy than ppi layers .
the networks with random interactions among nodes tend to show higher entropy .
the comparison of entropy of each ppi layer with the maximum entropy as well as with the corresponding random network indicates presence of varying complexity in each ppi layer .
it recites the similar notion of varying complexity present in each layer which is deduced earlier by structural features .
it is potentially important since it may be in consequence with the specific developmental and evolutionary stimuli associated with each life stage .
further , nematode has the highest @xmath59 value which suggests the presence of more complexity in this layer than all other ppi layers . taken together , more complexity in nematode than all other ppi layers and the least @xmath18 value and the highest @xmath36 suggest in more randomness in this ppi layer .
as it is discussed earlier , the contribution of specific developmental factors at larval nematode development may result here in more complexity in ppi layer of nematode life stage than all other ppi layers .
the proteome analysis of each layer of _ c. elegans _ multilayer ppi network exhibits the overall similarity in structural features such as smaller diameter and larger average clustering coefficient than the corresponding random networks as also observed for other biological networks @xcite .
the degree distribution following power law in each of the ppi layer is indicative of the robustness of the underlying system .
although the widely studied structural properties exhibit similar statistics , the crucial differences in the network layers through the analysis of the degree - degree correlation and spectral properties , which also turn out to be of potential importance in understanding varying complexity in each layer .
the values of @xmath18 , @xmath36 and @xmath59 coefficients of each layer ubiquitously behave in similar manner and are found to be comparable with other ppi layers of underlying system .
interestingly , the layer of nematode life stage exhibits notable distinguishing properties than other layers , which in overall indicates that this layer being the most random among all the layers .
further , each ppi layer exhibits different degeneracy at the zero eigenvalue which is related to node duplication , suggesting the role of specific biological responses at each developmental stage in the process of gene duplication . to summarize , an extent of varying complexity is observed in the organization of ppi networks of individual layers of multilayer ppi network .
it recites the fact that biological complexity arises at several levels in the development of _ c. elegans _ such as , from single cell embryo to multicellular completely developed organism where each life stage is associated with different physiological and molecular changes @xcite .
the varying complexity observed in life stages can further be used to understand and capture important developmental changes in an organism .
99 ( 2009 ) 323 721 .
\(1998 ) 8417 .
\(1996 ) 368 .
\(1996 ) 22 .
\(1974 ) 71 .
\(2001 ) 127 .
\(2015 ) 124 .
\(2003 ) 11426 ; sol r. and valverde s. _ complex networks _ * 207 * ( 2004 ) 189 ; braustein s. , gosh s. and severini s. _ ann .
comb . _ * 10 * ( 2006 ) 291 .
\(2003 ) 280 ; boccaletti s. _ et al . , _ _ phys .
* 424 * ( 2006 ) 175 .
\(2009 ) 51 .
( 2006 ) 307 ; jalan s. , solymosi n. , vattay g. , and li b. _ phys .
* 81(4 ) * ( 2010 ) 046118 .
( 2011 ) .
http://figshare.com/articles/supplementary_material_a_multilayer_ppi_network_analysis_of_different_life_stages/1539528[supplementary material ] for detailed information on life stages of _ c. elegans _ and data collection . .
\(2010 ) 91 .
\(2003 ) 026126 .
\(1973 ) 1360 - 1380 ; onnela j. _ et al . , _
_ new j. phys . _ * 9(6 ) * ( 2007 ) 179 . in _ in an introduction to the theory of graph spectra
_ cambridge - new york ( 2010 ) .
\(2015 ) 043110 .
\(2006 ) 291 .
( 2015 ) . .
\(2010 ) 108702 .
( 2011 ) .
\(2002 ) 469 ; dorogovtsev s. and mendes j. _ proc .
london , ser .
b _ * 268 * ( 2001 ) 2603 ; han d. , qian j. and ma y. _ europhysics letters _ * 94.2 * ( 2011 ) 28006 .
( 2015 ) .
( 2010 ) .
\(2012 ) 66 .
\(2014 ) 220 ; welch j. j. , and waxman d. _ evolution _ * 57.8 * ( 2003 ) 1723 .
( 2012 ) .
\(2009 ) 791 - 803 ; typas a. and sourjik v. _ nat .
microbiol . _ * 13(9 ) * ( 2015 ) 559 .
( 2011 ) .
\(2009 ) 056114 .
( 2014 ) ; mndez - bermdez j. a. _ et al . , _ _ phys .
* 91.3 * ( 2015 ) 032122 .
\(2003 ) 014101 .
\(2005 ) 016106 ; agrawal a. _ et al . , _ _ physica a _ * 404 * ( 2014 ) 359 .
\(2009 ) 2425 ; kamp c. and christensen k. _ phys .
e _ * 71 * ( 2005 ) 041911 .
\(2005 ) 061911 .
\(1976 ) 287 ; rougvie a. and moss e. _ current topics in developmental biology _ * 80 * ( 2013 ) 153 .
978 - 0262514224 ( 2006 ) .
sj is grateful to department of science and technology ( dst ) , government of india and council of scientific and industrial research ( csir ) , government of india project grants emr/2014/000368 and 25(0205)/12/emr - ii for financial support , respectively .
ps acknowledges dst for the inspire fellowship ( if150200 ) as well as the complex systems lab members for timely help and useful discussions . | molecular networks act as the backbone of cellular activities , providing an excellent opportunity to understand the developmental changes in an organism .
while network data usually constitute only stationary network graphs , constructing multilayer ppi network may provide clues to the particular developmental role at each stage of life and may unravel the importance of these developmental changes .
the developmental biology model of _ caenorhabditis elegans _ analyzed here provides a ripe platform to understand the patterns of evolution during life stages of an organism . in the present study ,
the widely studied network properties exhibit overall similar statistics for all the ppi layers .
further , the analysis of the degree - degree correlation and spectral properties not only reveals crucial differences in each ppi layer but also indicates the presence of the varying complexity among them .
the ppi layer of nematode life stage exhibits various network properties different to rest of the ppi layers , indicating the specific role of cellular diversity and developmental transitions at this stage .
the framework presented here provides a direction to explore and understand developmental changes occurring in different life stages of an organism . * a multilayer ppi network analysis of different life stages in c. elegans * + pramod shinde@xmath0 , and sarika jalan@xmath1 + _ @xmath2 centre for biosciences and biomedical engineering , indian institute of technology indore , simrol , indore 452020 , india + _ @xmath3 complex systems lab , discipline of physics , indian institute of technology indore , simrol , indore 452020 , india + e - mail : [email protected] , @[email protected] _ _
recent developments in the quantitative analysis of complex networks have rapidly been translated to studies of different biological network organizations @xcite .
developmental biology is the study of the molecular and cellular events that lead to the generation of a multicellular organism from a fertilized egg @xcite .
although much is known about the morphological changes that take place during the development , there is a lesser understanding of the mechanisms by which these changes occur . due to lack of this knowledge , and because of the interest in understanding how something as complex as a living organism can develop from a single cell , developmental biology is one of the most active areas of biological research today @xcite .
the intimidating complexity of cellular systems appears to be a major hurdle in understanding internal organization of molecular pathways and their development in large scale evolutionary biological networks @xcite .
for instance , during the development phase of _ caenorhabditis elegans ( c. elegans ) _ from undeveloped embryo to completely developed nematode , it undergoes multiple physiological and physiochemical changes .
many key discoveries , both in basic biology and medically relevant areas , were first made in the worm . since its introduction , _ c. elegans _ has been used to study a much larger variety of biological processes @xcite .
together , these studies revealed a surprisingly strong conservation in molecular and cellular pathways between worms and mammals .
indeed , subsequent comparison of the human and _ c. elegans _ genomes confirmed that the majority of human disease genes and disease pathways are present in _ c. elegans _ @xcite .
here , the global architecture of protein - protein interaction ( ppi ) network of each life stage of this model system is considered and focus is given to understand the behavior of individual layer of this multilayer network .
it is worth noticing that layers of a multilayer network can be tackled from different perspectives @xcite and might in principle be used to understand the developmental biological changes in different life stages of this organism .
recently , following information from theoretical and statistical mechanics paradigms , several structural and spectral measures for randomness and complexity have been proposed for social , technological and biological networks @xcite .
these measures have been shown to be extremely successful in quantifying the level of organization encoded in structural features of networks .
the measures like degree - degree correlation and von neumann entropy allow us to capture differences and similarities between networks , which furthers our understanding of the information encoded in complex networks @xcite .
this complexity resides not only in the sheer number of proteins and interactions taking part in particular layer of multilayer network , but also in how individual layer is evolved or designed to fulfill the cellular functions . to understand this
, an extend of varying randomness and complexity is deduced using degree - degree correlation and spectral properties of each layer of the multilayer ppi network .
further , the early nematode developmental stage is more complex among all the life stages of _ c. elegans_. this analysis provides a direction to understand and capture important developmental changes in an organism . |
everyday experience tells us that thin elastic sheets _ crumple _ , when confined into a small volume , _ e.g. _ a sheet of paper `` confined '' by ones hands .
crumpling also plays an important role in the mechanical behavior of packaging material and in the dissipation of the energy of collisions by the `` crumple zones '' of automobiles .
crumpling is therefore a problem of much intrinsic interest , but understanding this behavior is complicated by the complex morphology of a typical crumpled sheet . despite the complicated appearance of a crumpled sheet ,
the crumpling phenomenon is in itself very robust .
it is easily observed in thin sheets made from a variety of materials , suggesting that it can be studied using simplified or idealized models that capture the essential features of thin elastic sheets .
this approach leads one to consider a crumpled sheet as a minimum energy configuration for a simple elastic energy functional for thin sheets , _ viz . _
the fpl von karman ( fvk ) energy . using this approach of elastic energy minimization , the crumpling response is now understood as a result of the elastic energy of the sheet concentrating on a small subset of the entire sheet @xcite .
the energy in a crumpled sheet is concentrated on a network of thin line - like creases ( ridges ) that meet in point - like vertices .
recent work has resulted in quantitative understanding of both the vertices @xcite and the ridges @xcite . scaling laws governing the behavior of crumpled sheets
have been obtained in the physics literature @xcite .
minimum energy configurations for the fvk energy have also been studied in the context of the _ blistering problem _ , _ viz .
_ the buckling of membranes as a result of isotropic compression along the boundary .
the blistering problem is relevant to the delamination of thin films that are chemically deposited at high temperatures , as well as the mechanical behavior of micro - fabricated thin - film diaphragms @xcite .
there is a considerable body of mathematical work focused on the blistering problem @xcite .
upper and lower bounds have been obtained for approximations to the elastic energy @xcite , for the fvk energy @xcite and for full three dimensional nonlinear elasticity @xcite .
the fvk energy and full three dimensional nonlinear elasticity give the same scaling for the upper and the lower bounds .
this yields a rigorous scaling law for the energy of a blister .
as we discuss below , the scaling laws for the blistering problem are different from those for the crumpling problem , even for the _ same energy functional_. this indicates that the energy minimizing configurations for the fvk energy show an interesting dependence on the boundary conditions .
the minimization of the fvk elastic energy is an example of a non - convex variational problem that is regularized by a singular perturbation @xcite .
it is well known that this can lead to a variety of multiple - scale behaviors including energy concentration and/or small scale oscillations in the minimizers @xcite .
multiple scale behaviors , both _
microstructure _ and _ singularities _ , are ubiquitous in condensed matter systems .
the crumpling phenomenon appears to be a particularly simple and tractable instance of multiple scale behavior . for this reason
, there has been much recent interest in physics literature about the nature of the crumpling phenomenon @xcite .
asymptotic analysis @xcite and scaling arguments @xcite show that the ridge energy scales as @xmath3 where @xmath1 is the thickness of the sheet , and @xmath4 is the length of the ridge .
ben - amar @xcite and mahadevan @xcite show that the energy of a @xmath5-cone scales as @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the radius of the core associated with the vertex .
it is clear that the ridge energy is asymptotically larger than the vertex energy as @xmath8 .
however , which of these two energies is important for a given sheet depends on the relation between the nondimensional thickness @xmath9 of the sheet , and the `` crossover thickness '' @xmath10 which is determined by setting @xmath11 .
@xmath12 in turn depends on the values of the multiplicative constants for these scaling laws .
these multiplicative constants can not be determined by scaling arguments .
mahadevan @xcite estimate the constant for the vertex energy numerically using an ansatz for the shape of a sheet near the vertex , and they find that @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the complement of the tip angle of the cone @xcite . based on lobkovsky s work @xcite , boudaoud
@xcite estimate the value of the constant in the ridge energy as @xmath15 .
this implies , for the experiments in refs .
@xcite and @xcite , the vertex energy dominates the ridge energy
. it would be useful to prove these scaling laws , and determine the multiplicative constants rigorously , that is , in an ansatz - free manner . in this paper
, we propose a model problem that yields structures analogous to a single ridge in a crumpled sheet .
we prove a rigorous lower bound ( with a numerical value for the multiplicative constant ) for the elastic energy in our model problem .
this is a step toward rigorously proving the scaling law of lobkovsky for the ridge energy @xcite .
we also discuss how the techniques in this paper can be extended to prove similar results for a `` real '' crumpled sheet , as opposed to our model problem .
this paper is organized as follows in sec .
[ sec : setup ] , we describe the problem of interest , set up the relevant energy functional and determine the appropriate boundary conditions .
we also rescale the various quantities to a form that is suitable for further analysis , and recast the problem in terms of the rescaled quantities . in sec .
[ sec : l_bnd ] , we prove our main result , _ viz . _ a lower bound for the elastic energy for our boundary conditions
. we present a concluding discussion in sec .
[ sec : discussion ] .
we are interested in a _ minimal ridge _ , _
i.e. _ , the single crease that is formed when a long rectangular elastic strip is bent through an angle by clamping the lateral boundaries to a bent frame .
this situation is depicted in figure [ fig : ridge ] . from the symmetry of the problem ,
it is clear that we only need to consider one half of the strip .
this is represented schematically in figure [ fig : coords ] .
we will use ( the material ) coordinates @xmath16 on the reference half strip @xmath17 , @xmath18 . also , we associate a @xmath19 coordinate systems in space , so that as @xmath20 , the half - strip is asymptotically in the @xmath21 plane , as depicted in figure [ fig : coords ] .
the grid in the figure is generated by the lines @xmath22 and @xmath23 that are straight in the reference ( material ) coordinates .
@xmath24 represents the out of plane deformation , and the in - plane coordinate are chosen so that the @xmath25 and the @xmath26 axes are asymptotically parallel to the @xmath27 and @xmath28 axes respectively as @xmath29 . since the sheet is bent through an angle @xmath30 , as @xmath31 , the sheet will lie in the plane @xmath32 .
the symmetry of the two halves implies that the the line @xmath33 maps into the plane @xmath34 , which bisects the angle between the planes @xmath21 ( the asymptote as @xmath20 ) and @xmath32 ( the asymptote as @xmath35 ) .
the symmetry between the two halves also implies that the tangent to the lines @xmath22 at @xmath33 should be perpendicular to the plane @xmath36 .
consequently @xmath37 and @xmath38 at @xmath33 .
a mathematically justified way to obtain the elastic energy of the deformed sheet is to treat the sheet as a three dimensional ( albeit thin ) object and use a full nonlinear three dimensional elastic energy functional for the energy density .
this approach however does not take advantage of the `` thinness '' of the sheet .
in particular , we would like to treat the thin sheet as a two dimensional object .
this will greatly reduce the complexity of the problem .
the derivation of reduced dimensional descriptions of thin sheets has a long history .
there is a classical theory for thin elastic sheets built on the work of euler , cauchy , kirchoff , fpl and von karman @xcite .
many modern authors have considered the problem of deriving a reduced dimensional theory @xcite from three dimensional elasticity in a mathematically rigorous fashion through @xmath39 convergence @xcite .
convergence is the appropriate notion for convergence in variational problems . in the context of thin sheets , roughly speaking , finding the @xmath39 limit amounts to identifying an appropriate two dimensional energy functional whose minimizers give the limiting behavior of the minimizers of the full three dimensional energy in the limit the thickness @xmath40 .
this problem hasnt been solved in its entirety .
there are two situations for which reduced dimensional theories have been derived rigorously as @xmath39 limits of full three dimensional elasticity .
membrane theories @xcite are applicable in situations where the stretching is essentially uniform through the thickness of the sheet and bending theories @xcite are applicable in situations where the the sheet is essentially unstretched , and all the elastic energy is due to strains that are first order in the thickness of the sheet
. neither of these theories are applicable for the minimal ridge . for the minimal ridge ,
both the stretching ( membrane ) energy and the bending energy are important .
in fact , a ridge is a result of the competition between these two energies .
so we turn to the classical fpl
von karman _
ansatz _ for an appropriate definition of the elastic energy @xcite .
although the fvk energy is not rigorously derived from three dimensional elasticity , it can be thought of as the sum of the membrane and the bending energies that have been derived rigorously in different limiting situations .
we will further assume that , for the minimal ridge , the deflections @xmath41 and @xmath42 are small compared to the natural length scale @xmath4 .
the strains are of the order of the square of the maximum deflection divided by @xmath4 and they are small . after some rescaling , the energy of the deformed sheet is given by the linearized fvk energy @xmath43 dx dy \nonumber \\ & & + \sigma^2 \int ( w_{xx}^2 + 2 w_{xy}^2 + w_{yy}^2 ) \ , dx dy .
\label{eq : unscaled } \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 and @xmath28 are reference coordinates on the sheet , @xmath25 and @xmath26 are in - plane coordinates , @xmath24 is the out of plane displacement and @xmath1 is the thickness of the sheet .
the integrand for the first integral is given by the squares of the linearized strains , @xmath44 the blistering of thin films is also described by the elastic energy in ( [ eq : unscaled ] ) .
a similar energy also describes multiple scale buckling in _ free _ elastic sheets ( _ i.e. _ sheets that are not forced through the boundary conditions ) that are not intrinsically flat @xcite .
the difference between the blistering problem and a minimal ridge is in the boundary conditions , which we describe below .
since the strains are assumed to be small , @xmath45 . if the bending half - angle @xmath46 , so that @xmath47 , we get @xmath48 .
since the deformation goes to zero far away from the bend , we have @xmath49 also , the lateral boundaries at @xmath50 are clamped to the frame .
therefore , @xmath51 note that the appropriate boundary condition for the minimal ridge at @xmath33 is a free boundary condition , subject to the symmetry requirement @xmath52 .
we are going to replace this free boundary condition with a dirichlet boundary condition @xmath53 where we will leave the functions @xmath54 and @xmath55 unspecified , except for a size condition . defining @xmath56}(|v_0(x)|,|w_0(x)|),\ ] ]
we impose the size condition by requiring that @xmath7 be `` small '' .
the relevant small parameter in the problem is the non - dimensional thickness of the sheet , @xmath9 .
following lobkovsky @xcite , we introduce the rescaled coordinates and displacements by @xmath57 and @xmath58 since @xmath59 all have dimensions of a length , it is clear that the rescaled quantities @xmath60 are all dimensionless . with these rescalings ,
the dimensionless energy @xmath61 is given by @xmath62 \nonumber \\ & & + \left [ w_{yy}^2 + 2 \epsilon^{2/3 } w_{xy}^2 + \epsilon^{4/3 } w_{xx}^2 \right]dx dy .
\label{eq : scaled } \end{aligned}\ ] ] our quest for rigorous scaling results for the energy @xmath63 reduces to the following show that the rescaled energy @xmath64 , of a minimizer @xmath65 , is bounded above and below by positive constants _ uniform _ in the dimensionless thickness parameter @xmath66 , as @xmath67 .
setting @xmath68 the rescaled quantities satisfy the boundary conditions @xmath69 and @xmath70 we have the lateral boundary conditions @xmath71 also , the deformation at @xmath72 satisfies @xmath73 and @xmath74 where @xmath75 .
in this section , we prove a lower bound for the linearized elastic energy in eq .
( [ eq : unscaled ] ) , provided that the length scale @xmath7 associated with the boundary conditions satisfies a size condition .
@xmath76 is as defined in eq .
( [ eq : unscaled ] ) .
there is a constant @xmath77 such that , for all @xmath78 and @xmath79 satisfying the boundary conditions @xmath80 and the size condition @xmath81}(|v_0(x)|,|w_0(x)| ) = a \leq b \sigma^{1/3 } l^{2/3 } \alpha^{2/3},\ ] ] we have the lower bound @xmath82 we will prove the theorem by proving the scaled version of the statement , _ viz .
_ , the rescaled boundary conditions along with the rescaled size condition @xmath83 imply that @xmath84 the hypothesis for the theorem includes a size condition on the displacement at @xmath33 .
this is somewhat unsatisfying , as it is not _ a priori _ obvious that a ridge in a `` real '' crumpled sheet will satisfy this condition . in our search for a lower bound
, we can assume @xmath85 w.l.o.g . from eq .
( [ eq : scaled ] ) , it follows that for @xmath86 , @xmath87 . by the standard trace theorems , the boundary conditions @xmath88 and
@xmath89 are therefore assumed pointwise for almost every @xmath90 . since @xmath91 at @xmath92
, it follows that @xmath93 . using this together with jensen s inequality we get @xmath94dx dy \nonumber \\ & \geq & \int_0^{\infty } \left [ \frac{1}{2 } \left ( \int_{-1}^1 w_x^2 dx \right)^2 + \int_{-1}^1 w_{yy}^2 dx \right ] dy \label{eq : onlyw}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the functional @xmath95 dy\ ] ] bounds @xmath96 from below .
hence it suffices to obtain a lower bound for @xmath97 with the given hypothesis to prove the theorem .
let @xmath98 and @xmath99 denote the quantities @xmath100 and @xmath101 although @xmath98 and @xmath99 are only lower bounds for the `` true '' bending and the stretching energies @xmath102 and @xmath103 , we will nonetheless call @xmath98 and @xmath99 the bending and the stretching energy for convenience . for every @xmath90 , we define @xmath104^{-1},\ ] ] and for every @xmath105 , we define @xmath106 since @xmath107 , @xmath108 ( a.e . ) and @xmath109 ( a.e . ) .
for any function @xmath110 depending on @xmath90 and @xmath105 , let @xmath111 denote @xmath112 , so that , @xmath113 @xmath114 is a `` local '' ( in @xmath90 ) measure of the bending energy , and @xmath115^{-1}$ ] can be thought of as the bending energy density in @xmath90 that is obtained by integrating out the @xmath105 dependence .
we can also think of @xmath114 as the length scale associated with the bending energy as a function of @xmath90 , _ viz .
_ , we expect that the bending energy density in @xmath105 decays rapidly for @xmath116 ( see fig .
[ fig : ridge ] ) .
likewise , @xmath117 ^ 2 $ ] is a local ( in @xmath105 ) measure of the stretching energy . in terms of @xmath114 and @xmath118 , the bending an
the stretching energies are given by @xmath119 ^ 2 dy.\ ] ] we now begin our proof of the theorem .
the idea behind the proof is to show that the stretching energy @xmath99 can be bounded from below by a negative power of the bending energy @xmath98 , so that the total energy @xmath120 tends to @xmath121 as @xmath122 and @xmath123 .
this ensures the existence of a positive lower bound for @xmath97 ( and consequently also for @xmath64 ) . for every @xmath105
, we have the inequality @xmath124 if @xmath108 , @xmath125 is a @xmath126 function by the sobolev embedding theorem and the boundary conditions imply that @xmath88 and @xmath127 . consequently ,
for such an @xmath90 , @xmath128 we will estimate @xmath129 from this equation using the elementary inequalities @xmath130 and @xmath131 for all @xmath132 . by our hypothesis on the boundary conditions , @xmath133 by jensen s inequality @xmath134 combining these estimates , we get @xmath135,\ ] ] for all positive @xmath136 and @xmath137 .
in particular , setting @xmath138 and @xmath139 yields @xmath140 integrating this inequality in @xmath90 we obtain @xmath141 proving the lemma .
our proof is based on demonstrating that a small bending energy @xmath98 will lead to a large stretching energy .
this idea is quantified by the following lemma where we use eq .
( [ eq : integral_bound ] ) to estimate the stretching energy @xmath99 from below in terms of the bending energy @xmath98 .
let @xmath142 there is a constant @xmath143 such that , if @xmath144 , the stretching energy @xmath99 satisfies @xmath145 [ lem : essential ] we have , @xmath146 by the poincare inequality .
( [ eq : integral_bound ] ) now yields @xmath147.\ ] ] we will now extract the appropriate scaling dependence of @xmath118 and @xmath99 on @xmath148 and @xmath98 . setting @xmath149 , we deduce that a characteristic scale @xmath150 for @xmath105 is given by @xmath151 rescaling @xmath105 in terms of @xmath150 , we obtain @xmath152,\ ] ] where @xmath153 is as defined above , _
i.e. _ @xmath154 making the change of variables @xmath155 , and using @xmath156 , we see that @xmath157 ^ 2 dy \geq \frac{\pi^4 \alpha^{14 } k(\mu)}{512 e_b^5},\ ] ] where @xmath158 ^ 2 dz.\ ] ] @xmath159 is clearly a continuous function of @xmath153 and @xmath160 .
since @xmath161 , there is an @xmath162 such that for all @xmath144 , @xmath163 .
the lemma follows
. we can now prove the theorem .
let @xmath164 .
the hypothesis imply @xmath165 if @xmath166 , there is nothing to prove .
therefore , we can assume that @xmath167 .
then , it follows that @xmath168 consequently @xmath169 . minimizing @xmath120
, we see that @xmath170 the theorem follows by `` undoing '' our rescaling to express the results in terms of @xmath171 and @xmath63 . in the appendix ,
we show that @xmath172 therefore , we can choose @xmath173 and @xmath174 .
we see that @xmath175 is not exceedingly small .
rather it is @xmath176 .
also , it is not the best constant for this theorem , and we can get a better value by optimizing our choices for the constants ( @xmath136 and @xmath137 which we set to be @xmath177 and @xmath15 respectively ) .
we have proved a rigorous lower bound for the elastic energy of a ridge that is consistent with the results obtained by lobkovsky @xcite using scaling arguments , and by lobkovsky @xcite using matched asymptotics . in order to prove these scaling laws rigorously , we also need analogous upper bounds that are consistent with the same scaling .
this approach has been used successfully for a variety of other variational problems @xcite .
the upper bound is usually obtained by constructing a test solution that yields the bound .
one is often guided by scaling arguments in the construction of the appropriate test solution .
this is in contrast to the lower bounds , where one needs to obtain functional analysis type inequalities that captures the competition between distinct energies in the problem ( _ e.g. _ lemma [ lem : essential ] ) .
it is this competition that determines the scaling behavior of the problem .
we have not constructed the upper bounds , because we believe that they will follow from the scaling ansatz in lobkovsky s work @xcite .
we also believe that the upper bound will scale in the same manner as the lower bound , thereby giving us a rigorous scaling law for the energy of a single ridge . as we remark before proving the theorem ,
our result is not directly applicable to the minimal ridge since we have the extra hypothesis @xmath178 we need to replace this restriction with a free boundary condition at @xmath33 subject to the symmetry requirement @xmath34 , and the boundary condition @xmath38 . despite this caveat
, we claim that the analysis in this paper captures the essential features of the minimal ridge problem , namely the scaling in lemma [ lem : essential ] , and consequently the scaling law for the energy of the ridge .
we will show that this is indeed the case by investigating the problem with the `` true '' boundary conditions elsewhere .
a harder problem is to show that the scaling laws also hold for a real crumpled sheet , where the forcing is not through clamping the boundaries to a frame , but rather through the confinement in a small volume . in this case , there are interesting global geometric and topological considerations , some of which are explored in refs .
@xcite and @xcite . as lobkovsky and witten
@xcite argue , the boundary condition that the deformation goes to zero far away from the ridge implies that the ridges do not interact with each other significantly .
the ridges can be considered the _ elementary excitations _ of a crumpled sheet . in our quest for upper and lower bounds
, this translates to the statement that the test solutions for the upper bound can be constructed by piecing together local solutions near each ridge .
thus the upper bound is obtained relatively easily .
the hard part is to show that the confinement actually leads to the formation of ridges , and that the competition between the bending and the stretching energy for this situation has the same form as in lemma [ lem : essential ] . in this context
, we expect that global topological considerations , as well as the non self - intersection of the sheet will play a key role in the analysis , as they do in the analysis of elastic rods ( one dimensional objects ) @xcite . as we note above , the blistering problem is described by the same elastic energy ( eq . ( [ eq : unscaled ] ) ) , but with different boundary conditions .
our results show an interesting contrast with results for the blistering problem .
ben belgacem _ et al .
_ have shown that @xcite , for an isotropically compressed thin film , the energy of the minimizer satisfies @xmath179 where @xmath4 is a typical length scale of the domain , and @xmath180 is the compression factor .
a construction for the upper bound strongly suggests that the minimizers develop an infinitely branched network with oscillations on increasingly finer scales as @xmath40 .
in contrast , our results indicate that the energy of a minimal ridge satisfies @xmath181 and the energy concentrates in a region of width @xmath182 .
this shows that the nature of the solution of the variational problem for the elastic energy in ( [ eq : unscaled ] ) depends very strongly on the boundary conditions .
in particular the very nature of the energy minimizers is different for the two problems for the blistering problems , as @xmath8 the minimizers develop a branched network of folds refining towards the boundary .
the minimizers therefore display the problem of small scale _ oscillations _ @xcite .
the minimal ridge problem on the other hand displays the _ concentration _
phenomenon @xcite as @xmath8 , with the energy concentrating on a region of width @xmath183 .
it would be interesting to explore this issue further , and in particular , to understand the mechanisms by which the boundary conditions determine the nature of the minimizer .
in this appendix , we prove the inequality @xmath158 ^ 2 dz \geq \frac{1}{105 } - \frac{\mu}{6}.\ ] ] let @xmath184 .
then , for @xmath185 , we have @xmath186 ^ 2 = f^2 - 2 \mu f + \mu^2 \geq f^2 - 2 \mu f.\ ] ] for @xmath187 , we have @xmath186 ^ 2 = 0 \geq f^2 - 2 \mu f.\ ] ] using these inequalities in the definition of @xmath159 we obtain @xmath188 ^ 2 - 2 \mu z^2 ( 1 - z ) dz \geq \frac{1}{105 } - \frac{\mu}{6}.\ ] ] i wish to thank brian didonna , bob kohn , l. mahadevan , stefan mller and tom witten for helpful and enlightening conversations .
this work was started during a visit to the max - planck institute for mathematics in the sciences in leipzig , and i would like to thank the mpi for their hospitality .
this work was supported in part by the national science foundation through its mrsec program under award number dmr-9808595 , and by a nsf career award dms-0135078 .
this work is also supported in part by a research fellowship from the alfred p. sloan jr . foundation .
10 h. ben belgacem , s. conti , a. desimone , and s. mller , `` energy scaling of compressed elastic films - three - dimensional elasticity and reduced theories , '' _ arch .
_ , vol . 164 , pp . 137 , 2002 . h. le dret and a. raoult , `` le modle de membrane non linaire comme limite variationnelle de llasticit non linaire tridimensionnelle , '' _ c. r. acad .
paris sr .
_ , vol . 317 , no . 2 , pp .
221226 , 1993 .
b. a. didonna , t. a. witten , s. c. venkataramani , and e. m. kramer , `` singularities , structures , and scaling in deformed @xmath190-dimensional elastic manifolds , '' _ phys .
e ( 3 ) _ , vol .
65 , no . 1 , part 2 , pp . 016603 , 25 , 2002 .
o. gonzalez , j. h. maddocks , f. schuricht , and h. von der mosel , `` global curvature and self - contact of nonlinearly elastic curves and rods , '' _ calc .
var . partial differential equations _ , vol .
14 , no . 1 ,
pp . 2968 , 2002 .
l. tartar , `` compensated compactness and applications to partial differential equations , '' in _ nonlinear analysis and mechanics : heriot - watt symposium , vol .
iv _ , pp . 136212 , boston , mass . : pitman , 1979 . | we study the linearized fpl
von karman theory of a long , thin rectangular elastic membrane that is bent through an angle @xmath0 .
we prove rigorous bounds for the minimum energy of this configuration in terms of the plate thickness @xmath1 and the bending angle .
we show that the minimum energy scales as @xmath2 .
this scaling is in sharp contrast with previously obtained results for the linearized theory of thin sheets with isotropic compression boundary conditions , where the energy scales as @xmath1 . |
the comparison of theoretical predictions with experimental data has confirmed the validity of the standard model ( sm ) in an impressive way .
the quantum effects of the sm have been established at the @xmath6 level , and the direct and indirect determinations of the top quark mass are compatible with each other . in spite of this success , the conceptual situation with the sm is not completely satisfactory for a number of deficiencies .
some of them are the large number of free parameters and the hierarchical fermion masses .
the sm contains three generations of quarks in irreducible representations of the gauge symmetry group @xmath7 .
the possibility of extending them has been studied in different frameworks @xcite-@xcite which are based either on a fourth generation sequential family , or on non - sequential fermions , regularly called exotic representations because they are different from those of the sm .
these unusual representations emerge in other theories , like the @xmath8 model where a singlet bottom type quark appears in the fundamental representation @xcite ; also , top - like singlets have been suggested in supersymmetric gauge theories@xcite .
the principal feature of a model which extends the quark sector with an exotic fermion is that there are new quark mixing phases in addition to the single phase of the sm .
therefore , in this kind of models @xmath9 boson mediated fcnc s arise at tree level .
this fact can affect the mixing mechanism in the neutral @xmath10-system @xcite-@xcite . the possibility of indirect consequences of singlet quark mixing for fcnc and cp violation has been used to get bounds on the flavor changing couplings .
heavy meson decays like @xmath11 and @xmath12 @xcite , @xcite , rare decays @xmath13 @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , measurements like @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 meson physics @xcite,@xcite , @xcite , or even @xmath18 , @xmath19 @xcite have been considered for this purpose . in the last years
, the lep and slc colliders have brought to completion a remarkable experimental program by collecting an enormous amount of electroweak precision data on the @xmath9 resonance .
this activity , together with the theoretical efforts to provide accurate sm predictions have formed the apparatus of electroweak precision tests @xcite .
we are interested in using the electroweak precision test quantities in order to get bounds on the mixing angles for additional fermions in exotic representations .
specifically , we want to consider models that include a new quark with charge @xmath20 which is mixed with the sm bottom quark .
this kind of new physics was taken into account by bamert , et .
@xcite during the discrepancy between experiment and sm theory in the @xmath3 ratio .
they analyzed a broad class of models in order to explain the discrepancy , and they considered those models in which new @xmath21 couplings arise at tree level through @xmath9 or @xmath22 quark mixing with new particles .
our presentation is based on the parametrization of the @xmath0 vertex in an independent model formulation .
therefore these results can be used for different quark representations like singlet down quark , vector doublets model , mirror fermions and self conjugated triplets , etc .
the parametrization of the vertex in a general way has been reviewed by barger et .
@xcite , @xcite as well as cotti and zepeda @xcite .
the lep precision test parameters that we use are the total @xmath9 width @xmath23 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
the procedure to get bounds on the mixing angles is the following .
first , we analyze the @xmath0 vertex as obtained after a rotation of a general quark multiplet ( common charge ) into mass eigenstates . in particular
, we write down the neutral current terms for the bottom quarks , which are assumed to be mixed . with these expressions
we can evaluate the tree level contribution to the process @xmath24 ; we enclose this new contribution within the coupling constants @xmath25 ( vectorial ) and @xmath26 ( axial ) .
we then write down @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 including the new contributions , and we obtain bounds on the new parameters by using the experimental values from lep and slc @xcite . finally , we do a @xmath27 analysis and find the allowed region in the plane of the new parameters @xmath28 and @xmath29 introduced .
we also use the result obtained by grossman et .
al . , involving @xmath30@xcite , in order to narrow down the bounds in the contour plots .
to restrict new physics , we will use parameters measured at the @xmath9 pole .
these parameters are the total decay width of the @xmath9 boson @xmath1 , the fractions @xmath31 and @xmath32 @xmath33 @xmath34 @xcite , @xcite . considering the new physics ( np ) and the sm couplings , we can write @xmath35 \nonumber \\ & \times & n_{c}r_{qcd+qed}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath36 is the number of colors , @xmath37 are the qcd and qed corrections , and @xmath38 is the kinematic factor @xcite with @xmath39 gev .
we also are taking into account the oblique and vertex contributions to @xmath40 giving by the top quark and higgs boson .
for our purpose , it is convenient to separate the sm and np contributions as follows : @xmath41 the symbol @xmath42 is given by : @xmath43 + 2\beta ^{2}\left [ \left ( g_{a}^{np}\right ) ^{2}+2g_{a}^{np}g_{a}^{sm}\right ] } { \left ( 3-\beta ^{2}\right ) \left ( g_{v}^{sm}\right ) ^{2}+2\beta ^{2}\left ( g_{a}^{sm}\right ) ^{2}}.\ ] ] this equation could be written using the new physics parameters @xmath44 that were introduced in the eq .
( [ npparam ] ) , through the relationships @xmath45 and @xmath46 similarly , the @xmath9 decay into hadrons after considering the np , can be written as : @xmath47 here , only @xmath48 gets np corrections because only the sm bottom mixes with the exotic quark .
therefore , the @xmath9 partial decay into @xmath49 and @xmath50 quarks remains unchanged . on the other hand
, @xmath1 is equal to @xmath51 which again is re - written , with the eq.([hadron ] ) , as follows : @xmath52 using the above equations , for @xmath53 and @xmath54 we obtain the following expressions : @xmath55 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in a general way , @xmath3 is mainly a measure of @xmath56 ; therefore , the fraction @xmath3 is very sensitive to anomalous couplings of the @xmath22 quark .
following closely the notation of ref .
@xcite , if we have a multiplet @xmath57 with @xmath58 ordinary fermions and @xmath59 exotic fermions with the same electric charge @xmath60 : @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the unitary matrix that rotates the mass eigenstate @xmath63 into the interaction eigenstate @xmath64 .
@xmath65 means ordinary or light ( exotic or heavy ) fermions .
@xmath62 can be further the composed as follows@xcite : @xmath66 where @xmath67 if we suppose that the up quark sector of the sm is diagonal and that there are no exotic quarks , then @xmath68 corresponds to the classical kobayashi - maskawa matrix . in the sm
this matrix is unitarity , whereas in our model it is not : @xmath69 @xmath70 corresponds to the mixing of the ordinary - exotic quarks .
as mentioned , @xmath71 is not quite unitary and the factor @xmath72 indicates flavor changing transitions in the light - light sector .
the neutral current lagrangian for the multiplet @xmath73 is given by @xmath74 where @xmath75 and @xmath76 are diagonal matrices which contain the couplings of the neutral @xmath77 gauge boson to the matter fields ; they have the form : @xmath78 where @xmath79 and @xmath80 are the matrices of the isospin charges and the electric charge , respectively . @xmath81 and @xmath82 are the standard and exotic weak isospin 3rd componend of the multiplets . using the unitarity relations of the @xmath83 matrix from the eq .
( [ equation3 ] ) , the product @xmath84 in eq .
( [ lagrangiano ] ) can be written as : @xmath85 the neutral current lagrangian in the light - light sector can be written as @xcite : @xmath86 where @xmath87 for the sm with three generations , @xmath88 are @xmath89 matrices .
they can be produced fc transitions at the tree level depending of @xmath90 entries which are the mixing angles of the ordinary and exotic fermions . in this work ,
we only consider one @xmath91 exotic quark ( i.e. not mixing with @xmath49 and @xmath50 ) .
then , @xmath62 and the @xmath92 product become : @xmath93 where @xmath94 represent the mixing between bottom quark with the exotic ones .
therefore , the coupling @xmath95 gets modified by the @xmath96 factors : @xmath97
with the expressions for @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 in terms of the new physics contribution in section 3 , and with the experimental data from lep we get bounds on the parameters @xmath4 introduced in eq .
( [ npparam ] ) .
the experimental data that we used for the lep parameters , as well as their sm values are in table 1 @xcite , @xcite .
we do a @xmath98 fit of the observables @xmath1 , @xmath99 and @xmath3 , and then we proceed to obtain bounds on the parameters @xmath100 by taking on values in the best region allowed for them at @xmath101 c.l . this region is displayed in the figure . in order to get a more restrictive region we use the bound @xmath102 obtained by grossman et.al .
@xcite , which is represented by straight lines in the figure .
the intersection between the two regions is given by : @xmath103 we note that for @xmath28 the region is more restrictive than the one obtained by grossman et .
@xcite , while the @xmath29 parameter is not modified .
if we consider only mixing between an exotic bottom quark with the third sm family , independent of any group representations , it is given by a @xmath104 unitary matrix for left- and right - handed fermions .
the couplings for several @xmath105 representations are given in table 2 .
we can use these bounds in order to get constraints for the left and right mixing angles of each model .
they are shown in table 3 . summarizing
, we have used the fractions @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 to obtain bounds on the mixing angles of new quark bottom - type representations with the sm bottom quark .
taking into account the results of grossman et .
al.@xcite , we have gotten the allowed intervals @xmath106 and @xmath107 .
our results reduce the allowed region for the parameter @xmath28 while the parameter @xmath108 is not modified with respect to the results obtained by grossman et .
we may note that the results have been obtained from the tree level contributions , and we can get bounds on the mass of the new quark using oblique corrections @xcite . y. nir and d. silverman , phys .
rev . d*42 * , 1477 ( 1990 ) ; nucl .
b345 * , 301 ( 1990 ) ; d. silverman , phys .
rev . d*45 * , 1800 ( 1992 ) ; int .
a * 11 * , 2253 ( 1996 ) ; phys .
rev . d*58 * , 095006 ( 1998 ) .
j. c*3 * , 1 ( 1998 ) .
f. del aguila and m. bowick , nucl .
phys * b224 * , 107 ( 1983 ) ; p. fishbane , r. norton and m. rivard , phys . rev .
d * 33 * , 2632(1986 ) ; w. buchmuller and m. gronau , phys .
b * 220 * , 641 ( 1989 ) . | we analyze the @xmath0 vertex in the framework of models that add a new bottom quark in a nonsequential way and we evaluate the tree level contribution to the lep / slc observables @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 .
we obtain bounds for the mixing angles from the experimentally allowed contour regions of the parameters @xmath4 introduced here . in order to get a more restrictive region ,
we consider the experimental results for @xmath5 as well .
pacs numbers : 12.15.ff , 12.15.-y , 12.15.ji , 12.60.-i |
at the heart of the quantum theory lies the fundamental principle of describing physically observable quantities as hermitian operators acting on hilbert space of quantum states .
generally these operators do not commute , a trait giving rise to the fundamental uncertainty principle first formulated by heisenberg .
the uncertainty principle characterizes the statistical spread of the distributions corresponding to two different observables .
if the operators representing the observables do not commute , the statistical variations of their observed distributions , frequently called uncertainties , can not generally be arbitrarily small in a given state . however , the statistical variation of a single observable is not limited in any way by the uncertainty principle . for
two given non - commuting observables , a state in which the lower limit of the uncertainty principle is reached is called a minimum uncertainty state . decreasing the uncertainty with respect to one observable results in the increase of the uncertainty of the other .
the transfer of uncertainty from one observable to another with respect to the minimum uncertainty values is referred to as squeezing .
the squeezing of quantum fluctuations was first studied and experimentally verified in quantum optics , where the components of quantized electric field served as the squeezed observables.@xcite since then the phenomenon has been observed in superconducting circuits,@xcite and more recently , there has been a promising efforts to realize the squeezing in nanomechanical structures.@xcite due to the technological advances , the development in mesoscopic physics has been rapid in last decades , and many interesting quantum phenomena have been experimentally verified for the first time . also a number of new and important measuring devices , necessary to observe elementary quantum phenomena , have been invented . in this paper
we study the phenomena of the quantum squeezing in a mesoscopic superconducting quantum interference device ( squid ) , with emphasis on the creation and consequences of the squeezing .
however , the squeezing is an example of a manipulation of quantum fluctuations which could have direct applications in a practical quantum measurement .
experimentally the squeezing of the quantum fluctuations has been demonstrated in microwave frequencies by constructing a josephson parametric amplifier,@xcite with a 40% reduction of the vacuum noise .
theoretically the squeezing has been studied in a similar squid ring we consider here.@xcite the squeezing mechanism we study is different from one studied in ref . which was based on a rapid decrease of an external magnetic flux to switch on the josephson coupling .
we consider a parametric instability in a harmonic regime,@xcite a well - known procedure to create the squeezing and applicable in various different systems.@xcite it can be realized with an elementary flux control in an rf squid . in the limit of a negligible dissipation
the magnitude of the squeezing is exponential in short times and , it rotates between the charge and the magnetic flux of the squid .
a strong dissipation compensates the resonant driving and leads to a rotating quasistationary state where uncertainties periodically go below their groundstate values .
we calculate the noise spectrum of periodic squeezed states and discuss the measurement problem by analyzing a setup where the squid is coupled to a transmission line .
the parametric resonance is a well - known physical phenomena in a classical harmonic oscillator ( ha).@xcite a periodic time - dependent perturbation can lead to large effects , which are most significant when the period of the perturbation is twice the resonance frequency . driven in resonance , the energy of the system grows exponentially in time .
this is true for a quantum ha also.@xcite in addition , starting the resonant driving from the groundstate of ha it results in a rapid squeezing of the uncertainties of the conjugate observables of ha .
consider the hamiltonian @xmath0 where @xmath1 and @xmath2 are the canonical variables @xmath3=i\hbar$ ] , @xmath4 is the mass constant and the time - dependent dependent perturbation is included in @xmath5 .
furthermore , let us assume that the time - dependent part can be treated as a perturbation , @xmath6 .
the groundstate of the free hamiltonian ( @xmath7 ) in the position representation is @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is an inverse square of the characteristic zero point length scale .
an approximate solution to the schrdinger equation corresponding to the hamiltonian of eq .
( [ parres ] ) and the initial condition @xmath10 can be obtained analytically in the gaussian form @xmath11 where @xmath12 with @xmath13 .
physically eq . ( [ ratk ] ) describes a wave packet centered at @xmath14 , but whose width oscillates in time with an exponentially growing amplitude .
when the statistical spread in the real space is the widest , the corresponding spread in the momentum space is the smallest . defining the dimensionless quantities @xmath15 and @xmath16 we discover that in the state ( [ ratk ] ) we have @xmath17\rangle|/2=1/2 $ ] and the state remains minimum uncertainty state at all times .
the individual deviations may be written as @xmath18 where @xmath19 . from eq .
( [ koalpha ] ) we obtain @xmath20 the maximum uncertainty oscillates with a frequency @xmath21 between the position and momentum . at the times corresponding to @xmath22 the squeezing is given by @xmath23 .
the solution ( [ ratk ] ) is very accurate as long as the condition @xmath24 holds .
if @xmath25 the analytical solution agrees excellently with the exact solution up to the squeezing factor 5 , see fig .
[ squeeze3 ] . after that the lower value does not decrease further as in the analytical solution even though the general agreement is accurate .
the above example illustrates the mechanism behind the squeezing scheme we will now apply to a flux - controlled rf squid loop described in fig .
[ squid ] .
the hamiltonian for the system can be written as @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the capacitance of the junctions , @xmath28 is the self - inductance of the loop and @xmath29 is the flux bias externally applied through the smaller loop.@xcite the quantities @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the canonical variables corresponding to the charge in the capacitor and the magnetic flux in the loop and satisfy the commutation relation @xmath32=i\hbar$ ] .
thus the magnetic flux @xmath31 plays the role of the position coordinate and the charge @xmath30 corresponds to the momentum in the standard one - particle quantum mechanics.the flux value corresponding to the oscillator length @xmath33 of the harmonic part of ( [ ham ] ) is @xmath34 , where @xmath35 .
( 100,160 ) ( -40,0 ) in time .
the parametric driving with a strength @xmath36 makes the uncertainty to oscillate with the frequency @xmath21 below and above the groundstate value marked by the black dashed line .
the blue line corresponds to the analytical solution , the red line to the exact numerical solution and the green line to the exact solution with the ac flux modulation ( [ ehto ] ) .
, title="fig : " ] we treat the josephson term as a perturbation and therefore consider the parameter range @xmath37 , where we have defined the josephson inductance as @xmath38 .
if the quadratic potential is strong , the flux particle is restricted to the linear regime of the squid and the term @xmath39 may be expanded to the second order .
supposing that the condition for the validity of the approximation @xmath40 is satisfied , the hamiltonian ( [ ham ] ) takes the form @xmath41 where @xmath42 with @xmath43 . in the cosine expansion
the small term constant in @xmath31 has been dropped from eq .
( [ hamsquid ] ) .
now we have established a connection between eqs .
( [ parres ] ) and ( [ hamsquid ] ) provided that the external magnetic flux is modulated according to @xmath44 .
this could be achieved by increasing the magnetic field linearly inside the control loop .
the temporal evolution of the squid starting from the groundstate is readily solved by identifying @xmath45 and @xmath46 and applying eqs .
( [ ratk ] ) and ( [ alpha ] ) .
the dimensionless operators @xmath47 and @xmath48 satisfy the minimum uncertainty condition @xmath49 and the individual deviations behave as those in eq .
( [ uncer ] ) .
the linearly increasing magnetic flux is inconvenient practically since the magnetic field should be restricted to the control loop and it is difficult to isolate at high field values . in addition , the ac fields are obtained and manipulated more easily . from the approximate equivalence @xmath50 can be inferred that if the magnetic flux is modulated with an ac field according to @xmath51 then @xmath52 .
hence the magnetic flux should be modulated at the resonance frequency such a way that its amplitude is roughly a half of the flux quantum . for later purposes it is convenient to introduce the second - quantized creation and annihilation operators in the photon number fock space .
the squid observables may be written as @xmath53 operators @xmath54 satisfy the usual bosonic commutation relations . in this language
the hamiltonian eq .
( [ hamsquid ] ) is transformed to @xmath55 where @xmath56 . in the case where expectation values of @xmath31 and @xmath30 vanish , as above , the root mean
square deviations may be written as @xmath57 ( 100,140 ) ( -30,0 ) and @xmath30 correspond to the magnetic flux through the main loop and the charge at the junctions .
the flux @xmath29 through the smaller loop is controlled by an external magnetic field.,title="fig : " ]
in this section we introduce a measuring scheme in which the squid is coupled to a transmission line ( tl ) which serves as a wave guide carrying the radiation away from the system .
it also plays a role of a generic measurement device which causes a markovian back - action to the measured system .
in addition , the tl provides a practical theoretical model for studying the environmental effects to the squeezing .
the study of a non - classical radiation requires a quantum - mechanical treatment of the squid and the tl .
quantum mechanics of a tl is essentially similar with a one - dimensional quantized electromagnetic field and it has been discussed in ref . .
( 100,100 ) ( -60,0 ) consider the system in fig .
[ linja ] where the squid is magnetically coupled to a tl .
the magnetic flux of the nearby squid penetrates into the tl .
the inductance and capacitance per unit length in the tl are @xmath58 and @xmath59 and the wave velocity is given by @xmath60 .
the lagrangian for the line can be written as @xmath61 where @xmath62 and @xmath63 are the local current and charge densities .
following ref .
we introduce a new variable @xmath64 which , together with the continuity equation , allows one to write the lagrangian @xmath65 from the total charge neutrality that it follows that @xmath66 , so @xmath67 can be expanded by the eigenmodes @xmath68 where @xmath69 and the lagrangian takes the form @xmath70 the quantization of the quadratic lagrangian ( [ lagrange3 ] ) is well known . the hamiltonian can be written as @xmath71 where @xmath72=i\hbar$ ] .
this can be further written with the help of bosonic creation and annihilation operators @xmath73 and @xmath74 as @xmath75 and the hamiltonian ( [ hamilton1 ] ) becomes @xmath76 the eigenfrequencies are defined as @xmath77 .
the voltage and current operators in the tl can be derived from @xmath67 as @xmath78 and @xmath79 .
the magnetic interaction between the squid and the tl couples the operators @xmath80 and @xmath81 , where @xmath82 and @xmath28 are the current and the inductance of the squid loop .
supposing that the squid couples to each mode approximately as strongly , the interaction may be written as @xmath83 where m is the mutual inductance between the squid and the field mode .
now we could proceed to two directions . on one hand
we could study the squid hamiltonian by trying to eliminate the transmission line variables ( and other possible environment modes ) . on the other hand we are interested in the tl output radiation to measure the squid .
the first problem leads to a master equation description of the squid and it will be studied in the next section . the latter problem will be pursued here . from the heisenberg equation of motion for the operators
@xmath73 we obtain @xmath84 which can be solved as @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the flux operator of the squid . from this expression
one can see that the tl problem can be solved as soon as the the solution to the associated squid problem is known .
the flux @xmath86 is the only squid variable entering to the expression ( [ hei2 ] ) and can be solved independently provided that the tl variables can be successfully eliminated from the squid dynamics . substituting the expression ( @xmath87 ) into the formula for the voltage of the tl @xmath88,\ ] ] we get @xmath89 where @xmath90 is the voltage operator of the free tl and
the second term is proportional to the retarded squid field .
deriving eq .
( [ voltage2 ] ) we have assumed that the level separation in the tl is much smaller than @xmath91 , so the tl will act as a waveguide and not as a resonator .
the current of the tl has a similar expression .
so far we have treated the squid as an ideal system without any dissipation and decoherence effects .
real mesoscopic systems are much larger than the systems usually studied in atomic and molecular physics and generally need to be considered as open quantum systems .
also an important source of decoherence is the quantum measurement process in which the system is necessarily coupled to the external world .
a state of an open quantum system can no longer be represented by simply a state vector making it necessary to introduce the density operator .
the dissipation , energy absorption and suppression of quantum coherence effects can be naturally discussed within the density operator approach . assuming that the level separation in the squid loop is significantly higher than the temperature of the environment @xmath92 , the dominating environmental effect is the spontaneous emission .
the dynamics of the density operator after the born - markov elimination of the electromagnetic field modes can be described by a lindblad master equation @xcite of the form @xmath93+\kappa(2a\rho
a^{\dagger}-a^{\dagger}a\rho -\rho a^{\dagger}a),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the first term is responsible for the hamiltonian evolution by the operator ( [ kakkosh ] ) and the second term describes the spontaneous emission into the tl , which is assumed not to bring any signal back to the squid .
the coefficient @xmath94 is related to the quality factor of the circuit by @xmath95 . in the case of a free squid
the @xmath30-factor can be as high as @xmath96 .
the coupling to the tl should decrease @xmath30 significantly to guarantee an efficient measurement of the squid .
the value of kappa can be estimated then as @xmath97 , where @xmath98 .
the disadvantage of decreased @xmath30 is the increased decoherence which is hostile to the squeezing process . starting from eq .
( [ lind ] ) it is possible to derive the equations of motion for the expectation values of the creation and annihilation operators , @xmath99 as well as for those of the quadratic operators @xmath100 these two present a closed set of equations .
the missing combination @xmath101 can be deduced from the commutation relation @xmath102=1 $ ] . by solving the above equation system
we obtain the uncertainties ( [ var ] ) .
the nature of solutions to the system ( [ systeemi ] ) depends on the relative magnitudes of @xmath94 and @xmath103 .
if @xmath104 , the dissipation will eventually compensate the resonant driving and the solutions are periodic and bounded .
otherwise the expectation values grow increasingly in time .
this , however , does not imply increasing squeezing of quantities ( [ var ] ) . in the presence of dissipation the lowest value of the fluctuations has a finite lower limit . by expanding the expectation values in eq .
( [ systeemi ] ) to a fourier series and truncating them to the fourth order , we found an accurate analytical form for the periodic solution . in the limit @xmath105 , the lower limit of the periodic
squeezing is about 0.75 times the vacuum value of @xmath106 and @xmath107 , see fig .
[ fluksiep ] .
