tokens: There is no reason to believe that the EU legislature wished to allow an exporting producer which did not cooperate with the initial investigation to be subject to an individual anti-dumping duty rate at the end of a review procedure if it has excluded that possibility for new exporting producers . 47 In the third place , it is only in its reply that the applicant raised the argument that the Commission could , as a minimum , have treated it as a cooperating exporting producer from then on and , for that reason , grant it the benefit of the anti-dumping duty rate applicable to cooperating exporting producers pursuant to Article 9 ( 6 ) of the basic regulation .