ai-phone-leaderboard / src /core /glicko2_ranking.py
agh123's picture
fix: for Device Duel get max for each device/model combination
915fcba
"""
Glicko-2 Ranking System for Device Performance Comparison
This module implements a Glicko-2 based ranking system for comparing device performance
in benchmark tests. Glicko-2 is an improvement over the original Glicko system and Elo,
providing better handling of rating uncertainty and volatility.
The system:
1. Filters out emulators and iOS devices with insufficient GPU layers
2. Normalizes scores within each model group
3. Computes Glicko-2 ratings for devices based on their performance
4. Provides uncertainty metrics alongside ratings
5. Supports both combined and separate analysis of Token Generation and Prompt Processing
"""
import numpy as np
import pandas as pd
from collections import defaultdict
from typing import Tuple, Dict, List, Optional
import glicko2
import streamlit as st
# Cache configuration
CACHE_DURATION = 36000 # Cache duration in seconds (10 hours)
def preprocess_benchmark_data(
df: pd.DataFrame,
min_gpu_layers: int = 20,
pp_config: int = 512,
tg_config: int = 128,
) -> pd.DataFrame:
"""
Preprocess benchmark data by filtering out invalid entries.
Args:
df: DataFrame containing benchmark data
min_gpu_layers: Minimum number of GPU layers required for iOS devices
pp_config: Prompt Processing configuration to filter for
tg_config: Token Generation configuration to filter for
Returns:
Filtered DataFrame containing only valid benchmark entries
"""
# Create a mask for devices to keep
keep_device = (
# Keep non-iOS devices
(
(df["Platform"] != "iOS")
|
# Keep iOS devices with sufficient GPU layers
((df["Platform"] == "iOS") & (df["n_gpu_layers"] >= min_gpu_layers))
)
&
# Remove emulators
(~df["Normalized Device ID"].str.contains("Emulator", case=False, na=False))
&
# Filter by configuration
(df["PP Config"] == pp_config)
& (df["TG Config"] == tg_config)
)
filtered_df = df[keep_device].copy()
# Print filtering statistics
total_devices = df["Normalized Device ID"].nunique()
filtered_devices = filtered_df["Normalized Device ID"].nunique()
emulator_devices = df[
df["Normalized Device ID"].str.contains("Emulator", case=False, na=False)
]["Normalized Device ID"].nunique()
print("Filtering Statistics:")
print(f"Original devices: {total_devices}")
print(f"Emulator devices removed: {emulator_devices}")
print(
f"iOS devices with insufficient GPU layers removed: "
f"{total_devices - filtered_devices - emulator_devices}"
)
print(f"Final device count: {filtered_devices}")
# Print removed devices for verification
print(
f"Removed {set(df['Normalized Device ID'].unique()) - set(filtered_df['Normalized Device ID'].unique())} "
)
return filtered_df
def compute_glicko2_rankings(
df: pd.DataFrame, token_weight: float = 0.6
) -> pd.DataFrame:
"""
Compute device rankings using Glicko-2 rating system.
Args:
df: DataFrame containing benchmark data
token_weight: Weight for Token Generation in combined score (0.0 to 1.0)
Returns:
DataFrame containing device rankings and statistics
"""
# Initialize Glicko-2 ratings for all devices
ratings = {}
match_counts = defaultdict(int)
win_counts = defaultdict(int)
loss_counts = defaultdict(int)
# Default Glicko-2 settings
# Rating = 1500, RD (rating deviation) = 350, Volatility = 0.06
def create_glicko2_rating():
return glicko2.Player(rating=1500, rd=350, vol=0.06)
def normalize_scores(group: pd.DataFrame) -> pd.Series:
"""Normalize and combine scores within a model group"""
# Normalize Token Generation (higher is better)
token_min = group["Token Generation"].min()
token_max = group["Token Generation"].max()
token_norm = (
(group["Token Generation"] - token_min) / (token_max - token_min)
if token_max > token_min
else 0
)
# Normalize Prompt Processing (higher is better)
prompt_min = group["Prompt Processing"].min()
prompt_max = group["Prompt Processing"].max()
prompt_norm = (
(group["Prompt Processing"] - prompt_min) / (prompt_max - prompt_min)
if prompt_max > prompt_min
else 0
)
# Combine scores
return token_weight * token_norm + (1 - token_weight) * prompt_norm
# Get all unique devices
all_devices = df["Normalized Device ID"].unique()