( 120,120 ) ( -30,0 ) .
the blue curve is @xmath108 and the red curve @xmath109 .
the yellow and the green curves correspond to @xmath110 and @xmath111 respectively .
the black horizontal dashed line marks the groundstate value of @xmath108.,title="fig : " ] the nature of squeezed states in the presence of the dissipation is somewhat different from the pure squeezed states .
the pure squeezed states are linear combinations of the even photon number states .
the dissipation changes the spectral content so that the odd number photon states are also occupied .
the resulting state is no longer a minimum certainty state , see fig .
[ unpro ] .
( 120,120 ) ( -30,0 ) of the bounded periodic solutions @xmath112 ( blue ) , @xmath113 ( red ) and @xmath114 ( green ) .
the black horizontal dashed line marks the groundstate value of @xmath108 .
the minimum of the squeezing in the periodic solutions approaches to lower bound of about 0.75 times the groundstate value .
, title="fig : " ] in order to find the spectral properties of the signal radiated into the tl , we also need to evaluate two - time correlation functions , such as @xmath115 . according to the quantum regression formula @xcite , the function pair @xmath116 and @xmath117 obey the same differential equations than @xmath118 and @xmath119 for arbitrary operator @xmath120 .
choosing @xmath120 to @xmath121 we get @xmath122 for @xmath123 .
a similar pair of equations hold for @xmath124 and @xmath125 . solving eqs .
( [ qreg ] ) and the corresponding equations to the other pair , we can deduce an arbitrary second - order correlator in the whole time domain by using symmetries of the correlators .
( 120,120 ) ( -30,0 ) from the groundstate to the periodic steady state @xmath112 . after reaching the steady state , the uncertainty product oscillates with a frequency @xmath126 about the constant value.,title="fig : " ] an intuitive way to perceive
the squeezing phenomena is to plot the wigner function @xmath127 the wigner function is one of the quantum - mechanical analogues to the phase space probability distribution . even though it is not a genuine 2-dimensional probability distribution
, it has the property of giving the one - dimensional marginal distributions in arbitrary directions in the phase space @xmath128 and can therefore be used directly to illustrate the uncertainties of observables .
the groundstate of the squid has a circular symmetry which is distorted to an ellipse by squeezing , see fig .
[ wig1 ] . for ideal squeezed states the principal axes of elliptical contour lines
are inversely proportional reflecting the minimum uncertainty property .
the primary effect of the dissipation is to broaden the shorter axis resulting in an excess uncertainty .
( 100,150 ) ( -20,0 ) ( right ) in the @xmath129-plane .
the squeezed state rotates clockwise as indicated by the arrows .
the ellipse makes @xmath130 rotation in time @xmath131 .
, title="fig : " ] ( 100,100 ) ( 6,0 ) ( right ) in the @xmath129-plane .
the squeezed state rotates clockwise as indicated by the arrows .
the ellipse makes @xmath130 rotation in time @xmath131 .
, title="fig : " ]
based on eq . ( [ voltage2 ] ) the spectral properties of @xmath132
are directly related to spectral properties of @xmath31 and the free tl spectrum . here
we evaluate @xmath31-noise and , at the end of the section , discuss parameters relevant to the tl output noise .
the spectrum contains information about radiation emitted from the studied system . in ref .
an excitation of a two - level system with an energy splitting @xmath133 is considered as a spectrum analyzer .
the probability to detect the analyzer system in either of its states is proportional to @xmath134 at @xmath135 , where @xmath136 is an operator of the studied noise source which couples to the analyzer two - level system .
supposing that the system is in a steady state and the correlation time is short , the expression ( @xmath137 ) reduces to @xmath138 , where @xmath139 the expression ( [ spec1 ] ) is positive definite and determines the transition rates of the analyzer system . in the strong damping regime
the squid radiation is periodic and the steady - state expression ( [ spec1 ] ) is not appropriate as such .
rather , the detector rates are proportional to the time - averaged noise power @xmath140 where @xmath141 is the period of the motion . the expression ( [ spec2 ] ) generalizes ( [ spec1 ] ) in the sense that so defined spectrum is positive definite and gives excitation probabilities of the analyzer system in the long - time limit @xmath142 . since the squid couples to the tl with the operator @xmath143 , the @xmath144-spectrum is relevant in the tl radiation . from the time - averaged observables it is difficult to detect the squeezing directly .
this can be understood by considering the wigner function .
the fast rotation of the elliptic figure in fig .
[ wig1 ] averages out to a circular shape where no squeezing is present . the @xmath31-spectrum
( [ spec2 ] ) of the squid in parametric resonance resembles to a spectrum of a dissipative harmonic oscillator at finite temperature , see fig .
[ spect1 ] .
the spectrum displays peaks at frequencies @xmath145 and @xmath91 corresponding to emission and absorption processes .
a study of a fine structure also reveals weak resonance peaks at frequencies @xmath146 and @xmath147 .
these are the higher harmonics produced by the parametric driving process . in principle
there is also resonance at higher odd multiples of @xmath148 but they are extremely weak compared to @xmath145 and @xmath91 peaks .
the distance between the peaks is @xmath149 which characterizes the periodicity of the rotating squeezing .
( 100,260 ) ( -30,250)(a ) ( -20,130 ) of the periodic squeezed state @xmath150 .
the spectrum has resonances at frequencies @xmath151 .
( b ) the fine structure of spectrum ( a ) reveals the weak resonance peaks at @xmath152 .
, title="fig : " ] ( 95,145)@xmath153 $ ] ( 0,235 ) @xmath154 $ ] ( -30,120)(b ) ( -20,0 ) of the periodic squeezed state @xmath150 .
the spectrum has resonances at frequencies @xmath151 .
( b ) the fine structure of spectrum ( a ) reveals the weak resonance peaks at @xmath152 .
, title="fig : " ] ( 95,15)@xmath153 $ ] ( 0,100 ) @xmath154 $ ] the detailed analysis of squeezing can be performed in a phase - sensitive measurement . for that purpose
we define the rotating frame operators as @xmath155 and @xmath156 .
the rotating squid observables are defined analogously as @xmath157 and @xmath158 .
the rotating phase factors in @xmath159 and @xmath160 compensate the natural rotation of the harmonic creation and annihilation operators . in the new operators
the orientation of the squeezing is almost static and determined by the angle @xmath67 .
the wigner functions in fig .
[ wig1 ] appear frozen in time .
only a tiny time - dependent deformations resulting from the driving remains .
the noise varies periodically as a function of @xmath67 as the orientation of the squeezing is rotated , see fig .
[ rotspect1 ] . for a finite range of @xmath67
the squid noise goes below its groundstate value which is a direct evidence of reduction of the quantum fluctuations . for the parameters of fig .
[ rotspect1 ] , the groundstate noise at zero frequency is approximately 2.5 times higher than the minimum noise corresponding to @xmath161 .
the noise curves of squeezed states are slightly distorted respect to the origin , which indicates that there is a tiny asymmetry respect to the half axes of the ellipse in fig .
a parametric driving in the presence of a dissipation does not lead to a completely symmetric squeezing .
a phase - sensitive measurements can be realized , for example , with a help of a parametric amplification process.@xcite a harmonic modulation of the measurement signal with the frequency @xmath91 can be used to measure the rotating spectrum.@xcite ( 100,150 ) ( -30,0 ) of the squeezed state @xmath162 in the rotating operators .
the resonance peaks are now moved to the origin .
the initial time is chosen so that the minimum noise curve ( blue ) corresponds to @xmath161 .
the green , red and yellow curves correspond to the orientations @xmath163 respectively .
the black curve represents the groundstate noise .
the minimum noise curve remain below the groundstate noise , which is an evidence of squeezing.,title="fig : " ] ( 110,20)@xmath153 $ ] ( -10,120 ) @xmath154 $ ] the tl observables are sum of a free line observables and a retarded squid radiation contribution , see eq .
( @xmath164 ) .
the voltage noise of the tl is of the form @xmath165 , where @xmath166 is the vacuum noise of the tl .
the coupling constant @xmath167 depends on the actual material parameters and can be deduced from eq .
( [ voltage2 ] ) : @xmath168 where @xmath35 . for
the phenomenon to be measurable , the vacuum noise of the tl should not overwhelm the squid noise . from eq .
@xmath169 we can estimate the order of magnitude as @xmath170 . at low temperatures
the free tl vacuum noise is @xmath171 , where @xmath98 is the characteristic impedance of the tl .
then the relative effect is of order @xmath172 . for realistic values
@xmath173 , @xmath174 and @xmath175 the fraction becomes @xmath176 , which suggests that the squid noise is significant contribution to the tl output radiation in favorable conditions .
the parametric harmonic driving creates rotating squeezed quantum states in the squid ring .
if the environmental damping of the squid is negligible the squeezing of uncertainties is exponential for short times . in the presence of a strong damping
the magnitude of the squeezing is stationary .
the minimum uncertainty in the flux and charge go below the groundstate value periodically .
the phenomenon enables a quantum noise engineering which plays an increasingly important role in the quantum measurement theory as well as in the design of practical quantum devices . in principle , squeezed harmonic systems could be used as an ultra sensitive measurement devices of external perturbations coupled to it.@xcite the experimental creation of squeezed quantum states in a squid by a parametric driving is feasible with the current experimental methods .
we calculated the relevant noise properties of the periodic squeezed state . by introducing a coupling to the transmission line
, we analyzed the fully quantum mechanical emission spectrum of the squid and discussed briefly the conditions of an experimental verification of the phenomenon .
99 r. e. slusher , l. w. hollberg , b. yurke , j. c. mertz and j. f. valley , phys .
lett . * 55 * , 2409 ( 1985 ) .
r. loudon and p. l. knight , j. mod . opt . * 34 * , 709 ( 1987 ) b. yurke _
60 * , 764 ( 1988 ) .
et al . _ ,
a * 39 * , 2519 ( 1989 ) .
r. ruskov , k. schwab and a. n. korotkov , phys .
b * 71 * , 235407 - 1 ( 2005 )
. m. j. everitt _
et al . _ ,
a * 69 * , 043804 ( 2004 ) .
l. s. brown and l. j. carson , phys .
a * 20 * , 2486 ( 1979 ) .
i. averbukh , b. sherman , and g. kurizki , phys .
a * 50 * , 5301 ( 1994 ) .
l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , _ mechanics _ ( pergamon press , oxford , 1976 ) . yu .
makhlin , g. schn , a. shnirman , rev .
phys . * 73 * , 357 , ( 1999 ) .
r. schoelkopf , a. clerk , s. girvin , k. lehnert , and m. devoret in _ quantum noise in mesoscopic physics _ , ed .
v. nazarov , nato science series ii vol .
97 ( kluwer , dordrecht , 2003 ) ; h. j. carmichael , _ statistical methods in quantum optics 1 : master equations and fokker - planck equations _
( springer , berlin , 1999 ) . v. b. braginsky and f. ya .
khalili , _ quantum measurement _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1992 ) . | we study rotating squeezed quantum states created by a parametric resonance in an open harmonic system . as a specific realization of the phenomenon we study a mesoscopic squid loop where the state preparation procedure is simple in principle and feasible with currently available experimental methods . by solving dynamics and calculating spectral properties
we show that quantum fluctuations of squid observables can be reduced below their groundstate value .
the measurement is introduced by coupling the squid to a transmission line carrying the radiation to a secondary measurement device . besides the theoretical interest , our studies are motivated by an opportunity for a practical quantum noise engineering . |
the ability of light to influence the kinetic motion of microscopic and atomic matter has had a profound impact in the last three decades .
the optical manipulation of matter was first seriously studied by ashkin and co - workers in the 1970s @xcite , and led ultimately to the demonstration of the single beam gradient force trap @xcite , referred to as optical tweezers , where the gradient of an optical field can induce dielectric particles of higher refractive index than their surrounding medium to be trapped in three dimensions in the light field maxima @xcite .
much of ashkin s early work centered not on gradient forces , but on the use of radiation pressure to trap particles @xcite , and a dual beam radiation pressure trap was demonstrated in a which single particle was confined .
this work ultimately contributed to the development of the magneto - optical trap for neutral atoms @xcite .
recently we observed one - dimensional _ arrays _ of silica spheres trapped in a dual beam radiation pressure trap @xcite .
these arrays had an unusual property in that the particles that formed the array were regularly spaced from each other .
the particles were redistributing the incident light field , which in turn redistributed the particle spacings , allowing them to reside in equilibrium positions .
this effect , known as optically bound matter " was first realised in a slightly different context via a different mechanism to ours some years ago @xcite using a single laser beam and was explained as the interaction of the coherently induced dipole moments of microscopic spheres in an optical field creating bound matter . in the context of our study
optically bound matter is of interest as it relates to the way in which particles interact with the light field in extended optical lattices , which may prove useful for the understanding of three - dimensional trapping of colloidal particles @xcite .
indeed optically bound matter may provide an attractive method for the creation of such lattices that are not possible using interference patterns .
bound matter may also serve as a test bed for studies of atomic or ionic analogues to our microscopic system @xcite .
subsequent to our report a similar observation was made in an experiment making use of a dual beam fiber trap @xcite . in this latter paper
a theory was developed that examined particles of approximately the same size as the laser wavelength involved . in this paper
we develop a numerical model that allows us to simulate the equilibrium positions of two and three particles in a counter - propagating beam geometry , where the particle sizes are larger than the laser wavelength , and fall outside the upper bound of the limits discussed in @xcite .
the model can readily be extended to look at larger arrays of systems .
we discuss the role of the scattering and refraction of light in the creation of arrays . in the next section
we describe the numerical model we use for our studies and derive predictions for the separation of two and three spheres of various sizes .
we then compare this with both previous and current experiments .
= 1000 our model comprises two monochromatic laser fields of frequency @xmath0 counter - propagating along the z - axis which interact with a system of @xmath1 transparent dielectric spheres of mass @xmath2 , refractive - index @xmath3 , and radius @xmath4 , with centers at positions @xmath5 , and which are immersed in a host medium of refractive - index @xmath6 . the electric field is written @xmath7 , \label{efield}\ ] ] where @xmath8 is the unit polarization vector of the field , @xmath9 are the slowly varying electric field amplitudes of the right or forward propagating @xmath10 and left or backward propagating @xmath11 fields , and @xmath12 is the wavevector of the field in the host medium .
the incident fields are assumed to be collimated gaussians at longitudinal coordinates @xmath13 for the forward field and @xmath14 for the backward field @xmath15 where @xmath16 , @xmath17 is the initial gaussian spot size , and @xmath18 is the input power in each beam .
it is assumed that all the spheres are contained between the beam waists within the length @xmath19 .
consider first that the dielectric spheres are in a fixed configuration at time @xmath20 specified by the centers @xmath21 .
then the dielectric spheres provide a spatially inhomogeneous refractive index distribution which can be written in the form @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the heaviside step function which is unity within the sphere of radius @xmath4 centered on @xmath24 , and zero outside , and @xmath3 is the refractive - index of the spheres .
then , following standard approaches @xcite , the counter - propagating fields evolve according to the paraxial wave equations @xmath25 along with the boundary conditions in eq .
( [ bcond ] ) , where @xmath26 and @xmath27 is the transverse laplacian describing beam diffraction .
thus , a given configuration of the dielectric spheres modifies the fields @xmath9 in a way that can be calculated from the above field equations .
we remark that even though the spheres move , and hence so does the refractive - index distribution , the fields will always adiabatically slave to the instantaneous sphere configuration .
to proceed we need equations of motion for how the sphere centers @xmath21 move in reaction to the fields . the time - averaged dipole interaction energy @xcite , relative to that for a homogeneous dielectric medium of refractive - index @xmath6 , between the counter - propagating fields and the system of spheres
is given by @xmath28<\vec{e}^2 > \nonumber \\ & = & -\frac{\epsilon_0}{4}(n_s^2-n_h^2)\sum_{j=1}^{n}\int _ { } ^ { } dv\theta(r-|\vec{r}-\vec{r}_j(t)|)\left[|{\cal e}_+(\vec{r})|^2+|{\cal e}_-(\vec{r})|^2 \right ] , \label{u}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the angled brackets signify a time - average which kills fast - varying components at @xmath29 .
the most important concept is that the dipole interaction potential depends on the spatial configuration of the spheres @xmath30 since the counter - propagating fields themselves depends on the sphere distribution via the paraxial wave equations ( [ parax ] ) .
this form of the dipole interaction potential ( [ u ] ) shows explicitly that we pick up a contribution from each sphere labelled @xmath31 via its interaction with the local intensity . assuming over - damped motion of the spheres in the host medium with viscous damping coefficient @xmath32 , the equation of motion for the sphere centers become @xmath33 where @xmath34 signifies a gradient with respect to @xmath35 , and @xmath36 are the gradient and the scattering forces experienced by the j@xmath37 sphere , the latter of which we shall give an expression for below .
carrying through simulations for a 3d system with modelling of the electromagnetic propagation in the presence of many spheres poses a formidable challenge , so here we take advantage of the symmetry of the system to reduce the calculation involved .
first , for the cylindrically symmetric gaussian input beams used here we assume that the combination of the dipole interaction potential , and associated gradient force , and the scattering force supplies a strong enough transverse confining potential that the sphere motion remains directed along the z - axis .
this means that the positions of the sphere centers are located along the z - axis @xmath38 , and that the gradient and scattering forces are also directed along the z - axis @xmath39 .
second , we assume that the sphere distribution along the z - axis is symmetric around @xmath40 , the beam foci being at @xmath41 .
this means , for example , that for one sphere the center is located at @xmath40 , for two spheres the centers are located at @xmath42 , @xmath43 being the sphere separation distance , and for three spheres the centers are at @xmath44 . for three or less spheres the symmetric configuration of spheres is captured by the sphere spacing @xmath43 , and we shall consider this case here . for more than three spheres
the situation becomes more complicated and we confine our discussion to the simplest cases of two and three spheres . with the above approximations in mind the equations of motion for the sphere centers become @xmath45 at this point it is advantageous to consider the case of two spheres , @xmath46 , to illustrate how calculations are performed .
for a given distance @xmath43 between the spheres we calculate the counter - propagating fields between @xmath47 $ ] using the beam propagation method . from the fields we can numerically calculate the dipole interaction energy @xmath48 for a given sphere separation , and the resulting axial ( z - directed ) gradient force
is then @xmath49 .
thus , by calculating the counter - propagating fields for a variety of sphere separations we can numerically calculate the gradient force which acts on the relative coordinate of the two spheres . for our system
we approximate the scattering force @xcite along the positive z - axis for the j@xmath37 sphere as @xmath50 , \ ] ] with @xmath51 the scattering cross - section .
this formula is motivated by the generic relation @xmath52 for unidirectional propagation , with the scattered power @xmath53 , and @xmath54 the incident intensity .
the integral yields the difference in power between the two counter - propagating beams integrated over the sphere cross - section , and when this is divided by the sphere cross - sectional area @xmath55 we get the averaged intensity difference over the spheres . for the case of two spheres
we calculate the scattering force @xmath56 , evaluated at the position of the sphere at @xmath57 , and for a variety of sphere spacings @xmath43 .
a similar procedure can readily be applied to the case of three spheres .
the theory described above has some limitations that we now discuss .
first , we assume that the spheres are trapped on - axis by a combination of the scattering and/or dipole forces acting transverse to the propagation axis . for this to be possible
we require that the sphere diameter be less than the laser beam diameter @xmath58 .
furthermore , we have assumed paraxial propagation that neglects any large angle or back - scattering of the laser fields .
however , when light is incident on a sphere of diameter @xmath43 there is an associated wavevector uncertainty @xmath59 , and when @xmath60 back - scattering can occur , as it is within the uncertainty that an incident wave of wavevector @xmath61 along a given direction is converted into @xmath62 .
this yields the condition @xmath63 , with @xmath64 the free - space wavelength , to avoid back - scattering and so that our paraxial assumptions are obeyed .
our goal is to compare the axial gradient and scattering forces for an array of two and three spheres and compare with the experimental results .
however , the scattering cross - section for our spheres , which incorporates all sources of scattering in a phenomenological manner , can not be calculated with any certainty . our approach , therefore , will be to calculate the equilibrium sphere separation @xmath65 for the gradient and scattering forces separately , which does not depend on the value of the cross - section , and compare the calculated sphere separations with the experimental values . by comparing the theoretical predictions with the experiment for @xmath66 we can determine the dominant source of the axial force acting on the spheres .
to compare our theory with experiment we use data from our previous work @xcite and also recreate that experiment , but using a different laser wavelength and particle sphere size .
the previously reported experiment @xcite makes use of a continuous - wave 780 nm ti : sapphire laser , which is split into two beams with approximately equal power ( 25mw ) in each arms .
each of the beams is focussed down to a spot with a 3.5 @xmath67 beam waist and then passed , counterpropagating , through a cuvette with dimensions of 5 mm x 5 mm x 20 mm .
the beam waists were separated by a finite amount , which is discussed further below .
uniform silica spheres with a 3@xmath67 diameter ( bangs laboratories , inc ) in a water solution were placed in the cuvette , and the interaction of the beams with the sample caused one - dimensional arrays of particle to be formed .
the refractive index of the spheres is approximately 1.43 .
we also carried out a similar experiment using a 1064@xmath68 nd : yag laser where the beam waists were 4.3@xmath67 and we used 2.3@xmath67 diameter spheres .
the particles were viewed by looking at the scattered light orthogonal to the laser beam propagation direction viewed on a ccd camera with an attached microscope objective ( x20 , na=0.4 , newport ) . to compare our theory with experimental results we need to concentrate on a small number of parameters , the sphere size , the beam waist , the refractive index of the spheres and the beam waist separation .
we know the particle sizes and can make a good estimate as to their refractive index , further we can measure the beam waist to a high degree of accuracy .
the only problematic factor is the beam waist separation . due to experimental constraints
, this is quite difficult to measure .
we estimate the waist separation by filling the cuvette with a high density particle solution and looking at the scattered light from the sample .
the high density of particle allows us to map out the intensity pattern of the two beams and hence make an estimate as to the waist separation .
this is , however , an inaccurate method and leaves us with an error of more than 100% .
we therefore use our model to help us fix the beam waist separation on a single result and then examine the behavior of the model when varying other parameters .
the error in the beam waist separation is not as extreme as first it sounds however . modelling the system for a range of beam waist separations from 80@xmath69 m to 200@xmath69 m results in a predicted range of sphere separations as shown in figure 1 , 2.3@xmath69 m diameter spheres .
we see that although initially the beam waist separation difference makes a reasonable difference to the predicted sphere separation the region that we believe we are working in , @xmath70 m waist separation , is relatively flat
. therefore even if we do have a large error in this value , the predicted result does not vary significantly .
this increases our confidence that we have the correct beam waist separation with a higher uncertainty that our experimental measurements of this parameter suggests .
we begin by examining the case of the 2.3 @xmath67 diameter spheres .
the rate of change of sphere separation is seen to drop off as the waist separation increases .
the fit to a parabola is to aid the eye , rather than to suggest a quantitative relationship.,width=302 ] we consider the case for chains of both two and three spheres . for two spheres
we measure a sphere separation of 34@xmath67 , for a beam waist , @xmath71 at a laser wavelength , @xmath72 . using a beam waist separation of @xmath73
our model predicts an equilibrium in the scattering force of 34@xmath74 , as is shown in figure 2 .
the intensity in the x - z plane for this configuration is shown in figure 3 .
we see no such equilibrium in the gradient force , shown in figure 4 and conclude that the scattering force is the dominant factor in this instance . using the same parameters for the three sphere case give us a sphere separation prediction of 62@xmath67 , as shown in figure 5 .
again this dominates over the gradient force , this assumption being valid , as the theory gives a good prediction of our experimental observations .
our experimental result is 57@xmath67 , but we estimate our model value falls within the standard deviation error we observe on our experimental measurements . diameter silica spheres with the beam waists 180 @xmath67 apart .
@xmath75 and @xmath72.,width=302 ] diameter silica spheres with the beam waists 180 @xmath67 apart .
@xmath75 and @xmath72.,width=302 ] diameter silica spheres with the beam waists 180 @xmath67 apart .
@xmath75 and @xmath72.,width=302 ] diameter silica spheres with the beam waists 180 @xmath67 apart .
@xmath76 and @xmath72 .
the plot shows the separation between two of the three spheres , and the scattering forces are symmetric about the center sphere.,width=302 ] the data for 3 micron spheres carried out at a different wavelength than the 2.3 @xmath67 data ( @xmath77 ) also fits well with our theory . for two spheres , with
the beam waists @xmath78 apart , we predict a sphere separation of 47@xmath67 ( figure 6 ) while our experiment predicts a distance of 45@xmath67 . using the same parameters for the three sphere case we predict a sphere separation of 27@xmath67 ( figure 7 ) , while our experiment shows a separation of 35@xmath67 . again , as we predict equilibrium positions with the scattering force component , but not with the gradient force component , we conclude that the scattering force is the dominant factor in determining the final sphere separations . diameter silica spheres with the beam waists 150 @xmath67 apart .
@xmath71 and @xmath77.,width=302 ] diameter silica spheres with the beam waists 150 @xmath67 apart .
@xmath79 and @xmath77 .
the plot shows the separation between two of the three spheres , and the scattering forces are symmetric about the center sphere.,width=302 ]
our model accurately predicts separations for the case of two and three spheres , at certain sizes .
however we also performed experiments using @xmath80 diameter spheres and could not find any agreement between experiment and theory .
since our model uses a paraxial approximation , the assumption is that in these smaller size regimes the model breaks down .
this in contrast to the work detailed in @xcite which works in size regimes closer to the laser wavelength , @xmath64 , and begins to break down in the larger size regimes ( @xmath81 ) , where @xmath82 is the sphere diameter .
we also note that the beam separation distance becomes less critical as it becomes larger . for small beam waist separation distances ( @xmath83 ,
say ) , any change in this parameter leads to a sharp change in the sphere separation distance , whereas at the waist separation distances we work at the change in sphere separation distance is far more gentle , and hence gives less rise to uncertainty over exact fits with theory and experiment .
the other main parameter is sphere size , which has an appreciable effect on the predicted sphere separation .
the incident power on the spheres does not make much of a difference and is more of a scaling factor in the forces involved rather than a direct modifier in the model . predicted sphere separation is also sensitive to the refractive index difference between the spheres and the surrounding medium , so it is important that the spheres refractive index is well known .
it should also be possible to create two - dimensional and possibly three dimensional arrays from optically bound matter .
the extension to two dimensions is relatively simple to envisage with the use of multiple pairs of counterpropagating laser beams . in three dimensions
the formation of such optically bound arrays may circumvent some of the problems associated with loading of three - dimensional optical lattices @xcite .
it is often assumed that the creation of an optical lattice ( via multibeam interference , say ) will allow the simple , unambiguous trapping of particles in all the lattice sites , thereby making an extended three - dimensional array of particles .
such arrays may be useful for crystal template formation @xcite and in studies of crystallization processes @xcite .
however crystal formation in this manner is not particularly robust in that as the array is filled the particles perturb the propagating light field such that they prevent the trap sites below them being efficiently filled
. arrays of optically bound matter do not suffer from such problems , as they are organized as a result of the perturbation of the propagating fields .
further the fact that the particles are bound together provides more realistic opportunities for studying crystal and colloidal behaviour than that in unbound optically generated arrays , such as those produced holographically @xcite .
we have developed a model by which the propagation of counter - propagating lasers beams moving past an array of silica spheres may be examined .
analysis of the resulting forces on the spheres allows us to predict the separation of the spheres which constitute the array .
we have compared this model with experimental results for different beam parameters ( wavelength , waist separation , waist diameter ) and found the results to be in good agreement with our observations .
the model , does not however , work with sphere sizes much less than approximately twice the laser wavelength .
our model is readily extendable to larger number of spheres , and will be of great use in the study of such one- and higher - dimensional arrays of optically bound matter .
dm is a royal society university research fellow .
this work is supported by the royal society and the uk s epsrc . | counter - propagating light fields have the ability to create self - organized one - dimensional optically bound arrays of microscopic particles , where the light fields adapt to the particle locations and vice versa .
we develop a theoretical model to describe this situation and show good agreement with recent experimental data ( phys .
rev .
lett .
89 , 128301 ( 2002 ) ) for two and three particles , if the scattering force is assumed to dominate the axial trapping of the particles .
the extension of these ideas to two and three dimensional optically bound states is also discussed . |
all our graphs are finite and without loops or multiple edges .
let @xmath0 be a plane graph .
we use @xmath11 , @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and @xmath15 to denote the edge set , vertex set , face set , maximum degree , and minimum degree of @xmath0 , respectively .
when the graph is clear from context , we use @xmath16 , rather than @xmath14 .
we use `` @xmath17-face '' and `` @xmath17-vertex '' to mean faces and vertices of degree @xmath17 .
the degree of a face @xmath18 is the number of edges along the boundary of @xmath18 , with each cut - edge being counted twice .
the degree of a face @xmath18 and the degree of a vertex @xmath19 are denoted by @xmath20 and @xmath21 .
we say a face @xmath18 or vertex @xmath19 is _ large _
when @xmath22 or @xmath23 .
we use _ triangle _ to mean 3-cycle .
we use _ kite _ to mean a subgraph of @xmath0 formed by two 3-cycles that share an edge .
we use _ element _ to mean vertex or face .
a _ proper total - coloring _ of @xmath0 is an assignment of a label to each element so that no two incident or adjacent elements receive the same label .
we call these labels _ colors_. a _
proper @xmath24-total - coloring _ is a proper total - coloring that uses no more than @xmath24 colors .
a _ total assignment _
@xmath25 is a function on @xmath26 that assigns each element @xmath27 a list @xmath28 of colors available for use on that element .
@xmath25-total - coloring _ is a proper total - coloring with the additional constraint that each element receives a color appearing in its assigned list .
we say that a graph @xmath0 is _ @xmath24-total - choosable _ if @xmath0 has a proper @xmath25-total - coloring whenever @xmath29 for every @xmath30 . the _ total chromatic number _ of @xmath0 , denoted @xmath31 ,
is the least integer @xmath24 such that @xmath0 is @xmath24-total - colorable .
the _ list total chromatic number _ of @xmath0 , denoted @xmath32 , is the least integer @xmath24 such that @xmath0 is @xmath24-total - choosable .
in particular , note that @xmath33 .
list edge chromatic number _
@xmath34 is defined similarly in terms of coloring only edges ; the ordinary edge chromatic number is denoted @xmath35 .
probably the most fundamental and important result about the edge chromatic number of graphs is : ( vizing s theorem ; vizing @xcite and gupta @xcite ) [ vizing - thm ] @xmath36 vizing conjectured that theorem [ vizing - thm ] could be strengthened by proving the same bound for the list edge chromatic number : ( vizing s conjecture ; see @xcite ) [ vizing - conj ] @xmath37 the most famous open problem about list edge - coloring is the list coloring conjecture .
bollobs and harris @xcite believed that vizing s conjecture could be further strengthened to give : ( list coloring conjecture ; bollobs and harris @xcite ) [ lcc ] @xmath38 we give a brief summary of previous results on list edge - coloring ; for a more thorough treatment , we recommend _ graph coloring problems _
borodin , kostochka , and woodall @xcite proved that the list coloring conjecture holds for planar graphs with @xmath39 .
vizing s conjecture is easy to prove when @xmath40 .
harris @xcite and juvan et al .
@xcite confirmed the conjecture when @xmath41 and @xmath42 , respectively .
borodin proved vizing s conjecture for planar graphs with @xmath43 @xcite .
wang and lih @xcite proved that vizing s conjecture holds for a planar graph @xmath0 when @xmath44 and @xmath0 has no two triangles sharing a vertex .
zhang and wu @xcite proved that vizing s conjecture holds for a planar graph @xmath0 when @xmath44 and @xmath0 has no 4-cycles .
we improve these results in several ways . in section 2
, we prove structural results for use in section 4 and section 5 , where we prove our main results . for simplicity , we state each of our results only for planar graphs . however , in section 3 we show that each result can be extended to the projective plane and that most of the results can also be extended to the torus and klein bottle . in section 4 , we show that vizing s conjecture holds for a planar graph that contains no kites and has @xmath44 .
this is a strengthening of the result of wang and lih @xcite and the result of zhang and wu @xcite .
we also show that the list coloring conjecture holds for a planar graph that contains no kites and has @xmath43 . in section 5
we prove results about list total coloring , which we describe below .
less is known about the total chromatic number than the edge chromatic number .
vizing and behzad conjectured an analogue to vizing s theorem : ( total coloring conjecture ; vizing @xcite and behzad @xcite ) @xmath45 the total coloring conjecture was proved for @xmath41 by rosenfeld @xcite and also by vijayaditya @xcite . for @xmath46 and @xmath47
it was proved by kostochka @xcite . for planar graphs , much more
borodin @xcite proved the total coloring conjecture for @xmath43 .
yap @xcite observed that the cases of the total coloring conjecture when @xmath48 or @xmath49 follow from a short argument that uses the 4-color theorem and the fact that @xmath50 for planar graphs when @xmath51 .
borodin , kostochka , and woodall @xcite showed that @xmath52 for @xmath39 .
the list total chromatic number seems to have been relatively unstudied until borodin , kostochka , and woodall conjectured the following : ( total list coloring conjecture ; borodin , kostochka , woodall @xcite ) @xmath53 for a planar graph with @xmath54 , they showed the stronger result @xmath55 .
we note that borodin s proof of the total coloring conjecture for planar graphs with @xmath1 in fact shows that @xmath56 .
almost all of our proofs for @xmath34 can easily be adapted to give results for @xmath32 .
again , we consider planar graphs with no kites . in section 5
, we show that if @xmath43 , then @xmath57 .
we also show that if @xmath58 , then @xmath56 .
before we prove structural results about planar graphs with no kites , we mention a theorem of o.v . borodin .
( borodin @xcite ) [ borodin2thm ] let @xmath0 be a plane graph with no kites .
the following statements are valid and all numerical parameters are best possible .
1 . @xmath59 ; 2 . if @xmath60 , then there are adjacent vertices @xmath27 , @xmath61 such that @xmath62 ; 3 . if @xmath60 , then there is either an @xmath63-face where @xmath64 or 10-face incident with ten 3-vertices and adjacent to five triangles . we will not directly use theorem [ borodin2thm ] , although part ( ii ) is very similar to some of our lemmas .
[ delta7 ] if graph @xmath0 is planar , @xmath0 contains no kites , and @xmath0 has @xmath65 , then @xmath0 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath9 and @xmath66 .
assume @xmath0 is a counterexample .
clearly , @xmath60 ; furthermore , each 3-vertex is only adjacent to @xmath16-vertices .
we use a discharging argument .
we assign to each element @xmath27 an initial charge @xmath67 .
the initial charges have sum @xmath68 .
we use the following two discharging rules , applied simultaneously at all vertices and faces in a single discharging phase : * * * each large vertex gives a charge of @xmath69 to each incident triangle .
* * each @xmath16-vertex gives a charge of @xmath70 to each adjacent 3-vertex . to reach a contradiciton ,
we show that for every element the new charge @xmath71 is nonnegative .
consider an arbitrary face @xmath18 . *
if @xmath72 , then at least two of the vertices incident to @xmath18 are large ; otherwise , we have @xmath73 . thus @xmath74 . *
if @xmath75 , then @xmath76 .
consider an arbitrary vertex @xmath19 .
* if @xmath77 , then @xmath78 , since each neighbor of @xmath19 is a @xmath16-vertex .
* if @xmath79 , then @xmath80 . * if @xmath81 , then @xmath19 is incident to at most 2 triangles , so @xmath82 . * if @xmath83 , then @xmath19 is incident to at most @xmath84 triangles . thus @xmath85 . * if @xmath86 , then let @xmath87 be the number of triangles incident to @xmath19 . for each triangle incident to @xmath19 , at most one of the vertices of that triangle has degree 3 .
thus , if @xmath19 is incident to @xmath87 triangles , then @xmath88 .
since @xmath89 , we get @xmath90 .
this expression is positive when @xmath91 .
we will use theorem [ delta7 ] to show that any planar graph with @xmath58 that contains no kites is @xmath92-edge - choosable .
we would also like to prove an analogous result for the case @xmath93 . to prove such a result , we need the following structural lemma .
we say that a triangle is of _ type _
@xmath94 if its vertices have degrees @xmath95 and @xmath96 .
[ delta6 ] if graph @xmath0 is planar , @xmath0 contains no kites , and @xmath97 , then at least one of the three following conditions holds : 1 .
@xmath0 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath98 .
2 . @xmath0 has a 4-face @xmath99 with @xmath100 .
@xmath0 has a 6-vertex incident to three triangles ; two of these triangles are of type @xmath101 and the third is of type @xmath101 , @xmath102 , or @xmath103 .
assume @xmath0 is a counterexample .
for every edge @xmath8 , @xmath0 must have @xmath104 .
thus , @xmath60 . we use a discharging argument .
we assign to each element @xmath27 an initial charge @xmath67 .
we use the following three discharging rules : * * * each large face @xmath18 gives a charge of @xmath69 to each incident 3-vertex . * * each 5-vertex @xmath19 gives a charge of @xmath69 to each incident triangle .
* * each 6-vertex @xmath19 * * * gives a charge of @xmath70 to each adjacent 3-vertex that is not incident to any large face .
* * * gives a charge of @xmath105 to each adjacent 3-vertex that is incident to a large face .
* * * gives a charge of @xmath69 to each incident triangle that is incident to a 3-vertex or a 4-vertex .
* * * gives a charge of @xmath70 to each incident triangle that is not incident to a 3-vertex or a 4-vertex .
now we show that for every element the new charge @xmath71 is nonnegative .
consider an arbitrary face @xmath18 . *
if @xmath72 , then we consider two cases . if @xmath18 is incident to a 3-vertex or a 4-vertex , then @xmath106 . if @xmath18 is not incident to a 3-vertex or a 4-vertex , then @xmath107
* if @xmath108 , then @xmath109 . *
if @xmath110 , then @xmath111 .
* if @xmath112 , then @xmath113 .
consider an arbitrary vertex @xmath19 . *
if @xmath77 , then we consider two cases . if @xmath19 is incident to a large face , then @xmath114 . if @xmath19 is not incident to a large face , then @xmath78 .
* if @xmath79 , then @xmath80 . *
if @xmath81 , then @xmath82 .
* if @xmath115 , then we consider separately the four cases where @xmath19 is incident to zero , one , two , or three triangles .
note that if @xmath19 is incident to @xmath87 triangles , then the number of 3-vertices adjacent to @xmath19 is at most @xmath116 .
* * if @xmath19 is incident to no triangles , then @xmath117 .
* * if @xmath19 is incident to one triangle , then we consider two cases . if @xmath19 is adjacent to at most four 3-vertices , then @xmath118 .
if @xmath19 is adjacent to five 3-vertices , then two of these adjacent 3-vertices lie on a common face , together with @xmath19 . since condition ( ii ) of the present lemma does not hold , this face must be a large face .
so @xmath119 .
* * if @xmath19 is incident to two triangles , then we consider two cases .
if @xmath19 is adjacent to at most three 3-vertices , then @xmath120 . if @xmath19 is adjacent to four 3-vertices , then two of these adjacent 3-vertices lie on a common face , together with @xmath19 . since condition ( ii ) of the present lemma
does not hold , this face must be a large face .
so @xmath121 .
* * if @xmath19 is incident to three triangles , then we consider two cases .
if at most one of the triangles is type @xmath101 , then @xmath122 .
furthermore , if two of the triangles incident to @xmath19 are type @xmath101 but the third triangle is not incident to any vertex of degree at most 4 , then @xmath123 . if two of the triangles are of type @xmath101 and the third triangle is incident to a vertex of degree at most 4 , then condition ( iii ) of the lemma holds
. we will apply theorem [ delta7 ] and lemma [ delta6 ] to get our first result about edge - choosability . to prove the @xmath92-edge - choosability of a planar graph @xmath0 that has @xmath44 and that contains no kites , we remove one or more edges of @xmath0 , inductively color the resulting subgraph , then extend the coloring to @xmath0 . intuitively , theorem [ delta7 ] and lemma [ delta6 ] do the `` hard work . ''
however , it is still convenient to prove the following lemma , which we will apply to the subgraphs of @xmath0 that arise from this process .
[ delta5 - 6 ] let @xmath0 be a planar graph that contains no kites .
if @xmath124 , then @xmath0 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath125 . if @xmath93 , then @xmath0 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath126 . if @xmath127 , then each edge @xmath8 satisfies @xmath128 .
in that case , the lemma holds trivially .
if @xmath93 , then the result follows from @xmath129 of theorem [ borodin2thm ] .
so we must prove the lemma for the case @xmath130 .
we use a discharging argument .
assume @xmath0 is a counterexample .
for every edge @xmath8 , @xmath0 must have @xmath131 .
thus , @xmath132 . we assign to each element @xmath27 an initial charge @xmath67 .
we use a single discharging rule : * * * every large vertex @xmath19 gives a charge of @xmath69 to each incident triangle .
now we show that for every element the new charge @xmath71 is nonnegative .
consider an arbitrary face @xmath18 . * if @xmath133 , then @xmath18 is incident to at least two large vertices , so @xmath74 . * if @xmath75 , then @xmath134 .
consider an arbitrary vertex @xmath19 . * if @xmath79 , then @xmath135 . * if @xmath81 , then @xmath136 .
note that the case when @xmath93 in lemma [ delta5 - 6 ] follows easily from ( ii ) in theorem [ borodin2thm ] ; however , we reproved it above because in section 3 we will adapt the proof of lemma [ delta5 - 6 ] to the projective plane , torus , and klein bottle .
before we state the next theorem , we need a new definition .
a @xmath137 is an even cycle @xmath138 with @xmath139 .
this definition was introduced by borodin in 1989 @xcite . since then
, it has been used to prove many coloring results ( for example , @xcite ) .
[ delta9 ] if graph @xmath0 is planar , @xmath0 contains no kites , and @xmath43 , then at least one of the following two conditions holds : 1 .
@xmath0 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath9 and @xmath140 .
2 . @xmath0 has a @xmath141-alternating cycle @xmath142 .
assume @xmath0 is a counterexample . clearly , @xmath143 .
our proof will use a discharging argument , but first we show that if @xmath0 is a counterexample to theorem [ delta9 ] , then @xmath0 has more @xmath16-vertices than 2-vertices .
let @xmath144 be the subgraph of @xmath0 formed by all edges with one endpoint of degree 2 and the other endpoint of degree @xmath16 .
form @xmath145 from @xmath144 by contracting one of the two edges incident to each vertex of degree 2 ( recall that each neighbor of a 2-vertex in @xmath0 is a @xmath16-vertex ) .
each 2-vertex in @xmath0 corresponds to an edge in @xmath145 and each vertex in @xmath145 corresponds to a @xmath16-vertex in @xmath0 .
so @xmath0 has more @xmath16-vertices than 2-vertices unless @xmath146 . if @xmath146 , then @xmath145 contains a cycle .
however , a cycle in @xmath145 corresponds to a 2-alternating cycle in @xmath0 .
such a cycle in @xmath0 satisfies condition ( ii ) and shows that @xmath0 is not a counterexample to theorem [ delta9 ] .
so , @xmath0 has more @xmath16-vertices than 2-vertices .
we assign to each element @xmath27 an initial charge @xmath67 .
in addition to the vertices and edges , we create a _ bank _ that can give and receive charge .
the bank has initial charge 0 . as with the vertices and edges
, we must verify that the final charge of the bank is nonnegative .
we use the following three discharging rules : * each @xmath16-vertex and @xmath147-vertex @xmath19 gives a charge of @xmath70 to each adjacent 2-vertex or 3-vertex . *
each large vertex @xmath19 gives a charge of @xmath69 to each incident triangle .
* each @xmath16-vertex gives a charge of @xmath148 to the bank .
+ each 2-vertex takes a charge of @xmath148 from the bank . the only rule that effects the bank s charge is ( r3 ) . since @xmath0 has more @xmath16-vertices than 2-vertices , the bank s final charge is positve .
now we show that for every element the new charge @xmath71 is nonnegative .
consider an arbitrary face @xmath18 . * if @xmath72 , then since at least one endpoint of each edge is large , at least two of the vertices incident to @xmath18 are large . thus @xmath74 .
* if @xmath75 , then @xmath76 .
consider an arbitrary vertex @xmath19 . * if @xmath149 , then @xmath150 . * if @xmath77 , then @xmath78 .
* if @xmath79 , then @xmath80 . *
if @xmath81 , then @xmath19 is incident to at most 2 triangles , so @xmath82 . * if @xmath151 , then @xmath19 is incident to at most @xmath152 triangles .
thus @xmath153 .
* if @xmath154 , then let @xmath87 be the number of triangles incident to @xmath19 .
for each triangle incident to @xmath19 , at most one of the vertices of that triangle has degree 3 .
thus , if @xmath19 is incident to @xmath87 triangles , then @xmath155 .
since @xmath89 , we get @xmath156 .
this expression is positive when @xmath157 . *
if @xmath86 , then let @xmath87 be the number of triangles incident to @xmath19 . for each triangle incident to @xmath19 , at most one of the vertices of that triangle has degree 3 .
thus , if @xmath19 is incident to @xmath87 triangles , then @xmath158 .
since @xmath159 , this expression is nonnegative when @xmath160 .
each of the proofs in section 2 only used planarity to show that the sum of the initial charges is less than 0 .
thus , each of the proofs also holds for the projective plane ( for which @xmath161 ) .
the proofs also `` almost '' hold for the torus and the klein bottle ( for both surfaces @xmath162 ) .
thus , to complete the proofs for the torus and the klein bottle , it is sufficient to show that after the discharging at least one element has strictly positive charge . in theorem
[ delta7 ] , each vertex of degree @xmath16 has positive charge . in theorem
[ delta9 ] , the bank has positive charge . in lemma
[ delta5 - 6 ] , when @xmath93 , each vertex of degree @xmath16 has positive charge .
since we can not prove lemma [ delta5 - 6 ] for the torus and the klein bottle when @xmath47 , we prove a weaker result : let @xmath0 be a graph with no kites that is embedded in a surface with nonnegative euler characteristic .
if @xmath163 , then @xmath0 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath164 . if @xmath127 , the result holds , since @xmath165
if @xmath166 , we use the same discharging argument as in lemma 6 .
we have already shown that @xmath167 for each element @xmath27 ; now we must show there exists some element @xmath27 such that @xmath168 . if @xmath93 , then each vertex @xmath19 of degree 6 has @xmath169
. suppose @xmath47 .
if the lemma fails , then @xmath0 must be 5-regular .
if @xmath0 contains no triangles , then each 5-vertex has positive charge ; if @xmath0 contains a triangle @xmath18 , then since @xmath0 is 5-regular , @xmath170 .
we now have the necessary tools to prove our main results . in the next section
we prove two theorems about edge - choosability . in the following section we prove two theorems about total - choosability . for simplicity , we state these theorems only for planar graphs , but after each proof we note which results hold for other surfaces .
let @xmath0 be a planar graph that contains no kites . if @xmath171 , then @xmath172 . if @xmath47 , then @xmath173 . [ main1 ]
let @xmath0 be a connected graph .
harris @xcite and juvan et al .
@xcite showed that @xmath0 is @xmath92-edge - choosable when @xmath41 and @xmath46 , respectively ( even for nonplanar graphs ) .
thus , we only need to prove the theorem when @xmath174 .
we consider separately the three cases @xmath130 , @xmath97 , and @xmath58 . in each case
we proceed by induction on the number of edges .
the theorem holds trivially if @xmath175 .
note that if @xmath176 , then edge @xmath8 is adjacent to at most @xmath177 other edges .
we use this fact frequently in the proof .
suppose @xmath178 .
let @xmath144 be a subgraph of @xmath0 .
since @xmath179 , lemma [ delta5 - 6 ] implies that @xmath144 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath180 . by hypothesis , @xmath181 . since edge @xmath8 is adjacent to at most six edges in @xmath144 , we can extend the coloring to edge @xmath8 .
suppose @xmath182 .
let @xmath144 be a subgraph of @xmath0 .
since @xmath183 , theorem [ delta7 ] and lemma [ delta5 - 6 ] together imply that @xmath144 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath184 . by hypothesis ,
since edge @xmath8 is adjacent to at most @xmath14 edges in @xmath144 , we can extend the coloring to edge @xmath8 .
suppose @xmath186 .
let @xmath144 be a subgraph of @xmath0 . by lemmas [ delta6 ] and [ delta5 - 6 ] , we know that one of the three conditions from lemma [ delta6 ] holds for @xmath144 .
we show that in each case we can remove some set of edges @xmath187 , inductively color the graph @xmath188 , then extend the coloring to @xmath187 .
\(i ) if @xmath144 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath98 , then by hypothesis @xmath181 .
since at most 6 colors are prohibited from use on @xmath8 , we can extend the coloring to @xmath8 .
\(ii ) if @xmath144 has a 4-face @xmath99 with @xmath100 , then let @xmath189 . by hypothesis @xmath190 .
since each of the four uncolored edges of @xmath191 has at most 5 colors prohibited , there are at least two colors available to use on each edge of @xmath191 . since @xmath192 , we can extend the coloring to @xmath191 .
( it is well - known for every even cycle @xmath191 that @xmath193 ; for example , this was shown by erds , rubin , and taylor @xcite . )
\(iii ) if @xmath0 has a 6-vertex incident to 3 triangles , two of type @xmath101 and the third of type @xmath101 , @xmath102 , or @xmath103 , then we assume the third triangle is type @xmath103 , since this is the most restrictive case .
let @xmath194 be the set of edges of all three triangles , plus one additional edge incident to a vertex of degree 3 in one of the triangles . by hypothesis , @xmath195 .
we show that we can extend the coloring to @xmath187 .
the ten edges of @xmath187 are shown in figure [ fig : ten - edges ] , along with the number of colors available to use on each edge .
we use @xmath196 to denote the list of colors available for use on edge @xmath197 after we have chosen colors for all the edges not shown in figure [ fig : ten - edges ] . since @xmath198 , either there exists some color @xmath199 or there exists some color @xmath200 .
if @xmath201 , we use color @xmath202 on edges @xmath203 and @xmath17 .
otherwise there exists @xmath204 . in this case ,
use color @xmath202 on @xmath203 or @xmath17 , then use some other available color on whichever of @xmath203 and @xmath17 is uncolored . in either case , we can now color the rest of the edges in the order : @xmath205 .
this completes the proof for the case @xmath186 .
the results in theorem [ main1 ] easily extend to the projective plane for all values of @xmath16 ; they also extend to the torus and klein bottle when @xmath58 .
[ main2 ] if @xmath0 is planar , @xmath0 contains no kites , and @xmath1 , then @xmath2 . since edges with a common endpoint must receive distinct colors , @xmath206 .
so we need to prove that @xmath207 . by induction on the number of edges ,
we prove that if @xmath144 is a subgraph of @xmath0 , then @xmath208 .
our base case is when @xmath209 .
the result holds for the base case by theorem [ main1 ] .
assume that @xmath210 . by theorem [ delta9 ]
at least one of the following two conditions holds : 1 .
@xmath144 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath211 .
2 . @xmath144 has a 2-alternating cycle .
suppose condition ( i ) holds . by hypothesis ,
since @xmath213 , we have at least one color available to extend the coloring to @xmath8 .
suppose condition ( ii ) holds .
let @xmath191 be the even cycle . by hypothesis , @xmath214 .
after coloring @xmath215 , each edge of @xmath191 has at least two colors available . since even cycles are 2-choosable , we can extend the coloring to @xmath191 .
theorem [ main2 ] easily extends to the projective plane , klein bottle , and torus .
[ total - color - low ] if @xmath0 is a planar graph with no kites and @xmath58 , then @xmath56 .
our proof is by induction on the number of edges in @xmath0 .
( our base case is all planar graphs with at most 4 edges . ) by theorem 4 and lemma 8 , every subgraph of @xmath0 contains an edge @xmath8 with @xmath9 and @xmath216 . by induction
, we have a total coloring for @xmath217 .
now we uncolor @xmath218 ; since edge @xmath8 is adjacent to at most @xmath16 colored edges and one colored vertex , we can color @xmath8 .
since @xmath9 , @xmath218 is incident and adjacent to at most @xmath219 colored elements ; thus , we can color @xmath218 .
theorem [ total - color - low ] extends to the projective plane , klein bottle , and torus . if @xmath0 is a planar graph with no kites and @xmath43 , then @xmath57 .
[ thm15 ] our proof is by induction on the number of edges in @xmath0 .
our base case is all subgraphs @xmath144 of @xmath0 with @xmath220 . by theorem
[ total - color - low ] , each subgraph @xmath144 satisfies @xmath221 .
our induction step is as follows . by lemma [ delta9 ]
, every subgraph @xmath144 of @xmath0 with @xmath222 satisfies one of the following two conditions : ( i ) @xmath144 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath9 and @xmath140 or ( ii ) @xmath144 has a 2-alternating cycle .
suppose that @xmath144 satisfies ( i ) . by the induction hypothesis
, we have a total coloring of @xmath223 . to extend this coloring to @xmath8 , uncolor vertex @xmath218 ; since edge @xmath8 is adjacent to at most @xmath224 colored edges and one colored vertex , we can extend the coloring to @xmath8 .
finally , since vertex @xmath218 is adjacent and incident to at most @xmath225 colored elements , we can color @xmath218 .
suppose instead that @xmath144 satisfies ( ii ) .
let @xmath226 denote the 2-alternating cycle @xmath142 . by the induction hypothesis
, we have a total coloring of @xmath227 . to extend the coloring to @xmath228 ,
we first uncolor each 2-vertex @xmath229 on @xmath226 . now
each edge in @xmath228 has at least two colors available . since even cycles are 2-choosable ( and equivalently 2-(edge - choosable ) )
, we can color the edges of @xmath226 .
finally , we can color each 2-vertex @xmath229 , since each such vertex is incident and adjacent to only 4 colored elements .
theorem [ thm15 ] easily extends to the projective plane , klein bottle , and torus .
doug west clarified the arguments and improved the exposition .
david bunde offered many suggestions that improved the exposition .
oleg borodin taught a lecture course on discharging at uiuc during the spring 2005 semester . without that course , this paper would not have been possible . thanks to an anonymous referee , who provided two very useful references .
thanks most of all to my lord and savior , jesus christ .
p. erds , a.l .
rubin , and h. taylor , choosability in graphs , _ proceedings of the west coast conference on combinatorics , graph theory and computing _ , arcata , california , 1979 , congressus numeratium , * 26 * ( 1980 ) 125157 . | let @xmath0 be a planar graph with no two 3-cycles sharing an edge . we show
that if @xmath1 , then @xmath2 and @xmath3 we also show that if @xmath4 , then @xmath5 and if @xmath6 , then @xmath7 . all of these results extend to graphs in the projective plane and when @xmath6 the results also extend to graphs in the torus and klein bottle .
this second edge - choosability result improves on work of wang and lih and of zhang and wu .
all of our results use the discharging method to prove structural lemmas about the existence of subgraphs with small degree - sum .
for example , we prove that if @xmath0 is a planar graph with no two 3-cycles sharing an edge and with @xmath6 , then @xmath0 has an edge @xmath8 with @xmath9 and @xmath10 .
all of our proofs yield linear - time algorithms that produce the desired colorings
. _ msc _ : 05c15 , 05c10 * keywords * : list coloring , edge coloring , total coloring , vizing s conjecture # 1 # 1 |
the experimental measurement and theoretical investigation of dilepton production constitute one of the most active and exciting fields in the physics of relativistic nuclear collisions @xcite .
because of their relatively weak final - state interactions with the hadronic environment , dileptons , as well as photons , are considered ideal probes of the early stage of heavy - ion collisions , where quark - gluon - plasma ( qgp ) formation is expected @xcite .
because of an additional variable , the invariant mass @xmath7 , dileptons have the advantage of a better signal to background ratio than real photons @xcite .
they of course also prove superior in processes involving two - body annihilations .
dilepton mass spectra produced in heavy ion collisions can basically be divided into three regions .
the low - mass region below @xmath8 ( @xmath9 1 gev ) is dominated by hadronic interactions and hadronic decays . in the intermediate - mass region between @xmath8 and
about 2.5 gev , the contribution from the thermalized qgp might be seen @xcite . in the high - mass region at and above @xmath10
the major effort in heavy ion experiments has been the detection and understanding of @xmath11 suppression .
so far , the experimental measurement of dilepton spectra in ultrarelativistic heavy - ion collisions has mainly been carried out at the cern sps by three collaborations : the ceres collaboration is dedicated to dielectron measurements in the low - mass region @xcite , the helios-3 @xcite collaboration has measured dimuon spectra from threshold up to the @xmath11 region , and the na38/na50 @xcite collaboration measures dimuon spectra in the intermediate- and high - mass regions , emphasizing @xmath11 suppression ( for a summary of low- and intermediate - mass dilepton measurements see refs .
in addition , dilepton spectra in heavy - ion collisions at energies of a few gev / nucleon were measured by the dls collaboration @xcite . in the near future
, dilepton spectra will be measured by the phenix collaboration @xcite at rhic , and by the hades collaboration at the gsi @xcite .
recent observation of the enhancement of low - mass dileptons in central heavy - ion collisions by the ceres @xcite and the helios-3 @xcite collaborations has generated a great deal of theoretical activity .
different models have been used to interpret these data .
the results from many groups with standard scenarios ( i.e. , using vacuum meson properties ) are in remarkable agreement with each other , but in significant disagreement with the data : the experimental spectra in the mass region from 0.3 - 0.6 gev are substantially underestimated @xcite ( see also ref .
this has led to the suggestion of various medium effects that might be responsible for the observed enhancement . in particular , the dropping vector meson mass scenario @xcite is found to provide a unified description of both the ceres and helios-3 data .
however , see also ref .
@xcite . in the high - mass region around @xmath10 ,
the @xmath11 suppression has been a subject of great interest , since it was first proposed as a signal of the deconfinement phase transition @xcite .
various investigations show that up to central s+au collisions , the normal pre - resonance absorption in nuclear matter can account for the observed @xmath11 suppression @xcite .
however , recent data from the na50 collaboration for central pb+pb collisions show an additional strong ` anomalous ' suppression which might indicate the onset of the color deconfinement @xcite . other interesting experimental data that have not yet received much theoretical attention are dilepton spectra in the intermediate - mass region from about 1 gev to about 2.5 gev .
both the helios-3 and na38/na50 collaborations have observed significant enhancement of dilepton yield in this mass region in central s+w and s+u collisions as compared to that in proton - induced reactions ( normalized to the charged - particle multiplicity ) @xcite .
preliminary data from the na50 collaboration also show significant enhancement in central pb+pb collisions @xcite ( see also ref .
@xcite ) . for dilepton spectra with mass above 1 gev , the contributions from charm meson decay and the initial drell - yan processes begin to play a role .
these hard processes scale almost linearly with the participant nucleon number , and can therefore be extrapolated from proton - proton and proton - nucleus collisions . such a study has recently been carried out by braun - munzinger _ et al _ @xcite . the results for p+w and central s+w collisions corresponding to the helios-3 acceptance are shown in fig .
[ pw ] , and are taken from ref .
these , together with the dileptons from the decay of primary vector mesons , are collectively termed ` background ' in this work .
it is seen that this background describes very well the dimuon spectra in p+w reactions , shown in the figure by solid circles .
however , as can be from the figure , the sum of these background sources grossly underestimates the dimuon yield in central s+w collisions , shown in the figure by open circles . since the dimuon spectra are normalized by the measured charged particle multiplicity , this underestimation indicates additional sources to dilepton production in heavy - ion collisions .
there are at least three possible sources for this enhancement : the additional production of charmed mesons and/or drell - yan pairs , a qgp formed in the collisions , and secondary hadronic interactions . while all these possibilities are of interest , and may actually coexist , in this work we concentrate on the contributions from the secondary hadronic interactions , which we believe need to be quantitatively assessed . in this work we limit ourselves to meson interactions .
however we will also comment on the role of baryons later .
for dilepton spectra at low invariant masses , it is well known that the @xmath12 annihilation plays an extremely important role in heavy - ion collisions .
it is also expected that other secondary processes will play a role in the dilepton spectra in the intermediate mass region , and we attempt to demonstrate this in a realistic calculation that compares with experimental data .
this will be done with the relativistic transport model used in ref .
@xcite for the study of low - mass dilepton and photon production .
the main motivation for such a study is to understand the origin of the observed enhancement in the intermediate - mass region , and to see whether the data calls for the formation of a qgp phase . in section 2
we discuss the elementary dilepton production cross sections that are needed as inputs in the transport model .
we shall emphasize the constraints imposed on these cross sections by the experimental data for the reverse process of @xmath6 . in section 3
, we discuss the thermal dilepton emission rates from the hadronic interactions , and compare our results with those from other approaches .
the elementary cross sections , as constrainted by the @xmath13 annihilation data , are then used in the transport model to calculate dilepton spectra in heavy - ion collisions at sps energies .
the results will be presented in section 4 .
the paper ends with a brief summary and outlook in section 5 .
in the low - mass region from 2@xmath14 to @xmath15 , it has been shown that @xmath16 annihilation , which is characteristic of heavy - ion collisions , plays an important role in explaining the observed enhancement .
similarly , it is expected that other secondary hadronic processes should also play some role in the intermediate - mass region .
indeed , previous thermal rate calculations based on kinetic theory show that in the mass and temperature regions relevant for this study , the following processes ( from the hadronic phase ) are important : @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 @xcite . among these processes , @xmath2 has been found to be the most important one , mainly because of its large cross section @xcite ( similar conclusions have been drawn for thermal photon production @xcite ) .
note here that we discuss only two - body reactions , as they should dominate the phase space region we are considering .
an important input in the transport model calculation of dilepton spectra in heavy - ion collisions is the elementary dilepton production cross sections for the processes outlined above . in next three subsections
, we will discuss the cross sections and form factors for pseudoscalar - pseudoscalar , pseudoscalar - vector , and pseudoscalar - axial vector meson annihilation .
in this class we have @xmath17 and @xmath18 annihilation . in the vector meson dominance model ( vmd ) , the feynman diagram for this process is quite simple and is shown in fig .
[ ppfeyn ] , where @xmath19 represents a pseudoscalar meson , @xmath20 the intermediate vector meson , @xmath21 the virtual photon , and @xmath22 the lepton pair .
@xcite for a discussion of the possible uncertainties in vmd .
we use a standard lagrangian for the pseudoscalar - pseudoscalar - vector interaction , @xmath23 the obtained dilepton production cross section in pion - pion annihilation is well known @xcite to be @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the magnitude of the three - momentum of the pion in the center - of - mass frame , @xmath26 is the mass of the lepton pair , and @xmath27 is the mass of the lepton .
it is well known that the electromagnetic form factors @xmath28 play important role in this process , providing empirical support for vmd : the pion electromagnetic form factor is dominated by the @xmath29 meson . in addition , at large invariant masses , higher @xmath30-like resonances such as @xmath31 were found to be important @xcite .
( [ ppee ] ) and detailed - balance , we can get the cross section for @xmath16 production in @xmath13 annihilation , @xmath32 this cross section has been measured with high accuracy in the mass region that is relevant to this study @xcite . in ref .
@xcite a detailed analysis of the experimental data was carried in order to determine the pion electromagnetic form factor .
four @xmath30-like vector mesons were found to be present .
the comparison of the form factor determined in ref .
@xcite with the experimental data from the olya collaboration @xcite ( circles ) , the cmd collaboration @xcite ( squares ) , and the dm2 collaboration @xcite ( triangles ) is shown in fig .
[ ppform ] . a direct comparison with the experimental cross section is shown in fig . [ ppxsect ] .
the agreement between the model and the experimental data is excellent .
this assures us that the elementary dilepton production cross section in pion - pion annihilation used in our transport model is well under control .
the pion electromagnetic form factor has been parameterized in different ways .
for example , in ref .
@xcite , one of us and kapusta proposed the following form , @xmath33 where @xmath34 mev , @xmath35 mev , and @xmath36 mev .
this parameterization reproduces the gounaris - sakurai @xcite formula and describes very well the experimental form factor from the @xmath37 threshold to about 1 gev in invariant mass , as shown in fig .
[ ppform ] by the dotted curve .
it however underestimates the data at larger invariant masses , since it neglects the role of higher @xmath30-like resonances .
the dilepton production cross section in kaon - antikaon annihilation is very similar , @xmath38 where @xmath25 is the magnitude of the kaon momentum in the center - of - mass frame .
the cross section for the reverse process of electron - positron annihilation can again be obtained from the detailed - balance relation , @xmath39 in these equations , @xmath40 and @xmath41 are the electromagnetic form factors of charged and neutral kaons , respectively . these form factor
are dominated by the phi meson , @xmath42 . at higher masses
, other vector mesons may become important @xcite .
the experimental form factor will be used in this work .
it is shown in fig .
[ kkform ] .
the solid and dotted curves are for charged and neutral kaons respectively , and the symbols are the experimental data for the charged kaon form factor from the cmd-2 collaboration @xcite ( circles ) , the dm2 collaboration @xcite ( squares ) , and the olya collaboration @xcite ( triangles ) .
the neutral kaon form factor follows from general arguments @xcite . the direct comparison with the experimental charged kaon cross section is shown in fig . [ kkxsect ]
again , very good agreement between the model and the data is seen . in this class
we include the following processes , @xmath1 , @xmath43 , and @xmath44 .
the first two processes effectively involve three pions , while the third one involves four pions . in transport models a process involving three or more pions in the initial state
can only be described as a two step process with an intermediate resonance .
the empirical success of transport approaches gives some credibility to this scenario .
note however that the treatment of quantum interference remains a possible issue in this framework @xcite .
the interaction lagrangian for this case is @xmath45 the first two channels have been studied in ref .
the cross section for @xmath46 annihilation is given by @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the magnitude of the pion momentum in the center - of - mass frame .
note that the above cross section is evaluated in the narrow - width approximation for illustration purposes only .
this simplification is not used in the actual transport calculation . the cross section for @xmath49
can again be obtained from detailed - balance .
the electromagnetic form factor @xmath50 can then be determined by analyzing the experimental data for @xmath51 . in ref .
@xcite , three isoscalar vector mesons , @xmath42 , @xmath52 , and @xmath53 were found to be important in order to fit the experimental data from refs .
@xcite ( see also ref .
@xcite ) , namely , @xmath54 here the summation runs over the three vector mesons listed above . while the coupling constants @xmath55 and
@xmath56 can be determined from the measured widths , the coupling constants for other two mesons and the relative phases were determined by fitting to the experimental data of refs .
@xcite . in this work ,
we determine these coupling constants by fitting to the latest data from the dm2 collaboration @xcite and the nd collaboration @xcite .
these parameters are only slightly different from those listed in ref . @xcite .
the comparison of our fit with the experimental data is shown in fig .
[ piroxsect ] .
similarly , the cross section for @xmath57 ( or @xmath58 ) is given by @xmath59 where @xmath60 is the magnitude of the kaon momentum in the center - of - mass frame . since a @xmath61 eventually decays into a kaon and a pion , the electromagnetic form factor in the above equation
can be determined by analyzing the experimental data for @xmath62 , as was done in ref .
the form factor was found to be dominated by @xmath63 , @xmath64 where the coupling constant @xmath65gev@xmath66 was determined by fitting the experimental data of the dm1 collaboration @xcite and the dm2 collaboration @xcite .
the comparison with the experimental data is shown in fig .
[ kksxsect ] . finally , the cross section for lepton pair production in pion - omega annihilation is given by @xmath67 where @xmath48 is the magnitude of pion momentum in the center - of - mass frame .
experimentally , the electromagnetic form factor @xmath68 was studied in ref .
@xcite by measuring @xmath69 .
the form factor was parameterized in terms of three isovector @xmath30-like vector mesons , @xmath29 , @xmath31 , and @xmath70 in ref .
@xcite , @xmath71 here the summation runs over the three @xmath30-like resonances listed above .
we will use the form factor determined in ref .
@xcite in this work .
the comparison with the experimental data of the nd @xcite and argus collaborations @xcite is shown in fig .
[ piomxsect ] .
in this class we consider chiefly @xmath72 , which is effectively a four pion process which we treat in the manner described previously .
thermal rate calculations indicate that this process is particularly important in the intermediate - mass region .
there are , however , significant differences between calculations . already in ref .
@xcite it was shown that the dilepton production rates based on different models for the @xmath73 dynamics can differ by an order of magnitude .
this problem was recent revisited in ref .
@xcite , where a comparative study was carried out for both on - shell properties and dilepton production rates using several models for the @xmath73 dynamics .
it was found that , although some of the models provide reasonable description of the on - shell properties , the corresponding dilepton rate could vary widely . by using some information from experimentally - constrained spectral function @xcite , it was found that the effective chiral lagrangian of ref .
@xcite , in which the vector mesons are introduced as massive yang - mills fields of the chiral symmetry , provide reasonable off - shell as well as on - shell properties of the @xmath73 system .
the interaction lagrangian in this model is slightly elaborate and is given in refs .
@xcite . the dilepton production cross section
can then be obtained @xcite @xmath74 where @xmath75 is a complicated function of coupling constants , masses , and kinematics , and @xmath48 is the magnitude of the pion momentum in the center - of - mass frame . one must now consider the issue of the electromagnetic form factor , @xmath76 . in principle , it can be determined by analyzing @xmath77 and @xmath78 data . although many analysis have been carried out
, an unambiguous determination of this form factor is not yet possible , since other intermediate - state can contribute to the same four - pion final state .
here we consider three scenarios , which should bracket this form factor . in the first scenario
, we assume that most of the strength in the @xmath79 channel comes from a @xmath80 intermediate state .
we can then determine @xmath81 from experimental data for @xmath77 from the @xmath82 collaboration @xcite , the m3n collaboration @xcite , and the nd collaboration @xcite .
further constraint on the @xmath83 is provided by the experimental data for @xmath84 , which can also come from @xmath85 intermediate state .
this scenario basically sets an upper limit for the dilepton production from the @xmath80 annihilation .
in a second scenario , we assume that the @xmath80 electromagnetic form factor is represented by the @xmath29 only .
we shall use the the parameterization of eq .
( 4 ) for this purpose .
the comparison of our results for @xmath77 in the two scenarios with the experimental data is shown in fig .
[ pia1xsect ] .
our cross section in the second scenario is similar to that extracted in ref .
@xcite . in the second scenario ,
the missing strength is attributed to @xmath70 which then directly decays into @xmath86 without coupling to the @xmath80 state . in fig .
[ pia10xsect ] , we show the comparison of our results in the first scenario for the process @xmath84 . the solid curve is the sum of our parametrizations for @xmath87 and @xmath88 .
note that in this first scenario , the interpretations of the @xmath89 and @xmath90 data sets are consistent : our fit is adjusted to provide a compromise between the two sets of measurements .
[ pia1xsect ] and [ pia10xsect ] . finally , as a lower bound we use the cross section @xmath91 determined by the dm2 collaboration using partial wave analysis ( pwa ) @xcite .
we first parameterize the data as shown in fig .
[ eepia1dm2 ] , and then use detailed - balance to obtain the cross section @xmath92 . note that the cross section at high masses is smaller than with our other two approaches .
the theoretical description of heavy - ion collision dynamics can be divided into two broad categories : transport ( cascade ) models and hydrodynamical models . in the latter model , ( local )
thermal and chemical equilibrium is usually assumed . to calculate dilepton spectra using the hydrodynamical model ,
one then needs to know the thermal dilepton emission rates , which we discuss in this section . according to kinetic theory , at a given temperature @xmath93 , the differential rate per unit time and per unit volume for a meson pair to annihilate into a lepton pair , @xmath94 ,
is given by @xmath95 where @xmath96 is the bose - einstein distributions for mesons , and @xmath97 is an overall spin - isospin degeneracy factor . approximating the bose - einstein distribution functions by the boltzmann ones , we arrive at a simple expression for the thermal rate , @xmath98 where @xmath99 is a modified bessel function
, @xmath100 is the isospin - averaged cross section , and @xmath101 is the usual kinematic triangle relation .
we consider here three temperatures , @xmath102 , 150 , and 180 mev .
the results for @xmath12 and @xmath103 are shown in fig .
[ trpk ] , the results for @xmath46 and @xmath104 are shown in fig .
[ trpr ] , and the results for @xmath105 and @xmath80 are shown in fig .
the results for @xmath80 are obtained in the scenario where the measured 4@xmath106 final states all come from an intermediate @xmath80 state . in the case of @xmath107 meson , here
we have also included the finite - width effects as in ref .
we mention that in the transport model , those are included for all the baryon and meson resonances .
the dilepton emission rates are seen to depend strongly on the temperature of the system . in heavy - ion collisions , as the system expands , its temperature rapidly decreases , so does the contribution to the dilepton rate .
so most of the dileptons are emitted in the early hot and dense stage of the collisions .
comparing with previous calculations , our results for @xmath12 and @xmath108 are in agreement with those of ref .
@xcite , and our results for @xmath46 and @xmath109 are in agreement with those of ref .
@xcite . finally , as expected , our results for @xmath105 and @xmath80 are different from those in refs .
@xcite , since we use new form factors for these processes which we obtain from @xmath13 annihilation data .
of all the processes considered here , the @xmath80 is found to be the most important one for intermediate - mass dileptons .
this is in line with previous observations @xcite .
dilepton emission rates from hot and dense hadronic matter have been calculated in different approaches . here
we discuss and compare our results with three of these approaches : the spectral function approach of ref .
@xcite , the chiral reduction formalism of refs .
@xcite , and a model based on quark - hadron duality @xcite . in general ,
the dilepton emission rate is given by the thermal expectation value of the electromagnetic current - current correlation function @xcite , @xmath110 different approaches differ in the way this correlation function is approximated and calculated . in ref .
@xcite , this current - current correlator was reduced to a number of spectral functions which can be extracted from the @xmath13 annihilation and @xmath111 lepton decay data . including the soft final - state interaction corrections that leads to the parity mixing phenomenon ( i.e. , the mixing between the vector and the axial - vector currents )
, the dilepton emission rate can be expressed as @xcite @xmath112 where @xmath113 , and @xmath114 , @xmath115 , and @xmath116 are the electromagnetic spectral function , the vector spectral function , and the axial - vector spectral function , respectively .
@xmath117 can be related to the total hadronic cross section of @xmath13 annihilation , @xmath118 similarly , the vector spectral function can be determined by selecting events with even number of pions @xmath119 finally , the axial - vector spectra function @xmath116 can be extracted from the differential probability of the @xmath111 lepton decaying into an odd number of pions .
thus , with these spectral functions extracted from the @xmath13 and @xmath111 decay data , one can determine the empirical dilepton emission rate using eq .
( [ huang ] ) .
note that the terms in @xmath120 represent a small correction .
@xcite , the idea of a hagedorn resonance gas approach was explored . there
, the vector meson mass distribution is characterized by the mass spectrum @xmath121 ( we use @xmath122 for the vector spectral function , and @xmath123 for the vector meson mass spectrum ) . the dileptons are associated with direct vector meson decays ( the vector meson dominance assumption ) . therefore the thermal rate can expressed as @xmath124 where @xmath125 is the vector - meson - photon coupling constant , which also determines the vector meson production cross section in the @xmath13 annihilation , @xmath126 in ref .
@xcite , it was assumed that the total cross section of @xmath13 annihilation is saturated by the production of vector mesons , which is supported by experimental observation @xcite , @xmath127 where @xmath128 is the experimental @xmath129 value , which reflects the strong interaction aspect of the @xmath13 annihilation physics . with this approximation
the dilepton emission rate can then be written as @xmath130 this is very similar to the results of ref .
@xcite , except here that the soft - pion corrections are neglected . in ref .
@xcite , it was further assumed that @xmath128 can be approximated by @xmath131 , the parton model prediction for @xmath129 .
the dilepton emission rate is then determined theoretically without referring to experimental data , @xmath132 for three flavor case , @xmath133 .
this equality states that the dilepton emission rate from hadronic gas can be approximated by the parton model prediction with the same accuracy as the parton model describes the total hadronic production cross section in @xmath13 annihilation .
this approximation would apply to invariant masses greater than @xmath134 1.5 gev . finally , in refs .
@xcite , a chiral reduction formalism @xcite was use to reduce the current - current correlation function in eq .
( [ cc ] ) into a number of vacuum correlation functions , which are constrained by the experimental data from @xmath13 annihilation , @xmath135 lepton decay , pion radiative decay , and two - photon fusion reactions .
this approach allows for a systematic expansion in terms of pion density ( and nucleon density if baryons are included ) . in fig .
[ trtot ] , we compare the dilepton emission rates obtained with our different scenarios with those obtained in the three models just outlined . the solid , long - dashed , and dash - dotted curves are our results based on our pictures for the @xmath80 cross sections . the scenario that includes the @xmath70 in the @xmath80 form factor leads to a larger rate above 1.2 gev invariant mass , as expected .
the open circles are the results of ref .
@xcite based on empirical spectral functions .
our result with a full @xmath80 form factor is in agreement with the spectral function result up to 1.6 gev invariant mass .
it is slightly above at higher invariant masses .
the scenario that excludes @xmath70 in the @xmath80 form factor is slightly lower than the spectral function result between 1.2 and 1.6 gev invariant mass . in other mass regions ,
they give comparable rates . finally , the use of the dm2 partial wave analysis for the @xmath80 cross section yields rates that are somewhat lower than those obtained in the other models , passed 1.75 gev invariant mass .
we will see later that hard background processes will mask this difference .
the short - dashed curve gives the results of ref .
@xcite , which is based on a su(3 ) version of the chiral reduction formalism .
the result is in good agreement with the one from empirical spectral functions @xcite , suggesting that higher - order interactions ( not explicitly included in ref .
@xcite ) are not significant at the temperatures considered here .
finally , the dotted curve gives the result of eq .
( [ ruus ] ) which makes use of the hadron - quark duality that allows the use of @xmath136 in the place of @xmath128 .
it is interesting to note that the dilepton rate from this approach is in very good agreement with the one obtained with empirical spectral functions above about 1 gev .
this supports the idea that , even though there are resonances in the the intermediate mass region , these resonances can not be easily resolved individually . as a partial summary ,
our results are based on kinetic theory which assumes pair - wise collisions of mesons . to make use of @xmath13 annihilation data as a constraint , we need to know the hadronic production cross section in specific channels , such as @xmath12 , @xmath103 , or @xmath80 .
data are available for most of the processes considered here . but for @xmath80 an unambiguous determination of its production cross section from the measured @xmath137 cross sections
is not yet possible .
this introduces model dependence . on the other hand ,
the other three approaches use directly the total hadronic production cross section in @xmath13 annihilation , without the need to separate them into specific channels and thus avoiding the uncertainties involved in such a separation . the nice agreement shown in fig .
[ trtot ] thus suggests that the model dependence in our approach is not severe .
furthermore , this level of agreement from different approaches for these elementary processes provides us with the basis for further discussions about the dynamics of heavy - ion collisions , the possibility of gqp formation , and charm enhancement .
to compare with experimental data , the thermal rate calculation is certainly not sufficient .
one needs a transport model that describes the dynamical evolution of the colliding system , and integrate the dilepton production rate over the entire reaction volume and time . in heavy - ion collisions at cern sps energies ,
many hadrons are produced in the initial nucleon - nucleon interactions .
this is usually modeled by the fragmentation of strings , which are the chromoelectric flux - tubes excited from the interacting quarks .
one empirically successful model for taking into account this nonequilibrium dynamics is rqmd @xcite . to define a relativistic transport model for heavy - ion collisions at these energies
, we have used as initial conditions the hadron abundances and distributions obtained from string fragmentation .
further interactions and decays of these hadrons are then taken into account as in most relativistic transport models .
this approach is found to provide a good description of hadronic observables ( such as transverse mass spectra and rapidity distributions ) in heavy - ion collisions at cern sps energies @xcite .
we should make here some comments on the treatment of resonances and multi - particle interactions in the transport model .
the narrow - width approximation was not used in our calculation .
the mass distribution of the resonances ( for example the @xmath107 ) in our approach is taken into account .
note that this realistic sampling of the spectral function is different from usual kinetic theory estimates of the dilepton emission rates where the resonance is usually given a fixed mass .
furthermore , in our transport model , the fact that the resonance has a finite life time is fully respected : its population is evolved dynamically . the resonance is formed in collisions and also eventually decays . in the early stage of the heavy - ion collision ,
resonance formation is favored since the density is high .
as the system expands and the density gets smaller , the resonance decay process gradually becomes dominant .
this is again different from kinetic theory calculations .
let s take @xmath138 as a concrete example . in our approach ,
a rho meson is first made from two - pions colliding .
it then interacts with a third pion to form an @xmath107 meson .
finally this @xmath107 meson annihilates a fourth pion to produce a lepton pair .
the explicit treatment of intermediate resonances takes care of the formation time typical of strong interaction , which is very important for heavy - ion collisions at sps energies .
furthermore , this algorithm also includes the possibility that in the course of the multi - step process the intermediate rho or @xmath107 meson might interact with other particles , say a nucleon , rather than with the third or the fourth pion .
this amounts to a dynamical generation of a broadened width . finally , for any reasonable comparison with experimental data from heavy - ion collisions , a transport model that describes the dynamic evolution of the colliding system is a required tool .
the contributions from the secondary processes outlined above are shown in fig .
[ swthml ] .
these are obtained in our relativistic transport model @xcite , including the helios-3 acceptances , mass resolution , and normalization @xcite . here
@xmath139 represents number of dimuon pairs within the 50 mev mass bin , normalized by the charged particle multiplicity .
it is seen that the @xmath80 process is by far the most important source for dimuon yields in this mass region .
the @xmath105 process also plays some role in the entire intermediate - mass region , while the contributions from @xmath12 , @xmath46 and @xmath103 are important around 1 gev invariant mass the relative importance of various processes follow basically the thermal rate predictions , as discussed in the previous section . in fig .
[ swtot ] , we add the secondary contributions obtained in our transport model to the background , and compare again with the helios-3 data for central s+w collisions .
it is seen that the data can be adequately reproduced .
this highlights for the first time the importance of the secondary processes for the intermediate - mass dilepton spectra in heavy - ion collisions .
this is an important step forward in the use of intermediate - mass dilepton spectra as a probe of the phase transition and qgp formation .
although the current data do not show any necessity to invoke the qgp formation in s - induced reactions , consistent with some conclusions from @xmath11 physics , we believe that the observation that the secondary processes do play a significant role in the intermediate - mass dilepton spectra is interesting and important . we note in passing that the change of slope observed in the experimental data corresponds in our interpretation to a crossover between the secondary processes and the ( drell - yan / charm ) background .
this represents a transition from soft to hard physics and this observation should be explored further in the future .
the results shown in figs .
[ swthml ] and [ swtot ] are obtained under the assumption that all the 4@xmath106 final state in the @xmath13 cross section proceeds through the @xmath80 intermediate state .
we also did a calculation in which the @xmath80 form factor contains only the normal @xmath29 .
the results are shown in fig . [ swfm ] by the dotted curve . finally , to complete our survey of possible constraints and uncertainties in @xmath140
cross sections , we did a calculation in which this cross section is obtained from the @xmath141 cross section determined by the dm2 collaboration in partial wave analysis ( pwa ) @xcite ( see fig . [ eepia1dm2 ] ) .
the results are shown by the dashed curve in fig .
the region between the solid and dashed curves thus reflect the uncertainty for heavy - ion collisions due to our limited knowledge of the @xmath80 cross section .
this area is not unreasonably large . from a formal point of view , it is fair to say that no strong evidence currently exists coupling the @xmath70 to a @xmath80 state @xcite , even though better 4@xmath106 data could help resolve this issue along with others of interference and @xmath142 contribution . note that the fact that the dm2 results are lower than in other scenarios at high invariant masses is concealed by the hard background . also shown in this figure is the results of ref .
@xcite which uses the dilepton emission rate obtained in the chiral reduction formalism with a simple fireball model for the dynamics of heavy - ion collisions .
it is see that their results are also in good agreement with the experimental data .
another issue we want to address here is the effects of dropping vector meson masses on the entire dimuon spectra from the threshold to about 2.5 gev . in ref . @xcite it was shown that the enhancement of low - mass dileptons could be interpreted as a signature of vector meson masses decreasing with increasing density and temperature
. this should affect the dilepton spectra in the intermediate - mass region , mainly through two effects .
one is the change of the invariant energy spectra of these secondary meson pairs .
the second effect enters through the modification of the electromagnetic form factor . since we can only conjecture how the masses of the higher vector resonances change with density and temperature
, we shall assume for simplicity that they experience the same amount of scalar field as the `` common '' rho meson , namely , @xmath143 @xcite .
the results of this calculation are shown in fig .
[ swmass ] . below 1.1 gev and especially from 0.4 to 0.6 gev , the agreement with the experimental data is much better when the dropping vector meson mass scenario is introduced , as was already shown in ref .
@xcite . at higher masses ,
the dropping mass scenarios somewhat underestimates the experimental data .
also note that our starting point was our first scenario . for completeness
, however , we have to state that there might be additional contributions from , e.g. , secondary drell - yan processes @xcite that were not included in this study .
there could also be enhanced production of charmed mesons .
furthermore , as we progress higher in invariant mass , the role of baryons has to be carefully assessed .
so far , the baryons seem to play little role in the overall dilepton yield @xcite .
this statement was examined in ref .
@xcite for masses below 1 gev , which is being extended to the intermediate - mass region in @xcite .
see however ref .
@xcite for an alternate discussion on the role of baryons .
in summary , we have carried out a study of intermediate - mass ( between 1 and 2.5 gev ) dilepton spectra from hadronic interactions in heavy - ion collisions .
the processes included are @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 .
we calculated the elementary cross sections for these processes based on chiral hadronic lagrangians for pseudoscalar , vector , and axial - vector mesons .
the corresponding electromagnetic form factors are determined by fitting to the experimental data for the reverse processes of @xmath6 . while the form factors for @xmath12 , @xmath103 , @xmath46 , @xmath105 , and @xmath104 are uniquely constrained by the @xmath13 data , there are still uncertainties in the @xmath80 form factor , for which we have considered three scenarios .
we used these cross sections with kinetic theory to calculate the dilepton emission rates at finite temperature .
the @xmath2 process was found to be the most important one in the intermediate - mass region , as was found in previous calculations .
our rates were compared with those from other approaches .
this provides us with the confidence that we have some control of the dilepton spectra from the secondaries hadronic interaction .
this is important for the use of the dilepton spectra as a probe of phase transition and qgp properties .
finally we apply these elementary cross sections in a relativistic transport model and calculate dilepton spectra in s+w collisions at sps energies .
again , the @xmath2 was found to be the most important process .
the comparison of our results with experimental data from the helios-3 collaboration indicates the importance of the secondary hadronic contributions to the intermediate - mass dilepton spectra .
this work can be extended in several directions .
although the current experimental data from the helios-3 collaboration are not very sensitive to the different assumptions of the @xmath80 form factor , it would be very useful to pin this down since the @xmath80 is the single most important source of the intermediate - mass dileptons from hadronic secondary collisions .
also , a more elaborate calculation of the charmed meson production and initial ( as well as possible secondary ) drell - yan contributions in heavy - ion collisions is needed .
such a calculation could put the conclusions reached in this work concerning the role of secondary hadronic processes and dropping vector meson masses on an even firmer footing .
finally , the current investigation can be extended to higher incident energies , such as those of the rhic collider , by combining the cross sections ( or thermal rates ) obtained in this study with , e.g. , hydrodynamical models for the evolution of heavy - ion collisions at the rhic energies .
this kind of study is useful for the determination of hadronic sources in the dilepton spectra to be measured by the phenix collaboration , and thus for the clear identification of the dilepton yield arising from the qgp .
we are grateful to nikolai achasov , gerry brown , sandy donnachie , axel drees , madappa prakash , ralf rapp , and ismail zahed for useful discussions .
this work is supported in part by the u.s .
department of energy under grant number de - fg02 - 88er-40388 , by the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada , and by the fonds fcar of the qubec government .
ko , and g.e .
brown , phys .
lett . * 75 * , 4007 ( 1995 ) ; g.q .
ko , and g.e .
brown , nucl . phys . *
a606 * , 568 ( 1996 ) ; g. q. li , c. m. ko , g. e. brown , and h. sorge , nucl . phys . *
a611 * , i539 ( 1996 ) .
w. cassing , w. ehehalt , and c.m .
ko , phys .
* b363 * , 35 ( 1995 ) ; g. chanfray , r. rapp , and j. wambach , phys .
lett . * 76 * , 368 ( 1996 ) ; d.k .
srivastava , b. sinha , and c. gale , phys .
c * 53 * , r567 ( 1996 ) ; k. haglin , phys .
c * 53 * , r2606 ( 1996 ) ; v. koch and c. s. song , phys .
c * 54 * , 1903 ( 1996 ) ; j.v .
steele , h. yamagishi , and i. zahed , phys .
b384 * , 255 ( 1996 ) ; j. sollfrank , _ et al . ,
c * 55 * , 392 ( 1997 ) ; c. m. hung and e. shuryak , phys .
c * 56 * , 453 ( 1997 ) ; r. baier , m. dirks , and k. redlich , phys .
d * 55 * , 4344 ( 1997 ) .
et al . , _ ( na50 collaboration ) , nucl . phys . *
a610 * , 404c ( 1996 ) ; d. kharzeev , nucl . phys . * a610 * , 418c ( 1996 ) ; c.y .
wong , nucl .
a610 * , 434c ( 1996 ) ; s. gavin and r. vogt , nucl . phys . *
a610 * , 442c ( 1996 ) ; j .-
blaizot and j .- y .
ollitrault , nucl . phys . *
a610 * , 452c ( 1996 ) . | we carry out a study of intermediate - mass ( between 1 and 2.5 gev ) dilepton spectra from hadronic interactions in heavy - ion collisions .
the processes considered are @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 , @xmath3 , @xmath4 , and @xmath5 .
the elementary cross sections for those are obtained from chiral lagrangians involving pseudoscalar , vector , and axial - vector mesons .
the respective electromagnetic form factors are determined by fitting to experimental data for the reverse processes of @xmath6 .
based on this input we calculate cross sections and thermal dilepton emission rates and compare our results with those from other approaches .
finally we use these elementary cross sections with a relativistic transport model and calculate dilepton spectra in s+w collisions at sps energies .
the comparison of our results with experimental data from the helios-3 collaboration indicates the importance of the secondary hadronic contributions to the intermediate - mass dilepton spectra . |
non - linear iterated maps are now known as an universal tool in numerous scientific domains , including for instance mechanics , hydrodynamics and economy @xcite @xcite @xcite .
they often appear because the differential equations describing the dynamics of a system can be reduced to non - linear iterations , with the help of poincar recurrence maps for instance .
the resulting iterations combine a great mathematical simplicity , which makes them convenient for numerical simulations , with a large variety of interesting behaviors , providing generic information on the properties of the system . in particular , they are essential to characterize one of the routes to chaos , the cascade of period doublings @xcite . in musical acoustics , mc intyre _
et al . _ have given , in a celebrated article @xcite , a general frame for calculating the oscillations of musical instruments , based upon the coupling of a linear resonator and a non - linear excitator ( for reed instruments , the flow generated by a supply pressure in the mouth and modulated by a reed ) .
in an appendix of their article they show that , within simplified models of self - sustained instruments , the equations of evolution can also be reduced to an iterated map with appropriate non - linear functions . for resonators with a simple shape such as a uniform string or a cylindrical tube ,
the basic idea is to choose variables that are amplitudes of the incoming and outgoing waves ( travelling waves ) , instead of usual acoustic pressure and volume velocity in the case of reed instruments .
if the inertia of the reed is ignored ( a good approximation in many cases ) , and if the losses in the resonator are independent of frequency , the model leads to simple iterations ; the normal oscillations correspond to the so called helmholtz motion , a regime in which the various physical quantities vary in time by steps , as in square signals .
square signals obviously are a poor approximation of actual musical signals , but this approach is sufficient when the main purpose is to study regimes of oscillation , not tone - color . in the case of clarinet - like systems ,
the idea was then expanded @xcite , giving rise to experimental observations of period doubling scenarios and to considerations on the relations between stability of the regimes and the properties of the second iterate of the non - linear function ; see also @xcite and especially @xcite for a review of the properties of iterations in clarinet - like systems and a discussion of the various regimes ( see also @xcite ) .
more recent work includes the study of oscillation regimes obtained in experiments @xcite , computer simulation @xcite as well as theory @xcite .
the general form of the iteration function that is relevant for reed musical instruments is presented in section [ iteration ] .
it it is significantly different from the usual iteration parabola ( i.e. the so - called logistic map ) .
moreover , it will be discussed in more detail that the control parameters act in a rather specific way , translating the curve along an axis at @xmath0 rather than acting as an adjustable gain .
the purpose of the present article is to study the iterative properties of functions having this type of behavior , and their effect on the oscillation regimes of reed musical instruments .
we will study the specificities and the role of the higher order iterates of this class of functions , in particular in the regions of the so called `` periodicity windows '' , which take place beyond the threshold of chaos .
these windows are known to contain interesting phenomena @xcite , for instance period tripling or a route to intermittence , which to our knowledge have not yet been studied in the context of reed musical instruments .
moreover , the iterates give a direct representation of the zones of stability of the different regimes ( period doublings for instance ) , directly visible on the slope of the corresponding iterate . for numerical calculations , it is necessary to select a particular representation of the non - linear function , which in turn requires to choose a mathematical expression of the function giving the volume flow rate as a function of the pressure difference across the reed .
a simple and realistic model of the quasi - static flow rate entering a clarinet mouthpiece was proposed in 1974 by wilson and beavers @xcite , and discussed in more detail in 1990 by hirschberg _
this model provides a good agreement with experiments @xcite and leads to realistic predictions concerning the oscillations of a clarinet @xcite . using this mathematical representation of the flow rate
, we will see that iterations lead to a variety of interesting phenomena .
our purpose here is not to propose the most elaborate possible model of the clarinet , including all physical effects that may occur in real instruments .
it is rather to present general ideas and mathematical solutions as illustration of the various class of phenomena that can take place , within the simplest possible formalism ; in a second step , one can always take this simple model as a starting point , to which perturbative corrections are subsequently added in order to include more specific details .
we first introduce the model in [ model ] , and then discuss the properties of the iteration function in [ properties].the bifurcations curves are obtained in [ bifurcations ] and , in
[ iterated ] , we discuss the iterated functions and their applications in terms of period tripling and intermittence .
in particular we see how the graph of high order iterates give visible information on the regime of oscillation ( number of period doublings for instance ) or the appearance of a chaotic regime , while nothing special appears directly in the graph of the first iterate .
two appendices are added at the end .
we briefly recall the basic elements of the model , the non - linear characteristics of the excitator , and the origin of the iterations within a simplified treatment of the resonator . in a quasi static regime
, the flow @xmath1 entering the resonant cavity is modelled with the help of an approximation of the bernoulli equation , as discussed e.g. in @xcite .
we note @xmath2 the acoustic pressure inside the mouthpiece , assumed to be equal to the one at the output of the reed channel , @xmath3 the pressure inside the mouth of the player ; for small values of the difference : @xmath4 the reed remains close to its equilibrium position , and the conservation of energy implies that @xmath1 is proportional to @xmath5 , where @xmath6 is the sign of @xmath7 ( we ignore dissipative effects at the scale of the flow across the reed channel ) ; for larger values of this difference , the reed moves and , when the difference reaches the closure pressure @xmath8 , it completely blocks the flow .
these two effects are included by assuming that if @xmath9 the flow @xmath1 is proportional to @xmath10 $ ] , and if @xmath11 , the flow vanishes . introducing the dimensionless quantities : @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the acoustic impedance of an infinitely long cylindrical resonator having the same cross section @xmath14 than the clarinet bore ( @xmath15 is the density of air , @xmath16 the velocity of sound )
, we obtain : @xmath17 the parameter @xmath18 characterizes the intensity of the flow and is defined as : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the opening cross section of the reed channel at rest .
one can show that @xmath18 is inversely proportional to square root of the reed stiffness ) then provides @xmath21 , or @xmath22 ; but @xmath8 is roughly proportional to the reed stiffness , so that the independence of the flow with respect to the stiffness requires that @xmath18 is inversely proportional to the square root of this stiffness .
] , contained in @xmath8 . in real instruments , typical values of the parameters are @xmath23 $ ] ; @xmath24 $ ] ; values @xmath25 will not be considered here , since they correspond to multi - valued functions @xmath26 , a case that does not seem very realistic in practice .
fig.[p - u - relation ] shows an example of function defined in eqs.([1 ] to [ 1ter ] ) .
it is obviously non - analytic ; it is made of three separate analytic pieces , with a singular point at @xmath27 the derivative of the function @xmath26 is discontinuous at @xmath28 ( point @xmath29 in fig .
[ p - u - relation ] , the index @xmath30 being used for the limit of possible beating ) ; a smoothing of the resulting angle of the function could easily be introduced at the price of a moderate mathematical complication , but this is not necessary for the present discussion .
entering the resonator of a clarinet as a function of the internal pressure @xmath31 ( pressure in the mouthpiece ) .
all physical quantities are expressed in dimensionless units , as explained in the text .
m@xmath32 corresponds to the contact point where the internal pressure in the mouthpiece bends the reed sufficiently to close the channel , so that the flow vanishes ; it remains zero in all region @xmath33 .
m@xmath34 is the inversion point where @xmath35 and where the acoustic flow changes sign .
the full line corresponds to @xmath36 , the broken line to @xmath37 . here
@xmath38.,width=377 ] waves are assumed to be planar in the quasi one dimensional cylindrical resonator . any wave can be expanded into an outgoing wave @xmath39 and an incoming wave @xmath40 , where @xmath41 is the time and @xmath42 the abscissa coordinate along the axis of the resonator ; at point @xmath43 ( at the tip of the reed ) , the acoustic pressure and flow ] are given by : @xmath44 or : @xmath45 \text { \ \ ; \ \ } p^{-}(t)=\frac{% 1}{2}\left [ p(t)-u(t)\right ] .
\label{4b-2}\ ] ] we will use variables @xmath46 instead of @xmath47 and @xmath48 . if we assume that the impedance at the output of the resonator is zero ( no external radiation , the output pressure remains the atmospheric pressure ) , we obtain the reflection condition : @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the resonator length and @xmath16 the sound velocity .
this equation expresses that the reflected wave has the same amplitude than the incoming wave .
losses are not included in this relation , but one can also introduce them very easily by replacing ( [ 4 ] ) by : @xmath51 which amounts to introducing frequency independent losses ; a typical value is @xmath52 . for a cylindrical , open , tube with no radiation at the open end
so that losses only occur inside the tube , @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is the absorption coefficient .
of course this is an approximation : real losses are frequency dependent depends on both frequency @xmath55 and radius @xmath56 for normal ambient conditions ( @xmath57{0xb0}}% % beginexpansion { { } ^\circ}% % endexpansion c$ ] ) , @xmath58 ( see e.g. @xcite ) . ] and radiation occurs but , since losses remain a relatively small correction in musical instruments , using eq .
( [ 4c ] ) is sufficient for our purposes .
we now assume that all acoustical variables vanish until time @xmath59 , and then that the excitation pressure in the mouth suddenly takes a new constant value @xmath60 ; this corresponds to a heaviside step function for the control parameter . between time @xmath61 and time @xmath62 , according to ( [ 4c ] ) , the incoming amplitude @xmath63 remains zero , but the outgoing amplitude @xmath64 has to jump to value @xmath65 in order to fulfil eqs.([1 ] to [ 1ter ] ) . at time @xmath66 , the variable @xmath63 jumps to value @xmath67 , which immediately makes @xmath64 jump to a new value @xmath68 , in order to still fulfil eqs.([1 ] to [ 1ter]).this remains true until time @xmath69 , when @xmath63 jumps to value @xmath70 and @xmath71 to a value @xmath72 , etc . by recurrence ,
one obtains a regime where all physical quantities remain constant in time intervals @xmath73 , in particular @xmath74 for the pressure and @xmath75 for the flow , with the recurrence relation : @xmath76 in what follows , it will be convenient to use @xmath62 as a natural time unit .
we will then simply call time @xmath77 the time interval @xmath78 .
notice that in order to get higher regimes ( with e.g. triple frequency ) , the previous choice of transient for @xmath79 needs to be modified ( see e.g.@xcite ) .
now , by combining eqs.([1 ] to [ 1ter ] ) and [ 4b-1 ] ) , one can obtain a non - linear relation @xmath80 between @xmath81 and @xmath82 : @xmath83 which , combined with ( [ recurrence ] ) , provides the relation : @xmath84 with , by definition : @xmath85 the equation of evolution of the system are then equivalent to a simple mapping problem with an iteration function @xmath86 .
the graph of this function is obtained by rotating the non - linear characteristics of fig .
[ p - u - relation ] by @xmath0 ( in order to obtain @xmath80 ) , then applying a symmetry ( to include the change of sign of the variable ) and finally a horizontal rescaling by a factor @xmath87 ; the result is shown in fig . [ fonction - iteree].this provides a direct and convenient graphical construction of the evolution of the system @xcite ; fig .
[ iteration ] shows how a characteristic point @xmath88 is transformed into its next iterate @xmath89 etc ... by the usual construction , at the intersection of a straight line with the iteration curve , i.e. by transferring the value of @xmath86 to the @xmath90 axis and reading the value of the function at this abscissa in order to obtain @xmath91 $ ] .
in what follows , we consider @xmath60 as the main control parameter of the iteration ; it corresponds to a change of pressure in the mouth of the instrumentalist .
a second control parameter is @xmath18 , which the player can also change in real time by controlling the lip pressure on the reed.for a given note of the instrument , parameter @xmath92 remains fixed , but of course depends on which lateral holes of the clarinet are closed , in other words on the pitch of the note .
the oscillations where the functions remain constant and jump to a different value at regular interval of times are reminiscent of the raman regime for the oscillation of bowed strings @xcite .
mc intyre et al .
have indeed noticed that , if one replaces the non - linear function by that corresponding to a bowed string , one obtains the raman oscillation regime of a string bowed at its center @xcite .
the analytical expression of the iteration function is given in appendix [ app1 ] .
figure [ fonction - iteree ] shows the function for given values of the parameters @xmath60 and @xmath18 , and three different values of the loss parameter @xmath93 for @xmath38 and @xmath94 solid line @xmath95 ( no loss in the resonator ) ; mixed line @xmath96 ; dotted line @xmath97 .
the circles on the right indicate the contact point m@xmath98 , those on the left the flow inversion point m@xmath99.,width=377 ] in the literature , the most commonly studied functions have the following properties ( see e.g. collet and eckman @xcite or berg et al @xcite ) : * they are defined on a finite interval and map this interval into itself ; * they are continuous ; * they have a unique maximum ; * their schwarzian derivative is negative .
a function verifying these properties will be called a standard function ; the function @xmath86 of interest in our case does not fulfil all these requirements . [ [ domain ] ] domain of iteration usually , the iteration function defines an application of the interval @xmath100 over itself . here , @xmath86 is defined on an infinite interval @xmath101 $ ] even if , obviously , very large values of the variables are not physically plausible . nevertheless , analyzing the different cases corresponding to eqs.([1 ] to [ 1ter ] )
, one can show that the function @xmath86 has a maximum @xmath102 obtained for : @xmath103 \label{xmax}\ ] ] with value : @xmath104 where @xmath105 is defined by : @xmath106 \text { . }
\label{5b}\ ] ] it can be shown that this maximum is unique for large value of @xmath18 ( @xmath107 ; for smaller values , a second maximum exists at a very large negative values of @xmath90 , i.e. for very large negative flow , but we will see below that such values of the flow can not be obtained after a few iterations
. therefore we focus our attention only on the maximum @xmath102 , which varies slowly as a function of @xmath18 because @xmath108 increases monotonically from 0 for @xmath109 to a small value ( @xmath110 for @xmath111 ) .
the geometrical construction of fig . [ iteration ] shows that , after a single iteration , the characteristic point m necessarily falls at an abscissa @xmath112 .
let us call @xmath113 the ordinate of the point on the iteration function with abscissa @xmath102 .
the two vertical lines @xmath114 and @xmath115 , together with the two horizontal lines @xmath116 and @xmath117 , define a square in the @xmath118 plane , from which an iteration can not escape as soon as the iteration point has fallen inside it . , which means that the iteration curve crosses the left side of the square , as is the case in fig [ iteration ] . ]
conversely , since every characteristic point has at least two antecedents , the iteration can bring a point that was outside the square to inside .
in other words , the square determines a part of the curve which is invariant by action of the function . for usual initial conditions , such as @xmath119 ,
the starting point already lies within the square , so that all points of the iteration keep this property .
we have checked that , even if one starts with very large and unphysical pressure differences ( positive or negative ) , the iterations rapidly converge to the inside the square . in what follows ,
we call it the iteration square .
the net result is that , if we do not consider transients , we can consider that the function defines an application of the interval @xmath120 $ ] over itself .
we are then very close to the usual mapping situation , except that here the interval depends on the control parameters ( since the value of @xmath102 depends on @xmath60 and @xmath18 ) , but with a relatively slow variation . , after a few steps the iteration remains inside an iteration square " shown in broken lines .
this square has its upper side tangent to the maximum of the function , at point @xmath121 , which after one iteration becomes point @xmath122 defining the lowest side of the square ( ordinate @xmath123 ) .
depending on the parameters , the iteration square contains or does not contain the contact point @xmath29 and the flow inversion point @xmath124 . here
@xmath125 , @xmath126 , @xmath127.,width=377 ] [ [ singularities ] ] singularities an interesting feature of the iteration function is the discontinuity of its first derivative occurring at the beating limit point @xmath29 at @xmath128 , given by : @xmath129 when the reed closes the channel ( @xmath130 , @xmath131 ) , @xmath132 , @xmath133 , the iteration function is linear .
another singularity , i.e. a discontinuity of the second derivative , is obtained at the crossover between positive and negative flow , the inversion point @xmath124 where sign of the flow changes .
its abscissa @xmath134 is given by : @xmath135 for @xmath136 , @xmath137 is negative and @xmath138 positive : therefore the initial point of the iteration ( @xmath139 ) lies in the interval @xmath140 $ ] , with neither contact with the mouthpiece nor negative flow , as one could expect physically . [ [ schwarzian - derivative ] ] schwarzian derivative the schwarzian derivative @xcite of @xmath86 is equal to : @xmath141 ^{2}\text{,}\ ] ] where @xmath142 , @xmath143 and @xmath144 indicate the first , second and third derivatives of @xmath86 , respectively . if @xmath145 , it is zero ; if @xmath146 , using the change of variables given in appendix [ app1 ] , @xmath147 can be shown to be equal to : @xmath148 , \ ] ] where @xmath149 is a function of @xmath150 - see eqs .
( [ a1 ] ) to ( [ a3 ] ) .
therefore its sign does not depend on the loss parameter @xmath92 .
after some calculations , the schwarzian derivative is found to be negative for all @xmath151 $ ] when @xmath152 otherwise , it is negative up to a certain value , then positive up to @xmath153 the calculation of @xmath147 for the case @xmath154 shows that it is positive , except for a small interval .
the iteration function therefore differs from a standard function because of the sign of the schwartzian derivative ; this is related to the nature of the bifurcation at the threshold of oscillation @xcite , which can be either direct or inverse .
[ [ beating - and - negative - flow - limits - beating - limits ] ] beating and negative flow limits [ beating - limits ] in fig .
[ iteration ] we see that , depending whether the contact point @xmath155 and flow inversion point @xmath124 of the iteration curve fall inside or outside the iteration square , a beating behavior of the reed and a sign inversion of the air flow are possible or not .
point @xmath29 falls inside the iteration square if its abscissa @xmath138 given by ( [ 5b ] ) is smaller than @xmath156 , which leads to : @xmath157 and @xmath158 , the line representing @xmath159 gives a border between the upper region , where reed beating may occur , and the lower region where it can not - see eq .
( [ 5d ] ) . as a point of comparison ,
the line labelled @xmath160 correspond to the limit obtained in @xcite for the particular case of a 2-state regime , and given by eq.([5f ] ) .
the figure also shows the line @xmath161 and @xmath162 associated with the possibility of negative flow ( the first one turns out to be very close to that associated with reed beating ) .
small values for the losses have been assumed ( @xmath163).,width=377 ] the limiting value @xmath164 is less than unity ( it tends to @xmath165 when @xmath166 tends to 0 and @xmath92 tends to unity ) .
this necessary condition is completely independent of the nature of the limit cycle , and less stringent than the limit @xmath167 obtained in @xcite , for a 2-state cycle : @xmath168 , \label{5f}\ ] ] where @xmath169 and @xmath170 fig .
[ limits ] gives a comparison between the two limits .
similarly , a necessary condition for possible inversions of the sign of the air flow is that point @xmath124 falls inside the iteration square of fig [ iteration ] , in other words that @xmath137 is larger than @xmath171 .
we show in appendix [ app2 ] that this happens if : @xmath172 the expression of the two limits @xmath173 and @xmath174 are given in the appendix and can be seen on fig .
[ limits ] .
they are solutions of @xmath175 , and exist only if the following condition holds : @xmath176 therefore , for a given @xmath177 negative flow is possible only above a certain value of @xmath92 ; this value is @xmath178 for @xmath179 , and tends to unity when @xmath18 tends to zero .
using a more realistic shape for the function @xmath86 with a rounding of the kink at @xmath138 ( no discontinuity of the derivative ) should lead to a shorter range of negative flow , making the phenomenon even less likely , as illustrated in fig .
[ limits ] . of course , the two above conditions ( [ 5d ] ) and ( [ 10j ] ) are necessary , but not sufficient ; they do not ensure that either beating or flow inversion will indeed take place , since this will be true only if the corresponding regions of the non - linear curve are reached during the iterations .
generally speaking , this will have more chance to occur in chaotic regimes , where many points are explored in the iterations , than in periodic regimes .
since no observation of negative flow has been reported in the literature , it is not clear whether this actually happens in real instruments . in conclusion of this section ,
the iteration function is similar to those usually considered in the context of iterated maps , without really belonging to the category of standard functions.the major difference is actually the effect of the control parameters on the function , since usually the control parameters acts as a gain , expanding the vertical axis of the graph ; here the parameter @xmath60 ( pressure in the mouth of the instrumentalist ) translates the iteration function along an axis at @xmath0 of the coordinate axis , while the other control parameter @xmath18 ( the pressure of the lip on the reed ) expands the function along the perpendicular axis .
it is therefore not surprising that we should find a parameter dependence of the dynamical behaviors that is significantly different from the standard results .
figure [ fig - bif ] shows an example of bifurcation curves , for @xmath180 and @xmath181 , and illustrates the relative complexity of the possible regimes .
the upper curve corresponds to the outgoing amplitude @xmath182 ( or @xmath90 ) , the middle curve to acoustic pressure @xmath31 , and the lower curve to the acoustic flow @xmath183 .
the three curves show the last 20 values obtained after computing 400 iterations for each value of the mouth pressure @xmath60 . by calculating @xmath184 iterations for a given value of the parameter @xmath60
, we have checked that the limit cycle is then reached .
obviously this method leads to stable regimes only . and @xmath185 .
for increasing values of the abscissa @xmath186 ( blowing pressure ) , corresponding to a crescendo , the curve show the values after 400 iterations of the outcoming wave @xmath187 ( top ) the pressure @xmath31 in the mouthpiece ( middle ) , and the volume flow @xmath183 ( bottom ) . above @xmath188
, the flow can be negative and the reed can beat .
the top figure also shows @xmath189 and @xmath190 ( mixed lines ) associated to the iteration square.,width=377 ] when the control parameter @xmath60 increases , the beginning of these curves follows a classical scenario of successive period doublings , leading eventually to chaos ; as expected , high values of the parameters @xmath18 and @xmath92 favour the existence of chaotic regimes , as well as beating reed or negative flow .
when @xmath60 continues to increase , another phenomenon takes place : chaos disappears and is replaced by a reverse scenario containing a series of frequency ( instead of period ) doublings .
we call this phenomenon a backwards cascade ( in order to distinguish it from the usual inverse cascade , which takes place within periodicity windows inside chaos @xcite ) ; this backwards cascade is a consequence of the specificities of the effect of the control parameter on the iteration function in our model , and of the particular shape of the iteration function ( for instance a straight line beyond the beating limit point ) . as a matter of fact , different kinds of cascades have been studied in the literature ( see e.g. @xcite and @xcite , in particular fig.5 ) .