# Initialize ratings for all devices
for device in all_devices:
ratings[device] = create_glicko2_rating()
# Process each model separately
for model, group in df.groupby("Model ID"):
# Add normalized combined score
group.loc[:, "combined_score"] = normalize_scores(group)
devices = group["Normalized Device ID"].unique()
# In Glicko-2, we need to collect all results for a rating period before updating
# A rating period could be all matches for a specific model
device_matches = defaultdict(
lambda: {"opponent_ratings": [], "opponent_rds": [], "outcomes": []}
)
for i in range(len(devices)):
for j in range(i + 1, len(devices)):
device1 = devices[i]
device2 = devices[j]
score1 = group[group["Normalized Device ID"] == device1][
"combined_score"
].iloc[0]
score2 = group[group["Normalized Device ID"] == device2][
"combined_score"
].iloc[0]
# Update match counts
match_counts[device1] += 1
match_counts[device2] += 1
# Determine outcome (0 = loss, 1 = win, 0.5 = draw)
if score1 > score2:
# Device 1 wins
outcome = 1
win_counts[device1] += 1
loss_counts[device2] += 1
# For device 1
device_matches[device1]["opponent_ratings"].append(
ratings[device2].rating
)
device_matches[device1]["opponent_rds"].append(ratings[device2].rd)
device_matches[device1]["outcomes"].append(outcome)
# For device 2
device_matches[device2]["opponent_ratings"].append(
ratings[device1].rating
)
device_matches[device2]["opponent_rds"].append(ratings[device1].rd)
device_matches[device2]["outcomes"].append(0) # Loss
elif score1 < score2:
# Device 2 wins
outcome = 0
win_counts[device2] += 1
loss_counts[device1] += 1
# For device 1
device_matches[device1]["opponent_ratings"].append(
ratings[device2].rating
)
device_matches[device1]["opponent_rds"].append(ratings[device2].rd)
device_matches[device1]["outcomes"].append(outcome)
# For device 2
device_matches[device2]["opponent_ratings"].append(
ratings[device1].rating
)
device_matches[device2]["opponent_rds"].append(ratings[device1].rd)
device_matches[device2]["outcomes"].append(1) # Win
else:
# It's a draw
outcome = 0.5
# For device 1
device_matches[device1]["opponent_ratings"].append(
ratings[device2].rating
)
device_matches[device1]["opponent_rds"].append(ratings[device2].rd)
device_matches[device1]["outcomes"].append(outcome)
# For device 2
device_matches[device2]["opponent_ratings"].append(
ratings[device1].rating
)
device_matches[device2]["opponent_rds"].append(ratings[device1].rd)
device_matches[device2]["outcomes"].append(outcome)
# Update ratings after the model rating period
for device, matches in device_matches.items():
if matches[
"opponent_ratings"
]: # Only update if the device had matches in this period
# Update the rating with the three separate lists that the API requires
ratings[device].update_player(
matches["opponent_ratings"], # List of opponent ratings
matches["opponent_rds"], # List of opponent rating deviations
matches["outcomes"], # List of outcomes
)
# Convert to DataFrame
ranking_data = []
for device, rating in ratings.items():
if match_counts[device] > 0: # Only include devices with matches
ranking_data.append(
{
"device": device,
"rating": rating.rating,
"rd": rating.rd, # rating deviation (uncertainty)
"volatility": rating.vol,
"matches": match_counts[device],
"wins": win_counts[device],
"losses": loss_counts[device],
# Conservative rating (95% confidence lower bound)
"conserv_rating": rating.rating - (2 * rating.rd),
}
)
# Create DataFrame
ranking_df = pd.DataFrame(ranking_data)
if len(ranking_df) > 0:
# Add win rate
ranking_df["win_rate"] = ranking_df["wins"] / ranking_df["matches"]
# Add platform information
ranking_df["Platform"] = pd.Series(
{
row["device"]: df[df["Normalized Device ID"] == row["device"]][
"Platform"
].iloc[0]
for _, row in ranking_df.iterrows()
}
)
# Set device as index
ranking_df = ranking_df.set_index("device")
return ranking_df
@st.cache_data(ttl=CACHE_DURATION)
def analyze_glicko2_rankings(
df: pd.DataFrame,
min_matches: int = 5,
min_gpu_layers: int = 20,
pp_config: int = 512,
tg_config: int = 128,
) -> Tuple[pd.DataFrame, pd.DataFrame]:
"""
Analyze and display ranking results with Glicko-2 ratings.