[ fig - bif ] , the variations of @xmath60 correspond to a crescendo : for a given value of @xmath60 , the initial value for the iteration , @xmath191 , is chosen to be equal to the last value @xmath192 obtained with the previous value of @xmath60 .
but we have also studied the decrescendo regime and observed that , in the chaotic regimes , the plotted points differ from the crescendo points ; on the other hand , they remain the same in the periodic regimes , indicating a direct character of the bifurcations ( no hysteresis ) .
we have found an exception to this rule : between values @xmath193 and @xmath194 , 2-state and 4-state regimes coexist , indicating an inverse bifurcation .
another inverse bifurcation , between a 2-state regime and a static regime , occurs beyond the limit of the figure , the two regimes coexisting between @xmath195 and @xmath196 ; this is not shown here ( the shape of the curve can be found in ref .
@xcite , see upper fig .
the two limits of the function @xmath86 , @xmath102 and @xmath197 are also plotted in the upper figure ( @xmath187 ) showing that , as expected , the corresponding values remain inside the iteration square ( [ domain ] ) . in the figure at bottom ,
the results for the flow @xmath183 exhibit lower limits for negative flow and for beating , which are very close to the theoretical limits , respectively @xmath198 and @xmath199 and are located within the chaotic regime .
negative flow disappears at the bifurcation between the 4-state and the 2-state regime , @xmath200 , a much lower value than the higher limit for negative flow @xmath201 .
@xmath202=@xmath203=@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@xmath2160.4409@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@[email protected]@xmath2240.4479@[email protected]@xmath2260.4538@xmath2271.@[email protected]@xmath2306.3544@xmath231 table 1 shows the critical values of @xmath60 corresponding to changes of regime . up to the first chaotic regime ( @xmath232 ) , the behavior follows the usual period doubling cascade scenario . between @xmath233 and @xmath234
a periodicity windows @xcite is obtained , with 6-state , then 12-state and 24-state regimes ( but no 3-state regime ) . above the value @xmath232
for which chaos starts , an inverse cascade type scenario is observed , then intermittences occur , chaos again , and finally the backwards cascade to the static regime .
we did not try to obtain the same accuracy for the values of all different thresholds , because the ranges for @xmath60 have very different widths ; for some values of @xmath235 , it has been necessary to make up to 2000 iterations , and sometimes it is not obvious to distinguish between a chaotic regime , a long transient , or an intermittency regime .
we now discuss how the iterated functions can be used to study the different regimes and their stability .
we write @xmath236 the second iterate of @xmath55 , and more generally @xmath237 its iterate of order @xmath77 ; the derivative of @xmath55 with respect to @xmath90 is @xmath238 . around the fixed point @xmath239 of the first iterate @xmath86 ,
a taylor expansion gives : @xmath240 which provides the well known stability condition for a fixed point @xmath241 of @xmath86 : @xmath242 since the derivative of the iterate of order @xmath77 is given by : @xmath243 one can show by recurrence that , when @xmath244 , it is equal to the @xmath77-th power of the derivative of @xmath55 , so that : @xmath245 ^{n}+ .. \label{ddd}\ ] ] if the fixed point is stable ( resp .
unstable ) with respect to @xmath86 , it is also stable ( resp .
unstable ) with respect to any iterate .
if @xmath90 is a vector , instead of a scalar , this linearized approach leads to the floquet matrix , and @xmath238 should be replaced by the eigenvalues of the matrix .
@xmath246 and @xmath38 .
the 1st iterate @xmath86 is shown with a mixed line , the 2nd iterate @xmath236 with a ( blue ) solid line , and @xmath247 with a ( red ) , thin mixed line .
the dotted lines are the first diagonal and the straight line perpendicular at the fixed point @xmath248 of @xmath86 , solution of @xmath249 the tangent lines to iterate 1 at the point @xmath250 is shown with a solid line.,width=377 ] @xmath251 and @xmath38 , with the same plots that in figure [ iteree_gamma=031 ] .
the tangent lines at the new fixed points of @xmath236 , @xmath252 and @xmath253 , are also shown.,width=377 ] examples of iterated functions of order 1 , 2 , and 4 are shown in figures [ iteree_gamma=031 ] and [ iteree_gamma=042 ] , with the same values of @xmath166 and @xmath92 as in figure [ fig - bif ] ; in the former , the blowing pressure @xmath60 is @xmath254 , in the latter , @xmath60 is @xmath255 .
the first iterate has a unique fixed point , @xmath256 , @xmath257 , located by definition on the first diagonal .
the fixed point is stable if the absolute value of the derivative at @xmath248 is smaller than unity , in other words if the tangent line lies between the first diagonal ( with slope @xmath258 ) and its perpendicular ( with slope @xmath259 ) . when @xmath260 @xmath261 , we see in fig .
[ iteree_gamma=031 ] that the fixed point @xmath262 is stable , so that no oscillation takes place .
when @xmath79 increases , m * becomes instable and , at the same time , gives rise to three fixed points of @xmath263 . for @xmath264 , fig .
[ iteree_gamma=042 ] shows that the tangent is outside the angle between the diagonal and its perpendicular , so that the fixed point is now unstable ; on the other hand , the second iterate @xmath263 now has two more fixed points @xmath252 and @xmath253 with slopes less than @xmath88 ( in absolute value ) : we therefore have a stable 2-state regime .
the same scenario then repeats itself when @xmath60 continues to increase : at some value , points @xmath252 and @xmath253 become instable in turn ( the corresponding slope exceeds @xmath88 in absolute value ) , and both points @xmath252 and @xmath253 divide themselves into three fixed points of @xmath265 ; the two extreme new points have small slopes for this iterate , which leads to a 4-state stable regime . by the same process of successive division of fixed points of higher and higher iterates ,
one obtains an infinite number of period doublings , until eventually chaos is reached .
this is the classical feigenbaum route to chaos .
some general remarks are useful to understand the shape of the iterates in the figures : * if the value of @xmath86 for the abscissa @xmath90 verifies @xmath266 , i.e. if the point @xmath267(@xmath90 , @xmath86 ) is on a horizontal line @xmath268 , all iterates go through the same point ; * the extrema of @xmath236 verify either @xmath269 ( i.e. @xmath270 ) or @xmath271 , because @xmath272 f^{\prime } ( x)$ ] ; therefore the extrema of @xmath236 are at either the same abscissa or the same ordinate as those of @xmath86 ; * more generally , for @xmath273 , if @xmath274 , then @xmath275 , and it is at a maximum ( its first derivative vanishes and the second one is negative ) , and if @xmath276 , then @xmath277 , and it is at a minimum ( its first derivative vanishes and the second one is positive ) ; * the kink of the first iterate ( beating limit point ) is also visible on the iterates ; * a well known property of the schwarzian derivative is as follows : if the schwarzian derivative of @xmath86 is negative , the schwarzian derivatives of all iterates are negative as well .
@xmath251 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 and 16 .
the convergence to the 2-state regime is visible.,width=377 ] figure [ iteree_16 ] shows the higher order iterates ( of order 4 , 8 and 16 ) in the same conditions as figure [ iteree_gamma=042 ] .
we observe that the iterates become increasingly close together when their order increases , with smaller and smaller slopes at the fixed points corresponding to the 2-state regime .
moreover , they resemble more and more a square function , constant in various domains of the variable .
this was expected : in the limit of very large orders , whatever the variable is ( i.e. whatever the initial conditions of the iteration are ) one reaches a regime where only two values of the outgoing wave amplitude are possible ; these values then remain stable , meaning that the action of more iterations will not change them anymore .
so , one can read directly that the limit cycle is a 2-state on the shape of @xmath278 , which has two values ; it would for instance have 4 in the limit cycle was a 4-state regime for these values of the parameters .
for the clarity of the figure , we have shown only iterates with orders that are powers of @xmath279 , but it is of course easy to plot all iterates . for a 2-state regime ,
even orders are sufficient to understand the essence of the phenomenon , since odd order iterates merely exchange the two fixed points @xmath280 and @xmath253 . in table 1
, the existence of two different stable regimes for the same value of the parameters signals an inverse bifurcation ; figure [ iteree_16b ] shows an example of such a situation . for @xmath281 , both the static and 2-state regimes are then stable , depending on the initial conditions . for the static regime ,
the curve @xmath282 coincides with the second diagonal @xmath283 , a case in which the fixed point is presumably stable ( the stability becomes intuitive when one notices that the tangents of the higher order curves lie within the angle of the two diagonals ) . for the 2-state regime
, the state of positive pressure value corresponds to a beating reed .
@xmath284 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , and 8 .
the curves of @xmath285 and @xmath286 are almost perfectly superimposed . around @xmath139 ,
the convergence to the static regime appears to be very slow . on the contrary
the convergence to the 2-state regime is rapid .
, width=377 ] @xmath287 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 4 , 8 and 16 .
, width=377 ] finally fig.[iteree_16c ] shows another case of existence of two different regimes for the same value of the parameters .
a 2-state regime can occur , as well as a 4-state regimes can occur .
it appears that the second one is more probable than the first one , when initial conditions are varied .
we now investigate some regimes occurring in a narrow range of excitation parameter @xmath60 .
\(i ) we first examine a chaotic regime occurring just before a 6-state regime ( period tripling ) and the transition between the two regimes .
figure [ iteree_12a ] shows the iterated functions of order 1 , 2 , 6 , and 12 .
the 6th iterated function crosses the first diagonal at the same points than the first and the second iterates only , which means that no 6-state regime is expected .
by contrast , the 12th iterate cuts the diagonal at more points , but with a very high slope , indicating that the corresponding fixed points can not be stable .
this , combined with the fact that no convergence to a square function ( constant by domains ) , such as @xmath278 in figure [ iteree_16 ] , suggests an aperiodic behavior ; the time dependent signal shown in fig.[figtransit_04445 ] looks indeed chaotic ( nevertheless the flow always remains positive ) .
the periodic / chaotic character of the signal can be distinguished by examining the time series , but a complementary method is the computation of an fft . for the signal of fig.[figtransit_04445 ] , the spectrum is more regular than the spectrum of a 6-state periodic regime .
nevertheless the frequencies of the latter ( the `` normal '' frequency @xmath288 of the 2-state regime with the frequencies @xmath289 and @xmath290 ) remains visible in the spectrum of the first one , as it is often the case for signals corresponding to very close values of the parameter .
a consequence is that these frequencies clearly appear when listening the sound .
@xmath291 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 6 and 12 .
a convergence to an aperiodic regime is visible .
the arrow indicates a region where @xmath292 is very close to the first diagonal , but does not yet cross it.,width=377 ] for @xmath293 @xmath38 , @xmath294 , @xmath295 ; the upper part shows the the pressure @xmath31 , the lowest part the values of the flow @xmath183 .
the regime looks chaotic.,width=377 ] figure [ iteree_12b ] is similar to figure [ iteree_12a ] , but with a slightly larger value of @xmath60 ( @xmath296 instead of @xmath297 ) . in the region indicated by the arrow ,
one notices that the 6th iterated function now cuts the first diagonal .
they are 12 points of intersection ( plus 1 common point with the first iterate as well as two common points with the second iterate , all unstable ) ; the slope of the tangent shows that 6 of them are stable , so that one obtains a 6-state , periodic , regime .
the variations of higher order iterates , e.g. @xmath298 , remain very fast ; the convergence to the limit cycle is then much slower than for fig .
[ iteree_16 ] , except if the initial point is close to a limit point ( e.g. that shown by an arrow : it turns out that the 12th iterated function is very close to the 6th one ) . as a consequence ,
the initial transient to the 6-state regime can be rather chaotic , as shown in fig .
[ figtransit_04469 ] , but convergence to a periodic regime does occur later .
this existence of periodic regimes above the threshold for chaos is called periodicity windows , which appears as a narrow whiter region in fig .
[ fig - bif ] . a difference with the usual @xmath299-state regimes ( when @xmath60 is below the chaotic range ) , for instance corresponding to fig .
[ iteree_gamma=042 ] , is that one obtains @xmath299 intersections with the diagonal , stable or unstable ; by contrast , for the 6-state regime , they are 6 stable and 6 unstable points .
@xmath300 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 6 and 12 . a convergence to a 6-state regime is observed .
the arrow indicates a region where @xmath292 cuts the first diagonal.,width=377 ] for @xmath293 @xmath38 , @xmath301 , @xmath302 the regime is periodic ( 6-state).,width=377 ] \(ii ) we now examine the transition between a 6-state regime and a 4-state regime through chaotic regimes or intermittency regimes . for @xmath303 , a 6-state regime
is obtained .
[ iteree_6a ] shows the iterates of order 1 , 2 , 4 and 6 .
the 4th and 6th iterates have common intersections with the first and second iterates , since both 4 and 6 are multiples of 2 .
the 6th iterate intersects the first diagonal at 12 other points , while the 4th cuts the diagonal at 4 points only .
these 4 points are unstable , thus no 4-state regime can exist . on the contrary , for the 6th iterate , half of the 12 points are stable ( i.e. with a small slope of the tangent line ) , so that one obtains a 6-state stable regime .
@xmath304 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 4 and 6 . a convergence to a 6-state regime is observed .
, width=377 ] what happens for a higher value of @xmath305 namely @xmath306 corresponding to a 4-state regime is shown in fig .
[ iteree_6b ] , with again the iterates of order 1 , 2 , 4 , 6 .
the 4th iterate curve crosses the diagonal for the same number of points than previously , but the 4 points are now stable .
the 6th order iterate does not intersect the diagonal , except at the common points with the two first iterates .
@xmath307 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 4 and 6 . a convergence to a 4-state regime
is observed .
, width=377 ] between the two preceding values of the parameter @xmath60 , both chaotic and intermittent regimes can exist . for @xmath308 , figure [ figtransit_inter2 ] shows intermittencies between a chaotic and a 6-state behaviors ( upper curve ) , and figure [ iteree_046623 ] shows that the 6th iterate is tangent to the first diagonal in 6 points , so that the resulting permanent regime can be interpreted as a kind of hesitation between two behaviors .
the 4 intersections of the 4th iterate remain unstable .
+ the lower curve in figure [ figtransit_inter2 ] shows another , more visible , example of intermittencies , obtained with slightly different values of the parameters , between a chaotic regime and a 4-state one ( actually it is a 8-state one , very close to a 4-state regime ) . for @xmath293 @xmath38 , @xmath309 @xmath295 ( upper curve ) : intermittencies between chaos and a 6-state regime
are observed .
however the lower curve ( for @xmath310 @xmath38 , @xmath311 @xmath295 ) shows a more clear situation of intermittencies between chaos and a 4-state regime .
, title="fig:",width=377 ] for @xmath293 @xmath38 , @xmath309 @xmath295 ( upper curve ) : intermittencies between chaos and a 6-state regime are observed .
however the lower curve ( for @xmath310 @xmath38 , @xmath311 @xmath295 ) shows a more clear situation of intermittencies between chaos and a 4-state regime .
, title="fig:",width=377 ] @xmath312 and @xmath38 , of order 1 , 2 , 4 and 6 , corresponding to intermittencies .
the sixth iterate is tangent to the diagonal .
, width=377 ]
the study of the iteration model of the clarinet should not be limited to the first iterate : higher order iterates give interesting information on possible regimes of oscillation . in the limit of very high orders ,
their shape gives a direct indication of the number of states involved in the limit regime , or of chaotic behavior .
one can also predict an intermittent regime of the iterations , which takes place when an iterate is almost tangent to the first diagonal , so that the iterations are trapped for some time in a narrow channel .
the phenomenon might be related to some kinds of multiphonic sounds produced by the instrument .
it is true that this phenomenon takes place only in a rather narrow domain of parameters , but this is also the case of the period doubling cascade , which has been observed experimentally .
one can therefore reasonably hope that the present calculations will be followed by experimental observations .
this work was supported by the french national agency anr within the consonnes project .
we thank also the conservatoire neuchtelois and the high school arc - engineering in neuchtel .
finally we wish to thank sami karkar and christophe vergez for fruitful discussions .
our purpose is to obtain an analytical expression of the iteration function @xmath313 from the basic model ( eqs .
( [ 1 ] to [ 1ter ] , [ 4b-1 ] , [ recurrence ] ) ) , the following quantities can be defined : @xmath314 @xmath315 @xmath316 can be obtained from the knowledge of the function @xmath317 given by the solving of : @xmath318 for the non - beating reed case , the study of function @xmath319 leads to a direct analytical solution , as explained below , at least if @xmath320 ( otherwise it is a multi - valued function ) . finally , with the notation @xmath321 and @xmath322 , if @xmath323 is the heaviside function , the iteration function is obtained , as : @xmath324 for this case , both @xmath150 and@xmath326 are positive and smaller than unity , because @xmath327 writing @xmath328 , eq .
( [ a2 ] ) is written as : @xmath329 .\ ] ] the study of function @xmath330 shows that it is monotonously increasing from @xmath61 to @xmath88 when @xmath331 increases from @xmath61 to @xmath332 therefore the equation @xmath333 has a unique solution when @xmath334 with this condition , it appears that the equation has three real solutions , and that the interesting solution ( located between @xmath61 and @xmath88 ) is the intermediate one . as a conclusion ,
it is possible to use the classical formula for the solution of the cubic equation : @xmath335 + \frac{1}{3\zeta } \text { \ ; } \\ \psi & = & \frac{1}{\zeta ^{2}}\text { ; } \eta = \sqrt{3+\psi } \text { ; } \mu = % \frac{9}{2}(3y-1).\end{aligned}\ ] ] for this case , both @xmath150 and@xmath326 are negative@xmath337 writing @xmath338 , eq .
( [ a3 ] ) is written as follows : @xmath339 .\ ] ] the study of the function @xmath340 shows that it is monotonously decreasing from @xmath61 when @xmath331 increases from @xmath341 therefore the equation @xmath342 has a unique real , positive solution when @xmath343 the two other solutions are either real and negative or complex conjugate , with a negative real part , because the sum of the three solutions is negative ( @xmath344 ) . as a conclusion , the solution can be written by using the following formulae : [ [ if - the - discriminant - is - positive ] ] if the discriminant is positive @xmath345 @xmath346 \text { \ ; } r=-\frac{\psi + \mu } { % 27\zeta } \text { } . \\ \sqrt{-x } & = & z = s_{1}-\frac{q}{s_{1}}-\frac{1}{3\zeta } \text { ; } s_{1}=\left [ r+\sqrt{discr}\right ] ^{1/3}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ [ if - the - discriminant - is - negative ] ] if the discriminant is negative @xmath347 @xmath348 -\frac{1}{% 3\zeta } \text { ; } \\
\eta ^{\prime } & = & \sqrt{-3+\psi } .\end{aligned}\ ] ]
the condition of existence of negative flow is given by @xmath349.this is equivalent to the condition on the antecedents , @xmath350 , where @xmath351 is the larger antecedent of @xmath137 , such as @xmath352 because @xmath86 is decreasing for all @xmath353 ( see fig .
[ fonction - iteree])@xmath337 therefore the volume flow is negative at time @xmath354 . in order to determine the limit value @xmath355
, the following equations are to be used : @xmath356 @xmath60 being positive ( a reasonable hypothesis for the normal playing ) , the unknown @xmath150 needs to be larger than the quantity @xmath357 eliminating @xmath60 in the above equations implies the following equation , with @xmath358 : @xmath359 or @xmath360 with : an example of function @xmath366 is shown in fig . [ figfonctionh(x ) ] .
it appears that no solutions exist if @xmath367 and two solutions exist if @xmath368 , i.e. if inequation ( [ 10h ] ) holds .
the two solutions can be obtained analytically .
however , for sake of simplicity , we give the exact solution for the larger one , @xmath174 , and an approximation for the smaller one , @xmath173 , obtained at the first order in @xmath369 : @xmath370 \text { , } \label{10a } \\ & & \text { with } \varepsilon = \frac{\lambda -1 + 2\lambda a_{\zeta } } { ( \lambda + 1)\zeta + \lambda -1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this error is found to be less than @xmath371 in comparison with the exact value .
condition ( [ 10h ] ) can be shown to be necessary and sufficient .
we do not give the entire proof , but it can be shown that another necessary condition for having two solutions is @xmath372 , or @xmath373 , but it is implied by condition ( [ 10h ] ) .
[ limits ] shows that the first negative flow threshold @xmath173 is very close to the threshold @xmath164 , and slightly smaller . for a given @xmath92
, the limit value of @xmath18 such as @xmath374 corresponds to the equality between the beating reed threshold and the negative flow one . for a given @xmath177 negative flow
is possible above a certain value of @xmath92 . for rather strong losses ,
if @xmath375 , no negative flow can occur . for a cylindrical resonator , this implies that @xmath376 .
collet , p. and eckmann , j.p .
, `` properties of continuous maps of the interval to itself '' , _ mathematical problems in theoretical physics _
, k. osterwalder ( ed . ) , springer - verlag , heidelberg , 1979 ; _ iterated maps on the interval as dynamical systems _ ,
birkhuser , basel , 1980 .
feigenbaum , j. , `` the universal metric properties of nonlinear transformations '' .
_ journal of statistical physics , _ 21 , 1979 , 669 - 706 ; `` the metric universal properties of period doubling bifurcations and the spectrum for a route to turbulence '' , _ annals of the new york academy of science _ , 357 , 1980 , * * * * 330 - 336 .
kergomard , j. , `` elementary considerations on reed - instrument oscillations '' . in _ mechanics of musical instruments _ , vol .
* 335 * ( a. hirschberg/ j. kergomard/ g. weinreich , eds),of _ cism courses and lectures _ , pages 229290 .
springer - verlag , wien , 1995 .
lize , a. , doublement de priode dans les instruments anche simple de type clarinette , master degree thesis , paris 2004 , http://www.atiam.ircam.fr/archives/stages0304/lizee.pdf [ http://www.atiam.ircam.fr/archives/stages0304/lizee.pdf ] idogawa , t. , kobata , t. , komuro , k. and masakazu , i. , nonlinear vibrations in the air column of a clarinet artificially blown , _ journal of the acoustical society of america , _ 93 , 1993 , 540551 .
kergomard , j. , dalmont , j.p . ,
gilbert , j. and guillemain , ph . .
`` period doubling on cylindrical reed instruments '' . _ in proceedings ot the joint congress cfa / daga04 , _ pages 113114 , strasbourg , 22th 25th march 2004 .
dalmont , j .-
p . , gilbert , j. , kergomard , j. and ollivier , s. `` an analytical prediction of the oscillation and extinction thresholds of a clarinet '' .
_ journal of the acoustical society of america _ , 118 , 2005 , 32943305 .
hirschberg , a. , van de laar , r. w. a. , marrou - maurires , j. p. , wijnands , a. p. j. , dane , h. j. , kruijswijk , s. g. and houtsma , a. j. m. a quasi - stationary model of air flow in the reed channel of single - reed woodwind instruments .
_ acustica _ , 70 , 1990 , 146154 .
dalmont , j .-
, gilbert , j. and ollivier , s. .
`` nonlinear characteristics of single - reed instruments : quasistatic volume flow and reed opening measurements '' , _ journal of the acoustical society of america , _ 114 , 2003 , 22532262 .
dalmont , j .-
p . and frapp , c. , `` oscillation and extinction thresholds of the clarinet : comparison of analytical results and experiments '' .
_ journal of the acoustical society of america _ , 122 , 2007 , 11731179 .
causs , r. , kergomard , j. , lurton , x. , `` input impedance of brass musical instruments - comparison between experiment and numerical model '' , _ journal of the acoustical society of america , _ 75 , 1984 , 241 - 254 .
mayer - kress , g. and haken , h. , `` attractors of convex maps with positive schwarzian derivative in the presence of noise '' , _
physica 10d _ , 1984 , 329 - 339 .
parlitz , u. , englisch , v. , scheffczyk , c. and lauterborn , w. , `` bifurcation structure of bubble oscillators '' , _ journal of the acoustical society of america , _ 88 , 1990 , 1061 - 1077 .
scheffczyk , c. , parlitz , u. , kurz , t. , knop , w. , lauterborn , w. , `` comparison of bifurcation structures of driven dissipative nonlinear oscillators'',_physical review a _ , 43 , 1991 , 6495 - 6502 . | the dynamical equations of clarinet - like systems are known to be reducible to a non - linear iterated map within reasonable approximations .
this leads to time oscillations that are represented by square signals , analogous to the raman regime for string instruments . in this article
, we study in more detail the properties of the corresponding non - linear iterations , with emphasis on the geometrical constructions that can be used to classify the various solutions ( for instance with or without reed beating ) as well as on the periodicity windows that occur within the chaotic region . in particular
, we find a regime where period tripling occurs and examine the conditions for intermittency .
we also show that , while the direct observation of the iteration function does not reveal much on the oscillation regime of the instrument , the graph of the high order iterates directly gives visible information on the oscillation regime ( characterization of the number of period doubligs , chaotic behaviour , etc . ) .
keywords : bifurcations , iterated maps , reed musical instruments , clarinet , acoustics . |
studies of detached , double - lined eclipsing binary systems ( debs ) allow for direct measurements of the masses and radii of stars .
these measurements have direct implications for theories of stellar structure and evolution .
our understanding of the structure of stars on the lower main sequence has improved over the past decade , but relatively few direct measurements of stellar mass and radius exist for objects with masses @xmath7 .
measurements of stars in this mass range allow us to test models of stellar structure where they are least well constrained by observation .
there are four known main sequence debs inhabiting this mass range and the properties of these systems are well - measured ( @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . in order to refine physical models of low - mass stars , more systems must be discovered and studied .
large - area synoptic surveys offer the best hope for the identification of new low - mass eclipsing systems .
the photometric databases of shallow , wide - angle , surveys such as those aimed at the discovery of grb afterglows or transiting planets , are already being combed for the most interesting binary systems @xcite , but the number of m dwarfs in these shallow surveys is limited .
these surveys have also been used to identify low - mass single - lined systems from which the mass and radius of an unseen companion can be inferred @xcite . the advent of deeper surveys with sparser time sampling ( less than one observation per day ) , such as pan - starrs @xcite and lsst @xcite , will become a vital resource for studies of variable objects of all types . since low - mass stars are intrinsically faint , deep surveys may prove particularly powerful for studies of these objects .
the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) and its follow - up survey sdss - ii are excellent prototypes of the types of data that these future surveys will produce . here , we report the first results from a program to identify debs in sdss - ii observations of an area of the sky scanned repeatedly as part of the sdss supernova survey program .
we present the discovery of a new deb along with mass and radius measurements of these two low - mass stars based on spectra taken with keck / lris and near infrared ( nir ) photometry gathered with the robotic telescope pairitel .
this discovery helps to fill in a poorly sampled portion of the mass - radius relation for low - mass stars . in section 2 , we describe the identification of this deb and the follow - up observations . in section 3
, we describe our analysis , modeling , and the derivation of the physical parameters of the system . in sections 4 and 5
we discuss our results in the context of the known low - mass eclipsing binary systems and future prospects for the discovery of similar systems .
the sdss - ii supernova survey @xcite repeatedly observes about 300 deg@xmath8 of sky centered around the celestial equator . the raw data ,
both imaging and uncalibrated outputs from the photometric pipeline , are made publicly available through the sdss sn archive server .
we downloaded all of the imaging data from @xmath9 band and the corresponding pipeline outputs available as of april , 2006 . in total , nearly @xmath10 individual 2048 by 1489 pixel images from 70 observing runs were available .
we calibrated the uncalibrated outputs of the photometric pipeline against stars from the sdss dr4 @xcite photometric catalog .
this was done by matching the pixel coordinates of stars in the raw @xmath9-band images to the coordinates of preselected catalog f - g - k stars and calculating a simple photometric solution for each individual image using raw @xmath11 magnitudes ( no color terms ) .
once the positions of stars in the raw @xmath9-band images were matched to the photometric pipeline outputs , a similar photometric solution was calculated in the @xmath12 and @xmath13-bands .
recent work by @xcite and @xcite presents more sophisticated methods for calibrating repeat observations in sdss .
we found our technique to produce individual light curves with rms of between 0.03 and 0.05 mag ( @xmath1419.0 ) , adequate precision for the detection of large eclipse signals .
we preselected a set of 19,000 m dwarf targets from the photometric database of sdss dr4 .
this was done following m dwarf colors presented by @xcite and requiring that objects have flags corresponding to high photometric quality .
our targets all have @xmath15 and @xmath16 , corresponding roughly to a sample of objects of spectral types m4 and later with @xmath17 band photometric precision better than @xmath18 .
faint objects with colors of @xmath19 are expected to be almost exclusively m dwarfs since other types of point sources , such as quasars and m giants , are very rare in this portion of the color - magnitude diagram @xcite .
we generated @xmath20 light curves for all of these objects , each light curve consisting of between 10 and 30 observations in each band .
we identified potential eclipsing sources by searching for objects that exhibited decreases in brightness of more than 0.20 mag which were found to occur simultaneously in all three bands .
this conservative requirement for the large amplitude of the dimming and the requirement that it be found in all three bands resulted in a robust method for identifying eclipsing candidates .
since we have relatively few observations of each target , we require a conservative detection threshold to ensure a very low rate of false positives . our analysis produced a list of 13 candidates that have been observed as part of an ongoing program to identify debs in sdss - ii .
of these candidates , sdss031824 - 010018 was the most promising .
the sdss - ii light curve of this object , which we call sdss - meb-1 , contained 15 points in @xmath21 and @xmath13 and displayed two epochs with fluxes that were lower than the mean flux by @xmath22 mag in each band .
an expanded sdss - ii light curve , containing additional data , is shown in figure [ figa ] .
the basic observed parameters of sdss - meb-1 are given in table 1 .
we observed sdss - meb-1 with the pairitel robotic nir observatory between 9 september , 2006 and 8 october , 2006 .
observations consisted of 30 to 60 minutes of individual 7.8s integrations on each clear night .
the pairitel camera takes images in the @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 bands simultaneously .
the pairitel imager was originally used for the southern portion of the 2mass survey @xcite .
the observations were automatically scheduled , collected , and reduced with the fully robotic observing system described in @xcite and @xcite .
the images were gathered using a randomized dither pattern and individual integrations were combined into mosaics with total integration time of @xmath26300s using _ swarp _ @xcite .
we produced differential aperture photometry relative to a set of comparison stars from the 2mass catalog and photometric errors were estimated based on read noise and photon noise .
our analysis resulted in 937 individual measurements in @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 bands .
we report the @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 measurements in table 2 .
we observed sdss - meb-1 spectroscopically using the lris @xcite instrument on keck on 20 september 2006 and 21 november 2006 .
spectra were taken at resolutions r@xmath27 and r@xmath28 using the @xmath29 grooves mm@xmath30 , 8500 blaze and @xmath31 grooves mm@xmath30 , 7500 blaze gratings with a 1@xmath32 slit .
these two setups cover the spectral ranges 5550 - 9270 and 6335 - 7600 , respectively .
we observed the standard star hd 19445 for flux calibration .
we extracted the red channel spectra following the optimal extraction method outlined by @xcite .
we did not observe any radial velocity standards , so wavelength solutions were determined using both hgnear comparison lamps and isolated night sky emission lines from the catalog of @xcite .
all spectra showed prominent emission due to @xmath33 and the @xmath34 spectra revealed two distinct emission lines .
the detection of h@xmath35 emission demonstrates that the stars have chromospheric activity . the percentage of low - mass stars that are found to be active peaks at spectral type m5 , where up to @xmath36 of stars may show @xmath33 emission @xcite .
we also obtained high - resolution imaging of the field around sdss - meb-1 on 15 october , 2006 using the scam camera on keck / nirspec . in @xmath37 seeing we find no companions between 1@xmath32 and @xmath38 down to an approximate limiting magnitude of @xmath39=18.5 .
an initial inspection of the pairitel photometry revealed large changes in the observed brightness of this system , a clear signature of an eclipsing binary .
we estimated the period of the system using the phase dispersion minimization method of @xcite in two stages .
a first pass using coarse resolution in trial frequency indicated a prominent peak in the periodogram at around 0.4d with lesser peaks at double and half this period .
we re - calculated a periodogram around @xmath40d using a fine spacing in trial frequency of 2.5 day@xmath30 .
we fit a parabola to the peak in this high - resolution periodogram to estimate the period of the system and found @xmath0=0.407037@xmath41d .
we determined a precise time of zero phase with a parabolic fit to the center of the primary eclipse in the folded light curve and estimated the epoch of primary eclipse to be @xmath42 ( hjd ) .
we determined the radial velocities of both components of the binary by modeling the two @xmath33 emission lines seen in the @xmath34 spectra .
for both the @xmath34 and @xmath43 spectra we began by fitting gaussian profiles to isolated emission lines in comparison lamp spectra in order to determine the width of the instrumental profile .
we found that the individual @xmath33 emission lines in the spectra of sdss - meb-1 were resolved in the @xmath34 spectra so the gaussian profiles were broadened to fit the data .
we assume the same width for each of the @xmath33 emission lines .
two of our @xmath34 spectra were acquired when the velocity separation between the two stars was close to maximal . in these spectra ,
the two emission lines are individually resolved and well separated and we fit a model of two super - imposed gaussians to a @xmath44 portion of the spectra around @xmath33 .
this model has five parameters : one for the centers of each gaussian , one for the width of both gaussians , one for their relative heights , and one for overall flux scaling .
we used @xmath45 minimization to fit for these parameters in the spectra taken near phase 0.25 .
a spectrum of sdss - meb-1 around the region of the two emission lines , along with the best - fit model , is shown in figure [ figb ] .
we used the fits to these well - separated lines to fix the relative heights of the emission lines and their widths .
the two emission lines are partially or totally blended in the rest of our data , particularly in the @xmath43 spectra where they are both unresolved and blended . for the remaining @xmath34 spectra we used the fixed widths and relative heights determined previously to fit for the velocities of the two components .
for the @xmath43 spectra we used the relative heights determined previously and widths corresponding to the instrumental profile determined from fits to emission lines in comparison lamp spectra .
we derived errors on the radial velocity estimates of each component in each spectrum based on the formal errors of the @xmath45 fit added in quadrature to the error estimate for the wavelength solution .
all of the radial velocities are corrected to the solar system barycenter using a the iraf routine _
bcvcorr_. our radial - velocity measurements are presented in table 3 along with the estimated radial velocity curve parameters in table 4 . while the uncertainty on our individual radial velocity measurements , particularly those from the @xmath43 spectra , are large , the radial velocities align very well with the epoch and period determined from the photometry alone . in order to estimate the system orbital parameters and the masses of each component we fixed the period and epoch of primary eclipse , assumed an eccentricity of @xmath46 , and
fit a three parameter model to the radial velocity data .
we estimated the two radial velocity amplitudes , @xmath47 and @xmath48 , and the systemic velocity , @xmath49 with a @xmath45 minimization . assuming a keplerian orbit with no eccentricity , the parameters of the radial velocity orbit translate easily into estimates for @xmath50 , @xmath51 , and @xmath52 @xcite .
we estimated the errors on each of these values through a bootstrap simulation .
we follow the convention that the primary star is the one eclipsed at phase 0 , which is also the more massive star .
this results in the marginally deeper eclipse depth seen at phase 0 .
the radial - velocity measurements , along with the best - fit model , are shown in figure [ figd ] .
close inspection of the spectra resulting in two discrepant ( off by @xmath53 from the model ) measurements from ut nov 21 ( near phase 0.45 ) indicated that the measurements were likely biased by the superposition of a sky emission line on the shoulder of the marginally - blended h@xmath35 lines .
in addition , some of our radial - velocity observations occur very close the time of primary eclipse .
assuming a rotation period locked to the orbital period of the system , we estimate that the amplitude of the rossiter - mclaughlin effect is small comparable to our radial - velocity precision . in order to increase the power of light curve modeling , and to break a partial degeneracy that exists in the determination of the ratio of the two stellar radii for systems with comparable eclipse depths or partial
eclipses , we estimated the light ratio from our @xmath34 spectra .
we fit spectra taken near phase 0.0 , when the component velocities are perpendicular to our line of sight , to template m dwarf spectra made available by @xcite .
we found good agreement between our spectra and the active m4 dwarf template spectra . in figure [ figc ]
we show the spectrum of sdss - meb-1 compared to the template of @xcite .
we solved for the light ratio by fitting spectra taken at other phases to the sum of two active m4 dwarf template spectra doppler shifted relative to each other and each scaled by a different multiplicative factor .
the doppler shifts of the two template spectra were fixed to values defined by the fit to the radial velocity curve .
we calculated a @xmath45 goodness - of - fit between the model comprised of the weighted sum of the templates and our spectra for a range of relative brightnesses between 0.5 and 2.0 . during the fitting , the area around the @xmath33 emission lines
was given no weight .
a fit to the region around the minimum of the resulting @xmath45 surface yielded a light ratio estimate of @xmath54 .
@xcite presents theoretical evolutionary models of low - mass stars , the predictions of which we can compare to this estimate of the light ratio .
the spectra used in our analysis span the wavelength range @xmath55 to @xmath56 , comparable to the @xmath57 band . at an age of 2 gyr and [ m / h]=0.0
, @xcite predicts a light ratio of 0.744 ( 0.740 at t=5gyr ) in the cousins / bessel @xmath57 band for the stellar masses determined from the fit to the radial velocity curve .
based on the reasonable agreement between our light ratio estimate and the value predicted from theory , we adopt the nir light ratio estimates of @xcite throughout our modeling of the light curves .
we estimated the error on this light - ratio estimate using a monte - carlo simulation by varying the masses ( assuming @xmath58 ) of the two components of the binary within their errors .
we estimated an uncertainty of @xmath59 in our light ratio estimate and do not include a systematic contribution due to any biases that may be inherent to the @xcite models themselves .
we modeled our nir light curves using the ebop @xcite technique as implemented in the code _ jktebop _ by j. southworth @xcite . here , we fixed the mass ratio , period , eccentricity , epoch , and the brightness ratio @xmath60 and fit for the sum of the radii of the stars in terms of the orbital separation , @xmath61 , the ratio of the radii of the stars , the inclination angle @xmath9 , and the ratio of the central surfaces brightnesses , @xmath62 .
we fixed the gravity darkening exponent to 0.32 as appropriate for a convective star @xcite and calculated the reflection coefficients from bolometric theory .
we used logarithmic limb darkening coefficients for a @xmath63=3200k , @xmath64 star from @xcite for nir passbands .
the _ jktebop _ implementation of ebop allows for the estimation of errors on the parameters using monte - carlo simulations .
based on the quality and quantity of the photometric data collected with pairitel , as well as the long time baseline of the observations , we did not attempt to model spots on the components of the sdss - meb-1 system . based on the ebop models of the system , the out - of - eclipse variations are expected to be very small compared to the photometric errors .
this allows us to evaluate the validity of our estimated photometric errors .
we scaled our photometric error estimates until the reduced @xmath65 of the data at phase @xmath66 , assuming constant brightness , was 1.0 .
we derived the errors on our estimated parameters from @xmath67 bootstrapping simulations and include our estimate of the uncertainty on the orbital separation @xmath68 .
we found other sources of error from fixed parameters , such as the mass ratio and the limb darkening model , to be negligible .
we fit the @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and @xmath71 band light curves with consistent results .
the photometric errors on our @xmath25 photometry are large ( @xmath72 ) compared to the eclipse depth and so the constraints on the system parameters from this band are relatively poor .
we derived final values for the light curve parameters in two stages .
first , the geometric ( @xmath9 , @xmath73 , @xmath74 ) parameters were determined from weighted average of those from the @xmath23 , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 observations . with these geometric parameters fixed , we ran the ebop analysis a second time to better determine the radiative parameters ( central surface brightness ratio @xmath62 and total light ratio @xmath60 ) . the model fit to our @xmath23-band data is shown in figures [ fige ] and [ figf ] and the parameters from our ebop analysis are shown in table 5 .
the physical parameters of the sdss - meb-1 system derived from the radial velocity and photometric analyses are given in table 6 .
we estimate the ratio of the radius of each component to the radius of its roche lobe to be 0.389 and 0.367 for the primary and secondary , respectively .
we estimated the effective temperatures ( @xmath63 ) of each component of sdss - meb-1 by combining the results of the ebop analysis with the barnes - evans color - surface brightness relation .
the ebop analysis of the nir light curves provides @xmath62 , the ratio of the central surface brightnesses of the two stars . from the work of @xcite
we can relate the ratio of the average surface brightnesses of the two stars to the ratio of their @xmath75 colors .
since the temperatures of the two stars are expected to be similar , our assumption of the same limb darkening model for each star allows us to assume that the ratio of the central surface brightnesses is the same as the ratio of the average surface brightnesses . following the color - temperature relations of @xcite we convert nir colors into temperatures .
these relations are used to both turn the color ratio determined from the barnes - evans relation into a temperature ratio and to estimate the average temperature of the system . from the combined color of the sdss - meb-1 , we estimate the luminosity - weighted average temperature of the system . converting the denis @xmath76 to a cousins @xmath77 following @xcite and the 2mass @xmath25 and @xmath23 to @xmath78 and @xmath79 following @xcite we estimate the luminosity - weighted average temperature of the sdss - meb-1 system to be @xmath80 .
the temperature ratio estimate and the estimate of the average temperature of the system comprise a system two equations in two unknowns , @xmath81 and @xmath82 , which we solve numerically to arrive at the @xmath63 estimates given in table 6 .
the errors on the temperature estimates are derived from monte carlo simulations in which the errors from each of the colors and color transformations are propagated .
we find that the temperatures of the two stars are consistent within the large errors and that the values agree well with the estimated temperatures for the components of the system cm draconis , which have similar masses @xcite .
we combine the results of the light - curve and radial - velocity analyses to produce the physical parameters of the system listed in table 6 .
the components of sdss - meb-1 fall in a mass regime were there are currently few direct mass and radius measurements from debs .
our measurements are in good agreement with the empirical mass - radius relation of @xcite as well as the theoretical models ( @xmath838.0 , 9.0 ; [ m / h]=0 ) of @xcite .
recent work by @xcite has explored the importance of rotation and magnetic activity in the evolution of low - mass stars in binaries . since both components of sdss - meb-1 show h@xmath35 emission , demonstrating magnetic activity , a more precise set of system parameters could place important constraints on these new models .
our two new mass and radius measurements , along with models and other low - mass stars from the literature , are shown in figure [ figg ] .
if our system were very young then our radius estimates would would fall about @xmath84 below the 0.1 gyr relation of @xcite .
while sdss - meb-1 does lie in the vicinity of orion , it is located more than @xmath85 from known star - forming regions .
we also compare the @xmath86 and @xmath63 estimates from sdss - meb-1 to models from @xcite . in figure [ figh ]
we compare the two components of sdss - meb-1 to isochrones and mass - tracks . using the solar metallicity models
, we find a best - fit age for the system of @xmath87 .
we find good agreement between the mass - tracks and isochrones from the @xcite models .
both bias in the color - temperature relation we use and interstellar reddening could be important in temperature estimates of debs . according to the maps of @xcite , the total reddening in the direction of sdss - meb-1 in the nir color we use to calibrate temperature
is @xmath88 .
based on comparison of the observed @xmath23-@xmath39 colors of sdss - meb-1 to the same isochrones , we estimate a @xmath69band modulus and a distance of the system of @xmath89 pc . at the position of sdss - meb-1 relative to the galactic disk
, we expect a significant portion of the total estimated reddening along the line of sight . since the average color of the system is an important factor in the determination of the individual temperatures , for @xmath90 we will underestimate the temperatures of the components of sdss - meb-1 .
we estimate that for each 0.1 mag increase in @xmath91 our estimated temperatures of the stars decreases by @xmath92k . with current data we lack sufficient precision to identify shortcomings in the models of low - mass stars .
increasing the total number of known low - mass deb systems across a wide range of masses will improve our understanding of these objects .
deep , large - area surveys with sparse time sampling represent an excellent resource for the identification of new low - mass eclipsing systems .
we have demonstrated that even as few as 15 high - quality , multi - color observations can be useful for identifying important new objects . while the amplitude of the eclipse signal is large enough to reliably identify promising candidates with synoptic surveys , objects discovered in this way present unique difficulties in terms of follow - up observations .
the sparse sampling of the discovery light curves requires a significant investment of observing time to generate a complete light curve . focusing on relatively faint targets with good photometric precision results in a vast increase in the total number of targets ,
particularly m dwarfs , and affords an increase in the number of viable targets for searching for eclipsing binaries and transiting planets . at the same time , the spectroscopic and photometric followup becomes more problematic and more expensive as the candidates become fainter .
the study of eclipsing systems with future synoptic surveys will require a shift in emphasis from discovery to follow - up observations .
robotic observing systems , such as pairitel , are ideally suited for this type or work and will become an integral part of transient science produced by future synoptic surveys .
the discovery of sdss - meb-1 highlights the potential importance of the sdss - ii , and future synoptic data sets , for studies of eclipsing systems .
the sdss - ii data are qualitatively different from the data sets typically used to search for low - mass eclipsing systems .
current planetary transit surveys tend to produce high - quality , high - cadence photometry for a relatively small number of targets .
future synoptic surveys will acquire fewer observations per target , with comparatively worse precision , but will observe orders of magnitude more targets .
we attempt to quantify the potential impact of sdss - ii on studies of low - mass stars by estimating the number of deb systems that are likely to be present in the sdss - ii data .
we used the @xmath93 to @xmath9-band absolute magnitude relations from @xcite and color relations of @xcite to estimate the absolute magnitudes of all of the point sources with @xmath94 contained in the sdss - ii repeat scan region .
these absolute magnitudes were first converted to bessel magnitudes and then to mass estimates following the solar - age , solar - metallicity isochrones of @xcite .
our estimate includes stars with mass @xmath95 .
we assume a total binary fraction of @xmath96 @xcite and integrate the mass - ratio distribution and semi - major axis distribution of @xcite in order to estimate the total number of binaries in our survey and the distribution of their parameters .
we place several constraints on these binaries to estimate the number of systems that could be identified in the sdss - ii data and confirmed with follow - up observations .
since radial velocity observations are crucial for obtaining masses and radii of these stars , we constrain our targets to be brighter than @xmath97 with both components exhibiting radial - velocity semi - amplitudes of at least 30 km s@xmath30 . in order to ensure that the system is double - lined
, we also require that the ratio of the luminosities of the components is no less than 0.1 .
we require that the system be in eclipse for more than @xmath98 of the time , so that the expected number of points in eclipse is @xmath99 with sdss - ii , and that the amplitude of the eclipse is @xmath100 .
we estimate the total number of stars in systems meeting these criteria in mass bins of width 0.05 m@xmath101 after scaling for the geometric probability of observing an eclipse for a given system .
the results of our simulation are shown in figure [ figi ] .
we estimate that the sdss - ii may contain as many as 12 low - mass eclipsing binary systems where both components are in the mass range @xmath95 .
our estimate attempts to count systems that are likely to be identified in the sdss - ii data and for which precise determination of mass and radius will be possible .
our simulation predicts the detection of between 1 and 7 stars ( @xmath102 confidence ) of mass @xmath103 , not inconsistent with our detection of the binary sdss - meb-1 ( comprised of two low - mass stars ) .
these estimates are only rough approximations since the binary fraction of m dwarfs , and the properties of their companions , are not well known .
work by @xcite points to an overabundance of short - period , @xmath104 m dwarf binary systems .
any such systematic differences in the properties of m dwarf and g dwarf binaries would effect the validity of our estimates . the high quality , and shear quantity , of the data produced by synoptic surveys like sdss - ii also opens up the possibility of searching for small companions extending down into the regime of brown dwarfs and extrasolar planets . in principle , it is possible to detect eclipses of jupiter - mass objects in the sdss - ii data . the giant planet and brown dwarf models of @xcite indicate that a companion more massive than @xmath105 results in an eclipse depth of @xmath100 for primaries with radii @xmath106 . while the @xmath98 eclipse signal is probably at the limit of detectability with our current photometric calibration of the sdss - ii data ,
@xcite have shown that homogeneous , @xmath107 photometry can be derived from repeat sdss observations .
future work focusing on purely differential photometry of stars in the sdss - ii data could potentially extend sensitivity to neptune - size planets orbiting the smallest stars . extrapolating from the 5 gyr , solar - metallicity isochrones of @xcite and the low - mass star colors of @xcite and @xcite
( converting sdss to bessell colors ) we estimate that our current selection criteria identifies @xmath26 40,000 ( @xmath108 ) targets with @xmath106 . while detection of a transit by a jupiter - mass object may be feasible , follow - up radial - velocity observations to confirm the mass of the system will be very difficult for all but the brightest objects .
our experience with sdss - meb-1 indicates that radial velocities with 10 km s@xmath30 precision should be feasible with reasonable exposure times for targets brighter than @xmath109 .
if we assume that a radial - velocity signal of semi - amplitude @xmath110 km s@xmath30 can be detected with a reasonable investment of telescope time , then companions with @xmath111 can be detected in orbits with periods @xmath112 days around all of these targets .
@xcite have demonstrated radial - velocity precision of 0.3 km s@xmath30 using high - resolution infrared spectroscopy , but only for relatively bright objects ( @xmath113 ) .
unfortunately , only about 1100 of the m dwarfs we selected are this bright but for these targets we are capable of radial - velocity confirmation of companions as small as @xmath114 .
still , radial velocity followup of these fainter systems may be feasible with the next generation of 30 m ground - based optical telescopes .
future deep , large - area synoptic surveys will contain a treasure trove of eclipsing systems and allow for the direct measurement of masses and radii of many low - mass objects down to the bottom of the main sequence .
we demonstrate that photometry of faint objects with sparse time sampling can be used to discover important new eclipsing systems . with these systems , the challenge will lie in the follow - up observations necessary to produce precise estimates of the physical parameters of the system and it is likely that robotic observing facilities will play a crucial role in these investigations .
we have presented here a new low - mass double lined eclipsing binary discovered in a data set that can serve as a prototype for the next generation of synoptic surveys , and demonstrated that follow - up observations of these objects are feasible . by extending to fainter objects and focusing on smaller stars it will be possible to greatly expand the number of viable targets for a search for eclipsing low - mass star and brown dwarf companions .
we would like to thank d. charbonneau , l. eyer , .
izevi , d. latham , and m. wood - vasey for useful discussions and assistance that contributed to this work .
we thank d. starr for all of his work on the pairitel system and j. southworth for developing the _ jktebop _ code and for making it available to the public .
we also thank d. perley and d. kocevski for assistance with some of our keck observations .
we thank an anonymous referee for thoughtful comments that helped to improve this manuscript .
chb is supported by the harvard origins of life initiative .
gt acknowledges partial support from nsf grant ast-0708229 and nasa s massif sim key project ( blf57 - 04 ) .
jsb is partially supported by las cumbres observatory as well as the sloan research foundation .
the peters automated infrared imaging telescope ( pairitel ) is operated by the smithsonian astrophysical observatory ( sao ) and was made possible by a grant from the harvard university milton fund , the camera loan from the university of virginia , and the continued support of the sao and uc berkeley .
the pairitel project is further supported by nasa / swift guest investigator grant nng06gh50 g .
we thank m. skrutskie , e. falco and the staff at fred l. whipple observatory for their continued support of the pairitel project .
we wish to extend special thanks to those of hawaiian ancestry on whose sacred mountain we are privileged to be guests . funding for the sdss and sdss - ii has been provided by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , the u.s .
department of energy , the national aeronautics and space administration , the japanese monbukagakusho , the max planck society , and the higher education funding council for england .
bertin , e. mellier , y. , radovich , m. , missonnier , g. , didelon , r. , & morin , b. 2002 . in
astronomical data analysis software and systems xi " , asp conf .
, vol . 281 .
d. bohlender , d. durand , & t. h. handley ( eds . ) , p. 228
- , @xmath9- , @xmath17- , and @xmath115-bands .
the 2005 observations during two eclipses are readily apparent in all bands .
the zero - points of the images were calibrated by tying the catalog psf_counts fluxes to sdss dr4 catalog magnitudes . ]
lc ra ( j2000 ) & 03:18:23.88 + dec ( j2000 ) & @xmath11601:00:18.4 + @xmath115 & 20.818@xmath117 + @xmath17 & 19.290@xmath118 + @xmath9 & 17.681@xmath119 + @xmath13 & 16.792@xmath120 + @xmath23 & 15.396@xmath121 + @xmath24 & 15.725@xmath122 + @xmath25 & 14.623@xmath123 + @xmath76 & 16.907@xmath124 + lccc 53995.8909 & j & 15.350 & 0.043 + 53995.8929 & j & 15.356 & 0.045 + 53995.8950 & j & 15.350 & 0.043 + 53995.8971 & j & 15.288 & 0.043 + 53995.8992 & j & 15.422 & 0.067 + 53995.9013 & j & 15.295 & 0.045 + 53995.9034 & j & 15.323 & 0.064 + 53995.9056 & j & 15.393 & 0.048 + 53995.9077 & j & 15.406 & 0.048 + 53995.9098 & j & 15.543 & 0.051 + ..... & ..... & ..... + lccccc 54000.13646 & 15.79 & 21.70 & @xmath116159.32 & 10.33 & 400/8500 + 54000.14036 & 27.63 & 24.28 & @xmath116120.50 & 11.14 & 400/8500 + 54000.14427 & 14.60 & 29.89 & @xmath116137.36 & 13.29 & 400/8500 + 54060.84514 & @xmath11649.19 & 14.90 & @xmath11664.03 & 7.39 & 1200/7500 + 54060.84904 & @xmath11655.76 & 19.44 & @xmath11665.21 & 8.83 & 1200/7500 + 54060.97794 & @xmath116147.97 & 5.88 & 49.48 & 5.19 & 1200/7500 + 54060.98185 & @xmath116152.38 & 5.79 & 45.47 & 5.18 & 1200/7500 + 54061.02872 & @xmath116117.77 & 7.52 & @xmath11620.83 & 5.50 & 1200/7500 + 54061.03263 & @xmath116114.74 & 7.67 & @xmath11628.96 & 5.52 & 1200/7500 + v@xmath125 ( km s@xmath30 ) & @xmath11661.24@xmath126 + k@xmath127 ( km s@xmath30 ) & 107.51@xmath128 + k@xmath129 ( km s@xmath30 ) & 121.70@xmath130 + o@xmath116c rms ( km s@xmath30 ) & 13.96 + e ( fixed ) & 0.0 + ( @xmath73)/a & 0.279@xmath131 & 0.284@xmath132 & 0.270@xmath133 & 0.280@xmath134 + @xmath74 & 0.928@xmath135 & 0.911@xmath133 & 0.870@xmath136 & 0.916@xmath137 + @xmath138 & 0.144@xmath139 & 0.149@xmath140 & 0.140@xmath141 & 0.145@xmath142 + @xmath143 & 0.134@xmath139 & 0.135@xmath144 & 0.126@xmath141 & 0.134@xmath142 + i ( @xmath145 ) & 85.87@xmath146 & 85.56@xmath147 & 85.72@xmath148 & 85.65@xmath149 + + @xmath150 & 0.977@xmath151 & 0.980@xmath152 & 1.075@xmath153 + @xmath60 ( input ) & 0.792@xmath154 & 0.811@xmath155 & 0.818@xmath155 + @xmath60 ( best - fit ) & 0.842 & 0.814 & 0.813 + ld [ c , d ] ( fixed ) & [ 0.5619,0.5212 ] & [ 0.5471,0.5310 ] & [ 0.4595,0.4603 ] & + + @xmath0 ( day ) & & & & 0.407037@xmath41 + @xmath156 ( hjd ) & & & & 2453988.7993@xmath157 + o - c rms ( mag ) & 0.06 & 0.08 & 0.14 + @xmath158 ( m@xmath101 ) & 0.272@xmath159 + @xmath160 ( m@xmath101 ) & 0.240@xmath161 + @xmath162 ) & 1.850@xmath163 + @xmath164 ( r@xmath101 ) & 0.268@xmath165 + @xmath166 ( r@xmath101 ) & 0.248@xmath167 + @xmath168 & 5.016@xmath169 + @xmath170 & 5.029@xmath171 + @xmath81 & @xmath172 k + @xmath82 & @xmath173 k + m@xmath174@xmath127 & @xmath175 + m@xmath174@xmath129 & @xmath176 + | we present observations of a new low - mass double - lined eclipsing binary system discovered using repeat observations of the celestial equator from the sloan digital sky survey ii .
using near - infrared photometry and optical spectroscopy we have measured the properties of this short - period [ @xmath0=0.407037(14 ) d ] system and its two components .
we find the following parameters for the two components : m@xmath1 , r@xmath2 , m@xmath3 , r@xmath4 , @xmath5k , @xmath6k .
the masses and radii of the two components of this system agree well with theoretical expectations based on models of low - mass stars , within the admittedly large errors .
future synoptic surveys like pan - starrs and lsst will produce a wealth of information about low - mass eclipsing systems and should make it possible , with an increased reliance on follow - up observations , to detect many systems with low - mass and sub - stellar companions . with the large numbers of objects for which these surveys will produce high - quality photometry , we suggest that it becomes possible to identify such systems even with sparse time sampling and a relatively small number of individual observations . |
in this paper we study a class of @xmath1 spin chains whose hamiltonian can be collectively written as @xmath2 where the @xmath3 s are real constants and the interactions @xmath4 are chosen as described below ( see eqs .
( 1.7 ) ) . in the previous formula , the operators @xmath5 act on a state @xmath6 of the canonical spin basis by permuting the @xmath7-th and @xmath8-th spins : @xmath9 the permutation operators @xmath5 can be expressed in terms of the ( hermitian ) @xmath1 spin operators @xmath10 with the normalization @xmath11 ( where the subindex @xmath12 labels the chain sites ) as @xcite @xmath13 let @xmath14 denote the operator whose action on the canonical spin basis is given by @xmath15 so that the operators @xmath16 span the standard cartan subalgebra of @xmath1 .
the operators @xmath17 are then defined by @xmath18 thus the second sum in eq .
can be interpreted as arising from the interaction with a uniform external @xmath1 `` magnetic '' field magnetic field term is of the form @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is a traceless hermitian matrix acting on the internal space of the @xmath7-th spin . by performing a rotation in this internal space we can diagonalize the matrix @xmath21 , effectively replacing it by a traceless diagonal matrix .
the latter matrix can in turn be expressed in the form @xmath22 , which yields the last term in eq . .
] of strengths @xmath23 .
note that in the case @xmath24 ( i.e. , for spin @xmath25 ) we can take @xmath26 and @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is a pauli matrix acting on the @xmath12-th spin s hilbert space .
. adopts the more familiar form @xmath29 and the hamiltonian reduces to @xmath30 with @xmath31 . in particular , the last term represents the interaction with a uniform magnetic field parallel to the @xmath32 axis with strength ( proportional to ) @xmath33 .
the three models we shall study are defined by the following choice of the interaction strengths @xmath4 : @xmath34 the _ haldane shastry _ ( hs ) chain @xcite : [ jijs ] @xmath35 @xmath34 the _ polychronakos frahm _ ( pf ) chain @xcite : @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the @xmath12-th root of the hermite polynomial of degree @xmath38 .
@xmath34 the _ frahm inozemtsev _ ( fi ) chain @xcite : @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the @xmath12-th root of the generalized laguerre polynomial @xmath41 with @xmath42 . in all three cases ,
@xmath43 is a real constant whose sign determines the model s ferromagnetic ( @xmath44 ) or antiferromagnetic ( @xmath45 ) character .
note that , while the sites of the hs chain are equispaced is interpreted as an angular coordinate , then the hs chain describes an array of spins equispaced on the unit circle , with long - range pairwise interactions inversely proportional to the square of the chord distance between the spins . ] , this is not the case for the pf or fi chains .
we shall denote by @xmath46 the hamiltonian of the chains in the absence of a magnetic field .
following standard terminology , we shall collectively refer to the chains - as spin chains of _ haldane shastry type_. they are all associated with the root system @xmath0 , in the sense that the interactions @xmath4 depend only on the differences of the site coordinates @xmath37 .
although several generalizations of these chains to the @xmath47 and @xmath48 root systems have been considered in the literature @xcite , in this paper we shall restrict ourselves to the above @xmath0-type models .
spin chains of hs type are the simplest models in condensed matter physics exhibiting fractional statistics @xcite .
historically , the hs chain - was introduced as a simplified version of the one - dimensional hubbard model with long - range hopping , from which it can be obtained in the half - filling regime when the on - site interaction tends to infinity @xcite . soon after its introduction
, it was shown that this chain is completely integrable , in the sense that one can explicitly construct @xmath49 mutually commuting integrals of motion @xcite . as first observed by polychronakos @xcite ,
these integrals of motion can be obtained from those of the _ dynamical _ spin sutherland model @xcite by means of the so - called `` freezing trick '' .
in fact , the freezing trick can also be applied to derive the pf and fi chains from the calogero @xcite and inozemtsev @xcite spin dynamical models . in particular , these two chains are also completely integrable .
apart from their integrable character , spin chains of hs type appear in many areas of current interest in both physics and mathematics , such as quantum chaos @xcite , supersymmetry @xcite , conformal field theory @xcite , the ads - cft correspondence @xcite , one - dimensional anyons @xcite and yangian quantum groups @xcite .
the partition functions of all three chains of hs type in the absence of a magnetic field , which have been computed in closed form using again the freezing trick @xcite , can be expressed in a unified way by the formula @xmath50 here @xmath51 , @xmath52 is an element of the set @xmath53 of partitions of @xmath38 with order taken into account , and the numbers @xmath54 in eq .
are positive integers defined by @xmath55 remarkably , the partition function @xmath56 of the chains - depends on the chain under consideration only through its _ dispersion relation _ @xmath57 using the previous expression for the partition function , basu - mallick et al .
@xcite showed that the spectrum of the spin chains of hs type is given by @xmath58 where @xmath59 and the quantum numbers @xmath60 independently take the values @xmath61 .
the vectors @xmath62 with components @xmath63 are in fact the celebrated _ motifs _ introduced by haldane et al . @xcite . as pointed out in ref .
@xcite , eq . defines a classical _ inhomogeneous _ one - dimensional vertex model with bonds @xmath64 each taking @xmath65 possible values , where the contribution of the @xmath12-th vertex is given by @xmath66 .
we shall show that this connection between spin chains of hs type and vertex models still holds in the presence of a nonzero @xmath1 magnetic field .
this is indeed the key result on which we shall base our unified approach to the analysis of the thermodynamics of all three chains of hs type .
the study of the thermodynamic properties of spin chains of hs type was initiated by haldane himself , who used the spinon description of the spectrum to derive an indirect expression for the entropy of the spin @xmath25 hs chain @xcite .
an explicit formula for the free energy of the pf chain in the absence of a magnetic field appeared shortly afterwards without proof in ref .
@xcite . in a subsequent publication
@xcite , frahm and inozemtsev obtained an analogous expression for the fi chain using the transfer matrix method , and also computed its magnetization for arbitrary magnetic field .
in this paper we have several objectives that we shall now summarize . in the first place
, we shall compute in closed form the partition function of the hs - type chains in the presence of an arbitrary @xmath1 magnetic field @xmath23 .
secondly , we shall use the expression for the partition function to establish the equivalence of the latter chains to a suitable classical inhomogeneous vertex model .
we shall then take advantage of this connection to determine the equilibrium thermodynamics of the spin 1-.7pt/2 chains of hs type in a unified and systematic way .
finally , we shall use the previous results to uncover a novel connection between spin chains of hs type and the classical ising model .
the paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec.pfs ]
we compute the chains partition functions in closed form by means of the freezing trick . following the approach of ref .
@xcite , in section [ sec.vms ] we construct a generating function for the partition function in terms of complete homogeneous symmetric polynomials .
we then define a similar function for the corresponding vertex models , and prove that both generating functions coincide for arbitrary values of their arguments .
this shows that the energies of each of the chains are identical to those of its associated vertex model . exploiting this connection , in section [ sec.thermo ] we use the transfer matrix method to find explicit expressions for the thermodynamic functions of the chains with spin @xmath25 . in the case of the pf chain
, we derive an exact formula for the free energy in terms of the dilogarithm function in an arbitrary magnetic field , and show that its magnetization can be expressed in terms of elementary functions .
section [ sec.zerob ] is devoted to a detailed study of the zero magnetic field case .
in particular , we show that the susceptibility can be expressed for all three chains of hs type in terms of the error function , discuss the connection of these chains with two - level systems , and derive low - temperature asymptotic expansions the chains thermodynamic functions . in section [ sec.zerot ]
we study the zero temperature limit in the presence of an arbitrary external magnetic field in both the ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic regimes .
we explicitly show that in both regimes there is a phase transition , as was to be expected on general grounds @xcite . in section [ sec.ising ] we present a novel interpretation of the thermodynamic quantities of spin chains of hs type as weighted averages of the analogous quantities over an ensemble of classical ising chains .
the paper ends with a short section where we compare our results with previous related work , and comment on possible extensions thereof .
in this section we shall derive a closed form expression for the partition functions of the hs chains in the presence of a constant @xmath1 magnetic field . for definiteness ,
we shall deal with the pf chain , whose interactions are defined by eq . .
as we mentioned above , this chain is obtained by applying the freezing trick to the @xmath1 spin calogero model in a constant magnetic field , whose hamiltonian we shall take as @xmath67 where @xmath68 and @xmath69 more precisely , let @xmath70 denote the hamiltonian of the scalar calogero model @xcite , and define @xmath71 so that @xmath72 it is well known @xcite that the chain sites @xmath73 of the pf chain are the coordinates of the unique minimum of the scalar potential @xmath74 in the principal weyl chamber of @xmath0 type @xmath75 , where the motion of the particles of the calogero model can be restricted due to the singularities of its hamiltonian . from this fact and eq .
it follows that in the large @xmath76 limit the eigenfunctions of the spin calogero model become sharply peaked around the sites of the pf chain , so that the @xmath1 degrees of freedom effectively decouple from the dynamical ones . by eq .
, in this limit the energies of the model are approximately given by the formula @xmath77 where @xmath78 and @xmath79 denote two arbitrary eigenvalues of @xmath80 and @xmath81 , respectively .
although the spectra of both the scalar and the spin calogero models can be easily computed , the previous formula can not be directly used to compute the spectrum of the pf chain .
indeed , it is not obvious a priori which energies of @xmath82 and @xmath80 can be combined to yield an energy of the pf chain . however , from eq .
it is immediate to obtain the following _ exact _ relation between the partition functions @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 of the hamiltonians @xmath82 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 :
@xmath86 this formula , first derived by polychronakos @xcite , is the mainstay of the freezing trick method ; see @xcite for a rigorous proof .
we shall next evaluate both the numerator and the denominator in the previous equation . to begin with ,
the partition function of the scalar calogero model is easily computed @xcite , with the result @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the ground state energy .
let us now turn to the partition function of @xmath82 .
consider , to this end , the spin functions @xmath89 where @xmath90 , @xmath91 , @xmath92 , @xmath93 is the ground state of the scalar hamiltonian @xmath80 and @xmath94 is the total symmetrizer with respect to particle permutations .
the above states are a ( non - orthonormal ) basis of the hilbert space of @xmath82 provided that ( for instance ) @xmath95 for all @xmath7 and @xmath96 whenever @xmath97 .
it was shown in ref .
@xcite that @xmath98 acts triangularly on the latter basis , with eigenvalues @xmath99 on the other hand , from the identities @xmath100 it immediately follows that the operators @xmath17 commute with the spin permutation operators @xmath5 , and hence with @xmath94 . by eq .
we then have @xmath101 where the eigenvalue @xmath102 is given by @xmath103 in the previous formula , the symbol @xmath104 denotes the number of components of the vector @xmath105 equal to @xmath12 .
it follows that the term @xmath106 in eq .
is diagonal in the basis , with eigenvalues @xmath107 in view of the latter equation , it is convenient to introduce the notation @xmath108 so that @xmath109 . using this notation
we can rewrite the eigenvalue in the more compact form @xmath110 from the previous considerations and eqs .
- it then follows that the hamiltonian acts triangularly on the basis , with eigenvalues @xmath111 using the previous equation , it is a straightforward matter to compute the partition function of the spin calogero model . to this end , let us represent the multiindex @xmath112 in eq .
as @xmath113 with @xmath114 and @xmath115 .
we then have @xmath116 where the last sum is extended to all spin quantum numbers @xmath105 compatible with the multiindex @xmath112 given by eq . ,
i.e. , such that @xmath96 whenever @xmath117 .
in fact , since the latter sum clearly depends on @xmath112 only through @xmath118 , from now on we denote it by @xmath119 . clearly , by eq .
we have @xmath120 with this notation , eq .
becomes @xmath121 the inner sum in the rhs is easily computed by performing the change of indices @xmath122 , where @xmath123 and @xmath124 , since the new indices independently range from @xmath125 to @xmath126 .
we thus obtain @xmath127 and therefore @xmath128 where the positive integers @xmath129 were defined in eq . .
from the freezing trick relation and eqs . -
, we immediately obtain the following explicit expression for the partition function of the pf chain - in the presence of an arbitrary @xmath1 magnetic field : @xmath130 the previous argument can be applied with minor modifications to both the hs and fi chains , thereby obtaining the following general expression for the partition function of the hs - type chains - : @xmath131 note that when the magnetic field vanishes , by eq .
@xmath119 becomes @xmath132 , and the previous expression for @xmath85 reduces to its zero field version .
a few remarks on the function @xmath119 are now in order .
let us first note that the latter function can be expressed as @xmath133 where @xmath134 the function @xmath135 can be considerably simplified by noting that the summation indices @xmath136 can be expressed as @xmath137 with @xmath138 .
thus @xmath139 and therefore @xmath140 the latter sum can be easily evaluated by noting that @xmath141 where @xmath142 denotes the complete homogeneous symmetric polynomial of degree @xmath12 in @xmath65 variables @xmath143 , given by @xmath144 recalling that @xmath145 is the schur polynomial associated with the single - row partition @xmath146 and using jacobi s definition of the latter polynomials in terms of determinants @xcite we conclude that @xmath147 expanding the determinant along the first row we obtain the alternative expression @xmath148 in particular , for spin 1-.7pt/2 ( @xmath24 ) we have @xmath149 , and either expression for @xmath135 easily yields @xmath150 the rhs of the latter formula can be conveniently expressed using the @xmath151-number notation .
recall , to this end , that given two real numbers @xmath152 and @xmath153 the symmetric @xmath154-number @xmath155_w$ ] is define by @xmath156_w=\frac{w^{\frac{x}2}-w^{-\frac{x}2}}{w^{\frac12}-w^{-\frac12}}\,,\ ] ] which reduces to the ordinary number @xmath152 for @xmath157 .
we then have ( in the spin 1-.7pt/2 case ) @xmath158_{q^{2b}}\,,\ ] ] so that the partition function of the spin 1-.7pt/2 chains - can be concisely written as @xmath159_{q^{2b}}\cdot\kern 2pt q^{\sum_{i=1}^{r-1}j{{\mathcal e}}(k_i)}\prod_{i=1}^{n - r}(1-q^{j{{\mathcal e}}(k'_i)})\,.\ ] ] note , again , that in the absence of a magnetic field the previous expression obviously reduces to eq . with @xmath24 .
in this section we shall prove that the spectrum of the hs chains - coincides with that of a classical inhomogeneous vertex model , which differs from the one in eq . by the addition of a magnetic field term .
our approach is based on the notion of generating function for the partition function , as used in ref .
@xcite for the zero magnetic field case . to this end , following the latter reference we define the generating function @xmath160 of the zero - field partition function as @xmath161 since @xmath162 by eq .
we have @xmath163 . more generally , substituting the expression for @xmath135 into eqs . - and using the definition of @xmath164 we readily obtain the identity @xmath165 similarly , the generating function @xmath166 for the partition function of the classical vertex model was defined in ref .
@xcite by @xmath167 where the nonnegative integers @xmath168 are given by @xmath169 again , it is obvious that the partition function @xmath170 of the model - is the value of its generating function at the point @xmath171 .
one of the fundamental results in ref .
@xcite is the fact that the generating functions and are _ identically _ equal , i.e. , @xmath172 evaluating the previous identity at the point @xmath171 we obtain the equality of the zero - field partition functions @xmath56 and @xmath173 , which is in fact the main result in ref . @xcite . on the other hand , if we evaluate the identity at the point @xmath174 and use eq .
we immediately obtain @xmath175 taking into account that @xmath176 we can rewrite eq . as @xmath177 where @xmath178 denotes the partition function of the inhomogeneous classical vertex model with energies @xmath179 with @xmath180 given by eqs . - . therefore , as stated at the beginning of this section , the spectrum of the spin chains - is identical to that of the classical vertex models defined by eq . - .
in the spin @xmath181 case , the previous equation can be simplified by noting that @xmath182 in eq .
can be expressed as @xmath183 and similarly @xmath184 introducing the spin variables @xmath185 , eq .
becomes @xmath186 the latter equation can be alternatively written as @xmath187 where @xmath188\ ] ] and we have set @xmath189 .
the last two equations define a classical _ inhomogeneous _ ising model in one dimension , where the coupling between the spins @xmath7 and @xmath190 is proportional to the dispersion relation @xmath191 , and the external magnetic field ( also inhomogeneous ) is given by eq . .
we shall next take advantage of the representation of the spectrum of the hs - type chains - with spin @xmath192 in order to determine their equilibrium thermodynamics in a unified way . to this end
, we must first normalize the hamiltonian to ensure that the energy per spin is finite ( and nonzero ) in the thermodynamic limit .
it is well known that when @xmath193 the mean energy of the hs - type chains is @xmath194 , with @xmath195 for the pf chain and @xmath196 for the hs and fi chains @xcite .
hence from now on we shall take @xmath197 where the constant @xmath198 is independent of @xmath38 . with this proviso , eq .
can be rewritten in terms of the discrete variables @xmath199 as @xmath200 where @xmath201 and @xmath202 .
we shall further assume that @xmath203 has a finite limit @xmath204 as @xmath205 . with the above notation
, the partition function of the chains - can be collectively expressed as @xmath206 where @xmath207 equation can be more concisely written as @xmath208 where @xmath209 and @xmath21 are @xmath210 matrices with elements @xmath211 or equivalently , @xmath212 the transfer matrix @xmath21 has two distinct eigenvalues @xmath213 and is therefore diagonalizable .
a straightforward calculation shows that @xmath214 where @xmath2151 & \enspace 1 \end{array } \right)\ , , \label{dipi}\ ] ] and we have set @xmath216 we thus have @xmath217 where @xmath218 is a symmetric matrix explicitly given by @xmath219r_i - r_{i+1 } & r_i+r_{i+1 } \end{array } \right)\,.\ ] ] the key observation at this point is that @xmath220 as @xmath205 .
indeed , note first of all that @xmath221 where @xmath222 so that @xmath223 . on the other hand , since @xmath224 the difference @xmath225 is @xmath226 , and hence @xmath227 which establishes our claim . from eq .
, it follows that when @xmath205 the leading term of @xmath228 is given by @xmath229\,,\ ] ] where @xmath230 note also that @xmath231 so that the matrices @xmath232 and @xmath233 both have finite limits as @xmath205 .
calling @xmath234 we then have @xmath235 and therefore @xmath236=\cosh({\beta}b)\left(1+\frac{\cosh({\beta}b)}{r_\infty}\right){\lambda}_+\ ] ] is the leading term of @xmath228 as @xmath205 . since the first two factors in the rhs of this formula are independent of @xmath38 , in the thermodynamic limit the free energy per spin @xmath237 is simply given by @xmath238 where the _ dispersion function _
@xmath239 is defined by @xmath240 ( cf .
we thus obtain the following remarkable formula for the free energy per site of the hs - type chains - : @xmath241 from the latter equation it is immediate to obtain the magnetization per site : @xmath242 for finite temperature , the magnetic susceptibility is also easily computed from the previous formula : @xmath243 in the case of the fi chain , some of the above equations have previously appeared in ref .
more precisely , eq . with @xmath244 reduces to eq .
( 21 ) of the latter reference , while eq
. for @xmath245 essentially coincides with eq .
( 24 ) of ref .
@xcite , which is stated without proof . as first noted in this reference for the @xmath244 case , eqs .
imply that the hs chain is thermodynamically equivalent to an fi chain with @xmath246 and @xmath247 .
the free energy and magnetization per spin - admit a simpler expression in terms of the so - called _ dressed energy _
@xmath248 defined by @xmath249 namely , @xmath250}{\sinh[{\beta}{\varepsilon}_{\mathrm{dr}}(x)]}\right){\mathrm{d}}x\label{fvepdr}\\[1 mm ] \mu(b , t)&=\int_0 ^ 1\tanh({\beta}{\varepsilon}_{\mathrm{dr}}(x))\,{\mathrm{d}}x\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] these are the well - known expressions for the free energy ( up to an additive constant depending on the normalization of @xmath81 ) and magnetization per particle of a system of _ free _ bosons with one - particle energies @xmath239 , @xmath251 $ ] , in the presence of a constant magnetic field @xmath33 .
note in this respect that , in contrast with the dispersion relation @xmath239 , the dressed energy @xmath248 depends on @xmath252 , @xmath33 and @xmath198 .
note also that in the case of the hs chain eq . is essentially equivalent to eq .
( 37 ) in ref .
@xcite , deduced by means of haldane s spinon gas approach @xcite . for future reference
, we shall also compute the internal energy and entropy per spin . to begin with ,
the internal energy per spin @xmath253 is given by @xmath254 with @xmath255 the entropy per spin @xmath256 is then easily derived from the usual formula @xmath257 we have not been able to express the thermodynamic functions in terms of known special functions for arbitrary values of @xmath33 and @xmath258 , with the remarkable exception of the polychronakos frahm chain . indeed , we shall now show that in this case the free and the internal energy , the entropy ( and the specific heat ) can be expressed in terms of the dilogarithm function @xcite @xmath259 while the magnetization and susceptibility are elementary functions of @xmath33 and @xmath258 . in eq .
@xmath260 denotes the principal value of the logarithm ( i.e. , @xmath261 ) , and the integral is taken along any path joining the origin with the point @xmath32 that does not intersect the branch cut @xmath262 .
we start by performing the change of variable @xmath263 , where @xmath264 and @xmath265 , in eq . for the free energy .
we readily obtain @xmath266 where @xmath267 .
the linear change of variable @xmath268 makes it possible to evaluate each of the last two integrals in closed form : @xmath269 taking into account the dilogarithm identity @xcite @xmath270 after some straightforward algebra we finally obtain the following closed formula for the free energy of the pf chain : @xmath271\bigr)\nonumber\\ & \hphantom{{}=}+{\operatorname{li}}_2\bigl(-{\mathrm e}^{-{\beta}b}\big[-\sinh({\beta}b)+\sqrt{\sinh^2({\beta}b)+{\mathrm e}^{-k{\beta}}}\,\big]\bigr ) .
\label{fpf}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the previous formula generalizes the analogous expression for zero magnetic field in eq . ( 23 ) of ref
. @xcite .
equation can be somewhat simplified by expressing the rhs in terms of the dressed energy . indeed , by eq .
with @xmath272 we have @xmath273 and therefore @xmath274 from the usual formulas for the internal energy , the entropy and the specific heat ( per site ) @xmath275 in terms of the free energy , it immediately follows that these functions necessarily include a term proportional to the last two lines in eq . , and therefore can not be expressed purely in terms of elementary functions . on the other hand ,
since the magnetization is obtained from the free energy by differentiating with respect to the magnetic field @xmath33 , it is clear from eq . that @xmath276 is an elementary function of @xmath33 and @xmath258 .
differentiating eq .
with respect to @xmath33 , or simply performing the change of variables @xmath277 in eq .
, after a straightforward calculation we obtain the remarkable formula @xmath278.\ ] ] using eq .
, we can rewrite the previous formula in terms of the dressed energy as @xmath279 differentiating the previous expressions for @xmath276 we also obtain the following closed formulas for the susceptibility per site : @xmath280
it is of interest to study the limit of the thermodynamic functions computed in the previous section for both @xmath281 and @xmath282 .
we shall deal in this section with the first of these limits , leaving the analysis of the zero temperature limit for the next one .
we shall start with the free energy and the internal energy per site , which can be immediately obtained by setting @xmath244 in eqs . and : @xmath283 u(0,t)&=\frac k2\int_0 ^ 1\frac{{\varepsilon}(x)}{1+{\mathrm e}^{\frac{k{\beta}}2{\varepsilon}(x)}}\,{\mathrm{d}}x\label{u0t}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the above formulas and eq .
it follows that the entropy per spin is given by @xmath284{\mathrm{d}}x\nonumber\\[1 mm ] & = \int_0 ^ 1\left\{\log\mathopen{}\left[2\cosh\mathopen{}\left(\case{k{\beta}}4{\varepsilon}(x)\right)\right ] -\frac{k{\beta}{\varepsilon}(x)}4\,\tanh\mathopen{}\left(\case{k{\beta}}4{\varepsilon}(x)\right)\right\}{\mathrm{d}}x\ , .
\label{s0t}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case of the hs chain , the latter equation is essentially equivalent to eq .
( 15 ) in ref .
@xcite , which was deduced using the equivalence of the hs chain to an ideal gas of spinons .
the zero - field specific heat @xmath285 can also be easily computed from eq . , with the result
@xmath286 obviously , the zero - field magnetization vanishes ( cf . ) , while eq . for the susceptibility reduces to @xmath287 in fact , the zero - field susceptibility can be expressed in terms of standard special functions for all spin chains of hs type . for the pf chain
, we have already obtained a formula for @xmath288 in terms of elementary functions for all values of @xmath33 and @xmath258 , cf .
. for the hs chain , a straightforward calculation shows that @xmath289 where @xmath290 denote respectively the error and the imaginary error functions @xcite .
similarly , for the fi chain we have @xmath291 from eqs . , , and , and the well - known asymptotic formula @xcite @xmath292 it follows that when @xmath245 and @xmath282 we have @xmath293 again , in the case of the hs chain the previous asymptotic formula was first obtained by haldane in ref .
@xcite . from the latter equation
it is apparent that the ferromagnetic zero - field susceptibility ( and hence the correlation length ) is exponentially divergent as @xmath282 .
this shows that all ferromagnetic chains of hs type undergo a phase transition at @xmath294 , which we shall analyze in detail in the next section .
equations and imply that the zero - field entropy and specific heat are even functions of the coupling constant @xmath198 .
this fact , which is not obvious a priori , was first noted by haldane @xcite for the entropy of the original hs chain .
haldane also pointed out that ( with an appropriate choice of the ground state energy , which amounts to replacing @xmath295 by @xmath5 in eq . ) the internal energy of the hs chain is again even in @xmath198 .
one can easily show that this property is shared by _ all _ spin chains of hs type , since from eq .
it readily follows that @xmath296 with @xmath297 in other words , @xmath298 is an even function of @xmath198 , which can be seen to be equivalent to haldane s statement given our normalization of @xmath81 .
a similar property , proved in exactly the same way , also holds for the free energy @xmath299 . as we saw in the previous section , in the particular case of the polychronakos
frahm chain the thermodynamic functions can be expressed in closed form in terms of the dilogarithm function . indeed , setting @xmath244 in eq .
we obtain the simple formula @xmath300 from the latter equation it is straightforward to derive similar expressions for the internal energy , the entropy and the specific heat of the pf chain in the absence of a magnetic field , namely @xmath301 using the previous explicit formulas , we have plotted the thermodynamic functions of the pf chain for zero magnetic field in terms of the dimensionless temperature @xmath302 ; see fig .
[ fig.pf ] .
( dashed red line ) as functions of the dimensionless temperature @xmath302 . in the first two plots , @xmath303 denotes the common value of @xmath304 and @xmath305 , cf .
insets : low - temperature behavior of each of the above thermodynamic functions.,title="fig:",height=162 ] ( dashed red line ) as functions of the dimensionless temperature @xmath302 . in the first two plots
, @xmath303 denotes the common value of @xmath304 and @xmath305 , cf .
insets : low - temperature behavior of each of the above thermodynamic functions.,title="fig:",height=158 ] + ( dashed red line ) as functions of the dimensionless temperature @xmath302 . in the first two plots
, @xmath303 denotes the common value of @xmath304 and @xmath305 , cf .
insets : low - temperature behavior of each of the above thermodynamic functions.,title="fig:",height=158 ] ( dashed red line ) as functions of the dimensionless temperature @xmath302 . in the first two plots
, @xmath303 denotes the common value of @xmath304 and @xmath305 , cf .
insets : low - temperature behavior of each of the above thermodynamic functions.,title="fig:",height=158 ] it is immediately apparent the qualitative similarity of these plots with the corresponding ones for a two - level system like , e.g. , a paramagnetic spin 1-.7pt/2 ion or the one - dimensional ising model with zero magnetic field @xcite . in particular , the specific heat @xmath306 clearly exhibits the so - called schottky anomaly , characteristic of this type of systems .
the schottky peak , which can be numerically computed without difficulty from eq . , is located at @xmath307 , with a maximum value of @xmath306 approximately equal to @xmath308 . on the other hand ,
the low temperature behavior of @xmath309 and @xmath306 markedly differs from that of a two - level system . indeed , from eqs .
and it immediately follows that @xmath310 hence both functions have a nonvanishing first derivative at @xmath311 .
as is well known , the entropy @xmath312 and the specific heat @xmath313 of a two - level system with energy gap @xmath314 satisfy @xmath315 so that the derivatives of all orders of @xmath312 and @xmath313 vanish at @xmath311 .
we shall next show that the previous analysis essentially holds for the hs and fi chains as well . to begin with , note that from eqs .
it follows that @xmath316 and thus @xmath317 u(0,t)-u_0&=\frac{|k|}2\int_0 ^ 1\frac{{\varepsilon}(x)}{1+{\mathrm e}^{\frac{|k|{\beta}}2{\varepsilon}(x)}}\,{\mathrm{d}}x\label{u00}\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] on the other hand , the free energy @xmath318 and the internal energy @xmath319 of a two - level system with gap @xmath320 , when normalized so that @xmath321 , are given by @xmath322 from the latter equation and eqs .
, it follows that the thermodynamic functions of a two - level system with gap @xmath320 are obtained by taking @xmath239 in eqs . and as the constant @xmath323 this observation suggests that , if the ratio @xmath324 is chosen appropriately , the thermodynamic functions of a two - level system with gap @xmath320 and those of a spin chain of hs type with coupling @xmath198 ( and zero magnetic field ) should behave in a qualitatively similar fashion . in order to establish the relation between @xmath325 and @xmath198
, we note that in the high - temperature limit one has @xmath326=\frac{|k|{\varepsilon}_0}4\,,\qquad \lim_{t\to\infty}u_{\delta}(t)={\delta}\,.\ ] ] for both limits to coincide , we must have @xmath327 i.e , @xmath328 should be equal to the average of @xmath239 over the interval @xmath329 $ ] .
in particular , in the case of the pf chain we have @xmath330 ( cf .
eq . ) , which explains the choice @xmath331 in fig . [ fig.pf ] .
as an example , we have plotted in fig .
[ fig.all ] ( left ) the specific heat per site of the pf , hs , and fi chains ( with @xmath332 in the latter case ) compared to its counterpart for a two - level system with half - gap @xmath331 . here
@xmath198 denotes the coupling of the pf chain and , following the previous analysis , we have fixed the corresponding couplings @xmath129 of the other chains by the requirement @xmath333 .
we shall next derive the low temperature behavior of the thermodynamic functions of the hs and fi chains in the absence of a magnetic field .
our strategy shall be to obtain an asymptotic formula for the specific heat , which we shall then integrate to obtain similar formulas for the remaining thermodynamic functions .
consider first the hs chain . since in this case
@xmath334 is symmetric about @xmath335 , we can write eq . as @xmath336 where @xmath337 is a large parameter .
performing the change of variables @xmath338 we immediately obtain @xmath339 ( see [ app.error ] for the details ) .
the last integral is easily computed : @xmath340 ( cf .
eq . ) , which combined with the previous equation yields @xmath341 note that the leading term in this formula is twice that in eq . for the pf chain , due to the fact that in the present case the leading contribution to the integral comes from both endpoints
. apart from this inessential difference , the specific heat at low temperature behaves as its counterpart for the pf chain , i.e. , it increases linearly with the temperature .
consider next the fi chain . if @xmath342 , proceeding as before we obtain @xmath343 again , in the low temperature range the specific heat increases linearly with the temperature .
finally , for the fi chain with @xmath344 we have @xmath345 where the last integral can again be exactly evaluated : @xmath346 where @xmath347 is dirichlet s eta function . using the elementary relation @xmath348 where @xmath349 is riemann s zeta function
, we finally obtain @xmath350 and hence @xmath351 in contrast with the previous cases , the specific heat @xmath306 has now an infinite first derivative at @xmath311 ; see fig .
[ fig.all ] ( right ) .
hence the fi chain with @xmath352 exhibits a second - order phase transition at zero temperature .
since asymptotic expansions can in general be integrated termwise to yield valid asymptotic expansions @xcite , integrating the asymptotic formulas and we can readily derive the low temperature behavior of the remaining thermodynamic functions of all spin chains of hs type .
thus , for the fi chain with @xmath344 we have @xmath353 \label{ufi0 } u(0,t)&=u_0+\frac{2\eta}3\,{\beta}^{-3/2}+{\mathrm{o}}({\beta}^{-1}{\mathrm e}^{-|k|{\beta}/2})\\[1 mm ] \label{sfi0 } \frac{s(0,t)}{{k_{\rm b}}}&=2\eta\,{\beta}^{-1/2}+{\mathrm{o}}({\mathrm e}^{-|k|{\beta}/2})\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have set @xmath354 for all other chains of hs type , the analogous results can be concisely summarized as follows : @xmath355 u(0,t)&=u_0+\frac{\eta\,\pi^2}{6|k|{\beta}^2}+{\mathrm{o}}(t^3)\\[1 mm ] \frac{s(0,t)}{{k_{\rm b}}}&=\frac{\eta\,\pi^2}{3|k|{\beta}}+{\mathrm{o}}(t^2)\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where now @xmath356 , orange ; @xmath357 , green ) chains with zero magnetic field and of a two - level system with half - gap @xmath331 ( dashed red line ) as functions of the dimensionless temperature @xmath302 .
right : specific heat per site of the fi chain with @xmath344 ( solid blue line ) versus its low - temperature approximation ( dashed red line).,title="fig:",height=160 ] , orange ; @xmath357 , green ) chains with zero magnetic field and of a two - level system with half - gap @xmath331 ( dashed red line ) as functions of the dimensionless temperature @xmath302 .
right : specific heat per site of the fi chain with @xmath344 ( solid blue line ) versus its low - temperature approximation ( dashed red line).,title="fig:",height=160 ]
in this section we shall analyze the low temperature behavior of the thermodynamic functions of a spin chain of hs type in the presence of a nonzero magnetic field . in the ferromagnetic case ( @xmath245 ) , we already know from the previous section that there must be a phase transition at @xmath294 .
this fact is also apparent from eq . for the magnetization , which for @xmath245 implies that @xmath358 the latter result can be corroborated by a computation of the zero - temperature magnetization per site directly from its definition . indeed , from eqs
- it follows that @xmath359 where @xmath360 denotes the average over all ground states . when @xmath361 and @xmath245 the ground state is obtained by taking @xmath362 for all @xmath7 in eq .
, and is therefore nondegenerate .
hence for @xmath361 we have @xmath363 as before . on the other hand , when @xmath244 the ground states are obtained from sequences of the form @xmath364 .
the average of @xmath365 over such sequences clearly vanishes , since the contributions of the sequences with @xmath12 @xmath366 s and @xmath367 @xmath366 s cancel each other .
thus @xmath368 , again in agreement with eq . .
in the antiferromagnetic case , it can be shown from eq . that there is a phase transition at zero temperature and magnetic field @xmath369 , where the _ saturation field _
@xmath370 is given by @xmath371}{\varepsilon}(x)= \begin{cases } \frac{|k|}8\,,&{\mbox{for the hs chain}}\vrule width0pt depth12pt height 17pt\\ \frac{|k|}2\,,&{\mbox{for the pf chain}}\vrule width0pt depth12pt\\ \frac{|k|}2\,({\gamma}+1)\,,&{\mbox{for the fi chain}}.\vrule width0pt depth9pt \end{cases}\ ] ] indeed , when @xmath372 we can rewrite eq .
as @xmath373^{-1/2}\,{\mathrm{d}}x\,,\ ] ] where @xmath374 , @xmath375 and @xmath376 note that the value @xmath377 for the hs chain is due to the symmetry of @xmath334 about @xmath335 in this case . if @xmath378 then @xmath379}{\varepsilon}(x)=\max\limits_{x\in[0,{\kappa}]}{\varepsilon}(x)$ ] , so that for all @xmath380 $ ] we have @xmath381 and @xmath382 as @xmath383 . hence latexmath:[\[\label{msat } i.e , for @xmath378 the magnetization per site saturates . on the other hand , if @xmath385 we have @xmath381 for @xmath386 and @xmath387 for @xmath388 , where @xmath389 denotes the unique root in @xmath390 $ ] of the equation @xmath391 , i.e , @xmath392\,.\ ] ] thus in this case we have @xmath393 and therefore latexmath:[\[\label{munsat } note that the rhs in both eqs .
and tends to @xmath366 as @xmath395 , since clearly @xmath389 tends to @xmath396 as @xmath395 . for the hs chain we have @xmath334 , and
hence @xmath397 equations @xmath398 and - ( with @xmath377 ) immediately yield @xmath399 which was first derived by haldane using the spinon gas formalism @xcite . likewise , for the pf chain we have @xmath400 , @xmath272 and thus @xmath401 , so that @xmath402 finally , in the case of the fi chain @xmath400 , @xmath403 , @xmath404 and thus @xmath405 in agreement with the result in ref .
@xcite . from eqs .
it is apparent that , although the magnetization per site is continuous at @xmath369 , the susceptibility @xmath406 has a discontinuity at these points ( cf .
[ fig.afpt ] ) .
hence , in the antiferromagnetic case all three chains of hs type present a second - order phase transition at @xmath311 and @xmath369 , where the saturation field @xmath370 is explicitly given in eq . .
the precise behavior of the zero - temperature magnetization and susceptibility for @xmath385 is , however , quite different for each type of chain .
indeed , in the case of the hs chain the susceptibility is an increasing function of @xmath33 for @xmath407 , and diverges as @xmath408 when @xmath409 . on the other hand , for both the pf and fi chains
the susceptibility has only a jump discontinuity at the critical points @xmath369 .
when @xmath407 the susceptibility is constant for the pf chain , while for the fi chain it decreases monotonically .
finally , it should be noted that the first derivative of the zero - temperature susceptibility has a jump discontinuity at @xmath244 for the fi chain with @xmath410 and the hs chain , while it diverges as @xmath411 at this point for the fi chain with @xmath344 ( cf .
[ fig.afpt ] ) . and @xmath344 for the latter chain ) as functions of the external magnetic field @xmath33.,title="fig:",height=147 ] and @xmath344 for the latter chain ) as functions of the external magnetic field @xmath33.,title="fig:",height=147 ] + and @xmath344 for the latter chain ) as functions of the external magnetic field @xmath33.,title="fig:",height=147 ] and @xmath344 for the latter chain ) as functions of the external magnetic field @xmath33.,title="fig:",height=147 ] as in the ferromagnetic case , the zero - temperature magnetization can also be computed directly taking advantage of the exact knowledge of the spectrum .
indeed , consider first the pf and fi chains . in this case
the term proportional to @xmath412 in eqs . - is minimized by the sequence @xmath413 , characteristic of an antiferromagnetic system , while the term proportional to @xmath33 is again minimized by the sequence with all components equal to @xmath414 .
it is therefore clear that the ground state is obtained by flipping the components of @xmath415 equal to @xmath416 starting from the _ left _ , until the resulting decrease @xmath417 in the term proportional to @xmath33 in eq .
is offset by the increase @xmath418 in the other term .
thus if @xmath419 the ground state is again obtained by taking @xmath362 for all @xmath420 , and the magnetization attains its saturation value @xmath414 . on the other hand , when @xmath385 the ground state is obtained from the sequence @xmath421 where for large @xmath38 the index @xmath7 is ( approximately ) determined by the condition latexmath:[\[\label{i } site is therefore given there could be a small number of ground states with corresponding sequences almost identical to , so that the average of @xmath365 over these ground states is approximately equal to its value on the latter state . ]
@xmath423 taking into account that @xmath424 , where as before @xmath389 is determined by eq .
( with @xmath400 ) , we obtain the following formula for the zero - temperature magnetization per site for @xmath385 : @xmath425 the latter equation clearly agrees with eq . with @xmath400 .
for the hs chain the analysis is very similar , except that the sequence @xmath415 minimizing the term proportional to @xmath198 in eq .
is now of the form @xmath426 } } } \kern-6pt,1,-1,1\dots,-1,1,\dots)\,.\ ] ] this is due to the fact that in this case the dispersion relation @xmath239 has a maximum at @xmath335 , is symmetric about this point , and is monotonically increasing in the interval @xmath427 $ ] .
for the same reason , if @xmath428 the ground state is now obtained from a sequence of the form @xmath429 where @xmath7 is again approximately determined by eq . .
thus in this case eq . should be replaced by @xmath430 which is essentially eq . for @xmath377 .
we shall next analyze the low - temperature behavior of the thermodynamic functions of the antiferromagnetic chains in the physically more interesting regime @xmath431 . to this end , we start by rewriting eq . for the free energy per site as @xmath432{\mathrm{d}}x,\ ] ] where @xmath433 and @xmath434 is given by eq . .
it is straightforward to show that the function @xmath435\ ] ] satisfies @xmath436 integrating this inequality with respect to @xmath32 over the interval @xmath437 $ ] we obtain @xmath438 integrating now with respect to @xmath152 over @xmath329 $ ] and taking into account eqs .
- we easily arrive at the asymptotic relation @xmath439 where we have used the notation introduced in eq . .
since @xmath434 is negative for @xmath386 and positive for @xmath388 , it is convenient to rewrite the latter equation as @xmath440 consider now the first integral in the rhs of the previous equation . performing the change of variable @xmath441 and proceeding as in the previous section
we readily obtain @xmath442 where the error term has been estimated as in [ app.error ] .
note that if @xmath431 we must have @xmath443 , and consequently @xmath444 .
observe also that , in order for the above estimate to be valid , we must have @xmath445 , or ( disregarding an inessential factor of @xmath446 ) @xmath447 the second integral in eq . can be similarly dealt with by the change of variable @xmath448 : @xmath449 this formula is correct provided that @xmath450 , or equivalently ( since @xmath451 ) , @xmath452 combining eq . with eqs .
- we obtain @xmath453 where @xmath454 and we have omitted an exponentially small term @xmath455 . using the value of these integrals in eqs .
- of [ app.int ] we finally obtain the asymptotic formula @xmath456 provided that @xmath457 since eq .
is an asymptotic power series expansion in @xmath252 , it may be differentiated termwise @xcite to yield corresponding expansions for the remaining thermodynamic quantities as @xmath282 . in the first place , taking into account that @xmath389 and @xmath434 are independent of the temperature we immediately obtain @xmath458 in particular , in the case of the hs chain eq .
is in agreement with haldane s original result @xcite . in order to compute the asymptotic expansion of the magnetization
, we observe that , by eq . ,
@xmath459 and , since @xmath460 , @xmath461 we thus have @xmath462 note , in particular , that the leading term in the latter expansion coincides with eq . .
using the values of @xmath389 and @xmath463 in eqs .
- and we easily obtain @xmath464 for the hs chain , and @xmath465 for the fi chain . in the case of the pf chain the @xmath466 term in eq
. vanishes .
in fact , in this case eq .
more directly yields @xmath467 the approximations are in excellent agreement with the exact result ( or , for the pf chain ) provided that the magnetic field is in the range ; see , e.g. , fig .
[ fig.muerrors ] for the hs and fi chains .
.,title="fig:",height=160 ] .,title="fig:",height=157 ]
we have seen in section [ sec.vms ] that the chains - with spin @xmath181 are isospectral to the classical inhomogeneous ising model in an external ( also inhomogeneous ) magnetic field defined by eqs . and .
in this section we shall exploit this fact to study the connection between the above chains and the _ standard _ ( homogeneous ) ising model , whose hamiltonian we shall conveniently take as @xmath468 with this normalization , the free energy per site in the thermodynamic limit is given by @xcite @xmath469 which is clearly reminiscent of the analogous eq .
for the spin chains of haldane shastry type .
in fact , we can give a heuristic derivation of the latter equation from eqs .
- and the previous formula for the free energy per site of the ising model . to this end ,
note first of all that the latter equations can be written as @xmath470 where @xmath471 we saw in section [ sec.thermo ] that when @xmath193 the term @xmath472 is @xmath226 , so that in this limit we have @xmath473 proceeding as in the latter section , from the previous equation we can show that when @xmath474 the partition function of the chains - is approximately given by @xmath475 where @xmath476 denotes the largest eigenvalue of the transfer matrix the ising model with coupling @xmath43 .
hence , in the thermodynamic limit the free energy per site of the chains - is given by @xmath477 on the other hand , when @xmath205 the partition function @xmath478 of the ising model is related to the largest eigenvalue @xmath476 of its transfer matrix by @xcite @xmath479 so that @xmath480 inserting this identity ( with @xmath481 ) into eq .
we obtain @xmath482 where we have used the fact that @xmath483 .
equation for the free energy of the spin chains - readily follows from the previous equation and the formula for @xmath484 . equation for the free energy of the haldane
shastry spin chains admits a statistical interpretation that we shall discuss next .
indeed , let us first rewrite the latter equation as @xmath485 where @xmath463 is defined in eq . .
since the function @xmath239 is monotonically increasing in the interval @xmath390 $ ] , performing the change of variables @xmath486 in the latter integral we immediately obtain @xmath487 where @xmath488 and @xmath489 note that @xmath490 has the sign of @xmath198 , so that the integration range in eq . is @xmath491 $ ] in the ferromagnetic case and @xmath492 $ ] in the antiferromagnetic one .
furthermore , from eq .
it immediately follows that @xmath493 hence , by eq . , the free energy of each of the spin chains - is the average of the free energy of an ensemble of standard ising models weighted by the function @xmath494 in eq . .
this function , which depends on the chain under consideration through the dispersion relation @xmath239 , is easily computed .
indeed , for the hs chain we have @xmath495 so that @xmath496 from eq . with @xmath497
we easily obtain @xmath498 similarly , in the case of the pf chain @xmath499 and therefore @xmath500 is constant .
finally , in the case of the fi chain we have @xmath501 and therefore @xmath502 hence the weight function @xmath494 is given in this case by @xmath503 introducing the dimensionless variables @xmath504 and @xmath505 ( where @xmath506 $ ] in the ferromagnetic case and @xmath507 $ ] in the antiferromagnetic one ) we can rewrite the previous formulas as @xmath508^{-1/2}\,,&{\mbox{for the fi chain}}\,.\vrule width0pt depth9pt \end{cases}\ ] ] versus dimensionless ising coupling @xmath509 for the hs ( light blue ) , pf ( blue ) and fi ( @xmath344 , green ; @xmath510 , orange ) chains in the ferromagnetic case . ]
equation clearly implies that any thermodynamic quantity of a spin chain of hs type is the average of this quantity over an ensemble of standard ising models with respect to the appropriate weight function @xmath494 in eqs . . in other words , a _ single _
spin chain of hs type is thermodynamically equivalent to a suitably weighted _
ensemble _ of standard ising models . from this novel point of view
, the fundamental difference between the three types of hs chains - is the fact that the weight function @xmath494 increases with the ising coupling constant @xmath43 for the hs chain , is constant for the pf chain , and decreases with @xmath43 for the fi chain ; cf .
[ fig.rhoj ] .
the study of this weight function can also uncover some unexpected relations between the different families of chains of hs type .
for instance , from eq .
it follows that the normalized densities of the hs chain and the fi chain with @xmath344 are dual , in the sense that they are related by the reflection @xmath511 ( cf .
[ fig.rhoj ] ) .
in this paper we derive the thermodynamics of the three families of spin chains of haldane shastry type - in a unified way .
the main idea behind our approach is to exploit the equivalence of these chains with a corresponding family of ising - like inhomogeneous vertex models . in the absence of an external magnetic field
, this fact had already been conjectured by frahm @xcite and by frahm and inozemtsev @xcite , and was recently established in a rigorous way in ref .
@xcite . in this paper
we generalize the results of the latter work to the case of an arbitrary magnetic field . using the equivalence between spin chains of hs type and inhomogeneous vertex models , in the case of spin @xmath181 we are able to compute the large @xmath38 limit of the chains canonical partition function by means of the transfer matrix method .
we obtain in this way an explicit unified expression of the free energy per site , which we systematically use for a detailed analysis of the thermodynamic properties .
in particular , we deduce asymptotic formulas for the relevant thermodynamic quantities in both the zero magnetic field and the zero temperature limits .
finally , we use the explicit formula for the free energy to show that spin chains of hs type are thermodynamically equivalent to a suitably weighted average of one - dimensional ( _ homogeneous _ ) ising models .
as remarked throughout the preceding sections , some of the formulas for the thermodynamic quantities of the hs - type chains derived in this paper have previously appeared in the literature , especially in the case of the original haldane shastry chain .
it should be stressed , however , that our approach to the thermodynamics of these chains differs from previous related work in two essential ways .
first of all , we treat all three families of spin chains of hs type in a unified way via their dispersion relation @xmath239 ( cf . ) . as discussed in the previous section , this is possible due to the equivalence of these models ( in the thermodynamic limit ) to an inhomogeneous ising model with couplings proportional to the values of the dispersion relation at the points @xmath512 , @xmath513 . on a more technical level
, our method for studying the thermodynamics of spin chains of hs type is simply based on the evaluation of the canonical partition function in the thermodynamic limit through the standard transfer matrix approach .
we thus bypass the more complex analysis relying on the equivalence of these models to an ideal gas of spinons used by haldane to compute the thermodynamic functions of the original hs chain @xcite , which requires the use of the grand canonical ensemble .
the results presented in this paper can be generalized in two different directions .
on the one hand , it should be possible to apply our analysis to general vertex models of the form , in which the coupling @xmath514 between consecutive spins is an arbitrary polynomial ( or even a @xmath515 function ) in the variable @xmath516 , @xmath513 . these models , which have been recently studied by basu - mallick and collaborators @xcite , share certain basic properties with spin chains of hs - type ; for instance , their energies are normally distributed in the thermodynamic limit . on the other hand , it should also be of interest to extend our results to other types of hs chains , particularly those associated with the @xmath517 and @xmath48 root systems ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) . the first step in this direction would be to ascertain whether these spin chains are isospectral to suitable vertex models analogous to
. work on these and related topics , which is presently going on , shall be presented in subsequent publications .
this work was supported in part by the micinn and the ucm
banco santander under grants no .
fis2011 - 22566 and gr35/10-a-910556 .
let us start with the error term in eq . .
we must show that @xmath518 where we have set @xmath519 .
note first of all that the lhs in the previous equation can be written as @xmath520{\mathrm{d}}t -\int_r^{\infty}\frac{t^2\,{\mathrm e}^{-t}}{(1+{\mathrm e}^{-t})^2}\,{\mathrm{d}}t\,,\ ] ] where the last term is easily seen to be @xmath521 . hence we need only show that @xmath522\,{\mathrm{d}}t = { \mathrm{o}}(r^{-1})\,.\ ] ] using the identity @xmath523 and integrating by parts we obtain @xmath524{\mathrm{d}}t\\ & \enspace=2r\int_0^r\left(1-\sqrt{1-\frac tr}-\frac t{2r}\right)g(t)\,{\mathrm e}^{-t}\,{\mathrm{d}}t+{\mathrm{o}}(r^3{\mathrm e}^{-r})\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath525 the elementary inequality @xmath526 implies that @xmath527{\mathrm{d}}t { \leqslant}\frac1r\int_0^rt^2g(t){\mathrm e}^{-t}\,{\mathrm{d}}t+{\mathrm{o}}(r^3{\mathrm e}^{-r})={\mathrm{o}}(r^{-1})\,,\ ] ] since @xmath528
. consider next the error term in eq . .
we must now show that @xmath529 or equivalently that @xmath530{\mathrm{d}}t={\mathrm{o}}({\lambda}^{-1})\,,\ ] ] since @xmath531 our assertion follows immediately from the elementary inequality @xmath532 which implies that @xmath533{\mathrm{d}}t{\leqslant}\frac2{{\gamma}^2{\lambda } } \int_0^{({\gamma}+1){\lambda}}\frac{t^3\,{\mathrm e}^{-t}}{(1+{\mathrm e}^{-t})^2}={\mathrm{o}}({\lambda}^{-1})\ ] ] on account of the convergent character of the integral @xmath534
consider the definite integral @xmath535 with @xmath536 . performing the change of variable @xmath537 and taking into account that @xmath538 ( cf
. ref .
@xcite ) , we readily obtain @xmath539{\mathrm{d}}z\nonumber\\ & = \frac12\,\log^2\mathopen{}\left(\frac{1+\sqrt{1 + 4{\mathrm e}^{{\alpha}x}}}2\right)-{\operatorname{li}}_2\mathopen{}\left(\frac{1-\sqrt{1 + 4{\mathrm e}^{{\alpha}x}}\,}2\right)-\frac{\pi^2}{15}\ , .
\label{ixal}\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence @xmath540 as to the second integral in eq .
, we first note that @xmath541 from eq . and
the dilogarithm identity @xcite @xmath542 it follows that @xmath543 and therefore @xmath544\nonumber\\&=\frac{\pi^2}{10 } + \lim_{x\to\infty}\left[\log^2\biggl(\frac{1+\sqrt{1 + 4{\mathrm e}^x}}2\,\biggr)-\frac{x^2}4\right ] , \label{i2lim}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have made use of the equality @xmath545 ( cf .
@xcite ) . since @xmath546 the limit in eq .
vanishes , and we finally obtain @xmath547 49 natexlab#1#1[2]#2 , ( ) . , ( ) . ,
( ) . , , ( ) . , , ( )
, , , , ( ) . , , , , ( ) .
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , ( ) .
, , ( ) . ,
( ) . , , , , ( ) . , , , , ( )
, , , ( ) . , , ( ) . ,
( ) . , , , ( ) . , , (
, , , ( ) . , , , ( ) . , ( ) . ,
( ) . , , ( ) . ,
( ) . , , ( ) . , , , , ( )
, , , ( ) . , , , , , ( ) . , ( ) .
, , , , ( ) . , , . .
, , , , , ( ) . , , , , .
, , , , . .
, , , , , edition , .