Args:
df: DataFrame containing benchmark data
min_matches: Minimum number of matches required for confident rankings
min_gpu_layers: Minimum number of GPU layers required for iOS devices
pp_config: Prompt Processing configuration to filter for
tg_config: Token Generation configuration to filter for
Returns:
Tuple of (all rankings DataFrame, confident rankings DataFrame)
"""
# First filter the data
filtered_df = preprocess_benchmark_data(df, min_gpu_layers, pp_config, tg_config)
# Compute rankings for all three scenarios
combined_rankings = compute_glicko2_rankings(filtered_df, token_weight=0.6)
token_rankings = compute_glicko2_rankings(filtered_df, token_weight=1.0)
prompt_rankings = compute_glicko2_rankings(filtered_df, token_weight=0.0)
# Rename columns to avoid confusion
combined_rankings = combined_rankings.rename(
columns={
"rating": "combined_rating",
"rd": "combined_rd",
"volatility": "combined_vol",
"conserv_rating": "combined_conserv",
"wins": "combined_wins",
"losses": "combined_losses",
"win_rate": "combined_win_rate",
}
)
token_rankings = token_rankings.rename(
columns={
"rating": "token_rating",
"rd": "token_rd",
"volatility": "token_vol",
"conserv_rating": "token_conserv",
"wins": "token_wins",
"losses": "token_losses",
"win_rate": "token_win_rate",
}
)
prompt_rankings = prompt_rankings.rename(
columns={
"rating": "prompt_rating",
"rd": "prompt_rd",
"volatility": "prompt_vol",
"conserv_rating": "prompt_conserv",
"wins": "prompt_wins",
"losses": "prompt_losses",
"win_rate": "prompt_win_rate",
}
)
# Combine all rankings into one DataFrame
# We'll keep one set of match counts as they should be the same
rankings = combined_rankings.copy()
# Add token generation rankings
for col in [
"token_rating",
"token_rd",
"token_vol",
"token_conserv",
"token_wins",
"token_losses",
"token_win_rate",
]:
rankings[col] = token_rankings[col]
# Add prompt processing rankings
for col in [
"prompt_rating",
"prompt_rd",
"prompt_vol",
"prompt_conserv",
"prompt_wins",
"prompt_losses",
"prompt_win_rate",
]:
rankings[col] = prompt_rankings[col]
# Filter for minimum matches
confident_rankings = rankings[rankings["matches"] >= min_matches].sort_values(
"combined_rating", ascending=False
)
return rankings, confident_rankings
def analyze_device_glicko2_matches(
df: pd.DataFrame,
device_id1: str,
device_id2: Optional[str] = None,
token_weight: float = 0.6,
) -> pd.DataFrame:
"""
Analyze all matches for one or two specific devices using the Glicko-2 methodology.