, , , , . , , , , . | we study the thermodynamic properties of spin chains of haldane shastry type associated with the @xmath0 root system in the presence of a uniform external magnetic field . to this end
, we exactly compute the partition function of these models for an arbitrary finite number of spins .
we then show that these chains are equivalent to a suitable inhomogeneous classical ising model in a spatially dependent magnetic field , generalizing the results of basu - mallick et al .
for the zero magnetic field case . using the standard transfer matrix approach , we are able to compute in closed form the free energy per site in the thermodynamic limit . we perform a detailed analysis of the chains thermodynamics in a unified way , with special emphasis on the zero field and zero temperature limits .
finally , we provide a novel interpretation of the thermodynamic quantities of spin chains of haldane shastry type as weighted averages of the analogous quantities over an ensemble of classical ising models .
spin chains of haldane shastry type , vertex models , transfer matrix method , thermodynamic limit |
the top quark s existence is now well established @xcite and top searches have given way to top studies . in measuring the top quark s properties in particular , its mass radiated gluons can play an important role .
this is due not only to the relatively high probability that @xmath1 events are accompanied by additional gluon jets , but also to the fact that gluons can be radiated in both the top production and decay processes .
this can complicate top momentum reconstruction , leading to ambiguities in identifying the top quark s decay products , increased systematic uncertainties , or both .
these effects in turn influence any measurement based on momentum reconstruction , and may also bias event selection based on identifying top events via invariant mass cuts .
therefore it is necessary to understand the distributions of radiated gluons in top quark events .
there have been a number of studies of gluon radiation in top quark production and decay at @xmath2 @xcite and @xmath3 colliders @xcite . in @xcite
we examined additional gluons in the processes @xmath4 at the tevatron @xmath3 collider in the soft gluon approximation and in @xcite we performed the exact calculation .
these studies included all effects of gluons radiated from the initial state partons , from the @xmath5 and @xmath6 quarks at the production stage , and from the @xmath5 and @xmath7 ( and @xmath6 and @xmath8 ) in the @xmath9 decay ; all effects of the width in the top propagator were also included .
these studies did _ not _ include gluon radiation from hadronically decaying @xmath0 bosons , so that , strictly speaking , they are directly applicable only to dilepton events , in which both @xmath0 s decay leptonically .
but in the most useful channel ` lepton @xmath10 jets ' only one of the @xmath0 s decays leptonically , and the other decays to quarks .
the presence of one charged lepton in this channel helps suppress backgrounds without sacrificing event rate , while jets from the hadronic @xmath0 decay allow for direct reconstruction of one of the top quarks decay products .
these events can also be accompanied by extra gluons .
in fact they are more likely to do so than dilepton events , because there are more colored particles available to radiate . in this paper
we extend the study of ref .
@xcite for radiation of soft gluons in top production and decay at the tevatron to include gluon radiation in hadronic @xmath0 decays , @xmath11 . in the next section we present analytic expressions for all contributions to the gluon radiation probability in the soft gluon approximation , with a discussion of properties of the @xmath0 decay piece . in section 3 , we apply the results of section 2 to @xmath1 production and decay at the tevatron and show the resulting gluon distributions .
expectations for the lhc are briefly discussed .
section 4 contains our conclusions .
at leading order , @xmath1 production and decay is given by the subprocess(es ) @xmath12 where @xmath13 or @xmath14 for hadron colliders , and the particles momenta are indicated in parentheses .
let us assume that the @xmath15 decays hadronically :
@xmath16 if we are interested in the all jets case , then both @xmath0 s decay hadronically and we also have @xmath17 now consider emission of a gluon with momentum @xmath18 .
it can come from any of the quarks or gluons in the above processes ( _ i.e. , _ any of the particles whose momenta are labeled ) .
this includes initial state radiation , gluons emitted by the top ( or @xmath6 ) quark in either the production or decay process , quark s virtuality picks up poles corresponding , respectively , to emission in the two stages .
see @xcite for a discussion . ] and gluons emitted by the daughter quarks of the @xmath5 and @xmath19 and the @xmath0 boson(s ) .
because of the infra - red divergence associated with radiation of gluons , an extra jet in a @xmath1 event will usually be soft . in the limit of soft gluon emission ,
several simplifications occur .
first , the gluon momentum @xmath18 does not affect the kinematics , so that all of the leading - order kinematic relations still hold .
second , the differential cross section factorizes into the lowest - order cross section multiplied by a gluon radiation probability ; following @xcite we can write @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the differential cross section for the lowest - order process ( _ i.e. _ , with no gluon radiation ) , @xmath22 is the energy of the soft gluon , and @xmath23 is the strong coupling .
the function @xmath24 is the sum of antenna patterns of the radiation from the different sources listed above .
it can be written generically as @xmath25 where @xmath26 is the contribution from emission at the @xmath1 production stage ( including initial - state radiation ) , @xmath27 is the contribution from emission off the @xmath5 and @xmath19 and their decay products at the weak decay stage , and @xmath28 is the contribution from interferences between these emissions . because we are interested in hadronic @xmath0 decays , it is useful to further decompose @xmath27 explicitly into the contribution from radiation off the @xmath5 s and @xmath7 s , and that from radiation off the quarks from the @xmath0 decay(s ) : @xmath29 @xmath30 includes contributions from one or both @xmath0 decays as appropriate .
the interference term @xmath28 contains contributions from the interference ( i ) between radiation in the @xmath5 decay and that in the @xmath6 decay and ( ii ) between radiation in @xmath1 production and radiation in either decay .
( as discussed below , there is no contribution to the interference from the @xmath0 decays because the @xmath0 boson is a color singlet . ) in principle @xmath28 can have substantial effects for gluon energies comparable to the top decay width @xmath31 @xcite .
however , the observable soft jets that are relevant to the @xmath3 collider experiments have energies much larger than @xmath31 , and so in practice the interference terms are numerically small .
explicit expressions for @xmath24 have been presented in @xcite for the @xmath32 and @xmath14 subprocesses , excluding hadronic @xmath0 decays .
the complete expressions , including in hadronic @xmath0 decays , are @xmath33 + c_8 [ \aqiiqii+ \apiipii -2\aqiipii ] \ ; , \nonumber \\
\cf{\mbox{\tiny dec , w } } & = & c_9 \widehat{p_3p_4 } + c_{10}\widehat{p_5p_6}\ ; , \nonumber \\ \cf{\mbox{\tiny int}}&= & \chi_1\ ; \left\ { c_2 [ \akipi -\akiqi ] + c_4 [ \akiipi -\akiiqi ] + c_6 [ \aqiipi -\aqiqii ] + 2 c_7 [ \aqipi -\aqiqi ] \right\ } \nonumber \\ & + & \chi_2\ ; \left\ { c_3 [ \akipii -\akiqii ] + c_5 [ \akiipii -\akiiqii ] + c_6 [ \aqipii -\aqiqii ] + 2 c_8 [ \aqiipii -\aqiiqii ] \right\ } \nonumber \\ & + & \chi_{12 } \ ; c_6 [ \apipii -\aqipii -\aqiipi + \aqiqii ] \ ; , \label{general}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the functions @xmath34 and @xmath35 are defined by @xmath36 \ ; \left [ ( q_2\cdot k)^2 + m_t^2 \gamma_t^2 \right ] } \ ; . \label{chidef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in terms of the gluon energy , we have @xmath37 , and so the cross section ( eq . ( [ softsigma ] ) ) has the infra - red behavior @xmath38 , as expected .
additional collinear singularities arise from the @xmath39 denominators when @xmath40 .
the coefficients @xmath41 depend on the color structure of the hard scattering and can be different for the @xmath32 and @xmath14 processes ( @xmath42 ) : ' '' '' coefficient & @xmath43 & @xmath44 + @xmath45 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 + @xmath48 & @xmath49 & @xmath50 + @xmath51 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 + @xmath54 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 + @xmath55 & @xmath49 & @xmath50 + @xmath56 & @xmath46 & 2y + @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath58 + @xmath59 & @xmath60 & @xmath60 + note that the coefficients @xmath61@xmath62 are involved only in the decay contributions ( including decay
decay interference ) and are therefore independent of the production process . the quantities @xmath63 and @xmath64 depend on the @xmath44 subprocess energy and scattering angle .
explicit expressions and a discussion can be found in @xcite . the production , @xmath65 decay , and interference contributions to @xmath24 have been studied in refs .
@xcite , to which the reader is referred for further discussion .
we shall focus here on the @xmath0 decay contribution . consider a single hadronically decaying @xmath0 : @xmath66 .
its most important feature , for our purposes , is that the @xmath0 boson is a color singlet .
radiation from its decay products at @xmath67 does not , therefore , interfere with gluons from other sources in the process .
its contribution to the radiation pattern simply adds incoherently to the total at this order .
in fact this contribution is just the familiar quark - antiquark antenna pattern , whose properties are well known and are discussed , _
e.g. , _ in ref .
its color structure is the same as for the decay @xmath68 .
here we remind the reader of a few of its properties . because the @xmath69 and @xmath70 from the @xmath0 decay are taken to be massless
, their contribution to @xmath24 depends only on their orientation relative to each other and to the gluon .
furthermore , the only other kinematical factor is an overall @xmath71 , which is common to all terms in @xmath24 .
explicitly , @xmath72 where @xmath73 , @xmath74 , and @xmath75 are , respectively , the angles between the gluon and the quark , the gluon and the antiquark , and the quark and the antiquark .
figure shows the distribution given in eq .
( [ antenna ] ) as a function of gluon angle for several @xmath76 angles .
we see the collinear singularities characteristic of radiation from massless particles .
in fact most ( but not all ) of the radiation is concentrated in the immediate vicinity of the two quarks , which translates in practice to strong sensitivity to jet separation cuts .
we also see the string effect the enhancement of radiation in the region between the @xmath69 and @xmath70 compared to that outside them
. this enhancement can be quite significant when the quarks are relatively close together in angle .
as the angle increases , the enhancement decreases , but does not disappear altogether , and for quarks that are back - to - back ( fig .
1(d ) ) we see the plateau characteristic of initial state radiation , where the radiating particles are also back - to - back .
finally we note that the preceding discussion of the @xmath0 decay contribution to the gluon radiation is true _
independent _ of the source of the @xmath0 , as a consequence of its being a color singlet object .
in particular , although we are concerned here with hadronic top production at the fermilab tevatron collider , hadronic @xmath0 decays in top production at , for example , an @xmath2 collider , are taken into account in exactly the same way . at the order to which we are working
, the @xmath0 decay antenna simply adds incoherently to the contribution from the remaining sources of gluon radiation in any process of interest .
and other colored particles in the scattering process begins at @xmath77 with the exchange of two gluons in a color singlet state .
this has been studied in the context of @xmath78 production @xcite . in general , such interference
is suppressed by factors of @xmath79 and @xmath80 , where @xmath81 is a scale characteristic of the gluon energies , and is therefore numerically very small @xcite . ]
the soft gluon radiation pattern described by eq .
( [ softsigma ] ) can be combined with the lowest - order cross section to obtain the full gluon distribution in a particular experimental situation . in this section
we present the resulting gluon distributions for @xmath1 production at the fermilab tevatron @xmath3 collider for the case where one @xmath0 decays leptonically and the other decays hadronically , _ i.e. , _ the ` lepton @xmath10 jets ' mode .
as we have seen in the previous section , the contribution from the hadronic @xmath0 decay adds incoherently to the other contributions .
the latter correspond to what we would have for the dilepton mode , _
i.e. , _ to the results in ref .
we note that results for the production and ` @xmath65 ' decay distributions presented below are virtually the same as in @xcite , where a more complete discussion of them can be found . our emphasis here
will be on the new features resulting from the @xmath0 decay contribution .
we consider the process @xmath82 , with gluons generated according to eq .
( [ softsigma ] ) , with @xmath83 in eq .
( [ general ] ) , for @xmath3 center - of - mass energy 1.8 tev .
we take @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 and we use mrs(a@xmath87 ) parton distributions @xcite .
we work at the parton level , with kinematic cuts corresponding roughly to those in the experiments : central production of leptons and quarks , some minimum separation of jets from each other and from the lepton , and energy and transverse momentum cuts appropriate to detectability of jets but also consistent with the soft gluon approximation .
the cuts are @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the pseudorapidity and @xmath90 . in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) @xmath91 represents the gluon jet and @xmath92 and @xmath93 represent any other detected jet ( @xmath7 , @xmath94 , or either of the quarks from the @xmath0 decay ) or the charged lepton .
the @xmath95 and @xmath96 cuts eliminate the collinear singularities associated with emission from massless particles .
the resulting distributions in the gluon energy and transverse momentum are shown as solid histograms in fig . .
the contribution associated with top production is shown as a dotted line , that for @xmath97 as a dashed line , and that for @xmath30 as a dot - dashed line .
( interference terms are included in the total but are too small to appear on the plots . ) from the figure we see two features of the @xmath0 decay contribution that will also appear in the rapidity distribution , _ viz .
, _ that it is comparable in both size and shape to the remaining decay piece .
recall that the latter comes from the decays of both the @xmath5 and the @xmath19 , whereas the former involves only the decay of a single top . the gluon pseudorapidity distribution is shown in fig .
; again the @xmath0 decay piece looks very similar to the ` @xmath65 ' piece . we conclude that hadronic @xmath0 decays contribute substantially to gluon radiation in the central rapidity region , more than doubling the amount of radiation associated with the top quark decays . for purposes of distinguishing the production and decay contributions in the dilepton case
, we also considered in @xcite the behavior of the gluon distribution as a function of angular distance @xmath98 of the gluon from the @xmath7 quark . in fig .
( a ) we show the distribution in @xmath98 for very small angles ( @xmath99 ) . except for allowing @xmath100 ,
we have retained the cuts specified in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) .
we see that in this region the distribution is dominated by the ` @xmath65 ' decay contribution ( dashed histogram ) and that as @xmath101 decreases , the distribution increases and then turns over , displaying the ` dead - cone ' behavior characteristic of radiation from massive particles @xcite .
in contrast , the distribution in the angular distance @xmath102 between the gluon and one of the ( massless ) quarks from the hadronic @xmath0 decay , shown in fig .
( b ) , should have a singularity when the quark and gluon are collinear .
we see that when we reduce the minimum allowed @xmath102 to @xmath103 , the distribution shows no signs of turning over at small angles .
the singularity is avoided only by the @xmath101 cut . while it is true that fig .
shows the difference between emissions from massless and massive particles , the effect occurs at angles much too small for the difference to be detected experimentally .
a less academic view appears in fig .
( a ) and ( b ) , where we look at the same distributions on a larger scale after reimposing the @xmath104 requirement .
the distributions look remarkably similar , the only real difference being which contribution dominates at small angles : the ` @xmath65 ' contribution ( dashed histogram ) in fig .
( a ) and the @xmath0 decay contribution ( dot - dashed histogram ) in fig .
( b ) . this could be used in principle to distinguish between the two decay contributions if one knew , from secondary vertex detection , for example , which were the @xmath7 jets and which were those from the @xmath0 decays ( assuming the gluon jet to be the softest one ) .
however the results are quite sensitive to both the @xmath101 cuts and to fragmentation , which is not included in our parton - level analysis .
a perhaps more promising way to separate out the @xmath0 decay contribution is to note that it is associated with only _
one _ of the top decays . if the top quarks are produced more or less back - to - back , then
some of that separation can be expected to survive the decay process . in that case
the charged lepton would tend not to be too close to the quarks from the other @xmath0 decay . and
since gluons prefer to be near the quarks that radiated them , radiation from the hadronic @xmath0 decay should increase with angular distance from the charged lepton .
the expected effect is quantified in fig . , where we show the gluon distribution as a function of the azimuthal angle difference between the lepton and the gluon .
we consider the azimuthal angles because the @xmath5 and @xmath19 are produced back - to - back in the transverse plane .
in addition to the cuts of eq .
( [ cuts ] ) , we require the angular separation of the @xmath7 and @xmath94 to be greater than @xmath105 , and that all detected particles ( lepton and all jets , including the soft gluon jet ) have @xmath106 .
these additional cuts are designed to increase the likelihood that the event is more central and the @xmath5 decay products more widely separated from those of the @xmath19 .
the pseudorapidity cut on the gluon has the added advantage that it eliminates a large portion of the contribution from production ( _ cf . _
fig . ) . in fig .
we see the expected behavior .
all of the distributions are suppressed below about @xmath107 because of the @xmath101 cut . beyond that , the production and ` @xmath65 ' decay contributions are relatively flat .
in contrast , the @xmath0 decay contribution ( dot - dashed histogram ) starts out at about the same size as the other two and increases with increasing angle , reaching a maximum about 50% higher than the initial value .
_ all _ of the increase in the total gluon distribution is due to the increase in the @xmath0 decay contribution .
similar effects would be expected in the distribution in azimuthal angle difference between the gluon and one of the @xmath7 quarks , due to the typical angular separation of about @xmath108 between the @xmath7 and @xmath0 from a single top decay . however , using the lepton is more practical experimentally because there is only one lepton in each event , decays , which can presumably be eliminated with an isolation cut . ] and also because identifying it and measuring its momentum does not involve the complications associated with doing so for jets . if both the @xmath15 and @xmath109 in a @xmath110 event decay hadronically , then there are six jets in the final state at leading order .
the advantages of this mode are its large branching ratio and the fact that , in principle , both the @xmath5 and @xmath19 can be fully reconstructed from their decay jets . in practice , combinatorics and huge qcd backgrounds make this task more difficult .
in addition , radiation of a gluon can give rise to an extra jet , further complicating matters .
if the additional gluon is soft , its distribution is given by eq .
( [ softsigma ] ) with the coefficient @xmath111 in @xmath30 as given in the table .
now , in addition to the @xmath15 decay contribution discussed above , we also have one from the hadronic decay of the @xmath109 .
this new contribution is the same as that from the @xmath15 , and it adds incoherently . therefore radiation from the @xmath0 decays is effectively doubled when both @xmath0 s decay to quarks .
this is illustrated in fig . , which shows the gluon rapidity distribution at the tevatron , where both @xmath0 s contribute to the @xmath0 decay piece ( shown as a dot - dashed histogram ) .
the cuts are as in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) .
their effect here is slightly different from above , however , because now there is no charged lepton , and the lepton and neutrino ( to which no cuts were applied previously ) are replaced by two quarks .
the jet cuts now apply to _ all _ of the particles in the final state .
this accounts for the fact that the @xmath0 decay contribution in the all jets case is slightly less than twice that for lepton @xmath10 jets .
the transverse momentum , energy , and @xmath101 distributions exhibit a similar doubling of the @xmath0 decay contribution , and are omitted for brevity .
the cern large hadron collider ( lhc ) will produce large numbers of top quark pairs .
gluon radiation in top production and decay at the lhc differs from that at the tevatron largely because of the difference in collision energies . at the higher - energy lhc , the top quarks are more energetic , and the cross section is dominated by the gluon - gluon initial state , in contrast to the quark - antiquark annihilation that dominates at the tevatron .
the result @xcite is a much larger proportion of production - stage radiation at the lhc than the tevatron , with relatively little ( on the order of 1020% ) radiation occurring in the decays in the dilepton case .
we expect the effects of radiation from hadronic @xmath0 decays to be similar to effects at the tevatron : radiation from a single hadronically decaying @xmath0 would be comparable to the total decay contributions from the @xmath65 and @xmath112 antennae
. production - stage radiation would continue to dominate .
we defer a detailed discussion to an exact treatment .
we have presented results for soft gluon radiation in top quark production and decay at the fermilab tevatron for the cases relevant for direct reconstruction of the top quarks : the lepton @xmath10 jets and all jets decay modes .
allowing for radiation at @xmath67 from hadronic @xmath0 decays is straightforward because the @xmath0 is a color singlet .
the corresponding contribution simply adds incoherently to the total , with no interference with the remaining contributions . for this reason , soft radiation in @xmath0
decays is also easily treated in top production in @xmath113 collisions by adding @xmath30 to the @xmath24 appropriate to the electron - positron initial state ( _ cf .
( [ softsigma],[curlyf ] ) ) .
we found that , at the tevatron , gluons radiated in hadronic @xmath0 decays contribute subtantially to the total amount of radiation in the central region . in particular ,
gluon radiation from _ each _ hadronic @xmath0 decay is comparable both in size and distribution to the _ total _ @xmath65 and @xmath112 decay contributions . the @xmath0 and non-@xmath0 contributions are thus difficult to distinguish . but by considering the distribution in the azimuthal angle between the gluon and the charged lepton in the lepton @xmath10 jets mode we saw that some separation is possible .
we also note that since the @xmath65 and @xmath112 decay contributions comprise the total decay contribution in the dilepton detection mode , the @xmath0 decay contribution could in principle be isolated by making a direct comparison of jet distributions in dilepton and lepton @xmath10 jets events . in attempts to measure the top mass by reconstructing the momenta of its decay products , it is very important to take into account the presence of extra jets due to gluon radiation .
as we have shown in the soft approximation , hadronic @xmath0 decays give rise to significant amounts of gluon radiation .
an analysis of the impact of this radiation on top momentum reconstruction requires an exact treatment , which we plan in future work .
* acknowledgements * this work was supported in part by the u.s .
department of energy , under grant de - fg02 - 91er40685 , and by the university of rochester summerreach program .
1truecm 99 cdf collaboration : f. abe _ et al .
* 74 * ( 1995 ) 2626 .
d@xmath114 collaboration : s. abachi _ et al .
* 74 * ( 1995 ) 2632 .
g. jikia , phys . lett .
* 257b * ( 1991 ) 196 .
khoze , l.h .
orr and w.j .
stirling , nucl .
b378 * ( 1992 ) 413 .
dokshitzer , v.a .
khoze , l.h . orr and w.j .
stirling , nucl .
b403 * ( 1993 ) 65 .
schmidt , hep - ph/9504434 , phys . rev . * d54 * ( 1996 ) , in press . l.h .
orr , t. stelzer , and w.j .
stirling , phys .
* b354 * ( 1995 ) 442 .
khoze , j. ohnemus and w.j .
stirling , phys .
* d49 * ( 1994 ) 1237 .
l.h . orr and w.j .
stirling , phys .
* d51 * ( 1995 ) 1077 .
b. lampe , phys . lett . * b348 * ( 1995 ) 196 .
orr , t. stelzer and w.j .
stirling , phys .
* d52 * ( 1995 ) 124 ; phys . lett .
* b354 * ( 1995 ) 442 .
v. barger , p.g .
mercadante and r.n.j .
phillips , phys .
* b371 * ( 1996 ) 117 .
dokshitzer , v.a .
khoze , a.h .
mueller and s.i .
troyan , _ basics of perturbative qcd _ ,
editions frontieres , 1991 .
g. gustafson , u. pettersson and p. zerwas , phys .
* b209 * ( 1988 ) 90 .
t. sjstrand and v.a .
khoze , z. phys .
* c62 * ( 1994 ) 281 ; phys .
* 72 * ( 1994 ) 28 .
martin , r.g .
roberts and w.j .
stirling , phys .
* b354 * ( 1995 ) 155 .
orr , t. stelzer and w.j .
stirling , in preparation .
* single @xmath0 decay contribution @xmath27 ( eq . ( [ antenna ] ) ) to the soft gluon radiation pattern in the @xmath115 plane , in arbitrary units , for @xmath116 ( a ) @xmath105 , ( b ) @xmath117 , ( c ) @xmath118 , and ( d ) @xmath119 .
* distributions in ( a ) the gluon energy and ( b ) the gluon transverse momentum , in @xmath1 production , via the subprocesses @xmath4 , in @xmath3 collisions at @xmath120 , with @xmath121 .
contributions from production ( dotted lines ) , @xmath97 decay ( dashed lines ) , and @xmath30 ( dot - dashed lines ) are shown along with their totals ( solid lines ) .
the cuts are listed in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) . * gluon pseudorapidity distributions in @xmath1 production , via the subprocesses @xmath4 , in @xmath3 collisions at @xmath120 , with @xmath121 .
the net distribution is shown as a solid line ; contributions from production ( dotted lines ) , @xmath97 decay ( dashed lines ) , and @xmath30 ( dot - dashed lines ) are also shown .
the cuts are listed in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) . * distribution in @xmath101 between the gluon and ( a ) the @xmath7 quark and ( b ) the charged lepton .
cuts are as in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) , except for allowing ( a ) @xmath100 and ( b ) @xmath122 . * distribution in @xmath101 between the gluon and ( a ) the @xmath7 quark and ( b ) the charged lepton .
the cuts are as in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) . *
distribution in the azimuthal angle between the charged lepton and gluon jet .
the cuts are as in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) , except @xmath106 for all detected particles and the angle between the @xmath7 and @xmath94 must be greater than @xmath105 . * gluon pseudorapidity distributions in @xmath1 production , via the subprocesses @xmath4 , in @xmath3 collisions at @xmath120 , with both @xmath0 s decaying hadronically .
the net distribution is shown as a solid line ; contributions from production ( dotted lines ) , @xmath97decay ( dashed lines ) , and @xmath30 ( dot - dashed lines ) are also shown .
the cuts are listed in eq .
( [ cuts ] ) . | in reconstructing the top quark momentum from its decay products , one must account for extra jets that can result from radiation of gluons . in this paper
we study soft gluon radiation in top production and decay at the fermilab tevatron .
we consider the cases where one or both @xmath0 bosons decays hadronically , _
i.e. _ , where at least one of the top quarks can be fully reconstructed .
we show results for gluon distributions at the tevatron and find that radiation from the @xmath0 decay products contributes substantially in the central region .
ur-1452 + dtp/96/08 + hep - ph/9605369 + may 1996 + 1.cm * soft gluon radiation in top events : effect of hadronic @xmath0 decays * 1.cm bond masuda , lynne h. orr .2 cm _ department of physics , university of rochester + rochester , ny 14627 - 0171 , usa _
+ .4 cm and .4 cm w.j . stirling .2 cm _ departments of physics and mathematical sciences , university of durham + durham dh1 3le , england _ + |
cataclysmic variables ( cvs ) are semi - detached interacting binaries in which a roche lobe filling k or m secondary transfers matter to a white dwarf ( wd ) .
cvs evolve to shorter orbital periods and show a `` gap '' between @xmath6 and 3 ( where @xmath7 hr ) during which time the secondary star loses contact with its roche lobe and mass transfer ceases . thus the binary becomes fully detached . at @xmath6
the secondary comes back into contact with its roche lobe and mass transfer resumes . for @xmath8 angular momentum loss from the binary
is thought to be due solely to gravitational radiation .
the cv subclass of dwarf novae ( dne ) are characterized by their semi - periodic outbursts .
su uma stars are dne lying below the period gap that exhibit short , normal outbursts ( nos ) and superoutbursts ( sos ) .
we refer the time from one so to the next as the supercycle .
sos show superhumps which are modulations in the light curve at periods slightly exceeding the orbital period .
there are two further subdivisions within the su uma grouping : ( i ) the vw hyi stars at long orbital periods , near @xmath6 , for which the decay rate is fairly constant during a so , and ( ii ) the wz sge stars at short orbital periods , a little greater than @xmath9 , which have less frequent , larger amplitude sos , for which the decay rate decreases during a so .
dne outbursts are thought to be due to a limit cycle accretion disk instability ( lasota 2001 ) in which material is accumulated in quiescence and then dumped onto the wd during outburst . during short outbursts in longer period dne , a few percent of the stored mass is accreted , and during long outbursts a significant fraction @xmath00.2 of the stored mass is accreted . for the su
uma stars , a so is thought to accrete @xmath10 of the stored mass .
although the accretion disk is never in steady state during the limit cycle , it is close to steady state during so , with the local rate of accretion inside the disk @xmath11 decreasing linearly from a maximum value at the disk inner edge to zero at the outer edge . the accretion disk modeling has traditionally been done within the shakura & sunyaev ( 1973 , hereafter ss ) formalism , using two values for the @xmath12 viscosity parameter , @xmath13 for gas in the hot , ionized disk , and @xmath5 for gas in the quiescent disk .
.35 cm there are two bright su uma stars in the _ kepler _ field exhibiting a variety of temporal behavior that make them worthy of a detailed statistical study of their outbursts , v1504 cyg ( _ kepler _ i d 7446357 ; @xmath14 ) and v344 lyr ( _ kepler _ i d 7659570 ; @xmath15 ) .
these are members of the vw hyi subdivision . to date
the two light curves have amassed 736.4 d at 1@xmath2min cadence .
excluding gaps and bad data points , the light curves contain 1000431 and 1000345 data entries , respectively .
previous studies of the _ kepler _ data on su uma stars have found quiescent superhumps in v344 lyr ( still et al .
2010 ) , presented numerical models of the long term light curve of v344 lyr ( cannizzo et al .
2010 ; hereafter c10 ) , and studied superhumps , both positive and negative , in the long term v344 lyr light curve ( wood et al .
2011 ) . .35 cm statistical studies of dne have been useful in delineating the long - term properties of outbursts , e.g .. , the outburst duration , recurrence times , and quiescent intervals , and placing physical constraints on models of outbursts ( e.g. , campbell & shapley 1940 , sterne , campbell & shapley 1940 , bath & van paradijs 1983 , van paradijs 1983 , szkody & mattei 1984 , cannizzo & mattei 1992 , 1998 , ak , et al .
2002 , simon 2004 ) .
several interesting studies of the su uma stars have been carried out .
for instance , van paradijs ( 1983 ) studied the variation in outburst duration @xmath16 with orbital period for 15 dne spanning the @xmath17 hr cv period gap .
he found that short outburst durations increase with orbital period , whereas long outburst durations are relatively constant with orbital period .
therefore for the su uma systems , which lie at short orbital period , the ratio @xmath18 is large .
the relation of superoutbursts to normal outbursts for dne below the period gap and the relation of long outbursts to normal outbursts for dne above the period gap are part of a general trend ; superoutbursts are just long outbursts in short orbital period dne .
this finding was amplified by ak et al .
( 2002 ) using a larger sample . in this work
we seek to extend previous studies by analyzing the high fidelity _ kepler _ light curves of two su uma stars to investigate the properties of the outbursts . in section 2
we examine the outburst properties of the nos and sos , in section 3 we discuss the results , in particular the scaling of the so decay rate with orbital period , and in section 4 we summarize our results .
the relatively small number of total outbursts observed in the two systems to date does not yet allow one to amass detailed frequency histogram distributions , as was done for instance by cannizzo & mattei ( 1992 ) for the @xmath0700 outbursts observed up to that time in ss cyg . however , the variations of the outburst duration @xmath16 and intervening quiescent interval @xmath19 within a supercycle contain information which can potentially guide theoretical models .
for instance , in the thermal - tidal model for the supercycle in the su uma systems ( ichikawa & osaki 1992 , 1994 ; ichikawa , hirose , & osaki 1993 ) , one sees a monotonically increasing sequence of no quiescent intervals leading up to a so .
now with the exquisite _ kepler _ data , this can be directly tested .
the nos of the fainter su uma stars such as v344 lyr have been poorly characterized prior to _ kepler _ due to their intrinsic faintness ( see , e.g. , fig . 1 of kato et al .
2002 ) .
figures 1 and 2 present the currently available long term light curves for v1504 cyg and v344 lyr . to obtain the apparent _ kepler _ magnitude from the original data , electron flux per cadence , a correspondence of @xmath20 to @xmath21 @xmath22 cadence@xmath3 was adopted .
each light curve encompasses six sos ; v1504 cyg had 59 nos while v344 lyr had 58 .
two systematic effects are worth noting : ( i ) there are gaps in the data due to monthly data downloads , quarterly @xmath23 spacecraft rolls , and spacecraft safe modes .
( ii ) in addition , there is no long - term absolute flux calibration for _ kepler _ ( haas et al .
2010 , koch et al .
2010 ) : ( 1 ) target masks do not contain all the flux from the target . the aperture is chosen to maximize a varying s / n over the whole quarter . as _
kepler _ orbits the sun , however , targets drift across the mask as a result of differential velocity aberration .
varying amounts of target flux fall outside of the pixel aperture over the quarter , so the target flux tends to vary smoothly over the quarter due to this effect .
another contributing factor to this effect is focus variation due to the thermal behavior following spacecraft slews , especially immediately after earth pointings for data download , or safe modes .
( 2 ) after each _ kepler _ rotation , the target falls on a different ccd chip with a different psf and the target is centered differently , e.g. , perhaps on a pixel boundary rather than a pixel center .
the 4 arcsec pixels undersample the psf .
this means that the pixel mask changes shape and size each quarter , with different amount of light losses .
( 3 ) with different shaped masks , the number and amount of contaminating sources in the mask will differ across the quarter gap .
the lack of long term flux calibration is evident in the elevated flux level seen in v1504 cyg during @xmath24 ( i.e , q2 of observations ) .
in addition the secular trending of the flux calibration within a given quarter may account for the apparent @xmath050 d @xmath25folding decrease of the quiescent level following the first two sos in v344 lyr , both of which occurred just after a roll maneuver . in view of these considerations , we limit our attention in this study to timescales rather than amplitudes . -3.5
cm in a standard light curve plot of magnitude versus time , a straight line decay means that the flux @xmath26 , which we would therefore refer to as an exponential decay . a decay which deviates from exponential could be concave upward ( slower - than - exponential ) , concave downward ( faster - than - exponential ) , or some more complicated shape
the decays of the nos are faster - than - exponential , which obviates theoretical studies that attempt to introduce a weak radial power law dependency into the ss @xmath12 parameter in order to get precisely exponential decays ( e.g. , ichikawa , hirose , & osaki 1993 ; cannizzo 1994 )
. we may quantify the deviation from exponentiality in the no decays by dividing the decay into bins , each spanning a small range @xmath27 , and calculating the locally defined decay rate @xmath28(d mag@xmath3 ) within each bin .
dividing the decay into a total of 10 bins for each star , we take @xmath29 for v1504 cyg and @xmath30 for v344 lyr . for demonstration purposes , the binning distribution for the decay of the first no in v344 lyr
is shown in figure 3 . within each bin
we compute a frequency histogram distribution of @xmath28 values for all no decays .
the results are shown in figures 4 and 5 .
the small numbers in each panel indicate the magnitude range in @xmath31 measured from the local maximum for each no .
thus , the upper panels show the decay rates computed near maximum light , and as one progresses to lower panels one is sampling the fainter portions .
for both systems one sees a shifting in the centroid of the frequency histogram distribution to lower @xmath28 values as the decay proceeds , equivalent to saying that the decays are concave downward . in both systems , the parts of the decays fainter than about 1 mag below no maximum asymptote to a centroid median of @[email protected] d mag@xmath3 .
thus the concave - downward aspect of the no decays is due in large part to the rounded maxima ; by the time the no has faded to within @xmath32 mag of quiescence , the rest of the decay is closely exponential .
-2.75 cm -2.75 cm bailey ( 1975 ) discovered that the decay rate for nos is correlated with orbital period ( see his figure 1 for eight well - studied systems ) , and derived the empirical relation @xmath33 d mag@xmath3 @xmath34 .
smak ( 1984 ) was the first to show that this relation can be used to infer @xmath4 .
subsequent work confirmed and expanded on this finding ( cannizzo 2001a ) .
warner ( 1995b ) looked at a larger sample than bailey and deduced the fit @xmath35 d mag@xmath3 @xmath36 .
for the two systems of interest in this study , for which @xmath14 ( v1504 cyg ) and 2.1 ( v344 lyr ) , respectively , the predictions for the rates of decay would be 0.64 and 0.80 d mag@xmath3 from the original bailey relation , and 0.82 and 0.99 d mag@xmath3 from the warner fit .
the presently determined values @xmath00.7 d mag@xmath3 in v1504 cyg and @xmath00.6 d mag@xmath3 in v344 lyr for the faintest bins are closer to bailey s original expression .
if one averaged over the entire decay , the values would be larger , closer to warner s expression . the precision of the current determinations are limited by the small number of total nos in both systems . with time
, better statistics will allow better determinations , as has been done for instance with ss cyg ( cannizzo & mattei 1998 , see their figure 6 ) .
figure 6 shows the outburst durations @xmath16 for the two systems .
based on the magnitude range for outbursts in the two systems , we use a cut of @xmath37 in v1504 cyg and @xmath38 in v344 lyr to define outburst onset and termination .
there is an obvious trend of increasing outburst width @xmath16 between consecutive sos : during a supercycle , @xmath16 increases by @xmath020@xmath270% .
figure 7 shows the asymmetry parameter @xmath39 , defined to be the ratio of the rise time to the total outburst duration , for the individual nos depicted in figures 1 and 2 .
figure 8 shows the quiescent intervals @xmath19 between successive outbursts . in both systems
there is a general trend of @xmath19 values that increase to a local maximum about mid - way between successive sos . for the last half of the v1504 cyg light curve and the first half of the v344 lyr light curve
this effect is quite pronounced .
in is interesting that while the values of @xmath39 and @xmath19 from one no to the next are fairly continuous , even across an so , the @xmath16 values show a sharp discontinuity across an so , resetting to a much smaller value . at roughly the time of the third so in v1504 cyg , strong negative superhumps appear ( wood et al .
2011 , in preparation ) and persist through the end of the light curve .
the presence of negative superhumps indicates that the mass is not accreting primarily at the rim of the disk .
although there is not an obvious change in @xmath39 at this time , it is perhaps noteworthy that @xmath19 increases .
this may indicate a strong drop in the mass transfer rate from the secondary star , which would increase the recurrence time for outbursts . in the magnetic systems such as am her , which lack accretion disks ,
one has direct evidence for the instantaneous mass transfer rate from the secondary stars in the long term light curves , and one does often see intervals during which the mass transfer rate reduces to a low level ( e.g. , hessman , gnsicke , & mattei 2000 ) .
figure 9 shows a composite of the six sos in v1504 cyg , positioned in time so that @xmath40 d corresponds to the crossing of @xmath37 during so onset . the rate of decay during
so is @xmath08 d mag@xmath3 .
figure 10 shows a composite of the six sos in v344 lyr , positioned in time so that @xmath41 d corresponds to the crossing of @xmath42 during so onset .
the rate of decay during so is @xmath012 d mag@xmath3 . within each system
the sos are quite similar in overall appearance and duration .
a summary of the parameters associated with the outbursts in the two systems is given in table 1 .
the behavior of the sequences of outburst durations @xmath16 and quiescent intervals @xmath19 during a supercycle are quite different .
the @xmath16 sequence shows an increase between sos in both systems .
this is consistent with a secular increase in the mass of the accretion disk .
the @xmath19 values , by contrast , increase to a local maximum roughly half way between sos before returning to their initial small value by the time the next so begins . thus the @xmath19 values are roughly continuous across sos . in both systems
the variation of @xmath19 values between sos appears to be inconsistent with the prediction of the thermal - tidal instability model , which shows a monotonic increase in @xmath19 between sos ( ichikawa , hirose , & osaki 1993 , see their figure 1 ; osaki 2005 , see his figure 3 ) .
this indicates that the triggering radius for nos does not move uniformly outward with each successive no , but rather attains a local maximum and then recedes . -2.75
cm -2.75 cm cccc no : @xmath16(d ) & [email protected] & [email protected] & no duration + so : @xmath16(d ) & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & so duration + no : @xmath39 & [email protected] & [email protected] & no rise / duration + @xmath19(d ) & [email protected] & [email protected] & quiescent duration + no : @xmath28(d mag@xmath3 ) & 0.7 & 0.6 & no decay rate + so : @xmath28(d mag@xmath3 ) & @xmath45 & @xmath46 & so decay rate the asymmetry of the nos is similar in the two systems , @xmath47 . according to theory , the degree of outburst asymmetry reveals whether the outburst is triggered at small or large radii in the disk ( smak 1984 ; cannizzo , wheeler , & polidan 1986 , hereafter cwp ; cannizzo 1998 , see his figure 6 and associated discussion ) .
outbursts triggered at large radii tend to have fast , asymmetric rise times ( @xmath48 ) , while those triggered at small radii are more symmetric ( @xmath49 ) .
smak referred to these two types as type a and type b , respectively , whereas cwp used the terminology `` outside - in '' and `` inside - out '' outbursts .
the low @xmath39 values in both systems studied in this work are consistent with the type a / outside - in outbursts .
it is interesting that the one outburst which seems to be certifiably symmetric and therefore presumably inside - out @xmath2 outburst 1 of v344 lyr @xmath2 occurred after an unusually long quiescence interval , which may have led to a more filled disk at the end of quiescence ( compare this outburst with that shown in figure 5b of smak 1984 and figure 3 of cwp ) . during this part of the v344 lyr light curve
there were strong negative superhumps ( wood et al .
2011 , see their figure 11 ) , indicating a tilted accretion disk .
this would have the effect of spreading the accretion stream impact over a large range in radii , thereby lengthening the time to build up to the next outburst .
-2.75 cm the mean durations of sos for v1504 cyg and v344 lyr are 11.9 d and 16.8 d , and the @xmath25folding rates of the ( slow ) decay during so are @xmath45 d mag@xmath3 and @xmath50 mag@xmath3 , respectively , where the errors indicate the standard deviations of the six measurements . thus the sos span @xmath01.5 @xmath25foldings in v1504 cyg , and @xmath01.4 @xmath25foldings in v344 lyr . given that the so accretion disks are close to steady state , the depletion fraction @xmath51 in the stored disk mass during so for the two systems
, @xmath52 is @xmath00.78 and @xmath00.75 , respectively .
( these numbers probably over - estimate the depleted mass fraction because they encompass portions of the so fainter than the @xmath25folding plateaus . )
these depletion fractions are larger than the @xmath53 inferred for long outbursts in dne above the period gap ( e.g. , cannizzo 1993 ) , and stem from the larger @xmath54 ratios in the su uma systems .
the ratio @xmath55 is consistent with the previous interpretation of fast decays being due to the action of a cooling front within the disk , and slow decays being the result of gradual accretion onto the wd , and therefore governed by the viscous time scale in the outer disk .
the viscous and thermal time scales can be written in terms of the local keplerian rotation frequency @xmath56 and the local disk height to radius ratio @xmath57 ( pringle 1981 ) .
the viscous time scale @xmath58 and the thermal time scale @xmath59 differ by a factor @xmath57 , therefore @xmath60 .
c10 present an equation for the rate of decay of a so , taken from warner ( 1995a , 1995b ) , which is based on the viscous time in the outer accretion disk @xmath61 where @xmath62 and @xmath63 .
this @xmath25folding time scale should approximate the decay rate , expressed in d mag@xmath3 .
hence in a large sample of dne the prediction is that the rate of decay during so should vary as @xmath64 .
our analysis shows , however , that in going from v1504 cyg with @xmath14 to v344 lyr with @xmath15 , the so decay rate increases from 8 d to 12 d. one does expect object - to - object variations in no and so properties which can be large compared to overall , secular trends with orbital period , but given the dependencies in equation ( [ brian ] ) and the inference from a large number of dne that @xmath4 , there is no way to account for such a steep variation , @xmath65 .
cccc sw uma & 10 .
& 1.36 & 1 + wx cet & 10 . & 1.40 & 2 + fl tra & 7.7 & 1.41 & 3 + v1028 cyg & 8.3 & 1.45 & 4 + ho del & 7.1 & 1.50 & 5 + go com & 6.7 & 1.58 & 6 + nsv 4838 & 10 .
& 1.63 & 7 + vw crb & 10.3 & 1.70 & 8 + eg aqr & 7.1 & 1.83 & 9 + v503 cyg & 9.1 & 1.86 & 10 it is worth pausing for a moment and looking at how the so slow decay rates for v1504 cyg and v344 lyr fit into the larger picture . table 2 lists the slow decay rate of sos for su uma stars taken from the literature ,
most of which are derived from vsnet data ( see kato et al . 2009 , 2010 ) .
we only show data for the vw hyi subclass for which the slow decay rate is relatively constant over the course of the so . in figure 11
we plot the so decay rates for the systems shown in table 2 , as well as v1504 cyg , v344 lyr , wz sge and u gem .
for wz sge we only plot the value for the initial , steep rate of decay , 4 d mag@xmath3 .
as noted in the introduction , the so decays in the wz sge stars exhibit a strong deviation from exponentiality presumably due to the accretion of virtually all the stored mass .
as the disk mass decreases , one expects a concomitant increase in the viscous time , leading to a pronounced concave upward so decay .
therefore only the very initial so decay rate gives a valid representation for the viscous time within the disk corresponding to the stored mass . as regards dne above the period gap ,
virtually none of the long outbursts ever observed exhibited enough dynamic range in their overall decay that one could reliably extract the rate of decay . only for the unusually long , 1985 october outburst of u gem
could this determination be made ( cannizzo , gehrels , and mattei 2002 ) , hence the single data point above the period gap in figure 11 .
if one takes the overall @xmath66 trend between wz sge and u gem as a true physical baseline , @xmath67 , the trend between v1504 cyg and v344 lyr in @xmath68 space , @xmath65 , is roughly the same , although the normalization is offset slightly . given the vertical scatter in figure 11 for the other su uma systems , this coincidence is fortuitous .
-1 cm -1 cm the failure of equation ( [ brian ] ) to account for the difference between the so slow decay rate in v1504 cyg and v344 lyr indicates that a more sophisticated expression may be required .
one obvious deficiency is that there is no dependence on @xmath5 which controls the available amount of fuel in quiescence to power a so .
the physics behind the viscosity in quiescence is unknown at present , and one could in principle have large variations in @xmath5 between systems at similar orbital periods .
let us go back to the definition of the viscous time scale @xmath69 .
since the controlling time scale in this situation is the slowest one , this expression is to be evaluated at the outer disk radius @xmath70 . following cannizzo ( 2001b )
, we consider the hot state of the disk by adopting a rosseland mean opacity @xmath71 g @xmath72 and mean molecular weight @xmath73 .
we can then write the viscous time as @xmath74 where @xmath75 , @xmath76 , and @xmath77 is the surface density at the outer disk edge . looking at this expression , we see that the warner ( 1995a , 1995b ) equation already contained an implicit assumption about @xmath78 , as it only contains @xmath13 and @xmath34 . to derive a more meaningful expression for @xmath79 in the context of sos we need to take into account two additional pieces of information , namely that during a so essentially all the mass accumulated during quiescence is accreted onto the wd , and thereby lost from the disk , and also that the accumulated mass depends on the critical surface density @xmath80 , which depends in turn on @xmath5 .
this scaling is given by ( lasota 2001 ) @xmath81 since the attainment of @xmath80 is the triggering mechanism for a dn outburst , the quiescence disk mass @xmath0@xmath82 at the time of so onset can be written as @xmath83 once the so has started , the mass that was present in the non - steady state quiescent disk gets redistributed into a quasi - steady disk with @xmath84 constant , and therefore with a radial profile @xmath85 ( ss ) . therefore the mass of the hot disk can be written as @xmath86 since the ratio @xmath54 is large in su uma systems , a substantial amount of mass needs to drain onto the wd before the surface is depleted enough for the cooling wave to start .
we now set @xmath87 equal to its standard functional form for a ss disk with gas pressure and free - free opacity , @xmath88 .
this is the same form that entered into equation ( [ visc ] ) . equating the disk mass at the end of the quiescent state with that at the beginning of the so
, i.e. , @xmath89 , gives @xmath90 the relevant @xmath78 value for equation ( [ visc ] ) .
therefore we can rewrite equation ( [ visc ] ) as @xmath91 this expression differs from equation ( [ visc ] ) in that it contains @xmath5 , reflecting the fact that the total amount of matter stored in quiescence enters into the viscous time scale in the resultant so disk .
in extreme mass ratio systems such as the su uma stars , the roche lobe of the primary asymptotes to @xmath00.82 of the binary separation ( eggleton 1983 ) . also , the relation between orbital separation and orbital period is @xmath92 , where @xmath93 is the orbital separation in units of @xmath94 cm .
if we further take the outer disk radius @xmath70 to lie at 75% of the primary roche lobe , we have @xmath95 .
since it is fairly certain that @xmath12 in outburst is always close to 0.1 , @xmath13 been scaled to that value in the previous equations . on the other hand , the @xmath12 value in quiescence is uncertain , and has been traditionally adjusted by trial and error for each system . for su uma stars ,
workers have typically had to adopt much smaller @xmath5 values than for dne above the period gap . given this uncertainty ,
let us take @xmath5 to be a power law in orbital period , @xmath96 . making these substitutions into equation ( [ visc2 ] )
we obtain @xmath97 the dynamic variation associated with one magnitude ( 2.512 ) is 0.924 times that associated with one @xmath25folding ( 2.718 ) .
therefore if we associate the rate of so decay , expressed in d mag@xmath3 , with the viscous time at the outer edge , which is an @xmath25folding time , then equation ( [ visc3 ] ) needs to be corrected by a factor 0.924 . by comparing the so decay rates of v1504 cyg and v344 lyr , we infer a decay rate @xmath98 .
furthermore , adopting @xmath99 for the su uma systems gives @xmath100 , and therefore @xmath101 solving for the constant and exponent in the @xmath5 scaling gives @xmath102 and @xmath103 @xmath2 a steep dependence of @xmath5 on orbital period .
for v344 lyr at @xmath15 we obtain @xmath104 , which accounts for why c10 , in their modeling of v344 lyr , had to adopt the small value @xmath105 .
the inference @xmath103 is only valid , however , if the trend between v1504 cyg and v344 lyr were representative of a trend with @xmath34 , which seems unlikely given the data for the other su uma systems .
based only on the su uma data , it would be more likely that @xmath106 has a large variation between the two systems . as noted earlier however ,
if one takes the wz sge @xmath107 u gem interpolation to be physically meaningful , then the v1504 cyg @xmath107 v344 lyr interpolation is fortuitously coincident .
a steep dependence of @xmath5 on @xmath34 may have observational support from another line of argument .
in a recent study of the aggregate properties of dne , patterson ( 2011 , see his figure 11 ) finds that the recurrence time for sos has a steep inverse relation with binary mass ratio @xmath108 , where @xmath109 .
since the secondaries in cataclysmic variables are , by definition , in contact with their roche lobes , this implies that @xmath110 scales with orbital period , and hence @xmath111 .
given that ( 1 ) sos accrete virtually all their stored mass @xmath112 , ( 2 ) the mass feeding rate into the outer disk from the secondary @xmath113 is thought to be relatively constant at @xmath0@xmath114 for systems below the period gap ( kolb et al .
1998 ; howell et al .
2001 ) , and ( 3 ) the recurrence time ( cannizzo et al . 1988 ) @xmath115 it is quite surprising that @xmath116 apparently has a strong inverse relation with orbital period . as one progresses to shorter orbital period ,
one expects more frequent sos since the disks are smaller and the critical mass is reached more quickly .
we are seemingly drawn to the same conclusion as previously , that @xmath5 must have a strong dependence on orbital period .
howell et al .
( 2001 ; see their figure 2 , panel ( a ) ) indicates a rough dependence @xmath117 for the su uma stars .
if we again set @xmath118 , substitute @xmath34 for @xmath70 in equation ( [ joe ] ) , and solve for @xmath119 , we obtain @xmath120 .
if the overall trend in @xmath28 for long outbursts between wz sge and u gem , which is roughly matched ( coincidentally ) by that between v1504 cyg and v344 lyr , is real , then two independent lines of reasoning imply a very steep dependence of @xmath5 on orbital period .
why should one have @xmath121 constant , while at the same time @xmath118 , where @xmath122 ?
current thinking on the physical mechanism for viscosity in accretion disks centers on the magnetorotational instability ( mri - balbus & hawley 1998 ) , an instability based on the shearing amplification of a weak magnetic field .
the nonlinear saturation limit of the mri in ionized gas is thought to explain why @xmath1230.1 ( mckinney & narayan 2007a , 2007b ) .
however , as the disk cools to the quiescent state and the supply of free electrons drops precipitously due to the exponential dependence of partial ionization on temperature below @xmath0@xmath124 k , the magnetic field no longer couples effectively to the gas , and fails to provide an effective viscosity .
menou ( 2000 ) tried to model the complete accretion disk limit cycle model for dne using only the mri , and failed .
he discussed the failure of the mri in quiescence , and predicted that if tidal torques ( a completely different physical mechanism from the mri ) dominate the angular momentum transport in the quiescent accretion disks in the su uma stars , one would expect an anticorrelation between @xmath116 and @xmath125 .
he presents data for six su uma stars showing an anticorrelation .
( patterson [ 2011 ] shows the anticorrelation in much greater detail . )
menou notes that theories of tidally induced spiral waves or shock waves indicate a strong correlation between effective torque and @xmath125 ( papaloizou & pringle 1977 ; goldreich & tremaine 1980 ) .
our finding @xmath126 seems to support the view that tidal torquing is the dominant angular momentum transport mechanism operating in quiescent accretion disks in interacting binaries .
for completeness we note that previous workers have commented on the apparent necessity of small @xmath5 to obtain the large amplitude sos and long recurrence times in the short orbital period dne .
for example meyer - hofmeister et al .
( 1998 ) found that the large required stored disk mass and outburst long recurrence time in wz sge mandated @xmath127 in the disk instability model .
meyer & meyer - hofmeister ( 1999 ) argued for a possible physical cause in the loss of coronal activity in the very cool atmospheres of the low mass k - type secondaries expected in such short orbital period systems , resulting in lower magnetic fields in the material entrained in the l1 point as it feeds the outer accretion disk .
however , in view of the findings of menou ( 2000 ) showing the lack of mri in quiescent disks , and the fact that if the mri were operating the strength of the final field within the disk would be unrelated to the amplitude of the seed field , we find the tidal torquing arguments more persuasive .
the @xmath5 value strongly influences two observables , the decay time of the viscous plateaus , and the recurrence times for outburst .
it is important to verify whether the steep @xmath5 relation mandated by the wz sge @xmath2 u gem trend shown in figure 11 is consistent with the observed recurrence times for the two systems . in other words , does the relation @xmath128 applied to both wz sge and u gem lead to reasonable recurrence times for both systems ? for wz sge , @xmath129 implies @xmath130 . from smak ( 1993 ) and
steeghs et al .
( 2007 ) we have @xmath131 , @xmath132 , and @xmath133 g s@xmath3 .
( smak s value for @xmath113 may be too low , as it is below the floor value expected solely from gravitational radiation [ howell et al .
2001 ] . ) using the value for the stored quiescent mass from equation ( 7 ) gives @xmath134 g. thus the recurrence time for sos from equation ( 13 ) is @xmath135 yr , versus the observed recurrence time for superoutbursts in wz sge ( no normal outbursts are seen ) of @xmath136 yr . for a standard value given by gravitational radiation induced mass transfer below the period gap @xmath137
, the recurrence time would be @xmath138 yr . for u gem , @xmath139 implies @xmath140 , from smak ( 2001 ) we have @xmath141 , @xmath142 , orbital separation @xmath143 cm @xmath144 cm , and @xmath145 . from equation ( 7 ) , @xmath146 g for the stored mass . given a mass transfer rate typical of systems above the period gap @xmath147 we use equation ( 13 ) to arrive at a recurrence time @xmath148 d. the observed recurrence time for outbursts in u gem is @xmath149 d , and for long outbursts only it is @xmath150 d ( since the outburst pattern basically alternates between long and short outbursts ) .
the long outbursts are more relevant as regards the recurrence time scale obtained from equation ( 13 ) since it is assumed most of the stored mass accretes .
thus for both wz sge and u gem the theoretical and observed recurrence times for long outbursts agree to within a factor of @xmath151 , indicating both systems can have the same scaling of @xmath5 on binary orbital period . since the orbital periods of the two systems are quite different , their values of @xmath5 are quite different .
the @xmath25folding decay times @xmath152 d for the mass of the accretion disk during so in v1504 cyg and v344 lyr represent @xmath153 orbital time scales in the outer disk @xmath154 540 s @xmath155 .
in other words @xmath156 .
the latest mri simulations of accretion disks , which should be applicable to the outburst state of dne , are not yet sophisticated enough to be directly compared to sos .
for instance , sorathia et al . (
2011 ) perform global magnetohydrodynamic simulations of accretion disks which span a dynamic range of only a factor of four in disk radii .
they also neglect the vertical dependence of the gravitational potential , which does not allow the effects of magnetic buoyancy in reducing the magnetic pressure within the body of the disk . in their simulations
they find @xmath157 for the depletion of accretion disk mass .
nevertheless their results are quite interesting in the context of our work because they show that the shakura - sunyaev @xmath12 values determined from the local @xmath158 and @xmath159 components of the magnetic field are about an order of magnitude lower than those determined from the averaged viscous time scale in the outer disk ( equivalent to the global decay rate of the disk mass ) , which is the more relevant determination in the context of comparison with dn decay rates .
king , pringle , & livio ( 2007 ) noted a factor @xmath160 discrepancy between observationally determined @xmath13 values and those calculated numerically from mri simulations ( the mri values being too small ) . although the local shearing box simulations cited by king et al . have been strongly criticized because of convergence issues ( fromang & papaloizou 2007 ) , the global calculations of sorathia et al .
also give @xmath161 . if the general trend between two methods of @xmath13 determinations by sorathia et al .
are confirmed in more sophisticated global mri calculations with larger @xmath162 and realistic vertical stratification , that may resolve the current apparent discrepancy between theory and observation . -4.75
we have analyzed long term _ kepler _
light curves of v1504 cyg , containing 65 outbursts , and v344 lyr , containing 64 outbursts . each system showed six superoutbursts .
the findings are : \(1 ) the no decays are faster - than - exponential , with most of the deviation occurring near maximum light . near quiescence
the decays are close to exponential , @xmath00.7 d mag@xmath3 for v1504 cyg and @xmath00.6 d mag@xmath3 for v344 lyr .
these rates are in line with that expected from the bailey relation .
our values are based on frequency histogram distributions of only @xmath050 nos and should improve as more outbursts are accumulated .
\(2 ) the no outburst durations @xmath16 increase by a factor @[email protected] over the time interval between consecutive superoutbursts , resetting to a small value after a superoutburst .
this is consistent with a monotonic increase of the accretion disk mass with each successive no .
\(3 ) the quiescent intervals @xmath19 between normal outbursts show a general trend in both systems of increasing to a local maximum about mid - way between superoutbursts .
( there was also an anomalously long quiescence interval at the start of the v344 lyr light curve , potentially the result of a tilted disk . )
this behavior for @xmath19 is inconsistent with osaki s thermal tidal instability model for sos , in which one expects a monotonic increase in @xmath19 values accompanying the monotonic build - up in disk mass and angular momentum leading to a so .
if @xmath19 is correlated with the no triggering radius @xmath163 , then @xmath163 moves outward with each successive no only through roughly the first half of a supercycle , and then recedes .
\(5 ) the inference of the steep relation @xmath165 gives strength to the notion of tidal torquing as the dominant angular momentum transport mechanism operating in quiescent accretion disks in interacting binaries . if one considers the slow decay rate of the long , viscous outbursts spanning dne from wz sge to u gem , one infers an overall variation @xmath166 .
it is unfortunate that only one long outburst in one dn longward of the @xmath17 hr period gap exhibited enough dynamic variation in flux during its plateau phase that a decay rate can be reliably extracted for the slow decay portion .
it is fortuitous , given the general scatter in dn outburst properties at a given orbital period , that the decay rate between v1504 cyg and v344 lyr shows a similar law @xmath167 .
these dependencies are much steeper than the @xmath64 expected from the previous theoretical expression , due to warner ( 1995a , 1995b ) . by starting with the definition for the viscous time scale in the outer disk during superoutburst , and taking into account the scaling for material accumulated during quiescence
, we derive a more physically motivated formula , and find that a steep dependence of the quiescent state value of @xmath12 is required , @xmath168 . in simple terms , the dramatic increase in stored quiescent mass with decreasing orbital period brings about a decrease in the viscous time scale of matter in the superoutburst disk , which is formed out of redistributed gas from the quiescent state .
recent work by patterson ( 2011 ) on the recurrence time scale in su uma stars for sos also supports a steep dependence of @xmath5 on @xmath34 .
the long outbursts in systems above the period gap and superoutbursts in systems below the gap both represent viscous decays , with the absence of transition waves in the disk .
it is somewhat counterintuitive that the recurrence time for these long , viscous outbursts varies as @xmath169 , and yet their decay time varies as @xmath170 .
the steepness of the @xmath171 relation explains why accretion disk modelers have had to adopt such small @xmath5 values for the su uma stars , compared to dne above the period gap , and also probably accounts for the fact that the extreme mass ratio black hole transient systems undergoing limit cycle accretion disk outbursts , like a0620 - 00 , have such long recurrence times for outbursts .
the _ kepler _ data have already provided important constraints on the physics of accretion disks , in particular the shakura - sunyaev @xmath12 parameter : c10 showed that an interpolation between @xmath5 and @xmath13 based on the degree of partial ionization of gas was needed to account for the shoulders in the sos of v344 lyr , and in this work we have shown that the scaling of so decay rate with orbital period mandates a steep dependence of @xmath5 on orbital period , enforcing the notion of tidal torquing as being the dominant viscosity mechanism in quiescent accretion disks .
bailey , j. 1975 , j. brit .
assoc . , 86 , 30 balbus , s. a. , & hawley , j. f. 1998 , rev mod phys , 70 , 1 bath , g. t. , & van paradijs , j. 1983 , nature , 305 , 33 campbell , l. , & shapley , h. 1940 , ann .
harvard , 90 , 93 cannizzo , j. k. 1993 , , 419 , 318 cannizzo , j. k. 1994 , , 435 , 389 cannizzo , j. k. 1998 , , 494 , 366 cannizzo , j. k. 2001a , , 556 , 847 cannizzo , j. k. 2001b , , 561 , l175 cannizzo , j. k. , gehrels , n. , & mattei , j. a. 2002 , , 579 , 760 cannizzo , j. k. , & mattei , j. a. 1992 , , 401 , 642 cannizzo , j. k. , & mattei , j. a. 1998 , , 505 , 344 cannizzo , j. k. , shafter , a. w. , & wheeler , j. c. 1988 , , 333 , 227 cannizzo , j. k. , still , m. d. , howell , s. b. , wood , m. a. , & smale , a. p. 2010
, , 725 , 1393 ( c10 ) cannizzo , j. k. , wheeler , j. c. , & polidan , r. s. 1986 , , 301 , 634 ( cwp ) eggleton , p. p. 1981
, , 268 , 368 fromang , s. , & papaloizou , j. 2007 , , 476 , 1113 goldreich , p. , & tremaine , s. 1980 , , 241 , 425 haas , m. r. , et al .
2010 , , 713 , l115 hessman , f. v. , gnsicke , b. t. , & mattei , j. a. 2000 , , 361 , 952 howell , s. b. , nelson , l. a. , & rappaport , s. 2001 , , 550 , 897 ichikawa , s. , hirose , m. , & osaki , y. 1993 , , 45 , 243 ichikawa , s. , & osaki , y. 1992 , , 44 , 15 ichikawa , s. , & osaki , y. 1994 , , 46 , 621 imada , a. , kato , t. , monard , l. a. g. b. , et al . 2008a , pasj , 60 , 267 king , a. r. , pringle , j. e. , & livio , m. 2007 , , 376 , 1740 koch , d. g. , borucki , w. j. , basri , g. , et al .
2010 , , 713 , l79 kolb , u. , king , a. r. , & ritter , h. 1998 , , 298 , l29 lasota , j .-
2001 , new astron .
, 45 , 449 mckinney , j. c. , & narayan , r. 2007a , , 375 , 513 mckinney , j. c. , & narayan , r. 2007b , , 375 , 531 menou , k. 2000 , science , 288 , 2022 meyer , f. , & meyer - hofmeister , e. 1999 , , 341 , l23 nogami , d. , uemura , m. , ishioka , r. , kato , t. , & pietz , j. 2004 , pasj , 56 , s155 osaki , y. 2005 , proc .
japan acad . ,
81 , 291 papaloizou , j. , & pringle , j. e. 1977 , , 181 , 441 patterson , j. 2011 , , 411 , 2695 pringle , j. e. 1981 , , 19 , 137 shakura , n. i. , & sunyaev , r. a. 1973 , , 24 , 337 ( ss ) simon , v. 2004 , baltic astron . , 13 , 101 smak , j. 1984 , acta astr . , 34 , 161 smak , j. 1993 , acta astr . , 43 , 101 smak , j. 2001 , acta astr . , 51 , 279 soejima , y. , et al .
2009 , pasj , 61 , 659 spogli , c. , fiorucci , m. , & raimondo , g. 2000 , ibvs , 4944 steeghs , d. , howell , s. b. , knigge , c. , et al .
2007 , , 667 , 442 sterne , t. e. , campbell , l. , & shapley , h. 1940 , ann .
harvard , 90 , 189 still , m. r. , howell , s. b. , wood , m. a. , cannizzo , j. k. , & smale , a. p. 2010
, , 717 , 113 szkody , p. , & mattei , j. a. 1984 , , 96 , 988 van paradijs , j. 1983 , , 125 , l16 warner , b. 1995a , astrophys .
, 226 , 187 warner , b. 1995b , cataclysmic variable stars ( cambridge : cambridge univ .
press ) wood , m. a. , still , m. d. , howell , s. b. , cannizzo , j. k. , & smale , a. p. 2011
, , 741 , 105 | we examine the _ kepler _ light curves of v1504 cyg and v344 lyr , encompassing @xmath0736 d at 1 min cadence . during this span
each system exhibited @xmath0@xmath1 outbursts , including six superoutbursts .
we find that , in both systems , the normal outbursts lying between two superoutbursts increase in duration over time by a factor @[email protected] , and then reset to a small value after the following superoutburst . in both systems
the trend of quiescent intervals between normal outbursts is to increase to a local maximum about half way through the supercycle @xmath2 the interval from one superoutburst to the next @xmath2 and then to decrease back to a small value by the time of the next superoutburst .
this is inconsistent with osaki s thermal - tidal model , which predicts a monotonic increase in the quiescent intervals between normal outbursts during a supercycle .
also , most of the normal outbursts have an asymmetric , fast - rise / slower - decline shape , which would be consistent with outbursts triggered at large radii . the exponential rate of decay of the plateau phase of the superoutbursts is 8 d mag@xmath3 for v1504 cyg and 12 d mag@xmath3 for v344 lyr .
this time scale gives a direct measure of the viscous time scale in the outer accretion disk given the expectation that the entire disk is in the hot , viscous state during superoutburst .
the resulting constraint on the shakura - sunyaev parameter , @xmath4 , is consistent with the value inferred from the fast dwarf nova decays . by looking at the slow decay rate for superoutbursts , which occur in systems below the period gap , in combination with the slow decay rate in one long outburst above the period gap ( in u gem ) , we infer a steep dependence of the decay rate on orbital period for long outbursts .
we argue that this relation implies a steep dependence of @xmath5 on orbital period , which may be consistent with recent findings of patterson , and is consistent with tidal torquing as being the dominant angular momentum transport mechanism in quiescent disks in interacting binary systems . |
it is well known that there is a remarkable connection between the statistical properties of certain random hermitian matrices , the zeros of the riemann zeta function , and fermionic gases @xcite .
underlying each of these objects are certain one - dimensional point processes ( defined more precisely in section 2 ) whose statistical properties ( under certain limits ) are believed to be identical .
the purpose of this paper is to provide generalizations of this unique point process to point processes in @xmath1-dimensional euclidean space @xmath2 for any @xmath1 , and to characterize their spatial statistics exactly .
since the characterization of a point process can be viewed as the study of a system of interacting point " particles , exact descriptions of nontrivial point processes in arbitrary space dimension , which are hard to come by @xcite , are of great value in the field of statistical mechanics .
there are three prominent theories of random hermitian matrices , which model the hamiltonians of certain random dynamical systems ; see the excellent book by mehta @xcite . if the dynamical system is symmetric under time reversal , then the relevant theory for integral spin is that of the gaussian orthogonal ensemble ( goe ) or the gaussian symplectic ensemble ( gse ) for half - integer spin . on the other hand , the gaussian unitary ensemble ( gue ) models random hamiltonians without time reversal symmetry , which is relevant to certain properties of the riemann zeta function .
although there are distinct one - dimensional point processes associated with each of these ensembles , our interest here will be in the gue because of its relationship to the riemann zeta function .
the gue of degree @xmath14 consists of the set of all @xmath15 hermitian matrices together with a haar measure .
this is the unique probability measure on the set of @xmath15 hermitian matrices that is invariant under conjugation by unitary matrices such that the individual matrix entries are independent random variables .
dyson @xcite showed that the eigenvalue distrubutions of the gue are closely related to those of the circular unitary ensemble " ( cue ) , which he exactly mapped into a problem of point particles on a unit circle interacting with a two - dimensional coulombic force law at a particular temperature .
this point process on the unit circle or , equivalently , on the real line @xmath0 in the large-@xmath14 limit ( when suitably normalized ) has a pair correlation function ( defined in section 2 ) in @xmath0 at number density @xmath16 given by @xmath17 equation also applies for the gue in the limit @xmath18 such that the mean gap distance between eigenvalues at the origin is normalized ; this limit has the effect of magnifying the bulk of the eigenvalue density on @xmath0 such that is well - defined .
we see that this point process is always _ negatively correlated _ , i.e. , @xmath7 never exceeds unity ( see fig .
[ zeta - zero ] ) and is repulsive " in the sense that @xmath19 as @xmath9 tends to zero . more generally , dyson @xcite proved that the @xmath3-particle correlation function ( defined in section 2 ) is given by the following determinant : @xmath20 montgomery @xcite conjectured that the pair correlation function of nontrivial zeros of the riemann zeta function ( which , according to the riemann hypothesis , lie along the critical line @xmath21 with @xmath22 ) is given exactly by the gue / cue function ( [ g2-zeros ] ) in the asymptotic limit ( high on the critical line ) when appropriately normalized .
this remarkable correspondence was further established by odlyzko @xcite , who numerically verified the riemann hypothesis for the first @xmath23 nontrivial zeros of the zeta function as well as at much larger heights and confirmed that the pair correlation function agrees with ( [ g2-zeros ] ) .
rudnick and sarnak @xcite proved that , under the riemann hypothesis , the nontrivial zeros have @xmath3-particle densities for any @xmath3 given by ( [ gn - zeros ] ) .
the reader is referred to the excellent review article by katz and sarnak @xcite , which discusses the connection between the zeros of zeta functions and classical symmetric groups , of which the three canonical random - matrix ensembles are but special cases . for spin - polarized free fermions in @xmath0 ( fermion gas ) at number density @xmath16 , it is known that the pair correlation function in the _ ground state _ ( i.e. , completely filling the fermi sphere " ) is given by @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the fermi radius , which is the one - dimensional analog of the well - known three - dimensional result @xcite .
therefore , we see that when @xmath26 , we obtain the gue / cue pair correlation function ( [ g2-zeros ] )
. the repulsive nature of the point process in this context arises physically from the pauli exclusion principle .
very little is known about how to generalize one - dimensional point processes associated with random matrices and number - theoretic functions to higher dimensions . in this paper , we analytically obtain exact generalizations of the aforementioned one - dimensional point process in @xmath1-dimensional euclidean space @xmath2 for any @xmath1 .
these processes are special cases of determinantal processes .
in particular , we obtain the @xmath3-particle correlation functions for any @xmath3 , which completely specify the point processes in @xmath2 .
we also show that spin - polarized fermionic systems in @xmath2 have these same @xmath3-particle correlation functions in each dimension .
we show that the point processes for any @xmath1 are hyperuniform , i.e. , infinite wavelength density fluctuations vanish , and the structure factor ( or power spectrum ) @xmath4 has a nonanalytic behavior at the origin given by @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) .
the latter result implies that the pair correlation function @xmath7 tends to unity for large pair distances with a decay rate that is controlled by the power law @xmath8 . in three dimensions ,
such a dominant power - law decay of @xmath7 is a well - known property of bosonic systems in their ground states @xcite and , more recently , has been shown to characterize maximally random jammed sphere packings @xcite .
realizations of the point processes are displayed in one and two dimensions , using a simulation technique described by us elsewhere @xcite , which vividly reveal their repulsive " nature .
in fact , we show the point processes can be characterized by an effective hard - core " diameter that grows like the square root of @xmath1 .
the nearest - neighbor distribution functions for these point processes are also studied by evaluating and rigorously bounding them . among other results
, this analysis reveals that the probability of finding a large spherical cavity of radius @xmath9 in dimension @xmath1 behaves like a poisson point process but in dimension @xmath10 , i.e. , this probability is given by @xmath11 $ ] for large @xmath9 , where @xmath12 is a positive @xmath1-dependent constant .
we also show that as @xmath1 increases , the point process behaves effectively like a sphere packing with a coverage fraction of space that is no denser than @xmath13 .
as we will see , this value of the coverage fraction has a special significance in the study of sphere packings in high dimensions . in section 2 ,
we present background and definitions concerning point processes that are particularly germane to the ensuing analysis .
section 3 discusses general determinantal point processes . in section 4 ,
we obtain the determinantal point processes in @xmath2 that are generalizations of the aforementioned one - dimensional point process associated with fermions , random matrices , and the riemann zeta function .
we call the most general of these point processes fermi - shells " point processes
. the asymptotic properties of various pair statistics are investigated .
we show that spin - polarized fermionic systems in @xmath2 have the same @xmath3-particle correlation functions in each dimension .
section 5 analyzes various nearest - neighbor functions for the special case of the fermi - sphere " point processes in @xmath2 .
we present concluding comments in section 6 , including remarks about possible connections of our point processes to random matrix and number theory .
a stochastic point process in @xmath2 is defined as a mapping from a probability space to configurations of points @xmath27 in @xmath1-dimensional euclidean space @xmath2 .
more precisely , let @xmath28 denote the set of configurations such that each configuration @xmath29 is a subset of @xmath2 that satisfies two regularity conditions : ( i ) there are no multiple points ( @xmath30 if @xmath31 ) and ( ii ) each bounded subset of @xmath2 must contain only a finite number of points of @xmath32 .
we denote by @xmath33 the number of points within @xmath34 , @xmath35 , where @xmath36 is the ring of bounded borel sets in @xmath2 .
thus , we always have @xmath37 for @xmath35 , but the possibility @xmath38 is not excluded .
we note that there exists a minimal @xmath39-algebra @xmath40 of subsets of @xmath28 that renders all of the functions @xmath33 measurable .
let @xmath41 be a probability space .
any measurable map @xmath42 is called a stochastic point process @xcite .
henceforth , we will simply call this map a point process . note that this random setting is quite general .
it incorporates cases in which the location of the points are deterministically known , such as a lattice .
a point process is completely statistically characterized by specifying the countably infinite set of @xmath3-particle probability density functions @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) @xcite .
the distribution - valued function @xmath43 has a probabilistic interpretation : apart from trivial constants , it is the probability density function associated with finding @xmath3 different points at positions @xmath45 and hence has the nonnegativity property @xmath46 the point process is statistically homogeneous or translationally invariant if for every constant vector @xmath47 in @xmath2 , @xmath48 , which implies that @xmath49 where @xmath50 is the _ number density _ ( number of points per unit volume in the infinite - volume limit ) and
@xmath51 is the _
@xmath3-particle correlation function _ , which depends on the relative positions @xmath52 , where @xmath53 and we have chosen the origin to be at @xmath54 .
we call @xmath55 the pair correlation function . for translationally invariant point processes without _
long - range order _
, @xmath56 when the points ( or particles " ) are mutually far from one another , i.e. , as @xmath57 ( @xmath58 ) , @xmath59 .
thus , the deviation of @xmath60 from unity provides a measure of the degree of spatial correlation between the particles with unity corresponding to no spatial correlation .
note that for a translationally invariant poisson point process , @xmath60 is unity for all values of its argument .
it is useful to introduce the total correlation function @xmath61 of a translationally invariant point process , which is related to the pair correlation function via @xmath62 and decays to zero for large @xmath63 in the absence of long - range order .
note that @xmath64 for all @xmath65 for a translationally invariant poisson point process .
an important nonnegative spectral function @xmath66 , called the structure factor ( or power spectrum ) , is defined as follows : @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the fourier transform of @xmath69 . for a translationally and rotationally invariant point process , it is useful to consider the cumulative coordination number @xmath70 , defined to be the expected number of points found in a sphere of radius @xmath9 centered at an arbitrary point of the point process , which is related to the pair correlation function as follows : @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the surface area of a @xmath1-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath9 .
it is clear that since @xmath7 is a nonnegative function , @xmath70 is a monotonically increasing function of @xmath9 .
the fourier transform of an @xmath73 function @xmath74 is defined by @xmath75 \rmd{{\bf r } } , \label{spec}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath73 denotes the space of absolutely integrable functions on @xmath2 .
if @xmath74 is a radial function , i.e. , @xmath76 depends only on the modulus @xmath77 of the vector @xmath65 , then its fourier transform is given by @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the modulus of the wave vector @xmath80 and @xmath81 is the bessel function of order @xmath82 .
the inverse transform of @xmath83 is given by @xmath84 we denote by @xmath85 the variance in the number of points @xmath86 contained within a window @xmath87 .
the number variance @xmath85 for a specific choice of @xmath88 is necessarily a positive number and is generally related to the total correlation function @xmath69 for a translationally invariant point process @xcite . in the special case of a spherical window of radius @xmath89 in @xmath2 , it is explicitly given by @xmath90 , \label{variance}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath91 is the number variance for a spherical window of radius @xmath89 in @xmath2 and @xmath92 is the volume common to two spherical windows of radius @xmath89 whose centers are separated by a distance @xmath9 divided by @xmath93 , the volume of a spherical window of radius @xmath89 , given explicitly by @xmath94 we will call @xmath92 the _ scaled intersection volume_. for large @xmath89 , it has been proved that @xmath91 can not grow more slowly than @xmath95 , where @xmath96 is a positive constant @xcite .
we note that point processes ( translationally invariant or not ) for which @xmath91 grows more slowly than the window volume ( i.e. , as @xmath97 ) for large @xmath89 are examples of _ hyperuniform _ ( or superhomogeneous ) point patterns @xcite .
this classification includes all periodic point processes @xcite , certain aperiodic point processes @xcite , one - component plasmas @xcite , point processes associated with a wide class of tilings of space @xcite , and certain disordered sphere packings @xcite .
hyperuniformity implies that the structure factor @xmath66 has the following small @xmath98 behavior : @xmath99 the scaled intersection volume @xmath92 appearing in ( [ variance ] ) and its associated fourier transform will play a prominent role in this paper .
the former quantity is defined by a convolution integral involving the indicator function @xmath100 for a @xmath1-dimensional spherical window " of radius @xmath89 centered at position @xmath101 @xcite , i.e. , @xmath102 where @xmath103 is the heaviside step function @xmath104 specifically , the scaled intersection volume is given by @xmath105 the scaled intersection volume has the support @xmath106 $ ] , the range @xmath107 $ ] , and the following alternative integral representation @xcite : @xmath108 } \sin^d(\theta ) \
, \rmd\theta , \label{alpha}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath109 is the @xmath1-dimensional constant given by @xmath110}. \label{c}\end{aligned}\ ] ] torquato and stillinger @xcite found the following series representation of the scaled intersection volume @xmath92 for @xmath111 and for any @xmath1 : @xmath112 } x^{2n-1 } , \label{series}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath113 .
for even dimensions , relation ( [ series ] ) is an infinite series , but for odd dimensions , the series truncates such that @xmath92 is a univariate polynomial of degree @xmath1 . in even dimensions ,
the scaled intersection volume involves transcendental functions ( e.g. , for @xmath114 , @xmath115 $ ] for @xmath116 ) .
figure [ intersection ] provides plots of @xmath92 as a function of @xmath9 for the first five space dimensions . for any dimension
, @xmath92 is a monotonically decreasing function of @xmath9 . at a fixed value of @xmath9 in the interval @xmath117
, @xmath92 is a monotonically decreasing function of the dimension @xmath1 .
the fourier transform of the scaled intersection volume function ( [ alpha ] ) , which is given by @xmath118 ^ 2}{v_1(r)},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath119 is the fourier transform of the window indicator function ( [ window2 ] ) .
therefore , the fourier transform of @xmath92 is the following nonnegative function of @xmath79 : @xmath120 it has been shown that finding the point process that minimizes the number variance @xmath91 is equivalent to finding the ground state of a certain repulsive pair potential with compact support @xcite .
this problem is directly related to an outstanding problem in number theory involving generalized zeta functions and lattices @xcite .
understanding such ground states can be facilitated by utilizing
duality " relations that link ground states in real space to those in fourier space @xcite .
we will be able to obtain the appropriate @xmath1-dimensional generalizations of point processes corresponding to the eigenvalues of the gue , the zeros of the riemann zeta function , or the one - dimensional fermionic gas by appealing to the notion of a determinantal point process in @xmath2 @xcite .
determinantal point processes were introduced by macchi @xcite , who originally called them fermion point processes .
soshnikov @xcite presented a review of this subject and discussed applications to random matrix theory , statistical mechanics , quantum mechanics , and representation theory .
it is also noteworthy that examples of determinantal point processes arise in self - avoiding random walks @xcite and uniform spanning trees @xcite . without loss of generality ,
the number density is set to unity ( @xmath16 ) in the ensuing discussion .
let @xmath121 be a translationally invariant hermitian - symmetric kernel of an integral operator @xmath122 .
a translationally invariant _ determinantal point process _ in @xmath2 exists if the the @xmath3-particle density functions for @xmath123 are given by the following determinants : @xmath124_{i , j=1,\ldots , n } , \label{rhon - det}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath125 . by virtue of the nonnegativity of the @xmath126 in the pointwise sense [ cf .
( [ positive ] ) ] and ( [ rhon - det ] ) , it follows that @xmath122 must have nonnegative minors and @xmath122 must be a nonnegative operator , which implies that @xmath127 is positive semidefinite .
the latter implies that the fourier transform @xmath128 of the kernel @xmath127 is nonnegative , and this property together with the condition @xmath129 implies that @xmath130 , i.e. , @xmath131 it follows that any positive semidefinite hermitian - symmetric kernel @xmath121 whose fourier transform satisfies the inequalities in ( [ f - k ] ) describes a determinantal point process with a pair correlation function given by @xmath132 such that @xmath133 and a @xmath3-particle density given by ( [ rhon - det ] ) .
we see that the total correlation function for a determinantal point process is given by @xmath134 the fact that the @xmath3-particle density functions can be written in terms of the determinant specified by ( [ rhon - det ] ) leads to bounds on @xmath126 . for example
, it trivially follows that @xmath135 a less obvious but stronger upper bound is as follows : @xmath136 we remark also that : @xmath137 each of these inequalities is a consequence of the determinantal form for @xmath126 and the characteristics of @xmath138 ; in particular , follows directly from fischer s inequality @xcite and an appropriate partition of the matrix representation for the operator @xmath139 .
equation is a result of the more general hadamard - fischer inequalities @xcite and the relation @xmath140 .
the positive semidefinite character of @xmath139 is essential for these inequalities to hold .
a unique property of determinantal point processes is that each of the @xmath3-particle correlation functions @xmath60 can be expressed completely in terms of the pair correlation function @xmath141 .
namely , at unit density we may write : @xmath142
^ 2\\ \rightarrow h(r ) = \pm\sqrt{1-g_2(r)}\label{hsqrt}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore : @xmath143_{1\leq i < j\leq n}\nonumber\\ & = \det\left[\pm\sqrt{1-g_2(r_{ij})}\right]_{1\leq i < j\leq n}\label{gng2}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the right side of is well - defined for all @xmath144 since @xmath145 .
we note that in general @xmath146 may be either positive or negative for a given value of @xmath9 as in ; therefore , the sign of the square root in must be chosen appropriately .
our ability to express each @xmath60 in terms of the pair correlation function @xmath141 is a reflection of the fact that the @xmath3-particle correlation functions depend on a common kernel @xmath138 ; such a reformulation is generally not possible for an arbitrary point process .
thus , one can infer the behavior of the @xmath3-particle correlation functions for @xmath147 solely from a knowledge of the behavior of @xmath141 .
a trivial example of a determinantal point process is the case in which @xmath148 and @xmath149 for @xmath150 .
the resulting pair correlation function is given by @xmath151 and @xmath152 , and this function belongs to the same equivalence class as the pair correlation function of the poisson point process with respect to lebesgue measure on the nonnegative reals @xmath153 ( i.e. , the functions differ only on a set of measure zero ) .
note that costin and lebowitz @xcite have considered the conditions under which a pair correlation function of the form @xmath154 is a determinantal point process in @xmath2 .
we note in passing that the number of points in a determinantal point process that falls in a compact set @xmath87 has the same distribution as a sum of independent bernoulli(@xmath155 ) random variables , where @xmath155 are the eigenvalues of the operator @xmath122 @xcite
. moreover , hough et al .
@xcite presented an algorithm to generate determinantal point process in @xmath2 , which we apply elsewhere @xcite .
here we obtain the appropriate generalization of ( [ g2-zeros ] ) that corresponds to a determinantal point process in @xmath2 .
first , we make the simple observation that the pair correlation function specified by ( [ g2-zeros ] ) is related to the fourier transform @xmath156 of the one - dimensional scaled intersection volume evaluated at @xmath157 and @xmath158 , namely , @xmath159 where @xmath156 is given by ( [ alpha - k ] ) for @xmath160
. a natural generalization of this pair correlation function in @xmath2 is to replace the one - dimensional fourier transform in ( [ g2-one ] ) with its @xmath1-dimensional counterpart ( [ alpha - k ] ) evaluated at @xmath157 and divided by @xmath161 , i.e. , @xmath162 however , the value of @xmath89 in each dimension must be chosen so that such a pair correlation function corresponds to a determinantal point process in that dimension .
in other words , if we take the positive semidefinite function @xmath127 to be given by the following radial function : @xmath163 @xmath89 must be determined so that the conditions ( [ f - k ] ) and ( [ conditions ] ) are satisfied . noting that the expansion of @xmath164 for small @xmath9 to leading order is given by @xmath165 [ cf .
( [ conditions ] ) ] yields that @xmath166^{1/d}. \label{r}\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we must show that a pair correlation function ( [ g2-d ] ) with @xmath167 satisfies the bounds of ( [ conditions ] ) and the bounds ( [ f - k ] ) on the spectral function @xmath168 .
the square of the function @xmath146 , specified by ( [ h ] ) , is clearly positive and achieves its maximum value of unity at the origin when @xmath167 and tends to zero in the limit @xmath169 , and hence the bounds of ( [ conditions ] ) are satisfied when @xmath167 . referring to relation ( [ window - fourier ] ) for the fourier transform of the window indicator function , we see that the fourier transform of ( [ h ] ) with @xmath167 is simply the indicator function @xmath170 which automatically satisfies ( [ f - k ] ) , where @xmath100 is specified by ( [ window2 ] ) and @xmath171 is given by ( [ r ] ) . in summary
, we have demonstrated that there is a determinantal point process in @xmath2 with @xmath3-particle densities given by ( [ rhon - det ] ) with the kernel @xmath172 where @xmath171 is given by ( [ r ] ) .
we will call such a determinantal point process a fermi - sphere " point process because @xmath168 corresponds to a spherical window indicator function in fourier space and , as we will see , corresponds to the ground state of a fermionic system in which the fermi sphere is completely filled ( see section 3 ) . in particular , the pair correlation function of such a point process @xcite is given by @xmath173 moreover , the corresponding structure factor , at unit number density , takes the form @xmath174 where @xmath175 is the scaled intersection volume of two @xmath1-dimensional spheres of radius @xmath171 separated by a distance @xmath79 , i.e. , the function @xmath92 , specified by ( [ series ] ) , with the replacements @xmath176 and @xmath177 .
relation ( [ s - d ] ) is easily obtained by taking the fourier transform of the total correlation function defined by ( [ h ] ) , where @xmath146 is given by ( [ h2 ] ) , and employing the definition ( [ factor ] ) for the structure factor .
it follows from the properties of @xmath175 in ( [ s - d ] ) that the structure factor @xmath4 obeys the following bounds for all @xmath79 : @xmath178 and achieves its maximum value of unity for @xmath179 .
the corresponding cumulative coordination number is given by @xmath180 note that the first term in ( [ z-2 ] ) is precisely the cumulative coordination number for a poisson point process in @xmath2 and that the second term is strictly negative for any @xmath181 , which is a reflection of the short - range repulsive nature of the point process .
we will show that for sufficiently large @xmath9 , the dominant contribution to @xmath70 will be the poissonian term @xmath182 .
we will see it is the cumulative coordination number @xmath70 , rather than the pair correlation function ( contrary to conventional wisdom ) , that enables one to identify and quantify an effective hard - core " diameter of the determinantal point processes .
it is instructive to examine the asymptotic behaviors of @xmath7 , @xmath4 , and @xmath70 for the fermi - sphere point process . by virtue of the asymptotic properties of the bessel function of arbitrary order ,
the small-@xmath9 and large-@xmath9 forms of the pair correlation function ( [ g2-d-2 ] ) are respectively given by @xmath183 and @xmath184 we see that @xmath7 tends to zero quadratically in @xmath9 in the limit @xmath185 , independent of the dimension .
the coefficient of the quadratic term in ( [ quad ] ) for positive @xmath1 attains it maximum value of @xmath186 for @xmath160 and monotonically decreases with increasing dimension , asymptoting to @xmath187 in the limit @xmath188 .
moreover , @xmath7 tends to unity for large pair distances with a decay rate that is controlled by the power law @xmath8 for any @xmath189 .
the latter result implies that the structure factor @xmath4 tends to zero linearly in @xmath79 in the limit @xmath190 . using ( [ series ] ) and ( [ s - d ] ) , it is easy to verify that as @xmath79 tends to zero at @xmath16 @xmath191 where @xmath109 is a @xmath1-dependent positive constant given by ( [ c ] ) .
we see that at unit density , the point process in @xmath2 for any @xmath1 is hyperuniform , and the structure factor @xmath4 has a nonanalytic behavior at the origin given by @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) .
the coefficient of the linear term in ( [ linear ] ) for positive @xmath1 attains it minimum value of @xmath192 for @xmath160 and monotonically increases with increasing dimension such that it asymptotes to @xmath193 in the limit @xmath188 . in three dimensions ,
this unusual linear nonanalytic behavior of the structure factor at @xmath194 is a well - known property of bosons in their grounds states @xcite and , more recently , has been shown to characterize maximally random jammed sphere packings @xcite . in fig .
[ fermions ] , we compare pair statistics in both real and fourier space for @xmath160 and @xmath195 at unit density . we see that the amplitudes of the oscillations in @xmath7 that are apparent for @xmath160 are significantly reduced in the corresponding three - dimensional pair correlation function
. the smallest value of @xmath9 for which @xmath7 attains its maximum value of unity , which we denote by @xmath196 , is determined by the first positive zero of @xmath197 , which for sufficiently large @xmath1 is given by @xmath198 since @xmath171 increases with increasing @xmath1 and grows like @xmath199 for large @xmath1 , @xmath196 grows like the square root of @xmath1 for large @xmath1 .
similarly , the smallest value of @xmath79 for which @xmath4 attains its maximum value of unity grows with increasing @xmath1 and for large @xmath1 grows like @xmath200 .
the results immediately above enable us to obtain the following small-@xmath9 and large-@xmath9 forms of the cumulative coordination number : @xmath201\qquad ( r \rightarrow 0 ) \label{z - small}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath202 it is straightforward to prove that the asymptotic result ( [ z - large ] ) is a rigorous lower bound on @xmath70 for all @xmath9 using the identity @xmath203 , the inequality @xmath204 for all positive @xmath9 , and relation ( [ z-2 ] ) .
indeed , since @xmath70 is always nonnegative , we have the lower bounds @xmath205 where the length scale @xmath206 is the zero of @xmath207
. the length scale @xmath208 can be regarded as an upper bound on the effective _ hard - core diameter _ , which clearly grows with increasing dimension as vividly illustrated in fig .
[ z - plot ] , which compares the exact form of @xmath70 with the lower bound ( [ z - bounds ] ) for @xmath195 and @xmath209 . for large @xmath1 ,
the effective hard - core diameter is given by the asymptotic expression @xmath210 \qquad ( d \rightarrow \infty ) , \label{d - asym}\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is seen to grow like the square root of @xmath1 .
this growth of the effective hard - core diameter with dimension is a conceptually important conclusion that runs counter to conventional understanding of corresponding fermionic systems , which identifies the inverse fermi " radius , i.e. , @xmath211 $ ] ( a decreasing function of @xmath1 ) with an effective hard - core diameter .
we elaborate on this point in section 3 .
the hyperuniformity of the point process implies that the number variance @xmath91 for a spherical window of radius @xmath89 must grow slower than @xmath212 ( i.e. , the window volume ) for large @xmath89 .
however , the fact that the large-@xmath9 behavior of the pair correlation function is controlled by the power law @xmath8 means that @xmath91 must also grow faster than the surface area of the window or @xmath213 .
in particular , upon substitution of ( [ g2-d-2 ] ) into ( [ variance ] ) , an asymptotic analysis reveals that for large @xmath89 @xmath214\gamma(1+d/2)^{1/d } } \ln(r)+ c(d ) \big\}r^{d-1}\nonumber\\ + { \cal o}(r^{d-2 } ) \qquad ( r \rightarrow \infty ) , \label{fermion - var}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath215 is a @xmath1-dimensional constant of order unity .
we remark that a similar asymptotic scaling is expected to hold even when the observation window is non - spherical ; a discussion of this point has been provided in @xcite .
we see that the number variance scaled by the window surface area , @xmath216 , grows like @xmath217 , independent of the dimension .
this unusual number variance growth law in three dimensions has also been recently seen in maximally random jammed sphere packings @xcite , which can be viewed as prototypical glasses because they are simultaneously perfectly rigid mechanically and maximally disordered .
note that the coefficient multiplying @xmath217 in ( [ fermion - var ] ) decays to zero exponentially fast as @xmath218 , and , therefore , the surface - area term @xmath213 increasingly becomes the dominant one in the large-@xmath1 limit .
this behavior should be contrasted with number variance for a poisson point process , which grows like the window volume , i.e. , @xmath97 .
figure [ points ] graphically depicts the fermi - sphere point processes in one and two dimensions , which are generated using the algorithm of hough et .
details and applications of this algorithm are reported by us elsewhere @xcite . here
we consider a generalization of the fermi - sphere point process in which @xmath219 is an indicator function for concentric rings in reciprocal space ; we denote the resulting determinantal process as the `` fermi - shells '' point process . without loss of generality , define @xmath220 radii @xmath221 , where @xmath222 and @xmath223 , such that the region of @xmath1-dimensional space within the ball @xmath224 is empty , the annulus between @xmath225 and @xmath226 is filled , and so forth .
we therefore have @xmath227 filled concentric rings in reciprocal space . since the conditions for a determinantal point process are fulfilled for any indicator function in reciprocal space @xcite , the pair correlation function will still be given by .
the calculation of @xmath146 proceeds as follows : @xmath228\label{apone},\end{aligned}\ ] ] which implies : @xmath229\label{aptwo},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath230 denotes the fourier transform to coordinate space .
it is important to note that the values of the various @xmath221 are not independent of each other and are constrained by the density ( here set to unity ) according to : @xmath231 = ( 2\sqrt{\pi})^d \gamma(1+d/2).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the filling of fermi shells generally introduces a greater level of short - range correlations relative to the fermi - sphere case ( see fig .
[ donut ] ) . note that we do not know of any correspondence of the general fermi - shells point process in @xmath2 for any @xmath232 to random matrix theory or the zeros of any generalized zeta function in number theory .
however , we can show that a spin - polarized fermionic gas in @xmath2 for any @xmath233 has the same @xmath3-particle densities . for simplicity
, this comparison will be done for the fermi - sphere case , i.e. , we will demonstrate that the @xmath126 are given by ( [ rhon - det ] ) with @xmath146 given by ( [ h2 ] ) provided that the fermi radius @xmath234 .
we first recall some general properties of the @xmath3-particle density functions @xmath126 for a ground - state noninteracting gas of fermions in @xmath235 .
assume that we have @xmath14 spin - polarized fermions in a volume @xmath236 with number density @xmath237 .
the @xmath3-particle density functions are defined for all @xmath238 with respect to the ground state @xmath239 by : @xmath240|\phi_0\rangle,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the operators @xmath241 are the creation and annihilation field operators , respectively . using the momentum representation , the field operators are defined in terms of the particle creation and annihilation operators @xmath242 : @xmath243\\ \overline{\phi_{\mathbf{k}}(\mathbf{x } ) } = \left(\frac{1}{v}\right)^{1/2 } \exp\left[-\rmi(\mathbf{k } , \mathbf{x})\right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath244 is the euclidean inner product of two real - valued vectors .
the field operators for fermions must satisfy the following anticommutation relation : @xmath245 wick s theorem along with the anticommutation relation immediately allow us to write the expectation value in as a determinant ( equivalently , see macchi s discussion of fermion processes @xcite ) : @xmath246_{1\leq i , j \leq n}\label{eight},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath247 denotes the permutation group for @xmath3 objects .
namely , wick s theorem relates the @xmath3-particle density functions to the @xmath248 ways of pairing the @xmath249 creation and annihilation field operators ; anticommutation of the operators introduces the factor of @xmath250 in . for the ground - state system , the argument of the determinant in
may be evaluated by filling the fermi sphere up to the fermi radius @xmath25 with the result : @xmath251 since @xmath252 is a translationally - invariant function , we will abuse notation slightly and write @xmath253 making the parameterization by @xmath25 explicit .
in accordance with our established convention and without loss of generality , let @xmath254 . for a system of @xmath14 spin - polarized fermions ,
the fermi radius @xmath25 is given exactly by : @xmath255\right\}^{1/d } = k.\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , we may equivalently write for : @xmath256 } r^{-d/2 } j_{d/2}(rk ) = h(r).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the result in shows that our proposed fermi - sphere point process corresponds _ exactly _ to the one generated by a system of noninteracting fermions in @xmath1 dimensions .
the connection for @xmath257 between this system of noninteracting fermions and the cue of random matrix theory implies that the correlations in the ground state resulting from the pauli exclusion principle are equivalent to those induced on a @xmath258 coulomb gas constrained to the unit ring and interacting via a logarithmic pair potential at finite temperature @xmath259 in units such that boltzmann s constant @xmath260 . the argument in appendix
a shows that this reduction of the probability density to a classical particle system with at most two - body interactions is peculiar to the choice of the indicator function in reciprocal space ; in general , one must include at least three - body interactions to describe the system appropriately .
we also mention the significance of in defining an effective hard core on the system of noninteracting fermions in each dimension .
this issue is equivalent to assigning an appropriate length scale for the widely - studied ( see , e.g. , @xcite ) fermi correlation hole .
an argument primarily due to slater @xcite suggests that the correlations which result from antisymmetry in the many - body wavefunction extend outward for a distance @xmath261 . the reasoning behind this choice of length scale relies on the introduction of an exchange hole into the system with approximate spherical symmetry and a radius determined by the de broglie wavelength associated with the fermi radius @xmath25 .
this notion has been quantified for interacting atomic systems by considering , for example , the difference of distribution functions derived from hartree - fock and hartree wavefunctions @xcite , but the @xmath262 scaling for the noninteracting case is still reported in modern texts @xcite .
however , we recall from that as @xmath1 increases , the value of the fermi radius also increases ; in fact , @xmath263 for sufficiently large @xmath1 .
this behavior implies that @xmath264 as @xmath265 , meaning that the effective hard core diameter would become negligibly small for sufficiently large @xmath1 if it were to scale as @xmath262 .
this conclusion contradicts the fact that @xmath19 pointwise as @xmath265 for all @xmath266 . in other words , the range in @xmath9
over which one finds a small probability of finding two particles in close proximity increases with dimension , requiring a different means by which to quantify the extent of the effective hard core .
the definition of @xmath70 in suggests instead that we take the value of @xmath208 in as a measure of the effective hard core diameter .
we note that since @xmath70 is a nonnegative monotonically increasing function of @xmath9 and , therefore , nonzero for some range in @xmath9 over which its lower bound is zero , @xmath208 must represent an upper bound to the effective hard core radius .
this representation of the effective hard - core diameter is quantitatively well - defined for any dimension due to the inclusion of the @xmath267 factor under the integral in from the surface area of the @xmath1-dimensional ball ; it is this factor which appropriately rescales @xmath141 such that represents a true lower bound on @xmath70 in any dimension by the argument above .
it is also for this reason that neither @xmath7 nor @xmath4 alone are sufficient to define the effective hard - core diameter in a quantitative manner .
in contrast to slater s scaling of the effective hard core diameter , @xmath268 in any dimension by the definition of the fermi radius , which is in accordance with the high - dimensional behavior of both @xmath141 and @xmath25 .
it is useful to characterize point processes by examining other quantities besides the @xmath3-particle correlation functions .
one popular descriptor used in one dimension is the so - called gap " distribution function @xmath269 @xcite , which characterizes the spacing between the points . in the random matrix theory literature
, this quantity often has erroneously and misleadingly been called the nearest - neighbor - spacing " distribution because gaps to the right of some reference point are considered .
however , @xmath269 makes no distinction between gaps to the left or right of some reference point .
the quantity @xmath270 gives the probability of finding a gap ( a line interval empty of points ) of length between @xmath271 and @xmath272 .
the function @xmath269 is called the _ chord length probability density _ in the theory of random media @xcite . in the case of random matrix theory ,
there exist exact representations of @xmath269 for the spacings of the eigenvalues in the goe , gue , and gse , but they can only be determined numerically for general situations .
a remarkably accurate approximation for the goe in the infinitely - large matrix limit is the so - called wigner surmise .
the wigner surmise has been generalized to any of the aforementioned ensembles as follows : @xmath273 where the parameters @xmath274 and @xmath275 , which depend on reciprocal temperature @xmath276 , are obtained from the normalization of both @xmath269 and its first moment , or the average gap size @xmath277 . for the goe , gue , and gse , @xmath278 , and 4 , respectively , and @xmath279 , @xmath280 , @xmath281 , @xmath282 , and @xmath283 , @xmath284 . for @xmath232 ,
the gap distribution function is strictly not a meaningful descriptor of point processes .
the natural generalizations of @xmath269 in higher dimensions are the nearest - neighbor functions @xcite .
nearest - neighbor functions describe the probability of finding the _ nearest point _ of a point process in @xmath2 at some given distance from a _ reference point _ in the space .
such statistical quantities are called void " or particle " nearest - neighbor functions if the the reference point is an arbitrary point of the space or an actual point of the point process , respectively . first , we recall the definitions of the void and particle nearest - neighbor probability density functions @xmath285 and @xmath286 , respectively : @xmath287 @xmath288 it is useful to introduce the associated dimensionless exclusion " probabilities @xmath289 and @xmath290 defined as follows : @xmath291 @xmath292 it follows that the exclusion probabilities are _ complementary cumulative distribution functions _ associated with the density functions and thus are related to the latter via @xmath293 and @xmath294 differentiating the exclusion - probability relations with respect to @xmath9 gives @xmath295 and @xmath296 the @xmath3th moment of @xmath297 is defined as @xmath298 of particular interest to us is the _
mean nearest - neighbor distance _
it is useful to express the density functions @xmath300 and @xmath297 as a product of two functions as follows : @xmath301 and @xmath302 where @xmath303 is the surface area of a @xmath1-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath9 given by ( [ area - sph ] ) .
the quantities @xmath304 and @xmath305 are called the conditional " nearest - neighbor functions and have the following interpretation : @xmath306 @xmath307 thus , it follows that the exclusion probabilities are also given by @xmath308 \label{ev - gv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath309 .
\label{ep - gp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we remark that knowledge of any one function @xmath138 , @xmath310 , or @xmath252 ( either void or particle ) is sufficient to determine the other two functions via the relations mentioned above . the nearest - neighbor functions can be expressed as infinite series whose terms are integrals over the @xmath3-particle density functions @xcite .
for example , the void and particle exclusion probability functions for a translationally invariant point process are respectively given by @xmath311 and @xmath312 the corresponding series for @xmath300 and @xmath297 are obtained from the series above using ( [ derv - ev ] ) and ( [ derv - ep ] ) .
in general , an exact evaluation of the aforementioned infinite series are not possible , except for simple processes such as the poisson point process . in the latter instance , because @xmath313 , both series ( [ ev - series ] ) and ( [ ep - series ] ) can be summed exactly to give @xmath314 , \label{e - poisson}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath315 is the volume of a @xmath1-dimensional sphere of radius @xmath9 given by ( [ v1 ] ) .
therefore , for a poisson point process , we have from ( [ derv - ev ] ) , ( [ derv - ep ] ) , ( [ def - hv2 ] ) , and ( [ def - hp2 ] ) that @xmath316 , \qquad g_v(r)=g_p(r)=1.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we see that there is no distinction between the void and particle quantities for the poisson distribution , which is generally not the case for correlated point processes . torquato has given rigorous upper and lower bounds on the so - called _ canonical @xmath3-point correlation function _
@xmath317 ( with @xmath318 and @xmath319 ) for point processes in @xmath2 .
since the void and particle exclusion probabilities and nearest - neighbor probability density functions are just special cases of @xmath320 , then we also have strict bounds on them for such models .
let @xmath28 represent either @xmath321 , or @xmath322 and @xmath323 represent the @xmath79th term of the series for these functions .
furthermore , let @xmath324 be the partial sum .
then it follows that for any of the exclusion probabilities or nearest - neighbor probability density functions , we have the bounds @xmath325 application of the aforementioned inequalities yield the first three successive bounds on the nonnegative void exclusion probability : @xmath326 where @xmath327 is the intersection volume of two @xmath1-dimensional spheres ( cf . ) .
the corresponding first two nontrivial bounds on the nonnegative nearest - neighbor probability density function @xmath300 are as follows : @xmath328 where @xmath329 is the surface area of the intersection volume @xmath330 .
bounds on the conditional function @xmath304 follow by combining the bounds above on @xmath331 and @xmath300 and definition ( [ def - hv2 ] ) .
for example , we obtain the following bounds @xmath332 and @xmath333 which should only be applied for @xmath9 such that @xmath304 remains positive .
the bounds above lead to the following properties of the nearest - neighbor functions at the origin : @xmath334 similarly , the first three successive bounds on the particle exclusion probability are given by @xmath335 where @xmath70 is the cumulative coordination number defined by ( [ z ] ) .
the corresponding first two nontrivial bounds on the nonnegative nearest - neighbor probability density function @xmath297 are as follows : @xmath336 where @xmath337 is the radial dirac delta function .
bounds on the conditional function @xmath305 follow by combining the bounds on @xmath338 and @xmath297 and definition ( [ def - hp2 ] ) .
for example , we obtain the following bounds : @xmath339 and @xmath340 which should only be applied for @xmath9 such that @xmath305 remains positive .
the bounds above lead to the following properties of the nearest - neighbor functions at the origin : @xmath341 we now obtain bounds on the mean nearest - neighbor distance @xmath342 at unit density using the aforementioned upper and lower bounds on @xmath338 .
let us define the following distances : @xmath343 \rmd r \label{l1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath344 \rmd r , \label{l2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath196 is the location of the zero of @xmath345 . in light of the bounds ( [ ep - bound1 ] ) and ( [ ep - gp - bound ] ) , it is clear that @xmath346 and @xmath347 bound @xmath342 from below and above , respectively , i.e. , @xmath348 the fermi - sphere point process is unique in that both the particle and void exclusion probabilities may be expressed as determinants over @xmath15 matrices , the elements of which are related to overlap integrals of the basis functions @xmath349 $ ] on @xmath350 , a @xmath1-dimensional ball of radius @xmath9 centered at the origin ( the exact location of the ball s center is irrelevant since the point process is translationally invariant ) .
the thermodynamic limit can then be taken appropriately .
we provide the details of this analysis elsewhere @xcite and immediately state the results : @xmath351\label{det1}\\ e_p(r ) = e_v(r)\tr\{a[\mathbb{i}-m(r)]^{-1}\}\label{det2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath352 is the @xmath15 identity matrix , and the matrices @xmath353 and @xmath88 are defined by : @xmath354 where @xmath50 is the number density .
we recall that knowledge of @xmath331 and @xmath338 is sufficient to determine all of the remaining nearest - neighbor functions @xmath355 and @xmath356 .
note that as @xmath357 , @xmath358 for all @xmath359 and @xmath360 , which provides the necessary results @xmath361 and @xmath362 we mention that these determinants must be evaluated numerically but essentially exactly for finite @xmath15 matrices , where @xmath14 is chosen to be sufficiently large to capture accurately the behavior of the system in the thermodynamic limit .
evidence for this convergence is provided in another paper @xcite .
we now obtain bounds for nearest - neighbor functions for the fermi - sphere point process and compare them to the corresponding aforementioned exact results . using the identity @xmath363 ^ 2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] the leading order term of the small-@xmath9 expansion ( [ quad ] ) , and the upper bound ( [ ev - bound2 ] ) , we obtain the weaker upper bound @xmath364
^ 2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] which is exact through terms of order @xmath365 .
therefore , we also have @xmath366 ^ 2 + { \cal o}(r^{2d+3 } ) \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath367 we see that through order @xmath368 , @xmath369 .
this bound will be shown to apply for any @xmath9 . employing the inequality @xmath370 [ cf .
( [ rhon - ineq ] ) ] in the upper bound ( [ ep - bound2 ] ) on @xmath331 and lower bound ( [ hp - bound2 ] ) on @xmath297 , we find the following corresponding weaker bounds : @xmath371 and @xmath372 these bounds in conjunction with the analogous evaluations of the bounds ( [ gp - bound1 ] ) and ( [ gp - bound2 ] ) on the conditional pair function @xmath305 yields its exact small-@xmath9 behavior up through terms of order @xmath373 : @xmath374 comparing this expansion to ( [ quad ] ) reveals that @xmath375 up through terms of order @xmath373 .
we can also show that @xmath376 and @xmath377 these results are obtained from definitions ( [ ev - gv ] ) and ( [ ep - gp ] ) and the following upper bounds on the exclusion probabilities : @xmath378 \qquad \mbox{for all } \quad r \label{ev - gv - bound}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath379 \qquad \mbox{for all } \quad r. \label{ep - gp - bound}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to prove and , we recall the series representations of @xmath380 and @xmath381 in and , respectively , which we may rewrite in the following more compact form : @xmath382 it is important to note that the series in converge absolutely for all @xmath144 , which is easily seen from the inequalities @xmath383^k}{k!}\label{evkineq}\\ e_p^{(k ) } \leq \frac{\rho^k}{k ! } \int_{\mathbb{r}^d } \prod_{j=2}^{k+1 } g_2(r_{1j})\theta(r - r_{1j } ) \rmd\mathbf{r}_j = \frac{[z(r)]^k}{k ! } \label{epkineq}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] equations and follow directly from the inequalities in and , respectively .
it is therefore true that @xmath384 as @xmath385 .
we now wish to compare the series in with the following series representations of the proposed upper limits in and : @xmath386^k}{k!}\label{evulseries}\\ e_p^{(ul)}(r ) = 1-z(r)+\sum_{k=2}^{+\infty } \frac{[-z(r)]^k}{k!}\label{epulseries}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the series in , , and agree up to their second terms ; the alternating series test then implies that the contributions from the remaining terms is no greater than the magnitude of the third terms in the series .
equations and therefore show that the series in and in actuality do bound the series in from above , thereby proving the claims
. the lower bounds in and immediately follow from monotonicity and positivity of the exponential function along with and .
the left panel of fig .
[ ev - ep-4d ] compares the upper bound ( [ ev - gv - bound ] ) and lower bound ( [ ev - bound1 ] ) of @xmath380 for a fermi - sphere point process for @xmath387 to the corresponding exact evaluation .
the right panel of the same figure compares the upper and lower bounds on @xmath338 for @xmath387 as obtained from ( [ ep - bound1 ] ) and ( [ ep - gp - bound ] ) , respectively , to the corresponding exact evaluation of it .
the upper bounds on both exclusion probabilities provide reasonable estimates of the exact results as compared to the corresponding lower bounds .
figure [ gp-4d ] compares upper and lower bounds on @xmath305 for @xmath387 as obtained from ( [ ep - bound1 ] ) and ( [ ep - gp - bound ] ) , respectively , to the corresponding exact evaluation of it .
not surprisingly , the bounds become better estimators as the dimension increases and therefore can be profitably used in high dimensions , where exact evaluations are difficult to obtain .
the left panel of fig .
[ ev - ep-17d ] shows the upper bound ( [ ev - gv - bound ] ) and lower bound ( [ ev - bound1 ] ) for a fermi - sphere point process for @xmath209 . it is seen that the bounds essentially converge to unity for the range @xmath388 and are relatively close to one another for @xmath389 .
the right panel of fig .