Args:
df: DataFrame containing benchmark data
device_id1: First device ID to analyze
device_id2: Optional second device ID to compare against
token_weight: Weight for Token Generation in combined score (0.0 to 1.0)
Returns:
DataFrame containing detailed match information with win probabilities
"""
matches = []
def normalize_scores(group: pd.DataFrame) -> Dict[str, Dict]:
"""Normalize scores within a model group and return as dict"""
# Normalize Token Generation (higher is better)
token_min = group["Token Generation"].min()
token_max = group["Token Generation"].max()
token_range = token_max - token_min
# Normalize Prompt Processing (higher is better)
prompt_min = group["Prompt Processing"].min()
prompt_max = group["Prompt Processing"].max()
prompt_range = prompt_max - prompt_min
# Calculate normalized scores for each device
result = {}
for _, row in group.iterrows():
device_id = row["Normalized Device ID"]
# Calculate token normalization
token_norm = 0
if token_range > 0:
token_norm = (row["Token Generation"] - token_min) / token_range
# Calculate prompt normalization
prompt_norm = 0
if prompt_range > 0:
prompt_norm = (row["Prompt Processing"] - prompt_min) / prompt_range
# Calculate combined score regardless of ranges
combined = token_weight * token_norm + (1 - token_weight) * prompt_norm
result[device_id] = {
"token_norm": token_norm,
"prompt_norm": prompt_norm,
"combined": combined,
}
return result
# Group by Model ID to compare within same models
for model, group in df.groupby("Model ID"):
if device_id1 not in group["Normalized Device ID"].values:
continue
# Aggregate multiple entries per device by taking the maximum performance
# This ensures we use the best performance for each device
device_agg = (
group.groupby("Normalized Device ID")
.agg(
{
"Token Generation": "max",
"Prompt Processing": "max",
"n_gpu_layers": "first",
"Platform": "first",
"Model File Size": "first",
}
)
.reset_index()
)
# Check if device_id1 exists in the aggregated data
if device_id1 not in device_agg["Normalized Device ID"].values:
continue
device1_data = device_agg[
device_agg["Normalized Device ID"] == device_id1
].iloc[0]
# If device2 specified, only compare those two
if device_id2 is not None:
if device_id2 not in device_agg["Normalized Device ID"].values:
continue
devices_to_compare = [device_id2]
else:
devices_to_compare = [
d
for d in device_agg["Normalized Device ID"].unique()
if d != device_id1
]
# Get normalized scores using the aggregated data
norm_scores = normalize_scores(device_agg)
# print("norm_scores: ", norm_scores)
# Compare with other devices
for other_device in devices_to_compare:
device2_data = device_agg[
device_agg["Normalized Device ID"] == other_device
].iloc[0]
# Skip if normalization failed
if device_id1 not in norm_scores or other_device not in norm_scores:
continue
# Get normalized scores
scores1 = norm_scores[device_id1]
scores2 = norm_scores[other_device]
# Calculate win probabilities based on normalized scores
# For token generation
token_advantage = scores1["token_norm"] - scores2["token_norm"]
token_prob = 1 / (
1 + 10 ** (-6 * token_advantage)
) # Higher advantage means higher win probability
# For prompt processing
prompt_advantage = scores1["prompt_norm"] - scores2["prompt_norm"]
prompt_prob = 1 / (1 + 10 ** (-6 * prompt_advantage))
# For combined score
combined_advantage = scores1["combined"] - scores2["combined"]
combined_prob = 1 / (1 + 10 ** (-6 * combined_advantage))
# Determine winners
token_winner = (
device_id1
if device1_data["Token Generation"] > device2_data["Token Generation"]
else (
other_device
if device2_data["Token Generation"]
> device1_data["Token Generation"]
else "Tie"
)
)
prompt_winner = (
device_id1
if device1_data["Prompt Processing"] > device2_data["Prompt Processing"]
else (
other_device
if device2_data["Prompt Processing"]
> device1_data["Prompt Processing"]
else "Tie"
)
)
combined_winner = (
device_id1
if scores1["combined"] > scores2["combined"]
else (
other_device if scores2["combined"] > scores1["combined"] else "Tie"
)
)
matches.append(
{
"Model": model,
"Device 1": device_id1,
"Device 2": other_device,
"n_gpu_layers 1": device1_data["n_gpu_layers"],
"n_gpu_layers 2": device2_data["n_gpu_layers"],
"Token Generation 1": device1_data["Token Generation"],
"Token Generation 2": device2_data["Token Generation"],
"Token Winner": token_winner,
"Token Win Prob": token_prob,
"Prompt Processing 1": device1_data["Prompt Processing"],
"Prompt Processing 2": device2_data["Prompt Processing"],
"Prompt Winner": prompt_winner,
"Prompt Win Prob": prompt_prob,
"Combined Winner": combined_winner,
"Combined Win Prob": combined_prob,
"Platform 1": device1_data["Platform"],
"Platform 2": device2_data["Platform"],
"Model File Size": device1_data["Model File Size"],
}
)
matches_df = pd.DataFrame(matches)
if len(matches_df) > 0:
return matches_df
else:
print(
f"No matches found for device {device_id1}"
+ (f" against {device_id2}" if device_id2 else "")
)
return pd.DataFrame()
if __name__ == "__main__":
# Example usage
print("This module provides Glicko-2 ranking for device performance.")
print("Import and use the functions in your own code.")
print("Example:")
print(" from glicko2_ranking import analyze_glicko2_rankings")
print(" rankings, confident_rankings = analyze_glicko2_rankings(df)")