[ ev - ep-17d ] depicts the analogous bounds on @xmath338 for @xmath209 .
note that the bounds on @xmath331 behave almost exactly like the bounds on @xmath338 at this value of @xmath1 .
this graphically suggests that as @xmath1 becomes large , the exact expressions for @xmath331 and @xmath338 approach the same step function , which we demonstrate below .
we now show that both @xmath381 and @xmath380 tend to the same step function @xmath390 in the large-@xmath1 limit , where @xmath208 is the estimate of the effective hard - core diameter defined by ( [ fermihole ] ) .
we begin by utilizing the following upper bound on @xmath338 : @xmath391 , \quad r\ge d. \end{array}\right .
\label{ep - bound3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this upper bound is obtained by combining lower bound ( [ z - bounds ] ) on the cumulative coordination number @xmath70 and upper bound ( [ ep - gp - bound ] ) , and hence is a weaker upper bound on @xmath338 than ( [ ep - gp - bound ] ) . as @xmath1 tends to infinity , we see that the upper bound ( [ ep - bound3 ] ) tends to the step function @xmath390 , i.e. , @xmath392 now we show that @xmath381 is bounded from below by the same step function in this limit , i.e. , @xmath393 to prove this , we note that the the lower bound ( [ ep - bound1 ] ) on @xmath338 tends to a unit step function as @xmath1 becomes large [ cf .
[ ev - ep-17d ] ] whose discontinuity location can not exceed the zero of @xmath345 , @xmath394 , which can be estimated to be given by @xmath395^{1/(d+2)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this estimate , which bounds the zero from below and becomes increasingly accurate as @xmath1 tends to infinity , is obtained by substituting the leading term of the asymptotic expansion ( [ z - small ] ) into @xmath396 and solving for @xmath394 . for large @xmath1 , @xmath394 has the asymptotic expansion @xmath397 \qquad ( d \rightarrow \infty ) , \label{d0-asym}\end{aligned}\ ] ] comparison of this expansion to that of the corresponding one for @xmath208 [ cf .
( [ d - asym ] ) ] reveals that @xmath208 bounds @xmath394 from above for sufficiently large @xmath1 and @xmath398 in the limit @xmath218 .
thus , the lower bound on @xmath338 in this limit is given by ( [ ep - lower ] ) .
combination of this lower bound with upper bound ( [ ep - upper ] ) leads to the following high - dimensional behavior : @xmath399 where we recall that @xmath208 grows like @xmath200 for large @xmath1 [ cf .
( [ d - asym ] ) ] . following the analogous analysis using the lower bound ( [ ev - bound1 ] ) and upper bound ( [ ev - gv - bound ] ) on @xmath331
, we can show @xmath400 it is noteworthy that this analysis means that the lower bound ( [ z - bounds ] ) on the cumulative coordination number @xmath70 becomes exact in the limit @xmath218 .
this in turn implies an effective " pair correlation function @xmath401 that tends to the following step function as @xmath1 tends to infinity : @xmath402 this effective pair correlation function @xmath403 is to be distinguished from the true pair correlation function ( [ g2-d ] ) , which tends to unity for distances beyond the length scale @xmath208 , but remains a quadratic function of @xmath9 for small @xmath9 .
because the effective pair correlation function is based on the behavior of @xmath70 , which weights the true @xmath7 by @xmath404 ( due to the appearance of @xmath303 , the surface area of a sphere of radius @xmath9 ) , @xmath403 tends to a step function in the high - dimensional limit .
the fact that the oscillations of @xmath7 seen in low dimensions ( cf .
[ fermions ] ) effectively vanish in the large-@xmath1 limit is consistent with the decorrelation principle @xcite , which , roughly speaking , states that unconstrained correlations that exist in low dimensions vanish as @xmath1 tends to infinity , and all higher - order correlation functions @xmath60 for @xmath147 may be expressed in terms of @xmath141 within some small error .
we have already shown in that the latter claim is true for _ any _ determinantal point process . the former claim is seen from the form of @xmath405 in , which immediately suggests that asymptotic unconstrained correlations in the fermi sphere point process diminish with respect to increasing dimension @xmath1 . in other words , @xmath141 flattens at unity for sufficiently large @xmath9 as @xmath1 becomes large , which implies that long - range correlations between any two particles in the system diminish with respect to increasing dimension , leaving only the small-@xmath9 correlations , which extend outward for a greater range in @xmath9 as @xmath1 increases .
this conclusion in conjunction with implies that for sufficiently large @xmath1 and for large particle separations , @xmath406 where @xmath352 is the @xmath407 identity matrix .
therefore , all @xmath3-particle correlations also diminish for large particle separations and large @xmath1 in accordance with a decorrelation of the system .
we remark that the fact that @xmath19 as @xmath357 does not affect the statement of the decorrelation principle for the fermi sphere point process ; borrowing the language of quantum mechanics , these correlations arise from the constraint of antisymmetry in the many - particle wavefunction and therefore must be enforced in any dimension . for sufficiently large @xmath1
this analysis implies that the system reduces to a sphere packing with an effective hard - core diameter equal to @xmath208 .
the connection to sphere packings implies that the fraction of space @xmath408 covered by the spheres at unit number density is bounded from above by the following inequality @xmath409 interestingly , minkowski proved a lower bound on the coverage fraction of the densest lattice sphere packings that asymptotically is controlled by @xmath13 @xcite .
we remark on the significance of this result in section 6 .
we now obtain analytical estimates of the mean nearest - neighbor distance @xmath342 at unit density using the general upper and lower bounds on @xmath342 [ cf .
( [ l1 ] ) and ( [ l2 ] ) ] .
consider the arithmetic average of ( [ l1 ] ) and ( [ l2 ] ) : @xmath410 for low dimensions , the arithmetic average of the upper and lower bounds for the fermi - sphere point process provide reasonable estimates of @xmath342 , as seen in table [ mean - table ] for the first four space dimensions , which also includes the corresponding exact results .
we see that the estimate @xmath411 captures the nonmonotone dependence of the mean nearest - neighbor distance with dimension .
moreover , the table shows that the upper bound becomes the dominant contribution to @xmath412 as @xmath1 increases and @xmath411 becomes increasingly accurate as the space dimensions increases .
c c c c c c @xmath1 & upper bound&lower bound & average of bounds & exact & @xmath208 + 1 & 0.917808 & 0.658199 & 0.788003 & 0.725728 & 0.5 + 2 & 0.688071 & 0.581193 & 0.634632 & 0.649823 & 0.564190 + 3 & 0.670304 & 0.593975 & 0.632139 & 0.654511 & 0.620350 + 4 & 0.687631 & 0.625009 & 0.656320 & 0.679561 & 0.670938 + [ mean - table ] note use of the upper bound ( [ ep - bound3 ] ) enables us to obtain the following weaker but analytically solvable upper bound on @xmath342 : @xmath413 \rmd r \nonumber\\ & = d\left [ 1+\frac{\gamma(1/d,1 ) e}{d}\right ] , \label{lambda - bound}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath414 is the incomplete gamma function . for large @xmath1
, we have the asymptotic expression @xmath415 \nonumber \\ & = d\left[1 + \frac{0.5963473622\ldots}{d } + { \cal o}\left(\frac{1}{d^2}\right)\right ] \qquad ( d \rightarrow \infty).\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , using the lower bound @xmath416 \rmd r \label{lambda - bound2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath394 is the zero of @xmath396 , and the aforementioned asymptotic analysis of the lower bound on @xmath338 , yields @xmath417 in summary , combination of the bounds ( [ lambda - bound ] ) and ( [ lambda - bound2 ] ) and the asymptotic expression ( [ d0-asym ] ) , enables us to conclude that the mean nearest - neighbor distance approaches the length scale @xmath208 as @xmath1 becomes large , i.e. , @xmath418 which asymptotically grows like the square root of @xmath1 according to ( [ d - asym ] ) and , as we concluded above , specifies the location of the step - function discontinuity of @xmath338 , @xmath331 and @xmath419 in the large-@xmath1 limit .
table [ mean - table ] shows that the length scale @xmath208 is already an accurate estimate of the mean nearest - neighbor distance for @xmath387 .
it is noteworthy that the asymptotic mean nearest - neighbor - distance formula ( [ lambda - asym ] ) is precisely the same as the asymptotic form of the mean nearest - neighbor distance of a poisson point process .
the latter for any dimension at unit density is given by @xmath420 @xcite , which in the high - dimensional limit is exactly equal to @xmath208 .
the fact that the mean nearest - neighbor distance for the fermi - sphere point process behaves like that of a poisson point process in the high - dimensional limit is not surprising in light of the decorrelation principle @xcite .
note that the expression for the mean nearest - neighbor distance @xmath421 for any density @xmath50 can be related to the corresponding quantity @xmath422 at unit density by the simple scaling relation @xmath423 figure [ mean ] shows the mean nearest - neighbor distance as a function of density for various dimensions ; the cases @xmath160 and @xmath387 are exact evaluations and the instance @xmath209 is obtained from the upper bound prediction ( [ lambda - bound ] ) and the scaling relation ( [ scaling ] ) , which is expected to be a highly accurate estimate .
we conclude this section by making some remarks about the conditional nearest - neighbor functions @xmath304 and @xmath305 .
the fact that the exclusion probabilities @xmath331 and @xmath338 tend to the same step function in the high - dimensional limit implies that @xmath304 and @xmath305 have the same large-@xmath9 behavior as @xmath1 tends to infinity . in fact , our exact evaluations of @xmath304 and @xmath305 for a finite range of @xmath9 in low dimensions indicate that each function becomes linear in @xmath9 for large @xmath9 and the ratio @xmath424 tends to unity .
figure [ gv - gp-1d-4d ] shows our evaluations of both @xmath304 and @xmath305 for the first four space dimensions for the range @xmath425 ( see our companion paper @xcite for further numerical details ) . in one dimension , one can show that the nearest - neighbor void functions are directly related to a radial function that is a solution to a second - order nonlinear differential equation @xcite .
this differential equation can be evaluated exactly for small and large @xmath9 . in particular , using this asymptotic analysis leads to the following large-@xmath9 behavior for @xmath304 for the one - dimensional fermi - sphere point process : @xmath426 the coefficient @xmath427 can be compared to the corresponding wigner surmise prediction of @xmath428 , which is obtained via the one - dimensional relation that exactly links @xmath331 to the gap distribution function @xmath269 @xcite , @xmath429 and eq .
( [ wigner ] ) with @xmath430 . presumably , @xmath305 has the same asymptotic behavior for @xmath160 , a conclusion supported by our numerical results @xcite .
interestingly , for both conditional probability functions to have the same linear behavior for large @xmath9 implies that the corresponding exclusion probability functions have the following large-@xmath9 behavior for finite @xmath1 : @xmath431 \qquad ( r \rightarrow \infty ) , \label{ev - poisson}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath12 is a positive @xmath1-dependent constant .
thus , this analysis reveals that the probability of finding a large spherical cavity of radius @xmath9 for a fermi - sphere point process in dimension @xmath1 behaves similar to that of a poisson point process but in dimension @xmath10 . for a poisson point process , the constant @xmath432 $ ] , [ cf .
( [ e - poisson ] ) and therefore if @xmath331 for a fermi - sphere point process in @xmath2 for large @xmath9 behaved exactly like that for a poisson point process in @xmath433 , then @xmath304 would be given by @xmath434 } r + { \cal o}(1)\qquad ( r \rightarrow \infty ) .
\label{gv - poisson}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the first four space dimensions , the coefficients multiplying @xmath9 in ( [ gv - poisson ] ) are given by @xmath435 , 2 , @xmath436 , and @xmath437 , respectively .
this can be compared to the exact coefficients , which for @xmath438 and 4 are given by @xmath439 , @xmath440 , and @xmath441 , respectively .
the last three values are estimates that we have obtained based upon extrapolations from the evaluations of @xmath304 ( see ref .
@xcite for further numerical details ) .
we see that the probability of finding a large spherical cavity of radius @xmath9 in @xmath2 is approximately the same as that for a poisson point process in @xmath433 , implying linear growth of @xmath304 or @xmath305 for large @xmath9 .
it is not unreasoanble to conclude that this approximation becomes increasingly accurate as @xmath1 increases .
further justification for this remarkable behavior is given in section 6 .
we have obtained and characterized a new class of determinantal point processes in @xmath2 , the most general of which we call fermi - shells point processes .
the @xmath3-particle correlation functions for any @xmath3 and @xmath1 , which completely characterize the point process , are determined analytically .
we focused primarily on a special case , the fermi - sphere point process , which in one dimension is identical to the point process that characterizes the spacings of the eigenvalues of the gue ( as well as the cue ) , the conjectured spacings of the nontrivial zeros of the riemann zeta function , and the positions of spin - polarized fermions in their ground state ( i.e. , completely filling the fermi sphere " ) .
we are not aware of any correspondence of the general fermi - shells point process in @xmath2 for any @xmath232 to random matrix theory or the zeros of any generalized zeta function in number theory .
if our determinantal point processes have connections to random matrices in arbitrary space dimension , the latter must be non - hermitian .
for example , ginibre @xcite showed that there are two - dimensional determinantal point processes that correspond to complex eigenvalues of random non - hermitian matrices .
thus , it is an open question whether the fermi - shells point process has any correspondence to random matrices .
we analyzed in great detail properties of pair statistics , including the pair correlation function , the structure factor , and cumulative coordination number , as a function of spatial dimension @xmath1 .
the point processes for any @xmath1 are shown to be hyperuniform such that the structure factor ( or power spectrum ) @xmath4 has a nonanalytic behavior at the origin given by @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) .
the latter result implies that the pair correlation @xmath7 tends to unity for large pair distances with a decay rate that is controlled by the power law @xmath8 . in three dimensions ,
such a dominant power - law decay of @xmath7 is a well - known property of bosonic systems in their ground states @xcite and , more recently , has been shown to characterize maximally random jammed sphere packings @xcite .
we also graphically displayed one- and two - dimensional realizations of the point processes in order to vividly reveal their repulsive " nature and demonstrated that they can be characterized by an effective hard - core " diameter that grows like the square root of @xmath1 .
our study of the nearest - neighbor functions of the fermi - sphere point process resulted in some noteworthy conclusions .
for example , we have seen that the probability of finding a large spherical cavity of radius @xmath9 in @xmath2 is approximately the same as that for a poisson point process in @xmath433 , implying linear growth of @xmath304 or @xmath305 for large @xmath9 .
this is a remarkable result because it represents the first class of nontrivial point processes that we are aware of whose conditional nearest - neighbor functions do not asymptote to a constant ; see refs . @xcite and @xcite for examples of correlated equilibrium and nonequilibrium point processes that possess @xmath304 or @xmath305 with constant asymptotes , respectively .
it is clear that the unusual property of linear growth of @xmath442 or @xmath443 for large @xmath9 is due to the long - range nature of the repulsive interactions . since
a fermi - sphere point process in @xmath2 is always hyperuniform , i.e. , large wavelength density fluctuations vanish , the probability of finding a large spherical cavity must be smaller than the corresponding quantity for any point process that is not hyperuniform , such as a poisson point process in @xmath2 .
the probability of finding a large spherical cavity is of course smaller in a poisson point process in dimension @xmath10 compared to that in dimension @xmath1 .
moreover , it is easy to show that the asymptotic form ( [ ev - poisson ] ) for @xmath331 or @xmath338 for large @xmath9 is always between the aforementioned corresponding rigorous upper and lower bounds on the exclusion probabilities .
we also found that the fermi - sphere point process becomes a sphere packing in the high - dimensional limit with an effective hard - core diameter equal to the length scale @xmath208 [ cf .
( [ fermihole ] ) ] .
thus , the fraction of space @xmath408 covered by the spheres at unit number density is bounded from above by @xmath13 .
this coverage fraction has a special significance in the study of sphere packings ; it arises not only in minkowski s famous century - old lower bound on the density of the densest lattice sphere packings @xcite but in lower bounds for saturated and disordered packings @xcite as well as the highest achievable density in the ghost " random sequential addition packing @xcite .
it should be noted , however , that there is strong evidence that there exist disordered sphere packings with @xmath408 not only greater than @xmath13 @xcite but with densities that exponentially improve on minkowski s lower bound @xcite . elsewhere @xcite we report results on the extremes of the nearest - neighbor statistics as well as voronoi statistics of the fermi - sphere point processes in the first four space dimensions .
in other work , we will quantify clustering and percolation properties of fermi - sphere point processes .
the authors are grateful to peter sarnak and juan maldacena for useful discussions .
this work was supported by the national science foundation under grant no .
our purpose here is to show that the @xmath3-particle probability density function for an arbitrary determinantal point process , even in one dimension , can not be written as a boltzmann factor of @xmath14 classical particles interacting through one- and two - body potentials at a finite temperature .
although this claim is true for each of the canonical ensembles of random - matrix theory , we show via a counterexample in one dimension that intrinsic @xmath3-particle interactions with @xmath444 are generally necessary to describe the system .
it is relatively straightforward to express the @xmath3-particle probability density function for the cue as a boltzmann factor of a classical system of pairwise - interacting particles . in analogy with the formalism of the one - dimensional fermi - sphere point process introduced in section 4.1
, we fill the fermi line at a constant density .
thus , may write @xcite : @xmath445_{n , m}=\prod_{n < m}[\exp(\rmi x_n)-\exp(\rmi x_m)];\end{aligned}\ ] ] therefore , @xmath446_{n , m}\right|^2&=\exp\left[-2\sum_{n < m}\ln|\exp(\rmi x_n)- \exp(\rmi x_m)|\right]\\ & = \exp\left[-2\sum_{n < m}\ln|\sin(x_n - x_m)/2|\right]\label{a3}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for small eigenvalue separations @xmath447 , the result in reduces to the form : @xmath448 ; i.e. , the state @xmath449 is skipped
. we may then express the three - body form of the probability density as : @xmath450_{n , m}\right|^2=\frac{64}{(2\pi)^3 } [ 3 + 2 \cos(x - y)+2 \cos(x - z)+2 \cos(y - z)]\nonumber\\ \times \sin\left(\frac{x - y}{2}\right)^2 \sin\left(\frac{x - z}{2}\right)^2 \sin\left(\frac{y - z}{2}\right)^2,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used @xmath451 and @xmath271 to represent @xmath452 and @xmath453 ; the subscripts denote the state @xmath3 of each particle .
the last three factors have the form of the pair interaction in
. to check whether the pre - factor containing cosines can be written in the same form , we write : @xmath454\label{threepot}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] assume that @xmath455 .
it must then be true that : @xmath456\\ & = \frac{\ln(3)}{3 } + \frac{1}{2 } \ln[5 + 4 \cos(x - y)],\end{aligned}\ ] ] but by substituting this expression into , we see that we do not recover the original functional form .
therefore , we have shown by contradiction that for general determinantal point processes , the interaction potential must contain at least intrinsic three - body terms .
20 odlyzko a m , _ on the distribution of spacings between zeros of the zeta functions _ , 1987 _ math . comput . _ * 48 * 273 ; odlyzko a m , _ the @xmath457-nd zero of the riemann zeta function _ , in : van frankenhuysen
m and lapidus m l , 2001 _ dynamical , spectral , and arithmetic zeta functions _ ( providence : ams ) pp .
139 - 144 a sphere packing is a point process in which there is a minimal positive distance between any pair of points . according to ref .
@xcite , a _ disordered _ sphere packing in @xmath2 is one in which the pair correlation function @xmath459 decays to its long - range value of unity faster than @xmath460 for some @xmath461 . | it is well known that one can map certain properties of random matrices , fermionic gases , and zeros of the riemann zeta function to a unique point process on the real line @xmath0 . here
we analytically provide exact generalizations of such a point process in @xmath1-dimensional euclidean space @xmath2 for any @xmath1 , which are special cases of determinantal processes .
in particular , we obtain the @xmath3-particle correlation functions for any @xmath3 , which completely specify the point processes in @xmath2 .
we also demonstrate that spin - polarized fermionic systems in @xmath2 have these same @xmath3-particle correlation functions in each dimension .
the point processes for any @xmath1 are shown to be hyperuniform , i.e. , infinite wavelength density fluctuations vanish , and the structure factor ( or power spectrum ) @xmath4 has a nonanalytic behavior at the origin given by @xmath5 ( @xmath6 ) .
the latter result implies that the pair correlation function @xmath7 tends to unity for large pair distances with a decay rate that is controlled by the power law @xmath8 , which is a well - known property of bosonic ground states and more recently has been shown to characterize maximally random jammed sphere packings .
we graphically display one- and two - dimensional realizations of the point processes in order to vividly reveal their repulsive " nature .
indeed , we show that the point processes can be characterized by an effective hard - core " diameter that grows like the square root of @xmath1 .
the nearest - neighbor distribution functions for these point processes are also evaluated and rigorously bounded . among other results
, this analysis reveals that the probability of finding a large spherical cavity of radius @xmath9 in dimension @xmath1 behaves like a poisson point process but in dimension @xmath10 , i.e. , this probability is given by @xmath11 $ ] for large @xmath9 and finite @xmath1 , where @xmath12 is a positive @xmath1-dependent constant .
we also show that as @xmath1 increases , the point process behaves effectively like a sphere packing with a coverage fraction of space that is no denser than @xmath13 .
this coverage fraction has a special significance in the study of sphere packings in high - dimensional euclidean spaces .
_ keywords _ : correlation functions , point processes , fermions , random matrix theory , number theory |
students must learn effective problem solving strategies in order to develop expertise in physics . specifically , they must be able to solve problems beyond those that can be solved using a plug - and - chug approach .
@xcite research shows that converting a problem from the initial verbal representation to other suitable representations such as diagrammatic , tabular , graphical or algebraic can make further analysis of the problem easier .
@xcite similarly , using analogies or considering limiting cases are also useful strategies for solving problems .
@xcite many traditional courses do not explicitly teach students effective problem solving heuristics .
rather , they may implicitly reward inferior problem solving strategies that many students engage in .
instructors may implicitly assume that students appreciate the importance of initial qualitative analysis , planning , evaluation , and reflection phases of problem solving and that these phases are as important as the implementation phase .
@xcite consequently , they may not explicitly discuss and model these strategies while solving problems in class .
recitation is usually taught by the teaching assistants ( tas ) who present homework solutions on the blackboard while students copy them in their notebooks . without guidance , most textbook problems do not help students monitor their learning , reflect upon the problem solving process and pay attention to their knowledge structure
. quantitative and conceptual problem solving both can enhance problem solving and reasoning skills , but only if students engage in effective problem solving strategies rather than treating the task purely as a mathematical chore or guess - work @xcite . without guidance
, many introductory physics students do not perceive problem solving as an opportunity for learning to interpret the concepts involved and to draw meaningful inferences from them .
instead , they solve problems using superficial clues and cues , and apply concepts at random without concern for their applicability . with explicit training
, these same problem solving tasks can be turned into learning experiences that help students organize new knowledge coherently and hierarchically .
the abstract nature of the laws of physics and the chain of reasoning required to draw meaningful inferences make it even more important to teach students effective problem solving strategies explicitly .
reflection is an integral component of effective problem solving .
@xcite while experts in a particular field reflect and exploit problem solving as an opportunity for organizing and extending their knowledge , students often need feedback and support to learn how to use problem solving as an opportunity for learning . there are diverse strategies that can be employed to help students reflect upon problem solving .
one approach that has been found to be useful is self - explanation " or explaining what one is learning explicitly to oneself .
@xcite chi et al . found that , while reading science texts , students who constantly explained to themselves what they were reading and made an effort to connect the material read to their prior knowledge performed better on problem solving on related topics given to them after the reading .
@xcite inspired by the usefulness of self - explanation , yerushalmi et al . investigated how students may benefit from being explicitly asked to diagnose mistakes in their own quizzes with different levels of scaffolding support .
@xcite they found that students benefited from diagnosing their own mistakes .
the level of scaffolding needed to identify the mistakes and correct them depended on the difficulty of the problems .
another activity that may help students learn effective problem solving strategies while simultaneously learning physics content is reflection with peers . in this approach ,
students reflect not only on their own solution to problems , but reflect upon their peers solutions as well .
integration of peer interaction ( pi ) with lectures has been popularized in the physics community by mazur from harvard university .
@xcite in mazur s pi approach , the instructor poses conceptual problems in the form of multiple - choice questions to students periodically during the lecture .
@xcite the focal point of the pi method is the discussion among students , which is based on conceptual questions ; the lecture component is limited and intended to supplement the self - directed learning .
the conceptual multiple choice questions give students an opportunity to think about the physics concepts and principles covered in the lecture and discuss their answers and reasoning with peers .
the instructor polls the class after peer interaction to obtain the fraction of students with the correct answer .
on one hand , students learn about the level of understanding that is desired by the instructor by discussing with each other the concrete questions posed .
the feedback obtained by the instructor is also invaluable because the instructor learns about the fraction of the class that has understood the concepts at the desired level .
@xcite this pi strategy keeps students alert during lectures and helps them monitor their learning , because not only do students have to answer the questions , they must explain their answers to their peers .
@xcite the method keeps students actively engaged in the learning process and lets them take advantage of each others strengths .
it helps both the low and high performing students , because explaining and discussing concepts with peers helps students organize and solidify concepts in their minds .
@xcite heller et al .
have shown that group problem solving is especially valuable both for learning physics and for developing effective problem solving strategies .
@xcite they have developed many `` context - rich '' problems that are close to everyday situations and are more challenging and stimulating than the standard textbook problems .
these problems require careful thought and the use of many problem representations . working with peers in heterogeneous groups with students with high
, low and medium performance is particularly beneficial for learning from the context - rich " problems and students are typically assigned the rotating roles of manager , time keeper and skeptic by the instructor .
@xcite our prior research has shown that , even with minimal guidance from the instructors , students can benefit from peer interaction .
@xcite in our study , those who worked with peers not only outperformed an equivalent group of students who worked alone on the same task , but collaboration with a peer led to co - construction " of knowledge in @xmath0 of the cases .
@xcite co - construction of knowledge occurs when neither student who engaged in the peer collaboration was able to answer the questions before the collaboration , but both were able to answer them after working with a peer on a post - test given individually to each person . here
, we describe a study in which algebra - based introductory physics students in the peer reflection group ( pr group ) were provided guidance and support to reflect upon problem solving with peers and undergraduate and graduate teaching assistants in the recitation class . on the other hand
, other recitation classes were run in a traditional manner with the ta answering students homework questions and then giving a quiz at the end of each recitation class .
our assessment method was novel in that it involved counting the number of problems in which students drew diagrams or did scratchworks on scratch books when there was no partial credit for these activities because the questions were in the multiple - choice format .
we find that the pr group drew more diagrams than the traditional group ( statistically significant ) even when there was no external reward for drawing them .
the peer - reflection process which was sustained throughout the semester requires students to evaluate their solutions and those of their peers and involves high level of mental processing .
@xcite the reflection process with peers can also help students monitor their learning . we also find that there is a positive correlation between the number of diagrams drawn and the final exam performance . in particular , students who drew diagrams for more problems performed better than others regardless of whether they belonged to the traditional group or the pr group .
the investigation involved an introductory algebra - based physics course mostly taken by students with interest in health related professions .
the course had 200 students and was broken into two sections both of which met on tuesdays and thursdays and were taught by the same professor who had taught both sections of the course before .
a class poll at the beginning of the course indicated that more than @xmath1 of the students had taken at least one physics course in high school , and perhaps more surprisingly , more than @xmath2 of the students had taken at least one calculus course ( although the college physics course in which they were enrolled was an algebra - based course ) .
the daytime section taught during the day was the traditional group and had 107 students whereas the evening section called the
peer reflection " group or pr group had 93 students .
the lectures , all homework assignments , the midterm exams and the final exam were identical for the daytime and evening sections of the course .
moreover , the instructor emphasized effective problem solving strategies , e.g. , performing a conceptual analysis of the problem and planning of the solution before implementing the plan and importance of evaluating the solution throughout the semester in both the traditional and peer - reflection groups . each week
, students in both groups were supposed to turn in answers to the assigned homework problems ( based upon the material covered in the previous week ) using an online homework system for some course credit .
in addition , students in both groups were supposed to submit a paper copy of the homework problems which had the details of the problem solving approach at the end of the recitation class to the ta for some course credit . while the online homework solution was graded for correctness , the ta only graded the paper copies of the submitted homework for completeness on a three point scale ( full score , half score or zero ) .
the weighting of each component of the course , e.g. , midterm exams , final exam , class participation , homework and the scores allocated for the recitation were the same for both classes .
also , as noted earlier , all components of the course were identical for both groups except the recitations which were conducted very differently for the pr and traditional groups .
although the total course weighting assigned to the recitations was the same for both groups ( since all the other components of the course had the same weighting for both groups ) , the scoring of the recitations was different for the two groups .
students were given credit for attending recitation in both groups .
attendance was taken in the recitations using clickers for both the traditional group and the pr group .
the traditional group recitations were traditional in which the ta would solve selected assigned homework problems on the blackboard and field questions from students about their homework before assigning a quiz in the last 20 minutes of the recitation class .
the recitation quiz problems given to the traditional group were similar to the homework problems selected for peer reflection " in the pr group recitations ( but the quiz problems were not identical to the homework problems to discourage students in the traditional group from memorizing the answers to homework in preparation for the quiz ) .
students in the pr group reflected on three homework problems in each recitation class but no recitation quiz was given to the students in this group at the end of the recitation classes , unlike the traditional group , primarily due to the time constraints .
the recitation scores for the pr group students were assigned based mostly on the recitation attendance except students obtained bonus points for helping select the
best " student solution as described below .
since the recitation scoring was done differently for the traditional and pr groups , the two groups were curved separately so that the top @xmath3 of the students in each group obtained a and b grades in view of the departmental policy .
as noted earlier , both recitation sections for the evening section ( 93 students total ) together formed the pr group . the pr group intervention was based upon a field - tested cognitive apprenticeship model @xcite of learning involving modeling , coaching , and fading to help students learn effective problem solving heuristics . in this approach ,
modeling " means that the ta demonstrates and exemplifies the effective problem solving skills that the students should learn .
coaching " means providing students opportunity to practice problem solving skills with appropriate guidance so that they learn the desired skills . fading " means decreasing the support and feedback gradually with a focus on helping students develop self - reliance . the specific strategy used by the students in the pr group involved reflection upon problem solving with their peers in the recitations , while the ta and the undergraduate teaching assistants ( utas ) exemplified the effective problem solving heuristics .
the utas were chosen from those undergraduate students who had earned an @xmath4 grade in an equivalent introductory physics course previously .
the utas had to attend all the lectures in the semester in which they were utas for a course and they communicated with the ta each week ( and periodically with the course instructor ) to determine the plan for the recitations .
we note that , for effective implementation of the pr method , two utas were present in each recitation class along with the ta .
these utas helped the ta in demonstrating and helping students to learn effective problem solving heuristics . in our intervention ,
each of the three recitation sections in the traditional group had about 35 - 37 students .
the two recitations for the pr group had more than 40 students each ( since the pr group was the evening section of the course , it was logistically not possible to break this group into three recitations ) . at the beginning of each pr recitation , students were asked to form nine teams of three to six students chosen at random by the ta ( these teams were generated by a computer program each week ) .
the ta projected the names of the team members on the screen so that they could sit together at the beginning of each recitation class .
three homework questions were chosen for a particular recitation .
the recitations for the two sections were coordinated by the tas so that the recitation quiz problems given to the traditional group were based upon the homework problems selected for peer reflection " in the pr group recitations .
each of the three competitions " was carefully timed to take approximately 15 minutes , in order for the entire exercise to fit into the allotted fifty - minute time slot .
after each question was announced to the class , each of the nine teams were given three minutes to identify the
best " solution by comparing and discussing among the group members .
if a group had difficulty coming up with a winner " , the ta / uta would intervene and facilitate the process .
the winning students were asked to come to the front of the room , where they were assembled into three second - round groups .
the process was repeated , producing three finalists .
these students handed in their homework solutions to the tas , after which the ta / uta evaluation process began .
a qualitative sketch of the team structures at various stages of the competition is shown in figure 1 .
the three finalists solutions were projected one at a time on a screen using a web cam and computer projector .
each of the three panelists ( the ta and two utas ) gave their critique of the solutions , citing what each of the finalists had done well and what could be done to further enhance the problem solving methodology in each case .
in essence , the ta and utas were judges " similar to the judges in the television show american idol " and gave their critique " of each finalist s problem solving performance .
after each solution had been critiqued by each of the panelists , the students , using the clickers , voted on the best " solution .
the ta and utas did not participate in the voting process . in order to encourage each team in the pr group to select the student with the most effective problem solving strategy as the winner for each problem , all students from the teams whose member advanced to the final round to win " the competition " were given course credit ( bonus points ) .
in particular , each of these team members ( consolation prize winners ) earned one third of the course credit given to the student whose solution was declared to be the winner " .
this reward system made the discussions very lively and the teams generally made good effort to advance the most effective solution to the next stage .
figure 1 shows one possible team configuration at various stages of pr activities when there are 27 students in the recitation class initially . due to lack of space ,
each of the initial teams ( round 1 ) in figure 1 is shown with 3 members whereas in reality this round on average consisted of five team members .
in each team , the student with the dark border in figure 1 is the winner of that round " and advances to the next stage .
all the students who participated at any stage in helping select the winner " ( those shown in gray ) were the consolation prize winners and obtained one third of the course credit that was awarded to the winner for that problem .
while we video - taped a portion of the recitation class discussions when students reflected with peers , a good account of the effectiveness and intensity of the team discussions came from the ta and utas who generally walked around from team to team listening to the discussions but not interrupting the team members involved in the discussions unless facilitation was necessary for breaking a gridlock . the course credit and the opportunity to have the finalists solutions voted on by the whole class encouraged students to argue passionately about the aspects of their solutions that displayed effective problem solving strategies .
students were constantly arguing about why drawing a diagram , explicitly thinking about the knowns and target variables , and explicitly justifying the physics principles that would be useful before writing down the equations are effective problem solving strategies . furthermore , the american idol " style recitation allowed the tas to discuss and convey to students in much more detail what solution styles were preferred and why .
students were often shown what kinds of solutions were easier to read and understand , and which were more amenable to error - checking .
great emphasis was placed on consistent use of notation , setting up problems through the use of symbols to define physical quantities , and the importance of clear diagrams in constructing solutions . at the end of the semester ,
all of the students were given a final exam consisting of 40 multiple choice questions , 20 of which were primarily conceptual in nature and 20 of which were primarily quantitative ( students had to solve a numerical or symbolic problem for a target quantity ) .
although the final exam was all multiple - choice , a novel assessment method was used .
while students knew that the only thing that counted for their grade was whether they chose the correct option for each multiple - choice question , each student was given an exam notebook which he / she could use for scratchworks .
we hypothesized that even if the final exam questions were in the multiple - choice format , students who value effective problem solving strategies will take the time to draw more diagrams and do more scratchworks even if there was no course credit for such activities . with the assumption that the students will write on the exam booklet and
write down relevant concepts only if they think it is helpful for problem solving , multiple - choice exam can be a novel tool for assessment
. it allowed us to observe students problem solving strategies in a more native " form closer to what they really think is helpful for problem solving instead of what the professor wants them to write down or filling the page when a free - response question is assigned with irrelevant equations and concepts with the hope of getting partial credit for the effort .
we decided to divide the students work in the notebooks and exam - books into two categories : diagrams and scratchworks .
the scratchworks included everything written apart from the diagrams such as equations , sentences , and texts .
both authors of this paper agreed on how to differentiate between diagrams and scratchworks .
instead of using subjectivity in deciding how good " the diagrams or scratchworks for each student for each of the 40 questions were , we only counted the number of problems with diagrams drawn and scratchworks done by each student .
for example , if a student drew diagrams for 7 questions out of 40 questions and did scratchworks for 10 questions out of 40 questions , we counted it as 7 diagrams and 10 scratchworks .
we hypothesized that the pr intervention in the recitation may be beneficial in helping students learn effective problem solving strategies because students solved the homework problems , discussed them with their peers to determine the top three student solutions and then were provided expert feedback from the utas and ta about those solutions .
chi et al .
@xcite have theorized that students often fail to learn from the expert " solutions even when they realize that their own approaches are deficient because they may not take the time to reflect upon how the expert model is different from their own and how they can repair their own knowledge structure and improve their problem solving strategies .
chi et al .
therefore emphasize that simply realizing that the problem solving approach of the instructor is superior than theirs may not be enough to help students learn effective strategies .
they noted that the feedback and support by instructors to help students understand why the expert solution is better after the students realize that they are better is a critical component of learning effective approaches to problem solving .
@xcite in the approach adopted in the pr group recitations , the utas and ta provided valuable expert " feedback to help students make these connections right after the students had thought about effective approaches to problem solving themselves .
in fact , since high performing utas are only a year ahead of the students , their feedback may be at the right level and even more valuable to the students .
@xcite such reasoning was our motivation for exploring the effect of the pr intervention .
our goal was to examine both inter - group effects and group - independent effects .
inter - group effects refer to the investigation of the differences between the traditional group and the pr group . for example
, we investigated whether there was a statistical difference in the average number of problems for which students drew diagrams and wrote scratchworks in the pr group and the traditional group .
we also examined group - independent effects , findings that hold for students in both the traditional group and the pr group .
one issue we examined was whether students who drew more diagrams , despite knowing that there was no partial credit for these tasks , were more likely to perform better in the final exam .
we also investigated the correlation between the number of problems with diagrams or scratchworks and the final exam performance when quantitative and conceptual questions were considered separately .
we also explored whether students were more likely to draw diagrams on quantitative or conceptual questions on the final exam .
although no pretest was given to students , there is some evidence that , over the years , the evening section of the course is somewhat weaker and does not perform as well overall as the daytime section of the course historically .
the difference between the daytime and evening sections of the course could partly be due to the fact that some students in the evening section work full - time and take classes simultaneously .
for example , the same professor had also taught both sections of the course one year before the peer reflection activities were introduced in evening recitations and thus all recitations for both sections of the course were taught traditionally that year .
thus , we first compare the averages of the daytime and evening sections before and after the peer reflection activities were instituted in the evening recitation classes .
table 1 compares the difference in the averages between the daytime and evening classes the year prior to the introduction of peer reflection ( fall 2006 ) and the year in which peer reflection was implemented in the evening recitation classes ( fall 2007 ) . in table 1 ,
the p - values given are the results of t - tests performed between the daytime and evening classes .
@xcite statistically significant difference ( at the level of @xmath5 ) between groups only exists between the average midterm scores for the year in which peer reflection was implemented .
the evening section scored lower on average than the daytime section on the final exam but the difference is not statistically significant ( p=0.112 for 2006 and p=0.875 for 2007 ) , as indicated in table 1 .
we note that while the midterm questions differed from year to year ( since the midterms were returned to students and there was a possibility that the students would share them ) , the final exam , which was not returned to students , was almost the same both years ( except the instructor had changed a couple of questions on the final exam from 2006 to 2007 ) .
we also note that the final exam scores are lower than the midterm scores because there was no partial credit for answering multiple - choice questions on the final exam .
the final exam which was comprehensive had 40 multiple - choice questions , half of which were quantitative and half were conceptual .
there was no partial credit given for drawing the diagrams or doing the scratchworks .
one issue we investigated is whether the students considered the diagrams or the scratchworks to be beneficial and used them while solving problems , even though students knew that no partial credit was given for showing work .
as noted earlier , our assessment method involved counting the number of problems with diagrams and scratchworks .
we counted any comprehensible work done on the exam notebook other than a diagram as a scratchwork . in this sense , quantifying the amount of scratchwork does not distinguish between a short and a long scratchwork for a given question . if a student wrote anything other than a diagram , e.g. , equations , the known variables and target quantities , an attempt to solve for unknown etc .
, it was considered scratchwork for that problem .
similarly , there was a diversity in the quality of diagrams the students drew for the same problem .
some students drew elaborate diagrams which were well labeled while others drew rough sketches .
regardless of the quality of the diagrams , any problem in which a diagram was drawn was counted .
we find that the pr group on average drew more diagrams than the traditional group .
table 2 compares the average number of problems with diagrams or scratchworks by the traditional group and the pr group on the final exam .
it shows that the pr group had more problems with diagrams than the traditional group ( statistically significant ) @xcite .
in particular , the traditional group averaged 7.0 problems with diagrams per student for the whole exam ( 40 problems ) , 4.3 problems with diagrams for the quantitative questions per student and 2.7 problems with diagrams for the conceptual questions per student . on the other hand ,
the pr group averaged 8.6 problems with diagrams per student , 5.1 problems with diagrams for the quantitative questions per student and 3.5 diagrams for the conceptual questions per student .
figures 2 and 3 display the histograms of the total number of problems with diagrams on the final exam ( with only multiple - choice questions ) vs. the percentage of students for the traditional and pr groups respectively .
figures 2 shows that some students in the pr group drew many more diagrams than the average number of diagrams drawn on the exam .
the histograms of the total number of quantitative or conceptual questions with diagrams vs. the percentage of students for the traditional and pr groups can be found here.@xcite we also find that students drew more diagrams for the quantitative questions than the conceptual questions .
tables 2 shows that , regardless of whether they belonged to the traditional group or the pr group , students were more likely to draw diagrams for the quantitative questions than for the conceptual questions .
the comparison of the number of problems with diagrams for quantitative vs. conceptual problems for each of the traditional ( n=107 ) and pr ( n=93 ) groups displayed in table 2 gives statistically significant difference at the level of @xmath6 .
it was not clear _ a priori _ that students will draw more diagrams for the quantitative questions than for the conceptual questions and we hypothesize that this trend may change depending on the expertise of the individuals and the type of questions asked .
table 2 also shows that , while there was no statistical difference between the two groups in terms of the total number of problems with scratchworks performed , the students were far more likely to do scratchworks for the quantitative questions than for the conceptual questions .
figures 4 and 5 display the histograms of the total number of problems with scratchworks on the final exam vs. the percentage of students for the traditional and pr groups respectively .
the histograms of the total number of quantitative or conceptual questions with scratchworks vs. the percentage of students for the traditional and pr groups can be found here.@xcite we note that the sample sizes are approximately equal and not too small , so the t - test will not be much affected even if the distributions are skewed .
@xcite the comparison of the number of problems with scratchworks for quantitative vs. conceptual problems for each of the traditional and pr groups displayed in table 2 gives statistically significant difference at the level of @xmath6 .
this difference between the quantitative and the conceptual questions makes sense since problems which are primarily quantitative require calculations to arrive at an answer .
we also find a positive correlation between the final exam score and the number of problems with diagrams .
table 3 investigates whether the final exam score is correlated with the number of problems with diagrams or scratchworks for the traditional group and the pr group separately ( r is the correlation coefficient ) .
the null hypothesis in each case is that there is no correlation between the final exam score and the variable considered , e.g. , the total number of problems with diagrams drawn .
@xcite table 3 shows that , for both the traditional group and the pr group , the students who had more problems with diagrams and scratchworks were statistically ( significantly ) more likely to perform well on the final exam .
@xcite this correlation holds regardless of whether we look at all questions or the quantitative questions only ( labeled diagram ( q ) and scratch(q ) for the quantitative diagrams and scratchworks respectively ) or conceptual questions only ( labeled diagram(c ) and scratch(c ) for the conceptual diagrams and scratch work respectively ) .
there is no prior research related to physics learning at any level that we know of that shows a positive correlation between the exam performance and the number of problems with diagrams drawn when answering multiple - choice questions where there is no partial credit for drawing diagrams .
it is evident from table 3 that for both conceptual and quantitative questions , diagrams are positively correlated with final exam performance .
in particular , we investigated the correlations between the number of problems with diagrams drawn ( or the amount of scratchwork ) and the final exam scores on the quantitative questions alone and the conceptual questions alone .
table 3 shows that within each group ( traditional or pr ) , the correlation between the number of diagrams drawn and the final exam score is virtually identical for the quantitative and conceptual questions ( r = 0.19 for quantitative vs. r=0.20 for conceptual in the traditional group , r=0.36 for quantitative vs. r=0.36 for conceptual in the peer reflection group ) .
we find that the diagrams drawn by the pr group explain more of the final exam performance .
in particular , the comparison of the traditional group and the pr group in table 3 shows that for each case shown in the different rows , the correlation between the number of diagrams or amount of scratchwork and the final exam score is stronger for the pr group than for the traditional group .
for example , the correlation coefficient @xmath7 for the number of problems with diagrams drawn vs. the final exam score is higher for the pr group compared to the traditional group ( r=0.40 vs. r=0.24 ) .
the pr group also showed a stronger correlation than the traditional group even when the quantitative and conceptual questions were considered separately for the correlation between the number of problems with diagrams drawn and the final exam scores .
similarly , the correlation coefficient for the number of scratchworks vs. the final exam score is higher for the pr group compared to the traditional group ( r=0.53 vs. r=0.39 ) .
we also find that scratchworks explain more of the performance for quantitative questions than conceptual questions .
in particular , table 3 also shows that , within each group ( traditional and pr ) , the correlation between the amount of scratchwork and the final exam score was stronger for the quantitative questions than for the conceptual questions .
while correlation does not imply causality , the stronger correlation may be due to the fact that students do not necessarily have to perform algebraic manipulations for conceptual questions but it may be a pre - requisite for identifying the correct answer for a quantitative question .
further examination of the quantitative - only correlations between the scratchwork and the final exam scores ( r = 0.42 for the traditional group , r = 0.59 for the pr group ) shows that the correlations are stronger for the pr group than the traditional group .
in this study , the recitation classes for an introductory physics course primarily for the health - science majors were broken into a traditional group and a peer reflection " or pr group .
we investigated whether students in the pr group use better problem - solving strategies such as drawing diagrams than students in the traditional group and also whether there are differences in the performance of the two groups .
we also explored whether students who perform well are the ones who are more likely to draw diagrams or write scratchworks even when there is no partial credit for these activities . in the pr group recitation classes
, students reflected about their problem solving in the homework with peers each week .
appropriate guidance and support provided opportunities for learning effective problem solving heuristics to the students in the pr group . in particular , students in the pr group reflected in small teams on selected problems from the homework and discussed why solutions of some students employed better problem solving strategies than others .
the ta and utas in the pr group recitations demonstrated effective approaches to problem solving and coached students so that they learn those skills .
each small team in the pr group discussed which student s homework solutions employed the most effective problem solving heuristics and selected a winner " .
then , three teams combined into a larger team and repeated the process of determining the winning " solution .
typically , once three finalists " were identified in this manner , the ta and utas put each finalist s solution on a projector and discussed what they perceived to be good problem - solving strategies used in each solution and what can be improved . finally , each student used clickers to vote on the best " overall solution with regard to the problem solving strategies used .
there was a reward system related to course credit that encouraged students to be involved in selecting the solution with the best problem solving strategy in each round .
students in the traditional group had traditional recitation classes in which they asked the ta questions about the homework before taking a quiz at the end of each recitation class .
each problem selected for
peer reflection " was adapted into a quiz problem for the traditional group .
the assessment of the effectiveness of the intervention was novel .
the final exam had 40 multiple - choice questions , half of which were quantitative and half were conceptual .
for the multiple - choice questions , students technically do not have to show their work to arrive at the answer .
however , students may use effective approaches to problem solving such as drawing a diagram or writing down their plan if they believe it may help them answer a question correctly .
although students knew that there was no partial credit for drawing diagrams or writing scratchworks , we compared the average number of problems with diagrams or scratchworks in the traditional and experimental groups .
our hypothesis was that students who value effective problem solving strategies will have more problems in which diagrams are drawn or scratchworks are written despite the fact that there is no partial credit for these activities .
in fact , the fact that there was no partial credit for the diagrams or the scratchworks helped eliminate the possibility of students drawing the diagrams or writing scratchworks for the sole purpose of getting partial credit for the effort displayed ( even if it is meaningless from the perspective of relevant physics content ) .
we note that to help understand the statistical differences between the pr and traditional sections , we chose to quantify the number of diagrams drawn in the multiple - choice final examination .
it should be stressed that the pr recitations emphasized a wide variety of preferred problem - solving strategies ( not just drawing diagrams ) . diagrams ( and scratchworks ) were chosen simply because they were more straightforward to quantify than other strategies .
we hypothesize that the use of diagrams represents a good marker " for overall improvement in problem solving strategies .
our findings can be broadly classified into inter - group and group - independent categories .
the inter - group findings that show the difference between the traditional group and pr group can be summarized as follows : * on the multiple - choice final exam where there was no partial credit for drawing diagrams , the pr group drew diagrams in more problems ( statistically significant ) than the traditional group . * the diagrams drawn by the pr group explain more of the final exam performance than those by the traditional group .
findings that are independent of group ( which are true even when the traditional group and pr group are not separated and all students are considered together ) can be summarized as follows : * there is a statistically significant positive correlation between how often students wrote scratchworks or drew diagrams and how well they performed on the final exam regardless of whether they were in the traditional group or the pr group .
in particular , those who performed well in the multiple - choice final exam ( in which there was no partial credit for showing work ) were much more likely to draw diagrams than the other students . while one may assume that high - performing students will draw more diagrams even when there is no partial credit for it , no prior research that we know of has explicitly demonstrated a correlation between the number of genuinely drawn " diagrams and student performance at any level of physics instruction . * the correlations between the number of problems with diagrams drawn and the final exam scores on the quantitative questions alone and the conceptual questions alone are comparable and positive . * students in both groups were more likely to draw diagrams or write scratchworks for quantitative problems than for the conceptual questions .
while more scratchworks are expected on quantitative problems , it is not clear _ a priori _ that more diagrams will be drawn for the quantitative problems than for the conceptual questions .
we hypothesize that this trend may depend upon the expertise of the individuals , explicit training in effective problem solving strategies and the difficulty of the problems .
we note that the students in the traditional group were given weekly recitation quizzes in the last 20 minutes of the recitation class based upon that week s homework .
there were no recitation quizzes in the pr group due to the time constraints .
it is sometimes argued by faculty members that the recitation quizzes are essential to keep students engaged in the learning process during the recitations .
however , this study shows that the pr group was not adversely affected by not having the weekly quizzes that the traditional group had and instead having the peer reflection activities .
the mental engagement of students in the pr group throughout the recitation class may have more than compensated for the lack of quizzes .
the students in the pr group were evaluating their peer s work along with their own which requires high level of mental processing .
@xcite they were comparing problem solving strategies such as how to do a conceptual analysis and planning of the solution , why drawing two separate diagrams may be better in certain cases ( e.g. , before and after a collision ) than combining the information into one diagram , how to define and use symbols consistently etc .
in addition , after the active engagement with peers , students got an opportunity to learn from the ta and utas about their critique of each winning " solution highlighting the strengths and weaknesses .
we also note that the pr recitations do not require any additional class time or effort on the part of the instructor . according to chi @xcite , students are likely to improve their approaches to problem solving and learn meaningfully from an intervention if both of the following happen : i ) students compare two artifacts , e.g. , the expert solution and their own solution and realize their omissions , and ii ) they receive guidance to understand why the expert solution is better and how they can improve upon their own approaches .
the pr approach uses such a two tier approach in which students first identify that other student s solution may be better than their own and then are guided by the utas / ta to reflect upon the various aspects of the winning " solutions .
we are very grateful to dr .
louis pingel from the school of education and dr .
allan r. sampson and huan xu from the department of statistics at the university of pittsburgh for their help in data analysis .
we thank f. reif , r. glaser , r. p. devaty and j. levy for helpful discussions .
we thank j. levy for his enthusiastic support of helping us implement the peer reflection " activities in his class .
we thank the national science foundation for financial support .
j. larkin , understanding , problem representations , and skill in physics " in s. f. chipman , j. w. segal and r. glaser ( eds . ) , thinking and learning skills ( lawrence erl . , hillsdale , nj ) , * 2 * , pp . 141 - 159 ( 1985 ) .
j. kaput , representation and problem solving : methodological issues related to modeling " , e. a. silver ( ed . ) , in teaching and learning mathematical problem solving : multiple research perspectives , lawrence erl . ,
hillsale , nj , pp . 381 - 398 , 1985 .
a. schoenfeld , `` learning to think mathematically : problem solving , metacognition , and sense - making in mathematics , '' in _ handbook for research on mathematics teaching and learning _
, edited by d. grouws ( mcmillan , ny , 1992 ) , chap .
334370 .
a. schoenfeld , `` teaching mathematical thinking and problem solving , '' in _ toward the thinking curriculum : current cognitive research _
, edited by l. b. resnick and b. l. klopfer ( ascd , washington , dc , 1989 ) , pp .
83103 .
r. dufresne , j. mestre , t. thaden - koch , w. gerace , and w. leonard , `` knowledge representation and coordination in the transfer process , '' in _ transfer of learning from a modern multidisciplinary perspective _ , edited by j. p. mestre ( information age publishing , greenwich , ct , 2005 ) , pp .
155215 . c. singh , assessing student expertise in introductory physics with isomorphic problems , part ii : examining the effect of some potential factors on problem solving and transfer " , phys .
res . * 4 * , 010105(1 - 10 ) , ( 2008 ) .
e. yerushalmi , c. singh , and b. eylon , physics learning in the context of scaffolded diagnostic tasks ( i ) : the experimental setup " , in _ proceedings of the phys .
conference , greensboro , nc , _ edited by l. hsu , l. mccullough , and c. henderson , aip conf .
951 , 27 - 30 , ( 2007 ) .
e. mazur , understanding or memorization : are we teaching the right thing " in conference on the introductory physics course on the occasion of the retirement of robert resnick , ed .
j. wilson , 113 - 124 , wiley , ny , ( 1997 ) . for example , see page 291 in the chapter on t - test assumptions and robustness " .
g. glass and k. hopkins , statistical methods in psychology and education " 3rd edition , needham heights , ma , allyn and bacon , 1996 .
r. j. marzano , r. s. brandt , c. s. hughes , b. f. jones , b. z. presseisen , s. c. rankin , and c. suhor , _ dimensions of thinking : a framework for curriculum and instruction _ , alexandria , va : association for supervision and curriculum development , ( 1988 ) .
a. collins , j. s. brown , and s. e. newman , _ cognitive apprenticeship : teaching the crafts of reading , writing and mathematics _ , in l. b. resnick ( ed . ) , knowing , learning , and instruction : essays in honor of robert glaser , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum .
, 453 - 494 , 1989 .
figure 1 : illustration of the team structure at the three stages of peer - reflection activities . before the students voted in the third round using the clickers , the ta and utas critiqued each of the three solutions at the final stage .
due to lack of space , only 3 team members per team are shown in round 1 but there were on average five members in each group in this round ( as generated by a computer program each week ) .
the consolation prize winners in gray obtained 1/3rd of the course credit awarded to the winner .
.means and p - values for comparisons of the daytime and evening classes during the year before peer reflection was introduced ( fall 2006 ) and during the year in which it was introduced ( fall 2007 ) .
the following were the number of students in each group : fall 2006 daytime n=124 , evening n=100 , fall 2007 daytime n=107 , evening n=93 . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] | we describe a study in which introductory physics students engage in reflection with peers about problem solving .
the recitations for an introductory physics course with 200 students were broken into the peer reflection " ( pr ) group and the traditional group .
each week in recitation , students in the pr group reflected in small teams on selected problems from the homework and discussed why solutions of some students employed better problem solving strategies than others .
the graduate and undergraduate teaching assistants ( tas ) in the pr group recitations provided guidance and coaching to help students learn effective problem solving heuristics . in the recitations for the traditional group ,
students had the opportunity to ask the graduate ta questions about the homework before they took a weekly quiz .
the traditional group recitation quiz questions were similar to the homework questions selected for peer reflection " in the pr group recitations .
as one measure of the impact of this intervention , we investigated how likely students were to draw diagrams to help with problem solving . on the final exam with only multiple - choice questions ,
the pr group drew diagrams on more problems than the traditional group , even when there was no external reward for doing so .
since there was no partial credit for drawing the diagrams on the scratch books , students did not draw diagrams simply to get credit for the effort shown and must value the use of diagrams for solving problems if they drew them .
we also find that , regardless of whether the students belonged to the traditional or pr groups , those who drew more diagrams for the multiple - choice questions outperformed those who did not draw them .
2em -0.25 in 6.9 in 9.62 in 1ex -.75 in |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.